VIZ GIVING: BEFORE GAS AND OIL...Mar 17, 2009 · VIZ GIVING: BEFORE THK GAS AND OIL BOARD APPLICANTS: CNX Gas Company LLC on behalf of Harrison- Wyatt, L.L.C and Sue Edwards, Judy

VIZ GIVING: BEFORE THK GAS AND OIL BOARD

APPLICANTS:

CNX Gas Company LLC on behalf of Harrison-

Wyatt, L.L.C and Sue Edwards, Judy Fuller,Mary June Shortridge Arms, GeraldineO'Quinn; James Price; Edgar Price Jr. ; andKatherine Price Sears.

91-0430-0116-03&%04

RKLIKK SOUGHT:A Supplemental Order for Disbursement of Escrowed FundsAmending Prior Orders Affecting Drilling Unit AA-9. a iiortion of Tract 2C(Referenced herein as "the Subject Drilling Unit" )

Locatiori: Buchanan Countv, Virginia

Action Details:

(1)To provide a calculation of funds, Unit Operator has deposited into thc Escrow Account forDrilling Unit AA-9 by Tract Subaccounts:

(2) To provide each applicant, in simple terms, a complete month over month RoyaltyAccounting of unit production, costs taxes and proceeds, depicting variables used in thecalculation of royalty payments to the unit escrow account.

(3) To disburse mrit funds to the Applicants, in accordance with their Unit Ownership Interestsrelative to those funds deposited by the Unit Operator into Subject Dr~ihng Unit'sEscrow Subaccount for VGOB Tract(s) identified in Table 1.

1. Hearing Date and Place: This matter came on for final hearing before the Virginia Gas and Oil Board (herein"Board") at 9:00 a.m. on March 17, 2009, at the Southwest Virginia Higher Education Center on the campus ofVirginia Highlands Community College, Abingdon, VA.

2. Aggearaaces: Mark A. Swartz of Swartz Law Offices appeared for the Applicant; and Sharon M.B. Pigeon,Assistant Attorney General, was present to advise the Board.

Jurisdiction and Notice: Pursuant to Va. Code $$ 45.1-361.1 er seq. , and in particular Va. Code )) 45.1-361.21 and 45.1-361.22, the Board finds that it has jurisdiction over the establishment and maintenance of an escrowaccount, with tract subaccounts, for each of the coaibed methane gas drilling units established by the Board throughits field rules that are subject to a Board pooling order. Further, the Unit Operator is required to deposit, asapplicable, those funds specified in Va. Code g 45.1-361.21.D., 45.1-361.22.A.2, 45.1-361.22.A.3 and 45.1-361.22.A.4 into the applicable escrow tract subaccounts. The Board finds that: (1)while it does not have jurisdictionto resolve conflicting claims to the ownership of the Coalbed Methane Gas produced by the Unit Operator from wellslocated on Subject Drilling Unit, and (2) while it does not have jurisdiction to interpret agreements by and betweenthe Gas owners/claimants and/or the Unit Operators or to abridge or contravene the provisions of such agreements,(3) pursuant to Va. Code P 45.1-361.22.A.5, the Board does have jurisdiction and authority to disburse fundsfrom the Kscrow Account provided the Board has been provided with a final decision of a court of competentjurisdiction adjudicating the ownership of coalbed methane gas as between the conflicting claimants or an agreementamong all claimants owning conflicting estates in the tracts in question or any undivided interest therein.

4. Prior Proceedings:

(a) On May 31, 1991,the Board executed its order pooling interests in the Subject Drilling Unit for theproduction of occluded natural gas produced from coalbeds and rock strata associated therewith (herein "Gas")in accordance with the provisions of Va. Code SS 45.1-361.21 and 45.1-361.22 (herein "Pooling Order" ). ThePooling Order was filed with the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Buchanan County on June 6, 1991,Deed Book375, page 758. The Supplemental Order was executed on October 20, 1993, and recorded in with the Clerk ofthe Court, Buchanan County on October 29, 1993,Deed Book 415, page 284.

(b) On March 9, 2006, the Board executed an order docket number 91-0430-0116%1,disbursing escrowedfunds from Tmcts 2B and 2C. The order was filed with Clerk of the Circuit Court of Buchanan County onMarch 13, 2006, Instrument Number 06-0000780.

(c) On January 31, 2008, the Board executed an order docket number 914430-0116-02,disbursing escrowedfunds from Tracts 2C. The order was filed with Clerk of the Circuit Court of Buchanan County on February 7,2008, Instrunient Number 084000442.

4.2 To the extent claims to the Gas were in conflict, pursuant to Va. Code S 45.1-361-22 payments attributable tosaid conflicting claims were ordered deposited by the Unit Operator into the escrow account established by thePooling Orders (herein "Escrow Account" ). According to the Pooling Orders and testimony, the coal estateownership interests of Harrison-Wyatt, LLC, and the gas and oil ownership interests of Sue Edwards, JudyFuller, James Price, Edgar Price Jr., Katherine Price Sears, Mary Shortridge Arms, and Geraldine O'Quinn in atract known as 2C in the Subject Drilling Unit were in conflict and became subject to the escrow requirementsof the Pooling Order.

4.3 The Unit Operator's Miscellaneous Petition regarding Tract 2C, a copy of which is attached to and made a parthereof, states under oath that Harrison-Wyatt, LLC and the Applicants have entered into an agreement withregards to Tract 2C and that by the terms of'the agreements, the parties have entered into royalty splitagreements regarding this tract and escrow regarding these individual conflicting claims detailed herein, is nolonger required.

4.4 The Unit Operator gave notice to Harrison-%yatt, LLC and the applicants that the Board would consider itsdisbursement authorization at its hearing on March 17, 2009, and consider whether to: (1)amend the PoolingOrder to provide for the disbursement a portion of funds on deposit in the Escrow Account attributable to Tract2C as identified in the attached miscellaneous petition (2) delete the requirement that the Unit Operator placefuture royalties attributable to a portion of said Tract 2C and the interests of Applicants identjtfied in themiscellaneous petition in the Escrow Account, and (3) continue the escrow account under this docket numberbecause parties other than those seeking disbursement under this order are subject to continued payments in theescrow.

4.5 The Unit Operator filed the attached accounting (Exhibit A) for Subject Drilling Unit's Escrow Account withthe Board ("Accounting" ).

Findings:5,1.Va Code 45.1-361.22.5 provides:

The Board shall order payment ofprincipal and accrued interests, less escrow account fees, from the escrowaccount to conjlicting claimants within thirty days of receipt ofnotiPcati on of (i) a final decision ofa court ofcompetent jurisdiction adjudicating the ownership of coalbed methane gas as between them or (ii) anagreement among all claimants owning conflicting estates in the tracts in question or any undivided interesttherein. The amount to be paid to the conjlicting claimants shall be determined based on the percentage ofownership interest of the conflicting claimants as shown in the operator 's supplemental filing made part of thepooling order that established the escrow account, the operator 's records ofdeposits attributable to those tractsfor which funds are being requested, and the records of the escrow account for the coalbed methane gasdrilling unit. The interests ofany cotenants who have not enteredinto an agreement shall remain in the escrowaccount.

5.2 Applicant has certified and represented to the Board that:

(1) Hamson-Wyatt, LLC and Sue Edwards, Judy Fuller, James Price, Edgar Price Jr., Katherine Price Sears,

Mary Shortridge Arms, and Geraldine O'Quinn respectively, are the owners of the coal estate, gas and oil

acreage estate underlying VGOB Tract 2C of the Subject Drilling Unit;

(2) Net interests attributable and to be disbursed to Applicants are shown in Table 1

VGOB rt pproret/DisbursementVCMB 91-0430-0116-03dc -04

'Table 1

ITrart ZC (a Portion of/I

,nis bnrsement Table

}Total Remaming Acres in Escrow after disbursements -01 and -02!I

IDisbutsement Petition - 03

2C }118.A. /!cuts Hc!m, Suoccsso1's, 01 Assigns

v/I - Suc Edwards, 101 St. Andrews Drive, Bristroi, VA 24202

g /Judy Fuuer, 17391 Cleveland Road, Abingdon, VA 24211

J- Mary June Shornidg Arms, 24404 Green Springs Road, Abingdon, VA 24211

i I- Geraldine Crguinnr Rt. 1, Box 112,Vansant, VA 24656

f g }Harrison-wyatt, LLC, c/o Wyatt Buick Pontiac, P.G. Box 11000,Danville, VA 24543

}Disbmscment Pcbtion - 04!

I 2C I%'. A. Arms Heim, Successors, or Assigns

//Ir James C. Prioc; 208 Counny Meadows Circle; Bristol, TN 37620

g;-EdgarAllen Price Jr.;1034Mmnc ForkRoad; Duok, WV 25063

J[ - Kaihcrine Prie- Sears; PG Box 34; Mount Acbo WV 26679Iy

I 2CkIarrison-wyatt, LLC, c/o !tvyatt Buiok Pontiac, P.G. Box 11000,Danville, VA 24543

I i/12o f

f1/12o I

1/60

148

1/96

I

Acreage

hderes 1

in tlnii

24.O6O }

o.2ol f

0201 I

Qosf

0.401 f

2.81 I

0.501 I

o.2» I

o251f

1.00 I

Gwners s/o ofRcnlau!1ng

Escrowed Funds

54//666 I

so.o i.;so,o i.l

50.056I

so.o/. I

I

50.0'/sio I

50.0 ihf

50.0%}

50.08/sf

so.o%I

Q. ioo I

o.loof

1.0Q3 I

0.201 I

i

1.404 f

I

0.251f

o.125 I

0.125

Q.soi f

0.1830%}

0.1830%1

1.8305%}

0.3661sio}

2.5627 roI

0.4576%Io.2288"i

I

0.22880r'o, I

0.9152%

Spbt Fxtu!valent

Agrccmeni Disbursement

ro Acres

6. Relief Granted:

For the reasons set forth in Paragraph 4 and 5 above, and based upon the Accounting and Table 1 above, the EscrowAgent is ordered to, within 10 days of receipt of this executed order to disburse funds for the unit and applicantsdetailed in Table 1 above. Prior to this disbursement. the Escrow agent is to ensure a corrected one-time payment has

been made relative to an error in calculaflon and disbursement in VGOB-91-0430-0116-02, made on February 14,2008.

Exhibit E to the Pooling Order, showing owners subject to escrow, is deleted and replaced with the Exhibit E attachedto this order. Further, the Supplemental Order filed in this cause is hereby modified to delete the requirement thatpayments attributable to the conflicting coalbed methane gas ownership interests of those applicants indicated inTable 1 be deposited by the Unit Operator into the Escrow Account, and, because there are other owners subject toescrow under the Supplemental Order, the Escrow Agent is directed to continue the Escrow Account for SubjectDrilhng Unit. To the extent not speciflcally granted herein, any other or further relief is denied.

Conclusion:Therefore. the requested relief and all terms and provisions set forth above in Paragraph 6 above be and hereby aregranted and IT IS SO OR9KRED.

Anneals:Appeals of this Order are governed by the provisions of Va. Code g 45.1-361.9 which provides that any order ordecision of the Board may be appealed to the appropriate circuit court and that whenever a coal owner, coal operator,gas owner, gas operator, or operator of a gas storage field certificated by the State Corporation Commission is a partyin such action, the court shall hear such appeal de novo.

9. Effective Bate: This Order shall be effective on the date of its execution.

DONE AND EXECUTED tbi ~ rr sf day of/Czar. =rr2, 2009, by a majority of the Virginia Gas and Oii Board.

Bradley bert, ~C

DONE AND PERFORMED this / ~ day of,/BA/!d A, 2009, by an Order of this Board.

David E. Asbury Jr.,Principal Executive toVirginia Gas and Oil Boar

COMMONWEAI. TH OF VIRGIMA )COUNTY OF WASHINGTON )

Acknowledged on this ' day of ~, 2009, personally before me a notary public in and for theCommonwealth of Virginia, appeared Bradley C. Lambert, being duly sworn did depose and say that he is the Chairman ofthe Virginia Gas and Oil Board and 9avid E. Asbury Jr., being duly sworn did depose and say that he is Principal Executiveto the Staff of the Virginia Gas and Oil Board, that he executed the same and was authorized to do so.

My commission expires: 89/ 30 / 2009

Diane J. DavisNotary Public 8174394

BEFORE THK VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

PETITIONER: CNX Gas Company LLC

RELIEF SOUGHT: (1) DISBURSEMENT FROMESCROW REGARDING TRACT(S) a portion of 2C(2) AND AUTHORIZATION FOR DIRECTPAYMENT OF ROYALTIES

DIVISION OF GAS AND OILDOCKET NO: VGOB 91-0430-0116-03491-0430-0116-04 (Combined)

HEARING DATE: March 17,2009

DRILLING UNIT: AA-9

BUCHANAN COUNTY, VIRGINIA

MISCELLANEOUS PETITION

1. Petitioner and its counsel: Petitioner is CNX Gas Company LLC, 2481 John Nash Blvd. , Bluefield,West Virginia 24701. Petitioner's counsel is Mark A. Swartz, SLftfARTZ LAWf OFFI C:ES, PLLC. , 601 Sixth Avenue,Suite 201, P.O. Box 1808, St. Albans, WV 25177-1808.

2. Relief sought: (I ) the disbursement of escrowed funds heretofore deposited with the Board's EscrowAgent{s) attributable to a portion of Tract{s) 2C as depicted upon the annexed Exhibit A; and (2) authorization to beginpaying royalties directly to the parties to the royalty split between Harrison-Wyatt, LLC and Sue Edwa ds. Judy Fuller, MaryJune Shortridge Aiins. Geraldine O'Quinn, James C. Price. Edgar Allen Price, Jr. and Katherine Sears.

3. Legal Authoritv: Va. Code Ann. $ 45.1-361.I et ~se ., 4 VAC 25-160-140., and relevant Virginia Gasand Oil Board Orders ("Board" ) heretofore promulgated pursuant to law.

4. Tvne of well(s): Coalbed methane.

5. Factual basis for relief reauested: Harrison-Wyatt LLC and Sue Edwards, Judl Fuller, Mary JuneShortridge Arms. Geraldine O'Quinn, 1ames C. Price, Edgar Allen Price. Jr. and Katherine Sears, have entered into royaltysplit agreement(s). Said royalty split agreement{s) allows the Applicant and Designated Operator to pay royalties directly tothe persons identified in Exhibit EE annexed hereto and, further, specifies how said royalties are to be divided and paid.

correct.6. Attestation: The foregoing Petition to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief is true and

CNX GAS COMPANY LLCBY IT'S PROFESSIONAL MANAGERCNX ANY LLC, P

DLItv

Supervisors Company LLC

2481 John Nash Blvd.Bluefield, West Virginia 24701

CNX Gas Company LLCUNlT AA-9

Tract Identifications

Harrison —Wyatt, LLC (Big Axe Tr. 15) —All MineralsIsland Creek Coal Company/Consolidation Coal Company - Coal Below Tiller LeasedJewell Smokeless Coal Corporation —Coal Above Drainage LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC —Oil, Gas and CBM LeasedRoger Street —Surface1.03 acres 1.2875%

2A. Harrison —Wyatt, LLC (Big Axe Tr. 39) - CoalIsland Creek Coal Company/Consolidation Coal Company - Coai Below Tiller Seam LeasedJewetl Smokeless Coal Co'rporation - Coal Above Jawbone Seam LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC - CBM LeasedD. W. Price Heirs —Surface and All Minerals except CoalCNX Gas Company LLC - Oil, Gas and CBM Leased36.07 acres 45.0875%

2B. Harrison —Wyatt, LLC (Big Axe Tr. 39) - CoalIsland Creek Coal Company/Consolidation Coal Company - Coal Below Tiller Seam LeasedJeweil Smokeless Coal Corporation - Coal Above Jawbone Seam LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC - CBM LeasedRobert A. Rash —Surface and All Minerals except CoalCNX Gas Company LLC- Oil, Gas and CBM Leased"I 8.84 acres 23.5500%

2C. Harrison —Wyatt„LLC (Big Axe Tr. 39) - Coalisland Creek Coal Company/Consolidation Coal Company - Coal Below Tiller Seam LeasedJewell Smokeless Coal Corporation - Coal Above Jawbone Seam LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC - CBM LeasedW. A. Arms Heirs, Successors or Assigns —Surface and All Minerals except CoalCNX Gas Company LLC - Oil, Gas and CBM Leased (52.47%)24.06 acres 30.0?50%

Page1 of 1

September 'I 7, 2004

QQQPAN'f oxY UBA. INc.ADORESSDrtAwEPe 0, wcHt AkDr, YA r+++tWELL NAME f=BMf-~~ eFARM TRAQ' nota sxsr rrLEASE HO. ELEVATION eeefs.ee'ACRES ~Do Q UADRgjqGLE vaksanryCOUHTYauc+nk+k DISTRICT eorm n~REG, ENGINEER v~ REG HQ. res~

ICERT. I ANO SURVam 'CERT NO.

FILE NO. ORAWING NO.@ATE &~r-wo SCALE t - c~~

I This p I el ts . v' new apdatedThl ~ plot~le. Ie not hosed an a tatnecoor dlnate system established tor t ho arooe

the well loeatlon,

LO CA T IO N M A P

No "CBMI-'A'A & nWEL

Topog~icItude and loby border Il

CERTI

cation ofwelion United StatesMaps, scale I to 24,OOO, iat-gitude lines being representedes as shown.

ICATION ~0 ~E PLAT

I, th ~ andere tgned, hereby aertlfy lnatthis pl at ts correct to the t eet of my

know l ~ d

lnl erma neof the We

EXHtBlT A Rett I/tered Qptneer Itig Certtf led~Land Sara ar ia Cho~

Exhibit E

Unit AA-9

Docket ¹VGOB 91-0430-0116List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants that require escrow

Acres in UnitPercentof Unit

Tract ¹2A - 36.07 acres

COAL FEE OWNERSHIP

(1) Harrison-Wyatt, L.L.C. , Tr.22c/o Wyatt Buick PontiacP.O. Box 11000Danville, VA 24543

36.07 acres 45.0875%

OIL 6 GAS FEE OWNERSHIP

(1) D.W. PriceRt. 1 Box 403Midland, VA 22728

36.07 acres 45 Q875%

Tract ¹2C- 24.06 acres

COAL FEE OWNERSHIP


24.06 acres 30.0750%

OIL & GAS FEE OWNERSHIP

W. A. Arms Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

24.06 acres 30 0750%

(1) Florence Arms Coleman Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(b) Elmer Coleman Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(b.1) Wanda Coleman CookRt. 1 Box 393Castlewood, VA 24224

0.134 acres1/180 of 24.06 acres

0.1671%

(b.2) Larry E. ColemanRt. 1 Box 232Cleveland, VA 24225

0.134 acres1/180 of 24.Q6 acres

0.1671%

(a.3) Adam F. ColemanAddress Unknown

0.134 acres1/180 of 24.06 acres

0.1671%

(c) Thurman Coleman Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(c.1) Ruth Nuckles ColemanAddress Unknown

Life Estate Only

(c.2) Michael ColemanRt. 1 Box 682Pounding Mill, VA 24637

Q.201 acres1/120 of 24.06 acres

0.2506%

Page 1 of 4 Rev. 2/16/Q9

Exhibit E

Unit AA-9

Docket ¹VGOB 91-0430-0116List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants that require escrow

Acres in Unit

Percentof Unit

(c.3) Mildred ColemanPO Box 894Pounding Mill, VA 24637

0.201 acres1/120 of 24.06 acres

0 2506%

(d) Onie Coleman Jackson Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(d. 1) Betty Johnson McClanahanRt.2 Box 116A-1

The Plains, VA 22171

0.057 acres1/420 of 24.06 acres

0 0716%

(d.2) Helen Johnson Faulkner12860 Birch LaneBeaumont, TX 77706

Q.Q57 acres1/420 of 24.06 acres

0.0716%

(d.3) Blanche Johnson Dale6202 Parkview LaneClinton, MD 20735

0.057 acres1/420 of 24.06 acres

0.0716%

(d.4) Agnes Johnson Bartee6207 Upton PlaceClinton, MD 20735

0.057 acres1/420 of 24.06 acres

0.07160/o

(d.5) Douglas W. JohnsonRt. 1 Box 95-RMarshall, VA 22115

0.057 acres1/420 of 24.06 acres

0.0716%

(d.6) Phyllis Johnson l3urland

1911 Millerville Pilce

Lancaster, PA 17603

0.057 acres1/420 of 24.06 acres

0.0716%

(d.7) Kathryn Johnson Webb17687 Mooresville RoadMooresville, NC 28115

0.057 acres1/420 of 24.06 acres

0.0716%

(e) Lorene Coleman Lester8443 East Troy Urbana RoadCasstown, OH 45312

0.401 acres1/60 of 24.06 acres

0.5013%

(2) Gertie Arms Coleman Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a) Ed Coleman Price Heirs, l3evisees,Successors or Assigns

(a.1) Hurley Street Heirs, l3evisees,Successors or AssignsHeirs //l ddresses unknown


1.2531%

(3) Gusts Arms Coleman Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(h) Alva C. Coleman Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(h. 1) Alva Lee ColemanP.O. Box 252Grundy, VA 24614


Page 2 of 4

0.1566%

Rev. 2/16/09

Exhibit iE

Unit AA-9

Docket ffVGOB 91 0430-0118List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants that require escrow


(h.2) Angel Coleman Mullins

62Q Mountain Brook CircleStone Mountain, GA 30087

0.125 acres1/192 of 24.06 acres

0.1 566%

(4) James (Jim) Arms Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a) Nelson Arms1195 Dayton Drive

Warminster, PA 18974


0.8354%

(b) Virgie Arms Maynard625 Ellen RoadNewport News, VA 23605


0.8354%

(c) Mae Catherine Arms Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(c.1) Peter Jacobsen9612 27th Bay AvenueNorfolk, VA 23518


0.8354%

(6) John Arms Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a) Hulet ArmsP.O. Box 10QMelrose, OH 45861


0.8354%

(b) John Dorsie Arms7891 State Route 66Oakwood, OH 45873


0.8354%

(c) Ruby Pauline Arms Jenkins7849 Keys RoadMount Vernon, OH 43050


0.8354%

(7) Alice Arms Jackson Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a) Alice Mae Elliott

3449 Johnstown RoadCenterburg, OH 43011


1 .2531%

(b) John Jackson, II

2846 Vanetta RoadCenterburg, OH 43011


1.2531%

(8) Vince Arms Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(c) Juanita I. Arms Decl Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(c.1) John DealAcfdress Unknown (Life Estate Only)

Page 3 of 4 Rev. 2/1 6/09

Exniiit i=

Unit AA-9

Docket ¹VGOB 91-04304)116List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants that require escrow


(c.2) Martha irene Deal375 Huntington CircleAlphareth, GA 30201

0.201 acres1/120 of 24.06 acres

0.2506o/o

(c.3) William V. DeclBox 14Maxie, VA 24628

0.201 acres1/120 of 24.06 acres

0.2506o/o

(e) William (Billy) P. Arms Heirs, Devisees,Successofs ot AssIgns

(e.1) Wanda Arms, widow

P.O. Box 294Rosedale, VA 24280

0.401 acres'l/60 of 24.06 acres

0 5013o/o

(9) Slemp Arms Heirs, Devisees,Successors or A-signs

(a) Pauline Arms JesseePt.H Box 454Coeburn, VA 24230


0.8354'/o

(b) Donald Arms7679 Dr. Ralph Stanley Hwy

Coebum, VA 24230


0.S354'/o

(c) Jean Arms Mullins

Rt. H Box 454Coeburn, VA 24230


0.S354o/o

{10) Dock Arms Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a) Dessie Arms13200 Mallicote Drive

Abingdon, VA 24210


2.5063'/o

(12) Virgie Arms Osborne Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

{a) James Osborne2S413 Mansfield RoadDevince, OH 43512


0 5013o/o

{b) Ron Osborne43983 Upper ClearCadiz, OH 43907


0.5013o/o

(c) Bill Osborne1280 3 SpringsRussellville, TN 37860


0 5013ok

Page 4 of 4 Rev. 2/1 6/09

)1-

Exhibit EEUnit AA-9

Docket ¹VGOB 91-0430-0116List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants with Royalty Split Agreements

Acres in Unit

Percentof Unit

Percentof Escrow

Tract ¹2B- 18.84 acres

COAL FEE OWNERSHIP


18.84 acres 23.5500% Already

Disbursed


(1) Robert A. RashP.O. Box 614Tazeweli, VA 24651

18.84 acres 23.5500% Already

Disbursed

Tract «2C - 24.06 acres

COAL FEE OWNERSHIP


24.06 acres 30.0750%


W. A. Arms Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

24.06 acres 30.0750%

(1) Florence Arms Coleman Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a) Edmond M. (Bud) Coleman Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a.1) Sue Edwards101 St. Andrews DriveBristol, VA 24202

0.201 acres1/120 of 24.06 acres

0.2506% 0. 'I 830%(Previously

Requested)

(a.2) Judy Fuller

17391 Cleveland RoadAbingdon, VA 24211

0.201 acres1/1 20 of 24.06 acres

0 2506% 0.1830%(PreviouslyRequested)

(2) Gertie Arms Coleman Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(b) Edna Coleman Price Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(b.1) James C. Price2Q8 Country Meadows CircleBristol, TN 37620


0.6266% 0.4576%

(c) Edgar Alien Price, Sr. Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

Page 1 of 4 Rev. 2/16/09

Exhibit EEUnit AA-9

Docket ¹YGOB 914)430-0116List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants with Royalty Split Agreements

Acres in Unit

Percentof Unit

Percentof Escrow

(c.1) Edgar Allen Price, Jr.1034 Moore Fork RoadDuck, N/V 25063

Q.251 acres1/96 of 24.06 acres

0.3133% 0.2288%

(c.2) Katherine Price SearsP.O. Box 34Mount Nebo, N/V 26679


0 3133o/ 0.2288%

(3) Gusts Arms Coleman Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a) Gladys Coleman Blankenship Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a.1) Elmer James JacksonP.O. Box 145Vansant, VA 24656

0.028 acres1/864 of 24.06 acres

0.0348% Alreaoy

D!sbulrsed

(a.2) Ettie Mae Hill

P.Q. Box 134Grundy, VA 24614

0.028 acres1/864 of 24.06 acres

0.0348% Already

D,sbursed

(a.3) Paul JacksonP.O. Box 117Davenport, VA 24239

0.028 acres1/864 of 24.06 acres

0.0348% AI eadyD'sbui sed

(a.4) Agnes Hurley

Rt. 1 Box 392Vansant, VA 24656

0.028 acres1/864 of 24.06 acres

0.0348% AIi eadyD'soursed

(a.5) Linda Ruth GilbertRt. 1 Box 409Vansant, VA 24656

0.028 acres1/864 of 24.06 acres

0 0348% AIi eadvD sbursed

(a.6) Lois Kate BoydP.Q. Box 685Vansant, VA 24656

0.028 acres1/864 of 24.06 acres

0.0348% Al eadyDisbursed

(a.7) Ira Roger JacksonP.O. Box 1Q79Vansant, VA 24656


0.0348% AI. eadyDlsbuf sed

(a.8) Rhonda Renee GilbertP.O. Box 26Davenport, VA 24239

0.028 acres1/864 of 24.06 acres

0.0348% Alr adyD'sl'ursed

(a.9) Marshall Qdell Jackson Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a.9.1) Richard Jackson McHenry8545 Maineville RoadQrrville, OH 44667

0.014 acres1/1728 of 24.06 acres

0.0174% Alreadyisbursed

(a.9.2) Sally A. Hartzler7296 Apple Creek RoadSterling, OH 44276

0.014 acres1/1728 of 24.06 acres

0.0174% /. ir adyDisbursed

Page 2 of 4 Rev. 2/1 6/09

Exhibit EEUnit AA-9

Docket ffVGOB 91-04304116List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants with Royalty Split Agreements

Acres in Unit

Percentof Unit

Percentof Escrow

(b) Howard Coleman Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(b.1) Opal Coleman18988 I-18Continental, OH 45831


0.3133 /o Aliready

" 'Isbc!rsed

(c) Beatrice Coleman Owens Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(c.1) Burton Eugene OwensP.O. Box 1933Grundy, VA 24614

0.125 acres1/192 of 24.06 acres

0 1566/o Arr'eady

D Isbcll sed

(c.2) Darlene Owens Mullins

P.O. Box 228Rosedale, VA 24280

0.125 acres1/192 of 24.06 acres

0 1566o/o Already

DIsbcrl"sed

(d) Sadie Coleman Peters301 Falls StreetDefiance, OH 43512


0.3133'/o Al eadyD scUl seel

(e) Herman Coleman1417 Fairfax RoadBellevue, NE 68005


0.3133o/o Already

DlscUI sec!

(f) Mae Coleman Shortridge279 Ridgewood Drive

Lebanon, VA 24266


0.3133o/o Already' ' sbUI'seel

(g) Lucy Coleman Looney883 Woodbriar Drive

Lebanon, VA 24266


0.3133'/o AlreadyDisbursed

(5) Luis Arms Street Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a) Charlie E. Street19171 Stone Mountain RoadAbingdon, VA 24210


2.5063'/o Already

Disbursed

(8) Vince Arms Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a) Tivis A. Arms1209 West Madison StreetMayodan, NC 27027



(b) Kelsie Arms EastridgeRt. 1 Box 768Boomer, NC 28606


0.5013'/o Already

Disbursed

(d) Josh Vince ArmsRt.3 Box 316Grundy, VA 24614



(11) Howell Arms Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

Page 3 of 4 Rev. 2/1 6/09

) I1

Tract-by-Tract Escrow CalculationAccount Balances as of 12/31/08

Unit AA-9

VGOB 91-0430-0116-03& 91-0430-0116-04Acres Escrowed: 54.7666

Owners

Harrison-Wyatt, LLC —CoalW.A. Armes Heirs - 08GSue EdwardsJudy FullerJames C. PriceEdqar Allen Price, Jr.Katherine Price SearsMary June Shortridqe ArmsGeraldine O'Quinn

18.69662C 24.06

0.20050.20050.50130.25060.25062.00500.4010

1/1201/120

1/481/961/961/121/60

OwnerTract ¹ Acres Acres Interest

Total TractPercent

of Escrow

34.1387%

Owners'Percent of

Escrow (50%)17.0693%17.0693%0.1830%0.1830%0.4576%0.2288%0.2288%1.8305%0.3661%

AmountDue Owners$112,942.88

$19,278.61$19,278.61

$206.74$206.74$516.85$258.43$258.43

$2,067.41$413.48

bl4 05

Page1 of1

/ ~~'

Exhibit EEUnit AA-9

Docket ¹VGOB 91-0430-0116List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants with Royalty Split Agreements

Acres in Unit

Percentof Unit

Percentof Escrow

(a) Mary June Shortridge Arms24404 Green Springs Road

Abingdon, VA 24211


2.5063~/o 1.8305%(PreviouslyRequested)

(12) Virgie Arms Osborne Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(d) Delmar OsborneP.O. Box 2625Grundy, VA 24614

0.40'l acres1/60 of 24.Q6 acres

0.5013% Already

Discursed

(e) Geraldine O'Quinn

Rt. 1 Box 112Vansant, VA 24656

0.4Q1 acres1/60 of 24.06 acres

0.501 3~/o 0.3661%(PreviouslyRequested)

Page 4 of 4 Rev. 2/16/09

Documents

VIZ GIVING: BEFORE GAS AND OIL...Mar 17, 2009 · VIZ GIVING: BEFORE THK GAS AND OIL BOARD APPLICANTS: CNX Gas Company LLC on behalf of Harrison- Wyatt, L.L.C and Sue Edwards, Judy