34
Exoplanets Edge on Face on Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effect

Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    6

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Exoplanets

Edge on

Face on

Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effect

Page 2: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Exoplanets

Let’s look into how we analyze the planet transit light curve …

Page 3: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

First, let’s assume the following:

o The planet is in a circular orbit. This is often true for planets

close to their star as tidal interaction with the star acts to

circularise the orbit of the planet.

o The stellar intensity is uniform across the stellar disk, i.e., the

stellar limb darkening is negligible. This is true at long

wavelengths, e.g. the I band (806±149 nm). ( We will come

back to this assumption later.)

o The planet is dark compared to the central star.

o The light comes from a single star, i.e., the light from the

planet host star is not blended with the light from another star.

Transit light curve analysis

Page 4: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit light curve analysisAstronomers’ (silly) confusion in the

use of the impact parameter b:

b = a cos i

to represent the projected distance

between the center of the star and that

of the planet.

However, often it is also used as

b = (a cos i) /R*

to be dimensionless. This normalized

definition gives simpler mathematical

terms in related equations. So we need

to pay attention to which b is used

under the circumstances.

Page 5: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit light curve analysis

The schematic of a planet transiting its host star (middle) with the corresponding

variation in brightness during the transit (top) and during the occultation (bottom). The

impact parameters b and the transit parameters (δ, tF, tT) used in the equations here

after are indicated on this figure.

Page 6: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Another view of the transit planet light curve.

Transit light curve analysis

Page 7: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit light curve analysis

Another view of the transit planet light curve.

b: impact parameter

a: distance between the star and planet

i: inclination angle

Page 8: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit light curve

analysis

Page 9: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit light curve

analysis

transit shape: the ratio of the

duration of the flat part of the

transit (tF) to the total transit

duration (tT), so this is purely

geometrical parameter

Transit shape and

Pythagorean theorem

Page 10: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit light curve

analysis

Page 11: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit light curve

analysis

Page 12: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit light curve

analysis

Page 13: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit light curve

analysis

Page 14: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit light curve

analysis

Page 15: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit light curve

analysis

Page 16: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit light curve analysis

But there is another step ……

Page 17: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit light curve analysis

Limb Darkening Effect

Page 18: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Limb Darkening Effect

The solar disk is (gradually) dimmer at the

edge than the center. Why?

(http

://spiff.rit.e

du/c

lasses/p

hys440/le

ctu

res/lim

b/lim

b.h

tml)

Page 19: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Parameterization of the Limb Darkening Effect

Center

Limb Limb

Limb darkening effect equation should be

able to produce profiles like this one.

Observed intensity profile

across the Solar disc.

Page 20: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Limb Darkening Effect

(http://spiff.rit.edu/classes/phys440/lectures/limb/limb.html)

(https://sites.ualberta.ca/~pogosyan/teaching/ASTRO_122/lect9/lecture9.html)

We see photons from the photosphere where the optical depth is not greater than 1.

(The optical depth is proportional to the product of the number density, cross section

and the physical length. It’s dimensionless.)

Page 21: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Limb Darkening Effect

o In reality, the stellar luminosity is not constant across

the stellar disk.

o The stellar disk is brighter at its centre than at its

edge.

o The photons received from the centre of the stellar

disk come from deeper into the stellar atmosphere

than those received from the edge of the disk.

o A photon coming from deeper into the stellar

atmosphere has a higher temperature and thus

appears brighter at the associated wavelength.

o Thus, at the corresponding wavelength, the stellar

centre appears brighter than the stellar limb, hence

the expression "limb darkening".

Page 22: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Limb Darkening Effect

(http://abyss.uoregon.edu/~js/ast121/lectures/lec23.html)

Page 23: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit light curve analysis

Planet transit illustration with limb darkening

Page 24: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit light curve analysis

Limb darkening in real

transit light curves

Without limb

darkening

Page 25: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit

Depth

Limb

Darkening

Ingress Egress

Limb Darkening Effect in Transit Light curve

Page 26: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular
Page 27: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular
Page 28: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit light curve & Limb Darkening Effect

Using a realistic model of stellar limb darkening is important when

fitting transit light curves, as the shape of the limb darkening will

influence the derived planet parameters (mainly the planet radius

and impact parameter on the stellar disk).

This intensity variation across the stellar disk is calculated from

stellar atmosphere models (e.g. ATLAS9, PHOENIX) where the

emergent intensity with regard to the line of sight is known. This

intensity is then passed through different instrumental filters (e.g.

the standard filters in Claret 2000 and Claret 2004, and the

CoRoT and Kepler filters in Sing 2010), and fitted with different

limb darkening laws to derive the associated limb darkening

coefficients.

http://kurucz.harvard.edu/grids.html (ATLAS9)

http://www.hs.unihamburg.de/EN/For/ThA/phoenix/index.htm (PHOENIX)

Page 29: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Parameterization of the Limb Darkening Effect

Let’s consider this geometry

and define the limb darkening

coefficient (u) as

which is a normalized

differential intensity between

the center and the limb.

Edge

The simplest known way to parameterize the limb darkening

effect is

and this is known as “linear case” of limb darkening effect.

r : projected distance to the

surface (= radial distance from

the observed center of the disc)

( = cos)

Page 30: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Parameterization of the Limb Darkening Effect

Comparisons of the expected limb darkening profiles from the linear case

with u = 1.0, 0.8, 0.6, 0.4 and 0.2 (from lowest curve upwards). The curve

for u = 1 is a circle. The radius of the disc is taken to be 1, r = 0 is the

centre of the disc and r = ± 1 is the limb.

( = cos)

Page 31: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Parameterization of the Limb Darkening Effect

Summary of the most commonly used limb darkening effect equations.

In practice, the choice of which limb-darkening law to use depends on the

signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) of the transit, the observational bandpass and

the stellar type. High S/N observations allow the shape of the limb

darkening to be more accurately constrained, and so can justify the usage

of a limb-darkening law with more coefficients.

Page 32: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular
Page 33: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular
Page 34: Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve Analysis and Limb Darkening Effectastrolab/files/Lecture_Lab5... · 2019-03-04 · Transit Exoplanet: Light Curve ... o The planet is in a circular

Transit light curve analysis