40
What is molecular filtration?

What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

What is molecular filtration?

Page 2: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000 times smaller than the particles removed by HEPA

filters

There are many, many more molecules in the air than particles 34 grams of hydrogen sulfide occupies 22.4 liters (0.8 ft3) of space at NTP There are 600,000,000,000,000,000,000,000molecules in this space

Particle filters will not remove molecules We need to do something different…

Page 3: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

How do Molecular Filters Work? All adsorbents are porous – full of very small holes

Very high internal surface area values Activated carbon: > 1000 m2/gram

Molecules diffuse from the external air into the pores, then trapped on the internal surface

Different adsorbents for different customer problems: Activated carbon – Broad Spectrum behavior

Impregnated activated carbon – targets specific molecules

Impregnated activated alumina – targets specific molecules

Page 4: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Broad Spectrum Visualization

Page 5: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Chemical Adsorption Visualization

Page 6: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Molecular Filtration Media

Broad Spectrum Carbon (non‐impregnated)

Targeted Media 

(Impregnated Carbon)

A‐ grades to control acids

B grades to control bases

J grades for other targets

N grades for nuclear power

Targeted Media 

(CamPure) 

Page 7: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

The effects of Molecular Pollutants Smell / odor

Domestic waste Cooking smells Aviation fuel (airports) Waste water treatment

Irritants (health effects) Ozone Nitrogen dioxide Ammonia Chopping onions

Poison / Toxin War Gases Hydrogen cyanide Isocyanates Dioxins Radioactive isotopes

Corrosion Acidic gases in paper mills Acidic gases in petrochemical refineries Reactive gases in museums Acidic gases in semi-conductor fabs

Page 8: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Gas Source Typical City Concentration (USA)

Health Guidelines

Nitrogen dioxide

Vehicle emissions

20 – 60 μg/m3 (long term)

WHO   40 μg/m3 1 year  average,  200  μg/m3 1 hour average.

BTEX Vehicle emissions

Benzene, toluene, ethyl benzene, xylene  (hydrocarbons)

Sulphurdioxide

Combustion processes

15 – 30 μg/m3 WHO   20 μg/m3 24 hour average,  500  μg/m3 10 minute average

Ozone Atmospheric pollution +UV

100 – 200 μg/m3 WHO  100 μg/m3 8 hour average,  

External sources of Molecular PollutantsWhere does bad air quality come from and how do I stop it?

UV

Page 9: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

What Are the Six Common Air Pollutants?The Clean Air Act requires EPA to set National Ambient Air Quality Standards for the six contaminants below. These pollutants can harm your health and the environment, and cause property damage.

Particulate Matter Enters with “fresh air,” can be generated 

internally Always removed with particulate filters 

(visible evidence)

Lead Generated internally, can enter with 

“fresh air” Removed with high efficiency 

particulate filters when presence is known from application

Carbon Monoxide No filters for CO and must be treated 

with fresh air

• Nitrogen Dioxide• Enters with “fresh air”• Sometimes removed with “molecular 

media”• Not visible and odor threshold is

• Ozone• Enters with “fresh air,” can be 

generated internally• Sometimes removed with “molecular 

media”• Sulfur Dioxides

• Enters with “fresh air”• Sometimes removed with “molecular 

media”http://www.epa.gov/airquality/urbanair/

5ppmwhile exposure limit is 3 ppm.

Page 10: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Internal sources of Molecular Pollutants

• 100s or 1000s of VOCs(Volatile Organic Compounds)

• Some chemicals are known, most are not

• Individually, concentrations are low

• What about the cocktail effect?

• Very expensive to measure

Page 11: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

How is molecular filtration applied?

Page 12: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Fresh or Make-up air

Return or Recirculation air

Exhaust air

Typical Building (any) Air Systems

Page 13: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Protecting people from odors and irritantsComfort and IAQ (HVAC) applications

City-center buildings Hotels Schools Hospitals Shopping malls Airports

Page 14: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Typical product solutions for Comfort/IAQ Issues Embedded Media

Filters Contemporary solutions Molecular filter only Combination filters Broad Spectrum Adsorption Rapid Adsorption Dynamics Use for non-specific problems

Page 15: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Typical product solutions for high concentration Comfort/IAQ Issues and Light Industrial

Loose Fill Thin Bed Traditional solutions Loose-filled media Very high initial efficiency Long lifetime Use for defined or specific problems

Page 16: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Loose Fill Cylinders

Page 17: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Protecting processes and artifacts from corrosive agentsProcess and Corrosion Control Applications

IVF clinics Formaldehyde, VOCs, NO2

Cultural heritage establishments Acidic gases, ozone

Petrochemical refineries Pulp and paper Waste water treatment Mining and ore refining

Page 18: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Protecting people and the environment from toxic gases Industrial Exhaust Applications

Nuclear power Radio-iodine

Uranium enrichment Hydrogen fluoride

Manufacture of polyurethane foam Isocyanates, amines

Military applications War gases

Domestic waste processing Odors , 100’s of different gases

Food and beverage

Page 19: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Media Embedded media (RAD)

Loose-fill mediaThin bed

Loose-fill mediaDeep bed

Product Form Compact, Panel, Cell, Bag

Cylinder, Panel, V--Cell

Loose-fill mediaDeep bed

Application Area IAQTraditional

Comfort, Light Process

Process, Industrial and

Corrosion Control

Primary Air System Re-circulation / Return Make-up Make-up, Exhaust

/ Re-circulation

Product Type and Application Area

Page 20: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Lifetime (hours)

Effic

iency

(%

)

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 10000

Leak‐free system

Leaky system

Elimination of leaks is critical for optimized TCO

APPROX 50 % LONGER LIFE

> 100% LONGER LIFE

Page 21: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Factors affecting performance

Page 22: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Labs, Resources, and Capabilities

Page 23: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Molecular Filtration Laboratory

4 PhD’s

Page 24: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Molecular Filter Test Rig (Schematic)

Gas orSolvent

DPDP

-+ +

RH T

Gas detectors

AHU Fresh air in

Recirculation chamber

Test duct

45-120 deg. F

25-90% RH

Page 25: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Test duct

• Test full size molecular filters tested under application real conditions‐ Set and control airflow, temperature  and relative humidity

Page 26: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

ASHRAE Testing In our lab in the Tech Center, Sweden we can test full size molecular filters and samples adsorbents in accordance with ASHRAE 145.1 and ASHRAE 145.2

ANSI/ASHRAE standard 145.1 – 2008, ʺLaboratory Test Method for Assessing the Performance of Gas‐Phase Air‐Cleaning Systems: Loose Granular Mediaʺ.

ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 145.2‐2011, ʺLaboratory Test Method for Assessing the Performance of Gas‐Phase Air‐Cleaning Systems: Air‐Cleaning Devices”

Page 27: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Gas or solvent vapor injection

• Challenge filter with gases

• Realistic application gas concentrations‐ The results are meaningful‐ Not artificially high concentrations (ASTM D6646)

Page 28: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

ASTM D6646 “This method compares the performance of granular or pelletized 

activated carbons used in odor control applications, such as sewage treatment plants, pump stations, etc. The method determines the relative breakthrough performance of activated carbon for removing hydrogen sulfide from a humidified gas stream.

“The mass transfer zone in the 23 cm column used in this test is proportionally much larger than that in the typical bed used in industrial applications. This difference favors a carbon that functions more rapidly for removal of H2S over a carbon with slower kinetics.”

present in field operations may affect the H2S breakthrough capacity of the carbon; these are not addressed by this test.”

Other organic contaminants 

• “This test does not duplicate conditions that an adsorber would encounter in practical service.”

Page 29: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Gas detectors

• Sensitive upstream / downstream gas detectors‐Measure: real time concentrations‐ Output: real time efficiency curves

Page 30: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

CLD Software Equations taken from established scientific

adsorption theory. Data from > 16 years of continual tests in the

molecular filtration laboratory Filtration media test rig Full-size filter test rig Data derived from application-real test protocols

(unlike some competitors) 50 years of experience of real world experience in diverse

molecular filtration applications

Page 31: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000
Page 32: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000
Page 33: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000
Page 34: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000
Page 35: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

2 31

Page 36: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Coupon Service(reactivity or corrosivity monitoring)

Measurement of a corrosive atmosphere.

More relevant than measuring individual gases. 

Is air treatment is required? What type?

Is air filtration equipment effective?

Room pressurization and tightness

Strips of pure copper and pure silver, exposed to the corrosive 

atmosphere, 30 days.

Passive technique – only shows average conditions over time.

Results available after lab analysis after exposure period.

Page 37: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Filter condition analysis A sample is removed from the filter and returned to the laboratory for

analysis The condition of the sample is compared to the spec for new material The condition of the sample is compared to material known to be

“exhausted”. The sample can then be positioned on a scale from “new” to

“completely used” A series of samples should be taken every 3 or 6 months for

“predictive” results.

Page 38: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Corrosivity Monitor – ISA-Check II Continuous reading corrosivity monitor. Copper and silver thin-film sensors. No need to hard wire. Portable. Windows based software. Very easy to set-up and download data .

ISA-CHECK IIsensor

Page 39: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Molecular Filtration Application Assessment New or Existing Facility Where in system

Make‐up, recirc, exhaust Application Type

IAQ, Process, Corrosion Control, etc Process Details

Flow rate Temperature RH%

Contaminants Name(s) or Chemical formula(s) Concentrations Usage (24/7 or intermittent)

Page 40: What is molecular filtration? - ASHRAE® – Pikes Peakpikespeakashrae.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Non-Commercial... · Molecular Filtration Fundamentals Molecules are 1,000-10,000

Contact Information Camfil

Trent Thiel [email protected] (510) 325‐9759 San Francisco, CA