7/28/2019 Wittgenstein and Fairy Tales

1/6

:,77*(167(,1$1')$,5

7/28/2019 Wittgenstein and Fairy Tales

2/6

:,77*(167(,1 $1' )$,5

7/28/2019 Wittgenstein and Fairy Tales

3/6

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

7/28/2019 Wittgenstein and Fairy Tales

4/6

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

7/28/2019 Wittgenstein and Fairy Tales

5/6

WLRQV7KDWLVWRVD\WRGHDOZLWKKLVSDUWLFXODURQIXVLRQ:H FDQQRWGR WKLVTXLWH JHQHUDOO\RU LQDGYDQFH RIWKHSUREOHPVDSSHDULQJ:KHQWKHWUHDWPHQWRUNVKDWVWRVD\ZKHQWKHSKLORVRSKHUVQRORQJHULQWKHJULSRIKLVSUREOHPERWKWDQGLWVWUHDWPHQWLOOHHPTXLWHWULYLDORUWKOHVV1RZZHFDQXQGHUVWDQGUHPDUNZKLFKRFFXUVLQ:LWWJHQVWHLQVFRPPRQSODFHERRNZKLFKKHNHSWWRZDUGVWKHHQGRIKLVOLIHQGZKLFKZDVSXEOLVKHGV&XOWXUHQG9DOXH

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

7/28/2019 Wittgenstein and Fairy Tales

6/6

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iQGOVR%XWWPD\RWRVR7KHSKLORVRSKHUVRQIXVLRQD\HLQFRUULJLEOHUKHPD\D\/RRNZDQWRFULWLFL]HDQJXDJHLWWJHQVWHLQLOORLQWXWKDWLVUHPDUNVPDGHQDQJXDJHRRIRXUVHWPXVWHQUGHUUKHKLORVRSKHUPD\D\KDWHZDQWVRJL\HDQJXDJHRXQGDWLRQVJDLQLWWJHQVWHLQLOOD\WKDWVLWZRUNVWRHVQWHHGQ\KDWPLJKWHVXSSOLHG\SKLORVRSKHUQGLQZD\WKDVQRQH:HLPSO\FWKLQNDONQHUWDLQD\V

$%287+($87+25&ROLQ5DGIRUGV3URIHVVRUI3KLORVRSK\.H\QHV&ROOHJH7KH8QLYHUVLW\DQWHUEXU\HQW8QLWHGLQJGRPHLVWKHXWKRUI7KH1DWXUHI&ULWLFLVPQGRIQXPHURXVUWLFOHVQWKHUHDOPRISKLORVRSK\LWHUDU\ULWLFLVPLWWJHQVWHLQQGRWKHUURGXFWLRQVIDFUHDWLYHQDWXUHVKRUWWRULHVVVD\VIDLU\DOHV