8/3/2019 vol 18 no 22 (2)

1/8

From the Angle of Farm Workers and Farm Work

The Rise and Fall of CesarChavez and the UFWBy Bill Hatch

Tells the Facts and Names the Names

dec. 16-31, 2011 Alexander Cockburn and Jeffrey St. Clar vol. 18, no. 22

L wi -

q p pp Cityof God, ig i Ri

i. 2002 w i

w, iig Big i B igp.I pi i i i

i Ri, i G. w, , i gi, i i q. Ip i, p, -

pi i gi

Now Its Rios Turn

Why the Olympic Games AreAlways Wars on the PoorBy Michael Volpe

ppi i i wig-

ig i i Bzii g ii i iipi pig

W p Opi i 2014 2016 i Ri.

I j i,

Wii, ii wi iii i Ri i. i, Wii , p - gi p i i -

. ii pp

w ipi

i. Wi i i ,Wii pi i ii. Wii -

wg g ig i i ; pi i ,

i, i, p. , , i pi. i, p i -

5 p , i -w.

wig pi

-wig, w-iig iizig ip i i. ji i i, wi

g- i (i, ,). g ii w,

Volpe contnued on ae

B, Trampling out theVintage: Cesar Chavez and the Two Souls

of the United Farm Workers. V, 2011,

848 pp.

I

Y, Z, pig -

ig i 1993, iig wppw i

ig the Bruce Church Inc. v.United Farm Workers i ig wi z i. O w Ipp w g ii

i, Y ii Pii, i p i w i i pi ,ig g Ri

Mg, MiRi -i i pii.

z i i i p w

giig pii g i i i i p-

, ig iz pp w z i: i Yi q pii

g p i w, pi i Y jii-i i ii.

w Yi, , g Gi Ri, w

z wi i - , w w pii,B I.

ig i pii

i, ig i Ri, I

iz W Ui Di

Lp z YW Li i 1974. I i g ,p wi ii

ig i, z. w i ipi i i

ig iig ig wi Y i w B i i , gippig i wi Trampling out the

Vintage. ig B , I , i w i wI i i ii gi

i w.B wi z

g w

w. i gi z i , wig , i-i w, wi iig gi-gp i ppi.

pii w w i 20 i igi i i pgp,

D Lg Oi P Mi , wigpp w i

g i MiRi. B g Hatch contnued on ae col.

8/3/2019 vol 18 no 22 (2)

2/8

w, , ig i wi ig,wig pi -i .

w g g- w i i pi. , wig ip i-

, pi g

w w wp i -.

Al Jazeera -

i p Bzi i g . i w -i, Pi p -w

g pp p Bzii i g .

I i wi i i i i , Wii

g i. i i

p p gp i i i i Ri. -

, g wi ii i ii p i. ,

i pi -ii i i ii. I w,

p.Y w w i pp-

i. i. w i

ig 100 . Rii i , i ig,i ii wi w i-

i pp. pi i w pi i, wg, p

. I i pi (iig

EDITORS

Alexander CockburnJeffrey St. Clair

ASSISTANT EDITOR

Alevtina Rea

BUSINESS

Becky Grant

Deva Wheeler

DESIGN

Tiffany Wardle

COUNSELORBen Sonnenberg

19-2010

CounterPunch

P.O. Box 228

Petrolia, CA 95558

1-800-840-3683

counterpunch@counterpunch.org

www.counterpunch.org

All rights reserved.

In Seoul, 720,000 peo-ple were forcibly evict-ed from their homes.In Barcelona, housing

became so unafford-able as a result of theOlympic Games thatlow-income earnerswere forced to leave thecity. In Atlanta, approxi-mately 30,000 peoplewere displaced and1.25 million in Beijing.

pp piqi i i pp . i City of

God ig ip pi i gg ppi i-

i i gi, ppi

wi w ig i ig i ii piip w w -

ii, iig i-w p, Wiii iiw wi CounterPunch.

City of God i i pp-ig gi p i i . i, ii Ri w

w Opi, New YorkTimes i Vi i w Opi i R Bzi. i p, ig

w pi ip Bzii, w i wi w wi pp wi G,

i i M, 21, w w i pB. W w w

w , pp i Bzi w w ig wi w pig w .

, pi i -

iii, izi, i, -

i i) iig i g pi p i wi -ii.

Wii - w, i

i i i ig. Wig- ig-, ,

ipi. I i wi i ig, w-ig i w ig-. Bzii ii

1988 giz i ii i, wii w pi [i.., ig -qi ig i], ig

Bzii ii, i i 5 i Bzii ii.

O g, Wii ,

ii i i i pg. Dz wp iii ig p ig i, i

g ii iii gi p .

M G ig, gp g ig i g i 2016, pi

i. I Opi,w ip, CounterPunch.

w iii w

ip p i ig w i Ri. I ig, ig ii, i

, i, w w w w w g w gi-i. pi pp-

i pp i iw ig g p w- p. i w pp -

w- --i ig-.

B Q Opi ppi w w wi iiig

p. I ig, i Mi R Hpi. piw w i 1990. ig i p, pi i w

w i Opi Vig, -. Y i w

p i , i .

Volpe contnued from ae

ec. 16-31, 2011

8/3/2019 vol 18 no 22 (2)

3/8

, i i i Opi Vig, w ip pi?

pi w i p-

pig i Ri w w pp i ig i iq. Hi Hig

Rig Eii, i P

Hig. 2007 i-p Opi G i, , , V,

ii. i w :I , 720,000 pp w -

i i i i pp-i Opi G i 1988. IB, ig -

Opi G w-i w i. I , 9,000 ii w i pp

( i i) p Opi-ipi pig , ppi 30,000 pp

w ip Opi- g-ii p. I , R w ip

p Opi- pp-i. I -p 2008 OpiG i Bijig, OHRE i 1.25 ii pp

ip Opi- p, wi - q ii ip

p i pi g-

ig . I L, ig 1,000 pp i

ii, Opi G .

OHRE i Opi G g-

p- iig i ip i i w i

ig , wi i igii i ig -ii. I ii, pi gii i

i, -p w p ppii pp iiiz . gi i ig i-

p, wi ippi giiz - i.

i pi .W ( i) g g, i i i piiz.

Ii Opi i, wi i ig, IO

i i p-ig. B IO i

wi ig Opi g wi i, i i ip i.

O g i Ri, Wii,

w ppig. I pi ii i ig,

Wii w i gw gig , gigp ii i- pig ii

i. I , i i i i 30 i ii -i.

M i i ii, w g w i i. H gp,

i ii, p -p p i-i. i 190 ii

Gi i i i p-, w ii pi ig ii w w . ig pi i

gi i i w p.W I w? D I

i ? wi i-

. , g g i w igig p p,

w, w i pi. W i w gig p p, i i g i gig

p, i.Wii i ig pi -

. i p G ig, i ig

ipp ig Opi i IO i ii i2009. I Ri, pp w

100 p . i i i p-pi i i. i, gw Bzi. Hig

W p Opi i p iig pi -i, i.

i g i i p, P ig Gw. ig

p i Pp p( Pp W p i),w 150,000 170,000 ppwi i wi ip i

ppi . Wi p-pi i p iCity of God wpp i New

York Times, i g j gig

w i ii pp-i g-.

Wii i , i g-, ip ww w g-

i ; I ig iig i ii i

, i -

ig ii Ri gig ppi . ip , w, ii

giig p i i g -i i w,

i ig i. CP

M i ig.

pig i, i i i , jii 2010.

Hatch contnued from ae

z ig w ii i

i p, WI, i i qi iig i g-

i, wi w i i g g gi igp i w, w wi -

i . Hig pp w , I

i pp p- i i i I i iz ig

i pp qi.B i w

p w - i i, i

z UW.E p i i ipi w -

w i i pi w i gizig.Mig iii w w i i i,

piig wi -pi w, ii giig, UW -i -

ii i i pi i. i p,

Mi w i ii wig i-i U..-Mi g-wpg ( B Pg), w

3

dec. 16-31, 2011

8/3/2019 vol 18 no 22 (2)

4/8

i, ig ig i K,Kig i i gi, I i g p-ii i i

i pii w -i qi i iii U.. ii i, wi

wg i

i-i. I giziz , i W ii (W), wi,

i ji L-IO, Ui W Ogizigi (UWO) i

Ui W (UW), i i i--i w w, i w i pp

i i i i 19 . Y, i i wi g

i gizig p bar-

rios wi z g ig i i i

i Ogizi gpwii cursillos

w g ii , i w pg pii-, i.

z i w i, w gig

i w gw D i g-i ii. I , Bii, w w i

ii w giz, p-i ww, i iq ig

pi w magonista -i i giig p-i w gi,

g- gii. ww i, zi ig ig -

i giz i g. H i wi p i

w i i z UW i

D -gp i, M (L Pgii, pigig, z i),

ii gi gp i i ii

.Y, i g 1966 i

D, i w (I w, giz-ig gii i),

ig w w wB p wi p -ig: Mi w

g, iig ii i gi-zi gig , j i U.., pi g j w i,

iz i i gWi Mi magonistas i WWI. W gi-zi w p,

w w w g iz Ipi i

G V ii,w 50,000 pi iMi i 1933.

B, ig ii i-

Subscription Information

Subscription information can be found

at www.counterpunch.org or call

toll-free inside the U.S.

1-800-840-3683

Published twice monthly

except July and August,

22 issues a year.

1 - year hardcopy edition $45

2 - year hardcopy edition $80

1 - year email edition $35

2 - year email edition $65

1 - year email & hardcopy edition $50

1 - year institutions/supporters $100

1 - year student/low income $35

Renew by telephone, mail, or on our

website. For mailed orders please

include name, address and email

address with payment, or call 1-800-

840-3683 or 1-707-629 3683. Add

$17.50 per year for subscriptions mailed

outside the U.S.A.

Make checks or money orders payable to:

CounterPunch

Business Oce

PO Box 228, Petrolia, CA 95558

Even more completeand detai l ed thanBardackes descrip-tion of the work of acelery-harvest crew ishis presentation of thework of communityand labor organizing.

R, w g i, g iq, -- gp i. B -piz i pi. Pp i i

pii gizi wippi w wi iii pi.

Pp ig pi

i ip , wiw ig Mi-iii g w,

w p Li Vz w Uii, e Shrunken Head of Pancho Villa, wi

i i , wi i, wig ji. Li, w pi

w ig i pi i i w pg,w i i(Zoot Suit LaBamba), i -

w p i i Bi.

i w

i p Trampling out theVintage. Liig pig p- iii g

, pig g g pi w i w i piii i wi gg

ji i w gii-. , pw ipw gg i UW, i

g piii.

i 55 i i wi ii gi-

i w , I ii pi- i, i w, z UW. I

B pi i z UW, ii . M i p

w B i i - iig g , w pig

i i w pi. D i i ? I i i j B ,

w ii i- i i p, iigi .

I p B Trampling Oute Vintage gwi MWii Factoriesin the Fields, i Grapes of

Wrath In Dubious Battle, EGz Merchants of Labor, R

4

ec. 16-31, 2011

8/3/2019 vol 18 no 22 (2)

5/8

Little Country Big U.S. Embassy

Tunisia Friendly Piece

On Uncle Sams Chessboard?By Rob Prince

I I i g, I w

p i iiwig w . Li. I

w p gg wi,

i 1967, I w g w, g wi wi p . I g Bgi LIi

Bgi Lg Vi, wI g wi gp Pp . , , I w

p i i w U.. E. , I w

pi w -gi. I w i g I gi i -ig pi. I g , i p i

(gi Vi W HHp p).

U.. ipi i g i i w ip w

i w w I. ig gp w w i i i w i

w, iig i p g ig, igi i i , gig , i-

izig wi pp, wi pp Bi w, ii!

iig w i w w w i gig .

ig w iig Lg I L g. i ig p pi w iig g i w qi.

i, i p- i i i w.

p, , i ii,

i i Dp ig i i D Dp.

Oi i i ii , Dp w -gi ipi , wig p

pi pi pig ip.

p w p-p 11

iiizi U.. ig pi? w p GO U..

g Ii Dp

iig g ipi piig i L?

Ui i w

i ii, i.p-p , i g-, i i w w

w . igi w. E iw i-, i E gi

ipi ig j i-i U.. ig pi i gi, gi ig i Mg, W. I iz

i piii ppi wi . I

Corridors of Migration, Wii

D We Shall Be All ( i IWW), wi g pgi i Trampling

Out e Vintage, i ig-p L. Lwi.

i i, I i,

p ii wB ppig :gw . w i W gii-; i

UW; iiz g . - iig; iig gizi w w

i gi gi iz,Ipi , qi V, qi V,

i Pj , p i wi-gp ; w izi; Hipi g ;

; i i-i . gizig; . B gp i g

i i i, p j gizig i i i. CP

B i i M, .

g qi: w pwig,i pii

j ii w U.. gi iii w ?

Lig i U..-ii -i, ip pi . iig gi-

, w, p gi gig ii i ig,Li gi.

p wi i

i, i i p Ui w w p- ipi Li,

i p i gi .

ii Li wi g-

i p w Li , wi pp ii i i i . ii

, g ig, ip. ppii Li ii; ii p ,

g i ppii pig Li Li g i i .

B ii i wii w ig gi, i- ig. I j wi pp i gi ig-

, wi i p-i w . j w. i pi: i

i w gi. O zi , i ,gi g , , gii i, i p-

ig i i w.w-p qi i.

Ri w ii gi g . i i-i i . H

gi i ii ii -i i -

pii i p. ii iig gi q.

i i g

gi g piig , i ii, wp w B i p-

pig G. I i w gi ii B i w , i w imodus vivendi w . gi

w p i i B i -

Hatch contnued from ae

5

dec. 16-31, 2011

8/3/2019 vol 18 no 22 (2)

6/8

gi i ii Wi 1990 i i i. Iw i i i. I i i, i i g

i pp g,wi w w ig

ii, w i

i g i i i gj p i p-

p. Igi p w pii i!

I i, ii i

igpi U.. g. g i i piiz i U... gi, Mg

Pi. gi i w gi g pi iii i pp

Ui (g RIOM/U..pi ) gwig

p , g - g i ii p g w i.

Ip i wi gi i Wig i ii, i w gi ii-i

pp i iiw, i 1990, i ipw. g i iig -

iip U.. i DiBji, i -i Dp . gi ig -

i i i- - i.

W i i qi

gwig i?E i g ig i i-

iip. gi

g ppi U... i, i p q-i. B i i gi piwi i ip i,

Ui , ig

The strategic alliancesbetween the Algeriangovernment most es-pecially its military andsecurity apparatus and the United Stateshave been growingover the past decade.

i i pw. I g ii Li, gi ,gi ig i i. gipi i w gi

ii --i, i .

w p gi -

i i pig G,

gi ipi i Ep i, 250,000i B i ig

i gi i . B ig , gi w p-pi wi ii iig i

pp. Ui i i -gi, i gi gi i.

M Bzizi -i-i i ii D 17, 2010, pi i gi. Pp gi j

ii, ig pii , j,ig, ig,wi i p i

w , i 1991. i

2011, gi piig gi

p pi p g- i Mi E, gi g w qi gg i g

w i ii: i-ig pi wi pi -i i-i pg

wi ig ig w

pi pi. g w ii

i pi j i pg p p -i . , i w.

i i p ww gi g p i -i w i ig

i: , i i w ii j ipg. B i

iizig ii i ii i g , pi,i i: i -i iiig pii

pw . I pp i , . I i pi, -

i wi wi g, g ig pi ig i wi w

i ig pi. i

i i.

gi z. Ip i pp / -

gi gi igi w i i-pigi (g i g i i). Ui

gg wi i, Ii i pp i

, i i iipi U.. i ii gi (i w-) pw.

gi ii-i p-p, i pw i g ig U.. gi ii. W i w i

ig- , i-ig i i iii w . B

, ip i wi Ui gi gi g i g i i ig wi

w pw , w i i i i p-ii Ep i ig (wi ig i i

ppig g).i U..-gi iip i

ig U..-ii

i w.g wi gi

ip U.. i

ii i, ig- U.. E igi ig g i, ip i g

g i . i jU.. ii p i gi g gi i ig. i iip

: i, jw wp.

i i pi w

w U... wi i i, gi , gi, w. g ii U.. p ii i i

g i. I 1990, G W, U... i qi, -i ii ip i i

i w Q ig ( q p-) U.. ii q.

Big i iig Wig g i, i i, Ui ipi ii

Q, wi w . i ii -i ig Q Mg.

ii, i p (pig

6

ec. 16-31, 2011

8/3/2019 vol 18 no 22 (2)

7/8

i wi U..., Ii i ( i i).

ii p i-

. I wi . I , gi ii gwig w

U.. i gg pg-

ig w. i, -i pi iw, i i p wg. i

(Ii i ) wi ii gw i pi pw, ig-

i Ui wi i i. I pp O iiii iig Ri Gi

i E P . i w I i wGi i i Wig,D.., i qi p-i ii

U...

, pii iii), i i Li, pi p i ii i w i gi. Vi! Bi

igg i ww j i.

I w i

i, wi w p i ii ( ig i i),

w i gi ppii U.. E iig i gi iig p

i pi ii.

pii

pw i ii i p B i g g i-p i wi Ui , i ig

i g. ii w

I 2006, i Epii (E) w p

g pi p-i ippi w - i i.

Dpig iw i, - i i i pii pi pii

i. ii wi pi

pi i i

gi ig w -ig i pi i wi p

izig i. B, i , w i ig iz i i i p

gi i izig i-. w iig i i i g

ig , i i igi.

I i Free Trade Doesnt Work:What Should Replace It and Why I p i i i gi p-i. O , ii

i pi pi-i i gi. i , i ,

Factory Farms as Reality and Metaphor

Terror, Domination and MeatBy Rob Urie

Q ii ig g p i i--i Ui , pi -w w i i pig.

Q pi ii ii ii i. Qi i i i pi

i. i, i i-

i w w i p. W ii ig g i -

i, , g i , w p i

i, wi, I i, qi wi i . I p. IQ, iAl Jazeera. CP

R P i Iii Uii D. H jpi@-

..

gwig pi w gi p, w ( g-

) pp wi iii i -i, i i

iiz p i ig . I i w, -i pii pi i w p: (1) iii

g i p i- i (2) p gw i p.

I i , i i , p pp ii

pii w wi p. Pi i q pi p i i i i i

i p.P w, wi

i ii

i wi gw p w pii - p i i.

Wi i, i pii-i w i, wi i pii.

Wi i

ii pii, w - pii.

i i g i

pp ig i i wi i w, iig iig ig . i g i pp i-

ig i i. B ii,, , w i i w,

i i g pii ii i w i q-i .

w , i -g i - ig wi -

ii i piiiig i, wi pp i i i

w . B wi iiig i i i i p pp -pi ? P w: w

pi iiig i. W i i?

E w p g gii-

i w i g g ipi i g ii pp i

- p pp w iw i- ii. M i- i i-pii,

i w p i wi p -.

, pii, w i ig

7

dec. 16-31, 2011

8/3/2019 vol 18 no 22 (2)

8/8

p iig i i qi p -ii . Hw i ppi i i

i ?Wi i g

() i -

w, iii w

pp i ( ig i i piw i g) i ii -

ig. i i ii-i ii ig, i p w i

i i g

PO B Pi,

Get your fall readingwww.counterpunch.org

s CssP

U.. PgPID

Pi . i, IL

Fs Cssreturn service requested

Eating meat requiresthe commodificationof what is intuitivelyto many not a com-modity if it was notfor the radical disso-

ciation created by thefactory farm system.

p p i p wi i p ig i i -ig , p wi i-

i pi, wi ipp g iig ip pi.

P p i i

i - , - i g pp i ii

pi. w - - ii i i, i ig pi. E

i i g i.

Wi pii pi -

i iig i-ig pii p, piii i i qi

p i pii qi i. M pp iipwi i w -

i . Eig qi ii w i iii i, i i w

i iii -- . i,

wi i -

(1) i (2) w i.

w - .

i i pii ii,pii . Wi ii i, pi , w -

g i. Bi w (i-i ig) i

i i i pi p pp,pig i i pw, p i, g

i pii, ig.

iiig i w pp

i pi i ii, -pii iig i i- ii, pi i

pi w i. pi ii gi i ii,

ipi gii iE i . CP

R U i i pii -

i iig i w Y.

8