Tt09 15 Verticalrelations1hs Copy

7/26/2019 Tt09 15 Verticalrelations1hs Copy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tt09-15-verticalrelations1hs-copy 1/33

!"#$#%&"' #( )$*+',-.

/#01-* 2%&,34$&56-'&,. #( 78(#-*

96",+-6 :;< =6-,&"1> ?6>1,&#$'



)$,-#*+",&#$

=6-,&"1>>. -6>1,6* &$*+',-&6' 1-6 6$*6%&"< %1$. @&( $#, %#',A B-%' *# $#, '6>>

*&-6",>. ,# "#$'+%6-' C+, -1,36- ,# #,36- B-%'D

!81%E>6< F##* E+>E E-#*+"6- ! E1E6- E-#*+"6- ! ',1,&#$1-. 03#>6'1>6- !

',1,&#$1-. -6,1&>6- ! "#$'+%6-'D

G36 *&H6-6$, E-#*+",&#$ E-#"6''6' &$ ,36 56-,&"1> "31&$ %1. ,1I6 E>1"6 &$ *&(J

(6-6$, B-%' @56-,&"1> '6E1-1,&#$A #- 0&,3&$ ,36 '1%6 B-% @56-,&"1> &$,6K-1,&#$AD

4$*6- 56-,&"1> '6E1-1,&#$L #$6 B-% %1. &%E#'6 M56-,&"1> -6',-1&$,'N @$#$>&$61-E-&"&$KL -6,1&> E-&"6 %1&$,6$1$"6L 68">+'&56 *61>&$KL 6,"DA #$ 1$#,36- B-% &$ ,36

56-,&"1> "31&$D



O+6',&#$'<

:D P# B-%' 3156 1$ &$"6$,&56 ,# 56-,&"1>>. &$,6K-1,6Q F31, 1-6 ,36 E#,6$,&1>

1$,&J"#%E6,&,&56 6H6",' #( 56-,&"1> %6-K6-Q

RD P# B-%' 3156 1$ &$"6$,&56 ,# &%E#'6 M56-,&"1> -6',-1&$,'NQ F31, 1-6 ,36

E#,6$,&1> 1$,&J"#%E6,&,&56 6H6",' #( '+"3 C+'&$6'' E-1",&"6'Q



G36 S1'&" =6-,&"1> !8,6-$1>&,.

" T#$'&*6- 1 56-,&"1>>. -6>1,6* &$*+',-. 0&,3 1$ +E',-61% %#$#E#>&',L ! L 1$*

1 *#0$',-61% %#$#E#>&',L "D

" G36 +E',-61% B-% E-#*+"6' ,36 &$,6-%6*&1,6 &$E+, 1 "#$',1$, %1-K&$1>

"#', #! D

" G36 *#0$',-61% B-% ,-1$'(#-% +$&, #( ,36 &$,6-%6*&1,6 &$E+, &$,# #$6

+$&, #( ,36 B$1> K##* 1, "#$',1$, %1-K&$1> "#', #"D

" G36 *#0$',-61% B-% '6>>' ,36 B$1> K##* ,# "#$'+%6-' 1, E-&"6 $D



Consumers

U

D

marginal cost cU

marginal cost c D

p

Q p

Vertically

integratedstructure



" U1-I6, *6%1$* (#- ,36 B$1> K##* &' %! $"D

!"#$%&'( )*$"+#'$%,*

" 2+EE#'6 ! 1$* " 1-6 56-,&"1>>. &$,6K-1,6*D

" /6$"6L ,36 %1-K&$1> "#', #( E-#*+"&$K ,36 B$1> K##* &' #! # #"D

" G36 56-,&"1>>. &$,6K-1,6* B-% '6,' ,36 %#$#E#>. E-&"6 $& !#! ##""L 036-6

$& !#" # $%& '$( $ ) $ $ #*%! $"

&' ,36 %#$#E#>. E-&"6 #( 1 B-% 0&,3 %1-K&$1> "#', #D G36 56-,&"1>>. &$,6J

K-1,6* B-%V' -6'+>,&$K E-#B, &'

'& !#! # #"" +

! $& !#! # #"" $ !#! # #""

"%

# $& !#! # #""

$(



Consumers

U

D

marginal cost cU

marginal cost c D

p

Q p

Vertically

separatedstructure

w



!"#$%&'( -".'#'$%,*/ 0%*"'# 1#%&%*+

" 2+EE#'6 $#0 ,31, ! 1$* " 1-6 56-,&"1>>. '6E1-1,6*D

" T#$'&*6- ,36 (#>>#0&$K '6W+6$"6 #( %#56'<

:D G36 +E',-61% B-% ! '6,' ,36 M03#>6'1>6N E-&"6 ) (#- ,36 &$E+,D

RD G36 *#0$',-61% B-% " '6,' ,36 M-6,1&>N E-&"6 $ (#- ,36 B$1> K##*D

" 2#>56 (#- ,36 '+CK1%6JE6-(6", 6W+&>&C-&+% C. C1"I01-* &$*+",&#$D



" G36 *#0$',-61% B-%V' E-#C>6% &'<

'$( $

) $ $ ) $ #"*%! $"*

1$* '# ,36 E-#B,J%18&%&X&$K -6,1&> E-&"6 &' $& !) # #""D

" G36 +E',-61% B-%V' E-#C>6% &'<

'$()

)) $ #! *%# $& !) # #""

$(

" G36 6W+&>&C-&+% 03#>6'1>6 E-&"6

%) '1,&'B6'

%) + #! D

" 2&$"6 %) + #! L 1$* '&$"6 ,36 %#$#E#>. @-6,1&>A E-&"6 &' &$"-61'&$K &$ ,36

%1-K&$1> "#', ,31, ,36 @-6,1&>A %#$#E#>&', (1"6'L ,36 6W+&>&C-&+% @-6,1&>A

E-&"6 (#- ,36 B$1> K##*L

% $L '1,&'B6'

% $ + $& !#! # #""D



" ?6%1-I'<

2 =6-,&"1> '6E1-1,&#$ &$*+"6' 1 3&K36- E-&"6 #( ,36 B$1> K##* @1$* ,36-6J

(#-6 1 >#06- #+,E+,AD

2 F36$ B-%' 1-6 56-,&"1>>. '6E1-1,6*L ,36-6 &' *#+C>6 %1-K&$1>&X1,&#$

@-."*+("#L !"#$%&' "( )"'*+*,&' -,"%"./ L :Y;ZA< +$*6- &%E6-(6", "#%JE6,&,&#$L 61"3 B-% 1**' &,' #0$ E-#B, %1-K&$ 1, 61"3 ',1K6 #( E-#*+"J

,&#$D @MF31, &' 0#-'6 ,31$ 1 %#$#E#>.Q [ "31&$ #( %#$#E#>&6'DNA

2 4$*6- 56-,&"1> '6E1-1,&#$L ,36-6 &' 1$ &$36-6$, 56-,&"1> 68,6-$1>&,.< 61"3

B-% *#6' $#, ,1I6 &$,# 1""#+$, ,31, 1$ &$"-61'6 &$ &,' @03#>6'1>6 #--6,1&>A E-&"6 -6*+"6' ,36 E-#B, #( ,36 #,36- B-%D G3&' 68,6-$1>&,. &'

&$,6-$1>&X6* +$*6- 56-,&"1> &$,6K-1,&#$D



3%4&544%,*

" G3&' -6'+>, '66%' ,# '+KK6', ,31, 56-,&"1> &$,6K-1,&#$ &' C#,3 E-#B,1C>6

1$* 06>(1-6J6$31$"&$K< +$*6- 56-,&"1> &$,6K-1,&#$L 1KK-6K1,6 E-#B,' 1$*

"#$'+%6- '+-E>+' 1-6 3&K36- ,31$ +$*6- 56-,&"1> '6E1-1,&#$D

" S+, ,3&' -6'+>, -6>&6' 3615&>. #$ ,36 1''+%E,&#$ #( >&$61- 03#>6'1>6 E-&"6'<

&, 0#+>* *&'1EE61- &( ,36 +E',-61% B-% "#+>* +'6 1 ,0#JE1-, ,1-&HD )$

,31, "1'6L ! 0#+>* "31-K6 !)* , " + !#! * '& !#! # #"""D G36 03#>6'1>6

E-&"6 ) + #! 0#+>* &$*+"6 " ,# '6, ,36 %#$#E#>. E-&"6 +$*6- 56-,&"1>

&$,6K-1,&#$ $& !#! # #""L 1$* ,36 B86* @#- (-1$"3&'6A (66 , + '& !#! #

#"" 0#+>* 1>>#0 ! ,# 68,-1", ,36 6$,&-6 -6$, #( ,36 56-,&"1>>. &$,6K-1,6*

',-+",+-6D !''6$,&1>>.L C. #H6-&$K ,36 #E,&%1> ,0#JE1-, ,1-&HL ! '6>>' ,36

56-,&"1> ',-+",+-6 ,# " 03# ,36-6C. C6"#%6' ,36 M-6'&*+1> ">1&%1$,ND



" [ ,0#JE1-, ,1-&H &' $#, ,36 #$>. 56-,&"1> -6',-1&$, ,31, 0#+>* '#>56 ,36

56-,&"1> 68,6-$1>&,.D [>,6-$1,&56>.L ,36 +E',-61% B-% "#+>* &%E#'6 $0+&*'1

2$*,0 .&*%+0%&%,0 34)56 0&,3 $ + $& !#! # #"" 1$* "31-K6 1 >&$61-

03#>6'1>6 E-&"6 ) + $& !#! ##""$#"D G36 *#0$',-61% B-% 0#+>* %1I6

X6-# E-#B, 1$* ,36 56-,&"1> ',-+",+-6V' \#&$, E-#B, 0#+>* C6 '& !#! # #""L

1' +$*6- 56-,&"1> &$,6K-1,&#$D

" ?]U &' +'+1>>. &>>6K1> C+, *#0$',-61% "#%E6,&,&#$ &' 1$ 1>,6-$1,&56 ^-6J

',-1&$,^ (#- ,36 +E',-61% B-%< &( ! '6,' ) + $& !#! # #"" $ #" ,36$

'6>>' ,# '656-1> S6-,-1$* "#%E6,&,#-'L ,3&' -6'+>,' &$ $ + $& !#! # #"" D



" 7%,0$+&*%+/ ?6. 1$* G&-#>6 @:Y_`A "#%E1-6 ,36 1>,6-$1,&56' (-1$"3&'6 (66'

1$* ?]U &$ ,36 ,0# "1'6' 036-6 ! &' +$"6-,1&$ 1C#+, @&A *6%1$* %!"

1$* @&&A *#0$',-61% "#', #"D " >61-$' 1C#+, ,36'6 &$ ,&%6 ,# '6, E-&"6'

C+, 1(,6- ,36 56-,&"1> "#$,-1", &' 1K-66*D

2 8$&%,9*:0 (00 < 2&$"6 ! &' +$"6-,1&$ #( '& !#! # #""L $#$>&$61- 03#>6J

'1>6 E-&"6' ,31, %1I6 " 1 -6'&*+1> ">1&%1$, &%E#'6 -&'I #$ "D )( " &'-&'I $6+,-1> &, 0&>> 1""6E, B86* (66 6W+1> ,# 68E6",6* %#$#E#>. E-#B,a

&D6D , + - !

'& !#! # #"""

)( " &' -&'I 156-'6 &, 0&>> #$>. 1""6E, 1

>#06- , L 03&"3 &' "#',>. ,# !(

2 G36 1*51$,1K6 #( 1 B86* (66 @-6>1,&56 ,# ?]UA &' ,31, E-&"6' 1-6 '6,C. ,36 &$(#-%6* E1-,. @"A C+, ,36 *&'1*51$,1K6 &' ,31, -6*+"&$K , &'

"#',>. ,# !(



2 G36 1*51$,1K6 #( ?]U +$*6- *6%1$* +$"6-,1&$,. &' ,31, -&'I "1$ C6

6>&%&$1,6* (#- ,36 -6,1&>6-D /#0656-L ,3&' 1*51$,1K6 *#6' $#, 1EE>. (#-

"#', +$"6-,1&$,.D

2 4)5 ; 8$&%,9*:0 (00 4$*6- *6%1$* +$"6-,1&$,. ?G@:Y_`A '3#0 ,31,

?]U &' C6 C6,,6- (#- ! 1$* (#- 06>(1-6 ,31$ 1 (-1$"3&'6 (66D /#0656-

+$*6- "#', +$"6-,1&$,. 1 (-1$"3&'6 (66 &' C6,,6- @(#- C#,3A ,31$ ./ & D



" G0# #,36- &$',1$"6' #( 56-,&"1> 68,6-$1>&,&6' @C#,3 03&"3 "#+>* C6 '#>56*

,3-#+K3 56-,&"1> &$,6K-1,&#$ #- $#$>&$61- 03#>6'1>6 E-&"6'A<

:D <"=%:+$0&. ."$&' 9&>&$?@ @" 31' ,# "3##'6 E-#%#,&#$1> '6-5&"6'L ,36

>656> #( 03&"3 "1$$#, C6 56-&B6* "#$,-1",+1>>.DA

RD A%2#+ :#B:+*+#+*"%@ @" -6W+&-6' 1$#,36- &$E+, ,31, &' "#%E6,&,&56>. '+EJE>&6* 1$* ,36 ,0# ,.E6' #( &$E+,' 1-6 &%E6-(6", '+C',&,+,6'b"#%E>6%6$,'DA

" P#0$',-61% E-6J'1>6 '6-5&"6 (-66J-&*&$K %1. 1>'# -6'+>, 036$ E-6J'1>6 1*J

5&"6 %1. C6 #C,1&$6* (-#% #$6 '6>>6- C+, ,36 K##* E+-"31'6* (-#% 1$#,36-D



!8">+'&#$1-. =6-,&"1> T#$,-1",'

6*$%$#54$ '*7 !"#$%&'( 6+#""8"*$4 %* $9" :;-;

" c#- %+"3 #( ,36 RZ,3 "6$,+-.L 4D2D "#+-,' 06-6 3#',&>6 ,#01-*' 56-,&"1>

%6-K6-' 1$* 56-,&"1> -6',-1&$,' '+"3 1' ?]U @20$ :0 &>>6K1>AL 68">+'&56

*61>&$K "#$,-1",' @$#'0 "( $0&:"%AL 1$* ,&6* '1>6'D

" c-#% ,36 :Y;Z'L ,36 MT3&"1K# 2"3##>N @P&-6",#-L ]#'$6-L S#-IL 6,"DA 1,J

,1"I6* >6K1> E-1",&"6<

:D [$,&"#%E6,&,&56 E-1",&"6' 1-6 $#, E-#B,1C>6 (#- B-%'D

RD =6-,&"1> 1K-66%6$,' 1-6 6d"&6$".J6$31$"&$KD



" T3&"1K# 2"3##> 31* E-#(#+$* &%E1", #$ 1$,&,-+', >10b6"#$#%&"'D )$ "#$J

,-1', ,# ,36&- #EE#$6$,'L ,36 E-#E#$6$,' #( ,36 T3&"1K# 2"3##> +'6* (#-%1>

%#*6>' @1>C6&, '&%E>6 %#*6>' #( %#$#E#>. 1$* E6-(6", "#%E6,&,&#$AD

<=&(54%>" ?,*$#'&$4

" [$ 68">+'&56 "#$,-1", ',&E+>1,6' ,31,L (#- 1 K&56$ '6, #( ,-1$'1",&#$'L #$6

E1-,. ,# ,36 "#$,-1", *61>' #$>. 0&,3 ,36 #,36- E1-,.D



" C+&%?&$? 8&:9*"% D".2&%/ ;:@ 5&E$&%01F"#:+"% D".2&%/@ @:YRRA

2 2,1$*1-* 01' 1 >61*&$K %1$+(1",+-6- #( *-6'' E1,,6-$'D

2 U1K-1$6J/#+',#$ 01' 1 >1-K6 -6,1&>6- &$ S#',#$D

2 !8">+'&56 *61>&$K "#$,-1", *6%1$*6* ,31, U1K-1$6J/#+',#$ *#6' $#,

'6>> ,36 E1,,6-$' #( 1$. #,36- %1$+(1",+-6-D

2 T#$,-1", 01' ',-+"I *#0$ C. "#+-,<

MG36 -6',-&",&#$ #( 61"3 %6-"31$, ,# #$6 E1,,6-$ %1$+(1",+-6- &$ 3+$*-6*'L E6-31E'

&$ ,3#+'1$*'L #( '%1>> "#%%+$&,&6' 1%#+$, ,# K&5&$K '+"3 '&$K>6 E1,,6-$ %1$+(1",+-6-

1 %#$#E#>. #( ,36 C+'&$6'' &$ '+"3 "#%%+$&,.D !56$ &$ >1-K6- "&,&6'L ,# >&%&, ,# 1'&$K>6 E1,,6-$ %1I6- ,36 E1,,6-$ C+'&$6'' #( *61>6-' %#', -6'#-,6* ,# C. "+',#%6-'

03#'6 E+-"31'6' ,6$* ,# K&56 (1'3&#$' ,36&- 5#K+6L %1. ,6$* ,# (1"&>&,1,6 (+-,36-

"#%C&$1,&#$'e '# ,31, E>1&$,&H fDDDg 0&>> '3#-,>. 3156 1>%#',L &( $#, W+&,6L 1>> #( ,36

E1,,6-$ C+'&$6''DN



2 T3&"1K# 2"3##> @S#-IL :Yh_A<

M2,1$*1-* "1$ 68,-1", &$ ,36 E-&"6' ,31, &, "31-K6' 1>> ,31, &,' >&$6 &' 0#-,3D ), "1$$#,

"31-K6 ,36 -6,1&>6- ,31, (+>> 1%#+$, &$ %#$6. 1$* ,36$ "31-K6 &, 1K1&$ &$ 68">+'&5&,.

,31, ,36 -6,1&>6- *#6' $#, 0&'3 ,# K-1$,D G# '+EE#'6 ,31, &, "1$ &' ,# "#%%&, ,36

6--#- #( *#+C>6 "#+$,&$KD fDDDg !8">+'&5&,. 31' $6"6''1-&>. C66$ E+-"31'6* (-#% &,L

03&"3 %61$' ,31, ,36 ',#-6 31' C1>1$"6* ,36 &$*+"6%6$, #H6-6* C. 2,1$*1-* fDDDg1K1&$', ,36 *&'1*51$,1K6 #( 31$*>&$K #$>. 2,1$*1-*V' E1,,6-$'D fDDDg G36 ',#-6V' *6"&J

'&#$L %1*6 6$,&-6>. &$ &,' #0$ &$,6-6',L $6"6''1-&>. -6i6",' ,36 C1>1$"6 #( "#%E6,&$K

"#$'&*6-1,&#$' ,31, *6,6-%&$6 "#$'+%6- 06>(1-6D fDDDg )( 2,1$*1-* B$*' &, 0#-,303&>6

,# E+-"31'6 68">+'&5&,. fDDDgL ,36 -61'#$ &' $#, ,36 C1--&$K #( 6$,-.L C+, '#%6 %#-6

'6$'&C>6 K#1>L '+"3 1' #C,1&$&$K ,36 'E6"&1> '6>>&$K 6H#-, #( ,36 #+,>6,DN



6 @,7"( ,A $9" ?9%&'+, !%"B ,* <=&(54%>" ?,*$#'&$4

" 2+EE#'6 ,36-6 1-6 ,3-66 1K6$,'<

:D 1 *#0$',-61% C+.6- @"Ae

RD 1$ &$"+%C6$, +E',-61% '6>>6- @! Ae

jD 1 E#,6$,&1> +E',-61% 6$,-1$, @- AD

" )$&,&1>>.L - &' $#, &$ ,36 %1-I6,L 1$* '# " "1$ "#$,-1", #$>. 0&,3 ! D

" G36 *#0$',-61% C+.6-V' *6%1$* &' %! $"D



" ! 31' "#$',1$, %1-K&$1> "#', #! D - 31' "#$',1$, %1-K&$1> "#', #- 0 #!

C+, 31' ,# E1. B86* "#', , + , ,# 6$,6- ,36 %1-I6,D

" 26W+6$"6 #( %#56'<

:D ! "1$ #H6- " 1$ 68">+'&56 "#$,-1", 1>#$K 0&,3 1 E1.%6$, 1 &$ -6,+-$(#- " '&K$&$K "#$,-1",D

RD " *6"&*6' 036,36- ,# 1""6E, "#$,-1",D

jD - *6"&*6' 036,36- ,# 6$,6- ,36 %1-I6, @1$* &$"+- , AD

kD G36 1",&56 +E',-61% '6>>6-' @6&,36- #$>. ! #- 6>'6 C#,3 ! 1$* - A '6,

E-&"6'L 1$* " *6"&*6' 3#0 %+"3 ,# E+-"31'6 @1$* (-#% 03#%AD



" [''+%6 ,31, &( - 06-6 ,# 6$,6- 1$* '6>> ,# "L &, 0#+>* "31-K6 ,36 E-&"6

$ + #! 1' #! % $& !#- "D

" [''+%6 1>'# ,31, - 0#+>* 6$,6- &$ ,36 1C'6$"6 #( 1$ 68">+'&56 "#$,-1",<

!#! $ #- "%!#! " + , D



The Chicago School argument

q

p

Q p M cU

p M cU

cU c E



]-#E#'&,&#$ A% 0G#*'*B$*#.H %" 0I,'#:*;0 ,"%+$&,+ =*'' B0 :*E%0?H &%? :" 0%+$/

=*'' ",,#$@

]-##( )( " '&K$' ,36 68">+'&56 "#$,-1",L 1$* '# - *#6' $#, 6$,6-L ! 0&>>

'+C'6W+6$,>. "31-K6 ,36 %#$#E#>. E-&"6 $& !#! "D )( " *#6' $#, '&K$ ,36

68">+'&56 "#$,-1",L ,36$ - 0&>> 6$,6- 1$* "31-K6 ,36 E-&"6 #! D /6$"6L " 0&>>

'&K$ ,36 68">+'&56 "#$,-1", 0&,3 ! #$>. &(

1 && $& !#! "

#!

%!2"32(

S+,

& $&

!#! "

#!

%!2"32 + '& !#! "*

1$* '# ! 0&>> $#, B$* &, E-#B,1C>6 ,# #H6- 1 '+d"&6$,>. 3&K3 E1.%6$, ,31, 0&>>

&$*+"6 " ,# '&K$ ,36 68">+'&56 "#$,-1",D



l#,6< G36 T3&"1K# 1-K+%6$, *#6' $#, -6>. #$ ,36 1''+%E,&#$ ,31, ! "1$ %1I6

1 ,1I6J&,J>6156J&, #H6- ,# "D G36 -6'+>, &' -#C+', ,# 1$. M6d"&6$,N C1-K1&$&$K

C6,066$ ! 1$* "D



]1-,&1> !8">+'&#$ G3-#+K3 2,&E+>1,6* P1%1K6'

6+9%,* '*7 C,($,* @[%6-&"1$ !"#$#%&" ?65&60L :YYhA

" T#$'&*6- ,36 %#*6> 1C#56 C+, 1''+%6 ,31, " 31' +$&, *6%1$* 0&,3 51>J

+1,&#$ 4L &D6DL

%! $" +'

, &( $ + 4- &( $ % 4

" G36 "#$,-1", C6,066$ ! 1$* " &' $#0 #( ,36 (#-% ! $* 3"L 036-6 $ &'

,36 E-&"6 ,31, " 31' ,# E1. ,# ! (#- #$6 +$&, #( ,36 K##* 1$* 3 &' ,36',&E+>1,6* *1%1K6 ,31, " 31' ,# E1. ,# ! &( " C+.' &$',61* (-#% - D

" ! 31' 1 B-', %#56- 1*51$,1K6a'6,' 3 C6(#-6 6$,-1$, "1$ 6$,6-D



" 26W+6$"6 #( %#56'<

:D ! #H6-' " 1 "#$,-1", #( ,36 (#-% ! $* 3"D

RD " *6"&*6' 036,36- ,# 1""6E, "#$,-1",D

jD - *6"&*6' 036,36- ,# 6$,6- ,36 %1-I6, @1$* &$"+- , AD

kD )( - 6$,6-'L &, #H6-' E-&"6 $- 1$* " *6"&*6' (-#% 03#% ,# C+.D )( -

*#6' $#, 6$,6-L " C+.' (-#% ! @E-#5&*6* $ % 4AD



S6K&$ 0&,3 ,36 "1'6 036-6 ,36-6 &' "6-,1&$,. 1C#+, #-

]-#E#'&,&#$ A% 0G#*'*B$*#.H ! =*'' "J0$ & ,"%+$&,+ ! $* 3" + !4* 4$ !#- # , ""@

" =*'' :*E% +9*: ,"%+$&,+@ - =*'' 0%+0$ &%? "J0$ +90 2$*,0 $- + #- # , @ "

=*'' 2#$,9&:0 ($". - &%? 2&/ +90 :+*2#'&+0? ?&.&E0 +" ! @

]-##(

" 2+EE#'6 - 31' *6"&*6* ,# 6$,6- ,36 %1-I6, 1$* 31' #H6-6* ,36 K##* 1,

E-&"6 $- D G36$ " 0&>> E+-"31'6 (-#% - &( ! V' M6H6",&56 E-&"6N $ $ 3 &'

$#, '%1>>6- ,31$ $- D

" !H6",&56 E-&"6 &' ,36 &$"-6%6$,1> "#', #( C+.&$K 56-'+' $#, C+.&$K (-#% !

1>>#0&$K (#- 3



" )( ! $* 3" + !4* 4 $ #- $ , "L - "1$ %1I6 \+', X6-# E-#B, C. 6$,6-&$KL

&$"+--&$K ,36 B86* "#', , L 1$* '6>>&$K ,36 K##* ,# " 1, E-&"6 $- + #- #, D)$*66*L 1, $- + #- # , L " &' \+', 0&>>&$K ,# E+-"31'6 (-#% - D

" G36 &$*+"6* #+,"#%6 &' 6d"&6$, @&, %18&%&X6' \#&$, '+-E>+'A 1$* 1>> #( ,36

'+-E>+' &' 68,-1",6* C. ,36 B-',J%#5&$K ! L '# ! "1$$#, *# 1$. C6,,6-D

l#,6< )$ 6H6",L ,36 "#$,-1", *#6' $#, 68">+*6 - C+, 1>>#0' ,36 &$"+%C6$, !

,# 68,-1", 1>> #( ,36 '+-E>+' (-#% ,36 %#-6 6d"&6$, 6$,-1$, - D

" 2+EE#'6 $#0 ,31, ,36-6 &' #%,0$+&*%+/ 1C#+, - V' %1-K&$1> "#', #- D

" c#- 681%E>6L '+EE#'6 ,31, 4 + -L #! + -5.L #- &' +$&(#-%>. *&',-&C+,6*

#$ ),* -*L 1$* , + ,D



" )$ ,3&' "1'6L ,36 6d"&6$, '#>+,&#$ 0#+>* C6 ,31, - 6$,6-' &( 1$* #$>. &(

#- 0 -5.D

" )( ,36 6$,-1$, 6$,6-' &, %+', E-&"6 1, ! $ $ 3"* '# ! 1$* " K6, 1 \#&$,

'+-E>+' 4 $ ! $ $ 3"

" G36 68E6",6* \#&$, '+-E>+' #( ! 1$* " &' %18&%&X6* &( ,36 6H6",&56 E-&"6

/ # $ $ 3 '#>56'

'$(/

0%!#- 0 /"!4 $ /" # 0%!#- & /"!4 $ -5."( @:A

" 0%!#- 0 /" &' ,36 E-#C1C&>&,. ,36 6$,-1$, "1$ E-&"6 C6>#0 / 1$* 36$"6

6$,6-'



" 2&$"6 #- &' +$&(#-%>. *&',-&C+,6* #$ ),* -*L 0%!#- 0 / " + / 1$*

0%!#- & /" + - $ /D

" G3+' @:A &%E>&6' ,36 #E,&%+% &' /' + -51D

" /6$"6L 6$,-. 0&>> #""+- &( 1$* #$>. &( #- 0 -51D G36-6 &' E1-,&1> 68">+'&#$<

,36 6$,-1$, '#%6,&%6' "#%6' &$D c-#% 1 '#"&1> E#&$, #( 5&60L ,3&' &'

&$6d"&6$, C6"1+'6 6$,-1$, ',1.' #+, 036$ -51 0 #- 0 -5.D

" )$ 1 '6$'6L E1-,&1> 68">+'&#$ &' 1 '&*6 6H6", #( ,36 @#E,&%1>A "#$,-1", C6J,066$ ! 1$* "D G36 #C\6",&56 #( ,36 "#$,-1", &' $#, ,# 68">+*6 C+, ,#

68,-1", -6$,' (-#% - &$ #-*6- ,# %18&%&X6 %18&%&X6 ,36 \#&$, E-#B, #( !

1$* " 1, ,36 68E6$'6 #( - D





G36 !$*

Documents

Tt09 15 Verticalrelations1hs Copy