21
Strategic Planning and Implementation Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean Ruth Johnston and Jeff Fillmore Organizational Excellence

Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    14

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

Strategic Planning and Implementation

Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean

Ruth Johnston and Jeff FillmoreOrganizational Excellence

Page 2: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

AGENDA

Liberating Structure Example

Our Approach

Strategic-Planning Workshops

Utilizing Liberating Structures

Employing Lean

Action-Planning Approaches and Techniques

Lessons Learned

Questions 2

Page 3: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

ABOUT THE UW

Founded in November 1861

55,767 Students (undergraduate, graduate, professional)

$1.3 billion in Research Awards (largest federally-funded public research institution in US)

Campuses in Seattle, Tacoma, Bothell

16 Schools & Colleges

UW Medicine - $3 billion budget

$3.1 billion in Endowment

3

Page 4: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

Structuring Invitation

– What is a primary challenge you face in your unit or institution

regarding strategic planning and/or execution? What do you hope to

learn during this session that could address that challenge?

How Groups Are Configured

– Pairs

– Find a partner from an institution different from your own

Sequence of Steps and Time Allocation

– In each round, 2 minutes per person to answer the questions. 4-minutes

per round

– Two rounds

– Report out examples of challenges and needs with session attendees

– Impromptu Networking

5

Page 5: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

CONTINUUM

STRATEGY PLANNING EXECUTION

Each of these components needs the other two in order to make an impact in an organization

6

Page 6: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

Our Method

Strategy sets focus and priorities

Using Liberating Structures and Lean principles throughout

allows more ideas and insights

Balanced Scorecards track progress and ensure a

thoughtful approach

Creating and charging work teams drives accountability

Focus on ideas and insights from the front lines

Use Kaizen (“Improvement”) teams to work on focused,

one-year priorities

7

Page 7: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

5/2016

UW PLANNING & MANAGEMENT (P&M) - STRATEGY MAP FOR 2016-2018

MISSION – WHAT WE DO

Transform the administration at UW to provide excellence in service delivery at best value

VISION - ASPIRE TO BE

P&M is the trusted source for innovative solutions to UW’s administration and planning needs

FY16 priorities

VALUES (*UW)

Excellence*Respect* Integrity* Innovation*

Collaboration*TransparencyResults FocusedSustainability

BUILD

ORGANIZATIONAL/

STAFF CAPACITY

FOCUS ON UW

CUSTOMERS

MANAGE

RESOURCES

IMPROVE INTERNAL

BUSINESS PRACTICES

Eliminate duplication, cut costs and reallocate resources today

for tomorrow

Improve and support UW-wide data storage, retrieval and

analytics

Allocate, lease, build and manage space effectively and meet emerging strategic needs

Improve service delivery in all units within P&M

Lead University District Innovation Zone Planning

and Campus Master Planning

Create and implement one stop portal/process for

requesting and resolving space needs

Develop solutions to energy needs and achieve climate

goals

Create professional development and recognition

opportunities for all staff

Develop effective leadership and management skills

Develop and support robust student internship

opportunities

Improve communication within and across P&M

Improve UW wide operational and organizational

processes/structures and efficiencies

Modernize enterprise systems, information systems and

processes

Streamline university budgeting and management processes

LEADERSHIP, FACULTY, STUDENTS,

STAFF, PARTNERS, COMMUNITY

78

Page 8: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

ONGOING ACTIVITIES

Project Teams

Project Sponsor

Project “Care and Feeding”First-Year

Strategies

Leadership Team Project Updates Quarterly Project Review Annual Strategy Review

Strategy

ProjectUpdates

Leadership Identifies Priorities

9

Page 9: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

PROCESS TIMELINE

INTAKE INTERVIEWS WORKSHOP PLANNINGDEBRIEF

1-3 Months 2 Weeks – 2 Months Day “0” 1-2 weeks 1-4 weeks

10

Page 10: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

Workshop Steps/Flow

Warm Up

Leadership Kickoff

OE Learnings

Mission, Vision, Values

SWOT

Identify/Prioritize Objectives

High-level Action Plans

11

Page 11: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

Workshop Approach

Table groups

Present question/idea

Individual brainstorming

Individuals share ideas with table

Table discusses ideas, looks for themes, etc.

Table prioritizes ideas and reports to large group

Large group discussion

Prioritization by large group

12

Page 12: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

Assume best intent

Share the floor and allow for all voices

Be honest and respectful

Be authentic

Listen

80% is good enough

Ask for clarity when needed

Be positive – change is hard!

Avoid side conversations

Free yourself of distractions (e.g. phones, etc.)

Have fun!

Workshop Ground Rules

13

Page 13: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

1-2-4-All -

Wicked Questions -

Triz -

25:10 -

Celebrity Interview -

Impromptu Networking -

Purpose to Practice -

Troika Consulting -

Liberating Structures

14

Page 14: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

Activity scope

Planning

Make it visual

Visual mapping

Continuous improvement in OE approach

Lean Principles and Tools

15

Page 15: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

PLANNING –PURPOSE TO PRACTICE

1516

Page 16: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

PLANNING –ACTIVITY SCOPE

1616

Page 17: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

BALANCED SCORECARD METRICS TEMPLATE

18

Page 18: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

STRATEGY MEASURE FRENQUENCY ACTUAL TARGET STATUS STRATEGY MEASURE FRENQUENCY ACTUAL TARGET STATUS

RES1.1 Percent of Faculty with Grant Funding Q 68% 90% F2.1 Donation Trends FY $2,138,992 NA

RES4.1 CNE Enrollment Trends FY 3248 3250 F2.2 Number of Donors to SoN FY 1394 1775

RES5.1 Student Retention FY 99% 100% F2.3 Cost per Dollar Raised FY $0.167 $0.166

RES5.2 Student Satisfaction FY 80% 90% F3.1 % of Student with Financial Support FY 16% 35%

RES5.3 Certification Results FY 99% 100% F4.1 Total Grant Dollars Received Annually FY $12,942,397 TBD

F4.2 Total Grant Dollars Received by Agency FY $12,942,397 TBD

F4.3 Benchmark Funding with Peer Institutions FY TBD TBD

STRATEGY MEASURE FRENQUENCY ACTUAL TARGET STATUS STRATEGY MEASURE FRENQUENCY ACTUAL TARGET STATUS

O3.1 Student Time-to-Degree FY 93% 100% RES5.5 Faculty and Staff Retention FY TBD TBD

O3.2 TIER Customer Satisfactoni Q 93% 90% S1.1 Staff Development Q 25 150

O4.1 TIER Blended Service Available Q TBD TBD S1.2 Faculty and Staff Diversity FY TBD TBD

S5.4 Faculty and Employee Satisfaction FY 3.65 4

Q = Quarterly >= 95% target

FY = Annual >= 90% target

BA = Bi-Annual < 90% target

Mthly = Monthly

Key

School of Nursing Metrics Dashboard -- QE 12/31/2013

RESEARCH, EDUCATION AND PRACTICE (REP) SECURING OUR FINANCIAL FUTURE (F)

OPERATIONAL EXCELLENCE (O) CREATING A SUSTAINABLE ORGANIZATION (S)

SCHOOL OF NURSING METRICS DASHBOARD

STRATEGY MEASURE FRENQUENCY ACTUAL TARGET STATUS STRATEGY MEASURE FRENQUENCY ACTUAL TARGET STATUS

RES1.1 Percent of Faculty with Grant Funding Q 68% 90% F2.1 Donation Trends FY $2,138,992 NA

RES4.1 CNE Enrollment Trends FY 3248 3250 F2.2 Number of Donors to SoN FY 1394 1775

RES5.1 Student Retention FY 99% 100% F2.3 Cost per Dollar Raised FY $0.167 $0.166

RES5.2 Student Satisfaction FY 80% 90% F3.1 % of Student with Financial Support FY 16% 35%

RES5.3 Certification Results FY 99% 100% F4.1 Total Grant Dollars Received Annually FY $12,942,397 TBD

F4.2 Total Grant Dollars Received by Agency FY $12,942,397 TBD

F4.3 Benchmark Funding with Peer Institutions FY TBD TBD

STRATEGY MEASURE FRENQUENCY ACTUAL TARGET STATUS STRATEGY MEASURE FRENQUENCY ACTUAL TARGET STATUS

O3.1 Student Time-to-Degree FY 93% 100% RES5.5 Faculty and Staff Retention FY TBD TBD

O3.2 TIER Customer Satisfactoni Q 93% 90% S1.1 Staff Development Q 25 150

O4.1 TIER Blended Service Available Q TBD TBD S1.2 Faculty and Staff Diversity FY TBD TBD

S5.4 Faculty and Employee Satisfaction FY 3.65 4

Q = Quarterly >= 95% target

FY = Annual >= 90% target

BA = Bi-Annual < 90% target

Mthly = Monthly

Key

School of Nursing Metrics Dashboard -- QE 12/31/2013

RESEARCH, EDUCATION AND PRACTICE (REP) SECURING OUR FINANCIAL FUTURE (F)

OPERATIONAL EXCELLENCE (O) CREATING A SUSTAINABLE ORGANIZATION (S)

19

Page 19: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

> 10 – 20 workshop participants is best

> Set expectations – explain the process to participants in advance

> Have a standardized approach that is flexible depending on client input and needs

> Provide communications templates to clients

> Clients appreciate not starting from scratch in the workshop

> There must be internal champions and sponsors

> Leadership must make this a part of their work too

> There will always be a process or expectation breakdown – be prepared and flexible

> Language is powerful and words matter – some groups find terms like “Lean”, Liberating Structures”, and “Customer” off-putting

20

Lessons Learned

Page 20: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

Thank you!

20

Questions?

Page 21: Using Balanced Scorecards, Liberating Structures, and Lean · 2017-04-25 · balanced scorecard metrics template 18. y e y l et s y e y l et s 1 g q 68% 90% 1 s fy 2 na 1 s fy 3248

Ruth Johnston, Ph.DAssociate Vice President Strategy [email protected] 685 9838

Jeff FillmoreConsultantOrganizational ExcellencePlanning & [email protected] 616 1603