1
1272 clearly than phlebography. Finally, these workers have clearly shown that surgery has much to offer in cases of superior vena caval occlusion where the underlying cause is non-progressive and the symptoms are disabling. 7. Katz, S., Hussey, H. H., Veal, J. R. Amer. J. med. Sci. 1947, 214, 7. 8. Kramer, P. New Engl. J. Med. 1954, 251, 600. 9. Golden, R. Radiological Examination of the Small Intestine. Philadelphia, 1945. 10. Glazebrook, A. J. Lancet, 1952, i, 895. 11. Macphee, I. W. Ibid, 1953, i, 678. 12. Falle, E. De C., Gill, A. M., Post, H. W. A. Postgrad, med. J. 1954. 30, 532. 13. Gill, A. M., Falle, E. de C. Lancet, 1952, ii, 356. TREATMENT OF PYLORIC STENOSIS THE results of medical treatment in chronic peptic ulceration give us no cause for self-congratulation. Relapse-rates are very high ; and such treatment iE doomed to failure in cases of pyloric stenosis, hour-glass deformity of the stomach, giant ulcers, and deeply penetrating ulcers. With regard to pyloric stenosis, it has been said that three factors are operating-namely, spasm, oedema, and fibrosis-and that, of these, spasm and oedema can be relieved medically. This may be so ; but unfortunately benefits are short-lived, and many believe that relapse is inevitable. Now Kramer 8 has found radiographically that the administration of belladonna alkaloids may worsen rather than relieve benign pyloric stenosis ; for this drug further slowed the passage of barium from the stomach. Probably this is due to the coincident decrease in gastric motility, which may also account partly for the relief of symptoms. Thus it seems that in patients with peptic ulcer and pyloric stenosis medical treatment may be positively harmful. It is therefore important to decide certainly whether pyloric stenosis is present. There is no better test than the time-honoured one of giving the patient charcoal biscuits last thing at night, and in the morning aspirating the resting gastric juice. If this contains charcoal, it is probably best to call in a surgeon. THE DISORDERED SMALL BOWEL IT is an appalling commentary on our capacity as healers that the consultant investigating the case of a patient with abdominal symptoms is usually relieved and delighted to find a sufficient organic cause. Treatment then follows diagnosis in orderly sequence, and the encounter leaves him with a satisfying sense of complete- ness. Nothing disturbs him more than failure to find a clear reason for abdominal discomfort : a haunting suspicion that organic disease is being overlooked urges him on to a succession of time-consuming and expensive investigations ; and all too often these leave him with a feeling of hopelessness and uncertainty which readily transmits itself to his unhappy patient. It is, of course, well known that the effect of mind over matter is nowhere more evident that in the gastro- intestinal tract. The reactions of the distal bowel to dramatic happenings must have been experienced by almost everyone. But the disordered workings of the small gut are less clearly and less widely understood. In recent years studies have been made of the abnormal barium patterns in the small gut, but usually only in the presence of arresting symptoms due to steatorrhoea or some other nutritional deficiency 9 after gastrectomy.1o 11 Dr. Falle and her colleagues,12 in continuance of work reported two years ago,13 have now described significant radiographic findings in a group of patients who were believed to have what they call " chronic disturbances of small and large bowel function." Some abnormality was evident in almost half the patients who were examined radiographically, although the deviation from normal was very slight in half of these. The com- monest disorder was clumping of the barium, which was best seen in a film taken at Pf2 hours ; changes in tone of the ileum or jejunum, and signs of accelerated passage of the meal, were also evident. That such radiographic findings were probably significant was suggested by complete failure to demonstrate them in patients who had no symptoms. Falle et al. suggest that all of these radiographic changes can reasonably be attributed to psychological tension, the existence of which was established without difficulty in most of their cases. It is highly likely that, when the function of the large intestine is disturbed, upper abdominal symptoms are due to a similar disorder in the jejunum and ileum. But even if we learn confidently to interpret the radiographic changes, the diagnosis of intestinal dysfunction must remain a clinical one, to be made only after careful exclusion of other causes. Patient and careful investiga- tion of the history is essential not only to diagnosis but also to the first stage in therapy, in which reassurance is more valuable than medication.l4 We are all so conscious of the frequency of functional" abdominal symptoms that we should not, be surprised that Dr. Falle and her colleagues put a third of all the new cases at their gastric unit in this category. But we should take note that by diligent and patient manage- ment they achieved complete remission of symptoms in well over half of their patients, and considerable improvement in another quarter. 14. Haves, D. W. Amer. Practit. 1954, 5, 787. 15. See Lancet, 1951, i, 333 ; Ibid, 1952, i, 913. 16. Control of Rats and Mice. Vols. and 2 : 1 Rats. Edited by DEXNIS CHITTY. Vol. 3: House Mice. Edited by H. N. SOUTHERN. London : Oxford University Press. Pp. 532 (1 and 2) and 225. £5 5s. a set. CONTROL OF RATS AND MICE STANDARD methods of rat and mouse destruction, devised during the 1939-45 war,15 were largely based on work at the Oxford Bureau of Animal Population, a full account of which has now appeared.16 The species studied were the common " brown" rat of Europe, Rattus norvegicus Berkenhout ; the even less appropriately named " black " rat, R. rattus L. ; and the house mouse, Mus musculus L. The magnitude and difficulty of the research on these species can now be appreciated. The conditions in which these rodents live are exceedingly diverse ; their habits make them most elusive- (no doubt this is a result of natural selection in man-made environments) ; and control methods must be both simple and economical. The Oxford work was based on extensive observation of behaviour and population changes in natural conditions. The common rat was found to develop, in a stable environment, regular movements on well-defined path- ways. The appearance of an unfamiliar object, such as a trap or a pile of bait, leads to avoidance of the place where this has been put. But familiarity breeds contempt: the regular placing of harmless bait over several days leads to acceptance of the bait even when poison is eventually added. This familiar "prebaiting " obviates the remarkable tendency of this species to refuse foods which have previously caused illness-for example, poison bait of which only a small sample has been taken. The other species of this genus, R. rattus, has been less closely studied, but it behaves in a generally similar way. The house mouse does not develop specific poison shyness; but its behaviour is so variable from day to day that it is at least as difficult to poison. The important work on feeding behaviour was paralleled by studies of the effects of poisons. Toxicological studies showed that the old standby poisons-barium carbonate and red squill-have rather low toxicities. Red squill may be quite ineffective, unless the consignment is carefully selected. Today, the main strong poisons of choice are zinc phosphide, arsenic, and antu (alphanaph- thylthiourea)-all after prebaiting-but antu is unsuitable for use against R. rattus. The Oxford workers are properly sceptical of the value of ’ 1080’ (sodium monofluoroacetate) despite the enthusiasm with which it was first received, especially in the U.S.A. : it is exceed-

TREATMENT OF PYLORIC STENOSIS

  • Upload
    donhan

  • View
    221

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: TREATMENT OF PYLORIC STENOSIS

1272

clearly than phlebography. Finally, these workers haveclearly shown that surgery has much to offer in casesof superior vena caval occlusion where the underlyingcause is non-progressive and the symptoms are disabling.

7. Katz, S., Hussey, H. H., Veal, J. R. Amer. J. med. Sci. 1947,214, 7.

8. Kramer, P. New Engl. J. Med. 1954, 251, 600.9. Golden, R. Radiological Examination of the Small Intestine.

Philadelphia, 1945.10. Glazebrook, A. J. Lancet, 1952, i, 895.11. Macphee, I. W. Ibid, 1953, i, 678.12. Falle, E. De C., Gill, A. M., Post, H. W. A. Postgrad, med. J.

1954. 30, 532.13. Gill, A. M., Falle, E. de C. Lancet, 1952, ii, 356.

TREATMENT OF PYLORIC STENOSIS

THE results of medical treatment in chronic pepticulceration give us no cause for self-congratulation.Relapse-rates are very high ; and such treatment iEdoomed to failure in cases of pyloric stenosis, hour-glassdeformity of the stomach, giant ulcers, and deeplypenetrating ulcers.With regard to pyloric stenosis, it has been said that

three factors are operating-namely, spasm, oedema, andfibrosis-and that, of these, spasm and oedema can berelieved medically. This may be so ; but unfortunatelybenefits are short-lived, and many believe that relapseis inevitable. Now Kramer 8 has found radiographicallythat the administration of belladonna alkaloids mayworsen rather than relieve benign pyloric stenosis ; forthis drug further slowed the passage of barium from thestomach. Probably this is due to the coincident decreasein gastric motility, which may also account partly forthe relief of symptoms.Thus it seems that in patients with peptic ulcer and

pyloric stenosis medical treatment may be positivelyharmful. It is therefore important to decide certainlywhether pyloric stenosis is present. There is no bettertest than the time-honoured one of giving the patientcharcoal biscuits last thing at night, and in the morningaspirating the resting gastric juice. If this containscharcoal, it is probably best to call in a surgeon.

THE DISORDERED SMALL BOWEL

IT is an appalling commentary on our capacity as

healers that the consultant investigating the case of apatient with abdominal symptoms is usually relieved anddelighted to find a sufficient organic cause. Treatmentthen follows diagnosis in orderly sequence, and theencounter leaves him with a satisfying sense of complete-ness. Nothing disturbs him more than failure to find aclear reason for abdominal discomfort : a hauntingsuspicion that organic disease is being overlooked urgeshim on to a succession of time-consuming and expensiveinvestigations ; and all too often these leave him with afeeling of hopelessness and uncertainty which readilytransmits itself to his unhappy patient.

It is, of course, well known that the effect of mind overmatter is nowhere more evident that in the gastro-intestinal tract. The reactions of the distal bowel todramatic happenings must have been experienced byalmost everyone. But the disordered workings of thesmall gut are less clearly and less widely understood.In recent years studies have been made of the abnormalbarium patterns in the small gut, but usually only in thepresence of arresting symptoms due to steatorrhoea or

some other nutritional deficiency 9 after gastrectomy.1o 11Dr. Falle and her colleagues,12 in continuance of

work reported two years ago,13 have now described

significant radiographic findings in a group of patientswho were believed to have what they call " chronicdisturbances of small and large bowel function." Someabnormality was evident in almost half the patients whowere examined radiographically, although the deviationfrom normal was very slight in half of these. The com-monest disorder was clumping of the barium, which wasbest seen in a film taken at Pf2 hours ; changes in toneof the ileum or jejunum, and signs of accelerated passage

of the meal, were also evident. That such radiographicfindings were probably significant was suggested bycomplete failure to demonstrate them in patients whohad no symptoms. Falle et al. suggest that all of theseradiographic changes can reasonably be attributed topsychological tension, the existence of which was

established without difficulty in most of their cases.It is highly likely that, when the function of the large

intestine is disturbed, upper abdominal symptoms aredue to a similar disorder in the jejunum and ileum. Buteven if we learn confidently to interpret the radiographicchanges, the diagnosis of intestinal dysfunction mustremain a clinical one, to be made only after carefulexclusion of other causes. Patient and careful investiga-tion of the history is essential not only to diagnosis butalso to the first stage in therapy, in which reassuranceis more valuable than medication.l4We are all so conscious of the frequency of functional"

abdominal symptoms that we should not, be surprisedthat Dr. Falle and her colleagues put a third of all thenew cases at their gastric unit in this category. But weshould take note that by diligent and patient manage-ment they achieved complete remission of symptomsin well over half of their patients, and considerableimprovement in another quarter.

14. Haves, D. W. Amer. Practit. 1954, 5, 787.15. See Lancet, 1951, i, 333 ; Ibid, 1952, i, 913.16. Control of Rats and Mice. Vols. and 2 : 1 Rats. Edited by

DEXNIS CHITTY. Vol. 3: House Mice. Edited by H. N.SOUTHERN. London : Oxford University Press. Pp. 532(1 and 2) and 225. £5 5s. a set.

CONTROL OF RATS AND MICESTANDARD methods of rat and mouse destruction,

devised during the 1939-45 war,15 were largely based onwork at the Oxford Bureau of Animal Population, a fullaccount of which has now appeared.16 The species studiedwere the common " brown" rat of Europe, Rattus

norvegicus Berkenhout ; the even less appropriatelynamed " black " rat, R. rattus L. ; and the house mouse,Mus musculus L. The magnitude and difficulty of theresearch on these species can now be appreciated. Theconditions in which these rodents live are exceedinglydiverse ; their habits make them most elusive- (no doubtthis is a result of natural selection in man-madeenvironments) ; and control methods must be both simpleand economical.The Oxford work was based on extensive observation

of behaviour and population changes in natural conditions.The common rat was found to develop, in a stableenvironment, regular movements on well-defined path-ways. The appearance of an unfamiliar object, such asa trap or a pile of bait, leads to avoidance of the placewhere this has been put. But familiarity breeds contempt:the regular placing of harmless bait over several daysleads to acceptance of the bait even when poison is

eventually added. This familiar "prebaiting " obviatesthe remarkable tendency of this species to refuse foodswhich have previously caused illness-for example, poisonbait of which only a small sample has been taken. Theother species of this genus, R. rattus, has been less closelystudied, but it behaves in a generally similar way. Thehouse mouse does not develop specific poison shyness;but its behaviour is so variable from day to day that itis at least as difficult to poison.The important work on feeding behaviour was paralleled

by studies of the effects of poisons. Toxicological studiesshowed that the old standby poisons-barium carbonateand red squill-have rather low toxicities. Red squillmay be quite ineffective, unless the consignment is

carefully selected. Today, the main strong poisons ofchoice are zinc phosphide, arsenic, and antu (alphanaph-thylthiourea)-all after prebaiting-but antu is unsuitablefor use against R. rattus. The Oxford workers are

properly sceptical of the value of ’ 1080’ (sodiummonofluoroacetate) despite the enthusiasm with which itwas first received, especially in the U.S.A. : it is exceed-