Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    1/36

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    2/36

    Jul

    y 1998

    Vol

    26,

    No.7

    ONTENTS

    1 Straight & LevellEspie "Butch" Joyce

    lC News

    3 Ae romail

    4 From The EAAlWorthington

    Collection/John Underwood

    8 Cessna 140 Fuel Caps/Neal Wright

    11 Mystery PlanelH.G. Frautschy

    12 David Gay s PT-17 Stearm an!

    H.G. Frautschy

    17 Flight of an Angel/Pat Quinn

    21 A Handy Welding Table/

    H G Frautschy

    23 What Our Members

    Are Restoring/H.G. Frautschy

    26 Pass it to Buck/Buck Hilbert

    28 Calendar

    29 Welcome New Members

    30

    Membership Information/

    Classified Ads

    r ~ ~

    Page 23

    FRONT

    COVER The

    Grand Champion An

    t ique of

    the 1998 Sun

    'n

    Fun

    EAA

    Fly-In

    was

    David

    Gay's

    1943

    Boeing

    Stearman A75

    Nl,

    a PT-17

    finished

    in the

    bright

    colors

    of the

    U.S.

    Army Air Co rps. EM

    photo

    by

    Jim Koepnick, shot

    with a

    Conan EOS-l n equipped with an

    80-200mm

    lens. l tJJ sec. @ f20 on Fuji Sensia

    100 ASA slide film. EM Cessna 210 plane fiown by

    Bruce

    Moore.

    BACK COVER During the last half

    of

    the '30s, the aviation magazine

    Popular

    Aviation

    featured

    a series

    of

    full-color plates

    depicting squadron

    markings,

    in

    signia and civilian color schemes

    on

    their

    back

    cover.

    This

    p ate, from

    the

    Feb

    ruary

    1937 issue of

    the magazine,

    shows the

    rhyme

    and reason

    behind

    those

    colorful

    markings on Navy shipboard aircraft. The closely tr immed edges of the

    pla

    te

    are

    as

    the magazine was

    pr

    oduced.

    Copyright 1998 by the

    EM

    Antique/Classic Division Inc. A

    ll

    rights reserved.

    VINTAGE

    AIRPLANE

    (ISSN

    00916943)

    is

    published and owned

    exclusively

    by the

    EM Antique/Classic

    Dvision, Inc. of the E

    xperimental

    Aircraft

    Assoc

    iation and is published monthly at EM Aviation Center. 3000 Poberezny Rd

    P.O. Box

    3086, Oshkosh, Wisconsin 549033086.

    Periodicals Postage paid

    at

    Oshkosh

    ,WISConsin 54901

    and

    at additional mailing offices . The membership

    rate

    for

    EM

    Antique/Classic Dvision,

    tnc. is $27.00 for current

    EM

    members for 12 month period of which $18.00 is for the publication of VINTAGE AIRPLANE Membership is

    open

    to

    all

    who are interested in aviation.

    POSTMASTER

    : Send address

    changes to EM Antique/Classic

    Dvision,

    Inc., P O. Box

    3086, Oshkosh, W

    549033086. FOR

    E

    GN AN

    DAPO

    ADDR

    E

    SS

    ES- Please allow at

    least two

    months

    for

    delivery of

    VINTAGE

    AIRPLANE

    to

    foreign

    and

    APO addresses via surface

    mail.

    ADVERTISING - Antique/Classic Division does not

    guaran

    tee or endorse any product offered through the advertising.

    We

    invite

    constructive

    criticism and welcome any report of inferior merchandise obtained through our advertising so that corrective measures can be taken.

    EDITORiAl

    POLICY:

    Readers are encouraged to submit stories

    and

    photographs. Policy opinions

    expressed

    in articles are

    solely

    those of the

    authors. Responsibility for accuracy

    in

    reporting rests entirely with the contributor.

    No

    renumeration

    is

    made.

    Material should be sent to: Editor,

    VINTAGE

    AIRPLANE, P.O.

    Box 3086, Oshkosh, WI 54903

    -

    3086. Phone 920/4264800.

    The

    words

    EAA,

    ULTRALIGHT

    , FLY WITH THE FIRST

    TEAM

    , SPORT AVIATION , FOR THE LOVE OF

    FLYING

    and

    the logos of

    EAA, EAA

    tNTERNATIONAL

    CONVENTION

    ,

    EAA

    ANTIQUE/CLASSIC DIVISION,

    INTERNATIONAl

    AEROBATIC CLUB, WARBIRDS OF AMERICA

    are

    registered trademarks. THE

    EAA

    SKY SHOPPE

    and

    logos of the EAA AVIATION FOUNDATION , EAA ULTRALIGHT CONVENTION and

    EAA

    Air

    Venture

    are

    trademarks

    of

    the above associations and their use by

    any

    person other than he above association is

    strictly

    prohibited.

    EDITORIAL STAFF

    Publisher

    To m

    Poberezny

    Editor-in-Chief

    Jack Cox

    Editor

    Henry G.

    Fraut

    sc

    hy

    Managing

    Editor

    Golda Co x

    Computer

    Graphic

    Specialists

    Nancy

    Ha n

    son

    Olivia L.

    Phillip

    Pie

    rr

    e

    Katze

    Staff Photographers

    Jim

    Koepnic k LeeAnn Abrams

    Ke n Lic htenbe rg

    Advertising/Editorial

    ASSistant

    Isabelle W

    ske

    EAA ANTIQUE/CLASSIC DIVISION, INC.

    OFFICERS

    President

    Vice-President

    Espie

    "Butch' Joyce

    George Daubner

    P.O

    .

    Box 35584

    2448

    Lough Lone

    Greensboro, NC 27425 Hartford.

    WI

    53027

    910/393-0344

    414/673-5885

    Secretary

    Treasurer

    Steve

    Nesse

    Charles

    Harris

    2009

    Highland Ave.

    7215 East

    46th St.

    Albert Lea, MN

    56007

    Tulso

    .

    OK 74145

    flJ7/373-1674

    9 1 8 6 2 2 ~

    DIRECTORS

    John BerencU Gene Marris

    7645

    Echo Point

    Rd. 5936

    Steve Court

    Connon Falls, MN

    55009

    Roanoke, TX 76262

    flJ7/263-2 41 4 817/491-9110

    Phil Coulson

    Robert

    C. Bob' Brauer

    28415

    Springbrook

    Dr

    .

    9345

    S. Hoyne

    Lawton.

    MI

    49065

    Chica,W,

    IL60620

    616/624-6490

    312 79-2105

    Joe Dickey

    John

    S. Copeland

    55

    Ookey

    Av

    .

    1A Deocan Street

    Lawrenceburg, IN 47025

    Northborout, MA

    01532

    812/537-9354

    fIJ8/3

    3-4775

    Dale A. Gustafson

    Stan Gomoll

    7724 Shady Hill

    Dr

    .

    1042 90th Lone, NE

    Indianapolis,

    IN

    46278

    M i n n e o ~ l i s

    MN

    55434

    317/2934430

    61

    /784-1172

    Jeannie

    Hill

    1708 Bay Oaks r.

    P.O.

    Box 328

    Albert Lea. MN

    56007

    HOIVOld, IL60033

    flJ7/3732922

    815/9437205

    Dean Richardson Robert D. "Bob ' Lumley

    6701 Colony

    Dr.

    1265 South 124th St

    .

    Madison,

    WI

    53717 Brookfield, WI 53005

    tJJ8/833-

    1291 414/7822633

    Robert

    l i c k t e l ~

    S.H. 'Wes" Schmid Geoff Robison

    2359 Lefeber

    Avenue

    1521

    E.

    MacGregor

    Dr.

    Wauwatosa,

    WI

    53213 New Haven, IN 46774

    414/771-1545 219/493-4724

    George

    York

    181 Sloboda Av.

    Mansfield,

    OH 44906

    419/5294378

    DIRECTORS

    EMERITUS

    Gene Chase EE "Buck" Hilbert

    2159 Carlton Rd. P.O. Box 424

    Oshkosh.

    WI

    54904

    Union, IL60

    180

    920/231-5002 815/923-4591

    ADVISORS

    Steve Krog Roger Gomoll

    1002

    Heather Ln. 321-1/2 S.

    Broadway

    Hartford, WI

    53027

    Apt. 3

    414/96&7627

    Rochester, MN

    55904

    507288-2810

    Alan Shackleton

    David Bennett

    P.O.

    Box 656 403 Tonner Ct

    .

    SugOl

    Grove, IL60554.Q656

    Roseville

    . CA

    9567

    8

    630-466-4931

    916-7827025

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    3/36

    STRAIGHT

    LEVEL

    by ESPIE BUTCH JOYCE

    This is the last Vintage Airplane

    of you who are making the trip to

    year will read until after

    return home in August.

    When I listed the Judging Chairmen

    the June issue, there were a couple

    of

    would like to correct these

    now as I got several

    phone

    calls

    this error. You know the

    - wipes out a thou

    ." Our

    members

    do read

    cover to cover, and we get

    good and bad comments on a regu

    basis. The correct I

    isting

    of the

    Chailmen

    is

    as follows .

    Antique A wards:

    Dale Gustafson , Chairman

    317/293-4430

    Classic Awards:

    Dean Richardson, Chairman

    608/257-880 I

    Contemporary A wards:

    Richard Knutson, Chairman

    608/592-3712

    While writing about the Judging

    I would like

    pass along some information about

    of

    Spencer, Virginia.

    Pete

    was Co-Chairman of the

    An

    many

    years until his

    him not to be able to at

    Oshkosh any

    more.

    t

    had

    been

    since

    late' 50s. t was in the mid-sixties

    he began to show

    his

    talent for

    aircraft. At

    that

    time I was

    a Pitts

    SIC

    and Pete was build

    an EAA Biplane. We helped each

    in looking for parts and other

    - at that time homebuilts

    Also

    ,

    what

    we

    now call

    Classics

    modern aircraft, and I had not

    used

    a radio , since

    the

    red and

    lights

    worked

    fine.

    One of

    the

    projects I remember

    Pete doing is a

    Clipwing Monocoupe

    110

    Special

    that belonged to Morton

    Lester. Pete and Morton were cousins

    and resided in the same area, and these

    two people evolved into a team that was

    unmatched. Pete's craftsmanship com

    bined with Morton's ability to find and

    finance projects brought back many air

    craft from a premature grave for all to

    enjoy seeing again.

    After being ill for some time, Pete

    passed away during the second week

    of

    June. His talent, craftsmanship, and ad

    vice will be missed by many people

    in

    the future.

    During the 1998 edition

    of

    EAA Air

    Venture, because of the joint display of

    aircraft

    with the

    NBAA , we will

    not

    have a Parade of Flight this year. We

    will , however, have a number

    of

    activi

    ties you can take part in to add to your

    enjoyment.

    The Red Barn, located at the North

    end of the Antique/Classic area, is the fo-

    cal point to check out when an activity

    will take place and how you might

    be

    part of the fun. On the porch or inside

    the

    Mini-Museum

    is our

    information

    booth, where you can get just about every

    one of your questions answered. rf the

    people there do not know the answer ,

    they'll be able to direct you to a person

    who will be able to help with your con

    cern.

    If

    you would just like to sit on the

    tour tram and be carried throughout the

    showplanes with someone who can de

    scribe what you are seeing, we have that

    available for you from morning until the

    airshow begins.

    On Sunday night, August 2, we will

    have our annual Antique/Classic Picnic.

    Tickets for this scrumptious dinner can

    be purchased at the Red Bam. This

    is

    a

    good time for all , but there are a limited

    number of seats . Since the tickets sell

    very

    good

    , don't wait too long to pur

    chase yours.

    Once again this year

    we

    have the

    Antique

    /

    Classic Fly-Out

    to

    Shawano

    ,

    Wisconsin. As a pilot , you will be

    hosted to a free breakfast sponsored by

    the people

    of Shawano . You

    will

    be

    back at Oshkosh

    in

    time to be returned

    to your parking spot before the air show

    begins. This Fly-Out will be conducted

    on Monday, August

    3

    A first for us this year

    is

    the addition

    of

    a metal

    working demonstration

    ,

    hosted by a number of metal

    shaping

    experts. One

    of

    our expanded efforts to

    educate our membership, it will take

    place in the workshop tent located next

    to the Red Barn. They'll be demonstrat

    ing their skills , and at the same time

    explaining how you might be able to do

    the same yourself.

    We will again be running transporta

    tion from the first Antique/Classic row

    to the last one, row 140 or so. Last year

    we had almost 1,200 show aircraft in

    the Antique/Classic area alone

    All of the showplane camping area

    and most

    of

    the Antique/Classic

    area's

    layout will remain unchanged this year.

    There are a great many

    of

    changes to the

    other areas

    of

    the Convention site, so

    r

    would advise you to take time to look at

    a site map (it' s included

    in

    the Conven

    tion program which is available from the

    Telephone Pioneers of America volun

    teers). Check the map before walking a

    mile or so , only to find that your que st

    has been moved in a different direction

    When your day at Oshkosh needs

    some relaxation time,

    come

    join

    us at

    the Red

    Barn

    and relax on

    the porch

    .

    Once you have rested, it's a good time

    to shop in the merchandise section of

    the Red Bam.

    Anytime you have any concerns or

    need some help with a problem, please

    do not hesitate to ask for help at the Red

    Barn and

    we will do

    our best to

    help

    you. All of your Division Officers, Di

    rectors, Advisors, volunteers and myself

    want your

    stay with us to be a reward

    ing experience

    . You can

    lend

    your

    support to the membership during the

    rest

    of

    the

    year

    by

    asking your

    fellow

    pilots to

    join

    up with us .

    Let's

    all be

    safe out there - we want you to be able

    to

    continue

    to be a

    member

    for a long

    time. Let's all pull in the same direc

    tion for the good of aviation.

    Remember we are better together. Join

    us

    and have it all

    VINTAGE AIRPLANE

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    4/36

    A/C NEWS

    compiled

    by

    H G Frautschy

    PETERSEN MOVES!

    Norm

    Petersen, who's

    been

    an Associate

    Editor of

    EAA

    publications for 17 years, has

    moved

    within

    EAA to work full time with the

    EAA Information Services staff

    headed by Ben

    Owen.

    As

    anybody who

    has called

    or written

    Norm over the

    years

    can

    attest, he's long been

    a fountain of

    knowledge

    on the widely varying

    aspects

    of

    sport

    aviation,

    from

    homebuilding

    (he

    built

    his

    Starduster

    II N7NP

    back

    in

    the

    1970's)

    to float flying (when the next person

    on the staff

    gets

    their float

    rating,

    that'll make

    two float pilots

    on EAA's

    staffi).

    That doesn't mean that

    he's

    not

    going to ap

    pear in print any more

    (who

    else

    could write

    "Vintage Seaplanes"?), but

    it

    does mean that he

    will get to do one of the things he

    does

    best-

    interact on

    a daily basis

    with EAA members

    from across

    the

    world, helping them solve the

    questions that come up for each as they enter

    the world of sport aviation.

    We

    certainly

    wish Norm the best

    in

    his new

    endeavor, and

    we

    thank him

    for

    the

    thousands

    of words he's written to further the cause of

    vintage

    aviation

    .

    Great

    job so far,

    Norm!

    If you're looking for an elusive

    bit

    of

    info,

    or just

    need some help

    getting started

    on

    a

    restoration

    or

    homebuilt project,

    as

    an

    EAA

    and Antique /Classic member you

    can

    get the

    information

    you

    need from EAA's Informa

    tion Services. Want

    to

    know

    how

    you

    can

    have

    2" high

    registration

    numbers on your vin

    tage airplane? They'll cite

    you

    the FAR and

    head you in the right direction. It's just one of

    the

    many ways

    EAA stands ready

    to help

    you

    - give them a call,

    at

    1-920-426-4821, or

    -6761

    (Fax), or E-mail them

    at

    infoserv

    .eaa.org. You

    can even send them a letter via

    regular

    mail (!)

    at

    Information Services, EAA

    ,

    P.O.

    Box 3086,

    Oshkosh

    ,

    Wl 54903-3086.

    2 ULY 1998

    ELECT ION R

    EMINDER

    Don't forget

    to mail

    in

    your ballot for the

    election of officers and Directors of the

    EAA

    Antique

    /

    Classic Division. Included in

    the June

    issue, just tear it out, fill in

    the

    appropriate

    blanks

    and

    send it

    on

    its way with

    a stamp

    on

    it. To be

    counted,

    it must

    be

    received

    no

    later

    than

    July

    27, 1998.

    PARKlNG AT OSHKOSH?

    We'd all like to make a volunteer's job a

    lit

    tle easier as they stand in an orange vest directing

    a line of

    airplanes to the right spot

    for

    parking.

    You can

    do

    your part by making

    up

    a legible

    sign to

    hold

    up

    to the Flight Line Operations

    volunteers after you clear

    the

    runway at EAA

    AirVenture

    Oshkosh '98. If you're flying an

    Antique

    (built

    on or prior to August 3 ,

    1945)

    ,

    Classic

    1145

    through 12-55)

    or

    Contemporary

    (1955 through 1960) into the

    Convention,

    make

    up a

    sign that

    you

    can read

    from 50

    feet away

    (filling

    up an 8-112 x

    II

    sheet of

    paper

    would

    work

    well)

    with

    the

    letters "ACC" printed

    on

    it. Got

    a seaplane? SP .

    How

    about your

    buddy flying in with his

    Cherokee?

    GAC

    (General

    Aviation

    Camping)

    or

    GAP

    Gen

    eral Aviation

    Parking). Even the

    warbirds

    can

    do

    it

    -

    WB

    - as can the homebuilts -

    HR .

    NEED EAA AIRVENTURE INFO?

    If you're planning

    to attend

    EAA

    AirVen

    ture by

    flying

    in

    , you'll

    need to obtain

    a copy of

    the NOT AM issued by the FAA. The easiest

    way

    is to

    sinlply pull

    it

    out of the

    June

    issue of

    Sport

    Aviation

    -

    it is located between pages

    80

    and 81.

    You can

    also

    access

    it via EAA's "Fax

    On

    Demand" service. Call 732-885-6711

    and

    e

    ready

    to enter the

    Fax

    number you

    wish

    to

    have

    a copy of

    the Fax-On-Demand Directory sent

    to. Follow the

    voice

    prompts for your instruc

    tions. The NOT

    AM is also available on EAA

    AirVenture's website

    at http

    //www.flyin.org

    [fyou're

    planning on flying in no-radio,

    it

    is required you

    follow

    the

    NORDO proce

    dures exactly at this

    late

    date,

    you should get

    your copy

    as

    soon

    as

    possible.

    We

    strongly

    recommend

    you

    obtain your

    copy of the NOT AM as early as

    you can

    and

    familiarize

    yourself

    with the

    instructions. It's

    not hard

    to fly

    in, and many

    pilots consider it

    a

    lot of

    fun, but

    there are a

    lot

    of aircraft

    in

    bound

    to Oshkosh, and

    it

    helps knowing what

    you're

    supposed to

    be

    doing without having to

    rustle through the papers

    in the

    cockpit trying

    to find the

    NOT

    AM.

    Keep your eyes outside

    and follow

    the

    controller's directions, and

    we'll

    see you at EAA AirVenture

    Oshkosh!

    TYPE CLUB ADDITION

    Howard Aircraft

    Foundation

    P.O. Box 252,

    Volga, WV

    26238

    D

    ues: $15.00 per year

    Newsletter: 4 issues per year

    E-Mail: [email protected] or

    [email protected]

    We

    b p

    age

    :

    http://members.aol.com/HowardClub

    Submitted by:

    Dav

    id B.Schober, CPE

    Instructor,

    Aviation Maintenance

    Fairmont

    State College

    National Aerospace Education Center

    Rt. 3

    Box

    13, Bridgeport, WV 26330-9503

    (304)

    842-8300

    BARRY

    GOL

    D

    WATE

    R

    One of America's most ardent support of

    military

    and

    civilian aviation has passed

    away

    at

    the

    age of89. Barry

    Goldwater

    is

    known to

    most

    of the nation as the founder ofmodem

    day

    conservatism, an

    influence

    that continues

    after

    his

    death, but to

    EAAer's

    around

    the

    world,

    he

    is remembered for his

    love of

    aviation, and his

    willingness to put his enthusiasm

    into

    action

    .

    When asked, he enthusiastically added

    his

    efforts

    to

    EAA's "Wings

    On

    Dreams"

    cam

    paign, serving

    as the

    chairman of that

    fund

    raising

    drive that would result in the realiza

    tion and

    construction of

    the

    EAA Aviation

    Center in Oshkosh.

    Long

    respected

    for his

    views

    on aviation

    matters, he

    also served on

    EAA's President's Council. For EAA, his

    legacy lives

    on in

    the

    Goldwater Conference

    Center, which

    is

    decorated

    with

    plaques which

    feature half-shell model airplanes of many of

    the

    over 160 different aircraft, both civilian

    and military, he flew

    during

    his lifetime

    as a

    civilian aviator

    and

    in

    the

    military ,

    where

    he

    eventually rose to the

    rank

    of Major General in

    the

    Air

    Force Reserve.

    GEO RGE GRUNDY

    The

    name George Gundy may

    not leap to

    one's mind when pioneer aviation is talked

    about, but

    it

    may from now on, for

    George

    was

    the very last

    of

    his kind

    - he

    was the sole

    re

    maining Early Bird, having soloed prior to

    December 17,1916. George, the

    son of

    wealt

    hy

    New York family whose fortune

    was

    sufficient to allow the young Grundy the

    chance to dabble in just about anything his

    heart desired, took

    up

    flying

    as a

    sport while

    a

    teenager. He soloed

    a

    Benoist biplane on Sep

    tember 17, 1916, a short time after his 18th

    birthday. Last

    year, both

    he

    and

    fellow Early

    Bird Walter 1. Addems

    were

    presented

    with

    Early Bird pins which had

    been

    flown on the

    space shuttle Atlantis in the summer of 1997.

    Addems passed away this past November,

    making Grundy

    the

    last

    man in

    their last

    man's club." Grundy, who was 99

    years

    old

    at

    the time of his passing, had managed to

    survive

    the turbulent

    early

    days of

    aviation

    even

    though

    he

    had done some airshow wing walking

    , as

    well

    as instructing

    at

    his father

    's

    "Staten Island

    School ofAviation" (his dad never showed any

    interest in

    aviation,

    preferring

    to run

    various

    businesses rather than

    run

    an engine). Aviation

    was a youthful avocation

    for

    Grundy, who

    moved

    on

    to other things, remaining a busi

    nessman

    until

    his retirement to Florida.

    ....

    http:///reader/full/infoserv.eaa.orghttp:///reader/full/infoserv.eaa.orghttp:///reader/full/infoserv.eaa.orghttp:///reader/full/http//www.flyin.orghttp:///reader/full/http//www.flyin.orghttp:///reader/full/http//www.flyin.orgmailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://members.aol.com/HowardClubhttp:///reader/full/infoserv.eaa.orghttp:///reader/full/http//www.flyin.orgmailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://members.aol.com/HowardClub
  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    5/36

    FRANCE AFTER THE

    GREAT

    WAR

    This is a rather belated answer to Re

    Clark s letter and photo of an

    ne factory in France during

    1

    See page 4, March issue) .

    The building containing all the air

    is

    not a factory.

    t

    is part

    of

    the

    iant U.S. Army Air Service Production

    at Romorantin, France. The

    was taken after the war, when hun

    of

    French and German warplanes

    ssembled and stored for ship

    to

    the U.

    S.

    With the exception

    of

    Fokker D.V

    II s,

    over 100 SPAD

    , 204 S.E.5 s and SA s,

    43

    Nieu

    24 s

    and 20

    Nieuport

    28

    s, relatively

    of

    these got to the U.S., much less

    up and flown here .

    The photo is one

    of

    quite a few offi

    taken

    of

    the interior

    of

    the

    reduced to post

    size and could be bought in the Post

    of

    these have

    up in various photo collections as

    ly albums. I have a few , and

    ab

    le

    to

    borrow others

    to

    copy .

    Enclosed are three different views that

    interest Vintage Airplane readers.

    To comment on

    Ms

    . Clark

    s

    photo

    right front, the airplanes

    built British Sopwith 1-1 /2

    The French unloaded just over

    of

    these obsolescent two-seaters on

    A.E.F. Nearly 70 got shipped to the

    The fourth plane, judging from its

    is a French

    14 . Those farther down the line

    to be

    Nieuports.

    Sincerely,

    Peter M. Bowers

    EAA 977, AlC

    758

    Seattle, WA

    Continued

    on page -

    This

    view shows most of the factory-new

    that were shipped to the U.S.

    dozen

    were

    used

    at McCook Field for test

    new

    engines

    up to

    300

    hp.

    Others went

    Army

    flying schools in

    Texas

    while

    some

    were

    Squadrons as

    backup for the

    XIII s and S.E.S s wi th which they were

    served as

    squadron hacks.

    VINTAGE

    AeroMail

    (Right) This could be a

    view across

    the

    aisle

    from Ms. Clarks photo.

    The plane front

    left

    is

    another 1-1/ 2 Strutter,

    and i ts

    rudder

    , with

    French stripes and let

    tering, is

    on

    the ground

    under its

    nose

    .

    The

    next

    four are

    Nieuport 24s.

    Three

    of

    their rudders

    have

    stripes

    in

    the American

    order, with the blue

    at

    the trailing

    edge . The

    rudder on the fourth

    Nieuport has the stripes

    in the French order; red

    at the trailing edge. Father down the line, under an unidentiflable model, is a rudder with stripes

    in

    the

    erroneous and little-used American stripe order of red

    at

    the trailing edge blue, and white at the front.

    VINTAGE

    AIRPLANE

    3

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    6/36

    e orthin

    by

    JOHN UNDERWOOD

    EAA

    1989 C

    1653)

    In 1976

    the

    EAA Aviation

    Foundation was given a collec-

    tion ofglass

    plate

    negatives by

    W L Worthington EAA 100415)

    of Inglewood, CA. The photog-

    rapher is unknown but we do

    know he worked

    for

    the promi-

    nent

    Packard

    dealer, in

    Los

    Angeles, Earle C. Anthony. An-

    thony was a pioneering motorist,

    who built

    his

    own car as a

    teenager, circa 1900. It is said

    he was involved in the first auto-

    mobile accident in Los Angeles

    He later owned radio and televi-

    sion stations. The photographer

    was tasked with showing

    off

    the

    Pa

    cka rds in the best light, and

    that often meant combining avi-

    ation and the autos.

    Noted

    aviation writer John

    Underwood has lived

    in th

    e Los

    Angeles area

    for

    many

    years

    and has had an

    interest

    in

    the

    aviation

    history Southern

    California, long a hotbed ofavi-

    ation activity. We asked him to

    look over the collection and fill

    in

    details he may have regarding

    the peo

    pl

    e or airplanes shown in

    the photos. Thanks for your help,

    John

    HG F

    (Left)

    Cactus

    Kate's Kid , a Packard Eight

    painted rather loudly, shows

    up

    in a few of the

    photos taken at Burbank. On the right is

    John

    Macready, one of the Shell 11 pilots under Jimmy

    Doolittle.

    The

    Lockheed Vega, NC926Y, ended

    up in the Lithuanian Air Force following

    its

    hitch

    as Shell

    No.4.

    (Lower left) The Lockheed assembly hangar at

    Burbank, CA. That's not a Russian 6-wheeler with

    the red star, but a

    Ford

    Model A

    2 Ton

    truck. The

    same vehicle was built in Russia from 1929

    onward Into

    WW

    -II.

    (Below) Lockheed Vega SIN 24, NC194E, after

    being repossessed from Brock & Schlee, who

    operated

    an

    airline out of Detroit (on floats). It

    crashed

    soon

    after this picture was taken, with

    fatal results.

    4

    JULY

    1998

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    7/36

    Pictures on this page This Vega 5,

    C744

    was

    another rock

    and

    The automobile is a

    ackard Sport Roadster.

    The

    photo

    ust

    have been

    taken

    in

    929

    ecause the Vega was

    written off early

    that

    year. There are no license

    on

    the Packard, and the two

    remain

    unknown

    VINTAGE AIRPLANE 5

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    8/36

    (Above and right)

    We ve published these photos in the past,

    but they certainly deserve another look.

    Everybody

    loved

    Marvel Crosson.

    She helped

    her

    brother

    Joe run

    a garage in

    San

    Diego so

    he

    could take time off to learn to fly.

    Then

    Joe taught Marvel in 1923-1924. She

    held

    a

    Commercial

    Pilot

    s

    license

    and

    flew

    in

    Alaska before entering the

    first

    Womens

    Transcontinental Air Derby becoming a fatali

    ty on the

    second

    leg,

    probably

    due to carbon

    monoxide poisoning.

    The

    Viking Sedan auto

    mobile

    was

    close kin to the Olds and

    LaSalle

    but only lasted the 1929-30 seasons.

    The

    Travel

    Air must

    be one

    of the

    San Diego

    Air

    Service s W 40005. This was a very rare

    model and

    the SDAS

    had

    a fleet of them.

    Joe

    later became a

    Pan

    American executive.

    (Right and below) Herb Lippiatt, (in helmet,

    gog-

    gles

    and

    lace-up flying boots) with his first Travel

    Air 4000,

    powered

    with a Wright 14

    Lipp

    became

    the Los Angeles area distributor for Travel Air

    before switching to

    Waco. He was

    outstandingly

    successful in aircraft sales and

    had

    the

    Cessna

    line in 1947

    when he

    died suddenly. Most likely

    these photos were taken at the old Clover Field

    in Santa Monica.

    6 JULY1998

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    9/36

    (Photos on this page) Center stage

    In this series of shots Is Ryan B-5

    Brougham NC73 M . This airplane

    belonged

    to

    Ted

    Glldred, Sr., of

    San

    Diego, C and

    It

    's the one he flew

    to

    Ecuador with Dean Farran in March

    April 1931. A similar 8-5, painted in

    the same markings, is on display In

    the San Diego Aerospace museum in

    Balboa Park. The original airplane

    was named Ecuador. The Glldreds

    had

    business Interests in South

    America, Including the Culver Cadet

    agency in

    Peru

    .

    VINTAGE

    IRPL NE

    7

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    10/36

    "JUSTLITTLE TRIP

    AR

    OUND

    THE

    PATCH"

    by

    NEAL

    F. WRIGHT,

    Cessna 120/140

    Club

    THE G S

    C P

    STORY

    One

    of

    our Cessna 12 14 club members and an associ

    ate had the exciting and traditional

    moment of

    terror" n his

    Cessna 140. The plane, fully fueled and going for its first

    flight after an electronics addition at a remote foothill air

    port, was being flown off a field which had a

    cliff

    at the end,

    with the town below some several hundreds

    of

    feet. Just off

    the end

    of

    the runway, near the edge of the cliff, the engine

    quit. After the pilot did all the recommended things, the en

    gine caught just above the power poles along the streets. A

    climb

    and

    a safe

    landing from

    a very

    high downwind

    was made.

    Knowing that stopped engines often mean fuel starvation,

    the FBO removed the gas caps in turn and when the brand

    new half-vented gas cap on

    the right tank

    was removed,

    a

    moaning sigh was apparent to all the bystanders- the tank

    apparently had not been

    vented

    during the

    exciting

    half

    of

    the flight. A vacuum developed as the fuel

    was

    used until

    vacuum and the hydraulic head of fue l were equal, meaning

    no more flow. Fortunately, there was only one of the new

    half-vented gas caps on the plane and the emergency switch

    over to the norn1ally-vented tank allowed fu ll fuel flow and

    recovery before the lower elevation landing that seemed so

    imminent only lifetime-long moments before.

    Upon

    inspec

    tion

    of

    the new cap, t was noted that the red silicone "valve"

    of

    the new-style gas cap had adhered to its seat and had not

    allowed any air to flow into the tank.

    The

    red silicone valve

    of

    the gas cap should not have sealed to its seat, but it had

    and could on others.

    The new half-vented cap had been a mandated addition at

    the recent annual, supposedly to comply with the Airworthi

    ness Directive 79-10-14 rl (referred to as the AD from here

    on)

    . The big town

    prominent and well-paid FBO

    A I

    had

    been

    adamant

    ... buy the new gas cap and install it or we

    won't sign off the plane What the "expert" missed was that

    the cap should only be used on l40A and subsequent Cessnas,

    not on the older 120s and 140s. There was no admonishment

    n the AD nor was there any literature from the gas cap man

    ufacturer about the risk

    of

    using the caps on

    other

    types

    of

    planes. These participants

    weren't

    the first or the last to be

    misled since the half-vented cap continues to be misused to

    this day,

    and

    there

    are

    120s

    and

    140s

    out

    there

    at

    serious

    risk right now.

    Every time this event of loss

    of

    power and the quick de

    scent is discussed ,

    someone

    mentions that

    if

    the plane had

    landed

    or

    crashed in the street, it would have been

    another

    accident totted up to pilot

    error

    because, by the time the

    FAAINTSB fellows did their thing, the tank with the stuck

    valve would have been bent-vented by a

    power

    pole in the

    street. Since planes built during the same as the 12 14 period

    shared common

    small parts

    like

    gas caps,

    it

    seems

    likely

    that other types

    of

    planes may now have the same potential

    for stoppages

    if

    the owners have purchased the half-vented

    caps without knowing their hidden dangers. And yes, even

    the Cessna dealers will sell you the wrong caps because they

    know that all those little planes are the same". The half

    vented" cap looks like this:

    Air Inlet Port 3)

    Allen Head Screw

    Gasket

    i I I I I I ' _ i i i l l l _ i i i i i l l l l l . ~

    Retainer Cap Body

    Polyethylene

    Lugs (2)

    Spring Washer

    Silicone

    Valve Holder

    8 JULY 998

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    11/36

    This

    text refers to a half-vented

    gas cap

    though that term will

    not be found

    elsewhere;

    I

    use that

    name

    because that

    is

    what

    it

    does

    and no other name so descriptive has appeared in

    the research.

    It is

    half-vented

    in that

    it

    is supposed

    to

    allow air inflow

    to

    the

    tank,

    but prevents

    any

    outflow

    of

    air or fumes or even

    fuel if

    the

    fuel

    ex

    pands from

    heat.

    It is a nicely designed unit , looks good,

    and the

    culprit

    model appears about

    like

    the

    illustration

    above suggests.

    Why was the

    gas cap designed to be half-vented? The

    140A

    and later Cessnas have three features which our older planes

    lacked: I) a forward-facing tank vent

    on

    top o

    the wing,

    2)

    a

    juncture ofthis common vent

    to

    a tub e running between tanks

    to

    allow sharing

    the

    common vent, plu s

    3)

    non-ve nted gas caps

    on

    both tanks. Vent blockages occurred

    on

    the newer planes, fuel

    stoppages occurred, and

    th

    at

    led

    to

    the AD for the

    Cessna planes

    starting with

    the 140A.

    Properly

    used

    on the designated planes,

    the

    cure mandated by

    the

    AD

    would

    provide an alternate

    path for inflow

    of

    air as

    fuel

    is

    used even

    if

    the

    common external vent has a blockage. Mandating

    only one new cap instead

    of

    two was

    based on

    the

    premise

    that,

    i

    one

    blockage

    was

    possible

    but

    unlikely, then

    two

    vents (the

    new

    half-vent cap and

    the

    original common vent) would surely

    make

    a

    blockage statistica

    ll

    y

    imposs

    ible. The problem outlined here

    is

    not a complaint of

    poor design

    ,

    but

    rather of

    the

    misapplication of

    the

    half-vented caps. They sho uld not be us

    ed on

    airplanes suc h

    as our Cessna 1201140 s which depend on full-vented caps.

    The

    Airworthiness directive 79-10-14 rI states (paraphrased)

    ...To

    provide an alternate source o fuel tank venting in case

    of.. .vent obstruction

    by

    foreign material. This can

    be

    accom

    plished by the

    new half-vented

    (my word) fuel caps

    .

    There

    is no diagram in

    the

    AD

    show

    ing the

    vent

    systems, either

    before or

    after

    the modification. In hindsight

    ,

    based on

    the

    misuse

    ofthe half-venting

    caps, it

    is unfortunate that

    the AD did

    not note

    the half-vent

    feature,

    it

    did

    not show a system , and it contained

    no

    admonishments about not using the gas cap for a type

    o

    sys

    tem

    which was

    not

    made for

    it

    and

    could be vent-strangled

    by

    it.

    Do you see

    the

    trap? It is made up o three things: a) the

    new

    mandated

    gas

    caps were

    half-vented,

    which means

    that

    they will

    let air in

    ,

    given that the valve in them is

    faultless,

    but they will not

    let air or fumes or expandingfilel out, one of those little things

    the fails t mention; b)

    the

    gas caps are supposed

    to

    be used

    only on the 140As

    of

    our group, plus all

    other Cessnas

    that have

    a

    common fuel vent, but that

    was not

    made crystal clear either by

    the

    AD

    or

    the

    manufacturer of

    the

    cap

    or

    the

    STC for the caps

    or

    the

    distributors and dealers; and c)

    Cessna

    owners

    are

    unaware of

    the

    hazard so they blithely assume the new caps must be better

    than the old ones, and , if they are good for the 140As, they must

    therefore be okay

    for the 120s and the 140

    s'

    When

    misapplied,

    with or without having a stuck silicone

    valve

    , pilots

    and tanks are

    at risk.

    Here 's what the vented and non

    vented cap looks

    like

    The original cap

    (top)

    for the

    Cessna 120s

    and

    140s look

    some

    thing like this, with the two vent holes

    providing air inflow or fume outflow

    without restriction.

    They are

    both

    way vents since fumes can

    exit

    and

    air can enter without any valve inter

    fering. The non-vented cap (bottom)

    looks identical,

    but without the vent

    holes, only weld bumps which secure

    the inner cap to the outer cap.

    The half-vented cap sectioned, indicating the free flow of

    fumes or air i f the silicone valve is removed.

    The important part of the

    cap showing

    the

    silicone

    valve is shown as

    though it

    has two

    wings, but

    really

    is round.

    The same view, but with the silicone valve in the closed po

    Sition, as

    it

    would be

    if

    the pressure on the tank side is the

    same or greater than the pressure outside the tank. The air

    flow,

    of

    course, is shown halted. Not only fumes can t get

    out, but fuel

    can't get

    out

    if it happens to ex

    pand from being heated

    by the sun.

    If the 120/140

    takes off on the left tank,

    and if the right tank has

    the half-vent cap, then

    there

    is

    a hazard

    if

    the

    pressure

    builds up

    as

    the alti tude increases

    This greatly expanded view shows what the silicone valve

    looks like.

    The material and

    shape of the valve ensure

    the valve is pliable so as to open easily. The valve is 5/8

    in diameter.

    VINTAGE

    AIRPLANE

    9

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    12/36

    These

    half-vented

    caps

    should never be used on

    a

    plane

    that was

    designed to be dependent upon the

    through-hole , two-way venting, individual gas caps A

    hot sun, a full tank, a long wait between flights, and some

    of

    the new fue l

    which

    sme lls so odd and gums so we ll can

    cause grief.

    If

    the tanks on our 120s and 140s can ' t get air in

    when they need it to replace the fuel volume depleted when

    flying because the silicone valve sticks to its seat, then that

    is one hazard, and another hazard exists when the plane

    with the new cap is heated by the sun . With a half-vented

    cap installed, the effect

    of

    the force

    of

    the expansion

    of

    the

    fuel, and the fumes within, should be quite a sight to behold

    when the fumes or fuel can t get out, as would also be the

    case simply from altitude-induced pressure differentials .

    The

    tanks and the wings and the fuel system

    downstream

    can suffer extreme trauma from the pressure Remember

    These half-vented caps are designed to only let air in, and

    nothing out. The greater the pressure from the inside, the

    tighter a seal the silicone va lve will make. (Since this was

    written, I have heard from 12 11 40 owners who now under

    stood why their sealed tanks bulged and/or leaked with the

    half-vented caps )

    Systems

    The AD had no diagrams, as though written by someone

    who did not really understand what he was describing, or

    maybe there were too many variations to cover properly;

    here, note the "normal" 1201140 early and late versions and

    the "normal" 140A fuel systems and then take a look at the

    expected action

    of

    the half-vented gas caps. To make the

    systems simpler, items such as drain cocks and gas gauges

    are not depicted.

    The

    early Cessna

    120 140

    version of the fuel system. Note

    that

    if

    one tank cap inlet vent is blocked, as happened with

    the 140 mentioned in the beginning

    of

    this article, there is no

    other source of inlet air to replace the volume of fuel used.

    Note,

    too

    that

    if

    a tank vent is

    outflow

    blocked, there is no

    way for internal tank pressure from solar heating to escape

    so the tank will have to bulge; the half-vented caps are that

    style. They prevent any outflow of air, fumes or fuel and are

    meant

    to allow only inflow, and that only if the silicone valve

    doesn t stick

    The later 120/140s had a tank- to-tank vent tube added as

    this sketch indicates. In the event one gas cap was blocked ,

    both tanks could still vent in both directions.

    The as-designed Cessna 140A fuel system, again simplified

    and stylized

    to

    show only that there

    is

    a tank vent and no-vent

    caps. If the single vent is blocked by a hornet's nest or ice,

    there is no way to get fuel out of either tank after a vacuum de

    velops from fuel outflow. Venting was totally dependent on the

    single, top of the wing common vent.

    The Cessna 140A tank system with the AID mandated re

    dundant half-vented gas cap installed. The new cap allows

    air inflow as the fuel is used in the event the central vent is

    blocked.

    Otherwise,

    the tanks

    breathe

    just

    as in

    the

    older

    120/140s. Note that if the central vent is blocked, there is

    danger of tank pressurization for a plane

    on

    the ground.

    Continued

    on p ge

    -

    10 ULY 1998

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    13/36

    ulyMystery Plane

    I

    pril

    Mystery

    Plane

    t seems a lot

    of

    you remembered this

    good looking cabinjob from before WW-II.

    Supplied by James Rezich, Winnebago, IL,

    it

    is ... well, I'll let Charley Hayes

    tell

    you ...

    Hi

    H.G.,

    Something supernatural says

    surely

    the April Mystery Plane is the

    one ofa-

    kind Wendt.

    Charley Hayes

    New Lenox, IL

    Here' s what Ralph Nortell, Spokane,

    WA

    wrote:

    The Mystery Plane for April is the

    Wendt

    W-1 , Series 400 monoplane. Introduced in

    Aero Digestfor Feb. 1938, the Wendt W-1

    was described as a two-place, dual-con

    trol monoplane ofconventional design

    and structure. Power was a 90 hp Warner

    Scarab Jr . , and

    performance

    figures

    listed were: high speed, 140 mph, cruise,

    125, landing speed, 30; and a range of

    600 miles. The trim proportions included a

    span of29'9 , and a length of19'9 .

    Western Flying

    Annual

    Directory of

    April,

    1939

    lists the Wendt as the Fal

    coner

    W-2

    Series 400.

    The

    only apparent

    significant change was a new wing o

    NACA airfoil section,

    in

    place

    of

    the orig

    inal Clark Y

    Aero Digest Annual Directory ofMarch,

    1940 lists the Wendt as the Swift W-2 , now

    powered by a Ken Royce/LeBlond 5-F

    of

    90

    hp.

    No other significant changes were

    indicated.

    As

    there are no later listings,

    the Wendt apparently faded out with other

    promising aircraft o the

    period

    with

    ATC Pending.

    The Wendt W was designed and built

    by

    the Wendt Aircraft

    Corp

    ., North

    Tonawanda, NY. President and Treasurer

    was George W. Wendt; Sales Manager,

    George Contant; V.P .l

    Secretary

    Kopf;

    General Manager, Robert Klimas.

    Unfortunately, we didn't receive word

    as to its final disposition, but it did prove

    From Brian Baker comes

    this month's Mystery Plane

    which does look a bit like

    our

    answer

    plane this

    time - but it is different

    Your answer

    needs

    to

    be

    in

    to

    EAA HQ no

    later

    than

    August 25

    1998

    for inclu-

    sion

    in

    the October

    issue of

    Vintage Airplane.

    by

    H G

    Frautschy

    to be one-of-a-kind. We hope to dig up

    more

    on the

    Wendt,

    and

    when

    we do,

    we ll

    do an article on the airplane else

    where in the magazine, where more space

    will allow a more in depth feature.

    Correct answers were received from:

    Robert Nelson, Bismark, ND and David

    M. Albright, Cincinnati, OH, who both

    sent in a copy

    of

    the factory brochure;

    Marty Eisenmann, Alta Lorna, CA; Larry

    Beidleman, Granada Hills, CA;

    Peter

    Havriluk, Granby, CT;

    Archie

    Block,

    Cozad, NE; Charles Trask, York Haven,

    PA; Ted Giltner, Tamaqua, PA; William

    Knox, Woodstock, GA; James B. Hays,

    Brownwood, TX; Doug Rounds, Zebu

    lon, GA; Ken Muxlow, Minneapolis, MN

    WendtW-l

    and Russ Brown, Lyndhurst, OH.

    Earl Leverentz, Jackson, TN also sent

    in

    a response, and a big surprise-he has

    most

    of

    the drawings for a Wendt W-2

    Swift, and is nearly complete with its con

    struction! We'll have more on the Wendt

    and

    this

    project in a

    future issue

    of

    Vintage Airplane.

    Send

    your Mystery Plane correspon

    dence to:

    Vintage Mystery Plane

    EAA

    P.O. Box 3086

    Oshkosh,

    WI

    54903-3086

    . . .

    VINT GE AIRPLANE

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    14/36

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    15/36

    aving

    an

    eye

    for

    esthetically pleas

    ing lines has long been a part

    of

    the life of David Gay (EAA

    397118

    AlC

    20291), Orlando, FL. One

    of

    the

    principles of Gay and Morrissey Archi

    tectural Group

    in

    Winter Park,

    he

    and his

    partner

    are

    one

    of

    the featured architects

    in

    Disney's planned community, Celebration.

    The flowing lines

    of

    an airplane have

    also been a strong part

    of

    his life since

    he

    was a youngster. His photo album for

    the

    Stearman

    starts

    off

    with

    a

    shot of

    Dave as a proud fifth grader, holding his

    new Carl Goldberg

    2A

    Skylane. Al

    ways busy with his hands ,

    David s

    late

    father Jerry, bought him and his brother

    Jerry a table saw when Dave was seven

    years old. He was given plans for

    an

    8

    ft

    .

    long rowboat and the plywood to build

    it

    for his eighth birthday. Dave gives a lot

    of

    credit

    to

    his dad for taking the time to

    carefully show the boys how to use the

    tools correctly and work with a wide va

    riety of materials.

    Dave built surfboards during his col

    lege years to earn money, and he and

    his

    brother Jerry

    restored an

    Aeronca

    Jim Koepnick

    7EC Champ when they were teenagers.

    He s

    also built a few houses along the

    way as well.

    Amazingly , this is only his second

    aircraft restoration. He s owned a Super

    Cub and

    a

    Husky since restoring the

    Champ, and 7 years ago he went for a

    ride in a Stearman at Bob White Field.

    When

    he

    got

    in

    the cockpit, the pilot said

    to him, "This is probably going to be an

    expensive ride for you." He was right

    In October of

    1993

    Dave bought

    a

    project from Mike Danforth, who had re

    cently purchased a basketcase to get a

    few

    parts

    he

    needed

    for repairs.

    Mike

    had been involved in a mid-air collision,

    which fortunately didn't result

    in

    serious

    injury . But his Stearman needed repair

    ing , and the

    rest of

    it

    was

    available.

    David spent the next couple of months

    simply sorting out the parts and pieces

    of

    seven wings (all rotten,

    but

    with good

    hardware) a very good fuselage (it had

    been cut for the duster modification, but

    was hung up

    in

    '47 and never completed)

    and all sorts

    of

    other miscellaneous parts.

    Dave took the fuselage to Jim Kimball's

    shop

    in

    Zellwood, FL, where Jim did the

    welding to return the fuselage back to its

    original configuration. After sandblast

    ing, a coat

    of

    epoxy primer, followed by

    a topcoat

    of

    urethane paint

    in

    the appro

    priate

    shade

    of green

    to

    duplicate

    the

    look

    of

    zinc chromate.

    Dave s philosophy on tackling the

    project was similar to any large project

    that can be intimidating. Break

    it

    up into

    a series

    of smaller

    projects, finishing

    each one and then moving on to the next.

    Each one became a two-week project, or

    whatever it called for. The landing gear

    seemed like a good place to start, so he

    had

    it taken apart by Joe Wright

    in

    Hamilton, OH, who had the fixture and

    hydraulic press needed to disassemble the

    struts. The parts then went back

    to

    David,

    who reworked the oleo struts and put

    in

    a

    new set

    of

    chevron

    seals. The

    brakes

    were next, with a used set

    of

    Hayes brakes

    getting replacement pads, and the slave

    cylinders

    getting

    replaced

    with over-

    hauled units. The brake master cylinder

    is

    one

    of

    the "new-restored" made by Gid

    Air, with the original housing used in

    VINTAGE IRPL NE 3

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    16/36 4 ULY 998

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    17/36

    Far

    left)

    The

    moming after the awards ceremo-

    ny, David

    Gay

    is all smiles

    as

    he

    proudly holds

    the 1998

    Sun

    'n Fun Antique

    Grand

    Champion.

    Above) With

    the

    side panels

    lifted the

    Stearman

    is

    a great example of

    an

    early military

    airplane designed for easier maintainability) the

    cockpit controls and firewall forward equipment

    can be seen.

    All of the green paint

    is

    a urethane

    enamel, carefully matched in color to the dark

    zinc

    chromate

    used on

    the original.

    Upper right) As

    an

    expedient method to inspect

    the fittings, the Stearman features these trans-

    parent inspection panels

    at

    critical brace and

    control locations on the wings and tail.

    (Below)

    The

    cockpit of the Stearman is

    as

    close

    as

    one

    can get to the original from the days of

    WW-II, right down to the wide lap belts. He even

    has the original instrument panel facia covers, a

    rare item these days.

    conjunction with a new sleeve. Starting

    his

    project also

    put

    him

    in touch with

    one

    of

    the world's leading suppliers

    of

    Stearman parts

    n

    Chickasha, OK.

    I

    purchased a new gas tank from

    Dusters

    Sprayer

    Supply, along with

    about a jillion other parts from them,"

    said David. " I basically took the whole

    airplane down to its very smallest com-

    ponent and rebuilt

    t

    from the ground up .

    I've replaced all

    of

    the bearings and put

    n new control cables, old wear surfaces

    and tried my best to keep everything in

    an authentic stock condition, other than

    fabric and the finish."

    Covered in aircraft quality Dacron ,

    with the final finish is a urethane paint

    that

    s

    no longer available. He opted for

    the 1942 yellow wings and blue fuse-

    lage scheme, with the red and white

    striped tail.

    The

    wings, as

    mentioned before,

    were a real mess, and their rebuilt took

    almost a year and a half

    of

    effort. A set

    of wing ribs of outstanding workman-

    ship were built by Jeff Morgan, and they

    comprised the core

    of

    the wing restora-

    tion. Having a complete set

    of

    blueprint

    microfiche of all the Stearman drawings,

    and a full set

    of

    assembly drawings also

    made putting the parts back together a

    lot

    easier

    ,

    but

    you still have to do the

    work It was also a

    big

    help that there

    are eight other Stearmans based on Bob

    White Field n North Orlando, so he has

    plenty

    of

    support.

    VINTAGE AIRPLANE 15

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    18/36

    "Bob White Field is just a real friendly

    place for tail draggers and there's a lot

    of

    local Steannan knowledge," says David.

    He also wanted to point out the support

    and encouragement, not to mention ex

    pertise, he was given by Jim and Kevin

    Kimball, along with Jim s brother, AI,

    who helped with the reconstruction of the

    ailerons. Plenty

    of

    other folks helped as

    well. Tim Preston is a flight instructor in

    Steannans at Bob White Field, and Steve

    Fletcher, who used to own this particular

    airplane,

    is

    a duster in Immokalee, FL.

    Dave's wife, Ann had been very tolerant

    and encouraging, allowing various parts

    of

    the airplane to be stored

    in

    and around

    the house during the restoration. The

    Gay s home, a traditional Florida design

    with a tin roof, has a large porch pro

    tected with a beautiful overhang. At the

    beginning of the restoration, the 220 hp

    Continental was stored on the front porch,

    and in the best tradition of having fun

    with a restoration, they decorated

    it

    with

    Christmas decorations when they held a

    holiday party Later, the engine would go

    out to Claude Holland of Holland Aircraft

    Engines - it would prove to be one of the

    last engines overhauled by Claude.

    Along

    with Ann, his other two

    biggest supporters are Rachel and

    Lorena

    , the Gay s daughters.

    Lorena

    has really taken to flying, and enjoys it

    very much. Flipping through the restora

    tion book, we can watch the girls grow,

    as they were 8 and II years of age when

    the Stearman project was started, and

    are now 3 and

    6

    now.

    Other helpers include Jim, Connie,

    Bryan and Joel Smith who are the Gay's

    next door neighbors, and Gary Osoling,

    a friend of David's. Michael Morrissey

    is his

    business

    partner,

    who

    was also

    taken with the project. Special thanks

    also go to Roger Painter, who allowed

    him access to his Stearman, including

    about 50 hours of flight time as Dave

    got ready to fly his

    biplane. Finally

    ,

    Dave ' s brother Jerry, who also helped

    rebuild the Champ, also helped on the

    Steannan. Jerry put

    in

    lots of hours dur

    ing the restoration, and continually gave

    encoragement.

    First flown on March 16, a small

    gathering of

    family

    and

    friends

    wit-

    nessed the PT -17 roar down the runway

    at Bob White and reclaim the sky. The

    next month,

    David brought the Stear

    man over to Lakeland-Linder Regional

    Fly-In for the 1998 edition

    of

    the Sun ' n

    Fun EAA Fly-In, where it was awarded

    the Grand Champion Antique trophy. ....

    6 ULY 998

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    19/36

    I

    was

    Sunday,

    March 16, the day

    be

    fore

    St. Patrick's Day. My

    day.

    After

    consulting

    with

    noted

    air racer

    Klaus

    Savier

    EAA

    258013), master builder

    Joe

    Krybus (EAA 140019) had finished the

    adjustments

    to

    the Ellison Throttle Body

    injector.

    His

    work

    was done.

    The owner,

    Bruce Kemper (EAA 22106) and I pre

    pared

    it for

    flight.

    Bruce's

    friend

    ,

    Kathym

    Mora, carefully recorded the events

    by

    photograph, video camera and tape

    recorder, transcribing

    all

    that

    was

    said

    and

    done. t

    was

    rolled out

    of Joe's hangar

    and

    was now

    ready

    for flight.

    Bruce tumed to

    me and

    said,

    Are

    you ready

    to go? I

    was

    a

    little

    overwhelmed,

    but

    yes,

    I

    was

    ready.

    t was my tum

    to fly

    the

    Jungmeister.

    Bruce

    Kemper has been an antique

    air

    plane

    pilot since

    the mid

    1950's, owning

    several Stearmans, a Waco UPF-7

    and

    a

    PT

    -22. He

    flew into Santa Paula Airport

    by

    PAT

    QUINN

    EAA 261

    781

    A / C 10079

    one day following some aerobatic dual

    with the great Lindsay Parsons. Lindsay

    introduced Bruce

    to

    the legendary Mira

    Slovak, who

    offered Bruce an opportunity

    to fly his 180 hp Lycoming powered

    Bucker Jungmann

    of

    his

    own.

    In

    the 1960s the Swiss Air Force re

    leased

    to

    private ownership its fleet

    of

    Bucker Jungmeister Bu-133 aircraft that

    had

    been manufactured under license

    by

    Domier prior

    to WW-JI.

    Bruce traveled to

    Switzerland

    and

    purchased

    as

    many Jung

    meisters

    as he

    could get. Bruce met and

    became friends with Albert Ruesch , the

    late, great Swiss Bucker pilot and many

    time European aerobatic champion. For

    nearly 30 years, Albert ran

    an

    aerobatic

    school

    at

    Porrentruy, Switzerland utilizing

    Jungmanns and Jungmeisters .

    So

    well

    thought

    of

    was Ruesch that the Swiss

    government made it mandatory for all

    Swissair and Swiss Air Force pilots

    to

    graduate from

    his

    aerobatic course.

    Bruce retumed

    home from his

    buying

    spree with

    six

    Jungmeisters

    for his friends

    and himself. A couple of years later he re

    ceived a phone call from Albert Ruesch

    suggesting that

    he

    purchase a

    very

    special

    Jungmeister that

    he had found for sale

    ,

    U

    n

    This was

    in

    Ruesch's opinion , the

    sweetest flying Jungmeister around .

    t

    was built by Dornier

    in

    1940 as serial

    number

    19

    and had been registered as

    HB-MKK

    on the

    Swiss civil registry.

    Bruce bought

    and

    shipped this beauty

    home to Santa Monica, CA. Knee deep

    in

    Buckers

    and

    going through a personal

    crisis , he placed it in the back

    of

    his

    hangar unassembled where

    it

    languished

    in

    storage.

    Eventually, it became the sample air

    frame for a planned modernizing using a

    VINTAGE IRPL NE 7

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    20/36

    U-72

    and Joe

    Krybus in flight over one of the

    many

    fertile valleys

    in

    southern California with

    the Barksdale church just below the left wheel

    in

    this

    photograph_

    The

    cockp it of Bucker Jungmeister U-72 com

    plete with the offset control

    sti k

    and modern

    Instruments. The

    fold down

    sides allow the cock

    pit to neatly surround the pilot without restrict

    ing their view.

    180

    Lycoming firewall forward conver

    sion kit for Ruesch's Jungmeister fleet.

    Unfortunately, the kit

    builder

    Hank

    Kennedy of Santa Paula, CA

    was

    killed

    in

    an unrelated flying accident and that pro

    gram died with him .

    U-72 sat around another fifteen years

    18 JULY 1998

    while Bruce flew his Seimens-powered

    Jungmeister, U-88 , and a newly com

    pleted Jungmann with a 180 hp Lycoming

    powerplant owned by Bruce and Ken

    Williams. But that old What if? seed

    had been planted, so Bruce asked Joe

    Krybus, one

    of

    the most knowledgeable

    Bucker experts in the country, if not the

    world, to plug U-72 into his

    Bucker

    restoration shop

    at

    Santa Paula on a part

    time basis. Recently, with some shop

    time available, the project was attacked

    in earnest. The plan was to restore the

    plane using modern materials where

    needed for practical flying but keeping it

    as original appearing as possible.

    And

    , oh

    yes

    , install that 180 hp Lycoming that Al-

    bert Ruesch had dreamed about. The

    result was breathtaking.

    Finally, on March 9,1997, it was ready

    for the first flight. That honor went to

    Bruce, followed by Joe Krybus. Another

    flight was taken

    by

    Joe a few days later.

    The fourth flight was mine.

    r strapped

    in

    started, then taxied

    to

    the

    runup area. All systems checked and it

    was ready to roll. To compare accelera

    tion differences between the stock

    160

    hp

    Seimens-powered Jungmeister and this

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    21/36

    lightweight Lycoming

    version, I decided to

    come

    on with the

    power quickly. Just as

    quickly, torque began

    to lift the right wing

    Right stick was added

    along with some back

    pressure and it virtu

    ally leaped into the air

    and

    climbed out at a

    deck angle that would

    impress any

    Pitts

    driver. WOW

    After the obligatory

    clearing turns and

    some stalls, it was

    time

    to

    see

    what this

    goldenrod

    baby

    could do. Loops great. Snap rolls impec

    cable. Four-point rolls super crisp. Slow

    rolls, oh boy

    What

    perfect slow rolls .

    Now, every pilot knows when they botch

    something. Others may not recognize it,

    but the pilot knows. In the Jungmeister,

    it lets you know but it also makes it so

    easy to do it right. The controls are so

    light, so well

    balanced and

    so harmo-

    nized. Words cannot accurately describe

    it without a comparison. I suppose a real

    U 72 rests on the

    ground

    at Santa Paula Airport northwest o Los Angeles CA

    good concert violinist could playa de

    cent tune on a one hundred dollar fiddle

    and great music on a quality violin, but

    an average violinist

    on

    a Stradivarius

    could sound like Itzhak Perlman. So

    it is

    with the Jungmeister - even an average

    pilot looks good.

    I completed my

    aerobatic sequence

    with one final slow roll then left the aero

    batic box and headed back towards Santa

    Paula. A mechanical gremlin has bitten

    the

    airspeed indicator, so I had to fly

    strictly by feel. I approached runway 22

    into a strong and roily wind . The touch

    down on the long oleo main landing gear

    was

    a

    squeaker.

    What a great feeling

    Landing completed, I taxied back to the

    ramp, rolling up to the waiting Bruce

    Kemper, who saw my huge grin and sim

    ply asked, "Well?"

    To which I replied, "Bruce,

    if

    die and

    go to Heaven,

    I'm

    going to ask God for a

    Jungmeister like this one, because angel

    wings couldn't possibly be any berter."

    VINTAGE

    AIRPLANE

    19

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    22/36

    About Albert

    Ruesch

    and Bruce Kemper

    When

    Bruce arrived at Porrentruy,

    about

    50 miles north

    of Bern, Switzer

    land, it was a warm, late spring

    Saturday in

    1968.

    The setting was

    like

    something out of a television

    travel log

    .

    t

    was a beautiful green valley set in

    rolling hills between two distant moun

    tain ranges with the upper spires

    tipped

    in

    a virgin white snow. The airport was

    a grassy meadow set

    in

    this emerald

    valley. Alongside were

    the

    administra

    tive buildings and an indoor/outdoor

    restaurant with patrons

    eating, drinking

    and watching the airport activities. A

    class of about twenty-five aerobatic stu

    dents were undergoing a rigorous ground

    school while

    waiting

    their

    tum to fly. This

    was

    in

    an

    effort

    to

    earn

    the Vol

    de

    Vwtu

    osite, the state approved permit

    to do

    aerobatics. The instructor was the young

    and overbearing ChiefPilot.

    Albert Ruesch had promised Bruce his

    first flight

    in

    one of his school's lung

    meisters while

    in

    Porrentruy. Bruce

    was

    there

    to

    meet this legend in person and

    to

    see

    if

    the promise would be fulfilled.

    They conversed in

    some

    small talk,

    which

    was difficult because Albert spoke very

    little English and Bruce spoke even less

    of

    the

    native French. Soon

    it

    was

    time to

    fly the lungmeister , so Albert turned

    Bruce over

    to the

    English speaking Chief

    Pilot for instruction. The superior acting

    Chief Pilot treated Bruce as

    if

    he

    were a

    novice dummy student. With the entire

    class

    of

    students looking on, he con

    ducted a

    very

    long preflight and cockpit

    check. Then came

    his

    flight instructions,

    punctuated with lots of you will and

    you must. t

    was

    implied that aerobat

    ics were prohibited. The final instructions

    were to stay within sight

    of

    the airfield

    and

    to

    overfly

    it

    when finished, where

    upon the Chief Pilot would indicate

    by

    hand signals whether it was okay for

    Bruce to land.

    Well

    the Seimens engine was running

    strong and the warmth

    of

    the beautiful

    day, along with the intoxicating smell

    of

    the fresh grass rising into the air simply

    overtook Bruce's better judgment,

    so he

    proceeded to put on a half-hour display of

    the finest aerobatics

    he

    had ever flown.

    Cuban eights, inverted spins, hammer

    heads and every other maneuver in his

    aerobatic repertoire.

    He

    capped this with a

    grass rubbing blast

    down

    the

    runway

    with

    a chandelle around the wind sock

    to

    the

    downwind.

    When

    the Chief Pilot did not

    show himself, Bruce did a steep

    180

    de

    gree slip

    to

    the touchdown point marked

    by red flags. Kicking it straight

    at

    the

    last

    moment,

    he

    completed a perfect touch

    down and ultra short ground roll.

    Taxiing back

    to

    the tie

    down

    area, the

    gentle ticking

    of

    the Seimens radial

    was

    drowned out

    by

    the wild cheering

    of

    the

    twenty-five aerobatic students

    and the

    ap

    plause of the restaurant patrons.

    After shutdown, the jubilant students

    escorted Bruce into the airport Pub for a

    mandatory celebration.

    As

    they

    passed the

    arrogant

    Chief

    Pilot, he refused

    to

    ac

    knowledge

    Bruce s

    presence. Albert

    Ruesch came

    up

    to Bruce, threw an arm

    around his shoulder and said

    in

    the best

    English he could muster, Aerobatics

    okay. Thus started a friendshipand mu

    tual admiration that lasted until Albert's

    passing

    in 1989.

    In

    a bit

    of

    irony, Ruesch's young son,

    Markus, would make

    his first lungmeis

    ter flight in Bruce s U-88 during the

    Bucker fly-in at

    Santa

    Paula ,

    CA in 1993.

    A

    favor

    returned. . . .

    Porrenbuy, Switzerland , 1972. In this beautIfUl country obatIc school used both the

    two-place

    .Jungmann and serving area of the airport restaurant 8 well 8

    setting

    n

    a

    Swiss VIIIey, Bruce

    Kemper was given

    his sIngIe-pIace JqneIster

    for

    aerobatIc 1natruc:tIon On PlIatua Porter, often used

    8

    gilder tug or

    ump plane

    to . . . he JungmeIster. Albeit Rueacha

    the

    far right

    you

    can the tables for the outdoor

    for

    paracllutlata,

    8 well 8 many

    other

    utility Olea.

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    23/36

    Handy Welding

    Table

    If you' re into restoration,

    welding

    table is

    pretty

    for fabricating small

    medium sized parts. Dur

    the EAA Air Academy,

    welders work on a

    dozen tables designed

    built

    by Bill Roerig,

    e volunteer welding

    Now there's

    special about a weld

    table, except that

    it

    must

    your fire bricks, and

    at a comfortable height

    your to work upon.

    I ' ll give you the dimen

    for the

    EAA

    Air

    Table you see here,

    t I'd caution you to start by

    supply of fire

    start trim

    - layout your

    on the floor, pushed

    each side ofthe cube

    you've laid out,

    trim your top angle

    allow the

    brick to

    while laying

    The

    Air Academy students use the tables throughout the week while they leam the fine points

    of

    welding with a oxy

    acetylene torch

    The

    sturdy nature

    of

    the tables means the welder does not have

    to

    worry about his work being compro-

    sheet metal bottom

    mised while he tries

    to

    juggle the torch and the piece

    to be

    welded

    the working surface.

    Also, one more caution: DON

    'T

    USE

    BRICK AS

    WORK SURF ACE

    generated by a weld

    explode as steam, sending particles

    of

    the ordinary brick flying

    arms or face.

    Having your fire bricks on hand will

    on which

    you

    weld

    your

    table if you

    choose

    to

    it out ofwood

    As you can imagine, there is no re

    it- also included in this arti

    are a coup

    le

    of shots of irAcademy

    Tom Seversen'

    s

    portable

    complete

    with

    baby buggy

    Indeed, the only component

    buy was the fire brick. A

    by

    H.G.

    FRAUTSCHY

    check with the local material supply

    yard here in Oshkosh says the

    cost

    of

    each 9 x 4-112 x 2-112 fire brick is .90

    each. With the scrap lumber you proba

    bly already have, you could easily get

    buy with a 20

    dollar

    bill, even if you

    had to go to the local thrift store to buy

    an old buggy for the wheels Probably

    your only caution would be to avoid the

    edges

    of

    your wooden table, since you

    don't

    want

    to set your table on fire. It

    wouldn't be

    a

    good

    idea to

    throw

    a

    bucket

    of water on a burning

    table

    loaded with hot fire brick- the steam

    explosion could be dangerous.

    EAA's welding table is 35" tall, ex

    cluding the bricks.

    15

    bricks are used,

    with a couple more purchased to act as

    fixtures to hold various pieces while

    welding.For our particular bricks and

    layout, the inside dimensions of the top

    of

    the table were 27-1 /

    4 x

    22-3/4". The

    top and middle braces are made of

    2-1/2" angle iron, and the legs are 1-5/8

    O.D. pipe, with one end threaded to ac

    cept a screw-on pipe cap. (They give the

    table a finished look and besides, you

    can use the caps to level the table on

    concrete floors )

    The

    top of the

    table

    has a

    piece

    of

    sheet steel inserted and welded in place

    to contain the bricks. It's better to com

    pletely support the bricks, rather than

    use a few cross braces underneath

    the bricks occasionally crack, and it

    would be inconvenient for the brick to

    fall on the floor or your toe while your

    were welding.

    The

    call outs on the

    photos should

    help fill in the details so you can build

    you

    own to su it your purposes . Let's

    melt some metal

    VINTAGE AIRPLANE

    2

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    24/36

    fire brick

    Welding rod

    holder

    1-5/8 Pipe

    Heavy

    sheet

    metal

    bottom

    Table is 35 t ll excluding fire

    brick

    1-5/8 Pipe

    (Above) The standard EAA Air Academy welding table_

    On

    a welded tab on

    the corner of the table is a length of square tubing used

    to

    hold spare weld

    ing rod in a convenient location_

    Extra fire brick to hold

    parts to be welded

    9 4-1/2 2-1/2

    This one varies slightly from the one in the lead

    photo, In that the welding rod holder Is made

    up

    of a pair of round tubing sections, the bottom one

    with a small

    round

    plate welded

    to

    the bottom_

    (Lower left and below) Here's Tom Seversen 's welding table, built

    up

    from

    scrap lumber and made portable by adding buggy wheels and a extending the

    sides on one end, which serve as handles_ A new set of fire bricks on the

    tops gives Tom a great surface

    to

    do his welding work_

    (Above) Adult Air Academy partic ipant Lanny

    Guyton, Honolulu,

    HI,

    practices his technique

    on

    one of the welding tables built

    up by

    Bill Roerig_

    You can see how the fire brick is laid out tightly

    to one another,

    and

    extra bricks are used to hold

    parts to be

    welded_

    22

    JULY 1998

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    25/36

    OUR MEMBERS ARE RESTORING

    by H G

    Frautschy

    M

    any members will remem

    ber

    the beautiful

    Caproni

    CA 100 I-ABOU restored by Gero

    lamo Gavazzi EAA 360771, A C

    15849)

    of

    Milan, Italy. We published

    a story of

    the

    airplane in the

    July

    1995 issue

    of Vintage Airplane.

    Well,

    it

    seems

    he has

    hard

    at it

    again, this time restoring a land

    plane version

    of the CA 100,

    I-AMBT.

    Built n 1933 as a float plane for training n the Italian Air

    Force (above, left), t was sold

    n

    39 to a private individual,

    and spent the war years

    n

    the same hangar as I-ABOU. Af

    ter the war, t was sold to a company n Milan who used t to

    tow banners, launching the banners

    n

    mid-air via a pair

    of

    bomb-bay type doors (left).

    The airplane continued to be used for aerial advertising

    with both banners and smoke writing until 1962, when it

    was left to rot

    n

    a hangar

    n

    Milan. The photos showing the

    airplane after t had been n prolonged storage (below) were

    taken

    n

    1986.

    After protracted negotiations, Gerolamo was able to buy

    the airplane and

    s

    now in the process of making his dream

    of seeing both I-ABOU and I-AMBT in the air together

    come true. We look forward to seeing reports

    of

    his progress

    on the airframe and the Columbo S63 motor.

    VINTAGE

    IRPL NE

    3

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    26/36

    This is Floyd Schorsch (EAA

    510948), Bismarck, ND,

    who's

    tickled

    to be standing with hi s newly restored

    Aeronca 7 AC .

    t was

    finished on

    May I, 1998 after he had to overcome

    a few challenges to hi s hea lth . Floyd

    would like to thank Gary Gylten and

    Gary Stagl for their help - he says it

    couldn't have been done without them.

    Powered with a Continental A -65 it

    cruises at 85 mph.

    24 ULY 998

    Looking so pretty sitting in the water

    off the shoreline filled with pine woods

    is

    Republic Seabee N87493,

    SIN 44.

    It's owned and flown by Odell (EAA

    262957 AIC

    26561) and Diane (EAA

    513115) Matthis Havelock, NC. Diane,

    proudly wearing her 99's tee shirt,

    stands ready at the handy bow door

    of

    their amphibian.

    One

    of

    492 Seabees

    still on the reg ister, t is powered by a

    Continental GO-480 of295

    hp

    .

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    27/36

  • 8/12/2019 Vintage Airplane - Jul 1998

    28/36

    by

    E.E. "Buck" ilbert

    EM 21 N 5

    P.O.

    Box 424 Union

    IL

    60180

    M

    ore

    years ago

    than

    I care

    to

    talk about,

    Dorr

    Car

    penter handed

    me a

    little

    brass plaque

    that

    reads One Mid

    Air Collision Can Ruin Your Whole

    Day." We laughed about that, and

    I

    tucked

    it

    away

    in one of my

    many drawers.

    Then

    one day in a

    United DC-7

    just

    about right over downtown De

    troit we had a very near miss

    with

    an F-84 at 25,000 ft. I had been idly

    staring out the front windshield and

    it happened so quickly all I had time

    to do was crank the wheel hard over

    as the

    fighter went

    under

    the left

    two engines. My Captain never even

    saw the

    other

    airplane and I

    got

    a

    very dirty look and a chewing out

    for grabbing the controls away from

    the

    autopilot

    and

    doing

    the

    hard

    over. He didn't believe me when I

    told him what happened.

    I've

    had three near misses in my

    airline

    career. All

    three

    were

    in

    controlled airspace,

    and would

    you believe that two were with the

    same Captain?

    The second was with this guy go

    ing into New York's JFK in a DC-8 .

    Normal approach procedure was

    off

    Colt's neck VOR in those days, and

    descent was out over the bay as the

    vectors put us in the string of pearls

    6 JULY

    998

    PaSSitto

    Buel{

    for

    landing on the northwest run

    ways or

    maybe

    the southwest,

    whatever the pattern

    of

    the day.

    We were

    descending through

    10,000 when

    the

    RAPCON

    con

    troller advised us

    of

    fast moving

    traffic

    coming

    from our left side.

    We were in the clouds in solid IFR

    so I asked the

    controller

    to

    keep

    an eye on

    it. He

    asked if we

    wanted to take evasive action. My

    Captain (yep, the same one from the

    DC-7 ) refused.

    Bases of the clouds were reported

    to be about 10,500 by previous traf

    fic. The

    controller was giving us a

    second-by-second update as we be

    gan to break out. I was looking past

    the Captain out the left side window

    and *&"'%$ there he went I went,

    because I had a head on view of him

    and his F-94 as he pushed down and

    went

    under us

    and could make out

    his head and snot catcher (02 mask)

    ashe

    threw back his head and came

    out under my side window. Thank

    goodness the DC-8 had such a long

    nose, or he would have had us right

    in the Nos. I and 2 engines

    When I got my breath back I told

    the controller

    what

    had

    happened.

    He

    asked if we wanted to

    file

    a

    near miss report and the captain

    adamantly refused Again, the cap

    tain

    had not

    even seen the

    other

    airplane

    and

    again I caught some

    flack for overstepping my boundary

    as a First Officer. I was advised that

    he was the Captain, and

    darn

    it, he

    would make the

    decisions.

    I shut

    up, but I

    vowed

    this would never

    happen to ME.

    Shortly after that, maybe within a

    year or so, I got promoted to Cap

    tain. I began carrying the little brass

    plaque with me and I would prop it

    up

    on the instrument

    panel glare

    shield to remind me,

    and

    my duly

    briefed crew, that someone would

    be looking out the window(s) at all

    times. If

    there

    was any disturbing

    influence on the flight deck, instead

    of all three crew