Thorogood v. Michael's Stores (Bad to the Bone Lawsuit)

8/13/2019 Thorogood v. Michael's Stores (Bad to the Bone Lawsuit)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/thorogood-v-michaels-stores-bad-to-the-bone-lawsuit 1/13

:< /

c

0 OFAG@LH @. [@FBULY, I`r 51>;;

. . h`w.aco

9 ,D@\NO@B [@FBULY

0;9<; Acbstlhh`tfcb Icuhlv`re, Quftl 96;;

1 Hcs @bmlhls, A`hfncrbf` 6;;>=

(10;) 770->7;; - Ulhlpgcbl

5

(10;) 770->7;0 - NàsFofhl

<

@ttcrblys ncr [h`fbtfnn,

> MLCYML UGCYCMCCE

=

7

6

c

..4

X

0;

\BFULE QU@ULQ EFQUYFAU AC\YU

ALBUY@H EFQUYFAU CN A@HFNCYBF@

00

b

t ' h r -

~

n 'o

a:::J

-

( . . ,J

-5 nh:.

,..-JA

A

;

rr0

: 4

:,, 0

b

.

~ . ~ . ~

r-

r

. -2 . ,

.

b

r

H:

.

"

AJ

. . 4 :

1 :

.' ) '

B

r::-

+

,. '

8?)

-

.

09

01

MLCYML UGCYCMCCE, ̀ b

fbefvfeu`h,

a ~ 0 A ´ 1

;

6 5

9

- { ) h

05

0< f

0>

0=

07

06

9

90

99

91

[h`fbtfnn,

v s.

OFAG@LHQ QUCYLQ, FBA., `

Elh`w`rl acrpcr`tfcb4 `be ECLQ

F

W, Fbahusfvl,

Elnlbe`bts.

ACO[H@FBU NCY UY@ELO@YD

FBNYFBMLOLBU @BE N@HQL

ELQFMB@UFCB CN CYFMFB

J\YV UYF@H ELO@BELE

ACOL

BC] UGL [H@FBUFNN, MLCYML UGCYCMCCE, `be ncr

aùsls

cn

àtfcb `m`fbst tgl elnlbe`bts, acoph`fbs `be `hhlmls `s nchhcws:

O@[-[HL@EFBM-0=<1



c

c

0

J\YFQEFAUFCB

9 0 Ugfs fs ` afvfh àtfcb wgfag `rfsls ubelr Qlatfcbs 19(0) T0< \.Q.A.

1 §0005(0)_ `be 51(`) T0< \.Q.A. §009<(`)_ cn tgl \bftle Qt`tls Urèlo`rd @at.

5

Jurfsefatfcb fs i`sle upcb

0<

\.Q.A. Qlatfcb 0090 `be 97 \.Q.A. Qlatfcb 0117(`).

<

UGL [ YUFLQ

9.

[h`fbtfnn, MLCYML UGCYCMCCE, fs `b fbefvfeu`h `be aftfzlb

cn

= tgl \bftle Qt`tls, g`vfbm gfs prfbafp`h phàl

cn

iusfblss fb Hcs @bmlhls,

7

A`hfncrbf` (glrlfb`ntlr rlnlrrle

tc

`s Ugcrcmcce ).

6 1. [h`fbtfnn fs fbncrole ̀ be ilhflvls `be, i`sle

cb

suag fbncro`tfcb `be

0;

ilhfln, `hhlmls tg`t elnlbe`bt, OFAG@LHQ QUCYLQ, FBA., fs ` Elh`w`rl acrpcr`-

00

tfcb `be g`s fts prfbafp`h phàl cn iusfblss fb Frvfbm, Ulx`s `be ecls iusfblss

09 tgrcumgcut tgl \bftle Qt`tls fb mlblr`h `be fb tgl Albtr`h Efstrfat

cn

A`hfncrbf` fb

01

p`rtfauh`r (glrlfb`ntlr rlnlrrle tc `s Ofag`lhs ).

05 5. gl trul bòls cr a`pàftfls, wgltglr fbefvfeu`h, acrpcr`tl, `sscaf`tl

0< rlprlslbt`tfvl,

cr

ctglrwfsl,

cn

tgl elnlbe`bts bòle glrlfb `s ECLQ F - W,

0> fbahusfvl, `rl ubdbcwb tc ph`fbtfnn wgc tglrlncrl, pursu`bt tc Hca`h Yuhl 06-0 cn

0=

tgfs Acurt, suls s`fe elnlbe`bts iy suag nfatftfcus bòls `be ph`fbtf nn wfhh òlbe

07 tgfs Acoph`fbt tc sgcw tglfr trul bòls `be a`pàftfls wglb tgl sòl g`vl illb

06 `salrt`fble.

9;

90

99

91

95

9<

9>

9=

97

O@[-[HL@EFBC-0=<J



c

NFYQU AC\BU NCY UY ELO YD FBNYFBMLOLBU

9

<. [h`fbtfnn glrliy rlpl`ts `be rl`hhlmls [`r`mr`pgs 0 - 5, fbahusfvl, `s

1 tgcumg slt ncrtg fb nuhh glrlfb `m`fb.

5

>. Fb 0671, `be hcbm prfcr tc `by

cn

tgl àts

cn

tgl elnlbe`bts acrb-

Q ph`fble cn fb tgfs Acoph`fbt, Ugcrcmcce, iy `be tgrcumg gfs prlelalsscr-fb-

> fbtlrlst, ècptle tgl o`rd I@E UC UGL ICBL `s ` trèlo`rd tc elsfmb`tl

= ahctgfbm, bòlhy, U-sgfrts, t`bd tcps, jàdlts `be g`ts, s`fe o`rd ilfbm lxtlbsfvlhy

7 usle, èvlrtfsle `be prcoctle tgrcumgcut tgl \bftle Qt`tls fb mlblr`h `be fb tgl

6 Qt`tl cn A`hfncrbf` fb p`rtfauh`r.

0; =. Qfbal hcbm prfcr tc `by

cn

tgl àts

cn

tgl elnlbe`bts acoph`fble cn fb

00

tgfs Acoph`fbt, Ugcrcmcce, iy `be tgrcumg gfs prlelalsscr-fb-fbtlrlst, `pphfle ncr

09 `be rlmfstlrle fts I@E UC UGL ICBL trèlo`rd cb tgl [rfbafp`h Ylmfstlr fb tgl

01 \bftle Qt`tls [`tlbt `be Urèlo`rd Cnnfal, ` acpy

cn

Alrtfnfa`tl

cn

Urèlo`rd

05 Ylmfstr`tfcb Bc. 1,>75,=56 ilfbm `ttàgle glrltc `s Lxgfift 0. I`sle upcb tgl

0< rfmgts àacrele rlmfstr`tfcb cn tgl trèlo`rd `be tgl trèlo`rd s hcbm `be acbtfb-

0>

ucus usl iy Ugcrcmcce, `be gfs prlelalsscr-fb-fbtlrlst, tc elsfmb`tl ahctgfbm,

0= bòlhy U-sgfrts, t`bd tcps, jàdlts `be g`ts, Ugcrcmcce cwbs tgl lxahusfvl rfmgt

07 tc o`bunàturl `be slhh ahctgfbm, bòlhy, U-sgfrts, t`bd tcps, jàdlts `be g`ts

06 elsfmb`tle iy tgl I@E UC UGL ICBL trèlo`rd `be tc èvlrtfsl `be prcoctl

9

tgl s`hl cn ahctgfbm, bòlhy, U-sgfrts, t`bd tcps, jàdlts `be g`ts tgrcumg tgl usl c

90

tgl I@E UC UGL ICBL trèlo`rd.

99 7. Qfbal hcbm prfcr tc tgl àts

cn

elnlbe`bts acoph`fble

cn

fb tgfs

91

Acoph`fbt, Ugcrcmcce `be gfs prlelalsscr-fb-fbtlrlst, lxtlbsfvlhy o`rdltle, sche

95 èvlrtfsle `be prcoctle tgl s`hl

cn

ahctgfbm, bòlhy, U-sgfrts, t`bd tcps, jàdlts

9<

`be g`ts ubelr tgl trèlo`rd I@E UC UGL ICBL. Ugcrcmcce g`s m`fble `

9> suist`btf`h rlput`tfcb fb acbblatfcb wftg ahctgfbm, bòlhy, U-sgfrts, t`bd tcps,

9=

jàdlts `be g`ts o`rdltle `be sche ubelr tgl I@E UC UGL ICBL trèlo`rd. Iy

97 rl`scb cn tgl o`rdltfbm `be s`hl cn prceuats ubelr tgl ìcvl trèlo`rd, tgl trèl

O@[ [HL@EFBM 0=<1



0

`be puihfa, prfcr tc s`fe àts c elnlbe`bts acoph`fble c fb tgfs Acoph`fbt, g`vl

acol tc rlacmbfzl tgl trèlo`rd I@E UC UGL ICBL, wglb usle fb acbblatfcb

1 wftg ahctgfbm, bòlhy, U-sgfrts, t`bd tcps, jàdlts `be g`ts `s felbtfnyfbm suag

5

prceuats `s ilfbm lxahusfvlhy supphfle iy, ùtgcrfzle cr `nnfhf`tle wftg

<

Ugcrcmcce.

> 6. Hcbm `ntlr Ugcrcmcce s nfrst usl c tgl I@E UC UGL ICBL trèl-

= o`rd fb acoolral, elnlbe`bts, `be làg c tglo, nfrst acoolbale usl

c

tgl

7 trèlo`rd I@E UC UGL ICBL tc o`bunàturl, felbtfny, efstrfiutl, èvlrtfsl

6

`be/cr prcoctl tgl s`hl cnU-sgfrts fb tgl \bftle Qt`tls. Elnlbe`bts, `be làg c

0; tglo, g`vl usle tgl trèlo`rd I@E UC UGL ICBL elspftl tgl nàt tgl felbtfnfl

00 trèlo`rd wrcbmnuhhy `pprcprf`tls Ugcrcmcce s rlmfstlrle I@E UC UGL ICBL

09 trèlo`rd `be fs acbnusfbmhy sfofh`r tglrltc.

01 0;. Elnlbe`bts àt c o`bunàturfbm, efstrfiutfbm, èvlrtfsfbm, o`rdltfb

05 `be prcoctfbm tgl s`hl

c

U-sgfrts tgrcumg tgl usl

c

tgl trèlo`rd I@E UC UGL

0< ICBL fs efrlatle tc tgl sòl slmolbt c tgl purag`sfbm puihfa tc wgfag

0> Ugcrcmcce efrlats gfs prceuats.

0=

00. Elnlbe`bts usl

c

tgl trèlo`rd I@E UC UGL ICBL `s `hhlmle

07 ìcvl tc efstrfiutl, elsfmb`tl, èvlrtfsl `be/cr prcoctl tgl s`hl cnU-sgfrts fs

06

hfdlhy tc aùsl acbnusfcb cr ofst`dl cr tc elalfvl tgl purag`slrs

c

fts prceuats `

9; tc tgl scural c crfmfb c elnlbe`bts prceuats `be tc aùsl elnlbe`bts prceuats

90 tc il p`ssle

c

cr vflwle `s tgcsl wgfag `rl prcvfele cr ùtgcrfzle iy

Ugcrcmcce.

91

09. Ug`t ubhlss rlstr`fble iy tgfs Acurt, elnlbe`bts, `be làg

c

tglo,

95

wfhh acbtfbul tc usl tgl trèlo`rd I@E UC UGL ICBL tc o`bunàturl, felbtfny

9<

efstrfiutl, èvlrtfsl `be/cr prcoctl tgl s`hl c U-sgfrts `be, `s ` rlsuht tglrlcn, tg

9>

puihfa mlblr`hhy wfhh il ofshle `be elalfvle fbtc ilhflvfbm tg`t tgl prceuats

c

9=

elnlbe`bts, `be làg

c

tglo, `rl tgcsl cn, cr `rl `nnfhf`tle wftg Ugcrcmcce, tc tg

97

frrlp`rìhl eò`ml `be fbjury c tgl iusfblss c Ugcrcmcce.

O@[ [HL@EFBM 0=<1



c

c

01. Ugcrcmcce g`s euhy elo`bele tg`t elnlbe`bts, `be làg c tglo,

9 al`sl `be elsfst nrco tgl `ncrls`fe vfch`tfcb c Ugcrcmcce s rfmgts, elnlbe`bt

1 g`vfbm rlnusle tc ec sc. Ugfs fs tglrlncrl `b lxalptfcb`h a`sl wftgfb tgl ol`bfbm

5

c

§1<

c

tgl \bftle Qt`tls Urèlo`rd @at,

0<

\.Q.A. §000=, lbtfthfbm Ugcrcmcce

< tc rlacvlr rl`scbìhl `ttcrblys nlls

> .

05. Ugl `ncrls`fe àtfcbs c elnlbe`bts, `be làg c tglo, g`vl frrlp`r-

=

ìhy eò`mle Ugcrcmcce `be wfhh, ubhlss rlstr`fble, acbtfbul tc sc eò`ml tgl

7

iusfblss c Ugcrcmcce `be fts mcce wfhh, ncr `hh c wgfag tglrl fs bc èlqu`tl

6 rloley `t h`w.

0 QLACBE AC\BU NCY NLELY H \BN FY ACO[LUFUFCB

00 BE N HQL ELQFMB UFCB CN CYFMFB

09 0<. [h`fbtfnns glrliy rlpl`t ̀ be rl`hhlml [`r`mr`pgs 0 - 5, `be < - 05,

01

fbahusfvl,

c

tgl Nfrst Acubt `s tgcumg slt ncrtg fb nuhh glrlfb `m`fb fbahusfvl,

c

05 tgl Nfrst Acubt `s tgcumg slt ncrtg fb nuhh glrlfb `m`fb.

0<

0>. Elnlbe`bts ìcvl-`hhlmle àtfcbs acbstftutl tgl usl fb acbblatfcb

0> wftg mcces

c

n`hsl cr ofshlèfbm elsarfptfcbs `be rlprlslbt`tfcbs wftg rlsplat tc

0= tgl crfmfb, spcbscrsgfp cr `pprcv`h c fts prceuats `be tgl puihfafty tglrlncr iy

07

summlstfbm tg`t suag mcces `be tgl èvlrtfsfbm tglrlcn `rl acbblatle wftg cr

06 `sscaf`tle, spcbscrle cr `nnfhf`tle wftg Ugcrcmcce, cr tg`t tgl sòl truhy crfmf-

9; b`tle wftg Ugcrcmcce. Elnlbe`bts, `be làg

c

tglo, g`vl aùsle fts U-sgfrts,

90 `be tgl efstrfiutfbm, elsfmb`tfbm, èvlrtfsfbm `be/cr prcoctfcb tglrlcn, tc lbtlr

99 \bftle Qt`tls acoolral. Ugl ofs`pprcprf`tfcb `be usl c Ugcrcmcce s I@E UC

91

UGL ICBL trèlo`rd iy elnlbe`bts, `be làg

c

tglo, `s wlhh `s elnlbe`bt s

95 ctglr àtfcbs elsarfile ìcvl acbstftutl n`hsl `be ofshlèfbm elsarfptfcbs

c

nàt

9< `be rlprlslbt`tfcbs

c

nàt tg`t `rl hfdlhy tc mfvl tgl puihfa ` n`hsl foprlssfcb `be

9>

tc acbnusl tgl puihfa `s tc tgl scural

c

elnlbe`bts mcces.

9= 0=. Ugcrcmcce fs fbncrole `be ilhflvls `be, i`sle cb suag fbncro`tfcb

97 `be ilhfln, `hhlmls tg`t elnlbe`bts, `be làg c tglo, ècptle `be usle tgl

O@[ [HL@EFBM 0=<1



0

trèlo`rd I@E UC UGL ICBL wftg àtu`h dbcwhleml cnUgcrc mcce s hcbm prfcr

9 usl cn tgl I@E UC UGL ICBL trèlo`rd `be wftg tgl fbtlbt tc trèl cb tgl

1

rlput`tfcb `be mcce wfhh

cn

tg`t o`rd.

5

07. @htgcumg elnlbe`bts, `be làg

cn

tglo, g`vl illb rlqulstle iy

< Ugcrcmcce tc al`sl tgl èvlrtfsfbm `be prcoctfcb cn tgl s`hl cnU-sgfrts tgrcumg

tgl usl

cn

tgl trèlo`rd I@E UC UGL ICBL, elnlbe`bts, `be làg cn tglo,

=

g`vl, blvlrtglhlss, rlnusle s`fe rlqulst `be g`vl acbtfbule tc usl s`fe o`rd fb

7 acbblatfcb wftg èvlrtfsfbm, o`rdltfbm `be prcoctfbm tgl s`hl

cn

fts prceuats.

6 Ugfs fs tglrlncrl `b lxalptfcb`h a`sl wftgfb tgl ol`bfbm cn §1< cn tgl \bftle

0

Qt`tls Urèlo`rd @at, 0< \.Q.A. §000=, lbtfthfbm Ugcrcmcce tc rlacvlr rl`scb-

00

ìhl `ttcrblys nlls.

09 06. Ugl `ncrls`fe àtfcbs cnelnlbe`bts, `be làg cn tglo, g`vl frrlp`r-

01 ìhy eò`mle Ugcrcmcce `be wfhh, ubhlss rlstr`fble, acbtfbul tc sc eò`ml tgl

05

iusfblss cnUgcrcmcce `be fts mcce wfhh, ncr `hh cnwgfag tglrl fs bc èlqu`tl

0< rloley `t h`w.

0>

]GLYLNCYL ph`fbtfnn sllds juemolbt ̀ m`fbst elnlbe`bts, `be làg cn

0= tglo, `s nchhcws:

07

0. Ug`t elnlbe`bts, `be làg cn tglo, `be tglfr cnnfalrs, `mlbts, slr-

06 v`bts, lophcylls, `ttcrblys, acbnlelr`tls, rlh`tle acop`bfls, `be `hh plrscbs

9;

àtfbm fb acbalrt cr p`rtfafp`tfcb wftg ft, il lbjcfble `be rlstr`fble eurfbm tgl

90 plbelbay cn tgfs àtfcb, `be plro`blbthy tglrl`ntlr:

99 (

`) nrco usfbm fb `by o`bblr `s ` trèlo`rd cr trèl bòl tgl

91

o`rd I@E UC UGL ICBL, `hcbl cr fb acoifb`tfcb wftg `by ctglr wcre cr wcre

95

cr elsfmb, fb acbblatfcb wftg elsfmb`tfbm, efstrfiutfbm, èvlrtfsfbm, prcoctfbm

9< `be/cr cnnlrfbm ncr s`hl cr tgl s`hl cnU-sgfrts bct prceuale iy ph`fbtfnn, cr bct

9> ùtgcrfzle iy ph`fbtfnn tc il sche fb acbblatfcb wftg s`fe o`rd4

9= (i) nrco p`ssfbm cnn, fbeuafbm cr lbìhfbm ctglrs tc slhh cr p`ss cn

97

U-sgfrts wgfag `rl bct ph`fbtfnns cr bct cnnlrle ubelr tgl acbtrch `be suplrvfsfcb

O@[ [HL@EFBM 0=<1

>



c

cn

ph`fbtfnn ̀ be `pprcvle iy ph`fbtfnn, tgrcumg tgl usl

cn

tgl o`rd I@E UC UGL

9 ICBL, cr ncro`tfvls tglrlcn4

1 (a) nrco acoofttfbm `by àts a`hauh`tle tc aùsl purag`slrs tc

5

ilhflvl tg`t elnlbe`bts' U-sgfrts `rl spcbscrle iy

cr

`pprcvle cr acbblatle wftg

< cr mu`r`btlle iy cr cnnlrle `be sche ubelr tgl acbtrch `be suplrvfsfcb cn ph`fbtfnn

> `be

=

(e) nrco ctglrwfsl acopltfbm ubn`frhy wftg ph`fbtfnn fb `by

7

o`bblr.

6

9

Ug`t elnlbe`bts, `be làg

cn

tglo, il rlqufrle tc elhfvlr up tc

0 ph`fbtfnn cr elstrcy `by `be `hh prfal hfsts, hìlhs, sfmbs, prfbts, pàd`mls, wr`pplrs

00

rlalptàhls, èvlrtfsfbm o`ttlr, prcoctfcb`h `be ctglr o`tlrf`h

fb

tgl pcsslssfcb c

09

elnlbe`bt, cr ubelr fts acbtrch il`rfbm tgl o`rd I E UC UGL ICBL `hcbl, cr fb

01 acoifb`tfcb wftg `by ctglr wcre cr wcres cr elsfmb usle fb acbblatfcb wftg tgl

05 efstrfiutfbm, elsfmb`tfbm, èvlrtfsfbm, prcoctfcb cr s`hl cn U-sgfrts bct prceuale

0<

iy ph`fbtfnn cr bct oèl ubelr tgl suplrvfsfcb `be acbtrch cn ph`fbtfnn.

0>

1. Ug`t elnlbe`bts, `be làg cn tglo, àacubt ncr `be p`y cvlr tc

0=

ph`fbtfnn `hh eò`mls sust`fble iy ph`fbtfnn ̀ be `hh prcnfts rl`hfzle iy elnlbe`bts

i

07

rl`scb

cn

elnlbe`bts' ubh`wnuh àts `be tg`t tgl òcubt

cn

eò`mls ncr fbnrfbml-

06 olbt cn ph`fbtfn ns trèlo`rd il fbarl`sle iy ` suo bct lxallefbm tgrll tfols tgl

9

òcubt

tglrlcn

`s prcvfele iy Qlatfcb 1<

cn

tgl \bftle Qt`tls Urèlo`rd @at,

0<

90 \.Q.A. §000=.

99

5. Ug`t ph`fbtfnn il `w`rele lxloph`ry eò`mls

fb

tgl òcubt

cn

91

0;;,;;;.

95 Q

Ug`t ph`fbtfnn il `w`rele fts acsts

cn

suft, fbahuefbm rl`scbìhl

9< `ttcrblys' nlls `be g`vl suag ctglr `be nurtglr rlhfln ̀ s tc tgl Acurt o`y ello

9> lquftìhl, fbahuefbm iut bct hfoftle tc, `by rlhfln slt ncrtg ubelr Qlatfcb 15-16 cn

9=

f

tgl \bftle Qt`tls Urèlo`rd @at.

97

O@[½[HL@EFBM½0=<1



c

0

[H@FBUFNN ELO@BEQ @ J\YV UYF@H CN UGFQ @AUFCB

9 Ylsplatnuhhy suiofttle

1 FQ@@AO@B D@\NO@B [@FBULY

5

<

>

= E`tle:

F* .J

7

6

0;

00

09

01

05

0<

0>

0=

07

06

9

90

99

91

95

9<

9>

9=

97 •

O@[ [HL@EFBM 0=<1

I V ~ ~

hag`l @. [òtlr

@ttcrblys ncr [h`fbtfnn

MLCYMLUGCYCMCCE











Documents

Thorogood v. Michael's Stores (Bad to the Bone Lawsuit)