129
University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for fission lifetime measurements Kravchuk, Vladimir Leonidovich IMPORTANT NOTE: You are advised to consult the publisher's version (publisher's PDF) if you wish to cite from it. Please check the document version below. Document Version Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record Publication date: 2004 Link to publication in University of Groningen/UMCG research database Citation for published version (APA): Kravchuk, V. L. (2004). Development of an atomic clock for fission lifetime measurements. s.n. Copyright Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download or to forward/distribute the text or part of it without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license (like Creative Commons). Take-down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Downloaded from the University of Groningen/UMCG research database (Pure): http://www.rug.nl/research/portal. For technical reasons the number of authors shown on this cover page is limited to 10 maximum. Download date: 18-08-2021

University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

University of Groningen

Development of an atomic clock for fission lifetime measurementsKravchuk, Vladimir Leonidovich

IMPORTANT NOTE: You are advised to consult the publisher's version (publisher's PDF) if you wish to cite fromit. Please check the document version below.

Document VersionPublisher's PDF, also known as Version of record

Publication date:2004

Link to publication in University of Groningen/UMCG research database

Citation for published version (APA):Kravchuk, V. L. (2004). Development of an atomic clock for fission lifetime measurements. s.n.

CopyrightOther than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download or to forward/distribute the text or part of it without the consent of theauthor(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license (like Creative Commons).

Take-down policyIf you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediatelyand investigate your claim.

Downloaded from the University of Groningen/UMCG research database (Pure): http://www.rug.nl/research/portal. For technical reasons thenumber of authors shown on this cover page is limited to 10 maximum.

Download date: 18-08-2021

Page 2: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

! "#$$% &' () * +,$%-.!/ /$

Page 3: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

0213547698;:=<?>A@B8DCE3F6HGI0J13LKNM3HO(8E4P<913OQ<R8;SKN@L@FTU8V@9WXSL3F<918VMXYZTNOE@B3HMX[\3F<A]^3F3H:_<913<A]^8%<R8D]P3F6a`Hb

021KN`c]^8E69W51OE`d[\3F3H:5Y)3F6a4e8E6aS3HMLOE`fYZOQ69<d8E4)<913g693H`R3HOQ6a@h1LY698EiE6hOES8E4<913jakl<9KN@a1><9KN:imCE8n8E6dop:MZOESL3H:=<R3F3HTqr:M3F69sF8n3FWtM3F6cuvOQ<R3F6aKU3Hw5xyozquX|h~]m1KN@a1KN`Z:ZOE:@FKNOETNTU`9pYY\8E69<R3HM[l<913_jRm3HM3F6aTOE:M`R3%q69i;OE:ZKN`9OQ<9KU3CE8n8E63F<R3H:`9@a1ZOQYY\3HTNK RWXqr:M3F6R>sF8n3FWVwvxymqt|hb 6apW)GP6aOQZ`9@h1^3H:n<R6apSoZOE@FKNTNKU<9OEKU6mP3HM6aK R4JK ?WV`9p:KNCE3F6a`9KU<R3HKU<g698;:K:iE3H:

Page 4: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Ut)LL9m \?¡\¢?¡£ ¤mLa5¥m¢

! "#$$% &' () * +,$%-.!/ /$

¦g§h¨©«ª­¬¯®F°\§h±eª³²

²¯©~§´V©D§¯µ§¯±·¶h¸V±7¹\¸º´n»l¹_°\©«²I¼)¨®«²B¨V§¯»V»n²t±7¹_¼\©½±7¬hµZ¾)¹\¼\©©~¹¿»n²¯¾\¾\§aÀ©«²B©~¹)¬¯®F° »lÁ)Áz©D¹»V»l¹_¼\©%Ât±Ã¶hµ¬¯¾\¹)±e´V©D§¯¬h±e²B©D±e²IÄL§¯¨V¹)±7¹\¸V©D¹

¨VÁŸV©~Æ~»l¸º´n»l¹¼)©Â©D®D²B¨l§ÇÈ»l¸V¹\±É ®~¾)¬~Ê ¼\§DËmÌmËÍzÀr»n§h²B¬Dʱ7¹°\©«²¨VÁz©D¹Î »V»l§²B©L´l©~§¯¼)©~¼\±e¸V©~¹¨VÁ

´Z§¯±·¶h¼ »l¸Ï;ÐÒÑv»V»l§a²IÐlÓVÓlÔ¨lÑÕÏEÖ)ËÏ;×Ò¾\¾\§

¼\¨Z¨V§

ØÙaÚgÛaÜÝaÞ¤L9ÛL¤PI9ßzàâá Úfmßzàt5¸l©~Î ¨V§¯©D¹¨VÁÐÏ%»lÁ)§¯±7ã^ÏEäånÔ²B©/Ǩl¬¯µl¨l¾dÊ Â¾\¬hãy»l¹)¼

Page 5: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

æ 698;S8E<R8E6HG æ 698E4b 6HbPçbZè^é8;1:3F6^8Q>­Y698;S8E<R8E6HG 6Hb¢çIb·bêKTN`9@a1lp<^3F8n8E6aM3HTNKN:i;`9@B8;S%SKN`9`9KN3EG æ 698E4b 6Hb^u_bu8E6yR3HOE:

æ 698E4b 6HbPëLbkVKU]^3FW=>­,KNTN@BsFmì:`RWQOæ 698E4b 6Hb b0 6aOEp<9SOE::

Page 6: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

í îðïðñòïóñ,ô

õ öH÷)øDùDú ûdü ý;øDþ7ú÷ õÿQbNÿ æ 693F47OE@B3 bbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtb ÿÿQb qrp<9TNKN:3 bbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtb

5øDú Èþeýºýeú ý lbNÿ kV1ZOQY)3 8E4)<913n>­6hOHL`RY\3H@B<R6aOr693H`9pZTU<9KN:i4e6a8;S13HOHCl=>AKN8;:L693HOE@B<9KU8;:` lb v>A`913HTT KU8;:KUsHOQ<9KU8;:ÒYZ698E[ZOQ[ZKNTKU<9KU3H`^:3HOQ62sF3F698%KSLYZOE@B<gYZOQ6aOES3F<R3F6 b lb u8;TU3H@FpTNOQ69> q69[ZKU<9OETl>­6aO«(3HS%KN`9`9KU8;:(478E6mMK)3F693H:n<J TNKU473F<9KNSL3H`rbtbÕÿlb! kVpZSSOQ69/8E4c<913tOQ<R8;SKN@t@FTU8V@9WºM3FCE3HTN8EYZSL3H:n<tbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbÕÿ

" #%$nù&$ þ')( ú *2ø&+,.-/lù~þ01l÷)ø&2341nø& ú û65 õlbNÿ p@FTU3HOQ6JS3F<918lMZ`btbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtb7Vÿ

lbNÿQbNÿ m3Hp<R698;:SIpTN<9KUYZTNKN@FKN<9KU3H` btbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtb7VÿlbNÿQb 98Z>­6hOHºSIpZTU<9KUYZTNK@FKU<9KU3H` btbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtb7:

lb u8;TU3H@FpTNOQ69> q69[ZKU<9OET `9<9pM%8E4fTNOQ<R3B>­`9`9KU8;:Ò<9KNS3H`bbtbtbbbtbtbbtb7:;lb ^6al`R<9OET[ZTU8V@9WVKN:i5<R3H@a1:ZK=<np3Lbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtb7?>lb! æ 698EY\8;`R3HMSL3F<918VMêbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtb7:

@ núùBA "DC bNÿ 3H:3F6aOET@B8;:@B3FY<9`m8E4c<913:lp@FTU3HOQ62Z`a`9KU8;:ÒMV:OESKN@F`âbbbtbtbbtb7E

bNÿQbNÿ 0J13tè OE:iE3FCVKN:OE:ZMºo8EWnWE3F69> æ TNOE:@aW3<lpOQ<9KU8;:bbbtbtbbtb7E bNÿQb ët6aOESL3F6a`2M3H`9@B6aKUY<9KN8;:/8E4d<913t^698D]J:KNOE:SL8E<9KU8;: b/btbtbbtb7: bNÿQb 0J13tMKF p`9KU8;:ÒSL8VM3HT btbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbG ÿ

b qr:3B>­[)8VM(MKN`9`9KNYZOQ<9KU8;:(SL3H@a1OE:ZKN`9S btbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbG ) b uvpTU<9K >AMZKNSL3H:`9KN8;:OETèzOE:iE3FCVKN:ºOQYY698;OE@h1478E62Z`9`aKU8;: bbbtbtbbtbG )H b! 0z3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p693gM3FY\3H:M3H:@B3¢8E4):np@FTN3HOQ6f4e6aK@B<9KU8;:IOE:ZMLTNKNSKU<9` 8E4Z8;:3B>

[\8VM/MK`9`9KUYZOQ<9KN8;: btbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbG );C

Page 7: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

$ þ IKJML%NOPL%NRQ

ST,.-/lù~þ01l÷)ø U"lbNÿ qCE3F6aOETT `R3F<9pY btbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbbtbtbtbbbtbbV:lb ^3HOES OE:M<9OQ69iE3F<.bbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbbtbtbtbbbtbbV:lb 3F<R3H@B<9KU8;:`Rl`9<R3HS` btbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbbtbtbtbbbtbbV:H

lblbNÿ uvKN:K\o8E69] OQ6aM_OETNTbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbbtbtbtbbbtbbV:Hlblb 3Wn>­6aO«ºM3F<R3H@B<R8E6a`btbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbbtbtbtbbbtbbVH?>lblb odKN`9`aKU8;:ÒM3F<R3H@B<R8E6a` btbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbbtbtbtbbbtbbVH

lb! X¢TN3H@B<R698;:KN@F`gOE:MMOQ<9OOE@Y<lpKN`9KU<9KN8;:ÒbtbtbbtbtbbbtbbtbtbtbbbtbbVH:Hlb kl<R6apZ@B<9p693r8E4d<913tMOQ<9OOE:OETNl`9K`bbtbtbbtbtbbbtbbtbtbtbbbtbbVH:;

Z [ºú)ü]\^'vý;ú)þy÷ ý=þ7û6l÷zý_5`2÷]23aA.5«þ'5 C)õHlbNÿ 02KNS3rOE:ZOETUl`aKN`_btbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbbtbtbtbbbtbb7ElÿHlb kl3HTU3H@B<9KN8;:Ò8E4c<913tZ`9`9KN8;:/476aOQi;SL3H:n<9`23H:3F69iEÒi;OQ<R3 bbtbtbtbbbtbb7E?Hlb æ OQ69<9KU<9KU8;:8E4z<913I@B698;`9`2`R3H@B<9KN8;:KN:Ò693HOE@B<9KN8;:@a1OE:Z:3HTN`Xbtbtbbbtbb7E?Hlb! ^8E696a3H@B<9KU8;:º<R8<9136a3HOE@B<9KU8;:@h1OE::3HT VKU3HTNMZ`Ibbbtbbtbtbtbbbtbb7E?H

C ^ùQþa-^'vý=úþy÷ ýnþeû6V÷ ý_5b2÷]23aA.5«þ'5 c EnbNÿ 02KNS3rOE:ZOETUl`aKN`_btbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbbtbtbtbbbtbbV;:Enb 8EYYZTU3F62`a1KU47< @B8E6a693H@B<9KU8;: btbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbbtbtbtbbbtbbV;:;Enb dm>­6aOHº`RY\3H@B<R6aOLOE:OETNl`9K` bbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbbtbtbtbbbtbbVVÿEnb! 23H`apTU<9`gOE:MMZKN`9@Fp`9`aKU8;: bbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbbtbtbtbbbtbbV:;

c eIú)÷ ý7ü5«þ7ú÷5b2÷ ûêúü ø&7ú ú3 õ_fõ;lbNÿ kVpS%SOQ69/OE:ZMº@B8;:@FTNp`9KN8;:` btbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbbtbtbtbbbtbbÿY>ÿ;lb qrp<9TN8n8EW btbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbtbbtbtbbbtbbtbtbtbbbtbbÿY>

g þa\^yþ7ú3hZù2U-^A õ_fDCi lûlù?a2÷ û65j5231l÷$k2øHø~þ7÷h õõ"[l2Z÷D(ú úùDû õõm

Page 8: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

n9o p /!%rq-.(

sRtus v /wHÚgßfx :_ÿ::(^8;16mOE:Mê13F3HTU3F6JYZp[ZTNKN`913HM/<913HKU624yOESL8;p`JOQ6a<9KN@FTU3jR0213u3H@a1OE:K`9S8E4\mpZ@FTU3HOQ6odKN`9`9KU8;:Zwzy ÿ?­bd0J13HKU6M3H`9@B6hKUY<9KU8;:I8E4`9`9KU8;:LKN`f:8«]693F473F69693HML<R8tOE`<913^8;16R>­,13F3HTU3F6tS8lM3HTc478E6t:npZ@FTU3HOQ6Z`9`9KN8;: b021K`mSL8VM3HTdKN`OÒ`R<9OQ<9KN`9<9KN@FOETfSL8VM3HT³G0213tZ`9`9KN8;:V>AM3H@FOHº6hOQ<R3IKN`JY698EY\8E69<9KU8;:OET<R8/<913:npZS[\3F628E4TU3FCE3HT`mOQ<m<913Z`a`9KU8;:[ZOQ6a6aKU3F64e8E6tO(i;KUCE3H:X3|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:3H:3F69iEEb x :<913L:3|l<rE3HOQ6t<913 p<9@a1XYZ1nl`aKN@FKN`R<ë6hOESL3F6a`f@B8;SSL3H:n<9`f8;:5<9132^8;169>­ê13F3HTN3F6¢SL8VM3HTVKN:51KN`d@B8E6a:3F6R>A`9<R8;:3gYZOQY\3F6f8;:MK\p`aKU8;:ly!:H­bçJ3m`9piEiE3H`R<R3HM/<R8IM3H`a@B6aKU[\3gZ`9`9KN8;:LOE`¢OMl:OES%KN@FOETVY698V@B3H`9`]m13F693476aKN@B<9KU8;:vYZTNO«l`rOE:KNSY)8E6a<9OE:=<698;TU3Ebtçm3L`918«]^3HMX<91OQ<r<913L^8;16R>­,13F3HTU3F6Z`a`9KU8;:]JKM<91]mKNTNTz[)35`R<R698;:i;TU693HMZp@B3HM KN:YZOQ69<9KN@FpZTNOQ6r]J13H:4e6hKN@B<9KU8;:XKN`CE3F69vTOQ69iE358E6CE3F69`9SOETNT³bo8E6Ò<913:3|l<(<91693F3XM3H@FOEM3H`Ò:8E<ÒSIpZ@a1,OQ<R<R3H:=<9KN8;:] OE`(YZOEKNM<R8<913Ië6aOESL3F6a`mOQYY698;OE@h1 Z[p<2KN:º<913[)3Fi;K::KN:i58E4gÿE>E`<913`9pZ@F@B3H`9`J8E4f`R3FCE3F6hOETSL8VM3HTN`z8E4ZM3F3FY>AKN:3HTNOE`R<9K@P@B8;TNTKN`9KU8;:`Py!?> )V? );V`a18«]^3HM5<91OQ<d<913go8EWlWE3F6R> æ TNOE:Z@9WMK\p`aKU8;:È3<npOQ<9KN8;:p`R3HMK:ë6aOESL3F6h`OQYY698;OE@h1] OE`%KN:ZM3F3HM693HTU3FCQOE:n<4e8E6%<913M3H`a@B6aKUY<9KU8;:I8E4\:np@FTN3HOQ6cYZ698l@B3H`a`R3H`Fb x :ÒÿE?kl<R6ap<9KN:Z`RWntM3F6aKUCE3HM5OE:LKN:n<R3F69Y\8;TNOQ<9KU8;:478E6aSpTNOÒ478E6I<913%Z`9`9KU8;:_]JKNM<91_K:_@FOE`R3%8E42`aSOETNTOE:MÅTNOQ69iE3%CVKN`9@B8;`aKU<9KU3H`by!:­bl:lpSL3F6aK@FOET¢`R8;TNp<9KU8;:_8E4g<913Òo8EWlWE3F6R> æ TOE:@9W3<npOQ<9KN8;:Å] OE`Y693H`R3H:n<R3HMK:ÅOv8;:3B>MKSL3H:`9KU8;:ZOETMKF p`9KU8;:vSL8VM3HTc8E4^6aOE:icì3j~?`y!::­b x :<913]P8E6aW8E4¢_OEMZO~Y?%yE??cZ`9`9KN8;:MV:OESKN@F`m8E418E<r:npZ@FTU3HK ] OE`r`R<9pMKN3HMp`9K:i%O/<A]^8Q>AMKNSL3H:`aKU8;:OETèzOE:iE3FClK:_3<lpOQ<9KU8;: bv^8;:Z@FTNp`9KU8;:_8E4g<913H`R3/`9<9pMKU3H`IKN`t<91OQ<j?<913(Z`9`9KU8;:_8E4218E<:lp@FTU3HK KN`g`9<R698;:i;TUÒMKN`9`aKUYZOQ<9KUCE3HwVb

kKN:@B3mKN<PKN`^:8E<^Y)8;`a`9KU[ZTU3J<R8M3F<R3F6hSKN:3MKU693H@B<9TU18«],ClK`9@B8;p`^:np@FTN3HOQ6 S%OQ<R<R3F6KN`H=8;:38E4 <913]^O«l`^<R88E[<9OEKN:(KN:478E6aSOQ<9KU8;:/KN`¢SL3HOE`ap6aKN:i<913m`9`9KU8;:%<9KNSL3m`a@FOETU3E]J1ZKN@a1_K`<913%`9@B8EY\38E4 <91K`<913H`9KN`Hb(uvOE:=X3|VY)3F6hKNSL3H:n<9`t1OHCE3([\3F3H:Y\3F69478E6aSL3HMOETU6a3HOEMº4e8E6SL3HOE`ap6aKN:i%<913I`9`9KU8;:vTNKU473F<9KNSL3Ebm0J136h`R<mKN:ZMKN@FOQ<9KU8;:8E4f<913Sp@h1TU8;:iE3F6%<9KNSL3H`/:3F3HM3HM 4e8E6/Z`9`9KU8;:+<913H:Y693HMZKN@B<R3HM[lP8;16/OE:M ê13F3HTN3F6%] OE`<913L6a3H`9pTU<8E4P3|VY\3F6aKNSL3H:n<9`F ]J13F693:3Hp<R698;:SpTU<9KNYZTNKN@FKU<9KN3H`2]^3F693SL3HOE`9p6a3HMy!:;V:V/:HVE­bÈ021ZKN`8E[Z`R3F69CQOQ<9KU8;:+] OE`OETN`R8X8E[<9OEKN:3HM+4e698;S 3|VY\3F6aKNSL3H:n<9`F]m13F693 >­YZOQ69<9KN@FTN3/SpTU<9KUYZTKN@FKU<9KU3H`rOE:M86aOHV`47698;S <913%i;KOE:=<5MKUY\8;TU3L693H`98;:OE:@B3/M3H@FOH]^3F693SL3HOE`ap693HMy )­b 0J13SOEKN:MK`9OEMCQOE:=<9OQiE38E4<913H`R3vSL3F<918VM`F M3H`9@B6aKU[\3HMKN:ÅSL8E693/M3F<9OEKNT¢TNOQ<R3F6«dK`t<91OQ<I<913%Z`a`9KU8;:<9KNS3/`9@FOETU3(KN`M3F<R3F6aSKN:3HMÅKN:MKU6a3H@B<9TU[lvp`aKN:i(<913F8E693F<9KN@FOETS8lM3HT`OE:MMKF\3F6`R<R698;:i;TUM3FY\3H:MKN:i%8;:X]J1K@a1SL8VM3HTKN`ºpZ`R3HM b x :,693H@B3H:n<SL8E6a3_MKU693H@B<ºSL3HOE`9p693HSL3H:n<9`p`9K:i<913_@B69l`9<9OET[ZTU8V@9WVKN:i

ÿ

Page 9: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

IR &b9uuYU B_

<R3H@a1:ZK=<np3Ky!Vÿ|u8E6y?3HOE:5OE:M@B8;TNTNOQ[\8E6aOQ<R8E6h`z8E[Z<9OEKN:3HMKN:t<913^693Fi;KU8;:8E43|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:3H:3F69i;KU3H`pY<R8:?>u3Y OÒ<9KSL3`9@FOETU3OQ<TN3HOE`R<8;:3L8E6aM3F6tTN8;:iE3F6t<91OE:KN:X<913KN:MKN693H@B<t3|VY)3F6hKNSL3H:n<9`Fb0J13/M3FY\3H:M3H:@B3%8;:È<913ÒOQYYZTNKN3HM_SL3F<918VMÈ693<npZKU693H`t<R8@a13H@aW%<913H`93mZ:ZMKN:i;`¢]JKU<918E<913F6 OETN<R3F6a:OQ<9KUCE3rSL3HOE`9p6a3HSL3H:=<9`^8E4 <913Z`9`aKU8;:<9KNS3`9@FOETU3Eb x :ÈYZOQ69<9K@FpTNOQ6Hf8E<913F6MZKU693H@B<53|lY\3F6aKSL3H:=<9OET SL3F<918lM`5KN:È<91K`I3|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:3H:3F69iEÒ693Fi;KU8;:OQ6931KUi;1ZTU%M3H`9KN6aOQ[ZTU3Eb

çm3F693m]^3m`apiEiE3H`R< OtY6aK:@FKUYZOETNTN:8«CE3HT\MKN693H@B<¢SL3F<918VM/<R8ISL3HOE`9p693J<913Z`9`aKU8;:<9KNSL3`9@FOETU3tpZ`9KN:i5OE:jROQ<R8;SKN@@FTU8l@aWlwVbP0213SOEKN:ÒKNM3HO58E4z8;p62SL3F<918VMºKN` <R8LZ:ZM<913Y6a8E[ZOQ[ZKNTNKN<AÅ<R88E[Z`R3F69CE3@a1OQ6hOE@B<R3F6aKN`R<9KN@+6hOHV`8E4<913YZ693B>A`9@FKN`9`aKU8;::np>@FTU3Hp` KN:Ò@B8;KN:@FKM3H:@B3]JKU<91(Z`9`9KN8;:%476aOQi;SL3H:n<9`F]J1K@a1(KN` OMZKU693H@B< :np@FTN3HOQ62SL8lM3HT >KN:M3FY\3H:M3H:=<SL3HOE`9p69358E4P<913LZ`9`9KN8;:<9KNS35`a@FOETU3Eb x :XOEMMKU<9KU8;:)<9135@B6a3HOQ<9KU8;:8E4<913Rv>A`913HTNT18;TU3m`918;pTNM5[\3JM3H@B8;pYZTU3HM%4e698;S <9132Y6a8l@B3H`9`P8E4 :npZ@FTU3HOQ6¢3|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;: b KU693H@B< x 8;:KUsHOQ<9KN8;:x Tx |f47pTNZTNTN`c<91KN`693<npZKU693HSL3H:n<SL8;`R<^@FTU8;`R32[lEb x :<91KN`fY6a8l@B3H`9`<913ÒY698~R3H@B<9KNTU3(Wl:8l@aWl`58;p<5OE:+3HTU3H@B<R698;:+47698;S <913v>A`913HTNTP]JKU<91ÈOY698E[ZOQ[ZKTNKU<A<91OQ<r`9@FOETU3H`]JKU<91vKU<9`mOQ<R8;S%KN@5:npSI[\3F6mOE:MvCE3HTU8V@FKU<AEb3L@B8;:`9KNM3F6mKN:vYZOQ69<9KN@FpZTNOQ6<913%OETUY1OÒ<R6aOE:`R473F6t693HOE@B<9KN8;:1?>vu3YW ~p1¡£¢Bm3¤r¡£¥£¡F021§¦ ¨ª©Hq«¤r¡£¥£©Y¬K­~b%3OEKNS <R8%SL3HOE`ap693W¬@a1OQ6aOE@B<R3F6hKN`R<9KN@të®l>­6aO«Ò`9Y)3H@B<R6hpSSL3HOE`9p6a3HMºKN:Ò@B8;KN:@FKNM3H:Z@B3]JKU<91º`9`9KU8;:Ò476aOQi;SL3H:n<9`mOE:ZM¯¨ª©«qb0213<9KNSL3t:3F3HM3HM4e8E6mZTNTNK:iOb¬®v>A`913HTNT\C~O~>@FOE:@BXM3F<R3F6aSKN:3HMv47698;S <913L:OQ<9p6aOET°¬±²n>­6hOHXTNKN:3I]JKNM<91³y!:KN`WH`´ÿY>_µ ¨ª¶`F]J1K@a1Òi;KUCE3H`2pZ`gOE:ºp:K=<lp38EYY\8E69<9p:KU<<R8%@h13H@9WºTU8;:iL`9`9KU8;:ÒTNKU473F<9KNSL3H`Hbc02133|V@FKN<9OQ<9KU8;:º3H:3F69iEÒKN` OQ[\8;p<ÿ?>%u3YI]J1ZKN@a1ÒSL3HOE:`JOL:np@FTN3HOQ6g<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p693r8E4ru3Yb;u8E693F8DCE3F6Hl8E<913F6d693HOE@B<9KU8;:L@a1ZOE::3HTN`d@FOE:5[\3P@B8;:`aKNM3F693HM5OETN`R8<R8rZ:M18«]<913<9KNSL35:3F3HM3HM4e8E6rZ`a`9KU8;:M3FY)3H:ZM`J8;:v<913L:lp@FTU3HOQ6<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p693Eb0213z¡£¢BJ3KU8;:XOE`O(Y698~R3H@B<9KNTU35]^OE`@h18;`R3H:Mp3I<R8º<913L1KNi;1+v>A`913HTTzKU8;:ZKUsHOQ<9KU8;:Y698E[ZOQ[KNT >KU<AEz]J1KN@h1`9@FOETU3H`tOE`·¸ ¡ b x :@FTp`9KUCE3LOE:MX3|@FTNp`9KNCE35S3HOE`9p693HSL3H:n<9`]^3F693%SOEM3]JKU<91<913 YZp6aY)8;`93¢<R8t`R<9pM¹v> OE:ZMLOEMMKU<9KU8;:ZOETº>A`913HTNTlKU8;:KUsHOQ<9KN8;:IYZ698E[ZOQ[ZKNTKU<9KU3H`Fb OETN@FpTOQ<9KU8;:`t478E6<913`»l>­6aO«Å`RY\3H@B<R6aO`91OQY\3%M3FY\3H:M3H:Z@B3%8;:<913/@B8;SLY\8;p:ZM:npZ@FTU3Hp`dTNKU473F<9KNSL3]^3F693 Y\3F69478E6aSL3HMKN:8E6hM3F6d<R8tM3H`9@B6aKU[\3P3|lY\3F6aKNS3H:=<9OETNTNrOE@h1KU3FCE3HM`RY\3H@B<R6aOVb

021K`r<913H`9KN`r<91lp`tOEKNS%`r<R83|lYTU8E693O:3F]S3F<918lMÅp`9KN:iÒ<913LYZ698EY\3F69<9KU3H`r8E4<9133HTN3H@B<R698;:KN@t`9<9OQ<R3H`J8E4f<913IOQ<R8;S.<R8(SL3HOE`9p6a3t<913t<9KNS3`9@FOETU3I8E4fZ`9`9KU8;:Ò8E418E<:npZ@FTU3HK³b

s¼t£½ ¾ I¡ Ùah5021KN`^<913H`aKN`2KN`g`R<R6hp@B<9p693HMºKN:(<9134e8;TNTN8«]JKN:iI] OHEb x :Ò<913I@a1OQY<R3F6T5<913jROQ<R8;SKN@@FTU8V@9Wdj2SL3F<918VMÒ]J1KN@h1ºKN`gp`R3HMÒ478E62<913`9`9KU8;:Ò<9KNS3r`a@FOETU3tM3F<R3F6aSK:OQ<9KU8;:ºKN` Y6a3B>`R3H:n<R3HMKN:ÅM3F<9OEKT³b æ 693FYZOQ6aOQ<R8E6aÅ`R<9pMKN3H`8E42<913(KN:Z@FTNp`9KUCE3`¿l>­6aOHÈ`RY\3H@B<R6aO6a3B>`9pTU<9K:iºKN:13HOHCln>AKU8;:_693HOE@B<9KN8;:`OE:M_<9133|\3H@B<8E4 <913%SpTU<9KUYTU3KN8;:KUsHOQ<9KU8;:_OQ6a3

Page 10: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

_ÀFÁUÀÂJM Ãa "

`9pZSSOQ6aKUsF3HMK:`R3H@B<9KU8;:ÄlbNÿQbê0213ºMKU693H@B<Åv>A`913HTNTgKU8;:KUsHOQ<9KN8;:+Y698E[ZOQ[ZKTNKU<9KU3H`KN:?>u3YM ~p ¡£¢ m3tKN:MZp@B3HM%6a3HOE@B<9KU8;:` ]^3F693M3F<R3F6aSKN:3HM/3|VY\3F6aKNSL3H:n<9OETNTUOE:ZMÒ<91KN`CQOETNp3KN`2WE3F<R8Ò<913IZ`9`9KN8;:<9KNSL3`9@FOETU33|lY\3F6aKSL3H:=<Fbm0213] OHv8E4f8E[<9OEKN:K:i`v>`913HTNT KU8;:KUsHOQ<9KN8;:ºY698E[ZOQ[KNTNKU<9KU3H` KN`JM3H`9@B6aKU[\3HMºKN:º`93H@B<9KU8;:jlblbg0213tM3FY\3H:M3H:@B38E4<913Æ«n>­6aO«I`RY\3H@B<R6aOm8;:5<913 @B8;SLY\8;p:M:npZ@FTU3Hp`cTNKU473F<9KNSL3PK`zYZ693H`R3H:n<R3HMK:I`R3H@B<9KN8;:lblb x :Å@a1ZOQY<R3F6zOE:_8«CE3F6aClKU3F]8E4g<9133|VY\3F6aKNSL3H:n<9OETSL3F<918lM`4e8E6I<913Z`a`9KU8;:TNKN4e3F<9KNS3tSL3HOE`9p693HS3H:=<9`mKN`2Y6a3H`R3H:=<R3HMb^0213SOEKN:vSL3F<918VM`2KN:@FTpMKN:i5SL3HOE`9p693B>SL3H:n<9`8E4<913L:3Hp<R6a8;:vOE:M_rKOE:=< KUY\8;TU3IJ3H`R8;:OE:@B3x­ |8>­6aOHSIpTN<9KUYZTNKN@¯>KU<9KN3H`mOE`]^3HTNTzOE`r<913@B69V`R<9OETc[ZTU8V@9WVKN:i(SL3F<918VMvOQ6a35M3H`9@B6aKU[\3HMK:`R3H@B<9KU8;:Z`KlbNÿQbNÿQlbNÿQbl¼lbX6a3H`RY\3H@B<9KUCE3HTUEbqrp6LYZ698EY\8;`R3HMSL3F<918VMKN`5Y6a3H`R3H:=<R3HMKN:`R3H@B<9KU8;:lb! 478l@FpZ`9KN:i/8;:X<913L:np@FTN3HOQ6YZ1=V`9KN@F`rOE`RY\3H@B<9`r<91OQ<r]^3F693:8E<MKN`a@Fp`9`R3HMKN:X@a1OQYZ<R3F6lb 0J13vSOEK:iE8;OETm8E4@a1OQYZ<R3F6` +KN`<R8+MKN`a@Fp`9`LiE3H:3F6hOETm@B8;:@B3FYZ<9`/8E4<913:lpV>@FTU3HOQ6g`9`9KU8;:ÒMV:OESKN@F`xy`R3H@B<9KN8;: bNÿ«| OE:MÒ<R8M3H`9@B6hKU[\3mKNSLY\8E69<9OE:n<gOE`RY\3H@B<9`F`9p@h1OE`<913MKF p`9KU8;:SL8VM3HT2xy`9p[Z`93H@B<9KU8;:¯ bNÿQb;|hz<913L8;:3B>­[\8lMMKN`9`aKUYZOQ<9KU8;:SL3H@a1ZO~>:K`9SÝxy`R3H@B<9KU8;: b;|2OE:ZM<913SIpTN<9K >AMKNSL3H:Z`9KU8;:OET)è OE:iE3FCVKN:vOQYY698;OE@h1478E6JZ`a`9KU8;:xy`R3H@B<9KN8;:b b;|hb¢0z3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p6a3mM3FY\3H:M3H:Z@B328E4:npZ@FTU3HOQ6P476aKN@B<9KN8;:OE:M(TNKNSKU<9`8E4 8;:3B>[\8VMvMK`9`9KUYZOQ<9KN8;:OQ6a3%MKN`9@FpZ`9`R3HMXKN:_`R3H@B<9KN8;:Ç b! b/0J13L3|lY\3F6aKSL3H:=<9OET¢@a1OQY<R3F6zM3H`a@B6aKU[\3H` <913`R3F<9pY478E6J<913t<R6hKUYZTU3@B8;KN:@FKM3H:@B3tZ`a`9KU8;:Ò<9KNSL3I`9@FOETU33|VY\3F6aKNSL3H:n<9`xy`R3H@B<9KN8;:blbNÿ«|hn<913 M3F<R3H@B<9KU8;:%`RV`R<R3HS`fpZ`R3HMLKN:5<913g3|VY\3F6aKNSL3H:n<2xy`R3H@B<9KU8;:blb;|hn<9133HTU3H@B<R6a8;:KN@F`JOE:ZMº<913MOQ<9O/OE@Y<npZKN`9KU<9KU8;:_xy`93H@B<9KU8;:jlb! n|hbg0213MOQ<9O%OE:ZOETUl`aKN` Y698V@B3B>Mp693OE:Mº<913693H`apTU<9`2OQ693YZ693H`R3H:n<R3HMKN:ºM3F<9OEKT KN:@a1ZOQY<R3F6a`¼HLOE:ZM+Enb x :@a1OQYZ<R3F6H<913YZOQ6a<9KU<9KU8;:8E4f<913693HOE@B<9KU8;:@a1ZOE::3HTN`m8E4f<913I@B8;TTNKN`9KU8;:Z`gKN:¡£¢Fm3&¤K¡£¥£¡F021vOQ693M3F6hKUCE3HM b x :_@h1OQY<R3F6ÅE(<913%l>­6aOH_`9Y)3H@B<R6hOOETN`R8@B6a3HOQ<R3HMÅ]JKN<91C~OQ6hKU8;p`693HOE@B<9KN8;:@h1OE::3HTN` OQ693OE:OETNnsF3HM bodKN:ZOETNTU@a1ZOQY<R3F6¼;@B8;:=<9OEKN:Z` <913SOEKN:Ò@B8;:@FTNp`aKU8;:`^OE:M<9138;p<9TU8n8EW)b

Page 11: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

@ IR &b9uuYU B_

Page 12: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ȱo É Ê Ë Z ±Ì

x :<91K`2@a1OQYZ<R3F6<913Y6aK:@FKUYZTU38E4f<913jROQ<R8;SKN@@FTU8l@aWlw(KN`2M3H`9@B6aKU[\3HM b x <KN`2[OE`R3HM8;:5<913gTNKN4e3F<9KNS3¢8E4OrCQOE@FOE:@B5KN:I<913Í>A`a13HTNTl@B693HOQ<R3HML]JKU<915Or@B3F69<9OEKN:5YZ698E[ZOQ[ZKNTKU<AEb`2Y6a3FYZOQ6aOQ<9KU8;:<A]^8/3|VY\3F6aKNSL3H:n<9`2]^3F693Y\3F69478E6aSL3HMvOQ<mëM x b02136a`R<28;:3] OE`M3FCE8E<R3HMÅ<R8`R<9pMv<913LY693H@FK`R3L`91OQY\358E4^@h1OQ6aOE@B<R3F6aKN`9<9KN@Ųn>­6aO«`RY\3H@B<R6aOVbL0213693H`apTU<9`]^3F693p`R3HM<R8+M3FCE3HTU8EY,<913XOE:OETUlsHKN:iÅYZ698l@B3HMZp693478E6lÎ 6aO«l`(47698;SMK)3F693H:n<r3HTU3HSL3H:n<9`FbL0213LTNKN:3H`OQ6a3L<R<R3HM`9KNSpTU<9OE:3F8;pZ`9TU<9OQWVKN:iºKN:n<R8OE@F@B8;p:n<OEMMZKU<9KU8;:OETRºf>A`913HTTKN8;:KUsHOQ<9KU8;: b0213`R3H@B8;:ZM,3|lY\3F6aKNS3H:=<(]^OE`ºM8;:3KN: 8E6hM3F6<R8Ò8E[<9OEKN:<913%v>A`913HTT KU8;:KNsHOQ<9KU8;:Y698E[ZOQ[ZKTNKU<AÒ[lSL3HOE`9p6aKN:iÒ@a1OQ6hOE@B<R3F6aKN`R<9KN@zÅ6hOHV`LKN:+@B8;KN:@FKNM3H:Z@B3/]JKN<91Å3HTNOE`9<9KN@FOETNTUÅ`a@FOQ<R<R3F693HMYZOQ69<9K@FTU3H`Fb_0213(Y698E[OQ[ZKNTNKU<8E[<9OEK:3HM KN:,<91K`Ò3|lY\3F6aKNS3H:=<º] OE``9@FOETN3HM OE:M p`93HM4e8E6<913_Z`9`aKU8;:TNKU473F<9KNSL3M3F<R3F6hSKN:OQ<9KU8;:bÈ0213(<]P8Å3|lY\3F6aKNS3H:=<9`LOQ693º[Z6aKU3YÏÅM3H`9@B6aKU[\3HM+KN:`R3H@B<9KU8;:Z`ÅlbNÿOE:Mlb_OE:M1OHCE3[)3F3H:+Yp[ZTNKN`a13HM d`R3F3y!E2OE:M9y!:;?­¢693H`RY\3H@B<9KUCE3HTNEbkV3H@B<9KU8;:lbº@B8;:n<9OEKN:`IOMKN`a@Fp`9`9KU8;:8E4^<913%M3FY\3H:M3H:@B358E4^<913Ųl>­6aO«_`RY\3H@B<R6aOETf`91OQY\38;:È<913ÒTNKU473F<9KNSL3/8E42<913^8;SLY\8;p:Mmp@FTN3Hp`Fp`9K:i+:18;TU<YÐÃ`I<913F8E69Ñy!V^ ?^8E4u8;TU3H@FpTNOQ69> q69[ZKU<9OETrx³uXqt|5OE:M ^8;SY)8;pZ:MV>Ap@FTU3Hp`(x­ r|n>­6aO«3HS%KN`9`9KU8;:È478E6<9132`9<9pMKU3HM5`RV`R<R3HSºbf0213g`91ZOQY)3H`d8E[Z<9OEKN:3HM5]JKU<915<91ZKN`c<913F8E69L1OHCE3J[)3F3H:LOQYZYZTNKU3HMKN:Å<913/OE:ZOETUl`aKN`t8E4g<913/Z`9`9KN8;:_<9KNSL3(`9@FOETU3/3|lY\3F6aKNS3H:=<Fb x :Å`93H@B<9KU8;:§lb! X693H`apTU<9`@B8;:@B3F6h:KN:i(<9135M3FCE3HTU8EYZSL3H:n<r8E4¢<9135OQ<R8;SKN@5@FTU8V@9WSL3F<918VM4e8E6SL3HOE`9p6aKN:i/<913Z`a`9KU8;:ºTNKU473F<9KNSL3H` OQ693I`9pSSOQ6hKUsF3HM b

½Mtus Ò à5ÚÓ( ¤RwX¡\à5ÕÔ ÖM×n Ú/Ø'Ó(ßc¡\ Ú \LÙ?¡\h5¥Ùw« ¤mÜà5¢ÚfWØK×la¤mâ Úgßc¡ 9¤5

è 3F<¢p`fOE`9`9pZSL32Ot`9KN:i;TU3Í>A`a13HTNTVCQOE@FOE:@BEb02132`9@h13HSOQ<9KN@23H:3F69iELTU3FCE3HTMKOQiE6aOES8E4Zi;p693PlbNÿg`a18«]J`cOETNTn<R6aOE:`9KN<9KU8;:`z<91OQ<zTNT;<913Æv>A`913HTNTl18;TU3EQ]J1ZKN@a1OQ693^693F4e3F6a693HM<R8OE`zMKOQiE6aOESTKN:3H`Fb 0J1693F3<lpOE:n<9pS :lpSI[)3F6h`.Úvx7<913PY6aKN:Z@FKUYZOET:<lpOE:=<9pZS :lpS5>[\3F6¯|h°Ûx78E69[KU<9OETPOE:i;pTNOQ65SL8;SL3H:n<9pS/|OE:MjÜx7<R8E<9OETgOE:i;pTNOQ65SL8;SL3H:n<9pS/|OQ693`918«]J:8;:X<91356aKUi;1n<`9KNM38E4¢<913MKNOQiE6aOESºbIo8E6t3|OESLYZTU3EKN:v<913/kVKN3FiE[ZOE1::8Q><9OQ<9KU8;:+<913(<R6hOE:`9KU<9KU8;:³Ý ¨ßÞà¡ >ÿá ¨ßÞà¡ K`I6a3F4e3F696a3HM<R8_OE`%`â ¡ b 0213F693ºOQ693Ò<A]^8SOEK:SL3H@a1OE:ZKN`9S`tTN3HOEMKN:iÒ<R8+ãl>­6aOHXY6a8lMpZ@B<9KU8;:KN:OE`RVSSL3F<R6aK@L13HOHCl=>AKN8;:693HOE@B<9KN8;:`FbÒ02136h`R<t8;:3%K`<913Ò 8;pTU8;SI[ÅKN:n<R3F6aOE@B<9KU8;: bÒ0213%13HOHClY698~R3H@B<9KNTU3WV:8V@9WV`28;p<m<9138E69[KU<9OET 3HTU3H@B<R698;:OE:M<913IKN:Z:3F62`913HTNTC~OE@FOE:@BvKN`g<91lp`J@B693HOQ<R3HMb021ZKN`¢YZ698l@B3H`a`^K`^@FOETTU3HM KN693H@B< x 8;:KNsHOQ<9KU8;:x Rx |hb0213`R3H@B8;:ZMºSL3H@a1OE:ZKN`9S8l@F@Fp6a`]J13H:<9135CQOE@FOE:@BXKN`m@B6a3HOQ<R3HM_Mp3<R8Ò<913LM3F3|V@FKN<9OQ<9KU8;:8E4¢<913LM3H@FO«lKN:i(6a3H`9KNMV>

Page 13: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Z IR:ÁU9N¯äBåT_æçèBÃ3éUê

K

L

M

N

O

I

I

II

III

I

II

III

IV

IIIIIIIVVVI

VII

IIIIII

V

α α β β β β β β β β δ δΙΙ Ι ΙΙ Ι ΙΙ Ι

β β1 2’ ’

3 1 5 5 212 2 1 n1

2

2

2

3

3

3

3

3

44444

4

555

l0

0

0

1

1

1

1

2

2

0112233

011

j

1/2

1/2

3/2

1/2

1/2

3/2

3/2

5/2

1/21/23/23/25/25/27/2

3/21/21/2

4 4

1/2

4

2

ë aì Y`ÁUÀ__í³îðïàñòuóMôõßöFï4ò÷òuøðùBúMûüòuý&òuûUþ:öFôù&øðôBóôBîðîªÿ)óTöü÷ùMôKîªöü÷ù&û ò îßñòuûüûkñBûüòpOET 13HOHCl:npZ@FTU3HK³b 021KN`gYZ698l@B3H`a`JKN`m@FOETNTU3HM x :n<R3F6a:OETc 8;:=CE3F6a`aKU8;:x x 2|hb\0 8(`R<9pM<913`91OQY\3(8E4m<913 l>­6aOH`RY\3H@B<R6aO693H`9pZTU<9KN:iv4e698;S MZKF)3F6a3H:=<L13HO«Cnn>AKU8;:693HOE@¯><9KU8;:`F\OE:3|lY\3F6aKSL3H:=<m]^OE`Y\3F69478E6aSL3HMv]JKU<91[)3HOES%`m47698;S.<9135`9pY\3F6a@B8;:MpZ@B<9KN:i@Bl@FTN8E<R698;:ÇJtqrb]?>u3YM ~pHçm3 ¨ ¨ª¡ ¥ ¨ª© q ¡£¢ m3 OE:MÇ;?>u3YM ~p çJ3¡^/¨ª¡«Æ©P°¨ª©«qK¶KU8;:[\3HOES`r]^3F693p`R3HM b%TNTfKU8;:`r]^3F693LY6a8lMpZ@B3HM`9KNSpT ><9OE:3F8;p`9TNKN:X<913bX^ x 8;:Èkl8;p6a@B3x0X x k|hb0213L[\3HOES`r]^3F693%`93FYZOQ6aOQ<R3HM_[l

Page 14: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ÁUÀ_ÀÂQU:]%° Yu]?BuYbY ÃìaY_æ ? _¯|?BaÅC

0

10000

20000

30000

40000

65 70 75 80 85 90 95Energy (keV)

Cou

nts

Kα2 Kα1 Kβ1/ Kβ2

/

Pb

BiPo

ë aì YbÁkÀÁk øàô|úî! _òï õßøðÿóÄøðòîßÿû õßöü÷ù#"=ø&ó³õßñ)ò°øßòôBï£õðö$&÷&%')(%ò+*-,|ÿ&.0/ò21346587:9;< ñòþ)ôBîßñòþûüö ÷òî _òï£õðøßÿ)ó9øðò+ øðòîßòu÷õðî°ôTõðñøðòuòÍï&ó B÷)òu÷õ>=@?:ACB?:AD1FEô÷)þG?HAI1J%KL õ°õðñø6Bÿù&ñ¹õðñòþôYõàô

<9p:ZKN:iº<913(JOEMKU8o693<lp3H:@B xymof|t8E42<913(@Bl@FTN8E<R698;:OQYZY698EY6aKOQ<R3HTUEbº0zOQ69iE3F<9`]^3F693%¨ª¶¨M ¥ 0cOV3¡£¢£¶¶£¡ æ [OE:ZMç¡£¥£¡N ¢ 021º]JKN<91Ò<91KN@9WV:3H`9`93H`¼lb>VlbHlZOE:ZMl b;LSLi ~@FSÅ¡;693B>`RY\3H@B<9KUCE3HTNEbÒ 1OQ6hOE@B<R3F6aKN`R<9KN@l>­6aO«_`RY\3H@B<R6aOº]^3F693%SL3HOE`9p693HM]JKU<91ÅO1KUi;1Yp6aKU<3YZTNOE:OQ6%l>­6aO«+M3F<R3H@B<R8E6/]JKN<91OE: OE@B<9KUCE3OQ693HO8E4LÿY>:>ÅSSb¡Dbê0213M3F<R3H@B<R8E6] OE` Y\8;`9KU<9KU8;:3HMÒ:3HOQ6¼?>Om]JKN<91/6a3H`RY\3H@B<g<R8L<913r[)3HOESMZKU693H@B<9KU8;:ÒOE:MÒ8;p<9`aKNM3<913`9@FOQ<R<R3F6hKN:i@a1ZOES[\3F62OQ<2OLMKN`9<9OE:@B3r8E4^?>L@FS47698;S <913r<9OQ69iE3F<FbPm:Ò3H:3F69iE/6a3H`R8Q>TNp<9KU8;:58E4:PCQM::3Y] OE`P8E[<9OEKN:3HM/OQ<POE:%l>­6aO«L3H:3F69iEL8E4]E?WE3Ybl0J13¼ l>­6aOH`RY\3H@B<R6apZS693H`9pZTU<9KN:it47698;Sr?>Lu3YW ~pHçJ3W¤ ¡£¢£¶ æ [(K`P`918«]J:(KN:Zi;p693TlblbP0213

Page 15: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

c IR:ÁU9N¯äBåT_æçèBÃ3éUê

ë ì_3YbÁUÀSR3 < ñ)ò UT øßòùBöSB÷G"]õðñò V øàô|úzî _òï£õðøßÿ)ó øßòîªÿ)ûõðö ÷ùD"=ø6Bó õßñ)òTøðòô&ï£õðö$&÷%'(%ò+*-,|ÿ 3!4XW ò>1ZY 5 Y < ô < ñòîBûüöüþ¹û öü÷òÍøðò+ øðòîßòu÷õàî.õðñòÍò _òuøðö óKòu÷õàôûkþôYõàôB?õðñòÍþôBîßñòþû öü÷ò4öüî6ô L õ^ôBîðîªÿóKöü÷ù[&÷û úKîßö ÷ù&û ò îªñòû ûö$&÷öS\ôYõðö$&÷; < ñò4þ]BõªõðòþMûüö ÷)òøðò+ øðòîßòu÷õðî]ô L õôBîðîªÿ)óTöü÷ù )û ÿ)î°ô&þþ:ö õßöSB÷)ôBûUîªöü÷ù&û ò[^ îßñòuûüûö$&÷öS\ôYõðö$&÷;

<R<9KN:iºYZ698l@B3HMZp6935]JKNTNTz[\3M3H`9@B6aKN[)3HMXTNOQ<R3F6IKN:X`R3H@B<9KU8;:1lblb p3L<R8<913L<AlYZKN@FOET693H`R8;TNp<9KU8;:_8E42<913º3ÒM3F<R3H@B<R8E6a`58;:3(@FOE:+`R3FYZOQ6hOQ<R3/8;:TN vY\3HOQWV`IKN:<913 ¿l>6aOHº`RY\3H@B<R6apZSºG°bâ ¡ 3`â ¨ UG_ ¨` OE:Mla_ ¡X` b ^8E69693H`RY\8;:MZKN:i<R6hOE:`9KU<9KU8;:Z`g@FOE:[\34e8;pZ:MLKN:5i;p6a3¼lbNÿQb0213gTNOQ69iE32VKU3HTNMZ`z478E6¢ K x ·cbT¤Xÿ«|dOE:M æ 8/x ·cbT¤l;|dKN:MZKN@FOQ<R3<913IKSLY\8E69<9OE:@B38E4f<913 x ,YZ698l@B3H`a`R3H`2Y6a8lMpZ@FKN:iL<913t3HTN3HSL3H:=<9`m8E4fOQ<R8;SKN@I:npSL>[\3F6T·dÑ·cbb^çm8«]^3FCE3F6H\lKN3HTNM`gOQ693M8;SKN:OQ<R3HM[n Tx KN:ºYZOQ69<9K@FpTNOQ6g478E6m1KUi;13F63H:3F69iEOE:ZMI478E6d13HOHCVKU3F6dY698~R3H@B<9KNTU3H`FbcJ8E<R3g<91ZOQ<cKN:I<913^Z`9`9KN8;:TNKU473F<9KNSL3P`R<9pMKU3H` x Y698V@B3H`9`R3H`^M8I:8E<P@B8;:n<R6aKU[Zp<R3Mp32<R8<913mCE3F69%TU8;:i<9KNSL3H`rxyTU8;:iE3F6^<913H:eÿY> µ ¨ `h|gOE`a`R8l@FKOQ<R3HM]JKN<91<913M8>­6aOHvM3F3|V@FKN<9OQ<9KU8;:`Fb20g]^8/OE`9Y)3H@B<9`m]^3F693I@B8;:`aKNM3F693HMK:<913tKN:@FTp`9KUCE3SL3HOE`9p693HS3H:=<9`Fb0J13r6a`R< 8;:3@B8;:@B3F6a:Z`g<913M l>­6aO«/Y6a8lMpZ@B<9KU8;:@B698;`9``R3H@B<9KU8;:`Hbv0213/`R3H@B8;:MÈOE`RY\3H@B<@B8;:@B3F6h:`I18«]<913/3|\3H@B<58E4g<913/SpTU<9KNYZTU3KU8;:KUsHOQ<9KN8;:Å@a1ZOE:iE3H`<913/`91ZOQY)3%8E4g<913 l>­6aO«Å`RY\3H@B<R6apSºbqrp63|VY)3F6hKNSL3H:n<9OET

Page 16: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ÁUÀFÁUÀ ?ÃÃ.agf&:aj|ihD]haÃT ?:DfBYçælDB¼D:Yæç m

Ùl>­6aOH(Y698VMp@B<9KU8;:º@B6a8;`9`2`R3H@B<9KU8;:Z`g]P3F6a3t@B8;SLYZOQ693HM]JKU<91(<913t<913F8E6a3F<9KN@FOET@B8VM3ëMdmggqkkÅ[ZOE`R3HM+8;:+<913º478E6aSOETNK`9S M3H`9@B6aKU[\3HMÈKN: y!2OE:M`918D]J`5CE3F69ÈiE8n8VMOQiE693F3HS3H:=<Fb¢0J13J3|\3H@B<P8E4 <913mSpTU<9KUYTU32KU8;:KUsHOQ<9KN8;:478E6P<913`913HTNT`1KUi;13F6P<91OE: º@FOE:[)3KN:ZKU<9KNOETNTU:3Fi;TU3H@B<R3HM bP0J1np` ]^3@B8;:@B3H:n<R6aOQ<R3HM8;:TU/8;:OEMMZKU<9KU8;:OETDºf>A`a13HTNTKU8;:ZKUsHOQ<9KU8;:ÅOE:ZMÅ478;p:MÅ<91OQ<I<91ZKN`t3|\3H@B<LKN`t693HTOQ<9KUCE3HTU_`9SOETT³cK­b·3EbTU3H`9`I<91OE:8;:3OEMMZKU<9KU8;:OETºf>A`913HTNT18;TU3KN` @B693HOQ<R3HMKN:(<913`R<9pMZKU3HM(693HOE@B<9KU8;:`Fb0J13F693F478E693EKN:/<913OE:OETNl`9K`r8E4^<913Z`9`9KN8;:X<9KNSL3%`9@FOETN33|lY\3F6aKSL3H:=<<91ZKN`3|\3H@B<]JKNTTz[\3KUi;:8E693HM bb<nYZK@FOETf3|)3H@B<I8E4P<913%OEMMKU<9KN8;:OET°ºf>A`913HTNTdKU8;:KUsHOQ<9KU8;:ÅKN``918D]J:_KN:Xi;p693blbº478E6<913º6a3HOE@B<9KU8;: ¡£¢ J3+¤ ¨ª¶¨ 0cOV^]J13F693Ò<91KN`3|\3H@B</KN`5SL8;`9<LY698;:8;p:Z@B3HMÈOE:ZM+<913Y6a8E[ZOQ[ZKNTNKN<A%478E6r@B693HOQ<9KU8;:<913IOEMZMKU<9KU8;:OET]ºf>A`913HTT 18;TU3]^OE`K>Vb E?;lbRTNTz:npS3F6aKN@FOET693H`apTU<9`g@FOE:[\3r478;p:MºKN:Çy!E?­b

½MtའÔr×n\à5¢ÙaÙv9¤LjfÚ^¡\a¤m Ó5 ¤ k5Ú[kLaÙh?¡\a5Úgljf ¤hÜ Ó5Úgßc¡ Ó5Úg Ú2Ü d¡\

x :8E6aM3F6/<R8+M3F<R3F6aSK:3<913MKU693H@B< >A`a13HTNT2KU8;:ZKUsHOQ<9KU8;:YZ698E[ZOQ[ZKNTKU<A+:3HOQ6(sF3F698KNSYZOE@B<ÒYZOQ6aOESL3F<R3F6HOE:,3|VY\3F6aKNSL3H:n<Ò]^OE`ÒY\3F69478E6aSL3HM,OQ<ëM x ^]m13F693@a1OQ6hOE@¯><R3F6aK`R<9KN@ç6aO«l`/]P3F6a3vSL3HOE`9p693HM KN: @B8;KN:@FKNM3H:Z@B3]JKU<913HTOE`R<9KN@FOETNTU+`9@FOQ<R<R3F693HMYZOQ6a<9KN@FTU3H`Fbp@FTU3HOQ6%KNSYZOE@B<LYZOQ6aOESL3F<R3F6h`@FOE:[\3@B8;:`9KNM3F693HM³>X8;:<913OQ<R8;S%KN@`9@FOETN3OE`J]^3I@B8;SYZOQ693<913HS ]JKU<91<913èv>A`913HTT 6aOEMKNpZ`F3<npZOET<R8nmopQ q+rsutiv µ ¢8w ¥x ]J13F693ym ¢ QW::?>:>_4yS'OE:M8;:ZTU Tx Y698V@B3H`9`R3H`YZTNOHO6a8;TU3KN:+<91K`@FOE`R3Eb,0213¡£¢ m3 M [\3HOES47698;S<913m`9pY\3F6a@B8;:ZMp@B<9KN:i@BV@FTU8E<R698;: Jtqr,] OE`PpZ`R3HM bd0zOQ69iE3F<9`]^3F693¡£¥£¡F0214¡£¢£¶ æ [ ¼¨ N 0g[OE:ZM ¨ª¡£¢«kV:]JKN<91+<91KN@9WV:3H`9`93H`L8E4K b;lÍlb EntÿQb>ÅOE:M>VbISLi ~@FS ¡ l693H`RY\3H@B<9KUCE3HTUEbf0213Í6aOHV`P]P3F693SL3HOE`9p6a3HM%p`9K:i<A]^8LTNOQ69iE3R?>@FS ¡OQ693HO1ZKUi;1V>­YZp6hKU<AI3 YZTOE:OQ66n>­6aO«M3F<R3H@B<R8E6a`Fb0213 3HTNOE`9<9KN@^693HOE@B<9KU8;:L@a1ZOE::3HTV] OE`KNM3H:=<9KUZ3HM(pZ`9KN:i5<913t KUiQ>A KU<R3kVY)3H@B<R6a8;SL3F<R3F6Ixy 2k|My!H:­b¢0J13^2kº]^OE`2`93F<JOQ< zO~ @B8;:`9KM3F6aOQ[ZTUº`9S%OETNTU3F6<91OE:<9135iE6aOQsHKN:iÒOE:i;TU3H`F\]J1ZKN@a1v6aOE:iE3HMX[\3F<A]^3F3H:EOxߨª¡£¢«kV:)|OE:MÿEÿ O x0¡£¥£¡F021|hb0J13Jp<913F694e8E6hM@B698;`9``93H@B<9KU8;:_OQ<W O 6aOE:iE3H`t47698;S>VbH5Wl[ ~`R6x ¨ª¡£¢ k:|¢<R8`lb>LWl[ ~`R6x ¡£¥£¡ 021)|hb0213`R8;TNKNMÒOE:i;TN3t@B8«CE3F693HM[n(<913t 2kKN`Tlb(S`R6HbXPTNOE`R<9KN@FOETNTNÒ`a@FOQ<R<R3F693HMJ3IYZOQ69<9KN@FTN3H`J]^3F693693Fi;KN`R<R3F693HMp`9K:iO/M3F<R3H@¯><R8E62`RV`R<R3HS @B8;:`9K`R<9KN:iI8E46HIYZ18;`R]mKN@a1(M3F<R3H@B<R8E6a`txy`R3F3t`93H@B<9KU8;:llb;|PY)8;`aKU<9KU8;:3HM(KN:<9134e8V@FOETYZTOE:38E4f<913 2k)b OQ<9O/]P3F6a3OE@F@FpSpTNOQ<R3HMv<R8/1O«CE3IOQ[\8;p<ÿY>I<R6ap3@B8;KN:Z@FKNM3H:n<RX6aO«l`Fb/021358«CE3F6aOETTYZ18E<R8l3|%@FKU3H:Z@Bv] OE`8E[<9OEKN:3HM[nX@FOETNKU[Z6aOQ<9KN:i]JKN<91I`R<9OE:ZMOQ6aMI6aOEMKU8;OE@B<9KUCE3g`R8;p6a@B3H`c8E4 ¡ ¨ Sº ¨ ¡ X¢p ¨ª¥£¥ OrOE:M M ^8YZTNOE@B3HM5OQ<<913<9OQ69iE3F<mY\8;`9KN<9KU8;: b¢02133IM3F<R3H@B<R8E6a`]P3F693Y)8;`aKU<9KU8;:3HMOQ<ÿ: O ]JKN<91Ò693H`RY\3H@B<<R8Ò<9135[\3HOES MKU693H@B<9KN8;:vOQ<OºMKN`9<9OE:@B3I8E4Æ(@FS 4e698;S<9135<9OQ69iE3F<FbzTcOQ[`R8E69[\3F6a`]JKN<91<91K@9WV:3H`9`R3H`8E4mÿSS KN:v<913L@FOE`R3L8E4¢SL3HOE`ap693HSL3H:n<9`r]JKU<91v<913 ¨ N 0g[XOE:M¨ª¡£¢«kV:X<9OQ6aiE3F<9`IOE:M1ºSS KN:@FOE`93%8E4 <913Å¡£¥£¡F021_OE:ZMÇ¡£¢£¶ æ [_<9OQ6aiE3F<9`3|\3H@B<9KUCE3HTU693HS8«CE3HM<9135KN:=<R3H:Z`R3@B8;:n<R6aKU[p<9KU8;:8E44ºÄv6aOHV`8;:v<913TU8D]g>­3H:3F69iEv`9KNM3t8E4¢<913

Page 17: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

õf IR:ÁU9N¯äBåT_æçèBÃ3éUê

0

200

400

600

800

1000

80 90 100 110 120Energy (keV)

Cou

nts

Kα2

Kα1

Kβ1/

Kβ2/

30 MeV/u Ne+Th

ë ì_3YbÁUÀ$~ l øðô|úTî! _òï õßøðÿó"kõðøßÿòPï&ö ÷)ïuöüþòu÷)ïuòî:°ö õßñ¹òuûFôBîªõßöFï )ôBøªõðöüïuû òî+Bøßòîªÿ)ûõðö ÷ù"=ø&ó õßñòKøðòô&ï£õßöSB÷n'(%ò+*-,|ÿn34 W ò1363 < ñ; < ñòKþô&îªñòþbî òï£õðøßÿó±øßò0 øßòîªò÷õðîõßñòøßòîªÿ)ûõ"õßñ)ò L õªõðö ÷ùU )ø:ï òþ:ÿøðò=g3E %K

`RY\3H@B<R6apSºbf0213r@B8;pZ:=<26hOQ<R38E4.Ò6aOHV`g] OE`gOQ[)8;p<¼lbWlçmstKN:(3HOE@a1X3tM3F<R3H@B<R8E6HOE:M478E6t3HTNOE`R<9K@FOETNTUX`9@FOQ<R<R3F693HMYZOQ69<9KN@FTU3H`M3F<R3H@B<R3HMKN:X<9134e8V@FOETfYZTOE:3M3F<R3H@B<R8E6a`OQ[\8;p</ÿH?>WVçJsÒKN:_<R8E<9OET­bj <nYZK@FOET¢<R6ap3/@B8;KN:@FKM3H:=<¹n>­6hOHÅ`RY\3H@B<R6apZSÝ478E6I<913¡£¢FJ3%¤ ¡£¥£¡F021693HOE@B<9KU8;:KN`J`a18«]J:vKN:ºi;p693èlb! bJ0213tY698;SLYZ<2<R8%6aOE:ZM8;S 6aOQ<9KN8]^OE`OQ[\8;p<WlGNÿQb02135OQ[Z`R3H:@B358E4¢[OE@9WliE698;p:MXOQ[\8«CE3L<913L1KNi;13H`R<3H:3F69iE+²l>6aOHV`¢M3HSL8;:`R<R6aOQ<R3H`<913gY698EY\3F6f6aOE:M8;S`9p[<R6aOE@B<9KN8;:L8E4<9132:np@FTN3HOQ6°8/6aO«l`4e698;S<9132Y6a8;SLY<°n>­6aO«L`RY\3H@B<R6aOVbf0213g[ZOE@aWniE698;pZ:MOQ<¢TU8D]P3F6P3H:3F69i;KU3H`¢KN`fMp3g<R8t<913693H`RY\8;:`R3g8E4)<913Íl>­6aO«5M3F<R3H@B<R8E6Hb¢02132OQ[`R8;TNp<R3v>A`913HTTKU8;:KUsHOQ<9KU8;:5YZ698E[ZOQ[ZKNTKU<9KU3H`]P3F6a3ÒM3F<R3F6aSKN:3HMOE`<913/6hOQ<9KU8v[\3F<]P3F3H:+<913Ò:lpS[\3F6I8E42<R6ap3Ò@B8;KN:@FKNM3H:=<¿6aOHV`OE:ZM_<913%:lpSI[\3F68E4^3HTOE`R<9KN@FOETNTUX`9@FOQ<R<R3F693HMYZOQ69<9K@FTU3H`F <9OQWVKN:ivKN:=<R8OE@F@B8;pZ:=<

Page 18: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ÁUÀFÁUÀ ?ÃÃ.agf&:aj|ihD]haÃT ?:DfBYçælDB¼D:Yæç õZõ

10-4

10-3

0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6reduced velocity

P K/Z

2

12C 100 MeV20Ne 600 MeV

Pb

TbSn

Th

ThPbAu

Sm

Sn

Ag

Zr

proton 7 MeVproton 15 MeV

4He 50 MeV

4He 25 MeV4He 40 MeV

4He 74 MeV

ë aì YbÁkÀk < ñò îªñòû ûBö$&÷ö$\ôYõðö$&÷# )ø9)ô9öüûüöõ úB÷&øßóMôBû öS\uòþõ6^õßñò6îÿ)ôBøßò"õðñòC )ø òï£õßöüûüò¼ôYõ6BóKöüï÷ÿ)ó>9_òuø8B"Bø W òI="=ÿûüûî6ÿ)ôøðòîK^ô÷)þaZ="=ÿû û õßøðöFô÷ù&û òî6K6öSB÷)îþ:ò õðòuøðóTöü÷òþ"=ø6BóBÿ)øRò _òuøðöüóTò÷õðî¼õBù&ò õðñòuø °öõðñçõðñò%þôYõàôG Böü÷&õàî["=ø6Bórõðñòõßñ)òuøTò òøßöüóKòu÷õðî"&ø> ø6õ6B÷)î=g _òu÷ïuö øàï ûüò8Kô÷)þçôBû$ )ñ)ô )ôøßõßöFï ûüòîD= ò÷lõßøðöüôB÷ùBûüòB"=ÿûüûöü÷?ýBòøðîßòMõßøðöFô÷ù&û òB"=ÿûüû î6ÿ)ôøðòBôB÷)þ _òu÷ÅïuøîßîKCPôYõàô& i&ö ÷õàîc"=ø&óp"&ø ø6õ&÷)î[=g _òu÷%îÿ)ôBøßòî6K6ôBøßòôBûüîîßñ|°÷; < ñòD"=ÿûüû/ï ÿøðýBòèöüî"=ø6Bó ôi6íÂïôûFï ÿûFôYõðö$&÷y"BøRõßñ)òD ø6õ6B÷)î°ö õßñjøßòûüôõßöüýöFî õðöüïÍñ?ú:þ:ø6Bù&òu÷öFï#6ô|ý&ò)"=ÿ÷)ï£õðö$&÷)îôB÷)þèõðôöü÷ùWöü÷õWô&ïuï&ÿ÷õ°õßñòRö ÷ï øðòôBîßòþ9öü÷)þ:öü÷ùi < ñ)òþô&îªñ)òþzï ÿøðýBòÆöFî^õßñ)òz6íïôûFï ÿûFôYõðö$&÷I"&ø W òôõ2'&(%ò0*),|÷?ÿ)ïuû ò0B÷zöü÷èõðñò:íÄô ø6 öüóMôYõßöSB÷ < ñòKøðòþ:ÿ)ïuòþbýBòuûS:ï ö õ ú"õßñòMþôõðô i&ö ÷õàî4ñôBî)9_òuòu÷þ:òuõßòuøðóKö ÷)òþ`ö ÷`õßñò:íô ø6 öüóMôYõðö$&÷¹ôBîc6òuûüû:zBø°ó&BøðòÍþ:ò õàôöüûüî°îßòuòU X¡¢

<913Ir3Mn>­6hOHÒM3F<R3H@B<R8E6m3|/@FKU3H:@BEb p3<R8L<913I1KUi;1Ò`R<9OQ<9KN`R<9K@F`g8E4]Ò6aO«%>¢3HTOE`R<9KN@@B8;KN:Z@FKNM3H:@B3H`Fn3F69698E6a`PKN:<91ZKN`f3|VY)3F6hKNSL3H:n<¢OQ693rM3F<R3F6aSKN:3HML[nL<913mp:@B3F6a<9OEKN:=<KN:

Page 19: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

õ_ IR:ÁU9N¯äBåT_æçèBÃ3éUê

<913t3|%@FKN3H:@B/8E4d<913Ir3Mn>­6hOHºM3F<R3H@B<R8E6a`OE:Mº<913<9OQ6aiE3F<J<91KN@aWl:3H`9`Fb02136a3H`9pTU<g8E4c8;p6JKU8;:ZKUsHOQ<9KU8;:ºY6a8E[ZOQ[ZKNTNKN<A%SL3HOE`ap693HSL3H:n<9`J:3HOQ6JsF3F698%KNSLYOE@B<

YZOQ6aOESL3F<R3F6tK`mi;KNCE3H:KN:<9OQ[TU3ÅlbNÿQb02135<9OQ[ZTU35OETN`R8ºTNK`R<9`J<913<913F8E693F<9KN@FOETdY693HMZKN@¯><9KU8;:`5xy@B4by!?>DH?>HVÿ|7|hb0213H`R3IY693HMKN@B<9KN8;:`2OQ693SOEM35KN:<]P8ÒMKN`R<9K:@B<JOQYY6a8l>KNSOQ<9KU8;:Z`Fbg0213Z6a`R<28;:3KN`2<913Ip:KN<R3HMOQ<R8;S OQYY698BVKNS%OQ<9KU8;:x0¬Tr|2]J13F6a3KU<mK`OE`9`9pS3HMX<91OQ<OE`<9135Y6a8~?3H@B<9KNTN3LY)3H:3F<R6aOQ<R3H`<913KN:Z:3F6r3HTU3H@B<R698;:KN@5`913HTNTN`F\<913H`R3`913HTNT`^OEMQRp`9<^<R8L6a3YÏ3H@B<g<913tKN:@B6a3HOE`R3HMÒ[ZKN:MZKN:it8E4c<913t@B8;SI[ZKN:3HMÒY6a8~?3H@B<9KNTN3rOE:ZM<9OQ69iE3F<:lp@FTU3HOQ6@h1OQ69iE3Eb x :X<913`R3H@B8;:MX<913`R3FYZOQ6aOQ<R3HMOQ<R8;S'x­k|OQYY698BVKNS%O~><9KU8;:È<913(Y698~R3H@B<9KNTU3/S8«CE3H`5<R8l84yOE`R<<R8X3|)3H@B<L`9p@h1+Ov@h1OE:iE3Eb x :3HKU<913F6L@FOE`R3E<913693HTU3FCQOE:=<PCE3HTU8l@FKN<A%KN`P<91OQ<^8E4 <913Y698~R3H@B<9KNTU3J6a3HTNOQ<9KUCE3J<R8<913rër>A`913HTT3HTU3H@B<R698;: b021KN` 6a3HMp@B3HMÒCE3HTU8V@FKU<A¤£ o KN`gM3F:3HMºOE`

£ o Q ¥¦ ¸¦ o¨§x lbNÿ«|

]J13F693 ¦ ¸ OE:ZM ¦ o OQ6a3/<913ÒY6a8~?3H@B<9KNTN3/OE:M v>A`913HTNT¢8E69[ZKU<9OETP3HTU3H@B<R698;:ÈCE3HTU8V@FKU<9KU3H`693H`RY\3H@B<9KUCE3HTUE ¥ Q ©ªsuti«­¬¬ µ ¢8w ¥xg®¯ KN`/OÈ`9@B693F3H:ZKN:iÅYOQ6aOESL3F<R3F6º`918D]JKN:i_<913:8;:>1=VM698EiE3H:ZKN@L@a1OQ6hOE@B<R3F68E4 <913Åv>A`913HTNTdKU8;:ZKUsHOQ<9KU8;:X3H:3F69iEEz]J13F693G° ±KN`r<913ë>`913HTNT\[KN:MKN:iI3H:3F6aiEÒOE:ZM+·²³³5<9133|\3H@B<9KUCE35OQ<R8;SKN@t:lpSI[\3F6g8E4c<913t<9OQ69iE3F<Fb)´Q ÿlbH3YKN`P<913r2VM[\3F69iI@B8;:`9<9OE:=<Fb x :/<913M¬R OQYY698BVKNS%OQ<9KU8;: ¦ o OE:M ¥ p`93·²³³QÕ·µÇ¤·¶bf]m1KNTU3(KN:_<913k ·²³³JQÕ·cb,KN`5p`93HM bv,13F693HOE`5478E6LTNKUi;1n<Y698~R3H@B<9KNTU3H`<913/MK)3F693H:Z@B3%[\3F<A]^3F3H:Å<913%<A]^8Y693HMKN@B<9KN8;:`tKN`I`9SOETNT³z4e8E6513HO«ClKU3F6Y698~R3H@B<9KNTU3H`<913MKF\3F693H:@B3KN`M<lpKU<R3L`R<R698;:izKN:XYZOQ6a<9KN@FpTNOQ6478E6m3Eb0213L3|VY)3F6hK >SL3H:n<9OET693H`9pZTU<9`gOQYY\3HOQ62<R8%KN:ZMKN@FOQ<R3<91OQ<JOQ6a8;p:M¤£ o· ÿtOL<R6hOE:`9KU<9KU8;:Ò47698;S<913¬R,<R8<913kkKN`f693<lpKU693HMbfqrp6¢693H`9pZTU<9`OQ693`9pSSOQ6hKUsF3HMKN:%i;p693Rlbt<R8EiE3F<913F6]JKU<91Or@B8;SLYZKNTNOQ<9KN8;:I8E4Z8E<913F6TNKUi;1n<?>AKU8;:5MOQ<9OVbf0213^47pZTNT;<R6aKOE:i;TU3H`dOE:M47pZTNT=` <lpOQ693H`OQ6934e698;S <913M;lbIu3YM ~p9y!H:H?)OE:ZM`?>5u3YW ~pÒJ33|lY\3F6aKSL3H:=<9`H=693H`RY\3H@B<9KUCE3HTNEb0213KU8;:KUsHOQ<9KU8;: Y698E[ZOQ[KNTNKU<9KU3H`LOQ6a3v:8E6aS%OETNKUsF3HM<R8È<913XOQ<R8;SKN@v:npSI[\3F6%8E4t<913Y698~R3H@B<9KNTU3E·µ^)pZ`9KN:ia¸ oU¹ ·µ ¡ ]J1ZKN@a1vOETNTU8«]m`J8;:3I<R8(`a@FOETU3I<913ITNKUi;1n<JYZ698~?3H@B<9KTU3MOQ<9OVbJo8E6r<913I693HMp@B3HMCE3HTU8V@FKU<A<9135kCQOETNp3] OE`@a18;`R3H:)OE`m<R8/iE3F<<913I[)3H`9<8«CE3F6aOETT¢`9@FOETNK:ibL0213KN:@FTpM3HMXTNKUi;1n<?>AKU8;:MOQ<9OOQ6a3L<913693H`9pZTU<9`r8E4PYZ693FClKN8;p`r3|n>Y\3F6aKNSL3H:n<9`t8;:ÈO æ [<9OQ6aiE3F<478E6Òÿvu3Y Y698E<R8;:Z`(x78EY\3H:È@FKU6a@FTU3H`h|tOE:M ?>u3Yx747pZTNT@FKU6a@FTN3D| >­YOQ69<9KN@FTU3H`m4e6a8;SÙy!HE&­)4e8E6K:/u3Y x78EY\3H:<R6hKNOE:i;TU3D|h >/u3Y.x747pZTNTKN:nCE3F6a`R3r<R6aKNOE:i;TN3D|hVOE:ZMlE& u3Y x78EY\3H:Ò@B698;`9`¯| >­YZOQ69<9K@FTU3H` 4e6a8;SÕy!H OE:ZM/<9136a3B>`9pTU<9`¢8E4]Etu3Y Y698E<R8;:`¢8;:%CQOQ6aKU8;pZ`f<9OQ69iE3F<9`x78EY\3H:/` <lpOQ693H`¯|c4e6a8;Sy ÿ;­b0213247pZTNT@Fp69CE3m693H`9pTU<9`4e698;S OkÍ@FOETN@FpZTNOQ<9KU8;:%`a@a13HSL3m4e8E6PY698E<R8;:`POE`¢YZ698~?3H@B<9KTU3H`p`9K:i693HTNOQ<9KUCVKN`R<9K@g1=VM698EiE3H:K@ ]^O«CE34yp:@B<9KN8;:`F;KN:L]m1KN@a1693H@B8;KNTZOE:ZMKN:@B693HOE`93HM[ZKN:ZMKN:i3|)3H@B<9`1OHCE35[\3F3H:<9OQWE3H:KN:=<R8ÒOE@F@B8;p:n<by!HVÿEHE&­b02135MOE`913HMX@Fp69CE3693FY6a3H`R3H:=<9`<913r@B8E69693H`RY\8;:MK:iI@FOETN@FpZTNOQ<9KU8;:`P4e8E6gm3K:%<913tk OQYZY698KNSOQ<9KN8;:jy!?>UH?>?­bf3:8E<R3<91OQ< <913pZ`9pOET·µ ¡ `9@FOETNK:iM8l3H` :8E<^OQYZYZTULOE:=VSL8E693478E6#£d ÿQb0J13J693HO~>`R8;:(KN`<91OQ<^<913OEMKNOQ[ZOQ<9KN@J6aOEMKNpZ`F=K³b·3EbUl<913J6hOEMKNp`¢]J13F6932<913mKU8;:KNsHOQ<9KU8;:Y6a8l@B3H`9`

Page 20: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ÁUÀSR3Àpº_Ã?BÃ: JKXhà Y¯?æç0_y0¹ g»]Y¹IRL Ãag0æV õ"

¬T k 3|lY\3F6aKSL3H:=<0zOQ6aiE3F< £ o ¸ o £ o ¸ o ¸ o 3F696a8E6¼¸ o¡£¥£¡ 021 >VbH:H b; >Vb E:E :lbH Vÿ ¡£¢£¶ æ [ >Vb E& :;lb! >Vb;E :HlbH : ¨ N 0g[ >Vb:; )lb E ÿQbNÿBE H bH HE E¨ª¡£¢«kV: ÿQb: E:EnbH ÿQbH?> ÿEÿlb> E ÿY>

N6]hDÃ`ÁUÀ_ < ñò0Bøðò õðöüïôû?ô÷)þRò _òuøðö óKòu÷õàôû:þ:öüøßòï£õ îªñòû û?öSB÷öS\ôõßöSB÷ ø9)ô9)ö ûüöõðö òî½¾öü÷ÿ÷ö õðî";E8']¿ "Bø'(Åò+*),Yÿ W ò¶ ø6 òï õßöüû òî+6ôûFï ÿûFôYõðö$&÷)î"&øUõßñ)ò]ÿ÷ö õßòþ¼ôõBó=gÀ4í2KôB÷)þKõßñ)òPîßò+ )ôBøðôõßòþMôYõ&ól=:í#Kô ø6 ö óMôYõðö$&÷Wôøðò/ùBöüýBò÷Wöü÷)ï ûüÿ)þ:öü÷ùRõßñòÆï&øßøðòî i&÷)þ:öü÷ùøðòþ:ÿï òþèýBòû$:ïuöõ úÁ ¾

KN`2WlKN:3HSOQ<9KN@FOETNTU/47O«CE8E693HM [)3H@B8;S3H`JSp@a1vTNOQ69iE3F6J<91ZOE:@FTNOE`9`[email protected]>A`913HTNT\6aOEMZKNp`478E6TKUi;1=<R3F6<9OQ69iE3F<9`FbX^_8E[Z`R3F6aClKN:i<913(8«CE3F6aOETTPOQiE693F3HS3H:=<L[\3F<A]^3F3H:+MOQ<9OOE:M<913F8E6aEZKU<gOQYY\3HOQ6a` <91OQ<2<913W¬ROQYY698BVKSOQ<9KU8;:Ò]^8E69Wl`2[)3H`9<^478E6[£Â>à En]m1KNTU3<913IkkOQYYZ698KNSOQ<9KU8;:OQYY\3HOQ6a` <R8[\3tOQYY698EYZ6aKNOQ<R3478E6[£d ÿQb

8;:`9KNM3F6hKN:i<913tSOE`9` <R6aOE:`94e3F6g693HOE@B<9KN8;:ç¡£¢FJ3è¤M¡£¥£¡F021ç¦ ¨ª©Hq ¤®¡£¥£©Y¬T­m]^3@FOE:L`9@FOETN3^8;p6f3|lY\3F6aKNS3H:=<9OETNTN8E[Z<9OEKN:3HM5693H`9pZTU< 478E6f<913gMKU693H@B<°v>A`913HTTnKU8;:ZKUsHOQ<9KU8;:Y6a8E[ZOQ[ZKNTNKN<AÒ4e8E6<91ZKN`r@FOE`R3p`9KN:i%<913L478;TNTU8D]JKN:i(OE`9`9pSLYZ<9KU8;: bt0213LOESLYTNKU<9pM3IKN`KN:n<R3FiE6aOQ<R3HMOETU8;:i/<913<R6aODR3H@B<R8E69E<91lp`]P35<9OQWE3L<]P8º1OETU4f<R6hOD?3H@B<R8E69X@B8;TNTNK`9KU8;:`F8;:3r478E6gJ3OE:M(8;:3r478E62q5bVoZp69<913F6 ]^3r@B8;:Z`9KNM3F6 <91OQ<¼·µ ¡ `9@FOETNKN:i5KN` `R<9KNTTCQOETNKNM478E62<913¹?>(u3YW ~pm3¤021Ò6a3HOE@B<9KU8;:OE:M@FOETN@FpTNOQ<R3I¸ o Ä ²ÅÆ OE`

¸ o Ä ²ÅÆ · x ÿÇ ¸ o Ä ² ¤ ÿ· Æ· Ä ² Ç ¸ o Ä ² | ¡ Q >Ã;Vÿ|¸ o Ä ² · ÿà Ez´_ÿY> µ ¡ Ãx lb;|

021ZKN`fCQOETNp3JKN`P`9p%@FKN3H:=<9TULTNOQ6aiE3J478E6^OISL3HOE:KN:iE4ypT@B8;K:@FKNM3H:@B3m3|lY\3F6aKSL3H:=<¢]JKU<91Z`a`9KU8;:Ò476aOQi;SL3H:n<9`Fb

½Mt6È É ¤mÙaßLÙ9Úg × ¾ :kL?¡)Ú2ÙlÖM×n Ú°Ø ¢Ü 9))a¤m»wH¤mÛÊÒ ¢¡ËÌ ÙauwHd¡\hÜ ^8;:Z`9KNM3F6aK:iX<913@B8;K:@FKNM3H:@B3vSL3HOE`9p693HS3H:=<9`([\3F<A]^3F3H: 6aOHV`ÒOE:MZ`a`9KU8;:476aOQi;SL3H:n<9`Fc]P36a3HOETNKUsF3<91OQ<I<913%@h1OQ6aOE@B<R3F6aKN`9<9KN@%`91ZOQY)3L8E4 <913` n>­6aO«`RY\3H@B<R6aO@FOE:[\38E[<9OEKN:3HMX8;:ZTUvKU4P<913LOHCE3F6aOQiE3/Z`9`9KN8;:TKU4e3F<9KSL3K`@B8;SLYZOQ6aOQ[ZTN3]mKU<91<913TNKN4e3F<9KNS38E4<913%v>A`913HTT CQOE@FOE:@BEbIè 3F<p`r`R<9OQ69<r]JKU<91v<913LOE`9`9pSY<9KU8;:v<91OQ<r<913@h1OQ6aOE@B<R3F6aKN`9<9KN@èn>­6aO«v`91ZOQY)35KN`:8E<O)3H@B<R3HM_[nv<913I`9`9KU8;:TNKU473F<9KNSL3Eb0213èl>­6aOH

Page 21: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

õ)@ IR:ÁU9N¯äBåT_æçèBÃ3éUê

Y698VMp@B<9KU8;:Ò6hOQ<R3KN` i;KUCE3H:º[l ÍiÎ oÍÏ QpÐ ÎÑ Ä x Ï |Ò µÓ|Ô § x lb;|]J13F693ÐKN`2<913èv>A`913HTNT 18;TU3IM3H@FOH6aOQ<R35OE:M ÎÑ Ä x Ï |JKN`2<913I:lpS[\3F6m8E4:np@FTN3HKOQ<2<9KNSL3 Ï <91OQ<JMZKNMº:8E<2Z`a`9KU8;:(E3F<Fb

ÎÑ Ä x Ï |Q Î ¢ Ò µ;Ô Þ6Õ § x lb! n|]J13F693GÖK`m<913Z`9`9KN8;:TKU4e3F<9KSL3Eb Î ¢ KN`r<913L<R8E<9OETP:npSI[\3F68E4^:lp@FTU3HKcY6a8lMpZ@B3HM <91npZ`g3FCE3H:=<9pZOETNTUÒ<913t:lpS[\3F6g8E4dZ`9`aKU8;:(3FCE3H:=<9` Î ³DQ Î ¢ b¢0J13H:

Î o×QÙØÛÚ¢

Ð Î Ñ Ä x Ï |Ò µÓÔ ÍÏ QpØÛÚ¢

Ð Î ¢ Ò µ;Ô Þ6Õ Ò µÓ|Ô ÍzÏ Q Î ¢ Ð;Öÿ¤ÜÐÖ Ã x lb;|

x :<91KN`J]^O«<913`9`9KU8;:vTNKU473F<9KNSL3Ö@FOE:v[\3M3F<R3F6aS%KN:3HM47698;S <913:lpSI[\3F628E4/n>­6hOHV`JSL3HOE`9p693HMKN:º@B8;KN:Z@FKNM3H:@B3]JKN<91Ò<913Z`9`9KN8;:Ò4e6aOQi;S3H:=<9` Î o µ ³lGÎ o µ ³Î ³¸ o Q Ð;Ö

ÿ4¤ÜÐÖ § x lbH;|]J13F693¸¶o KN`t<913v>A`913HTNTPKU8;:KUsHOQ<9KN8;:_Y698E[OQ[ZKNTNKU<EzM3F<R3F6hSKN:3HMKN:Å`R3H@B<9KN8;: lblbçJ8D]P3FCE3F6«24e8E6/<913`918E69<R3F6%Z`a`9KU8;:TNKU473F<9KNSL3H`5<9133H:3F69iE+8E4r<913vK:KU<9KNOET OE:M>:OET¢`9<9OQ<R3H`8E4g<913%3HTU3H@B<R698;:[)3H@B8;S3H`t<9KNSL3B>AM3FY)3H:ZM3H:=<tOE:ZMÅ@FOEp`R3(MKN`R<R8E6a<9KU8;:8E4<913% l>­6aO«v`RY\3H@B<R6aOVbocKNi;p693%lbHÒ`918«]m`OÒu8;TU3H@FpTOQ6R> q69[ZKN<9OET^x³uXqt|mMKNOQiE6aOES4e8E65m3&¤rJ3Ef<9OQWE3H:+OE`5OiE3H:3F6aKN@(`RlS%SL3F<R6aKN@`9l`R<R3HSbXqr:Å<913/TU3F47<I`aKNM38E42<913MKNOQiE6aOESÝ3H:3F69iE_TU3FCE3HT`t8E4g<913 ¬R OOQ693/`918«]J:OE`IO47p:Z@B<9KU8;:8E4g<913(KN:=<R3F69>:npZ@FTU3HOQ6LMKN`R<9OE:@B3¤´5b x 4g]^3º@B8;:@B3H:n<R6aOQ<R3º8;:TU_8;:ÈZTTNKN:iº<913v>A`913HTNTPCQOE@FOE:@B]P3]P8;pTM/8E[`R3F69CE3O5[6a8;OEMº[ZOE:M(8E46/6aO«l`x0<npZOE`9K >ASL8;TU3H@FpZTNOQ6P(6aO«l`¯|^693H`9pTN<9KN:i4e6a8;S <913TNTNKN:i<913ÅÿáPCQOE@FOE:@BOE`<913<A]^8OQ<R8;S%`/`R3FYOQ6aOQ<R3OE`(KN:+Z`9`9KN8;: b3Y\3F69478E6aSL3HM@FOETN@FpZTNOQ<9KU8;:`478E6t<913%693HTU3FCQOE:=<t6a3HOE@B<9KU8;: ¡£¢ m3 ¤ ¡£¥£¡ 021¦ ¨ª© q¤Ù¡£¥£©Y¬T­<R8+`9<9pM18D]Õ¬ l>­6aOH `9Y)3H@B<R6hOÅ]JKTNT2@a1ZOE:iE3M3FY\3H:MKN:iÅ8;:<913^8;SLY\8;p:M>Amp@FTN3Hp`%x­ |tTKU4e3F<9KSL3Ebo8E65<91KN`@FOETN@FpTNOQ<9KN8;:`t]^3(pZ`R3HM1:18;TN<YÐÃ`<913F8E69º8E4uXqOE:M Ân>­6aO«º3HSKN`9`aKU8;:y!VU ­b^3@B8;:`9KNM3F6J13F693I<A]^8Q>A@B8;TNTNKN`9KN8;:uq9l>­6aO«/Y6a8lMpZ@B<9KU8;: b x :(<91KN` `9@B3H:ZOQ6aKU85<913r<9OQ69iE3F<JKN`^CE3F69/<91KN@aW/`R85<91OQ<2SL8E6a3<91OE:8;:3@B8;TTNKN`9KU8;:@FOE:_<9OQWE3%YZTNOE@B3Eb x :O6a`R<@B8;TNTNK`9KU8;:Oçv>A`913HTNTd18;TU3LKN:X8;:38E4 <913%OQ<R8;S`KN`Y6a8lMpZ@B3HMX]J1KN@h1_KN`<R6aOE:Z`R4e3F6a693HMX<R8<913vÿáP uXq`9<9OQ<R3/KN:<913`R3H@B8;:Mv@B8;TNTNKN`9KN8;: b x :<913tYZ693H`R3H:n<m@FOE`R3I<913I18;TN3tKN`J@B693HOQ<R3HMv[l(<913Y698~R3H@B<9KNTU3tK:<913 Tx Y698V@B3H`9`Fc[Zp<<913%Z`9`9KU8;:XYZ698l@B3H`a`KN`tOE:ZOETU8EiE8;p`t<R8v<913/uXq <R6aODR3H@B<R8E69Ebx : y ) KU<^]^OE`g`a18«]J:/<91OQ< <913r@B8;:=<9K:nppZSMZKUY\8;TU32CE3HTU8V@FKU<A/SOQ<R6aKF%3HTN3HSL3H:=< [ÞÝgßKN`m3<npOETc<R8(<9135o8;p6aKU3F6r<R6aOE:Z`R4e8E6hS 8E4<913I<9KNS3M3FY\3H:M3H:=<ruq MKUY\8;TU3ISOQ<R6aKF3HTU3HSL3H:n< [Gß x¢´x Ï |R|h]JKN<91Þ´x Ï |^<913t@FTNOE`9`9KN@FOET<R6aOD?3H@B<R8E6aÅxyKN:=<R3F6h:np@FTN3HOQ6JMKN`R<9OE:Z@B3D|

[Gß x¢´x Ï |R|Qlà@ácâã - ã á ßä § x lb EE|

Page 22: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ÁUÀSR3Àpº_Ã?BÃ: JKXhà Y¯?æç0_y0¹ g»]Y¹IRL Ãag0æV õ_

ë aì YbÁkÀuåUV(BûüòïuÿûüôBø !æ ø69öõàôûþ:öüôBùBøàôóç"Bøõßñ)ò W òX1 W ò6îßú:î õðòuó < ñöFî L ù&ÿøßòöüî õàôBò÷"=ø6Bóè$E0é|¡@]J13F693UácâcKN`2<913tKN:KU<9KOETcÿáPÅuXq18;TU3t`9<9OQ<R3IOE:M¤á ß K`g<913Z:OET 18;TU3t`R<9OQ<R3E[ÞÝß x@êP|Q ÿë ì ØÛÚµ Ú

ÍÏ [Gß x¢´x Ï |R|6m ¨íî x Ï |¶ïÒðÝ6y ñØ Ô x@êóòê ¨íî x Ï ` |¤ôê ß x Ï ` |R| ÍÏ ` §x lb;;|]J13F693 m ¨íî x Ï |eÒ|ð)Ý6yuòõØ Ô Ðzx¢´x Ï ` |R| ÍÏ ` § x lb;|KN`c<913gYZ698E[ZOQ[ZKNTKU<AtOESLYTNKU<9pM3P4e8E61ZOHCVKN:iOLÿáPºuXqC~OE@FOE:Z@BEb x :<913g3|VY693H`a`9KU8;:lbUÐzx¢´| K` <913gM3H@FO«I6hOQ<R3^8E4Z<913ÿáP/C~OE@FOE:Z@BEb0213 @B8;:=<9KN:lppSMKNY)8;TN3CE3HTU8V@FKU<ASOQ<R6hKF/3HTU3HS3H:=<J@B8;:Z`9KN`R<9`g8E4d<916a3F3t@B8;:=<R6aKN[Zp<9KU8;:`HG

ö x@êP|QpØ Úµ Ú

ÍzÏ QpØ ¢µ Ú

¤FØ b¢¤FØ Úb § x lbNÿY>=|

Page 23: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

õZ IR:ÁU9N¯äBåT_æçèBÃ3éUê

ë ì_3YbÁUÀu÷U(GBûüòï ÿ)ûüôBø !æ ø9)öõàôûø&ó& i&ÿ÷)þ W ÿ)ïuû òÿ)î øàô|úzòuóKöüîðîßö$&÷a ø69)ô9öüû ö õ ú"BøýYôøðö$&ÿ)îøù:úèýYôûüÿòî+B]°ñòøßò#ù¨Fû ¾Cüzýþ öüî6õðñò Iÿ õßøàô÷îªö õßöSB÷D"=øßò8ÿòu÷)ïuúU"Bø2?#Rô÷)þúzöüî6õðñòøBó& Bÿ÷)þ W ÿ)ï ûüòuÿ)î^ûüö$"=ò õßöüóKò < ñ)öüî L ùBÿøðòÆöüî6õàôBò÷I"=ø6Bó ¡]J13F693KN`2O%`R<9KN@9WVKN:i%<9KNSL3t[\3F<A]^3F3H:<]P8Ò:lp@FTU3HK³b¢odKUi;p693èlb EL`a18«]J`m@FOETN@FpTNOQ<R3HMuq l>­6aOH/3HSKN`9`aKU8;:(Y698E[ZOQ[ZKTNKU<9KU3H`f478E6g<913W?>:>u3YKa¤rK)`9lSS3F<R6aKN@`Rl`R><R3HSºbf0213 `91OQY\3^8E4Z<913Pl>­6aOH`RY\3H@B<R6apS`R<9OQ69<9`d<R8[\3P8E4@a1OQ6aOE@B<R3F6hKN`R<9KN@g:OQ<9p693^OQ<êÖ¤QÂ?>Vbmo698;S <913IM3FY\3H:M3H:Z@B3t]JKU<91¨êÖ¨ÂÿY>/KN<J@FOE:[\3@B8;:Z@FTNpM3HM<91OQ<m<913@B8;:=<R6hKU[Zp<9KU8;:Z`2478E6 ¢µ Ú OE:ZM Úb OQ6935`9SOETNT­b x :8;p6r@FOE`R35]^3I]JKTNT:8E<<9OQWE3KN:n<R8OE@F@B8;p:n<m<913IKN:@B8;SKN:i ¢µ Ú Mp3t<R8/OLCE3F6a`918E69<Ix eÿY>_µ ¡¨ `h| 4e8E6aS%OQ<9KU8;:<9KNS3Eb

Page 24: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ÁUÀSR3Àpº_Ã?BÃ: JKXhà Y¯?æç0_y0¹ g»]Y¹IRL Ãag0æV õkC

0213^8;p<RiE8;KN:i Úb ]JKU<91LTU8;:iE3F6f<9KNSL3H`2x e 4´5ÿY>_µ ¡£¢ `h|cKN`dOETN`R8t:3Fi;TU3H@B<R3HMOE`KU<d[\3B>@B8;SL3H`JKNSLY\8E69<9OE:n<^8;:ZTU]J13H:¤êÖÒKN`g`aSOETNTfx ÿY>=|hZKN:(]J1ZKN@a1Ò@FOE`R3t<913t`RY\3H@B<R6apS]^8;pTNM(MKN`9OQYZY)3HOQ6^KN:<913¼8>­6aOH/[ZOE@9WliE698;p:M(Y6a8lMpZ@B3HM[l<913rZ`9`9KN8;:476aOQi;SL3H:n<9`xy`R3F3vMKN`9@Fp`a`9KU8;:ÈKN:@a1OQYZ<R3F6 EE|hbçJ3F6a3 ö x¢´|aQ ö x0>=|hx@ê ¨í!î x0>=|-òZê ß x0>=|R|LOE:MÐQpÐzx0>=|gOQ693t@B8;:`9<9OE:=<Fb x <26a3HMp@B3H` [ÞÝgß x@êP|^<R8<913è 8E693H:n<Rst4e8E6hSºG[ÞÝgß x@êP|e ÿë ì Ø

b¢ÍzÏ ö x0>=|Ò|ð)Ý6y ñhx@êôòê ¨íî x0>=|.¤ôê ß x0>=|R| Ï òçÐzx0>=| Ï ¹ &Qx¢mM¤ôñF||y Ò|ð)Ýcx@ñhx@êçòFê ¨íî x0>=|.¤ôê ß x0>=|R|×òôÐ x0>=| ¹ ;|ò ÿ § x lbNÿEÿ«|

]J13F693 m Q ´Ò ÿë ì [ ¢ñhx@êçòê ¨íî x0>=|.¤ôê ß x0>=|R|òôÐ x0>=| ¹ à x lbNÿ;|0213Y698E[ZOQ[ZKTNKU<A%8E4z<913uq8E6r º6aO«Ò3HSKN`9`9KN8;:/]mKNTNT)[\3

Í ¸Í ê e ÿÖ Ø Ú¢ Ò|ðÝdxò ¹ ÖZ||ã [ x@ê § ||ã ¡ Í Q x¢m ¡ ¤ ¡ |Bx?ÿ4¤ ÿ

ÿP¤ÜÐ;Ö ò1 ÿ¤ÜÐ;Ö ¹ x?ÿ4¤ÜÐÖ ¹ ;| ¡ ¤xRx@êóòê ¨í!î ¤ôê ß |6Ö)| ¡ |Q ÿ

x@êçòê ¨íî ¤ôê ß | ¡ ¤ÜÐ ¡ ¹ ´ x?ÿ4¤ ÿ

ÿ4¤ÜÐÖ ò ÿ4¤ÛÐÖ ¹ x?ÿP¤ÛÐÖ ¹ ;| ¡ ¤xRx@êçòê ¨íî ¤çê ß |6ÖZ| ¡ |0à x lbNÿ;|

x :n<R3FiE6aOQ<9KN:i8«CE3F6yê[n ß Í ê Í ¸ ¹ Í ê e Ó Õ¨ Ó Õ ]J13F693 ÓÓ KN`/<913 >A`a13HTNTÏZp8E693H`9@B3H:@B3(lKN3HTNM c<91KN`KN``9KSLYZTU3<npZOQ<9KU8;:³lbHlb_ 8;:`9KNM3F6hKN:iÅx@ê ¨íî òê ß |KN`<913CQOQ6aKNOQ<9KU8;:/4e6a8;S <9133H:3F69iE8E4<913MKOQiE6aOES TKN:3H`Fn]P3r3H:M(pYÒ]JKU<91%<913rZ:OET`RY\3H@B<R6apZSºG

¸/x¢Ö § ñ | Q ÿx¢° ¹ òñ | ¡ ¤ Ð ¡ ¹ x ÿ4¤ Ð;ÖÐ]Ö |

´ x?ÿP¤ ÿÿ4¤ÜÐÖ ò ÿ4¤ Ð;Ö ¹

x?ÿ4¤ÜÐÖ ¹ ;| ¡ ¤xRx¢° ¹ òñ |6ÖZ| ¡ |0à x lbNÿ| n|0213 K:M3|Iñ9lKN`fO@a1ZOE::3HTN`fKN:5<913Æn>­6aO«`9Y)3H@B<R6hpSºb x :5<9132@FOET@FpTNOQ<9KU8;:`d478E6/¬êOE`OIg 3<lpOQ<9KU8;:blbNÿ| I]^OE`Pp`R3HM5]JKN<91G° OE`¢3H:3F69iE58E4<913JMKNOQiE6aOES±«l>­6aO«5TKN:3H`Fb q Ô Q ÐõQ ÿY>HL3Yx7<913:OQ<9p6aOET TKN:3]JKNM<91Ò478E6¼¬KN` <9OQWE3H:47698;S y!:7|gOE:MyÖ]^3ICQOQ6947698;S.<913<9KNSL3ÖÞQ ! #"%$ @B8E69693H`RY\8;:MZKN:i<R8ÒTNKU473F<9KNSL3t8E4¢<913¬±>A`a13HTNTCQOE@FOE:@Bx H´+ÿY>_µ ¨ª¶ `h|m<R8v<913CE3F69`918E6a<<9KNSL3x ´+ÿY>_µ ¡£¢ `h|hb(0213L693H`9pZTU<9KN:i

Page 25: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

õc IR:ÁU9N¯äBåT_æçèBÃ3éUê

10-1

1

10

90 95 100 105 110 115Energy (keV)

P

6×10-18 s (characteristic for U)

10-18 s

5×10-19 s

10-19 s

5×10-20 s

ë ì_3YbÁUÀ'&3 6ôûFï ÿ)ûüôõßòþ³îßñ)ô òîG"Mõðñò V øàô|ú1î òï£õßøàô "&øÅõßñ)ò+þ:ö)(_òøßò÷õÞøBó i&ÿ÷)þ W ÿï ûüòuÿ)î[=À2K6ûüö "=òuõßöüóKòî0

`RY\3H@B<R6aOOQ693gY6a3H`R3H:=<R3HM%KN:i;p693lb;lbP^8;:`aKNM3F6aKN:im<913H`93g693H`9pTU<9`H;KU<fKN`fKNSLY\8E69<9OE:n<<R88E[Z`R3F6aCE3<91OQ<JOQ<J<9KNSL3H`2`918E69<R3F6J<91OE: · ÿY>_µ ¨ N `Ix@êÖ · ?>=|^<913`a1OQY\38E4c<913 l>­6aO«ê`RY\3H@B<R6apZSâTU8;`R3H`Ò<913@a1ZOQ6aOE@B<R3F6aKN`R<9K@`R<R6ap@B<9p6a3Eb^@B8;SYZOQ6aKN:i+<91K`i;p693X<R8i;p693Çlb E]P3_:8E<9K@B3<91ZOQ<KN:M3FY\3H:M3H:n<9TU8E4I<913Y698~R3H@B<9KNTU3B>­<9OQ69iE3F<`RV`R<R3HS <913@h1OQ6aOE@B<R3F6aK`R<9KN@TNK:3º`91OQY\3`918;pTMÈOQYZY)3HOQ6/OQ<GêÖ · ?>VbTU693HOEMOQ<º<9KNSL3H`ºTU3H`a`/<91ZOE:ÿY> µ ¨ª¶`Ò<913X]JKNM<918E4I<913¯ l>­6aOH,TNKN:3H`H23H`RY\3H@FKNOETNTUK:<913693Fi;KN8;:X8E4^<913ÅG_Zz[\3H@B8;SL3]JKNM3F6]mKU<91X693H`RY\3H@B<<R8<913/@a1OQ6aOE@B<R3F6hKN`R<9KN@TKN:3

Page 26: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ÁUÀ$~ ÀÂQUæçæç8ç^Å:æBÃ3éj V_Ãa)Dæç? õm

`91ZOQY)3Eb 021lp`2KU4c4yp`9KU8;:V>­`9`9KU8;:ºTNKN4e3F<9KNS3H`gOQ693ITU8;:iE3F6J<91OE:ÿY>_µ ¨ N `2]^3I`a18;pTNMÒ[\3OQ[ZTN3(<R88E[`R3F69CE3º693HTNOQ<9KNCE3HTUÅ`91OQ6aY¿l>­6aOHTNKN:3H`Fb_0213º@FOETN@FpTOQ<R3HM`RY\3H@B<R6aOKN:i;p693¹lb;]mKNTNT)[\3t4e8;TM3HMº]JKU<91<913t3|VY)3F6hKNSL3H:n<9OET 693H`R8;TNp<9KU8;: K³b·3Eb^<913Wl>­6aO«v3M3F<R3H@B<R8E6%693H`RY\8;:`R3Ò4yp:@B<9KU8;:+OE:M+p`R3HMOE`5:iE3F69Y6aK:=<9`5KN:È<913ºOE:OETUV`9KN`8E4m<913@B8;KN:Z@FKNM3H:@B3Ò3|VY)3F6hKNSL3H:n<9`Fbm8E<R3<91OQ<KN:È<913M3F6aKUCQOQ<9KU8;:`5KU<LKN`5OE`9`9pS3HM+<91OQ<<913XZ`a`9KU8;:,TNKU473F<9KNSL3XMKN`R<R6hKU[Zp<9KU8;: 4e8;TTU8«]J`Ò<913_p`9pOET3|VY)8;:3H:=<9KNOETrM3H@FO«,<9KNSL3MK`R<R6aKU[Zp<9KU8;: b021KN`%<9KNSL3MKN`R<R6aKN[Zp<9KU8;:KN`(KN:M3F3HM p`R3HMêKN: 3<npOQ<9KN8;: lbNÿlb x :@h1OQY<R3F64KN<dK`fMKN`9@Fp`a`R3HM<91OQ<<91KN`dMK`R<R6aKU[Zp<9KU8;:IM8n3H`f:8E<f<9OQWE3KN:n<R8tOE@F@B8;p:=<¢<9133|\3H@B<¢8E4\YZOQ69<9K@FTU3g3FC~OQY\8E6aOQ<9KN8;:47698;S<913mZ`9`9KU8;:ZKN:ir:np@FTN3Hp`Fbd0 8t:ML<913JKSLYZOE@B<8;:º<913tY693HMK@B<R3HMº@a1OQ6aOE@B<R3F6hKN`R<9KN@Kl>­6aO«`RY\3H@B<R6apSºV8;:3@FOE:v`R8;TUCE3t3<lpOQ<9KU8;:+lbNÿ:lpSL3F6aK@FOETNTUmK:`R3F69<9KN:ig<913Z`9`aKU8;:<9KNSL3PMKN`R<R6aKN[Zp<9KU8;:47698;S <913P3FC~OQY\8E6aOQ<9KN8;:@B8VM3Eb3@B8;S3[ZOE@aW(<R8%<91KN`gKN:º`R3H@B<9KN8;:+lblb

½Mt+* Ò LÜ Ü ÚgDØ'¤RwX¡\à5 Ú^¡)¤mÜ 9ß ßÙa¤tß ÛLm¢Ùa¤RÓLÜ P¡0213F693tOQ693t<916a3F3KNSLY\8E69<9OE:n<2KU<R3HS`J<91OQ<J`9pS%SOQ6aKUsF3<913IOQ<R8;SKN@t@FTU8V@9WºM3FCE3HTN8EY>SL3H:n<FbdocKN6a`R<KN` <913¢@a1ZOQ6aOE@B<R3F6aKN`R<9K@¢`91OQY\3Eb x <] OE`c`R<9pMKU3HMt[nSL3HOE`9p6aKN:i2KN:Z@FTNp`9KUCE3 n>­6aO«I`RY\3H@B<R6aOrKN:I693HOE@B<9KU8;:Z`fKN:<913^3H:3F69iE6aOE:iE3^8E4)KN:n<R3F693H`R<Fbd0213^3|)3H@B<8E4Z<913OEMMZKU<9KU8;:OET_ºf>A`913HTNTnKN8;:KUsHOQ<9KU8;:5] OE`d4e8;pZ:M<R8[)3gSK:8E6 xyTN3H`9`d<91OE:58;:32OEMMZKU<9KU8;:OETº>A`913HTNTf18;TN3%KN`@B6a3HOQ<R3HM|tOE:ZM_@FOE:Å[\3%:3Fi;TU3H@B<R3HMK:<913%OE:OETNl`9K`8E4g<913Z`a`9KU8;:<9KNS35`a@FOETU3L3|lY\3F6aKSL3H:=<Fb%kl3H@B8;:ZMKN`r<913MKU6a3H@B<W>A`a13HTNTdKU8;:KUsHOQ<9KN8;:vYZ698E[ZOQ[ZKNTKU<AEbx <] OE`PSL3HOE`ap693HM[lL693<lpKU6aK:i@B8;KN:@FKNM3H:Z@B3H`]JKU<913HTNOE`R<9KN@FOETNTN5`a@FOQ<R<R3F693HMÒJ3mYZOQ6R><9KN@FTN3H`g4e6a8;S <913z?>/u3YM ~pJ3z¤021º6a3HOE@B<9KU8;: bg0213tYZ698E[ZOQ[ZKNTKU<A] OE`m4e8;p:ZMº<R8[\3%x Vÿ-,;|Í´_ÿY>_µ ¥ b 021KN` CQOETNp3t@FOE:v[\3t`9@FOETU3HM4e8E6m<913SOE`9`J<R6aOE:`R473F62693HOE@B<9KN8;:?>Lu3YM ~pºm3¹¤ 0J1l¦Õq ¤Â¬ ­ <R85i;KUCE3LÿBEM´vÿY>_µ ¥ l]m1KN@a1(KN`^`9p%@FKN3H:=<9TUTOQ69iE3478E6 Y)3F6a4e8E6aS%KN:i@B8;KN:Z@FKNM3H:@B33|lY\3F6aKSL3H:=<9`^]JKN<91%<913rZ`a`9KU8;:/4e6aOQi;S3H:=<9`Fb0J1KU6aM/KN`<913`91OQY\328E4<913RÕl>­6aOH`9Y)3H@B<R6hpSºb x <P]^OE`^@FOETN@FpTOQ<R3HM/p`aKN:i¹:18;TU<YÐÃ`^u8;TN3H@¯>pTOQ6q69[ZKN<9OETOE:M 8;SLY\8;p:Mp@FTU3Hp`Ín>­6aO«3HSKN`a`9KU8;:º<913F8E6aº]JKU<91º693H`9Y)3H@B<m<R8<913t^8;SLY\8;p:ZMmpZ@FTU3Hp`^TNKU473F<9KNSL3Eb x <P]^OE` 478;p:M%<91OQ<gOQ<^TKU4e3F<9KSL3H`¢`918E69<R3F6 <91OE:ÿY> µ ¨ N `4e8E6z¬ OE`5OX 8;SLY\8;p:MÅp@FTU3HpZ`Fd<913(`a1OQY\3%8E42<913»l>­6aOH`RY\3H@B<R6aO`9KNi;:KUZ@FOE:n<9TUÒ@a1OE:iE3H`OE:ZMTU8;`R3H`KU<9`@a1OQ6hOE@B<R3F6aKN`R<9KN@`R<R6apZ@B<9p693Eb x :vOEMZMKU<9KU8;: Z<913l>­6aOHÒ3HSK`9`9KU8;:ÒY6a8E[ZOQ[ZKNTNKN<AL[\3H@B8;SL3H`J`aSOETNT³b

Page 27: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Uf IR:ÁU9N¯äBåT_æçèBÃ3éUê

Page 28: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

. o / ! 10 Ê 32 !º / Å Ê q$

x :(<91KN` @a1OQYZ<R3F62<913KNSLY\8E69<9OE:n< 3|lY\3F6aKNS3H:=<9OET\SL3F<918VM`^<R8SL3HOE`9p693rZ`9`9KU8;:ÒTNKN4e3B><9KNS3H`fOQ6932M3H`9@B6aKN[)3HM5OE:ML@B8;SYZOQ693HM b^@B8;SY693H13H:`aKUCE3 8«CE3F69CVKU3F]47698;SçKNTN`9@h13F6OE:M28;`a`9:3F6d@FOE:I[\3P4e8;p:ZMKN:y!E&­bc3 @B8;:Z`9KNM3F6c<913 SL3F<918VM`[ZOE`93HMI8;:IY693H`a@FKN`?>`9KN8;:v:3Hp<R698;:XSIpTN<9KUYZTNKN@FKN<9KU3H`F<913i;KNOE:n<rMZKUY\8;TU3t693H`R8;:ZOE:@B3x­ |JYZ18E<R8;:XSpT ><9KUYTNKN@FKU<9KU3H`HZ<913LSL8;TU3H@FpZTNOQ6R>­8E69[ZKN<9OETz`R<9pZM8E4PTOQ<R3B>­Z`9`9KU8;:<9KNS3H`F OE:MX<913L@B69V`R<9OET[ZTN8l@aWlKN:i<R3H@a1:ZK=<np3Eb x :OEMMKU<9KU8;:]P35MKN`a@Fp`9`2<9136a3HTU3FC~OE:n<r:np@FTN3HOQ6mYZ1nV`9KN@F`OE`?>Y\3H@B<9`g478E62<913Ml>­6aO«(<R3H@h1:K=<lp3EbÈWtus Ì 5ßÙaÚg ÜÝd¡\à5¤tÛL4657857 9;:=<?>!@ABDCE<GF+>H+IJFHKH+>!H:=L02132SOEKN:LKNM3HOr8E4\<913m:3Hp<R698;:LSpTU<9KUYTNKN@FKU<9KU3H`cSL3F<918VML<R8t8E[Z<9OEKN:LZ`9`aKU8;:LTNKU473F<9KNSL3Ö³JKN` <R8rSL3HOE`9p693P`9`9KU8;:4e6aOQi;S3H:=<9`dKN:@B8;KN:@FKNM3H:@B3¢]JKN<91:3Hp<R6a8;:` 3FCQOQY\8E6aOQ<R3HM5KN:<913Y693H`a@FKN`9`9KU8;:/OE:M(Y\8;`R<9`9@FKN`9`aKU8;:%`R<9OQiE3H`HbP^%OE:OETUlsHKN:i<913rM8;p[ZTN3mMKF\3F693H:n<9KNOET@B698;`a``R3H@B<9KU8;:Z` M ® îM © MON <913/O«CE3F6aOQiE3ÒY693H`9@FKN`a`9KU8;:SpTU<9KUYZTKN@FKU<AôÂQP d @FOE:Å[\3M3F<R3F6hSKN:3HMvKN:vO(SpTU<9K >A`R8;p6a@B3IOE:OETNl`9K`2<91OQ<<9OQWE3H`OEMCQOE:=<9OQiE3L8E4<913MK)3F693H:n<WVKN:3HSOQ<9K@F`\8E4V:3Hp<R698;:` 47698;S<913¢@B8;SLY\8;p:M:lp@FTU3Hp` OE:ZM<913Z`a`9KU8;:r476aOQi;SL3H:n<9`Fb0213Y693H`9@FKN`a`9KU8;:ÒTNKU473F<9KNSL3@FOE:º[\3tM3HMpZ@B3HMOE`

Ö ¸SR ²-T ÂEP dï ÖÃ x lbNÿ«|Ö4e8;TNTN8«]J`m4e6a8;S <913I<R8E<9OETcYZOQ69<9KN@FTU3M3H@FOHv]JKNM<91 ]m1KN@a1KN`J<913`apS 8E4YOQ69<9KNOETM3H@FO«Ò]JKNM<91` â 478E6JOETNT M3H@FOH@a1ZOE::3HTN`FbJxym8E<R3EZ<91ZOQ<2<91KN`gKN`JO5698;pi;1OQYYZ698K >SOQ<9KN8;:ºOE`[ÖºKN:@B693HOE`93H`g]JKU<91(3HOE@a13HSKU<R<R3HM:3Hp<R698;:|hb0213YZOQ69<9KNOET\M3H@FO«(]mKNM<918E4VYZOQ69<9K@FTU3ñ\OE`zOJ47p:Z@B<9KU8;:8E4V<913¢3|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:I3H:3F69iE° ­ OE:MIOE:i;pTNOQ6cSL8;SL3H:n<9pS 8E4c<913t@B8;SLY\8;p:Mº`RV`R<R3HS K` i;KUCE3H:º[lxy`93F3t3Eb·ibTy!:7|

â?x¢° ­ § |Q x :áâ3¤,ÿ«|ìVU\x¢° ­ § | ÚW X)Y ¢?Z

Y6[ \X][W

ZY6[ \µX][ Ø ©_^ µ ±a`¢

U)x¢° ­ òcbâòedâ §gf | X xhdâ­| Í dâ6Ãx lb;|x :<91K`2478E6aSIpZTNObá â OE:ZM+ÛfOQ693<913`RYZKN:OE:ZM8E69[ZKN<9OETOE:i;pTNOQ6SL8;SL3H:n<9pS.8E4f<913YZOQ6a<9KN@FTU3H`3HSKN<R<R3HM_47698;SÝOE:KN:KU<9KNOETf:lp@FTU3HpZ`]JKU<913H:3F69iE°è­~b f KN`t<913/`RYZKN:X8E4<913:OET :npZ@FTU3Hp`Fb0213<R8E<9OET3|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:3H:3F69iE/8E4d<913:OET :npZ@FTU3Hp`2KN`

Vÿ

Page 29: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

3 I¼:DR3®J&_8Uaji±i/% &Yaæç?ÃæçU

ë ì_3YGR3À_2øBó& ÿ:õðòþ î òï£õðøðô¤"Íï+Bó& Bÿ÷)þj÷?ÿ)ïuû òÿ)îWûüö "=òuõßöüóKòîU"&øMõßñ)ò L øàî õ8B^õßñòîªòï&÷)þMô÷)þMõßñòõßñöüøðþW÷òuÿ:õðø&÷;BòuóKöõßõßòþ&"=ø&óÑõßñò4ö ÷ö õßöFôû_÷?ÿ)ï ûüòuÿî+ < ñöFî L ù&ÿøðò/öüî]õðôBò÷"=ø&óè %X¡¢

° ­³ Q° ­ ò;bâò;dâ § x lb;|]J13F693kb ârKN`L<913º[KN:MKN:i3H:3F69iE+8E4<9133HSKN<R<R3HMYZOQ69<9KN@FTN3EblUÈOE:M X M3H:8E<R3<913/`9YZKN:V>AM3FY\3H:M3H:=<TU3FCE3HTPM3H:`9KU<OE:ZM_<R6aOE:`aSKN`9`9KN8;:@B8n3|%@FKN3H:=<Fd693H`RY\3H@B<9KUCE3HTNEb TU3HOQ6aTNÖ/KN`¢:8E<PO@B8;:`R<9OE:n<P[Zp<¢@a1OE:iE3H`^OE` O47p:Z@B<9KU8;:8E4:° ­ OE:M b/,<AlYZKN@FOET3|VOESYZTU3¢KN`\<913]P8E6aW8E4çKN:M3R~:Fy!:;?­D]J13F693<913FSL3HOE`9p693HMY693H`a@FKN`9`9KU8;:OE:ZMY\8;`R<9`9@FKN`9`aKU8;:L:3Hp<R698;:5VKU3HTNMZ`d4e8E64Er47p`aKU8;:V>­Z`9`aKU8;:IOE:ZMÅ<npZOE`9K >­Z`9`aKU8;:693HOE@B<9KU8;:`K:<913J3|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:(3H:3F6aiEL6aOE:iE3J47698;Sr;?><R8z )5u3Ybl0J132Z`9`aKU8;:%TNKN4e3F<9KNS3H`KN:<913OE:OETUV`9KN`f8E4 <91ZKN`f3|VY)3F6hKNSL3H:n<f]P3F693M3HMp@B3HM/p`9KN:irOu8;:n<R3t OQ6aTU8t<R3H@h1:K=<lp3Eb x :<91KN`¢Y698V@B3HMp693m<913mTNKN4e3F<9KNS328E4 <913r:np@FTN3Hp`¢KN`#ÖaQm 478E6^3HOE@a1ºM3H@FO«%`R<R3FYºOE:M(OM3H@FOH<9KNSL3 Ï M KN`2M6aOH]J:Èx Ï M Q µ

X ¯on ´K`g6aOE:M8;S.:npZS[\3F62[\3F<A]^3F3H:j>OE:MÅÿ«|hb

Page 30: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

R3À_ÀL% &Ã?:¹æ& 3 U"

ë aì YGRUÀÁk < ñò L îßîßöSB÷Kû ö$"=ò õðö óKòîþ:òþ:ÿ)ïuòþ "=ø6Bó þ:öp(òuøðòu÷õôB÷)ôûüú:îªòîDÿ)îßö ÷ù¼ò òøßöüóKòu÷ õàôûüû ú-9:õðôBö ÷òþ[ øðòîðï öFîðîªöSB÷÷)òuÿ:õðø&÷RóRÿûõðö$ )û öFï ö õßöüòî0HûS&îßòþRï öüøðïuû òî+Bô&î õðòuøðöüî:î ôB÷)þ¼ïuû$îªòþøðòï õðô÷)ùBûüò4øðò+ øðòîßòu÷õ^õßñ)òÍøßòîªÿû õðîc"¶ rq0¡¢B % X¡ô÷)þ X¡¢Bøßòî! _òï õßöüýBòû ú0213<R8E<9OET M3H@FO«(<9KSL3tOQ4e<R3F6:`R<R3FYZ`JKN`

Ï Q W â Y ¨ Ï M Ã x lb! n|

0213¢Y698V@B3HMp6a3PM3H`9@B6hKU[\3HMOQ[\8«CE3gOETNTU8D]J`c8;:3^<R83H`9<9OQ[ZTNKN`91IOQ4e<R3F6Or`9p;%@FKU3H:n<z:lpS5>[\3F68E4 @FOETN@FpTNOQ<R3HM3FCE3H:n<9`t<913@B8E69693HTNOQ<9KU8;:_[)3F<]P3F3H: ÂDP dOE:MÛÂ Ï dOE:M<91lp`GÖ³ÛQÂ Ï dtbodKUi;p693jlbNÿ`918D]J`%`9Y)3H@B<R6hO8E4@B8;SLY\8;p:M:lp@FTU3Hp`M3H@FOH<9KNS3H`@B8;SLYZp<R3HMÅ]JKN<91<91KN`IOQYY698;OE@h1 bJ8E<R3(<913(TU8Ei;OQ6aKU<91S%KN@L`9@FOETU3H`OE:MÈOETN`R8<91OQ<J<913tOE@B<9pOET`9`9KU8;:Ò<9KNS3tKN`2SL8;`R<9TN(M3F<R3F6hSKN:3HMÒ[l/<913tTNOE`R<JM3H@FO«º`R<R3FYb x :<913(OE:OETUV`9KN`8E42çmKN:ZM3j~YK?v<913(`9<9OQ<9KN`R<9KN@FOET^SL8VM3HTfYZOQ6aOES3F<R3F6a`4e8E63<npZOQ<9KU8;:lb(@FOE:[\3693H`R<R6hKN@B<R3HM<R8º@B3F69<9OEK:3|V<R3H:=<[lp`9K:i/OETN`98%<91347OE@B<r<91OQ<r:3Hp<R6a8;:`

Page 31: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

k@ I¼:DR3®J&_8Uaji±i/% &Yaæç?ÃæçUOQ693t3HSKN<R<R3HM`R3<lp3H:=<9KOETNTU%]mKU<91ºO%uvOl]^3HTNTMK`R<R6aKU[Zp<9KU8;:

Í PÍ ° Q ° ¡ Ò s µ © Þ b x à x lb;|

çJ3F6a3sQut © ­q K`d<913J:lp@FTU3HOQ6f<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p6a32OE:MGm KN`d<9132TN3FCE3HTM3H:`9KN<AEb x :L<913]P8E6aW8E4kKU]P3FWn>­,KNTN@BsFJì:`RWQO¹~Y.?y!E&=<913¢698;TU3¢8E4V:lp@FTU3HOQ6cMV:OESKN@F`K:tM3HMp@FK:i<913J`9`9KU8;:%<9KNSL3m`a@FOETU3J47698;S Y693H`9@FKN`a`9KU8;::3Hp<R698;:%SpTU<9KUYTNKN@FKU<9KU3H`c] OE` @B8;:`9KNM3F6a3HM b0213X693H`9pZTU<9`(8E4y!:;]^3F693693HOE:OETNnsF3HM]mKU<91,OÈS3F<918lM@B8;SI[ZKN:ZKN:i+`R<9OQ<9KN`R<9KN@FOET@FOE`9@FOEM3L@FOETN@FpTOQ<9KU8;:`m]JKU<91v<913Ml:OES%KN@F`28E4¢:lp@FTU3HpZ`?>A:npZ@FTU3Hp`J@B8;TTNKN`9KU8;:Z`F[ZOE`R3HM8;:+<913º@B8;:@B3FY<L8E4m8;:3B>­[\8lMMKN`9`9KNYZOQ<9KU8;:xy`93F3`R3H@B<9KU8;: b;|hb x :+<91K`IOE:OETNl`9K`<9135OHCQOEKNTNOQ[ZTU3I3|V@FKN<9OQ<9KU8;:3H:3F69iExy13HOQ<h|mOE`rO/47p:Z@B<9KU8;:8E4¢<913Y\8E<R3H:n<9KNOETc3H:3F69iE`9p694yOE@B3x æ X^k|ºxyM3F4e8E6aS%OQ<9KU8;:|5] OE`<9OQWE3H:êKN:n<R8OE@F@B8;p:n<Fb0213 æ X^k+K`OETN`R8ÈO47pZ:@B<9KU8;:+8E4<9KNSL3EPK:YOQ69<9KN@FpTNOQ6K:<913KN:@B8;SKN:i+x74yp`9KU8;:)|OE:ZM<913º8;p<RiE8;KN:ixy`9@FKN`9`aKU8;:|P<R6aODR3H@B<R8E6aKU3H`Fb20J13 æ X kÒiE8;KN:i%4e698;S 47pZ`9KU8;:Ò<R8/`a@FKN`9`9KU8;:@B8;:i;p6aOQ<9KN8;:KN`º6aOQ<913F6çÏZOQ<Fb.0J13F693F478E693Er<913ÅMp6hOQ<9KU8;:,8E4I<913ÅTNOQ<R<R3F6<9KSL3_KN`ºYZOQ6a<º8E4<913<R<9KN:i(Y698V@B3HMp6a3<R8Ò8E[<9OEKN: Ö³lb0213693H`9pTN<9`J8E[<9OEK:3HMXKN:vMl:OES%KN@FOETPy!EfOE:ZMYZp6935`R<9OQ<9KN`9<9KN@FOETfOE:OETUV`9KN`%y!:;OQ6935Y693H`93H:=<R3HMKN:i;p693ÅlbÒOE``R8;TNKNM@FKU6a@FTU3H`OE:ZMOE`R<R3F6aKN`9Wl`Fg6a3H`RY\3H@B<9KUCE3HTUEb0J1np`H^[lKN:@FTpMKN:iMV:OESK@F`8E4<91347pZ`9KU8;:V>­Z`a`9KU8;:693HOE@B<9KU8;:`IKN:<913/OE:OETUV`9KN`Fz<913Z`9`aKU8;:TNKU473F<9KNSL3H`OQ693(OQYY698BVKSOQ<R3HTU8;:38E6aM3F68E4SOQi;:KU<9pZM3mTU8;:iE3F6¢<91OE:(KN:<913m`R<9OQ<9KN@OQYY6a8;OE@a1/8E4 çmK:M3JOE:M/@B8;TNTNOQ[\8E6aOQ<R8E6a`Hbm:8E<913F6P3|OESLYZTN3mKN`¢<913J]^8E69WL8E4 mp[ @a13H:n;O ~^:FTy!:­l]J13F693m<913mOE:OETNl`9K`8E4<9132Z`a`9KU8;:L<9KNS32`9@FOETU32] OE`¢Y\3F69478E6aSL3HMLK:L<9132476aOESL328E4 MK\p`aKU8;:5SL8lM3HT]y!:cxy`R3F3`R3H@B<9KU8;: bNÿQb;|hb 0J13693H`9pTN<g8E4c<91ZKN`g]^8E69WÒ4e8E6[ ¢ m6T¤ ¨ª¶£¢ çJ4fOQ<>° X qOv Q )%u3YKN``918«]m:vOE`<9135@FTU8;`R3HM` <lpOQ6935KN:ibMlbv)OE:ZMvKN`OQ[\8;p<T%<9KNSL3H`rTNOQ6aiE3F6m<91OE:<913mMZOQ<9O47698;Sy!:;?)OE:M/OQ[)8;p<Plb<9KNSL3H`¢TN8«]^3F6P<91OE:/<913MOQ<9O47698;S y!E&478E6P<913693HOE@B<9KU8;: ¢Ym6ͤ ¨ª¶¨a0zOI]JKU<91/<913`9OESL3[)3HOES3H:3F6aiEOE:M/:3Hp<R698;:(SIpTN<9KUYZTNKN@FKN<AEb0213º693H`apTU<8E4m<91K`5]P8E69W+KN`5<91lp`LKN:n<R3F6aSL3HMKOQ<R3º[)3F<]P3F3H:<913ºC~OETp3H`L8E[<9OEKN:3HMKN:[\8E<91OE:OETUV`9KN`mMKN`9@Fp`a`R3HM3HOQ6aTKU3F6HbJ0213H`R3IMK`9@B693FYZOE:@FKN3H`2[6aK:i%SL3I<R8/3|VY693H`9``R8;SL32@B6aKN<9KN@FOETlY)8;K:=<9`d8E4)p`9KN:i<9132:3Hp<R698;:5SIpTN<9KUYZTNKN@FKN<9KU3H` SL3F<918lM5478E6f<913gZ`9`aKU8;:TNKU473F<9KNSL3SL3HOE`9p693HSL3H:n<Fbw iE3H:3F6aOETf6a3HSOQ69WXKN`r<91OQ<<913SL3F<918lM8E4 M3HMpZ@FKN:i(<913LZ`9`9KN8;:TNKU473F<9KNSL3

47698;S <913t3|lY\3F6aKSL3H:=<9OETTU/8E[Z<9OEKN:3HMºY6a3H`9@FKN`9`9KN8;:º:3Hp<R698;:vSIpTN<9KUYZTNKN@FKN<9KU3H`PK`1KNi;1TU/S8lM3HT M3FY)3H:ZM3H:=<Fb0J13693H`9pTN<9`g`918«]m:KN:Òi;p6a3¹lb@FTU3HOQ6aTN(KNTTNp`?><R6aOQ<R3%<91KN`r`R<9OQ<R3HSL3H:n<FbŬm`aOQiE3L8E4P<916a3F3MKF\3F693H:=<rSL8VM3HTN`KN:<913LOE:OETNl`R3H`TU3HOEMZ`g<R8CE3F69ºMKF\3F693H:n<g693H`9pTN<9`Fbw J3H@B3H:=<@FOETN@FpTNOQ<9KU8;:Z` 4e698;S O@B8;S[KN:3HMºMV:OESKN@FOET OE:ZMº`R<9OQ<9KN`R<9KN@FOET SL8lM3HTxy`R3F3 ib°lbHKN:`93H@B<9KU8;:%lb;| `a18«]È<91OQ<c<913^`a@FKN`9`9KU8;:<9KNSL3^`R<R698;:i;TUt@h1OE:iE3H`KU4 <9133HS%KN`9`9KU8;:%8E4 @a1ZOQ69iE3HMÒYZOQ69<9KN@FTN3H`PKN`^OETN`R85@B8;:`9KM3F693HM lKN:%YOQ69<9KN@FpTNOQ6P4e8E6

Page 32: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

R3À_ÀL% &Ã?:¹æ& 3 3

OE:L3|V@FKN<9OQ<9KU8;:3H:3F6aiE51ZKUi;13F6f<91OE:ÿY>:>u3Y y!:­b0J1KN`dOE`RY\3H@B<¢SOQWE3H`¢<913SL3F<918VM:8E<2`9pKN<9OQ[ZTU3r4e8E6J<9131KUi;13F6g3|V@FKU<9OQ<9KN8;:3H:3F69i;KN3H`Fbw ocKNi;p693llbNÿ(`a18«]J`<91OQ<5<913ÒZ`a`9KU8;:ÈTNKU473F<9KNSL3%KN`5M3F<R3F6hSKN:3HM[ZOE`9KN@FOETTU[n<913vTNOE`9<%3HSKU<R<R3HM,:3Hp<R698;: b 021lp`F <9133|lY\3F6aKSL3H:=<9OETJ3F69698E6(KN: :3Hp<R698;:SIpTN<9KUYZTNKN@FKN<9KU3H`t@FOE:+TU3HOEMÈ<R8OvCE3F6aTNOQ69iE3Ò3F696a8E65K:Å<913(Z`9`aKU8;:Å<9KSL3(`a@FOETU3M3F<R3F6aSKN:ZOQ<9KU8;: bw 0213g3H:n<R6aOE:@B3J@h1OE::3HTV3|\3H@B<9`Ry!:H:Z1OHCE32<R8[)3 <9OQWE3H:/KN:=<R8tOE@F@B8;pZ:=<FVK³b·3Ebd8;:]J1KN@h1v`9KM38E4P<913 p`aKN:OQ698Q> rOETTU8;:3C~OETNp3(xy`R3F3`R3H@B<9KN8;:¯lb! º<913`R<9pZMKU3HM`Rl`9<R3HS KN`g`9KN<9pOQ<R3HM bw o698;S ]^8E69WM3H`9@B6aKU[\3HM K:<91ZKN`<913H`9KN`XOE:M47698;S<913@B69V`R<9OET5[ZTU8V@9WVKN:iSL3F<918VMKU<LOQYY\3HOQ6a`L<91OQ</O`9KN:i;TU3ºO«CE3F6aOQiE3`a@FKN`9`9KU8;:+<9KSL3M8l3H`:8E<9p`?><9KU4eX<913%Y693H`R3H:@B3/8E4 [)8E<91TU8;:iOE:ZMÅ`918E6a<?>ATNKU473F<9KNSL35Z`9`9KN8;:_@B8;SLY\8;:3H:n<9`FbX2b·ib<913/Y6a3H`R3H:@B3(8E42OZ`a`9KU8;:ÅK`R8;SL3F6]^8;pTNMÈ`RWE3F]<913ÒOHCE3F6aOQiE3ºZ`a`9KU8;:<9KNSL3Eb20213ITU8;:i%`9`9KU8;:TKU4e3F<9KSL3t@B8;SLY\8;:3H:n<KN`m:8E<mOE@F@B8;pZ:=<R3HM478E6KN:<913OE:OETUV`R3H`g]JKU<91ÒYZ693H`9@FKN`9`aKU8;:Ò:3Hp<R698;:SpTU<9KNYZTNKN@FKU<9KN3H`Fb465785]x yz|8~@CE<JFh>H+I-FHKH+>H+:=L

`zOE:5OETU<R3F6h:OQ<9KUCE3¢<R8:3Hp<R698;:@FTU8V@9W<913Pi;KOE:=<dMKUY\8;TU3f693H`98;:OE:@B3x­ |zSL3F<918VM<R8+SL3HOE`9p6a3v<913vZ`9`9KN8;:<9KNSL3X`9@FOETU3v]^OE`ÒM3FCE3HTN8EY)3HMêKN:<9133HOQ6hTU?>ÐÃ`Fb :8DCE3F69ClKN3F]@FOE:[\34e8;pZ:MKN:9y ):­b0213KNM3HO_KN`<R8ÈSL3HOE`9p6a3Z`9`aKU8;:476aOQi;SL3H:n<9`KN: @B8;KN:@FKNM3H:Z@B3º]JKU<911KNi;13H:3F69iE§86aOHV`8E6hKUi;KN:OQ<9KN:i4e698;S <913X M3H@FO«Eb0213r `R<R6a3H:iE<91(47p:Z@B<9KU8;:%] OE` `R<9pMKN3HM/`RV`R<R3HSOQ<9K@FOETNTU478E6^MZKF)3F6a3H:=< :npZ@FTU3HOQ6`RV`R<R3HS`HbÈ021ZKN`47p:Z@B<9KU8;:+KN`5]P3HTT^M3FZ:3HMOE:MM3FY\3H:MZ`I8;:+<91693F3ºYZOQ6aOESL3F<R3F6h`FG<913r`9pSL>­6apTU3J`9<R693H:iE<91 l<913t 3H:3F69iEEOE:M/<913t ]JKNM<91bc0213m`9pSL>­6apTU3`R<R6a3H:iE<91/@FOE:([\32<9OQWE3H:Ò3<lpOET<R8I<913@FTNOE`9`9K@FOET`9pZS6apTN3Ebd0J13 ,3H:3F69iE/OE:M]JKM<91tOQ693^Wl:8«]J:IYZOQ6aOESL3F<R3F6h`Fbc0J13¢Y\3HOQWY\8;`9KU<9KU8;:t8E4<913 K`z@h1OQ6aOE@B<R3F6aKN`9<9KN@8E4c<913SOE`a`g8E4d<913t:npZ@FTU3Hp`FG

°8 ¯ T E? µ ¨ßÞॠPÒrà x lbH;|0213t@B8;:=<R6aKN[Zp<9KU8;:Ò8E4d<913Y6a3B>POE:MºY\8;`R<9`9@FK`9`9KU8;: M3H@FOHºKN`2<91np`JOQ[)8;p<¼D> u3YOQYOQ69<FbÈ0J1KN`OETNTU8«]m`58;:3Ò<R88E[<9OEKN:+<913ÒY698E[OQ[ZKNTNKU<4e8E6z8>­6aOHÈ3HSKN`a`9KU8;:8E4I<913Y693H`9@FK`9`9KU8;: tb202136a3HTNOQ<9KUCE3HTUêTNOQ69iE3_@B8;:n<R6aKU[Zp<9KN8;: 8E48E<913F6l8>­6aOH3HSK`9`9KU8;:vY698V@B3H`9`R3H`rTU3HOEM`<R8ºOÒTNOQ69iE353|VY)8;:3H:=<9KNOETz[ZOE@aWniE698;pZ:M]J18;`R3L`91OQY\3KN`:8E<%3H:=<9KU6a3HTUp:ZOES[ZKNi;p8;p`Fb^8;:Z`R3<np3H:=<9TUÈ<913ºY6a8l@B3HMp693º<R8_3|V<R6aOE@B<%Z`a`9KU8;:TNKN4e3F<9KNS3IKN`r6aOQ<913F6tp:@B3F69<9OEKN:b0213LOESI[ZKUi;pKU<8E4P<913SL3F<918VMXKN``918D]J:XKN:<913]^8E69W8E4CQOE:з<rçJ8E4K~Y?ÅyE>?­b x :vibMlb/<913`aOESL3I3|VY\3F6aKNSL3H:n<9OETNTUÒ8E[<9OEK:3HMMOQ<9Oxy@FTN8;`R3HML@FKU6a@FTU3H`¯| OQ6a3g<R<R3HM5]JKU<915MKF\3F693H:n<dC~OETNp3H`z478E6f<913g476aKN@B<9KU8;:5@B8l3|%@FKU3H:n<

Page 33: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

UZ I¼:DR3®J&_8Uaji±i/% &Yaæç?ÃæçU

with GBW the Bohr-Wheeler fission width, g the nuclear vis-cosity, t the time, and t the time at which the flux across thebarrier reaches 90% of the quasistationary value. We param-etrized t anew from the results of Grange et al.

t~b ,T !5~2g !21ln~10E f /T !10.0112gA/T @10221 s# . ~4!

Here, E f is the height of the fission barrier, T is the tempera-ture, and A is the mass number. t has been calculated forevery nuclear state in the cascade. Another expression for twas obtained by Bhatt et al. @16#, but the g-ray spectra cal-culated with this expression are hardly different.

In the original version of CASCADE the probability fordecay of a nucleus moving from the saddle point to the sciss-ion point is not calculated. To take this effect into account,the fission width has been treated analogously to the fissionflux. The flux at time t at the saddle point is ~almost! equal to

the flux at the scission point at time t1tssc , with tssc the timerequired to propagate from the saddle point to the scissionpoint @17#:

tssc5tssc0 ~A11g2

1g !. ~5!

From the graphs presented by Grange et al. @15#, a value fortssc0 the saddle-to-scission time in nonviscous nuclei, can beinferred: tssc

052.2310221 s. Assuming the same time depen-

dence for the fission width, one can approximate the latter asfollows:

G f~ t !50, t,tssc

5G fBW~A11g2

2g !

[email protected]~ t1td2tssc!/t#%, t.tssc . ~6!

The concept of time, which is unknown in the statistical codeCASCADE, was implemented as follows. The lifetime td of anuclear state with excitation energy E* and angular momen-tum J , which is used as a time step in the calculations, isgiven by

td5\

Gn~E*,J !1Gp~E*,J !1Ga~E*,J !1Gg~E*,J !1G f~E*,J ,t !~7!

in which Gn etc. are the decay widths for all decay channelstaken into account by CASCADE: i.e., neutron, proton, a par-ticle, g ray, and fission decay. The justification for the use ofG f in this equation is that the lifetime of a state is inverselyproportional to the total width including G f . The bookkeep-ing of these time increments is done in matrices t(E*,J)with the same dimensions as the matrices for the populationcross sections, i.e., every nuclear state is characterized by the

charge, mass, excitation energy, angular momentum, and thetime at which the decay to it took place. Note that Eqs. ~6!and ~7! are coupled; therefore, they are solved iteratively.Including G f in Eq. ~7! will influence through the coupling toEq. ~6! the fission probability and thereby the GDR yield.

In the original CASCADE code no distinction is made be-tween compound nuclear fission and quasifission. We imple-mented this distinction as follows. With the one-body dissi-

FIG. 2. Results of the fits of the GDR parameters at four differ-ent values of g, for the experiment with Eb5216 MeV. The solidcurve indicates the sum of the prefission spectrum ~short-dashedcurve! and the postfission spectrum ~long-dashed curve!. For com-parison, a calculation with g55 is also shown ~dotted curve!.

TABLE I. Results of the fission time scale for the differentvalues for the viscosity.

Eb g Bscale t fa

@MeV# ~10220 s)

216 0.01 1.0 4567216 0.1 1.2 1565216 1 1.0 4768216 4 0.7 49362238 0.01 0.8 4561238 0.1 1.0 861238 1 0.8 4761238 2 0.65 24061

aThe numbers used as error bars indicate the sensitivity to thethreshold on the fission cross sections that is taken into account inthe calculation. Here, it represents the difference in t f for thresholdof s f50.5 mb compared to 0 threshold.

54 R1517VISCOSITY AND FISSION TIME SCALE OF 156Dy

ë ì_3YGR3ÀSR3°òîßÿû õðî&"Põßñ)ò)J î òï£õßøàô L õðîU"BøKõßñ)òÅþ:öp(òuøðòu÷õçû$îªòþ+ïuö øàï ûüòîôøðò%ò _òuøðö óKòu÷õàôûþôõðôzB¶ )øßò L îßîßöSB÷ ô÷)þJ &îªõ L îðîßö$&÷ L õªõßòþÇî òï£õßøàôlôøðòzö ÷þ:öüïôYõðòþ 9?úîªñzBøßõ þôBîßñòþ`ô÷)þ ûSB÷ù þ)ôBîßñòþ`ï ÿøðýBòî+BUøðòî _òï£õðö ý&òuûüú < ñòWîBûüöFþ`ïuÿøßý&òKöüîÆõðñòWîßÿóè"õßñò- )øßò ô÷)þD iî õàîßïuöüîðîßö$&÷ï+B÷õßøðö$9)ÿ:õßöSB÷)î0

xy:8E< YZ698EY\3F6aTUJ@FOETNTN3HMtwQClK`9@B8;`9KU<lwJ[nr<913¢OEp<918E6a`h|6aOE:i;KN:ig47698;S9>Ã>ÿ¢<R8Tl~]J1KN@h1KN:<R3F6hS`¢8E4 <913JZ`9`aKU8;:TNKU473F<9KNSL32K`47698;S± ÃR´ÒÿY>_µ ¨ N <R8¹ ÃR´(ÿY>_µ ¨ª¶ `Fbçm8«]^3FCE3F6HM3H`RYZKN<R3<913I47OE@B<<91OQ<<913`9Y)3H@B<R6hO%OQ693<R<R3HMv]P3HTNTzp`9KN:i<913 YZOQ6aOESL3F<R3F6a`]P3t@FOE:º:8E< S%OQWE3tOE:=(@B3F69<9OEKN:º@B8;:@FTNpZ`9KU8;:ÒOQ[\8;p<P<913Z`9`9KU8;:(TNKU473F<9KNSL3mC~OETp3Eb/m`KN:º<913t@FOE`93478E6J:3Hp<R698;:SIpTN<9KUYZTNKN@FKN<9KU3H`¢<913t693H`9pTN< K`2SL8VM3HTM3FY\3H:M3H:n<Fb0gCE3F<R3F6~Y?by!H:?f1ZOHCE35<R6aKU3HMv<R8Ò3H:1OE:@B3<913% `RY\3H@B<R6aO/[n@B8;SYZOQ6aKN:i(<913è8Z>­6aO«`RY\3H@B<R6aO(8E[<9OEKN:3HMXOQ<tMK)3F693H:n<[)3HOES 3H:3F69i;KU3H`Fb¹`KU<rOQYY\3HOQ6a`<91OQ<r<913LZ`9`aKU8;:

Page 34: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

R3À_ÀL% &Ã?:¹æ& 3 C

ë aì YGRUÀS~3 øðô|úï+Böü÷)ï öFþ:ò÷)ï ò î! _òï õßøàô¤"Bøû Y Eg¤(%ò+*-,|ÿôB÷)þFû 3 E0'z ¤(Åò+*),Yÿ= L û ûüòþèô÷)þ _òu÷MõðøßöFô÷ù&û òî+B&øßòî! _òï õßöüýBòû úK < ñò L ûüû òþ¹ï öüøàï ûüòî.øðò+ )øßòîªò÷&õ6þ:öp(òuøðòu÷ï ò4î _òï õðøßÿó@B8;SLY\8;:3H:n<KN`TNKU<R<9TU3O\3H@B<R3HMÈ[nX<9133H:n<R6aOE:@B3(@a1OE:Z:3HTf3H:3F69iEEd<913/MKF\3F693H:@B3[\3F<A]^3F3H:L<913g`RY\3H@B<R6aO`a18«]J`d<913m `RY\3H@B<R6apSOQ<1KNi;1I3|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:3H:3F69iEºxy`R3F3ib/lb! n|hb¢m3FCE3F69<913HTN3H`9`FOETN`R813F693mS8lM3HTM3FY\3H:M3H:@B3mKN`¢M8;S%KN:OE:n<Fb x :4yOE@B<^<913SL3F<918lM5KN`cSL8;`R<9TU693HTU3FCQOE:=<d478E6c3|V<R6aOE@B<9KU8;:58E4<913^<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p693 M3FY\3H:M3H:n<f YZOQ6hOESL3F<R3F6a`Fb

x :È<913º]^8E69WÅ8E4 K«ì8;`RsF3Fi;Kè~Yè?F y ÿBEJOETNT OHCQOEKNTNOQ[ZTU3Ò3|VY\3F6aKNSL3H:n<9OET MOQ<9OXKN:V>@FTNpZMKN:i:3Hp<R6a8;:OE:M/ 8Z>­6hOHSpTU<9KUYZTKN@FKU<9KU3H`cOE:ML3FCQOQY\8E6aOQ<9KU8;:6a3H`9KNMp3g@B698;`a``R3H@B<9KN8;:`478E6¢<913`RV`R<R3HS ¨ª© q¤ ¡£¢£¶ æ [l¦ ¡£¡ H021]JKU<91L<913m[\3HOES3H:3F69iE56aOE:i;KN:i47698;S ÿY>:>º<R8ÿBE:Eu3Y]^3F693%`aKNSIpZTU<9OE:3F8;p`9TNOE:OETUlsF3HM b%o6a8;S <91KN`OE:ZOETUl`aKN`O<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p693IM3FY\3H:M3H:@B38E4f<9135:lp@FTU3HOQ64e6aK@B<9KU8;:@B8l3|%@FKU3H:n<¼8xy@FOETTU3HMvMZKNSL3H:V>`9KN8;:TU3H`9`:npZ@FTU3HOQ65ClKN`a@B8;`9KU<AYZOQ6aOESL3F<R3F6/KN:Ñy ÿBE7|I]^OE`5478;p:M b_0PlYZKN@FOETNTU¯8D l]J1ZKN@a1KN:ZMKN@FOQ<R3H`LTNOQ69iE3:lp@FTU3HOQ6%4e6aK@B<9KU8;: b+0213º693H`9pZTU<9`58E4mCQOE:з<%çm8E4%yE>:2]^3F693693HOE:ZOETUnsF3HMKN:§y ÿBE&cp`aKN:i%OE:8E<913F6CE3F6h`9KU8;:8E4¢<913I`R<9OQ<9K`R<9KN@FOETfÆrkZÆ X,@B8VM3Ebçm3F693M8yQ UòÿY>K`g:3F3HM3HMº<R8%M3H`9@B6aKU[\3r<913 `RY\3H@B<R6apSºb

x <g693HSOEK:`^<R8L[)3`R3F3H:<R8L]J1KN@h1Ò3|l<R3H:MÒ<913<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p693tM3FY\3H:M3H:@B3K:b8KN`¢OE:%OQ69<9KU4yOE@B<¢8E4 <9132<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p693M3FY\3H:M3H:@B3g8E4 <913J`R<9OQ<9KN`R<9K@FOETZSL8VM3HTYZOQ6hOES5>3F<R3F6a`Hb x :<R3F6aS%`J8E4<913Z`9`aKU8;:TNKN4e3F<9KNS3t<913I`aKU<9pOQ<9KU8;:KN`F<913F693F478E693E)`9<9KNTNT6hOQ<913F6p:Z@B3F69<9OEKN: b

Page 35: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Uc I¼:DR3®J&_8Uaji±i/% &Yaæç?ÃæçUÈMt£½ É ¤mÙaßLÙ9Úg × ¾ :kLR¡)Ú2Ùv¡ 5ÛzØ'¤¼wÙ9Ú^¡)^×\9¤ð¡\hÜ m:ºOQ<R<R3HSY<g8E4cS3HOE`9p6aKN:i<913Z`a`9KU8;:(TNKU473F<9KNSL3rp`9KN:izv>A`913HTNTCQOE@FOE:@B/YZ698lMZp@¯><9KU8;:º] OE`mS%OEM3KN:Ò<913]P8E69WÒ8E4u8;TNKU<R8E6aKN`¹~P:FWy )?­bP0213t`9<9pMKU3HM`9l`R<R3HS ]^OE`Enbºu3YW ~pǬM¤K¬Ibdm>­6aO«v`RY\3H@B<R6aO(]^3F693L693H@B8E6aM3HM478E6<91693F3L@FOE`R3H`Fb x :<91356h`R<@FOE`R35[\8E<91j¬J>ATNKUWE3693HOE@B<9KU8;:Y6a8lMpZ@B<9`m`9p69ClKNCE3HM b x :v<913`93H@B8;:MX@FOE`R3L8;:3z¬2>ATNKNWE3Y698VMp@B< Z`9`aKU8;:3HM b x :º<913<91KU6hMº@FOE`R3t[\8E<91º693HOE@B<9KU8;:Y698VMp@B<9`gp:ZM3F69iE85Z`9`9KN8;: b0213%l>­6aO«X`9Y)3H@B<R6hOº4e8E6OETNTf<916a3F3%@FOE`R3H`OQ693%`918D]J:_KN:_i;p693blblbºè3F<Ip`t`R<9OQ69<OE:OETUlsHKN:i<913H`932`RY\3H@B<R6aO]JKU<915<913g6a`R<`9KSLYZTU3 @FOE`R3El]J13H:5[\8E<91%¬2>ATKUWE32693HOE@B<9KU8;:Y698VMp@B<9`g`9p69ClKNCE3HMÒZ`9`9KU8;:b^ <mOQ698;p:MÿY>:>LWE3Y]^3`R3F3W¬ n>­6aO«l`J]JKU<91ÒY\8l8E6693H`R8;TNp<9KU8;:xyOQ[\8;p<rÿY>WE3Y|PMp3m<R8 8EYYZTU3F6^[698;OEM3H:KN:in]J1KN@h1/M8l3H` :8E< OETNTU8«]Y693H@FKN`93+·g>AKM3H:=<9KNZ@FOQ<9KU8;: b </<9131KUi;13F6%3H:3F69iE`9KNM3 8,6aOHV`47698;Só 8;pTU8;SI[3|V@FKN<9OQ<9KU8;:@FOE:È[)3(`R3F3H: b x :Å<913º@FOE`R3Ò8E4J`aKN:i;TU3(OE:MM8;p[ZTU3/Z`9`9KU8;:êx7[OE:M@Q693H`RY\3H@B<9KUCE3HTU|T¬J>ATNKUWE3bãl>­6aOHV`OQ693/OETN`R8CVKN`9KU[TU3Ebo8E6I<91K``Rl`9<R3HS <913bv>A`913HTNTKU8;:KUsHOQ<9KN8;:+Y698E[ZOQ[ZKTNKU<A_:3HOQ6sF3F698_KNSLYOE@B<LYZOQ6aOESL3F<R3F6]^3F693S3HOE`9p693HMKN: y : :­bx :<91OQ<%]^8E69WKU<%KN`%`918«]m:<91OQ<%<913v>A`913HTNTgKU8;:ZKUsHOQ<9KU8;:Y6a8E[ZOQ[ZKNTNKN<A`9<R698;:i;TUM3FY\3H:M`8;:<913L<R8E<9OETWlKN:3F<9KN@3H:3F69iEXTU8;`9`F K­b·3EbMK`9`9KUYZOQ<R3HM3H:3F6aiEEbo698;S <91K`OE: KNSYZOE@B<YZOQ6aOES3F<R3F6/KN`M3HMp@B3HM bê02133|VY\3F6aKNSL3H:n<9OET 693H`9pTN<9`@B8;pTNM:8E<%[\3693FY698VMp@B3HMÈ]JKN<91Å<913F8E6a3F<9KN@FOET2@FOETN@FpTOQ<9KU8;:`4e8E65<91313HOHCl`RVSSL3F<R6aK@(`9l`R<R3HSb0213r693H`9pZTU<P8E4z<91KN` SL3HOE`9p693HSL3H:n<2KN`rÿQb;C~OE@FOE:@FKN3H`gY\3F6 @B8;TTNKN`9KU8;:b6:ºKNSLY\8E69<9OE:n<@B8E69693H@B<9KU8;:KN` <913@B8;:=<R6hKU[Zp<9KU8;:ºMZp3m<R8 x :n<R3F6a:OET ^8;:nCE3F6a`9KN8;:Ò]J1KN@h1(:3F3HM` <R8[\3`9p[<R6hOE@B<R3HM478E6P@FOE`R3H`^OtOE:M%[b x <¢6a3HSOEKN:`fp:Z@FTU3HOQ6¢<R8t]m1KN@a13|l<R3H:M%<91KN`@FOE:/[\3M8;:3rp:OESI[ZKUi;p8;pZ`9TUEbd^p< M3H`RYZKU<R3m<913TU8«]`R<9OQ<9KN`9<9KN@F` OE:M(693H`R8;TNp<9KN8;:%<913Y693H`R>3H:@B38E4^¬2>ATNKNWE3KÙl>­6aOHV`2KN:ZMKN@FOQ<R3H` OLTU8;:iQ>ATNKN4e3F<9KNS3mZ`a`9KU8;:Ò@B8;SLY\8;:3H:n<g<R8L8l@F@Fp6]JKU<91vO/@B3F69<9OEK:476aOE@B<9KU8;: b20J13IOE:OETNl`9K`28E4f<91KN`J3|lY\3F6aKSL3H:=<J]^OE`Y\3F69478E6aSL3HMp`R>KN:i8;:3B>­3HTU3H@B<R698;:SL8;TU3H@FpTNOQ6J8E69[ZKU<9OETN`24e8E6O%@B3H:n<R6aOET `RVSSL3F<R6hKN@W¬M¤K¬@B8;TNTNKN`9KN8;:`Fb021KN`JOE:OETUV`9KN`JTN3HOEM`2<R8ÒOCE3F69TOQ69iE3476aOE@B<9KU8;:v8E4f<913ITN8;:iQ>ATNKU473F<9KNSL3Z`a`9KU8;:@B8;S5>Y\8;:3H:=<PKN:@B8;:n<R6aOE`R<^]JKU<91L<913m693H`9pTN<9`MKN`9@FpZ`9`R3HML`R8I47OQ6Hbf0213JTU8«]^3F6 TNKNSKU<9`d478E6¢<913TNOQ<R3Z`a`9KU8;:X<9KNSL3H`t]P3F693%4e8;p:ZMX<R8[\3k ; ´ÿY> µ ¨ª¶`OQ<t<9133|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:Å3H:3F69iE8E4R >_u3Y OE:M ´ ÿY>_µ ¨ª¶ `LOQ<L<913(3|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:3H:3F69iEÅ8E45ÿY>u3YIb0213Y698E[ZOQ[KNTNKU<9KU3H`r<R8X8E[Z`93F69CE3/<913H`R3(TN8;:iQ>ATNKUCE3HMZ`9`9KN8;:Å@B8;SLY\8;:3H:n<9`]P3F693(478;p:M_<R8[\3³>à E:EIOE:MÄ>Ã:l693H`RY\3H@B<9KUCE3HTUEbf0213m<R8E<9OETO«CE3F6aOQiE3t`9@FKN`a`9KU8;:L<9KNS3J<91lp`P@FOE:[\3m693FYZ693H`R3H:n<R3HMºOE`-Ö³ÄHôÿY>_µ ¨ª¶ `^4e8E6[° ­ eÑ >Lu3YOE:M¤Ö³ÄÃNÿT´ÿY>_µ ¨ª¶`t478E6D°­e ÿY>u3Y OE`9`9pSK:iº:8@B8;:n<R6aKU[Zp<9KN8;:4e6a8;S <913%`a18E69<?>ATNKU473F<9KNSL35Z`R>`9KU8;:@B8;SLY\8;:3H:n<xyK³b·3EbM3F<R3F6aS%KN:KN:iv<913TU8D]P3F6%TKNSKU<4e8E6L<913OHCE3F6aOQiE3X`9@FKN`9`aKU8;:<9KNSL3D|hb_0213F693(S%OHÅ[\3(TNOQ69iE3ÏZp@B<9pOQ<9KN8;:`IK:Å<913Ò3|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:È3H:3F69iEÈMKN`R<R6hKU[ZpV><9KU8;:[\3F<A]^3F3H:X<913%¬2>ATNKNWE3IY6a8lMpZ@B<9`Fb^8;:`R3<lp3H:n<9TU<913LOE`9`9pZSLY<9KU8;:v<91OQ<r[\8E<91Y698VMp@B<9`1ZOHCE3J<913J`9OESL323|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:%3H:3F69iEL@FOE:%:8E<[\3cRp`9<9KU3HM bdçJ8D]P3FCE3F6«l<913KNSLY\8E69<9OE:n<m6a3H`9pTU<m8E4<91KN`]^8E69WKN`rO(:8;:V>­sF3F698l¬J>ATNKUWE3z7l>­6aOHvlKU3HTMvTU3HOEMZKN:i%<R8OTU8;:iQ>ATKU4e3F<9KSL3m`9`9KU8;:º@B8;SLY\8;:3H:n<Fb¢02134e6aOE@B<9KN8;:M3HMp@B3HMº@FOE:[\3tMKN`RYZp<R3HM(OE`

Page 36: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

R3ÀFÁUÀpº_Ã?BÃ: JKXhÃøu +/Ãa: 8a+aæç Um

ë aì YGRUÀk < ñò øðô|úRî! _òï õßøàôÆøßòïBøàþ:òþ>"&ø.÷ L îßîßö$&÷MôKB L îðîªöSB÷&"õðñòB÷)ò/øßòôBï õßöSB÷ ø6:þ:ÿ)ï õc9K^ô÷)þ L îðîªöSB÷" õßñòÆõ ¶KøßòôBï õßöSB÷ ø:þ:ÿï£õðî°ï8K

OQ<R8;SK@OE:Mº:npZ@FTU3HOQ6gY698V@B3H`9`R3H`2OQ6a3t@B8;pYZTU3HM bd3t]mKNTNT)@B8;SL3t[ZOE@aW/<R8L<91K`gKN:(<913TNOQ<R3F6mM3F<9OEKNTU3HMMZKN`9@Fp`9`aKU8;:/K:º`R3H@B<9KU8;:jEnb! b

Page 37: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

"3f I¼:DR3®J&_8Uaji±i/% &Yaæç?ÃæçUÈMtÈ Ë DØ¡\Ú2ÙõkLÙa¤tßh5¥ ¡\ß àLLI50213Y6hKN:@FKUYZTN3m8E4d<913t@B69V`R<9OET [ZTU8V@9WVKN:i5<R3H@a1:ZK=<np3@FOE:[\3tM3H`9@B6hKU[\3HMºOE`2478;TNTU8«]m`Fb0213(13HOHCl=>AKN8;:[\3HOES [\8;S[ZOQ6hM`Ov`9KN:i;TU3/@B69l`9<9OET^`93F69ClK:iOE`5O<9OQ69iE3F<Fb m4e<R3F6O6a3HOE@B<9KU8;:È]JKU<91_8;:3/8E42<913(@B69V`R<9OET^:npZ@FTU3HK³dZ`9`9KN8;:8l@F@Fp6a`5KN:`9KNM3L<913(@B6al`R<9OET­b 3FY)3H:ZMKN:i8;:L<9132<9KNSL3J:3F3HM3HM478E6¢`9@FKN`a`9KU8;:OE:M<9132CE3HTU8V@FKU<AL8E4\<913JY693B>­Z`9`aKU8;::npZ@FTU3Hp`JO%@B3F69<9OEKN:MKN`R<9OE:@B3]JKNTNT\[\3t<R6aO«CE3HTNTU3HMvKN:<913I@B69l`9<9OET³bg0213OE:i;pZTNOQ6mMK`?><R6aKU[Zp<9KU8;:È8E4m<913º`9`9KU8;:+476aOQi;SL3H:n<9`L3|1KU[ZKU<9`5MKNYZ`5KN:+<913MKU6a3H@B<9KU8;:+8E4@B6al`R<9OETOl3H`/x7[ZTU8V@9WVKN:in|h ]J13H:X<913TNKU473F<9KNSL35KN`r`918E69<Fb5o8E6TU8;:iE3F6tTNKU473F<9KNSL3H`<913LZ`9`aKU8;:4e6hOQi;SL3H:=<9`mOQ693:8E<J[ZTU8V@9WE3HMOE:M@FOE:3HSL3F69iE3IOETU8;:i<913I@B69l`9<9OETOl3H`JZTNTNK:iI<913MKUYZ`Hbc0213[TU8l@aWlK:i6aOQ<9KN86a3FY693H`R3H:n<9KN:i<913rZTNTNK:it8E4 <913rMZKUYZ`rxyK³b·3Ebf<913r6aOQ<9KU858E4<913tSL3HOE:ºVKU3HTNMZ`^K:`9KNM3OE:MÒ8;p<9`9KM3r<913tMKUY)|¢OETNTU8D]J` 8;:3<R8%M3F<R3F6aSKN:3<913Z`R>`9KU8;:5TNKU473F<9KNSL3Eb6m:53|VY\3F6aKNSL3H:n<dp`9KN:im<91KN`dSL3F<918VM]^OE`Y)3F6a4e8E6aS3HMIKN:K x èº[lu8E6³?3HOE:~/?FTy!Vÿ|­b0213OEMCQOE:n<9OQiE38E4<91KN`¢3|lY\3F6aKNS3H:=<P]JKU<91/693H`RY\3H@B<P<R858E<913F6SL3HOE`9p6a3HSL3H:=<9`Ip`9KN:i(<913@B69l`9<9OET[ZTU8V@9WVKN:iºSL3F<918lMKN`t<913KN:nCE3F6a`R3WVKN:3HSOQ<9K@F`]J1KN@h1KN:Z@B693HOE`R3H`m<913CE3HTU8V@FKU<E)<913F693F[nº[\3H@B8;SK:i/SL8E6a3I`R3H:`aKU<9KUCE3t<R8Ò`918E69<TNKU473B><9KNSL3H`Fb^0213t`R<9pZMKU3HMº`RV`R<R3HS ] OE`R Òu3YW ~p¡£¥£¶Y¬ ¤ ¡£¶FkKp`9KN:i476aOQi;SL3H:n<9OQ<9KU8;:693HOE@B<9KU8;:`dOE`dKN:I<913^Y693H`R3H:n<z]^8E69W)bc0J13¢3|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:53H:3F6aiEt]^OE`dM3F<R3F6hSKN:3HM4e698;S<913%SL3HOE`ap693HMÅ:3Hp<R698;:_SpTU<9KUYTNKN@FKU<]JKU<91X<913/OEKNM8E4g`R<9OQ<9KN`R<9K@FOET¢@B8VM3%@FOETN@FpTO~><9KU8;:`FbJ3Hp<R698;:`I]P3F693ÒSL3HOE`9p693HMÅ]mKU<91ÅO+ ìM3F<R3H@B<R8E6Hb0J13/p:Z@B3F69<9OEKN:n<9KU3H`8;:<9133|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:º3H:3F6aiE/KN:@FTpM3rO,5ÿr:3Hp<R698;:ºSpTU<9KUYTNKN@FKU<3F6a698E6H]J1K@a1(693H`9pTN<9`KN:+OE:+3F69698E658E4,T >u3Y4e8E6G°­ÞQ ÿH?>_u3Y7y )H­bÈ0213ÒOQ<R8;SKN@º:lpS[\3F658E4<913Z`9`9KU8;:ZKN:i%:lp@FTU3HK ]^OE``R3HTN3H@B<R3HMOE`W·Q :,lbr0213693H`9pTU<9`J8E4<91KN`m3|VY)3F69>KNSL3H:n<mOQ693`918D]J:KN:ib¼lbHjy!:cOE`@FTU8;`R3HM@FKU6a@FTU3H`HbJCE3F6aOQiE35`9@FKN`a`9KU8;:TKU4e3F<9KSL3H`8E[<9OEKN:3HM+KN:<913ºOE:OETUV`9KN`I8E42<91K`]^8E69WOQ6a3ÒOQ<LTU3HOE`9<8;:3/8E6aM3F68E4SOQi;:KU<9pZM3TU8;:iE3F6r<91OE:v<918;`R358E[<9OEKN:3HM]JKN<91v:lp@FTU3HOQ6rSL3F<918VM`Fbr021KN`mKN:MK@FOQ<R3H`J<913Y693H`R>3H:@B38E4O/TU8;:iQ>ATNKU473F<9KNSL3Z`9`aKU8;:@B8;SLY\8;:3H:n<FbJ0213<A]^8º`R8;TNKNM@Fp69CE3H`m693H`9pTU<J4e698;S<913^8;S[KN:3HM V:OESKN@FOETfkl<9OQ<9KN`9<9KN@FOETcu8VM3HT^x­ ku+;|m@FOETN@FpTOQ<9KU8;:`2478E6r8;:TU:3Hp<R698;:Z`f3HSKU<R<R3HMxyTU8«]^3F6^@Fp69CE3D|dOE:ML478E6P:3Hp<R698;:`OE:ZM@a1OQ6aiE3HM%YZOQ6a<9KN@FTU3H`f3HSKN<?><R3HMêxypYY\3F6I@Fp69CE3D|hbv0213/KSLY\8E69<9OE:=<I`R<9OQ<R3HSL3H:n<<R8v[\3%3|VY693H`9`R3HM13F693(KN`t<91OQ<KU<r]P8;pZTNM[)358E4PiE693HOQ<OEMCQOE:=<9OQiE3/KU48;:3L@B8;pTNMS3HOE`9p693LKN:X`9OESL3L] OH<913L`9@FKN`R>`9KU8;:v<9KNSL35MKN`R<R6hKU[Zp<9KU8;:ºK:`R<R3HOEMv8E4<9135OHCE3F6aOQiE3<9KSL3EbT`rO/`aKNSLYZTU33|VOESLYTU3E O4e3F]TU8;:iQ>ATNKU473F<9KNSL3^Z`9`aKU8;:KN:irKN`R8;S3F6a`d]JKNTNTVSOQWE3J<9132OHCE3F6aOQiE3r`9@FKN`a`9KU8;:<9KNSL32Sp@a1TU8;:iE3F6HK³b·3Ebd<913r693H`apTU<9KN:iITNKU473F<9KNSL3J]m13H:j:a;3FCE3H:n<9`2OQ693rKN:@FTpM3HMvxypYY\3F6P@Fp69CE3D|@FOE:[\3gCE3F69LTU8;:ibf0213gY698EY\3F6] OH5]JKNTNTl[\3g<R8YZ693H`R3H:n<Z`9`9KN8;:LTNKU473F<9KNSL3gMKN`R<R6hKU[ZpV><9KU8;:`Fb x <2KN`JOE:º3|lY\3F6aKSL3H:=<9OET @h1OETNTU3H:iE3t<R88E[<9OEKN::8E<28;:3t<9KSL3B>AOHCE3F6aOQiE3693H`9pZTU<[Zp<@B8;SLYZTN3F<R3<9KNSL3LMKN`9<R6aKU[Zp<9KN8;:`2478E6tCQOQ6aKU8;p`r3|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:3H:3F69i;KU3H`Fb%`@FOE:_[\3`R3F3H:47698;S OL@B8;SYZOQ6aKN`R8;:8E4c<9133|lY\3F6aKNS3H:=<9OETOE:ZMÒ<913F8E693F<9KN@FOET 693H`9pTU<9`HO%<npKN<R3TNOQ69iE3MKN`9@B693FYOE:@BE=3H`RY\3H@FKNOETTUIOQ698;pZ:Ma°­[Qÿ?>u3Y=3|KN`R<9`Fb¢q4 @B8;p6a`93En<913F8Q>693F<9KN@FOET)@FOETN@FpTNOQ<9KN8;:`]^3F693JY\3F69478E6aSL3HM/OE`9`9pS%KN:itO@B3F69<9OEKN:/4e6aK@B<9KU8;:`R<R693H:iE<91xy`R3F3

Page 38: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

R3ÀSR3ÀÂI¼8;)ÃøhDÃ3éUa ì | ]k "õ

ë aì YGRUÀuåUí/ýBòøðôBùBòTîßïuöüîðîªöSB÷ÅõßöüóTòMô&î4ôI"=ÿ÷)ï õßöSB÷"ò ï ö õðôYõðö$&÷bò÷òuøðùBúû$îªòþÅï öüø ïuû òî¼øðò+ øðòîßòu÷õ¼ò òøßöüóKòu÷õðôBûøðòîßÿû õðî>"=ø&ó %]E¡@ < ñòõßñ)òuø> Böü÷õðîTøðò"=òuø¼õô%ó&:þ:òuûïôûFï ÿûFôYõðö$&÷n=îßòuòÆõðò õK

@h1OQY<R3F6/ n|hb0z8t`R<9pMI]J1OQ<d<913g693H`apTU<9KN:ir@a1ZOQ6aOE@B<R3F6aKN`R<9K@Æn>­6hOH5`RY\3H@B<R6apS]^8;pTNMTU8l8EW/TKUWE3KN:Ò<91KN`g@FOE`R3EZ<913Z`9`9KN8;:Ò<9KNSL3MKN`R<R6hKU[Zp<9KU8;:%Y693HMK@B<R3HMÒ[n(<913I kuj@B8VM3xy`918D]J:XKN:Zibè/8E4¢693F4 bby!:7|m] OE`p`R3HM<R8º`R8;TUCE353<npZOQ<9KU8;:ÇlbNÿÒ:npZSL3F6aK >@FOETNTNEb x <<9p6h:`f8;p<P<91OQ<¢<913m693H`9pTN<9KN:iTn>­6hOH`91OQY\3JK`fCE3F69`9KNS%KNTNOQ6f<R8<913J`91OQY\3[ZOE`93HMÒ8;:ºOE:Ò3|lY\8;:3H:n<9KNOET)<9KNSL3MKN`9<R6aKU[Zp<9KN8;:L]JKU<91¤ÖaQÂ Ï d,[\3HKN:i<913OHCE3F6aOQiE38E4<913º<9KNSL3MZKN`R<R6aKU[p<9KU8;:_8E4<913v kujX@B8VM3Ebop69<913F6%MKN`9@FpZ`9`9KU8;:`@FOE:[\3478;p:MºKN:º@h1OQY<R3F6a`KE5OE:Mç;lb

Page 39: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

" I¼:DR3®J&_8Uaji±i/% &Yaæç?ÃæçUÈMt* v ¤RÓ(¤J)ÛâÜ d¡ à5¤tÛ0213F693ÒOQ693Ò478;p65Y)8;`a`9KU[ZTU3/`9@B3H:OQ6aKU8;`LK:13HO«CnÈKU8;:+KN:MpZ@B3HMÅ693HOE@B<9KN8;:`LOQ<LKN:=<R3F69>SL3HMKNOQ<R3(3H:3F69i;KN3H`ITU3HOEMZKN:i<R8Y698~R3H@B<9KNTU3B>ATNKNWE3%476aOQi;SL3H:n<IY6a8lMpZ@B<9KU8;: b0213F_OQ6a3`918D]J:5KN:ti;p693Ælb En=]J13F693^O`a@a13HSOQ<9K@FOETlKTNTNp`R<R6hOQ<9KU8;:8E4<913 Y6a8l@B3H`9`93H`cK` i;KUCE3H:bæ 0 oOE:M M3H:8E<R3LY698~R3H@B<9KNTU3E <9OQ6aiE3F<F Y698~R3H@B<9KNTU3B>ATKUWE3I476aOQi;SL3H:n<tOE:MX8E<913F6TNKUi;1n<IYZ698~?3H@B<9KTU3B>ATNKUWE3ÒYZOQ69<9K@FTU3H`Ff693H`RY\3H@B<9KUCE3HTNEbÅ0213ÒY698V@B3H`9`5TNOQ[\3HTNTU3HMÈO=|hP`a18«]J`@FTNOE`9`9K@FOET 4e6hOQi;SL3H:=<9OQ<9KN8;: ]J1K@a1 18D]P3FCE3F6«KN`g:8E<mO`R<R698;:iL6a3HOE@B<9KU8;:@h1OE::3HTOQ<8;p6J3H:3F69iEÒ8E4dK:=<R3F693H`9<Fb x :<913Y698V@B3H`9`g[)| OE:3|V@FKN<R3HMY698~R3H@B<9KNTU3 æ ­[693HOQWV`JpYKN:n<R8(O/Y698~R3H@B<9KNTU3B>ATNKNWE3t4e6hOQi;SL3H:=<oOE:MYOQ69<9KN@FTU3H`mtb x :v8;p6rSL3F<918VM<913<R6aOE:`R>4e3F65693HOE@B<9KN8;:È@«|IKN`p`R3HMb æ OQ69<9KN@FTU3ÒKN`I<R6aOE:`R473F69693HM<R8X<913(<9OQ69iE3F<L0z478E6aSK:iOv@B8;SY)8;pZ:MÅ:lp@FTU3Hp`0R¤rbdqrp6I`R<9pMZKU3HMÅ@FOE`R3ºKN`<913 >­<R6aOE:Z`R4e3F65693HOE@B<9KN8;: ?>u3YW ~p¯¡£¢FJ3Ť±¡£¥£¡F021j¦ ¨ª©Hq ¤±¡£¥£©Y¬;b021lp`F8;p6r@B8;SLY\8;p:M:lp@FTU3Hp`0R¤rKN` ¡£¥£© ¬;]J1KN@h1Òp:M3F69iE8l3H` Z`9`aKU8;: OE:MÒ<913Y6a8~?3H@B<9KNTN3B>ATNKUWE3r4e6hOQi;SL3H:=<2o+KN` ¨ª© q5b0213(TNOE`R<5@FOE`R3ºM|tK`O<R6aOE:`R473F6693HOE@B<9KU8;: f]J13F693/OY698~R3H@B<9KNTU3B>ATKUWE3476aOQi;SL3H:n<5K`3|V@FKN<R3HMOE:MX`R3<np3H:=<9KNOETTUM3H@FO«l`r[lYZOQ6a<9KN@FTU33HSKN`9`9KN8;: bPSL3HOE`9p6hKN:iÒ:3HOQ6aTUOETNT)<913rY698~R3H@B<9KNTU3B>ATNKNWE3J476aOQi;SL3H:n<9`gKN:(3HOE@a1º3FCE3H:n<g]P3SK:KNSKUsF3J<913@B8;SLYZTNKN@FOQ<9KN8;:@FOEp`R3HMÈ[l@FOE`R3H`5[)|OE:MÈM|hbXê13H:ÈS3HOE`9p6aKN:i<913Ò<9OQ69iE3F<?>ATNKNWE3(476aOQi;SL3H:n<5ClKO<913@h1OQ6aOE@B<R3F6aKN`9<9KN@KÒ6aOHV`2<913I@a1OQ69iE3<R6aOE:`R473F6JKN`g<9OQWE3H:vKN:n<R8OE@F@B8;p:=<OEp<R8;SOQ<?>KN@FOETNTUEb0213ll>­6aOHSL3F<918lM <R8Å@FTNOQ6aKU47È693HOE@B<9KU8;: @h1OE::3HT`1OE`[\3F3H:3|VYZTU8;KN<R3HM3|l<R3H:Z`9KUCE3HTUOQ<ëM x y!HlD: :­bm3]mKNTNT 3HSLYTU8«º<913SL3F<918VM8E4Pè3F3FiE<R3~YÍ?y ÿ|<R8º3H`R<9OQ[ZTKN`91<9135lKN3HTNM`8E4¢<913LCQOQ6aKU8;pZ`m6a3HOE@B<9KU8;:_@a1ZOE::3HTN`KN:ZM3FY\3H:M3H:n<J8E4<913Ml>­6aOHºSL3HOE`ap693HSL3H:n<9`xy`R3F3@a1OQY<R3F6KH;|hb

0213r3|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:Ò3H:3F6aiE/8E[<9OEK:3HM([n(@B8;SLY\8;p:MÒ:npZ@FTU3Hp` 0R¤rKN:Ò@FOE`R3t@«|^K`3<npZOET=<R8m<913¢WVKN:3F<9KN@3H:3F69iE%x7[\3HOES 3H:3F69iE| 8E4<913¢<R6hOE:`R473F69693HMtYOQ69<9KN@FTU3¢bQ^8;SL>Y\8;p:MÒ:npZ@FTU3Hp` ¡£¥£© ¬ 8E[Z<9OEKN:` OE:º3|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:º3H:3F6aiE%8E4dOÅ?>u3YW ~p >­YZOQ69<9KN@FTN3EK³b·3Eb2ÿ?>Lu3Ybk SL8E6a3mY6a3H@FKN`R3m@FOET@FpTNOQ<9KU8;:Òp`9K:it<9138EY<9KNSpS>­CQOETNp3rSL8lM3HTxy`R3F3(3Eb·ibêKTN@BsFJì:Z`RWlK¢OE:M_,KNTN`9@h1np< yE?7|i;KUCE3H`/ÿEÿ;u3YIbd0213/]JKNM<918E4g<9133|V@FKN<9OQ<9KU8;:_3H:3F6aiE`RY\3H@B<R6apZS 4e8E68;p6693HTU3FCQOE:=<I@FOE`R3%@«|Lxy`R3F3/i;p693Ålb EE|t@FOE:_[\3@FOETN@FpTNOQ<R3HMÈ]JKN<91KN:<913(476aOESL3F]^8E69W_8E4J<913(`R<9OQ<9K`R<9KN@FOET^SL8lM3HT¢8E42476aOQi;SL3H:n<9OQ<9KU8;:[n8;TNMZ1OQ[\3F6ly!:?­b x :+<91K`LSL8lM3HT^S8;SL3H:=<9pZS @B8;:`R3F69CQOQ<9KU8;:K`LOE`9`9pSL3HMK:<913693B>AMZKN`R<R6aKU[p<9KU8;:8E4 <913LYZ698~?3H@B<9KTU3:npZ@FTU3F8;:`FbL0213F6a3F4e8E693E 4e6aOQi;S3H:=<9`I1OHCE3(OSL8;SL3H:n<9pS MK`R<R6aKU[Zp<9KU8;:%]mKU<91Ò<913t]JKM<91 G

P ¡ QP ¡¢ x µ ò3f|x µòÿ«| § x lb EE|]J13F693¡µ OE:ZM; OQ693%<913%Y698~R3H@B<9KNTU3/OE:MÅ476aOQi;SL3H:n<IS%OE`9`I:lpSI[\3F6a`F 6a3H`RY\3H@¯><9KUCE3HTUÒOE:MyP ¢ KN`gO@B8;:`R<9OE:n<FZ3<lpOET <R8

P ¡¢ Q Ý ¡ ² R£¢ â Ã x lb;;|

Page 40: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

R3À$~ À¥¤ÆY)]¯æç U "3"

ë aì YGRUÀ÷kí+îßïàñòóMôYõßöFïDöüû ûüÿ)îªõßøàôYõßöSB÷)"=ø6BóÛõ6:î õàôBþU X¡u"?õðñò:"&ÿø ø6:ï òîßîßòîûüòô&þ:ö ÷)ùõ6 )ø òï£õðö ûüò ûüö$&ò"=øàôù&óTò÷õc )ø:þ:ÿ)ï õßöSB÷;çm3F693ÆÝa ² R£¢ â · :?>%u3YM ~@IKN` <913to3F6aS%KSL8;SL3H:n<9pSºb/X/lY\3F6aKNS3H:=<9OETNTNaP ¢ ] OE`478;p:M<R8[\3X`9SOETNTN3F6(Mp3<R8+<913_^8;pTU8;SI[,3HTNM3|\3H@B<OE:M æ OEpTNKJ[ZTU8V@9WVKN:i]J1ZKN@a1`R<9KNTNTgYTNOHV`/O698;TU3OQ<(O[\3HOES'3H:3F69iE8E4è?>+u3YW ~p b x :8;p6Ò@FOE`R3 P ¢KN`E?;lbvu3YM ~@(<9OQWE3H:4e6a8;S <913(OE:OETUV`9KN`8E42è 3F3FiE<R3 ~T?§y ÿ|­bº0213693HTOQ<9KU8;:[\3F<A]^3F3H:<913º3H:3F69iE+]JKNM<91Û¼° ³XOE:M+<913SL8;SL3H:n<9pS MZKN`R<R6aKU[p<9KU8;:_]mKNM<91P@FOE:º[\3]26hKU<R<R3H:OE` ¼° °¦ · P

ݧ § x lb;|

Page 41: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

"U@ I¼:DR3®J&_8Uaji±i/% &Yaæç?ÃæçU]J13F693õ°¨OE:MÇÝaOQ693<913v4e6hOQi;SL3H:=</3H:3F69iEOE:MSL8;SL3H:n<9pSº 693H`RY\3H@B<9KUCE3HTNEb021lp`F^<9133H:3F69iE+]JKM<91+8E4r<913<R6aOE:`94e3F696a3HM >­YOQ69<9KN@FTU3Åx7]^3v@FOE: 693FYZTNOE@B3<913KN:M3|ª© [n×´ KN:ê3<npOQ<9KN8;:`çlb E+OE:Mlb;|ÒK`¤¼G°¨ · :Hu3YbJ021lp`FJ<9133|V@FKN<9OQ<9KU8;:3H:3F69iEXMKN`9<R6aKU[Zp<9KN8;:8E4 @B8;SLY\8;p:MX:npZ@FTU3Hp` ¡£¥£© ¬ @FOE:_[)35Y6a3H`R3H:=<R3HMOE`JOLi;OEpZ`9`9KNOE:Ò]JKN<91ºOSOKNSIpZS 8E4 ÿEÿ;%u3YOE:MºO]JKNM<91Ò8E4°:H%u3YIb

0213478;TNMK:iLOE:i;TU3[\3F<A]^3F3H:<]P8/Z`9`9KU8;:Ò476aOQi;SL3H:n<9`2@FOETN@FpZTNOQ<R3HMOE`

 ¥ ³³dQ m¬«­ Ï m)Ú¢x ÿx Ý ¯ ¹ ݵ|

xRx Ý ¯ ¹ Ý µ |£P µ ¤®P b |)ÂÜ°o dP絶°µ | § x lbNÿY>=|]J13F693¯Pçµ^kݵêOE:M°>µ,OQ693SOE`a`F SL8;SL3H:n<9pS OE:M_3H:3F69iE8E4^<913LY6a8~?3H@B<9KNTN3EbP b KN`<913/<9OQ6aiE3F<SOE`a`Fbç °o dKN`t<913(O«CE3F6aOQiE3ÒWlKN:3F<9KN@3H:3F6aiE693HTU3HOE`R3(4e8E6Z`9`9KN8;:Òi;KUCE3H:º[l(<913MKU8;TOL`Rl`9<R3HSOQ<9KN@F`èyElÿY

ÂÜ°o dQ >ÃNÿEÿ;: ·R¡°± ¤ÄEiÃ!P Òj § x lbNÿEÿ«|]J13F693T OE:Me²OQ693<913rSOE`9`^OE:M/<913m@h1OQ69iE3r8E4<913mZ`9`9KU8;:ZKN:it:lp@FTU3Hp`Fb x :8;p6`R<9pMKN3HM <R6aOE:`94e3F6693HOE@B<9KU8;:×Âè° o d KN`3<npZOET¢<R8+ÿBE>u3Y OE:MÅ<913(4e8;TNMZKN:iOE:i;TU3 KN`# ¥ ³³dQÿBE? ¢ bd0213P]JKNM<918E4<913^4e8;TNMZKN:iJOE:i;TN3^KN`H~18D]P3FCE3F6«;<R8n8TNOQ6aiE3<R8%p`R3KU<g3|\3H@B<9KUCE3HTUºOE`2OLS3HOE:`g<R8SL3HOE`9p693<9133|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:º3H:3F6aiEEbP0213SOEK:OEMCQOE:=<9OQiE38E4P8;p6tSL3F<918VMKN`rp`9K:i· KNM3H:n<9KUZ@FOQ<9KU8;:8E4P<9135Z`9`9KU8;:ZKN:i/:lp@FTU3HpZ`]JKU<91Ò<913Ip:K=<lp3K l>­6aO«Ò`9Y)3H@B<R6hOL4e8E6J3HOE@a13HTN3HSL3H:=<Fb

0213iE6hOQsHKN:i%OE:i;TN3t@FOE:[\3M3F<R3F6aSKN:3HMºp`9KN:i5<9134e8E6aSpTNOE` 47698;S yE OE`¥r³ R Qm«!­YáñªÚ¢x m´ Ñ òóm | § x lbNÿ;|

mQ Ò ¡

·µ°·¶b ¨ª¡ ° µ ¹ µ § x lbNÿ;|´ Ñ · y ÿÃNÿx °±µ ¤ °±b |¶ò>à Zx µ °±µ ¤ µ °±b |¤&]´ à x lbNÿ| n| ¨ª¡ Q µV¶µ vµ ¶ µ v KN`d<913g693HMZp@B3HMSOE`9`¢:npSI[\3F6Hbdo8E6¢<913g6a3HOE@B<9KU8;:`?>u3YW ~pb¡£¢BJ3¤ ¡£¥£¡ 0J1<913iE6aOQsHKN:i/OE:i;TU35KN` ¥ ³ R QÿEÿ ¢ bm021lp`F\KU<KN`2693HOE`98;:OQ[ZTU3<R8/YTNOE@B3I<913

Y698~R3H@B<9KNTU3B>ATNKNWE34e6hOQi;SL3H:=<M3F<R3H@B<9KU8;:È`RV`R<R3HS 9p`R<t8;p<9`9KNM3<913iE6aOQsHKN:iOE:i;TU3<R8OHCE8;KNM+OvTNOQ69iE3Ò@B8;:=<R6aKN[Zp<9KU8;:<R8<913Ò@B8;p:n<I6aOQ<R3(47698;S <913(3HTNOE`R<9K@FOETNTU`9@FOQ<R<R3F693HMYZOQ69<9KN@FTN3H`Fb x <2K`2`R<9KNTNT\`9p;%@FKU3H:n<g<R8%M3F<R3H@B<W¨ª©HqYOQ69<9KN@FTU3H`Fb

TN8E<m8E4P3|lY\3F6aKNS3H:=<9OETcOE:Mv<913F8E693F<9KN@FOETd]^8E69W1OE`r[\3F3H:M8;:3<R8º`R<9pM<913Z`9`9KN8;:[ZOQ696aKN3F6HzKN:ÅYZOQ69<9KN@FpZTNOQ6t478E6 ¡£¥£¡ 021 bº0213 ¡£¥£¡ 021_`9`9KU8;:[OQ696aKU3F6KN`<R6aKUYTU3B>1npZSLY\3HM5]JKU<915<9132CQOETNp3H`8E[<9OEKN:3HMK:53HTU3H@B<R698;:V>AKN:ZMp@B3HM5Z`9`aKU8;:53|lY\3F6aKSL3H:=<¼yE?H?OQ6932° µ Q Ãmu3Y° ±óQ HÃmu3Y° Ñ Q à E2u3YI~KN:MK@FOQ<9KN:i <91693F3¢S%OVKNS%OV

Page 42: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

R3À$~ À¥¤ÆY)]¯æç U "

OE:M¯Ã:e·° \\ · Ã:(u3YH° \\\ Q®Ã! u3Y)K:MKN@FOQ<9KN:iL<A]^8ÒS%KN:KNSOVb2o8E6¡£¥£© ¬<913M8;p[ZTU3B>A1lpSLY\3HMÈZ`9`9KN8;:[ZOQ696aKN3F6a`58E[<9OEKN:3HM KN:<913<913F8E693F<9KN@FOET2]^8E69Wy!&¢OQ693n° µ Q ÃH:u3YC° ±Q Ã:u3YC° \\ Q±ÃEu3Yb çm8«]^3FCE3F6HdKU<KN`iE3H:3F6hOETNTU_OE`9`9pZSL3HMÈ<91OQ<LOQ<3H:3F69i;KU3H`5]^3HTNTPOQ[\8DCE3º<913/`9`9KU8;:[ZOQ696aKN3F6HfO`aKN:i;TU3[ZOQ6a6aKU3F65`9p%@B3H`FbÈu8VM3HTN`<91OQ<LY6a3HMKN@B<<913H`R3ÒC~OETp3H`5OQ693Ò[ZOE`R3HM+8;:+<913ºTNK=<lpKNMM6a8EYM3H`9@B6aKUYZ<9KU8;:Ò8E4c:lp@FTU3HK­b

0J13CQOETNp3478E6 <913 ¡£¥£© ¬+Z`9`9KN8;:[ZOQ696aKN3F6 @FOETN@FpTNOQ<R3HMIp`9KN:ig<913 kVKN3F69Wm478E6aSOETKN`9SKN`b Ãu3Yb 0J13vO«CE3F6aOQiE3_OE:i;pTNOQ6(SL8;SL3H:n<9pSó<R6aOE:`R473F6(OE`a`R8l@FKOQ<R3HM]mKU<91 ><R6aOE:Z`R4e3F6KN:1?>Xu3YM ~p ¡£¢ J3ç¤ ¡£¥£¡ 0J1§¦ ¨ª© q¤ ¡£¥£© ¬ 693HOE@B<9KU8;:+KN`è: b0J1KN`693HMZp@B3H`g<913Z`a`9KU8;:Ò[ZOQ696hKU3F6gC~OETp3<R8Å Ãu3YIb

0J13L^pZ`9KN:OQ698Q> OETNTU8;:35@B6aKU<9KN@FOETfS%OE`9`OE`RVSSL3F<R69@a1OQ6aOE@B<R3F6hKUsF3H`t<913MZKU693H@¯><9KU8;:X8E4P<913M6aKNClKN:i%478E6a@B3L]J13H:X<]P8:lp@FTU3HKc<R8;p@h1Äy!H:­bLo8E6S%OE`9`OE`RVSSL3F<R69 TNOQ69iE3F6/<913H:<913 p`9KN:OQ6a8Q> rOETNTU8;:3ºSOE`a`%OE`RVSSL3F<R69 ±¸<913v@B8;SLY\8;p:M:lp@FTU3Hp`24e8E6aS%OQ<9KU8;:<9OQWE3H`mYZTNOE@B3I4e8;TNTN8«]^3HM[l(<913@FTNOE`9`9K@FOETZ`9`aKU8;:º`9@B3H:OQ6aKN8b o8E6  ±¸ <913/`aSOETNTU3F6IYZOQ69<9:3F6i;OEKN:`IKN:ÅSOE`a`IOE:M<913F693(KN`O@a1ZOE:@B3/478E6<913MK:np@FTN3HOQ6z`RV`R<R3HS<R8r`R3FYZOQ6aOQ<R3g]JKN<918;p< <913^@B8;SLY\8;p:ZMI:lp@FTU3Hp`z478E6aSOQ<9KU8;: b^TN`R8KU<rKN`:3H@B3H`9`9OQ6a<R8:8E<9KN@B35<91OQ<r<9133H:n<R6aOE:@B3@a1ZOE::3HTdSOE`9`rOE`RVSSL3F<R69v3|)3H@B<9`KN` KNSY)8E6a<9OE:=<P8;:TU478E6g[\8;S[ZOQ6hMKN:it3H:3F69i;KU3H`gTU3H`9`^<91OQ<?>¹ OQ[\8«CE3<913r[ZOQ6a6aKU3F6Hbo8E65OE:n<R6aOE:`R473F6693HOE@B<9KN8;:KN:_8;p6I@FOE`R3/8E4 d ± OE:M_<913%478E6aSOQ<9KU8;:Å<9KNSL38E4P<913@B8;SLY\8;p:M:npZ@FTU3Hp`rKN`r3|VY)3H@B<R3HMX<R8º[\3L`9SOETT xyOQ[\8;p<W`´+ÿY>_µ ¡¨ `h|y!:H­b0213F693F4e8E6a3E ]P3LSO«OE`9`apSL35<91OQ<tKN:OETNTc693HOE@B<9KU8;:_@h1OE::3HT`m]^3`R<9pMZKU3HM \OÒ<R6ap3@B8;SLY\8;p:ZMº:np@FTN3Hp`gKN` 478E6aSL3HM b

Page 43: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

"3Z I¼:DR3®J&_8Uaji±i/% &Yaæç?ÃæçU

Page 44: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

º o É Ê È!»p@FTU3HOQ6PZ`9`9KU8;:%@FOE:%[\3J`R3F3H:(OE`^O@B8;SLYZTN3|LMl:OES%KN@FOETY698V@B3H`9`Fb x :<913m6a`R<P`R3H@¯><9KU8;:` bNÿiE3H:3F6aOET)@B8;:@B3FY<9` 8E4<913m:lp@FTU3HOQ6 Z`9`9KN8;:%MV:OESKN@F`PKN:@FTNpZMKN:irCVKN`9@B8;`9KU<E476aKN@B<9KU8;:OE:MMK`9`9KUYZOQ<9KN8;:tOQ693PM3H`9@B6aKU[\3HM b 0J13¢SL8VMKUZ@FOQ<9KN8;:8E4<913P^8;169>­ê13F3HTN3F6Z`a`9KU8;:]JKNM<915]mKU<915<9132ë6aOES3F6a`OQYY6a8;OE@a1OE:M<9132M3FY\3H:M3H:@B3 8;:%<913g4e6hKN@B<9KU8;:KN`gMZKN`9@Fp`9`93HMºKN:Ò<91KN`2`93H@B<9KU8;:º]JKU<91ZKN:(<913MKF p`9KN8;:(S8lM3HT M3FCE3HTU8EY\3HMº[n6hOE:izì3~T?º0213Åj?8;:3B>­[\8lMlwMZKN`9`9KUYOQ<9KU8;:XSL3H@a1OE:ZKN`9SÝOE:ZM_<913Åj?] OETNT >AOE:ZMV>­]JKN:M8«]Jw478E6aSpTNO4e8E6/<913º476aKN@B<9KU8;:+478E6a@B3@FOETN@FpZTNOQ<9KU8;:OQ693ºYZ693H`R3H:n<R3HM KN:`R3H@B<9KN8;:³ blb x :`R3H@B<9KN8;:Å b<913mSpTU<9K >AMKSL3H:`9KU8;:ZOETnèzOE:iE3FClK:%OQYY6a8;OE@a1478E6¢`9`9KU8;:K`MKN`9@FpZ`9`R3HM b.`9pSSOQ6a_KN`i;KUCE3H:KN:È`R3H@B<9KU8;: b! b0J13(S%OEKN:+`9@B8EY\3(8E4m<91KN`5@a1ZOQY<R3F6KN`<R8SOQWE3ÒOE:+OQ<R<R3HSLY<58E4Jp:ZM3F6a`R<9OE:MZKN:iº]J1OQ<I]P3Ò@FOE:+TU3HOQ6a:4e6a8;SÝ<913(693H`9pZTU<9`t8E4<913`9`9KU8;:ºTNKN4e3F<9KNS3rS3HOE`9p693HSL3H:n<9`Fb*tus £¢5 Ú2Ùvßf¤m5ßfÓI¡\¤RwX¡\à5 5ßÙ9ÚgD))a¤m

ÛzØ5Ú2ÜÝ9ßf¼?57857 ½¡¾G:¿¨8B?À¸:Á?HBDVBJÂÄÃA¸Å6Ÿ:=@~ÆcF+8BGKÅ¥:=Ç6<?§>H+ABx :<913(TNKU<R3F6aOQ<9p6a3L<913`<lpOE:n<9KU<9KU3H`tM3H`a@B6aKU[ZKN:iÒMl:OES%KN@FOETfY698EY\3F69<9KN3H`8E4 <913/:lpV>@FTU3HOQ6J693HOE@B<9KU8;:`9pZ@a1ºOE`2:lp@FTU3HOQ62476aKN@B<9KN8;: lMZKN`9`9KUYOQ<9KU8;: VMKF p`9KU8;:(@B8n3|/@FKU3H:=<9`JOE:MCVKN`9@B8;`9KN<A/OQ6a38E4e<R3H:S%KFl3HM(]J1ZKN@a1ÒSKN`aTU3HOEM(<913693HOEM3F62OE:Mº@FOEpZ`R3tKN:@B8;SLYZ693H13H:V>`9KN[ZKNTNKU<9KN3H`Fb x :<91KN`f`9p[`R3H@B<9KU8;:LOE:%OQ<R<R3HSY<<R8M3H`a@B6aKU[\3 <913H`R3¼<lpOE:n<9KU<9KU3H`KN`fS%OEM3Eb0213P`R<9OQ69<9K:imY\8;KN:n< ]mKNTNT;[\3P<R8r@B8;:Z`9KNM3F6c<913 P6a8«]J:KOE:ISL8E<9KN8;:I8E4OmYOQ69<9KN@FTU3P]JKU<91SOE`a`¦P SL8«CVKN:i%]JKU<91O%CE3HTU8l@FKN<A®È¦ KN:O%S3HMKNpSºbP0213t3<lpOQ<9KU8;:8E4dS8E<9KU8;:8E4<91K` YZOQ69<9KN@FTU3ÉËÊaÌ)ÍÎÉËʬÏt1nVM698VMl:ZOESKN@RÏZp@B<9pOQ<9KU8;:Z`2@FOE:º[\3]26aKU<R<R3H:ºOE`P Í È¦ÍzÏ ¤18VPÐȦ QPÑÈÒ x Ï | n x' bNÿ«|

Í È«ÍÏ QÓȦ x' b;|021ZKN` 3<lpOQ<9KU8;:KN` WV:8D]J:OE`c<913^è OE:iE3FCVKN:I3<npOQ<9KN8;:IOE:MI<913P4e8E6a@B3sPÑÈÒ x Ï | @FOEp`93HM[lt1=VM698VMV:OESKN@/ÏZp@B<9pOQ<9KU8;:Z` KN`zWl:8«]J:OE`c<913PèzOE:iE3FClK:478E6a@B3Ebf021KN` 3<npZOQ<9KU8;:@B8;SLYTU3F<R3HTU5M3H`9@B6aKU[\3H`c<913J^698D]J:KNOE:%SL8E<9KU8;: bdçJ3F6a3Í8ÒK`d<913g4e6hKN@B<9KU8;:L@B8l3|%@FKU3H:n<F]J1ZKN@a1(KN`^Y698EY\8E69<9KU8;:ZOETZ<R85<913rCVKN`9@B8;`9KU<Ô/8E4zO5SL3HMKNpZSºbco8E6JO5`RYZ13F6aK@FOET^698D]g>:KOE:ÒYZOQ69<9KN@FTU3EG

8yQªÔ HìH´P § x' b;|E

Page 45: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

"3c IR &~3N¼ ?8]J13F693n´ KN`<913%6aOEMKp`8E4g<913(`RYZ13F693Ebº0213ClK`9@B8;`9KU<8E42OE:ÈKNM3HOETi;OE`@FOE:[\3M3F6aKUCE3HMOE` ÔaQ

ë ì ë Õ P ¢ § x' b! n|]J13F693 K`r<913%SOE`9`t8E4P<913LYOQ69<9KN@FTU3H`tS%OQWlKN:iÒpY<913CVKN`9@B8;p`SL3HMZKNpSºV K`<913<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p693OE:M Õ KN`m<9135P8;TN<RsHSOE::@B8;:`R<9OE:n<Fb&P ¢ KN`m<9135@B8;TNTNKN`aKU8;:@B698;`9``R3H@B<9KU8;:8E4g<913/S3HMKNpS YOQ69<9KN@FTU3H`]JKU<91_3HOE@h1È8E<913F6Hb0213%è OE:iE3FCVKN:Å4e8E6a@B3ÒKN`IO6aOE:M8;S 4e8E6a@B3IOE:MÒ<913O«CE3F6aOQiE3ICQOETNp3

Â Ò x Ï |#dQ >à x' b;|0213KN:n<R3H:`9KN<A8E4^<913%èzOE:iE3FCVKN:X4e8E6h@B3 ö K`M3F<R3F6aSKN:3HMv47698;S <913%ÏZp@B<9pOQ<9KU8;:>MKN`9`aKUYZOQ<9KU8;:(<913F8E693HSG Ò ¡ Q ö Q&8 Õ P x' bH;|o8E6J<913tM3F<9OEKNTU3HMM3H`9@B6aKUY<9KN8;:/8E4c<9KNSL3t@B8E6a693HTNOQ<9KU8;:`J`R3F3t@a1OQYZ<R3F6IÿEÿ8E4Íy! ­b0213M3F6aKUCQOQ<9KU8;:/OQ[)8DCE3M3HSL8;:`R<R6aOQ<R3H`^<91OQ<P<9134e6aK@B<9KU8;:`9p\3F693HM%[nO^698«]J:ZKNOE:YZOQ69><9KN@FTU3JM3FY)3H:ZM`:8E<P8;:TU58;:<913mClK`9@B8;`9KU<8E4 <913mSL3HMKpSDÔOE:M%KN<9`<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p6a3E[Zp<cOETN`R88;:<913PYZ698EY\3F69<9KU3H`8E4<913 P6a8«]J:KOE:YZOQ6a<9KN@FTU3PKN<9`R3HTU4 xySOE`9`PâOE:ZMI<913`RYZ13F6hKN@FOET`91OQY\32]mKU<91L6aOEMKp`´|hb021lp`f476aKN@B<9KU8;:OE:ZMCVKN`9@B8;`9KU<OQ693J<]P8MKF\3F693H:n<@B8;:@B3FY<9`Fb

0213(MKN`R<R6hKU[Zp<9KU8;:4yp:@B<9KU8;:Å8E4g<913%CE3HTN8l@FKU<9KN3H`IOE:M@B8n8E6hMKN:OQ<R3H`I8E4gYZOQ69<9KN@FTN3H`YZOQ69<9KN@FKNYZOQ<9KN:iKN:,^698«]m:KNOE: SL8E<9KN8;: ´fxSÈ« § Ȧ § Ï |htKN`ºM3H`9@B6aKU[\3HMê[nê<913_o8EWlWE3F6R>æ TNOE:Z@9W 3<lpOQ<9KU8;:J]J1K@a1ê@FOE:,[)3XM3F6aKNCE3HM47698;Sð<913è OE:iE3FClKN:ê3<lpOQ<9KU8;:xy`R3F3y! :7|hG Ö ´Ö Ï ¤DȦ

Ö ´Ö È« Q öÖ¡´Ö Ȧ ¡ ¤

ÖÖ È¦ xa8Ȧ ´|0à x' b EE|0213L6aKNi;1=<?>A1OE:ZM_`9KNM358E4 3<lpOQ<9KU8;:Ç b EºM3H`9@B6aKU[\3H`r<913/MKF p`9KU8;:Y698V@B3H`9`8E4 YZOQ69><9KN@FTU3H`Fb ö KN`J@FOETTU3HM<913MK\p`aKU8;:@B8;:`R<9OE:n<rKN:CE3HTN8l@FKU<`RYZOE@B35OE:MvKN`mM3FZ:3HMK:4e8E6hSIpTO bHlbÅè 3F<Lp`I@B8;:Z`9KNM3F65<913Ò^698«]J:ZKNOE:+SL8E<9KU8;:+KN:8;:3ºMKNSL3H:`aKU8;:_8E4OYZOQ69<9KN@FTN3JKN:OY)8E<R3H:n<9KNOETZ]P3HTNTcxy`R3F3i;p693 bNÿ«|hb x 4êÅKN`¢<913J47693<lp3H:@BL@B8E69693H`9Y)8;:ZMV>KN:iX<R8_1OQ6aS8;:KN@/]P3HTNT­¢8;:3º@FOE:]26hKU<R3Ò<913è OE:iE3FCVKN:+OE:M+<913o8EWnWE3F6R> æ TNOE:@aW3<npZOQ<9KU8;:`2OE` Í ¦ÍzÏ ¤18 ¦ ¤ôê ¡ ð¤Q Ò x Ï | x' b;;|OE:M Ö ´Ö Ï ¤ ¦

Ö ´Ö ð òFê ¡ ð Ö ´Ö ¦ Q öÖ¡ ´Ö¦ ¡¤ÖÖ¦xa8 ¦ ´| § x' b;|

693H`RY\3H@B<9KUCE3HTUEb

Page 46: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

~ À_ÀØ×? YÃ6B_ &&0M° ÅkBÃa?: 0_¯Uæça "3m

ë ì_ |a~3ÀaÚÙ6ø|°÷öFô÷èó&õßöSB÷"õßñ)ò- )ôøßõßöFï ûüòÆö ÷%ô iBõßò÷&õðöüôBûòû û¼?5785]x Û;@8Cª:@LÂ?:=LKÚ@HI?>H+ABØA¸Ü>!¾G:lÝe@A=ÞßBJH+8BDCªA8>H+AB¨5x :Å<913/]^8E69W8;:+^698«]J:ZKNOE:S8E<9KU8;:Ñy!:H:^ë6hOESL3F6a`5@B8;:`9KNM3F693HM_<913(Y698E[OQ[ZKNTNKU<478E6IOvP6a8«]J:KOE:YZOQ69<9KN@FTN3<R83H`9@FOQY\3/8«CE3F6LOY\8E<R3H:n<9KNOET[ZOQ6a6aKU3F6/xy`R3F3/i;p693b b;|hb¬`9KN:i5<913t1ZOQ6aSL8;:KN@rOQYYZ698KNSOQ<9KU8;:(478E62<913]^3HTNT OE:MÒ<913[OQ696aKU3F6g138E[<9OEK:3HMO`R8;TNp<9KU8;: 8E4t<913o8EWnWE3F69> æ TNOE:@aW 3<lpOQ<9KU8;: b3v]mKNTNT2MK`9@Fp`9`L8;:ZTU<913v@FOE`938E4^TNOQ69iE3LCVKN`9@B8;`9KU<vOE`tKN<rK`m6a3HTU3FC~OE:n<478E6<913:npZ@FTU3HOQ6Z`9`9KN8;:`9<9pMKU3H`F\]J13F6935<913`RV`R<R3HS K`g3|lY\3H@B<R3HMº<R8/[\38DCE3F6aMOESLY\3HM bPè OQ69iE3tCVKN`9@B8;`aKU<AÒSL3HOE:`J<91OQ<

ã P8 ¦ ãà ã P Í ¦ÍzÏ ã$à x' bNÿY>=|0213tè OE:iE3FCVKN:Ò3<lpOQ<9KU8;:K:Ò<91KN`g@FOE`R3@FOE:[\3693F]26aKU<R<R3H:ºOE`

8VP ¦ QP Ò x Ï |0Ã x' bNÿEÿ«|x :<913o8EWlWE3F6R> æ TNOE:@9W 3<npOQ<9KN8;:<913MK`R<R6aKU[Zp<9KU8;:_4yp:@B<9KU8;:á´fx@ð § ¦ § Ï |693HMZp@B3H`<R8´fx@ð § Ï |^OE:M<913t:3F]3<lpOQ<9KU8;: ]J1ZKN@a1ºKN`g@FOETTU3HMÒ<913IkVSL8;Tp@a18D]J`RWVK\MKF p`9KU8;:3<lpOQ<9KU8;: @FOE:[\3]26aKU<R<R3H:ºOE`FG Ö ´Ö Ï Q ö `

Ö¡ ´Ö ð ¡ § x' bNÿ;|

13F6a3 ö ` Qãâ bärå K`<913MKF p`9KU8;:L@B8;:`9<9OE:=< KN:@B8l8E6aMKN:ZOQ<R3m`RYZOE@B3Eb x :+y!:H?)ë6aOES3F6a``918«]^3HM<9134<npOE`aK >A`R<9OQ<9KU8;:OQ6at`R8;TNp<9KU8;:t8E4<913^kVSL8;Tp@a18D]J`RWVK;MKF p`9KN8;:r3<npOQ<9KN8;: b021ZKN`J`R8;Tp<9KU8;:6a3FY693H`R3H:n<9`<913I6hOQ<R3I]JKN<91]J1ZKN@a1vP6a8«]J:KOE:YZOQ6a<9KN@FTU3H`SL8«CE358«CE3F6

Page 47: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

@ f IR &~3N¼ ?8<913tY\8E<R3H:n<9KNOET [ZOQ696hKU3F6Hb«UQ ê

ìê ¢ x%æ ç ¡ ¤x ìê ¢ | ¡ òç |Ò µaè Þ b § x' bNÿ;|]J13F693UêOE:MÞê ¢ OQ693<913t47693<np3H:@FKU3H` 8E4d<913KN:ZKU<9KNOET\OE:Mº<913tK:=CE3F6a`931OQ6aSL8;:ZKN@¯>8;`9@FKNTNTOQ<R8E6IY\8E<R3H:n<9KNOETN`Ff693H`9Y)3H@B<9KNCE3HTUEbK`<913Ò13HKUi;1n<8E42<913(Y)8E<R3H:n<9KNOET^[ZOQ696hKU3F6OE:MéKN`c<913g<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p6a3Eb ç KN`c<9132MZKN`9`9KUYOQ<9KU8;:@B8l3|%@FKU3H:n<F;]J1K@a15KN`d@B8;::3H@B<R3HM]JKU<91Ò<9134e6aK@B<9KU8;:º@B8n3|/@FKU3H:=<8OE`FG

8ÞQ çVê ¢ Ã x' bNÿ| n|

ë ì_3Y~ ÀFÁU < ñ)øßòòõðøðô òï£õ6Bøðö òîC"ôÙ6ø|°÷)öüôB÷ )ôøßõßöFï ûüòB]°ñ)òuøðò2&÷ò4òîßïô _òîcYý&òuøõßñò iBõßò÷&õðöüôBû;9)ôBøßøðö òø00213º@B8;:@B3FYZ<L8E4m^698«]m:KNOE:+YZOQ69<9K@FTU3H`5MKF p`9KN:i8«CE3F6%<913(Y\8E<R3H:n<9KNOET [ZOQ696hKU3F6

@FOE:º[\3OQYZYZTNKU3HM/<R8L<913:npZ@FTU3HOQ6gZ`9`9KN8;:/YZ698l@B3H`a`rxy`93F3ti;p693T b;|hbP0J13P6a8«]J:KOE:YZOQ69<9KN@FTN3^KN:<91K`z@FOE`R32K`z<913 `aTU8«]JTN@a1OE:i;KN:i`91OQY\3 M3FiE693F3 8E4Z47693F3HM8;SM3H`a@B6aKU[\3HM[nðzf]J1KN@h1Å@B8;pYTU3H`t<R8<913+jR18E<9wX:np@FTN3HOQ6ISOQ<R<R3F6L<91OQ<5@FOE:[)3/ClKN3F]P3HMÈOE`5O13HOQ<5[ZOQ<91 bX021lp`I:lp@FTU3HOQ6Z`9`aKU8;:@FOE:È[\3/`93F3H:ÈOE`LOMKF p`9KN8;:_KN:çð bê13H:ôð693HOE@a13H`5[)3FE8;:ZM_<913Ò`9OEMMTN3Y\8;KN:=<Dð ¢ xy`R3F3/Zi;p693b b;|<913(Z`9`aKU8;:[ZOQ696hKU3F6I1OE`[\3F3H:L@B698;`9`R3HM bd0213g@B8;pYTNKN:i[\3F<A]^3F3H:ð%OE:M513HOQ<f[ZOQ<91LK`fSOEM3 ClKOm<913 :lp@FTU3HOQ64e6hKN@B<9KU8;:L@B8l3|%@FKU3H:n<mxy`R3F32<913ÍÏp@B<9pOQ<9KU8;:V>AMZKN`9`9KUYOQ<9KU8;:<913F8E693HSº=]m13F693-Q t © ­qKN`:lp@FTU3HOQ6t<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p693OE:MmKN`<913:lp@FTU3HOQ6TN3FCE3HTfM3H:`9KU<vYOQ6aOESL3F<R3F6¯|hb0213`9TU8D]M3FiE6a3F3/8E4g47693F3HM8;S @FOE:OET`R8[\3%KNM3H:=<9KUZ3HM]JKU<91Å<913/:lp@FTU3HOQ65SL3HOE:V>­3HTM

Page 48: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

~ À_ÀØ×? YÃ6B_ &&0M° ÅkBÃa?: 0_¯Uæça @ õ

]J13F693HOE`r<91356aOQYZKNMv693H`9KMpOETcKN:=<R3F6hOE@B<9KU8;:`r@FOE:[\3I3<lpOQ<R3HMX]JKN<91v<913513HOQ<[ZOQ<918E4)<9132:lp@FTU3HOQ6¢TNK<npKM b0213gYZOQ6a<9KU<9KU8;:[\3F<A]^3F3H:%SL3HOE:V>­Z3HTNMLOE:M5693H`9KMpOETVKN:n<R3F6aOE@¯><9KU8;:Z`2KN`g1KUi;1ZTU/:8;:>­<R6aKUCVKNOET³bf0213@B8;:Z:3H@B<9KU8;:º[\3F<A]^3F3H:vClKN`a@B8;`9KU<AÒOE:Mº476aKN@B<9KN8;:ºKN`<913F6a3F4e8E693p:@B3F69<9OEK: b2021KN`mKN`JS8;`R<@FTN3HOQ6m]J13H:@B8;:`9KM3F6aKN:iL8;:3B>­[)8VMMK`9`9KUYZO~><9KU8;:_xy`93F3I`R3H@B<9KU8;:ç b;|hZ]J13F6a3<913tTNK=<lpKNMV>AM698EY/SL8VM3HTM3H`9@B6aKU[\3H`^<913tSL3HOE:V>­Z3HTNMKN:]J1KN@h1<913:lp@FTU3F8;:`/SL8«CE347693F3HTU xyKN:M3FY\3H:M3H:=<5YZOQ69<9K@FTU3SL8VM3HTe|hbkVp@a1OTNK<npKM%1OE`2K:Z:KU<R3SL3HOE:V>­47693F3tYZOQ<91OE:MÒ<91npZ` sF3F698CVKN`9@B8;`9KU<Ebo6aKN@B<9KN8;:KN`gKN:n<R698Q>MpZ@B3HMÒClKNO5<913t]JKN:M8«]g>­] OETNT\MKN`9`aKUYZOQ<9KU8;:ÒSL3H@h1OE:KN`9S xy`93F3I`R3H@B<9KU8;:ç b;|hb

x <%KN`%KNSLY\8E69<9OE:n<<R8Å:8E<R3v<91OQ<%<913<R6aOE:`9KU<9KN8;:V>A`R<9OQ<R3vS3F<918lMY698«CVKNM3H`<913Y6a8E[ZOQ[ZKNTNKN<A<R83H`a@FOQY)3<913[ZOQ696aKN3F6g[n« ¢ Q×êÒ µaè Þ b à x' bNÿ;|x :(<913r3H:M(8E4c1K`POQ69<9K@FTU3Åy!:Hë6aOESL3F6a` `9piEiE3H`R<R3HMº<R8OQYYZTNL<913t`R8;TNp<9KN8;:%8E4z<913kVS8;TNp@a18«]J`RWVKQ3<lpOQ<9KU8;:t478E6 <913P@FOE`R3P8E4V:lp@FTU3HOQ6zZ`9`9KN8;: b 0213¢Z`9`9KU8;:r]mKNM<91 ±¸êKN`fM3F<R3F6aSKN:3HM]JKU<91KN:<9132`9<9OQ<9KN`R<9KN@FOETZ<R6aOE:`9KU<9KN8;:V>A`R<9OQ<R32^8;16R>­,13F3HTU3F6^SL8lM3HTªy ÿ&OE` ±¸êQ Í

ì Î ­ § x' bNÿH;|]J13F693 Í Q ¨ë s © x KN`%<913XTU3FCE3HTm`9YZOE@FKN:i8E4t<913X@B8;SLY\8;p:M :lp@FTU3HpZ`vxËUKN`%<913TU3FCE3HTdM3H:Z`9KU<A|hb Î ­KN`<913L:npSI[\3F6m8E4 TU3FCE3HTN`rOQ<<9135Z`a`9KU8;:v[ZOQ696aKU3F6478E6tO/i;KNCE3H:3|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:º3H:3F69iE

Î ­ QpØ © ^ µaè¢

U ­ x¢° ­ ò1pò;dh| Í d x' bNÿBEE|ë6hOESL3F6a`X@FOESL3<R8,<913@B8;:@FTNp`aKU8;:K:ry!:H?5<91ZOQ<<913È<R6hOE:`9KU<9KU8;:>A`R<9OQ<R3P8;16R>,13F3HTU3F6SL3F<918VM jRKN`gRp`9<9KU3HM_KU4^<913/4e6aK@B<9KU8;:_KN`t:8E<CE3F69_`9S%OETNT³z:8E6I`R8TOQ69iE3<91OQ<J<913M698EYClKU[Z6aOQ<9KU8;:`gOQ6938«CE3F69Y\3F6aKU8VMKN@FOETTU%MOESLY\3HMÒ<R8(O1KUi;1ºM3FiE6a3F3HwVb x :<913/TNKU<R3F6aOQ<9p6a3L8;:3%@B8;SSL8;:ZTUKUi;:8E693H`<913%3|\3H@B<8E4 <913/@Fp69C~OQ<9p693L8E4g<913Y\8Q><R3H:n<9KNOET\]^3HTNT³b0213Z`9`aKU8;:(]JKNM<91(693H`9pZTU<9KN:iI4e698;S <913të6aOESL3F6a`gOQYZY698;OE@a1ºK` <913H:p`93HMºKN:Ò<913t478E6aS Q ±¸êÇy Ç 8 ¡ ¤,ÿ[òj8 à x' bNÿ;;|0213m6aOQ<9KN8 ¹ ±¸ê K`^`a18«]J:ºK:%i;p693K b5OE`gOI4yp:@B<9KN8;:/8E4z<913:npZ@FTU3HOQ6g4e6hKN@B<9KU8;:@B8l3|%@FKU3H:n<8cb x 4D8kìÕÿ5xy@FOE`R3r8E4<913m`aSOETNTCVKN`9@B8;`aKU<A|ët6aOESL3F6a`¢4e8E6aSpTNOI1OE`P<913478E6aS y!:H Q ±¸êÇy ì8 à x' bNÿ;|¼?5785]4 ½¡¾G:ÂJHhí¨<JLjHABDCªA6ÂG:=Fx :<913MZKF\pZ`9KU8;:SL8VM3HT2M3FCE3HTN8EY)3HM[n 6aOE:izì3~Yz? y!:m:lp@FTU3HOQ6/Z`9`9KN8;:KN`CVKU3F]^3HMOE`POMKF p`9KU8;:5Y6a8l@B3H`9`8E4)<913JZ`9`aKU8;:5C~OQ6hKNOQ[ZTU3-ð(8«CE3F6^<9132Z`a`9KU8;:L[ZOQ6a6aKU3F6Hb

Page 49: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

@ IR &~3N¼ ?8

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

10-2

10-1

1 10γ

Γ/Γ B

W

ë ì_3Y~ ÀSR3/ôõßöS"?õßñ)ò_îÆøàôóKòuøàî L îðîªöSB÷-°öFþ?õðñ[YýBòøkõßñòïÙ¶Bñø Ëð ñ)òuòuûüòuø L îßîßöSB÷-°öFþ?õßñôBî°ô"=ÿ÷)ï õßöSB÷"õßñ)òÍ÷ÿï ûüòôøc"=øðöFï£õßöSB÷zï?òOñMïuö ò÷õ0x :v<9138;:3B>AMKNS3H:`9KU8;:OETzo8EWlWE3F6R> æ TNOE:Z@9W3<npOQ<9KN8;:+ b/<9135MKF p`9KN8;:@B8n3|/@FKU3H:=<KN`gi;KUCE3H:[n ö Q8 ò § x' b?>=|]J13F693

òK`r<913693HMpZ@B3HMSOE`9`8E4 <913LZ`a`9KU8;:KN:i(`RV`R<R3HS OE:ZM KN`r<913:lp@FTU3HOQ6

<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p693Ebê ¡ ðv]^OE`m`9p[Z`9<9KU<9p<R3HMÒ[l/<91347p:Z@B<9KU8;:lx@ð\|+x@ð |Q ÿò ÖÖ ðôó x@ð | x' bVÿ«|

0213ÒY\8E<R3H:=<9KOET ó x@ð\|I8E4<913ºZ`a`9KU8;:KN:iv`RV`R<R3HS ] OE`@a18;`93H:OE`OX478;p69<91V>­8E6aM3F6Y\8;TUl:8;SKNOET ó x@ð |Q òVõ ð ¡ x@ð¤ò3­H|Bx@ðŤ®F| § x' b:;|

Page 50: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

~ ÀFÁUÀÂJM h]Uçg8:_+æ|gæ @ "

]J13F693õ-/OE:M®­/OQ6a3(Y\8;`9KN<9KUCE3/YOQ6aOESL3F<R3F6a`L478E6L<913º:lpSL3F6aKN@FOETPY698V@B3HMp6a3E<R8

SKSKN@O/Y)8E<R3H:n<9KNOET ]P3HTNTzOE:M[OQ696aKU3F6m]JKU<916a3HOETNKN`R<9KN@rCQOETNp3H`m478E6O%Z`9`9KU8;:ZKN:i`RV`?><R3HSºb0J13m:3F],OE`RY\3H@B<gKN:<91ZKN`PS8lM3HTKN`P<913m[pKNTNMV>ApYL<9KNSL3m:3F3HM3HM%<R85693HOE@h1(<913`9OEMZMTU3Y)8;K:=<F:8E<2OE@F@B8;p:n<R3HM478E62KN:ºë6hOESL3F6a`g`R<9OQ<9KU8;:ZOQ69/`R8;Tp<9KU8;: bf021K`^@FOET@FpV>TNOQ<9KN8;:OE`9`9pS3H`g<91OQ<m^698D]J:KNOE:YZOQ69<9KN@FTU3H`JOQ693`R<9OQ69<R3HMv8?_KN:º<913[)8E<R<R8;S 8E4d<913]^3HTNTdx73<npKTNKU[6aKpS`R<9OQ<R3D|hbP0213J693H`9pZTU<¢8E4<913:lpSL3F6aK@FOET`R8;Tp<9KU8;:8E4 <913o8EWnWE3F69>æ TNOE:@9W53<lpOQ<9KU8;:/KN``918D]J:KN:i;p693 b! OE`¢OIMOE`913HM@Fp69CE3JOE:M/@B8;SLYZOQ693HM%]JKU<91OI`R<R6aOEKUi;1n<PMOE`a13HM%TNK:3g693FY693H`93H:=<9KN:it<913J`9`9KU8;:L6hOQ<R3m@FOETN@FpTOQ<R3HM/p`aKN:itë6aOES3F6a`Z`a`9KU8;:]JKNM<91x7478E6aSIpZTNOj bNÿ;;|hb+0J13º@FOETN@FpTNOQ<9KU8;:Z`I]^3F693ºY\3F69478E6aSL3HMÈ478E6 Q ÿu3YOE:Mv4e8;p6MKF\3F693H:n<2C~OETp3H`28E4f<913MKN`9`aKUYZOQ<9KU8;:º@B8l3|%@FKU3H:n< ç b20213t693HTOQ<9KU8;:[\3F<A]^3F3H:È<913(<9KNSL3%478E6ð+<R8v693HOE@h1+<913Ò`9OEMMTU3%Y)8;K:=<OE:MÅ<913(:lp@FTU3HOQ64e6hKN@B<9KU8;:@B8l3|%@FKU3H:n<JKN:Ò<913I@FOE`R3t8E4d8«CE3F6aMZOESLY\3HMSL8E<9KU8;:y ÿY>: ]^OE`24e8;p:ZMº<R8[\3

Ö ¨ Q çVê ¡¢ Û'Ú¢x ÿY> |Q 8ê ¢ Û'Ú¢xÿY> |0Ã x' b:;|

0J13SL3HOE:Å`aOEMMTU3B>­<R8Q>A`9@FK`9`9KU8;:X<9KNS3L]^OE`IM3F6aKUCE3HM_K:X<913]^8E69Wv8E4gçm8E47S%OE::OE:MºKFÇy!Vÿ|zp`aKN:i5ë6aOESL3F6a`Ð`R8;TNp<9KU8;:Ò8E4d<913to8EWnWE3F6R> æ TNOE:@aWº3<npOQ<9KN8;:º4e8E6J<913KN:nCE3F69<R3HMº8;`a@FKNTNTNOQ<R8E6JOE`öÖ ¡ Q ê ¢ x Ç ÿ¤§8 ¡ ¤18|6´x æ ó x@ð ¢ |cò ó x@ð ` | | § x' b n|]J13F693[´KN`fO4yp:@B<9KU8;:LM3FY)3H:ZMKN:i8;:L<9132Y\8E<R3H:n<9KNOET3H:3F6aiEMK)3F693H:Z@B3H`f[\3F<A]^3F3H:<913 `9OEMMZTU3ð ¢ OE:M<913 `9@FKN`9`9KN8;:ð ` Y\8;KN:n<9` OE:M<913 :lp@FTU3HOQ6c<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p693rxy`R3F3Wy!Vÿ|OE:M693F473F693H:@B3H`<913F693HK:|hbv021lp`Fd<913ÒOHCE3F6hOQiE3Z`9`9KN8;:_<9KNSL3(@FOE:È[)3Ò@B8;:`9KM3F693HMOE`J<913I`9pZS8E4f<913t[ZpZKNTNMV>ApYÒ<9KNS3IÖ ¨ OE:M<913SL3HOE:`aOEMMTU3B>­<R8Q>A`9@FK`9`9KU8;:º<9KSL3 öÖ ¡@B8;SLY\8;:3H:n<9` öÖaQÖ ¨ ¤ öÖ ¡ à x' b:;|x :(<91KN`gSL8VM3HT)<913693HTNOQ<9KN8;:/[\3F<]P3F3H:º<913t:np@FTN3HOQ6g4e6aK@B<9KU8;:Ò@B8n3|%@FKN3H:=<Æ8vOE:ZMÒ<913Z`a`9KU8;:Ò<9KNSL3ÖºK` 3|lY6a3H`9`R3HMSL8;`9<23|lYTNKN@FKU<9TUEb*tའ¾ 56×k(¤tÛzØ Û9))Ó5Ú^¡\a¤m ÜÝß à5Ú2L9\Ü0213¢@B8;:@B3FY<c8E4<913Ij?8;:3B>­[)8VMVwJMK`9`9KUYZOQ<9KN8;:SL3H@a1OE:ZKN`9S 478E6c<913P:lp@FTU3HOQ6c`Rl`9<R3HS] OE`rKN:=<R6a8lMpZ@B3HMvKN:v<913]P8E6aW8E4¢ TU8V@9WVKÍ~?by ÿEÿY­b0213I@FTNOE`9`aKN@FOETmj?<]P8Q>­[\8VMVwMK`9`9KUYZOQ<9KN8;:SL3H@h1OE:KN`9S KN`r@h1OQ6aOE@B<R3F6aKUsF3HM_[nO(`a18E69<SL3HOE:X47693F35YZOQ<91X[\3F<A]^3F3H:<913YZOQ69<9K@FTU3H`m@B8;:Z`R<9KU<9p<9KN:i<9135TNK=<lpKNM b2çm8«]^3FCE3F6H KN:Z`9KNM3t:lp@FTU3HKz]JKU<91vSL8lM3F6aOQ<R33|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:v3H:3F69iEº<913:npZ@FTU3F8;:KN@tS3HOE:47693F3tYZOQ<91KN`mTU8;:i%OE:MvOE:8E<913F6rSL3H@a1ZO~>:K`9S KN`z693<lpKU693HM<R8M3H`9@B6aKU[\3¢:lp@FTU3HOQ6fMKN`a`9KUYZOQ<9KU8;:b0213¢3H:3F69iEKN`z3|V@h1OE:iE3HM5[\3B><]P3F3H:(<913:np@FTN3F8;:`¢OE:M%<913mS8«CVKN:it[\8;p:MZOQ6aKU3H`f8E4 <913:npZ@FTU3HOQ6P`RV`R<R3HSºl]J1K@a1

Page 51: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

@3@ IR &~3N¼ ?8

ë ì_3Y~ À$~ < ñò L îßîßö$&÷zøðôõßò¼ô&î/ô&"=ÿ÷)ï õßöSB÷G"DõßöüóTò>"BøPþ:öp(òuøðòu÷õG÷+ô÷)þøôZE(%ò+* %r8¡¢ < ñòRôYõªõðòu÷õßöSB÷zñ)ô&î^õU9_ò[ )ôBöüþ"&ø°õßñ)ò¼þôBîßñòþïuÿøðýBòî°ôB÷)þ%îªõßøàôöüùBñõ/þôBîßñòþûüö ÷)òî=îßòuòÆõðò õK

OQ693vS%OEM3vpY[n<913v@B8;TNTU3H@B<9KNCE3v[\3H1O«ClKU8E6/8E4<913v:lp@FTU3F8;:Z`FgK³b·3Eb<913v:lp@FTU3HOQ6SL3HOE:V>­3HTM b¢0213tS8;`R<JKNSLY\8E69<9OE:n<2@B8;:@B3FY<mKN`g<913j?] OETNT >AOE:ZMV>­]JKN:M8«]Jw478E6aSIpZTNOy ÿEÿ|­bè3F<pZ`@B8;:`9KNM3F6Or8;:3B>AMKNSL3H:Z`9KU8;:OETli;OE`]mKU<915<9132YZOQ6a<9KN@FTU3H`d[\8;p:@FKN:im[ZOE@aWOE:M478E69<91[\3F<A]^3F3H:<913L]^OETTN`]JKU<91XCE3HTN8l@FKU<9KN3H`Gò ¦ OE:M ¦ z693H`RY\3H@B<9KUCE3HTUEb%ê13H:<913] OETNTN` `R<9OQ69<2SL8DClK:iL]JKU<91(CE3HTU8V@FKU<AcùxËù¥ì ¦ |^<913r693YÏ3H@B<R3HMºYOQ69<9KN@FTU3H`gSL8DC=>KN:i%K:KU<9KNOETNTNKN:Åx78E6rOQi;OEKN:`R<h|g<913MKU6a3H@B<9KU8;:º8E4f] OETNT ]JKNTT)1ZOHCE3CE3HTU8l@FKN<AFò ¦ ¤jùx78E6 ¦ ò³jùr|hb/23HOE@a1ZKN:iº<913L8E<913F6]^OETNTd<913Fv693YÏZ3H@B<OQi;OEKN:X<R81O«CE3CE3HTU8V@FKU<A ¦x78E6Gò ¦ |hb x <@FOE:[)35`918D]J:<91OQ<MKN`9`aKUYZOQ<9KU8;:K`m8;:ZTUºY698EY\8E69<9KU8;:ZOET <R8eùR¥Qb0213KNSLY\8E69<9OE:n<`R<R3FYÅKN:8;:3B>­[\8VMvMK`9`9KUYZOQ<9KN8;:KN`r<913@h1OQ8E<9KN`9KN<AXOE`9`9pSLYZ<9KU8;:]J1KN@h1`R<9OQ<R3H`<91OQ<rO693YÏ3H@B<R3HMYZOQ6a<9KN@FTU3OE@Y<lpKU693H`mKN:`98;SL3] OH<913CE3HTU8V@FKU<Aº8E4KN<9`m`9p6R>698;p:MZKN:iYOQ69<9KN@FTU3`R8L<91OQ<g<R8%6a`R<^8E6aM3F6JKN<^]mKNTNT693Fi;OEKN:ºKU<9`gKN:ZKU<9KNOETCE3HTU8l@FKN<AEbmxy`R3F3i;p693è b;|hb x :v<91KN`J@FOE`935MZKN`9`9KUYOQ<9KU8;:KN`JY698EY\8E69<9KU8;:OET<R8 ¦ ù ¡ b x :8;p6m3|OESLYZTN3MKN`9`aKUYZOQ<9KU8;:(]^8;pTNMº8V@F@Fp6mpZ:=<9KNT OETT YZOQ69<9KN@FTN3H`2SL8«CE3[ZOE@aWÒOE:ZM478E69<91º]JKU<91CE3HTU8l@FKU><9KU3H` ¦ ¤kù OE:ZM¨ò ¦ ¤ùb¢u8E6934e8E6hSOETNTU5KU<P@FOE:/[\3J`918D]J:<91ZOQ<P<913m]^OETT478E6aSIpZTNO

Page 52: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

~ ÀFÁUÀÂJM h]Uçg8:_+æ|gæ @

assumption

v v

−v+2w −v+2w−v

v+2w

w w w w

−v+2w

v chaotisity

ë aì Y~3Àk < ñòôÙ6ø6|°÷öüôB÷I )ôBøªõðöüïuû òÍï+Bûüû öFþ:öü÷ù&°öõðñèõðñòÍó&Yý?ö ÷ù ^ôûüûKN`zi;KUCE3H:5[lKN:n<R3FiE6aOQ<9KU8;:8«CE3F6P`9p694yOE@B3P3HTN3HSL3H:=<9` Í PÒSOQWlK:impY5<913 :lp@FTU3HOQ6f`91OQY\3

ò Í °ÍzÏ QáU ¦ôú xËù×ò ö | ¡ Í PÃ x' b:H;|çm3F693UtKN`z<913g:np@FTN3HOQ6dS%OE`9`dM3H:`9KU<OE:M ¦ KN`c<913 OHCE3F6aOQiE3m`RY\3F3HMI8E4Z<913g:np@FTN3F8;:`FbùêKN`d<913J:8E6hSOETVCE3HTU8V@FKU<A8E4<913J`9p694yOE@B3g3HTU3HSL3H:n< Í POE:M ö K`d<913JM6aKN4e<cCE3HTU8V@FKU<AxyKN:Ò8;p623|VOESYZTU3tKN:KN<9KNOETNTU ö Q >OE:MÒ:OETNTU ö Qªù|hb

m3|V<Fn@B8;:`9KM3F6f<A]^8:lp@FTU3HK³E]J1ZKN@a13|@a1OE:iE3JYZOQ69<9KN@FTU3H`d<91698;pi;1LOt`9S%OETNTl]JKN:V>M8D]]mKU<91%OQ693HO¼Pdb0213J3H:3F69iEMZKN`9`9KUYOQ<9KU8;:KN:%<91KN`¢@FOE`93rK`¢M3H`9@B6hKU[\3HML]JKU<91%<913]JK:M8«]478E6aSpTNO5M3F6aKNCE3HMKN:Çy ÿEÿ|­G

ò Í °ÍzÏ Q ÿ U ¦ ¼GPxËû ¡Ô ¤ jû ¡R |0Ã x' bEE|

çm3F693¯û Ô OE:Mû R `R<9OE:M_4e8E6t<913<9OE:iE3H:n<9KNOET¢OE:MX6hOEMKNOETfM6aKN4e<rCE3HTU8V@FKU<9KU3H`Fz693H`RY\3H@¯><9KUCE3HTNE\K­b·3Ebm<913693HTNOQ<9KNCE3ICE3HTU8V@FKU<[\3F<A]^3F3H:X<913I<]P8º:lp@FTU3HK³b x :§y!Vÿ|d<9135@B8;SLY\8Q>:3H:n<r4e8E6r<913LMK`9`9KUYZOQ<9KN8;:OE`9`R8V@FKNOQ<R3HMX]JKN<91v<9135S%OE`9`rOE`RlS%SL3F<R69vK`OEMZM3HMXOE:M<913t@B8;SYZTU3F<R3t]JK:M8«]478E6aSpTNOLKN`

ò Í °ÍÏ Q ÿ U ¦ ¼PxËû ¡Ô ¤³jû ¡R |¤ ÿH

U ¦¼Pªü ¡ § x' b:;;|

]J13F693 ü KN`^<913r6aOQ<R38E4c@a1OE:iE38E4c<913rCE8;TNpS38E4z8;:3:npZ@FTU3Hp`Fbf021lp`FV<913r] OETNT >OE:M>­]JKN:M8D] 478E6aSpTNOM3H`9@B6aKN[ZKN:iv<913Ò3H:3F69iEMZKN`9`9KUYOQ<9KU8;:K:O`RV`R<R3HS 8E4m<A]^8

Page 53: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

@ Z IR &~3N¼ ?8KN:n<R3F6aOE@B<9KN:i:lp@FTU3HK@FOE:[)3]J6aKU<R<R3H:ºOE`

ò Í °ÍzÏ Q Õý y U ¦ ú xËùò ö ¨ | ¡ Í P ¤lU ¦ ú xËù×ò ö ¡ | ¡ Í P¤ ÿ U ¦ ¼GPxËû ¡Ô ¤ jû ¡R |.¤ ÿH

U ¦¼P ü ¡ |ª § x' b:;|

]J13F693 ö ¨ OE:M ö ¡ OQ6a3vM6aKN4e<5CE3HTU8V@FKU<9KU3H`%4e8E6/<9136h`R<OE:M `93H@B8;:M KN:n<R3F6aOE@B<9KN:i:npZ@FTU3Hp`FV693H`RY\3H@B<9KUCE3HTNEb x :Ò<913@FOE`R38E4z`RVSSL3F<R6aK@m`9`9KU8;:K:iI`RV`R<R3HS ö ¨ Qlò ö ¡OE:M ü · >V]J1KNTN3<913tC~OETp38E4d<9136aOEMZKNOET\CE3HTU8V@FKU<Aº@B8;SLY\8;:3H:n<JKN`2Sp@h1TNOQ69iE3F6<91OE:<913tC~OETp3t8E4d<913<9OE:iE3H:=<9KNOETz@B8;SLY\8;:3H:n<Fb 0J13t`R<R693H:iE<918E4f8;:3B>­[\8lM(MK`?>`9KUYZOQ<9KN8;:KN`i;KUCE3H:+[lO4yOE@B<R8E6 Õý b0213ÒSL3HOE:KN:i8E4 Õ¬ý @FOE:+[\3(M3H`a@B6aKU[\3HMOE`4e8;TTU8«]J`HGmKU4<9135@h1OQ8E<9KN`9KN<AXOE`9`9pSLYZ<9KU8;:vK`m8;:ZTUYZOQ69<9KOETNTU@B8E69693H@B<<9138;:3B>­[)8VMMKN`9`aKUYZOQ<9KU8;:]P8;pTM8;:TUv1OHCE3LO(4e6hOE@B<9KU8;:8E4¢KU<9`OE`9`9pSL3HMX`R<R6a3H:iE<91 K³b·3Eb Õ ý · ÿxy`R3F3r3Eb·ibTy ÿ| :­.yE& :OE:M/693F473F693H:@B3H` <913F6a3HKN:|hb x 4 8;:Ò<913m8E<913F621OE:M Õ ý d ÿ<913H:OE:Å8E<913F6I478E6aS 8E42MKN`9`9KNYZOQ<9KU8;:SL3H@h1OE:KN`9S Sp`R<[\3478;p:Mb x :Å693H@B3H:=<3|VY)3F6hK >SL3H:n<9OETPMOQ<9OOE:OETUV`9KN`t<913F693/K`OE:ÈKN:MKN@FOQ<9KN8;:8E4 Õ ý  ÿQb`IOE:Å3|VOESYZTU3/TN3F<p`@B8;S3/[ZOE@aW_<R8Zi;p693`lbHlb0J13/@FOETN@FpZTNOQ<9KU8;:`Y\3F69478E6aSL3HMKN:Äy!: OQ693Ò`918«]m:OE`m`98;TNKNM@Fp6aCE3H`mOE:M]P3F6a3IM8;:3IOE`9`9pSK:i Õý Q9>ÃHlbXCE3H:v<918;pi;1<9133|VY)3F6hK >SL3H:n<9OETcMZOQ<9O/M8(:8E<<JCE3F69]P3HTNT­Z]^3@FOE:X@B8;:@FTNpZM3t<91OQ< Õ ý ÂÿÒxySL8;`R<rTNKUWE3HTUOQ698;p:M§>Ã;|KN`I:3F3HM3HMK:_<91KN`IMOQ<9OOE:OETUV`9KN`Fb x :<913%]^8E69W_8E4g,KNTN@BsFJì:`RWVKT~?<913r`R3HSKU>­3HSLYZKU6aK@ 4e8E6aSpTNO@B8;::3H@B<9KN:i<913rMKN`9`aKUYZOQ<9KU8;:L`R<R6a3H:iE<91 Õ ý OE:M%<913:npZ@FTU3HOQ62476aKN@B<9KU8;:º@B8l3|%@FKU3H:n<Í8X]^OE`g478;p:MÒ<R8/[\3Õ ý · 8§¹¨ßÞà¥

E à x' b?>=|o698;SÕ<913X8E[Z`93F69C~OQ<9KN8;:8E4W8ÐÙÈKN:693F4b«y ÿBExy`93F3 lbNÿQb;|Ò]P3XZ:M Õ ý d'ÿQ]J1KN@h1%i;KNCE3H`gOI] OQ6a:K:iIOQ[\8;p<^<913`R<9OQ<R3HSL3H:n<g<91OQ< 8;:3B>­[\8lM%MKN`9`aKUYZOQ<9KU8;:K`P<913M8;SKN:ZOE:=<2SL3H@h1OE:KN`aSKN:Ò<913:lp@FTU3HOQ62<R3HSY)3F6hOQ<9p693693Fi;KU8;:OQ698;p:Mçu3Yb*ètÈ É LÙ?¡ ð×nÛaÜÝ¢5\9¤m5Ú2ÙvÞÚ25¥mfIaÕÚÓ%Ó5 ¤mÚgß à»wH¤m))a¤mo8E6¢O693HOETNK`R<9KN@¢M3H`9@B6aKUY<9KN8;:8E4<913 :lp@FTU3HOQ6dZ`a`9KU8;:IY698V@B3H`9`c<913g:np@FTN3HOQ6d`a1OQY\3^1OE`<R8v[\3%M3H`9@B6aKU[\3HMSL8E693/Y693H@FKN`93HTUEbº0213%SpTU<9K >AMZKNSL3H:`9KN8;:OETdè OE:iE3FCVKN:_3<lpOQ<9KU8;:8E4fSL8E<9KU8;:Í ÝâÍÏ Q ò

Ö óÖ=þ â ò ÿÖÖ=þ â x µ ¨ | ß â Ý ß Ý â ò¯8â ß x µ ¨ | ß â Ý â ¤ õ â ß ´ ß x Ï | x' bVÿ«|

Í þ âÍÏ Qx µ ¨ | â ß Ý ß x' b:;|

Page 54: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

~ ÀSR3ÀpºÃ= æç?aÃVÿ]) ì_VU : Y_|ó0 8_ @C

ë aì Y~3ÀuåU < ¶ þ:ö óKò÷)îªöSB÷ôûÍîßïàñ)òuóMôYõðöüï¤ øðòîßòu÷õàôYõßöSB÷ô"Tõßñ)ò L îßîßöSB÷ ø6?ïuòîðî%þ:ò îðï øðö$9_òþèöü÷¤ %S¡@] OE`2p`R3HMÒKN:(<913]^8E69W%8E4c_OEMO+~?KyE?­]yE? OE:MÒKN:(<913]^8E69W%8E48;:n<9@a1OQ6~?±y! m<R8M3H`9@B6aKU[\3º<913vZ`9`9KU8;:Y698V@B3H`9`Fb x : 3<npZOQ<9KU8;: bVÿ<913`a13HTNTg3F4e>473H@B<LKN`<9OQWE3H:KN:=<R8OE@F@B8;p:n<KN:<913ÒY\8E<R3H:=<9KNOET^3H:3F6aiE ó x þ |hb â ß KN`<913Ò`91OQY\3M3FY\3H:M3H:=<@B8;TNTU3H@B<9KNCE3%KN:3F69<9KO/<R3H:Z`R8E6IOE:M 8iâ ß KN`r<913%`91OQY\3LM3FY\3H:M3H:n<4e6hKN@B<9KU8;:<R3H:`98E6HbJ0213I6aOE:M8;S.478E6a@B3´x Ï |g1ZOE`J<9135KN:n<R3H:`9KU< â õ â â õ â ß Q8iâ ß xy`R3F3<913ÏZpZ@B<9pOQ<9KU8;:V>AMK`9`9KUYZOQ<9KN8;:5<913F8E693HS bH;|hb¢çm3F693¨ KN`¢<913<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p693m8E4<913r@B8;S5>Y\8;p:M:lp@FTU3HpZ`Fb%0213`9<9OQ<9KN`R<9KN@FOET¢3HSKN`9`9KN8;:X8E4 :3Hp<R698;:`tOE:ZM_@a1OQ6aiE3HM_YZOQ69<9K@FTU3H`Mp6aKN:iI<913SL8E<9KU8;:ºKN` <9OQWE3H:K:=<R8LOE@F@B8;p:n<JKN:(<91KN` SL8VM3HT³b x : y! :<91693F3rYZOQ6hOES5>3F<R3F6a`r]^3F693Lp`R3HM<R8ºM3H`9@B6hKU[\3<913L:lp@FTU3HOQ6`91OQY\3EG23HTU8;:i;OQ<9KU8;:X8E4¢<913L:lp@FTU3Hp`­~<913è<npOEM6apY\8;TU3M3F478E6aSOQ<9KU8;:º8E4d<913I:np@FTN3Hp`vOE:M<9138l@B<9pY\8;TU3tM3F4e8E6aS%OQ<9KU8;: 8E4<913I@B8;SLYZOE@B<`91ZOQY)3H`HbmkV@a13HS%OQ<9KN@FOETNTUº<913IZ`9`9KN8;:Y698V@B3H`9`KN`JKTNTNp`R<R6hOQ<R3HMKN:i;p693W bHl)]J13F693E)OETU693HOEMº4yOESKNTNKOQ6g<R8(p`HZ@a1OQ8E<9K@I@B8;TNTN3H@B<9KUCE3S8E<9KU8;:KN`m`918D]J:KN:<A]^8Q>AMKNSL3H:`aKU8;:OETZ:lp@FTU3HOQ6^M3F478E6aSOQ<9KU8;:(`RYZOE@B35x ­ § |hb¢0213JZ`9`aKU8;:LY698E[OQ[ZKNTNKU<KN`r<913LY698E[ZOQ[ZKTNKU<A<R8@B698;`9`<913MOE`913HMTNK:3LOE:MX693HOE@a1Å<913`9@FKN`a`9KU8;:XY\8;KN:n<FbM3F<9OEKTU3HMM3F<R3F6hSKN:OQ<9KU8;:I8E4<913P4e6hKN@B<9KU8;:OE:MIK:3F69<9KNOgYOQ6aOESL3F<R3F6a`dKN:<913^èzOE:iE3FCVKN:3<lpOQ<9KU8;:l bVÿI@FOE:[\3r4e8;pZ:MºKN:º`R3H@B<9KU8;:jlb58E4y! :­b

0J13@FOET@FpTNOQ<9KU8;:`^KN:@FTpMKN:i<913r:3Hp<R698;:ÒSIpZTU<9KUYZTNK@FKU<9KU3H`fOE:M(<913rWVKN:3F<9KN@J3H:V>3F69iEMZKN`R<R6aKU[p<9KU8;:4e8E6P<913m@FOE`93H`¢8E4 8;:3B>dOE:M<]P8Q>­[\8VMMKN`a`9KUYZOQ<9KU8;:5SL3H@h1OE:KN`aS`]^3F693 Y\3F694e8E6hSL3HM5KN:lyE?­bf0213 693H`9pTN<9`cOQ6a32`918«]m:K:IZi;p693Æ b Enb0213 @FOETN@FpTNOQ<9KN8;:`]^3F693Y\3F69478E6aSL3HMÒ478E62<A]^8%693HOE@B<9KN8;:` ¨ N o¤ ¨ª¶¨ 0cOx¢° ­ Q ;?>à E%u3Yt|gOE:ZM ¨ª© q ¤¨ª¶ x¢°è­Q.ÿ:Ã;u3Y|hbzo8E6[\8E<91693HOE@B<9KN8;:`<913@FOETN@FpZTNOQ<R3HM693H`9pZTU<9`r4e8E6<913:3Hp<R698;:SpTU<9KUYZTKN@FKU<9KU3H`OQ693KN: SIp@h1[\3F<R<R3F6/OQiE6a3F3HSL3H:=<(]JKU<91<9133|VY)3F6hKNSL3H:V>

Page 55: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

@ c IR &~3N¼ ?8

ë ì_3Y~ Àu÷U < ñò°øðòîßÿûõàî"Bø.õßñò/òóKöõßõßòþK÷)òuÿ:õðø&÷)î+B ø6õ&÷)î.ôB÷)þ )ôøßõßöFï ûüòîõBù&ò õðñòuø°öõðñnûRô&îôU"=ÿ)÷)ï£õðö$&÷a"C346487C9bï&ó Bÿ)÷)þ%÷?ÿ)ï ûüòuÿîûüö "=òuõßöüóKò>"&øõðñòTïôBîßò["]õßñò Y 1 Y 5 Y < ôRøðòô&ï£õðö$&÷èöü÷ q%|¡@<9OETzMZOQ<9O/KN:v@FOE`R3]J13H:8;:3B>­[)8VMMK`9`9KUYZOQ<9KN8;:ºSL3H@a1OE:ZKN`9S.]^OE`m3HSLYZTU8DE3HM bJ0213`9OESL3693HOE@B<9KU8;: ¨ N oѤ ¨ª¶¨ 0cO%] OE`r@B8;:`9KNM3F6a3HM478E6m<913@FOETN@FpZTNOQ<9KU8;:`KN:1y! c478E6OTNOQ69iE356aOE:iE3L8E4P3|V@FKN<9OQ<9KU8;:3H:3F69iEEb0213L:3Hp<R6a8;:SpTU<9KNYZTNKN@FKU<9KN3H`2478E6<913L3|V@FKU<9O~><9KU8;:_3H:3F69iE_8E4-° ­ Q«;?>à Eu3Y OQiE693F3(]JKU<91_<913%_OEMOÐÃ`693H`apTU<Fbº0213/8«CE3F6aOETNTM8;SKN:ZOQ<9KU8;:8E4<913J8;:3B>­[\8VMMKN`9`aKUYZOQ<9KU8;:LSL3H@h1OE:KN`aSºn]m1KN@a1%]^OE`^[6a8;pi;1=<^OE` O@B8;:@FTNp`aKU8;:IK:[\8E<91lyE?OE:Mly! :­;KN`ciE3H:3F6aOETTUtOE@F@B3FY<R3HM bçm8«]^3FCE3F6H=<913^] OQ6a:K:ii;KUCE3H:(KN:L<913m3H:M8E4 Y6a3FClKU8;pZ`¢`R3H@B<9KU8;:/`R<9KNSpTNOQ<R3H`P47p69<913F6693H`93HOQ6a@a1/8E4 4e6hKN@B<9KU8;:%OE`OL4yp:@B<9KU8;:Ò8E4f:lp@FTU3HOQ6g<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p6a3Eb*èt* ¢Ü Ó( Ú^¡ 5 ÛLÓ(¢5ÛL¢5ßf¤RwÅt5ßÙaÚg wHaßc¡\9¤

Ú25ÛâÙahÜÝR¡)¤¼wŤm56×k(¤tÛzØ Ûa\uÓ5Ú^¡ 9¤m0213rè OE:MZOEp/<913F8E69%8E4co3F6aSK >ATK=<npZKNM`¢`apiEiE3H`R<9` <A]^8L693Fi;KNS3H` 8E4 CVKN`9@B8;`9KU<9KN3H`Ty!:­b0213(6a`R<693Fi;KNS3ÒK`<913º@FTNOE`a`9KN@FOET @FOE`R3E¢]m13F693(<913ºSL3HOE:+4e6a3F3(YOQ<91§Û ¦ cÖ\]J13F693 ¦ K`<913o3F6aSKmCE3HTU8l@FKN<AOE:MÜÖ Wµ ¡ K`<913<9KSL3[\3F<A]^3F3H:Ñ<npOE`aK >YZOQ69<9KN@FTN3@B8;TNTNKN`aKU8;:`Fb0213ClK`9@B8;`9KU<È8E4Oo3F6aSKmTNK=<lpKNM+KN`LY6a8EY)8E6a<9KU8;:OET <R8Å<913SL3HOE:/4e693F3YZOQ<91/OE:M l<91np`H=CQOQ6aKU3H`P]JKU<91<R3HSY)3F6hOQ<9p693mOE`JÔáWµ ¡ bf0213m`R3H@B8;:M693Fi;KNSL3(KN`I<913/@FOE`R3Ò8E42YZ698EYZOQi;OQ<9KU8;:8E4gsF3F698`R8;p:Mb0213%Y1=V`9KN@F`IKN:Å<91ZKN`@FOE`R3@FOE:_[\3LM3H`9@B6aKN[)3HMOE`t4e8;TNTN8«]J`Fb¡²\3F698`R8;p:MOQ[`R8E69Y<9KU8;:K`t@FOEp`R3HM[lX@B8;TNTNKN`9KN8;:`[\3F<A]^3F3H:/<913R<lpOE`9K >­YZOQ6a<9KN@FTU3H`OE:M%<913HKU6^`9p69698;pZ:MKN:ibK`9@B8;`9KU<KN`f<91lp`¢YZ698EY\8E6R><9KU8;:OET <R8%<913tOQ[Z`R8E69YZ<9KU8;:ÒY698E[ZOQ[KNTNKU<8E4fO5sF3F698Q>A`R8;p:M]^O«CE3]J1K@a1ÒCQOQ6aKU3H`g]JKN<91<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p693tK:Ò<91KN`g693Fi;KSL3tOE` ¡ K³b·3EbGÔ á ¡ b

`I]^3ºOETU693HOEM_`9<9OQ<R3HM <913Ò@B8;::3H@B<9KU8;:È[\3F<A]^3F3H:ÈClK`9@B8;`9KU<ÅOE:M4e6aK@B<9KU8;:K`

Page 56: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

~ À$~ ÀçN?æl&Y:3YÍ]? ? &PUkBÃa'|a_) zÃaæç=8]k h]3Wg8_W@m@B8;SLYTNKN@FOQ<R3HM b x :Y6aOE@B<9K@B3El8;:3mOE`9`9pZSL3H`POITU8;:iSL3HOE:%47693F3mYZOQ<91 V`R8<91OQ< OIYZp693SL3HOE:>­3HTNM_OQYYZ698;OE@a1 z3Eb·ib/[OE`R3HM_8;:<913%TNK=<lpKNMXM698EY_S8lM3HT­z@FOE:_[\3p`93HM<R8M3H`a@B6aKU[\3m<913Y)8E<R3H:n<9KNOET³]m1KNTU34e6hKN@B<9KU8;:ÒKN` <9OQWE3H:47698;S OL:8;:V>AKN:n<R3F6aOE@B<9KN:iLo3F6aS%K >i;OE`LSL8VM3HT^KN:È<913(4e8E6aS 8E4m]JKN:M8D]g>­] OETNT¢MK`9`9KUYZOQ<9KN8;: bj¬`9KN:i<913ÏZp@B<9pZOQ<9KU8;:V>MK`9`9KUYZOQ<9KN8;:<913F8E6a3HS.xy`R3F32478E6aSpTNOK bH;|f<9132KN:n<R3H:`9KU<I8E4)<913JèzOE:iE3FClK:54e8E6a@B3m@FOE:[\3 M3F<R3F6aSKN:3HM bz0213^SpTU<9K >AMZKNSL3H:`9KN8;:OET;è OE:iE3FClKN:5OQYYZ698;OE@a1xy`93F3^YZ693FClKN8;p`d`R3H@¯><9KU8;:)|z]^OE`^OQYYZTNKN3HMI<R8M3H`9@B6aKN[)3 <913J3|lY\3F6aKNS3H:=<9OETMZOQ<9O%x74e8E6^KN:`R<9OE:Z@B32Y693H`9@FK`9`9KU8;::3Hp<R698;:SpTU<9KNYZTNKN@FKU<9KN3H`h|hb02136a3H`9pTU<9`(`918D]J`%<91ZOQ<(<9138;:3B>­[\8VMMKN`9`aKUYZOQ<9KU8;:SL3H@h1OE:KN`aS@FOE:[\3tOQYYZTNKN3HM/478E6JTU8D] 3|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:3H:3F69i;KU3H`Fb

x : y ÿBEt<913_4e6hKN@B<9KU8;:,@B8n3|/@FKU3H:=<8] OE`478;p:M,<R8[\3XY698EY\8E69<9KN8;:OET<R8®R¡p`aKN:i`R<9OQ<9KN`9<9KN@FOETPS8lM3HTP@FOETN@FpTNOQ<9KN8;:`t]JKN<91_ë6aOESL3F6h`8;:3B>AMZKNSL3H:`9KN8;:OETfSL8VMKU>@FOQ<9KU8;:X8E4P<913^8;16R>­,13F3HTU3F6Z`a`9KU8;:]JKNM<91+xy`R3F3L478E6aSpTNO` bNÿ;;|hb5çm8«]^3FCE3F6Hz<913SpTU<9K >AMZKNSL3H:`9KN8;:OETOQYY6a8;OE@a13H`g8E4z_OEMOLOE:M8;:n<9@a1ZOQ6Ixy`R3F3Y693FCVKU8;p` `R3H@B<9KN8;:|`918«]^3HM<91OQ<t476aKN@B<9KU8;:XM3FY\3H:MZ`m8;:_<913@a1OE:i;KN:i:lp@FTU3HOQ6t`91OQY\3E]m1KN@a1S%OQWE3H`O8;:3B>AMKSL3H:`9KU8;:ZOETSL8VM3HT\KN:OE@F@Fp6aOQ<R3tKN:(<913M3H`9@B6aKNY<9KU8;:(8E4 <913:lp@FTU3HOQ6gZ`a`9KU8;:Y6a8l@B3H`9`Hb_0213l<np3H`R<9KU8;:+18«]<913Ò:lp@FTU3HOQ65CVKN`9@B8;`9KN<AM3FY)3H:ZM`8;:+<R3HSY)3F6hOQ<9p693693HS%OEKN:` 8EY\3H: b

0cOQWVKN:imK:=<R8OE@F@B8;p:=<d478E6aSpTNOÍ b?>rOE:MI<913¢6a3H`9pTU<478E668 ÄJ8E[<9OEKN:3HMKN: y ÿBE&]^34e8;pZ:MÒ<91OQ< Õý [)3H@B8;S3H`2SIpZ@a1TNOQ6aiE3F62<91OE:_ÿr]JKN<91ºKN:@B693HOE`9K:i:lp@FTU3HOQ6J<R3HS5>Y\3F6aOQ<9p6a3Eb021KN` `R3F<9`g<913tTNKNSKU<P8;:º<913tOQYYTNKN@FOQ<9KU8;:(8E4c<913r8;:3B>­[\8lM(MKN`9`aKUYZOQ<9KU8;:SL3H@h1OE:KN`aS OE:M/OE:8E<913F6 MKN`9`9KNYZOQ<9KU8;:SL3H@h1OE:KN`aS KN`¢693<npZKU693HM bzêKU<91(KN:@B6a3HOE`9KN:i:lp@FTU3HOQ6<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p693Ò:lp@FTU3F8;:V>A:lp@FTU3F8;:+@B8;TNTNK`9KU8;:`%xyS8E693ºOQYY698EY6hKNOQ<R3HTU <npZOE`9K >YZOQ6a<9KN@FTU3@B8;TNTNKN`aKU8;:`h|P1O«CE3t<R8[\3t@B8;:`9KNM3F693HMºOE:M <91lp`FZOÅj?<R6aOE:`9KU<9KN8;:w4e698;S <913:8;:>A@B8;TNTNKN`9KN8;:OET<R8X<913@B8;TNTKN`9KU8;:OET¢693Fi;KNSL3Ò478E65<913ºClK`9@B8;`9KU<_8E4mOo3F6hSK >ATNK=<lpKNM1OE`m<R8%[\3SOEM3Eb20g]^8Q>­[\8lMºMK`9`9KUYZOQ<9KN8;: ¨ KN`J<913ISL3H@h1OE:KN`aS ]J1K@a1M3H`9@B6aKU[\3H`<91353H:3F6aiEMK`9`9KUYZOQ<9KN8;:KN:<91KN`@FOE`93EbTNTd:npZ@FTU3Hp`?>A:lp@FTU3Hp`r@B8;TNTKN`9KU8;:SL8VM3HTN`rOQ<@B8;TNTKN`9KU8;:3H:3F69i;KN3H`¢OQ[\8«CE3OQ[)8;p</ >Iu3YM ~p/OQ693J[OE`R3HML8;:<]P8Q>­[\8VMLMKN`9`aKUYZOQ<9KU8;: b0213F693F4e8E6a3Ef<A]^8Ç<np3H`9<9KU8;:`5OQ6aKN`R3Eb0213/6h`R<IKN`HOQ<]m1OQ<L:np@FTN3HOQ6<R3HSY)3F6hOQ<9p693<913(<R6aOE:`aKU<9KU8;:_47698;S 8;:3B>r<R8v<]P8Q>­[\8VMÅMKN`a`9KUYZOQ<9KU8;:_<9OQWE3H`5YZTNOE@B3Ebv0J13/`R3H@B8;:ZM<lp3H`R<9KU8;:v@B8;:@B3F6a:`<913I<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p693M3FY\3H:M3H:@B38E4<913I:lp@FTU3HOQ6476aKN@B<9KU8;:v@B8n3F4e>Z@FKN3H:=<rOE`KU<rKN`r:8E<@B3F69<9OEKN:<91OQ<KU<r4e8;TTU8«]J`m<9135CVKN`9@B8;`9KU<vM3FY\3H:M3H:@B347698;Sm ¡<R8e µ ¡~b021KN`rSOQWE3H``9`9KU8;:V>AM3H@FOHvOE:KSLY\8E69<9OE:=<rY6a8E[)3<R8`R<9pMMKN`9`aKUYZOQ<9KU8;:SL3H@h1OE:KN`aS`Fb

:8E<913F6(693HTU3FCQOE:n<`<lp3H`R<9KU8;:êKN`%pY <R8È]J1KN@h13H:3F69iE `a18;pTNM`9`9KU8;:M3H@FOH° "!#$%!'&()"!*+!'&()"!,-()( "!/.0"(12-3546!!*+78-( !96*:78( -!';<->=? .07@7BAC46"4> ?D1EGF6H 4!I $J-!-K)!IA%LM46N&--O$P&()(1QR4( GTSUV!W N46*"4>X.0"(12-3546!!R-Y'&46 "!LZ1,4/-( () "!# ![-9>46(465 !()&-N\]^-_6$` 4&()a;( [_=' !9b- ;<-8c)3Ncde"( & !6$fgI46-%-! :Qb)O ;& "!$J&!_)! !-( &Ib !9K3NG46!*ihI(j5]^-_846!I!b&-( -"!b*+!b&-( -"!-"( ( "!-S

Page 57: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Uf IR &~3N¼ ?8

Additional information about caloric curves was reportedby the INDRA Collaboration @28–30#. It is our understand-ing that the excitation energy determinations and tempera-tures for those experiments are currently under review @31#;therefore, we have not included them in this work.

B. Correlation of temperature, excitation energy, and mass

In Fig. 1 we plot the correlated values of the temperaturesand excitation energies per nucleon, which have been deter-mined in the experiments represented in Table I. For com-parison, we plot curves corresponding to Fermi-gas modelpredictions with inverse level density parameters K58 and13. Also included, for further reference, is a ‘‘total vaporiza-tion’’ line representing the ~purely hypothetical! two-stagescenario of separation into constituent nucleons, at a cost of8 MeV/nucleon followed by thermal heating. Although thereis a significant increase in the divergence of the results athigher excitation energies, the combined data still exhibit thequalitative features observed previously in many of the indi-vidual experiments, i.e., an apparent Fermi-gas-like rise atexcitation energies per nucleon below 3–4 MeV/nucleon, avery slow rate of temperature increase at higher energies(;4 –9 MeV/nucleon), and some indication of an increaseagain at higher energy, ;9 MeV/nucleon.

In some of the experiments considered, the more centralcollisions were selected by an appropriate experimental filter,and the excitation energy was varied by changing the projec-tile energy @9,10,18,19#. In such cases the masses of the ex-cited systems ~following pre-equilibrium emission! were rea-sonably well constrained. In other experiments a single

projectile energy was used, and a range of impact parametersfrom peripheral to central was investigated @6–8,11–14,16,17#. In those cases the initial masses and excitationenergies of the excited systems studied may vary signifi-cantly with impact parameter. That the results included inFig. 1 include experiments which span a broad range of massis illustrated in Figs. 2 and 3, which present plots of theprimary excitation energies and temperatures as a function ofthe derived values of the primary mass. The wide mass varia-tion inherent in many of the individual experiments is clear,as is the fact that different experiments may sample the samemass range at significantly different excitation energies. Wepreviously suggested that mass variation is an important fac-

FIG. 1. Caloric curve data from Refs. @6–20#. Measurements oftemperature vs excitation energy per nucleon are represented bysymbols. Reference @6#, open circles; Ref. @7#, solid black circles;Ref. @8#, solid black diamonds; Ref. @9#, open triangles; Ref. @10#,open square; Refs. @11,12#, solid black squares; Ref. @13#, solidblack diamonds (84Kr), open diamonds (134La), and shaded dia-monds (197Au); Ref. @14#, shaded triangles; Ref. @15#, cross inshaded squares; Refs. @16,17#, shaded circles ~Ag!, and shadedsquares (197Au); Refs. @18,19#, 3 in shaded squares; Ref. @20#, 3’s.Fermi-gas model lines for K58 ~dashed line! and K513 ~solidline!, and a ‘‘total vaporization’’ line ~see the text!—connectedsmall open circles are shown for comparison.

FIG. 2. Excitation energy per nucleon as a function of A. Ref-erence @6#, open circles; Ref. @7#, solid black circles; Ref. @8#, solidblack diamonds; Ref. @9#, open triangles; Ref. @10#, open square;Ref. @11,12#, solid black squares; Ref. @13#, solid black diamonds(84Kr), open diamonds (134La), and shaded diamonds (197Au); Ref.@14#, shaded triangles; Ref. @15# cross in shaded squares; Refs.@16,17#, shaded circles ~Ag! and shaded squares (197Au); Refs.@18,19#, 3 in shaded squares; Ref. @20#, 3’s.

FIG. 3. Temperature as a function of A, the mass number of theprimary de-exciting nucleus. Reference @6#, open circles; Ref. @7#,solid black circles; Ref. @8#, solid black diamonds; Ref. @9#, opentriangles; Ref. @10#, open square; Refs. @11,12#, solid black squares;Ref. @13#, solid black diamonds (84Kr), open diamonds (134La), andshaded diamonds (197Au); Ref. @14#, shaded triangles; Ref. @15#

cross in shaded squares; Refs. @16,17#, shaded circles ~Ag!, andshaded squares (197Au); Refs. @18,19#, 3 in shaded squares; Ref.@20#, 3’s.

CALORIC CURVES AND CRITICAL BEHAVIOR IN NUCLEI PHYSICAL REVIEW C 65 034618

034618-3

ë ì_3Y~ À'&3 < ñ)ò6ïôûSBøðöüïï ÿøðýBòø9ÿöüûüþTÿ >"=ø&ó õßñò^ûFôøðùBòôBó&Bÿ÷õ"ò òøßöüóKòu÷õðôBû?þ)ôYõðôï&û ûüòï õßòþèöü÷¤ q8¡@[\3`R<9pMKU3HM0k x 4P<913/:np@FTN3HOQ6t<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p693%693HOE@a13H`IOºCQOETNp3L8E4gOQ[\8;p<¹u3Y O<R6aOE:`9KN<9KU8;:(4e698;SOLo3F6aSK TNK=<lpKNM%<R8OL:npZ@FTU3HOQ6 i;OE`IxyTNK=<lpKNM>­i;OE`¢YZ1ZOE`R3r<R6aOE:`9KU<9KN8;:|<9OQWE3H`LYZTNOE@B3¯y!H:?­bX0213Ò@FOETU8E6aKN@/@Fp69CE3ºKNTNTp`R<R6aOQ<9KN:iº<91KN`t<R6hOE:`9KU<9KU8;:ÈKN``918D]J:K:i;p693% b;lb x <tK`t:3H@B3H`9`9OQ6a<R8vSL3H:=<9KN8;:_13F693L<91OQ<<913@FTNOE`9`9K@FOETf[ZKN:OQ6aZ`9`aKU8;:Y698V@B3H`9`M8l3H`:8E<8V@F@Fp6tOE:=VSL8E6935478E6t<91KN`r1KNi;1v<R3HSY)3F6hOQ<9p693xyOQ698;p:M ºu3YOE:MTNOQ6aiE3F6¯|^OE:Mº<913ISOEKN:ºM3H@FO«ºY698V@B3H`9`gKN`2:lp@FTU3HOQ6JSpTU<9KN4e6aOQi;S3H:=<9OQ<9KU8;:b

0213vZ`9`9KN8;:TNKU473F<9KNSL3SL3HOE`ap693HSL3H:n</KN`%Y698E[ZOQ[TU8;:38E4t<913SL8;`R<(SL8lM3HT >KN:M3FY\3H:M3H:=<P]^O«l`g<R8`9<9pM/:lp@FTU3HOQ6 476aKN@B<9KU8;:b x :Ò<91KN`^<913H`aKN`^<913Kn>­6hOH/S3F<918lMKN`cM3FCE3HTU8EY\3HMKN:I8E6aM3F6z<R8M3F<R3F6aSKN:3<913^Z`9`9KU8;:ITNKU473F<9KNSL3EbUbcqp6cS3F<918lMIOETNTU8D]J` <R8KN:@FTNpZM3cO26aOE:iE38E4V3|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:3H:3F6ai;KU3H`F~]J1KN@h1KN`KNSLY\8E69<9OE:n<\4e8E6 <913<R3HSLY\3F6aOQ<9p6a3M3FY\3H:M3H:@B38E4f4e6aK@B<9KU8;: bg0213t6a3H`9pTU<9`J4e8E6C~OQ6hKU8;p`23|@FKU<9OQ<9KU8;:v3H:3F69i;KN3H`m@B8;pTM[\38E[<9OEKN:3HM[n5i;OQ<9KN:i8;:OYZOQ69<9K@FpTNOQ6f693HOE@B<9KU8;:/@a1OE:Z:3HTOE:MTN8n8EWVKN:iOQ<<913n>­6aO«`RY\3H@B<R6apSºb x :+`Rl`9<R3HSOQ<9KN@Ò`R<9pMKN3H`8;:3ºSO«18EY\3(<R8X3H`R<9OQ[ZTNKN`a118D]<913ÒCE3F69

Page 58: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

~ À$~ ÀçN?æl&Y:3YÍ]? ? &PUkBÃa'|a_) zÃaæç=8]k h]3Wg8_èõMK)3F693H:n<rYZKN@B<9p6a3H`r8E4^13HO«Cnn>AKU8;:@B8;TNTNKN`9KN8;:`x7<]P8Q>­[\8VMMKN`9`aKUYZOQ<9KU8;:|JOE:MXZ`a`9KU8;:x78;:3B>­[\8VMÒMKN`9`9KNYZOQ<9KU8;:|@FOE:[\3t@B8;::3H@B<R3HM b

Page 59: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

3 IR &~3N¼ ?8

Page 60: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

l±o m 2onqpsrut0v pxwzy

x-|~fi6~fI|G[ |~,|G6iXe^if[+'feRea[6iW'T|i'e6i0'Z'[[|G'e|G'|~|>\W[|G'e|G<6'[ '< '¡+e^+f[i'fe¢|~£6^¤ 6I¥^ '¦|[[|G'e|G'§i|~x|>¥^<-¨£i'©b5¨f' f#£6^ª[|G'e|G<[9x-<f|^|~Ce^if[i'¦|Z^ |G¥<^+¥f6«-'e|iie¨>i¬< ¤ 6I¥^ '¦|[[|G'e|G'¢|~|~­®+f¯<6I6°<i±e^f+G|i¥W ¤²<³ ~f^Gi~®[|G'e|G<6'\´\[|<ii\I^ |''e|G6^fi[5<f®fI|W<[µa fi|i^RaG|G'¶I<i f'G'¦|G'#iu|~f+56~fI|G['

·¸6¹ º¼»½g¾M¿5ÀÀÁ0½BÂMà ÄÅ ~fW|G6iWe^if[i'e ea[6iW'T|ÆK</0[ ¤ <6W'I|/ÇÈTxiÉ­I66~Z ²IÊ<Ê^² Å ~f|G<ÌË[Í ¤ |~e0[i '¦|<\[| Ìiu~b§+ª£f¥^ fÎaiÏI Å ~¡Ð Ê­®[ÈÑ ®Ò'<Ó'¦|G[6N|~ËI<[ f fo6~<[/ÔOG[±~<|G<¥<6I~#Îa1Õ¦ÖK<,~f||~ Å ~ |I¥<[|[xf6iN|~Ë<[ f ×6~<[%|_C¢£6^W[|G'e|G<6[±i<e'eË<[6i¥sG^ii§<¥^ ¤/²<²aØ Õ©ÙÚ ¤ Õ^ÛÜ'<6~MËa+iª±ie| Îa1Õ Å ~|_CRiI¥</I6'Ô ²IÊ [Ý'<6~±Ö\\¦¨6b#[|G'e|G<6\[Æi<e'®^ |ifÆ ¤ |~ËI<[ f f¶6~f</[I|\|~fi|<fe ¤g³ [ ¤ ^Þ|~/|I¥<[|i ¤ ^T| ¤ |~/ß\+fb[gÐWÞß\ifK[ÆW<Æiu|~fÆË<[ fo6~f</[iu<6f[5|G'WbË<à6'[CáX|~e|iI|G\ ¤ |~\Ë<[ fâ~f</0[N ¤ ^+fK<C¥^+ 'MÅ ~f ¤ ^iiRe^+fI|^© ¤¢ãÊä åÇ[ËiI¡ÔO'fi|>æÏ Ø Õ<Õ祦Ñ[WèbÖ<fÌÎ Êä éß<Wi[uÔO'f|_®Ï Ø Î Ê ¥¦Ñ[ è Ö°x|<+b^ |G¥<^+¥/±I|i['C|G0'f[|G6I|G|~ ¤ ^i<f¬<[[~f¥^~®Ë<[ f¶+fi|~¢~f</0[b Å ~¢ËI<[ f fêifif|~~f<[f 6if¥\|~fe0[i '¦|c<CÕëRÏ Êaìí /I' Å ~\­®if¯<KI6X°<i[|G'e|i^sGa|G',ge^fi|i¥® ¤²<³ ~^G+6~[|G'e|G<6[C<¢i<e'^ |6i ¤ |~ ËI<[ f fî6~<[[^ |G,|~ ei| ¤ ^i/ßé[|<i'¡'6e6f|^ ¤ <i[|G'e|i^®GG|G'W5 G'#iu|~e[6i '¦|5[<, ¤ ^ ff,i,G'e|i^Îa)Ða

·¸-ï ðæ½g¿5ñ ¿5òóô¿N¾Mõ½BÂÅ ~f ÝGö Òb÷Gø'<oK<Nea|G<e|G' ¤ ^Ó|~ÆùKúKûxüÔOù%'e|G6^ú[<|G^#û'-¨^f<e1x^ýüa^ 6eÖ®<fþ<[e'[6I|G'þi|~æ|~ç [6e^f fe|i¥©ea[<|G6^ßÆáûâÔOß\[ÿ'"ÿ[I|G' \^fif¥<'¨áû6'fÖC|GW<,'[¥<R ¤B³IÊ^³ ­#[È¢ Å ~ea¨[6iW'T|K<[ ¤ <6 'Éi¡|~5¨>~f<+c ¤ |~Xe[<|G^I'lx-£f¥^ 6Îa)Ð|~5ßáûª<[6I|+¥fiI¥<6<ý+c~bM Å ~NÒ0'<ý|~ ÊØ Ð<Î<fÌÐ Ê ­#[ÈÆÑ ,iiW|~Wif5 ¤ |~i%f+I¥<6<,g´ 6if¥Æ|~\ea[6iW'T|C|~

Î<Ð

Page 61: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

"!#$&%(')+*,

40°

60°

30°

45°

10°

AL AL

GE−2

GE−2 GE−1

FD−2 FD−1Ω=19.1%+3.3%=22.4%

Th

MINI FOWRWARD WALL MINI FOWRWARD WALL

FOIL FOIL

Ne − beam in

beam out

BEAM PIPE

SCALE 1:2

-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-

/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././/./././././././././

0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.00.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0.0

1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1

Ω=3.3%

Ω=19.1%

2 %43657&8496:.;=<?>A@CBED+FG<IHJ@CKL>M;=<N>AOMFGB=PQ<SRI@CFGTURVFXW<ITYRV<S<VZB6<IOMFQ[\<T$>^]_P`A<V>Ma=Bb

Ò'<ýK<g'iI|iË<' G|I5|~WWiiW<[ '¦|dc e| fI|^f[ Å ~fN0'<G<|K<GW [|G6i/i#<|~~<6fe[^¦|<B<fË<[|i[<Bf'e|i^f<fI^ |ÐWîi¡f+< [|G[' Å ~|>ai[<B'< [ f'¦| 6i¥R|~ e[6i '¦|<WÏ ³

Page 62: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

8Xg8ih+='j=*Lkl&3Y 7

2 %(3Y5L&8fgCmn;=@_>M@Co$OM]CB=;N@_K>pHq@srY`M`tFG@CTuW=<V>A<Rv>M@CO^`B=PX]CRI<WSFGTU`AFGW<#>A;U<nD&]CRIa=a=[wR^;U]C[ux6<IOb

fßÓÔV''e|G6+[<:Ö

Å ~ Ý è Ý Å ~|I¥<[|Æ|~u|~f+¬' ¤CÊØ Ð<Î# ¥¦Ñ[ Ý K<Æ fG'i|~ ea¨[6iW'T|[ Å ~\|I¥<[|N|~f+¬'KK<N6~^G',<N|G<e¨+y[|>['#<~f[Ëi¥~fi¥^~,e^if[i'¦|5G|I|i|i[5<f#ifiWze'i¥£±^ ¤ 6I¥^ '¦|^6[ Å ~|I6¥<[|K<i<e'I|<¡<¥^¢ ¤ ÕTÎ/|~'0'e|\|G,|~¢'<îi ÔOG[£f¥¢ÎaiÏbÖ~i6~uK<^fÆiu<6[5|GXWifife[\6~f<bi¥ ¤ |~£i^,[|G'e|G<6[

Å ~KÐ Ê ­®[ÈÑ ÒK'<Ü<c~^G''[< fGK|~N¨>~'ia^fze'I|^<¨I+i|>¢[<'C<?| Ý ÔOG[~fIf|G[ ² Öc<f |~f5' fi|i¥e[i|I|^W'[6¥<¢<¥< ¤ |~|I¥<[|-¨>i¬< ¤ 6I¥^W'T|Ri ¤ ^åÎ Ê |G©Ï'Î Ê ­#[È¢C~[,|~[Ëaif'fe'¤ <K|~'G'fe\ ¤ |~^¥I¨>+ ¤ [|+ £6^e^W0^f'T|N~fbË<\[' ¤ ^ ffÔOG[~fIf|G[\Ð^Ö

Page 63: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

~ "!#$&%(')+*,

2 %43657&8G7=:.;=<dd?l@CB6<IO^]&>MFQTUoWFG]CoCO^]_[EbLFGPQPG<WRIFQO^RVPG<sOM<IB=OM<`A<IT>M`>M;=<dx6<]C[aU`A<WFQT>M;=<S<VZB6<IOMFQ[\<IT>b

·¸^ é½BÂ0½"@ÂV\ò ÁLÁf½%ñ Á

.(.A t"s=U ¡¢A¢

Å ~ue[|I|^s'[6¥<[|G[WifI|^ç ¤ |~,|I¥<[|-¨>+¬< ¤ 6I¥^ '¦|Wi^, ¤|~i <|<¦||<G¬uix|~ea[6+ 'T|Re^fe[6i¥É|~f£6^s|iW[<i '< 6' 'T|'ÇxçG'e|i^xÐa1Õ|/K< ~|~fI| i|G6<f ¤ ['<e|^f|~fe[i|I|^'[¥<[<0R[|G[6W+'¡a '< 6+¥#|~X^ |G¥<^i¥I|i[i'[¯<|~i 60^/|~R­®ic¯<KI6°<i%[|G'e|^ÉaG|G'qe^fiG|+¥u ¤N²<³~^Gi6~ [|G'e|G<gK<% fG'Z Å ~fKÇÆÈRxc­®+f¯<KI6 °<i[|G'e|^aG|G'iZ±I| ¤ |~ÇÈTxZ¯<KI6°<+< fG'+Æ|~G[6' ¤ ea[6+ 'T|e^fe[6fif¥~''Ëa¦¨>^#'<e|i^f£ ²IÊ ²¤ fÕfÏI ³¥¦

Å ~~^i6~¢[|G'e|G<'a~i£¥^ NÎa)ÎaTe^fi|8 ¤ ¤ <G|5Ô¨§© ²aØ Õf"Ö

Page 64: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

8G78iª«¬C%(­Y*l®¯®I'°® ±

2 %(3Y5L&8G²7m;=@C>A@$oCO^]_B=;³@CK.]D&]CRIa=a=[´R^;U]_[xY<O?aY`t<W©FGT>A;=<\>MOAFGB=PG<RV@CFGTURIFGW<TURV<\<IZµB6<IOMFQ[\<T$>b

+<G|i¢[i¦|iiiI|G<ÒùÏ Ê^² ß×|~X|~i¬'\ ¤ Ï ê<,6bÞÔ¨§¶×Ð ²IÊf"Öi<|i[+T|i+iI|G</Ò\ùÏ<Ï'Î|~|~fi¬'/ ¤ Î Ê W,ù%<~ç~^G+6~[|G'e|G<g~<@<<e|Ë<NI'\ ¤ Ð ²aØ ÎBëÐ ²aØ ÎWWÝ Å ~[i¦|iiiI|G<68IK<f|i[<iie^ ±'|G<¥<[|~[X f6i¥¡¡~'I|-¨f'6i¥¡ [|~M¸·C<|~ªi<G|+X[+T|i+iI|G<6[WË['a^f~<|G^¢ f|ii[¹º ²¤^ãI² Ñ ² <f5If'¡i¡|G&cf^<fß\ ¤ ^+ Å ~,e^f'e|^x0[|_C['ª|~,i<|i,<fç|~,~f<|G^/ fi|i[¢K<^f\ f6i¥|~f<f|+[<±|_CI¨>e^W0^f'T|N¥^i f\û Å È ³ Ï'ÎIßÑ·\ Å ai[<±<0[I|^Ë<^|I¥< ¤ </|~f~^i6~[|G'e|G<6K<©»Ï'Ð Ê<Ê È¢ Å ~X­ifC¯<KI6°<i[|G'e|i^®GG|G'oK<~'i' ¤ ^Þi¥^~¦|[

Å ~/|G<|<c<f¥^ fiI6<¥<ebË<['É|~|~ ­®i8¯<6I6°<+8K< ¤ ^» ²IÊ ¢|Gl¼ ²^ã i|~ Ë<[|+[<%<f ¤ ^½» ²¤ ¢|Gl¼ ²¤ i|~~f<6fe[^¦|<cfP¨'e|i^M Å ~<'f+¥ ¤ <|~Æe|i¥'<Þ6<f¥<'¶¾Ï<Ï ö Å ~¥<6+e'i¥W<f¥^¤ <|~uÐ Ê ­®[ÈÑ ÝGö Ò)¼ Ý è Ý Å ~É'<e|i^si«¿$ÀVÁ© Ï<Ï ö Å ~a f[c|~u6~^'¥<[^ [|G6É'Ë<^i¢+I¥<Xe^ f¦|I|G ¤ ^ 'i<G|i[<ii6[I|G|G['I|i['' Å ~bË<[6I¥<¢e^ T|5I|G ¤ <|~/­if¯<KI6#°<+M<ÕTЬ,ue<

Å ~Kf6if[i% ¤ |~N~f^Gi~ [|G'e|G<%<[6I|^[< 5'e6'< ¤ ^P¨

Page 65: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

 "!#$&%(')+*,

2 %(3Y5L&8fmn;=@_>M@CoCO^]_BU;Ã@_K]`tFGT=oCPG<NB=;=@`tHsFXR^;W=<V>A<Rv>M@COb

b[ Å ~i¥^~¦|5^ |G± |i5+T|G[¥<6I|G'bË<[|_CufXy['¦|5|i Æ¥^I|G'Ô ¤ <G|\<\Ö Å ~ ¤ <|5|~fi#6[iT|+iiI|G<5<e|\<<#'f[¥<T¨>i^[ijW[|G'e|G<b±~i|~Æ|~f+¬,¼[i¦|ii+I|G<5<e|<\ |G<|<8'[¥<<L±G|G<i¥ [|G'e|G<' Å ~fe<'iI|i^ÄÅƻǼ±<|%<iC^|Gi'¦| ¤ ¢6'<e|^a fe|% f<i¥^ ¨^ f<KßÜ|>ai[<Me< iÆ ¤ |~fiN±<| ¤ <^Æ~f^Gi~#[|G'e|G<i5~fb#+£f¥^ Îa ³ %ß\i'' '¦| ¤ 6^È|ÉþÏ |G³|ÉþÏ Ê [<Rif'T|£'W|~X ¤ ¨£['¦|5'G^+ |^M Å ~Æe|G'fi^®i,|~f«·<Mifi[I|G'#<Ê·¢i,£f¥^ 6Îa ³ a6~bg|~NËy0'e|C ¤ |~5^ iSÌI6|i[N~f|[ Å ~N±I|i[Ni'¦|£[I|i^fe'f /[<®'6e6',< ¤ ^i[Nß\W£6G|G|G[|~¢ii'N[¢6'|~^ ¥^~ç|~f#Wiffi ¤ |~f,<ff ¤ < '<6~x±~^Gi~ç[|G'e|G<XifËif f<ii<ù%<~#ii\iK<G[iI|G',i|~Re[|<+°| ¤ ^ÍÏ|GWW+/ fé ¤ Ï Ê /xu|~f[Ë<'T|-¨iGN<f<i[|~|5¨>i'¦|£[I|^<@<f|<if'/aÆi¦|G[^iI|i¥i|~fË<[|i[<f'e|i^0[|_C['|~R'I'G|Æ|_Ciif'[´I|®'×|~£f6G|<IbË< |~i<G|ii¢ fG'e|G6I^iI|^<G'^|~'I'G||>#iif'[ Å ~ff«G'e|G'®^fe¨>fi 'f6^f<MG'e|G6 f ¤ <\|~Æ|G<|<s|¼ ¤ <iZ[|G'e|G<\+,'<6~[Ë<'T| i/~ÉiÉ£f¥^ RÎa ã Å ~f+ÆG'e|G6 f ~b|~fI|/|~R'G^i |i^ ¤ <fXy['¦|c'' '¦|%ig6 Í['¦|c|Gfi|i¥^ fi6~'<e|i^W6~f<'i[^x- I|i[ iI|~Æ6~<f'M ¤ i¦|G['G|[0áa¥<'Mfe^fif[6i¥¢|~ÌZ¨|G6<f ¤ ['<e|i^#ÝGö[Ò«¼Ý è Ý Å ~¸Î Ï í á¼ Ý è í&ÐÃÑ lx-¡|~X|G6We^+f[i'fe'/<f<iÔO[X6~If|G[ ã Ö

Page 66: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

8G78iª«¬C%(­Y*l®¯®I'°® Ò

2 %(3Y5L&8XÓ:nÔ+B=FXRI]CPL<IZ]C[\B=PQ<@_K#]«BU]COt>MFGRIPQ<FGW=<IT>AFQrYRI]_>AFG@CT³BUPQ@C>?HsFQ>A;Õ]BY]_OA>AFX]_PGPQÔEPGFQTµ<]_OMFQÖ<WÕRV@$[ux=FGTU]&>MFQ@$TÕ@_Kd×Ø]_TYW)Ù×Ãb³:.;=<ÃPGFQT=<`u]COA<aU`A<WÇKz@COS>M;=<ÃrUTY]_PnPGFGT=<]COAFGÖ]_>AFG@CTÚ `t<<Û>M<VZ+>^ÜVb

|~f<I+i|' ¤ <^¨+fI6'<e|^~f<f'+5 f~®<ÝGö[ÒÎ Ï í áؼØÌ<fÝÏ í áÞÎßÏ Ý úi¼àÌIi[ f'M

Page 67: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

~7á "!#$&%(')+*,

10 2

10 3

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

HHe

Li

BeB

CN O

F

Ne

ZID

Cou

nts

2 %(3Y5L&8fâ,:.;=<`ABY<Rv>AOMa=[ã@_K7>M;=<`Aa=[ @CK]CPQP@$xU`t<OAD$<WEäåFQTE<]$R^;«<DC<T$>b

.(.çæ èÝéåê#ëË=ìdéíé7î6íUï

Å Æ~f¥^~¨ f6|>Æ+I¥<5I'WÔ ²IÊ [ Ý '<~±Ög\Ka¨6'[|G'e|G<6\ÔO 'icùºd¹²IÊ<Ê<Ê ¨>ûþ<f,ù­ ²IÊ<Ê<Ê ¨6Ï Ê ¨>ûÖN[Æ fG' ¤ <[|G'e|+¥q¦¨6ba' Å ~Æ[|G'"¨|G<6RC[6<[6I|if¥I|,iiµa fisfi|G<¥<'ª|G'W0[I| < Å ~®^i|^x ¤ |~f\Xf[|G'e|G<6¢</6~^G'I|/fiG|<eW ¤5³ [ ¤ ^q|~W|I¥<[|[ Å ß\iffb|~É|~fi6¬af' ¤ Ð#W ' Ë<R|~fR~fi¥^~Ée^ f¦|/I|GR[< f'ab5¨'[¥<Wন'[ Å ~I±G^i |G&Í['feW[ 6Ë<K<C '<6 'Wa i<[+¥

Page 68: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

8G78iª«¬C%(­Y*l®¯®I'°® ~ð

10-2

10-1

1

0 25 50 75 100 125 150 175 200 225 250Energy, keV

Eff

icie

ncy,

%

2 %(3Y5L&8Xñ?<VµòW<I>A<RV>A@$Os<VóÃRVFG<ITURIÔ«RIa=OAD$<Cb:.;=<SOM<Io$FQ@$T«@CKFGT>A<OA<`p>.Kz@COd>A;=<:.;Å]_TYWôõ ZO^]ËÔ`#O^]_TUoC<`#KzOM@C[ öC÷u>A@ÅøCøËùú$<Iûb

1

1.1

1.2

1.3

1.4

1.5

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90Count rate, kHz

FWH

M, k

eV

2 %(3Y5L&8XüC:.;U<#OM<`A@CPGa>AFG@CTS@CK=>A;U<.?<.W<V>M<RV>A@CO]C`]sKzaUTURv>MFQ@$Tu@_K6RV@CaUT$>OM]_>A<$ý&[<]C`Aa=OM<WHsFQ>A;þMÿ#@Kz@CO >M;=<"<T=<IOMoCÔ@_K ø?úC<Iûb$:.;=<ÛPQ@&Hq<`t>B6@CFGT$>#;U]C`#]SD&]_PGa=<d@_KJ÷ öùú$<Iû¸Kz@CO.>M;=<RV@$a=T>.O^]&>M<N@_K.øCbuú"ÖCb|~N<f^<e|Ë<^ 6e'÷'úÏ>èGè&·LÏ Ý ù% < Ý Ï6ß×I|g|~N|I¥<[|C0^6|^MÅ ~f6~f^ie ¤ |~\6<f^<e|Ë<G^ f6e'%K<NW<i<6[K|G¢eË<[5|~\'[¥<[¥^i^¡ ¤ +T|G['|XÔΠʧ² Î Ê ¬<[ÈÆÖ Å ~ 6' f|if¥X&Í[i'fe¡[ Ë< ¤ <^ ¤

Page 69: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

~ "!#$&%(')+*,

|~[|G'e|G<%ic~fbW+£f¥^ 5Îa ¥ Å ~N&ÍX['fei|~5[¥^i^ ¤ Å ~ <f Ð,6'/Ô ¤IÊ Ï<Ï'Î ¬<[ÈÆÖNiI0^ f|ÏbÙR Ð if¥ |~Æ6<fi^<e|Ë<÷[ú^ 6eÆi|~'iI|Ë<'i/~f¥^~<e|Ë|_uÔ ¤aØ)² Î/­°·KµÖ8|~5¯f fia° i|~Å\< ¤ ­i/ ÞÔO¯8°É­Ö¤ <C|~5'[6¥<¢ ¤ Ï ²<² ¬<[ÈÌ<C '< 'X<% ¤ ffe|i^ ¤ |~e^ f¦|g6I|G< Å ~f' fi|N ¤ |~i5 '< f' '¦|i56~biu£f¥^ 6/Îa ¤ NßÜ+i'I5['f'eÆ<¤ ^ fM´\ f6i¥u|~ e[6i '¦||~We^ f¦|6I|G ¤ <Æ'<6~ç\W[|G'e|G<¢< ² ά6e< Å ~R' |i¥#6'G^i |^iI^ |¯8°É­ß Ï Ø Ïu¬<[È ¤ <|~u'[¥<6<¥< ¤IÊ Ï<Ï'Î ¬<[È¢

ߧ|>ai[<f+f[i fiË<%a¨6' G'e|G6 zic[f6'G'T|G'i£f¥^ ÎaiÏ Ê ¦ÆG^+iii<°¡C£fG|<f<G%i¥^igiG^iI|G'0'I¬ ¤ ^¼G^ eÔOe<'G^fi¥N|G|G6<fi|^¢'[¥<ÅIÖ@i<6[c|GÆ<|<i f'[iKf'e6f|i^/ ¤ |~N'0^Gi#|~f¢[|G'e|G<XÔ¨à»J<Ö Å ~/±I6< [|G[6\<f|<if'®I¢¬<[f|£' ¤ <\<+'' '¦|\ÔO['bÖ Å ai[<i/C\ fG ã I6< [|G[6C|G/f'e6 Ô¨ »Ö"!Ô-ÏbÖR¥^< fi<© ¤ e[6|<i§i|~M$#B¢Ô ² ÖXI6< [|G[&%0Ïiffi[I|+¥~[6|~uea^'¦|i<|<iG|I| ^|~,N¨'[¥<i<ÔÐ^Ö¢<e^'T|+<C|<+'e6i0'R< ')( *@Ô^»Ô¨»°$IÖv+% ² Ö8ÔVÕY¼Î^ÖC±I6< [|G[6 ,Ï<f-, ² |~fI|N±i'W|~f< ^<.%±Ï<f% ² ^R|~~f¥^~¨'[¥<+<Ô ³ ÖC/I6< [|G[/%Т<K«c±I|e^T|G |^[|_C['<¬[I|G|G[¢'I¬sÔ¨$+Ô-Ïu¼ ² $+0&12 Ý ÖGÖÆ<f%0ÏI8<fZ£f<ii<0Ô ã Ö%I< [|G[ %TÕi fG'W|G'e5|~^¥I¨6<¥<\<6¬¦¥<^ f^|~bN¨'f[¥<+< Å ~¦ f'[<[£±3XÔ¨ »¸<Öi ¤ ^ i¦|G[Ë<+i|~'G'e||GÕ¦\üa|I6|i¥ ¤ ^¶|~/N¨'[¥<i<±|~£fG|i¦|G[ËI<i ®|G<¬[I|G|G['[¥<ÕÔ-Ï?¼ ² 0&142eÝbÖÔ¨ » $IÖs5%¦Õ Ø ÔÎaiÏbÖx#|~ÆG'e^fiT|G[6Ë< ¤ ^ $+Ô-ÏÛ¼ ² =0&142 Ý ÖC|G$» à5%0ÏÔ¨ã»JÖ"6')( *@Ô^» ÊØ Î ëÉÔ7%0ÏC+#Ö Ý Öë8')(9*BÔ^»Ô¨ã»J<Öv+% ² Ö#¼:%aÐ Ø ÔÎa ² ÖxW|~5|~f iT|G[6Ë< ¤ ^Ø$q»© 5%0ÏN|G¸»$\5,ÏN^ f%'G^f ¤ ffe|i^i5 + ¥^< f6i<Ô¨ » $Öd6';(9*@Ô^» ÊØ Î ëÉÔ^»Ô¨ » <Öv+#Ö Ý Ö Ø ÔÎa)Ð^ÖßM£f<iiiu|~+<G|5i¦|G[Ë< ¤ ^ » $\6,ÏÔ¨ã»J<Ös6')( *@Ô^» ÊØ ÎWëÔ<,ÏC+#Ö Ý Öë=')( *@ÔGÔ¨»Ý<Öv>, ² Ö Ø ÔÎa1Õ¦Ö

Å ~iI¥<<ËI<¦|I¥< ¤ ^ K£f|G|i¥¢fe'f 6i|~/ |P¨'' '¦|K<f<¦¨i[K°¡¢< f /|~fI||~f|G<|<@G'e|G6 f +6 fo ¤ e^¦|G6 |i^f?@ ¤ ^|~ÆI|G^WN|~,i¥^Ǩ>6~'i0~^ ¤ <N'<6~#'i' 'T|N ¤ |~ÆI|G^Wia f/[

Page 70: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

8G78iª«¬C%(­Y*l®¯®I'°® ~BA

300

400

500

600700800900

1000

2000

3000

4000

80 85 90 95 100 105 110 115 120

THKα Kβ

Energy, keV

Cou

nts

2 %(3Y5L&8(9>C7:#Ô+B=FXRI]_PFGTURVPGaU`AFQD$<Zµ¨O^]ËÔE`AB6<Rv>MOAaU[ÞOM<`Aa=P >MFQTUo«KzOM@C[ED$÷FÅ<Iû GËaIHJKd<LHNMOH:.;@$x>M]CFQT=<WHsFQ>A;?<"Z+µçO^]ËÔW=<V>A<Rv>M@COb:.;=<ÛKza=PGP,PQFGT=<"OM<IBUOA<`t<T$>^`<IZ+B6<IOMFG[<T>M]_P,W=]_>M]=b:.;=<?W=]C`A;=<WPQFGT=<?OA<B=OM<`A<IT>M`r=>b m@$`AFQ>AFG@CTU`n@_K>A;U<Nù[@`p>qFQT>M<ITU`A< õ Z+µçO^]ËÔuPGFQTU<`#Kz@COq:.;]COA<N`t;U@&HsT«@$T«>M;=<?>A@$Bb

|ÌÔO1<d|QP ¤ <B|I¥<[|ga f['a<fE|QPN¼,ÏIY|QPN¼ ²¤ <Ba f['IB'<e|i^/a fe|ÖÅ ~f[ ¤ <6<|~Æ|G<|<0'e|G f,,¹ÔOùKÖ±[<,ef'',¦

RÔ¨Ö"É ö ¼TS @ ?@ US VXWÏÌVÔp|ÖNÔ¨ »

VÔp|ÖGÖ"Y ÔÎa)Î^Ö

Page 71: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

~ "!#$&%(')+*,

~[ ö iÆ|~fbË<[<i<¬a¥<^ ffZ Å ~R<6W<ize['Zªea&Í['¦|ÅÌV

fe¨e6/|~'iI|Ë<i¦|G'f|_# ¤ |~ËII6^ f\fiI¥<6<ê|G6<|^fÔV|~e<e¨G^ffif¥®'[¥^i'Å

VÖ ¤ < |~,if¥^RǨ>~'iK~^uI|G^Wi,|I|G' ¤ ¥^Ë<'

'' '¦|[Äx-x6~If|G[ ² .ZÚÏ'Сf+I¥<6< iifR'f[¥^'W|~se<'G^fi¥'iI|Ë<i¦|G'f|i'NC[6¢ f'M~i6~®C[[<i[ f+I|G'®i|~#|~­úK´¯©ea<Å ~'G[<i[ fiI|^cC[65[ ¤ < ' ¤ <g|~5|~6[iG<|G<'c|~©| ã Ð[Y ¥<² Y ¤IÊÔ ¤ <[|<iiKG[Æ~fIf|G[ ² Ö%¯f<|~<f<i ¤ |~|G6i\e^i[i'fee0[P¨ '¦|[¦~f[I\i¦|G['G|G'RW<ifi©|É ¤IÊ <fÕ| ¤<² [Z° ¥ fiI¥<6<iiR'[¥^i'#ÔV|~,'[ËI<T| ]\<s_^|G6<|^f¢ ¤ £f¥^ ² iÏbÖ¢<fç'+¨|Ë<i¦|G'fi|'N[ fG'Z Å ~'ÆfI|W[Æ<f|<+' ¤ ^Þ|~` ff0Ñ+`n·KÒ$`¦ ['I<f#I|G^iÆfI|W'I66~G[Ë<[£PÏ'Î ¦

Å ~R' |i¥#£|/ ¤ |~fRi[i fË<W¦¨6bG'e|G6 [<R['+£f¥^ 6ÎaiÏ Ê <5 <~',iif<6x-u£f¥^ 6ÎaiÏ Ê |~ÆW<+0ie[<eXiR|~Æa^[¥^^[|>['ª|~®ea[6iW'T|<5<s|~#£f|G|G'©G'e|G6if ,|GÉ|~f®<ff|i^f<àc¨>~f'iM^ffe'I|i^Mc´[|<+i[<, ¤ ^ ff,i,'e|^ ² iÏI

Å ~/bË<[6<+8~f<¥<i,'G^+ |^#e^ ±I'®|GR£f¥^ 6 ² 1ÕR+f |GXiI¥<[e^ f¦|56I|G<f#<¬a¥<^ ffZ

.(.ç Aï+ïtn déíé7î6íUï¯^ /£^[|G'e|G<[W i|I|ÇÈTx Å ~f £^[|G'e|G<[[Ë<'¨<'¢+/[^Ke^+iI<6I|^¢|~/|~5­\ f¦^<f £1Ð ²¦ fi¥\<¢<6¥^if<a'i¥^ ¤ º@jú\ Ò/¦ú^ e[')£PÏ ³+¦ Bߪ~<|G<¥<6I±~ ¤ |>Æ£6^¢[|G'e|G<6%+fiC|~KË<"¨ f f 6~f</[/i/~bÉiÉ£f¥^ XÎa1Õ Å ~Wfif[i¢ ¤ |~X£i^[|G'e|G<<[6I|^#[<Æ'e6'u< ¤ ^i[ Å ~Æif[+'T|K£6^ ¤ 6I¥^ '¦|<^f¥|~',|G6«G'e|G<i |~fbN¨' 6¥^<®[|>['|~[I|~É<Ì<afi<'/ ¤ |~,[|G'e|G< ^ffe[X|~X¥^< W^'[ f'[¯[u''e|G6^f <f0^6P¨|Ë<'R6~fI¥<',i^fKIÆe'I|G',<f,<[e'[I|G',|GbKI6,|~''e|G6a'N+X|~f~^ <¥<'[^ %''e|GiK£f'iM@° ~'W|~~f¥^~Ë<^|I¥<Ifii'/^|~5''e|G6a'ee['5|~'~f^iM¦'e^ffIu^ffe'I|i^XWbX[[ 5iR|~'fi|>W¥^<[' fi|i¥i/f'I6e0^f'T|i<a¢ f|+i[I|^ ¤f¤ [C''e|G^fB<B ¤ ffe|i^ ¤ |~ f+G|<fe<Wx ¤ |~W<¢i<ie^fG|G fe|G' ¤ uG[6i' ¤ |~fi6'[|~'i'e|G6i/£f'i#G|G6'¥<|~+fe'<G'6IiRf'I|~/''~f+6~#[< f'\<[Ë<' ¤ <G|G[<[e'i[6I|^®<#/ |i+[I|^ ¤ |~'i'e|G^f[

Å ~¥<^i¨iI|G'®| f¥^G|G'6'N|~fi<W[|G[ ¤ Ï ÊWä ¶G[Ë<'<|~f<C'[ Å ~K<C±i<Ce^iG|if¥ ¤ Õ Ê '8C[K+<e'¢+/\I6<+'¥<[^ [|Gu|G |~Æ[I|~+<\I|5 iG|<fe ¤ Ð/,Cüa<[if¥¢[|_C[',|~f'\K< ² W, Å ~6/+<<±i<e'¡iu [|<iii ¤ 6< |~<i ¨Wifze['®­#iI ¤ ^+CÔV|~fi6¬af' ²aØ Î ä RÖ5I||~/'¦|G6<fe< Å ~[I|~fa¢i<f'[~fi~ ¤ <6 '|~/<¬i¥R ¤ |~[|G'e|G<6I|\|~< ¢|i <0C[W<¢ ¤

Page 72: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

8G78iª«¬C%(­Y*l®¯®I'°® ~L

1

10

10 2

10 3

10 4

10 5

100 200 300 400 500FD_E1

Cou

nts

2 %(3Y5L&8(9Y96n:.;=<Å`A@CPGFGWÇPGFGT=<«;UFG`t>AOM@Co$OM]C[´OM<IBUOA<`t<T$>^`u]CT°FGTURVPGaU`AFQD$<«<T=<IOMoCÔÕ`tB6<RV>AOMa=[@$x>M]CFQT=<WSHsFQ>A;u@$T=<#rY`A`AFG@CTuW<I>A<Rv>A@$Ob:.;=<.W=]C`A;=<WµçPGFQTU<n;=FX`p>M@Co$OM]C[åOM<IB=OM<`A<IT>^`>M;=<#<T=<IOMoCÔ`ABY<Rv>MOAa=[ @CKU>M;=<s`A]C[<nrY`M`tFG@CTW<V>M<Rv>M@COo$]_>A<W@CTu>A;=<.B=OM@C[\B> RV@$FQTYRVFXW<ITURI<n>MFQ[\<.HsFGTUW@&HHsFQ>A;>A;U<`t<RV@CTYWÃrY`M`AFQ@$TW<I>A<Rv>A@$Ob

fiT|G'R[6[ |C^I6X|~R|~e^f fe|i¥i'<[N^,i|6 ¤ <e<"i¥^~XË<^i|I¥< ¤ »Î Ê<Ê ÈzK<\Ii',|GR|~¢[I|~af/+<< Å ~/<fa/'C[6 |\I|¥<^ fu<|G'T|i<Z|~^ ¥^~#'< ii£f[ÆÔ¨º0ßÖ· ¤ <|~¡e[6i '¦|#G[Ë<[6<Æ|G'G|# ¤ |~|_Cx£±^Ì[|G'e|G<#[

Page 73: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

~7~ "!#$&%(')+*,

[ ¤ < 's fif¥<xß\½ÌZ¨>G^ 6e< Å ~,¥^f< ¤ ^ |~)ºß¶< ¤ ^ f|G#I0^ f|XÐ Ê ÈÍ|~ç|~f®Ifii's~f¥^~çË<^|I¥< ¤ »Î Ê<Ê È¢g~fii ¤ <|~f~''Ëaª£±^ ¤ I¥^ 'T|®f 6if¥|~ea[6+ 'T|X|~¡¥^f<K<,I0^ f|Ï'Î Ê È¢±´ 6if¥W|~e[6i '¦|5|~/£i^#[|G'e|G<6\[£+',|~iG< f|<¥^<NI|N/' 6 ¤ Î Å <' Å ~\Ifii'X~fi¥^~WË<^|I¥<Æ ¤ Î Ê<Ê È<N<I«G f|G'|Gu0Ð Ê »ÉÕ Ê Èý'bÜ|~GI¬i¥W|~f'~^iZ Å ~¢[|G'e|^&Í['e ¤ <|~Æ£6^ ¤ I¥^ 'T|<[^GÆ|GÏ Ê<Ê ÙR

x-/£¥^ ÎaiÏ<ÏK|~fi[i fË<%'[¥<G'e|G6 æ ¤ ^f ¤ |~C£±^¢[|G'e|G<6i@~b/<8|~KG^ii/ii%~iG|G<¥<6<, Å ~C'[¥<G'e|G6 ¤ |~K< £6^[|G'e|G<B<f|<i'/iÆe^i[i'feg|~Æ<<|~[@£6^Æ[|G'e|G<ciZ6~b/<|~ff<~'iiK~fiG|G<¥<<, Å ~5G''e|i^ ¤ |~fN'[¥<¥^I|G ¤ <g£6^ ¤ 6I¥^W'T|i5f+[ fG'ui,'e|^ ³ ²

·¸b cçÀ½d@¾ òÅIcÁÜ¿5òó ó ¿Â¿ ¿SedÃÅÁ- V\ò

ßsi ±i£f'|G6¥<¥<[G¨'i'e|G^fi[@6~f' Ci~bi£¥^ %ÎaiÏ ² ^x|~fiZ66~' |~'i'e|G^fi[ ¤ <¢|~|~f[X[|G'e|i^GG|G'WRÔO¯@° ¨­ifg¯f<IÉ°<iùר\f[|G'e|G<6X<x¯B´Í¨/¯Bii^x[|G'e|G<6ÖWI®~fbMÌü¥^f<+ ¤ ^¯@° ~<|G^¢ f|+[6CC[/Gi|Ni,<®<e|Ë</G±i|G|G[N|G<|<i#<Tf-'[6¥<[g¨¥^f<ÔOùÖ8<fIf-|i ;g¨>6¥^f<MÔ Å ÖÔV|~fiBG+|G|i¥+@f<|B6~bi/£f¥^ 6KÎaiÏ ² ÖÅ ~¢¯8° f-'f[¥<[g¨>6¥^f<@¥<¦'\ËiWuÎ Ê<Ê [I¢'ib,|GRX<iË<Gii|G|G[Ôüaii|G|G["Ö¯x|~u<6Ë<Ri|G|G[¢|~hf-'[¥<ig¨>¥^f<KK< G+|/I¥^<is<¤ 's+T|G¡|_C~fI¥<®i¦|G[¥<6I|if¥<<<¥^ ,|Gf¥^i|<e^¦Ë<[|G[6Ôkj´ÆúÓ¯f<G|ù%fefif¥ç<Ìû5'<^ |ÔO¯@ùCûßÖI`ZúKb§ÕTÐ Ê<Ê ·5Ö Å ~f£6G|#i¦|G[¥<6I|^+^i|~R^¥#ÔÐ Ê<Ê f"Ög|+ ¥^I|GXÔ¨¢ÖN<fu|~ÆG'e^f®iT|G[¥<I|^#iN^f|~~<|,Ô ¥ ÕfÖ|i u¥^I|GÔòÄÅ¢Ö Å ~R+T|G[¥<6I|i^|~É|~fui^¥<|~6~<|¥^I|G'ui[ ¤ < 's|GÉ<|<iª±I|i[®+'T|i£[I|^æÔOG[G'e|^Îa)Ð^Ö Å ~¯@° f-|iW;g¨>¥^f< ¤ <6 '§i©çe^f|<T|-¨ ¤ 6<e|^ie6iifI|G<ÔúK¯B´l`úÐÕ ²IÊ Ö< ¤ '+T|Gu|+ e¨|GI¨>f¥^|<@e^¦Ë<[|G[XÔ Å ´Æúm`Zú6bÐ<Ð ã<ã Ö Å ~f¯@° áû ¥^f<±[6Ë<' ¤ 6^ÓúK¯B´3n <e^f'e|G'R|G/«-<6i|>e^if[if'fe5<¥^iK ffi|NÔ­úxá\6|G''ÐÏ ã ÑÒ$`BÖGÖ Å ~fùof-'[6¥<[g¨>i¥^f<K< ¤ '|G¢¢G'e|G^e<a< ±i£f[ÔüßÖ´ 6if¥Æ|~\ea[6iW'T|[¦~[|~\¨>~f'i^ffe'I|i^Éf6<Iiii|'[, '< 'ÌÔOG[,G'e|i^ ² ² Ö¢i|/K< ¤ ^ fÉ|~fI||~'G|6'G^i |^ifËaif' f6i¥|~f¢G'e|G^6e<¦< ii£f[á\6|G' ³^ã ÐaÅ ~<Wi£f'¡6¥^f<cK</'T|¢iT|G<<f<i<¥^ W|G¥^|<ge^¦Ë<[|G[#ÔOß´Æú<fùC' ¥ Ï ² ¯gÖ Å ~f5ùmf-|iW;g¨>¥^f< ¤ <6 'W+úK¯B´þÔá|G'NÕ ã ÐIßÖBK< ¤ 'i¦|G |~ Å ´ÆúzÔ7`ZúKb,Ð<Ð ã<ã Ö Å ~ù§áû¼¥^f<0K<G'¦|N|GW|~Æ6< ­ú<¥^iX ff|[®üiiiI6®|~R¯B´Þ6¥^f<iC[Rf'e|G'Z Å ~XWaf 'Æ fG' ¤ <|~¯B´Ìi¥^f<igI|~j´Æúx¯@ùCûßzÔ7`ZúKb ÕTÐ Ê<Ê ·5ÖúK¯B´ýÔá\|G' ¥IÊ<Ê<Ê Ö%<

Page 74: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

8Q²L8iqp(+¬_I&­6*L%(¬C®\=*kÝkL=Õ=¬sr5%4®%z%4­6* ~±

FW−T

FW−E

GE−T

GE−E ADCSA

CFD

CFD

Splitter

TDC

TDC

MC=3

FD−T

FD−E

TDC

Short Gate E∆

Long Gate EDGG

DGG

Common Stop

All TDC’s

DGG

DGGGate

Gate

CFD

1−26

1−26

1−2

1−2

1−2

1−2

OR

OR

OR

Master Trigger

QDC

QDC

QDC

2 %(3Y5L&8(9gut+FG[BUPQFQrU<WÇ>AOMFQo$oC<IOAµ¨<IPG<Rv>MOA@$T=FXRI`N`AR^;U<I[\<CýL>A;=<`tÔ+[xY@$PG`]COA<<IZB=PG]CFQTU<WÕFGT>M;=<N>A<IZ>b

Å ´ÆúzÔá|G'Ð<Ð ã<ã ÖÅ ~W<G|G[i¥^f<CÔ­<G|G[ Å ¥<¥<["ÖKK<\X<¥^+¢áû¼ ¤ |~¢|G6Æe^+f[P¨

Page 75: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

~7Â "!#$&%(')+*,

'fe/­ú <f#f'[<',6i¥^'K ¤ <i|~6[Æ[|G'e|^®aG|G'[ Å ~ËII6^ [Ë<'T|\|>a'e^ i,i'¦|£f'ua ¤ ['fi¥We<6'G^ffi¥Wi<¥^i f+G'5i,|~fGIK6~<f'i8 ¤ Å ´Æú\ Å ~fCW<G|G[ci¥^f<TK<B fG' ¤ <@|~Ke^W ^G|G< ¤<i Å ´Æún [ ¤ <c|~j´Æú5Ñß\´Æú¥^I|G'%<f ¤ <c|~5G|I|c ¤ |~NfI|<[µa fi|i^M

Å ~XfI|<[µa fi6|^~' Ri~fbi¡£f¥^ 6XÎaiÏ'Ða Å ~X¯@ùCûßofI|Ôkj´Æú\ Å ´úÖ<f|~fu<fùC'Wß\´ÆúýfI|®C[6'<ɦ|~R¯@ùCûßÓ6iË<[Ô7`Zú6b®ÕTÐ Ê ÏbÖ8a[I|G'i,úKß\­ßúÜe6I|G<Z<f|G6< ¤ [6'®|Guuf f<8<| ' <çÔO´\ºC­v`ZúÏ<Ï ¤IÊ ÖWaf < Å ~´\ºC­åfI|RC[ 6'<^ |¦È­ùc¨±<G'Éß\~fRf6ae'<' Å ~W~f<f~fI¬<|~|~fW|G6¥<¥<[aG|G'q<ff fe'a f+¥RuÈ­ù¼ú5áû·NáÍÔúáif[if'fe¢û[¥^iG|G[÷5áI60Ö¢ß ¤ |G[|~#'<f^ |W|~®I|¡C[6®G|G<'ª^wºúÈ\´ <fx^x´` Å |I#¦ç f+¥|~ / | ¤ ffe|^f<¯qºÛº%´5ßjoIfii[I|i^ÔOG[ û ¤ £ ²<³¦ Ö Å ~fi\Ifi+[I|^<N<+G¢Ii' ¤ <K<|~R|~^¨>ii\<fR|~+y0¨>iif\<f<iaG''cÈ­ùs[<[6C[6# fG'sf i¥|~,ea[6+ 'T|iç<6f[ |G'<ç^ |W+¥^'<fse^if[¨'fee^ f¦|\I|G'[ Å ai[<8'<|i f 6if¥ |~/e[6i '¦|K<I^ | ² ÎÙR Å ~Xif|i<B|+Wi¥, ¤ |~X''e|G^f+[K</f^ f+¥® í ö úG^ 6e ¤ <¯@°ª¨ù e^i[i'fe'5<,<®ß\ÌM¨>^ 6e ¤ <¯B´¨ù e^if[if'fe'[fG |~fI|<iC''e|G^fi[¢e^ fiÉX[I|G'ç'I/|~fXe[6i '¦|<%G[| f<fe^ fi<« fG|G',i|~^ |K'<,

·¸G· w¾ZÃE@ÂþM½ x¡Âzy½ ó ¿Â¿î¿5ò¿5ÀvÁÁÅ ~WfI|<f<iG|G fe| Wi6~'I|i[<i¡~i£¥^ ÎaiÏeÕ,ß< '¦|^'®+#G'e|^Îa1Õ|~/+y±¨>+iÆfI|X<f<iNK<[ ¤ <6 '® fi¥ |~f¯.º"º%´ßjéIfii[I|i^M0+f[i ff+¥|~ úN´5ßjéifI £ ã+¥¦ Å ~6'<fi¥ ¤ ^<[Ë<'T|£±/K< fG'<<i± | ¤ |~ ¯qºÛº%´5ßjZßf<<^ |G f|\|~ffI|C[56i|G|G'ª|G ºß°i¼Ã¼ £ ²$¦ 6~fI'§ ' << Å ~®[Ë<'¦|,fI|C[ |i,úK^i fWf-°§+G;guÒ Å Ð º`8ù ¤ <WI|<f|G<'¡i ·5áÆáÇ £PÏ ¦ £i'[¥IÊ<Ê<Ê<Ê [Ë<'¦|Æ[W6|G|G'¡i'<~J·NááÇo£< Å ~fWiiW|\K<Æf |G#|~f ' <©<i[I|^M Å ~f¶·NááÇq£±'[e^±i'ª+ºß8°¼Ã¼q f+¥Ò Å Ð ºq`ùÑ<úSßRxÒq<[6I|^M x-ºß°i¼Ã¼ |~¡fI|ç[¡<f<6e['Ì f+¥ËI^ f^ |+'[Z1<¢|~WGI¨>[<ii'Ç Ð ­®ßún 'ß ¤ |G[Æ|~³ºß°i¼Ã¼é<f<ia+|~Æ£<Mqa¨6bu0'e|GC[f[I' ¤ <|~f£f|G|i¥

x-|~<f<i\|_C®<i¡<G'e|[i¦Ë<^Ë<'M Å ~£fG|i|~W[|G[G¨WifI|i^É ¤ '<e|^s6~<f'i<f|~uf<±Iii|_|G<±G[Ë<,|~u'[ËI<¦|6~f<'i[ Å ~fiuK<®^fÉ fif¥|~ff«G'e|ie¨>ii¬< ¤ 6I¥^W'T|e^if[i'e'|~s£±^ ¤ 6I¥^ '¦|[ Å ~#G'e^f©<G'e|W<ea|G<e|i¥|~®|G6 #|G6ie^if[if'feÍa¨6bG'e|G6 Å ~f+g<iG/'µ¦ '%[I6 ¤ f|~>$|7N~>9>× f¨|G6<e|^M

Page 76: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

8X8m&5L¬C5LË©­.LkLÕ=*L pz¯®%4® ~7Ò

2 %43657&©8497i?]&>M]_µ¨]$R4a=FX`tFQ>AFG@CTE`MR^;=<I[\< Ú `A<I<?>A<IZ+>^Üvb

Page 77: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

±,á "!#$&%(')+*,

Event file

Output: writing to PAWshared memory

FPPDAQ

GeneratingNTUPLE

NTUPLE/CHAINPAW++

Final spectra

HBOOK files

Input: reading from a file

Analysis usingx−ray fitting

routines

2 %43657&©849+²LitR^;U<I[]&>MFGR]_POM<IB=OM<`A<IT>M]_>AFG@CTÃ@CKL>M;=<W=]_>M]\]_TU]CPQÔ`AFG`.`t>AOMaURv>Ma=OM<Cb

Page 78: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

w w : w 6i¡¢a£-W|~f+gG'e|^X|~<<a6ig ¤ e^i[i'fe'%0[|_C['Xf«G'e|ie¨>+¬< ¤ 6I¥^ '¦|Ô¨ºq`¯gÖ\<f£6^ ¤ I¥^ 'T|XÔO¯@¯gÖ\ii80 '6e6'M Å ~WW<i 60^/ ¤|~f+ <f<iWi|G[|G[6W+u|~®< ^ f¦|W ¤ º`8¯8¨>¯@¯×e^if[i'e' ¤ <|~'<e|i^6~f<'i ¤ +T|G['|[¯f^ibi¥u|~ fe'f 6¢f+[ fG'iG'e|i^² )Ð/|~µa f<T|i|>]¤F¥a|~¦ [ ¤ £i^[Ë<'¦|[<fX|~a f[ ¤ 'i§e^if[+'fe®|~ª£±^ ¤ I¥^ 'T|-¤ ? ì ¥/ f|X[|G[6Wif'M Å ~'GËI<i 'XI®^fiçW'<fi¥ ¤ f ¤ <RÉI|i[ f+IW'<e|^§6~f<'N1<iª|~fiK'W|~f\<W<ife'I|^X ¤ |~¦¨''iXiW'<~,iffiËai f<a'<e|^u6~f<'[<çu<f|<i'Z Å ~,e<'0^fi¥®¦¨6b'i<f|<+' ¤ ^ |~fR|Ge^i[i'fe<f<iXiif+[ fG'§i©|~¡e|u~fIf|G['ÓI|i¥ç^ e[|<+'<e|^~f<f'B<i|G#[|G[6i¢|~W'Ë<[6I¥<Xe[i|I|^'[¥<<f®<¥^ fiI5 ^W'T| f ÔOG[/G'e|i^®Ða1Õ¦Ö

¦Æ¸6¹ §Éñ ½Þ¿5ò¿5ÀVÁ6Á

Å ~fW<+/± ^G ¤ |~K|i N<f<ia+8ae' Ki@|GÆ[|G[6WifC|~Kf6^ f|e^i[i'¦|X|iW+fb ¤ <R|~f|ii¥6¥^f<iX ¤ |~~^i6~§[|G'e|G<6<f© ¤ |~£6^ª[|G'e|G<[¨£©£f¥^ ³ iÏ|~|+ Xy0[6'fe®[|>[' G'i'e|G'~f^Gi~[|G'e|G<g<f^ ¤ |~%|_C£6^Æ[|G'e|G<6Bi@~M Å ~¯@°É\­l Õ Ø Îf8 ¤ |~f^ f|8|i 0'I¬/<6¥^iI|G' ¤ ^Ü|~ËIiI|^i/|~|iW\ ¤ c¥^~¦|[ Å ~f^Wf|C|+ if§''e|^ufe'f 6K<N[ ¤ <6 '¤ <<i5Î ² Ô ²<³ ~^Gi6~s[|G'e|G<<f ² £±^s[|G'e|G<Ö ifËif f<%|i ffy0['eRG'e|G6 Å ~R0^6|^ ¤ |~,e'T|G6^iç ¤ |~uf6^ f||+ u0'I¬K<I|Æ ^G| Ïf~f ¤ |G''iI|Ë<|G#<i8<|~[Æ|+ ¢Xy0[6'fe¢0'e|G/ß\iG|~N^i|^¢ ¤ |~f5e'T|G^+ <C6~'6¬<' ¤ <g|~5Xy0[6'T|c6 fc<fK< ¤ ^ ff|GWG|Ii< Å ~f^Wf|N|i +fb ¥^I|G' ¤ 6^Þ<iMG'e|G6[G'i'e|G'¤ <5|~ ¤ |~[<f<i[£-/£f¥^ ³ ² |~fC|_CI¨>f+ 'f^<T|iWCG'e|G6 fÓÔOfXy['feC[|>['|i ¤ |~G''e|G'u~^i6~R[|G'e|G<<X|~f'e^fu£i^X[|G'e|G<Ë<[6 fNf ¤ ¨¤ ['fe/0[|_C['|i / ¤ |~/''e|G'®±~^Gi~®[|G'e|G<<f®|~£6G|5£6^[|G'e|G<eÖi~M Å ~[uI,£fË<u|>a' ¤ [Ë<'¦|Wf6'G'T|G's+|~i¢<|[Å ~fi¦|G'fGXiI¥<^f<%+i [f6'G'T|/|~Xf^ f|/e^if[i'e'[|>['|~|_C£^sf[|G'e|G<6X+s6<f^Úe^if[i'e' |~ç|~®~^G+6~x[|G'e|G<bÅ ~fXË<[|+[<ÔO~f<6fe[^¦|<:Ö/iiX[f'G'¦|¢|~uf^ |/e^if[+'fe'¢[|>['

ã Ï

Page 79: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

± u«Ó7 ª­Y5©p(ŬC­6%4*¬C%(kL+*¬C+®\=*L pz¯®%4®

1

10

10 2

10 3

-60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100(FW_T1-FD_T1), ns

Cou

nts

2 %(3Y5L&³Ó8(9YÛT=<Iµ¨WFG[\<ITU`AFG@CTU]CPY>MFQ[\<uW=F«ª,<IOM<ITURI<S`tB6<RV>AOMa=[iKz@$Odmu¬7Lµò)RV@$FQTURIFGW=<ITURI<`b|~±~^Gi~®[|G'e|G<<f|~/£f6G|/ÔO'e^f±Ö5£^®[|G'e|G<Æi#<f^ eI¨if[if'fe'%|~|~f\G'e^ÔV£6G|Ög£^R[|G'e|G<' Å ~e^if¥[¥^^R ¤ <+|~[uii'Æ[f'G'¦|¢|~|G X^ f|e^+f[i'fe'/[|>['|~~f^Gi~[|G'e|G<<fu|~£6^,[|G'e|G<6[¯Bif<i<|~Æ6W<i< ^ f¦|5 ¤ fI| ^i¦|^ |if ¤ '<~, ¤ |~i+'%'6e6'IbË<6[f'G'¦||G66<f^ée^if[¨'fe'[

Page 80: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Ó78Xg8m>p(¬C%(­Y* ­d®­®®%4­6*8ç&=36')+*,®\+*L&3U¯ 3Y= ±iA

2 %(3Y5L&³Ó8fg6:.H#@Cµ¨WFG[\<ITU`AFG@CTU]CP=>A;UOA<<VµçKz@CPXW>AFG[\<SWF«ª,<IOM<ITYRV<N`tB6<RV>AOMa=[ `A;=@&HsFQTUoù>pÔB6<`@CKRV@$FQTYRVFXW<IT>d<ID$<IT>M` Ú `t<<?>A<VZ+>vÜvb

¦Æ¸-ï w½CÀ½d@ Vò x¯y½°WÁ0ÁIò±x'¾M¿Nõ\ñ ½%ò\ÂÁþ½%ò½g¾Mõåõ¿Â0½

£-£¥^ NÎaiÏ<ÏC ¤ G'e|^ Îa)Ð|~Kif[i f6Ë<%<fe^if[+'T|8'[¥<¢G'e|G6 ¤ |~£6^[|G'e|G<[W~fbM ß ¤ |G[¥^I|i¥,^|~ f6^ f||i +fbþe¨|_C['u|~£i^[|G'e|G<6'|~\ib§'[¥<WI6|C ¤ |~f\e^i[i'fe\G'e|G6 f

Page 81: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

±6 u«Ó7 ª­Y5©p(ŬC­6%4*¬C%(kL+*¬C+®\=*L pz¯®%4®

0

100

200

300

400

500

0 100 200 300 400 500

10

10 2

10 3

FD_E1

FD_E

2

2 %43657&³Ó78G7s:.;=<E>pH#@Cµ¨W=FQ[\<ITY`tFG@CTU]CP.B=PQ@C>ÃOA<B=OM<`A<IT>AFGT=o<IT=<OAo$Ô)@_K?>A;=<³`A<RI@CTUW¶rY`M`AFQ@$TW<V>M<RV>A@CO#DC<OM`AaU`<T=<IOMoCÔ@_K>M;=<drUO^`t>rY`M`tFG@CTÃW<I>A<Rv>A@$OM`b:.;=<"o]&>A<"@CT\>A;U<"B=OM@C[\B>.RV@CFGTURIF µW<ITYRV<SHsFGTUW@&HJx6<V>pHq<I<T>M;=<N>pHq@r6`A`AFQ@$TW=<V>A<Rv>M@CO^`s]_TUW«>A;U<S<IT=<OAo$Ôo$]&>M<`s]COA<N]_B=BUPQFG<Wb

6~f<f¥<' ÍX['T|i®|~6'G'e||G#|~i[i fË<G'e|G6 f# Å ~fiiff+[I|G'|~fI|%'f[¥<¥^I|G'~'Ë<|G/5Ifi' ¤ <%<|~£^ f[|G'e|G<6C+ <6[C|GIbË<R|~W''e|G^iW^i<f<ig¥^<i ¤ |~ii¥^~T|~fI¥<'I|i[i'[1< |~®'f[¥<ç¥^I|G^©|~#|G6 f#£i^ ¤ I¥^ 'T|R~f<|G#W<< Å ~f|>I¨>fi '^f<KG'e|G6 f ¤ |~,e<'iI|^ç[|_C['s|~fR£±^ ¤ I¥^ 'T|'[¥^'i¢~i£f¥^ f ³ )Ða Å ~R'[¥<É¥^I|G' iI¥<[|~' ã Î~f<f'+

Page 82: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Ó78G78³²"Ë%z%(­Y*Ý­[sLŬCË­6®®®+¬_%4­6*l%4* &U¬_%(­Y*J¬=**L>p(® ±

¤ <<|~¡£6^[|G'e|G<¢I6Ifii'~'a f[i¥u|~fiG'e|G6 f, Å ~'[6¥<¥^I|G' ¤ <X|~f#£i^x[|G'e|G<6u'e's~[®I<iG fG'xix|~<f<ia+K ¤ |~|G6e^if[+'fe'Ni|~u|~u6'[

¦Æ¸M ´¿N¾0ÂGÂIò $xÂzy½c¾ Á0Á¼Á0½d@ÂIò ò ¾M½g¿S@ÂIòµy¿5ò ò½%ÀÁ

Å ~f£6^ue^NG'e|i^,iKfiG|G6i |G'WË<[ iI¥<ËII6[|_ ¤ '<e|^,6~<¨'+[£-£¥^ ³ 1Õ,|~ I||i^i6~b ¤ <|~ 6~f<'iif[i fi¥|¶ÜÎÔV|G<ie| Ö Å ~Æi'¦|£[I|^u ¤ 6~<f'i5+u|~fiK<|iN[£',<

10 2

10 3

10 4

5000 6000 7000 8000 9000

B-group C-group N-group O-group F-group

Channels

Cou

nts

(×10

3 )

10 2

10 3

10 4

6000 6020 6040 6060 6080 6100 6120 6140 6160 6180 6200

C

C+H

C+H+H

C+H+H+H

C+He

C+H+He

C+H+H+HeC+He+He

Channels

Cou

nts

(×10

3 )

2 %(3Y5L&³Ó8G²7u:.;U<¶R^;U]COAo$<W+µ¨BU]_OA>AFXRVPG<Õ[ua=PQ>AFGB=PGFGRIF >pÔ BUPQ@C>M`b·òTw>M;=<°PG@&H#<O³B=FXRv>Ma=OA<°>A;=<Ö@@$[\<WÕOM<IoCFG@CTÇHsFQ>A;°>A;=<®nµçPG<]$WFGT=o³BU]COt>MFGRIPQ<«FG``t;=@&HsT7b©s<]CRv>MFQ@$T)R^;U]_TUT=<IPX`RI@CT>M]CFQT=µFGT=o>A;=<$ BU]COt>MFGRIPQ<`s]_OM<ÛFGTUWFXRI]_>A<Wb

Page 83: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

±,~ u«Ó7 ª­Y5©p(ŬC­6%4*¬C%(kL+*¬C+®\=*L pz¯®%4®2)¸ Vº¹ zÏ Ê è ë¶|e»¯¼[½)¼§Ï Ê Ý ë=¾À¿1.¼ Ï Ê ë=¾À¿ Ø Ô ³ iÏbÖ

¯<ue<W<K|~82)¸ VÁ¹ ¤ <X|~¡ú¼\¼\¼\®'<e|^§6~f<ff'i ³ Ï ²IÊ o£-|~ <|G|G^ +e| ¤ £¥^ ³ 1Õ®Çe[a^ '¡[¥^i^ ¤ <Æ~f<f'+Æif[i fi¥RúiÆ~fbM Å Ii ³ iÏii|<iB<G[Ë<'É'<e|^6~f<ff'i|~|~f'Æ'iI|iË<ai'if[ Å ~®6<f^ ff|G6<e|^sK<W[ ¤ <6 ' ¤ <<iK6'<e|^ª~f<f'i'Å ~\~f¥^~[KiiWi| ¤ <|~\6<f^ée^ f¦|CK< ¤ ^ fW|G¢/ÏbÙ× ¤ |~\f^ |[£-|~XC<¬¡ ¤ `[[¥<|GÂ)Ã>ĺÅå£ ÕfÏ ¦ |~RÐ Ê ­®[ÈÑ Ï 'Ò¼ÞÝ è Ý Å ~'<e|^<®G| ff'Z Å ~f±I||^ ¤ |~¡£6^ e^#G'e|i^ÌbË<[Õ Ê fXy['¦|'<e|^x~f<f'+<f'G'¦|G'M Å ~#e^ IiG^ç ¤ |~#6~fI6¥<'¨I|i[i/ |i+[|'¾ Æ Õ¡<f|<i'x+|~iC<6¬<fs+i£ ÕfÏ ¦ i ~siç|Ii³ ² %°¡[<®e^f[i f|~fI|^ N'iI|Ë<'i ¤ ^iÌ|~^GÆ '<6 '#iÝ£ ÕfÏ ¦ ~fi~,~f<#+WiiING[| <fu'<e|^6~fI6<e|G[iG|i[[

Å ~¡eË<[6I¥<É ¤ |~¡G^ii <¥^iaª|~fÉ­®i\¯f<I °<i[|G'e|^GG|G'Ói%ie^ [|G< Å ~[6 ¤ <<a'<e|^u~f<f'i%iif0Wiif'T|£'®Ô ¤ <e<W<¦<,áü\5'<e|i^X~f<f'|~ |~I|i[i5'[Iif¥[|G'e|^iKi'¦|£f'X<N<,áæ'<e|i^R~f<f'VÖ Å ~e<'e|^,['f'X|G<f|<+X|~f<e| f<Z±I||^,iNf'e6',iu|~ ¤ ^ii¥ G'e|i^

¦¸b ÇɾM¾M½d@ Vòå ¯y½Þ¾M½g¿S@ Vò uy¿5ò ò½%Àǽ%À6ó Áßoe<'e|^ç [|~faÉ<¢f<^G'Éi£ ÕfÏ ¦ Å ~X<ii'® ¤ |~XW[|~aiW|Ge<'e| ¤ <X|~®I6|i[' ~i6~s'6[I0'©[|G'e|^§f #|Gife^ ±[|GebË<[6I¥< ¤ |~ ¤ f+NG^iix<f¥^#a|~f[|G'e|^©GG|G',5£ ¤ $È 1NÉ"ÊV iW|~f '< 6',ai'i ¤ <'<e|^®~f<f'zËCC/[<,56|GÆ<#'µ¦ fI|i^

È 1OÉÊV S>Ì V Ì/Í Î ÁÏ 1Ì Ø Ô ³ ² Ö

[6 V Ì +%|~f<I±ii|_/|G¢<G[Ë<\'<e|^u~f<f'[Ð<C6'<e|^X~f<f'ËÛ Î ÁÏ 1Ì iK|~Æ|G6 fÆai'i, fWW'ubË<[<iM^±6'<e|^®~f<f'i'~fi~[<#|~[6 ¤ <0<f|<+'# f+¥|~i¦Ë<[6^Ñ!

$Î ÁNÏ 1Ì SV ì ÏV Ì Í

È 1OÉÊV Ø Ô ³ )Ð^Ö

Å ~W<Ii+|>WI|G6P¡|G<G[Ë<X'<e|^6~f<ff'q, Ì ^ |Æ ¤ ®a f/[ ¤6~f<'i®% V e^¦|<ifi¥¡<iK'|G|G'çI|i[i'¢+¥^Ë<'MC< 6 ¥<¥<'G|G'xi£ ÕfÏ ¦ fif¥Wi^W+<0iG|G6± |^¯!

V Ì @ ÓÒ % V, ÌÕÔ ÍsÖ4×XØÌ @ Í Ô-Ï»ÖÌ @ Ö É"Ù ì ×XØ Ø Ô ³ 1Õ¦Ö

Page 84: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Ó78Q²L8ã­UË&+¬_%(­Y* ­ÕÅ&U¬_%(­Y*ݬË=**L>pq¯%4>p4k® ±7±

û'<e|^®~f<f' û5'iI|iË<a'+MÙ ²¤ ¤\¼ Îa Ê^²¼\\¼ ³<³¥¼\\¼\¼\ ÊTã<ã¼\¼\\¼\¼\ Ê<Ê=¥

² ÏI ³$¼ Ða1Õ<Õ$¼$¼\ )Î ³<²$¼$¼\$¼\ ÊTã Ï$¼\$¼$¼\$¼\ Ê<Ê Õ

\¼ ã ¥¥\¼\¼\ ÏI ³¥¼\\¼\¼\ ²^ãI²¼\¼\\¼\¼\ Ê Ð<μ\¼\\¼\¼\¼\ Ê<Ê Ð\¼$¼\ ÏI ³<³¼\\¼$¼\ 1Õ Ê^²¼\\¼\¼\$¼\ Ê^³ μ\¼\\¼\¼\$¼\ Ê<Ê^³¼\$¼$¼\ ²<³^ã¼\\¼$¼\$¼\ Ê^³Iʼ\¼\\¼$¼\$¼\ Ê<Ê=¥¼\¼\\¼\¼\$¼\$¼\ Ê<Ê^²¼\$¼$¼\$¼\ Ê^²¤¼\\¼$¼\$¼\$¼\ Ê<Ê^³`8 ² )Î ¥`8(¼\ ÏI Ê=¤`(¼\¼\ ² Î Ê`(¼\¼\¼\ Ê Õ Ê`(¼\¼\¼\¼\ Ê<Ê Õ`8(¼\ ÏI Ê Ï`8(¼\$¼\ ²<² Ð`(¼\$¼\$¼\ Ê^²<³`8(¼\¼\ 1Õ ãI³`(¼\¼\¼\ iÏ Ê Ï`(¼\¼\¼\¼\ Ê Ï ³`(¼\¼\¼\¼\¼\ Ê<Ê^²`(¼\¼\$¼\ iÏ Ê<Ê`(¼\¼\¼\$¼\ Ê Ï ¥`(¼\¼\¼\¼\$¼\ Ê<Ê Ï`(¼\¼\$¼\$¼\ Ê<Ê=¤

Page 85: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

±, u«Ó7 ª­Y5©p(ŬC­6%4*¬C%(kL+*¬C+®\=*L pz¯®%4®· ÏI ãI³·$¼\ ãI²¤·$¼\¼\ iÏ ³ Õ·$¼\¼\¼\ Ê^² Ï·C$¼\¼\¼\¼\ Ê<Ê^²·$¼\ ³<³ Ï·$¼\$¼\ iÏ<Ï'з$¼\$¼\$¼\ Ê<Ê=¥·$¼\¼\ ²<³¤·$¼\¼\¼\ Ê^³IÊ·C$¼\¼\¼\¼\ Ê<ÊTã·$¼\¼\$¼\ Ê Õ Ê·$¼\¼\¼\$¼\ Ê<Ê^³

· ÏI ³¤·¼\ )Î ã з¼\¼\ iÏ<Ï ²·¼\¼\¼\ Ê Ï'ηS¼\¼\¼\¼\ Ê<Ê Ï·¼\ 1Õ ¤ η¼\$¼\ Ê^³<²·¼\¼\ iÏ ãI²·¼\¼\¼\ Ê ÐÏ·S¼\¼\¼\¼\ Ê<Ê Ð·¼\¼\$¼\ Ê Ï'Î

ú ÏI ¤ Ðú¼ 1Õ ¥ Ï

ú¼\¼\ Ê=¥<³úu¼\\¼\¼\ Ê<Ê=¤

ú¼\ )Ð ¤ Ïú¼$¼\ Ê Ð<Ðú¼\¼\ iÏ<Ï ²

úu¼\\¼\¼\ Ê Ï ³Ò ÏI)Î ã

Ò\¼ ²¥ ÏÒ¼\\¼ Ê ÐÏ

Ò¼\¼\\¼ Ê<Ê^²Ò\¼ ² Ï<Ï

Ò¼\\¼ Ê Ð ¤

Page 86: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Ó78Q²L8ã­UË&+¬_%(­Y* ­ÕÅ&U¬_%(­Y*ݬË=**L>pq¯%4>p4k® ±,Ò

á ÏI ¥ Ðáü\ iÏ ¤¤

áü\¼\ Ê ÏeÕáü\ iÏ'ÐÏ

¯ ² iÏ<ϯd¼\ Ê=¥ Õ

Ò Ða ãI³Ú ©zp4Ó78496uÛ ZB6<IOMFQ[\<T$>^]_PGPQÔ@Cx=>M]_FGT=<W)BU]COt>MF >MFQ@$T)@_Ks>M;=<RIOA@`A``t<Rv>MFQ@$T)@&DC<Ou@CxY`t<OAD$<WOM<]$Rv>AFG@CTR^;U]_TUT=<IPX`Ib

úK~fI¥<'¨I|i[ û'iI|Ë<'i0Ù û'iI|Ë<Æ'iMÙ¢ f|±ii[|_ ÔV|~fiN<¬fÖ Ô7`Z[[¥<|G<¬fÖ¾ þÏ ³¥ ã ³<³ 1Õ¾ ² ²<² ã ²<³ iϾ ÌÐ ³ ã<ã ³ )Î ã¾ §Õ ÏI)ÐÏ ¥ ÕfÏÚ ©zp4Ó78XgÓÛ ZB6<IOMFQ[\<IT>^]_PGPQÔ @Cx>^]_FGT=<W BU]COt>MF >MFQ@$T @_K >M;=< RVOM@$`M` `A<RV>AFG@CT FGT

R^;U]COAo$<W+µ¨BU]COt>MFGRIPQ<Û[ua=PQ>AFGB=PGFGRIF >MFQ<`dRV@$[BY]_OM<WÃHsFQ>A;E>M;=<SOM<`Aa=P >^`.@_Kz¬<I<o_>M<Ü ÝUøßÞçb£-ª|~i'µa fI|^

ÖÌ @ iX|~&ÍX['fes|Gs[|G'e|u|~I|i[ ¤ e[|<ii|Å ¥<[|u|~£f<f<I+i|>sWI|GPsC¡I fi¥|~ ¤ <e|G<6fe'I|i^ ¤ |~f6<Iiii|'[¦1< V Ì ³à @ V Ì @ Ø Ô ³ )Î^Ö

`[| fX~b ^®e< ¤ <] V Ì @ <fá V Ì !8£ ¤ |~#'<e|i^©~f<f'Ði\ú¼\z<f®|~fiWIR6~f<ff'ÑËKi\ú¼\¼\¼\oÔ ² ±I|i['úÌ<f¶zIf6'G'T|ÖM|~'F, Ì þÏ<f% V ÌÐ<Æ|~f<I±ii|_WI|G6 V Ì ¿+8[<i[ iI|G'< V Ì ¿ Ò Ð

ÏÔ ÍsÖ Ï¿ Í Ô-Ï»

Ö ¿Ö è ì Ï ÐÍsÖ ¿ Í Ô-Ï»

Ö ¿Ö Ý Ø Ô ³ ³ ÖÅ 6Ëi<i<iu|~f+N[<G V Ì"â Ö"â gß\fM£±f<i<|~Æ<Ii+|>a V Ì i V Ì V ÌâÕÍ V Ì ¿ÌÐ

ÍsÖ4âÕÍsÖ ¿ Í Ô-Ï»Ö ¿Ö Ý Y Ô ³ ã Ö

1<@|~5 [|~fa 6'i'@^ |~N' ±6i[<ii ¤ ^ f ¤ <e|G<6fe'I|i^W ¤ e^cG'e|^ÔOG[ <iÝ£ ÕfÏ ¦ Ö Å ~W<i ^G/ ¤ |~ If+i[I|^ ¤ |~fi [|~i^

Page 87: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Â7á u«Ó7 ª­Y5©p(ŬC­6%4*¬C%(kL+*¬C+®\=*L pz¯®%4®û5'<e|i^ û'iI|Ë< '<6 ' û5'+I|Ë<e<'e|G'6~<f' 'i±Ù ai'iMÙ¯8¨¥<^

¯ ¤<³ ¾ Ê ¤ ¤<² ¾zÐa)ίd¼\ Õ Ê ¾ Ê ² ¥ Ê ¾ÓÏI)Ð

ᨥ<6^ á ¥ Õ¾ Ê ¥ ³ Õ¾zÐa ³

áü\ ¤ iÏ«¾ Ê ² Ï ³ ¾ÓÏI ²áü\¼\ Ê ¤ ¾ Ê iÏ Ða Ê ¾ Ê ã

áü\ ³ Ê ¾ Ê ² Ï ã ¾ÓÏI ¤Ò¨¥<^

Ò ã Õ¾ Ê ã Õ ã ¾zÐa ¤Ò¼\ Ï'о Ê )Ð ÏeÕ¾ÓÏI Ê

Ò¼\¼\ ÏI1Õ¾ Ê iÏ Õ ¤ ¾ Ê ¤Ò¼\¼\¼\ Ê iÏ«¾é Ê Ð ÏIiÏE¾ Ê 1Õ

Ò¼\¼\ ÏI ¥ ¾ Ê iÏ Ï Ê ¾ ² ÊÒ¼\ ¤ ¤ ¾ Ê )Ð ² оÓÏI1Õ

úC¨¥<^ ú ³ о Ê ³ Ð ³ ¾ ² ¤

ú¼\ Ï ³ ¾ Ê )Ð Ï ² ¾ Ê ¥ú¼\¼\ ² ã ¾ Ê iÏ Ða ã ¾ Ê 1Õ

ú¼\¼\¼\ Ê ² ¾é Ê^² ² 1ÕǾ Ê ãú¼\¼\ Ða ³ ¾ Ê iÏ Ï'ξÓÏI ¥

ú¼\¼\\¼ Ê )ξé Ê Î ³ iÏE¾ÓÏI ³úu¼\ Ï'о Ê ² Ï ³ ¾ÓÏI)Ð

ú¼\$¼\ ÏI Ê ¾é ÊTã ¥ ¥ ¾ÓÏI ³Ú 9©p(Ó8X[Å<]$`taUOA<W]_TYWRV@$OAOM<RV>A<WBU]_OA>AFQ>AFG@CT«@_KL>A;=<SRVOM@$`M`q`t<Rv>AFG@CTY`Kz@$O.qýYýK ]_TUWÝOM<]$Rv>MFQ@$T«R^;U]CT=T=<IPo$OA@$a=BU`b[<G+B|G/[|G[6iNe<'e|G'Xai'if ¤ <g|~5'<e|i^W6~f<'ic ¤ i¦|G['G|%+¬<áü\<Cú¼\$¼\Â;kã[=£-É£ ÕfÏ ¦ f[|G'e|^&Í['f[' ¤ </|~fR¯<6I6°<i[|G'e|^GG|G' [/ea+i[|R '< 'Z Å ~ÆËI<i ' ¤ <\f[|G'e|^¶z<I|i['B[ ¤ ^ ff|G ÊØjãÊ <f ÊØ)³ Îa¦'0'e|iË<'<@´ |G|~5W<ii[ebË<[6I¥< ¤ |~/G^+i®<¥^ia#|~¢­if8¯<KI6°<i8f[|G'e|^Ga|G'¶|~f&Í['f[i'is^ fX[<GI<i['T£|X+W<iGÉ+ <|<T| |G '¦|^x|~fI|C ~f<RiI¥<['<¶<'f+¥I'uie^ I6i^|~å£ ÕfÏ ¦ Å ~i~f<<i<çi <e|¢^|~X&ÍX['fe'6 f|¢</|~fR<¥^ iI¢iG|G6± |^¡i¢fXy['¦|

Page 88: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Ó78Q²L8ã­UË&+¬_%(­Y* ­ÕÅ&U¬_%(­Y*ݬË=**L>pq¯%4>p4k® Âð

¤ <|~f«z<f¶¢I|i[i'/ÔOG[¢£f¥^ '\ÎaiÏ/<Îa)Ð ¤ £ Õ Ê+¦ Ö°¡[|G[6i'&Í[i'f[' ¤ <|~ÇÞ<f¸R±I|i['/¦G^Ëi¥®'µa fI|^ ³ )Ð<f|I¬i¥|~Wii/ ýËI<i ' ¤ <K|~&Í['['K'<fi¥/|G0^6|Ë<'iCi Î ÁNÏ 1Ì <G|I6|i¥Xe^f|^ ¤ <XG'I6~MÒe|\|<'µa f'®|~fI|$#ä]å VXæ.ç #ä]å V ø#Ï æ ~f[]# i/|~ue<'e|G's'i<fh¾ i/|~R~fI¥<'¨±I|i[,¢ f|+i[|><á fN&Í['feu' | ¤ ^ ffu|~fi5buI6

Ö ¿É ÊØ Î ÊX¤ <¼±I|i[Æ[|G'e|i^<f

Ö ¿q1 ÊØ Ð<Î ¤ <«W±I|i[W[|G'e|i^M Å ~WaG|G'I|i [</iÖ ¿ <fÖ ¿1iN|~ÆW<+,[<+u|~Æe<'e|G'ai'i ¤ < ^G|~f<f'iÆÔO[[<5i

|~5+<G|ge^i fW ¤ |I ³ )Ð^Ö Å Ii ³ )ÐiiG|B '<6 'W<f e<6'e|G'W'+I|Ë<'if ¤ <|~ ¤ ^ \¥<^ ¤ '<e|^6~f<ff'i)!K¯¨¥<6^ ZZᨥ<^ Z0Ò5¨¥<6^ <fúC¨¥<6^ xÔO1<Æ¥<^ ±C[ ¯á¢MÒ×<fúæI|+['\C[Wf[|G'e|G'±Ö£-|Ii ³ 1Õ|~f®I|i|^s ¤ |~'<e|^§6~f<ff'iiX~MK~'s^ç^¤ 6I¥^ '¦|ÔO¯5á¢KÒÍ<,ú5Ö~f<X['©[|G'e|G'Z1<¥^I|G^§|~ifI6'<e|i^ª6~<f'iW<xG[®|~f®e^T|G |^x ¤ f^¨ifI6É6~f<'iW|GÉ|~If±I'T|ifI6X'<e|i^~f<f' Å ~¦ [ ¤<³ ã<ã ³ ÕR<fÎ ³ ÙR'0'e|iË<'<[f \|GW¢ifI 6'<e|^M Å ~[6<6KI'G|iWI|G'u|G '|~'#Î Ù¤ <5|~+fIX~f<f'+5<f#I|i'<G|ÆÏ Ê Ù ¤ <5<|~[6~f<ff'i[Ð if¥®|~,e<'e|G'çËI<i '¢ ¤ |I' ³ )Ð<f ³ 1Õ^fu[<s[<+[ fiI|GR|~

'+I|Ë<%I6||^ ¤ <BfXy['T|s| P¼[½ Å I ³ )Îi+G|Z|~CI||i^ ¤ <@ffy0['¦||QP¼½ ¤ <|_C[<G'fi6[ fG'IË<< Å ~W£6G|[<Gui~[W^X¥^I|G'^~f<f'ic+TË<^Ëi¥'<f+¥±I|i[ÆÔO¯8¨¥<^ Zᨥ<^ ^Ò5¨¥<^ fZaúC¨¥<^ f0ÖÅ ~ii~+®|~/|G< ¤ ^ \<'+ ¤ |Ii ³ )Îa Å ~G'e^f[<G i5~'¥^I|if¥u+\f^/^¡¯á¢Ò</úæ^fÔOb[ ¤ ^ f\±<'i\ ¤ |I ³ )Î^Ö Å ~'6 f|KiiG|G'uiu|I± ³ )Î ~f'Ë<|~[<6[~fi6~uI ¤ ^ii¥¢|~^GÆ+u|I³ )Ð,<fi[ ^ ¤ |~W'6 f|i¡|I± ³ 1ÕÔOG[XI0Ë<Ö Å ~ 'G|6~f^ie¤ <5<G[6Ëaif¥¢±ifIX|G6<f ¤ [5'<e|^5iNaX¥^I|+¥W^#W6i¥^I|+[<

Å /6 fWWI6ze[5|~fig~fIf|G['a<f|<+'W|~I||^ ¤ |~5£6^We^6G'e|i^#bË<[\<iM<[Ë<'#'<e|i^®6~<f'i[ Å ~Ʀ [5 ¤ º`8¯¨>¯B¯xe^+f[P¨'e'q¤F¥+%i|~<[C ¤ Ï Ê ÷ ¤ <C'<~u ¤ |~\<iW'<e|i^R~f<f'+[ Å ~I6|i<¦e6^cG'e|^ ¤ <B|~á§6~f<ff'<< fW+¥|~fC£6^/f<I+i|>|GÏIaiB'G|iWI|G'W|GÆÎ<Î^~fi~ iNÏ Ø ÕÙþ ¤ |~N|G<|<'<e|^Xe^gG'e|i^ÔVÕ Ê<Ê<Ê /0ÖWú<'e|i^f\C[W< fi¥R|~W [|~fa'e'IË<W<f|~\I|i|^W ¤ |~f'i<6Ga[+I|G'X|~XXy0[6'T|S| P¼[½ K<f[|G[6Wi'Zµ£|K< ¤ ^ ff,|~I|5|~ ^|Ëy'e|Ë<¥^I|Giu|G6±Æe^if[if'feÆ<f<iN~f^ fiÆG[|N^ i¥^I6|i[<

Page 89: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

 u«Ó7 ª­Y5©p(ŬC­6%4*¬C%(kL+*¬C+®\=*L pz¯®%4®

û5'<e|^ û5'+I|Ë<e<'e|G'6~f<' ai'iMÙ

¯¯ ¤<³

¯d¼\ Õ Êá ã<ã

áü\ ¤ )Ðáü\¼\ Ê ã

áü\ Ï'ÐÒÒ ³ Õ

Ò¼\ ¤ ³Ò¼\¼\ ÏI ã

Ò¼\¼\¼\ Ê iÏÒ¼\¼\ Õ ³

Ò¼\ ²IÊúú Î ³

úu¼\ Ï Êú¼\¼\ ÏI1Õ

ú¼\¼\\¼ Ê )Îúu¼\\¼ ã ³

ú¼\¼\\¼ ÏI ³úu¼\ Ï ã

úu¼\$¼ Îa ¤Ú 9©p(Ó8G²7,m ]_OA>AFQ>AFG@CT@_K7>M;=<NOA<]CRV>AFG@CTR^;U]CT=T=<PG`qHs;=<T«@$T=PQÔ@CT=<ÛKzOM]CoC[\<IT> Ú qýYý9K¸@CO.Üq;U]C`.x6<I<TÅW<V>M<Rv>M<W Ú `A<I<N>M<VZ+>^ÜVb

Page 90: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Ó78Q²L8ã­UË&+¬_%(­Y* ­ÕÅ&U¬_%(­Y*ݬË=**L>pq¯%4>p4k® ÂBA

û'<e|^®~f<f' |QP¼½ û5'+I|Ë<e<'e|G'¥<^ ai'iMÙ

¯¨¥<6^ ¤IÊ ¥ ʤ Ï ¤<²

á\¨¥<^ ¤IÊ ²Iʤ Ï Ï ³¤<² ³ Õ

Ò5¨¥<^ f ¤IÊ Ï<Ϥ Ï ²¥¤<² ÏeÕ¤ Ð Õ ã

úC¨¥<^ f ¤IÊ Ï'Τ Ï Ï ã¤<² ²Iʤ Ð Ï ²¤ Õ Ð ³

¯ ¤IÊ Õ Ê¤ Ï ¤<³

á ¤IÊ ÏeÕ¤ Ï ¤ ʤ<² ã<ã

Ò ¤IÊ Õ)Τ Ï ²<²¤<² ¤ )Τ Ð ³ Õ

ú ¤IÊ ã )Τ Ï ¥ )Τ<² Ï ¥¤ Ð Ï Ê¤ Õ Î ³Ú ©zp4©Ó8f,m ]_OA>AFQ>AFG@CT@_KL>A;=<SÔ+FG<IPXWKz@$OdWFèª6<OA<T$>?äÑéê ë Ú `A<I<?>M<VZ+>^ÜVb

Page 91: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

 u«Ó7 ª­Y5©p(ŬC­6%4*¬C%(kL+*¬C+®\=*L pz¯®%4®

Page 92: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ì ívî-ïð ¨ñòBhñóh 6ñó 6i¡¢aB£-|~fi~fIf|G[|~fW<f<i ¤ |~Wå6ba '< 'Éie^if[i'e |~ºq`¯É<X¯B¯iiff'G'¦|G'M Å ~\<f<iCif[i ff'%<[[ 6I|G6<^â6 ¨|G6<e|i^MC´\<fi[6~f ¤ |/e<'e|i^fW<fç¡¢ f|iG|G[£f|G|if¥ae' R|~~fI6<e|G[6i|i a¨6bG'e|G6 Å ~fi~fIf|G[Æ+iZ e^f[i ff'|~,fi-¨[ f6^, ¤ |~/ea[6iW'T|<M6' f|5<®e^ IiG^#|~,|~^G/<f|<i'®¦|~/¦ f[i'IG¨>[¬uea[6+ 'T|<f#|~ea[6iW'T|5 i¥ |~/ea|<Z¬¦¨if¥¢|G'~ffiµa <

ô ¸6¹ §Éñ ½Þ¿5ò¿5ÀVÁ6Á

Å ~fW<iª ^G, ¤ |~®|G6i®e^i[i'fe#|+ <f<ia+i|Ge|G6<e|,|G6 fe^if[if'T|6b¨º`8¯§¨>¯B¯G'e|G6 Å ~W¥^I|G'If+' ¤ </|~ºq`¯8¨¯B¯ªe^+f[i'fe<f<i<f|~£^®'[¥<#¥^I|G ¤ |~/[Ëai^ fG'e|i^'<i§Ë<i+©i§|~f6ae'f fIf±i'©|Gs|~|G6e^if[if'fe¡<f<i[á|~Æ<f|^u ¤ |~¢\/[|G'e|G<\f[',e^i['Z£-£f¥^ f ã iÏg|~C|i gffy0['eg[|>['\%[|G'e|G<B<fÆ|~%£f6G|M£6^[|G'e|G<Xi~bM£-e^WI6iG^i|~£¥^ ³ iÏu|~uf^ f|e^if[+'fe+fbý+Æ/ 6~i[Æf |G®|~×6+G|i W ¤ |~R[|G'e|G<,ÔkõoÐ Êf"Ö<f,ËII6iI|^fN+u|~6~I¥<e^i'e|i^,|i <

¯B¥^ f ã ² iR|>I¨>fi 'f6^f<|i G'e|G6 fô~bi¥É|~f|iWf ¤ ¨¤ ['feW[|_C['#G''e|G'~^Gi6~¡[|G'e|G<<f¡|~fW£f6G|£±^¡[|G'e|G<Ë<[66 f|~f|i fXy['fe/[|>['|~f\[|G'e|G<Æ<f|~¢£f6G|£^®e¨|G'e|G<' Å ~#f6^ f|e^i[i'fe#[|_C['©|~®£6G|<fª|~®G'e^ª£6^[|G'e|G<K<\'µ¦ '#<i Å ~/+T|G'fË<[|i[<@iif[f'G'¦||~f6^ f|e^i[i'fe'0[|_C['©|~~^G+6~x[|G'e|G<,<fª|~®£6G|W£6^x[|G'e|G<~ie^T|<+fi¥W<f^ e^+f[i'fe'5|~,|~ \/f[|G'e|G<' Å ~[+ fG|G[5 ¤[Ë<'¦|c<i¥^'¢~<6ze[^T|<ii\'G'¦|8|~fCf6^ f|8e^+f[i'fe'8[|>['|~5\[|G'e|G<5<|~\£f6|%£6^Xf[|G'e|G<' Å ~\fiI¥<^f<0iif ¤ [i G|G[6Cf'G'¦|f6^ f|/e^+f[i'fe'¢[|>['ç|~®\,[|G'e|G<W<f|~u~f^Gi~[|G'e|G<bÅ ~fue6^i¥¡^i¦| ¤ |~f'G,|~[®+i'e^T|<+f |~,f6^ f| |G6±Re^+f[P¨'e'[ Å ¥<[| |~u|G6 fX|G6iXe^+f[i'¦|¢0'e|G®^,~f<¢|G ff|G6<e|¢|~6<^ýe^¦|G6 |i^f ¤ 6^z|~5f6^ f|B^< Å ~N<f^ýG'e|G6 ze^T|<i|~ue^¦|G6 |i^ ¤ ^ |~[u|>a'/ ¤ [Ë<'T|[ Å ~£6G|i~'É|~fX£6^[|G'e|G< i/i¡f6^ f|e^i[i'feW|~¡|~X~^G+6~'/<fÉi6<f^ eI¨

¥ Î

Page 93: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Â7~ uâ Ú Ë%4p(ŬC­6%4*¬C%(kL+*¬C+®\=*L pz¯®%4®

2 %43657&â8496CÛT=<VµòWFG[<TU`AFQ@$TU]_P&>MFQ[\<nW=F«ª,<IOM<ITURI<`tB6<RV>AO^].xY<I>pH#<<IT?>A;U<#?<n]_TYW">M;=< rY`M`AFQ@$TW<V>M<RV>A@COb:.;=<NB=OM@C[\B>do]&>A<NFX`.FQTYWFGR]&>M<Wb

if[if'fe,|~ç|~\[|G'e|G<b Å ~#G'e^f©i ~'x|~#£6^s[|G'e|G<iÆif^ f|Æe^+f[i'fe|~|~,\[|G'e|G< <f+¡6<f^qe^if[i'e|~|~~^i6~f'[Æß|~f¢|~6|>a0W+~'®|~f £^[|G'e|G<+\+6<f^îe^+f[i'fei|~|~\[|G'e|G<¢<f¡i6<f^îe^+f[i'fei|~|~\~^G+6~'[ Å ~f6<ff^â ff|G6<e|^fe'f \¦'< |~fI|K|G6i

Page 94: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

â84968 Ú %4'°U*L9p4¯®%(® ±

2 %(3Y5L&â8fg":.Hq@_µòWFG[\<ITU`AFQ@$TU]_Pd>A;=OM<I<Iµ(Kz@$PGWl>MFQ[\<ÕWFèª6<OA<TURV<`tB6<RV>AOMa=[Eb6#@$FQTURIFGW=<ITURI<RI@CTUWFQ>AFG@CTx6<V>pHq<I<IT>M;=<N>pH#@rY`M`tFG@CTEW<I>A<RV>A@$OM`.FX`d]_BUB=PQFG<Wb

6<^Óe^if[i'e'ÔV|~f0^+T|C^ |if\|~f[+ fG|G[6K '¦|^'±ÖC[<ue¨¥^'e|G'sÔOi ¤ <e||~[IË<[6 f|G<e|G'¦® ¤ <e|G< ² Öß\|<\e'e|G'|~6<f^ åa¨6'¡G'e|G6 e^fi| ¤ |~^W+f<T||I6¥<[|Æa¨6''i¤ ^þ|~´6'e|e£_^fze'I|^ fe'[ Å ~f^ f|g<f|~fN6<f^ý0'e|GI~fb#+u£f¥^ ' ã )Ð<f ã 1Õ'0'e|iË<'<

Page 95: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Â7 uâ Ú Ë%4p(ŬC­6%4*¬C%(kL+*¬C+®\=*L pz¯®%4®

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

80 85 90 95 100 105 110 115 120Energy, keV

Cou

nts

2 %43657&â8G7LmnOA@$[B=>Û>MOAFGB=PG<RI@CFGTURVFXW<IT> õ Z+µ¨OM]ËÔE`ABY<Rv>AOMa=[ào]&>A<W³@$T³>A;U< OM<]$Rv>MFQ@$TR^;U]_TUT=<IPçb

ô ¸Gï ´Ä Ä À6½g¾zÁyÅ4xe s¾M¾M½d@ÂIò°§~f'|~f/f6«-'e|ii/a f[' f|G6<f ¤ [6\W<\|GR|~/|I6¥<[|Ʀ f[i' f[|~f Å `8¯ii y0[5 6'e^i Å ~[6 ¤ <<a¨6bu0'e|GWIÆ´\<f[~f ¤ |G'u<f,f^<¨''M Å ~Æ´\<f[5~ ¤ |N[<®0ef''#<

ö÷ É ÷ Ô-ÏÛ¼ùø2 e^7¿¦Ö Ø Ô ã iÏbÖ[6à ÷ iK|~fa¨6bX'[6¥<XiR|~'e^i6'G| ¤ 6<W< ø i|~Ë<'[|>X ¤ |~f'e^iK<f¸¿+/|~fR<¥^iX[|>['ç|~R'e^iKf6'e|^É<f|~R<G[6ËI|^f'e|i^+®|~ iI<6I|G<6®GG|G',/ß\ Wi¥X|~fI||~«-'e|iiWbË<'i|~'<ÓË<'a[i|><¬i'WI|i[<M[<+[ fiI|^f[[ ¤ < 'MB°§i|~u|~fiK< fW¨|^< ¤ ^z|~0^6|^ ¤ |~5±~^Gi~W[|G'e|G<'|~'e^i'e|^W<|Ë<'[|>X<K[|G[6i'MQ£-|~f+CK'¿/< ø I6f[£' ¤ <K'<6~#ifI[Ë<'T|[

Page 96: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

â8Xg8iª«­Yp($î%úç¬$­UË&+¬_%4­6* Â7Ò

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

80 85 90 95 100 105 110 115 120Energy, keV

Cou

nts

2 %(3Y5L&â8G²7d]CTUW@C[ã>AOMFGB=PQ<RI@CFGTURVFXW<T$> õ Zµ¨O^]ËÔ`tB6<RV>AOMa=[ o$]&>M<W@CT>M;=<ÆOA<]CRV>AFG@CTR^;U]CT=T=<P(b

Å ~[ ¤ <<ifI'<e|^#~f<f'iÆÔúÒÜ<f#áÆÖC[ÆG''e|G'®<fR|~e<6'e|^fW^Æ ÷ C[Ifi'ç[Ë<'¦|-¨i< Å ~f,' f| ¤ |~fiWfe'f i^fsf6<0[ ¤ <RiIç'<e|^ 6~f<'i[51<æ~[Ý|e»¯¼[½¸¼|ûP¼[½ ¤IÊ ¼âÏ Ê Ï Ê<Ê þ¯<ue< ±<N~'ª|~¶ºq`¯ýi,áåÔp|e»¯¼[½È ¥ Ö<fª|~Å `8¯Ìi Ð Ôp|QP¼[½ ¤<² Ö&£|K</~f<0'É|~fI||~f' |i¥# a¨6bG'e|G6¤ ^é|~fiKf6ae'f f^ fiu~fbË<Æ ~fI[KG|G6 fe| f<~b[Ë<['f f\|G |~f$ü±¨6bX±<¬a¥<^ ffM±fi[ f6G'uiu|~Æe|G'e|^ZfWe^f[i f6^,[<#6bMb[Ë<['|~fÆ< ^ f¦|N ¤ ´\<fi[5~f ¤ |<,f^<'i¥<u¦¨'R0'I¬R^ fi y0['[<<G[6Ë<'a®<f<iYe'if¥|~¢6<f^êG'e|G6 f#±~f[|I¥<[|6baG|<^ f|uÔOG[u£f¥^ f ã 1Õ¦Ö£-|~R6<f^ a¨6'G'e|G6|~RW^G|i¦|G'fGX \ Ï 'I¬¡K</~^G'M Å ~~ ¤ |/<ff6^<'fi¥® ¤ |~fi'I¬¡K<[|G[Wi'<\ ¤ ffe|^® ¤ |~¢'<e|^6~f<ff'@''e|^M Å ~6' f|I~fbi£f¥^ f ã )Îa¯f^q|~iÆf6ae'f f<8^fX[<e^f[i fX|~fI|/´\<f±[~ ¤ |B[\W<i^/~f¥^~'|cË<i fN ¤ZÊØ)³IÊ ¬<[ÈÌK< ¤ ^ ffWiW|~[<G ¤ ¥^I|+¥

Page 97: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Ò7á uâ Ú Ë%4p(ŬC­6%4*¬C%(kL+*¬C+®\=*L pz¯®%4®

Z_PLF

Dop

pler

shi

ft, k

eV

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

6 7 8 9 10

2 %43657&©â8XÛ@CBUB=PQ<Od`t;UF Kf>dFGTEúC<Iû ]$`s]Kza=TURv>MFQ@$TE@_K¯ý@CK7>A;U<mu¬7qb^x|~úÓ'<e|^©6~f<'©ßÍi+'IW['f'fe, ¤ ´\<fi[~f ¤ | ^x|~f|e»¯¼[½ÉK< ¤ ^ ffZ Å ~¯8°É­ ¤ |~Æ \ Ï 'I¬XiNie'<G',a ÊØ Ï ² ¬<[ÈÜ^'Ë<[6I¥< ¤ <<iM'<e|i^#6~f<'i[

Ò^¨ifI6~f<f'+/[<<G[6Ë<'iÉ|~X¯f<I°<+C[|G'e|G<W<W+fIu6~f<ff'Z~'®^ ¤ |~f ¤ I¥^ 'T|\'[I'\[|G'e|^M Å ~[|<i+C[6fi6[ fG' iW|~5f[Ë^ f%6~fIf|G[bdC[Ë<['|~f+gi +'@|~fI|C<[Ë<'T|-¨iG5´\<f±[%~f ¤ |ge<6'e|^Xi'<fc|G/Æ5^¥Æ6' f| ¤ <C~f<f'ig<|~[%|~f<|~W|G6 f ifI6~f<ff' Å ~ G^+ |^|G#|~f+Æi|G#|I¬<R~f ¤ |iT|G#<[e^ T|i|~ £f|G|if¥Xf6ae'f f/ ¤ |~ 6~I6<e|G[6iG|+¢¦¨6b'i[ Å ~fii\^i<

Page 98: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

â8G78³þÃÿMË$¯l®In+¬CI&©U*L9p4¯®%(® Òð

'[< fG|~´\<f[Kf6^<'fi¥iCË<[uW<iBÔ Ê iÏ ² ¬<[Èܯ@°É\­Öe^ I6'|G#|~fWea[6+ 'T|<g'G^i |i^xÔ-ÏIiÏ ² ¬<[Èo¯@° ­Ö8° ~'<ig'<e|^f/IfiWIuiI,'<e|^f\~f[/|~fEºq`¯©'['G'µa 'T|+<i<|~ Å `¯ªii ¤ f+W6~fI<e|G[6fe[',aÇ|QP¼[½% Å ~f~fI6<e|G[6+G|iG'e|G6 fé+if~f ¤ |G'a|~5<W^ fT|g+ffi[I|G'i¢£f¥^ 6 ã )Îa Å ~NW<i´\<f[Bf6^<'fi¥\i+T<iif[i ' i |~\'e6if|^ ¤ |~\6~fI6<e|G[iG|i0'I¬W6~fI<µ£-Wf<e|ie|~f+5i5<|WG|G^¥Xi +£[I|^M<^fR|~ÆiIX~f<f'iIÆ'i[Ë<¦|[ÔOG[|~Æ' |Niu|I ³ )ÎW ¤ [Ëai^ fNG'e|^±Ö

ô ¸M ¦¾M¿sÚÁÄR½d@Â0¾M¿î¿5ò¿5ÀVÁ6Á

ß ¤ |G[[ ¤ <6Wi¥|~f6<^× ff|G6<e|^C\<f|<i'X|G6 |G6i5e^if[i'¦|G'e|G6R¥^I|G'¡^ËII6^ ºq`¯ n [ Å ~' fi|i¥X0'e|GRI6W~b+£¥^ ã ³ #üa'e|G6,~i|~fi£f¥^ 6IW[±if'i ¥ 6~f<ff'i[Z~i6~e<6e¨G^fZ|G Ê 1Õ¬<[È©i/a¨6'/'[¥<< Å ~^|^ ¤ |~N~fI6<e|G[6i|iKoa¨6''I¬ ¤ Å ~<f Ð if[i fi¥|~< fW'®´\<f[~f ¤ |[I6¢ifi[I|G'M £-|~f+K£f¥^ Æ<iM0'e|GWI<W<ife['u|GW'<~#<|~[\iu<6[|Ge^ I|~~I0'' Å ~®~I0' i¦<¬Ë<[xiiiI ¤ <|~®fXy['¦| '<e|^©6~f<ff'i[ f||~u'if¢IuG|I|iG|i[<+Éiff[0''T|[¡üa|G6 fe| f'¢|~fI| I,G['ç[<<|<i8[f''T|6~fI<e|G[6iG|i 6'[ Å ~[ ¤ <<|~e^f[i f6^[<W<f|~fI|.ü6ba ¤ ^Þ|~£i^ ¤ 6I¥^ '¦|e^¦|G6± |G<|ie'IuiR|~a¨6bu'[¥<,[¥^^Z Å ~a f[|GXea|G<e||~/µ¦ f<¦||I|Ë<¢i ¤ <6WI|^,I^ ||~< ^ T| ¤ |~ å6ba ¤ <Æ|~ ffy0['¦|'<e|^~f<f'+,G<~fi|i[I|G'<f<ia+Kfe'f iK'µa f6'M

Å u'G|iWI|G ~fI|'i e^ fiea'e|[M|~ Ú¦¨'0'e|GX±<G'^|~'e'T|%' f|g ¤ |~£^ + ¤ [|+ N[|G[6Wif'|~ |~5e6aG|<¬i¥ [|~fa £ ² Ï ¦ [ i¢ fiI|G'M Ð i¥R|~£6^+ ¤ [|+ '<|~fa f/[ ¤^ fe^+f[i'fe'Ô¨º`8¯8¨>¯@¯gÖC<f|<+'ui[Ëai^ fC~fIf|G[5|KiC^i5|Ge'I|G\ f~WÆG'e|G6 ¤ <%6'<e|^~f<f'iB ¤ i¦|G['G|[ Å ~K¦¨'ai'ifB[[<i[ iI|G's fif¥'µa fI|^ ² ³ ¤ 6~If|G[ ² Å ~u' fi|+¢6~bs+£¥^ ã ã £-X|~fi£f¥^ |~|G6 \|G6ie^if[if'T|KG'e|G6/¥^I|G',^R|~áæ'<e|i^~f<f'Ni~fbç|G<¥<[|~[X|~ç|~,+/ f+I|G'sG'e|G6súK^fi[i¥®|~f'GG'e|G6,[<se^f[i fu|~fI||~u£6^i ¤ [|i '[<s<|R^f¥<[ |~f<|~^<f|<+'X+ £ ² Ï ¦ gß\ Wi¥Æ|~I|C|~\£6^i ¤ [|iW5C[6\|_ie<K^¥<|~'6 f| ¤ ^Þ|~/ea|<Z¬i¥WW[|~a®C/C^ i#~fbË<['®IiÆ|G£É ff</¥^ f^ f|~X¦¨'6~fI' ¤ ^ |~ü¨6bÉ<6¬¦¥<^ fM Å ~fi/i|~£fG|+ <|<T|<G[6ËI|^ZgÒ<|G|~fI|NiR|~+/ f+I|G'XG'e|G6 â±<G'^R|~' | ¤ ^ £ ² Ï ¦ |~ Ð ¦¨'Ra'+'6 f|i¥ ¤ ^é+fI '<e|^ÔòÌZ¨|G6<f ¤ ["Ö\^ifI|G'[ Å ~'<G^Éi\|~ Ëy0'e|iË<W«G'e|^¡ ¤ f^¨ifI6

Page 99: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Ò uâ Ú Ë%4p(ŬC­6%4*¬C%(kL+*¬C+®\=*L pz¯®%4®

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150

F

O

N

C

ThU

Energy, keV

Cou

nts

2 %43657&â8GÓ77:LOAa=<>AOMFGB=PQ<RV@$FQTURIFGW=<IT> õ Zµ¨O^]ËÔ`ABY<Rv>MOM]o]&>M<WÅ@$TÅ>A;=<D&]_OMFQ@$aU`dOM<]$Rv>MFQ@$TR^;U]_TUT=<IPX`Ib\:.;=<\B6@$`AF >MFQ@$TU`?@_Kn>M;=<ÃR^;U]COM]$Rv>A<OAFX`t>AFXRPGFQT=<`N@_K#>A;=<:.;Õ]_TUWô FQTURIPQaYWFQTUoE>A;=<"@$B=B=PG<IO"`A;=FQKf>"]_OM<ÛFGTUWFXRI]_>A<Wb'<e|^6~f<'ia|~X¯<6I6°<iC[|G'e|^ÉaG|G'#£-¡|Ii ã iÏ|~fifI6Xe^¦|G6 |i^u ¤ |~<G[Ë<',±ifIX'<e|^®~f<f'+NIii|G'M

Å ~£f6G|ÆG|G[i¡|~W£±f<c<f<iÆ+|G#f[±IW6~fI<e|G[6iG|iX妨6bG'e|G6 ¤ <#'<6~|ûP¼[½ Å ~fiRfe'f 6+,'e6' iÌ~fIf|G[ ² Å ~f

Page 100: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

â8G78³þÃÿMË$¯l®In+¬CI&©U*L9p4¯®%(® ÒBA

30

35

40

45

50

55

60

65

80 90 100 110 120 130 140

ThU

Energy, keV

Cou

nts

2 %(3Y5L&â8fâ_:LOAaU<>AOMFQB=PG<#RI@CFGTURVFXW<T$> õ Zµ¨O^]ËÔ"`tB6<RV>AO^]so$]_>A<WÛ@$TN>A;=<.)OM<]$Rv>MFQ@$TNR^;Y]_T=T=<P(b#;U]COM]$Rv>M<IOMFG`t>AFXRNPQFGT=<`d@_K >M;=<:.;©]_TUWÅô]_OM<FQTYWFGR]&>M<Wb":.;U<I@COM<V>MFGR]_P`tB6<RV>AO^]Ã`t;U@&Hd`.>A;=<OM<`Aa=PQ>AFGT=oZ+µçO^]ËÔÔ+FG<IPXWÅ@Cx=>M]_FGT=<WEaU`tFGT=o>A;=<OA<`ta=PQ>M`"@_K >M;=<RIOAÔ`t>M]_PLx=PG@+R^ú+FGT=oÃ<IZ+B6<IOMFG[<T>Ü øÞ¨b'6 f|i¥¶¦¨'G'e|G6C[6 ¤ ^+'|~¢|~5e[6i '¦|<a'G^i f|^M Å ~'6e6f|^X ¤ |~i¥^a¨6'R'I¬X[<, ¤ ^ fuiuG'e|^#Îa)Ða ² ¤ 6~fI|G[Îa Å ~f#´<[~ ¤ |<fxf^<'f+¥¡fi[ f6G'çI®if[+ f'iç|~#K'

Page 101: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Ò uâ Ú Ë%4p(ŬC­6%4*¬C%(kL+*¬C+®\=*L pz¯®%4®áG[Ë<',±ifI |QP¼[½ ·KifI6

6~f<' e^¦|G6 f|^MÙú ¤ Õ Î ³Ò ¤ Ð ³ Õá ¤<² ã<㯠¤ Ï ¤<³Ú 9©p(©â8(9Y#FGTU]COAÔNRV@$T$>MOAFGx=a>MFQ@$TS@_K>M;=<#@$xU`A<IOMDC<W?x=FGTU]COAÔ?OA<]CRV>AFG@CTR^;U]CT=T=<IPX`bL:.;=<n>M]_xUPQ<

Kz@COd]CPQPOM<]$Rv>MFQ@$T«R^;U]CT=T=<IPX`.PG<]CW=FQT=o>M@\W=F«ª,<IOM<IT>?ä¯é[ê9ë°FG`d`A;=@&HsTFQTE`A<Rv>MFQ@$T=b ÝUb'e6i0'©i©|~[Ëai^ fX'e|^M Å ~¦¨6bª'ifC[6<f<iYe[' f+¥G[Ë<[6<fe'f ''C|G£fs|G~fi~sea|G'ªµa f<T|i|I|Ë<®'6 f|We^ f+xea|G<e|G'M

=sî,é7d=éÉ£|~i@fe'f C'<6~+ffËif f<<0'e|G fÜ¥^I|G' ^ e[|<i'<e|i^ 6~f<¨'0<K<f<iYe['RaXe'I|if¥¢¢^^Wi<<¬a¥<^ ff¡Ô ã |~u<6f["ÖcaW£f|+¥|~W'¦| 6<f¥<W ¤ |~W|G6 W0'e|GW°§i|~¡|~<W<ife'I|^ ¤ |~X~fI ¤ |~f+C±<¬a¥<^ ffu<5 ¤ [I6< [|G[N|~e[6i '¦|<G'e|G6¢C[£f|G|G'|G<¥<[|~[|~|~6~fI<e|G[6iG|ia¨6'®|G6 fe| ' ¤ <Ã| P¼[½ 6<¥^if¥ ¤ ^ ¤IÊ|G ¤ Õ Å ~£|G|i¥Wf6ae'f fÆiN<'#^#|~fWI|G6P,i¦Ë<[6^® [|~M Å ~f¦¨'I|G|G[É'e<¥^|^ae' i'e6'+É[|<i%iÉG'e|i^Îa)Ða ² Å ~X' f|Æ ¤ |~fiÆ£|/IXf'G'¦|G'+|I ã ² Å ~I|G|G[6'e<¥^f|^¤ <+i5f |G|~Æf''feÆ ¤ ü¨6b,'I¬a ¤ £±^ ¤ 6I¥^ '¦|[ Å ~fiNi['I6' ^f|G6I|G' ¤ ^Þ|~f£fi|G' f| ¤ <\| P¼[½ ¤ Õ'iK|~fI|I/<G[Ë<'¤ <XÒê<©áê'<e|^©6~f<'i[C~[,|~W+/ f |QP¼[½Ü+ ¤ С<f ¤<² 'G'e|Ë<'<CúK^fG'µa 'T|i |~fiCfe'f ¥^Ë<'K f[Ci+W| ¤ <|~'iX ¤6~fI<e|G[6iG|iN/6ba[ Å ~f6' f|B ¤ £f|G|i¥fe'f 6\ÏNiB±<|G|G' i£f¥^ 6 ã ¥£|~iB£f¥^ K|~N<|G|G'Xiif''T|Be[6i '¦|<|G6 Ne^if[+'T|cG'e|G6 ¥^I|G'u^R|~\Ò'<e|^u6~f<' Å ~\G^iiRiif'G'¦|%|~f'6 f|% ¤ |~£|<f|~Xf<6~'¨><|G|G'çiif f'G'¦||~fR+/ f+I|G'ÉG'e|G6 fq<G'^É|~f' fi|Æ ¤ |~X£^Éi ¤ [|i <f|<if'i£ ² Ï ¦ Å ®<f|<i®C[ii| ¤ <|~a¨6'u'ifK<®<|~[5fe'f 6ÆiK'µa f'M

=sî,é7d=é æÅ ~C[iiW|X ¤ |~¦¨' ai'ifRC[6G[|®i§|~ ¤ ^ii¥çK'<Þ¯<'<6~®'<e|^®~f<f'|~fÆ<6W<ize'I|^u ¤ |~fÆ'Ë<[6I¥<' fÓ ¤ <i'<e|^

Page 102: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

â8G78³þÃÿMË$¯l®In+¬CI&©U*L9p4¯®%(® ÒL

30

35

40

45

50

55

60

65

85 90 95 100 105 110 115 120 125

Np

Energy, keV

Cou

nts

2 %(3Y5L&â8Xñ:7OMa=<#>AOMFQB=PG<.RV@CFGTURIFGW<T> õ Z+µçO^]ËÔ?`AB6<Rv>MOM]"o$]_>A<Wu@CTu>A;=<eK¶OA<]CRv>MFQ@$TuR^;U]CT=T=<IP`A;=@&HsTN]C`W@C>t>M<WNPGFQT=<$bz#;U]COM]$Rv>M<IOMFG`t>AFXRPQFGT=<`@_K+>A;=<ÑK"B]_OM< FQTYWFGR]&>M<Wbzt+FQ[a=PX]&>A<WN`tB6<RV>AO^]Ú W=]C`A;=<Wµ¨W@C>t>M<W©PQFGT=<ÜN`A;=@&Hd`?>M;=<OA<`taUP >MFQT=oZ+µ¨OM]ËÔÅÔ+FG<IPXW©@$x>M]CFQTU<W©aU`tFGT=o>A;U<ÃOA<`taUP >^`N@_K>M;=<ÛRIOAÔ`t>M]_PUx=PQ@R^ú+FGT=o<VZB6<IOMFQ[\<T$> Ü =øÞçbÑt+@$PQFXWPGFQTU<dOA<B=OM<`A<IT>M`>A;=<dOM<`Aa=PQ>#@CK6>M;=<drU>#aU`AFQTUoB=OM@RV<Wa=OM<ø Ú `t<<Û>M<VZ+>sKz@COdW=<V>M]CFQPX`^Üvb

~f<f'i@[K£f|G|G'|G<¥<[|~[C|~/|~N6~fI6<e|G[iG|i¢6' ¤ <Û|QP¼[½ ¤ ^ ¤IÊ|G ¤ Õ+X|~fÆ< K',<5iRfe'f 6ÏI Å ~Æi'¢ ¤ |~fi£f|5i|GW'i+WifI|Ge^WW^hü 6' ¤ ^Ú|~#£6^ ¤ 6I¥^ '¦|[K|~[siiK #I6|W ¤ |~<6¬¦¥<6^ ffMcû5'6 f|i¥\'if ¤ ^z|~f+Bfe'f 5IN'G'¦|G'i|Ii ã ²

Page 103: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Ò7~ uâ Ú Ë%4p(ŬC­6%4*¬C%(kL+*¬C+®\=*L pz¯®%4®

2 %43657&â8Gü7$:LOAaU<n>MOAFGB=PG<qRI@CFGTURVFXW<IT> õ Z+µ¨OM]ËÔN`ABY<Rv>AO^]Ûo$]&>M<WS@$T>M;=<eK°OM<]$Rv>AFG@CTR^;U]_TUT=<IP`t;U@&HsT]C`qT=@$Tµ(rYPQPG<W;=FG`t>A@$oCO^]_[Eb¯t+;U]CW=<WÃ;UFG`t>A@$oCO^]_[ B=OA<`t<T>M`n>A;=<?r=>A>A<W«T=@$OA[]_PGFGÖ]&>MFQ@$T@_K,]_PGPOA<]CRv>MFQ@$TR^;U]CT=T=<PG`bÛ]&>MR^;U<W;=FG`t>A@$oCO^]_[ B=OM<`A<IT>^`7>M;=<.r=> FGTURVPGaUWFGT=oST=@$OA[]_PGFGÖ]&>MFQ@$T]_TUWR^;U]_O^]CRV>A<IOMFX`p>MFGR#ZOM]ËÔ`>M@Co$<V>A;U<IOb:.;=<OA<IKz@COM<CýC>A;=<Û;U]&>^R^;=<W]COA<]NFG`n>A;=<"Z+µçO^]ËÔBU]_>t>A<OATKz@COÛä éê9ë JösD=b£['®¢<G[Ë<|~fI| ¤ <|QP¼½ ¤ Õu|~/'i5'e^ / f~W<i[ ¤ <|~Ò<f,áæ'<e|^,6~<f'i[ Å ~f'6 f|% ¤ |~£f|G|i¥/fe'f \iK~bi£f¥^ 6 ã ¤ Å ~N~f<' G'e|G6 ziB|~5<6<ife'I|^ ¤ |~5'Ë<[I¥<'X ¤ <i¦'<e|^ ~f<f'i8£f|G|G'¢|G|~ea[6iW'T|<aG'e|G6 fÓÔO^¨£+'±Ö Å ~f

Page 104: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

â8G78³þÃÿMË$¯l®In+¬CI&©U*L9p4¯®%(® Ò±

|ûP¼[½ ¯B|N' | ù%< ¯B|' f| ùg<º%e'f WÏ ºg6ae'f f ²

ú¤IÊ ¨_Ð ã Ï ²^ãI² ¨6Ï ãI² ²^ã Ϥ Ï Õ Ê Õ ² Ï ã ¨ ³<² ² Ï ¥¤<² Î ³ Ï ² ÏeÕ ² Ï Ê ² ÏeÕ¤ Ð ² ÕTÎ Ï ¤^ã ² ÐÕ Ï ¤^ã¤ Õ Î<Î ¥ Ï ¤ Õ Ï Ê Ð Ï ¤<³Ò¤IÊ ³ Î ² Î<Ð ÏeÕ ² ² Î ²¤ Ï ÕTÐÕ Ï ¤¤ ³ Ð Ï ¤¤¤<² ¨6Ï ã Ï ¤<² ¨ ² Ð Ê Ï ¤ Ф Ð ² Ï ã Ï ã+¤ ² Ð ¤ Ï ã+¤¤ Õ ³ Õ ³ Ï ¥IÊ Ð<Î ã Ï ¥ Ïá¤IÊ ã+¥ ² Î ¤ ² Ð ² Î ¥¤ Ï Î ¥ Ï ²IÊ Õ ¥ Ð ²IÊ Î¤<² Ð ³¥ Ï ¤ Î ÏeÕ Ï ¤<³¤ Ð Ð ¥ Ï ¥<² ¨6Ï ²¥ Ï ¥ Ф Õ Õ ã Õ Ï ¥ Ï ¨_Î ¤ Ï ¥ Я¤IÊ ¥ Õ Ï ¤<³ Ð<ÐÕ Ï ¤ Õ¤ Ï Õ ² ÏeÕ<Õ ¨6Ï'Ð ã ÏeÕ<Õ¤<² Ï ¤¤ ÏeÕ ² Õ<Õ ÏeÕTФ Ð ¨6ÏeÕ ã Ï ²¤ ¨ ² Ï ² Ï ²¤¤ Õ ¨Õ ² Ï ²¥ ¨_Ð ³ Ð Ï ²¤Ú ©zp4â8fg,s<`Aa=PQ>M`s@CK7>M;=<Nr=>daU`AFQTUouBUOA@RV<Wa=OM<` Ú `A<I<N>M<VZ+>^ÜVb

~fI|~'WG'e|G6 Ü+B' f|+¥£f|g i¥\fe'f ² ^~f[K|~5<6W<+fe'I|^i5£f|G|G',|G<¥<[|~[|~u|~f6~fI<e|G[6iG|iÆ,6'[£-,|~/~fI|6~'®I|G|G[6®|~+fIÒo6~f<ff'Ôp| P¼½ ¤ ÐagÒ0ÖÆi<G[6Ë<'MB~fiW®'i f<c'i ¤ <|QP¼½ ¤ Õ¢'W<+f%Ëii<u£|KiC+ <|<T|C|G <|G|~I| ¤ <K|~±ifI'i ¤ ÒþWe^fi|G'T|N'6 f|5iK<f|<+' ¤ <5<|~ufe'f '[

Page 105: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Ò7 uâ Ú Ë%4p(ŬC­6%4*¬C%(kL+*¬C+®\=*L pz¯®%4®ô ¸b z½gÁà À-ÂÁþ¿5òóôó³6ÁLgÃÁ0ÁVò

ú^/ifif¥ ² fe'f 'fi[ f6G'#IbË<<0£i^#i ¤ [|i ii|N fif¥ 'µ¦ f¨|^ ² ³¤ 6^å|~fa¨6b©'ifR<f§|~¡e<'0^fi¥Éf^ e^if[i'eai'if,fi6[ fG' iÌ~fIf|G[ ³ [<Ì[<i[ fiI|G'M Å ~¡'[ËI<¦|#[<G'I6|Þ ¤ Ï ¥^I|G'^¡|~W¯ '<e|i^6~f<'.| ¤<² ¥^I|G'^¡|~fRáé'<e|^6~f<'L|É ¤ Ð¥^I|G'^,|~Ò¼'<e|^6~f<'f<f¶|É ¤ Õ¥^I|G'#^#|~fúÜ'<e|^6~f<'i[W<f|<+'M Å ~fWe<'G^ff+¥Xe[|I|^É'[¥^'I ³IÊ BÏ<Ï ¥ cÏ'Î<ÎaZ<f ² Ð Ê ­#[È¢M1<< Wi¥W±ifIu'<e|^i¦Ë<^Ëi¥ZÌg í `8¦<ÊË·K|G6<f ¤ ['I'G'e|Ë<'i<B¯f<@|~fK¯<fWáª'<e|^6~f<'i@^f|~ 0[5+iW|NI/'f fe'M Å ~ 0[5+iW|K f+¥ ®Ï)#e^£±'fei+W|IÆÏ Ø ÐCëÏ Ê ì ÏtÊ5c<f-ƪРØ)² ëÏ Ê ì ÏtÊN[^'G'e|Ë<'i< Å ~fKÒ©'<e|^ ~f<f'fËaif'/£f|GX¦ f/[ ¤ <¢|~X£±^i ¤ [|i !#Ô-Ï Ø ¤ ¾þÏ Ø Î^ÖÆësÏ Êaì ÏtÊ [ße^f[i f6^ ¤ <c|~úÉ'<e|^W~f<f'+@[< f<|@K6b¢0'[< GC|~fK<W^ fT| ¤ |~f¦¨6ba'+Õ¤ ç ? ¤ ? ì ¥¦°¡W'[<iB|~fI|/ife'f ,Ï'i ¤ <|ûP¼[½ ¤ Õ¢< ¤ ^ ff ¤ <K<i6'<e|^u6~f<ff'ig[6~fI¥<e^f[ËI|i^Ri<|N<i§|~i[<iGiRfe'f ² |~fiËy0'e|5e^ iu<|K0e^ i[|G''i+WP¨fI|G'M Å ~· '<e|i^®6~<f'MK<<|<f<6e['®<I|\ f~#~f¥^~,e[|I|^'[¥<,|~/6~fI6<e|G[iG|iƦ¨6b#I|G|G[6[<f<|5Æ<G[Ë<'Z Å ~Æ' |N ¤|~R£^i ¤ [|i I6Xii|G'Éi|I ã )Ю|G<¥<[|~f[ |~|~fXfI|<f|<if'i|~WeG|<c±a6¬a+¥uea[6iW'T|³£ ² Ï ¦ <¡i|~We[6i '¦| ¤ ­®^i|G<6+Â) >ĺÅÅ£ ÕTÐ ¦ £-å£ ÕTÐ ¦ X^¥I¨>iË<'®£i^®i ¤ [|i /e^ ^'T|<[Ë<'#i|~ ¶ ¥ ëçÏ Êaì ÏtÊ ¤ <zÕ Ê ­®[Èo<f ¶æÕuëçÏ Êaì ÏtÊ ¤ <ë Ï Ê Î#­®[È|~Xe<'G^ff+¥ ¤ 6<e|^f¶ ÊØjã<ã <fÕ¶ ÊØ Î ² 'G'e|Ë<'<gß\ Wi¥Æ|~f~<|-¨>+Ë<'¡£6^¡i ¤ [|i e^ ^'¦|Æ|G# Ê B1<,+ a<@iG|G6± |^M|~u f[¢+iW| ¤ <|~,'Ë<[6I¥<,£±^i ¤ [|i I6Õ§¶ ³aØ)² ëxÏ Ê ì ÏtÊR ¤ < qÕ Ê ­®[È <fƧ¨¶ ²aØ Ïuë©Ï Ê ì ÏtÊ ¤ < åÏ Ê Î­#[È Å ~#ËII6^ Ë<+ ' ¤ <Æ|~bË<[6I¥<X£±^¡i ¤ [|iWI6~¡¥<6I~i[<i®+£f¥^ ã iÏ Ê £_|~f^ fi#¢<|G'|~fI||~¢f'G'¦|\I|RI6 ¤ <fXy['¦|''W'T| Ô¨ºB Ð ÒÖN~f['<a f['ff fe'i®|~f<¬# ¤ £ ² Ï ¦ <f¸£ ÕTÐ ¦ 'Xy0[b\áfi|~fiBe[6i '¦|c|~N''W'T|g ¤ |~N£6^fif¥\a f['ic<e| <i[|G[6Wif'<|~^ ¥^~®|~/f' |G^#a f/0['W<if ffe[|<iZq£-#I6|i[ fiI5I|\bÜe[¨|I|^#'f[¥<XËII6^ NGa|G' WbR'<#|Ge^cie|+¥' f| ¤ <5|~/i ¤ [|i f |GXy0[6'T|5a f['I|G6 fe| ¤ |~<e| <Z¦ ['£-#¥<'[6<Z^/Wb,e^f[i f|~fI|5^ ' f|NI6/i,I¥<['W'T|\|~,|~f' fi|C ¤ £ ² Ï ¦Z¤ <N|~e[|I|i^u'[¥^'K ¤ Ï ²IÊ <fÏ'Î Ê ­®[È/b[Ë<['|~f f[iiWi|<f|<+' ¤ <|~Wb[e[|I|^'[¥<sÔ ³IÊ ­#[ÈÆÖ<|I¬aif¥i¦|G®<[e^ f¦|/|~Xea^'¦|i<gf'e'<G ¤ |~fW£i^i ¤ [|i < ¤ fe|^¡ ¤|~ue[i|I|^s'[¥<iff+[I|G'/|~I|¢|~f,' f|/ ¤ £ ² Ï ¦ <f'G'[i<i£ ÕTÐ ¦e^ fiÉ0 Ë<['G|iI|G'M Ð ¤ <6| ffI|G'<@|~XaG|G'I|i fe[|<i¦|>¡f W|G

Page 106: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

â8Q²L8+®5p4®=*LkÝk%4®¬C5®®%(­Y* Ò7Ò

ùc[6i '¦| ùg[i|I|^#'[6¥<<±­#[È ¯Bii^,i ¤ [|i §Ï Êaì ÏtÊ £ ÕTÐ ¦ Õ Ê ¶ ³ ²

Å ~iKC<6¬ ³IÊ ÆýÏI)У ² Ï ¦ ³ Ï ³ Ê£ ² Ï ¦ ¤IÊ Îa1Õ£ ÕTÐ ¦ Ï Ê Î ¶ ² iÏ

Å ~iKC<6¬ Ï<Ï ¥ ÆæÐa ²£ ² Ï ¦ Ï ²¥ ÐaiϾ Ê ¤

Å ~iKC<6¬ Ï'Î<Î ÏI ¤ ¾ÓÏI)Σ ² Ï ¦ Ï ³¤ ÏI ¤ ¾ Ê ãÚ ©zp4©â8G7Ys<`taUP >^`nKz@$Oq>A;=<?Z+µçO^]ËÔ\Ô+FQ<PGW=`.]CTUWRI@COMOA<`tB6@CTUW=FQT=ourY`M`tFG@CTÃPGFQKz<V>AFG[\<`.@CK7>A;UOA<<

WFèª,<IOM<IT>s<VZBY<OAFG[\<IT>M`b|~ü±¨6',±<¬a¥<^ ff#+u^ fI| e[i ff'NWG|G^¥XG|I|G' '¦|[

° ~['<@|ZK<8ea'e|G'/|~fI||~´'e|u£^ffe'I|i^6' ¤ ^æ|~%|I6¥<[|^ fi0|~W<iX<G|<[iW|~ff6'G'T|e0[i '¦|[¦ ¤ ^ ff|~fI||~ü±¨6bu<¬a¥<^ ff ¤ ^ |~Æ£6^ ¤ 6I¥^ '¦|iN|~fiiWi|i¥ ¤ <e|G<'ßþ®¨>6~'i^fe'I|^ f6<Iiii|>/+ |~5<6f[% ¤ Ï Ê ÙzC^ i 5 <\Iff<fiI|G< Å ~fie^ f+<6~f[Ë<'ua~¦^6i¥¢aG|G'Ó|~X¢~'bËa[N«-'e|+<¦~fi\G|iibË<^ifi¥ |~fÆffÍ[ fi|'K<G[iI|G'#i|~,Ga [|G6iGG|G'Þ<i £ ÕTÐ ¦

Page 107: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ðYáLá uâ Ú Ë%4p(ŬC­6%4*¬C%(kL+*¬C+®\=*L pz¯®%4®

[21][42]This work

Excitation energy, MeV

Ave

rage

fiss

ion

lifet

ime,

10-2

1 s

10 3

10 4

50 100 150 200 250 300

2 %43657&â849C+s<`ta=PQ>M`@CKU>M;=<.rY`M`tFG@CTPQFQKz<V>MFQ[\<s@Cx=>M]_FGT=<WuFGT®Ü =øÞ Ú rUPGPG<W>AOMFG]CT=oCPG<`^Üvý&FGT®Ü Ý+D ÞÚ @$BY<TERIFQO^RVPG<`^Üq]_TUWFGTRIa=OMOA<T$>sHq@COMú Ú @$BY<T«>MOAFX]_TUoCPG<`^Üvb

Page 108: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

¨ñóóa¨ñó 6ñ ¨ y lƸ6¹ w/à ñ ñ ¿N¾Ú¿5òó s\òEgÀ6ÃÁVòÁ

£-®|~i|~f'iC<¬®|~¢I|G^i/[ia6¬® [|~ ¤ < '< i¥£±^i ¤ [|i 'K<[Ë<'<'M¯<|~ [Ë<'i< '¦| ¤ |~ I|G^Wi[¬® [|~fa|~[ea¨[6iW'T|[Æ[ ¤ <6 'MQ£-,<ff|^Za|~f|~[<R ¤ ''e|G6^WI¥^[|i|G<¨i|^f\i®GG|G'W|~WbËi¥u6~fI¥< e'¦|G[6K<<fIf|G'|G,'e6i0|~a¨6'u'W+^,f f6i¥¢£i^M£-|~u£f6G|¢e0[i '¦|/|~,~I0R ¤ |~fu~fI6<e|G[6+G|iX¦¨'çG'e|G6 fK<5G| f'MQ£_|< ¤ ^ fu|~fI| ¤ <|~Ð Ê ­®[ÈÑ Ò$¼ Å ~#[<GÆ|~f/ |^fe'I|^f<I+i|>ÔV|~W<f|^f<8àc¨>~f'i:Ö~f<u¥ui <e|i|~e¨ |i¥G'e|G6 f×<f[<0[¥^'e|G'M Å ~iBC<6¬ <% i+~'i°£1Ð ã$¦ <f WWI6fe['i®~fIf|G[ ² úK^fe[6fif¥W|~~fIÆ¢~fbË< ~bi6~fI|G[² ~bÓ|~R6~fI<e|G[6iG|i[ ¤ |~X ¦¨6bÉG'e|G6 f ['ff^É|~fX£6^i ¤ [|iW<,úK<+[ fiI|^fÆC[X[ ¤ < '¡^<i ¤ ß\f~^i|Æ|~[<Æ£1ÐÕ ¦C¤ <|~ffy0['¦|£^Ri ¤ [|i '% ¤ |~ Ð ¦ f[i'Q£_|< ¤ ^ ffR|~fI|NI|Ni ¤ [|i ¤ I^ |Ï Ê ì ÏX|~fWa¨6'G'e|G6 q^G'¢|/6~fI6<e|G[iG|iX~fI<I£É|~G'e^Xe[6i '¦||~\'e|K®¨>6~'ii^ffe'I|^Xf<I±ii|_¢K<N[|G[6i'¤ <N|~< '<e|^#~fi'µa f6if¥e^if[if'fe'K|~X'i<G|i[<+[I|G|G['ÒuI|i[''ß Ë<+ X ¤²aØ Ï#Ù ¤ <|~,¨>~'i^fze'I|^É<Ii+|>K< '<6 'M Å ~fiK<¬u|~#' f| ¤ <<|~[\+¥^~T|N±I|i['< i+~'ui£1Ð ¥¦ <f,6 fWWI6ze['X<i+R~fIf|G[ ² C¯<5|~|G6<f ¤ [N'<e|i^fK|~fiËI<i K<N[<'#<6 fWif¥|>~f< ¤ |G6«G'e|G<,e^iiii^f[û£R|~|~fi6e[6i '¦|[|~fI|ic|~ ¤ [ f% ¤ |~fic|~'6i[^ 6baC[ '<6 '+We^if[if'fe5|~W|~£6^ ¤ 6I¥^ '¦|<f^ |G¥<^+¥±I|i['[ Å ~iI¥<'|/f6<'î ¤ <e'i|~ü¨'®±<¬a¥<^ ff'W|G|G'a,£i^ ¤ 6I¥^ '¦|[ùc^|+¥W|~6~fI<"¨|G[6+G|i¦¨',I|G|G[6#^ <f<iKae' 'K¥^Ë<Æ 0[5+iW| ¤ |~a¨6''if' Å ~Æi+W|NI+,|~Æ<6f[ ¤ Ï Êaì ÏtÊ [5á +iW|K<i ¤ <|~/^¥i ¤ [|iW' ¤ ^ ffçi|~ß\Ò$£N`̱a6¬a+¥e[6i '¦|)£ ² Ï ¦5¤ < |~ue[|I|i^'[6¥^'Æ ¤ I^ |RÏ ²IÊ <f©Ï'Î Ê ­®[È¢8~i ¤ <|~Xe[|I|i^'f[¥<¡ ¤³IÊ­®[Èý^ f[+iW|+<i[' Å ~fie^ iW'<|~I||~¢bË<[<i@' f|iifi[I|Ë< ¤ W<i[N£±^,i ¤ [|iW'[

ÒbÓ[| fi6[ f|~' f|Æ ¤ |~fi<¬ie^WI6iG^|~e[6P¨ '¦|<M'6 f|[~[6Xy0[6'T|N [|~fK[Æ fG' ¤ < '<6 6i¥¢|~£6^i ¤ [|iW<8ß\iea[6+ 'T|c[<5[i<£'¢<%'|~[%'e|5ÔV|~I|G^W+5[¬

Ï Ê Ï

Page 109: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ðYá u«ñ7 ­Y*¬sp(5L®%4­6*®=*kÝ­657p4­­<f¡|~Xea|<c¬i¥, [|~fÖ<iffi'e|WÔV|~a f['I[¬Ö]£¡|~ff'e|\ [|~f|~<[ËI±'6 f6~<\|~'i®' f|+¥ ¤ ^ |~f/I|G^Wi|G6<fi|^f<fR|~ea|<¬i¥¢I|G|G[6ffËa+|~f+ ¤ <WI|^RI0^ f||~£^/i ¤ [|i %+/\ ^G|ÆWa'¨>if['f'¦|MK'<e£-|~Kif'e| [|~¨aN|~<±G[ËII'5 6~#<|~' f|G^#¢ f|+i[|'[¦|~ü±¨6',¢ f|±ii[P¨|' ¤ ^é|~i<¦|K´^\û5'G^<feÆ'['u<fR|~'+f 'iCI f'<C<Ri± | ¤ <KÆI6|i[ fiI%Wa'i <6[|G/f'f fe5|~£i^Wi ¤ [|i <BßC¬bz<6'< ¤ ^Í6~fIf|G[ÐX|~ 'P¨>['ff'T|\<f<i\[<i'<|G¥^fi£[<T|iRffy0['¦|5'6 f|[á/<G'e||G|~iif'[i6^MK¯<e< i<|~,|~f' |G^[¬u|~£±^,i ¤ [|iWÆi5W<iX[|G[Wi',au|~i<|'W|G|G'R' |G^XI|%~i6~0^+T|g|~f<[[ 6<e ¤ |~fG|I|i|i[<±e'[<Xf<|'ii'É ^M&£-<TÉ[<<%<iC|~R+ff'e|ÆW'< ' '¦|iff+[I|GX~<6|£i^,i ¤ [|i '[£-¡|~ 'e'¦|Æ<¬ ¤ \^¦|6~fI-Â)>ÄÁÅ £ ² Ð ¦ |~£^|iWWfiG|G6i |^¤ <KÝ è Ð i|~ ¥IÊ ­®[ÈK<| ff' |~W|~Æú^/i'X´\af<i[<±<üa|I|iG|+[<%­#' Å ~f ' f| ¤ |~fi<¬<f<<|~f[<G'e|)!¥^I|i¥#^f[£6^W' f|G^fc<5´û§~<|G^f%i<G'%|~fI|¢< iN|G¢¢ f6~X~<|G[£i^+ ¤ [|+ '[¢á®f6'e|W[|~aC^ f+ I|G,<[Ë<W|~ ^¥<[£i^i ¤ [|i ''Ñ£ ¤ |G6 f<Ii|^ fiÆei<+|~C+I¥<Cffy0['e%[|>['/a f['I '< 6' 'T|%<f|~Nf'e|c [|~faf' Å ~fKbË<[6I¥<£±^i ¤ [|i <f|<if'|~#a f['I\[¬If<|G'f6|Ë<|GXi^¥Wi ¤ [|i '5<#<[e<6fif¥W|G|~f+|~[<[|i[<K<¬|~,f'e| [|~f ¤ <WW'< 6if¥®|~u£6^+ ¤ [|+ RI6|GÉ#f6 ¤ [6'Má£-s|~ ¤ ^iibif¥®6'G|G6ie|W|~f®fi[ ^ç|G|~®f6'e| [|~f[

Å ~/ ^'[ fiI¨<|<MG| X ¤ iI|G/£i^u|i '5a#­#^+|G<6iÂ;.ÄÁÅã ÕTÐ ¦'<fu|GxC[#+iW|X ¤ |~¡£±^©|i < Å ~' fi|R+ffi[I|G^¥I¨>iiË<'£i^Ée^ ^'¦| ¤ <®W«G<6|_¡ ¤ |~Xa fe'a f['Çb[Ë<['g|~'G' fi|e^ fi bË<['|iWI|G' ¤ <Æ|~f ¤ ^iibif¥R6'<G^f)! Å ~fWW<i'<G^i|~fI|N¦ ['I5<fuI|G^Wi\fe'G'NI6|G^¥^e^ f'uiX|~fiC<6¬± Å ~f¨>~'iM^fe'I|^,f6<Iiii|>WK<[|G[Wi'#< ¤ ffe|^u ¤ |G<|<8¬aif[|i'[¥< ^'û£- Ð ¼ Ð '<e|^W|~f¨>~'i<fW£^<Ii+|'@e^ fiWG|+i['ffXy['T|i,^<|~f[ ¤ <e|G<66 f6~<\|~I||i^® ¤ |~f¢'f[¥<^6bË<[|~ Ð ¨>ii¬< ¤ 6I¥^ '¦|[ Å Wif<'<G^IR|~X¢ f|i ^ffe'I|i^ÔV|~àg¨>~'iM<fZ'G'[i<i<|~f^ ¨>~'iVÖa~fi6~,i'<,|G ¤ <G|G[£+ii¥ ¤ |~ ¨>~'+~^TÔO"Ö<|~a f\|G#<ife'<¢ ¤ |~|G6 /¦¨6b'iZ Å ~fü¨6ba ¤ ^Þ|~£^ ¤ 6I¥^W'T|\i,|~Ʀ¨6b,[¥^^[<<ie^T|G |GÆ|G|~Æ'i#<<G[Ë<'i,^ C<6¬± Å ~Æ6'e'T|C<¬u ¤ ᢠß/% fibËÂ).>ĺţ ã<ã$¦ ±<G'¡^|~feG|<gia6¬aif¥,|G'6~ff+µ¦ f6i¥^®e^T|G6<ie|G<¡' |[Å ~5£±^ i ¤ [|iW' ¤ ^ fWi |~f+cC<6¬ ¤ <g|~e[i|I|^W'[6¥<¢ ¤ I^ |gÕTέ#[È i ã¦Ø Ðgë¢Ï Ê ì ÏtÊN[< |BI|B|~Ke[i|I|^'[¥</ ¤ I^ | ³ έ#[ȧ|8Iif

Page 110: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ñ78Xg85L"p(­­ ðYáBA6<%|G Ê £_|Ni'e'I6X|G '¦|^u|~fI|K|~£6^fi¥¢¦ ['±+X|~i%<¬K<ci¢|~N <5' f|G^[£['¦|B[¥^^,Ô ÝGÝ í_Ð Ö^ß<|~f[c'e'T|c<¬/ ¤ ü0 ß/ÇÆI<Wi<TÂ)/>ĺÅÇ£1Ð<Ð ¦ Z<iR±<G'^|~ ea|<B¬i¥XW[|~a6i¥^\<[Ë<' <e^¦|G6<fie|G<' fi|[ Å ~e^f[i f6^# ¤ |~i5<¬®ifi[I|G'|~fI||~ ¤ <e|^ ¤ |~f^¥I¨>+Ë<'W£6^e^W0^f'T|Ô ç Ï Êaì Ï_÷ "ÖciC'g|~f' ² ÙRÅ ~fW£i^fi¥,a f[' f/G| ff'Éi¡|~fiC<6¬¡< Ý ÏtÊ Å ~M Å ~' f|Æ ¤ |~eG|<C¬i¥ea[6iW'T|Õ£ ² Ï ¦ I6X|~u ^G|[|<ii'M Å ~u<ËI<T|I¥<u ¤|~f+g<¬iC|~ fG ¤ ~f¥^~¨Ë<'[|_W¦ f[i'±'<i¥Æ|G ¢'<i¥^ ^ f<f<P¨iKf6ae'f f<s[[Ëi'e ¤ <5|~fei|G'fe ¤ ^¥ i ¤ [|i e^ ^'¦|K< ¤ ^ ff,iu|~±a6¬a+¥/I|W[Ë<^i |i^fN<fu~[6|~£i^X|+ 'N[i ¤ [6' ¤ ^é£f||G¢|~f\±a6¬a+¥/fi[BßÌf<i'âiX|~fiC<¬K<|~fI|K|~| ¤ |~fC£6^fif¥5¦ f[i'Te^ fi¢<|@%[|G[6W+'M8ßx0<|G'¦|i<ii+I¥<[8<¨' i5|~fI||~^f¥I¨>iË<',£6^#i^ [65[<6~f<f¥<|~/¬i¥ 6I|X<f+<|GI6|~ ^¥R£^®|i '[ Å ~i+<iuXf<±' ¤ <^ [|~< ¤ <Æ|~'G a f['@|~W¨>~'+@~f^/ii@<baÆ0£+'Mã-¡<iBfi[ f6^fe^fe[fi¥Rf'e| [|~f\Xf+G|ife|^i\W<¢0[|_C['¡R~<6|-¨>iË<'<f ^f¥I¨>iË<' ¤ 6<e|^, ¤ £6^fi¥a f[' Å ~f+[i'I6uiffi[I|G'K|~I|'Ë<[6I¥<i ¤ [|iW'\I6if Í['¦|\|G6~fI6<e|G[fe[X#W'< ' '¦|[ Å ~f[WiÆ,G|G6^¥[' ¤ <f'e6f|i^#i,|G[6 ¤ i ¤ [|i /fiG|G6i |^f<<\^/<1¥i|~<¬u ¤ \^T|~fIÅ£ ² Ð ¦

Å ~' f| ¤ |~ £6^i ¤ [|i ¢<f|<i'¡+|~fi\C<6¬ 6¥<' ¤ </<ffP¨|^<8e[6i '¦|[~[6¢|~f/a¨6b^fe'I|^f<I±ii|_#~^ fi¢¢ f~iI6¥<['81<u®~f''Ë[f6«-'e|iiW~^ fi G'M Å ~I|G^Wi[a6¬ [|~[Ë<'i<0'i|~f+|~'iiRË<[f^W+i¥R [|~ ¤ <|~£6^i ¤ [|i '<6 ' '¦|[^^fe|~5[ '¦|gffÍX[ f|'@[<WKbË<[6e^W<%ß©+I¥<5<ËI<¨|I¥<W ¤ ^ Æ [|~|G# '< f i^ ea[6+ 'T|i¢ f|<f[^ f#ffy0['¦|'<e|i^®6~<f'i[±<ibi¥|~£±^,i ¤ [|iW\|GXÆ'f fe'#< ¤ ffe|^u ¤e[|I|^ç'[6¥<<súK~I6<e|G[6iG|+a¨6bI|G|G[ ¤ < '<~|ûP¼[½Ü ff</¥^ ¨^ f6#iff+[I|G'5~f+6~'' '¦|£6^f[$£^ \Ëai[¼'6 f|<f|<i'i|~fi|~'6iW'u£6G|G|G[ ¤ < ¤ 6|~[ea[6+ 'T|<B<f|~f[<[|i[<gG| f'[~f[\I|G^i\fe'G'NI fG'u<N¢|Ga^|GWG| fWa f['IN£6^Ra<Wi[¤ < ËII6[|_X ¤ |~Æe[|I|^#'[¥^'5<#GG|G'W[

Ƹ-ï ºþÃ/ÂÀV Å ~f®I|G^Wi[¬x [|~ ¤ <u '< 6+¥|~£^ªi ¤ [|i ®[Ë<'i<0'©i|~f+|~'iWb0WIi' ¤ < ¤ f|~[ÆG| f'[Å[6 ¥<¥<'G|i^f ¤ < ¤ f| e[6i '¦|Kii0Æfi6[ fG'M

ß ¤ ^iN¨> Xea[6iW'T|%e^ iW5[ ¤ <6 '' aif¥iI¥<[G^iiW<f¥^

Page 111: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ðYá7 u«ñ7 ­Y*¬sp(5L®%4­6*®=*kÝ­657p4­­ebË<[6I¥< ¤ <5|~ºq`¯f~i6~uK<<|<f|iW<Z+u|~fiKe0[i '¦|ÔV<1¥e^¨I'|G£ ÕfÏ ¦ Ögß\<|~[c<'Ü|~fI|c ¤ <e'i¢|~fiB<¬/iB|~fK+I¥<.ü¨6bai'i ¤ 6^ £6^ ¤ I¥^ 'T|' Å ~[6 ¤ <<@|~¨>~f'ic^ffe'I|i^f<I+i|>~^ f+WiI6¥<['WßÉ^ffe'I|^<Ii+|>®+|~ <6[Æ ¤ Ï Ê Ùêii@WG^i |i^#|Gu|~fif<'# Å ~fie^ fi®0¢<6~fi[Ë<'¡ fi¥XX~'bËai[\«-'e|+ÔV<1¥Cß5<ÇÆ"Ö

ß\<|~[e[6i '¦|Æ[<WW<f ^<+ ¤ |~fG| f ¤ ­#^+|G<6iaÂ;>ĺÅ㣠ÕTÐ ¦ ~[6#ç6ba [®f[|G'e|G'ªise^i[i'feu|~磱^f+¥6e¨<e|^a fe|[ Å ~[ |~fWG| ff'6'<e|^K< ã )Î#­®[ÈÆÑ Ý èvÊ Ð ¼ Ý èvÊ Ð ~[|~ƨ>~f'i±~f^'KC[6Æe'I|G'#iu ^¨[| fI|Ë< '6~<fi ÔOG[G'e|^#Ða ² <fR|~\f[Ë^ fG'e|^±Ö Å 'Ë<^i,e^Wii[I|^C[< f'u¦W|~f|>^¨>fi|i¥^ fi6~fIB£6^fi¥'<e|^6~f<'i[<<<GW [|G6iC'<e|^Ô ¤ <e<W Ð ¼ß\ ±Öe^ fi, G'#if|G'<M£-,|~fi5[<^fIgI|~[e¨ig[Ë<'T|/ÔV£^i¥Æ'<e|i^uff fe|[a^ |G¥<^i¥ ß\ ¨>i¬<I|i[<fuîa¨6baÖ[<We^f+['M_£- 6~É| ff'|~W¦¨6b¡'G^i f|^¡<f[<É0X¥^f ¤ ¨i[<¦|Éi bË<'e^ I6+¥|~|~u'6 f|Æ'G'¦|G'+É£f¥^ f ² ¤ £ ÕTÐ ¦ úKI ¤ fN´\<f[W6~f ¤ |¢e<6'e|^ª~'Ë<#|G¡#if[+ f'iç|~fie[6i '¦|[ßâ[I6I|GG| ® ¤ / fi|^ffe'I|i^ ¤ <Æ|~W~^G'¡6'<e|^~fbË<W|G#if|+<iR0[ ¤ <6W'<\' |i¥ a¨6b®'i ¤ ^ê|~^ ±/¨>~'+^fze'¨|^W'~f<fe'C|~5|G6 \ꦨ' 'iM Å ~fi%'<fg|G¢<WË<['G|iWI|i^X ¤ |~f£i^,i ¤ [|i <

ßÓ6~f<+'¥^i¥,e[6i '¦|Æ[<WW<f fif¥R|~fi ¤ [|i ¤ ,ËI<[<fei|~ àc¨>~'+~i6~iI^ |ÎëÏ Ê ì Ï_÷¢ ¤ <\|~fW^G|\+T|G'f¢à^"!$#Æiif ¤Å ~M Å ~f 60^ ¤ |~fiÆe[6i '¦|i|G'I66~ ¤ <|~u^¥I¨>iiË<'£6^e^ ^'¦|[×ßq~f<i'¥^+¥É<f<| f|> ¤ <,|~[<[|+[<G| ff'Xi+5|G[|G[6W+K|~5~fIK ¤ |~fKন'G'e|G6 fz<g ¤ ffe|^¢ ¤ £i^¢+ ¤ [|+ <Å ~¢<Ë<¦|I¥< ¤ fif¥ |~¢àg¨>~'i^ffe'I|^i5|~f/¢ f6~iI¥<[^ffe'I|i^f<I±ii|_<8¯B¥^ ¥ iÏ56~bg|~5àc¨>~f'i^ffe'I|^<Ii+|>Æ<g ¤ ffe|i^ ¤ |~5'f e' Ë<'[|>< Å ~f5^ffe'I|^Wf<I+i|> ¤ <C|~5'<e|^Ï Ê<Ê ­®[ÈÏ Ý ú¼ Ý è Ý Å ~MKea[6iW'T|<iiÉ<f|<if'ªi £ ³<³¦ Ni®Ï ¥ ÙRK~fi~xiÏ Ê |i 'iI¥<[5|~f',|~¨>~'+0i^ffe'I|^,<Ii+|>Wi,[ f'¦|5C<6¬±d·,6~a^if¥,~''Ë[f6«-'e|ii/|~f6<Iiii|>,i+Z[Ë<'¡iI¥<['£|~fi\e[6i '¦|~''Ëa¦¨>^if fe' ¤ fi^¨£i^x'<e|^|~§|~'< '[¥<ª ¤ ¤ [­#[ÈÆÑ e^ i5e^fi[6'M Å ~Nàc¨>~'+^ffe'I|^ e6^gG'e|^i|~fic[<Gi5Ë<[6®iI¥<uÔOI0^ f|\ά¦ ¤ <<GW [|G6i/GG|G' |~#|~/f«G'e|i/'[¥< ¤ ¤ [þ­®[ÈÆÑ ±Ö±± ||~f+5If'I'®f<||GR0|~/i+W|i¥f6<' ¤ <|~ff'G'¦|Z|G6ice^if[if'fecea[6+ 'T|[@­#<[Ë<['^iÆ5'<e|^+¬<gè Ý ü¼«ÏtÊ í °|~àx¦¨6b,[¥^^, ¤ |~ Å ~#e^ ^ ff,a f[' f ¤ <iiN<ifX0[|_C['®|~à<f a¨6'[¥^^ ¤ °Ü Å ~¢<i®<'¶e^ fi/¢ f|i^ffe'I|i^M£_|['f5|G0Æ| ff'#[I6I|G'uaR '<6 6i¥W+f[i fiË<àx¦¨','i,<i|

Page 112: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ñ78Xg85L"p(­­ ðYáL

2 %(3Y5L&³ñ8(9Y&% µò`t;=<PQP.FG@CT=FGÖ]_>AFG@CT¶B=OA@$xU]_xUFQPGF >pÔ)]$`\]³Kza=TYRv>AFG@CT @_KÛ>A;=<EOM<WaYRV<W°DC<PQ@RVFQ>pÔCbFGoCa=OM<NFG`q>^]_úC<TKzOM@C[lÜ )Þ¨b:.;=<I@$OA<I>AFXRI]_PW=]_>M]\]_OM<?>M]CúC<IT«KzOM@C[ Ü ')Þ¨bK<5^iR|~£6G|K|> ea[6+ 'T| ¤ <N|~fi|~'6iKC<6¬±%´ |GW|~f+I¥<àg¨>~'i8^ffe'I|^e^G'e|^|~'/|_C,e[6i '¦|u<|\'µa f¢ f~'<â|i <gß\fMT£±f<i<¦|~|Ge^+f[i'feea[6+ 'T|e^ fi0\^i|~Æ6< ÆK',<5K<^fÆiu|~[ 6'T|N<¬0

Å ~[IWW<¦®'<G^|G#e^T|ia 'G'I6~i|~ £f'+® ¤ ¦ f[i'I£-¨i^#f<Wi[Ni#|~a f['I5|G' [6I| fÆ[¥^^ ¤ ^ Ï|GRЭ#[È¢ÈgI6i^ fi'e' ¤ i ¤ <6I|^<f|<i'sG ¤ IWi|G[6WW ¤¤ 6ie|^çea&Í['¦|Fü8C<¤ 6ie|^G|G'¥<|~)(Ê|~XËII6[|>® ¤ f<'<®|~[<'''Ë<'<'~fI||~'[ËI<T|cf6ae''%i£6^ I<gß\iG|~µ¦ '|^ ¤ |~5|G6<f6|^ ¤ ^^e¨@|G|_CI¨ fiiI|^ '~f<fic'W<ic<'M Å ~[<[|i[<± 'iI#f[''ç|~fI|W[<xe^/iuËII6^ f¢<[ËI|i^f|GÉe^ ,|G¡e^ ±[|G'6e6f|^ZRùga[6iW'T|<ii|/'µ¦ 'Æe^f6iG|G'¦|/ '< f' '¦| ¤ £6^i ¤ [|iWiG|G6± |^ i¥|~I|G^iÆ[¬u<f,<|~[\f'e|5W[|~a[

Page 113: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ðYáL~ u«ñ7 ­Y*¬sp(5L®%4­6*®=*kÝ­657p4­­

Page 114: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

* +-, ./+021436587 9;:

£PÏ ¦)< >$|>= ~3ã"; Â@?BADC&CFEHG±úKù%ûÒãºHIKJ<¥LINMLO`QPSRINM"INTLGVUXWYZIKT\[ 77á G@Ï ¤¤ ÎV]£ ²$¦)< >$|>= ~ã4s Â_^"`acbdbeGÆúKùCûÒ ºfIKJLgLINMLO `FPSRhINM"IKTLG\ËLUiINjKPSJkW mlòð7ðonðA G

Ï ¤¤¤ ]£1Ð ¦ ûp]fßqWroJksSYiG>t&]ºrTuji]hv Ò Ô-Ï ¤^ã+¤ ÖwGcÏ ² ÐV]£ Õ ¦ ûxJLRDUiIKY5ßqWroJksSYiGfû U[Ë>]oJLyfzJV|m]ºrTuji] ± Ô-Ï ¤¥ Î^ÖwG ¤¤ ÎV]£1Î ¦~ ]o].·MLsjZYZUiIXGc°]8Ë"MLW yUXsSUXWBG.]]&PsjNNrVoYiGc´]gúrOdPSUXsSUi jZ"MuGMLW|

t&]±üuZLJ jKVPGht&]ºrTuji]h Ô-Ï ¤¥L ÖwG@Ï'ÎV]£ $¦~ ]o]u·MLsjKYZUiIXG]]PsjKNrVoYiGÆûp] ]üoPSUXO~jKjZUXWBG\º&]júq] Ò]úIKJkeiUXWmGº&] ·q]

Jks|roJVJLINWmGoMLW|t&]±üuZLJ jKVPGÒqis]ºrTuji]hv L~L Ô-Ï ¤¥^ã ÖwGcÏ'ÐÏ"]£ ãC¦ ûp]S·MLjKjiGp=ã)ÄXÂß~8~ßÂß9ãs7o) iÂß" ¡¢7owGÆüV£INPWogLUiIZ¤ÈUiINsM"goG·UiIwsPWu¤ UXP|UXsSRDUiIKg"¤>Ò UifJLIN>GÏ ¤¥IÊ ]

£ ¥$¦ Ç] ]7·MLoUiIXG¯j¥]h¦M+eXsTLGL]zJkO~O~jZUXWmGLºQ]MüuNr§oIKLUXjiGhMLWh|z¨]Lº&MLhsPG7ºrTuji]`BUiYZYi] ~L v Ô-Ï ¤^ã+¥ ÖwGm©L©<ÐV]£ ¤$¦ ·]jüD]·-rhMLW|M"INPmMLW|ªz¨]Ç«rMLsP¬Ve&eXMLO~MLWmGºrTuji]fûxU[Ë]m­ L Ô-Ï ¤¤ ÏbÖwGm© ¤ ©V]£PÏ Ê¦ Ç] «]·rM"YZYiGº&] INMLWog@ÿULGMLW|)·q]7qPssSUiIXG,ºHrTuji]ûxU[Ë]D­ AA Ô-Ï ¤¥L ÖwG ¤ ÎÕo]£PÏ<Ï ¦ o]·-sJVNVPG®] ·JkWUXrmGFo] û«]ÒqP°¯DGD]Mû MLW|oIwo£BGz±]MûxJLRDUXsGMß]o]üuPSUiIKGDMLW|

]0üu PM"YZUXKuPGfßqWWm]ºrTuji] ð7ð[A Ô-Ï ¤^ã+¥ ÖwGMÐ<Ð Ê ]£PÏX© ¦ Ò«]·-JkroIqMLW|co] ß]roUiUXsSUiIXG7ºrTuji]fû U[Ë>] 7~ Ô-Ï ¤ Ð ¤ ÖwG0Õ© ]£PÏ'Ð ¦ ]fúMLjKjKPWogoGTÈ¥]uzUiYKM"goG Ð ]uzJkjZUXsGoMLW|RÇ]ÒPPYKMuGYºHrTuji]aû Ui£B] ð6Â7 Ô-Ï ¤¤IÊ ÖwG

Ð ÐV]£PÏeÕ ¦~ ]0úrMLh|rINP>MLWh|ü]ºMLsGºHrTuji]fûxU[Ë]m­ ~ Ô© Ê<Ê Ð^ÖwG Ê ÎÕ ÏX©V]

Ï ÊTã

Page 115: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ðYáL hq²Vh³Q²w«´¥µ²/¶®·£PÏ'Î ¦ ü] ®]¸¦-]×úrBGÓ`f] º&]ýùfujZYZI§JkO\G¹MLWh| û«] ·q]º¦&PIKUXjZYZJkWoULG»PWYZUiINWUiY8jKPYZU

rYZYZ£Ñ!jÑ<ÑWVisSUXM"IN|M"YKMu]¸WVisSUXM"I]¸sm]¸jZUѼp½¾¿ÀÁ> Dlzá Ô-Ï ¤¤¤ Öw]£PÏ $¦ º&]júq] Ò]%ú-IKJkeiUXWmGdºrm]¸Ã¥]YKroUXjKPjiGgûP ZVjKhWPËLUiINjKPYZUXPSY IKJkWPWogLUXWmGNÏ ¤¥¥ G-hWu¤

£hRhsPjKrUX|m]£PÏ ãC¦ £Ä]fÃ@P'ÿJkjveiUigkPGÒ«] º&]üurhMXpG£Ä]HzªM+eXO~|M"IXGß«]dqM"YveXPSLJkoYZUXsPjiGMLWh| ºQ]dºMLsÅGºrTuji]fûxU[Ë]m­ ~nð Ô© Ê<Ê<Ê ÖwG Ê ©Õ Ï'ÐV]

£PÏ ¥$¦ z±]BÃqJkjZYiGBü] JL££DUXWMLmGBo]MÇpPjKPWogoGü]Mû§JkrhsGBMLW|lº&]8üuNroJLIwWmGºHrTVjX]û U[Ë>]v Ô-Ï ¤¥ ÏbÖwG ¤ ÐV]

£PÏ ¤$¦ Ð ]h¦MLWoJeMLW|\]B`FPwrYZUXWBG7ºHrTVjX]fûxU[Ë]B`BUiYZYi] ðY Ô-Ï ¤L Î^ÖwG © ã ]£© ʦ û«] roUiYZYKPÅG o]"UXsSgLUXjKjZJkWBGNÈ]ßËu|oUXPwrPSLJbËGº&] JksoRDU[Ë>GN·q]-M"LJLRhjKjZJkWmG

Ò]±ú-JksSJkWWhMuG ] Å M"gksPUXWYZULG±ü]ÇJL£DUXNTLGÈ¥] `f]fÇIwM'ËkNrVoG7]]oPsjKwrYiGù ]]gßqW|oUiINjNjZJkWmG"º&]cÒML|UXs°¤ Å IKJkWjZuPG`H]&)UXjKYZUiIKRDUiIKgoGCÈ¥]s·-UXssPWPÅGz±] `f]üV£DUiIN|hoYZJoGoMLW|úq]±üuYZUiINMuGºHrTVjX]ûxU[Ë]`BUiYZYi] Òð Ô© Ê<Ê Ð^ÖwG Ê=¤ © ãÊ Ï"]

£©Ï ¦ ¦-] Jks|oUXWRhMLO\GDz¨]DzcJLIZUXMLWmGDo] MLsPWmGù ]`QPÿUXWM"IN|mG7·q]`BJLYZYiG¥]ºÿUiINPSUiIGz±]Nú/roU[ËMLssPSUiIXG/Ã¥]-Ã@MLËLUiINgkWoULGû«]ÇpPINjKNrBG o]júq]?ºQJkPzeXM"YiGqo]KûxUXOdPssPSUXo¯Gúq]Tú-JkrUXWmG^ß«]`n JkPSIG ]ºfIÿU[ËLJLYiGuÃ]TüuwrMLO¥jiG]Ã@oINMLsÅGz¨] Å JksSUXOJkW|ULGMLW|Ã]kMLi¬VoUiYiG7ºHrTuji]fûxU[Ë]B`BUiYZYi]  Ô-Ï ¤¤¤ ÖwGÎ Ê ÏX©V]

£©L© ¦ ß]jü] Jks|rM"RDUiIXGºHrTVjX]`BUiYZYi] BAÆ Ô-Ï ¤^ã Õ¦ÖwGMÐ Êk ]£©<Ð ¦ £Ä] JkWYKwrM"IXGz¨]FzJLIZUXMLWmGFMLW|Éü] ·MLjKWM"INTLGùHoINJL£hrTuji]z`BUiYZYi] ± Ô© Ê<Ê ©^ÖwG

Ð<Î<ÎV]£©Õ ¦ £Ä]£w] JkWYKNrM"IXGMß] ùx] UiYZYKPWogLUiIG`H]1È] oIKTkMLWmGMLW|ª]>¨M"gkWoUiIXG ºHrTVjX]hJLy

ßYZJkO\]0Òhis] ~BA Ô© Ê<Ê<Ê ÖwG@Ï ¥¥ ]£©<Î ¦ º&] INMLWog@ÿULG`FP@kWo¤Nj@PWogoG/MLW| ] ß«])UXP|oUXWhO_§ssSUiIGNºrTuji]KûxU[Ë]q­ ±

Ô-Ï ¤¥ Ð^ÖwGm© Êk ÐV]£© $¦ È¥]z¨]LMLWWUXWmGºHrm]¸Ã¥]oYKroUXjNPjiGû P ZujKWPËLUiIwjKPSYZUXPSY IKJkWPWgLUXWmG© Ê<Ê Ï"G>Wo£>oRo¤

sPjKroUX|m]£© ãC¦ Ã¥]7qPsjKwroUiIxMLW|)]û JkjKjKWoUiIXGfßqWWm]ºrTuji]¦oI] ð± Ô-Ï ¤¤ ©^ÖwG±Õ ã Ï"]£© ¥$¦ Ã¥]o]dqPW|ULGHÃ¥]"PsjKNrUiIXG"]gûxJkjKjKWUiIXGÛ·q] UiRhMLUiIXG-z±]`BUXrOdMLWWmGMLWh|

z±]PsS£DUiIKYiGºHrTVjX]fûxU[Ë]m­ Ô-Ï ¤¤ ©^ÖwG@ÏX©L© ¤ ]£© ¤$¦ z±]nJUiyO~MLWmGqºHrm]¸Ã¥]mYKroUXjKPjiGû P ÇujKWPiËLUiINjKPSYZUXPSY IKJkWhPWogLUXWmG%Ï ¤¤¤ GWo£>oRo¤

sPjKroUX|m]

Page 116: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

hq²Vhq³F²w´¥«µ²/¶®· ðYá7Ò

£1Рʦ «]JLyOdMLWWcMLW|)]ÒgLJoG7ºHrTuji]B`BUiYZYi] ~LoÆ Ô-Ï ¤^ã" ÖwG ¤^ã ]£1ÐÏ ¦ «]JLyOdMLWWcMLW|] ûp]ÒqP°¯DGºHrTVji]`BUiYZYi] ðiBoÆ Ô-Ï ¤¥ Ð^ÖwG@Ï<Ï ã ]£1ÐL© ¦ z¨]7qWTkML|PGºHrB]¸Ã]hYKroUXjKPjiG Ð WPËLUiIwjKPSYTeJLyÃUiRhIKUXÈUXWmG>© Ê<Ê<Ê GDWo£hRhsPjKrUX|m]£1Ð<Ð ¦ ü] ß«]0ÇpM"INMLO~PMLWmG>o]jüD]>¦oJLINjKYZUiIXGBo] Ð ]±ßqW|oUiINjZUXWBG]ßqjKjKO~MLWWBGúq]7·-IKJkh|oULG

o]aúrU[ËMLssPSUiIXGo]jüD] UXPSgLUiIXGu¦-] Ik§hWoUiIXGTÈ¥] ß]¦ÇproJu|oTVIKU[ËG¦-]VzªMLsM"gkoYKPGVMLW|ß«] Ð gke&eiJkWPG±ùHoIKJL£DUXMLWǺrTuji]hLJkINWm]hv ð± Ô© Ê<Ê Ð^ÖwG±Õ ¤ ]

£1ÐÕ ¦ Hm] `f]<ÇpsPOJkWYZJËVPNrmGÉk 7ã">Ä|>¡w<ãÈwG6M"INJVJV| ßqiML|oUXO~PSºHoRhsPjKroUiINjXGúrIZ¤`BJkW|JkWu¤tºM"INPjǤ>ÒUifJLIKGÏ ¤¥L ]

£1Ð<Î ¦ ·]fÇpJLYKsPIÿWjZuPG,«]]oPsjKwroYiGº&]júq] Ò]0ú-INJkeiUXWmG«]fÇ«M"£UiIGfùx] ùx]ÇJks|oUXWu¤roJLyÊG ] Ç]]Ñ`BUiUigLYZULGû«] «]üuPSUXOdjKjZUXWmGDMLW|ª¥] ¹¥] ¹@PSULGMÒisÅ]ºrTuji]Bv B~Ô-Ï ¤¤ ÏbÖwGÐ Ê ÐV]

£1Ð $¦ «] ß]ÇINMLO~UiINjiGºHrTujKPiM ± Ô-Ï ¤ Õ Ê ÖwGB© ¥ Õo]£1Ð ãC¦ È] `H]ÇINMbËkNrVoGxß«]z±]Ë"MLW8|oUXWj·-UiIKgoG˦-]ª¦sSUXIKJLYiGÌz¨] ß]_|oUÞqmG«]u`-§JkrWoUiIXG#«]]FPsjKwrYiG&z±]nº&JksMLjKPSGQz±]µ`BUiMLW|oJ jZ"M¤>ûxJLRhM"GMLW|Ç]±üuÍsM"RLJ jZ"MuGºHrTVjX]ûxU[Ë]>v ~ Ô© Ê<Ê ÏbÖwG Êk © ã Ï Ê ]

£1Ð ¥$¦ È] `H]ÇIwM'ËkNrVoGY]]"PsjKwrYiG^ß«]z±]IËMLW®|oUXWE·-UiIKgoGU·q]LÃ@M'ËuP|jiGk¦-]L¦sSUXu¤IKJLYiG"z±]$qWTkML|PGLz¨] ß]|U"hmG]`-§JkrWoUiIXGMLW|ß]bË"MLW«|UiIF)Jk|oULGºrTuji]ûxU[Ë]hv ~ ± Ô© Ê<Ê Ð^ÖwG Ê ÎL© ãÊ=¤ ]

£1Ð ¤$¦ `f]¸Ã¥]$`QMLW|MLMLW|¼ùx]z±]$`QPSyjNrPSYveLG«Î-¡Ä7ã">ÄÏ Â;7ãiwGú&UiIKgkMLOJkWºfINUXjKjiGá¯VyJLIN|u¤>ÒUi6fJLIK¤ Å JLIKJkWYZJ"¤üuTV|WUiT¤tºM"INPjZ¤¦oINMLWoVyIKYiGÏ ¤¥IÊ ]

£ Õ Ê¦ «] Ç]]q`FUiUigLYZULGuºHrB]¸Ã]YKroUXjKPjXGKûP ZVjKhWPËLUiINjKPYZUXPSY IKJkWPWogLUXWBGÏ ¤¤ ©VGWu¤£hoRhsPjKroUX|m]

£ ÕfÏ ¦ «] Ç]]u`FUiUigLYZULG@ß] `f]n·-JVJkWjZYZINMuGo]¸Ã¥]nqPWWoUiyUXs|mGMù ] ùx]ÇJks|oUXWroJLyÐGZûp] ]üuPSUXO~jKjKUXWmGÆÇ]üoPSUi¤ÅPsËeiTÿWjZ"MuG¥t&]üuJkjKPWmG«] PsËeiTÿWjZuPGpMLW| ]]PsjKNrVoYiGºHrTuji]fûxU[Ë]m­ ~ Ô-Ï ¤¤ ©^ÖwG ¤¤ Ï"]

£ Õ© ¦ o] ]hzMLÈUicMLW|ªo]jü]·-INPSgLgkjXG>o]ºrTuji] Æ©± Ô-Ï ¤^ã Õ¦ÖwGBÏ'ÐÏX©V]£ ÕTÐ ¦ o]¸Ã¥]DzJksPSYZJLIwjiGD] ù ]DzUiTLUiINroJLyÐG8úrm]ZüVYZJkssSUiIG±ûp]ßqWroJksSYiGDÃ¥]]8üV£DJVJkWoUiIXG`f] ]«zJLIKUiYZYZJoG]`H] ]¢üVJLRDJLYZ"MuGWûp]]«ziÃqJkWMLs|BG ]o]p)JeXWhPM">GÑz¨] ß]

zXzªMLrMLWmG `f]s·sOUXWoyUXs|mGcÒ]%ú-JksSJkWWMuGHz±]gÒUXjKjKPGfMLW|çù ]zJLIKUXWeiJkWhPGºHrTVji]fû U[Ë>]`BUiYZYi] ±á Ô-Ï ¤¤ Ð^ÖwGMÎ<Ð ã ]

Page 117: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ð7ð6á hq²Vh³Q²w«´¥µ²/¶®·£ Õ<Õ ¦ ]¸Ã]BzJksPSYZJLINjXGMúrB]üVYZJkssUiIXG0û«]0ßqWroJksYiG>] ùx]BzUiTLUiINroJLyÐGBÃ]]üV£DJJkWUiIXG

û«]o]«zªiÃJkWhMLs|mG_`f] ]¢üVJLRDJLYZMuG ]o]p)JeXWPM">G_`H] ]zJLIKUiYZYZJoGÑz±] ß«]zªXzMLrhMLWmG¦ù ]LzJLIKUXWeiJkWhPGz¨]^ÒUXjKjKPÅGkMLW|¥]L§JksfchPGt&]ºrTuji]L Ô-Ï ¤¥L ÖwG¤ Ï"]

£ ÕTÎ ¦ `H] ]>zJLIKUiYZYZJeMLW|ªo]jü]±üaËLUXWYZUiGLºHrTuji]`BUiYZYi] 7ÂÆ Ô-Ï ¤^ã Î^ÖwGm© ]£ Õ $¦ z±]ªzJLIÇUXMLWBG¢z±]úrU[ËMLssPSUiIXGúq]úJkroUXWmGÒÃ]ªÃqMLfËLUiIKgkWoULGËo]cÃ@oINMLsÅG

] MLsPWmGD¦] Jks|oUXWR>MLO\GDÃ]BMLi¬oUiYiGZû«]MÇpPSINjKwrmGùx]z`FPSUXWM"Iw|mG·q]¯`BJLYZYiGß]¸º&UigkrMLPIKULG6®]¸º&UiINPSUiIGo]júq]¸º&JkPfeXM"YiG ]åºfINU[ËLJLYiGÓ]ûxUXOdPssPSUXo¯GÃ¥]0üuwrO~MLjXGMLW|z±] Å JkhsSUXOJkW|oULGfÒqis]ºrTuji]hv ~BALá Ô-Ï ¤¤¥ ÖwGm© Ê<Ê "]

£ Õ ãC¦ ] ·]^ÒqM"YZJPSYveLG¦û«]L¨ML|MuGTÇ]=qM"gLUXsG Å ]<ÇUXYZgLUXWmGz±]zoININMXTLGTß]zªM"LUiU[Ë>G`H]j@PWmGº&]0üuO~PYKrmGoMLW|úq]qMLO~PsSYZJkWBGºHrTVji]fû U[Ë>]B­ ~L Ô© Ê<Ê ©^ÖwG Ê ÐÕ Ï ¥ ]£ Õ ¥$¦ ]Ò®§JLIKUXWRDUiIKgoGLºHrTVji]`FUiYZYi] BÆ Ô-Ï ¤^ã Õ¦ÖwGm© ¥¤ ]£ Õ ¤$¦ º&]7ºMLsBMLWh|z¨] Å roJUXWUXjKjZUXWmGfßqWWm]fû U[Ë>]Òqis]ºM"IKYi]üuiP] 7 Ô-Ï ¤¤ Õ¦ÖwG ÎV]£1Πʦ z±]7º&JksMLjKPSGo£INPiËM"YZUpÈJkO~O¥WPiM"YKPSJkWmGh© Ê<Ê ©V]£1ÎÏ ¦ ]fû MLW|oIwo£cMLW|Ô]o]0üVPM"YZUXKuPGÒqis]ºrTuji]hv 7Ò Ô-Ï ¤¥ Õ¦ÖwGBÏ Ê ÎV]£1ÎL© ¦ ],ûxJkjKjKWUiIXG¨Ã¥]ÕqPsjNNroUiIXG¨Ã¥]]ÕqPW|ULG ·] UiR>MLoUiIXGÕz±]-`BUXrO~MLWhWmG

z±]PsS£DUiIKYiGoMLW|#ù ]hzcJLIN|hroJLINjZYiGºrTuji]fûxU[Ë]m­ á Ô-Ï ¤¥¤ ÖwGm© © ¤ ]£1Î<Ð ¦ È¥] ß«]MûoRmNroUXWTkMuGZß«]1È¥]MÇpeXWoUiYKjKJbËGm] ] Å IIeXMLjZMuGBÃ¥] Ò]MÈfM"VrYKPWmGMß] ß«]

ßqsSUȯoMLW|oIKJË>Ge£Ä]¸Ã¥]BßqsSurM+eiJbËG] §ßTVjKY§JoGü]1È¥]@ÇprhsSUiRhWPSLJË>GBÈ¥] ]e`BTkM"£hPWmGá¥]£Ä]á@jZUiYZIKJË>GuHB] ùx]º&UXWPSJkWeXroLU[ËuPwrmGVHm]1È]ºHTkM"YZLJbËG>MLW| ] º&] Å PSJkoIwPWmGºrTuji]fûxU[Ë]m­ 7 Ô-Ï ¤¤¥ ÖwGcÏ'Î ¥^ã ]

£1ÎÕ ¦ º&]ûxTuOeXMuGDÃ¥]úrhO~PSUXsSUi jKMuGt]üuZLJjZVPÅG ]o]·MLsjZYZUiIXG·q]±ÇJLYKsPÿWjZuPGû«] «]0üoPSUXO~jKjZUXWBGuMLWh|)«]]PsjKwrYiGfÒisÅ]ºHrTVji]hv ð± Ô-Ï ¤¤IÊ ÖwG@Ï'Î ¤ ]

£1Î<Î ¦ ü]£Ä]@üuMLsUXO»MLW|ò`f] ùx]û`BUiULGcßYi]ÃqM"YKMMLW|ÒisÅ]QÃ@M"YKM Å M"RhsSUXj ðY Ô-Ï ¤^ã" ÖwG©<Ð<ÐV]

£1Î $¦ ß]CüuM¯uUXWMuGß]CúrM"YZYZUiIÇUiULGKûp] Ç]Cú/roJks|rVoIKTLGCüD]jü]cÇpM"£DJJLIXG-MLW|¢Ã¥]z¨]ÒqML|o"M"INWPGºHrTuji]ûxU[Ë]m­ Ò Ô-Ï ¤¤ Õ¦ÖwG ¤ ÐL©V]

£1Î ãC¦ Ç]©üoPSUi¤ÅPsËeiTÿWjZ"MuGÖo]¢PsËeiTÿWjZuPGzûp] ]§üuPSUXO~jNjZUXWmGMLW| ]]PsjKwrYiGºHrTVji]fû U[Ë>]B­ ð Ô-Ï ¤¤ Î^ÖwGD© Ê ÎÕo]

£1Î ¥$¦ û«] ]0üVYZJLujZYKML|mG0úJkO~O\]fÒqis]ºM"IKYi]LºrTuji] ð[A Ô-Ï ¤¥ Õ¦ÖwGm©<ÐÏ"]

Page 118: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

hq²Vhq³F²w´¥«µ²/¶®· ð7ð7ð

£1Î ¤$¦ È]z±]0üVYZINYKPWjZVTLGºHrTVji]`FUiYZYi] ±VÆ Ô-Ï ¤^ã Ð^ÖwGBÏX©Ï"]£ Iʦ Ã] Å INMLYKO~MLWWmGu£INPiËM"YZUpÈJkO~O¥WPiM"YKPSJkWmGh© Ê<Ê ©V]£ Ï ¦ Ã] Å INMLoYKOdMLWW\MLW|\¦-]û§JkjKUXsGfÒhis]i£ÐWjKYZINO\]zUiYKroJV|hj ðY~LÒ Ô-Ï ¤¥IÊ ÖwGm©<Î ¤ ]£ © ¦ ] Å INMLoYKOdMLWWmGÒhis]ºHrTVjX]>v ~7ÂL Ô© Ê<Ê ÏbÖwGm©<Ð<Ð""]£ Ð ¦ Å ]jü] Å ËLUiYZUiIXGD]o] MLM"IN|rJÇULGß«]mzªMÈG Å ]±ûMLO~jZJTLGZß«]0ßYKML"GFo]L·MLÈUXsM"IG

ß«]·-INMLiÈJoGß]·|hMuGD¦-]úMLOUiIwMuG·] UiINjZuPW|mG]ÇpJLIKYZUXWmGD]MÇI±ÿJksMLjiGß«]@zcUXWYKroULG·q]zPssPSJkWmG\«]\ÒPy$UXWoUXNLUiIXGz±]ºPSgkWMLWoUXssPGo] ß]ºHPWjZYZJkWmG«]1Ë]¸|m]ºHsSJVUigoG¦-]±üuNrVjKjNsSUiIXGuMLW| ]±üusSUiYZYZUXWBGºHrTVji]û U[Ë>]`FUiYZYi] ±,~ Ô-Ï ¤¤L ÖwGÏ Ê Ð<ÎV]

£ Õ ¦ ûp]o]IÈfML|oUiIG¦ß]<ËMLW|oUiI)Jkh|oULGTûp]]k|oUxzcUXP ÇUiIXGVo]z±]=MLWjKYZUiUXWmGMLW|ź&] ß]ßO¥W|jKUXWmGºHrTVji]fû U[Ë>]v ðY Ô-Ï ¤^ã" ÖwG ©V]

£ Î ¦ ß«]z±]fË"MLWc|oUXW)·-UiIKgoGÒqis]£ÇWjZYZI]MLW|zUiYKrm] ÆÅÒ7Ò Ô-Ï ¤¤ Î^ÖwG Ð ã ]£ L$¦ o] ]ËMLWcÃ@P ZGºHrm]¸Ã¥]YKroUXjNPjiGfû P ÇujKWPiËLUiINjKPSYZUXPSY IKJkWPWogLUXWmGMÏ ¤¥ ÕoGhWo£hoRo¤

sPjKroUX|B]£ ^ãC¦ o] ]ZËMLW±ÃqP ÇG#]]QPsjKNrVoYiG@ß«] ]&ÃqIKUXWYZULGMLW|ß]Ë"MLW¨|oUiI«)Jkh|oULG

t&]ºHrTVjX]hv AnðU Ô-Ï ¤¥ Ð^ÖwG@Ï"]£ ¥$¦ o] ] ]gË"MLWƺ&JksGSºHrm]¸Ã¥]fYKrUXjKPjiGKû P ZujKWPËLUiIwjKPSYZUXPSY IKJkWPWogLUXWmGÏ ¤¤L GxWu¤

£hoRhsPjKroUX|m]£ ¤$¦ ûp]ÈfMLW|oUXWRDJkjKNrBGho]¸Ã¥]·PSUiINO~MLWmGh] º&]`BUXjZYZJkWoULGo]¸¦-]B`FPMLWogoGoÃ]]7ºfIwPW|sSULG

ß«] ß]üuJkWeiJLgkWPGü]¦ÇpMLPsMLjiGÃ¥]z±]ÒML|o"M"INWPÅGMLW|,ü]jü]¦Ç«M"£JVJLIXG6ºHrTVji]aûxU[Ë]­ Ô-Ï ¤¤L ÖwG0û ¤^ã<ã ]

£ ãʦ~ ]fË"MLW¯nYuJLyÊG] ] ß«] UXjKjKUXsPWoGfß«]]z¨]LºHsSJkO£DUXWmG] ºQ]jüD]fËMLWüuNrhM"gLUXWmGz¨] Ò]ÛqM"INM"LUXrmGÒ]CÇ«MLsMLWYKM"IK¤>ÒMTLUXjZYKMLWM"uPGq]júq]jü]"·MLÈUXsM"IXG«]CËMLW|oUiIºHsSJVUigoG£w]>ÃqPbÿJkjveiUigkPGhMLW|,ß]ÇpgksSUiIXGºHrTuji]fûxU[Ë]m­ Ô-Ï ¤¤L ÖwGûÏ'ÎÏ'ÎV]

£ ã Ï ¦ È] ù ]0È@PSJksMuGZÇ~]Çp PM"YZLJjZVPÅGBMLW|¨z¨]m¨MLsLUiIXGnºHrTuji]MûxU[Ë]­ Að Ô-Ï ¤¥ Î^ÖwGÏ'Î<Î Ê ]

£ ã © ¦ Å ]o¨ML|MuG®]fßRULG>MLW|,Ò«]úM"IKMLWmGºHrTVjX]fûxU[Ë]B`BUiYZYi] ±,á Ô-Ï ¤¤ Ð^ÖwGÐ<Î<Ð ¥ ]£ ã Ð ¦ Å ]m¨ML|MuG Å ]¯£ÐwrPS"MXMuG&MLWh| Å ]ßqjKMLWoJoGÎ ~sã"Â4Â4" ×"ZØ_iÂ)ÙF ~cÚ"BÂ)~"<>>Ä < >XØ; ~ß ãÂ>eÛH$NÄ7>=«Î.~"|Â)~kÂÄÃÇØ3ÂÈ=7~>ÅÜ 7ãi¥=ã)ÄXÂÈG

¦&sJLINP|MuG Ð üßéÔ© Ê<Ê Ð^ÖwGYZJ~RDU£hoR>sPjKroUX|B]

Page 119: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ð7ði hq²Vh³Q²w«´¥µ²/¶®·£ ã Õ ¦ ]QPsËeiTÿWjZuPGcÇ]güuPS-Ui¤ÅPsËeiTÿWjZ"MuGMLW| «]]PsjKNrVoYiGdºHrTuji]@û U[Ë>]

­ Ô-Ï ¤¤L ÖwGMÐL©<ÎV]£ ã Î ¦ ]oPsËeiTVWjKVPmMLW|°«]]PsjKwroYiGºrTuji]fû U[Ë>]m­ A7Ò Ô-Ï ¤¥¤ ÖwGD©Õ ã ÎV]£ ã"$¦ z±] ¤`f]ufJkWoUXMLOdMuG±ùx]MLÈJLRhjiGho]¸Ã¥] Å ]fßIKINh|M¤>Ò UiYZJoG·q]jü]·rMLWh|M"INPGuÃ¥]ÃU

¦oINUXWWoULG/ü]uº&JkO~OÿULG/Ç]uº&UiINjZTuWmGMLW|æÇ~] JbË"M"UiIKYiG/Òqis]ºrTuji]v ~Lá Ô-Ï ¤¤L ÖwGm© ÐV]

£ ã<ãC¦ á¥] ß]HO~PWJbËGZüD] Hm] ºHsM"YZJkWoJË>GQÃ]já®]ùHIKUXOUXWoLJoG8á®]1È]m¦oJLYKPWhMuGùx]m¦jZ¤wrPWPG¦-]zªMLsM"gkoYKPÅG ]BÈfMLWWPWPÅG ] PM"Iw|PWMuG ]¦M+eXPSJoG%ß]û`QMLO«RDUiIKYZJoGß] Å MLiÈJkWoULG ß]zJLIKJkWPÅG/ùx]q¦PSJLIKUiYZYZJoG ûp] ß]û PiiPG`f]\ÈfMLWWhiiPG¥MLWh|û«]7ºMLsMLO~M"INMuG>kJkoINWm]uJLyYKroUúrTuji]0üVJu"]oJLyfkM"£hMLW ±á Ô© Ê<Ê ÏbÖwG ¥¤ ]

£ ã+¥$¦ ¦-]tM"IKYKjiGfÇÆÈ$£KßWhWMLsûxUi£DJLIKYÆÏ ¤¤L Gh£F] ¥¤ ]

Page 120: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

Ý Þàß Þá3â.-5äã ß å¢Þ åË5çæ Þèãêéë5íì¢ì6+/ã 1

UiYOUiYZUXWËMLW)|U¥sSU[ËLUXWhjK|oI\Ë"MLW)jZ£hsP ZYZUXW|oU«LUiINWoUXW_PjqUiUXW_RDUXsMLWogLINP ZLUjKYKM"£RhP &roUiYRDUi£hMLsSUXW¢ËMLW|U-UXPgLUXWjKNrhM"££DUXW/Ë"MLWroUiYZU/LUiINWhO~M"YZUiINPSUL]Q£ÇWroUiYRhP veiJkW|oUiI|oUËVPjNÈJkjKPSYZUXPSYÔ|oUO~M"YZUË"MLWdjZYZINJL£UiIwPSgkroUXP|±ÖFUXW INP GËVPWgqRDUi£hMLsUXWPWRDUXsMLWogLINP ÇLUO~M"YZUeroJUejKWoUXsUiUXW±|INo££DUXsQLUiINWTËusSJVUXPjZYZJLyÐGQPW¨y$UXPSYZUUiUXWÕroUiYZUdM"YZJVJkOLUiINWmG.eXPwrjZ£DJkWYKMLMLWÔjZ£hsPSYKjKYPWeY-UiU@VsSUXPWoUiIKU|INo££DUXsji]&ÃqUÒUX|oUiINsMLW|jZUy$TujKPijÇINMLO~UiINjMLj|oU-UiUiINjZYZUx|PSU|MLM"IKJL£®-UiUXji] Å JVwrroUiUiy$YroUiYWoJLg\eiUiUiIfsMLWgqgLUX|hoIN|/ËLJJLIw|M"YÇIwMLOUiINjjKogLgLUXjKYKPSUxPW®roUiYfjZYKMLW|hMLM"IN|Å·-JkroIZ¤ÅroUiUXsSUiIHOJu|oUXsaËLJVJLIHjZ£hsP ÇYKPWg -UiIN|PWgLUi£hMLjZYi]ßqsroJVUiUXsrUiYpUȯV£DUiINPOUXWYZUiUXsgËMLjZYKjKYKMLM"Y|M"Yp INP GËVPWgeRDUXsMLWogLIwP ǪPjiGPj|oUOdM"YZU«MLM"INPW¶eiUiUiIqJkOdjZYZIKUX|oUXWm]xÃqU¥IKUX|oUXWªPj |M"Yq|oUjK£hsP ZYKPWogkjZYKP Z|eiJÑLJLIKYPjXGVPWÑ|oUqJLIN|oUiIKgLINJJLYZYZUË"MLWÏ Êaì ÏtÊ j-JLyUXsDUiUXWÔM"YZYZJkjZUXÈJkWh|oUXÔMLjÖw]HÃ@MLM"IN|JJLISeXP KWUiIxgLUiUXWªOUiYKroJu|oUXj/YZUÆËuPW|UXW\|PSU|oUpsSU[ËLUXWjN|oI/£INUXiPSUXjVhWWoUXW\OUiYZUXWm]

Å JLYeWVYZJU¶eXP ZWÌY-UiUO~UiYKroJV|UXjWËVINP WËLUiIeJkWYPSLUXs|m]6ÃUUiUiINjZYZU_O~MLM"VYgLUiRIwPSRËMLWª|oU«PWYZINPWjNPSUiLU@VsSJLuË"MLW|oU«LUiINWm]ÃqPUPj/gLUiR>MLjZUiUiIN|ªJL£ªroUiY O~UiYZUXWË"MLWÔroUiYxMLMLWYKMLsmWUXoYZIKJkWoUXWÔ|M"Y/|oUroUiYZULUiINWRËLUiIN|hMLO£YKËLJJLIw|M"Yx|oU@LUiINWÔjZ£hsP ÇYi]ºHIKJLRhsSUiUXOÍË"MLW¨|oU&eiUfÇLUiIwWoVsJL[g\PjXGF|M"Yp|oJVJLI«|oU~WoUXYZIKJkWTËLUiIw|MLO£hPWgÔ|ULUiINWLJk|UiI -JLIN|oY UXWª|oU«usSJL\MLsjroUiY M"IKUjKYZUiUX|jsMLWogeXMLOUiIqYKPSYi].£ÇW|oU£INM"VYKP ZRhsP ÇVY|M"Yx|oUËLUiIKVIKUigLUXWsSU[ËLUXWhjK|oIKUXWÔjZYZUiINÑM"yrMLWoLUXsP dzeXP ZWuË"MLWcroUiYNËLUiIN|hMLO£o¤PWgkjKOJu|oUXs]

ÃqUÔY-UiUX|oU\OUiYKroJu|oUÔPjgLUiRhMLjZUiUiIN|îJL£¢|oURËVshNrYZYKP Z|îPW±UiUXWÒINPjZYKMLsSIKJVJkjZYZUiIï ã)~Ä¡ k>Äpð ĺ;ãÈÏ ×iñ]ÓÃqUiUXsSYÇUXj\hPSY~UiUXW§ËLUiINjKWoUXssSUiIdRDJLYKjZUXWOUiYÑUiUXWM"YZJJkOLUiIwWPW±UiUXW±VINPjKYKMLs]°qPSUiIN|oJVJLI«-JLIN|oY®|oUdLUiIwWmG|PSUePW±|oUeRJLYKjNPWogc-JLIN|oYgLUXO~MLM"YiGPYroUiY¥IKJVJkjZYZUiI®gLUXjZYZJLYZUXWm]£ÇWJeXP KW¨LJLINYZURËuswrY®|oJVJLI¥rUiYVINPjZYKMLsÛeXMLs|oUÑLUiINWjZ£>sP ZYZUXWm]QÃqU jZ£>sP ZYKPWogkjZ£INJV|hÈYZUXW«uWWoUXWMLssSUiUXWsMLWogkjf|U MLjKjZUXWËMLW~rUiYfIwPjZYKMLsRDUi-UigLUXWm]h£ÐW¢MLssSU\MLW|oUiIKUXW¢IwPNrYKPWogLUXWÒ-JLIN|oUXW eiU\gLUXjKYZJL£Y ï ð ĺ;ãÈÏ9ÂßÄñ\|oJVJLId|oUYKjNjZUXWpsPSgLgLUXWh|oUIwPjZYKMLsM"YZJkOUXWB]QÃqUf£hsMLM"YKjF-MLM"I&|oUfLUiINW«jZ£hsP ZYiG|m]«] eL]&|oUfsUXWogLYZUË"MLW_roUiYËVshNrYZ£hML|ËLJJLIpjZ£>sP ZYKPWogoG>Pj|MLM"INRhP UiUXW_RDUXsMLWogLINP ÇLU£hM"INMLOUiYZUiIX]áq£|oU&eiU®O~MLWPUiI"MLWªhPSY|oU¥MLM"INjKNrhP ZWhsP ZVroUXP|mG|M"Y@OUXWUiUXW_jZ£>sP ZYKPWogkj/yINM"gkOUXWYeXPSUiYsMLWgkj@RUi£>MLMLs|oU®MLjKjZUXWË"MLW)roUiYIwPjZYKMLsGm|oUsSU[ËLUXWjN|oI\ËMLW_UiUXW±jZ£hsP ZYZUXW|oULUiINWÕ-JLIN|oUXWîM"y$gLUXsSUXP|m]ùHI«eXP KW¨UXwrYZUiI ËLUiUXs-UËyDUXÈYZUXW¢|PSUÑ|oUdRDUi-UigkPWog®Ë"MLWÒ|oUjZ£>sP ZYKPWogkjfyINM"gkOUXWYZUXWc|oJVJLIUiUXW\VINPjZYKMLsSINJJkjZYZUiIuWWoUXWÑRDU § ò W¦ËVsJUX|oUXWB]qqPSUiIN|oJVJLI

Ï<Ï'Ð

Page 121: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ð7ðY óÅ+kL)p4U*Lk®Å®=')+*uô=%(*L3

2 %4365L5L«ñ78XgÑtR^;=<I[]_>AFX`AR^;=<D$@+@CO^`p>M<IPGPQFGT=oDË]CT)W<\õAq>M@+@C[\ú+PQ@$ú"ö[\<V>M;=@W<Ã@$[ W<ÃPG<IDµ<ITU`MWa=aUOdD&]_TE`tB=PGF ÷ò>A<ITYW<SúC<OAT=<T>M<S[\<V>A<T

Pj®WPSUiYgLJUX|ÒYZUÔJbËLUiIIeXPSUXWÒJLyOUXWÒMLssUËLUiINjZYZJLINUXW|oUÔUËyUXÈYZUXWÌPW±INUiLUXWPWog_roUiUiyYgLUiRINMLwrYRhP rUiYxRDUi£hMLsSUXWRËMLWª|oUpsSU[ËLUXWjN|oIX]UiYR>sP ZY|hM"Y_|U±Y-UiUËOUiUiYKOUiYKrJV|oUXWeiUiUiIËLUiINjNNrPssSUXW|oUîsSU[ËLUXWjK|IKUXW

JL£hsSU[ËLUiIKUXWB]ùHUXWMLsSYZUiINWhM"YKPSU[ËLUOUiUiYKO~UiYKroJV|UeiJk|jSeiUiUiIqUXsLJkO eXP KWm]£ÇWrUiYUiINWËLJJLIx|hPSYH£INJUiyjKNrINPSyYHPjUiUXWe£DJLgkPWg«JkW|oUiIwWoJkOUXWÑUiUXWÔWPSUXUqOUiYKroJu|oUYZUJkWYÊ PSVLUXsSUXWm]cÃqU&eiUÔO~MLM"YgLUiRINPË"MLWÕrUiY«yUXPSY«|M"YUiUXW¨gkM"Y,ÔroUiY«JkWYZRIKUiLUXWËMLW¨UiUXW)UXsSUiVYZIKJkW±ÖqPW)|oUWǤjKNrPsBËMLW_UiUXWJei-MLM"I«M"YZJVJkO¹UiUXWÕsSU[ËLUXWjK|hoIroUiUiyYËMLW_JkWgLU[ËLUiUiIÏ®MLji]«ÃqU~OUiYKroJu|oU®Pj@jKNroUXOdM"YKPjKNr)hPSYZgLUXsSUigk|_PWøgkoI ¥ ]©V]«)UgLUiRINPLUXWdUiUXWÑIKUXMLÈYKPSUqMLM"IKRhP HUiUXWuÒUiJkWo£IKJZUXÈYKPSUXsDPSY-|oUËLUiINjNWoUXssSUiI-RDJLYKjZYOUiYUiUXW Å roJLIwPOYKM"IKgLUiYZLUiIwWm]£ÇW|U¥RDJLYKjKPWoge-JLIN|oY@UiUXWÝUXsPOd|oUiUXsSYZUJËLUiIKgLUX|oINM¤gLUXWÑ-MLM"IN|JJLIUiUXWÑgLU §UȯuiPYZUiUiIN|oU Ð IwMLMLWoLUiINWeJkWYKjZYKMLM"Yi]? UiY£INJÇUXÈYKPSUXsroUiUiyYUiUXWRhW|UXsSUXWoUiIKgkPSU\Ë"MLW®Ð Ê zU[È£DUiIxWVisSUiJkWÉÔOÒUiJkW\RDUXjZYKMLM"Y hPSY © Ê WVisSUiJkWoUXW\|hjroUiUiyYrUiY© Ê ëÐ Ê IÊ<Ê zU[ÈVPWUiYKPjKNrUHUXWoUiIKgkPUÖBMLM"IN|oJVJLIfroUiY&gLUi£IKJu|ÈUiUiIN|UÐ IwMLMLWcJkWogLU[ËLUiUiI@UiUXWcUȯoiPSYKM"YKPSUȤÅUXWUiIKgkPSU«VINP ZgLY5Ë"MLW,ÕXëÐ Ê zÏX© Ê zcU[È Ô¨UXsPhORDUXjZYKMLM"YxPSYÕWisUiJkWoUXW±ÖH-M"Y/JËLUiIKUiUXWoLJkOYOUiY/UiUXWÔYZUXO~£UiIwM"YKoIKËMLWc©®zU[È

Page 122: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

óÅ+k$)p(=*Lk®Å®='°*uô==I%(*L3 ð7ð6

Ô© Í Ï Ê Ï ö Ç/Öw]nUiYveiUXsSy|oU~rML|)RDUiIKUXPSVY@VhWWoUXW_-JLIN|oUXW¨OUiYÃUXsPhOù£IKJZUXÈYKPSUȤsSUXWË"MLWsÏX© Ê zU[ÈúPW_UiUXW_yjKPUiIKUXMLÈYKPSULGmUXNrYZUiI|JJLIp|oUYZIwMLWjZyUiIZ¤ÅIKUXMLÈYKPSU®Ô ÝGö ÒULGÏ í áÆÖYZU\gLUiRIwPSLUXWmGf-JLIN|oY~|UÑ"MLWj#Ï Ê<Ê LUiUiIegLIKJLYZUiI~JkOçUiUXWËUXsSUiYZINJkW¢PSY|oUÇ@¤jNNrPs%ËMLWîroUiY Å roJLINPO~M"YZJVJkO¹YZU\jKsMLMLWm]ÒM|oUÑIKUXMLÈYKPSUÔPj|hPSY«|jUiUXWÕgkM"YPW_roUiY Ð INMLMLW¨M"YZJVJkO\]®¨MLWWoUiUiI|oUWÇ@¤jKwrPs&gLU[ËVhs|_JLIw|oY|oJJLIUiUXW¨JbËLUiIKgkMLWogË"MLWUiUXWUXsSUiVYZIKJkWPSYxUiUXW_roJLgLUiINgLUXsSUigLUXW_RhMLMLWmGJLIw|oY|MLM"INRhP û §JkWYZgLUXWjZYZINMLsPWogPYZgLU&eiJkW|oUXWm]cÃ@PSUÔjZYZINMLsPWogcPjM"INM"VYZUiINPjKYKPSUi¡ËLJJLI Ð INMLMLWm]®ßqsj¥|oUdLUiINWîjZ£hsP ÇY"MLW\gLUiUXWc"M"INM"VYZUiINPjZYKPUiLUû §JkWYZgLUXWOUiUiIJLIw|oUXWcPSYZgLU&eiJkWh|oUXWm]

ÃqUMLM"INjKwrP KWsP ZVrUXP|\JkOù"M"INM"YZUiIwPjZYKPSUiLU û §JkWYZgLUXWjZYZIwMLsPWogÔYZU®JLRhjZUiIËLUiINUXWYZUigLUXsP ÇLUiIKYKP Z|cO~UiY jZ£hsP ÇYKPWgkjZy$IwM"gkOUXWYZUXWÔUXWªroUiYxJËLUiIKUiUXWoLJkO~jZYKPgLU¥|oUiUXsËMLWcUiUXW£INJÇUXÈYKPSUXsy$INM"gkO~UXWY-Pj|hjfUiUXWÔ|PSINUiYZUqO~MLM"YCËLJVJLI/|oUsU[ËLUXWjK|I%Ë"MLWdUiUXWÔjZ£hsP ФYZUXW|U¥LUiIwWxÔçeXPSU|oU®y$JLINO¥sSU®PW_|oU¥øgkoI ¥ ]©^Öw]¥)U~WoJVUXOUXW_|oU&eiU~OUiYKroJu|oU|oUfZM"YZJVJkOusSJL[gOUiYKroJu|oU®JkO~|M"YeiUgLUiRhMLjZUiUiIw|¨PjqJL£¨|oUUXPSgLUXWjNNrM"££DUXWË"MLW)roUiYM"YZJVJkOûPWÑYZUigLUXWjZYZUXssPWog¥YZJLY |oUWoUXoYZINJkWoUXWousSJL~JLyUXs fÇLUiINWVsSJLig|PSUqgLUiRhMLjZUiUiIw|PjJL£ª|oUpUXPSgLUXWjNNrM"££DUXWuË"MLWc|oU«rUiYZULUiINW)eiUXsSyÐ]

ÈJVJLIN|M"Yf|UO~UiYKroJV|UgLUiYZUXjZYHLJkW®JLIN|UXWmGOJVUXjZYUiUiINjZYWoJLgUiUXWMLMLWYKMLsËLJVJLIZ¤RDUiIKUXP|UXW|oUO~UiYKPWogLUXW ËLUiIKIwPNrYJLIw|oUXWm] Å UXW®UiUiIwjZYZU OJVUXjZYRDUi£hMLMLs|¥-JLIN|oUXW~roJVUgLIKJVJLY/|oUq-MLM"INjNNrP KWsP ÇuroUXP|JkOúUiUXWÔgkM"YYZUjKsMLMLWÔPWÑ|oUÇjNNrPsWVeUXPgLUXWsP ZPji]Å UXW¥Y-UiUX|oUxOJVUXjZYJLIN|UXW«RDUi£hMLMLs|JLy>rUiY&jZ£DUXÈYZINhOWPUiYQUiINWhjZYKPSgqJLIN|Y8ËLUiINjKYZJ"¤JLIN|Ô|oJVJLIN|M"YOUiUiIN|UiIKU@UXsSUiYZINJkWoUXWÔUigLgLUXjNsM"gLUXW\uWWoUXWeJLIw|oUXWm]gùHWÑYZUXWjNsSJLYZYZUOJVUXjZYxJVJL\roUiY yUXPSY/-JLIN|oUXWRUXjNNroJk |c|M"Y|oU«WM"YKINsP ZLUsP KWRINUiUX|oYZUËMLWª|oUJËLUiIKgkMLWogLUXWËLUiINMLW|UiIKY|oJVJLIN|M"Yq|oU«sSU[ËLUXWhjK|oIËMLWroUiYM"YZJVJkOèYi]go]1Ë>]jZ£hsP ZYKPWog-JLIN|oYNËLUiIKLJLINYi]Ð PSY|oU&eiUcOUiYKPWogLUXWçËMLsY~M"y YZUcsSUXP|UXWî|hM"Y ËLJJLId|UÑRDUXjKwroIKU[ËLUXWÒIKUXMLÈYKPU|oU

MLM"INjKwrP KWsP ZVrUXP|ÉÏ"] ã Ù¹Pj@JkOíUiUXWÇ@¤jNNrPsUXsUXÈYZIKJkW±PYqYZU~jKYZJLYZUXW¨gLUX|oINUXW|oUUiUXWªLUiINWRJLYKjNPWogo]UiYqM"INM"VYZUiINPjKYKPSUiLU¢û §JkWYZgLUXWhjZ£DUXÈYZINOàRhsP ZYPSUiYKjM"yYZU® P ФLUXWË"MLW)|M"YËMLW_UiUXW_£>oIKU¥gkM"YZYZJUXjZYKMLWh|¨YZUXW_gLU[ËLJksSgLUWË"MLW`m¤jNNrPsPSJkWhPjKM"YKPSU¥|PSUgLUXsP ÇVYKP K|PSg¨£hsMLM"YKje"MLW ËuPW|oUXWm]þùHwrYZUiIGq|oUgLU[ËLJksSgLUXWeXP ZWPWroUiYÑUXPSgLUXWsP ZLUUȯu£DUiINPOUXWYYZUWËLUiIKMLM"INsSJeiUXWm]uùfUXW¨YTV£hPjKwrËLJVJLIKRDUiUXs|ËMLW±UiUXW¨"M"INM"VYZUiINPjZYKPSUijZ£DUXÈYZINhOèPjøhgkoI ¥ ])ÐV]UiYYKroUiJLIKUiYKPjKNr)RDUiIKUiLUXWh|oUjZ£DUXÈYZINO¡eiJkW|oUiIp|oU®RhP Ф|oIwM"gLUË"MLW6`m¤jNNrPs@PSJkWhPjKM"YKPSU_PjÔ|oU_gLUXjZYKPS££DUXs|UªsP KW|oJJLIcrUiYÑgLUXO~UiYZUXWâjZ£DUXĤYZINhO\]ÃqUXËLUiIwjKNrPssSUXWËLJVJLI|oUerJLgLUiI¥gLUXsUigLUXWîsP ZWUXWÝeXP KW±rPSUiINRhP p|P|oUXsP ǪYZUeXPSUXWB]zcUXWOJVUiYeXPNrrPSUiIKRhP -gLJVUX|ªINUXMLsPjZUiIKUXWª|M"Y|hPSY jZ£DUXÈYZINOàroJVJLy|eXM"LUXsP Çû §JkWYZgLUXWjKYZINMLsPWogYZUXW±gLU[ËLJksSgLUuË"MLW±M"YZJkO~MLPIKUdRDJLYKjKPWgLUXW¨RDU[ËM"YuÔ|m]p] eL]\UXsMLjKYKPjǤwroU«LUiINWRDJLYKjKPWogLUXW0Ö--MLM"INRhP /gLUiUXW Ð INMLMLWªgLUXO~MLM"Yq-JLIN|oYi]/ÃqU«IKUX|oUXWªPjx|M"Yq|oU|oJVJLINjKWUiU¢Ë"MLW_UiUXW¨M"YZJVJkOLUiINW)JkWgLU[ËLUiUiIXÏ Ê<Ê<Ê<Ê LUiUiIVsSUXPWoUiIqPj|MLW)|oU Ç@¤jKwrPsË"MLWdroUiYM"YZJJkO\GVMLM"IN|oJVJLI|oUx"MLWjJL£ÑPSJkWPjNM"YKPSU/JLIN|oUiIKgLINJJLYZYZUXjCËLUiINjKwrPsSYfOUiY-|oU"MLWj/JL£cUiUXWLUiINWoIKUXMLÈYKPUL]

Å roUiJLIKUiYKPjKwroUMLWMLsSTujZUËMLWÔ|oU@gLU[ËLJksSgLUXW#ËMLW\|oUqUXPW|hPSgLUqsU[ËLUXWjK|ICË"MLWÔroUiYÇ@¤jNNrPsgkM"YQYZUXWogLU[ËLJksgLU5ËMLW®jZ£>sP ZYKPWogxsMLM"YUiUXW¦ËLJk|PSgL-UigeXPSUXW®|M"Y|oU-WhM"YKoINsP ÇLU

Page 123: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ð7ð6~ óÅ+kL)p4U*Lk®Å®=')+*uô=%(*L3

300

400

500

600700800900

1000

2000

3000

4000

80 85 90 95 100 105 110 115 120

THKα Kβ

Energy, keV

Cou

nts

2 %4365L5L«ñ78G7müS]_O^]_ú>A<OAFX`p>MFQ<ú³xý@CT>MoC<ITÕ`ABY<Rv>AOMa=[´D&]_TÇ:.;=@COMFGa=[EýLo$<I[\<V>M<ITÕoC<Wa=OM<ITUW<WFQ>d<VZBY<OAFG[\<IT>b

sP KWRhIKUiUX|oYZUË"MLW_|oU®gkM"YZYZJUXjKYKMLW|)gLIKJLYZUiI-JLIN|oYWMLM"INOdM"YZU®|U¥LUiIwWªLJLINYZUiI«sSUiUiyYiG-M"Y-JL£ÑRhMLjKPj%ËMLW UXPjZUXWRDUiIKgkjJkWeiUiLUiINrUXP|jZIKUXsM"YKPSUxYZUqRUigLIwP Ç£DUXW~Pji]ÃULJLIKYKjZYZUsSU[ËLUXWjK|hoI|hPSUeWoJLgYZJLY®UiUXW¢roUiIKLUXWRhMLM"IjZ£DUXÈYZINO8sSUXP|oYPj«JkWgLU[ËLUiUiI®Ï Êaì Ï jÔ Ê ]iÏ«MLjÖw] £ÇWc|oUp£IwM"YKP ZePjx|PSYxWoJLgdgLUiUXWªrMLMLsRhM"IKUpsPOdPSUiYgLUiRhsSUiLUXWmGLeiJkMLsj sM"YZUiI|P|UXsP ZÅeXMLsmJLIw|oUXWm]£ÇWeroUiYUȯu£DUiINPOUXWYiGRDUXjKwroIKU[ËLUXWÔPWÑ|PSYH£hIKJUiyjKwroINPSyYiG-UiIN|oUXWÑPWeUiUXWÑjK£UXiPMLMLsgLUiRDJk |U«JL£hjZYZUXssPWogWû §JkWYZgLUXWjKYZINMLsPWogoGjZ£hsP ÇYKPWgkjZ£IKJu|ÈYZUXWeUXW£hIKJÇUXÈYKPUXsSy$IwM"g"¤

Page 124: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ð7ð6 óÅ+kL)p4U*Lk®Å®=')+*uô=%(*L3

Page 125: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

óÅ+k$)p(=*Lk®Å®='°*uô==I%(*L3 ð7ð±

OUXWYZUXW6gLUXOUiYZUXWB] º&UiIgLUiRDUXoIKYZUXWhPjÔUiIw|6gLU §UXPjZY|hM"YcMLssSU¨|oUiYZUXÈYZJLIKUXW¼ËuoIZ¤|oUXWB]Ã@PSYPjxWoJVJV|eXM"LUXsP ÇÑJkOá|UpUXWoJLINOURhP K|oINM"gLUË"MLW|oUM"YZJkO~MLPSIKURJLYKjNPWogLUXWPWîroUiY û §JkWYZgLUXWjZ£DUXÈYZINhO ËMLWîøgkI ¥ ])ЪYZU\UXsPO~PWoUiIKUXWB]Ã@PSY®RhsSUiUi±YZUigLUXWË|oUËLUiIKMLNrYKPWogîPW eiUiUiIÑgLJUX|OJLgLUXsP Z]á£ÇWËroUiYËLUiINIKUigLUXWjZ£DUXÈYZINOç-UiIN|ªËLUiIZ¤ËLJksSgLUXWhjgLU&eiJVwrY®WMLM"I«rUiYpM"IwM"YZUiINPjZYKPSUiLUdjZ£DUXÈYZINhOÍËMLW Ð INMLMLW)MLWWoUiUiI«UiUXWeXINjZYZJLy|oUiUXsSYZUMLjegLUXO~UiYZUXWm]ýßWh|oUiIKUINUXMLÈYKPSUiMLWhMLsSUXWmG MLM"IKRhP JVJLMLWh|oUiIKUM"YZJVJkOLUiINWoUXWcJLIN|UXWÔgLUXO~MLM"YiGhUiIN|UXWÔU[ËLUXWoUiUXWj/JkW|UiIVeiJVwrYi]-ÃqUeiJUiV£IKJuÈUȤ|IKU«O~MLM"VYgLUiRhINPSRËMLWª£hM"YZIKJVJkWroUiINLUXWWPWogMLM"IKRhP xrUiYqjZ£DUXÈYZINhOûPWcøhgkoI¥ ])Ð-JLIN|oY-gLUiRINPSVY\Ô|Uf-ËuPWogLUiINM"y|oIN[gËMLW Å roJLIwPOXÖ&JkOþ|oU@jZJVJLIKYZgLUXsP ZLUq£hM¤YZIKJkWUXW,ËMLW|oUpMLW|oUiIKUpM"YZJkO~UXWYZUpgLUXWUiIKUiIKUXWm]UiY RDUXsMLWgLINP ZVjZYZU@JLRhjKYKM"LUXsBRhsSUiUiÔ|oU«jKYZINMLsPWog Ë"MLWc|oUjZ£hsP ZYKPWogkjKy$INM"gkO~UXWYZUXW

YZUeXP KWm]ÃqUÔLUiINWoyINM"gkOUXWYZUXWîhPSY«jZ£hsP ÇYKPWogÇeiUXW|oUXWîWMLOUXsP Ç_JVJL¨gkMLO~O~MLjZYZIwM¤sPWog±PSYÑPWÌrUiYegLUiRhPUX|ÌMLM"IÔU)|oUû §JkWYZgLUXWjZYZINMLsPWogîO~JUiYZUXWOUiYZUXWm]qPSUiIZ¤|oJVJLIpJkWYKjZYKMLM"Y®UiUXW±MLwrYZUiIKgLINJkW|Õ|hPSUd|oU£hM"YZINJJkWrUiIKLUXWWPWgcrPW|oUiINYi]ML|h|oUXW|oU~jK£hsP ZYKPWogkjLUiINWoUXW)UiUXW±sSU[ËLUXWjK|hoIËMLW¨JkWogLU[ËLUiUiIXÏ Ê MLjiGF|MLWÝeiJkh|oUXW)-Ud|oUËuPWogLUiINM"y|oINLUXW©ËMLW|oU)jZ£>sP ZYZUXW|oULUiIwWoUXWgLU[ËLJkW|oUXWOJVUiYZUXW6roUiRRDUXWm]zÒquWWoUXWdU@jKsSUXwrYKjË"MLjZYKjZYZUXssUXWe|M"Y|oUqsSU[ËLUXWjK|IKUXW~usSUXPWoUiIÛeXP KWe|MLWÔ©¤_Ð¥MLji]fÃqUMLM"IN|oUXWÔ|PSUqgLU[ËLJkW|oUXW)eXP ZWÑOUiY/|oU@VINPjZYKMLs>YZUXNrWhPSUi>GeiJkh|oUXWÔ|MLWÔMLMLW\|oUroJLgLU"MLWYseXP ZWm]&ÃqUxOUiYKPWogLUXWEeXP KW®PW¥UXsSpgLU[Ë"MLsÈJkWjKPjZYZUXWYOUiYf|U-LUiIwWoVsJLVOUiYKPWogLUXWmG|PU\Ë"M"INP §UiINUXWÔYKjKjZUXW Ê ]iÏUXWÉÏMLji]HÃqU«OUiYKPWg~PSY/|PSY£IKJVUiyjKNroIwPSy$YsMLM"YSeXPSUXWBG|M"YRhP psU[ËLUXWjK|oINUXWË"MLW Ê ]iÏÔMLj®roUiY¥YZUXNrWPjKNrîJkW|oJVUXWsP ÇJLIw|oY«JkOä|oU:fZM"YZJJkO¤usSJLuOUiYKroJu|oU;gÑYZUgLUiRINPSLUXWB]`BU[ËLUXWhjK|oIKUXW_sMLWgLUiIp|MLWsÏMLj\eiJk|oUXW)OJLgLUXsP ÇgLUXOUiYZUXWVhWWoUXWÔ-JLIN|oUXWcPWÔUiUXW®ËLUiIKRDUiYZUiIN|\Uȯu£DUiINPOUXWYi]

ùHIeXP KW±PW|oUiIN|MLML|±OJLgLUXsP ZVrUX|oUXW¨JkO8roUiY«RDUXjZYKMLMLWh|oUdUȯu£DUiINPOUXWYpYZURËLUiIZ¤RDUiYZUiIKUXWm]KùfIeXP KWcRhP GËLJVJLIKRDUiUXs|ÔLUiINWoIKUXMLÈYKPUXj MLM"IKRhP |oU«MLWjËLUiUXsQrJLgLUiIqPjxJkOUiUXW_UXsSUiVYZIKJkWogkM"Y«YZU~jKsMLMLWm]¥ÃqMLM"Iw|oJJLI«JLIN|Y@|U®MLwrYZUiINgLIKJkW|)IKUXsM"YKPSUiyHJkWRDUXsMLWu¤gLINP ÇLUiIX]PUiIËLJJLI¥OJVUiY|oUdO~UiUiYZYZUXNrWPUi)UXsHUiUiINjZY«MLMLWogLUi£>MLjZY-JLIN|oUXWB]uáqJLËLUiIKUXPjZY/roUiYx|M"Y/|oUM"YZJkO~MLPSIKU£hIKJVÈUXjNjZUXWÑRUiYZUiI/gLUXO~UiYZUXWcUXWÔRDUXjKNrIKU[ËLUXWÔJLIw|oUXWm]ÈUiUXs8ËLJJLINRUiINUXP|oUXW|Ô-UiIK\Pjx|hjNËLUiIKUXPjZYËLJJLIw|M"Y OUXWUiUXWªWPUX-U£DJLgkPWog~"MLWM"gLUXWcUiUXW fZM"YZJJkOusSJLigdOUiYKPWogYZU«|oJVUXWm]

Page 126: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ÿ 5äã 0 043ß

£-Jks|sPSLUpYZJdYKrhMLWo\MLssBYKroU£DUiJL£hsSU«roUXs£hPWogMLW|ªjKo££DJLIKYKPWg®O~U«JkWªYKroU«MXTYZJdÈJkO~£hsSUiYZUpYKrPjYKroUXjKPj/-JLIK]

roU)øINjZY\-JLIN|jM"IKU±ML||oINUXjKjZUX|6YZJÆqMLWjPsjKNrVoYiG@y$INJkO roJkO £ÔrMLUsSUXM"IwWoUX|¨MsJLY«PW¨WVisSUXM"I¥MLW|±M"YZJkO~P~£hrTVjNPijiGBUȯu£DUiINPOUXWYKMLsYZUXNrhWP¬VoUXjiGMLW||M"YKMMLWMLsSTujKPjX]&£ÊY¥MLj¥Mª£hsSUXMLjNoIKU~YZJJLIN¨ PSYKrÕMLUiIKT±£IKJLyUXjKjKPSJkWMLsMLW|ÕIKUȤjZ£DJkWjNPSRhsSU£UiIwjZJkWm]dqM"IKYZUXsP ZdRDUX|MLWoVYiGqMLWj£MLOëgLIwM"YZUiys-YZJ_O«TÕ£IKJkOJLYZUiIÅUiIKRDUiIKY` §JkrWoUiI¥y$JLIroUXs£î|INPWogcYKrUeUȯV¤£DUiINPO~UXWYKj¥MLW|ÒÈJLIKIKUXÈYKPSJkWÒJLyYKroU\O~MLWVjKÈINPS£hYi]Õ£« PjKrÕYZJ_YKrMLWo±YKrUeIKUXML|hPWogÈJkO~OdPSYZYZUiU!ǺfIKJLyÐ]îz±]HzcJLIÇUXMLWmG?ºfIKJLyÐ]~]güoPSUi¤ÅPsËeiTÿWjZ"MªMLW| ºHIKJLyÐ]ÕÃ¥] INMLoYKO~MLWhWÔy$JLIYKroUXPSIxPWYZUiIKUXjZY PWÔYKrPj-JLIK\MLW|\yJLIxYKroUpiM"IKUiysmIKUXML|hPWogJLy&YKroUO~MLWVjKÈIwPS£YiGu rPwr\ÈJkWYZIwPSRhoYZUX|\YZJdYKroUøhWMLsLUiINjNPSJkW\JLyYKroUYKroUXjKPji]£m-Jks|«sPSLUHYZJYKrMLWopMLssYKroUH£DUiJL£hsUf£hM"IKYKPiP£hM"YKPWogxPW«YKroUHYKrIKUiUUȯu£DUiINPOUXWYKj|oUXjNÈINPSRDUX|PWpYKrhPjm-JLIK!@ß|MLW|oUXW·-UiIKgoG=·M"IKINT@Ã@MVP|hjiGkzM"IN|oUÛqmG^üVYZUiyMLWJL£DUXNTLGßYZYKPsM IwMLjveXWMLroJLIK"MXTLGû JksSy@üuPSUXOdjKjZUXWm]güV£DUXiPMLs>YKrMLWoujHYZJOTdyINPSUXW|zªM"YTkMLjÛWTkML|PuyJLIfO~M"uPWog@øhjKjKPJkW|oUiYZUXÈYZJLIwjfyJLIYKroUøhWMLsVUȯV£DUiINPOUXWYi]û£FPjKrYZJYKrMLWo)YKroUuß áû úTVisSJLYZINJkW±gLIKJk£ÕyJLIYKrUeUȯoÈUXssSUXWYRDUXMLOë£DUiIKy$JLIwO~MLWÈU|INPWog¥YKroUUȯu£UiIwPOUXWYKji]£ÑMLO gLINM"YZUiys@YZJwºfIKJLyÐ]úzªM"IKUi ºQJksMLjKPSÌyJLI\YKroU¨zúÃ@¦úiMLsisM"YKPSJkWjÑJLyYKroU~|hPM"gLINMLOíMLW|¨jNM"YZUXssPSYZUsPWUXjqMLWh|)YZJ°ºfINJLyÊ]Ã@PSIK INMLYKO~MLWW_yJLIpYKroUXüfúKßiMLsihsM"YKPSJkWjqJLy-YKroUª¤jKroUXss&PSJkWPfeXM"YKPJkWª£hIKJLRhM"RhPsPSYKPSUXji]úHIKJLyÊ]¢ß|INPMLMLW"MLW)|oUiI)Jk|U/£Jks|sPSLU/YZJ«YKrhMLWo®y$JLIfYKrU ÈJkWYZIwPSRhoYKPSJkW®YZJJkoIf£hM"£DUiIfJkWdYKroUxIKUXjNsSYKjJLy&YKroU«|PIKUXÈYª¤jKroUXssDPSJkWPzeXM"YKPSJkWÔ£IKJLRhM"R>PsPSYKPSUXj-WoUXM"IeiUiIKJdPO£>MLÈY/£hM"INMLOUiYZUiIX]£@MLO¹YKrhMLWoys&YZJÃqIX]d¦hM"RhPMLWM INMLOUigkWM\yJLIpYKroUeroJkjZ£hPSYKMLsPSYTMLW|¨PWYZUiIZ¤UXjZYKPWog~|PjKihjKjKPSJkWj|INPWog®O«TuPjKPSYYZJa`8Ò$`ò`BUigkWM"IKJePW\¦oUiRINhM"IKTc© Ê<Ê ÐV]£MLjxIKUXMLssSTÑsKVTÔYZJdjKrM"IKU«YKroUpJÍdÈU PSYKr\£DUiINjZJkWhj/ roJRDUXiMLOU¥O«TLUiIKTgLJVJV|Ëy$INPUXW|ji]ÒzcTÒøINjKY¥JÍeÈUȤO~M"YZUMLjd¦M"RhINPÈUc¦sSUXoIKJLYi]¢)UªrML|ËM)sSJLYJLyUȯoiPSYKPWogª|PjKijNjKPSJkWjpMLWh|¨-UiIKUÑrUXsS£hPWog\UXMLwrîJLYKroUiI|oINPWg\UȯV£DUiINPO~UXWYKji]c¦JLIYKroU~sMLjZYÏ"]ÔTLUXM"INjO«T_JÍdÈUȤOdM"YZUeMLjùO~Ps IwMXTVLJ]]£@MLO¹gLINM"YZUiysYZJªrPOMLW|erPjyMLO~PsT,ÔÃ@MLWPUXsMpMLW|ÔzPMTÖyJLIjKo£h£JLINYKPWogpOUL]Q£ÐYPjWM"YKoINMLshYKrM"YCùO~PsPj@OTªøhINjZY$|i>~> Øw]dzTjKUXÈJkW|Õ|i>~> ØpPjßWh|oIKUiTû JLgkMLNroUujZuPSTLGFroJ\Pj

Ï<Ï ¤

Page 127: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

ð[7á ª«=*>u­­Y&k

MLsSMXTujxRINPWogkPWog®M~rM"££VTeM"YKO~JkjZ£hroUiIKU« roUiIKULUiI rU«Pji]qPs|oU"MLWÌ|oUiIezUiUiIeMLWh|wPs|oU-`FMLW|hjZYZINM¤£® PjKrîYZJÕYKrMLWoîy$JLIdjKJksVPWog

O~MLWTÔML|hO~PWPjKYZINM"YKPSJkWÑ£IKJLRhsUXO~ji]£B PsskMLsSMXTujIKUXOUXORDUiIQJkoIRIwPssPMLWYmyJJLYZRhMLssYZUXMLOÞÔÈJkMLwroUXj)!s UXW JLIKYZUiIMLW|qM"IKIKT PO~UiINjKO~MTÖ>¤>YKroUf PWhWoUiImJLyuYKroUCû Ð PWYZUiIQ¦oJVJLYZRhMLss JkoIwWMLOUXWYiG© Ê<Ê ÐV]£MLO gLINM"YZUiysmYZJdMLssmOTÔÈJkssSUXM"gkoUXjÔ¨ºrÃjZYK|UXWYKj/MLW|°ºQJkjKYKÃJuijÖ/y$JLIxYKrUWPÈU-YKPOUU/jZ£DUXWYQ|oIwPWog OTºHrhÃÌjZYK|hPSUXj)!ZßqsSUȯuMLWh|oUiIXG<ßWh|oINP KMuG·|h|rML|oUGÃ@MLWmGxÃ@MLWTkMLsGÃIwM"gkMLWmG5ùHsjNMuGNqMLO~P|BGpM"IwjZYZUXWmG zªM"INĤÊkMLWmG zªM"INPMuG zªMLjZJk|BGzsML|oUXWmGhzJkjKsSUXO\G0üuUiIKgLUiTLGû MLs£hrmGûxUXO~ÈJoG Ð OdM"MLWYKrm]£HPjKr~YZJYKrhMLWodOTd£hM"IKUXWYKj M"YÊTkMLWM~MLW|I`FUiJkWP|mGuO«TeRIKJLYKroUiI@PSYKMLsSTdMLWh|O«TgLINMLW|£hM"IKUXWYKjÆû POdO~MuG8üVUiINM"øhOdM\MLW|qsML|PO~PSIqyJLIpYKroU~ÈJkWjZYKMLWYjNo££DJLIKY|oINPWogYKrUXjZUpTLUXM"INji]

ßqW|mG"øhWMLssTLGYKroUOJkjZYPO£DJLIKYKMLWYF-JLIN|jQgLJYZJ@OT«sSJLUXsTp PSyU£ÐINPWMxMLWh|jZJkW£Ðs ZMu] rMLWo@TLJk¥yJLI&YKrU-iM"IKUMLW|¥£hM"YKPSUXWhÈU-|INPWog/YKrPjQ|PzÍdisSYBMLW|®PWYZUiIKUXjZYKPWog£DUiINPSJu|PSYKrJkoY/TLJk\YKrPjxJLIKÔÈJks|WoULUiI rMLU«RDUiUXWc|oJkWoUL]

üVUi£YZUXORDUiIXGh© Ê<Ê Ð IKJkWPWogLUXW

Page 128: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

üuYZUXssPWogLUXWÑRDUXroJLIKUXWh|oU@RhP rUiY/£IKJVUiyjKwroINPSyY\½>½ $Á"!$#Õ½uÂ&%~Á('*)>Âv %Á"#îÀ,+­ $Á+.-'ÊÁh¾/ À¿X¿ÀÁÂ10À2'½%À3#±½4½5)¿6Q¾½ #Õ½VÂ&%¿

] `H](INMkNrVo>G© ¥ á@ÈYZJLRDUiIq© Ê<Ê Ð

7 ] roUßYZJkO~PÉú/sSJVNO~UiYKroJV|âO~MXTRDUXÈJkOU¨YKroU¨OJkjKYcU&ÍdiPSUXWYcOUiYKroJu|YZJËOUXMLjKoIKU)ø>jKjKPSJkWsPSyUiYKPOUXj)!À£ÐYÔMLssSJ jÔJkWU)YZJËjKPO¥sSYKMLWoUiJkjNsSTËjZYK|oTjZTVjKYZUXO~j¥ PSYKrî|PXyDUiIKUXWY¥UȯoiPSYKM"YKPSJkWÒUXWoUiIKgkPUXjiGf rPsSU~YKroUÔNrM"IwMLÈYZUiINPjZYKPѯINMXTujQP|oUXWYKPy$TqYKroUHUXsUXOUXWY&WhO«RDUiIBJLyuYKroUøhjKjKPSJkWhPWog/WhisSUXjCÔ rPjmYKroUXjNPjÖw]

©V] roU£IKUXjKUXWÈUpJLyjKroJLIKYxMLWh|csSJkWog~ø>jKjKPSJkW\sPy$UiYKPO~U@ÈJkO~£JkWUXWYKjNrMLssUXWogLUXjYKroU_UȯV£DUiINPO~UXWYKMLsPjZYKjÑYZJîø>W|-MTVj\YZJËWJLYÑJkWhsSTÌOUXMLjKIKU)YKroU)M8LUiINM"gLUøhjKjKPSJkW_sPy$UiYKPO~ULGmRhoYMLsjZJ\YKroUdøhjKjKPSJkW_sPy$UiYKPO~U¥|PjZYZINPSRhYKPSJkWÔ £Ä] JkWYKNrM"IÂ).>ÄÁÅGùoIKJL£hrTVjX]Q`FUiYZYi] ± G±Ð99#Ô© Ê<Ê ©^ÖGÖw]

ÐV]ù:"M"£JLIwM"YKPSJkW)ÈJV|UXjpM"IKUYKWoUX|_YZJª|oUXjKÈINPSRDU¥YKroU~jZYKM"YKPjKYKPiMLsfMLjZ£DUXÈYJLy-YKroU|oUȤÅUȯuiPYKM"YKPSJkW±JLyxrJLYWVisSUXP] roUiT)M"IKUÑWoJLY«YKroUdINPSgkrYpYZJJksj«YZJ|oUXjKÈINPSRDUYKroU«|oTuWMLO~PijJLy|oUȤÅUȯoiPSYKM"YKPSJkWmG>PWÔ£hM"IKYKPihsM"I/øhjKjKPJkWm]

Õo] roU®jZYK|oTcJLy-roUXM8VT¤PSJkW_IKUXMLÈYKPSJkWjrhMLjqO~JLUX|)JkW_YZJ\rPSgkrUiI@MLWh|rhPSgkroUiIUXWoUiIKgkPSUXji]F£ÇW)PSYKjM"LUdPSYpsSUiyYO~MLWT¬VoUXjZYKPSJkWhjWMLWjZ-UiIKUX|mGBjNNr¨MLjpYKroUWM"YKoIKU®JLy|hPjKjKPS£>M"YKPSJkWMLW|£hrhMLjZUYZIwMLWjKPSYKPSJkWhjPW_OJu|oUiINM"YZUXsTroUXM"YZUX|¨WVu¤isSUXM"I O~M"YZYZUiIX]

V]qzcJu|oUiINW®roUXMT¤PSJkW¥£hrTVjKPijFUȯu£DUiINPOUXWYKj&IKUX¬hPSIKUÈJkO~£hsSUȯO¥sSYKP|UiYZUXÈYZJLINj PSYKr¡Õ^ÛËjKJksP|)MLWogksSUeMLW|¨McsM"INgLUd|oTuWMLO~P®INMLWgLU~JLy£hM"IKYKPisSUYÊT£DUXjMLW|UXWoUiIKgkPSUXji]£ÐWYZUXW|oUX|\OJkjKYKsSTeyJLI rPgkru¤ÅUXWoUiIKgLTÑjZYK|PSUXjYKrUiTÑM"IKU«UȯuÈUXssUXWYKsSTjKPSYZUX|«YZJqjZYKh|oTsSJ/¤ÅUXWUiIKgLTpøhjKjNPSJkW«|oTuWMLO~Pij%Ô¦oJLIUȯoMLO£hsSU ßû¦û£ùq`FÃ¥G¦] INMLOUigkWMÕÂ).>ÄÁÅGÒqis]e£ÇWjZYZIX]gßqW|czUiYKrm]v A7ÂLÒ G±Õ ã ÕÔ 7 ¤¤^ã ÖGÖw]

] roUdjZTujZYZUXO~M"YKPdjZYK|TJLyYKroUÑPjZJkjZ£>PW)|oUigLIKUiUXjJLy/y$INUiUX|oJkO»PW±roUXM8VT¤PJkWIKUXMLÈYKPSJkWjPssB£hIKJuP|oUÈINiPMLs&PWo£hoYy$JLIYKroU~|UXjKÈINPS£YKPJkWJLyYKroU~WhisSUXM"IUX¬M"YKPJkW\JLyjZYKM"YZUL]

ã ]qzcUXMLjKINPWogcM"YZJkO~PdjZ£DUXÈYZINMÉÔ3 MLWh|à¯)INMTVj"Ö@jKroJks|_RUdgkPLUXW±jZUiIwPSJkjÈJkWjKP|oUiIwM"YKPSJkW\PWÔYKroU«jKUXM"INNry$JLI jNo£DUiIZ¤roUXM8VTÑUXsSUXOUXWYKji]

¥ ]úoIKIKUXWYd-JLINs|£IKJLR>sSUXO~jdM"INUÈJkWWUXÈYZUX| PSYKrYKroUªyMLÈYÔYKrM"YÔYZUXNrWhPiMLsPWWoJ;M"YKPSJkWhj£IKJuÈUiUX|)yMLjZYZUiIYKrhMLW¨jZJuiPMLsfMLW|¨ihsSYKoINMLs|oULUXsJL£hOUXWYKj)!£ÐYPj-UXMLjKPSUiIYZJ~|oUXjKPSgkWÑWoUi-UXM"£JkWhjJLyQO~MLjKj|oUXjKYZINÈYKPSJkWÑYKrMLWÑYZJøhW|eMXTujYZJ~IKUX|ÈU£hIKUÐZh|PÈUMLW|\RhPgLJLYZIKTL]

Page 129: University of Groningen Development of an atomic clock for ...æ 698;S 8EY 698;S 8E

¤ ] rU¥Ã@oYKwr_UX|iM"YKPSJkWMLsjZTujZYZUXOíO~ML|U¥MÑRhPSgÔjZYZUi£_yJLIK-M"Iw|ªPSYKrYKrU®|UȤiPjNPSJkWÔYZJejZYKM"INYÂß9ãi ׫wrPs|IKUXWÔM"Y M"gLUÕo]

7 Ê ]/£ÇW¢YKroU®ÒUiYKroUiINsMLW|j~PSY~PjJLy$YZUXWÌRDUXsPSULUX|¢YKrM"YXû PWVj~zªPNroUXsjdPWLUXWYZUX|fÇYZJLYKMLMLsLJVUiYZRhMLsXgu]°J-ULUiIXGfPSY-MLj¥ÈJkWioINIKUXWYKsT_|ULUXsSJL£DUX|¨RVT<fMLsSUiIKT`FJLRhMLWoJujZVT\PWÔYKroU«O~P| 7 ¤^ãÊ j JkWcMdjKiPSUXWYKPSøhqRhMLjKPjX]