Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
JUN 1 S 2014 COURT OF APPEALS /
"STAT::;~~!!~:~!~GTON .......... b • \~·ll:'\ ilv----------
-~--L~¥'0-.. wc-t\:~vv .. }.t~~.., .kk\-~r ~<; ~c ..... ~+.: .. ·:h~_VV"-e.Y\.-\ oF ~ t-\•o~\ _ {jrco~s ·-\u _ ·t"'.e..... h\"'\ ~(:: -t~~ 1..-..l~'> f. \ ... d, __ IV\. __
:\h~ "> C..O" .. t~± .. b~ ____ ("'0.-~- _ A-\\oi'V\.~,. _
. _ _ _ _ kJ.L ~ __ \h~.:. _ ~ .:,-\<.'("""-~~~~ -\· _ of' ~"-"k).,.i\ 1_u"'=., .... ._\. jr-:oo,.; ~S __
1 :I:,._ ~~ _ \::E:!,.'>~~,A~v.\\1 _ ~~u<:>-\t""J to L..,>~-\-l.cM-b.l..J ~~
-~-\€k..... o-f-_ 5u. \\j ~')e.e..l Q~ -±\....-e... -'Zj\o'..J~"> ~-+
b-e, \~'0.1<.. ""'""( ~\~ i'-, . \\f':-.Uolu.-.-\c;.,' '- )- _ o,.v.,..c.,( We .. ')_ .
~a-..-oc_ -~J\~ \.,..,._C..OV""-~<\-.\l'~-\-1 _ ~& ~~- W ;~\,.~A ~-,')
Sf\(.~ __ L..J \\\ ..... s~~-~\- -\-\..-.e.'><- c .. \cr...~~'>- c.;~. -\\..:-.e--<--c,.,~~r~ -s~\el. <.;.\\ow .. \~"'--.<.._. \a l.-) ~~ c}._l(:;J..J yv--.1 '*'u,_ cf' [ju·,\{y.
f\t'h ~ ~erl:.-,vz._ re.xa,.~ 1 ::S:. ~v:<- cli'">UU-"I'eCl
~-\-- -:I:-- )\t\CUi&_ \oe- o..\\w<c"l -\t.) Wt~~ ..,...,.{ \>\~ loc.s.e~l
ov-. v"'( _ ~\o.- cf-~u:.\\7 be.;~ ·,>'"\vAv.,.,;~~'{ c....~ ~·~~0<...
. ~0\J... ~k '("""\.l ~\~ \v:-..v~\tol, ~ £...),\\. '::,c. d~<;c..,~s.v,
. -~• l""-GD"""'~<-\~-Z 0~ y-.,.1_ ~~.:.~. lc:...\~c- \~ ~-.._<.._ ~}~!\·"), bv\- ~ \ \'<):\-- X- l.J;u~l_ LilA-<- -\-o cA iS C..u S" ~ "> o v--e:_ I~.(.. -e.,-.,-\ \'(
cA._~ G-_CJ.Vt': ,-J.c;t ln.t<:·c--~\~, • ......._1
t.J~cJ,.\. t-Jo01.A... __ l:x_ _ -+~ . t--y
$_e~\·(.N"'-'<- ~La.\.) e'.,__ _ __ ~OS~\ s~\~\y 0~ L_;\-~. ~;"> 1 C:,
. of- ~~ q\e.~A\"':) _ >.:J\,)·,\'\, , ::X:: kv~ ~~ -\.:.\.:~ -~,, _
~\- L)t,) l..J\~\v-- ~'( ~\e."- bu\- :C. do V\.0\- \--ec..~-\\ -\l_J'>
.e.\J<! k\V'J \,..>Ca-.)~~\-- \-o_ .. 1.L ""'-\Ax . ..,_\ tu"'- -io-.t V""'-( Cu..:"'"s~.t
.b.C -\:k_ (o,.,,c~. . f\~~r- C<-V \<....W:"':) ~'( An::-.V\..Su:-~\>~ )2r~·lr'-- ~( . ~\.)\\{ -~\"t'-'~- h-u-.c\~ c-.4 V"'-Y Sev-.-\-e"''~lJ
---~r\~J . -;s:..... .. .h..,v-<.. cA~SLoV<?Tc".li~ ~ .. ...,-\- _ ~.:C.. LJc,'> )"yf_ve.:·
. '"'~,c~A.. o(:-_. -\~~c.,. LoiA.S~':-'c..""'_A,._# Q l-e-e"':>=-·- c-c...vJ~W -\r,:, ..... "><-ly-\~ ~y ~,(iL-- vW.\- ~vJ~j -~ r\.J\\. uv0.er')-\.::;.v.c..t\~- 0~
I f -
_ -J~ _ u,ll-..')~UQ:>._"-~~ .oC- v--.1 _ ~ k.:.._ -+\.,.,\') weN~ v-~v'"-<- v...__r f-~'~ Jy-,.~_(Av""\c:-r::t· ··-A~ w;h C- qc·~c>~\.1-<...._ Lt(,.c_ .S~v--,\:<.k\4.._
~~~--A._ ~o~)~~-~ c.o""s'i'~:-'-~~~ _of- '""'i ~\4~ -~·-) . W.w\.c.~---b<- q'-_ cAlf''""\- ..C.O.~<'-S~ve...""'c.---<-- ~~;..._ --lk--<.J~~~~-
C.o..,Mw~ _ .\?-<--- av~~\co~J... c-r 5-ee-'-"'- (;'-.~ "'- ~Y'""-\c-S)
-, e...\~<.:>: o.~ Llo,..~ . ~v'>~ ~( .. ~~~- -\c:._ +: he. iv-.v"-1«1. ,\<. ~\. .I . - \ ( \ \ - D _ . s'"''<- _. ... : __ Cl\tf:~ __ -UD-"'"s~e...~AL.e._,_" . se..L. s~-r-c:- v~ _ f\0>~ __ _
tVa. lo'-.St.f"I-S" _ u.~.'-'~ s~lr<--> .:\\ ~..v\ _ -~,..,;~.,\. -\o.
~\~<'~- -'\u, .c£- 0\.J •\\y _ \o ~\-~ ~~\ c ~ ,SeLo~
cJ.._~'('~ _ \'0...~<- oC-- G~~\J._,, .. ~,<._ ">~~e.r\'-'r _(...o....>r~ 1 G'-.'-'~C:..""-
Cc'-'A\'(1 .-::s-~ \oc--,J._.)c:,~ , -::J · 1 ol-e__v..:-cA v...--.o\w._ • Ve..,\evk.~\-
~~~\-e.L ... ~<--- Gu• ... N-:)r 0"- ""''(~co;-\~ ~9-{:n-~.ct. -~~ ~<
Su~ ~e.~~ . Co"'~ )...-- Vo\ \ '.v .r r 1 "S. _ ~\c~ ~" .. \ :
\) yv-...c..~~ .. ),,-,;X'f Cor--."""''-'"'- l \-1 ~\c-..C-~<-~ \ ~-e\\f""
.Lo~A'? \-A-~\-c->_ cA''~ c.o .. ,s~v~'-<- o\- '(\-et,._ 1 tA."""-~'-
_.1:). k~v-1<- \o \~~~f"'V'--.. dd-<~~_ . .\- o~-- 11"'-&,\A(,(~ ... '\c)r.-T
__ \ V"':'~OS \ s·\Jo'l'- o~ {_ o ~ .,..,..._u Y"-:'>...1 \{ \~"'-.,.,_-\- .\-e.r-~
\<~er~ q\u.._ 'i:Y\..\Jc,\tcl-~?- _So l,-J ~-\l'- .... -\be C.O'->r\-
~c:-,~\ '~ \o __ tv-.... kcv--_ vv--<.,. . <!>~ ... ~ ~u~')~\-(. ~\.:<.... ..
'i<-"'~L-L.. ~\~ (,...._
(.\1'.1 . ~\«--..._ -~~- .. :M.~ ..
. v--o~ \~Gacr"'ld--. . ..\'~
- \-<,~rak._ -\"'-\J~\\~)
~~., ,\),-<--..__ c.ov-.-,Lvt<~ . +~ ... f<-{.c,-t:,"'-.. "\ ;-ov<,..<j _ . -~~ .-:L be~)
v--.'1 ~\<>- ~\~o. ">~"-~"'"' b.e.
~ ... ~b~ :s::- o.c\v-_~~\-d_- .· . .\o \~·.ctt~- - c.~ .... u...~-•s*"~cl•"'-'j . e.ve.~-\~~"""')· W_;~\... .. ~ -~ '{\~~~ ~o _
- Y\.o\- ~ .. :\-\.<- V'-'~ !(\y.._ V'o\\.)v-.\-.::.~.· (<)e.._.::_ _ s\c._\:e_ V, ~OS). ~ r\,·o \\. NCJ ~ 2.'04.1-.S' W ~c..h_ -s~~\~'.>: Ll8 Eve....... -\-Louc
0l... \"-e..<...<.>tcA
I
.S~.S .ckJ:.e-~,""'.)- c:..cl~1\-') \o \'..::c..c:l..'~ 1 l,\.lf\.0\..:..-s~c ... ~,v-..;.) 1
u..vvt... S\~Y'o..\l<':'\.~ -"'- "\.u.-.. 1 ~''-:! c..'u""\~'> c._ c;.-\\.cJ _ ~\~<-':>lJv--x\ro""-~:y- %-.L- ~\<->--.- ,~ v o\\.)>A.\c~"··( G en t"''~ :y\~, ,~
. M\ \('\,)\( Vt::tlv"'\~o...t"-{ v"Y'--\,e...:,s .. ~. h..~~vu;l~--""--\- _ ~-;J~<-SSe."':>
c,...v-., \A~r~~ ,,~1"':) o(- -\""-<- \c-...w ,._nd_ \=~ \-"> _ ) . . ..... . {A~ \\1""\.. ~:.s C.<-S#- ~ -~ Lo",-)....., ~~'v\.slJ -\e:.
\"""'-\o~v.-- V""'~- 0 C- c-. \10S'> \\\<.... .. L.l (c._ Se..n.\<'.v-.LA,... \:,-(.~'5 ..
~ L.o-.r..St."{)l-,e<~ .. o~ ...,...,.._'} ~\u'-l LJ~\(...~ ~L t'"-<...<....c~J-..-. -
- . $'-:-:c.~ I -~ -~'o\H'-~ . -:_s:. G\u-~'-( \G..L\t.._~ ~...... ~
~\\ --<\o')~(.-~s~ov..._ ..... oC- c;.V'- \..\.11'-(:lc.r-5\t:;.~.l:~ o~- ~ ~
\V\.. _~\to"' . \o ~\.....<-- \'.,~~2 c~ V."'-•-( ~\t:.t:.... ~l..,)s_
"'-\4o \~.f'e5] v ......... 1 ~\<.A- \ "'-v~ .. \:-~1 c;._.vv}..._ \ v--...vo\.ui/\.-\ .. -.. r- "-/,
C:,\.c; o SU!-- _ ~--\~.1--c:.. V. S, V"'"'-. 1\J o. z..:~ 1-\5 ~- \- Ji
W"'-\'"'l, . 7\-~\~-) : _ ~ c..ovc\ o+- '"'~\>a:.\s 1 Se.~~re.. \c.l, j. 1
~-e . .\J.. ~-,\: ;_ ~- ~-""---\ We .. -,_ cl-e.h.~ d -eC~a-\~v~
~9? h~,,~c.e.... . cf . (.c:u"""Se...\. 1 o..~ ·1..) ~~-;-cl_ cl~ \1\..C.?\-
a...\'~ii~V"'"\Ive..-\'-l ',)'h::w :-\~ ... \- ck\-ev~~ . u..~e.rs+~
~~c:. \oW 4ii.fe_ ·\V'- ~""\;~ \o -\"'""'-~ ~-\-., c~-1 ev-\-e.-..4. ~ ~\=. . t"'"~d\~~.,..,.A\-( .... ~ Vo\...,,.\<,r.lt'')
So . -~c-..~"'- _ w ~~ -t~L \c~J<... o ~ ~V\.Ol.Jl~~e..
:.:C. \..-~ o 9:- ~ \. \. -\\_,._<-- Cc.v-..~ ~U e-v..~<...) o ~- .,"""' ~ ~ le_"'- 1
- ~'-(- ~~"<-'-..... S~u(vl h<_ LoV\.5lh-r c::c..L ~ v\..vc.:.,l~c;l. c;,'""-c).._ F .. s\.....o~\cl ~..e._ ,~\\..01....) c.o{__ -\o L~ i -\L-.otrc--...0 . v---.1 l~l~~ .. . . . .. .
tf \.5o . ~y . ~~ 5\,.-o\.Aol.. l:x_ .... u:.wvSJotcr~ .\v--vc....\tcA \.y~ec;L o~ ~ ~-\ ~~ ... \-- -\-'lv<__
Cc:N~ '>l \ ""'-~\'0~~'-( ~\1.\.-e.A_ ~ . ~\uc"'\
h.<,:~ ~"'-"'- ~v~~-, {.~e_.:_ -;,\.._\.,_ V bs Na b 2BLf1 ,_<) Wht <--~ ')-\-.;-\<.> 
-Cj'-)~\\'( , -~ \-e.c.cAc~ S'W>H~ ~SO"""- -\\-.~ ~u t~
.. -~~ ~r-t~- ov, _N.c.?V .\1 1 ~\ V\D..r,e_ of-
~:<- ~~\y..,,,\. .\. \ ~i.vv~ ~~ ~\..>~<- \ . .) )-~'""- --\o
__ tALc..e~\- ... _ v~-~ ~\-u,'-. o'? ()u_.\\~ L.Je\'--e.,.._. r~~ .oV"\.
\-e....Lo\J.- (\.Or:- c)..tc:.l_ ~ ~~Se--(.).J:\o\ \-e..<..~2\<.. ""'~')
•• c~\v~\ ~<:;,;.:,, • 0"'"'- \.e.LD<-t:~ • ••• p,~L -f\"\~\ c.l{
_1\r,-t- ~Wu .... W-c.-F<- . 0rr-0\\1 .c..k-KV\.Owl.~J-~~Se.ct_ ---~·-·· ·
.v.he.- \AO-r-: W""? _ ~-. C\t:,:....\\_'( ,V'.-\-e..t-to~;Ac-~ OV\
.. ~'(-- Cov.d.ue.;~ _ ~ _ t\_~\~$ __ of- ~ _ ---~~ \~\ _ h;.> \s 1
_W~\-'"'-h __ ~<- \'<.4o\'::c;·l .. s\,.~ 1
A\so .. :r:.. vve_ve c .. _______ _ ~"'~ "'I ~c-..:ve_ ()...._ .t,..J \"'-\*~ ... wv ~\ c.._ s.~-~\v~\. b~st~ _,
. ~0 e.\J·e~A- -t.\.x,u~~ -~ \-<..Lc.>c-J..._ :5\.-~ot..Y_, _ ~ ~
~-~-- <Ju~e- 5c"'~A -~-e._ \'-e.-0.<-.'\Je.A ~i:O~c-.bl<- Ct:wJ.oz_
t:e..~oc~c; \ ~:\~~~""'\s. ~v....A.. ~_.r \~~o\:~'> Ud'-'~
h-<- .Wo\1~.- US<- ~r __ ~-\-~\ ka..§>u .. ~\1.\e .. o~. ~<---
~~'"'""'\ ~~<,'•S . ~:~d'e... fe,A_ Ov-... \":<..t.c>S.<"- I t..Jkk..-~ ~<. .
"{:'-e..L,c- tel_.. ~W') t . . ~D .. ~\'~\o!;-e_ ~-\-e._ Wch V\.0 -~-c..:k .. \ \oc .... c.; l ~ cx.c..\\V\LL)\ .... ~ . cv, r<-U;J\c~ -~ \ ~- ~\...) ... \~
. ~\.t.A... -~ri~- -~~- ~-\- ~v'"S ~ .c.c-~_c\- c.A~S~-"'
~ ~\-u .... t,.J.J~h. ~ ~"A-.~ ~-~ ~-~~ 7~~ r~~r
-~- -~\<A. \"'-V~~p\_ ~--- ~\\oLJ ~c:... -~-o. Wrthdr-"-J-> ~-1-.. . 9\u: .. -r
. /A) £-~J I ~ h),\\ \o<..... a\.\',(.\..'?~1 """'j ~(... \ V'-,.(.o ....... ~<-A~~<
ck- :i/"''1 ~\,e.~- .. _ {\7 "'- . bv..-,b .~\":". k w ~~r-~,,\ 6(- V"\c-. A\&,~
fj'-n\\.y~~~ ~\'<... <.:~<- \t.~> e~ ~- -t'.K.~~ ....... ~Lf'j \v-cllctc,_ L1s1'('J-.
\V'-: \-e:-.1\o\ ·--~~ e.>(~?.\. -~<- lv""ld~--.. kc- i\A\.h~vll',.~-~ '<\-<-~ L..u 1\ .. . <L- cAISGUS$t'A \-..~r-...._. -f'C-.<.... ~v-c1..rc...t .. ·..._ qor \V'\-e..:(-\-e_L-\cv<-... Co....lv-..~e_\
l r }' ~ =? r ~ .t- ~ ~ ~ " ::'. 1 :p 3 :5· C> tf!~ '::t:.. ~ • ' f ~~~~~ f. :ts_.,." ~
:1-- [.. -;;:::.
ttkr- J~ ~J·;[~lfis~ ~ ..... 4> ' [ t)
1- c' ~ ~ [. ('
f ~ ~ ~ i t t ~ r ~ ; ~ 1 bf ~ 1 ~ ~ 9- ~ ~ I } 9-~ ~ Y- t \/'- '
tr'" 1 ~rr f>~(~~~rJ~ 5 ~ 1 ~ 0 £ .., V'
1 tq -t ?- V'
gl fr t:~ffrt-~~J;r*-- . ~ - ' ?-r ,.,., c: c.
t (' :; __:[ r 0 -r c _,
-./' ~
I ....._ -r - &'\ ~ ~- b J' V\ 7 ~ ~ 5 } ~ b F c
..., -o
>-~ r (/ u !' , J ~[1 ~ j ~; """ } V\- ~ J [
/ :p
r. ~ '"l-r-~ ~I' r;:,$ >' i' -.. ~ ["
f f if)
?=t~~~}~~~6"~·- :r~, ~ ~ i ~ f -0 (' ,.
itJ~~t ~t~~trr~~~ r r ;;;; . ~ cr t c ~ r t ~ ~ r - ,. c .y 3 > r 6 t -1- ...-( VJ ~ c -t ~
._:( ·- ~ !' ~ . - -_ 0 ~ ~ . l [ t
e.. ~ t \J' V' - r ~ ~ ~ -t J -r
'r r ~ 0 -1._ + -r [.
J?t ~J '"til~ }f~ ~ ~ ~ t -- - ~ . -<' I P ~ -?
:" 1-± ~ ('
J'u [;' ~ ftt "')-\- (' )> ~ r 3-. t t b' ~ l f vi } ~ L ~ ~} r ~ --1 <r
c "' " . ~ f' ~\ 0 c t r~~<'J'? -r~,~ ~fc )' ~ 9- J,\ -..( c
~ -rr. r~~ ~ ~ - y- ;>
~ ~ r r ~ r ,;~
--:r- ~
1'\~ -f'\....<-- ~\)~~ \)0\--~ol~ C"'-- Lc~~ ~ ~
~u~\~ ~ V\,-(.J(,r~, D\A.. Nov~~ \I~ z..oo'i.
--f-C_ ~Y\i'~ oF-- Nov~b<.r-- ll-'6.. z.e:,cq, ~e.. ~eMdA"'-+ ~-1- o' ~CA;MI)_ 2:.'-l ~t.N-.S a.f+e.r- '-"'~ Su4'c,rck_ ~~~1-
whtk.. s\-\\\ ~ s.u-r-oc:k- w~.\-c;~ ~v~ V\o W\~\ "'-.~\~
w"-h>c...\..to"' W"<;> c...\\cw -\v -e.IA~ ~ ~\-e.-"- ot- ~uf..~y# ft~ by ~<- (()~\) t:;.\\ou:.>t""'J +~'- ~t- -k> ~?'~ fj\J~\y
~'7 Ufo\c-.1--e? ~s-~ '''0~1- -\-o dv<- ~roc.os, tL-l A~ <'t-bi.J-
\J~v\e....~-
(t\t<e.r SoM<-- e;c~St"v.(... re..-s~c..h. ~ \-- i> c..-\~ ~....,-\- +"'-<-
J.t..-(:~""'~5 ~l~ c~ Dv;\~ We.."> vwr r'V'-~ ~pv~i-~1
c."'c)._ ~ vk.--~~-1- s k,u LIIL loe- c...\\ oW~ -\-o L.J ~~M..l DJ\.
hfS ~\~ , )~ ~-\--~ L J Vlll A1.Sh.:..lf J t-tt..-J Wll\ z.vl Z,bb [3] w ~ { '-~ s i-'-'1----e.-5 .
1 I\
W~ -(.At\ (f.. c..:r,"""" (V\ ~I vl'!k~vvt- V"'\\V ~ s ~o Ut~cLr~L.J~\ c- '"0\J~\~ ~'!A. O""- 4-\-.."L- \o&-..SIS +\...:..-1- 4--\....-<-
~\.-u- c..o.v\rJ_ V\.D-\- ""-&-'-'·<- \o~ ~~ KVt.Du~ly 1 \~!\-<JH~r'~.,k\/ 1 D."'-C).... \Jo\uvAe-...N\f ~(AU)-L- o·~ vv-.-c-v-Ac..A ~c_oV'--p-<.-+-e~ c....vo.d.....
~~ li~ "'(A)t~ \o~~-<._ -r~ ~ ... "'\ ~ ~.-r U:...\\ <) ~\o zu~J,-~ -+\,..L ole..-~ Co~'{> <--+--c~uy
c...\- ~ --\--\ ~ ~ ~ \-t::A-- w(;..,s ~ -ed._ 1 ~-c C.OV'('~
Y'-;.(,..'( \1\.0~ c).~'-( ~ ~-\-~ IAV\ 1-e.-s.s f'+- ~-t.,...sr+-
~~~o,·ll'\.~ ~F\-<; -\-o ~~~ Gt~ i"GpO-I".\- 6V\. +'Lv<_ 0 }J
~~ C..cYv·'''i~ zu~+fvv-..1 ~ 1'U-J /0./i.OCiJ.
--::t='" V" -\-""- \ <, (...G..'.><. +k ct.&-~-\-'> c..+\-~"'-"\- c,}r
)utc(..f~ Wou\Q..._ ~ ly c.-eA\. ~ ~u~ \,...\~
(..6.__~-<--;~etw'i ~ ~ -\o ~ 70tu-c.lAA ~~\.v\--5
, :),.
(AV\ff- ~<- c:.)..J--e.""-~~ S~·""'-~ c.... Sutc.Jc.l<- \1\..(,) \--<-.
~)ov.A.\ \'( ~-e-~ see'- ~ ~ \)"-'~-<- 1 $ kcu\.c.L ~
~~ ~v<- ~ ~ ~ W~ "'0\-- oq_ c...\-u.-r
r;.~ ~ouli\.6L """"~ *"~- (...e.)"""-y-cA-~ --to ~l~ eu~\~ ..
~ ~ 1 Wuu\.cL """evK-<- -tk.-~'CJ~> Y'l-t:A ~ VV\.~t~+
i~AQuc,~- ~V\.uo\v~ ~\-u....- 1 ui.,rc_.k. Woolc,L ~llow fl..v<_
c}v&--e,v...~ •.• J- 4o w '*'-~we..-\ ~ ~ ~ l~ , 5-6!-- S -\-W- V.
Mt.r~ke..\ \ t L-\ L.L w"" ~. [sj LJ~tc.k s~s ;
\\r-e-r ~\J'(""~oS.V, ot- C\~ l..i. ?__(t;) 1
ttill.d~ l.J~r-J,_
e.... c.AJ~~ W\e-.1 Wl~ckJ&J.J~( PL 0u~1\y ~ l-c.."- uL_GI-\
rt'tL.-.e...-~5c..'y +o w-r-~ c.... '"rt'o.V\.t~~-\- '"'~u ~v'-<-", Cc..'-'\
l V\.Volv""" ~'1 ~ \ ~ o~ 6 u J \ \y -\-o e..... !.-{" \ v--\ """'""' c...""-~<-C-611\.~ ~ ~ '> ~ ''Me.""\ ~c:.-S-\- fv\-0 \J ~ :\ rc...<..!}
\\-::r:V' ~c.rs~\\ 1
\f'\1\.o.s-~~c:...\\ ~ "JOlt\.<-- o(?-f- ~\S ~~feAt~
VJO'OuwJ.- ~<- +~ ~ o~ "'-'c; ~ \-u... o~ tu·,\\i o,;v-..c/..._ { \-
Wc..s ct-v\-~i"'-~ -\'"-.~ '-".-e.. c__.ou\rA_ V\..0-\- l,Jc..AV-<- "'-'<:> Go\1\.S-t\\-~'\o~\ r\~\..~') c....~ ~\~ ~u~\~. :C."' fV\.M""S~\\
~-!. o(.ov\vr 4)o..toL "' VV\~'Ivv:.\\ S ~\-u... Wc....S a.... V'-"\C:..vdf.<-~~V\.
of \,..,\'", \V'-C...\~'1~\y cA-~r-~5~ c...,v.._c)._ cA_ulu-,fuv..."'\
s ~ ~<- ~ """(""a(_ rNf\. t:J.._ ~ ~s \.v...\\ t-J c:.. s S'\J n:...1 eJ..c... \ "'\--- ~-<-'' o r l1 -r-~ 'r"\-L-- 0 f- ""' '> ~\.<A... ''-ry c.. >r b lo '-{ ...
S t:~d"' ~ -\"\,.\; c..c... ... -<- wk.N._ ~ '~ We>
Co""'~~\~ ev"'-h.Jc...~to""S ~t;-tCN""" -\o --\'~ ~~ Suf<J~
c....~~~.\- I w\....~v~ s\-c...~~ ~ ~"'-~""-\- Su~W~
~""" yo ~ -1- -r&J..,\J """"e-v \-' <- S~-eh s oL' ~-c:.-r- [j -\--) \5J ( ~ ev-e-f"-<
~'- c; DC..'"'-\. c:::A.,lsor-~ ~~ ~c.v-r~no\~ ~c..\- ~
,~ cA..<-\\)s\o~\. ~t~\-s o.A- --\-l~'CJ> .. fr\so """""--<~""~~ ""'-s "'- yv..VA-~\i ""'~ ~ C5 r '\o \ ~0 \.~ c.lrs ~
(;M/'-rJ- ck-~s s fO"'- • A\\ o-f- ~s-<-- ~'s ~ \ ~ a.__
I • _, ti 1 I
\)wr)r- \V\.. tv~-\-to"'-"j -t-~<- c\,~\- 5 C.6"""""\'-e..~
tA.Jr ~ -\-\~ 6f- ""''<> ~~'\\-y ~t~. s~ s-\-~\<.- v. vocU-- ryo wVl z.oi_ t>\~ 1 "5 tt..L, t.-l~li ?_ 2-d... ~o'2..--U~t:.l)
wkr~ s-\-..k> ~ \\.
~-<- t-~Urc:N-s ~ *~~\. -~\.)~<- ~ Coli\.<) l ~ ~"'- ~~a-......... N<.. f J W ~<-~.u- or 11\.0\- -\-c.>
o('""e}..<-r c-.._ ~~\. '"'t-V~~ f~\o ~ W\1-"-~~
of- C.."'- G....c-0-.J s eJ._ \""'·tuk.-~ "' c1&-~s CA...w~c...e.., ~~V\.0-.r-1 Lc>1Ad.uUr I ~<..\'So~\ c.~ ~v-.,r\y "'\S~ 1
<c....,~ \,~G..V ~o-r- 1 VV'\.~1'-c.A,\ ~ 'V S 1 c)..,.\&... \'f"k_ \'L~o-f'\- S
(AV'I.c)._ -\-'~~ s1-~~~ ot- ~<- ~Dle..~.S' Gz.h..>IA'i~!'
_L"' \)ersoV\A.\ ~~~~ of- f"\~~~ \Coli... l..J"" ~
gr;~ [1,.~1] -:rJ\- s~~: \\
\>\"oc..edv~ of +~ C..O~~Q\..(.
s-\-"" ~<- LG~-e.r to. 11. R.GU) c,,.r"<- 1/V\..~ ~ c...'-'\oL V\.0+'{'V\~'-( cl f \<C.~""(, 11 S ~k V. l...Lrc:..k._lc,. '-'..0(_ <i, 0 l.J11t ~
1qg l &ot;, h s8 1 P. 2cfL Lt..'""LI u q Bz) '' ,, 1 1 ~u") 1 Ot~t~ -~ f5 Pe.c..')C>\.-\
-\-t:> cto\.Ji;,+ o.... ck .. J-~~~) Go~~<.--\-evt£.-y 1
-fc'l<- Cou-f"--\- ~s+
f.o\tow 4-k-- s+c..+u~ +o ct~~ tvv<.. ""' '> o-r h~ Co~~~ ~ ~-\-~ -k--re..l. tt C;-l..( of ~#)-<- 1/ ..
~o"cl.Dvt 1 "3 c, tviA. A-pp t15'1, 4'111 t~), P. ZoZ 7~// (jqac;;)
\\ rt;_Jt ~ -\-o a bSt::A'v~ \?{'(.) c...er.J--u-.r-6
~uevk -\-o ~c-o~ C...""- a...u:..u~.5 "'a~5" V'-6-\- +o ~ tt\~ tJ~i\<- \V\.~~-c\:-~ ~ s-\-~ ~\ t s ~ ~\~\. c.f-oiu-L- \)1'0C..~S"- 5<\-ev~~ \/. 0-'V\e.avt 2~ u~ A- yr BCi 4, qol 1 (:;u~ ~. 2oe 57o LJ'i"~~)CGi~ Dto-~1 L.!I.e7 l.tS iG,Z.) 9~\-L 1 ~8> LLS. 31>")"
' r ~ ~ ¥ t ¥- ~ ~ 1- ~tt ~ ~ ~ ? c1 ~ r-~ r ~ ~ r r ~ ~ r '~ - ~ f ~ ~ ~ r { ~ ~ } r ~ r ~ i'
1 f ~ t J 0- ~ ~ ~ t }Jf~~jft-tf-!f ftt ~!~J[_~ttti~ -v[-r ~5~~·"rF~;:\~·r~ ~?f~ ~ t~~
J r 7> ~ ~ ~ _, Ac_ ~ r -t_ c ~. t J:~~~~ {-r ~~~rr~
C ~ \- ' -.:(~:t 0 ~ [ t tC ~ : 2 r ~- -Z f ~t- ~ r I' ~ 1 ~ t l ~ 1 + 1 ~ 1 ~ - u~ ~ j {:_ (\ f 1-. , i ~ r -- · i f f ~ -" · f c f> 2 5 q ~- r c
~ J ,,-r ~ ~ ~ c : J' ;;- -r~)i.~rU',.., ~ ;;;:~ c "~
ftf~~r1-: ri~t ~¥tr~:_JJrJ~fflf f t ~ ~ o r <;;' 17: c r F 1- f ~ " r ~ !I- r -o ~ ~ t j 1 [ ~ ~ -£ ~0 ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ r- r ~ _:[ ~ f ~ -f r r ~ 1
r -t~ff-Z~ ~t~~ J li"fli!-.-'a (! 'f ~ ~ ~ CJ .~I E f"' c.J> {ft ~ f ....
~ %
~""+ -to Wf~\ h\c, ~\)'\\y t(\~ -\o Corr-~t- c.....
~V\.\ ~+ i~v*l<: . .(. ·
. B. w'ht..~ O<" ~ VV'\t'". i\t-e.,.v·,,o(..c,\ f"t~\,...:lr- -\-o ~<... ~r-e,.~~RJV\.
0~ (.OUV\.~ I o....c, e\-~~ bv( AM- '\ "2."2.. of. ~ w.ar ~k
~I' -\'~ ~ L)J\~ ~f'O..J~ i""~-e..c.Jrlv-L by S~""j
'--'\c., Lou"'-Se.iS ~t"'e-5~~ ~'i\ ~vJ c- ~~eJ~~ <,;~
~ \'-e.J.-.C)OV\.,J,\~~ 5. ~ -\"'-\~ CA.,~ ~ ~\- (_(,..\A.. ~
\'1\,~v..c... c..cnrs\~ ~~ C,.O'J""S~ ~ ~1' ~'s ~( ~+-
'~s.~ ~ h,.~ ~ Cb~ ~ ~ ~ 4-~ ~v~-t-~
or.. \'~t~ 'IV'~\. ~\,}~ a....~-\'~ ~
c..~~.eJJA.. ).Vi'c..tcM-1
b.J\- {V'\.</\-~1 c...,\\ow~ +~ ~~
.1z, ~\'eA._ -\o ~ e.... ~\eh_ c:&- fju\\~· ~uS 1 ~\.ct. ~{'c)\J~
~~~ (.o.)\1\.t,.d w~ \V\.~1\1'4L 'lo...{ 11'\.olr N\Q.'i\\r"".j ~\c; olu~ I (' _ _A - ..1- \\. \ \ \. L ..L \ \ ll-. -\o c •. })'?\S-\- -\'k ~\ C...C.""t"Uc:JV''f ~ SU'O ~T~"~' y \V\.
~r'V't""'~~'-~ w~\.....er -\o ~\~ bu,\~ o-t- v'\.0"\-, S-e-<
:x:"'- ~e... Rt(..eL t\~ b.>V\, 7.P- B-z' BB~-~'1 P. '2..el loSt-.G..<t<\2) I I
u~ \~ s-\-t...\--c...5 ; \\
----rC ~~ ~ ~ ~'ti \I' <--S -Tc, t:...\Af ""'-S of-
'\~~~"~ c...c;n\c;)r~ e~ c.vvv-..~-d ""'- ~~ ~\-u:-.- ~t"O£.LS<) ..
W\~ v, \.oc.-K~>r 4./4., U..h -s-c.., ?I, toG, s, L-+-. "'>"'-, ; '"lo 1 B8 L. l.cJ....
"Lc:L "2.-0""> U '\ 8~) Vu~~ Q_\~ b:...'~GJ~tJ 1 ~""'">e,l ~ ~ M'{ +o "-c;sts-\- ~~ okf~ '\~c.».y_ e..,;v,u-..... c,>uks1-c..."'--fM\'( "'
'"' ~'"'"~ w~~ .to ~\~ ~u't\\y. s\-c.,\-<- v. oslo~ 1oz.... w"' G-el- 8-z ~t!t, 6ot'-~ "· UL fo~'> {jcte11)("ur-..~ s+-ev+c:_. v.
I L[; . J II
~ , 10 l.JvL_ l4?r· "22-'1 \ L"YZ-1 "~ s, P: ~ q.o t, 6 '1 Bi))
' ~ ~ t ~ r I ~. f ~ r~ ~~ ~ f ~' t !)' ~
~ -¥_ 1b ~ I ) r s. t e.g ~ ~ ~ t t -::r 3 ~ ~~ f r"' ~
tr h ~ ci ~ ~~A) ~"' ~ ~ l r ~ (' r { ~ ~ 5 .J' 11 ~- ~a ~s., ~~'At) ~J-\-~~t~~[~~ ~ ~t ~~ ~~~2~- }r; ~ \:\ ~ 0 ~ -- ~ 0 f 0 0 ~ ~ 0 5 + ~ r 0 1'- s.. ~ k J r ~ ~ ~ "' r ~ -r .J\ ~ > ~ o .l ?-- fV\ ~~~ ~- ~c ~'I~.-/ F ~ t\ t.J'- -b c ~0 (' ~ ~;r~ V\J ~ 1
~ ~() ~ 2' ( ~ _,...0 c: '7 ~ 0 r~~ 1~~ --tJ~~~9--( ~~ ~~~-I)'-\; ':f~t ~-~-
q rt~~ J&fll1~ }i~~r1 ;~r F 1 $j ~ ~ ~ i .l 0 -( ,.. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
} f ~ f ~ -p r ~ ~ v- ~ ~ r ~ ~ . ?- + ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ -"' (" r ~ ~ ~ -o > ~
t _r J J f 1 --~' ~: _,.. " -r > }' ~P: .}~ ~ rJ -{):t~ irf~ ~
1
·
~Fr Jr-[;r~ t, ~ '~- e. t- -t r c:rg- r _r F ~ I' r ~ ~
t !.,. ;::/ >" ~ :v
.,~ ~ '$ r _. C
~ r ~ t ~ \'_ [ ~ t ~ ~ .... ~ r c:Jf
:t>"' 0 ... c ...() ""f
~ i § t~ ~ ~J ~ a f ~ ~ 'ft "'., cPS\-~ t~ 1 F t-e ~~ ~ c ~ ; .. ; (; ~ t(\ tl' [\l - -r-t ')
4 t 1 ~ { c. ~ 0 -;: e;~ 1'"? ~ r 1'"_ ~ ? _J-~ ~- c ~ ...r:: r ~ ~ r ~
r r"' ¥: ~ 6f~
I !
V\0~ . do\~ . ~0 ~\'~'> ~<~ ""'cS\-~c,\._\\lf(._- -::r::l0-~t:_~\ ~·c~b\C~\.....,.,~ .. cf- ~~vx~ \'-\2. LJ.V'- :-z..c-L b5~.
--::c\. -~?r" .... ~~s :
. '~.. ~v~l\'x:..lt~.;;_, C..ovr--\ . &.<_;\-~\~ -~ ... -\:- _
\o"t \'\~~~~~ CD..J..--">ot..:\ v"-o\- \'~ts i ~ ~ \c,su-<- o(f-
C.O~'(-<--h~c...-( ,. .. L..Jl--~'-"''- ~~ h.>"~s c\e~.r -evrc&""-0:<......
__ C\.~·-··· C~",o.,-..._ \o_ ck>v'=A ~'XcALV\.VT 1 .~ ohcJ ~
~-e..c.,\~<--- ek~\v<- c...~<,\'-)~-Cj\.~~ o(- Cou~\ .. c...~ \\ (\_ . ~ ~. ~'\~.') \)'c~v~d \c-.\S _ ~\~ .. /.
:£-... s:e-1~~~~0\\y _ \~Vt"~+ -\'k~~\ c_~·\er \-e\.H<O?..L.>t\1\.J
. . ~\\, ... y. (2A ~ _ c._v~,.t.,_. ~t:.. . Sv~~c\-c\\""':J doL-w~""''\--\ _) \."
\.A:M-~~V'-.\- A- J -· ~--~ ~- C.C.V\\- .\o c....\\oW_ .. """"-<--
-I \o i,..,.ll~J.r-CA..~ -~'( ~\~ o~-- f)v;\\'1 ' ~sc..L ov-.
j-~'( -~\-u"' \oe1~~- \\01.c..cV"'.~"--\-c...y>..\- 1 \hvohJ.n.·-\""'r:-r ~V\P'\ _
:~ ~'"<---- ~v'\.0~\\J...... :1:.. ~ee.\ . ~ o"-\'1 w~'·( k _ _ _ Con-~\--~ ~\S _ VV'\.h.v--. ~ \: ,(,-,-\- ~ """~\.) ·>\, c:.-.<_ ~ov~ _ \a_<..,. --\v
I · r 1 o-l\ow v- e.- \-0 w,~\.cA,c..J,..; ~~""-'( 1(\-o...._ D\ ~r ~\,.. <...
j Co'\!"\- -\o _\) ~ ~ <- v--,.'f _ Co•·''-U \c.;\ f e~v-...) 1 A-~ \-e-r ,,e..v\<.1-'i.-vJ ~v, 6AG;> i~' c.:.,~\A \o<_ v~"<- ~"'-· I I ~\olo-~ ~~~t.('~ "' ~~ '). V\A\K-. C.~'i- 'v_K.-e.v'- V lok.kA
~Wkt(....~' :LLTtsc ),(> ~l~J \.e-,), :L LJoJ.J....u }rk-<. -\-a
-\\-\<'::."'-\-<... ~"-<-... .. LeN'\~<, ~- -+\.--.<.'·' ·\-n....-,~ c.,~ \(r\ \-ev.t<.WI~
. _o.,~ _ ~~kA"'r~ -~\~ c:iA~J'"
~"{~~\\.'{ Su'o\M.\1-\-~~A.. \,_-;(
-~~<> -- ' - ~'~~. 6·\S·V·"\ ----=:::::z\ L- ~ A---- ~. \S. \L.\
ATTACHMENT - A
JNZINQE CHELAN COUNTY REGIONAL JUSTICE CENTER COMMENT INQUIRY
Name ARANDA, THOMAS TYLER MASTER ID# 116247 Booking Number 08-0170132
Comment Code G GENERAL COMMENT Entry Officer 1193
LARSEN, SEAN M
Cell
2/17/12 QPADEV001M 09:03:17 LESLIEC
Comment TODAY AT APPROX. 0707 MR. ARANDA ATTEMPTED SUICIDE WHILE
HOUSED IN 28. INMATES IN 2A PRSSED THIER CALL LIGHT TO GET
STAFF RESPONSE. ARANDA'S TRIAL STARTS TOMORROW.
Entry Date 11/16/09 Time 8:13:56
Extended Exists
F3=Exit F17=Extended Comments Fl2=Previous
JNOLIQC CHELAN COUNTY REGIONAL JUSTICE CENTER OFFICERS LOG INQUIRY
Date 11/16/09 Time 7:20 Shift 1
Officer 2562
Record Type MH
KUBICHEK, SARAH
MENTAL HEALTH
LOG ENTRY H2-ARANDA,THOMAS HAS BEEN PUT IN THE SUICIDE
2/17/12 QPADEVOOlM 09:09:01 LESLIEC
SMOCK AND 15 MIN. CHECKS HAVE BEEN STARTED AT 0717
Entry Person SARAHK Date 11/16/09 Time 7:22:25
Extended Exists
F3=Exit F17=Extended Comments F12=Previous
·JNOLIQC CHELAN COUNTY REGIONAL JUSTICE CENTER OFFICERS LOG INQUIRY
Date 11/16/09 Time 9:22 Shift 1
Officer 1113 HUGHES, JEFF A
Record Type GI GENERAL INFORMATION
LOG ENTRY CDMHP HERE TO EVALUATE ARANDA,THOMAS AFTER HIS
SUICIDE ATTEMPT. (CURRENTLY ON WATCH IN H2) .
Entry Person JEFFH Date 11/16/09 Time 9:23:00
Extended Exists
F3=Exit F17=Extended Comments
2/17/12 QPADEV001M 09:08:14 LESLIEC
F12=Previous
. JNOLIQC CHELAN COUNTY REGIONAL JUSTICE CENTER OFFICERS LOG INQUIRY
2/17/12 QPADEV001M 09:07:57 LESLIEC
Date 11/16/09 Time 10:03 Shift 1
Officer 2562 KUBICHEK, SARAH
Record Type MH MENTAL HEALTH
LOG ENTRY H2 ARANDA,THOMAS REFUSING TO SPEAK WITH CDMHP
MARSHALL,LESLIE OR HIS ATTORNEY. HE SAYS HE JUST
WANTS TO BE LEFT ALONE.ADVISED MARSHALL AND CPL
HUGHES.
Entry Person SARAHK Date 11/16/09 Time 10:06:16
Extended Exists
F3=Exit F17=Extended Comments F12=Previous
. ' . .. I-'lL ED " .~ -· . :.J
JUN 18 2014
\ ('(j!~~~~;i~~(~;:;ALS I . I<"' . ,u f"'T o ww.> .. ~- 1 \ _ ~y ec~c. ... ~ ·. ~;Ar:5~~~~~~: --~ "1 ____ -l _
I _ . _ ·~<--- ~\\ddJV\~ ~'"~cO 0...-\-L_ - ~ ":>-\ <:.. \e.lM-<-~\--
ofl ~1-\fo~\ (j~IN.J-.<. k u ... s.e_ #:~.\~_\\~.--6 .. \-;-L .c~ l->!~ V'--"\1 ~+k\ny\s _ o~e,v,;~ bf'<<.k- ..
~\ec,_,.:,e__ \'~~~u,~ .. .:.\o_ . \-e.:~.. V:-:'\..-<:_ ')'Sv\.dlJ _ -}l-e.~c:.__
~~~<;..-:>. /;..)_e,~<-:- \..g_c\~V·eA -~~. ccMec-L l .. J_~h +~\
kct~\:-. ~"""k_ .yoJ .. ~ ~ .. ~~~.
5 C'Y'L-es:--e __ \"(
~----.. --~---~. - .. /'--. -. ----..c:_-. -:-. ~ . -- .
. ~--- .f\ ~~~<:) --~~~ .. \ _ Y~)fc,~, ...
· ... '\\-S"". Ltz. __ L <), {_Lc_ __
~ C-\l Cov .... ~c .. ~A-\-i~-c LvAJ . ~~I LJ~ . qgs-z.o
