23
Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP NC AWWA-WEA Annual Conference November 14, 2016 T.J. Lynch, City of Raleigh Aaron Brower, City of Raleigh Tim Woody, City of Raleigh Michael Bullard, Hazen and Sawyer Amy Hanna, Hazen and Sawyer

Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    17

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP

NC AWWA-WEA Annual Conference

November 14, 2016

T.J. Lynch, City of RaleighAaron Brower, City of RaleighTim Woody, City of RaleighMichael Bullard, Hazen and SawyerAmy Hanna, Hazen and Sawyer

Page 2: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Neuse River Resource Recovery Facility

• Currently expanding from 60 mgd to 75 mgd

• Planning for expansion to 90 mgd (~ 2040)

• Aerobic digestion and lime stabilization onsite

• Composting offsite

Page 3: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Offsite Composting

Current Biosolids Outlets

Class B LiquidRaleigh Plus

Page 4: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Drivers for Change

Page 5: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Drivers for Change

• Age of Equipment

• Uncertainty of future Class B land application

Page 6: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Drivers for Change

• A strategic part of the City’s Climate Energy Action Plan

• Make enough digester gas to fuel over 3,000 passenger vehicles!

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Garbage truck = 96 DGE/day Passenger car = 500 GGE/year @75 mgd 5,150 DGE/day, or 4,500 GGE 50 buses or over 3,000 passenger vehicles
Page 7: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Decision to Convert to Anaerobic Digestion

• Covered and Uncovered Aerobic Digesters• 2.6 million KWhr/yr

Page 8: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Technology Evaluation

Presenter
Presentation Notes
CAMBI – Crawley Kruger - Oxford Also evaluated: Incineration Thermal Drying Solar Drying
Page 9: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Technology Evaluation

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Also evaluated: Incineration Thermal Drying Solar Drying Europe Trip
Page 10: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Drivers for Change – Benefits of THP

Anaerobic digester volume ↓ Capital Cost ↓

Biogas production ↑ Revenue ↑

Volatile solids reduction ↑ and dry mass ↓ Hauling Cost ↓

Final cake solids ↑ Hauling Cost ↓

Low odor, Class A product Public Health ↑Environment ↑

Page 11: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Project Description

Page 12: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Thermal Hydrolysis Process (THP)

• A sludge “pressure cooker” operating at about 330F/165C (90 psig)

Page 13: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

THP Benefits and Considerations

BENEFITS

• Decreased digester volume

• Increased biogas production

• Increased VSR

• High quality biosolids• Class A • Low odor

CONSIDERATIONS

• Stronger sidestream• Nitrogen• Phosphorus• COD

• Possible impacts to UVT• Pre-conditioning required• Sludge cooling• Rapid Volume Expansion

Page 14: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Proposed Biosolids Process

EQ

CLASS A CAKE STORAGE

FOG RECEIVING

SCREENINGS

LOW PRESSURE

GAS STORAGE

PS

SLUDGE SCREENS

SCREENED SLUDGE WET

WELL

PRE-DEWATERINGTHERMAL

HYDROLYSIS

COOLING SYSTEM

ANAEROBIC DIGESTERS

SLUDGESTORAGE

FINAL DEWATERING

SIDESTREAM NITROGEN REMOVAL

THICKENING

GAS CLEAN UP

BIOGAS

BOILERS

STEAM

RETURN TO HEAD OF PLANT

WAS

BLEND TANK

CAKEBIN

RNG PIPELINE INJECTION

SCREENINGS

PASTEURIZATION

TWAS

STEAM FROM BOILERS

FLARE

Page 15: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Sidestream Considerations

• Improved VSR across digestion increases nutrient mass loadings in the sidestream. (+20%)

• Deammonification offers a reduced energy and reduce carbon pathway for nitrogen removal.

• Dilution will be required with post-THP centrate because of toxicity and nutrient loading

Presenter
Presentation Notes
THP considerations due primarily to formation of refractory dissolved organic carbon (DOC) and dissolved organic nitrogen (DON)
Page 16: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Fats, Oils and Grease

Benefits of Co-Digestion

• Boost biogas production

• Divert waste from collection system

• Revenue

Market study of grease interceptor waste

• 2015: 30,000 gal/day, 2040: 60,000 gal/day

FOG

Co-DigestStorePasteurizeScreenReceive

Presenter
Presentation Notes
50,000 gal/day of FOG boosts biogas production by 25% (808,000 cuft/day vs 1,015,000 cuft/day). +4 cu ft digester gas/gal
Page 17: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Digester Gas Utilization

Page 18: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Project Benefits

Page 19: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Net Energy Production with Renewable Natural Gas

2+ MW hr/hr

CWSRF Green Reserve$50M @ 0%

MW

hr/

hr

Page 20: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

0

5,000

10,000

15,000

20,000

25,000

30,000

35,000

40,000

2020

2021

2022

2023

2024

2025

2026

2027

2028

2029

2030

2031

2032

2033

2034

2035

2036

2037

2038

2039

2040

Resid

uals

Disp

osed

, DT/

yr

Current THP + MAD

THP reduces residuals mass for final disposal

Page 21: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

NRRRF will reduce operating costs with THP

$-

$50

$100

$150

$200

$250

20-y

r NPV

Ope

ratin

g Co

sts a

nd R

even

ue (

$M, 2

016$

)

Current THP + MAD

Disposal Cost Labor Cost Maintenance Cost Operation Cost Revenue

Page 22: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Next Steps

• In detailed design

• Selecting CMAR Contractor

• Construction to begin Q3 2017

Page 23: Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP · Unlocking Resource Recovery at the Neuse River RRF with THP. NC AWWA- WEA Annual Conference. November 14, 2016. T.J

Thank You!