58
We may keep the corals but lose the reefs

We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200

We may keep the corals but lose the reefs

Page 2: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 3: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 4: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 5: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 6: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 7: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 8: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 9: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 10: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 11: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 12: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 13: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 14: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 15: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 16: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 17: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 18: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 19: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 20: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 21: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 22: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 23: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 24: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 25: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 26: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 27: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200

Hughes and Tanner 2000

Gardner et al. 2003

Page 28: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 29: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 30: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 31: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 32: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 33: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 34: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 35: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 36: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 37: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 38: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 39: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 40: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 41: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 42: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 43: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 44: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 45: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 46: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 47: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 48: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200

Gladfelter 1982

Page 49: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 50: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 51: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 52: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 53: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 54: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 55: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200

Tomascik et al. 1996 Coral Reefs 15: 169-175

1991 - 1996

Page 56: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 57: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 58: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200