Upload
itobar
View
75
Download
3
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] 2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] < 1 >
Two-stroke- Sales introduction courseOctober 2009
Carsten DommermuthSenior Manger Sales Support
Business Unit Power Plants
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
MAN Diesel as a sole provider of all ranges
MAN Diesel engines in comparsion
MAN Diesel at the worldwide power plant market
Environmental policy and engine based power generation
Two stroke vs. four-stroke
Maintenance cost- comparison two-stroke vs. four-stroke
Reference two-stroke power plants
back-up Biofuel for two-stroke engines
Table of content
<2>
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Without any comment….
50% of World Trade is Powered by Engines from MAN Diesel
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
MAN Group
Commercial Vehicles
MAN Latin America
Diesel Engines
Turbo Machinery
RENK (76% stake)
TrucksBusesEnginesServices
Marine applications / power plants Turbochargers Services
CompressorsTurbinesServices
Gear systemsSlide bearingsTesting systemsServices
TrucksBusesServices
Transport-Related Engineering2008: Revenue €14.9 billion; Operating Profit €1.7 billion; 51,300 Employees
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Sole Provider of a Diesel Engine Programme from 450 kW to 97,300 kW
<5>
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] <6>
Development and ProductionLocations
St. Nazaire
Augsburg
Frederikshavn
Copenhagen
Shanghai
Aurangabad
Velká Bìteš
• Germany• Denmark• France• Czech Republic
• China P.R.• India
Holeby
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
MAN Diesel GroupLocations in Europe
Great BritainMAN Diesel Ltd.After-sales services
FranceMAN Diesel SASFour-stroke engines, after-sales services
GermanyMAN Diesel SEHeadquarters, four-stroke engines, turbochargers, after-sales services
AugsburgVillepinte/Paris
Saint-Nazaire
Stockport
Hamburg
Holeby
Copenhagen
Frederikshavn
Rostock
Sta
tus:
12/
05
Employees worldwide: 7,700
Velká Bìteš
DenmarkMAN Diesel, Two- and four-stroke engines,propellers and propulsion packages, after-sales services
Czech RepublicPBS Turbo s.r.o. Turbochargers
Colchester
<7>
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] <8>
up to 80 080 kW
MAN Diesel Copenhagen, Denmark
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
MAN Diesel Licensees
<9>
CroatiaAdriadiesel 1998Brodosplit 1967Uljanik 1984
U.S.A.Fairbanks Morse Engine 1995
Low-Speed Medium-Speed High-Speed Turbocharger CP-Propeller
IndiaKirloskar 1977
JapanDiesel United 1963J.F.E. Engineering 1964Hitachi 1951Kawasaki 1911Mitsubishi 1929Mitsui 1926Niigata 1973
KoreaDoosan Engine 1983Hyundai Heavy Industries 1976STX Heavy Industry, STX Engine 1977STX Enpaco 1995
PolandH. Cegielski Poznan 1959
RussiaBryansk 1959
SpainNavantia 1965
VietnamVinashin 2004
China P.R.Shanghai Xinzhong Power Mach. Plant (CXZ),CSIC 1980Shaanxi Diesel Engine Heavy Ind., (SXD) CSIC 2004Henan Diesel Engine Heavy Industry, (HND) CSIC 2007Wuhan Marine Machinery Plant, (WMMP) CSIC 2006Dalian Marine Diesel, CSIC 1980Yichang Marine Diesel, CSIC 1989Zhenjiang CME, CSSC 1980Hudong, CSSC 1980MES Diesel, CSSC 2007Dalian Locomotive (DLRC) 2004Hangzhou Zhonggao Engine (ZGPT) 2006STX Dalian, STX Fushun 2007Jiangsu Antai (JAD) 2007Shandong Juli 2008Jiangsu Guotai Marine Diesel 2008CSR Ziyang Locomotive 2008Zhongji Hitachi Zosen Diesel Engine (ZHD) 2008Rong An 2008Yungpu 2008Zhejiang Yungpu Heavy Machinery 2008
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
MAN Diesel Leading Position on the two stroke market
Source: BRL Shipping Consultants Lloyds Ship Manager June 2007
MAN Diesel92%
Mitsubishi2%
Sulzer(Wärtsilä)
6%
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
MAN Diesel Engine Program
Sole Provider of a Diesel Engine Programfrom 500 kW to 97,300 kW
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
MAN B&W Diesel Engine Programme
30,000
20,000
40,000
600
10,000
60,000
50,000
Engine output P (kW)mech
0700
Engine speed (r/min)500200 300 400
Medium speed
70,000
100
Four-stroke
80,000
Two-stroke
Low speed
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Two-Stroke Licensees
Spain IZAR – Manises 1941
Korea Hyundai HSD STX
Poland Cegielski 1959
Russia Bryansk 1959
Japan Mitsui Makita Hitachi Kawasaki
Croatia Uljanik 1954 Split 1984
China HHM DMD YMD
1980 1980 1989
1926198119511981
197619831984
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
6S35MC and 10K98MC-C on Testbed
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] <15>
up to 80 080 kW
Two stroke engine 10K98MC-C
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Comparison IC engine vs. gas turbine
Carsten DommermuthSenior Manger Sales Support
Business Unit Power Plants
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Power Efficiency Comparison at ISO 3046
Operation conditions:Gas turbines:(according to ISO 3977)Diesel engines:(according to ISO 3046)
*Type: MAN Diesel SE
Reference of Graphic:Article from Mr. H. W. Köhler, MAN Diesel SE: „Diesel engines and gas turbines in cruise vessel propulsion – a technical and commercial comparison“, 1999
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Influence of Ambient Conditions on Rating of Internal Combustion Engines
25
48
80
Air inlet temperature CCooling water temperature C
Ambient conditions
o
o
46
100
90
Medium speed diesel
3542Design
Overall efficiency
Gas turbine
Low speed diesel
30 35 4520 40
% Power Power restriction
Efficiency, low speed diesel
% Power
2535Min.
4552Max.
50
49
Ambient temperature Co
47
80
100
90
Low speed diesel (%)
„Base Load“
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Influence of flexibel load profile on Rating
„Part Load“ Output Reduction Two stroke Engine
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Fuel flexibility for a better economical performance
Carsten DommermuthSenior Manger Sales Support
Business Unit Power Plants
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Examples of Liquid Fuels Burned in MAN B&WTwo-stroke Low Speed Diesel Engines
Fuel No A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O UnitsViscosity 3.8 84 85 141 198 255 470 520 560 690 710 800 1200 50,000 - cSt/50°CDensity 968 995 970 993 938 977 985 983 1,010 1,008 1,030 935 998 1,040 1.01 kg/m
at 15°CFlash point 98 84 80 103 100 106 90 95 90 79 84 >40 80 >70 °CConradsonCarbon 0.3 17.2 12.1 13.3 9.4 14.5 16.8 14.8 17.3 22.1 24.7 9.4 14,1 24.2 11.7 % weightAsphalt 0.78 15.1 8.9 9.2 3.7 10.0 11.3 12.8 14.6 19.3 29.0 1.02 12 - -Sulphur 0.10 2.72 1.16 0.91 0.83 0.87 0.90 1.18 2.22 3.52 3.30 0.37 4 4.8 2.8Water 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.00 0.01 0.02 0.02 0.01 0.00 0.00 0.00 - 0,65 0.05 -Ash 0.00 0.065 0.025 0.03 0.03 0.025 0.03 0.035 0.04 0.07 0.09 0.043 - 0.035 0.18Aluminium - - - - - - - - - - - - 12 2.0 1 mg/kgVanadium 0 220 20 23 12 17 24 45 122 300 370 415 312 149 - mg/kgSodium 0 27 23 24 25 40 35 22 22 24 50 9 - - - mg/kgCCAI 912 874 849 866 807 843 844 841 868 864 885 - - - - -
3
>60
% weight% weight% weight% weight
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
MAN B&W Two-Stroke Dual Fuel Low Speed Diesel, Fuel Type Mode
Gas
100% load30 - 40% Fuel
Fuel 100%
8%
“Minimum fuel” mode
100% load
Fuel
Fuel 100%
Fuel-oil-only mode
100% loadFuel
Gas
Fuel 100%
8%
“Specified gas” mode
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
40 MW Plant, Chiba, Japan
Power Plant at CHIBA Power Plant in Japan
Engine:MAN B&W 12K80MC-GI
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Examples of Gaseous Fuels Burned in MAN B&WTwo-Stroke Low Speed Diesel Engines
Composition Units Natural gas types VOC fuel typesCH4 vol.% 88.5 91.1 26.1 - - -C2H6 vol.% 4.6 4.7 2.5 1.1 6.3 -C3H8 vol.% 5.4 1.7 0.1 65.5 - -C4H10 vol.% 1.5 1.4 - 23.9 5.0 6.1C5+
vol.% 6.5 88.7 93.9CO2 vol.% - 0.5 64.0 - - -N2 vol.% - 0.6 7.3 - - -
Molar mass kg/kmol 18.83 17.98 35.20
Lower calorific value kJ/kg 49170 48390 7050Lower calorific value kJ/Nm3 41460 38930 11120
Density:at 25 oC/ 1 bar abs kg/m3 0.76 0.73 1.43at 25 oC/ 200 bar abs kg/m3 194 179 487
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Waste Energy UtilisationEnvironmental friendly and a chance for optimising also economical efficiency of the electrical generation process
Carsten DommermuthSenior Manger Sales Support
Business Unit Power Plants
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Low Speed Diesels – Waste Energy Utilisation
Turbo generator
Process steam
District heating
Process heating
(60-65 C)o (80-85 C)o
(230-260 C)o
Process water
District heating
PressurisedProcess heat
District heating
Electricalenergy
Turbo generator
Process steam
District heating
(80-130° C)
Energy fromlubricatingoil coolingA) Heat
exchanger
Energy fromjacket coolingA) Heat
exchangerB) Direct use
Exhaust gas energyA) Steam boilerB) Heat exchanger
Air cooler energyA) Hot water
=> 100 CB) Hot water
=> 100 C
o
TCS unitA) Power
turbine
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Two-stroke Low Speed DieselCombined Cycle
50 60 70 80 90 100 110 Load [%]
57
55
53
51
Thermal efficiency [%]
MAN B&W 2-stroke diesel engines are well known for theirlow specific fuel oil consumption, overall efficiency, andlong-term reliability.The recent dramatic increase in fuel oil costs has revivedinterest in methods for maximising fuel economy in 2-strokeengine systems, while ensuring continued high systemreliability.
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
600 kW MAN B&W TCS Unit for Exhaust Gas Energy Recovery
Generator Gear box Exhaust gas turbineCoupling
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Typical Utility Installation (Macao)
Heat balance data: Unutilisedenergy
Generatorcooling: 1.5%
Radiation: 0.5%
Lub. oil cooling: 4.1%
Exhaust gas: 22.5%
Jacket watercooling: 7.0%
Heat exchanger
Total energy utilisation:Electrical energy = 50.0%Thermal energy = 1.2%Total energy utilisation = 51.2%
Engine shaftgeneratoroutput 47.7%
Turbogenerator
1.3%
Energy in fuel: 100%
Utilisedenergy
TCSgenerator
1.0%
1.2%
High temp.Low temp.
Charge air cooling: 22.5%
A Sankey diagram is a specific type of
flow diagram, in which the width of the
arrows is shown proportionally to the
flow quantity. Is shows exactly the well
known first law of thermodynamics
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
MAN Diesel SE Power Market
<30>
Carsten DommermuthSenior Manager
Business Unit Power Plants
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] 3/333363416 (GMD12/ACJ)
Two-stroke Low Speed Engines for Stationary Applications
Range from 20-50 MW
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
2009 and 2010Stationary two-stroke projects
Actual and upcoming projects only two-stroke (as of 09-2009)
Western Pacific Ocean: 80 MW (12K80-MC-S)
Greece: 100 MW Tender (12K90MC-S)
North America: 50 MW Tender (12K90MC-S)
Italia: 20 MW Private Project (12K60MC-S)
Albania 120 MW Private Project (12K80MC-S)
Southwest Asia 600 MW governmental project (12K90MC-S)
Several enquiries for Bio projects (range from 4-max. 20 MW) L35MC-S
<32>
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] < 33 >
Environmental policy The new driver for modern power plant solutions
Carsten DommermuthSenior Manager
Business Unit Power Plants
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] <34>
Emission facts
The emission issue will become more and more important in the future.
In local areas, regulations will be even stricter than they are today.
The main driver for sophisticated MAN Diesel two-stroke environmental technology is the market dominance of MAN´s two-stroke engines in the marine business.
Our two and four-stroke power plant solutions fulfill high standards of international regulations like World Bank and IFC.
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] <35>
Emission facts
Emissions from diesel and heavy fuel oil engines
NOx (Nitrogen Oxides): Function of peak combustion temperatures and oxygen concentration.Reduction: Primary or secondary methods
SOx (Sulphur Oxides): Function of fuel oil sulphur content.Reduction: The most effective means is to lower the sulphur content in the fuel.
CO2 (Carbon dioxide): Function of the thermal effienecy of the complete generating process.
Particulate emissions: A result of:
Ash content in fuel/cylinder and lube oil.Partly burned lube oil dosage.
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] <36>
Environmental policy and regulations
are the main driver for
modern power plant solutions
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
CO2 Emission as function of plant efficiency
3334790.2007.03.28 (3230/JH)
400
450
500
550
600
650
700
750
800
35 40 45 50 55 60% efficiency
CO2g/kWh
CO2
g/kWh
3334790.2007.03.28 (3230/JH)
HFO 380cSt
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Exhaust Emissions
Heat
Air8.5 kg/kWh 21% O2 79% N2
Fuel175 g/kWh 97% HC 3% S
Lube1 g/kWh 97% HC 2.5% Ca 0.5% S
Work
Exhaust gas13.00% O2 75.80% N2 5.20% CO2 5.35% H2O1500 vppm NOx 600 vppm SOx 60 vppm CO 180 vppm HC
120 mg/Nm3 Part
Two stroke Engine air and exhaust gas flow
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Exhaust Emissions
World Bank (2008) Guideline for thermal power plants > 300 MWth
NOx[mg/m3]
SOx[mg/m3]
PM [mg/m3]
WB 2008 740 580 30-50
1% S in fuel and non degraded air shed
How can we meet the current World Bank or the local emission rules?
Measurements with 15%O2 in dry Exhaust Gas
… or local requirements, or values defined by an Environmental Assessment Study
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Schematic SCR Flow ChartExhaust Emissions
2-stroke engines
4-stroke enginesEngine SCR T/C Boiler
Engine T/C SCR Boiler
350 ºC 270 ºC
350 ºC
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Exhaust Emissions
Two stroke solution for reduction the SOx (SO2)- “Main driver for this emissions is the available fuel”
To meet minimum World Bank without secondary method a low sulphur content is the driver
Measurements with 15%O2 in dry Exhaust Gas
NOx[mg/m3]
SOx[mg/m3]
PM [mg/m3]
WB 2008 740 580* 50
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
0 1 2 3 4 5S-Content in Fuel Oil %wt.
SOx
Emis
sion
s m
g/N
m³ @
15%
O2
*1% S in fuel
… or local requirements, or values defined by an Environmental Assessment Study
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Electrostatic Precipitator – Reference List
1990 40MW 4 x 7K60MC-S Cheju, Korea1997 38 MW 3 x 7K60MC-S DCM, India2004 60 MW 2 x 9K80MC-S BLPC, Barbados2005 40 MW 1 x 12K80MC-S Komipo, Korea
1 x MAN 12K80MC-S engines
(40 MW) Engines in Korea
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Jeju Island, South Korea
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Stationary Applications
Emission Testedtechnology
Proventechnology
Influence on1st cost
Influence on Influence onrunning cost maintenance
Control method effort
CO2
Efficiency X up down
NOx
Engine adjustment
Water emulsification
SCR
EGR
X up
X up up
X up up up
X up up
Particulates
Fuel selection
Engine adjustment
Precipitators
X up
X
X up up
SOx
Fuel selection
DeSOx
X up
X up up up
Liquid fuel two-stroke diesel engine emission control status
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] <45>
Two-stroke vs. four-stroke
Carsten DommermuthSenior Manger
Business Unit Power Plants
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Economics in power generation
Comparison of pricing in power generation for
2-stroke and 4-stroke
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Comparison two stroke vs. four stroke
Investors view Driver for a two stroke Solution
Two stroke Engine with a higher thermal efficiency. (Net Heat Rate)
Two stroke has a lower specific Fuel Oil consumption than four stroke.
Two stroke with longer Time between overhaul (TBO) in service.
Two stroke engine with lower mean piston velocity (MPV) as indicator for lower maintenance costs.
Two stroke is very flexible in fuel share.
Fuel Oil90%
Maintenance6%
Lube Oil4%
Typical Cost Distribution for running costs in Electricity Generation
The equity pay back time for a two stroke solution is under ceteris paribus nearly the same with 4,5 years under a
NPV Analysis. Reasons are the higher thermal efficiency, lower fuel and spare part consumption
*Without cost of capital
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Comparison of annual running cost for ~330 MW base load power
Power Plant Solution Calculations without capital costs- capital costs for equity and debt are depending on customers business case
7 x 12K90MC-S With TCS and steam turbine
328,9 MW net
18 x 18V48/60With steam turbine
303 MW net
SFOC 172,3 g/kWh 192 g/kWh
Fuel oil costs per year (230 US$/MT) 91,6 Mio.US$ 93,8 Mio.US$
System oil consumption (per unit) 4,8 kg/h 11,5 kg/h
Cylinder oil consumption (per unit) 1,0 g/kWh -----
Lube and cylinder oil costs 3,8 US$/kg 3,8 US$/kg
System oil costs (plant) 1,1 Mio.US$ 5,66 Mio.US$
Cylinder oil costs (plant) 8,9 Mio.US$ ----
Maintanance costs (7200h/a) 7,0 Mio.US$/year(3,0 US$/MWh)
18,59 Mio.US/year(7,8 US$ /MWh)
Total operating costs per year 108,6 Mio.US$ 121,85 Mio.US$
Specific operating costs per yearbased on 7000 h/a*
0,049 US$/kWh net* 0,057 US$/kWh net*
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Electricity generating costs based on a ~330 MW base load power plant solution
Power Plant Solution
Capital costs
7 x 12K90MC-S With TCS and steam turbine
328,9 MW net
18 x 18V48/60With steam turbine
303 MW net
Construction time 2,5 1,5
Equity ratio 40% 40%
Tax rate 30% 30%
Equity costs 15% 15%
Loan costs 5% 5%
Weighted costs of capital 8,1% 8,1%
Full eletricity generation costs 56 US$/MWh 60,2 US$/MWh
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Results of comparison two stroke vs. four stroke in annual running costs for ~330 MW
1,1
5,66
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Two stroke
Four stroke
Lub oil costs per plant in Mio.US$/a
0 2 4 6 8 10
Two stroke
Four stroke
Cylinder oil costs (plant) Mio.US$/a *
*Four stroke engines without a cylinder oil system
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Results of comparison two stroke vs. four stroke in annual running costs ~330 MW
7
18,59
0 5 10 15 20
Two stroke
Four stroke
Maintenance costs (7200h/a) Mio.US$/a
115,6
126
110 115 120 125 130
Two stroke
Four stroke
Total operating costs per year in Mio.US$
High price differences are caused by 2 main servicing at 15.000 operating hours and 30.000 operating hours for 4-stroke engine.First main servicing for 2-stroke engine at 32.000 operating hours
Source: B. Jacobsen and P.G. Povelsen, MAN Diesel A/S, -G. Ambrasas, MAN Diesel SE
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
The main drivers forpower plant investment decisions
Ranking for Independent Power Producer (IPP)1. Heat Rate.
2. High electricity market prices.
3. Best financial case under Net Present Value - The net added $-value of cash flow/investment in today’s money- adjusted by thediscount rate
4. Return on investment attainable for investors.
5. The internal rate of return of an investment. (IRR)
6. Project implementation time (project development/financing, engineering, construction, etc.).
7. Interest rate/loan tenor.
8. Flexible operation, short start and easy shutdowns.
9. Comparatively low operation and maintenance (O&M) costs.
The focus for IPP power plant investment decisions is more financial orientated
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
The main drivers forpower plant investment decisions
Ranking for Publicly Owned power projects 1. High Reliability.
2. High Availability
3. Long and steady operation up to first major overhaul.
4. Heat Rate.
5. Comparatively low operation and maintenance (O&M) costs.
6. Best financial case under Net Present Value - The net added $-value of cash flow/investment in today’s money- adjusted by thediscount rate
7. Return on investment.
8. The internal rate of return of an investment. (IRR)
9. Project implementation time (project development/financing, engineering, construction, etc.).
10. Interest rate/loan tenor.
The focus for public owned power plant investments is more orientated at save and steady energy supply
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
The main drivers forpower plant investment decisions
* EPC package incl. 2x 9K80 MC-S engines, 1x Steam Turbine and 2x TCS Systems
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
The main drivers forpower plant investment decisions
Typical cost distribution of a EPC two stroke project (in %)
Full EPC turnkey price:
- Installed capacity: 62.000kW Net
- 115 Mio. US$
- Specific price: 1850US$/kW
Engines20%
Generators11%
Mechanical Equipment
24%
Electrical Equipment
8%
Balance of Plant/Civil
20%
Transport and Logistic
4%
Errection and Comissioning
10%
Engineering3%
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] <56>
Two-stroke vs. four-strokeMaintenance costs
Carsten DommermuthSenior Manger
Business Unit Power Plants
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Comparison of maintenance costs ~330 MW
<57>
Specific Maintenance costsTwo-stroke 7,3 €/kW/year
Four-stroke 21 €/kW/year
2,40
6,36
Two-stroke Four-stroke
Annual maintenance costs in Mio. €
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Comparison of maintenance costs ~330 MW
Accumulated maintenance costs for
20 years
Two-stroke 48,02 Mio.€
Four-stroke 127,26 Mio.€
<58>
48,02
127,26
Two-stroke Four-stroke
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Comparison of maintenance costs ~330 MW
<59>
Engine 7 x12K90MC-S
Two-stroke
18 x18V48/60
Four-strokeCylinder 84 324
Valves 84 648
Spare part costs only forvalves in 20 years(140.000h)
8,89 Mio. € 27 Mio. €
Different engine designs a the main reason
for high different in maintenance pricing
Main influence factors for maintenance costs:
Number of cylinders and cylinder heads, number of moving parts and mean piston velocity
Example: Number of Valves
*based on 7000 h/a: Estimated maintenance costs for a 12K90 MC-S engine. Exhaust valve-TBO 16.000 h –pricing 12.000 € plus blue colar costs (7 h x 7€/h) in total 12.100 €
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Comparison of maintenance costs ~330 MW
<60>
Specific Maintenance costsTwo-stroke 7,3 €/kW/year
Four-stroke 21 €/kW/year
2,40
6,36
Two-stroke Four-stroke
Annual maintenance costs in Mio. €
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Comparison of maintenance costs ~330 MW
Accumulated maintenance costs for
20 years
Two-stroke 48,02 Mio.€
Four-stroke 127,26 Mio.€
<61>
48,02
127,26
Two-stroke Four-stroke
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Comparison of maintenance costs ~330 MW
<62>
Engine 7 x12K90MC-S
Two-stroke
18 x18V48/60
Four-strokeCylinder 84 324
Valves 84 648
Spare part costs only forvalves in 20 years(140.000h)
8,89 Mio. € 27 Mio. €
Different engine designs are the main reason
for high differences in maintenance pricing
Main influence factors for maintenance costs:
Number of cylinders and cylinder heads, number of moving parts and mean piston velocity
Example: Number of Valves
*based on 7000 h/a: Estimated maintenance costs for a 12K90 MC-S engine. Exhaust valve-TBO 16.000 h –pricing 12.000 € plus blue colar costs (7 h x 7€/h) in total 12.100 €
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
MAN Diesel SE Two-stroke reference plants
<63>
Carsten DommermuthSenior Manager
Business Unit Power Plants
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] 3/333363416 (GMD12/ACJ)
Two-stroke Low Speed Engines for Stationary Applications
Range from 20-50 MW
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
As at 2002.10.16
Clifton Pier Power Plant, the Bahamas
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Bahamas, 2 x 33 MWProject Organisation
Alstom Power S.A., Spain- Main contractor- Generator- Mechanical and electrical aux. systems- Logistics- Site erection- Commissioning
MAN B&W Diesel A/S, Denmark- Diesel engine design
Manises Diesel Engine Co. S.A., Spain- Diesel engine supply- Site erection- Commissioning Conceptual plant engineering
Foundation design
Commissioning assistance
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
As at 2002.10.16
Clifton Pier Power Plant, the Bahamas
Clifton Pier Power Station: Location: Bahamas
Operator: Bahamas Electricity Corp
Fuel: Heavy Fuel Oil
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
2 x 100 MW HFO Barges for the Phillipines4 x 12K90MC-S 2 x 100 MW HFO Barges for the Phillipines4 x 12K90MC-S
The world largest Power Barge- 95 Meters long, 45 Meters Wide, 50 Meters high, 22000 Ton
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Mindanao Plant Performance
Engine data
Engine type 12K90MC-S
Number of cylinders 12
MCR kW 51.240
r/min rpm 102.9
Bore cm 90
Stroke cm 230
Mean piston velocity m/s 7.89
Mean effective pressure bar 17,0
Length m 23
Width m 7,9
Height m 14,9
Total weight t 1830
Heaviest weight for maintenance t 10
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
12K90MC-S, San Carlos, Mexico
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
12K90MC-S, San Carlos, Mexico
Olachea (San Carlos) Location: Mexico
Operator: Comision Federal de ElectricidadeConfiguration: 2 X 32-MW, 1 X 42-MW 12K90MC-S engine.
Fuel: Heavy Fuel Oil
EPC: MHI, Hyundai, MAN B&W, ABB
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
200 MW GMR Plant at Chennai, India
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
125 MW, Ibiza, Spain
Ibiza-Holiday Island in the Mediterranen Sea-
Base and Midle load powered by MAN Diesel two- and four stroke engines
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
125 MW, Ibiza, Spain
Ibiza- Location: Baleares, Operator: Endesa SpainConfiguration: 4 X 8.5-MW 6K74ES engines, 2 X 15.4-MW 10K67GSCA enginesOperation: 1973-1981Fuel: HFOE/G supplier: MAN B&W
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
90 MW Plant at Fort George, Mauritius3 x 9K80MC-S
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
90 MW Plant at Fort George, Mauritius3 x 9K80MC-S
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
90 MW Power Plant, Guam
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
90 MW Power Plant, Guam
1999 2000 1999 2000
D8 D9
Availability % 96.3 93.1 95.1 93.6
Reliability % 99.0 98.3 97.6 94.0
Scheduled outage hrs. 234 272 217 274
Unscheduled outage hrs. 84 95 207 138
Load factor % 82 94 83 94
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Many Thanks for your attention….
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] <80>
MAN Diesel Contacts Power Plants Sales
Carsten Dommermuth
Senior Manager
Two-stroke, stationary power plants
MAN Diesel SE
Business Unit Power Plants
Phone: +49 821 322-3184
Mobil: +49 171 7645070
Postal address:
Stadtbachstr. 1
86153 Augsburg, Germany
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
MAN Diesel SETwo-stroke engine bio fuel application
Carsten DommermuthSenior Manager
Business Unit Power Plants
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Customer: PBB GmbH, cogeneration IPPC (Independent Power Producer Company) based in Oldenburg,
Scope of delivery: Turnkey CHP (Combined Heat and Power) plant to a site in the city of Brake, near Bremen, Germany.
Engine: MAN B&W 7L35MC-S engine, supplying 4.2 MWel to the national grid and 3.6 MWth to a palm-oil refinery situated nearby. The engine is a two stroke, low-speed, crosshead uniflow diesel engine.
Fuel: Crude palm oil with a Total Acid Number (TAN) of up to 15 mg/KOH/g.
Heat rate: 7,400 kJ/kWh at site ambient conditions, corresponding to an efficiency of 49%; plant total efficiency in CHP-mode 87%.
Exhaust gas cleaning: The plant is equipped with an SCR (Selective Catalytic Reduction) catalyst, an oxidation catalyst and an electrostatic precipitator
< 82 >
Two-stroke Bio Project under the German EEG in Brake
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] < 83 >
Two-stroke Bio Project under the German EEG in Brake
MAN Diesel B&W 7L35MC-S engine with 4,5 KWmech
Power Plant site from PBB GmbH in Brake, Germany
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Name of project Brake Emden Italy DanishTest Method Unit
Free fat acid % 7 6.5 5.56 12.48
Conradson carbon residue ASTM D 189 % wt 0.5 2 0.52 0.74
Water content fuel max. ASTM D 95 % vol 0.5 <1 0.11 0.1Flash point, PMcc ASTM D 93 °C 200 >60 239 -Phosphorus ISO 10478 mg/kg 100 - 15 -Total acid number Din.EN-ISO 660 mg KOH/g 14 13 11.2 24.96
Calorific value, net ASTM D 240 MJ/kg 36 37-39 36.9 35.5
Density at 15°C ASTM D 4052 g/ml 930 kg/m3 0,89-0,92 0.8888 0.9142Viscosity at 50°C ASTM D 445 cSt 32 40 28.3 28
Sulphur IP 336 ppm 10 <50 1 -
Ash ASTM D 482 % wt 0.01 <0.1 <0.01 0.005
Two-stroke Bio Crude Palm Oil Specifications
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] <85>
Density/15 °C 900 – 930 kg/m³ DIN EN ISO 3675, EN ISO 12185Flash point > 60 °C DIN EN 22719
Lower calorific value > 35 MJ/kg(typical: 37 MJ/kg) DIN 51900-3
Viscosity/50 °C< 40 cSt
(corresponds to viscosity/ 40 °C< 60 cSt)
DIN EN ISO 3104
Cetane number > 40 FIACoke residue < 0,4 % DIN EN ISO 10370Sediment content < 200 ppm DIN EN 12662Oxidation stability (110 °C) > 5 h ISO 6886Phosphorus content < 15 ppm ASTM D3231Na + K content < 15 ppm DIN 51797-3Ash content < 0,01 % DIN EN ISO 6245Iodine Number < 125 g/100g DIN EN 14111Water content < 0,5 % EN ISO 12537TAN (total acid number) < 4 mgKOH/g DIN EN ISO 660
Cold Filter Plugging Point < 10 °C below lowest temperature in fuel system EN 116
Source: Dr. Gehring MAN Diesel SE
MAN Diesel four-stroke BiofuelSpecification
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Two-stroke Bio Conversion of Standard Stationary HFO Engine to CPO Engine
Larger fuel valves Introduced (coated)
Reinforced camshaft Introduced
Larger fuel pumps introduced; modifiedMaterials (coated)
Modified components
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] < 87 >
Two-stroke Bio Project with Crude Palm Oil
The emission levels are based on the ISO 8178 measurement method, except for PM values, which are stated according to EPA 17.
NOx level assumes to fuel bound nitrogen. The emissions are recalculated to 15% of O2 at dry exhaust gas at ISO 3046 ambient conditions.
No remarkable SOxemissions.
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Emissions measured at the test bed withoutexhaust gas cleaning (15% O2)
< 88 >
Two-stroke Bio Project with Crude Palm Oil
CO mg/Nm3
NOXmg/Nm3
HC mg/Nm3
PM mg/Nm3
100% MCR
90 2600 35 80
75% MCR
60 2600 45 70
50% MCR
80 2400 55 65
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Two-stroke Bio MAN B&W two-stroke engine L35MC-S at test bed
< 1 >
http://www.manbw.com/engines/TwoStrokeLowSpeedEngines.asp?model=L35MC-S
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
The MAN Diesel reference Palm Oilplant in Brake is equipped with an SCR, Oxi-cat and an electrostatic precipitator*
< 90 >
Two-stroke Bio Brake fulfil the strict German TA Luft
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic]
Two-stroke Bio SCR Arrangement MAN B&W Low Speed Biofuel Engine
TC
Generator
Cyl.1
Power house
Silencer
Chimney
Exhaust gas boiler
Electrostatic precipitator
SCR
Total back pressure to be below 350 mmWC
Suction blower
2009/04/01© MAN Diesel [current topic] < 92 >
Two-stroke Bio project investment costs for 4,5 MWmech in a CHP mode
E&M turnkey pricing approx. 1100 €/kW incl, SCR, Oxicat and ESP (4,95 Mio. €)
CHP installation 100 €/kW (450 T€)
Engines20%
Generators11%
Mechanical Equipment
24%
Electrical Equipment
8%
Balance of Plant/Civil
20%
Transport and Logistic
4%
Errection and Comissioning
10%
Engineering3%