University of California Commission On The Future--Final Report (2010)

8/8/2019 University of California Commission On The Future--Final Report (2010)

1/52

University o Caliornia

Commission on the UtUre

Final RepoRt

novembeR 2010


2/52

Dcr ,

letter to the regents

W r sd rs hs rr h h rs h UC Css h Fuur. i rcs

gr d hugh d d r h s sr hs, y y h cssrs, u s y

h sr s h oc h prsd wh surd h, d h rs f Wrkg Grus

h dd rss r h Css. t rs, w rugh hs r dg cc h

h ss hs Ursy s y r Cr d h , d h hs rssy

dds g d dr gh drscy rd crcuscs. i h c grwgc r scrc uc drs, c d fc sur r h Ursy hugh y

rscs srg d cry wc hs wd crs wh s dcds. a h s , h

d r wrd-dg xcc chg d rsrch grws r r d urg. ths s ru r

y ur rscs, cudg g cc css, h hy ur shr, h

rsry ur cus, d ur ry rgrss s scy.

S w us scur d dc ur ss. W h ud, hwr, h ds d cssus c r

rdy wh h qus s hw rwrd hw xd ur ccshs d hc ur

xcc. thus, ks s dsc cus wh s rqurd scur d sgurd wh w h:

udgry dsc k sur w h h rsurcs sur ur s; d yc dsc

xr crrs s d ucr cgcs. ad s w d hs, w h gs

rsrcy, shrd grc d ccuy whch w c surcs srgh s

w dsg d ud h uur h Ursy.

th rcds cudd hs rr rd r s rwrd d rwrk r h

UC h uur s w k chgs h w d d.

Scry,

Russ S. Gud

Chr h brd Rgs d C-Chr h Css

mrk G. Yud

prsd h Ursy d C-Chr h Css


3/52

table of contents

introduction 2

Recommendations 2

BRieF oUtLine oF tHis RePoRt 4

context What We are facing 6

FiscaL context 6

enRoLLment and tRansFeR PRojections 6

recommendations adopted by the commission 10

PReseRving and enHancing exceLLence 10in teacHing and cURRicULUm

UndeRgRadUate enRoLLment and access stRategy 13

sUstaining ReseaRcH and gRad Uate edUcation 17

management: FiscaL disciPLine and 19administRative ReFoRm

advocacy and otHeR measURes 22

other recommendations considered 26by the commission

Recommendations not endoRsed By 26tHe commission

contingency Recommendations 27

appendix a. commission cHaRge and memBeRsHiP 28

appendix b. WoRKing gRoUPs cHaRge 30and memBeRsHiP

appendix c. commission PRocess and meetings 39

appendix d. statUs oF Recommendations Received 42By tHe Uc commission on tHe FUtURe


4/52

2 ucuture.universityocaliornia.edu

i wrk k up wh llu bu r.

t h h Ur clr

ul l ru Wrl Wr ii ur

h . y r , clr

h publ rrh ur h h b

p prr h hruh , lw r

h br. i h , hwr, h r r pr,

r ur, r h wur.

a h k r hhr. Prll, h Ur

l uh r rll

ru rur h r clr

r h r rr h hruh w uul

rr. Hw h r u wh l

s-pr rur? Hw rh u

wh r r r ppul, h

w clr? Hw h prur url

ppul rwh h r? Hw u,

hruh u- rrh hhl u

wrk r, r r w ur b

r h ? i h , wh k h wrk

h ubl 10-pu publ ur

introduction

th Ur clr h rr hr. a h r r

l, rph, ulurl pll h h Ur k hr, hruh rul

lk hw b br l r ur h. th uur b . i

u b h wh rh hk r rl h wh b h r h br

prr h r, pr lu h u h r r h Ur

. th hll wll b rk urr bl bw wh rlbr r

r, wh pr. th l u b r h Ur r h hr r

r r clr wll r h uur h h p. th wrk h rpr

rpr h b ur r hk hruh h pl bu pr uru.

. Rhr, h uur bl h

ppulu r . i clr r

b hp ppru r h wrl, h h

Ur clr u b bl, h r rl

h brh h, pr h r lh h

ph rwr.

Recommendations

th p mm pp b h

cmm w h w b

pp h m. a h mm w

m b b Wkg Gp mp

, , , m, m m

10 uc mp, w rg b

h . (s appx B.)

th cmm h mp g m

wh h pj m. W h

b m q h m g

ll wrl-l rrh u.

ucuture.universityocaliornia.edu


5/52

3

W lu h uh u b , wh

ul r, h Ur clr

pl rl h 30 r prbl h rl

h pl h p 150.

th c purp, hwr, l. Prpll,

w r r rp h r- -r

hll whl prr rl p qul

. th r h ul lu, bu u rwr pr h rwrk r h

u Uc lrhp.

i hul b h, h Ur pl

ll h prp h rpr, hul h l r

wr, hr r hr ur h wr p

h whh h c w

r ( ohr R

cr b h c) h b r

puru rr prr h l h

Ur. th ur lu r urhr

r ru, uh r u, rr rll hr rl u

b pu, h h urhr r , uh

l u rll, wz h ul

wrk r, r w pl bul pr.

th uur clr, ul -b

wh w b l br fu b ur

u ul, h w k . our 20

r, w whh w prw hr, ll

wh rlpp r.

th currulu, r h r h

r-l prp u ul, lu

pr --r b r

bl pl ur r, r phw

r ru hr r. th wll ru h

r r u, wll bl h Ur

pru r bhlr r ru wh bu

h ll l rur. ahr r

r r pl prr plr h qul

bl u rr ull l ur r Uc

r r. spll, w hp lp r

uppr bu whhr r p

l u hlp r Uc qul

u, prhp ru rul pur.

Urru erll a lur h r u h clr mr

Pl r Hhr eu l r rh rr

u, rh pru rr

l bl r clr l, rl

l r rqur r u rrr

r clr cu cll Uc pu,

r p r urru rll.

nr rll wul b r b h

ubr s-u clr rll. nr

u p hhr u ur hr rll

ubz b pr.

Rrh gru eu r rl ur

. th c r

u r h ru u rll

l blh uppr Uc rrh ,

pll h pu-p l r rl u.

W l bl h rr ph ul-pu

rrh r wll b - whl ull

r ll rhr ppru r

h prp.

Fl dpl ar Rr lu

ubl ph pr ur

urhr r r l r l-

uppr prr. W l uppr h pl

h R Pr w

r rubl ur r

w rr h Frl r r

rul h r h u rh

uc coMMission on tHe uture


6/52


h Ur p r wrk ur rl r r

r. th w r l, uul,

wul br rl hur ll llr ull Uc.

a ohr mur r fu

h rl l bu pll h h

hr h Ur. th p publ u

r h p w r hul b u,

wll rr rur u Uc purp, plh, lu

. W hul l r pru h Frl

r pr pl ul uppr r

rrh ur wh pl r u

r u r lw- l.

th c wrk h u

r r r b rbl lk

wh ur l r hr r. Pll

l ubl h ppl clr

h Br R.

th ul, hwr, rul pl rl

rull r h Ur wrk. th r h

ul r rpbl r h

rl ru, urrulu, prl,

rrh. th h r ur, , hrr,

h ul rl u b h rl pr rul

u r u h ur .

i llw, hrr, h l r , h

c r b ull

whu h h a

cul, dl s ul . s, ,

ur l h rpr ru pr

h u b l h pr r p

l h w. i r, ur, h Br

R h lbr b hr wh pl

r l rpbl h ul, chllr,

Pr r hr.

BRieF oUtLine oF tHis RePoRt

th rpr pr llw: Fr, w

rl h whh w r

rp, lu bu rll pr,

h lkl qu r ur . s, w

pr h r p b h c

r: () Prr h ll

h urrulu; (b) Urru rll ; () su rrh ru u;

() m: l pl r rr;

, () a hr ur. th pr

r rll u, l r

pr h c wb.1

Fll w pr rl h h c hr

l r r bl r wrh l u,

bu b h ; uur lp

rqur h h b bruh rwr

r .

1 hp://../wm.hm


7/52

5uc coMMission on tHe uture


8/52


context What We are facing

FiscaL context

th wrk h c ur l

rk b l l hll r h

l-r h Ur b

h s. th Ur r hll hwll rl $5 bll pur h Ur

r pr bu r h , lu:

normalinationarycostincreasesforfacultyandsta

lr, pl hlh b, qup lbrr

rl, ul, hr -lr ;

growingunfundedliabilitiesforretireepensionand

hlh b;

theneedtoclosecompetitivefacultyandsta

lr p;

thedesiretoimprovethestudent-facultyratioand

rr rul bu;

acriticalneedtoincreasethenumberofgraduate

u h ru u uppr

pk;

investmentsinessentialacademic,technologicaland

l rruur.

th hll r h Ur ur h ru

r h , prulrl h wwr r

s uppr, w ru .

s uppr r Uc h fuu r ,

wh h . Uc hr h l s

bu, hwr, h l rkl r h l r.

i h l 1980, r h 5 pr h s grl

Fu w Uc. B 2009-10, h Uc hr h

l 3.1 pr.

mr l, s u h kp p wh

f rll rwh, prulrl r h l

. s 1990-91, r f-u s

uppr r u Uc u l 54 pr.

su r h r l bu w-h(40 pr) h r. ohr ru

h rul ru rul

r, ul lr l ru

u r rul qup, lbrr rl,

l . a rul, rll f-u

p pr u r r u h l b

25 pr r 20 r.

enRoLLment and tRansFeR PRojections

clr mr Pl r Hhr eu pr h

ll clr r h p -hh h hhhl ru l b r pl whr Uc.

i l rqur Uc pl r ll lbl

clr cu cll rr u wh ppl.

dp h hrll s u, Uc u

mr Pl bl b r ll lbl clr

r rh rr ppl pl h

, lhuh wr r r r r pu

hr r h. th h rul r-r Uc

rll h prlll h lr-r clr hh

hl ru l.

n l h Ur r rr ubr

u, Uc l uh p-r

U.s. rrh ur bl rll

ll r u b. a

39 pr ll Uc urru rll r h ll

2010 r r rl Pll gr r lw-

l, r 8 pr p r


9/52


10/52


150,000

175,000

200,000

225,000

250,000

275,000

2011-122009-10 2013-14 2015-16 2017-18 2019-202007-08

262,000

233,200

216,255

28,800

EnrollmentGaps

45,700

Total Actual & Estimate No growth after 2010-11Total 2007-08 Budget Total LREP

Figure 2:L ell gap

Caps L ra ell Pla (LreP) Pjcs

Notes: UC ull year ull time equivalent (including summer); includes resident and non resident undergraduate, graduate, health sciences and other

proessional students

Source: UC Commission on the Future, presentation by the E xecutive Vice President or Business Operations


11/52


m ubl prr

rll rr ppl r ur u

ll k pr ur ppru . th

u r ll uul ur pu,

lubl r ur rpr,

l ru h l urru

r l h s. th rr u

h r rh clr hhr u

ul l h mr Plwll wrh ur r h uur. t h , Pr

mrk g. yu h p Uc

rr, wh r 1,000 l w rr

u (8 pr r) r w r l

13,915 pr r ll 2010. th h

h h Ur w r ru rll

w clr rh b 3,800 r w r

(11 pr r).

th mr Pl prrb r 60:40 uppr

lwr urru u rr h

pl uppr p r u ll rru (Uc r 2009-10 w 66:34 u rh

r wh pl hr ll r).

th rul b u ur l

rr u h ruhl hl h ubr r-

rh. currl, h r u ll

rr rh 1:2.4 u pr

h rr u wul b h h

1:2 r.

e rur wr u r h

ru r 46,000 r u r w,

Uc h h lr, , lbrr,

hu hr phl p

h u. Fr h rl, pl,

l r, wll b prulrl hll

r pu l p hr phl

l.3 th w pu, mr, w rll 3,500

u pl r 11,000 2020 25,000

bul-u, bu uh p wll rqur rur. e

Uc rll wr r f r h rbl

uur, u r Uc pl prr rl

w r rw h phl

l whh r qu l rz

rr bul pu

rqur. g h p pl l ,

Uc wll hr w ru

uppl l s u r wll purulr brk--rr lr lb.

th R ap b h c

h rpr pr r l ur 20

r; h c wb

rl bkru u h pl h purp

r.

3 s uc 2008 smw em Pj: ug G em thgh 2020-21, Ph 1 rp, p. 3, hp://www.p.//wp/p/lreP080401_2.p.


12/52


13/52


recommendation:

th c r h pu, wrk

hruh hr dl s, u pr

urru u bl ru ur r r

l b:

() r- urrulu rqur pl

ur h h r rl bur;

(b) pr r--r ur hul ul

ur h u k

r prr wr r;

() r pl phw r urru

u pl r l r hr

r, lu h r r bhlr

r r prr plh h b.

Prr rr h r wll b rpr ull

h R wh h r rpr u spbr 2011.

recommendation 2: cr Lwr-d trr

Phw a cu cll su Pl

hr a Prr

Wrk b h a dl s ru

rr brrr h prr r r;

hwr, ll lw b h grr

sp. 29, 2010, aB 2302, rqu h Ur

u rul lwr-

r prrqu hh- rr r.

th bll urhr rqu h Uc [] r

u ll ur h pr u lwr-

prpr r Ur clr

r h wll b p b h Ur.

Whl h trr Prpr Ph

rqur h urrl r Uc

pu r h p 20 rr r, hr r

rbl r pu rr lwr-

r prpr h phw h

l w r ur r h Uc pu.

grr lwr- r prpr

rqur r pu k r h

p h rr pr r u. srl

rr l h h pl z h ubr

u k b u, hrb pr --r r up r p r l u.

Bul h rr rl r,

plr ul hh- r Uc hul b

bruh hr rh r rr phw

wh rr r l ur r

ll urru pu.

recommendation:

th c r h h a s

p r rl h pr r u

rrr r clr cu cll Uc

pu b p lwr- rrqur, hrb l ur

hh- r ll

urru pu. th r wll p h

rr pr h h pl z h

ubr u k b h u. th

r bul r b h irl

c h a s rr lwr

urrulu l urru r.

th a s wll ub pl l

h Pr, b j. 31, 2011, lp lwr-

r rqur.

recommendation 3: eh h assist Wb

ipr h su trr Fu

th arul s sul irul

su trr (assist) wb h l rpr

ur rul hw ur r r


14/52


15/52


a r l p h qul p

h prr rw urk b h pu,

wll k ul prhp rrl

h. nrhl, wrhp r rur,

whhr hr ur publ r pr, rqur u uh

h rr h ll r .

recommendation:

th c r h h Pr eu v Pr wrk wh h pu

b pr prr rw. chllr

hul wrk wh h pu dl s

rpr bu r h rw, wh

prulr u rur r, uur p,

ppru . eh chllr chr h

dl s hul rpr h Pr h

prr h r ur hr ul bu .

UndeRgRadUate enRoLLment andaccess stRategy

recommendation 5: Rr h Ur

c ah mr Pl tr r

Frh trr su

th r r h Ur r

pr h clr mr Pl r Hhr

eu, whh p, hr h, h (1) h

pl u r whh h Ur clr

rw rh hul rpr h p -hh

clr publ hh hl ru; (2) ur

rbu u ll rr ph, h Ur

hul u ubr uppr- rr

l 60:40 r bw uppr-

lwr- u. th mr Pl w lr

pr ur u wh

h Ur lbl rqur. a h ,

h mr Pl h s b u pr

qu rur ur h Uc ll

lbl u.

i r r Uc h r qu s u

uppr rwh urru rll. i u

rh, wll b pbl ulll ur

ul r lr h w w

lr ru b u, wh ur

qull pr ll. B urr

h u pr h mr Pl rll

prpl, h c hp ll r ur

h rh r w rur r h plr w pprh h ru.

a r rr, h r h hl l

50-r l h. th rr ph k h bhlr

r r rbl, pr r r

ruur (lu pr- rll) h

prrbl u, h prur

pu p Uc rur.

al, h u uppr- u

r p bu llr l r

plz l. a pl, h rurqu u b r. Fr r

prp, hwr, rr u rqur l w

r Uc rur rr ru wh Uc

bhlr r. sr rr u r h

ubr r h Uc r wh ll

rul rur.

recommendation:

th c r h h Pr lp

rlu b jur 2011, r h R pprl, h

rr h Ur h mr Pl

r r h ubr prpr u wh

r h rh rr ll, h h

rur r lbl, uh h:

UCwillcontinuetoguaranteeadmissiontoatleastone

Uc pu h p -hh clr publ

hh hl ru;


16/52


UCwillcontinuetoenrollsucientnumbersoftransfer

u uppr-lwr r

l 60:40 ll pu (r 2009-10 w 66:34

u rh r wh pl

hr ll r). Rur pr, l wll

k ur h clr r u

ll u rll r r w clr

r rh (r 2009-10 w 1:2.4).

recommendation 6: cu tl eplr Full

ol iru r Urru, wll r

sl-suppr Prr Ur e

ol u rpl ur ph

rl pr wh urru, ru,

urrul Uc pr u. i

2009-10, r pl, Uc e prr r

1,250 ull l ur, r 90 pr whh rr

hr rr r r, 78 , rulr Uc

r; hr wr r 55,000 u rll, whh

r h qul ull- u, rprbu w h urr z Uc mr. thruh Uc

e, w r lr lr r l l

ru, lhuh ll rll r ull

rr r wr Uc r r r.

i qu rl qul, , wrkl b

rl wr hl b u

h Uc ul l lr ru wul

r rl b. (th c, lk h a

s h o h Pr, r h

purp u bl l ur h wul

lu u l wrk r

hll l pl r h

wul pr r u

ul.) Wh h rl rl ur urr -pu

prr, h r r, r l

ru :

Reducecourseimpaction,reduceschedulingconicts

r ur rll b bl

u r r whu b pu, hu

ru u r --r;

Createsomenewanddistinctiveopportunitieswith

rp ur , l wrk ppl,

(), h r lr

ppru r u;

Facilitatemulti-campuscourseoerings,cross-

rll llbr h, whh wul

h h urru lr pr b

llw u k ur r pr r

h Uc ;

Encourageelectronicpublicationoftextbooksandcourse

rl, ru r u.

i h r pul, lr r, ub a

s pprl, pu lp p lprr ru u qul b r

Uc u. th l ru k

pr rbu ur . th wul

b pll pr lh h ru p

u bl h hrz.

mrr, h h u-p u hr

h h rll h rl -pu prr

r r hruh l ur lr b

Ur e, l ur prr :

ExtendUCsreachinacademicpreparationofuniversity-

bu hh hl u ll u

(.., hruh ul-rll);

Addressunmetneedsforpost-baccalaureatedegreesand

r hh- l;


17/52


18/52


19/52


20/52


21/52


recommendation 12: ir gru su erll

m L R Pl gl Rrh m

Prrb h mr Pl

th u ru u rl Uc

h, rrh r , h

ulurl lp h . our ru

prl hl prr r

r h hhl qul, l ru wrlw, wh h wrk wh ul r

rrh h urru. t b ll

l lbl r, hwr, h prpr

ru rll rl urru rll

u b qu uppr h rrh rul

. a rl ru u l rul

r r p ul, wh r pll qu u

h rl u wh wh wrk. a Uc

h l p urru rll r h

p 50 r, ru rll h kp p;

ru u h lpp r -hr -h

l rll.

th u ru u r p

h urru u, bh rul

u l uppr. thrr, ur urr

bl l pr, u r ru

rll rwh wul rqur h pu ru

urru rll upbl rul

lh ur h mr

Pl rll l.

th c lu h u

rh ru u rl l

Uc wh h mr Pl qu

ll rrh ur. Uc lr u

lp r r, rl pr,

plh rrl r whh prrz

rr ur rrh .

recommendation:

Rz Uc rl h mr Pl h

prr rrh rl-r u, h

c r h h Ur r h

prpr ru rll r 22 pr

l rll 26 pr b 2020-216, wh ul

r b h pu.

th c urhr r h h pu,ur h u h Pr, lp lr

pl h wll h h rll r b

ru u r. th pl hul b pr

h Pr b au. 1, 2011, h r h

blh rll r r 2012-13 h

nbr R Bu.

management: FiscaL disciPLine andadministRative ReFoRm

recommendation 13: ipr trpr b Rrr

tu Pl F

c wh lu h or a (1868) h

clr mr Pl r Hhr eu (1960) h ll

up h Ur b u r r clr,

Uc h lbl - u hr

u. Hwr, p h lbl, h rl

1990 h eu F h Prl dr F

h b qul u h r pll

ur. th w pr rl ru r r

rul p. i r, h su sr F

pr ru r -rul u prr

r, pprprl lbl .

Lbl u hr u r ru

u wh h ur

h r b h rl publ, h rl r

hr whh h Ur rpr

u hr. cll ur rpr hr

6 tg b uc 2008 smw em Pj: ug G em thgh 2020-21, Ph 1 rp, hp://www.p.//wp/p/lreP080401_2.p.


22/52


ul hr h rl r hr

r . Fr pl, hl

prp bh lur r ur

ul (iPeds, U.s. nw & Wrl Rpr, .),

bur u r ru prr r

ul hr (.., r ul

b, llwhp prr). i ll h ,

u u Uc p h r u

rpr h prr ul hr r rulp. oll, Uc r r h r

pr h rl qu. Fr pl, gi Bll

p clr r pr hl

wr l bu p r url h

ll u hr b publ ll -

r whh, clr, hll zr.

recommendation:

th c r r h eu

F h Prl dr F (bu h su

sr F) u. Lbl h u hr

u r ru u wh h ur h r b h

rl publ, h rl r hr

whh h Ur rpr u hr.

th c r h h Pr, r

ul wh h a s pprpr

s , lp h r pl r, r

h R pprl nbr 2010, r h

eu F Prl dr F u.

recommendation 14: ep ipl Uc

i sw ar Rr, wh h

gl $500 mll aul s

ar rr h b u

h Pr R r rl r. s

ul r rqur

pr, rrh u, lbrr, u r

, pr pl, pu-w

w r, l pr, ll

r u rl. c rl rl

rrh h (hr r r

) r rpr 25-30 pr h Uc

r u bu. Whl r h b k

ru h , h r ubl.

t h h r b ru pr pr, pl ,

pr, p h b r pr wh

h Uc r r rur

rrh u. alhuh h o h Pr

h pu h lr pl

ur, h c l bl h

ur u b ull , u,

p bl h Ur bul ubl

l l. thruh uul pl h

, r h Ur ul rr l

$500 ll ull uppr r rrh

hr uu r b , ru r.

status report:

o jul 14, 2010, h R p rlu

rr r . th rlu r

h Pr, ul wh ll

pu rpr, , whr pprpr,

pl b-pr r ,

lu bu l u r ,

l , hu rur , prll

, hr url hl uppr .7

th c r h prr rpr

h r r b pr l

ull h R.

7 s hp://www../g/gm/j10/2.p.


23/52


recommendation 15: alr dlp sl-

suppr Prr ir $250 mll pr yr

F yr h i dr r h Prr

sl-uppr prr h h pl r

ru r pr, prulrl

pr lr rruur (.., wh

hr pr r Uc e) r

h prr. or Uc ur -Uc u,whhr hruh e publ prr r urr

rll, wul br w llr h Ur.

curr Uc l-uppr prr r bu

$100 ll ull, bu $25 ll pr r b

prr . Hwr, h ru r

h hh-, l-uppr u mBa prr.

t , hr l-uppr prr r rll

ll r u b prr .

grw h prr lp w

l-uppr prr ul r ru r h

Ur p Uc ur. Fr pl,

r bhlr r pl prr, whh

r hh ll r urr wrk r

lp , ul rul l ru

r r Uc whl l pr hr u

Uc u r qul u. slrl, u l-

uppr prr pr Uc ur

hh hl u ll u prr hr

rul Uc ul pll pr --

r b ru h r h u wul b

rqur k h r Uc.

ip p l-uppr prr

lu u pl (r pl,

pl h rr rll l-uppr s

uppr u h ur) wll l

rruur uppr r r r w

prr. a p l-uppr prr

Uc hul r bh p b:

(1) lp lrr pl rwrk r r

pr l-uppr prr h pr pu

pr fbl h r ubl

h h wul ur h s rur

r b u h prr;

(2) rruur uppr

r h pu pr ul ll up

p l-uppr r.

recommendation:

th c uppr l plr h

p Uc l-uppr prr, r

h h Pr h v Pr r a Pl

wrk wh h a s urhr lp h l-

uppr r p prpl, r bh

pl prl p. Prr h r

wll b rpr h Pr spbr 2011.

recommendation 16: R Uc-W ab r

Pr Fur

th Ur h h ru u pr

ur r h p 20 r. i h p , Uc

pu h lll r r $1 bll ull,

r r $1.6 bll Fy 2007-08. th Ur

hr ur, hwr, rk b hh ll

rr h u r. apprl 95 pr

Uc rll w pu rr, r

wh 80 pr r publ u 55 pr

r pr u. ol 2 pr ll uppr

r r urr, l r w. t pu

h , h $1.3 bll u r Fy 2008-09,

u r $25 ll ul b hrrz urr.

ir rll ur lp w l

r h u urr r r fbl u

ul r ru uppr Uc r

u : ul ll, ru u uppr


24/52


25/52


26/52


27/52


28/52


other recommendations considered

by the commission

i h 20 r r, h

c l lbr rl h h

r h bu h r wrh l u,

h b

ur hul h l u wr.

Recommendations not endoRsedBy tHe commission

recommendation a:ap mul-yr tu shul

i rr prr qul u r Uc u,

h Ur h h r w u ru

prll bkll h r s bu u h h

urr. th u r h b prbl r

u hr l bu bh hr z

hr uprbl. t h p rurpru b lr, up u r h ur

-u, Uc ul p ul-r u hul

r hr ur-ru whh wul r

p ubr r .., h pl --

r bw ur r r r rh

w hr r r rr u.

ap ul-r u hul wul, hwr,

ru fbl u ru rqur h

Ur k pl. s u

u wul b ur u r r,

ru rqur b h u u ul s u, r pl wul h b

r b h 30 pr u wh wul b

ub h w u r. i , ppl

h ul-r u hul hul b

r b h s. i h

brup s bu u, h Ur h

p r u r u h

hul u.

Fr h r, h c r

h Ur p ul-r u hul r

urru u h .

recommendation b:chr drl tu b cpu

cpu r hr l p r

u. alhuh u lhl l Uc

bur hll, k p u

r h l ru ur h Uc

rpl hr u hrll. i ppr h

ubl hr ll h pu r

r-h-br u r whu h p

rll.

allw u r b pu b h

pr h u r r pu

r. drl u ul bh pr l u rll pu b

pr l, llw u r

pu whr r rll l.

allw r u ll wul l p h

Ur l ru pr u r

h ul b rbu w b ll pu.

y hr r hll wh hr

rl u, lu: rr r pr

r ul r pu r u- purp;

pl p h pr rpu r

qul pu; h pl

pl rr lp rbu l

h b ll pu.

th c rll bl h Uc h

hu hr u ru r

prpr r h r h .

Hwr, h c urhr r h h


29/52


Pr lp p r h uul pl

pu rl u r hul h b r

prr Uc qul h uur.

contingency Recommendations

shul h l r p s hr u

ur u l p whr h Ur

lr u l qul r , h R,

Pr, chllr a s

r r ll h llw ur:

Curtailstudentenrollment,potentiallyfallingshortof

h h mr Pl r r b

h c ( R 5) rr

bh h urru (rh rr)

ru ll.

Re-examineUCsnancialaidstrategies,also

r b h c ( R 7),lu ru h pr w urru

u ru h (urrl 33 pr)

u l r u.

Raiseoreliminatethesystemwidelimitontheproportion

r urru u

rll (h c r 10 pr

w p R 8).

Substantiallyincreasetuitionandfees,includingcharging

rl u b pu (u b), pr

br-b prr u h Ur.

DownsizetheUniversitysfacultyandstaworkforce,

lu l h rpl ul l u

rr, r hr pr. th

r h c r h

a cul.

Forgonewbuildingandcapitalprojectsthatarenot

blul l r . th r l

r h a cul.

th c bl h Uc h hr h

h r ru h u

h Ur h r r. Hwr, h

ur l b hul b plr w h

h h l h r Uc prulru l. th ur, ull

hr, h ru pl r h uur h

Ur h s clr.


30/52


31/52

uc coMMission on tHe uture 29

Rull s. gul Br R chr, c-chr

mrk g. yu Pr, c-chr

ewr L. ab Rrr drr a sr, Uc s d

(R s ar, jul 1, 2009-ju 30, 2010)

j m. Brl ir dr crr, UcoP (su R, jul 1, 2009 -ju 30, 2010)

g Blk chllr, UcLa

ch Brw Prr, Uc s Brbr

j ch su R

mr cruh eu drr, Rrh gr Prr o, UcoP

(a s chr, sp. 1, 2008-au. 31, 2009)

al dllkr Prr, Uc Rr

mhl v. drk chllr, Uc ir

chrphr el, jr. shl Lw d, Uc Brkl

yl nu gr Pr ceo, Brll sr, i. Pr, Phllp gru

iu (alu R, jul 1, 2009-ju 30, 2010)

Wrr Hll aluu, Uc Brkl

shrr L. L R (c mbr r jul 16, 2009 -au. 11, 2010)

m Lz R

clu m Pr, Uc su a

(c mbr r sp. 1, 2010-d. 31, 2010)

Hr (Hrr) Pwll Prr, Uc s d (a s chr, sp. 1, 2009-au. 31, 2010)

ar Pulk eu srr-trurr, clr Lbr Fr

vr shz v Pr, U s su a (c mbr

Pr, Uc su a, sp. 1, 2009-au. 31, 2010)

Hr t. y chllr, Uc s Brbr

all Zrbr Pr ch eu or, clr chbr cr

s Bkwh v Pr r Rrh gru su, br

nh Brr eu v Pr, br

dl gr v Pr, a Pl, Prr cr, br

Lwr H. P Pr eu v Pr, br

dl L. s a s chr, br

Pr tlr eu v Pr ch Fl or, br

uc coMMission on tHe uture

uC CommiSSion on the Future


32/52

appendix b. WoRKing gRoUPs cHaRge and memBeRsHiP

30


33/52


34/52


programs that are not cost efective? Should there be a new

model ocusing UC on graduate and proessional education

and undergraduate education that cannot be delivered by other

public segments?

Evaluatethesizeandbreadthofacademicprogram

r h rbu h r b pu,

wh u r plz. th rup wll

r wh r h pu hul b lr rr hr ul prr, r hr rwh

ubr urru, ru prl

u hr pl r. Ful

rrh pr p, pr

lbl u, uqu rur (ur prr,

r prhp, phl l, .) hr

rl r wll b r h pr.

Theworkgroupwillconsideranddeveloprecommendations

rr h pu rll (rh, rr,

urru, ru prl, r, -

r, .) b pu r h whl.

2. education and curriculum

What alternative educational delivery models will both maintain

quality and lower educational delivery costs?


r r l ul lr, lu:

urrulu r prr;

hw r pr hw

w r wh u; l r ru;

u rqur ur; rur r

rqur; l h ubr u prbl

(lu a Pl u); r-ru

ru; hr-r blur r; u:

ul r; . th pr h l

ul lr wll b , wll r

r r.

ConsiderhowtheUniversityworksincollaborationwith

K-12, u ll, clr s Ur

hr prr h h hh qul

u pbl.

Considerandexamineothermodelsofhighereducation

wh h U s lwhr, p prulr

l h wrk rrh ur,

publ ur l r u.

3. access and affordability

How can UC best meet the needs o Caliornia and at what

levels o access and afordability assuming diminishing

resources? Should there be greater reliance on Caliornia State

Universities and Caliornia Community Colleges or access?

Should ees be increased?

Theworkgroupwillundertakeacomprehensiveevaluation

urr lr u b z, l pl ruur, wll h p

h lr u r.

Considerandexamineotherfee,aidandaccessmodels

wh h U s lwhr, p prulr

l h wrk rrh ur,

publ ur, l r u.

4. funding strategies

How can traditional and alternative revenue streams be

maximized in support o UCs mission?

Theworkgroupwillexploreanddeveloprecommendations

z u r rl ur lu

h , rl pr r, wll

lr ru r. nw r wll u

w h u r r pr,

rul , rruur pl pr.


35/52


Theworkgroupwillalsodeveloprecommendationsfor

p l h Ur

upprr h r.

5. research strategies


r w l r ru p h rrh

rpr, lu ru u uppr, upprr, rrh u, r rr,

llbr, pl r. nw l

r llbr rrh wh pu r

pu, wh ur prr, h lp

hbr l wll b plr.

Bestpracticesindevelopinganddeliveringresearch

pr urru, ru, p-rl

llw prl u wll l b .

th r h b u r r. th

c wrkrup wll rl pru u b h o h Pr, a

s, pu ul rrhr hr

lbr. ipl r wll

b ub rl rw b h a s

h r r whh h l uhr. Fr

r ll hr r, h a s

wll h ull ppru r ul rw.


36/52


gr Bluhl, c-chr chllr, Uc s cruz

ch Brw, c-chr Prr Frh, Uc s Brbr

nr abr Prr eru, shl Lw, UcLa

Kh all eu v chllr Pr, Uc mr

d Br Prr ahrpl, Uc s cruz

Phlp Bu sr v Pr, mr sl

Rbr cpbll Frr mbr, clr s abl

mul dl gru su, Uc Brkl

drk dFr Uc Br R (R-d)

mrr Fru Prr elh, Uc d

mr Fr Prr erl s, Pl, m, Uc Brkl

jh g Prr, Klr, Prk, cull Br

dbrh grp Prr, shl dr, Uc s Fr

K j Prr chr, Uc ir

grh jh su, Uc s Brbr

d mrhll eu d, cll Lr s, Uc s Brbr

mrk mu Prr erl er, Uc Rr

d mllr dpu a chllr, UcLa

clr Pr v chllr, Hu Hlh s d,

shl m, Uc d

j Pk Prr Bl, Uc s d

jh sbrk Frr ir ch s, Uc o h Pr

d sur Prr sl, Uc s Brbr

Rl sz Uc Br R

s thr d, Phl Bll s, Uc s cruz

Lwr P ( ) Pr eu v Pr, Uc o h Pr

Size & ShAPe Working grouP


37/52


38/52

ucuture.universityocaliornia.edu36

j Brl, c-chr ir dr crr, UcoP (su R, jul 1, 2009 -ju 30, 2010)

mhl drk, c-chr chllr, Uc ir

aku a-awuku a Prr chl erl er, Uc Rr

mhl Brw Prr, grz gru shl eu, Uc s Brbr

R cp Pr, m cu cll, s d

ol dz m sr or, cr chz dpr ch

ch su, UcLa

drk du-Rk chr, dpr mhl arp er, Uc ir

K grubh chr, dpr Fl cu m, Uc s Fr

Br Hrw su, Uc mr

sl Hur Prr, gru shl eu ir su, UcLa

Bb jb Prr Ph, Uc Brkl

H mkrh Uc Br R

B obur d, shl vrr m, Uc d

ak R-t a Prr sl, Uc s d

P Ru v chllr r su ar, Uc s d

Fr Ruz Uc Br Rsu sr Prr mlulr, cll, dlpl Bl, Uc s cruz

nh Brr ( ) eu v Pr r Bu opr, Uc o h Pr

ACCeSS & AFFordAbiLity Working grouP


39/52


g Lu, c-chr eu v chllr, Uc s Brbr

s ol, c-chr v chllr r F, Bu cpl Prr, UcLa

er Brb su, UcLa

L B Prr vulur el, Uc d

H Bh Prr e, Uc s Brbr

Hr Br d, gl shl Publ Pl, Uc Brkl

dl g. Burh iii Frr ceo, Rh (rr)

sr Fbr chr, dpr ar arph, Uc s cruz

d grr Prr, mbl Rrh U, Uc s Fr

Br grh a drr cpl Pl sp m, Uc mr

Rbr H tru, el Wlr H, jr. Fu

gr H Prr e, UcLa

R H Uc Br R

Pr Krpp a Prr, Fl m su, Uc ir

crl L Prr Pl Phl, Uc Rr

jh mr v chllr r Rur m, Uc d

mrh mhl v chllr r Pl Bu, Uc ir

ar Pulk eu srr-trurr, clr Lbr Fr

Rbr Rh Prr, gl shl Publ Pl, Uc Brkl, rr U.s. srr Lbr

mur slr Pr ceo, al tw chr-el, UcLa Fu Br drr

Ll t-shll Uc Br R

Bru vrr Uc Br R

Pr tlr ( ) eu v Pr ch Fl or, Uc o h Pr

Funding StrAtegieS Working grouP


40/52


41/52


appendix c. commission PRocess and meetings

cReation oF Uc commissionon tHe FUtURe

Uc R chr Rull gul r h Uc

c h Fuur jul 2009. th c

w hr wh lp w r h Ur

wh h h Ur , whl

rr ur , rbl

h hh ll qul ru, rrh, publr hlh r. Uc u u pl l

rl u clr ulurl l,

pr rll l pbl wh

lbl rur h h s r l

r h uur.

c-hr b R chr gul Pr

yu, h c w p br r

r Uc u h Ur. a h

pp r h c r: urr

rr Uc R j Brl, j ch, shrr

L, m Lz yl nu gr; UcLachllr g Blk; Uc ir chllr mhl drk;

Uc s Brbr chllr Hr y; Uc Brkl

shl Lw d chrphr el; rr a

s chr mr cruh; rr a s chr

Hr Pwll; prr ch Brw (Uc s Brbr)

al dllkr (Uc Rr); rr Uc R

r ewr ab; clu m, pr

h Uc su a ( p rrl hl

b vr shz); Wrr Hll, luu Uc

Brkl; clr chbr cr Pr all

Zrbr; ar Pulk, u rr-rurr

h clr Lbr Fr, aFL-cio. e br r h Uc o h Pr r Pr

Lrr P, eu v Pr nh Brr

( p rrl hl b K Lpp), eu v

Pr Pr tlr, v Pr s Bkwh

v Pr dl gr.

WoRKing gRoUPs PRocess

th Uc c h Fuur w uppr b

wrk rup rz ru h br p r

h z hp Uc, u urrulu,

rbl, u r, rrh r:

size and shape of uc, hr b Uc s cruz chllr

gr Bluhl Uc s Brbr prr br ch Brw, plr h

pprpr rll ll prr r r

h Ur rwr, wll w pr

rl h rr pr r u.

education and curriculum, hr b Uc Brkl

shl Lw d br chrphr

el Uc d prr Kh Wll, lk

whhr hr r lr lr l h wll

bh qul lwr , lu

r r h prpr u wh

ru ur r r l.

access and affordability, hr b h-Uc su

R j Brl Uc ir chllr mhl

drk, bh br, rw hw Uc

b h l pr bl

rbl u r u ppul

l h rur.

funding strategies, hr b Uc s Brbr

eu v chllr g Lu UcLa v

chllr s ol, u hw z

ru r rl lr ur, ru

hruh r r ,

h Uc r.

research strategies, hr b rr a s

chr mr cruh Uc s Brbr chllr

Hr y, bh br, lk

hw Uc ulz w l r rrh pr

llbr, wh u h .


42/52


43/52


Recommendation RevieW PRocess

th c pr h a s, cul

Uc s abl Uc su a wh

ppru rll rw rp h

r pu rh b h wrk rup

mrh ju. th w h r rup wr

r ur h c lbr h

ru r, h rl wr rpub b h a s, whh lu

l r 10

l , wr rbu br

p h c wb: hp:www.

urlr.urprHcP2yu_

FrRu_s_c61110.p hp:www.

urlr.urprculrp_

Ru2cotF.p.

i , pl h r pu

rwr h R b h Uc c h

Fuur wll b ub rl rw b h as h r r whh h l uhr. Fr

r ll hr r, h a s

wll h ull ppru r ul rw.

commission meetings and deLiBeRations

th c r publ

up r h wrk rup, hr pr

r pkr, u r

r h prpl pu rwr h c.

sept. 8, 2009

th c r u hhr pr r h rup. th c l

hr r u pkr j v. Wll, u

rr, dl Pr Pr eu c,

wh rb h rl l u Uc

hr ur r h ur.

noV. 12, 2009 a h nbr , h c

r up r h wrk rup hr

r pr pl pkr: mrk Blr,

pr ceo, Publ Pl iu clr

(PPic); Rbr B. Rh, prr, Uc Brkl, gl

shl Publ Pl, rr U.s. srr

Lbr; Rhr c. ak, pr ru, Ur

clr; d Prp grr, pr

ru, Ur clr.

dec. 8, 2009 a pr lbr, h

c hl publ ru h UcsF m Bpu l publ pu r r u

Uc rbu clr h hr

u hrll. th c l hr

pr r dl L. s, hr h

a s; L K, hr h cul Uc

s abl; h-su R-

j ch, wh l br.

march 23, 2010 th c r pr

h r ru r r h

wrk rup mrh. th publ pr

ur h l lu pr bUr lbr rpr.

June 14, 2010 a ju, h c

u u r r h

wrk rup h r l rll

hll h Ur. a h , h

c l hr r lp b

h a cul.

aug. 31, 2010 th c auu

u l prpl r h wrk rup.

i , h c r r h

r u ph bh h ju

auu .

oct. 11, 2010 a r rpr h c w

rw ur o. 11, 2010.

th rl r h h

c r lbl hp:uuur.

urlr.upr.


44/52


appendix d. statUs oF Recommendations Received By tHe

Uc commission on tHe FUtURe p h mm b hp://../

WoRKing gRoUP: siZe and sHaPe

WorkinggrouP reCommendAtion

CommiSSiondiSCuSSiondAte

ASSignedLeAd ACtion/neXt StePS

ACAdemiCSenAtereVieW

sz shp

R 1: n-ru rll

8312010 cpu,Pr

cpu blh -r rllr. Pr r wprpr rpr ull R.(s l aa 1, Fs 6)

cpl6112010

R 2: Lwr-rr phw

6142010 as

a s ub pl l h Pr b j. 31, 2011.

cpl6112010

R 3: assist wbpr

6142010 aar

Pr P vP skk urhr lp hr b mrh 2011.

cpl6112010

R 4: all hlhpr r

n rwr h . cpl6112010

R 5: elrru pr

6142010 Pr Rlu R jul 2010 rPr pl b-prr . (s l Fs 2, ep 9)

cpl6112010

R 6: sr pl w

8312010,101110

cpu;aar

t dr: cpu dl s wrk pr r rprprr ull R, wh r rpr u

spbr 2011. (s l ss 8, ec 1, ep 2).a Prr: Pr wrk wh pu b pr prrrw. chllr dl srpr Pr prr ur ulbu . (s l ec 4, ep 1)

cpl8132010

R 7: cpu ul

1011201 0 Bu er w u r prurrl urw. (s l aa 7)

cpl8132010

R 8: erll 8312010 cpu;Pr

t dr: cpu dl s wrk pr r rprprr ull R, wh r rpr uspbr 2011. (s l ss 6, ec 1, ep2). mr Pl R: Pr lprlu b jur 2011 r R pprl.

(s l aa 1) gr erll: cpu lp pl r ru rll pr h h Pr b auu2011. (s l aa 3)

cpl8132010


45/52


WoRKing gRoUP: edUcation and cURRicULUm





eu currulu

R 1: mul rurr l t r

8312010 cpu cpu dl s wrk pr r rpr prrull R, wh r rpr uspbr 2011. (s l ss 6, ss 8,ep 2)

cpl6112010

R 2: olru

6142010 aar

d spl ar el pr l pl prr R jul2010. (s l ep 6 7)

cpl6112010

R 3: ep l-uppr pr- prr

6142010 aar

Pr P v Pr gr wrk wh a cul urhrlp h l-uppr r pprpl. Prr h r b rpr h Pr spbr 2011. (s lep 3)

cpl6112010

R 4: sw plrwrk

10112010 cpu;aar

Pr wrk wh pu b pr prr rw.chllr dl s rpr Pr prr ur ul bu. (s l ss 6, ep 1)

cpl6112010

R 5: Qul rwrk

Not moving orward at this time. cpl8132010

R 6: iprrr b publhlwr- pr-r rqur



46/52






Accss aAfal

R 1: Rr Uc

8312010 cpu,Pr

mr Pl R: Pr lprlu b jur 2011 r R' pprl.( l ss 8) n-r: cpu blh -r rll r.Pr r w prpr

rpr ull R. ( l ss 1, Fs 6)

cpl6112010

R 2: Rr Uc' l bl

8312010 Pr Pr lp rlu b mrh 2011r R pprl.

cpl6112010

R 3: Rr Uc ru u

8312010 cpu,Pr

cpu lp pl r rurll pr h h Pr bauu 2011. (s l ss 8)

cpl6112010

R 4: Fl lbl ruuu (dReam a)


R 5: mul-r hul

6142010 Not moving orward at this time. (See also FS 5) cpl6112010

R 6: R r u

6142010 Pr Pr lp r pl rr R pprl nbr 2010.

cpl6112010

R 7: swl ull


R 8: Fluppr r l- l


R 9: cpufbl uur r lbl


WoRKing gRoUP: access and aFFoRdaBiLity


47/52


48/52






rsacSas

R 1.1: ir c Rr 6142010 o Rrh

P vP Bkwh pm icr rg nmb 2010. (s s 3, s 4)

cpl6112010

R 1.2: eur llr br pru u- rrh


R 1.3: "Uc gr chllRrh i"


R 1.4: srl rk pr rl rrh rpr


R 1.5: a lll r rrh

8312010 a p w b p hrg h h .

cpl6112010

R 2.1: irhp llwhp r u

8312010 chllr chllr ull rpr hPr r h r urhr ul bu hprr lp h prr.

(s l Rs 2.6)

cpl8132010

R 2.2: ap wrrh


R 2.3: cr pr h publwh rrh rul

8312010 Not moving orward at this time. cpl8132010

R 2.4: mz Uc lbrr' p upprrrh


R 2.5: eh rrhprulpuprr

8312010 o Rrh

vP Bkwh p pmpm p mp m-mp h P whx mh.

cpl8132010

R 2.6: mr, rr prl lp rruprl u p

8312010 chllr ch p hP h x gh bg mg hpg pg h pgm.(s rs 2.1)

cpl8132010

WoRKing gRoUP: ReseaRcH stRategies


49/52






AcacCcl

R 1: m hh qul urruu

6142010 am s wg g hmm.

na

R 2: cp rur r

ul prl

6142010 am s

wg g hmm.

na

R 3: i h l hrll:r ru, wz, r wbul pl pr, bl pprpr u r w prr

6142010 am s wg g hmm.

na

WoRKing gRoUP: academic coUnciL


50/52


51/52


52/52

Documents

University of California Commission On The Future--Final Report (2010)