L I - 1 ~nisi+w~w~-%~iiqnra~~ud't::4iiaiBw ~m~w~rwnSdq~n.r.ruImoJ~onA'n~u~~~i iai~wrinnpnuiui~ma~~ud~~ii5'11iiiwIa~ii~nKn~1~iu~G~~~u &~l(indi-auhii

o~hknauuo~npnultlii 4 d3zrn3 ?a ~ h n g n 3 ~ ~ q f i f m u nUaii?"~%4~~3a~d L: Y daniwCSi uariiirnqdsra~6rdon?iuqftn3'zu cw.rka:uun~iuqla~~u~h~~onivo~

1 rl Y 40 npnuiu ~ n n ~ n u i u ~ ~ u n u i n o i u ? ~ n ~ i u ~ ~ n ~ ~ u ~ # b b d d ~ r a i ' ~ ~ u u " ~ ~ ~ ~ nisdf id~f i id6

rinngnuiuiirflu&o~d~31u~~nff u~CI"uqan~3uodrl3::dil &#un?iuqiin~tu(dtfh

qmn3uiTorr3nu o~ia iQwu'nn~nui~

uonsin$u:itham:ciu~ai6wu'nng~uiu~~~an~~i1do~1u~i'~ioi~~~nau'~~

qnnd3umu qna~6n3 'Ldiir~wnini~uian?anin~anmc rinnpnuiu'ljl~iliju.nu'ido~ 4d v m L: r l ~ A ~awidunia nuvwwinai 8 u n i ~ nuionnurriiuu lund?u~iuuo~nini~uiauu~1n3

il y nnns ~~ldirnnpnuiu lwnmonacn"&a~l~rinngnuio ibu auini~~i i r innpnuio rl4 d Y A- L undmaingnuiu Gr~inu+-maucao ~ d u h

d~nii$u~nn~uiu~~1fl6irl?n~i~~rid~raim~~~~n&i~u n~iihosrinnpnuiu I ? o n i s ~ f l ~ i d ? n n ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ n ' ~ d ~ u ~ u n ~ ~ d ~ : : a i ~ u ~ ~ d i j u A ~ n ~ o ~ ~dd~zwq~i jFnpuio m u m n i ~ 1 # 6 i d ? n w ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ ; ~ u ' n n ~ o ~ i i ~ 1 l f ( ~ o ~ i j ~ m n ~ ~ u d n d ~ t : m ~ ~ d ~ ~ o ~ i m ~ ~ ~ u QCiuiiuo~uniau rinnpnuiulTJ~~ofirnrloii~~u~flu~~iu~~~\tuni~u

k ~ u q , l ~ n ~ u ' U ~ ~ % i h ~ n n ~ ~ u i ~ ~ ~ ~ o ~ 2 d~mi.rffa 1) n ? i u q h ~ u uar

2) @IU~JMI%U

rawyiismu

a ~ ~ u q i s q q ~ f l # n ~ w ~ a u b d ~ ~ b c inurur1~uk? ld~odn~1u~~n3~ ur~i~ng~nmG (i7.17 1.fi~rimurilun33u D 1 ~ u s t ~ ~ ~ v L L R L ~ U I L H ~ W ~ "Reason" umnpmu&u *Inp~nmG

4 d * d iln~iaflunssuuardbnqwanmn~3uniiqGn~~u fiin~~nmflJl~n~iub~una3u uaz'ldii Arrl rnnlwan~nL~m"ingLnm6u"u~~Y8nttu udn?iuqiin.raud~n~nuiu~~~t:n~iuq~n3fu

1uf~nu1dfioimmidu~n27u~~uf ~ ~ ~ u E J ~ c I ? I w ~ L ~ ~ P ( ~ ~ w ' I ~ ~ stf i~i .rcui8na~~~d-l

2. Qi7UYn Positive

f i j i ~1~ac1~m'ud~ : :~n~1qnn~~ i l~~1~ : :a1a~~au~n~nn '~qn~~ i

Lester ward nka41 n a ~ u q ~ s ~ ~ u ~ ~ u ~ a u d ~ : : n o u u o d u n Y ' d ~ u n ~ ~ r d

a~ua33unrlu'~n1~iuun'u ud9ch~ti1lAiiana1u~iq~iuun'u h f i ~ k ~ o n ~ a h t a h

ii?adiluci~nuviold ~ ~ o u ~ u k o n ~ ~ f i n w ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ f l n ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ n ~ d a f ~ ~ ~ ~ a u o ~ a ~ ~ o d ~ ~ ~ u A. 2 P $dnn~o~l~inrumu~a~u~~ld~an~r)~na~auna~uunwf o ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ w ~ i i ~ u a ~ ~ ~ d a : : uvi

~ % d u o ~ $ d n n ~ o ~ k o ~ ~ o n ~ a n ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ n w ~ o d ~ ~ ~ V ; ~ ~ ~ u u n ' u ~ d o ~ f l ~ ~ ~ a i ' ~ ~ ~ ^ ? a u o ~ a u ~ o ~

dold i r r t a

Karl Marx LLB: Frederick Engelo ~ ~ b ~ ~ L 6 1 < ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 3 ~ ~ ~ 1 L ~ u d l c r ' d ~ u ~ x i 6 i ~ 3 1 ~

wuornn i iynnad~uh&Tud~rlu~6~~nniwo~n~ua::waw~au~n uaril~udIlliTuriou

hu~l3~~~a~ul f fuwad~: :~unr fu1n ihuda~qu6auu~~~1ul&fuwad~::lu'11ri~ou n14

ufluod Marx k a a f i ~ ~ ~ u u n ~ ~ u i n a " ~ a u ~ u ~ # ~ ~ R u L B u L ~ ~ u o J ~ ~ ~ u s ~ ~ " u#an3:01u wad~du?r6~1nnTtu1n~~~n::wa~ija~~~1~~uun'u~ dalnnuLfld~uodn.r.r& Guqun'

u: P luln~afi~~ual.ndaud~::~~;fu daw~ ddo~nnfwu~nf L L ~ = : H ~ W Q ~ uahadrmin~ua aw~ilu

17' Plato, The Republic, Book IV. 18.

Aristotle, The Politics, Book Ill. 19' Lester F. Ward, Applied Sociology, p. 22. *'' Karl Marx, Critique of the Gotba Program, p. 10.

Herkrt Spencer I~~~?I~HuIL IYoJAI< I "qta33uW b b d ~ n l l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ( ~ i ~ d ~ & n d i ~ mu&, ~ o n ~ ~ u ~ ~ a . r . r u ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ o ~ n ' u n ~ i u ~ ~ u o ~ n ~ ~ d ~ ~ u ~ ~ a ~ n ' u n ~ i l l ~ B n ~ n i uyabnq.r! n 8.4 11111 8.411 on.rrnwnqruaqnnn unqrninitchuu3 dondo( uar~~aamqiuiiak4u ur iodi~l~f ia~u ta3niwuo~bonauo:n'pcqn~in'na~lau8n.rmwuo~$~nu~~ I~n'RuruoJ Herbert

Spencer ^ O ~ m i ~ ~ ~ ~ i n ~ h ~ o ~ % w ~ a i u 1 ~ i ~ u a i ~ ~ o ~ u ~ ~ d u ~ ~ f i ! ~ i j 3 t l u w ~ i i n a 3 u u o ~ 41MLQJ

W m soll.~ nh~<in~iuq8a~mor#o~d~~nou&~unaiu~nuoflin uadn3rnw A # ~ n o ~ ~ ~ a r i i o ~ ~ ~ " i u i ~ ~ : : n i ~ ~ u o ~ i ~ n u ~ a agn.r:riiMnu 1 ) !ni~w'amlm.rirnalnicauini~#nwitu

o d i ~ n l i ~ u q ~ ~ n u ~ f l n i . r # n a ~ ~ u h ~ ~ s ~ f ~ i ~ r ~ ~ n ~ n ~ w n ' u n ~ i u ~ n u o n i n d a ~ ! ~ ( ~ u

aSnul&o*d3 2) sr i io$ni . r6~l l imumuncnu~m~nu~~~~n~~umui~~~~ou"~u~i~~&~nu 1 o~rrl%n~mwlum~iimuG:ol~iian~iu~nuomnlu$~n~~l& UR: 3) ~ o ~ i f i ~ i ~ ~ ~ q n & ~ u l f l a u i e u r i u ~ ~ b ~ ~ ~ w ' a u i d a : : ~ n ~ a i A ~ # ~ o ~ d ~ ~ 6 o uon~inni .r#nwua:oi iw~~&aC~8~.~! hudcnouih 7 !nhu ih ni.rQacnsi~qdk.ln~~~dw=:~um~6fu~u 9 riic luld-iivl~

A b r lumd'io~~2iurndd 3 nu. ~wonnuiuil4' l u u ~ : d u i ~ ~ u a d ~ i d ~ : : d i d ~ u " i u ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ a i ~ ~ ld6n~imoio1dl? ~ i d u ~ u n i ' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ n i w w i ~ B u ~ ~

,John ~ a w k nhq i i n~iuqta33u6o~d3rnau6~~ I) ~ d d l ~ t u u n i ) Q~i ingi ~vii~;leun'u!.rin~iuui~intn~n~w UAL 2) n13Ca3:~uASnu~~w~~qfwpiislfl~~dqnnu~~

John Rawls ~ i u ~ ~ u d 3 : 1 u % d ~ o ~ n ~ u ~ u ~ d u ~ ~ ~ d ~ d L ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ d n ~ i u ~ n u ~ n i n b b a ~ ^ o ~ f n i w biidu a t X o ~ ~ n i ~ 4 ~ : u u s i J n u ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ f l ~ R ~ 1 d ~ ~ l u a d ~ ~ d ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ uort{u

Y d.r:luad~ o ~ a ' ~ w . r ~ u ~ f l u ~ u o ~ i u o ~ n ~ i u q 6 ~ ~ ~ ~ u & i a u Thomas H o b k ~ b$u'h n ~ i u q 3 n ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ n u n i ~ ~ d o ~ n l 3 f l ~ J n ' ~ f l ? l ~ ~ ~ f l J

daoa5ulu#n i i ~ n i u n8mfwbiu n ~ i u ~ n u a m m ~ a d ~ ~ n i w ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ i u i i 6 q ~ o ~ a ~ ~ d Y E A mu~uniKIJdamv~uo~~~nu~~a::uodu~~f i !n~iu~i~qd~n~i aJuwwonnuiun~dao61iiuvo~

uywkrhb~~iunamnu~i juonin~~a~~~~iu~n~niwuo~nu~d ~do~flnao~o~16odi~ dclon~%t~~ ~ h o m s a ~ o b b e s ~ilu~nd.naq?uriirTn Positive ~ u n q i u ~ $ ~ y a ~ ~ ~ i uyw~&o~bi(tt

21' Herbert Spencer, Justice, p. 46.

22' William S. Sorley, The Morel Life, p. 95-1 13.

John Rewls, A Theory of Justice, p. 60-61. 24' Thomas Hobbes, De Cive, ch. I.

25' Jsremy Bentham, Theory of Legislation, p. 1 23.

2' r

3 5

$

&

cb

2 0,

2- $

i5 3

dt 3,

s 3

5t

2

3t s

If 3-

P-'

E~

8

4

3 5-

tL

rn

3

n

s; 5

. 29

<

St

!3 J

;t 2

m3

f

i2

'. G

s!

E~

Morris v. Crown Offlce, 2 W.R.L. (1970) 792.

c w n Z iiqnnuar 3 ~tou ~d30ni~a~lww!5rio~ luakrqnasm ~wwinwidr~uuiiirmnwilu'~~u qwnsdfio ~ w d Denning ddb~u(~winl~~dfl~ab~uduin n h a i i iir~u!uldoiaqnnl !lid n onIll+ainhiiu ni~n~:riiuo~~uiauna~!6~uni'~uneio~d!&~~~a~naiu~a~~u udnaiuiia

1.Ld Yod~uioinaxini3 ~ ~ i l a ~ ~ n i a d i i a n ~ n u i u TauWdi%iini!Mnnou riiaiu'~in~41lu 0: Y r iJnuuo~ho~ ~ui!d~iinpui~uu~u~n~au~quyw6~~ars'nwiuyw~K~i~~Q~~1~unii~t

& w d a mu!d &uu y~nia iung~uiuf i~ in 'u i ia iu~~ubo~bbar~ia iu i~nu~~dnaiu i ia ni3nclwq

41fjn 3 3 h . 4 ~ ~ L ~ ~ ' B ~ n l 3 ~ d ~ ~ ~ ! f l d ' b d ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ b b 3 J b ~ ~

2. rinn~~uiuiiatl#n~~uiuo~i~bOuxia~u ibiuri n i s l # i i u i l ~ i i i duo~nu w d o lurn~ng~muohshn~~~~bhdKa~o~~iiui~~uiwwi!& hod indu miunaiuoiw:ldiu

iin8dnw#wii!d~iluxi33u oirnisoill:~#qa~i~l~d!dflodn~una~n"nw#uii'bdb~u%a~u d aldu

bnuunnws2uua.r nGiwinwiifjnlunaiuiia~ius'u7uuu~ifuan'u~udw1ufli!~ nlzu -3 'Lddwlnu~Kn~iuouui~oi~nf ju~n~!& ~ l b ~ u l : ~ ~ d d i J $ M ~ U ~ U u " U b Q d b ~ U W U l U kd d a t u a ~ n p ~ u i u o i q i ~ q q ~ ~ i $ ~ u u u n " ~ n a i u f i a & a u udbdods:~a~uniaboi~a

.r & i juuniuia~lnw o i u t n ~ u ~ n i s ~ m d d f l o ~ ~ ~ u u u ~ ~ u i l ~ n i ~ ~ ~ u w u i u ~w.n:!&rii dsduaflKn'ud3:bw~"1112 n i s ~ ~ ~ a d o ~ ~ u ~ i u i ~ ~ ~ i d u o d w ~ n d i u o ' u n i ~ i u

ngvwiu m i a P ~ G o i a m i G w i n w i n ~ ~ ~ i u n ~ ~ u i u uduou~unqaGiG~luniaiii~ualww~az ni~rii~~arii~iiu~-1uvi~lKmiaaiuiandounaiunaiu!dqGxi~'~ulu6auwn~~uiua~!6

~ d u n i u w ~ : ~ i a u i y q 7 i i K a u n a i u ~ a 8 u ~ ~ ~ ~ i n n i ~ r i i ~uana iuw 'cm i~o iq i~~

auh~nnuiia!d!l ~~riPrsounaiu'b8 ~~dfiih@iru~iu!duo~~naiu n a i u ~ ~ ~ u f l ~ : ~ j n ~ o ~ d A 0 'buna~usoi~auoon~#n~au!~~nui!d~at~~uniu~#nb~unai~~fin doui rz~ i is i ib i iun~

d~inaii(~iiu~iufiii~au3ni~~nnauau~6n'u ci i l f iYa~&iu~%n~r3u udnaiuiiafi~ d P God ua:(~Gu~iu!duounouflod m i a j n i . u ~ w w i n w l i i i ~ a u d n a i ~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ a : ~ o n i ~

1 1 - 3 ( 1 4 l w w ~ ~ ~3uni~l#qaGiii~~Aaeiounaiunaiu! dqixif ~uw~na'uw~riu'or~n"~~i 98u i i~s 'u4 iu

u~~i~~a:ihu~GY'~q~n*!unfnwdauw'~unaiunaiu!dq~xiaaulung~~~iu~~!& i h ~ u 5 ~ i a a n w o~~~:oanwa~~ian~a~niwa~~i~wiu~sTulww iriuunu~q3oi~~:aonwa:'~iaY'qq3

a d 1

G~lwanmu w 3 t 3 i a ~ q 7 h ~ u a f i u ~iluaawounaiunaiuldqGaaau~una~uiuw~

u o n ~ i n n i s l # ~ i u i m Q i ~ ~ ~ i u n p ~ u i u ~ ~ ~ a ~ n n p H u ~ fiom3~naiuna~mu r i n n r ~ ~ m u n i u 7 a n ~ # n a i u q ~ % a a u b h ~ ~ n ~ u n i ~ u

~w'ar i~ l r~n iunngwu~u~f i~n~~u~f i~~~r~#u \K ~ d u nLiunnuiiaa1wts:s1'11Y'qq3i1K2u

n21uia~wh~1nn13'I%~Qn cnaljrnSi~3wi1 rnsoonthdods:hwvld \d~ihmuiaenu Jd A A d

wsrsiaY'qjfl~Guu onL.rodwudna r i4(cyhmolnnu~~ni~Cqtbr i~d~~~3ua~ R191q11d-1 t: w 1 uugrn~auaisrcirniq~od~q~ Ldot~dmu ~qw~~d~.r:Jiil~~ ~ ( i i ~ o ~ ~ ~ ~ j ~ ~ i i a ~ u i ~ ~ I ~ L ~ I Q & M I ? ~ ~ % ~ u I J ~ T : L ~ ~ ~ d u &duo2 ~~d1tio~duduci1aauunu~~u13udau

r d1rioaf1di1u2u~6~ ~~o~1ha1u\~aily~1~1~:~uflia1u1~r11iun6u13ui1u~~u\K

Y ~iinrmulu'qi~~.ruvplb~rimu7n~0~~~1 m a ~ n ~ ~ ~ n f ~ ~ K n n ~ w u ~ u ' I ~ ~ u ' w i ~ a u o ~ ~ u w K n ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ . ~ . ~ ~ ~ I C ~ ~ I K J ~ ~ I ~ I O ~ Q ~ ~ I ~ I J ~ O ~ I I ~ ~ ~ I R ~ ~ J ~ ~ I Q ~ ~ I L ~ I ~ T ~ ~ ~ I 6a

uon~1niia*ryqahukC~6iQqrb(1(i1~mou~1nuG~~~d~:nou&~u hut$d1\iiimljud2u w 1 4 - 1 w d w w w I g cilriowiid ~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ u ~ u ~ n a o ~ n o u i L n p ) ~ o ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ u u \ ~ o r j t u o ~ n ~ ~ i~di~)uni~~::nfu

W W I g A W I aiyq~ ~ : u : ~ ~ r n u o ~ Q ~ ~ s ~ d ~ n a ~ u ~ ~ u w ~ f : : i ~ i ~ d ~ n i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ' ~ ~ ~ R j u u ~ u o g ~ a ~ a ~ u

n 1 u i ~ ~ a i l $ d i ~ ~ n ~ \ ~ ~ ~ 1 d t : : ~ ~ ' 1 1 d ~ i ~ ~ c y c y i d i i l [ i l a ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ \ d I ~ ~ ~ v N I ~ I ~ I ~ J ~ ~

rr6nnilheilRn~iuoliiil~niilnFm ~ I R ~ ~ ~ ~ " L ~ U ~ ~ ? I ~ L L U ~ I U I U T P I ? I U ~ ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : : L L A \ ~ # I r s J ~Ilun~iuiingiuehniwo nilnntzua~rlfln0uw6ililiu Idldnk6~wti::\d~Bu?'rnq~

tdiiil u a i ~ ~ a i n a i n ~ i u r ~ ~ i i ~ ~ ~ a ~ ' ~ ~ a u " ~ ~ ~ ~ a i l f n ~ ~ d h a i l ~ a ~ ~ n " l ~ d ~ u d ~ i l n ~ ] ~ ~ ~ i u Y

f l i ~ ~ n i t ~ n ? i u c i ~ 1 l 6 t ~ n n ? i u q ~ i ~ ~ t u

3. rinngwu1usi6~qu~~flngwu~u~i?iafi~1u~~u~3~~ 60 ng~u~u'Ia'li~ilusf.ru t: Y l i n n g w m u i i o w u ~ u ~ u u ~ v n g ~ u i u u ~ ~ ~ ~ u % f f u v 'Iun~fdnfifoddf:~n~u"w~n~uwdd

d u n i ~ Rule of Law 60 ~ ~ : L ~ R ~ ~ R ~ Q ~ & ~ U ~ Q H U I U O\Kdnn~a~ii2u~nna u~:'Iungwu~u

~ng~nm~o~\u~doonng~857u\&aiud~rn~'I~ wCn~nm~vo~n~rnlud~:Jo~~im~~'qfia~

luniunngwulu~u~ot i ~ n ~ s a f i l u n g v u ~ u l ~ w o a n I o ~ n ' u n a i u q i ~ ~ ~ ~ u 41uGlY'qqT ~8lulon.nngw)Hrnu u(iduou~vni~n'.o$u Rule of Law Q:QInng~u1ua1~61~1o'I~) \ i \~

1 P a u 1 4 n a n i ~ ~ ~ n u . n u ~ ~ w 1 u 1 ~ 0 ~ w u ~ i ~ ~ n ~ ~ 7 u 1 o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a 1 ~ m 1 i 1 ~ n ~ ~ u 1 u d 3 ' ~ u 1 ~ ~ w u ~ d rfims:d 1 imCnrn3 nfm 2 r n ~ ~ L I ~ ~ ~ z d ~ ~ j i n ~ ~ x n ~ r n ~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ u ~ ~ u ~ : ~ u ~ ~ ~ I ~

dduinhu~ 21f:d 3 ~flc1~iu~~u~ou ~ ~ D I . I I U ~ I ~ ~ ~ Q I ~ ~ I ~ D J ~ ~ I ~ L L ~ ~ ~ I ~ ~ T L L K ~ ~ ' ~ I ~ ~

1 6 ~ n i d ~ i n ~ ~ f i ~ ~ m ~ 3 ~ I T L L ~ U L ~ ~ U ~ ~ U A ~ I H ~ U C ~ I ~ U ~ M I ~ U O ~ Q I ~ ~ ~ ' L ~ ~ ~ I ~ ' I ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ 6~unngwu1u'Ifiiian~1u~~us~f~1~#~~~dunuin'Iun1~~~~~vng~u~uiau d q o l w ~ n h d 6

i1n~u1uR'2u~M~\&~~11f~wuo\d'~intthu~1?~7f bunl:nm dhd 7 ~ w w k l f i d n g ~ w dna.:i~uuai n m : ~ u u n ~ f i ~ ~ ~ m ~ ? u ~ ~ n n ~ f ~ w r " ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ d d \ d ' I ~ n m : n f ~ u n ~ f n ~ w ~ n ~

a.r2oufinumtiua nn~unltnf~um7nrlw~rnddn~um'Iorifi~iBuu~~3'~f~u~mf 29

n%niurid.r taiauiiaiui.r n r i i ~ ~ u 3 n i d ~ ~ K O J ' I ~ ~ U ~ ' L Y ~ ' ~ Q ~ ~uciJnud.r:a~tdlmula' *rl w n~~uiudnn.rodn~.rd~u~'Iuo~ir'n.r~itdnn'~o~~~oodfin~ ~~nnu~ioufluG~nunamo~

~u.kunpanu iicin n P a n u ~ ~ ~ ~ w j , njnm?nd.r:a?s~n3.r0=:d~~%muau'i~l.ri~0:

qnXo~ onG~~M~ft~nud.r:aitd~~uiiu"nng~uiu~Ci~diunuindnm.r o~~lluiiu7u d 4-

uin l u a ~ i ~ o ~ u i n ~ d ~ :s iu iSubi~~ iunu~~uun~d&~un~~uiu ~ r o u ? s l ~ w n i JAU