69

thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

����������� ������������������ ����������� �������! �#"$�%�&'���(�%�*),+-�.�/�������0��12���.3��4����5�

+��#���6"$������#"$�7�5�8"$�:9;��"<"=�#�/��>�3:?@�A���B������1C�0�D����%�����FEG������H��$���

IKJLNMPO�Q=RGS�T�UWV�X7QZY

[]\_^A`badc*\fehgji�kl`banmpopelarq�k(i�g$s�ehg$`n`bopelg$s$t$u8g=v$ewq�gxu8g$y�mzelmp{=mz`�|4}^�`nadc$g$|~kl|~s J t ��{$� I q4e�t*�������

��\��Z\ehgxi�kh`nanmpopehabq�k(q�g=v��#|����${�mz`bo�i�g$s~elg$`b`nopelg$s$t��|~o0mpc$`rq�y�mz`nopg�]g=el�~`nopy0elm J tB[.|~y0mp|~g*t(���~���

�<{ I ��elmpmp`bv�mz|�mpc$`���`b�q�o�mz��`bgKm�|�}�[#ozq4ehgxq�g$v��#|~s~g=elmze��~`��abel`bg$an`by�ehg��q4o0mzehq�k�}�{$k��khkl��`ngKm�|�}Amzc$`�o0`b�6{$eho0`b��`bgKmzy }�|~o�mpc$`

v$`ns~op`n`�|�}��|<anmp|~o�|�}�¡�c$ehkl|~yp|~�=c J ehg��#|~���${=mdq¢mzeh|�gq�k(�#|�s~g$elmpel��`���abel`bg$an`

q4m�mzc$`��£��$�<£���¤¥����i�^ ^���u��¥��^ u8^��]^�iG¦�§,^�if��¤¥��¦�¨A¦�©�ª

��`b��mz`b� I `no¥«4¬~¬K«a­ ��q�ypypq�adc6{$yp`®mpmpy�u8g$y0mpelmp{=mz`�|�}�^�`nadc$g$|~kl|~s J «4¬~¬K«�\¯£]khk*o0ehs~cKmpy

op`by0`bo��~`bv�\

�#`no0mze��`bv IKJ ° ^A|~��q�yp|�¡�|�s~s~eh|�]g$abq�y¥q4g$v�¤�`bkl`bg�±²c$elmzq�³�`no�¡�o0|�}�`by0yp|~o

^ c$`by0ehy¥��{$� `bo0�<elyp|~o

£¥anab`n�=mz`nv IKJZ° i�q�o0k%´@\��ehklkh`bo�#|4µ��#cq�ehont��`b�$q�o0mp��`ng6m]©�ozq4v${q4mp`¶�#|�����elm0mz`b`

Page 2: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

����������� ��������������������������� ��!"����#�%$&�(')�*��+,��!-���/.0 �1�2����������34�5�167��#�*�8� 0 �1�#�9':�������('��;�<��'�">=;�?'&':�1�@�BA�6

C �*�D�/�#���#3E���GF7��!H������IJ�����LK��)���IKJ

M�elgq J ¡A\B´�{=�Fq�o

N)O�P�QSRUT�TWVYXZTW[�TW\V^]#V`_acbWTWQSVed&T�[gf�hib,acRjdkacd/Xml([9ngd�RUTWRjogVpN:qeRUV`dqrVYs7[gdt O�ngO/s�T#u9v�wxcv9v9x�w&RjdZ_acbWTWRyacz-f{O�zU|zjzUQSV`d9T�[cf*T}\�Vpb}V`~&O�RjbWV`Q�V`d&T}sif{[gb�T}\�VX:V`ngb}VeV�[cf�]#[:qrTW[gb7[gf��1\�RjzU[&s�[9_�\)��RUd�l([gQS_�O�T}aBT}RU[9dacz�l([9ngd�RUTWRjogVpN:qeRUV`dqrV

I����9':����!�'� \�RysiTW\�VYs�Rys7_�b}[g_�[9sWV`s�a�QSVrT}\�[:X:[gzj[gn9��f{[gb�T}\�V^X:V`sWRjngd�[cfDQSagd:��QSa9q,\�Rjd�V�RUd:�TWV`b�f�a9qrVYs�P)��qr[9Q�P�Rjd�Rjd�n�TW[9_:�LX:[B�7d�acd/XJP/[gT�T}[gQ���O_�_�b}[:qrV`s}sWV`s�Rjd�o)Rys�Rj[gd��� b}[gQ%a7qr[9Q�_O:T}acTWRj[gdagzB_/V`b}sW_/VYq�T}RUo9VgwY�(V�_�b}[g_�[9sWVDTW\acT�TW\V1sWqeRUV`d&TWRU|/q��Lqr[9ngd�RUTWRjogV~&O�V`s�TWRj[gd�[gf�qr[gQ5P�Rjd�RUdnmTW[9_:��X�[B�7d acdX;P�[cTWTW[gQ���O�_ �)d�[B�7zjV`X:n9V�Rjs�sWRUQSRjzjagbTW[�TW\�V�V`d�ngRjd�V`Veb}RUd�n�~&O�VYs�T}RU[9d�[cf�zyacP�VezjRUdn�aZTWb,acRjd�Rjd�n�sWVrT�Rjd�amsWO�_/V`bWo)Rys�VYXzjV`acb}d�Rjd�n�_�bW[9P�zjVeQ��� VSRjd)ogV`s�TWRjn9acTWV5TW\�VYs�V�~&O�VYs�T}RU[9ds�RUd�TW\�VSb}V`agzUQ�[gf?f�agqeRjagz?acdagzU�:sWRjs`� � V

_�b}[g_�[9sWV�TW\�V�OsWV�[cf�a zURjd�V`agbkQS[9bW_�\/acP�zjV�QS[:X:Vez����*������f{[9b b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&TW�Rjd�n�TW[g_���X:[B�7d8s�T}bWO/q�TWObWVmacd/X�OsWV�R¡TST}[�QS[:X:V`z�oBacb}RU[9Os5f�agqrRyacz�oBacb}RyaBTWRj[gd/ssWOq,\�agsZQS[gO�TW\¢sW\ag_/VYskagdX�Ve£)_bWVYsWsWRU[9d�w7T}\�V�_�[9sWV�[gf^f�agqeV`s�acd/XJo)RjsWOaczsW_/V`V`q,\¢��o)RjsWVeQSV`s,��� � Vmag_�_�zj��a�sWO�_�Veb}o)RjsWV`X�zUVYacb}d�RUdn�QSVrT}\�[:X�P/agsWV`X [9dsWO�_�_�[gbWT�o9V`qrTW[gb�Q�agq,\�Rjd�Vm�¤N:¥�����b}Ven9bWVYsWsWRU[9dmf{[gb�VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}RUdnkT}\�VS_acb,acQSVe�TWV`b}s�[cf#������s�X:RUb}V`qrTWzj��f{b}[gQ¦_�RU£:VezU��P/agsWV`X;b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gds^[cf�f�agqeV`s`� � Vqr[9Q�P�Rjd�V#TW\�VYs�V�Q�VeTW\�[:X�s1f{[gb�X:VYs�Rjngd�Rjd�n5d�Ve�pw)QS[gb}V#sWVezUf§��qe[gd&T}agRUd�VYX�s��:s�TWV`QSsf{[gb�b}V`qe[gngdRU¨`RUd�n5f�agqeRjagz-Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gds`w)V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWRjd�n�f�agqeRjagz-_/[&s�Vpacd/X�f{[9b7bWVYqr[gng�d�Rj¨eRjd�nSo)RjsWVeQSV`s`�

� \�VYs�Rys�N)O�_�Veb}o)RjsW[gbY© � [9QSa9s�[S��[gn9ngRj[� RUTWzjVg©?ª�d/qeags7agdX�«�V`zUV`d � \R¡T,ac�gV`b7�?b}[cf{V`s}sW[gb

Page 3: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� �����������

� ����������������������� ! � ! ��VYacb}d�Rjd�n f{[9bph([gT�T}[gQ���O_ t d/aczj�)sWRyse© t" V`agz¡��TWRjQSV�N:�)s�TWV`Qf{[gb � agqeRjagz t dagzU�:sWRjs ���p���p���p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� ! v

! � x ��VYacb}d�Rjd�n � [9_:��X�[B�7dk��acb,acQSVeTWVeb,s����p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� ! x! � u t __�zURyqeacTWRj[gds7TW[���acd�����a9q,\�Rjd�V$#Ld9T}VebWf�agqeV`s4�p�p���p���p�p��� !�%! � % N)Rjngd�RU|/q`acd&T�l([gd&TWb}RUPO:TWRj[gds��p���p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� !'&! �)( *�ogV`bWo)RjVe��[gf�T}\�V � \�VYs�Rys����p���p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� !�+

, -/.102�����3��46587�069'.1�02:;:�����0<�'=�'�?>@.106ACBC��DE.FBG��06�'H��3��4I06���J ��06ALK�9'�39M�ONQPR0<�S.19 �1Tx:� ! � a9qrVp]�VrTWVYq�T}RU[9d�N)�:s�T}VeQ ���p���p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� !'U

x:� ! � ! N)�)Rjdms�V`ngQSVed&T}acTWRj[gdZacdX�qr[9QS_/[9d�Ved&T�TWb,agq,�)Rjd�n �p��� !'Ux:� ! � x � agqrVp]�VrT}V`q�T}RU[9d ���p���p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� xgv

x:� x � a9qrRyacz � V`aBT}O�b}V�]�VrT}V`qrTWRj[gdmacdX��m[9O:TW\m�*[)q`aczjRU¨YaBT}RU[9d4�p�p��� xgvx:� x:� ! V dqr[:X:Rjd�nSzU[:q`aczjRU¨`V`Xko�agbWRyaBT}RU[9dsiOsWRUd�n�«�agacb7��a�ogV`zUVeT}s x !x:� x:� x �*[)q`aBT}RUd�nSV`�gV`s�agdXZd�[9s�TWb}RUzys;�p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� xgu

x:� u �m[9O:TW\�_acT�TWV`bWd�acd/aczj�)sWRys �p���p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� x %x:� u�� ! W V`d�Veb,aBT}RUd�n�T}\�V�TWb,acRjd�Rjd�n�sWVrT¦���p���p�p���p���p�p��� x %x:� u�� x t O:TW[9QSacTWRyq�s�V`zUVYq�TWRj[gd8[cf�a�sW_agb}sWVZsWO�PsWVrT�[gf�«#a9acb

� a�ogV`zUVeT7qe[)V�X�qrRjVed&T}s����p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� xY(x:� u�� u �*RUd�VYacb#�*V`a9s�T�N�~9O/acb}V`s�b}Ven9bWVYsWsWRj[gdZ[gd�TW\V5«#a9acb#qe[c�

V�X�qeRUV`d&T}s��p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� x &x:� u�� % N)O_�_/[9b�T�¥�VYq�T}[gb,sif{[gb���Rjd�VYacb " Ven9bWVYsWsWRj[gd �p���p�p��� x &x:� u��)( " VYs�Oz¡T,s7[cf��m[gO:T}\m��acb,acQSVrT}Veb V s�TWRjQSacTWRj[gd ���p�p��� x +

x:� % ]�Rjs}qrOs}sWRU[9d¢���p���p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� u !Z -/.102���;���;4<58[\069'.1� J :�:��]�O06�]=^���`_a9�����DE02�������b�ONdce�<�]:f=;067�A�.

ce����.1A/gh06�]0<DE.i��.i��9 ZO,u�� ! ��Rjd�V`agb7Q�[9bW_\acP�zjV�Q�[:X:V`zHf{[gb7QS[:X:V`zURjd�n�QS[gO:T}\s ���p�p��� u9u

u�� ! � ! *�o9Veb}o&RjVe��[cfD������s����p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� u9u

u

Page 4: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

u�� ! � x l([9ds�T}bWO/q�TWRjd�n�acd��*��� f{[9b7QS[)X�VezjRUd�nSQS[gO�TW\s��p��� u %u�� x ��VYacb}d�Rjd�n�TW[�V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWV�T}\�V��*��� _/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,sDX�RUb}V`qrTWzj�pf{bW[9Q

RjQSagngVYs����p���p���p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� ui(u�� x:� ! W V`d�Veb,aBT}RUd�n�T}\�V � b,acRjd�Rjd�n�N)VrT �p���p�p���p���p�p��� ui(

u�� u " VYs�O�zUT}s#acdXZ]#Rys}qrOs}s�Rj[gd����p���p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� u &u�� u�� ! N)Rjd�ngzjVp��Veb,s�[9dk�m[9O:TW\m�m[9bW_�\/acP�zjV���[)X�Vez����p�p��� u &u�� u�� x �mOz¡T}RU_�zjV^��Veb,sW[gdk��[gO:T}\���[gb}_�\acPzUV��m[:X:Vez;�p�p��� % u

� J :�:�A��3�Y02��������9\���bce06�R58c 06�]=;���;. ������.i��N 0<�S.19 ���

% � ! " VYqr[gn9d�Rj¨eRjd�n � agqeRjagz V £:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gd/s ���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� % (% � ! � ! V £)_bWVYsWsWRU[9d t £)VYs �p���p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� %i&% � ! � x V £)_�Veb}RjQ�V`d&T}acz�]�VrT,acRjzjs��p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� %2+% � ! � u " VYs�Oz¡T,s�acdXZ]�Rjs}qrOs}sWRU[9d��p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� %2+

% � x V s�TWRjQ�aBT}RUd�n � agqrRyacz���[&s�V����p���p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p����( !% � x:� ! " V`_�b}V`sWVed&TWRjd�n���[9sWV�ª�s�Rjd�n�aS��Rjd�V^]�b}a��7Rjd�nS�*��� ��(9x% � x:� x ��acT}q,\�Rjd�n V X�ngVr��Q�ac_s(T}[SaS��[&s�Ve������� �p���p�p����(9x% � x:� u �*V`acb}d�Rjd�n5TW\�V^��agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s([cfDTW\�V^��[&s�Ve������� �p����(gu% � x:� % " VYs�Oz¡T,s�acdXZ]�Rjs}qrOs}sWRU[9d��p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p����(Y(

% � u " VYqr[gn9d�Rj¨eRjd�nS¥#Rys�Oagz*N)_�VeV`q,\Z�?¥�RjsWVeQSV`s��p���p�p���p���p�p����(��% � u�� ! � b}agRUdRUd�n�]�aBT,aS�p���p���p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p����(��% � u�� x #LQS_�zjVeQSVed&T,aBTWRj[gd�]�VrT}agRUzys ���p���p���p�p���p���p�p����( U% � u�� u " VYs�Oz¡T,s�acdXZ]�Rjs}qrOs}sWRU[9d��p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� & v

��� �����SA��;9'�3�O�;9\06��� PR�;���;��.�� ���]H O,(:� ! � \�V^hiRjnS�1RjqrTWO�b}V��p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� & x(:� x ��[9s}sWRUP�zjV�Ve�2N)�:s�TWVeQ�s ���p���p�p���p���p���p�p���p���p�p��� & u(:� x:� ! " V`zjacTWVYXZN:qeRUV`d&TWRU|/qpacdX��1\�RUzj[9sW[g_\�Rjq`acz���O�VYs�T}RU[9ds � &S%

Page 5: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

E²�������A�7���%�1#� �A��"=�

� \�VZs�RU£��gV`agb}s`w�X:O�b}RUd�n��7\�Rjq,\ #p�([9bW�9V`X;[gd TW\�VkbWVYs�VYacb,q,\�b}Ve_�[gbWTWVYX;\�Veb}Vgw\a�o9V(aczysW[#P�VeVedSa�_/V`bWRj[:X^[cf-X:b,ags�TWRyq1sWVezUf§�¤T}b}agds�f{[9bWQ�acTWRj[gd���#�T�\a9s�s�\ag�gV`d^Q���i[gb}zjX)��o)RUV`��TW[�TW\V�o9Veb}��bW[)[gT}s�acdXkzjVrf§T�QSVpa5QS[9bWV�Q�aBTWObWV�acdXk\�[9_/Vef{O�zUzj�P�VrT�T}Vebp_�Veb,s�[9d�� � [ZT}\�V�Vr£)TWV`d&T�T}\aBT^V`ogV`bW��sWRUdngzjV5_�Veb,s�[9d��7\[�q`acQSVSRUd&T}[Q���zjR¡f{V�_�zja��9V`X�apb}[gzjV�Rjd�TW\Rjs1TWb,acds�f{[gb}Q�aBT}RU[9d�w9agdX�TW[�TW\�V�Vr£)TWV`d9T(TW\acT1T}\�RjsTWb,acd/s�f{[9bWQ�aBT}RU[9dk\/ags7Rjd��O�V`dqrVYXmQ��kbWVYs�VYacb,q,\�w)TW\V^zURys�T�[cf�_�Ve[g_zUVpT}[�TW\/acd��Rys�V`dX:zjV`s}se�`#Ld�TW\�VkRUd&T}Veb}V`s�T}s5[cf#sW_agqeVgwf#^s�\/aczjz(zjRUQSRUT5Q5�)sWVezUf7TW[�TW\agd��)RUdnTW\[9sWV��7\[9sWV�qe[gd&TWb}RjP�O:TWRj[gdkTW[�T}\�Rjs7TW\�VYs�Rys7\a9s�P/V`Ved�QS[gb}V�X�RUb}V`qrT`�

#�Q�Os�T^|b,s�TpT}\acd��Q5��_agbWV`d9T,s��7\�[�\a�o9VSzURjogVYX��7RUTW\�RUQSQSVedsWV�ngb}RjVrf[gd�Q5��agqeqe[gO�d&TYw�agdX;�gVeT5d�V`ogV`b^zU[&s�T�\�[g_�V Rjd QSVkagdX;�gV`_:T5�7RysW\�RUdnmTW\�VP�V`s�T�f{[9b�QSVg�$#�sW\aczjzDf{[gb}Veo9Veb#P�V�ngb,aBTWVef{O�z�T}[ T}\�VeRjb�_�b}a��9Veb,s�[9d�Q���P�Ve\agz¡f��t T�� # � w � [gQSQ5����agspa�ngb}V`acT^agX:o)Rys�[9b`wH_�b}[Bo)RjX�RUd�nZT}\�V��)RUd/X�[gf�sWO�_�_�[gbWT`wVed/qr[gOb}agngVeQSV`d9T#agdX�f{b}VeVYX:[gQ TW\acT#f{V`�2ngb,agX:OacTWV�s�TWO/X:Ved&T}s�qeagdm\�[g_�V^f{[9b`�#(sWRjdqrV`bWV`zU��T}\acd� \�RjQ f{[9b7\�Rjs7s�TWV`�iagb}Xs�\�Rj_Z[cf*T}\�Rys��?\] _�bW[9ngb,acQ����acd)� _�Ve[9_�zjVm\�Vezj_/VYX�QSV�aBT�oBacb}RU[9OsSs�T,acn9V`sS[cf�TW\RjsST}\�V`sWRys�RUd8T}Veb}QSs

[cf7qr[:X:V�agdX;X:Rjs}qrO/sWsWRU[9ds`���mRU�9V��g[9d�V`s�n&a�ogV�QSVSTW\�V�Rjd)o�agzUO/acP�zjV�qr[:X:V�f{[gbP�O�RjzyX:RUdn�QS[gb}_�\agP�zjV1QS[:X:VezysewgN:\a��9agd^�mO��)\�Veb���VeVi��agsDaczj�ia��:sH_acTWRjVed&T��7R¡T}\Q��SQ�acd)��~&O�V`s�TWRj[gd/s1[9dksWO�_�_�[gbWT(ogVYq�T}[gbiQSa9q,\�Rjd�V`siacdX �mRU�9V$*�b}Ved�T,acO�n9\&TQSV�agP/[9O:T��ia�o9VezjVrT}s`� � \�[9QSa9s#¥�VeT�T}VebYw V X:n&acb *�s�O�d/a�wH¥�[gzj�gV`b�hizyacd�¨9w t d:�TW[9d�Rj[ � [gb}b}agzUPaw1l(\�RU�Bag\�R¡T}[ �ac�Ba���RjQ�a�w1��acbWTWRjd8N)¨`O�QSQ�V`b`w " �9agd " RUf{�&Rjd�whiVeb}dX�«�V`RjsWVezjV�acd/Xpac\�pa��<N)Od�n �iVeb}VmogVeb}��\Vezj_:f{O�z��7\�Ved #Sd�V`V`X:VYX\�V`zU_��p��agbW�)_acT�acd/X W agX�R¤w-Rjd�TW\VeRjb�[B�7d�Rjd�RjQSR¡T,acP�zjV5��a��:s�Q�agX�V�Q���s�T}a��aBT�lih�li�;s�QS[)[cT}\macdXkzURjogV`zU�9�� RUdagzUzj�gw�#�QSa9X:V�s�[9QSV�ogVeb}��sW_/VYqrRyacz�f{b}RUV`dX�spRjd�h�l�N�agdX lih�li�<�7\[

Q�agX:V�a^n9bWVYaBTiX�R �-Veb}VedqeVgw)d�[gTi[9d�zU��T}[�Q����i[gb}��RUdZacdX�[9O:T�[cf�T}\�V�X�Ve_agb�TW�QSVed&T`w)P�O�T�agzjsW[^T}[�Q���n9bW[B��T}\�agsia�_�Veb,sW[gd���N)RyX�X:\agb�T}\�T}agO�ng\&TiQ�V�\�[B��T}[P�V�akng[)[:X�RyX:V`agzURys�T`w " a���V`sW\�\�[B��T}[kP�V�a n9[&[:Xmb}V`agzURys�T�agdX � [gd)��\�[B�2T}[agqrTWOagzUzj� X:[�T}\�RUdn9s`�

Page 6: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� ��������� �

�������� � � ���a���

#Ld�bWVYqrVed&T��gVYacb,sew�TW\V�_�bW[9P�zjVeQ�[cf�X:VrT}V`qrTWRjd�nmacdX�acdagzU�)¨eRjd�nkf�agqeV`s�\ags�P�Vr�qr[9QSV�a�qe[gb}Vi_bW[9P�zUV`Q [cf-qr[9Q�_O:T}acTWRj[gdagz:o&RysWRU[9d�� � \Rjs�_�b}[gPzUV`Q \ags�_bW[Bo9V`XTW[�P�V�q,\agzUzjVedngRjd�nSd�[cT#[9d�zj��f{b}[gQ T}\�V^_�Veb,s�_�V`qrTWRjogVp[gf�T}\�V�qr[9ngd�RUTWRjogVps}qrRjVed:�TWRys�T��7\�[ s�V`Ve�:s�TW[�OdX:Veb,s�T}acd/X�T}\�VmQSV`q,\agd�Rys�Q�s�O�d/X:Veb}zU�)Rjd�n;_/V`b}qeVe_:T}OaczT}a9s��:s�P�O:Tpaczys�[�f{bW[9QGTW\�V�_/[9RUd&T�[cf?o)RjVe� [gf1acd�V`d�ngRjd�V`Veb#�7\[ZsWVeV`�)s#TW[ZX:Vr�sWRUn9d�s��:s�TWVeQ�s�f{[9b�T}\�V5X:VeTWVYq�TWRj[gd�agdX�agdaczj�:s�Rys7[cf�f�a9qrV`s`� #LdmTW\Rjs�TW\�VYs�Rysew��iVs�TWOX:�magdX�qr[9QS_acb}VpTW\V5b}[gzjV`s#[cf�TW[9_:�LX:[B�7d�acdX�P/[gT�TW[9Q���O�_�_�b}[)qeV`s}s�VYs�Rjdf�agqeRjagz*acd/aczj�)sWRyse�G#Ld�TW\�V^_bW[:qrVYsWs`w��iV^s�V`Ve� TW[ a9X�X:b}V`s}s7a�~&O�V`s�TWRj[gd�Rjd�qr[gn9d�RU�TWRjogV�sWqeRUV`dqrV#agP/[9O:T1T}\�V#b}[gzjV7[cfHT}[g_:�LX:[B�7d�Rjd:f{[gb}Q�aBT}RU[9d�Rjd�_�Veb,qrV`_:TWOagzT,agsW�:sacd/X�agzjsW[m_�b}[Bo)RjX:V�amX�V`sWRUn9d;f{[gb�a�sW�:s�T}VeQ TW\acT�qeagd;P/V�T}b}agRUdV`X�f{[gb^f�agqrRyaczacd/aczj�)sWRyse�� \�V5s}qrRjVed&T}R¡|/qr��PRU[9zU[9ngRyqeacz�~9OV`s�TWRj[gd�[gf?_/V`b}qeVe_:T}RU[9d�\ags�P�VeVed�agX�X:b}V`s}sWV`X

Rjd;TW\�V�T}\�Ve[9bW��[cf�qr[9QS_�O:T}acTWRj[gdagz?o)RjsWRj[gd�� t s�_�b}[g_�[gO�dX�V`X�P)����agbWb�� u9u���wTW\Rjs#TW\�V`[gb}�ko)RjVe��s�o)RjsWRU[9d�ags�a�_�O�b}Vezj�ZP/[gT�TW[9Q���O�_<�§f{VeVYX)��f{[gb}�iagb}X�7_�bW[:qeV`s}s�7\�V`bWVpacd�Rjd�_�O:T�bWV`_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd [gf�T}\�V^RjQ�acngVpRys�qe[gd)ogV`b�T}V`X�Rjd�s�T}acn9V`siT}[�af{O�zjz¡� �VYX:ngVYX5u9]�bWV`_�bWVYs�V`d&T}aBT}RU[9d�� t zUz/X:[gQ�acRjd:�Ls�_�V`qeR¡|�q1�)d�[B�7zjV`X:n9V(Rys�o)RUV`�(VYXags*P/V`RUdn�\agb}X:��qe[)X�V`X�Rjd^TW\Viagb}q,\�RUTWVYq�T}O�bWV1[cf:TW\V(P�[cTWTW[gQ���O�_^_�b}[:qrVYsWs`��«#[B���Veo9VebYw-bWRjng\&T#f{b}[gQGT}\�V5TWRjQ�VS[gf W V`s�T}agz¡T�_sW�)q,\[gzj[gngRys�T}s����[g\�zjVeb�� x U �{��R¡T�\agsP�VeVed8s�\[B�7d�TW\acTSa�_�b}RU[9bWR([gb}n9agd�RU¨YaBT}RU[9dacz(_�bWRjdqeRU_�zjV`s5QSRUn9\&T�_�zya���a�qebWO��qrRyacz�b}[gzjV�Rjd�V`ogV`d�ogV`bW�msWRUQS_�zjVS_/V`b}qeVe_:T}Oacz�Ve£)_�Veb}RjVedqeV`s`� � \�V`sWV�_�bWRjdqeRU_�zjV`s�iVeb}V�sWO�_�_�[9sWV`XkT}[�P�V^d�V`O�b,aczjzU��V`dqr[:X:VYX�acdXZQS[9s�TWzj� O�d/qr[gd/sWqeRU[9Ose�?��aBT}VebYwhibWOd�Veb�� + ��s�\�[B�iV`XkT}\aBT#_�Veb,qrV`_:TWRj[gd�Q�a�� P�V�n9O�RyX:V`XZP)�Zqe[gds}qrRj[gO/s�P/V`zURjVrf�sacd/X�Vr£:_�V`q�T,aBT}RU[9dse� t ngb}V`acT5X:V`agz�[cf�_sW�:q,\�[c��_�\)�:s�Ryqeagz1b}V`sWO�z¡T,s�\/a�ogV�P�VeV`dagXX:OqrVYX�RUd�sWO�_�_�[gbWT#[gf�TW\�VYs�V�qezjagRUQ�s`�7«�[B�iVeogV`b`w�TW\�Rys#Rjd��OVedqeV^[cf�O�dqe[gd:�s}qrRj[gOs�[9bWn&acd�Rj¨`acTWRj[gdagz�_�b}RjdqrRj_�zjV`sp[9b�qe[gds}qrRj[gO/s�P/V`zURjVrf�s^agdX�Vr£:_�V`q�T,aBT}RU[9dsew[cf§T}Ved�zj[)[9sWVezj�Zq`aczjzUVYX�TW[9_:�LX:[B�7dmRUd �O�Ved/qrV`s�\a9s#d�[gT�P�VeV`d��iVezjz¡��O�dX:V`b}s�TW[)[:Xf{b}[gQ a�qe[gQS_�O:T,aBT}RU[9dacz�_�Veb,sW_/VYq�TWRjogVm�7RUTW\�bWV`n9acb,X�s5TW[�R¡T,s�b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd

&

Page 7: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

acd/X RUT}s7Rjd&TWV`b}a9q�TWRj[gdZ�7RUTW\�P/[gT�T}[gQ���O_k_�b}[:qrVYsWsWV`s`�" V`qeVed&T^s�T}OX:RjV`s���lia�o�agdacn9\ � !S! ��w*�mOQ5f{[9b}X � uY( ��w �9[gd�VYsew*N:RUd�\/a�w�VeTpagz¤�� u % �{��\a�o9V�acd/aczj�&¨`V`XJa9s�_�V`qrT}sk[cfpTW[9_:�LX:[B�7dJRUd �O�Ved/qrV`skRjd�o)RjsWRU[9dJf{b}[gQ a

qr[9QS_�O:T}acTWRj[gdagzc_�Veb,s�_�V`qrTWRjogVg� � \�RjzUV�T}\�V`sWV1s�TWOX�RUVYs*\a�o9V�P/V`Ved^QS[cT}RUoBacTWV`X�P)�s}qrRjVed&TWRU|/q���P�Rj[gzj[gn9Rjq`acz)~9OV`s�TWRj[gds`wcT}\�Ve�5\a�ogVibWV`zURjV`X�[9d5QS[:X:Vezys�f{b}[gQ Q�a9q,\�RUdVo)RjsWRj[gd�f{[gbpb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&TWRjd�nkTW[9_:��X�[B�7d�Rjd:f{[gb}Q�aBT}RU[9d�� #Ld�lia�o�agdacn9\ � !S! ��w�T}[g_:�X:[B�7d�Rjd:f{[gb}Q�aBTWRj[gd�Rys7b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&TWVYXka9s7_�b}[cT}[cT��)_/VYs7[cf�[gP ��V`q�T#qezja9sWsWV`s#s�T}[gb}V`XRjdZQSV`Q�[9bW�k�7\�Ryq,\�agbWV�OsWV`XZT}[�Q�aBT}q,\�Rjd�_�O:T�RUQ�acn9V`s`� #Ld �g[9d�V`s`w/N)Rjd�\awVeTacz�� � u % ��w�a�QS[gb}_�\agP�zUV5QS[)X�Vez7��hiVe�)QSVebpagdX���[9ngngRj[� u ��wH¥�VrT�T}Vebpacd/X���[gng�ngRj[ � (9x ��w �g[9d�V`s7agdX���[gn9ngRj[�� x ���{��b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}s(T}[g_:�LX:[B�7dZRUd:f{[9bWQ�acTWRj[gd�� � \VzyaBT�T}Veb��i[gb}� aczysW[�Vr£:_�zj[gb}V`s�TW\VmRUQS_�zjRjq`aBT}RU[9ds�[cf�TW[9_:�LX:[B�7d�RUd��/O�VedqeV`s�[9dRjQ�Q5O�d�RUT���T}[Zd[gRys�V�acd/X�QSRysWsWRjd�n�RUd�_O:T`� #Ld;P�[cT}\�T}\�V`sWV��i[gb}�)s`w-TW\V�Rjs}s�OV[cfiTW\V�RUd&TWV`b}a9q�T}RU[9d�[gf(T}[g_:�LX:[B�7d�Rjd��OVedqeV`sp[9d�P�[cTWTW[9Q5��O�_;_�b}[:qrV`s}sWV`s�\agsP�VeVed�agdsW�(V`bWVYX�P)��Rjd)og[9�&Rjd�n�TW\V�sWqeVedagbWRj[�[cf�acdagzU�:sWRjs�P)��s��)d&TW\�VYs�Rys`�D�mOQ5�f{[gb,X � s � uY( ����acT�TWV`bWd � \Ve[gb}�;aczys�[�b}VezjRjV`s^[9d�acd/aczj�)sWRys^P)��s��)d&TW\�VYs�Ryspf{[9b5RUT}sVr£:_�zyacd/aBTWRj[gdZ[cfD_/V`b}qeVe_:T}RU[9d��1«#[B�(V`ogVebYw)s�Oq,\ZT}[cT}agzHbWV`zURyacd/qrV�[gdmacd�acd/aczj�)sWRysP)� sW�&d&T}\�V`sWRjs7ag_�_�b}[9a9q,\ _�b}V`sWVed&T}s(T��i[S_�bW[9P�zjVeQ�se©

� t daczj�:s�Rys�P)��sW�)d9T}\�V`sWRys�RUdSn9Ved�V`b}agz:bWV`zURjV`s�[9dSa�T}bWRjo)Rjagz�P/[gT�T}[gQ���O_�_bW[g�qeV`s}s1R�� Vg��[gd�V#�7\�Veb}V�T}\�Veb}V#Rys1d[pTWb,acds�f{[gb}Q�aBT}RU[9d�[cf-TW\�V�Rjd�_�O:T7s�Rjngd/acz��«#[B�(V`ogV`b`w?�iV�X:[;�&d[B�ETW\acTSTW\�V�Rjd�_�O:T���bWVeTWRjdacz§�5RUQ�acn9VkRjd�acd8[gbW�n&acd�RysWQ@O�dX�Veb}ng[)V`s�sW[gQSV�qr[9QS_�zUVe£�T}b}agds�f{[9bWQ�acTWRj[gds`� � \�Rys�b,acRys�VYsDTW\�V~&O�VYs�T}RU[9d�©��7\)��X:[)V`s(TW\�V�Rjd�_�O:T7RjQSagngV�O�dX:V`bWn9[5a�qr[9Q�_zUVe£�T}b}agds�f{[gbW�Q�acTWRj[gd�acd/Xm�7\aBT�bWV`zjacTWRj[gdmqr[9O�zjXmTW\�Rys7T}b}agds�f{[9bWQ�acTWRj[gd�\a�ogV�T}[kagd&�T}[g_:�LX:[B�7d5RUd:f{[9bWQ�acTWRj[gd��@#Ld�ngVedVeb,acz�wB�(V7sW\�[gO�zyX5Vr£:_/VYq�T�TW\V(T}b}agds�f{[gbW�Q�acTWRj[gds(RUd TW\�V�P�[cT�T}[gQ���O�_�_�b}[:qrV`s}s1TW[�P�V�a��-V`q�T}V`X�P)�ST}\�V#b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed��T,aBT}RU[9d5[gf/T}[g_:�LX:[B�7d�Rjd:f{[9bWQ�aBT}RU[9d�agdX5o&RyqrVe��o9Veb,sWa� � \�Rys�agsW_/VYq�T�[cf/TW\�V_bW[9P�zUV`Q Rys7d�[cT�a9X�X:b}V`s}s�VYX RjdZTW\�V^agdaczj�:s�RysiP&�ks��)d&TW\�VYs�Rys7s}qrVed/acb}RU[/�

� t daczj�:s�Rys�P)��sW�&d&T}\�V`sWRjsDRjdSngVedVeb,acz)�([9bW�:s�[gd�zj�pT}\�bW[9O�ng\�RUTWVeb,aBT}RUo9V(_bW[g�qeV`X:ObWVYse�@#�T�bWV`zURjV`s^[gd�ams�VYacb,q,\�Rjd�TW\�Vks�_a9qrV�[gfi_agb}agQSVrTWV`b}s�b}Ve_bWVe�sWVed&T}RUd�n5TW\V�T}[g_:�LX:[B�7d���QS[:X:Vez��^T}[�|/dX�T}\�V�P/VYs�T7_agb}agQSVrTWV`b}s(�7\�Ryq,\QSRjd�RjQ�Rj¨eV�sW[gQSV5f{[gb}Q [cfiVeb}bW[9b#QSV`a9s�ObWV�P/VeT��(V`Ved�TW\�VSQS[:X:Vez1RUQ�acn9VagdX�T}\�V5Rjd�_�O�T�RjQSagngV9�h#Ld�_�b,agqrTWRyqrV9wT}\�Rjs�Rys�a9q,\�RUV`ogVYXZTW\�b}[gO�n9\�s�[9QSV�)RjdXZ[cfDngb,agX:RjVed&T���Pa9s�VYX sWV`acb,q,\ �7\Rjq,\ZRjs#qr[gQS_�O�T}aBT}RU[9daczjzj��RUd&TWV`dsWRUo9VagdXSs�V`VeQ�s�zjV`s}s�_zjagOs�RjP�zjV7ngRjogV`d^TW\V�qr[gQS_�zjVr£:RUT��^Rjd&o9[gzjogVYX^Rjd5T}\�ViT}a9s��[gfD_�Veb,qrV`_:TWO/aczHb}V`qr[9ngd�RUTWRj[gd*�

ª�d�zjRj�gV�TW\�V�T}[g_:�LX:[B�7dk_�bW[:qeV`s}s�VYsew&TW\V�P�[cTWTW[9Q5��O�_Z_�b}[)qeV`s}s�VYsiRUdZ_/V`b}qeVe_:�TWRj[gd�\a�ogV1sWVeV`d^Vr£)T}VedsWRUo9V1Rjd)ogV`s�TWRjn9acTWRj[gd�f{b}[gQ2a#qe[gQS_�O:T,aBT}RU[9dacz9_/V`b}sW_/VYq�T}RUo9Vacd/X^ac_�_zURyqeacTWRj[gd^Rjd^oBacb}RU[9Os�Ved�n9RUd�V`Veb}RUdn#s��:s�TWV`QSs`�DN:VeogV`b}agzgo)Rys�Rj[gd^_bW[9P�zUV`Q�sb,acd�n9RUd�nZf{b}[gQ TW\�VkzU[B�EagdX;QSV`X:RjO�Q¦zUV`ogV`z1[gdV`s^sWOq,\ ags�V`X:n9V X:VeTWV`qrTWRj[gd�w

Page 8: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

X:V`_:TW\�V`s�TWRjQ�aBT}RU[9d�agdXk[g_:T}Rjq`acz �[B��TW[STW\Vp\�RUn9\�zUV`ogVezH[9d�V`s7sWOq,\�ags7s�TWb}Oq��TWObWV1f{bW[9Q%QS[gTWRj[gd�agdXp[gP ��V`q�T�b}V`qr[9ngd�RUTWRj[gd*w`\a�o9V?P�VeVed�qea9s�TDRUd�a�P�[cT�T}[gQ���O�_Q�acd�dVeb�acdX^agzUn9[gb}R¡T}\�Q�s*sWO�ngn9V`s�TWVYX�f{[gb�TW\�V`RUbDRjQ�_zUV`Q�V`d&T}aBT}RU[9d�� � \�V1f{b,acQSVe��i[gb}��[cfHzjV`agbWd�Rjd�n�T}\�Ve[9bW��\ags?_�bW[Bo9V`X�_agb�T}RjqeO�zjagbWzj�5sWOq`qrV`s}s�f{O�z�f{[9b1QS[:X:VezjRUdnqrV`b�T,acRjdm_�\�V`d�[gQSVed[gd�sWOq,\�ags#[gP���VYq�T�X�VrTWVYq�T}RU[9d�ags�a�P�[cT�T}[gQ���O�_�_�b}[:qrV`s}s`�N&T,aBTWRys�TWRyqeacz���VYacb}d�Rjd�nmTW\Ve[gb}�;�ia9s�X:V`ogV`zU[9_/VYX�P)��¥?ac_�d�Rj��acdX�qr[c���i[gb}�gVeb,s� (cv:w %YU w ( ! ��ags�TW\�V�_�bW[9P�zjVeQ [gf^V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWRjd�n Rjd�_�O�T���[gO:T}_�O:Tkb}VezyaBT}RU[9dsW\�RU_/sf{b}[gQ VeQS_�RjbWRyqeagzX�aBT,a���#LdX:V`_/V`dX:Ved&T}zU�9w9T}\�V7T}\�Ve[9bW��[cfHb}VengOzjagbWRj¨`acTWRj[gdSX:Veo9VezU�[g_�V`X�P&� � Rj�)\�[gd[Bo�agdX t b}sWVed�Rjd � % u��H��agsiac_�_zURjV`X�TW[5a5zjV`acb}d�Rjd�n^_�b}[gPzUV`QZwdagQ�V`zU��VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}RUdn d�V`O�b}agz�dVrT��i[gb}�Zagb}q,\�RUTWVYq�T}O�bWVYsew�P)� W RUb}[9sWR¤w �9[gd�VYs�agdX��[gn9ngRj[ � xgv���� � \�Rys��([9bW��f{[gO�d/X�ac__�zURyqeacTWRj[gd^Rjd^T}\�V�X:VrT}V`q�T}RU[9d�[gf:f�agqrVYs��¤N)O�dnacd/X ��[gn9ngRj[�� % v���w " [B�7zjVe�9w)h�agzUO���aw:VrT�acz�� � xcu��{��w:_�V`X:VYs�T}bWRyacd/s7acdXkqeacb,s�����ac�_agngVe[9bWn9RU[9OmVrTpacz�� � U �§�r� #Ld�T}\�V`sWV�ac_�_bW[&agq,\�VYs7TW[9_�X:[B�7d�RUd�f{[gb}QSacTWRj[gd��ia9sRjdqr[9bW_�[gb,aBT}V`XST}\�bW[9O�ng\Za�zjagP/V`zUVYX�T}b}agRUd�Rjd�nSs�VeT�acdXkac_�_�V`agb}s�agsi_agb�T7[gf�TW\�VTWb,acRjd�Rjd�n;_�\a9s�Vm[9d�zU�9� � \�VeTW\�V`b�T}[g_:�LX:[B�7d�RUd �O�Ved/qrV`s�\a�ogVmacd)��f{O�b�T}\�Vebs�TWb}Oq�T}O�bWV�acd/X RUf�T}\�Ve� _�zja���agd)��bW[9zUV�RUdZT}\�Vpagq�T}OaczH_�Veb,qrV`_:TWO/acz�T}a9s���Rys�d�[gTqrzjV`agb`�� \�V�s�TWO/X:�S[cfHTW\V�TW[9_:�LX:[B�7d�acdXSP�[cTWTW[9Q5��O�_�_bW[:qrVYsWsWV`s?Rjs(bWV`zUV`oBacd&T1d�[gT

QSVeb}Vezj��f{[gb�TW\�V�sWqeRUV`d&TWRU|/q?O�d/X:Veb,s�T,acdX�RUd�n�[cf_�Veb,qrV`_:TWRj[gd�P�O:T�aczys�[#f{[gb�TW\�V�X:Vr�sWRUn9d [cf*TWV`q,\d�[gzj[gn9RUVYs?T}\aBT7QSRUQSRyq�\&OQSagd _�Veb,qrV`_:TWOagz�qeag_agqeR¡T}RUVYsew)acdX TW\)Os\a9s^ac_�_zURyqeacTWRj[gd;RUd<a�o�agbWRjVrT���[cf7Q�acd:��Q�agq,\�Rjd�V�Rjd&TWVebWf�agqeV`s`� t s�a�n9Ved�V`b}agzb}O�zUV9w)Q�[&s�T�sW�:s�T}VeQ�s(TW\acT7sWVeV`�STW[�QSRUQSRyq�\)O�Q�agdk_�Veb,qrV`_:TWRj[gd�w�X�[5d�[gT�f{O�dq��TWRj[gd��7R¡T}\�[gO:T�b}V`qr[9O�b,s�V�T}[�acd)�pqr[9ds�TWb,acRjd9T,sewYP�O:T�Rjds�T}V`a9XpbWV`zU��[9d�a�oBacb}RjVrT���[cfqr[9ds�TWb,acRjd9T,s�T}\aBTpV`dqr[:X:VS_�\)�:s�Ryqeagz¤wHPRU[9zU[9ngRyqeacz�acd/X�V`qe[gzj[gn9Rjq`aczD�&d[B�7zUVYX:ngV9�� [9b#T}\�V5T}agsW��[cf1\RUn9\�VebW��zjVeo9Vez�_/V`b}qeVe_:T}RU[9d�wH_�\)�:s�RyqeagzDqe[gds�TWb,acRjd&T}s#agbWV5RUd/s�O:f§�|/qeRUV`d9T�acdX�P�Rj[gzj[gngRyqeagz�agdXmV`qe[gzj[gn9Rjq`acz�qe[gds�TWb,acRjd&T}s�acb}V�\agb}X�T}[ b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&TY�� \�V`bWVef{[gb}Vgw:s��:s�TWV`QSs7sWOq,\mags(T}\�Vp[gd�VYs�_/V`b�f{[9bWQSRjd�nS[gP���VYq�T�b}V`qe[gngdR¡T}RU[9d�w)RUd:�qrb}V`a9s�Rjd�n9zU�5bWV`zU��[gd�Q�acd)Oagz/agd�d�[cT,aBT}RU[9d�ags1a�QSV`acd/s?[cf�RjdsWVebWTWRjd�npT}[g_:�LX:[B�7d�)d�[B�7zjV`X:n9Vg� t d)��s�T}Ve_�T,ac�gV`d�TW[B��acb,X�s?a�ngV`d�Veb,acz�acdX�s�TWb}OqrTWO�b}V`XSb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed��T}acTWRj[gd [gf#P�Rj[gzj[gn9Rjq`acz(agdX�VYqr[gzj[gn9Rjq`acziqr[gd/s�T}b}agRUd&T}s�RUd\�Veb}Ved&T5Rjd T}\�VZ\&OQSagd_�Veb,qrVe_�TWOagz_�b}[:qrV`s}s��i[gO�zyXSQ�ac�9V�TW\�V#T}agsW��[cf�X:V`sWRjngd�Rjd�npT}\�V`sWV#sW�)s�TWV`Q�s1sWRUng�d�RU|/qeagd&TWzj��V`a9s�RjVebY�

#Ld T}\�Rys1T}\�V`sWRysew:�iV�sWVeV`�STW[�o)RUV`�JTW[9_:��X�[B�7d�RUd �O�Ved/qrV`s�Rjdka5QS[gb}V�s�TWb}Oq��TWObWVYX�Q�acd�dVebpacdX�_�b}[Bo)RjX:V�aksW_�V`qrRU|/q�b}[gzjV^f{[gb�T}[g_:�LX:[B�7d�Rjd:f{[9bWQ�aBT}RU[9d�RjdTW\V�P�[cTWTW[9Q5��O�_Z_�b}[)qeV`s}se�f#LdZ_acbWTWRyqrOzjagb`w9TW\�VpP�[cTWTW[9Q5��O�_Z_�b}[)qeV`s}s1Rys7qea9s�T7RjdTW\V5f{b,acQSV`�([9bW�m[gf(zjV`acb}d�Rjd�nZ�7\�Veb}V�T}\�V�ng[&acz�Rys�TW[�zUVYacb}d�aZQ�ac_�_RUd�nZf{b}[gQacd�Rjd�_�O�T�sW_agqeV�TW[�agd [gO�TW_�O:TSs�_/agqrV9� � \�V�Rjd�_�O:TSs�_/agqrV Rjs�T��)_�Rjq`aczjzU��TW\�VsW_agqeV�[gfisWVedsW[gb}��X�acT}aZ[gbp[9Ps�V`bWoBagP�zUVYs�acdX�TW\�V�[9O:TW_O:T�s�_/agqrVSb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T,sTW\V�qeaBT}Ven9[gb}RUVYs5Ve£:_/V`bWRjVedqeV`X8Rjd8_�Veb,qrV`_:TWRj[gd*� � \�VmP�[cTWTW[gQ���O�_�_�b}[)qeV`s}sSRjsb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&TWVYXmP)�mTW\V5f{Odq�T}RU[9d�[9P:T}agRUdV`X�P)��zjV`agbWdRUd�n/w�TW\acT^QSag_s�TW\�V�sWVed:�sW[gb}� X�aBT,aSTW[�TW\�VpT}\�V�_�Veb,qrV`_:TWO/acz�q`aBT}Veng[9bWRjV`s`� � V�sWO�ngn9V`s�T7TW\acT#T}[g_:�LX:[B�7dRjd:f{[gb}Q�aBTWRj[gdSsW\�[gO�zyX�s�_�V`qeR¡f{��a�s�TWb}OqrTWO�b}V�[gd�TW\�V7[9O:TW_O:T1s�_/agqrV�[9b�TW\�V�sW_agqeV

Page 9: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� RUn9O�b}V ! � ! © t P�zj[:q,��X�V`sWRUn9dSf{[gb(a5s��:s�TWV`Q@T}\aBTiQ�RjQSRjq`s1_�Veb,qrV`_:TWO/acz-acP�RjzURUT��g�� \�Vpb}[gzjV�[cfDTW[g_���X:[B�7dZ�)d�[B�7zjV`X:n9V�Rys7Rjd�\�Veb}Ved&T�Rjd�QSagd)Oacz�agd�d�[cT,aBT}RU[9dZagdXRUT5qeagd;qe[gdqeVeRjoBacP�zj��P�V�b}Ve_�zyagqeV`X�P)��s�TWb}Oq�T}O�b}V`s�T}\aBT�QS[:X:V`z1T}\�V sW_agqeV�[cf_�Veb,qrVe_�TWOagz�qeaBT}Ven9[gb}RUVYse�

[cf?_�Veb,qrV`_:TWO/acz�q`aBT}Veng[9bWRjV`s`w[9b#Rjd�[cT}\�Veb��i[gb,X�s7P�V�a�QS[:X:V`z�[gf�TW\�VSs�_/agqrV�[cf_�Veb,qrVe_�TWOagz1qeacTWVen9[gb}RUVYse��«�a�o)RUd�nmsWOq,\�ams�T}bWO/q�TWObWVS�i[gO�zyX;aczjzU[B�4OspT}[mbWVe�_�zyagqeV�TW\�V�QSagd)Oaczagd�d�[gT}aBT}RU[9dS[cf�Vr£�agQ�_zUVYs��7R¡T}\�_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s�[gf�T}\�V#s�TWb}Oq��TWObWV�T}\aBT�QS[)X�Vezys^T}\�V [9O:TW_�O�T�sW_agqeVg� � \�Rys^��a���[cf7_�b}[Bo&RyX:Rjd�nmT}[g_:�LX:[B�7dRjd:f{[gb}Q�aBTWRj[gd8aczjzU[B��s�Os�T}[;QSag�gVkTW\�VmX:VYs�Rjngd8[cf�Q�acd:��Q�agq,\�Rjd�VZRUd&TWV`b�f�a9qrVYsQ�O/q,\mQ�[9bWV^sWVezUf§�Lqr[gd&T,acRjd�V`XHw/bWVY~&O�RUb}Rjd�n�zUVYsWs#Q�acd)Oacz�RUd_�O:T`�h#Ld � Rjn� ! � ! �iVRjzUzjOs�TWb,aBTWV�T}\�Rjs#sWq,\�V`QSV�RjdZTW\�V�f{[9bWQ [cf�a5PzU[:q,� X:Ryacn9b}agQ��� V�X�VeQS[gds�TWb,aBT}V�T}\aBT^sWOq,\�a�sWVezUf§��qe[gd&T}agRUdV`X�Q�agd:��Q�a9q,\�RUdV�Rjd9T}VebWf�agqeV

sW�)s�TWV`Q Rysp_�[9s}s�RjP�zjV�P)��a9X:[g_�TWRjd�n�a�T��i[c��_�bW[9d�ngVYX�ag_�_�b}[9a9q,\�� *�d;T}\�V�[gdV\agdXHw:�iV�sW\�[B��TW\acTiT}\�V�f{b,acQSVe�i[gb}�S[cf�zUVYacb}d�RUdn5Rys7s�OR¡T,acP�zjV�f{[gb7QS[:X:VezjRUdnTW\VZP�[cTWTW[9Q5��O�_<_�bW[:qeV`s}se� � V�\a�ogVZX:VeQS[9ds�T}b}acTWVYX�TW\RjsSP)�;TW\VZO/s�V�[cf�azjV`acb}d�Rjd�nc��Pa9s�VYX�ag_�_�b}[9agq,\�Rjd�TW\�VZacdagzU�:sWRjs^[cf7QS[gO:T}\s ���O�Q�acb5agdX���[gng�ngRj[ � %2+ �{��� #Ld�TW\Rjs`w�T}\�V�zjV`acb}d�Rjd�n�ac_�_�b}[9a9q,\<��V`acb}zjRUV`b^q,\acb,agqrTWVeb}Rj¨eV`X�P)�mTW\�VX:VeTWV`qrTWRj[gdJ_�b}[gPzUV`Q �7\�V`bWV�a�X:Rjs}qrb}VrT}V�[gP ��V`q�TZqrzyags}s��ia9s�V`s�TWRjQ�aBT}V`X���ia9sVr£)T}VedX:VYX;TW[�TW\�VZ_�b}[gP�zjVeQ [cf�V`s�TWRjQSacTWRjd�n�qe[gd&TWRjd)O�[gO/s�~&Oacd&T}R¡T}RUVYs5sWOq,\ ags[g_�Vedd�V`s}s1agdX�s�QSRjzUV#[cfHQS[gO:T}\se� � \�Rys?�i[gb}����ags?Q�[gTWRjoBaBTWVYXSP)��T}\�V#n9[9acz[cfX:VYs�Rjngd�Rjd�n�a�bWVYaczU�¤T}RUQSVpsW�)s�TWV`Q qeag_acPzUV�[cfDzU[:q`aBTWRjd�n�acd/XZagdaczj�)¨eRjd�n�\&OQSagdf�agqeV`s(f{[gb�Ve£)_bWVYsWsWRU[9ds`�;#�T7�i[gb}�)si[9d�TW\V�_bWRjdqrRj_�zjV�[cf�zjV`agbWdRUd�nSa5bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gdf{O�dqrTWRj[gdZf{b}[gQ aS«#a9acb7��a�ogV`zUVeTiPa9s�VYX Rjd�_�O�T�bWV`_�bWVYs�V`d&T}aBT}RU[9d [gf�QS[gO:T}\s�T}[\agdX zyacP�VezjV`XZ_agb}agQSVrTWV`b}s�X:V`d�[cT}RUdn�[9_/V`d�d�VYsWs7agdX�s�QSRjzUV9�«�[B�iVeo9VebYw*T}\�Rjs��([9bW��aczys�[�[g_�Veds�O�_�TW\V _�[9s}s�RjP�RjzURUT���[gf7P/V`RUd�n�acP�zjV�T}[

zjV`acb}d�_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s�[cf�QS[)X�VezyspTW\/aBT�acb}V�qeag_acPzUVS[cf�QS[:X:VezjRUdnmTW\�V�qezja9sWs^[cfQS[gO:T}\s`w*RUf�sWOq,\;QS[)X�Vezys�Vr£:Rjs�T`� � V�qe[gdsWRjX�Vebpa�zURjd�VYacbpQS[gb}_�\agP�zUVSQS[:X:Vezags#acd�ac__�bW[9_�b}RjacTWVps�T}bWO/q�TWObWV�f{[9b�TW\V^[gO:T}_�O:T�s�_a9qrVp[gfDT}\�V^zjV`agbWd�Rjd�n�_�b}[gP��zjVeQ f{[9b?V`s�TWRjQ�aBT}RUd�n�f�a9qrRyacz:Ve£)_bWVYsWsWRU[9d�� � V�zjV`agbWd�bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gd�f{O�dqrTWRj[gds?TW\acT

Page 10: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

Q�ac_p_�RU£:VezU��P/agsWV`X�bWV`_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gds-[gf)RjQ�acn9V`sHRjd&TW[7T}\�V1_agb}agQSVrTWV`b}s-[gf�a7QS[gbW�_�\agP�zjV1QS[:X:Vez�� � VisW\�[B��TW\/aBT*T}\�Rys�\/ags*ag_�_�zjRjq`aBT}RU[9ds*Rjd�X:R �-Veb}Ved&TDa9s�_�V`qrT}s�[cfQ�acd:��Q�agq,\�Rjd�ViRUd&T}VebWf�agqrVYs�RUd/qrzjOX:Rjd�npVr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gd5bWVYqr[9ngd�RUTWRj[gd�wBo)Rys�V`QSV7bWVYqr[gng�d�RUTWRj[gd�agdX�_�[9sWV?V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWRj[gd*�R#LdpT}\�V1d�Ve£)T*T��i[�s�VYq�TWRj[gd/sewBa7P�b}RjVrf�Pa9q,�&n9bW[9O�dX[gdkTW\V`sWV^ac_�_�b}[9a9q,\�V`s(Rys�_�bW[Bo)RyX:V`X��

����� ?@�A���B������1 &®�f�:9;��"�"=�#�/��>�3 EG������H��=����) E� �%��� � "$�0� ����H��6"$�A� &'�f� D����%������EG������H��=���

t sW�:s�T}VeQ q`ac_agP�zjVp[cf�zU[:qeacTWRjd�n�\)O�Q�acdZf�agqeV`s�agdXmacd/aczj�&¨`RUdnSagdXZV`s�TWRjQ�aBT��Rjd�n T}\�VSVr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gd/s�T}\�Veb}VeRjd�Rjd�b}V`agzDTWRjQ�VS\a9s�ac_�_�zjRyqeaBT}RU[9ds�RUd�Rjd9T}VezjzURjngV`d&TQ�acd:��Q�agq,\�Rjd�V5RUd&TWV`b�f�a9qrVYs�agdX�Rjd�[cTW\VebpX:[gQ�agRUds�sWOq,\�a9s�o9Veb}��zU[B� P/acdX)��7RyX)TW\mo)RyX:Ve[�qe[gd:f{V`bWV`dqrRjd�nwo&RjbWTWOagz*agqrTW[gb�acdXZo)RjX�Ve[�V`QSagRUz�� � \�Vp_�b}[gP�zjVeQRys^X:R X�qeO�zUT�P/VYqeagOs�V�RUT^Rjd&o9[gzjogVYspams�V`bWRjV`s�[gf�X:R X�qrO�zUT^T,agsW�)s�VYagq,\;[cf��7\�Ryq,\Q�O/s�TpP�V�s�O2X�qeRUV`d9T}zU��bW[9P�Os�T`� � \�V�Q�acRjd�T}agsW�:s�RUd�sWOq,\;aZsW�:s�T}VeQ q`acd�P/VsWO�QSQSagbWRj¨eVYXka9sif{[gzjzU[B��s`�! ��]�VrT}V`qrT�acdXkzj[)q`aczjRU¨`V�f�agqrVYs�RUdmaSqrzjO:TWTWVeb}V`XZPa9q,�)ngb}[gO�dX��x���]�VrT}V`qrT�acd/Xkzj[:qeagzURj¨eV�X�R �-Veb}Ved&T7f�agqeRjagz�f{VYaBTWObWVYs�s�O/q,\�a9s7Ve�9V`s`wd�[&s�T}bWRjzysagdXZQS[gO:T}\��

u� t daczj�)¨eV�T}\�V`sWV�bWV`ngRj[gds(TW[�VYs�T}RUQ�acTWVps�OR¡T,acP�zjVp_acb,acQSVeTWVeb,s`�� \�V^�9Ve� TW\�V`[gb}VrTWRyqeagz�RysWsWO�V`s7TW\acT�d�V`V`XZTW[�P�V5a9X�X:b}V`s}s�VYX�T}[�f�agqeRUzjRUT}aBT}V�sWOq,\amb}V`agz¡��TWRjQSV s��:s�TWV`Q agbWVST}\�V RjQ�acngV bWV`_�bWVYs�V`d&T}aBT}RU[9dspOsWV`X�f{[9b�VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}RU[9d[cf?X:R �-Veb}Ved&T#f{VYaBTWObWVYs#acd/Xm_acb,acQSVeTWVeb,s�agdX�TW\V5aczjng[9bWRUTW\QSs�Os�VYX�f{[gb#TW\�V`RUbV`s�TWRjQ�aBT}RU[9d��� a9qrRyacz&_aBTWTWVeb}ds�acd/X�TW\�V`RUb�q,\agd�ngVYs*q`acd5qe[gd)ogV`��a#�7RjX�V(b,acd�n9V?[cf/Vr£:_�b}V`s��

sWRU[9dsew�acdX�b}VengOzjacTWV�s�_�[g�9Ved;qr[9d&o9Veb,sWacTWRj[gd�acdX�s�[:qeRjagz�RUd&TWV`b}a9q�T}RU[9d�� � a9qrV`sacb}VS\�Rjng\�zj��X��&d/acQSRjqS_/aBT�T}Veb}dsp�7\�Ryq,\�O�dX�Veb}ng[�Q�acd)��d�[9d:��bWRjngRyX�T}b}agds�f{[gbW�Q�aBT}RU[9dse���mOq,\�[gf/T}\�V#_bWV`o&Rj[gO/s��([9bW��TW[^qeag_:TWObWV�f�a9qrRyacz/X�Vrf{[gb}Q�aBT}RU[9ds�\agsb}VezjRUVYX�\�V`a�o)RjzU�k[gd�T��i[Sf{[gb}QSs#[cf�_agb}agQ�VeTWV`bWRj¨`agP�zUVpQS[:X:V`zjs`wdagQSVezj�gw�ngVe[9Q��VrT}bW��[cf�f�a9qrV�Q5OsWqeO�zyaBTWObWV�agdX;\�V`a9X�s�\/ac_�V���hizyac�gVkacdX #�s}acb,X � x % ��w V sWs}aacd/X���Ved&T}zjagdX � ! ����w � Veb}¨e[g_�[gOzU[&s�agdX � aBT}Veb,s � % x ��w��?O�RjzjzUVSVrT^agz¤� � ! �§��agdXQS[cT}RU[9d�V`s�TWRjQ�aBT}RU[9d���hizyagq,��acd/X�1agqe[&[9P � ( ��w V ¨`¨`aBT�� !'U �{��� � \�RjzjV�T}\�V�f{[gbW�QSVeb�d�VeVYX�s7T}[�P/V5\acd/X)��qeb}acf§TWVYXHw�T}\�V�zyaBTWTWVeb�bWV`zURjV`s�[gdmb}Ve_�V`aBT}V`X�VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}RU[9d[cf�[9_:TWRyqeagz �[B�%�7\�Rjq,\�q`acdmP�V�qr[9QS_�O:T}acTWRj[gdagzUzj� Rjd&TWV`ds�RjogV9� t dmRjQ�_�[gbWT}agd&TagsW_�V`q�Ti[cf�[9O�b(�i[gb}��Rjs1TW\acT1T}\�V�QS[:X:V`zjs1f{[gb�aczjz/[gf�TW\V�sWO�P:��T}agsW�:s?d�V`V`X:VYX�T}[agq,\RUV`ogV5TW\�V�|/dacz?n9[9agz�Rjs^agO:TW[9Q�aBTWRyqeagzUzj�mzjV`acb}d�VYX�f{b}[gQ Vr£�acQS_�zjV`s`� �m[9bWVe�[BogV`b5RUT�X:[)V`sSd�[gT�QSag�gVZOsWVZ[gf�acd)��u9]GRUd�f{[gb}QSacTWRj[gd<[gbSVr£:_�zjRjqeR¡T�QS[cT}RU[9d[gb5s�V`ngQSVed&T}acTWRj[gd��mN)[9Q�V �([9bW��[9d�xc] o&RjVe����Pa9s�VYX�QS[:X:V`zjs�[cf�f�agqeV`sp\a�o9V

Page 11: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

aczysW[#P�VeVed5Vr£)TWV`dX:VYX^T}[�Ve£)_bWVYsWsWRU[9d^b}V`qr[9ngd�RUTWRj[gd��¤hiVe�)QSVeb�VrT�acz�� � % ��wghiV`�&QSV`bacd/X���[gn9ngRj[�� u �Hacd/XZl([)[cT}V`s?VeT�agz¤� � ! x �{����«�[B�iVeo9Veb�T}\�V`sWV�o&RjVe����Pa9s�VYXSQ�[:X)�Vezys�agbWVpVe£)_zURyqrRUTWzj�mX:Ve_�VedX�Ved&T#[gd�qe[gb}bWVYs�_�[gd/X:VedqeV�P/VeT��(V`Ved�f�agqeRjagzHf{V`acTWO�b}V`sacd/XZTW\�V`bWVef{[gb}V^bWV`_/VYaBT}V`X�V`s�TWRjQ�aBT}RU[9dm[cf�TW\�Rys�qr[gb}b}V`sW_/[9dX:Ved/qrV^X:O�b}Rjd�n acd/aczU��:s�Rys`�;#Ld X�V`sWRUn9d�RUdnp[gO�bis��:s�TWVeQ�w&�(V#P�O�Rjz¡TiQ�[:X:V`zjs?TW\acTiX:[�d�[cT1b}Vezj��[gd�sWOq,\Vr£:_�zjRyqrRUT#qr[gb}b}V`sW_/[9dX:Ved/qrVg�� \�V5agdaczj�:s�Rys�[gf�f�agqrVYs#�7RUTW\RUd�a o)RUV`����Pa9s�VYXZ_acb,agX:RjngQ>Rys#agq,\RUV`ogV`X�P)�

TW\V�zj[:qeagzURj¨`acTWRj[gd�agdX�acdagzU�:sWRjs�[cfio�agbWRj[gO/s#f�a9qrRyacz�b}VengRj[gd/se� � \Rjs�Rysp~&O�R¡T}V�a\agb}X�_�b}[gPzUV`QGX�O�V^T}[�TW\V�d�[9d:��b}RjngRyXZTWb,acds�f{[gb}Q�aBTWRj[gd/s�TW\acT�oBagbWRj[gOs7f�agqrRyaczb}VengRj[gd/s#O�d/X:Veb}ng[/��N)[gQSV�bWV`ngRj[gds�[cf?T}\�V�f�agqeVZ�¤s�Oq,\�ags�QS[gO:T}\s,��q`acd�o�agbW��7RyX:Vezj�g� t _�RU£:Vez-PagsWV`Xkb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd�f{[9b7s�Oq,\Za��7RjX:V`zU��oBagbW�)Rjd�n5_/aBT�T}Veb}dRys�[gf§TWV`d�Rjda9X:V`~&OacTWVg� � \�RjzUVSzj[)q`aczjRU¨YaBT}RU[9d�[cfis�[9Q�V�f�a9qrRyacz�bWV`ngRj[gds�Q�a��mP/VsWRUQS_�zjR¡|/V`XSP)��T}\�V�zj[:qeaczjRj¨`aBT}RU[9dS[cf-TW\�V�f�agqrV9wgT}\�V7T,agsW��[cfHQ�ac__�RUdnpTW\�V�f�agqrRyaczb}VengRj[gd���Vg� n��TW\�V�QS[gO:T}\/�?TW[�a5s�VeT([cf�_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s#��sWOq,\ a9s1X:V`ngb}VeV�[gf�[g_�Ved:�d�VYsWs�[9b�sWQSRUzjVY��Ryspa�X�acOd9T}RUdnZ[9d�V�s�RjdqeV�RUT^Rys�d�[cT�qezUVYacb�\�[B�4sWOq,\;aZQSag_qeagd�P/V5QSa9X:V^b}[gP�O/s�T�d�[gT�[9d�zU� TW[�T}\�V�oBagbWRj[gOs7f�agq�T}[gb#a���VYq�T}RUd�n�TW\�V5RUQ�acn9V_acT�TWV`bWdZ[cfDTW\V�f�agqrRyaczHb}Ven9RU[9d P�O�T#aczys�[�TW[SV`bWb}[gb,siRUd�RUT}s�zj[)q`aczjRU¨YaBT}RU[9d��� \�V?��a�ogV`zUVeT�PagsWV`X�b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd�\ags�a�zU[9d�n7\�Rys�T}[gb}��agdX�\ags*bWVYqrV`d9T}zU�

P�VeVed�ac_�_�zjRjV`XZTW[ TW\�V5_�b}[gP�zjVeQ�s7[gf?RUQ�acn9V�X�acT}acP/agsWVpbWVeTWb}RUV`o�agz*Rjd �9a9qr[9Ps�VeTacz�� � x & �-agdX�_�V`X:VYs�T}bWRyacdkX:VrT}V`q�T}RU[9d Rjd ��ac_/acngV`[gb}ngRj[gO�VrT�acz�� � U ���f#�Ti\a9s?P�VeV`dsW\�[B�7d�TW[�P�V b}[gP�O/s�T^T}[�zjRUn9\9T}RUdn�qr[9dX:RUTWRj[gds^agdX�oBacb}RyaBTWRj[gd/s�RUd�qe[gzj[gbY�@#�TRysiagzjsW[5q`ac_agP�zjV�[gf�qeag_:TWO�b}Rjd�n5RjdZR¡T,s�[BogVeb,qr[9QS_�zUVeTWV7f{[9bWQ T}\�V�ngV`d�Veb,acz-s�\/ac_�V[cf�TW\�Vm[9P���V`qrT��7\�RUzjVmRjngd�[9bWRjd�n�TW\�V�|dVeb�X:VeT}acRjzyse� #�T�Rys�aczys�[;�)d�[B�7d<TW\acTaBT5zU[B� Ved[gO�n9\�bWVYs�[9zUO:T}RU[9dspRUT5RyspT}[gzjVeb,acd&T^TW[�s�Q�aczjz(TWb,acdsWzjacTWRj[gds`� #Ld [gObac__�bW[&agq,\;�iV�\a�ogV Os�VYX�acd [Bo9Veb,qr[9Q�_zUVeTWV�«#a9acb^��a�ogV`zUVeT�b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gdTW[8X:VrT}V`qrTkd�[&s�T}bWRjzjs TW[�|b,s�TZzU[:qeagzURj¨eV�TW\�V�Q�[9O:TW\%acdXJTW\�V`d�OsWV�a�sW_agb}sWVsWO�PsWVrT1[gf*qr[)V�X�qrRjVed&T,s?[cf-T}\�Rjs([BogV`b}qe[gQS_�zjVrT}V7�ia�o9VezjVrT1X:Ryq�T}RU[9dacb}�5a9s1a^sWVrTi[cfb}Vengb}V`s}sW[gb,s#�7\�Ryq,\;[gO:T}_�O:T^T}\�V X:R �-Veb}Ved&T^_acb,acQSVeTWVeb,spX:VYs�RjbWVYX��{Rjd�[gO�b�q`agsWVX:V`ngb}VeV#[gf*[g_�Vedd�V`s}s�acdXks�QSRjzUV���� � \�Rys�ac_�_�b}[9a9q,\�RysisWRjQ�Rjzyacb(TW[�TW\�V�QSVrT}\�[:XOsWV`X�P)� W b,aBf�VrT�acz�� � x9x �iagdX V P�Rj\agb}aZVrT�acz�� � ! ( �(�7\Veb}VSTW\�V�[9O:TW_O:T}s�[cfX:R ��V`bWV`d&T^PacdX:��_a9sWspqe[gQS_�[gd�V`d9T,s�[cfiTW\�V RUd�_O:T^RUQ�agngV�acb}VSOsWV`X;ags�Rjd�_�O:TTW[�aSqrzyags}sWR¡|V`b`�t f�agqeV^X:VrT}V`qrTWRj[gdms��:s�TWV`Q Rys�TW\�V�|/b}s�T#s�T}Ve_ZTW[B��acb,X�s�acd)�kQ�[9O:TW\magdaczj�&�

sWRjs�s��:s�TWVeQ�� � \�V^f�agqrV5X:VrT}V`q�T}RU[9d�_agb�T#��ags#X:V`s}qrb}RUP�V`X�Rjd�RUT}s#d�[gd�b}V`agz¡��TWRjQSVf{[gb}Q Rjd *�s�O�d/a�w�VeTpagz¤� � !�% ��� � \�Rys^sW�:s�T}VeQ Rys^acd�Vr£�agQ�_zUVS[cfi\�[B�@�iV�agX)�X:b}V`s}s�TW\V�[cT}\�Veb?Rys}s�O�V#bWV`zjacTWV`X5T}[^[gO�b1_�bW[9P�zjVeQ�wgdagQSVezj�gw&[cfHbW[9P�Os�T?zUVYacb}d�Rjd�nTWVYq,\�d�Ry~&O�V`s5f{[gb�VYs�T}RUQ�acTWRjd�n�TW\�VmX�acT}aB�LX:b}RUo9Ved<Q�[:X:V`zjs`� � [gb�T}\�RjsS_O�bW_�[9sWVgw�iV�OsWV`X�TW\�VpN)O�__/[9b�T7¥�V`qrTW[9b���agq,\�Rjd�V5��N)¥�����qrzyags}s�RU|/qeacTWRj[gd���l([gbWTWV`s�agdX¥?ac_d�RU� � ! u �§�*�7\�Ryq,\�Rys�P/agsWV`X^[9dpTW\Vi_bWRjdqrRj_�zjV([gf/s�TWb}Oq�T}O�b}agz9b}Rys���QSRUdRUQSRj¨`aB�TWRj[gdmagdX�T}\)Os7QSRUdRUQSRj¨eV`s�a�P/[9O�dXZ[gdZTW\VpngVedVeb,aczjRU¨YaBTWRj[gdkVeb}bW[9b`�f#Ld�[gb,X:V`bTW[�Q�ac�9V#T}\�Rjs7sW�:s�T}VeQEb}V`agz¡��TWRjQSV��iV�\/a�ogV#Rjdqe[gb}_/[9b}acTWV`X s��)Rjd:��sWVen9QSVed&T}acTWRj[gdTW[�b}V`X:O/qrV�TW\�V�sWV`agb}q,\�s�_/agqrV5f{[gb�T}\�VSf�agqeV�X:VrT}V`q�T}[gbY����[:qeagzURj¨`acTWRj[gd�[gfiV`�gVYs

Page 12: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

acd/X d�[&s�T}bWRjzys�Rjs�OsWV`XkT}[�zj[:qeagzURj¨eV�TW\VpQ�[9O:TW\*�� \�V�_�b}[gP�zjVeQ [cf�Q�ac_�_�Rjd�n�T}\�V�zU[:q`aczjRU¨`V`X�QS[gO:T}\�b}Ven9RU[9d�T}[�TW\�Vks�VeT^[cf

X:VYs�RjbWVYX8_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s�Rys�_/[&s�VYXJags�TW\�V�_bW[9P�zUV`Q [gfpzUVYacb}d�RUdn a;bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gdf{O�dqrTWRj[gd<f{bW[9Q¦TW\�Vm«�agacbS��a�ogV`zUVeT�qr[)V�X�qeRUV`d&T}s�[cf�TW\�V�RjQSagngVkTW[�_acb,acQSVe�TWV`b}s([cf�[9_/V`d�d�VYsWsiacdX s�QSRjzUV�[gP:T,acRjd�V`X�P&�SQ�acd)OagzUzj��acd�d[cT}acTWRjd�n�a�TWb,acRjd�Rjd�nsWVrT`� � \�Rysi_�b}[gP�zjVeQERys?T,agq,�)zjV`X�O/s�Rjd�n�N:¥�� bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gd�acd/X�f{[gb}Q�s(TW\�V�QS[9s�TRjQ�_�[gbWT}agd&T#qr[gQS_�[gd�V`d&T�f{[gb�[9O�b�_�ObW_�[9sWV`s`� � \Rjs�s��:s�TWVeQ>\a9s7P/V`Ved�T}b}agRUd�VYX[gd�Q5O�z¡T}RU_zUVpf�a9qrVYs�acdXZRys�qeag_acPzUVp[gf�X:VeTWVYq�TWRjd�n�f�a9qrVYs�acdXZzj[:qeaczjRj¨eRjd�n�Ve�9V`s`wd�[&s�T}bWRjzjs�acdX�QS[gO:T}\s�f{[gbDQ�O�zUTWRj_�zjV(_�Veb,s�[9ds�Rjd5a#ngV`d�Veb,acz&Ved)o)RUb}[gdQ�V`d&T`� � O�b��TW\Veb}Q�[9bWV9wcT}\�V�sW�:s�T}VeQ Rjs?TWb,acRjd�V`X�TW[�agdaczj�)¨eV7T}\�V#zj[:qeaczjRj¨eV`XSQS[9O:TW\�_/aBT�T}Veb}dTW[ V`s�TWRjQSacTWV�X:Ven9bWV`V`s7[gf?[g_�Ved�d�VYsWs�acdX�s�QSRjzUV9� � \�V�VYs�T}RUQ�acTWV`X�_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,sacb}V^OsWV`XZT}[kX:b}RjogVpT}\�V�\�VYagXmQS[Bo9VeQSVed&T}s#acdX�f�a9qrRyacz�Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gds�[cf1a�q`acbW�TW[)[9dZq,\agb}a9q�T}Veb�RUd�b}V`agz/T}RUQSVp[9d�a�n9Ved�V`b}agz�_O�bW_�[9sWVpqr[9Q�_O:TWV`b`�

����� ?@�A���B������1C���.3��4����5���������� �("=�%��

� \�V�X�V`sWRUn9dm[cf?a�zjV`acb}d�Rjd�nc��Pa9s�VYXkb}V`agz¡��TWRjQSV^s��:s�TWV`Q f{[9b�TWb,agq,�)Rjd�n�acd/Xmacdac�zj�&¨`RUdn�f�a9qrV`s�sW\�[B��s1TW\acT�RUT7Rjs�_�[9s}sWRUP�zjV�TW[�Os�V�_�ObWV`zU��P�[cTWTW[gQ���O�_ZQ�VeTW\�[:X�sTW[SQ�ac�9V�\�V`a9X)����a���Rjd�sW[gQSV�\agb}XZ_�b}[gP�zjVeQ�s�[gf�_�Veb,qrVe_�TWRj[gd��1«#[B�(V`ogV`b`w9TW\�Vf�agqrTSTW\acT�T}\�Vms��:s�TWV`Q OsWV`sSQ�acd)OagzUzj� acd�d[cT}acTWVYX Vr£�agQ�_zUVYs�f{[9b�zUVYacb}d�Rjd�nsW\�[B��s�TW\acTpTW[9_:��X�[B�7d��)d�[B�7zjV`X:n9VSRjspRjd�\�V`bWV`d&TpTW[mRUT}s�sWOq`qrV`s}s`� #�spQ�acd)Oagzacdd�[cT,aBTWRj[gd�TW\�V�[9d�zU�p��a��p[cf�s�_�V`qeR¡f{�)Rjd�n�TW[g_���X:[B�7d5�)d�[B�7zUVYX:ngV � #Ld5TW\V�q`agsWV[cfHf�a9qrRyacz�acdagzU�:sWRjs`wgT}\�Rys(~&O�VYs�T}RU[9d qeagd�P/V�agsW�gVYXSQ�[9bWV#_/[9RUd&TWVYX:zj�Sa9s?f{[9zUzj[B��s`�

� � \/aBT1acb}ViTW\�V7P/agsWRjq�O�dR¡T,s�[cf�f�agqeRjagz�s�\ag_/VYs��BQS[cTWRj[gd/s �k«�[B�8qeacd�T}\�Ve�P�Vpb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&TWVYX �

� � \/aBT�b}VezyaBT}RU[9d�X:[)V`s#TW\�V5_�RU£)V`z�RjQ�acn9V^[cf�f�a9qrV`s#P/VYacb�TW[�T}\�V`sWV�b}Ve_bWVe�sWVed&T,aBTWRj[gd/s ��liagdkT}\�[9sWV�P/VpzjV`agbWd&T �

� \�V�agds��iVeb�TW[�T}\�Vm|b,s�TZ~9OV`s�TWRj[gd�X:V`QSagdX�ska;Q�[:X:V`z�f{[9b QS[:X:VezjRUdnTW\V�qrzyags}s7[cf?QS[9O:TW\s#�7\�Ryq,\mRjs�qeac_/acP�zjVp[cf�b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&TWRjd�nST}\�V�Rjd�\�V`bWV`d9T�qr[gd��s�TWb,acRjd9T,sH[gd�QS[gO�TW\^sW\ac_�V`s�acdX�QS[cT}RU[9dse� t QS[gdn9s�THTW\�V?Q�agd&��QS[:X:VezU��P/agsWV`Xac__�bW[&agq,\�VYs^T}[;Q�[:X:V`zURjd�n;[gP ��V`q�T�qezja9sWsWV`s`w�TW\V��*RUdV`acb���[gb}_�\acPzUV��m[:X:Vez����������Rjs�acd�RjQS_/[9b�T,acd&T#[9d�Vg� � \�V5agd9T}V`qeV`X:V`d9T,s�[gf1�*����s�qeagdmP/V�f{[gO�d/XRjdkT}\�V^�i[gb}��[cf�hiVe�)QSVeb#agdX���[gngn9RU[ � u ��w¥�VrT�T}Veb�acdXZ��[gn9ngRj[ � (gx ���7\�[�X:Vr�s}qrb}RUP�V�TW\�V#Q�[:X:V`zURjd�n^[gf�X:R �-Veb}Ved&T1[9P���V`qrT}s�[gf-TW\�V#s}acQSV7[9P���V`qrT(qrzyags}s�OsWRUdn^azjRUd�VYacbDqr[gQ5P�RjdaBT}RU[9d�[gf�_�b}[cTW[gT��)_/VYsew�acdX�T}\�V1�i[gb}�#[gfª�zjzUQ�agd�acdXph�a9s�b}R � % ( ��7\�[SQS[:X:Vez-T}\�VpQ�O�zUTWRj_�zjVpo)RUV`��s�[cf�a�sWRjd�ngzjV�[gP���VYq�T7P)��zURjd�VYacb�qr[9Q�P�RjdacTWRj[gd[cf�_bW[gTW[cT��)_�Ryqeagz1o)RjVe��s`� t �*��� �([9bW�:s�P&�;VYs�T,acP�zjRjsW\�Rjd�n�_R¡£:VezU���7RjsWVkqe[gbW�b}V`sW_/[9dX:Ved/qrV^P�VrT��iVeV`dmTW\�V�_�b}[cT}[cT��)_�Ryqeacz�RUQ�agngV`s#[cf1agd�[gP���VYq�T�qrzyags}se� � \�RjszjV`agXs�TW[�amX�OaczU��b}Ve_bWVYs�V`d9T,aBT}RU[9d�[gf7agd;RUQ�acn9V�ags5aZTWVr£)T}O�bWVkacdX�amsW\ac_�Vg�

Page 13: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

hi��zURjd�V`agbWzj�mqr[9Q�P�Rjd�Rjd�n T}\�V5TWVr£)T}O�bWVSacd/X�sW\ac_�V�sWVe_/acb,aBTWV`zU�9w/RUT�Rjs�_�[9s}s�RjP�zjVTW[�ngV`d�Veb,aBT}V�d�V`��RUQ�agngV`s([cf�[gP���VYq�T}siRjd�T}\�V�s}acQSV�qrzyags}se����acTW\�V`QSacTWRyqeagzUzj��a�*��� b}Ve_bWVYs�V`d9T,s�aSQSagd�RUf{[gzyX RjdZTW\�V�sW_a9qrV�[cf�_�RU£)V`zjs�[9d��7\�Rjq,\magd&� RUQ�acn9VP�Vezj[gd�n9RUd�n5TW[5TW\V�qezja9sWsiRys�qr[gd/s�T}b}agRUd�VYX�T}[5zjRUV9�?�*����s(�7RjzjzHP/V�Vr£:_�zyacRjd�VYX Rjdngb}V`acTWV`b�X�VrT}agRUzHRjdma�zjacTWVeb�q,\/ac_:T}VebY��*����s�\a�o9V?P/V`VedpOsWV`X�T}[#QS[:X:Vez9[gP���VYq�T�qezja9sWsWV`s*s�Oq,\^a9s-f�agqeV`s`wBqeacb,s�agdX

X:RjngRUT}s^���g[9d�V`s#acdXm��[9ngngRj[ � x�����w�hizjagd�¨ � %i& ��w-l([)[cT}V`s7VeT�acz�� � ! x �{��� " VYqrVed&T}zU�RUT�\/ags�P/V`Ved�OsWV`Xmf{[9b�TW\�V�sW�&d&T}\�V`sWRjs�[gf1o)RjsWOacz�sW_/V`V`q,\8� V ¨`¨`acT�agdX���[9ngngRj[� %<! �{����hiO:T�sW[�f�agb`w�RUTS\ags5Q�acRjd�zU�;P�VeV`d<amT}[)[gzif{[gb5RUQ�acn9VksW�)d9T}\�V`sWRys5agdXRUT}spOsWV�f{[gb^RjQ�acn9VSagdaczj�:s�Rys�\ags�P�VeV`d s�[9QSVe�7\acT�zjRjQ�RUTWVYXHwDQSagRUdzU�mf{[9b�TW\�V_�O�b}_�[9sWV1[cf/ogVeb}RU|/qeacTWRj[gd�acf§TWVebDT}\�Vis�T}agngV([cf[9P���V`qrT�X:VeTWVYq�TWRj[gd*��N)O/q,\5acd/aczj�)sWRys\a9s5P�VeV`d8ag_�_�b}[9a9q,\�V`X;T}\�b}[gO�n9\ TW\V�qe[gQS_�O:T,aBT}RU[9daczjzU��Rjd&TWV`ds�RjogV�acd/aczj�)sWRysP)�ZsW�)d&TW\�VYs�Rys�QSVrT}\�[:X�[9d�zU�9�Q#Ld �9[gd�VYs#agdX���[gn9ngRj[ � x�����agdX�l([)[cT}V`s#VrT�agz¤�� ! x ��wBTW\ViQ�acT}q,\�Rjd�n�_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s�agbWViqr[9Q�_O:TWVYX�P)�pQSRUdRUQSRj¨eRjd�n�TW\�V7s}~9O/acb}V`XVeb}b}[gbiP/VeT��(V`VedkTW\�Vpd�[Bo9Vez-RjQSagngV�acdX TW\V�QS[:X:V`z�RUQ�agngV�Os�Rjd�n�aSs�T}[:q,\ags�TWRyqngb,agX�RUV`d9T#X�V`s}qrVed&TS�¤N W ]��#agzUn9[gb}R¡T}\�Q�� � \�Rys7TWVYq,\�d�Ry~&O�V�Rys�qe[gQS_�O:T,aBT}RU[9daczjzU�Rjd9T}VedsWRjogV �{T}ac�)Rjd�n�QSRjd&O�TWV`s#TW[ QSacT}q,\mV`ogVed�a�s�Rjd�n9zUV^RjQ�acn9VY��� t TWVYq,\�d�Ry~9OVTW\/aBT qr[9O�zyX8qe[gQS_�O:T}V�TW\�V�QSacT}q,\�Rjd�n�_agb}agQSVrTWV`b}s��7RUTW\�qe[gdsWRjX�Veb,acP�zj��zUVYsWsqr[9QS_�O:T}acTWRj[gds�acdX�OsWRUdn�[gd�zj��o)RjVe����PagsWV`X�b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T,aBTWRj[gd/s��i[gOzjX;Q�ac�9VTW\V`sWV�QS[:X:V`zjs7O/s�Vef{O�z�RjdZb}V`agz¡��TWRjQSV�ag_�_�zjRjq`aBT}RU[9dse�

#Ld�T}\�RjsZT}\�V`sWRysew��(V�Vr£:_�zj[gb}V�TW\V�_�[9s}sWRUP�RjzjR¡T���[cf5zUVYacb}d�RUdn TW[8V`s�TWRjQ�aBT}VTW\VkQ�aBT,q,\�Rjd�n�_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s^[cf�a������ X:Rjb}V`q�T}zU�;f{b}[gQ�_R¡£:VezU��PagsWV`X�b}Ve_bWVe�sWVed&T}acTWRj[gds�[cf(agd�Rjd�_�O:TpRjQ�acngV9�^�*����s�\/a�ogV^T}\�VSng[)[:X�_�b}[g_�VebWT��ZTW\acT�P)�o)RUbWTWOV�[gfiqe[gds�TWb}Oq�T}RU[9d<��Os�Rjd�n�Vr£�agQ�_zUVYs}��a��*��� bWV`_�b}V`sWVed&T}s�TW\VSs�T}acTWRys��TWRyqes1[cfHT}\�V�qezja9sWs1[cfHRUQ�agngV`s(ags1[g_�_�[9sWV`X�T}[�[cT}\�Veb(QS[)X�Vezys?�7\�Ryq,\�d�V`V`XST}[^P/V\agdX)�Lqrb,aBf§TWVYX �{V9� n/��TW\�[&s�V5PagsWV`Xm[9d�f�a9qrRyaczDQ�Os}qrO�zyaBT}O�b}VY��� � \acT�Rys�P/V`RUdnRjd&o9V`s�TWRjn9acTWV`X�\�Veb}VSRjs�T}\�VS_/[&sWsWRUPRUzjR¡T���TW\acT������������ ����������������������������������� !"$#%#'&�( ��)*���+������,����� (-& � ( �/.0� (21 �3�+� &�( ��)��� � ( ��45��768�92���:�+�;�����������6<����������>=?� (-& �����9�9���/��� ( ��@ � \)OsiRUT7QSa���P�V�daBT}O�b,acz�TW[SzjV`acb}d�T}\�V�_acb,acQSVeTWVeb,s([cfaS�*���¦a9siTW\�V�|b,s�T7s�T}agngV�[cf�a�_/V`b}qeVe_:T}OaczHT,agsW�-�� \�V��i[gb}��[gf1l([)[gTWV`s�acdXmqe[c���([9bW�9Veb,s � ! x ��\a9s#qe[gQSV^qrzj[9sWVpTW[kac_�_�b}[�£)�

RjQSacTWRjd�n�[gOb�QSVrTW\[)Xse� � \�V`RUbkQ�[:X:V`z�f{[9b�[gP���VYq�Tkqezja9sWsWV`sS�)d�[B�7dJa9sSTW\�VagqrTWRjogV sW\ag_/VkQ�[:X:V`z(RysSs�RjQSRUzyacb5RUd<s�_�Rjb}R¡T5TW[�T}\�V��*��� PO:TSX�R �-Veb,s�Rjd�RUT}sX:VeT}acRjzyse�G#�T#zja9q,�:siTW\�V^X:V`dsWV�qr[9bWb}V`sW_/[9dX:V`dqrV�|VezyX�[cfDTW\V��*��� �/«�[B�iVeo9VebYwTW\Ve�^aBTWTWV`Q�_�T�T}[�qe[gQS_�O:T}V1T}\�V�QSacT}q,\�Rjd�n�_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s�[gf�TW\�V`RUb�a9q�TWRjogVis�\/ac_�VQS[:X:Vez*f{bW[9Q TW\V^RUQ�agngVp�7RUTW\�aSo)RUV`�%TW[�sW_/V`V`X)��O�_�TW\V^_�b}[)qeV`s}s7[cf�acd/aczj�)sWRysP)�5sW�)d9T}\�V`sWRyse� � \�V#sW_/V`V`X)��O�_�Rys1a9q,\�RUV`ogVYX�P)��zUVYacb}d�RUdn�sWVeo9Veb,acz:Q5O�z¡T}RUoBagbWRyaBT}VzjRUd�VYacb5bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gds�f{b}[gQ T}\�V V`bWb}[gb^RjQ�acn9V���X:R �-Veb}VedqeV P�VrT��iVeVed TW\�Vkd�[BogV`zacd/X�T}\�VpQS[)X�VezHRjQSagngVYs}�iacd/X�T}\�V^ac_�_bW[9_�bWRyaBT}V�_�VebWTWObWPacTWRj[gdZ[cf�TW\�VpQS[:X:Vez_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s5�§TW\V��)d�[B�7d�X:RjsW_�zyagqeVeQSVed&T}s�[gf?TW\�V�QS[:X:Vez�_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s,��w�TW\)Osa�og[9RjX�RUd�n�TW\V#qr[9Q�_O:T}acTWRj[gd�[cf-ngb,agX:RjVed&T}s`� � \Rjs1Q�VeTW\�[:X�Rys?ac�)Rjd5T}[pzUVYacb}d�Rjd�nTW\VST}acdngVed&T^_�zyacdVSTW[�TW\V�Q�acd�RUf{[gzyX�RUd�_�RU£:Vez1sW_a9qrV�f{[gb}QSV`X�P)��TW\V�QS[gbW�

Page 14: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

_�\agP�zjV�QS[)X�Vez���#Ld [gO�b(Q�VeTW\�[:XHw&T}\�V#V`Q�_\agsWRjs1Rjs1[gd�zjV`agbWdRUd�n�T}\�V�qe[gQS_�zjVr£d�[9d:��zjRjd�V`agb�TWb,acds�f{[gb}Q�aBTWRj[gd/s�TW\acT��([9O�zyX�q`acb}bW��TW\�V�Rjd�_�O�T5b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gdTW[�T}\�VpQ�aBT}q,\RUd�nS_agb}agQSVrTWV`b}si[gf�T}\�V^�*��� X:RjbWVYq�T}zU�9�N)RjdqrV��*����s�acb}V5qr[9ds�TWb}Oq�T}V`Xmf{b}[gQ�Ve£�acQS_�zjV`s`w�P/agsWV`X�[9d�T}\�V5�)RjdX�[cf

Vr£�agQ�_zUVYs*OsWV`X�wcR¡T�RysD_/[&sWsWRUPzUV(TW[�X:Vr|/d�Vi~&OagzURUT}acTWRjogV`zU�9w�T��([��&RjdX�s�[gf/�*����se�� \�Vp|/b}s�T#�)RUd/Xm[cf?�*����s�QS[:X:Vez�TW\V5sW_agqeVp[cf?zjRUd�Ve��X�b}a��7Rjd�n9s7agdX�d�V`V`X�T}[P�V^P�O�Rjz¡T�Os�Rjd�n�Ve£:agQS_�zUVYs�[cf�zjRUd�V^X�b}a��7Rjd�n9s`� � \�Rys�q`acdmaczys�[�P�VpRjd9T}Veb}_�b}VrTWVYXags#P/V`RUdnZqe[gds�TWb}Oq�T}V`X��7RUTW\�_�\�Ved[gQSVedagz�Ve£�acQS_�zjV`s#agdXmQS[:X:VezjRjd�nka _�\�Vr�d�[9Q�V`dacz?sW_a9qrVg� � \V�[cTW\Veb^�)RjdX�[cf7�*����s�acb}V�PO�RUzUT^OsWRUdnmbWVYacz�RjQSagngVYsacd/X�TW\�V`bWVef{[gb}V�QS[:X:Vez�TW\V�sW_agqeV�[gf?_�R¡£:V`zjs`� t s�a�b}V`sWO�z¡T�[gdV5qeagd�qr[9dqrV`RUo9V[cf1T��([ZX:R �-Veb}Ved&T��ia��:s�RUd��7\�Ryq,\��*����s�qeacd�f{[gb}QGTW\�V�Pa9s�Rys�[cf?T}[g_:�LX:[B�7d�)d�[B�7zjV`X:n9V(Rjd�_/V`b}qeVe_:T}Oacz/s��:s�TWVeQ�s`� � \VedSOsWRUd�npzjRjd�Vr�LX:b,a��7RUd�n��*����sewgTW\�V�*����s#b}Ve_bWVYs�V`d9T�_�\�Ved[gQSVedagz�qeaBT}Ven9[gb}RUVYs�acdXmTW\�V`bWVef{[gb}V�P)��zUVYacb}d�RUdn�TW\�VQ�ac_�_RUd�nSf{b}[gQ>_�RU£:VezU��Pa9s�VYX b}Ve_bWVYs�V`d9T,aBT}RU[9dsiTW[ �����¦_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}si�iV�acb}VzjV`acb}d�Rjd�n�T}[ZX:Rjb}V`q�T}zU�mVYs�T}RUQ�acTWV�_�\�Ved[gQSVedagzDq`aBT}Veng[9bWRjV`s`� � \�V�s}acQSV5Rjs�d�[gTTWb}O�V�[gf(T}\�V�_�RU£:Vez(������s^agdX�Vr£)TWb,agqrTWRjd�nmQSV`agd�RUdncf{O�z?_\�Ved�[9QSVedagz1qeacTWVr�ng[9bWRjV`siQSRjng\&T7bWVY~9ORUb}V�f{O�b�T}\�Veb�agdaczj�:s�Rys`� � \V`sWV�Rys}s�O�VYs��7RUzjz�P�V^X:RysWqeOsWsWV`XZRjdTW\Rjs�T}\�V`sWRyse�

#Ld�T}\�Rys�TW\�VYs�Rys`wc�(Vi_�b}[g_�[9sWV1T}[pqr[gd/s�T}bWOqrTD_R¡£:Vez�������sDT}[�QS[:X:V`z:o�agbWRj[gO/sQS[gO:T}\ s�\/ac_�V`s^agdX�Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gds`� � [gzjzU[B�7Rjd�n �g[9d�V`s�acdX;��[gn9ngRj[ � x � ��w�TW\�V�*��� Rys�qe[gds�TWb}OqrTWV`Xmf{bW[9Q�Vr£�acQS_�zjV`s�[cf1QS[9O:TW\s`�^�?b}RjdqrRj_acz?l([gQS_�[gd�V`d&Tt d/aczj�)sWRys��¤�il t �([9d�TW\V�Ve£:agQS_�zUV�TWVe£)TWO�b}V`siacdX��[B��s�aczjzU[B��s1Os(TW[�bWVYX:OqeVTW\V�s�VeT^[cf�_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,se� � V�TW\Ved;OsWV N)¥�� b}Ven9bWVYsWsWRU[9d��{¥?ag_�d�Rj� � ( ! �§��T}[zjV`acb}d�a d[gd:��zURjd�VYacbZbWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gd8f{O�dqrTWRj[gd�f{bW[9Q a<s�_/acb,s�V�sWO�PsWVrT�[cf�«�agagb��a�ogVezjVrT#qe[)V�X�qrRjVed&T}s�TW[ TW\�V5QSacT}q,\�Rjd�n�_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s7[cf�T}\�Rjs��*��� X:RjbWVYq�TWzj�g�� \�ViTWb,acRjd�Rjd�nps�VeT#�{RjdS_acbWTWRyqrO�zyacb�T}\�V��^[gf/T}\�V^���������D_acRjb,s}�*f{[gb�T}\�Rys�zUVYacb}d�Rjd�n_�b}[gP�zjVeQ2RysDngV`d�Veb,aBT}V`XpP)�pV`s�TWRjQ�aBT}RUd�n�TW\V(T}bWOV(Q�aBT,q,\�Rjd�n�_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s�OsWRUdnTW\V�N W ] aczjng[9bWRUTW\Q X:V`s}qrb}RjP/VYX Rjd �g[9d�V`s�acd/XZ��[9ngn9RU[ � x������� VmVe£:_�zU[9bWVmX:R �-Veb}Ved&T�agsW_/VYq�T}s�[cf#T}\�Rys�QSVrTW\[)X��¢l(zUVYacb}zU��T}\�Vm_�VebWf{[gbW�

Q�acdqeVkRysSzjRU�9Vezj�;TW[�P/V�a���VYq�TWVYX P)��T}\�V�d&OQ�P�VebS[cf�X:R �-Veb}Ved&T�_�Ve[g_zUVkTW\�V�*��� TWb}RUVYs�T}[�QS[:X:Vez�� t qeqr[9b}X�RUd�n9zU�8�iV�qr[9ds�RyX:V`b�TW\V�qea9s�V�[cf�a sWRUdngzjV_�Veb,s�[9d��*��� acdX�a^Q�O�zUTWRj_�zjV�_�Veb,s�[9d �*����� t d [9P&o)Rj[gOs1Vr£)TWV`dsWRU[9dSTW[�VYs��TWRjQ�aBT}RUd�n��*��� _acb,acQSVeTWVeb,s*X�RUb}V`qrTWzj��Rys*TW[#Rjd�RUTWRyaczjRU¨`Via�s�OPs�VY~&O�Ved&T�n9b}a9X:RjVed&TX:VYsWqeVed&T�aczjng[gb}RUTW\�Q f{[9b�TW\�VpQS[gb}Vpagq`qrO�b,aBT}V�VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}RU[9dk[gf�T}\�V�_acb,acQSVeTWVeb,s`�� V�_�b}V`sWVed&T(sW[gQSV7bWVYs�Oz¡T,s?[gdST}\�V��)RjdX�[cf�sW_/V`V`XSO�_�TW\acT1Rjs1zURj�gV`zU���7RUTW\�T}\�Rjsac__�bW[&agq,\��

����� E 3�3������(��"���#����"$� � �����4� ���Z������� ! �#"$�%�&'���(�%�

V s�TWRjQ�aBT}RU[9dm[cf�TW[9_:��X�[B�7d��*����_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s�qr[9O�zjX�P/V�ac_�_�zjRjV`XZTW[ TW\�V�X:Vr�sWRUn9dk[gf�Rjd9T}VezjzURjngV`d&T#s��:s�TWVeQ�s�RjdZT��([�X:R ��V`bWV`d&T���a��:se�

Page 15: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

�¤a9�

�{P/�

� RUn9O�b}V ! � x:©b#LzjzUO/s�T}b}acTWRjd�n�TW\V�T��i[ �)RUd/X�s [gf5ac__�zURyqeacTWRj[gds�TW\acT T}\�V�VYs�T}R¡�Q�aBT}RU[9d [cf�TW\VZ����� _agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s^q`acd P�V O/s�VYX;f{[gbY�<�¤a9� � \Vk�*��� _aB�b,acQSVrT}Veb,siqe[gds�TWRUTWO�TWVpT}\�Vp\�Rjng\�V`b���zUV`ogV`z-q`aBT}Veng[9bWRjV`s�agdX�acb}V�VYs�T}RUQ�acTWV`Xkf{b}[gQ_�RU£:VezU��Pa9s�VYXmb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gds�acd/X��{P���TW\�V��*��� _agb}agQSVrTWV`b}s�acb}V5O/s�VYX�agsRjQSagngV�f{V`acTWO�b}V`s7agdX TW\�Vp\�Rjng\VebW��zjVeo9VezHqeacTWVen9[gb}RUVYs�acb}V�sW_/VYqrRU|V`X�sWVe_agb}acTWV`zU�9�

� #Ld�[gd�V�qeagsWVgw7\RUn9\�VebW��zjVeo9Vez�_�Veb,qrV`_:TWO/acz�qeaBT}Ven9[gb}RUVYs�acb}V�Rjd9T}bWRjdsWRjq`aczjzU�b}Ve_bWVYs�V`d9T}V`XkP)� T}\�V^�*���¦_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,se� #�T�Q�a��kbWVY~9ORUb}Vps�[9Q�Vp_�[9s�T��_bW[:qrVYsWsWRjd�nSTW[�Ve£)TWb,agq�T7T}\�V`sWV�q`aBTWV`ng[9bWRjV`s7PO:T*� ( �?�2�+��� ( ��26 6 ��2��� �+� =��� ������� �+�����c� � \�V`bWVef{[gb}Vgw�TW\�VZPa9s�RyqSf{b,acQSVe�i[gb}��[gf7TW\�VYs�VZs��:s�TWVeQ�s5RjsT}[kQ�ag_mf{bW[9Q�_�RU£)V`z¡��Pa9s�VYX�bWV`_�bWVYs�V`d&T}aBT}RU[9ds7T}[�T}\�V5\RUn9\�Veb�zUV`ogV`zDq`aBT��V`ng[9bWRjV`s�Ved/qr[:X:V`X�Rjd�TW\�V������ _acb,acQSVrT}Veb,sS��sWVeV � RUn/� ! � x��¤a9���r� #�T^RjsT}\�Rys#qea9s�Vp�7\Rjq,\�Q�ac�9V`s�_�[9s}s�RjP�zjV�TW\�V�X�V`sWRUn9dZ[gf?s�V`z¡f§�Lqr[9d9T,acRjd�V`XkQ�acd:�Q�a9q,\�RUdV�Rjd&TWV`b�f�a9qrV`s`�

� t X:R �-Veb}Ved&TksWRUTWOacTWRj[gdJacb}RjsWV`s`wi�7\�VedJ�iV�qr[9ds�RyX:V`b�OsWRUd�n;T}\�V������_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s5a9s�a�f{V`acTWO�b}VZogV`qrTW[9b�f{[9b5T}\�VZRUQ�acn9Vg�E#Ld�TW\�Rys�qea9s�V TW\�V����� _agb}agQSVrTWV`b}s�X:[�d�[gT5b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&TpT}\�V _�Veb,qrV`_:TWOagziq`aBT}Veng[9bWRjV`s^[cfRjd&TWV`bWVYs�TYwP�O:T�s�V`bWo9V�a9s7Rjd�_�O:T�T}[ acdma9X�X:RUTWRj[gdagz*s�T,acn9V�[gf�zUVYacb}d�RUdnw�Rjd�7\Rjq,\8TW\Vm|dagz�qeaBT}Ven9[gb}�;TW[�P�V�V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWVYX8QSa���P/Vm\agdX)��zjagP/V`zUVYX�¤s�V`V � RUn/� ! � x��{P������� V(X:VeQS[gd/s�T}b}acTWV�TW\V�f{[gb}Q�V`b*qr[9dqrV`_:T�[cf:a7sWVezUf§��qe[gd&T}agRUd�VYX�QSagd:��QSa9q,\�Rjd�V

Rjd9T}VebWf�agqeVgw&TW\�b}[gOng\ a5d�Ve�%s��:s�TWV`Q TW\acT7q`acd TWb,agq,��f�agqeRjagz�Ve£:_�bWVYsWsWRj[gds`� � \VsW�)s�TWV`Q �([9bW�:s�P)��V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWRjd�n�TW\�V�_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s�[gf�a _�RU£:Vez��*��� [gfpTW\�VQS[gO:T}\�s�\ag_/VYs�[cf7ams�Rjd�n9zUVS_�Veb,s�[9d�OsWRjd�n�N)¥�� b}Ven9bWVYsWsWRU[9d��\#�T^Rjsp[9P)o&Rj[gO/sTW\/aBT�T}\�Rjs#�([9O�zyXmaczjzU[B�¢Os7T}[�TWb,agq,�kQ�[9O:TW\mQS[Bo9VeQSVed&T}s`� t X�X:RUTWRj[gd/aczjzU�9w�iVaczysW[�sW\�[B��TW\acT�TW\�V�_bWRjdqrRj_agzqr[9Q�_�[gdVed&T}s�[gf/T}\�V �[B�8s�_a9qrV7[gf/T}\�V�QS[gO:T}\�*��� qr[gb}b}V`sW_/[9dX�T}[�X:Rys�T}RUdqrT^f�agqeRjagz?Vr£:_�b}V`s}sWRU[9dse� � \�Veb}Vrf{[9bWVSVYs�T}RUQ�aBT}RUdn�*��� _agb}agQSVrTWV`b}siaczjzj[B��s(O/siTW[5TWb,agq,�Sf�agqeRjagz-Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gds(T}[&[/�f#LdZqe[gd&TWb,ags�TTW[Zaczjz*VYacb}zURjVeb�s��:s�TWVeQ�s#TWb,agq,�)Rjd�nSf�agqeRjagz�Ve£)_bWVYsWsWRU[9ds^� �?O�RUzjzjV5VeT�acz�� � ! ��w � VebW�

Page 16: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

¨e[9_/[9O�zj[9s�acdX � aBT}Veb,s � % x ��w&hizjag�gV7acdX\#�s}acb,X�� x % ��w V s}sWa�acdXS��V`d9T}zjagdX � ! ����whizja9q,�ZagdX �1a9qr[)[gP � ( ��wHhiVe�)QSVeb�VrTpacz�� � % ��w V ¨`¨`acT � !�U ��w�l([)[cTWVYs#VeT�agz¤� � ! x �acd/X �O�Q�acb�acdX5��[gn9ngRj[ � %2+ �§��[9O�bDsW�:s�T}VeQ2Rys�agP�zjV1T}[�X:Rjb}V`q�T}zU��VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}V1T}[g_:�X:[B�7d����*�����(_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s�f{b}[gQ P�[cTWTW[9Q5��O�_k_�R¡£:V`z¡��PagsWV`X bWV`_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gds`wacd/X�T}\&O/s�a�og[9RjX�siQ�acd)Oagz�acd�d[cT}acTWRj[gd��l([gd&TWRjd)O�Rjd�n�RUdSa�s�RjQSRUzyacb�ogV`RUd*wc�(V7agzjsW[�Ve£:_�zU[9bWV(TW\V7_/[&sWsWRUPRUzjR¡T���[cf/zjV`agbWd��

Rjd�n�T}[kVYs�T}RUQ�aBT}V^T}\�V5_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s�[cf1akzjRUd�V�X:b,a��7RUd�nZ�*��� � � V�qe[gds�TWb}OqrTa�zjRUdV�X:b,a��7RUd�n������¦T}\aBT#QS[:X:V`zjs�f�agqrRyacz�_/[&s�V5acdX�N)¥���b}Vengb}V`s}sWRU[9dZagdX�iV zjV`acb}d�T}[�V`s�TWRjQ�aBT}VkRUT}s�_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s^f{bW[9Q _R¡£:VezU��PagsWV`X�b}Ve_bWVYs�V`d9T,aBT}RU[9ds[cf�T}\�VSRUQ�agngVg� � \�V5TWb,acRjd�Rjd�nksWVrT�RUd�TW\�Rys�qea9s�V5Rjs�[gP�T}acRjd�VYXmP)�mQSacT}q,\�Rjd�nZaqr[&acb,s�ViV`X�ngV7Q�ac_�[gf/T}\�V�Rjd�_�O:T1RjQ�acn9V�TW[�TW\V�zURjd�V#X�b}a��7Rjd�np�*���>OsWRjd�n�TW\�VN W ] agzUn9[gb}R¡T}\�Q�� � agqeRjagzH_/[&s�VpVYs�T}RUQ�acTWRj[gdZ\ags7agzU��a��:s(P�VeV`d�RUQS_�[gbWT}acd&T�f{[gbsWO�PsWV`~&O�Ved&T5f�agqrRyacz�acd/aczj�)sWRys^RjdqrzjOX:Rjd�n�f�a9qrVZbWVYqr[9ngd�RUTWRj[gd����mOq,\�_bWV`o&Rj[gO/s�i[gb}��[gd8_/[&s�VmVYs�T}RUQ�aBT}RU[9d<\/agsSb}VezjRUVYX<[9d�f{VYaBT}O�bWV�X�VrTWVYq�T}RU[9d�f{[9zUzj[B�(VYX�P)�ngV`[gQSVrT}bWRyqSQS[:X:VezjRUdnmTW[�VYs�T}RUQ�acTWV�T}\�V�_�[9sWVg��N)[gQSV��i[gb}��\/ags^P�VeV`d X:[gdV[gdkQ�aBT}q,\RUd�nSQS[:X:Vezys��{QS[gb}_�\agP�zjV�QS[:X:V`zjs�RjdZq`agsWV�[gfDhiVe�)QSVeb7agdX ��[9ngngRj[� x ��wHV`zja9s�T}Rjq5ngb,ac_\s�Rjd�q`agsWV�[cf �bWO�n9Veb�VrT^acz�� � ugv �§��OsWRUdnkacd/aczj�)sWRys#P)�ms��)d:�TW\V`sWRjs(QSVrTW\[)Xse� " VYqrVed&T}zU�SRUTi\a9s1P�VeV`d sW\�[B�7d�P)��N)\�Veb}b,ac\�VrT�acz�� � xY( �-TW\acTW acP�[gb7��a�ogV`zUVeT}s�qr[9Q�P�Rjd�VYX �7RUTW\m�il t [9dk_R¡£:Vez*RUQ�acn9V`s�qeagd��&RjVezyXZa5_�[9sWVr�sWRUQSRjzjagbWRUT���s�_/agqrV9�M*�O�bp�i[gb}�mqeagbWb}RUVYs�TW\�Rys�RjX�V`akf{[gb}�iagb}X�acdX��(V�qe[gQS_�O:T}Vb}VezyaBTWRj[gd/s�\�Rj_s5P/VeT��(V`Ved<_�R¡£:V`z7bWV`_�bWVYs�V`d&T}aBT}RU[9ds�agdX�a�_�[9sWVZsW_agqeVkX:Ve|d�VYXOsWRUdnSa�zjRUdVr�LX:b}a��7Rjd�nS�*��� �

" V`qeVed&TWzj�^RUT�\ags�P�VeV`d�sWO�ngn9V`s�TWVYXpTW\/aBT?�*���>_agb}agQSVrTWV`b}sDqr[9O�zyX^P�V7Os�VYXf{[gb�\�Rjng\Veb7zjVeogV`zHacdagzU�:sWRjs�sWOq,\Za9s(f�agqrV�RyX:Ved&T}R¡|/q`aBT}RU[9d��¤h(zyacd¨�� %Y& �*acdX V X)���acb,X�s#VeT^acz�� � x ! �§�r� � \V`sWV�QSVeTW\�[:X�s�f�agzUz�Rjd�T}\�VSzjacT�T}VebpqeacTWVen9[gb}��[cfiag_�_�zjR¡�qeacTWRj[gds�R¤� Vg�;Pa9s�VYX�[gd8s�O_/V`bWo)Rys�VYX;zUVYacb}d�RUdn��7RUTW\ T}\�V��*��� _acb,acQSVrT}Veb,sags#acd�RUQ�agngV�f{V`acTWO�b}Vg� � \�V^ag_�_�zjRjq`aBTWRj[gd��iV�qr[9dsWRjX:V`b7Rjs�TW\�V�bWVYqr[gn9d�RUTWRj[gdZ[cfo)RjsWVeQSVYse��¥�RjsWVeQSVYs�agbWV�T}\�V1o)Rys�O/acz9agdaczj[gn9O�V`s�[cf�_�\�[9d�VeQSVYs1� V ¨e¨YaBT�agdX^��[gng�ngRj[ � %�! �{��� " V`qe[gngdRU¨`RUd�n�o)Rys�V`Q�VYs�\a�ogV�_�[cT}Ved&TWRyacz�ag_�_�zjRjq`aBTWRj[gd/s�RUdSVed\acdqeRUdnTW\V7_/V`b�f{[9bWQ�acd/qrV�[cf-s�_�VeVYq,\�b}V`qe[gn9d�R¡T}RU[9d5sW�:s�T}VeQ�s�[gb?X:b}Rjo&Rjd�n�_�\�[gTW[9bWVYaczjRjs�TWRyqa�oBaBT,acb,se� t f{O�zjz?T}bWVYaBTWQSV`d9Tp[gfio)Rys�V`Q�VYs�Rjs^P/V`�g[gd/X�T}\�V�s}qr[g_�V�[cfiTW\Rjs�T}\�Vr�sWRjs`��«#[B�(V`ogVeb*�(V(TWVYs�TDTW\�Vis�RjQS_�zjV1T}V`q,\�d�Ry~&O�Vi[cf�Q�ac_�_RUd�n�s�Rjd�n9zUViRUQ�agngV`s*RUd&T}[o)RjsWVeQSV�qrzyags}s�VYs*P)��T}b}agRUd�Rjd�n�qrzyags}s�RU|Veb,s�[gd^T}\�ViQSacT}q,\�Rjd�n��*��� _acb,acQSVeTWVeb,s`�t zUTW\[gO�n9\�TW\Rjs�QSVrT}\�[:X�\a9s#d[cT�P/V`Ved�f{O�zUzj�mVr£:_�zj[gb}V`X�w�RUTpb}agRjsWV`s�~&O�V`s�TWRj[gds[gdkTW\V^acP�RjzURUT���[gf������ _acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s(TW[�s�OPs�T}R¡T}O:TWV�f{[9b7RUQ�agngV�f{V`acTWO�b}V`s`�

����� �]��1.�������(����"G+��#�#"=�B�0��>]"$���.���

� \�V#sWRjngd�RU|/qeagd&T(qr[9d9T}bWRjP�O:T}RU[9ds?[gf-TW\�Rys?T}\�V`sWRys1Ve£&T}VedX�TW[^P�[cT}\�w:~9OV`s�TWRj[gds1[cfaSsWqeRUV`d&TWRU|/q���P�Rj[gzj[gngRyqeagz/d/aBTWObWV^a9s(�iVezjz*a9s�[cfDagd�Ved�n9RUd�V`Veb}RUdn5�)RjdXH�� \�V�sWRUn9d�R¡|�qeacd&T^qr[9d&TWb}RUP�O�TWRj[gds�[gf1TW\Rjs�T}\�V`sWRys�TW[�VedngRjd�VeV`bWRjd�nmac_�_zURyqeac�

Page 17: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

TWRj[gd/s7acb}V

� t _�O�b}Vezj��P�[cTWTW[9Q5��O�_^agdXpX�aBT,aB�LX:b}RUo9Ved�zUVYacb}d�Rjd�nc��PagsWV`X�b}V`aczU��TWRjQ�V(s��:s��T}VeQ q`ac_agP�zjV#[cf*TWb,agq,�)RUdnpf�agqeV`siacdXkacdagzU�)¨eRjd�n�f{[gbiPagsWRjq�Vr£:_�b}V`s}sWRU[9dssWOq,\magsi[9_/V`d�d�V`s}s�agdXksWQSRUzjVgw/ags��iVezjz�ags�_�[9sWVg�

� ��[)X�VezjRUd�n�QS[gO�TW\�s�\/ac_�V`spacd/X�Ve£)_bWVYsWsWRU[9ds�OsWRUd�n�_�RU£:Vez1������spagdXf�a9qrRyaczH_�[9sWVpOsWRUd�nSzjRUdVr�LX:b}a��7Rjd�nS�*����se�

� t zUVYacb}d�RUdnc��PagsWV`XZac_�_bW[&agq,\�T}[�V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWV^TW\�V^_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s([gf?�*����sX�RUb}V`qrTWzj��f{b}[gQET}\�VpRUQ�agngVg�

� l([9Q�P�Rjd�Rjd�n<TW\�V�acP�[BogV�ac_�_�b}[9a9q,\�V`skacdX�TW\VeRjb�ag_�_�zjRjq`aBT}RU[9dJTW[<TW\�VX�V`sWRUn9dk[gf*d�Ve�%s��:s�TWV`QSsi�7RUTW\�o)RjsWRj[gdkq`ac_agP�RjzURUTWRjV`s�sWOq,\ka9s(Ve£:_�bWVYsWsWRj[gdb}V`qe[gn9d�R¡T}RU[9d�w:_�[9sWV�VYs�T}RUQ�acTWRj[gd�acdXZo)RjsWVeQSV�b}V`qr[9ngd�RUTWRj[gd*�� \�V�Q�acRjd�qr[9d&TWb}RUP�O�TWRj[gd�[cf�TW\Rjs�TW\�VYs�RysSTW[<sWqeRUV`d9T}R¡|�q���P�RU[9zU[9ngRyqeagz�~&O�VYs��

TWRj[gd/s(zjRjV`s�Rjd T}\�Vps�O�n9ngVYs�T}RU[9d�[cf�a5sW_/VYqrRU|/q�s�T}bWO/q�TWObWV�acdX bW[9zUV�TW[�T}[g_:�LX:[B�7dRjd:f{[gb}Q�aBTWRj[gd RUdZP/[gT�T}[gQ���O_k_�b}[:qrVYsWsWV`s1f{[gbi_/V`b}qeVe_:T}Oacz-T,agsW�:s?��dagQ�V`zU��TW\acTapQS[gb}_�\agP�zjV�QS[)X�Vez�Rjsiqeag_acP�zjV�[gf-b}Ve_bWVYs�V`d9T}RUdnpTW[9_:��X�[B�7d��&d[B�7zUVYX:ngV�agdXTW\/aBT�TW\�VS_�O�b}_�[9sWV5[gf1zUVYacb}d�Rjd�n Rys�TW[ZV`s�T}acPzURys�\�a��¤X:RjbWVYq�T,�#b}VezyaBTWRj[gd/s�\�Rj_�P�Vr�T��iVeVedkTW\VpRUdqe[gQSRjd�nSbWVeTWRjdaczHRjQ�acngVpagdXkTW\�V�QS[gb}_�\agP�zUV�QS[:X:Vez�s�_a9qrV9�

����� ��� �%� � ���(� �.& "$���/�-���%�=���

#LdmT}\�V5dVr£)T�q,\ag_:TWV`b`w��iV5X:VYsWqebWRjP/V5RUd�X:VrT,acRjz*T}\�VSX:R �-Veb}Ved&T�qr[gQS_�[gd�V`d&T}s�[cfTW\V5b}V`agz¡��TWRjQSV�s��:s�TWV`Q f{[9b#f�a9qrVe�¤T}b}a9q,�&Rjd�n�agdX�agdaczj�:s�Ryse� � V�P�b}RUd�nk[gO:T�TW\�VP�[cT�T}[gQ���O�_�w*X�acT}ac��X:b}RjogVed�daBT}O�b}V5[gf1TW\VSsW�:s�T}VeQ agdX�qr[gQS_agbWV�RUT}s�_�VebWf{[gbW�Q�acdqeV5�7RUTW\�[cT}\�VebpsW�:s�T}VeQ�s��7R¡T}\�aZs�RjQSRUzyacb�n9[9acz�� #Ld;q,\ac_:T}Vebpu�wH�iVSs�\agzUzX:RysWqeOs}s1T}\�VpX:V`sWRjngd [gf�a5Q�[9bW_\acP�zjV�Q�[:X:V`z�f{[gbiTW\�Vpqezja9sWsi[cf�Q�[9O:TW\ZRjQSagngVYsacd/X�zUVYacb}d�RUdn�R¡T,s#_agb}agQSVrTWV`b}s7X�RUb}V`qrTWzj� f{b}[gQ TW\�V5RUQ�agngVg� #Ld�q,\ag_:TWV`b % w�iVX:VYsWqebWRjP/V�oBacb}RU[9Os(ag_�_�zjRjq`aBT}RU[9ds1[gf*[gObiag_�_�b}[9agq,\��7\Rjq,\kRUdqezUO/X:V�Ve£:_�bWVYsWsWRj[gdb}V`qr[9ngd�RUTWRj[gd*w�_/[&s�VSVYs�T}RUQ�aBT}RU[9d�acdX�o)RjsWVeQSV�b}V`qr[9ngd�RUTWRj[gd*� � Rjdaczjzj���iV�qr[gd��qrzjOX:VkP)�;qe[gdsWRyX:Veb}RUdnmTW\�VZd�V`� ~&O�V`s�TWRj[gds^TW\acT5T}\�Rys5�i[gb}��b}agRjsWV`s^agdX RUT}sRjQ�_zURyqeacTWRj[gdsif{[9b�qr[gn9d�RUTWRjogVpsWqeRUV`dqrVpa9s��(V`zUz�a9s�Ved�n9RUd�V`Veb}RUdn�

Page 18: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� ��������� �

� ��� � � � � ����� � e��� �� ��� ������ ����� � ��� � � ��� ��� � � �� � � � � ����� �$ ��� � � � �

� \�Rys?q,\ag_:TWV`b1X:V`s}qrb}RjP/VYs?a�TWb,acRjdagP�zUV�sW�:s�T}VeQ qeac_/acP�zjV7[cf-TWb,agq,�)Rjd�n�f�agqeV`s?agdXf�agqeRjagzBf{V`acTWO�b}V`s*zURj�gV�V`�gVYs*acd/X�d�[9s�TWb}RUzys�agdX�V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWRjd�n�P/agsWRjq�QS[gO�TW\�f{V`acTWO�b}V`ssWOq,\�ags�X�Vengb}VeVYs7[cf�[9_/V`d�d�V`s}s#agdXmsWQ�RjzjV�RjdmbWVYacz�T}RUQSV9� #Ld�X:Veo9Vezj[g_�Rjd�n�T}\�RjssW�)s�TWV`Q�w&�iV�\a�ogV�agX�X:b}V`s}sWV`XST}\�V#T��7RjdZRjs}s�OV`s([cf*RjQ�acngV�b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd�agdXaczjng[9bWRUTW\QSs�f{[gbizUVYacb}d�RUdn� � V�\a�ogV�O/s�VYXSTW\�V�«#a9acb1��a�ogV`zUVeT1b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gdTW[�bW[9P�Os�TWzj��q`ac_:T}O�b}V1oBacb}RU[9OsHf�a9qrRyaczgf{V`aBT}O�b}V`s`� � \�Rys�sW�:s�T}VeQ�wBO�d�zjRj�gV1_bWV`o&Rj[gO/sac__�bW[&agq,\�VYsew/Rjs�V`d9T}RUb}Vezj��TWb,acRjd�VYXmOsWRUd�nZVr£�agQ�_zUVYs�agdX�X:[)VYs#d�[gT�b}Vezj�m[gd�a_�b}RU[9bWR���\acdX:��qeb}acf§TWV`X/�iQ�[:X:V`zjs�[cf*f�a9qrRyacz-f{VYaBTWObWVYs7PagsWV`Xk[gdZ[g_�TWRyqeacz �[B��[9bf�agqeRjagz�Q5Os}qrO�zyaBT}O�bWV9� � \�Veb}Vrf{[9bWV5R¡Tpb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T,s�a _�O�b}Vezj�mP/[gT�TW[9Q���O�_8�§f{V`V`X)�f{[gb}��acb,X�1ag_�_�b}[9a9q,\�TW[�f�a9qrRyacz�acd/aczj�)sWRyse�� \�V�sW�:s�T}VeQ>�([9bW�:s�Rjd�s�V`ogVeb,acz�s�T}agngVYs�TW\acT#P�VengRjdm�7RUTW\�f�agqeV�X:VeTWV`qrTWRj[gd�w

f{[gzjzj[B�(VYX P)� zj[:qeagzURj¨`acTWRj[gdZ[cf�f�agqeRjagz-f{V`aBT}O�b}V`s�agdXZV`s�TWRjQSacTWRj[gd�[cf�QS[gO�TW\�_aB�b,acQSVrT}Veb,se� V agq,\5[cfT}\�V`sWV7s�T,acn9V`sDRjsDf{[9bWQ5O�zyaBTWVYX5a9s�a�_bW[9P�zUV`Q2RUdSsWO�_/V`bWo)Rys�VYXzjV`acb}d�Rjd�nmf{b}[gQ�Ve£:agQS_�zUVYse� � VZag_�_�zj�;TW\�VZd�V`� acdX�bW[9P�Os�T�T}V`q,\�d�Ry~&O�VZ[cfsWO�_�_�[gbWT^ogV`qrTW[9b�Q�a9q,\�RUdV`s��¤N:¥����pf{[gb^qrzyags}sWR¡|/q`aBT}RU[9d�Rjd�TW\�V�s�T}agngVS[cf7s��)RjdsWVengQSV`d9T,aBT}RU[9d�w�f�agqrV�X:VeTWVYq�TWRj[gd�acdX�Ve�9V�X�VrTWVYq�T}RU[9d�� V s�T}RUQ�aBT}RU[9d�[gf(QS[gO:T}\_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s�Rys^QS[:X:VezjV`X�ags^amb}Ven9bWVYsWsWRj[gd�f{bW[9Q a�sW_acb,sWV�s�O�P/s�VeT�[cf�qr[)V�X��qrRjVed&T,s��{Pa9s�Rys�f{O�d/q�TWRj[gd/s}��[gf-agdS[BogVeb,qr[9QS_�zUVeTWV7X:Ryq�T}RU[9dacb}�^[cfH«#a9acb���a�ogV`zUVeT}s`�

! �

Page 19: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

��a9� ��P/� ��qY�

� RUn9O�b}V(x:� ! ©�#LzjzjOs�T}b}acTWRjd�n7T}\�V(O/s�V([cf:TW\V(sW�&Rjd�sWVen9Q�V`d&T}aBT}RU[9d^acdX�qr[gQS_�[gd�V`d&TTWb,agq,�)Rjd�n�k��a9� � \�VSRjdX:[)[gb^s}qrV`d�Vgw?��P/��aBf§T}Veb^sW�)RUd;s�V`ngQSVed&T,aBTWRj[gd*w?��q`��acf§TWVebqr[9QS_/[9d�Ved&T7Vr£)TWb,agqrTWRj[gd�acdX TWb,agq,�)Rjd�n�

� ��� D����(��� �*"=�A��"$���#� ��H��<"=�A�

#LdJT}\�RjsZsWV`q�T}RU[9d�w��iV�P�b}RjV ��JX:VYsWqebWRjP/V�TW\�V�f�agqeV�X:VeTWV`qrTWRj[gd�sW�:s�T}VeQ �7\�Ryq,\zj[)q`aczjRU¨`V`s�a�f{b}[gd&T}agz�acdX5O�d�[:qeqezUO/X:V`X5f�agqeV7RUd�agd5RjQ�acngV7sWV`~&O�V`dqrV�agdX^T}b}a9q,�:sRUT`�e#�T O/s�VYs sW�&Rjd�sWVen9Q�V`d&T}aBT}RU[9dJacdX�QS[cT}RU[9d�TWb,agq,�)Rjd�n;TW[<�gVeV`_�TWb,agq,�<[cfqeagdX:RyX�aBT}V�b}VengRj[gd/s?Rjd�TW\�V�RjQSagngV9� � \�Rys(Rjs1f{[gzjzU[B�iV`XSP)��qrzyags}sWR¡|/q`aBT}RU[9d�[gfHTW\�VqeagdX:RyX�aBT}Vkb}Ven9RU[9ds5RUd&TW[�f�agqeVmacdX�d�[gd:��f�agqeV T}\)Os�zU[:qeagzURj¨eRjd�n�TW\�V�_�[9sWR¡T}RU[9dacd/Xks}qeagzUV�[cfDTW\V�f{b}[gd&T,acz-f�agqeVg�

��������� �� ���G�&��31� �*�(':��'����1�>�����!-�1� 6p�1�����1'�')���! ����3N)�)Rjd�X:VeTWV`qrTWRj[gd�Rjs�OsWV`X�TW[�s�V`ngQSVed&T�RUQ�acn9V`s�Rjd9T}[Zq`acdX�RjX�acTWV5\�V`a9X�b}VengRj[gd/sacd/XSPagq,�)ngb}[gOdXH� � \V�sW�&Rjd�X:VeTWV`qrTW[9b1�i[gb}�)s?P&�Ss}qeacdd�RUdnpTW\�V�RUd_�O:T�RUQ�acn9VRjd8b,ags�TWV`b�sWq`acd�acdX�qrzyags}sWR¡f{�)Rjd�n�VYagq,\8_�RU£)V`z�Rjd9T}[ s��)Rjd<[9b�d�[gd���sW�)RUd�� � \VsW�&Rjd QS[:X:VeziRys^[gP�T}acRjd�VYX�P)��T}b}agRUdRUd�n�a�N)¥�� OsWRUd�n�TW\�V T��([�qr[gQS_�[gd�V`d&Tf{V`acTWO�b}V�ogVYq�TW[9b��� ������� � � ������� ���7\�V`bWV���� ��� ���r�Sacb}V�bWVYXHw�ngb}VeV`d8agdX8P�zUOVqr[9QS_/[9d�Ved&T}s�[cf1TW\�V�_�RU£)V`z¤� � \�V`bWV�Vr£:Rys�T,s#QS[9bWV�s�[9_�\�Rys�T}Rjq`aBTWVYX�f{V`acTWO�b}V`s#f{[gbsW�&Rjd�X:VeTWVYq�TWRj[gd8���*VeVSacdX W [&[:X:�7Rjd � u ! �§�#P�O:TpX:O�V5TW[�qr[9ds�T}b}agRUd&T,s�[cf(bWVYaczU�TWRjQSVm_�b}[)qeV`s}s�Rjd�n;�iVZO/s�VYX8a�sWRjQ�_zUVm[9d�Vg� � V�qr[9zUzjV`qrTWVYX<[Bo9Veb�xcv9vgv�s��)Rjds}acQS_�zjV`s5[cf�X:R �-Veb}Ved&T�_�Ve[9_�zjVZ�7RUTW\<�7RjX�Vezj��o�agbW�)Rjd�n�sW�)RUd�TW[9d�VZagdX OdX:VebX:R ��V`bWRjd�nSzjRUn9\9T}RUdnSqe[gdX�R¡T}RU[9dse�� \�V^sW�&Rjdms�V`ngQSVed&T}V`XkRUQ�acn9V�Rjs�agdaczj�)¨eVYX Rjd&TW[�qr[9d�d�VYq�TWVYXkqe[gQS_�[gd�V`d9T,se�

� V�V`dqr[:X:V�agdX��9VeVe_�TWb,agq,��[gf1TW\V�_�[9sWRUTWRj[gdspagdX�o9Vezj[)qeR¡T}RUVYs�[cf1T}\�V�qr[9Q5�_�[gd�V`d9T,se� � \�Rys(RUd:f{[9bWQ�acTWRj[gd�Rys1OsWV`X�TW[�_bWVYX:RjqrT(�7\�V`bWV�TW\�V�qr[9Q�_�[gdVed&T(�7RjzUzP�V�sWVeV`d Rjd�T}\�V�d�Vr£)T�f{b}agQSV�acd/X�T}\&O/s(\Vezj_s�qr[gd/s�T}b}agRUdk[gO�b�s�VYacb,q,\�f{[gb7sW�)RUd��l([gQS_�[gd�V`d&T}s�T}\aBT�acb}V�s�Q�aczjzjVeb�T}\acd�a�_�b}V`X�Vr|d�VYX�TW\�b}V`sW\�[9zjXS[9b�TW\�[&s�V�TW\acT\a�o9V^d�[ QS[gTWRj[gd�acT�aczjz�agbWV�X:RysWq`acb,X:V`XZf{b}[gQ�qr[9dsWRjX:V`b}acTWRj[gd�� t s#TWRjQ�V�ng[)VYs[gdm��RUdS[gOb1qea9s�V7aBf§T}Veb(xgv�f{b}agQ�VYs�aBf§T}Veb1apqe[gQS_�zjVrTWV7b}V`s}qeagd/��wcTW\�V�sW�)RUd�sWV`acb,q,\Rys�f{O�bWTW\Veb�bWVYs�T}bWRyq�T}V`X�[gdzU�kTW[kbWV`ngRj[gds#�7R¡T}\�agqrTWRjogV�qe[gQS_/[9d�Ved&T,s5��R¤� Vg���7R¡T}\f�agqeV`s,��� t sZa;bWVYs�Oz¡T�T}\�V�_�VebWf{[gb}Q�acdqeVm[cf�TW\�Rys s�T}agngV�a9q�TWO/aczjzU�<RUQS_�b}[BogVYssWRUdqeV�sW_�O�b}RU[9Os�sW�&RjdmRys�VezjRjQ�RjdacTWV`XmagdXZTW\V5sWV`acb,q,\�Rjs#\�V`a�o)RjzU�Zqr[9ds�T}b}agRUdV`X

Page 20: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

Rjd�sW_acTWRyaczHVr£)T}Ved&T�ags�RjzUzjOs�TWb,aBTWVYXZRUdk|ngObWV^x:� ! �hi[cTW\msW�)RUdmsWVengQSV`d9T,aBT}RU[9dZagdX�qr[gQS_�[gd�V`d&T#acdagzU�:sWRjs�Rys7_�VebWf{[gb}Q�VYX [9dma

sWO�P:�LsWagQ�_zUVYX acd/X�|zUTWV`bWVYX RjQ�acngV�acd/X�RysiTW\�V`bWVef{[gb}V#f�a9s�T�acd/X�b}VezjRjagP�zUV9� � \�Rjss�T}acn9V5\/ags�_�b}[BogVed�TW[�P�V�o9Veb}�mOsWVrf{O�z?sWRUd/qrVSR¡T^V`zURjQSRUd/aBTWVYs�zjagbWn9V�b}Ven9RU[9ds�[cfTW\V�RjQ�acn9V�agdX sWVeo9Veb,acz-sWq`aczjV`s��{RjQ�acngV�b}V`sWRU¨`RUd�n�P�VeRjd�n�qr[gQS_�O�T}aBT}RU[9daczjzj��RUd:�TWV`dsWRUo9V7TW\�Rys(Rjs(_acbWTWRyqrOzjagbWzj��OsWVrf{Ozy�?f{bW[9Q qe[gdsWRyX:Veb,aBT}RU[9dSf{[gb?f�a9qrV�X:VrT}V`q�T}RU[9dacd/X \�V`zU_/s7RUdmX:[9O�P�zjRUdn5T}\�V�f{b,acQSV�b}acTWVg�

������� � F���!-� � ��')��!�':���1�� \�V^N)¥�� qezja9sWsWRU|Veb�OsWV`XZRjdkT}\�V�f�agqeV^X:VrT}V`q�T}RU[9dZsW�:s�T}VeQ \/ags�P�VeVedZT}b}agRUd�VYXOsWRUdn^(:w vgv9v�f{b}[gd&T}agz#f�a9qrV;acdX % (�w v9vgv;d�[9d:�¤f�a9qrV�_aBTWTWV`bWds`w#VYagq,\�_/aBT�T}Veb}dP�VeRjd�n�d�[gb}Q�aczjRU¨`V`X�T}[�a�sWRU¨`V([gf !�U�� !�U � #�T?qe[gQS_/V`ds}aBTWVYs�f{[gb�qrV`b�T,acRjd5sW[gO�b,qrVYs[cfDRUQ�agngV�oBacb}RjacTWRj[gdsiP)� sWO�P:TWb,agqrTWRjd�n�a�P/VYs�TW�¤|�T�PbWRjng\&TWdV`s}s(_zjagd�V�f{bW[9QETW\�V_�RU£:Vez�oBaczjO�V`s�T}[mqr[gb}b}V`q�T�f{[gb^sW\a9X:[B��s�acdX�\�Rys�T}[gngb,acQ�VY~&OaczjRU¨YaBT}RU[9d�[cf(TW\�VRjQSagngV�_acT�TWV`bWd/siTW[�qr[9Q�_�Ved/sWacTWV�f{[gb7zjRUn9\&TWRjd�n�acdXZqeagQSVeb,a�oBacb}RyaBTWRj[gd/se�� a9qrV#X:VeTWVYq�TWRj[gd�q`acdSP�V#s�OQ�Q�agbWRj¨eVYX�ags�f{[9zUzj[B��se� � [9b1ngb}V`acTWV`b?X:VrT,acRjz:TW\�V

b}V`agX�Veb�Rjs�b}Vrf{V`bWb}V`X TW[ *�sWO�daw:VrT#acz�� � !�% ���� l([9dsWRjX:V`b7V`a9q,\k[gf*TW\V^agq�T}RUo9Vpqr[gQS_�[gd�V`d&T}s�Rjd�sWV`~&O�V`dqrV9�

� N�qeaczjV�V`a9q,\Zqe[gQS_/[9d�Ved&T#sWVeo9Veb,acz/TWRjQ�VYse�

� l(O�T !�U�� !�U �7RUd/X:[B��s(f{bW[9Q TW\V^sWq`aczjV`XZqr[gQS_�[gd�V`d&T}s`�� �1bWVe��_bW[:qrVYsWs�VYagq,\��7RUd/X:[B���7RUTW\�P�b}Rjng\&TWd�VYsWs*qr[gb}b}V`q�T}RU[9d�agdX�\�Rys�T}[gngb,acQVY~&OaczjRU¨YaBT}RU[9d��

� l(zyags}sWR¡f{��VYagq,\Z�7RUd/X:[B�¢a9s�VeRUTW\�V`b7f�agqeV�[9b7d�[gd��¤f�a9qrV� V(T}ag�gV1TW\�ViogV`bW��|b,s�T�sWq`aczjV(acd/X�TW\�ViogV`bW��|b,s�TDzU[:q`aBTWRj[gd��7\�Veb}V(a�f�agqrV(Rjs

X:VeTWV`qrTWVYX ags(T}\�V�_�[9sWRUTWRj[gd [gf�TW\V�f�a9qrV9� � V�aczys�[5�gVeV`_�T}b}a9q,��[gf�TW\V�_�[9sWR¡T}RU[9dacd/X ogV`zU[:qeR¡T}RUVYs�[gf#TW\V f�a9qrV`s��7RUTW\�Rjd8V`agq,\<qr[gQS_�[gd�V`d&T`� � \�Rys�\�Vezj_s�OsSRjd_�b}V`X:Ryq�T}RUdn�TW\�V�_/[&s�RUTWRj[gdm[gf�TW\�Vpf�a9qrV^RjdmT}\�V�d�Ve£)T�f{b}agQSV�acdXZT}\)Os#b}V`X�OqrVYs[gOb1s�VYacb,q,\�f{O�b�T}\�VebY�/*�dqrV�TW\�V#f�agqrV�Rjs(X:VrT}V`qrTWV`X�R¡TiRjs1bWVYs�Rj¨eVYX�TW[�a^|�£:V`X�sWRU¨`V[cf ! xgv �M! xgv�f{[gb�f{O�bWTW\Veb?_�b}[:qrVYsWsWRUdn� � \V7bWVYaczU�¤T}RUQSVif�agqeV�X�VrTWVYq�T}RU[9dSsW�:s�T}VeQ�i[gb}�)s�qezU[&s�V�TW[ xY(^f{b,acQSVYs�_/V`b�s�VYqr[gd/XH�

� ��� D����%����� D��%��"$>��� � �*"$�%��"$���.� ���� � �#>]"$�?@���(�������(��"���#�

� a9qrV�zj[)q`aczjRU¨YaBT}RU[9d<qeagd<[9d�zj��ac_�_bW[�£:RjQSacTWV`zU�;_�b}V`X:Ryq�T�T}\�V�zU[:q`aBTWRj[gd8[cf�TW\�VQS[gO:T}\��<N)RjdqeVkT}\�VZf�agqeVZX:VeTWVYq�TWRj[gd8s��:s�TWV`Q�Rjs�sW[gQSVe�7\/aBT�T}[gzjVeb,acd&T�TW[�bW[g�T}acTWRj[gds�acd/X�TWRjz¡T}RUdnk[gf?TW\�V�\�VYagXHwHa�QS[9O:TW\�zU[:qeagzURj¨eV`b#T}\aBT�bWV`zURjV`s�sW[gzjVezj�Z[9d

Page 21: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

Rjd:f{[gb}Q�aBTWRj[gd;[gfif�a9qrV�zj[:qeaBT}RU[9d qeagd�P�V sWRUn9d�RU|/qeagd9T}zU��TW\�b}[B�7d�[���TW\�VkQSagbW�P)��\�VYagX�QS[BogV`QSVed&T}s�T}\aBTkagbWVmd[cT�Rjd�TW\�V�_zjagd�V�[cf�T}\�V�RjQSagngV9�¢�m[9bWVe�[BogV`b`w�a9s�QSVed&T}RU[9d�V`X�V`acb}zjRUV`b5QS[gO�TW\<sW\ag_/VYs�q`acd�q,\/acd�n9VkX:b,acQ�aBT}Rjq`aczjzU�;agsTW\V�_�Veb,sW[gd � s�Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gdkq,\acd�n9V`s`�/*#f§TWVedZRUT�Rjs�d�[gT�qrzjV`acb��7\acT7RjsiT}\�VpRjX�V`aczzj[)q`aczjRU¨YaBT}RU[9d�f{[9b�s�O/q,\;a��7RyX:V`zU��oBacb}�&Rjd�n�_acT�TWV`bWd*� t zUz?[gf�TW\�V agP/[Bo9VS_�\�Vr�d�[9Q�V`daSqeagdZ\/a�ogVpagX:o9Veb,s�V�V ��VYq�T}s�[gdZTW\�V�_/V`b�f{[9bWQ�acd/qrV�[cfDTW\�VpdVr£)T�s�T}acn9V[cf�QS[gO:T}\Sagdaczj�:s�Rys`�DN)[9Q�V�QS[gO�TW\SzU[:q`aczjRU¨`Veb,s�Ve£:Rjs�T?RUd�zjR¡T}Veb,aBTWObWViTW\Ve��V`R¡T}\�Vebb}Vezj�Z[9d�qr[9zU[9b�Rjd:f{[9bWQ�aBT}RU[9d�� *�zjRjogVeb�VrTpacz�� � u & �§��[9b�[9d�[g_:T}Rjq`acz �[B� �¤h(zyagq,�acd/X �1agqr[)[9P � (��§��P�O:T�[gO�b�ac_�_�b}[9a9q,\;�ia9spTW[�VedsWO�b}V�TW\/aBT�T}\�V QS[9O:TW\<bWVe�ngRj[gd�b}VeQ�acRjdsps�T}aBT}RU[9dacb}���7RUTW\;b}V`sW_/VYq�TpTW[m[gTW\�V`bpQS[gb}VSs�T}agP�zjV�zjagdX:Q�acb}�:s[gd5TW\V(f�a9qrV7sWOq,\�a9s�Ve�9V`s�acdX�d�[&s�T}bWRjzyse�;#Ld�T}\�Rjs1ags��iVezjz�ags�TW\�V7zyaBT}Veb?s�T}agngVi[cfQS[gO:T}\�agdaczj�:s�Rys`wBTW\�V7agP�RUzjRUT��^[cf�TW\�V7��a�ogV`zUVeT�T}b}agds�f{[gb}Q�TW[�Vedqe[:X:V�zU[:qeagzURj¨eVYXoBacb}RjacTWRj[gdsi_�zya��:s7aSqrb}OqrRyaczHb}[gzjVg�

��� � ��� � ��!-������#3����7!-�������H�*��D������D':���1�#��A#�)�W��3��¢�D��� �����(�*���H'��� a�ogVezjVrT,s�qeagdJP/V�RUd&T}Veb}_�bWVeTWVYXJags�V`dqr[:X:Rjd�n RjQ�acngV�o�agbWRyaBT}RU[9ds�zj[:qeaczjzj�<RjdsW_agqeV�acdX;sW_aBT}Rjagz�f{bWVY~&O�Vedqe�g�@#Ld;|ngO�b}V x:� xZ�iV�X:Ve_�Ryq�T�TW\�V uZT��)_�V`s�[cf�xX:RjQSVedsWRU[9daczi«#a9acb^��a�ogV`zUVeT}s`� � \�VYs�V�T��&_�V`s5RjdqrzjOX:V�P/agsWRjs^f{O�dq�T}RU[9ds�TW\acTqeag_:TWObWVpq,\agd�ngV�RjdZRjd&TWV`ds�RUT�� Rjd�TW\Vp\�[gb}RU¨`[gd&T}agz�X:RjbWVYq�TWRj[gd*w:TW\�Vpo9VebWTWRyqeagz�X:R¡�b}V`q�T}RU[9d�acd/X�TW\V�X�Rjagng[gd/aczysk��[gbSqr[gb}d�V`b}s,��� � \�V�s�T}acd/X�acb,X «#a9acb��ia�o9VezjVrT,s����aczjzjacT�� u&x �§��acb}Vp�7\aBT#agbWV��)d�[B�7dmags�qe[gQS_�zjVrT}V��{[gb#[gbWTW\�[9d�[gb}Q�acz§�?T}b}agds��f{[gb}Q acdX�agbWV7d�[gT1ogV`bW��OsWVrf{O�zf{[gb([gO�biac_�_�zjRyqeaBT}RU[9d���N)RUd/qrV��iV�d�V`V`X�n9bWVYaBTWV`bb}V`sW[gzjO:TWRj[gd�w*�(VSRjQ�_zUV`Q�V`d&T�acd�[BogVeb,qr[9QS_�zUVeTWV��{b}V`X:OdX�acd&T���ogVeb,sWRU[9d�[cf(TW\�V«#a9acb^��a�ogV`zUVeT}s�RUd �7\Rjq,\;T}\�VkX:Rys�T}acd/qrV P�VrT��iVeV`d�TW\V ��a�ogVezjVrT�qe[)V�X�qrRjVed&T}saBTSsWq`aczjV��Rys�

�x� J��~&OagX�bWO�_zUV�X:Ved/s�RUT����pRjds�T}V`a9X [cf�x� ;f{[gb5TW\VZs�T}agdX�acb,X

TWb,acd/s�f{[9bWQ��#N)RjdqrV�TW\�V�s�_/agqrRjd�n�P�VrT��iVeV`dmTW\V5qr[)V�X�qeRUV`d&T}s�Rys�s�T}RUzjz�Ve£:_/[9d�Ved:�TWRyaczDRjd�TW\V�s}qeagzUV����(V�a�og[gRyXmacd�Vr£:_�zj[9sWRU[9d�RUd�TW\�V�d)O�Q�P�Veb�[cf1qe[)V�X�qrRjVed&T}sacd/XkQ�agRUd&T}agRUdZT}\�V�qr[9QS_�zUVe£:R¡T��k[cfDTW\�V�agzUn9[gb}R¡T}\�Q acT��S�����7RUd�T}\�V^d)O�Q�P�Veb[cfD_�RU£)V`zjs����

#�T�Rys^d[cT5Od�bWVYagsW[gdagP�zjVSTW[�Ve£:_/VYq�T�TW\�Vk�ia�o9VezjVrT^b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd;T}[�P/Vb}VezjRjagP�zUVZf{[9b�zU[:qeacTWRjd�n�X:R ��V`bWV`d9T�f�a9qrRyacz7f{VYaBT}O�bWVYse����[9s�T acb}V`ags�[gf�T}\�V�f�agqeV�7RUTW\^\�Rjng\^f{bWVY~9OVedqe��qe[gd&TWV`d9T���s�TWb}[gd�n#o�agbWRyaBT}RU[9ds,�-acb}V?zU[:q`aczjRU¨`V`X^agbW[9O�dX�TW\�VVe�9V`s`wcT}\�V�d[9sWV#acdX�TW\�V�Q�[9O:TW\*� � \)Os1TW\Ve��acb}V#acQSV`dacP�zjV7T}[5X:VeTWV`qrTWRj[gd�P)�acd)�kQ�VeTW\�[:X�T}\aBT�Vedqe[)X�V`s#sWOq,\mzj[:qeacz*o�agbWRyaBT}RU[9ds7zjRU�9VpTW\V�«#a9acb���a�ogV`zUVeT}s`�� RUn9O�b}V5x:� u�sW\�[B��s�TW\/aBT�RjdmT}\�V5«�agacb#�ia�o9VezjVrT#b}V`sW_/[9dsWV�TW[ b}Ven9RU[9ds�agbW[9O�dXTW\V�d�[&s�V�acd/X�TW\V�QS[gO�TW\�w)f{[9b(T}\�Vpqr[9bWd�V`b?T��)_�V�P/agsWRjs`wgT}\�V�d�[9s�TWb}RjzjsiacdX�TW\�Vqr[9d&TW[gOb}s�[cf(TW\�V�QS[9O:TW\�s�T}acd/X�[9O:T��{\a�o9V�akzyacb}ngVSacP/s�[9zUO:T}VSo�agzUOV5f{[9b�TW\�Vb}V`sW_/[9ds�V���� � \V`sWV�RjX�V`ags5\a�o9V�Q�[gTWRjoBaBTWVYX�Os�TW[�Os�Vk�ia�o9VezjVrTpf{VYaBTWObWVYs�agsf{[gzjzj[B��se�! � � [gb�X:VeTWVYq�TWRj[gd�[gfDd�[&s�T}bWRjzyse�

Page 22: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

-1 11

-1 1 -1

(a) (b) (c)

� RUn9O�b}Vpx�� x�© � \�V^u�T��)_/VYs7[cf?x�X:RjQ�V`dsWRU[9dacz�d[gd:�Ls�T,acdXacb,X «#a9acb7��a�ogV`zUVeT}s����a&� ��ogV`b�T}Rjq`acz���wH�{P�� ��\�[9bWRj¨e[9d9T,acz���agdX;��q`� �}qr[9bWd�V`b ��

��a9� ��P/� ��qY�

� RUn9O�b}V�x:� u�© #LzjzjOs�T}b}acTWRjd�n�T}\�V�qr[9bWdVeb�T��)_�V�«#a9acb���a�ogV`zUVeT�bWVYs�_�[gdsWV�TW[<ungV`d�Veb}Ryq^QS[gO:T}\�sW\ac_�V`s`� �[gTWV5TW\acT�T}\�V5d[9s�TWb}RUzys�agdXmT}\�VSqr[gd&T}[gO�b,s#[gf�TW\�VQS[gO:T}\ms�T,acdXk[gO:TY�

Page 23: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

�¤v�� U w�v� ! � ��v� uw�v�� U �

�¤v�� ! w�v� % � ��v� uw�v�� & �� RUn9O�b}Vmx�� % © #LzUzjOs�TWb,aBTWRjd�n�sWO�P���V`qrTWRjogVmacdd�[cT,aBTWRj[gd<[cf�TW\�V�T}b}agRUdRUd�n�sWVrTSf{[gbX:V`ngb}VeV`si[gf���[g_�Ved�d�VYsWs`w�sWQ�RjzjVY���

x�� t s�f{V`acTWO�b}V`sif{[9b�acdagzU�:sWRjsi[gfDQS[gO�TW\�bWV`ngRj[gd��

��� � � � C �7!-��'��W��3 �HK1�*������ ���(�g':��W���N)zjRUn9\&TWzj� X:R �-Veb}Ved&T�_�b}[:qrV`X�O�bWVYsSacb}Vkac__�zURjV`X�TW[�X:VeTWVYq�TSTW\�V�V`�gV`sSagdX�d[9s��TWb}Rjzjs`� V �gVmX:VeTWVYq�TWRj[gd8Rys�X:[gdVZP)��T}b}agRUdRUd�n�a�N)¥�� qezja9sWsWRU|Veb��7RUTW\�QS[gb}VTW\/acd ugv9vgvZVe�9V�_aBTWTWV`bWds�acdX�u9vgvgvZd�[9d:��Ve�gV�_/aBT�T}Veb}dsp[gf7sWRj¨eV ! u � U � #LdTW\V�RUd&TWV`bWVYs�T,sp[cf�b}V`acz�T}RUQSV�_bW[:qrVYsWsWRjd�n��(VST}b}agRUd�aZzURjd�VYacb�qezja9sWsWR¡|/Vebp�7\�Ryq,\T}ag�gVYs�d�[9bWQ�agzURj¨eVYX _�RU£:Vezys�a9s�RUd�_O:T`��]#ObWRjd�n;X:VrT}V`q�T}RU[9d8sWVeo9Veb,aczizU[:q`aBTWRj[gd/sacd/X�s}qeagzUVYs��7RUTW\�Rjd�apqeagdX:RyX�aBT}V7bWV`ngRj[gd�Rjs1Vr£�acQSRjd�V`X5f{[gb?TW\�V�zj[:qeacTWRj[gdS[cf�TW\�VVe�9Vg� � \�Rys�agX�Q�RUT�T}V`X:zj� zjV`a9X�siTW[Sd)O�QSVeb}[gO/sif�aczys�V�_�[9sWR¡T}RUo9V`s`�#Ld�[gb,X:Veb�T}[�VezjRjQ�RjdacTWVSf�aczysWV�_/[&s�RUTWRjogVYsp[gdV�qeacd;V`Q�_zU[B��TW\�V�f{[9zUzj[B�7Rjd�nb}V`agsW[gdRUd�n/� � bW[9Q TW\�V�s�VeTi[gf*_�[9sWR¡T}RUo9V`s`w&[9d�V�q`acdZq,\�[)[9sWV�TW\/aBT�_/[&s�RUTWRjogV��7R¡T}\TW\V�\�Rjng\�VYs�TkzURj�gV`zURj\�[)[:X�[cf^P�VeRjd�n T}\�V�T}bWO�V�_/[&s�RUTWRjogV9�@��VeT�� X:V`d�[cT}VmTW\�VRjd�_�O:T�f{V`acTWO�b}V�o9V`q�T}[gb�acdX �-���*�#TW\�V�[gO:T}_�O:T�[cf�T}\�VSN:¥�� qezja9sWsWRU|VebY� � \)Os�������)wBT}\�V7_�[9sWR¡T}RUo9V�qezja9sWsDRUf �H���*�<v�D�*VrT��� � ��� ������� �����7P/V�T}\�V�RUd�_O:T}sqrzyags}sWR¡|VYX�ags#_/[&s�RUTWRjogV9�$#�f(aczjz�Ve£�qrVe_�T�[gdV�Rys�a�f�aczys�V5_/[&s�RUTWRjogV9w�TW\�V`d��iV5qeagdVezjRjQ�RjdacTWV�TW\�V�f�agzjsWVp_�[9sWR¡T}RUo9V`s�P)� q,\�[)[9sWRjd�n

������acb}n?Q�aB£��� ��� ��� �H��� � ���v9� �¤x�� ! �� \�Rys�Rjd)og[9zUo9V`s�VYs�T}RUQ�acTWRjd�n�T}\�V5Q5O�zUTWRyX:RUQSV`ds�Rj[gd/acz�X:VedsWRUT�� � ��� � �-���*� v9�D�7\Rjq,\�q`acdSP/V#ogVeb}�^RjzUzU��_/[&s�VYXH�;#Ld�[9b}X�Veb�TW[^sWRjQ�_zURUf{�5Q�acT�TWV`b}s`wg�iV#a9sWsWO�QSV

��sWVeVp�1zjacT�T�� u����{��w

� ��� � �H���*�8v&�"! � � �-���*� � �H���*�#�v9�$! � ���H���*� � �%�&�'�g� �¤x�� x9�

� V�qeagd�P/V�V`agsWRjzU�5V`s�TWRjQSacTWV � ���H���*� � �%�&�'�g��P)�5_zU[gT�TWRjd�n�agd�\�Rys�T}[gngb,acQ[cf�T}\�V5N)¥���[gO:T}_�O:T�f{[9b�T}\�V^_�[9sWR¡T}RUo9V�qrzyags}s�f{b}[gQ T}\�V^T}b}agRUdRUd�n�XaBT}a� � \�Rjs

Page 24: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

X:Rys�T}bWRjP�O:T}RU[9dZTWO�b}ds7[9O:T7TW[�P�V^P�Vezjz¡�Ls�\/ac_�V`XH�1«#VedqeVp�(V^q`acd�VezjRjQ�RjdacTWV�f�aczysWV_�[9sWR¡T}RUo9V`s^P)�;agq`qrVe_�TWRjd�nmTW\V�[gd�Vk_/[&s�RUTWRjogV�f{[gb��7\Rjq,\;T}\�VZN)¥�� [gO�TW_�O:T�Rjsqrzj[9sWV`s�T�T}[ TW\V�Q�aB£:RjQSa [cfpTW\RjsZqr[9dX:RUTWRj[gdagz�X:Rys�T}bWRjP�O:T}RU[9d�� � \RjsZs�RjQS_�zjVTWVYq,\�d�Ry~&O�V�\ags�n9RUo9VedZng[)[:X b}V`sWO�zUT}sif{[gb�f�agzjsWVp_�[9sWR¡T}RUo9V�V`zURjQSRUd/aBTWRj[gd*��[&s�T}bWRjzjsDacb}V1X:VeTWVYq�TWVYX^P)��RjX:V`d&TWRUf{�&Rjd�n�a�qeagdX:RyX�aBT}V1d�[&s�V(bWV`ngRj[gd�f{b}[gQ¢TW\�V

zj[)q`aBT}RU[9d�[cf�T}\�V�f�agqeV�agdX�|d/X:RUdn�T}\�V�zU[:qeagz/Q�ac£)RjQ�a�[gf�TW\V�agPs�[9zUO�TWV�o�agzUOV[cfD«#agagb(��a�ogV`zUVeT(qr[)V�X�qeRUV`d&T}siRUd TW\�V�b}RUn9\9T7acd/X�TW\V�zjVrf§T7\agz¡f*[gf�TW\Rjsib}VengRj[gd*�«�V`bWV��iVpqr[gQS_�O�TWV�TW\�V^«�agagbi��a�ogV`zUVeT}s(f{[gb7P/agsWRjsif{O�d/q�TWRj[gd/s7[cf�s�O�__/[9b�T�sWRU¨`V% � % acT�~&OagX:b}O�_�zjV�X:V`dsWR¡T��9� � \�V�zj[:qeacz�Q�aB£:RUQ�a�q`acdmP�V^T}ag�gV`d�f{[gb#V`R¡T}\�VebTW\VpogVebWTWRyqeagz-[gb�TW\V^qr[gb}d�V`bi��a�ogV`zUVeT}s`�� VmsWQS[&[gTW\�TW\�VZzU[:q`aBTWRj[gd/s�[gf#Ve�9V`s�acdX�d�[9s�TWb}RUzys5TW\)Os�[gP�T}acRjd�VYX�P)� a

QS[Bo)RUd�n�a�ogVeb,acn9V�|zUTWVebDT}[�b}V`X:O/qrV ��RUT�T}Veb�acd/X^Rjdqrb}V`a9s�V?b}[gPOs�T}d�V`s}sDacdX�T}b}a9q,�&�Rjd�n�

� ��� � �.>]"� 3���"�"=�%�B� �������8H��$���

#Ld�T}\�Rjs�sWV`qrTWRj[gd�w&�(V�X:V`s}qrb}RjP/V#TW\�V�acdagzU�:sWRjs1[cfHT}\�V�QS[9O:TW\k_aBTWTWVeb}d�[9P:T}agRUd�VYXf{b}[gQ�T}\�Vm_�b}Veo)RU[9OsSs�T,acn9Vk[gf�zj[:qeaczjRj¨`aBT}RU[9d T}[�VYs�T}RUQ�acTWVmPa9s�RyqZ_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,ssWOq,\�ags?X:V`ngb}VeV�[cf-[g_�Vedd�V`s}s?acd/X�s�QSRjzUV9� � V�\a�o9V�acT�T}VeQS_:TWVYX�TW[^QS[:X:V`z:TW\�V_�b}[gP�zjVeQ [cf�Q�ac_�_�Rjd�nST}\�V^QS[gO:T}\m_aBTWTWV`bWdZTW[ka�s�VeT�[cf�QSV`acdRUd�ngf{O�z�_agb}agQ��VrT}Veb,s(a9s1zjV`agbWdRUd�n^TW\�V�bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gd�f{O�d/q�TWRj[gd f{bW[9QEacd Rjd�_�O�T�sW_agqeV�T}[�[gO�TW_�O:T_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s`�

����� ��� � �*�#�����D'�����34'�"��%':������������3 �&�H'� \�V5TWb,acRjd�Rjd�nZsWVrT�f{[9b�zjV`agbWdRUd�n TW\�VSb}Ven9bWVYsWsWRU[9dmf{O�dqrTWRj[gd�Rjs�zjV`agbWd�VYX�a9s#f{[9z¡�zj[B��se�

� � \V�QS[gO:T}\�zj[)q`aczjRU¨YaBT}RU[9d�sW�:s�T}VeQGRys�OsWV`X�T}[�zj[)q`aczjRU¨`VpTW\V�QS[gO:T}\s�[cfX�R �-Veb}Ved&T(_�Veb,sW[gds(ags�T}\�Ve�SQ�ac�9V�Pa9s�Ryq7Vr£:_�b}V`s}sWRU[9ds?sWOq,\ ags(s�ObW_�b}Rys�V9w��[B�kacdX�acdngVebY�

� � \V�QS[gO:T}\skngb,acP�P�V`X�agbWV�d�[gb}Q�aczjRU¨`V`X8TW[8a sWRU¨`V�[cf�u&x � x ! agdXagd�d�[gT}aBT}V`X�QSagd)OaczjzU�;f{[9b�T}\�VmX:Ven9bWV`V [gf�[g_�Vedd�V`s}sSacdX<s�QSRjzUVZ[gd8as}qeagzUV�[cf*v^TW[ ! ��sWVeV�h(V`�)Q�V`b1VeT�agz¤� � % �HagdX�hiVe�)QSVebiacdX ��[gngn9RU[ � u��{���� \Rjs�Rys5X:[9d�V P/agsWV`X�[9d�TW\�VZs�OP���V`qrTWRjogV Rjd&TWV`bW_�b}VrT,aBT}RU[9d�[cf�T}\�V OsWVebagdXZd�[�agqrTWOagzHRUQ�acn9V�_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s�acb}V�QSV`a9s�ObWVYXH� � RjngObWV^x:� % s�\[B��ssW[gQSV�Vr£�agQ�_zUVYs�[cf�s�Oq,\�aSs�OP���V`qrTWRjogVpacd�d[cT}acTWRj[gd��

Page 25: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

����� � � IJA�':�1� ��'��W!Z�&�*���*!�'����1���?+7���&6#����&�;�&A#���&�H'��?+ �¢������ ���1�*���H'�!-�����E!H���*�('��

� \�VZRUd_�O:T�s�_/agqrV f{[gb5TW\�V�b}Ven9bWVYsWsWRU[9d;f{O�dqrTWRj[gd�RysSq,\�[9sWVed TW[�P/Vma�sW_agb}sWVsWO�PsWVrT�[gfiT}\�V�[Bo9Veb,qr[gQS_�zjVrT}V�«#agagb^��a�ogVezjVrT^qe[&V�X�qrRjVed&T}s5X:V`s}qrb}RUP�V`X�Rjd;TW\�V_�b}Veo)Rj[gOsDs�VYq�T}RU[9d��R#Ld�TW\�V7qr[9O�b,s�V([cf�T}\�V(Ve£:_�bWVYsWsWRj[gd�sW[gQSVi[cf�T}\�Viqe[)V�X�qrRjVed&T}sq,\agd�ngV�s�RjngdR¡|/q`acd&TWzj��acd/X�[cT}\�Veb,s�X:[Sd�[cTY� #Ld T}\�V�f{b}agQSVe�i[gb}��[gfDX�acT}a�qr[9Q5�_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gd*wB�(V��i[gO�zyX�_bW[ ��V`q�T�T}\�V�X�aBT,a�[gdSaps�O�P/s�_a9qrVi�7\�Ryq,\SX�V`qr[9bWb}VezyaBT}V`s�R¡T�{�7\Rjq,\ZRjsiT}\�VpsWagQSV�a9si�1bWRjdqeRU_�zjV�l([gQS_�[gd�V`d9T t d/aczj�)sWRys}�iacd/X�T}\�Ved�q,\�[)[9sWVTW\[9sWV(oBacb}RyacP�zjV`s��7R¡T}\�T}\�V�\�Rjng\�VYs�T�oBacb}RjagdqrV9��«�[B�iVeo9VebYwYTW\�Rys�RjsDd�[gT�TW\�V�sWagQSVags�q,\�[)[&s�Rjd�nkaZsW_acb,s�V�s�OPs�VeT��7\Veb}V5[9O�b�_�O�b}_/[&s�V�Rjs�T}[Zqe[gQS_�zjVrT}Vezj��a�og[gRyXTW\V qr[9Q�_O:T}acTWRj[gd�[cfiTW\[9sWV «#a9acb�qe[&V�X�qrRjVed&T}s�T}\aBT�acb}V�d�[cT�O/s�Vef{O�z1Rjd;TW\�Vb}Vengb}V`s}sWRU[9d��l(\�[)[9sWRUdn�a�s�_agb}sWVeb�sWVrT�[cf/qe[&V�X�qrRjVed&T}sDRjd5a�bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gdp_�b}[gPzUV`Q2\ags*TW\�V

agXX:V`X^a9X:oBacd&T}agngV?[gfb}V`X:OqeRUdn�TW\V(oBacb}RyacdqeV?[cf:T}\�V(VYs�T}RUQ�acTWVgwcagz¡T}\�[gOng\^P�RyagsQ�a���RUd/qrb}V`agsWVg��l([gd)ogV`d9T}RU[9dacz�ac__�bW[&agq,\�VYspT}[;X�[gRjd�n�T}\�RysSRUdqezUO/X:Vms�O�P/s�VeTsWVezjV`q�T}RU[9d�acdXSb}RyX:ngV7b}Ven9bWVYsWsWRU[9d��R#Ld�[9b}X�Veb�T}[^[gP:T,acRjd�a^sW_acb,s�V�sWO�PsWVrT([cf-TW\�V«#a9acbiqr[)V�X�qrRjVed&T,sew)�iV�q,\�[)[9sWV7T}\�[9sWV�«�agacbiqr[)V�X�qeRUV`d9T,s1�7RUTW\ TW\�V�Q�aB£:RjQ�O�QoBacb}RjagdqrV9� � \�RjsZRysZQ�[gTWRjoBaBTWVYX�P)��TW\V�f�a9q�TZTW\acTmqe[)V�X�qrRjVed&T}sk�7RUTW\%\�RUn9\oBacb}RjagdqrV?agbWV?TW\�[&s�V�T}\aBT�q,\acdngV�TW\V1QS[9s�TDX:OV?TW[�q,\acd�n9V`sHRjd^QS[gO�TW\�sW\ac_�V`sacd/X�acb}V^\�V`dqrV�s�T,aBTWRys�TWRyqeaczjzj�ZsWRUn9d�RU|/qeagd9T#f{[gb ��QSV`a9s�O�b}Rjd�n �5TW\Rjs�q,\agd�ngV9�Q#LdTW\Rjs�ac__�zURyqeacTWRj[gd�w&�iV�q,\�[&s�V#TW\�V ! x�qr[)V�X�qrRjVed&T,s1�7RUTW\ TW\�V�\�Rjng\�VYs�T�oBacb}RjagdqrV9�� \�V^oBagbWRyacdqeVp[cf?a�sWO�P:�LsWagQ�_zUVYXms�VeT#[cf�TW\V�«#a9acb#qe[&V�X�qrRjVed&T}s7Rys#sW\�[B�7dmRjdT}agP�zjVpx�� !

��� ��� ��� ��� ��� � ��� � ������ ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� �� � �� ����� ��� ������ ��� �� ��� ��� ��� ���

�¤a9���� �� ������ ��� ��� ��� �� ��� �������� ��� �� ����� ��� ��� ��� ������ ��� ��� �� ��� ������ ��� �

�{P/���� ��� ��� �� �� �� ��� � ��� ����� �� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ����� ��� ��� ��� ��� �� �� ���

��qY�

� acP�zjV1x:� ! © #[gb}QSagzURj¨eVYX�o�agbWRyacd/qrV�oBaczjO�V`sHf{[gbHT}\�V(«�agacb�qe[)V�X�qrRjVed&T}s*[cf:QS[gO:T}\sWV`~&O�Ved/qrV`s ��ags^TW\�V`�;[g_�Ved acd/X�qrzj[9sWVY��� �¤a9��¥�V`b�T}Rjq`acz�w7�{P/��«�[gb}Rj¨e[gd&T,acz1agdX��qY��l([gb}d�VebiT��)_�V`s`�

Page 26: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

����� ��� C ���#����� C �����g' ��� A������*������3?��*�)�&���1� �1� '�"�� �¢�����!-�����E!H�����1'��

*�dqeV��iVp\a�o9V�\/a�ogV�[gP:T,acRjd�V`XkTW\V^s�_agb}sWVps�OPs�VeT�[cf�qr[)V�X�qeRUV`d9T,sew)T}\�V^d�Ve£)TT}a9s��;Rys5TW[�zUVYacb}d TW\VkzjRUdV`acbSQ�ac_�f{bW[9Q¦TW\�VYs�V�qr[)V�X�qeRUV`d&T}s5TW[�TW\�VZ[gO�TW_�O:T_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s`� � V�RjQS_�zjVeQSVed&T7a�sWRUQS_�zjV�zjV`a9s�T�sW~&OagbWVYs�V`s�TWRjQ�aBT}V�[gfHTW\�V�qr[)Vrf§�|/qeRUV`d9T,sD[cf�T}\�V(zjRjd�V`agbDQ�ag_����*VrT���� ��*P/V(TW\Vio9V`qrTW[gb�[cf/qe[)V�X�qrRjVed&T}sD[9P:T}agRUd�VYXaBf§T}Veb�q,\�[)[9sWRjd�n�T}\�VisW_agb}sWV(sWO�PsWVrT�[cf-«#agagb���a�ogV`zUVeTDqe[&V�X�qrRjVed&T}s`w�f{[gbDTW\V �-T}\TWb,acRjd�Rjd�n�sWagQS_�zUV�Rjdma�T}b}agRUdRUd�n�sWVrT7�7RUTW\ �¦sWagQ�_zUVYse� � \�V`d�w

� ����� � ���� � � �������������

������� �¤x�� u&�

Rys�TW\�VmQ�aBT}bWRU£�[gf�aczjz�TW\V�qr[)V�X�qrRjVed&T,sS[cf�TW\�V�T}b}agRUd�Rjd�n;s�VeT`� t zjsW[;R¡f K ������ ������� � ��������� ��������� � Rys�TW\V�ogVYq�T}[gb�[gfpagzUz#TW\�V�[gO:T}_�O:T,ska9sWsWRUn9d�V`X<T}[�TW\�VTWb,acRjd�Rjd�n sWVrTY�h#�f 0 Rys#TW\�V�ogVYq�TW[9b#[gf?�(V`RUn9\9T,s�[gf�TW\�V5zURjd�V`agb�b}Ven9bWVYsWsWRj[gdkTW\�V`dTW\V?_�b}[gP�zjVeQ�RysHT}[�|dX�T}\�V?zjV`ags�T*s}~9O/acb}V`sHsW[gzjO:TWRj[gd�TW[ � 0 � K � � \V?s�[9zUO:T}RU[9dRys�qezUVYacb}zU� 0 � ��� K �7\Veb}V ��� Rjs*TW\�Vi_sWVeOX�[c��RUd)ogV`b}sWV�[cf � ��]#ObWRjd�n�T}V`s�TWRjd�nwTW\V^oBaczjO�V^[cfDTW\V^[gO:T}_�O:T�_acb,acQSVrT}Veb7Rys�n9RUo9Ved�P)� � � 0 � ���7\�Veb}V�� Rys�TW\�VogVYq�T}[gb�[cf�qr[)V�X�qeRUV`d9T,sif{bW[9QETW\V^s�_agb}sWV�s�O�P/s�VeT�[cfD«�agagb�qr[)V�X�qrRjVed&T,se������ ��� � A�6�6p�?�:'����*!�':�?��;+,�?� C �W���������8�*3?���*�)�)���1�#Ld�TW\Rjs�sWV`qrTWRj[gd�w/�(V^sW�gVeT}q,\ZTW\V^RjX�V`ags�P/V`\�RUd/XmOsWRUd�n N:¥�� f{[gb#zUVYacb}d�RUdn�bWVe�ngb}V`s}sWRU[9d�f{O�dqrTWRj[gds(��a�QS[gb}V?X:VeT}acRjzjV`X�X:V`s}qrb}Rj_:TWRj[gdpqeagd�P/V�f{[9O�dX�Rjd W [gzj[B�7Rjq,\�wVrT�acz�� � % ����agdXm¥?ag_�d�Rj� � ( ! �§��acd/X�ac_�_zU��RUT�f{[9b#T}\�V�sWRjQ�_zUV`b�q`agsWV^[cf1zjRjd�V`agbb}Vengb}V`s}sWRU[9d����*VrT! � �&���#"�� �$"¤� �%�"'& w)P�V�TW\�V�TWb,acRjd�Rjd�n�sWVrT�[gP�T}acRjd�VYX�P)��sWagQ��_�zjRUdnw&�7R¡T}\�d�[gRysWVgw)s�[9Q�V#O�d��)d�[B�7dSf{O�dqrTWRj[gd �-���*��� � V�acb}V#agsW�gVYX�TW[�X�VrTWV`b��QSRUdV�aSf{O�dqrTWRj[gd)(�TW\/aBT�ag_�_�b}[�£:RUQ�aBT}V`s �H���*�rw/Pa9s�VYX�[gd�T}\�V^�)d�[B�7zjV`X:n9Vp[cf S� � \�V�N)¥��¦qr[gd/s�RyX:Veb,s�ac_�_bW[�£:RjQSacTWRjd�n5f{O�dq�T}RU[9ds7[gf*TW\V�f{[gb}QZ©

(���� � � � �+*,"'& .- "0/�" ���*�.1 � �¤x�� % �

�7\�V`bWV�T}\�V?f{O�d/q�TWRj[gd/s"� / "W���*� � *"'& agbWV?q`aczjzUVYX & ��2� � ������wBacd/X ��acdX � - " � *"�& acb}Vqr[)V�X�qeRUV`d&T}s�T}\aBT�\a�o9V�TW[�P�V^V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWVYXkf{bW[9Q TW\V�X�aBT,a�� � \Rjs�f{[9bWQ [cf�ac_:�_�b}[�£:RUQ�aBT}RU[9dkq`acdZP/V^qe[gdsWRjX�Veb}V`XZags7acdZ\)�)_/V`bW_�zyacdV�RjdZTW\�V32���X:RjQSVedsWRj[gdagzf{V`acTWO�b}V�sW_agqeV�X�Vr|d�VYXSP)�^TW\V7f{O�dqrTWRj[gds /�" ���*�r� � \�V�X:RjQ�V`dsWRU[9daczjR¡T��5[cf�TW\�Vf{V`acTWO�b}Vps�_/agqrV�Rys7d�[cT7d�VYqrVYsWs}acb}RUzj�S|d�RUTWV9� � \�V^N)¥��¦X:Rys�TWRjd�ngO�RysW\�V`s�RUT}sWVezUfDP)�

Page 27: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

QSRUdRUQSRj¨eRjd�nSTW\�V�f{[9zUzj[B�7Rjd�n�f{Odq�T}RU[9daczHT}[SV`s�TWRjQSacTWVpRUT}s7_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,se�

� � � �"� !�

�, "�& � �$"�� (����#" � � � � � 1���� � �� �¤x�� (9�

�7\�V`bWV���Rys�aSqr[9ds�T,acd&T�acdX TW\V�f{[gzjzU[B�7Rjd�n%� ( � � ���HVeb}bW[9bif{O�dq�T}RU[9d�\ags�P�VeV`dX:Ve|d�V`X

� �$"� (����#" � � � � � ��Q�aB£H� � � "� (����#"�� � � � �� �}v9� �¤x�� & �¥?ac_�dRU�;s�\[B�(VYX�Rjd � ( ! �?T}\aBT�TW\�V�f{Odq�T}RU[9d�TW\acT�QSRUdRUQSRj¨eV`spTW\�V f{O�dq��

TWRj[gd/acz�RUdkV`~&OaBT}RU[9d��¤x�� (9�1X�Ve_�VedX�si[9d ap|dR¡T}V�d)O�Q5P/V`b([gf*_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s`w9agdX\a9siTW\�V�f{[9zUzj[B�7RUdn�f{[9bWQ�©

(���� � � � � �Y� � �, "'& ���$�" ��� "¤���<��� � �#"��#1 � � �¤x�� + �

�7\�V`bWV�� �" � "���v ��� "�� � �"�� v��$� ! ������� � ��w/acdX������ � K �7Rjs�T}\�V^sW[Sq`aczjzUVYX� ��������6)f{O�d/q�TWRj[gd*w/acd/XZX�V`s}qrb}RUP�V`siT}\�V^Rjd�d�Veb#_�bW[:X:O/q�T�Rjd�TW\�V 2���X:RjQSVedsWRj[gdagzf{V`acTWO�b}Vps�_/agqrV

����� � K � � *, "'& / "W���*� / ",� K �#Ldm[gO�b�qeagsWVgw/s�RjdqrVp�iV^acb}V�RUQS_�zjVeQSV`d9T}RUdn aSzURjd�VYacb�b}Ven9bWVYsWsWRU[9d�w&TW\�V^f{V`aB�TWObWVYs1T,ac�9V�T}\�V�f{[gzjzU[B�7Rjd�n5f{[gb}Q /�" ���*� � � " �§T}\�V���TW\�qr[gQS_�[gd�V`d&T�[gf��*��agdX����� � K �� � � K � #[B��R¡T#Rys�VYagsW��T}[�s�V`VpTW\acT�TW\V^zURjd�VYacb�b}VezyaBT}RU[9dZP�VrT��iVeV`dTW\V�sW_agb}sWV(sWO�PsWVrT�[cf-«#a9acb�qr[)V�X�qrRjVed&T,s�acdX^TW\�V�[gO�TW_�O:T?_/acb,acQSVrT}VebDRjs�n9RUo9VedP)� � � 0 � � 1 �5�7\�Veb}V 0 ��� �"'& ��� �" ��� "�� ��� " �r� *�d�zj�;a�s�Q�agzUzis�O�P/s�VeT[cf�T}\�V���� �" ���."�� � s�agbWV�X�R �-Veb}Ved&T^f{b}[gQ ¨eV`bW[/w*zjV`agX�RUd�n�TW[�amsWQ�aczjz1d)O�Q�P�Veb[cf�sWO�_�_�[gbWT�ogVYq�T}[gb,se� � \�VkQSagRUd a9X:oBacd&T}agngV�a9qeqrb}O�VYX;P&��OsWRUdn�a�N)¥�� RjsTW\/aBT�s�RjdqeV�RUT7Os�VYsiTW\�V�b}[gP�O/s�T�Veb}bW[9b1f{Odq�T}RU[9dkn9RUo9Ved P)��VY~9O/aBTWRj[gd��¤x�� & ��w:�iV[gP�T}acRjd�acdZV`s�TWRjQSacTWVp�7\�Ryq,\ZRjs7zjV`s}s7sWVedsWR¡T}RUo9V�TW[�[gO�TWzjRUV`b}s`�

����� ��� ���*�)A��L'����?+ � �1A7'�"����������4��')�*� � �9'���� �D':���1�� \�VSb}V`acz�T}RUQSVSf�a9qrV�X:VeTWV`qrTWRj[gd�acd/X�QS[gO�TW\;zU[:q`aczjRU¨YaBTWRj[gd;sW�)s�TWV`Q �i[gb}�)s�acTqrzj[9sWVkTW[ ! v�f{b}agQ�VYs�_/V`b�s�VYqr[gd/XH� � \�Rys�sW�)s�TWV`Q��ia9s�Os�VYX T}[�qr[gzjzjV`q�T +S+2!Vr£�agQ�_zUVYs�[cfHQS[gO:T}\�RUQ�agngV`s?�7R¡T}\ X:R ��V`bWV`d9TiX:Ven9bWV`V`s�[cfH[9_/V`d�d�V`s}s1agdX�sWQ�RjzjVf{[gb�a�s�Rjd�n9zUV?_�Veb,sW[gdpacdX�Q�agd&O/aczjzU��acd�d�[gT}acTWV`Xpa9s�X:VYsWqebWRjP/VYX�RUd^sWV`qrTWRj[gd�x�� u� ! �� \�V�RUQ�agngV`s��iVeb}V^_�b}Vr��_�bW[:qeV`s}s�VYX��7R¡T}\�RjzUzjO�QSRjdaBT}RU[9d�qr[9bWb}V`qrTWRj[gd�� � \�Rys�s�VeT��ags�OsWV`X�T}[mzUVYacb}d;a�zjRjd�V`agb^bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gd�f{O�dqrTWRj[gd;f{b}[gQ TW\�V sW_agb}sWV�s�O�P/s�VeT[cf�«#a9acbpqr[)V�X�qeRUV`d9T,s�TW[ZTW\�VS[9O:TW_�O�T^_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,sew-OsWRjd�nZTW\�V���Rjd�VYacbp��VYags�TN:~&OagbWVYs�acdX�T}\�V�N)¥�� qrb}R¡T}Veb}Rja� � V�sWQS[&[gTW\�TW\V#[gO�TW_�O:T([cf-TW\�V#bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gd

Page 28: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−2

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

SVM

LLS

�¤a9�

0 20 40 60 80 100 1202.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

5

5.5

6

6.5

7

SVM

LLS

�{P/�

� RUn9O�b}V x:�)(:© V s�T}RUQ�acTWV`X;X:V`ngb}VeV�[gfp�¤a9��[9_/V`d�d�VYsWs^agdXJ�{P��^sWQ�RjzjV�f{[gb�amsWVr�~&O�Ved/qrV�[cf ! x ! RjQSagngVYspP)��zjRUd�VYacb^b}Ven9bWVYsWsWRj[gd�zUVYacb}d�V`X�OsWRUdn���Rjd�V`agb���VYags�TN:~&OagbWVYs^acdX<N)O�_�_�[gbWT�¥�V`qrTW[9b���a9q,\�Rjd�V��7RUTW\ �>v�� vY(�agdX;f{[gzjzj[B�(VYX�P)�QSV`X:RyacdS|/z¡T}Veb}RUd�n��7R¡T}\ a�|zUTWV`b1[cf�zjVedncTW\�u�D«#RUn9\�Veb(oBaczjO�V`s1RUdX�Rjq`aBTWV�apQS[gb}V[g_�VedZQS[gO:T}\macdXZ[gb7aSQS[gb}V�s�QSRjzURjd�n�QS[gO:T}\��

P)��akQ�VYX:Ryacd�|zUTWVebp[gf(zjVed�ngTW\;u��\#Ld�|ngO�b}V�x:�)(��iVS_�bWVYs�V`d&T�T}\�VSbWVYs�Oz¡T,s�[cfTWVYs�T}RUdnpTW\�Rys(bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gd5TWVYq,\�d�Ry~9OV#[gd�apTWV`s�TisWV`~&O�V`dqrV#[cf ! x ! RUQ�acn9V`s`� *�dVqeagdSd�[cT}V7TW\acT?TW\V�zURjd�VYacb1zjV`a9s�T1s}~&Oacb}V`s�VYs�T}RUQ�acTWV#X:[)VYs1ags?�(V`zUz�ags�T}\�V�N)¥���7\�RjzUVpVYs�T}RUQ�acTWRjd�n�s�QSRjzUV�P�O:T�_/V`b�f{[9bWQ�s�_�[&[9bWzj��RjdkT}\�V^qea9s�V�[gfD[9_/V`d�d�V`s}s`�� V5\a�ogV5qrO�b}bWV`d&TWzj� RjQ�_zUV`Q�V`d&TWV`X�TW\�V�s��:s�TWV`Q T}[�V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWV�TW\�V�X:Ven9bWV`V

[cf?[9_/V`d�d�VYsWs�acdX�sWQSRUzjV�[gf?QS[gO:T}\s�RUd�b}V`agz�T}RUQSVg�pN)[ f�acbYwT}\�V^T}b}agRUd�Rjd�nZs�VeTqr[9d&T}acRjds�T}\�V�RjQ�acn9V`s7[gf�[9d�zj�k[9d�V^_�Veb,s�[9d��7h(O�T�RUT�s�\[B��s�a�ng[)[:Xmqeag_agqeR¡T��TW[ ngVedVeb,aczjRU¨`VpTW[�T}\�V�QS[9O:TW\s�[cf?[gTW\�V`b#_�Ve[9_�zUV9� � \�Rys#sW�:s�T}VeQ�aczysW[�bWOds#acT! v�f{b}agQ�VYs#_�VebpsWV`qe[gdXm[9d�a�n9Ved�V`b}agz*_�ObW_�[9sWV5��l�� � V5Ve£:_/VYq�T�TW\acT��7\�V`dQS[gO:T}\s�[gf?QS[gb}V^_/V`[g_�zjV5agbWV^a9X�X:VYX�TW[ TW\�V�TWb,acRjd�RUdn s�VeT�acd/X�a�d�[9d:��zjRjd�V`agbb}Vengb}V`s}sWRU[9d�Rjs�RjQS_�zjVeQSVed&TWVYXHwRUT��7RjzUz�P�V^acPzUV�TW[Sn9Ved�V`b}agzURj¨eV�Veo9VedZP/VeT�TWV`b`�

Page 29: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

0 20 40 60 80 100 1204

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

SVM

LLS

0 20 40 60 80 100 1202

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

5

5.5

SVM

LLS

�¤a9�

0 20 40 60 80 100 1203

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

SVM

LLS

0 20 40 60 80 100 1201.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

5

5.5

6

6.5

SVM

LLS

�{P/�

� RUn9O�b}V�x�� & ©$#LzUzjOs�TWb,aBTWRjd�nkTW\�V�agP�RjzURUT���[cfiTW\V�Q�[9O:TW\;_agb}agQSVrTWV`b�V`s�TWRjQSacTW[9bTW[Sn9Ved�V`b}agzURj¨eV�TW[�X:R �-Veb}Ved&T7_/V`[g_�zjVg�

Page 30: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140−2

−1

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

SVM

LLS

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 1403.5

4

4.5

5

5.5

6

6.5

7

7.5

SVM

LLS

�¤a9�

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−4

−2

0

2

4

6

8

10

SVM

LLS

0 20 40 60 80 100 1202.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

5

5.5

6

6.5

7

7.5

SVM

LLS

�{P/�

� RUn9O�b}V�x�� + ©$#LzUzjOs�TWb,aBTWRjd�nkTW\�V�agP�RjzURUT���[cfiTW\V�Q�[9O:TW\;_agb}agQSVrTWV`b�V`s�TWRjQSacTW[9bTW[Sn9Ved�V`b}agzURj¨eV�TW[�X:R �-Veb}Ved&T7zURjng\&TWRjd�n�qe[gdX:RUTWRj[gd/se�

Page 31: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� ��� � ���=�%>����$���#�

#LdpT}\�RjsDq,\ag_:TWV`b��(ViX:V`s}qrb}RjP/VYX�TW\�Viac_�_�zjRyqeaBT}RU[9d^[cf:��a�ogV`zUVeT���PagsWV`X�RjQSagngV?b}Ve_��b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gds`wHacdX;N)¥�� qrzyags}sWR¡|/q`aBT}RU[9d�acdX�b}Vengb}V`s}sWRU[9d�aczjng[gb}RUTW\�Q�s�TW[kTW\�V_�b}[gP�zjVeQG[gf?f�agqeV�X:VeTWVYq�TWRj[gd*w-f�agqrRyacz�f{V`acTWO�b}VSX:VrT}V`q�T}RU[9d�agdX�QS[gO�TW\�_/aBT�T}Veb}dacd/aczj�)sWRyse� � \�VpP/agsWRjq�QS[cT}RUoBaBT}RU[9dZTW[�OsWV�TW\�V5acP�[BogV�T��([ST}V`q,\�d�Ry~&O�V`s7qe[gQSV`sf{b}[gQ TW\VpRUd�\Veb}Ved&T7bW[9P�Os�T�q,\agb}a9q�T}Veb}Rjs�TWRyqes([cfDP/[gTW\�©�T}\�VpacP�RjzURUT���[gf*TW\V�f{[gbW�QSVebDTW[�b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&TDPagsWRjq([gP ��V`q�T?sW\ac_�V`s�agdX�b}V ��VYq�T�s�_O�bWRj[gO/sDX�VrT}agRUz�agdX�TW\acT[cf�TW\�V�zyaBTWTWVebiT}[�P�[gOdX n9Ved�V`b}agzURj¨`acTWRj[gd�V`bWb}[gbib,aBTW\VebiTW\agd V`Q�_RUb}Rjq`aczHV`bWb}[gbY�#Ld�sWO�QSQ�acb}�gwcRjd�[gO�b�ac__�bW[&agq,\�wB�iViOs�V7sW�)RUdSs�V`ngQSVed&T,aBTWRj[gd�acdX�qr[9QS_/[g�d�V`d9T�acd/aczj�)sWRys�T}[�sW_/V`V`X�O�_�a�N)¥��>qrzyags}sWR¡|V`b�P/agsWV`Xpf�a9qrV�X:VrT}V`qrTW[gbY� � V(TW\�V`dX:VeTWV`qrT^s�T,acP�zjV�f{V`aBT}O�b}V`s�[gd�TW\VSf�agqrVSsWOq,\�a9s�Ve�9V`s�acdX�d�[&s�T}bWRjzjs��7\Rjq,\;acb}VOsWV`X�TW[SzU[:q`aczjRU¨`V#T}\�V�_/[&s�RUTWRj[gdZ[cf�T}\�V�QS[gO:T}\�� t f§T}Veb7zj[)q`aczjRU¨YaBT}RU[9d�w)�(V�zjV`acb}da^zjRjd�V`agbib}Ven9bWVYsWsWRj[gd�f{O�dqrTWRj[gdkf{bW[9Q a�sW_acb,s�V�s�OPs�VeTi[gf�«#a9acb�qr[)V�X�qeRUV`d9T,si[cfTW\V�zj[:qeaczjRj¨eV`X QS[gO:T}\�TW[�[gO�TW_�O:T,s��7\�Ryq,\ b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T1T}\�V�X:Ven9bWV`V#[cf�[g_�Ved�d�VYsWsacd/X�s�QSRjzUV�[gf�TW\�VkQ�[9O:TW\*� � V�\/a�ogV�OsWV`X�T}\�V [9O:TW_�O�T�[cf7T}\�Rjs5s��:s�TWV`Q T}[X:b}RUo9V�TW\�VpVe£)_bWVYsWsWRU[9ds�acdXk\�VYagXZQS[BogVeQSV`d9T,si[cf�a�q`acbWTW[)[gdZq,\acb,agqrTWV`b`� � VP�VezjRUV`ogVpT}\aBT�T}\�V5sW�:s�T}VeQGqeagdmP/V5RUQS_�b}[BogVYXkP)��agX�X�RUd�n�Ve£�acQS_�zjV`s�[gf�f�agqrRyaczVr£:_�b}V`s}sWRU[9d [cfDQS[gb}V�_�Ve[9_�zjVg�N)[5f�acb�[gO�biT}V`q,\�d�Ry~&O�V�\agsib}VezjRUVYX�[gdk_�O�b}Vezj�SP/[gT�TW[9Q���O�_;�§f{V`V`X)��f{[gb}��acb,X�

_�b}[:qrV`s}sWV`s�T}[�X:VeTWV`qrT�agdX acd/aczj�&¨`V�f�agqeV`s`��hiO:T�TW\�V f�agq�T5TW\acT�a�QSagd)OaczjzU�acdd�[cT,aBTWVYX�TWb,acRjd�RUdn�s�VeT^�ia9spOsWV`X�RUd;T}b}agRUdRUd�n�T}\�V sW�:s�T}VeQ sWO�n9ngV`s�T}spTW\acT�gV`� T}[g_:�LX:[B�7d��)d�[B�7zjV`X:n9Vp\agX�T}[�P�V�Rjdqr[9bW_�[gb,aBT}V`XZRUd�[gb,X:Veb7T}[ Q�ac�9V�TW\�VsW�)s�TWV`Q _�Veb,qrV`_:TWOagzUzj��QSVYacd�Rjd�ncf{Oz¤��l(zUVYacb}zU�9w*RUf(T}\�V�T}b}agRUd�Rjd�n�sWVrT^��agspb,acd��X:[9Q�zj��zyacP�VezjV`X�wcTW\V�s��:s�TWVeQ � s�[gO�TW_�O:T(�([9O�zjX5\a�o9Vid[p_/V`b}qeVe_:T}Oacz�QSVYacd�Rjd�n�� \�Rys�TW\�V`d5_�b}[gQS_:T,s�acd�[9_/V`d5~&O�VYs�T}RU[9d�© � \acT�agbWV(TW\V(��a��:s�T}[�Rjdqr[9bW_�[gb,aBT}VTW[9_:�LX:[B�7d��)d�[B�7zjV`X:n9V7TW\acTi�i[gOzjX �WsW_/VYqrRUf{� ���7\aBT�_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s1d�VeVYX�TW[5P/VV`s�TWRjQ�aBT}V`X5P&�^TW\�V7P�[cTWTW[gQ���O�_�_�bW[:qeV`s}s�VYsDX�V`s}qrb}RUP�V`X5RUd5TW\Rjs?q,\/ac_:T}Veb � #Ld5TW\�Vd�Ve£&T#q,\/ac_:T}Veb��(Vpqe[gdsWRjX�Veb�TW\Rjs�~&O�VYs�T}RU[9dkRjd�ngb}V`acTWVeb7X:VeT}agRUz��

Page 32: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� ��������� �

� ��� � � � � ����� � I���

� ���� ��� ��� � ?����� �����a� �

��� � �� � � � �a� ��� � �� � ����� � ��� �

#Ld �g[9d�V`s`wDN:RUd�\/a�wDVrT�acz�� � u % ��w�a�Q�[9bW_\acP�zjVSQS[)X�Vez?��ags^sWO�n9ngV`s�TWVYX�a9s�TW\�VogV`\�RyqrzjVpf{[gb�V`Q�P�[:X:�)RUd�n�TW[g_���X:[B�7dm�)d�[B�7zjV`X�ngVg� #�f?sW[w/TW\�V`dmR¡T�f{[gzjzU[B��s�TW\acTa�QS[9bW_�\/acP�zjV QS[:X:Vez�sW\�[gO�zyX�qe[gds�TWb,acRjd;TW\VkP�[cTWTW[gQ���O�_�zjV`agbWdRUd�n�_�bW[:qeV`s}s�7\�Ryq,\Zqe[gd)ogV`b�T,s1_R¡£:VezHRjd:f{[9bWQ�aBT}RU[9d Rjd&TW[S\�Rjng\�V`b���zUV`ogV`z�qe[gngdR¡T}RUo9V�q`aBTWV`ng[9bWRjV`s`�*�d�V sWRjQ�_zUV���a���[gf#agq,\�RjVeo)Rjd�n�TW\Rjs�Rjs�TW[�\/a�ogVSTW\V [gO�TW_�O:T�[cf�TW\V zjV`acb}d&Tf{O�dqrTWRj[gd^Rjd�TW\V(sW_agqeV�[cf:TW\V?QS[gb}_�\acPzUV?QS[:X:V`zgb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&TWRjd�n�T}\�V?T}[g_:�LX:[B�7dRjd:f{[gb}Q�aBTWRj[gd*� #Ld�TW\�Rys�q,\/ac_:T}Veb#�iV�X:VYsWqebWRjP�V�a�QSVrT}\�[:X�f{[gb�_/V`b�f{[9bWQSRjd�nSTW\�Vs}acQSVg� � \Rjs�QSVeTW\�[:X8OsWV`s�a;zjV`agbWd�Rjd�ng��Pa9s�VYX�ag_�_�b}[9agq,\�TW[�VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}V�TW\�V�*����_acb,acQSVeTWVeb,s�X:Rjb}V`q�T}zU�Zf{b}[gQ>TW\V�RjQSagngVYs�[cf�T}\�V�[gP���VYq�T�qezja9sWs5�{Rjd�T}\�Rjsqea9s�V�QS[gO:T}\s,���� \�V�QS[cTWRjoBaBT}RU[9d^f{[gbDT}\�Rjs��i[gb}�pqr[9Q�VYs�f{b}[gQ�T}\�V�OsWV([gf�a�zUVYacb}d�RUdnc��PagsWV`X

ac__�bW[&agq,\ZRUdmb}V`agz¡��TWRjQSV^acdagzU�:sWRjs�[cf�QS[gO:T}\s����O�Q�acb#agdXm��[gn9ngRj[ � %1+ �§�rw/Rjd�7\�Ryq,\<RUT���ags�sW\�[B�7d T}\aBT a�b}Vengb}V`s}sWRU[9d�f{O�dqrTWRj[gdJqeagd<P�VmzUVYacb}d&T�f{b}[gQ a«#a9acb���a�ogV`zUVeTSP/agsWV`X8RUd_�O:Tkb}Ve_bWVYs�V`d9T,aBT}RU[9d<[gf�QS[gO�TW\s�TW[�\agdX�zjagP/V`zUVYX_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s7X:V`d�[cT}RUdn�[g_�Ved�dV`s}s#acd/Xms�QSRjzUV9��«�Veb}Vp�iV^Vr£)TWV`dX�T}\�V^QSVrT}\�[:XTW[�zUVYacb}d5T}[^X:RjbWVYq�TWzj��V`s�TWRjQSacTWV7T}\�V�Q�aBT,q,\�Rjd�np_acb,acQSVeTWVeb,s�[gf-agd��*���>f{b}[gQRjQSagngVYse�� \�Rys#QSVrT}\�[:X�q`acd�P�V5O/s�VYX�TW[kP&�)_a9sWs#[gb�s�_�VeVYX�O�_�qeO�b}bWV`d9T�qr[gQS_�O�T}aB�

TWRj[gd/aczjzU�SRjd9T}VedsWRjogV#QSVeTW\�[:X�s(TW\/aBT(O/s�V�acdagzU�:sWRjs1P)�SsW�)d&TW\�VYs�Rysew9f{[gbiQ�aBT,q,\�RUdn[gP ��V`q�T,s�TW[;QS[gb}_�\agP�zUV�QS[:X:Vezys`� � Vmb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T�TW\�VmQS[gO�TW\�RUQ�agngV`sSa9s�a

u9x

Page 33: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

reference prototype

textureflow

reference prototype

flow texture

� RUn9O�b}V<u�� ! © #LzUzjOs�TWb,aBTWRjd�n¢TW\�V8ogVYq�T}[gb}RU¨`V`X2b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T,aBTWRj[gd@[cfkagd@RjQSagngV9��?RU£:VezU���7RysWVkqr[9bWb}V`sW_�[gdX:V`dqrVYs�agbWVZqr[gQS_�O�TWV`X<P�VrT��iVeVed�TW\�VZ_�b}[cT}[cT��)_/VZRjQ5�acn9V acd/X�a�s�T}acd/X�acb,X;bWVef{Veb}VedqeV�RjQSagngV9� � \�V��/[B�EogV`qrTW[9b�qr[9ds�Rys�T}s5[cf�TW\�VX:Rys�_zja9qrVeQSV`d9T,s^[gf�V`agq,\�_R¡£:VeziRjd�TW\�VkbWVef{Veb}VedqeV�RjQSagngVkbWV`zjacTWRjogVSTW[�R¡T,s�_�[c�sWR¡T}RU[9d�Rjd�TW\�V�_bW[gTW[cT��)_�Vg� � \VSTWVr£)T}O�bWV�o9V`qrTW[gb^qe[gdsWRys�T,s�[cfiTW\�V�_bW[gTW[cT��)_�V�� � � 1 ���� 1 2�����9��TW[�TW\�Vpb}Vrf{V`bWV`dqrV�RjQ�acngV9�

sW_acb,s�V�s�OPs�VeT7[cf�zj[B��b}V`sW[gzjO:TWRj[gdk«#agagb��ia�o9VezjVrTiqe[)V�X�qrRjVed&T}s�agdXkag_�_�zj�STW\�Vb}[gP�Os�T1T}V`q,\�dRj~&O�V�[cf�N)O�_�_�[gbWTi¥�VYq�T}[gb7��agq,\RUd�VYs���N)¥����?f{[9b�zUVYacb}d�RUdn5a5bWVe�ngb}V`s}sWRU[9dmf{O�dqrTWRj[gd�f{bW[9Q T}\�V�«#agagb^qr[)V�X�qeRUV`d9T,s�TW[ZTW\V��*��� _acb,acQSVeTWVeb,s`�� V�s�T}OX:��T}\�V�s�_�VeVYX8O�_�T}\aBT�QSRjng\&T�P/Vm[9P:T}agRUdV`X<P&�<V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWRjd�n�TW\V`sWV_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}sDOsWRUdn^a�bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gd�f{O�dq�T}RU[9dSTW[pRjd�RUTWRyaczjRU¨`Vgw)ags�[g__/[&s�VYX�T}[^s�T,acd:�X�agb}XZacdagzU�:sWRjsiP)� sW�)d9T}\�V`sWRyse�

� ��� ?������A���-���f�B3����������²� ����A��&®�f�,� �����������1���.>]"$���

#Ld�T}\�RysisWV`qrTWRj[gdk�(V�_�b}[Bo&RyX:V�a^P�b}RUVef�[Bo9Veb}o&RjVe��[gf��*����siagdX�T}\�VeRjb7ac_�_zURyqeac�TWRj[gdkTW[�QS[:X:V`zURjd�nSQS[gO:T}\se�

��������� � �1�*� �����H� �?+ C � � �t zURjd�V`agb(QS[9bW_�\/acP�zjV#QS[:X:Vez-RysiPagsWV`X�[9d zjRUdV`acb�qr[9Q�P�RjdacTWRj[gds1[cf�a�s�_�V`qeR¡|�qb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd�[gf(Ve£:agQS_�zUVSRjQ�acngVYse� � \�VSbWV`_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd�Rjd)og[gzjogVYs#VYs�T,acP:�zjRjsW\�Rjd�n a�qr[9bWb}V`sW_�[gdX:V`dqrVpP�VrT��iVeV`dmV`a9q,\ZVe£�acQS_�zjV^RUQ�agngV^acd/Xma�bWVef{Veb}VedqeVRjQSagngV9� � \)Os*RUTDa9sWsW[:qrRyaBT}V`sH�7RUTW\^V`ogV`bW��RUQ�agngV1a�sW\ag_/V(ogV`qrTW[9b*acdX�a�TWVe£&T}O�b}VogVYq�T}[gbY� � RjngObWV^u� ! RjzUzjOs�TWb,aBTWVYs�TW\Rjs7o9V`qrTW[gb}Rj¨eV`Xkb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd�w:�7\Rjq,\mqeagdP�V�qe[gQS_�O:T}V`X�P)�STW\V#zjRUd�VYacb�qr[9Q�P�RjdaBT}RU[9d�[cf�Ve£�acQS_�zjV#RjQSagngVYs(a9s(sW\�[B�7d�Rjd� RUn9O�b}V�u� xk�¤N:VeV �9[gd�VYs7acdXZ��[gn9ngRj[�� x ����f{[9b7QS[gb}V�X�VrT}agRUzys,���

Page 34: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

��a&�= ++ ...b1

b2 b3

Model Texture Prototype Texture

�{P��= ++ ...c1

c2 c3

Model Flow Prototype Flows

��qY�

� RUn9O�b}V�u� x�© t zjRjd�V`agb�qr[gQ5P�RjdaBT}RU[9d<[gf�RjQSagngVYsSRUd<TW\�V������ f{b}agQSVe�i[gb}�Rjd&o9[gzjogVYs#��a&�(zURjd�V`agbWzj��qr[9Q�P�Rjd�Rjd�n�T}\�V�_�bW[gTW[gT��&_�V�TWVr£)T}O�bWVYsiOs�Rjd�n5TW\�V�qr[)V�X��qrRjVed&T,s 7 TW[5�&RjVezyX�a�Q�[:X:V`zT}Vr£)TWObWV�acdX���P/�?TW\�V�_�bW[gTW[gT��&_�V �[B��s(OsWRUdnpTW\�Vqr[)V�X�qeRUV`d&T}s � TW[Z�&RjVezyX�akQS[:X:Vez �[B�p���¤q`� � \�VSQS[:X:Vez�RjQSagngV�Rjs�[9P:T}agRUd�VYXP)����acb}_�RUdn�T}\�VpQS[)X�VezHT}Vr£)TWO�b}Vpaczj[gd�n�T}\�VpQS[)X�Vez �[B�

������� � 0 �1�#�9':�A#!�'��W��3@��� C � � +,�?�8� �7��������#34� �1A�':"��#LdS[gb,X:Veb�T}[�qr[9ds�TWb}Oq�T�T}\�V#sWRUd�n9zUV�_�Veb,s�[9dSQ�[9O:TW\������G�iV�qr[gzjzjV`q�T}V`XSacP�[gO�Txcv &S& RjQ�acn9V`s([cf�QS[gO:T}\s(f{bW[9QE[gd�V�_/V`b}sW[gd*� U u^[gf�TW\�VYs�V�RUQ�agngV`s(�iVeb}V#Q�acd:�OagzUzj�Zq,\[9sWVed�ags�Vr£�agQ�_zUV^RjQ�acn9V`s7T}[kqe[gds�TWb}Oq�T#TW\�VS�*��� � � \�V5bWVef{Veb}VedqeVRjQSagngViqeacd5P/V�q,\�[&s�V`d5sWOq,\pTW\/aBT�R¡T�qr[9bWb}V`sW_�[gdX�s*TW[�TW\Via�o9Veb,acngV��{Rjd^TW\Vio9V`qr�TW[9b�sW_a9qrV5X�Vr|d�VYX�P)��T}\�V��������#[cf?T}\�VSVr£�acQS_�zjV�RjQ�acn9V`s`��«#[B�(V`ogV`b`w/TW\�V�*��� qeagd�P/V�X:Vr|/d�V`Xm[9d�zj�ZP)�mq,\�[)[9sWRjd�n�a�b}Vrf{V`bWV`dqrV9� � \�Veb}Vrf{[9bWV��(V�T}ac�9Vb}V`qr[9O�b,s�V�TW[macd�R¡T}Veb,aBT}RUo9V5QSVrT}\�[:X��7\�Veb}V�T}\�V�b}Vrf{Veb}Ved/qrV�RUQ�acn9VSRjs�Rjd�RUTWRyaczjzU�q,\�[&s�V`d�acb}P�RUTWb,acb}RUzj�g��ª�s�Rjd�nkTW\�Rys�b}Vrf{Veb}Ved/qrVSacdX�TW\�V��*��� T}\aBTpRUTpX�Vr|d�VYsewTW\V a�ogV`b}agngV�[cf�TW\�V Vr£�acQS_�zjV�RjQSagngVYspRjs5qr[9Q�_O:TWVYXH� � \�Rjs5a�ogV`b}agngV�RUQ�acn9VTW\VedZf{[gb}Q�siTW\�Vpb}Vrf{V`bWV`dqrV�RUQ�agngV�f{[gb�T}\�Vpd�Vr£)T#s�TWV`_k[gf�T}\�VpR¡T}Veb,aBT}RU[9d�� � \�RjsQSVrT}\�[:X�qr[9d)ogVeb}ngVYs�Rjd5a#f{Ve� RUTWV`b}acTWRj[gds*TW[�a�s�T,acP�zjVia�o9Veb,acn9V�RUQ�acn9Vg� t P�[)[cT��s�TWb,ac_�_�Rjd�n�TWVYq,\�d�Ry~&O�V7Rjs�O/s�VYX�T}[pRUQS_�b}[BogV(TW\V#qr[9bWb}V`sW_/[9dX:V`dqrViP/VeT��(V`Ved5TW\�Vb}Vrf{Veb}Ved/qrV�acdXZ[cT}\�Veb7_bW[gTW[cT��)_�V�RUQ�acn9V`s

*�dqrV�TW\V�b}Vrf{V`bWV`dqrV�RUQ�agngV�Rjs(f{[gOdXkagdX qe[gb}bWVYs�_�[gd/X:VedqeV�P�VrT��iVeVed TW\�Vb}Vrf{Veb}Ved/qrV�acdX�_�b}[cT}[cT��)_�V`spVYs�T,acP�zjRjsW\�VYXHw*�iV�ngVeT�a U umX:RjQSVedsWRU[9dacz(�*������ \�V�X:RUQSV`ds�Rj[gd/aczjR¡T���[cf(_�R¡£:V`z�sW_a9qrV^P�VeRjd�nmxcv &Y& w/TW\�VS�*��� qr[9ds�TWRUTWO:T}V`s�azj[B�(V`b�X:RjQSVedsWRj[gdagz�b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T,aBTWRj[gd�[cf?T}\�V�s�_a9qrV��{[9b�Q�acdR¡f{[9zjX��[gf(QS[gO:T}\RjQSagngVYse��«#[B�(V`ogV`bSsWRjdqrVmQ�acd)�<[cf�TW\�V�Ve£�acQS_�zjVmRUQ�acn9V`s�agbWV�agzURj�gVZTW\Veb}VRys�zjRj�gVezj��TW[ZP�VSakngb}V`acT�X:VYacz�[cfibWVYX:O�dXacdqe�ZV`ogV`d�Rjd�T}\�Rjs�b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T,aBTWRj[gd*�#Ldm[gb,X:V`b7TW[�b}VeQS[Bo9V�T}\�Rys#b}V`X:OdX�acd/qr�gw/�(Vp_�VebWf{[gb}QG�il t [9d�TW\�V^Ve£�acQS_�zjVTWVe£)TWO�b}V^acdX�sW\ac_�V^o9V`q�T}[gb,s7acdXZb}VrT,acRjdZ[9d�zj��TW\[9sWVp_�bWRjdqeRU_agz*qr[9QS_/[9d�Ved&T}s�7RUTW\�T}\�V�\RUn9\�V`s�T�V`RUn9Ved)oBaczjO�V`s`� t s�a bWVYs�O�zUT��iV�[9P:T}agRUd�acd��������7\�V`bWV�a

Page 35: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

d�[Bo9Vez�TWVr£)T}O�bWVSRyspa zjRjd�V`agb�qe[gQ5P�RUd/aBTWRj[gd�[cf(TW\�VS_�b}RUd/qrRj_acz?qe[gQS_/[9d�Ved&T�TWVe£&�TWObWVYs(���7\�Rjq,\�X:[#d[cT�bWVYs�V`Q�P�zjV1acd)��[cfTW\�ViVr£�acQS_�zjV?T}Vr£)TWObWVYs}�*acdX5s�RjQSRUzyacb}zU�a�d�[Bo9Vez �[B�2Rjs�a�zjRjd�V`agb�qr[9Q�P�RjdacTWRj[gdm[cf1TW\�V5_�bWRjdqeRU_agzDqe[gQS_�[gd�V`d9T �[B��s`�t Q�O�zUTWRj_�zjVp_/V`b}sW[gdkQS[gO:T}\Z����� Rjs�[9P:T}agRUd�VYX�P)��f{[9zUzj[B�7RUdn�aSsWRUQSRjzjagbi_bW[g�qrVYX:O�b}VSVr£�qrV`_:T^�(VS�i[gb}�m�7R¡T}\;Q�[9O:TW\/sp[cf�QS[gb}V�T}\acd;[gdV�_�Veb,sW[gd�w�RUd;[gObqea9s�Vku�X:R ��V`bWV`d&T�_�Ve[9_�zUVk[cf�sWRjngd�RU|/qeagd&TWzj��X:R �-Veb}Ved&TSsW�)RUd TW[gdVkacd/X QS[gO:T}\sW\ac_�Vg�

� ��� ?@�A���B������1 "$�²�%�<"$�0� ��"=� "$���,?�� � 3������� ��*"$�%��7�����%��"�8H &'��.� ��� ��1.�%�

� \�V�_�b}[gPzUV`Q�[cf:VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}RUdn�TW\�V?Q�acT}q,\�Rjd�n��*���4_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,sHX:RUb}V`qrTWzj��f{b}[gQTW\VpRUQ�acn9VpRjs�Q�[:X:V`zUVYXmags�zjV`agbWd�Rjd�n�a�b}Vengb}V`s}sWRU[9d�f{O�dqrTWRj[gd�f{b}[gQ>acdmac_�_bW[g�_�b}RjacTWV�Rjd�_�O:T?b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T,aBTWRj[gd�[cf�TW\�V7RjQ�acngV(TW[�T}\�V�s�VeT?[cf-�*��� _acb,acQSVeTWVeb,s`�� \�V5RUd�_O:TpbWV`_�bWVYs�V`d&T}aBT}RU[9d�Rjs�q,\�[&s�V`d�TW[ZP/VSa sW_acb,sWV�s�VeT�[gf(«#a9acb#��a�ogV`zUVeTqr[)V�X�qeRUV`d&T}s?�7\RUzjV��iV�OsWV#s�O_�_/[9b�TiogVYq�TW[9b?b}Vengb}V`s}sWRU[9d�a9s�TW\�V�zUVYacb}d�Rjd�n^aczjng[g�b}R¡T}\�Q��

��� � ��� � �*�#�����D'�����34'�"��2��������������3 � �H'� \�V�TWb,acRjd�Rjd�n�s�VeT��ia9singVedVeb,aBTWVYXka9sif{[gzjzU[B��s`�

� #Ld�TW\�Vmq`agsWV [cf#TW\�V�s�Rjd�n9zUVZ_/V`b}sW[gd�Q�[9O:TW\8�*��� V`a9q,\ [cf�T}\�V�xcv &S&RjQ�acn9V`sSRys�Q�aBT}q,\V`X<TW[�TW\V��*��� OsWRjd�n�TW\�V�N W ] aczjng[9bWRUTW\�Q �§f{[gbX�VrT}agRUzys�[cf?T}\�V�N W ] agzUn9[gb}R¡T}\�Q f{[9b�Q�acT}q,\�Rjd�nk������s#TW[kRUQ�acn9V`s�s�V`V� x + �§�r� � \V7T��([pQ�agRUd�_agb}agQSVrTWV`b}sDT}\aBT(d�VeVYX�TW[pP�V7|�£:V`X�acT?TW\�Rys1s�TWV`_Rys�T}\�V^d)O�Q�P�Veb7[gfD_bWRjdqrRj_agz*qr[9Q�_�[gdVed&T}s�[gf�T}Vr£)TWO�b}V^acd/X �/[B�%sW_agqeVT}[^b}VrT}agRUd�agdX�TW\V�d)O�Q�P�Veb([cfHR¡T}Veb,aBT}RU[9ds�[cf-T}\�V�N W ]%aczjng[9bWRUTW\QZ� � Vf{[9O�dX;T}\aBT�bWVeT}agRUd�Rjd�nmT}\�V�T}[g_;T}\�bWV`V _�b}RjdqrRj_acziqr[9Q�_�[gdVed&T}s�[cf�TW\�VT}Vr£)TWObWV agdX �[B� s�_a9qrV�agdX�aczjzU[B�7Rjd�n�xS(gvZR¡T}Veb,aBTWRj[gd/sp[cf�N W ] �ia9ssWO2X�qrRjVed&T�T}[�n9RUo9VkO/s�a�ng[)[:X Q�aBT,q,\8agdX�agq,\�RjVeo9VkQSRjd�RUQ5O�Q _R¡£:VezV`bWb}[gbi[gd�a�ogV`b}agngV9� V a9q,\ RjQSagngV�RjsiT}\)Os�bWV`_�b}V`sWVed&TWVYX ags�a�s�RU£kX:RjQSVed:�sWRj[gdagzHogV`qrTW[9b`w)�7\�Ryq,\Zf{[gb}QETW\�Vp[9O:TW_O:T}s�f{[9b�TW\�VpzjV`agbWdRUd�nS_�b}[gPzUV`QZ�

� V agq,\S[cf-T}\�V�xgv &S& RjQ�acngVYs�Rys1sWO�P���V`qrT?TW[^TW\�V#«�agagb?�ia�o9VezjVrT�T}b}agds�f{[9bWQagdX5f{V`acTWO�b}V�s�V`zUVYq�T}RU[9d5Rjd)og[gzjo)RUdn�sWVezjV`qrTWRj[gd�[cf�TW\�[&s�V7«�agacb?qe[)V�X�qrRjVed&T}s�7RUTW\ TW\�V�\�Rjng\�VYs�TioBacb}RjagdqrV#a9s1Ve£:_�zjagRUdV`X�Rjd sWV`q�T}RU[9dkx:� u�� x:� � V�sWVezjV`qrT! xmqr[)V�X�qeRUV`d&T}s^�7RUTW\�TW\�Vk\�Rjng\�VYs�T�oBagbWRyacdqeV��7\�Ryq,\�f{[gb}Q TW\�VkRUd�_O:T}sf{[9b�TW\�VpzjV`agbWdRUd�nS_�b}[gPzUV`QZ�

t s�RjQSRUzyacbp_bW[:qrVYX:O�b}V5Rys�f{[gzjzj[B�(VYXmf{[gb�T}\�V�Q�Oz¡T}RU_�zjVS_/V`b}sW[gd�QS[gO:T}\��*����wTW\VZ[9d�zj��X:R ��V`bWV`dqrVmP�VeRjd�n�TW\acT�RUd8T}\�Rjs�q`agsWV��(V�\a9X T}[�b}VrT,acRjd�T}\�V�TW[9_

Page 36: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

VeRjng\&Ti_�bWRjdqeRU_agzHqr[gQS_�[gd�V`d&T}s([cf�T}\�V�TWVr£)T}O�bWV�acdX��[B��sW_agqeV`s(bWVYs�_�V`qrTWRjogV`zU�9wacd/X<b}V`~&O�Rjb}V ! vgv9v�RUTWV`b}acTWRj[gds�[cf�TW\�V�N W ] agzUn9[gb}R¡T}\�Q RjdJ[gb,X:VebST}[ ngVeT ab}V`agsW[gd/acP�zjV#b}V`qe[gds�TWb}Oq�T}RU[9d��

� ��� � �%�$>�� "$�7������ �����%>��=�=���.�

#Ld�T}\�RjsSsWV`qrTWRj[gd �iV�_�b}V`sWVed&T�T}\�VZQSagRUd�bWVYs�O�zUT}s5[cf�[9O�b�Ve£:_/V`bWRjQSVed&T}s`� � \Vb}V`sWO�z¡T,s�\a�o9V�T��([�X�Rjs�TWRjdq�T�agsW_/VYq�T,s���T}\�V�a9qeqrOb}a9qr�^[gfHTW\�V�VYs�T}RUQ�acTWV#agdX�TW\�V~&OaczjRUT���[cf�TW\VpRUQ�acn9V�bWVYqr[gd/s�T}bWOqrTWRj[gd�� � \�V^agq`qrO�b,agqe��[cf�TW\�VpVYs�T}RUQ�acTWV^qeagdP�V�~&Oacd&TWRU|VYXmacdX�QSV`a9s�ObWVYXkRjdmT��i[��ia��:s`� ! � � \�V�qrzj[9sWVed�VYsWs�[gf�TW\�V^VYs�T}R¡�Q�aBT}V7f{bW[9Q N)¥���b}Ven9bWVYsWsWRj[gd�TW[pT}\�V#[9d�V#[9P:T}agRUdV`X�f{b}[gQEac_�_zU�)Rjd�n5N&T}[)q,\/ags��TWRyq W b,agX:RjVed&T�]�V`s}qrV`d&T#[gb�x9� � \�V5Veb}bW[9b7RUd�T}\�V�b}V`qe[gds�TWb}Oq�T}V`XZRjQSagngV9� � \VT��i[SagbWV�qrzjV`agbWzj��b}VezyaBT}V`XZacdXk�gVeT�[9d�V^qeagd�d�[gT�P�V^sWO�PsWO�QSV`XkRUdZTW\Vp[cTW\VebY�� \�Vm~&OaczjR¡T��;[gf�TW\�V�RjQ�acngVkbWVYqr[9ds�T}bWO/q�TWRj[gd*w?[gd�T}\�V�[cT}\�VebS\agdXHw?RysSa

_�\�V`d�[gQSV`d�[gzj[gn9Rjq`acz�QSV`agsWO�b}V�agdX;aczUTW\�[9O�ng\�RUT^Rjspb}VezyaBT}V`X�TW[ZTW\V�P/[gTW\�TW\�VacP�[BogVkVeb}bW[9b�QSV`a9s�ObWVYsew1a�ngb}V`acT�X:VYacz�[cf��([9bW�;Rjd<o)Rys�Rj[gd8acdX�_/V`b}qeVe_:T}RU[9dsWVeVeQ�s�T}[mRUdX�Rjq`aBTWVST}\aBT^RjQ�acn9Vr��PagsWV`X�Q�VYagsWO�b}V`s�acb}VSd�[cT^n9[&[:X�RUd/X:Rjq`aBT}[gb,s[cf�_/V`b}qeVe_:T}Oacz#zURj�gV`d�V`s}s � %Y% ��� � \�Vm_�\�V`d�[gQSVed[gzj[gngRyqeagz�zURj�gV`d�V`s}s�[cf�bWVYqr[gd��s�TWb}Oq�T}RU[9d�Rys?Ve£)TWb}VeQSVezj��RjQS_/[9b�T,acd&T�TW[pT}\�V��i[gb}�^[gd�RjQ�acn9V�s��)d&TW\�VYs�Rys`��N)RjdqeV�iV1acb}V?d�[gT�X:RjbWVYq�TWzj��qr[gd/qrVeb}d�VYX��7R¡T}\^RUQ�agngV1sW�)d9T}\�V`sWRysHTW\Rjs�QSV`agsWO�b}V�\ags*zUVYsWssWRUn9d�R¡|�qeacd/qrV�f{[gbpOs`� «#[B�(V`ogVebYw��iVS�7RUzjz1qr[9QSQ�V`d&T^[gd;P/[gTW\�TW\V`sWV�agsW_/VYq�T}sP�Vezj[B�p�

����� ��� � �W��31��� ������&�1�G���(A7'�"����?��6�"��������2���7��*��m[9O:TW\�������s�ac_�_�V`agb7TW[k�([9bW�kP/VYs�T��7\�Ved�qe[gds�TWb}Oq�T}V`XZf{[9b�a�sWRUdngzjV^_/V`b��sW[gd�� � \�V�b}V`sWO�z¡T,s�acb}V�X:Rys�TWRjdq�T}zU��P�VrTWTWV`b7d�[cT7[gdzU��Rjd T}Veb}Q�s�[cfD~&Oagd&TWRUT}aBT}RUo9VVeb}b}[gb,sp[gd _R¡£:Vezys�acdX<�*��� _/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s^P�O:T�aczysW[�Rjd�TW\�V�~&OaczjRUT���[gf7TW\�Vb}V`qr[9ds�TWb}Oq�T}RU[9d��R#Ld�[9O�biVr£:_/V`bWRjQSVed&T}s`w&�(V�VYs�T}RUQ�acTWV`X s�RU£��*��� qe[)V�X�qrRjVed&T}sqr[9bWb}V`sW_�[gdX:Rjd�n;T}[�TW\�V�TW[9_�TW\�b}VeV�_�b}RUdqeRU_/acz�qr[gQS_�[gd�V`d&T}s�[gfpTW\�V�TWVe£&T}O�b}VsW_agqeV�acd/X�TW\V �[B��sW_a9qrV�bWVYs�_�V`qrTWRjogVezj�g� � [9b�V`agq,\k�*��� qr[)V�X�qrRjVed&T7a�sWVe_:�acb,aBT}V�b}Ven9bWVYsWsWRj[gd�f{O�d/q�TWRj[gdm\/agX TW[SP/VpzjV`agbWd&TY��?b}VezjRUQSRjdacb}� Ve£:_/V`bWRjQSVed&T}s7RjdX:RyqeacTWVYX�TW\acT W acO/sWsWRjagd��gVeb}d�V`zjs7�iVeb}V^X:Rys��

TWRjdqrTWzj�5sWO�_/V`bWRj[gb�T}[pV`s�TWRjQ�aBTWRjd�n�T}\�V��*���>_agb}agQSVrTWV`b}sDRjdSTWV`bWQ�s�[cf-d)O�Q�P�Veb[cf�sWO�_�_�[gbWT�ogV`qrTW[9b}s7agdXkTWb,acRjd�RUdn�V`bWb}[gb7qe[gQS_acb}V`X TW[�_�[gzj�)d�[gQSRyacz��9Veb}d�Vezys`�t sia^b}V`sWO�zUT(�iV#d�Ve£)Tiqr[9d:|d�VYX�[9O�b}sWVezjogVYs�TW[5Vr£:_�Veb}RUQSVed&T}RUd�n5�7R¡T}\ W agOsWsWRyacd�gV`bWdVezys�[gdzU�9� � \�V^f{b}VeV�_acb,acQSVeTWVeb,s�Rjd�T}\�Rys�_bW[9P�zUV`Q�w�d/acQSVezj�gw-T}\�V5RjdsWVed:�sWR¡T}RUo)RUT���f�agq�T}[gb�Yw�aZ�(V`RUn9\9T�[gd�TW\�V�qe[9s�T�f{[9b�PbWVYac�)RUdn�TW\V�V`bWb}[gb�P�[gO�dX��acd/X T}\�V^d�[9bWQ�agzURj¨`acTWRj[gdkf�agq�T}[gb��;�iVeb}V�V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWVYX�RUd/X:Ve_�VedX�Ved&TWzj� f{[9b#VYagq,\[cf7T}\�Vk����� _/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,spOsWRUd�n�qrb}[9s}s���oBaczjRjXaBTWRj[gd*� � \�V b}Ven9bWVYsWsWRU[9d�f{O�dq��TWRj[gd���ags�OsWV`X�TW[�V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWV�T}\�V��*��� _agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s�[cf�akTWV`s�T^s�VY~&O�VedqeVS[cf

Page 37: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

11st PC of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500−1

−0.5

0

0.52nd PC of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

13rd PC of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

� RUn9O�b}V?u�� u�© V s�TWRjQ�aBT}V`sH[gf:a7sWRjd�ngzjV?_�Veb,s�[9d������ �[B�;_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s-OsWRjd�n�TW\�VN W ] agzUn9[gb}R¡T}\�Q agdXZN:¥�� bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gd [gdma5TWV`s�T#sWV`~&O�Ved/qrV�[cf % ( U RjQ�acngVYse�

Page 38: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500−1.5

−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.51st PC of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

12nd PC of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500−0.5

0

0.5

13rd PC of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

� RUn9O�b}V�u�� % © V s�TWRjQSacTWVYs�[cf?a�sWRjd�ngzjV^_�Veb,s�[9d��*��� T}Vr£)TWO�b}V�_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s�Os��Rjd�n�TW\V�N W ] aczjng[9bWRUTW\�Q>acdX�N:¥���b}Ven9bWVYsWsWRU[9dk[9d�aSTWVYs�T�s�VY~9OVedqeV^[cf % ( URjQSagngVYse�

Page 39: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 1 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−0.3

−0.2

−0.1

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7PC # 1 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 2 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 2 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 3 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 3 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 4 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 4 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 5 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 5 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 6 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−0.5

0

0.5

1PC # 6 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6PC # 7 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−0.3

−0.2

−0.1

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4PC # 7 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 8 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120−0.5

0

0.5

1PC # 8 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

��a&� �{P/�

� RUn9O�b}V�u��)(:© V s�T}RUQ�acTWV`s�[cf���a&� �[B�GacdX2��P/��TWVe£)TWO�b}V�_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}sS[gfpagzUzTW\V�V`RUn9\9T�_�b}RUd/qrRj_acz-qr[9Q�_�[gdVed&T}s([cf�a5Q�Oz¡T}R¡��_/V`b}sW[gdk�*��� Os�Rjd�n5TW\�VpN W ]aczjng[9bWRUTW\Q agdX�N)¥�� bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gd�[9d�a;TWVYs�TmsWV`~&O�Ved/qrV�[gf ! v % RUQ�acn9V`s [cfRjdX:Rjo&RyX:Oagz ! �

Page 40: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 1 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 1 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 2 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5PC # 2 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6PC # 3 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140−2

−1.5

−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1PC # 3 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 4 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5PC # 4 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5PC # 5 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 5 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5PC # 6 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 6 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 7 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5PC # 7 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5PC # 8 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 8 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

��a&� �{P/�

� RUn9O�b}V�u�� & © V s�T}RUQ�acTWV`s�[cf���a&� �[B�GacdX2��P/��TWVe£)TWO�b}V�_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}sS[gfpagzUzTW\V�V`RUn9\9T�_�b}RUd/qrRj_acz-qr[9Q�_�[gdVed&T}s([cf�a5Q�Oz¡T}R¡��_/V`b}sW[gdk�*��� Os�Rjd�n5TW\�VpN W ]aczjng[9bWRUTW\Q agdX�N)¥�� bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gd�[9d�a;TWVYs�TmsWV`~&O�Ved/qrV�[gf ! u U RUQ�acn9V`s [cfRjdX:Rjo&RyX:Oagz*x:�

Page 41: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 1 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 1 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70−1

−0.5

0

0.5PC # 2 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 2 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 3 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

2PC # 3 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 4 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5PC # 4 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70−0.5

0

0.5

1PC # 5 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70−2

−1.5

−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1PC # 5 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

2PC # 6 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1PC # 6 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70−1.2

−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6PC # 7 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6PC # 7 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70−0.6

−0.5

−0.4

−0.3

−0.2

−0.1

0

0.1

0.2

0.3PC # 8 of Flow space

stoc gradsvm

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70−0.5

−0.4

−0.3

−0.2

−0.1

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5PC # 8 of Texture space

stoc gradsvm

��a&� �{P/�

� RUn9O�b}V�u� + © V s�T}RUQ�acTWV`si[gfi��a&���[B��acd/X���P/�(TWVe£&T}O�b}V�_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s1[gfDaczjz�TW\�VVeRjng\&T*_bWRjdqrRj_agz&qe[gQS_/[9d�Ved&T,s�[cfa#Q�O�zUTWRU��_/V`b}sW[gd^�����EOsWRUdn7TW\�V7N W ]8aczjng[g�b}R¡T}\�Q@acd/X�N)¥��>bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gd^[9d�a�T}V`s�T1s�VY~9OVedqeV([gf &YU RjQ�acngVYsD[cf-RUdX�RUo)RyX:Oaczu��

Page 42: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

�¤a9� �{P/� ��qY� ��X� �{V�� �{f}�� RUn9O�b}V^u�� ��©il([9Q�_/acb}RjsW[gdZ[cf�b}V`qr[9ds�TWb}Oq�T}RU[9d f{b}[gQ>�*���¦_agb}agQSVrTWV`b}s�VYs�T}R¡�Q�aBT}V`X�TW\�b}[gO�n9\�N)¥�� bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gd�agdX�TW\�b}[gO�n9\�N&T}[:q,\ags�TWRyq W b}a9X:RUV`d&Tp]�Vr�s}qrVed&T(��N W ]��Hf{[9b�a�sWRUdngzjV?_/V`b}sW[gdpQS[9O:TW\��������&��a9���[Bo9VezS#LQ�agngVgw)�{P��*N)¥����acb,acQSVeTWVeb V s�T}RUQ�acTWRj[gd�f{[gzjzj[B�(VYXkP)�mN W ]@f{[gb ! v�RUTWVeb,aBT}RU[9ds`w���qY�#N W ]@f{[gb! vkRUTWVeb,aBT}RU[9ds`w?��X�pN W ] f{[9b (cvkR¡T}Veb,aBT}RU[9dsew?��VY�pN)¥�� ��agb}agQSVrTWV`b V s�T}RUQ�ac�TWRj[gd�aczj[gdV�agdX��{f}�(TW\Vp_�bW[:qeV`X:O�b}V��7\�Rjq,\ZngV`d�Veb,aBT}V`s1TW\�V�T}b}agRUdRUd�nSX�acT}a�R¤� Vg�N W ]2_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb�V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWRj[gdZf{[9b#xS(cv5RUTWVeb,aBT}RU[9ds`�

�¤a9� �{P/� ��qY� ��X� �{V�� �{f}�� RUn9O�b}V^u�� U ©il([9Q�_/acb}RjsW[gdZ[cf�b}V`qr[9ds�TWb}Oq�T}RU[9d f{b}[gQ>�*���¦_agb}agQSVrTWV`b}s�VYs�T}R¡�Q�aBT}V`X�TW\�b}[gO�n9\�N)¥�� bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gd�agdX�TW\�b}[gO�n9\�N&T}[:q,\ags�TWRyq W b}a9X:RUV`d&Tp]�Vr�s}qrVed&T^�¤N W ]��if{[9b�a�Q�O�zUTWRj_�zjV��§TW\bWV`VY�i_�Veb,s�[9dkQS[gO�TW\m�*��� �*��a&� #[BogV`z #LQ5�acn9Vgw&�{P/��N)¥�� ��agb}agQSVrTWV`b V s�TWRjQSacTWRj[gd�f{[gzjzj[B�(VYX�P)�pN W ]�f{[gb ! vgv�RUTWVeb,aBT}RU[9ds`w��qY�pN W ]Ef{[9b ! v9vZR¡T}Veb,aBTWRj[gd/sew1�¤X�^N W ] f{[gb (gvgvkR¡T}Veb,aBT}RU[9dsewi�{V��^N)¥�� ��ac�b,acQSVrT}Veb V s�T}RUQ�acTWRj[gd aczj[gdV acdX��§f}�^TW\�Vk_�b}[)qeV`X:ObWV��7\Rjq,\ n9Ved�V`b}acTWVYs�TW\�VTWb,acRjd�Rjd�n�X�aBT,a�R¤� Vg�1N W ] _acb,acQSVrT}Veb�V`s�TWRjQ�aBT}RU[9dkf{[9b ! v9vgv^RUTWV`b}acTWRj[gds`�

Page 43: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

0 100 200 300 400 50016

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

Iterations

Pix

el L

1 E

rror

Subject 1

SGD after SVMSGD alone

0 100 200 300 400 50015

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

Iterations

Pix

el L

1 E

rror

Subject 2

SGD after SVMSGD alone

0 100 200 300 400 50013

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

Iterations

Pix

el L

1 E

rror

Subject 3

SGD after SVMSGD alone

�¤a9� ��P/� �¤q`�

� RUn9O�b}V#u�� ! v©��?zj[cTi[cf�_�RU£:Vez�Veb}bW[9b?o:s�T}\�V�RUTWV`b}acTWRj[gds1[cfHT}\�V�N W ]�agzUn9[gb}R¡T}\�Q��l([gQS_agbWRjd�n�TW\�Vpqea9s�V�[cfDRUd�RUTWRyaczjRj¨`aBT}RU[9d �7RUTW\kTW\�V^N)¥�� b}Ven9bWVYsWsWRj[gd�V`s�TWRjQ�aBT}Vacd/X��7RUTW\;T}\aBT^[gf(d�[mRjd�RUTWRyaczjRU¨YaBTWRj[gd*� � \�VSTW\�b}VeVS_�zj[cT,s^qr[9bWb}V`sW_�[gdX�TW[ZTW\�VTWVYs�TSs�VY~&O�VedqeV`s�[cf7TW\V�TW\bWV`V RjdX:Rjo&RyX:Oagzjs5Rjd�TW\�VkQ�O�zUTWRj_�zjV _�Veb,s�[9d QS[gO:T}\�*�����

% ( U RUQ�acn9V`s`� � RUn9O�bWVYspu�� umacdX;u� % X:Rys�_zja���TW\�V�b}V`sWO�zUT}s�f{[9b �[B� agdX�TWVe£&�TWObWVp_agb}agQSVrTWV`b}s�bWVYs�_�V`qrTWRjogVezj���7\�V`bWV^TW\�V^_�VebWf{[gb}Q�acdqeVp[cf�s�O_�_/[9b�T�ogV`qrTW[9bb}Vengb}V`s}sWRU[9d�Rjspqe[gQS_agbWVYX�T}[kT}\aBT^[9P:T}agRUdV`X�Os�Rjd�nms�TW[:q,\ags�TWRyq�ngb,agX:RjVed&TpX:Vr�s}qrVed&TY�R#�T?s�\[B��s�T}\�V�\�RUn9\5X:V`ngb}VeVi[cf�|�X:VezjR¡T��^TW\acTD[9d�Viq`acd5ngVrT�Rjd5VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}RUdnTW\V^�*��� _acb,acQSVeTWVeb,s�X:RjbWVYq�TWzj��f{b}[gQ TW\�VpRjQ�acngV9�

V £�acQS_�zjV`s^[cf7Q�aBT}q,\V`spOsWRjd�nmTW\V�T��([�Q�VeTW\�[:X�s5s�\[B�7d�Rjd � RUn9O�b}V u�� �b}VeogVYacz&T��i[�RjQS_/[9b�T,acd&T?agsW_/VYq�T}s`� ! � � \�V7s�_�VeVYXSagX:oBacd&T,acngV(TW\/aBT�[gd�V�[9P:T}agRUdsP)�kVYs�T}RUQ�acTWRjd�n�T}\�V5������_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s�X�RUb}V`qrTWzj�kRys�~&O�RUTWV�qrzjV`agb`� #Ld�[9d�zj� ! vRUTWVeb,aBT}RU[9ds?a�N W ]¢agzUn9[gb}R¡T}\�Q@Rjd�RUTWRyaczjRU¨`V`X��7RUTW\�T}\�V�VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}V#[gfHagd N)¥�� bWVe�ngb}V`s}sWRU[9d Rys�qeag_acP�zjV�[cf?agq,\RUV`o&Rjd�n�TW\V^sWagQ�V^~&OagzURUT����¤acdXmsW[gQSVrT}RUQSVYs�VeogV`dP�VrT�T}Veb���T}\acd�akN W ]4agzUn9[gb}R¡T}\�Q>bWO�dd�RUdn s�[9zUV`zU�kf{[gb$(cv�RUTWV`b}acTWRj[gds`�#xg� � [gbTW\[9sWV Rjd9T}Veb}V`s�TWVYX;RUd8s��)d&TW\�VYs�Rys5Rjs}s�OV`s`w�T}\�V�~9O/aczjR¡T���[cf�T}\�V b}V`qe[gds�TWb}OqrTWRj[gd_�\�V`d�[gQSV`d�[gzj[gn9Rjq`aczjzU��Q�a���zUVYa�ogV�amzj[cT^T}[�P�VkX:VYs�RjbWVYXH�m«�[B�iVeo9Veb�TW\Rjs�Rjs5a~&O�RjbW��[cf1TWb}�&Rjd�n TW[ZQ�[:X:V`z�Q�[9O:TW\/s�O/s�Rjd�n�T}\�V�_acbWTWRyqrO�zyacb��*��� X:VYsWqebWRjP/VYXRjd �g[9d�V`s(acdX���[9ngn9RU[ � x �����1N)RjdqrV#TW\�Rys(������Rjd)og[gzjogVYs�QS[gb}_�\�Rjd�n�agzUz/_�bW[gTW[g�T��)_/VYs(TW[Sa5sWRUdngzjV#b}Vrf{Veb}Ved/qrVgw)RUT7RUd)og[9zUo9V`s1zU[&sWs([cfDRUd:f{[9bWQ�acTWRj[gd��7\�V`dkX:VYaczjRUdn�7RUTW\ [9P���V`qrT}s�sWOq,\ ags(QS[gO:T}\si�7\�Ryq,\ \a�o9V#b,agX:RyqeagzUzj��X�R �-Veb}Ved&T�o&RjVe��si�7\�V`d[g_�Ved�agdX�qrzj[9sWV`X�� � \Rjs1bWVYs�O�zUT}s1RUd�_�[)[gbi~9O/aczjR¡T����7\�Ved Os�VYX�f{[gb(RUQ�acn9V�s��)d:�TW\V`sWRjs`� � [gbWTWO�d/aBTWV`zU�9wcT}\�Veb}V�acb}V7[cT}\�Veb�QS[gb}_�\agP�zjV7Q�[:X:V`z�7\�Ryq,\SngRjogV�P�VrT�T}VebsW�&d&T}\�V`sWRjs?bWVYs�O�zUT}s�� V ¨e¨`acT(acd/X���[gngn9RU[ � %<! �Hacd/X l([&[gTWVYs?VrTiacz�� � ! x��{��agdX�[gObQSVrT}\�[:XZq`acdZRUd�_�b}RjdqrRj_�zjV�P�VpVr£)T}VedX:VYXkTW[STW\[9sWVg�

����� � � � A#�L'���6���� ������&�1�G���1A�':"�� �?��6�"#�������2���7#�*�� \�V�q`agsWV�f{[gb TW\�V�Q�O�zUTWRj_�zjV�_�Veb,s�[9d8Rys�b}[gOng\�zj�<sWRUQSRjzjagb Ve£:qeVe_:T TW\acT�TW\�Vb}V`sWO�z¡T,s5ag_�_�V`acb5TW[;X:V`ngb,agX:VkRUd8~9O/aczjR¡T��9� � \�Rjs�Rys5TWb}O�Vk[gf�TW\V�q`ac_a9qrRUT��;[cfTW\V��*��� T}[�QS[)X�Vez�T}\�V^oBacb}Rj[gOs�QS[gO�TW\mRjQSagngVYs7ags7�iVezjz�a9s�TW\�V�N W ]@agdX

Page 44: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

TW\V�N)¥�� b}Vengb}V`s}sWRU[9d5VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}V`s`� � \�Rjs(Rys(qezUVYacb?f{b}[gQ4TW\V#f�a9q�T1T}\aBTi�(V�d�VeVYXTW[�b}VrT}agRUd<VeRjng\&TS_�bWRjdqeRU_agz�qr[9Q�_�[gdVed&T}s�[cf#TW\�VZTWVe£)TWO�b}VZagdX �[B� sW_agqeV`s`wRjds�T}V`a9X�[cf ��Os�TiT}\�b}VeV�RUdkTW\V�q`agsWV�[gf�TW\V^s�Rjd�ngzjV�_/V`b}sW[gdkQ�[9bW_\acP�zjV�Q�[:X:V`z¤wTW[k[gP:T,acRjd�b}V`a9s�[9dacP�zjV^b}V`qe[gds�TWb}Oq�T}RU[9d�� � \&O/s�Rjd�[9O�b�Vr£:_/V`bWRjQSVed&T}s��iV5V`dXO�_kV`s�TWRjQSacTWRjd�n !'& _agb}agQSVrTWV`b}s1RUd [gb,X:Veb(TW[5ngVrT�b}V`agsW[gd/acP�zjV7bWVYqr[9ds�T}bWO/q�TWRj[gd*�#Ld � RjngO�b}V�u� U �(V�_�b}V`sWVed&T�Vr£�acQS_�zjV`s([cf*Q�acT}q,\�VYs1T}[5d[BogVez�RjQSagngVYs?f{b}[gQTWVYs�T�sWVrT,s7acdXZqr[9Q�_/acb}V�TW\Vp[gO:T}_�O:T7[cf�TW\�V^N)¥�� b}Ven9bWVYsWsWRj[gdSTW[�T}\aBT�[gf�TW\�VN W ]Gaczjng[9bWRUTW\QZ� l([gQSQSVed&T,s5sWRUQSRjzjagb�T}[�T}\�VZsWRjd�ngzjVk_�Veb,sW[gd qea9s�VZqeagd P/VQ�agX:VZRjd�T}\�Rjs�q`agsWV�T}[&[/� #Ld � RjngObWV�u�� ! v��(VmaczysW[�_�b}V`sWVed&T�TW\�VmsW_/V`V`X O_b}V`sWO�z¡T,s�RUdZT}\�V�f{[gb}Q [gfDa�ogV`b}agngV�Veb}bW[9bi[Bo9VebiTWVYs�T#sWVrT7f{[9b�a�ngRjogVedZd)O�Q�P�Veb#[cfRUTWVeb,aBT}RU[9dsi[cf�TW\�V�N W ]@aczjng[gb}RUTW\�QERjd T}\�V�T��i[�q`agsWV`si�7\�Ved�Rjd�RUTWRyaczjRU¨`V`Xk�7R¡T}\TW\V�N)¥�� b}Vengb}V`s}sWRU[9d�V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWV^agdXk�7\�Ved�d�[gT`�� R¡T}\�T}\�V�ngb}[B�7RUd�n�ag_�_�zjRjq`aBT}RU[9d�[cf?QS[gb}_�\agP�zjV�QS[:X:Vezys#Rjd�RjQ�acn9V5acd/aczU�

�:s�Rys�agdXms��)d&TW\V`sWRjs`wQSVrT}\�[:X�s#TW[�VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}VpTW\VeRjb#_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s�f{b}[gQ>RjQSagngVYs�7RjzUz�P�V`qe[gQSV7Rjdqrb}V`a9s�Rjd�ngzj�pRjQ�_�[gbWT}agd&T`��#LdSTW\�Rys?qr[9d&TWVr£)TYwBTW\�V#zUVYacb}d�RUdnc��PagsWV`Xac__�bW[&agq,\�T}[SV`s�TWRjQSacTWRjd�nSTW\V�_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s([gfDaS�*��� Rys�dacTWO�b,acz�a9s(�iVezjz�agsqr[9QS_�O:T}acTWRj[gdagzUzj��f{VYagsWRUPzUV9� #Ld;TW\�Rys�q,\ac_:T}VebYw��iV s�TWOX�RUVYX qrV`b�T,acRjd agsW_/VYq�T}s[cf(TW\�RyspQSVrT}\�[:XHw*d/acQSVezj��T}\�V�Rjs}sWO�VS[cfisWRjd�ngzjVS_/V`b}sW[gd�o:s�Q�O�zUTWRj_�zjV�_/V`b}sW[gd�wacd/X�sW_�VeV`XSO_��7R¡T}\�bWVYs�_�V`qrT�TW[pT}\�V�N W ]¢aczjng[gb}RUTW\�Q���«�[B�iVeogV`b�QSagd)��[cT}\�VebagsW_�V`q�T,s7[cf�T}\�Rjs#_�b}[gP�zjVeQ d�VeVYX f{Ob�T}\�Veb�s�T}OX:�g�7N)[�f�agb�[gOb�bWVYs�Oz¡T,s7RUd/X:Rjq`aBT}VTW\/aBT�TW\V#s�Rjd�n9zUV7_�Veb,s�[9d��*���>Rys?d�[gT?[gd�zj��o9Veb}�^ng[)[:XSaBT?QS[:X:VezjRUdn^QS[gO:T}\sewRUT#Rjs�Q�[&s�T#agQSVedagP�zUV�T}[ X:RjbWVYq�T�VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}RU[9d�P&�ZzjV`acb}d�Rjd�n� � \�V�qea9s�V�f{[9b7TW\�VQ�Oz¡T}RU_�zjV1_�Veb,sW[gd^�*��� Rjs�QS[gb}V?acQ�PRUn9O�[gOs*acdXpRUT�sWVeV`QSs*TW[#O�dX:V`b���_/V`b�f{[9bWQTW\V�sWRjd�ngzjV�_�Veb,sW[gdk����� RUdkV`s�TWRjQSacTWRj[gd�agq`qrO�b,agqe�Sa9si�(V`zUzHags�~&OagzURUT���[cfDbWVe�qr[9ds�TWb}Oq�T}RU[9d��f*�d�V#�ia��pT}[p[BogV`b}qe[gQSViTW[�TW\Rjs1_�bW[9P�zjVeQ@Q�a��5P/V�T}[�qr[9ds�RyX:V`b[cT}\�Veb1Q�[:X:V`zjs?�7R¡T}\�P/VeT�TWV`b(sW�)d9T}\�V`sWRys�_/V`b�f{[9bWQ�agdqrV^� V ¨e¨YaBT1agdX���[gn9ngRj[ � %<! �acd/Xml([)[gTWV`s�VeT#acz�� � ! x �{��� � \�V^qrzyacRjQ T}\aBT#sWOq,\�V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWRj[gd��7RjzUz�acRyXkRjdZTW\�VX:VYs�RjngdZ[cfDbWVYaczU�¤T}RUQSVps��:s�TWV`QSs7agzjsW[Sd�VeVYX�siTW[�P�V�TWVYs�T}V`XH�

Page 45: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� ��������� �

� � � � � ���a��� ���

� � � � ��� � � � ����� ��� � � �

t d�V`� acdX�Rjd&TWV`bWVYs�T}RUd�n�_/acb,agX:RjngQ RUd���agd:��QSa9q,\�Rjd�V^Rjd9T}Veb,agqrTWRj[gd�Rjs#[gd�V�[cfsW[)qeRjagP�zjV \)O�Q�acd�[9RjX�bW[9P/[gT}s`w?�7\�Ryq,\8q`acd<RUd&TWV`b}a9q�TS�7R¡T}\<\)O�Q�agd�P�VeRjd�n9sSagssW[)qeRjagzDqebWVYaBT}O�bWVYs#O/s�Rjd�nma oBagbWRjVrT���[cf�s�[:qeRjagzUzj��bWV`zUV`o�agd&T�QS[:X�aczjRUTWRjV`s�s�O/q,\�agsf�agqeRjagz�Vr£:_�b}V`s}sWRU[9dsew:n9V`s�TWO�b}V`s`w�_�[9s�TWO�b}Vgwn9ac¨`Vgw�o9[gRyqrV9w�VrT,qc� � \�Rjs#qeaczjzys�f{[gbYwRjdTW\V��([9b}X�s�[gf�l(�)d&TW\Rjamhib}V`ac¨`Vez � & ��wDsWV`agQSzUVYsWsWzU��qr[gQ5P�Rjd�RUdnZRjdsWRUn9\&T}s�f{b}[gQs}qrRjVedqeVgw�agb�T�agdX�Ved�n9RUdVeVeb}Rjd�n� �1bWRjdqeRU_�zjV`X���a��:s�[cf�V �-V`q�T}RUdn�s�O/q,\;sWV`agQ��zjV`s}s�qe[gQ5P�RUd/aBTWRj[gd/s�q`acd�f{[gb}QGTW\�V�X:VYs�Rjngd�_�b}RUdqeRU_zUVYs#f{[9bpP�O�RjzjX�RUd�nmsW[:qrRyacP�zjVb}[gP�[cT}s`�

*�d�V�[cf�T}\�V�|b}s�T7s�T}Ve_siRjd T}\�Rjs�X:Rjb}V`q�T}RU[9d �i[gO�zyX�P�V�TW[�V �-V`qrTiT}\�V�X:V`sWRUn9d[cf#sW�:s�T}VeQ�spT}\aBTSqeagd qr[gQ5P�Rjd�VkamoBagbWRjVrT���[cf#qe[gds�TWb,acRjd&T}sp�7RUTW\8amzUVYacb}d�Rjd�n_�b}[:qrV`s}siTW[SzjV`agbWdkTW[�O�d/X:Veb,s�T,acdX;�¤acdXZb}V`sW_/[9dX�(TW[SRjQS_/[9b�T,acd&T�_/V`b}qeVe_:T}OaczqrOV`s`�R#Ld5TW\�Rys�TW\V`sWRjsD�iVi\/a�ogViVr£�acQSRjd�V`X^TW\�V�_�[9s}s�RjP�RjzURUT��^[cf-s�O/q,\�Rjd9T}Ven9b}acTWRj[gd[cf:T}[g_:�LX:[B�7d^qe[gds�TWb,acRjd&T}sH�7RUTW\^P�[cTWTW[9Q5��O�_^zjV`agbWdRUd�n#P&��_�[9sWRUdn7TW\�V(_�b}[gP�zjVeQags�[9d�V�[cf�X�RUb}V`qrTWzj� zUVYacb}d�Rjd�n�T}[;V`s�TWRjQSacTWVZTW\Vm_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s�[cf�QS[9bW_�\/acP�zjVQS[:X:Vezys�f{b}[gQ RjQ�acngVYse� #LdJT}\�Rjs�q,\ag_:TWV`b`w#�(V�s�\agzUz�X:RysWqeOs}sksW[gQSV�[gfpTW\�Vac__�zURyqeacTWRj[gds1[cf-TW\Rjs1TWVYq,\�d�Ry~9OVgw)�7\�Ryq,\ s�V`Ve�5TW[^RjzjzUOs�TWb,aBT}V#\�[B�8T}\�Ve��qeagd�P/VOsWVrf{O�z*RUdZTW\Vpo&RysWRU[9dZqe[gQS_/[9d�Ved&T7[cfDQ�acd:��Q�agq,\�Rjd�V�RUd&T}Veb,agq�T}RU[9d��

� ��� � �%�(�.1.��� �%����12D¥���%���������¥3���%�=�=���.���t PRUzjR¡T��ST}[�b}V`qe[gngdRU¨`Vgw&RUd&TWV`bW_bWVeTiacd/X�bWVYs�_�[gd/XSTW[�f�agqrRyacz�Vr£:_�b}V`s}sWRU[9ds?Rys�qr[gd��sWRjX:V`bWVYX�TW[�P�V�a#�gV`�^qr[gQS_�[gd�V`d&T�Rjd5Q�acd���Q�agq,\RUd�V(RUd&T}Veb,agq�T}RU[9d��R#�T,sDbW[9zUViagsDaf{O�dXacQSVed&T}agz9QS[:X:O�zyaBT}[gb�[cfsW[)qeRjagzgRjd&TWVeb,agqrTWRj[gdpRys*zjV`a9s�T�s�ObW_�b}Rys�Rjd�n7ngRjogV`d�TW\�VsWVeQSRUd/acz)�([9bW��[gf V �)Q�acd � !'& ���7\�Ryq,\�P�b}Rjd�n9sD[gO�TDT}\�V�O�d�RjogV`b}s}acz&daBT}O�b}Vi[gf�f�aB�

% (

Page 46: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

qrRyacz�Vr£:_�b}V`s}sWRU[9dsew9RUd�TW\�V�s�V`dsWV7TW\acT(T}\�Veb}V�agbWV#O�d�RjogVeb,s}aczb}VezyaBT}RU[9ds?P�VrT��iVeV`d_agb�T}RjqeO�zjagb�f�agqeRjagz/qe[gd:|n9O�b,aBTWRj[gd/s?acdX�qeVebWT}agRUd�V`Q�[gTWRj[gds`� � \�V`sWV�RyX:V`a9s?\a�o9VQS[cT}RUoBaBT}V`X8T}\�Vmf�agqeRjagz#agqrTWRj[gdJqr[:X:Rjd�n sW�:s�T}VeQ � � t l�N�� � !]+ ���7\�Ryq,\J_/[&s�RUT}sf�agqeRjagzDa9q�T}RU[9d�O�d�RUT}s�ags#TW\V ��PO�RUzyX:Rjd�nZP�zU[:q,�:s ��[cf1Ve£:_�bWVYsWsWRj[gds`� � \�RjzUV�T}\�Rjs�i[gb}��RysDRUd&TWV`bWVYs�T}RUdnwBRUT�\/agsDqrVebWT}agRUd�X:b,a��7Pagq,�:s`� � \�V�QSagRUd�X:b,a��7Pagq,��P/V`RUdnTW\/aBT�TW\�V�s�TWb}OqrTWO�b}V�[cf � t l�N�Rys�d�[cT�n9Ved�V`b}acTWRjogVg� V agq,\5f�agqeRjagz:agq�T}RU[9d5Od�R¡T?P)�RUT}sWVezUfHag_�_�V`acb,s�T}[pP/V#a9X)��\�[:q�RUd�b}VezyaBT}RU[9d5T}[pTW\V�Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gd/s��BVeQS[cT}RU[9ds�TW\acTRUT�Rys�a�_acbWTD[gf�� � \Rjs�qeagd5P�V�RUd&T}Veb}_�bWVeTWVYX�ags�a�zja9q,�p[cf-s�O2X�qeRUV`d9T�s�TWb}Oq�T}O�bWV�Rjd� t l�N�acdX�TW\Veb}Vrf{[gb}V�[gd�V�q`acdS~&O�V`s�TWRj[gd�TW\V7zURj�gV`zURj\�[)[:X5[gf�VYs�T}RUQ�acTWRjd�n�f�agqrRyaczagqrTWRj[gdSO�d�RUT}s�f{bW[9Q f�agqeRjagzqr[9d:|n9O�b}acTWRj[gds�a9s?acdSRjd9T}Veb}QSV`X:Ryacb}�pTW[pVe£:_�bWVYsWsWRj[gdb}V`qr[9ngd�RUTWRj[gd*�

#Ld T}\�V�zja9s�T7q,\ac_�TWVebYw)�(V�OsWV`Xka^ngV`d�Veb,aBT}RUo9V�s�TWb}Oq�T}O�b}V#�DTW\�Vp��������f{[gbQS[:X:VezjRUdn�QS[gO:T}\ _aBTWTWV`bWds`� � VkagzjsW[�s�\[B�(VYX�TW\acT�TW\V _agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}sp[gf�a_�RU£:Vez�������qeagdmP/V5X:RUb}V`qrTWzj�kVYs�T}RUQ�acTWV`XZf{b}[gQ>QS[gO:T}\mRUQ�agngV`s�Os�Rjd�n�zjV`agbWd��Rjd�n�ShiO:T�TW\�Rys^X:[)V`s�d[cTpd�V`qeV`s}sWagbWRjzj�ZRjQS_�zj��Vr£:_�b}V`s}sWRU[9d�bWVYqr[9ngd�RUTWRj[gd�� #�T^RjsRjd9T}Veb}V`s�TWRjd�nZTW[�a9s����7\�VrT}\�Veb�aZn9Ved�V`b}acTWRjogV�s�T}bWO/q�TWObWV�sWOq,\�ags^agd;����� RjsaczysW[�qeag_acPzUVk[cf#b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}RUd�n�f�agqeRjagz(Ve£)_bWVYsWsWRU[9ds5RUd8a�dacTWO�b,aczi��a��g� � Vacd/s��iVeb�TW\Rjs^~&O�VYs�T}RU[9d�Rjd�TW\�V�a�X�bWQ�aBT}RUo9V�acdX�ags^a�qe[gdsWV`~&O�V`dqrVS�iV�_bW[g�_�[9sWVpTW\�V�X:V`sWRjngdm[cf?agd�Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gd�b}V`qe[gngdR¡T}RU[9d�sW�:s�T}VeQ TW\acT�Rys#q`ac_agP�zUV�[cfQSR¡T}RUn&aBT}RUd�n/wgaBT?zjV`a9s�T�Rjd�_acbWT`wcTW\�V�f�agQ�RjzjRjagb�_�bW[9P�zjVeQ@[gf/Q�acd)Oagzacdd�[cT,aBTWRj[gd*�

� ������� ��� 6#��*�)�&���1�GI � �*�� \�V5�gVe��RyX:V`a P/V`\�RjdXmT}\�V5dVe� Ve£)_bWVYsWsWRU[9dmbWVYqr[9ngd�RUTWRj[gd�sW�:s�T}VeQGRjs#TW\/aBT�[cfTW\V������/��������� ( �;�� ����� t s�Ve£:_�zjagRUdV`XkRUd�s�VYq�T}RU[9dZu� ! � x�R¡T�Rys�_�[9s}s�RjP�zjV�T}[�T}ac�9Va�qr[9bW_Os7[cf�QS[gO:T}\mRUQ�agngV`s#acdXZ_�O:T#TW\�V`Q Rjd�qr[9bWb}V`sW_/[9dX:V`dqrV��7RUTW\�Rjd�TW\�Vs�TWb}Oq�T}O�bWV1[cfacd^�������]#�T�Rys*agzjsW[�_�[9s}s�RjP�zjV?T}[�_/V`b�f{[9bWQ2��l t [gdpT}\�V1Ve£�acQS_�zjVTWVe£)TWO�b}V`s�acdX �/[B��s�acdX�Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�TW\�VS�*����ags#a zURjd�VYacb�qe[gQ5P�RUd/aBTWRj[gdm[gf?asWQSagzUzjVebpsWVrT^[gf1TW\V�QSagRUd�_�b}RUd/qrRj_acz?qe[gQS_/[9d�Ved&T,s�[cf1T}\�VSTWVe£)TWO�b}V�acdX �[B�sW_agqeV`s`��]�[#T}\�V`sWV(_bWRjdqrRj_agz)qe[gQS_�[gd�V`d9T,sDbWV`_�bWVYs�V`d&TDsW[gQSVrT}\�RUdn�QSV`agd�Rjd�ncf{O�zacP�[gO�T#QS[gO:T}\�s�\/ac_�V`s � � [ acdsW�iVeb7T}\�Rjs�~&O�V`s�TWRj[gd*w�iV�QS[gb}_�\�TW\V5a�ogV`b}agngVQS[gO:T}\�RUQ�acn9Vmaczj[gd�n�TW\�V�T}\�b}VeVmQ�acRjd �[B� _�b}RjdqrRj_acz�qe[gQS_�[gd�V`d9T,se� � \Vb}V`sWO�z¡T,s�acb}V(sW\�[B�7d�Rjd � Rjn� % � ! � � \�ViRUd&T}Veb}V`s�TWRjd�n�[9O:T}qe[gQSVi[cfT}\�Rys�Vr£:Veb,qrRys�V(RjsTW\/aBT�Q�[9bW_\�RUdn5aczj[gdn^TW\V#|b,s�T(T}\�bWV`V�_bWRjdqrRj_agz�qe[gQS_/[9d�Ved&T,s1[gf �[B��sW_agqeVzjV`agXs�TW[�b}V`qr[9ngd�Rj¨`agP�zjVkQS[gO�TW\�X:Vef{[gb}QSacTWRj[gds�sWOq,\�ags�[9_/V`d:�Lqrzj[9sWVgw(sWQSRUzjVr�f{b}[B�7d�acdX�_/[9O:T���_�O�b,sWVg� � \�VYs�V�aB£:VYs��7\�Ryq,\8�(V�qeagd<qeagzUziT}\�VkVe£:_�bWVYsWsWRj[gdaB£:VYs�qeagd�P/V5OsWV`XZTW[Zags}qrV`b�T,acRjdkT}\�V5X�Vengb}VeV�[cf�Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gd�[gf?V`agq,\m�)RjdXmRjda^d[BogVez�QS[gO:T}\ RjQ�acngV9� � V�qeagd�Q�ac_ VYagq,\�Ve£:_�bWVYsWsWRj[gd�Rjd9T}[�a�zURjd�Ve��X:b,a��7Rjd�n�*��� s�O/q,\�ags#TW\�V5[gd�V�s�\�[B�7dmRjd � Rjn� % � x:� � \�Rys�zURjd�V5X�b}a��7Rjd�n��*����\agsu�X:Ven9bWV`V`si[cf�f{bWV`V`X:[9Q qr[9bWb}V`sW_/[9dX:Rjd�n^T}[�TW\�V^u�Vr£:_�b}V`s}sWRU[9d aB£:V`s`����ac__�RUdnTW\V(VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}V`Xp_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s�[cf:T}\�Vi_�R¡£:V`z)�����E[9d9T}[�T}\�V(zjRjd�ViX�b}a��7Rjd�n#�����aczjzj[B��s�Os�T}[�acdRUQ�aBT}V#a^q`acbWTW[)[gdS|n9O�b}V�TW[�QSRjQSRjq�T}\�V�f�a9qrRyacz/Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gds?[cf

Page 47: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� RUn9O�b}V % � ! © � \V V £:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gd t £:V`spsW\�[B�7Rjd�n T}\�V�b}V`sWO�z¡Tp[gfiQS[gb}_�\�Rjd�nkTW\�Va�ogV`b}agngV�QS[9O:TW\�RjQSagngVpaczj[gdn5T}\�V�|b,s�T�T}\�bWV`V �[B��_�b}RjdqrRj_acz�qe[gQS_�[gd�V`d9T,se�

TW\Vp_/V`b}sW[gd��

� ����� � ��� 6p����W� �*�(')��� � �H':�����W�� V�qr[gzjzjV`q�T}V`X�a�qr[9bW_Os�[cf %Y& ��Q�[9O:TW\�RjQ�acngVYs�[cfpa�sWRUd�n9zUVm_�Veb,sW[gd8�7R¡T}\oBacb}�)RUd�nZX:Ven9bWV`V`s�[cfiVr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gd/se��xgu % [cf1T}\�V`sWVS�(V`bWV5OsWV`X�TW[mqr[9ds�T}bWO/q�Tpa_�RU£:Vez�����G[gd�TW\V7zURjd�V`s?[cf�s�VYq�T}RU[9dSu� ! � x�����l t [gd�TW\�V#Vr£�acQS_�zjV`sDT}Vr£)TWO�b}V`sacd/X �[B��s1agzUzj[B�(VYX�Os?T}[�Ve£)_bWVYsWs�T}\�V�������Rjd�TWV`bWQ�s1[cf*a^sWQ�aczjzUV`b1d)O�Q�P�Veb[cfHT}Vr£)TWObWV�acdX��[B��_�bWRjdqeRU_agz�qe[gQS_�[gd�V`d9T,se�?N W ]%��ags(OsWV`XST}[�Q�aBT,q,\�TW\�Vqr[9bW_Os?[gf %Y& ��RUQ�agngV`s?TW[�TW\�V��*��� �:N:¥�� b}Ven9bWVYsWsWRj[gdS�ia9s?OsWV`X�TW[�zUVYacb}d�aQ�ac_�_RUd�n^f{bW[9Q a�s�_agb}sWV7��a�ogVezjVrTW��P/agsWV`X�bWV`_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gdm��sWVeV#sWV`qrTWRj[gdkx�� u� x9�TW[�TW\�VZVr£:_�b}V`s}sWRU[9d aB£:V`sk� �[B�E_�b}RjdqrRj_acz�qr[9QS_/[9d�Ved&T}s,�p_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s^OsWRUdnTW\V W acOs}s�Ryacdk�gV`bWd�V`z¤w�a9s7X:VrT,acRjzUVYXZRUdmsWV`q�T}RU[9dZu� u� ! �� ������� ���*�)A��L'������# � �W�)!HA#�)�)���1�� \�VZbWVYs�Oz¡T,acd&T�Q�ag_<��ags5TWVYs�T}V`X<OsWRUd�n;a�TWV`s�T�s�VeT�[cf % ugv�Q�[9O:TW\8RjQSagngVYsqr[9zUzjV`qrTWVYX�OdX:Veb�a7X:R �-Veb}Ved&T�qeRUb,qrOQSs�T}agdqrV��¤X:R ��V`bWV`d9T*Xa��gw`TWRjQ�V(acdX�zjRUn9\9T}RUdnqr[9dX:RUTWRj[gds,��TW\agd�T}\�ViTWb,acRjd�RUdn�sWVrTY� � \�V�VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}V`X�Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gd5_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s

Page 48: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� RUn9O�b}V % � x:© t zURjd�V�X:b,a��7RUd�n��*��� qe[gb}bWVYs�_�[gd/X:RUdn7TW[#TW\�V V £:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gd t £)VYse�

�iVeb}V#Q�ac_�_�V`X [gd&TW[�TW\�V�zjRUdV�X:b,a��7Rjd�n5����� [gf � RUn/� % � x � \�V�bWVYs�O�zUT�[cf�T}\�RjsVr£:V`b}qeRjsWV�Rys�sW\�[B�7d Rjd � RUn&se� % � uSacd/X % � % �� \�Vpb}V`sWO�z¡T,s�acb}Vp~&O�R¡T}VpVedqe[gO�b,acn9RUdn� � \�V`�ksW\�[B��T}\�V�f{V`a9s�RjP�RjzURUT�� [gfDVe£&�

TWb,agqrTWRjd�n�QSV`agd�RUdncf{O�z�Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gds7f{bW[9Q>X�acT}a��7RUTW\[gO:T�agd)�ZsWRUn9d�RU|/qeagd9T�\)O:�Q�acd�Vr£:_/V`b�Tp�)d�[B�7zjV`X:n9Vg� � \�V�N)¥�� bWV`ngb}V`s}s�Rj[gd�T}b}agRUdRUd�n�b}VrT}O�bWd/s�aZsWQSagzUzd)O�Q�P�Veb#[cf?s�O_�_/[9b�T�ogV`qrTW[9b}s7agdXZTW\�V`bWVef{[gb}Vp�(V5qeacd�Ve£)_�V`qrT�TW\/aBT�b}V`agz¡��TWRjQSVRjQ�_zUV`Q�V`d&T}aBT}RU[9d��7RjzUz�P�V�V`agsW�g� #Ld8_�b}RUdqeRU_zUV9w�TW\�Rys�QSVrTW\[)X8qr[9O�zyX P�VkVe£&�TWV`dX:VYX�T}[�QS[9bWVpqr[9QS_�zUVe£�QS[gO:T}\�sW\ag_/VYsiagdXZaczys�[5TW[S[cT}\�Veb�f�a9qrRyacz-b}VengRj[gd/ssWOq,\�a9s�V`�gVYse�^«#[B�(V`ogVeb�sW[gQSV5RjQS_/[9b�T,acd&Tp~9OV`s�TWRj[gds�qr[9O�zyX�P�V�b,acRysWV`X�agdXzjRUQSRUT}aBT}RU[9ds�_�[gRjd9T}V`XZ[gO�T`�t dkRUQS_�[gbWT}acd&T�~9OV`s�TWRj[gd qe[gdqeVeb}ds�T}\�V�Ve£:_�bWVYsWsWRj[gds�b}Ve_bWVYs�V`d9T}V`XSP)��TW\�V

Vr£:_�b}V`s}sWRU[9d�aB£:V`s`��]�[�TW\�VmX:Vef{[gb}QSacTWRj[gds5b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&TWVYX P)�;TW\VZVe£:_�bWVYsWsWRj[gdaB£:VYs�qr[9bWb}V`sW_/[9dX TW[�T}\�V^[gdV`s7T}\aBT�acb}Vp_/V`b}qeVeRjogV`X�� � RUzjz�T}\�Ve��qr[9bWb}V`sW_/[9dXTW[#TW\�V(Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gd/s�X:Ve_RjqrTWV`X�P)��agd�acbWTWRys�T � � \Veb}V1Rys*a#s�TWb,acRjng\&TWf{[gb}�iagb}X��ia��[cf�X:VYaczjRUdn��7R¡T}\pTW\V`sWV(~&O�V`s�TWRj[gd/se�Dl(ObWb}Ved&TWzj��TW\�V(QSag_�f{bW[9Q%TW\�V(_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s[cf(TW\�VS_�RU£:VezU��������T}[ZTW\�VSzjRUd�V�X:b,a��7Rjd�nZ����� [cf � Rjn� % � x Rjspagd�RyX:Ved&T}R¡T��Q�ac_���l(zjV`acb}zj��TW\acT�dVeV`X�d�[gT�P�VSTW\VSq`agsWVg�\#Ld�n9Ved�V`b}agz¤wH�iVSqeacd;qr[9dqrV`RUo9V[cf#TW\�V�Q�ac_�f{bW[9Q¦TW\�V�Vr£:_�b}V`s}sWRU[9d aB£:V`s5TW[�TW\VZzjRjd�VZX�b}a��7Rjd�n������ ags�au � u�Q�aBTWb}RU£-� � \Rjs5�7RUzjzibWVY~9ORUb}V acd agb�T}Rjs�T�T}[�_�b}[Bo)RjX:V�T��([�b}Ved/X:R¡T}RU[9dsp�! ��TW\acT5[cf7T}\�V�f�a9qrRyacz(Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gds^[cf�[g_�Vedd�V`s}sew�sWQSRUzjV acd/X�_/[9O:T`w?a9s^zjRUdVX:b,a��7RUdn9s�acdX;xg��zjRjd�V�X:b,a��7RUd�n&s�TW\acT^P/VYs�T�ag_�_�b}[�£)RjQ�aBT}V�T}\�V�Vr£:_�b}V`s}sWRU[9dsX:V`_�RjqrTWVYX�P)�ZTW\�V�Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gd�ac£:V`s`��hi��Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rjd�n�[9d�V5sWVrT�[cf(_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,sRjd�TWVeb}Q�s7[cfDTW\V^[cT}\�Veb���OsWRUd�n�TW\�V5N W ]@aczjng[9bWRUTW\Q��rw��iV�qeagd�qe[gQS_�O:T}V�TW\�V

Page 49: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� RUn9O�b}V % � u�©k��ac_�_RUd�n�TW\�VZV`s�TWRjQ�aBT}V`X Ve£:_�bWVYsWsWRj[gd�ac£)VYs�_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s^[gd<azjRUd�V^X�b}a��7Rjd�nS�*�����

Page 50: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� RUn9O�b}V % � % ©k��ac_�_RUd�n�TW\�VZV`s�TWRjQ�aBT}V`X Ve£:_�bWVYsWsWRj[gd�ac£)VYs�_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s^[gd<azjRUd�V^X�b}a��7Rjd�nS�*�����

Page 51: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

Q�aBT}bWRU£�TW\acT�T}b}agds�f{[gb}QSs�TW\�VSVe£)_bWVYsWsWRU[9d�aB£:V`s�_agb}agQSVrTWV`b}s�TW[kTW\�VSX:VYs�RjbWVYXVr£:_�b}V`s}sWRU[9dkqeacTWV`ng[gb}RjV`s`�t d�[gTW\�V`bD~&O�VYs�T}RU[9d^RysHTW\/aBT�[gf�ngV`d�Veb,aczjRU¨YacP�RjzjR¡T��9� � V(\a�ogV(s�V`Ved^Rjd�q,\ag_:TWV`b

u�T}\aBT(TW\�V�Q�O�zUTWRj_�zjV�_�Veb,s�[9d��*��� _/V`b�f{[9bWQ�s?zjV`s}s?b}[gPOs�T}zU�5TW\/acd�T}\�V�sWRUdngzjV_�Veb,s�[9d�� t T#TW\�V�sWagQ�V�T}RUQSV^�iV^\a�o9V^s�V`VedmRjd�q,\ac_�TWVeb�x5TW\acT#TW\V^zUVYacb}d�Rjd�nPa9s�VYX ac_�_bW[&agq,\;RjsSagP�zUV TW[�ngVedVeb,aczjRU¨`V�TW[�QS[gb}V�TW\agd�[9d�V _�Veb,s�[9d�� � \�RjszjV`agXsSTW[�Rjd&TWVeb}V`s�TWRjd�n ~&O�VYs�T}RU[9dse��N)\�[9O�zjX8�iV�qr[9ds�T}bWO/q�T�Q�Oz¡T}RU_�zjV�_�Veb,sW[gd�*����s�Rjd8[9b}X�VebSTW[�Ve£)TWb,agq�T�T}\�VmVr£:_�b}V`s}sWRU[9d8ac£)VYs � «�[B�>bWV`_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRjogVRys�[gd�V�_�Veb,s�[9ds�Vr£:_�b}V`s}sWRU[9d�aB£:VYs�TW[�n9agO�ngV�TW\V�Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gds�[gfiamX:R ��V`bWV`d&T_�Veb,s�[9ds � � \�VYs�V7~&O�V`s�TWRj[gd/s�\a�ogViQ�Oq,\�P�V`acb}Rjd�n�[9d5P�[cT}\�TW\�V�qe[gngdR¡T}RUo9ViagdXVedngRjd�VeV`bWRjd�nSagsW_/VYq�T}s�[gfDVe£:_�bWVYsWsWRj[gd b}V`qe[gn9d�R¡T}RU[9dksW�:s�T}VeQ�se�

� ��� ���6"������"$����1 D����%����� ���.���

� a9qrRyacz)��[9sWVgw�aczj[gd�n#�7R¡T}\�n9ag¨eV9wYRysDacd^RjQS_/[9b�T,acd&T�o)Rys�Oagz&qeO�V?f{[9b*T}\�ViRUd&TWV`bW_bWVe�T}acTWRj[gdm[gf�\)O�Q�agdmP/V`\a�o)RU[9b#acdX�Rjd&TWV`d9T}RU[9ds`����[&s�VpVYs�T}RUQ�acTWRj[gdmRys#a�qrb}RUTWRyqeacz|b,s�Tis�T}Ve_�Rjd�[gdV�[cfHT}\�V#�9Ve�5T}agsW�:s�f{[9b1Q�acd:��Q�agq,\�Rjd�V7Rjd&TWVeb,agqrTWRj[gdS��_/[&s�V#RUd:�X:V`_/V`dX:Ved&T�f�a9qrVpb}V`qe[gngdR¡T}RU[9d��?«�[B�iVeo9VebYw:R¡T�Rys�aSogV`bW��TWb}Rjq,�)��T,agsW� sWRUdqeV�TW\�Vac__/VYacb,acdqeVp[cf�TW\V�f�a9qrV5q,\/acd�n9V`s7o9Veb}�ZsWRUn9d�RU|/qeagd9T}zU���7RUTW\mT}\�V�_/[&s�V^[gf�TW\�Vf�agqeVg�f#�T�Rys�daBT}O�b}agz-TW[�ags}sWO�QSV#T}\aBT�\�VYagXk_/[&s�V�P�VeRjd�n�a5TW\�b}VeVpX:RjQSVedsWRU[9dacz~&Oacd&T}R¡T��kR¡T,s7V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWRj[gdZf{b}[gQGxc]2RjQ�acngVYs7Rys7RUd\�Veb}Ved&TWzj�kagQ�P�RjngO[gOs`� t s#ab}V`sWO�z¡T7_�[9sWVpV`s�TWRjQ�aBTWRj[gd�\a9s�P/V`VedmOsWOagzUzj� aBTWTWV`Q�_�TWV`X�P)�kQSacT}q,\�Rjd�n�X:R ��V`b��Ved&T7�)RUd/X�s�[cfDQ�[:X:V`zjsiT}[�TW\�VpRjQ�acngV9� � [gb7Ve£:agQS_�zUV9w:RUd�hiVe�)QSVeb7acd/Xk��[9ngngRj[� x ��a�_�RU£:Vez&Q�[9bW_\acP�zjV?QS[:X:Vez)[gf:f�agqrVYs�q`ac_agP�zjV?[cf�QS[:X:VezjRjd�n#_�[9sWV1oBacb}RyaBTWRj[gd/sRys7Q�aBT}q,\V`XZTW[�d[BogVez�f�agqrVpRjQ�acn9V`s`�G#Ldmqea9s�Vp[gf �bWO�n9Veb7VeT�acz�� � ugv���w/agdmVezyags��TWRyq�ngb,ac_�\�Rjs�Q�acT}q,\�VYX�T}[ W acP�[gb��ia�o9VezjVrTW��Pa9s�VYX�f�agqeRjagz�f{V`acTWO�b}V`s`��hi[gTW\�[cfTW\V`sWV�b}Vezj��[9dkT}\�V^acd/aczj�)sWRys(P)�Zs��)d&TW\�VYs�Rys7aczjng[9bWRUTW\Q TW[�agq,\RUV`ogV�TW\�VpQ�aBT,q,\[cfDQS[)X�VezHT}[�RUQ�acn9Vg�" V`qeVed&T��i[gb}�mP)��N)\�V`bWb,ac\;VeT�acz�� � xY( �(\/agspsW\�[B�7d�TW\�V�_�[9s}sWRUP�RjzjR¡T���TW\acTTW\Veb}V7Vr£:Rjs�T}s?bWV`zjacTWRj[gdsW\�Rj_s�P/VeT��(V`Ved�_�RU£:Vez�_/aBT�T}Veb}ds?agdX�TW\�V7_�[9sWV�[gf-a�f�a9qrVg�� \�Rysi�([9bW��sWO�ngn9V`s�T}s1TW\acTi[9d�V�sW\�[9O�zjX P/VpagP�zUV�TW[�zjV`acb}d a�X:RjbWVYq�T�QSag_�f{b}[gQ_�RU£:VezU��Pa9s�VYX b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T,aBTWRj[gd/spTW[�f�a9qrRyacz�_/[&s�V9� #Ld8[gb,X:VebYw�TW[;Q�ac�9VZsWOq,\8asW�)s�TWV`Q sWVezUf?qr[gd&T,acRjd�V`XHw�(Vpd�V`V`XZT}[��([9bW���7RUTW\�aSQS[:X:V`z*�7\�Ryq,\�Rjs�qeac_/acP�zjV[cfDQS[)X�VezjRUd�n�_�[9sWVg�f#Ld�zjRUn9\9T7[gf�T}\�V^ac_�_zURyqeacTWRj[gdZ[gdZVr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gdkbWVYqr[gn9d�RUTWRj[gdX:VYsWqebWRjP/VYXSRUdST}\�V�zyags�T(sWV`q�T}RU[9d�w&R¡T1Rys?d/aBTWOb}agz:TW[^Ve£:_/VYq�T1T}\aBT(�(V�QS[:X:V`z_�[9sWV�7RUTW\pT}\�V1_�RU£:Vez&�*��� X�V`s}qrb}RUP�V`X�Rjd�hiVe�)QSVebDacdXp��[9ngngRj[ � x ���D«�[B�iVeo9VebYw`sWOq,\a5Q�[:X:V`z-\ags�sWVeogV`b}agz�X�b}a��7Pa9q,�:se� *�d�TW\V�[9d�V�\acdX�w&RUT7Rjs�o9Veb}��X:R X�qeO�z¡T�T}[qr[9ds�TWb}Oq�TSs�RjdqrVkV`s�T}agP�zURysW\�RUdn�qr[9bWb}V`sW_�[gdX:V`dqrVYspP�VrT��iVeVed<_�RU£)V`z(RjQ�acn9V`s5[cff�agqeV`s7RjdmX:R ��V`bWV`d9T�_/[&s�VpRys7_�b}[gd�V�T}[�Veb}bW[9b}s`� t T7T}\�V�s}acQSV�TWRjQSVgwRUT#Rys�f�acRjb}zU�[gP)o)Rj[gOs�T}\aBT �iV�X:[ d[cT d�V`V`X�a qe[gQS_�zjVr£<_R¡£:Vez��*��� T}[�QS[)X�Vez#_�[9sWVg�� V�sWO�n9ngV`s�Tia�Q5Oq,\ksWRUQS_�zjVebYw�~&OaczjRUT}aBT}RUo9V�QS[:X:V`z�P/agsWV`Xk[gdka5zjRUd�VpX:b,a��7Rjd�n

Page 52: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� RUn9O�b}V % � (�© t zURjd�V^X:b,a��7RUdn������ bWV`_�bWVYs�V`d&TWRjd�n�T}\�Vp_�[9sWV�sW_a9qrVg�

�*����� � V#Ve£:_/VYq�T1T}\aBTiRUd Q�[&s�TiqeagsWV`s1�7\�Veb}V�_�[9sWV�Rjd:f{[gb}Q�aBTWRj[gd�Rys(d�VeVYX:V`XHwsWOq,\ZaS~&OagzURUT}acTWRjogV�QS[)X�Vez�Rys7s�O6X�qeRUV`d&T`�� � � ��� ����6����*�&�*�('����#3 ���1�&�����)����3�� C ���#� � ���H�8����3 C � �t ��Rjd�V7]#b,a��7Rjd�n������ Rjs�a�sW_/VYqrRyacz:qea9s�V�[cf/TW\�V7����� X�V`s}qrb}RUP�V`X5RUdSsWV`q�T}RU[9du�� ! � #Ld<amzjRUdVZX:b,a��7Rjd�n��*��� wD[9d�zj��T}\�V �/[B� sW_a9qrV Ve£:Rjs�T}s`wDTW\�VkTWVe£&T}O�b}VsW_agqeV(Rys�a�s�Rjd�ngzjVi_/[9RUd&T`w9R¤� Vg��TW\Veb}ViRys ��Os�T?[gd�ViT}Vr£)TWO�b}V��7\�Ryq,\5n9VrT}sDQS[gb}_�\�VYXTW[�_�bW[:X:O/qrV X:R �-Veb}Ved&T5sW\ac_�V`s`� t zjRUd�VkX:b}a��7Rjd�n������ �7\�Ryq,\�Q�[:X:V`zjs^TW\�V_�[9sWV�[cf�aZf�agqeV�Rys�sW\�[B�7d�RUd � RjngO�b}V % � (�� � \�VZ�*��� \/agspT��i[�X:V`ngb}VeV`s^[cff{b}VeV`X�[gQ�w�[gd�V bWV`_�bWVYs�V`d&TWRjd�nmTW\VkzjVrf§TW��b}RUn9\&T5_�[9sWV oBacb}RjacTWRj[gd agdX;TW\V [cT}\�VebTW\V�O�_:�LX:[B�7dS_/[&s�V7oBagbWRyaBT}RU[9d�� � V#sW\aczjzqeagzUz�TW\�Rys1������agsDT}\�V�_�[9sWVr�L�*�����

� � � � � � ��'�!/"#���#3 � #3?�-��� ��6�� ':�4� �Z�(�9�H� C � �«�[B�¢qeacd �(V�OsWV#T}\�V�_/[&s�Ve��������T}[5VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}V#T}\�V�_/[&s�V�[cfDa^f�a9qrV � *�d TW\�Vf�agqeV�[cf�RUT`wR¡T#X:[)VYs�d�[cT�sWVeVeQ ogVeb}��zjRU�9Vezj� s�RjdqeV�T}\�Vp_�[9sWVr�L�*��� Rjs�Q�agX�V�O_[cf�s�RjQS_�zjVpzURjd�VpX:b,a��7RUd�n&si�7\�Veb}V`a9s1T}\�V�f�agqeVps�\�[B��s�O_Za9s7a5b}Ryq,\�zU��TWVr£)T}O�bWVYXRjQSagngV9��hiO:T#a9s7s�\[B�7dkP)� �9[gd�VYs�acdX���[gn9ngRj[�� x ����w�RUT�Rjs�_�[9s}sWRUP�zjV�TW[SQ�aBT,q,\TW\V1zjRUd�ViX:b,a��7RUd�n�������s�TW[#d[BogVez9acdX^X�Rjs�TW[9b�T}V`X�zjRUd�ViX:b,a��7RUd�n&se� � V(Vr£)TWV`dXTW\Rjs*f{O�bWTW\�V`b�agdX^sW\�[B��TW\acTDRUT�RysD_/[&sWsWRjP�zUV?TW[�QSacT}q,\pT}\�V1_�[9sWVr�L�*��� TW[�V`X:n9VQ�ac_s�[gf?f�agqeV5RjQ�acngVYse� � \�V�Q�aBT,q,\�RUdnZagzUn9[gb}R¡T}\�QGRjs�TW\VSs}acQSV�ags�TW\�V�[gdVOsWV`X�f{[gb5Q�aBT}q,\RUd�n�T}\�V s�T}agdX�acb,X;�*��� Ve£�qrVe_�TpTW\acT5s�RjdqeV�TW\�V`bWV�agbWV�d[

Page 53: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

��a&� ��P/� ��q`�

� RUn9O�b}V % � & ©���a&� � agqeV�RUQ�acn9Vgw*��P/��liacdd&�kV`X:n9V�QSag_macdX;��qY��hizUO�b}b}V`XkV`X:n9VQ�ac_��

TWVe£)TWO�b}V�_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s�T}[�[9_:TWRjQSRU¨`V�[BogV`b`wgTW\�V�aczjng[gb}RUTW\�Q4RUd)og[9zUo9V`s�[9_:TWRjQSRU¨`RUdn[gdzU��[Bo9VebiTW\V �[B�¢agdXka�X�d�V�_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s��§f{[gb�X:VrT,acRjzjs7sWVeV � x + �{���� \�V5f�agqrV�RjQSagngV�Rjs�b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}V`X�a9s�akV`X:n9Vr��Q�ac_�OsWRjd�nZa�liacd�d)�mVYX:ngVe�

X:VeTWV`qrTW[9b � ! v���acdX�P�zjO�b}bWVYX�OsWRUd�n<a W acOs}sWRjagd<|/z¡T}Veb�� � RUn9O�bWV % � & ��� � \VP�zjO�b}bWVYX RjQ�acngV�Rys7Q�aBT,q,\�V`X TW[ST}\�Vp_/[&s�Ve������� Os�Rjd�n�TW\V�N W ]@agzUn9[gb}R¡T}\�Q��� \�V^Q�acT}q,\�Rjd�n�Rjd)og[gzjogVYs7[g_�TWRjQ�Rj¨`acTWRj[gdm[Bo9Veb ��_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s���x�_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,sb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&TWRjd�nST}\�V�x�X�Vengb}VeVYs7[cf�f{b}VeVYX:[gQ>[cf�T}\�V�_�[9sWVr�L�*����agdX & _agb}agQ��VrT}Veb,s�f{[gb�a�X�d�V�TWb,acds�f{[gb}Q�aBTWRj[gd/se� #Ld � RUn9O�b}V % � + �iV�s�\[B� TW\V�bWVYs�O�zUT}s^[cfQ�aBT,q,\�RUdn^f�agqeV#RjQ�acngVYs?T}[^T}\�V�_�[9sWVr�L�*����� t s(Rjsi[gP)o)Rj[gOs?f{bW[9Q4T}\�V�bWVYs�O�zUT}sTW\V�Q�aBT}q,\RUd�npRys?d[cT(agzU��a��:s�agqeqeO�b,aBTWV9� � \�Rys?Rys�Q�acRjd�zj��X�O�V7TW[^T��([pb}V`a9s�[9ds� ! �?N W ]%aczjng[9bWRUTW\�Q4ngVeT}s�T}b}ag_�_�V`XSRjd�zU[:q`aczQSRjd�RjQSa^[gbix9� � \�V�VYX:ngV�X:VrT}V`q��TW[9b�[gO:T}_�O:T^Rys�VeRUTW\�V`bpogVeb}�md�[9RjsW��[gb�QSRysWsWV`spqebWOqeRjagz�V`X:n9V`s`� #Ld�ngV`d�Veb,acz��iVf{[gOdX�TW\acT�Rjd�acP�[gO:T�xY(�TW\VSq`agsWV`s`wHTW\Veb}V�RyspaZo)RjsWRUPzUV�QSRys�Q�aBT,q,\�P�VrT��iVeV`dTW\Vp_/[&s�V�[cfDTW\V�f�agqrVpagdX�T}\aBT�[gf�T}\�Vp_�[9sWVr�L�*��� bWV`_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd��

� � � ��� C ������#�W��3 '�"�� ���D���� �H':���/���?+�'�"#� ���1�&�-� C � �N)RjdqrViRUT�Rys�_�[9s}s�RjP�zjV1T}[�VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}ViTW\�V�_�[9sWV(Rjd�a�Q�a���[9bWRUT���[cf�q`agsWV`s�P)�pQSacT}q,\:�Rjd�n T}\�V�_/[&s�Ve��������T}[Za P�zUObWb}V`X�V`X:n9Vr��QSag_�[cf1TW\�V�f�agqeVgw-T}\�V5d/aBTWOb}agz�Ve£&�TWV`dsWRU[9d��([9O�zyX�P/V5TW[ZagsW�kRUf�TW\�V�b}VezyaBTWRj[gd/s�\�Rj_mP�VrT��iVeVed�_�R¡£:V`z¡��PagsWV`X�b}Ve_bWVe�sWVed&T}acTWRj[gdm[cf�f�a9qrVYs#acd/X�TW\�V5_/[&s�Ve��������qeagd�P�V�zjV`acb}d&T`� � V�qe[gzjzUVYq�T}V`XmuY( &f�agqeV�RjQSagngVYs�f{bW[9Q T}\�V � V " V � X�acT}acP/agsWV� u + �i[gf�X:R �-Veb}Ved&T�_/V`b}sW[gds^�7R¡T}\oBacb}RU[9Os�_�[9sWV`s�agdX�RUd X�R �-Veb}Ved&T5agdX;O�d��)d�[B�7d;zjRUn9\9T}RUdn�qr[9dX:RUTWRj[gds`� � \VP�zjO�b}bWVYX;V`X:n9Vr��QSag_�[cf7T}\�V`sWV RjQ�acngVYs^��ags�QSacT}q,\�VYX;TW[�TW\�Vk_/[&s�Ve������� agsVr£:_�zyacRjd�VYXmRUd�TW\�V5zja9s�T�s�VYq�T}RU[9d�� t sWV`q�T}RU[9d�[cf1TW\�Rys#��ags�qr[9dsWRjX:V`bWVYXZf{[gb�OsWVags�T}b}agRUd�Rjd�n�Vr£�acQS_�zjV`s`��«�[B�iVeogV`b��iVi|b,s�T�_�b}O�d�ViTW\�V�sWVrT�P)�^b}VeQS[Bo)RUdn�TW\[9sWVRjQSagngVYs�f{[gb��7\�Rjq,\�T}\�V�N W ]4agzUn9[gb}R¡T}\�Q>X�[&VYs�d�[gT#ngRjogV5agqeqeVe_:T,acP�zjVpb}V`sWO�z¡T,se�� \�Rys�_�bW[:qeV`X:O�b}V^n&a�ogV�O/s�a TWb,acRjd�Rjd�nksWVrT�[cfixgugu�RjQ�acn9V`s`� � \V5_�RU£:VezU��P/agsWV`Xb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd�Rys7zjRU�9Vezj��TW[SRjd)og[gzjogV�_�RU£:Vezys�[gb7��a�ogVezjVrT,se� � VpVr£:_/V`bWRjQSVed&TWVYX�7RUTW\�qe[9agb}sWVpbWVYs�[9zUO�TWRj[gdm_�RU£:VezDbWV`_�bWVYs�V`d&T}aBT}RU[9ds`� � V5|b,s�T�s�OP:TWb,agqrT�a�P�V`s�T��|�T#PbWRjng\&TWdV`s}s�_�zjagd�V�f{b}[gQ T}\�V^_�RU£:Vez�o�agzUOV`s7[gf�T}\�Vpf�agqeVpRUQ�agngV`s7TW[�qr[9bWb}V`qrT

Page 54: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

��a&� �{P�� ��qY� �¤X� ��a9� �{P/� ��q`� ��X�

� RUn9O�b}V % � + © " VYs�Oz¡T,s([gf�Q�aBT,q,\�Rjd�n�[gf*TW\V�_�[9sWVr�L�*��� TW[�d�[BogV`z�f�agqrV�RjQSagngVYsOsWRUdnmN W ]��i��a9� � agqeV�RjQ�acn9Vgw1��P/�phizUObWb}V`X�liacd�d)��VYX:ngVSQ�ac_*w(��qY����aBT,q,\[gP�T}acRjd�VYX�P)��TW\�VZN W ] agzUn9[gb}R¡T}\�Q agdX���X����aBT,q,\;acf§TWV`b�b}VeQS[Bo)RUd�nma�XSdV_agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s`�

Page 55: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

f{[gbpzjRjng\&TWRjd�n�oBacb}RjacTWRj[gds`� � \�VSf�agqeV�RjQ�acn9V`s�[cf�s�Rj¨eV ! vgvkP)� ! xY( �iVeb}V5TW\�V`db}V`X:OqeV`X�TW[kaZsWRU¨`V5[gf � P)� ! v�� � \�V�bWVYs�O�zUTWRjd�n �gvkqr[)V�X�qrRjVed&T,s#f{[9bWQSVYX�TW\�VRjd�_�O:T7f{[9b�TW\�VpzjV`agbWd�Rjd�nS_�b}[gP�zjVeQ��

� � � ��� ���*�)A��L'������# � �W�)!HA#�)�)���1�� \�V5zUVYacb}d�RUdn�RUd)o9[gzjogV`s�[gP:T,acRjd�RUdnka�Q�ag_mf{bW[9Q>TW\�V �gv�X:RjQSVedsWRj[gdagz�Rjd�_�O:TTW[�TW\�V5[gO:T}_�O:T�R�� Vg��TW\VpT��([ _/[&s�V�X�RUQSVed/s�Rj[gds`� � [9b�zjV`acb}d�Rjd�nw/�(V�Os�VYXZTW\�Vf�acQSRjzURyacb�TWVYq,\�d�Ry~&O�V5[gf(N)¥�� b}Vengb}V`s}sWRU[9d�agzU[9d�n��7RUTW\�TW\�V W acO/sWsWRjagd��gV`bWdVez��� \�V f{bWV`V _agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s�[cf7TW\Rjs�_�b}[gP�zjVeQ¦�iVeb}V sWVrTSP&�;\agdXHw�RUT���ags^f{[gO�d/XTW\/aBT^T}\�V b}V`sWO�zUT}s^agbWV�d�[gT�_agb�T}RjqeO�zjagbWzj��sWVed/s�RUTWRjogVST}[mTW\�V f{bWV`V�_acb,acQSVeTWVeb,s`w[BogV`b�a��7RyX:VZb}agd�ngV [cf�T}\�Vk_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,se� � \Vkb}V`sWO�zUT}acd&T�QSag_ ��agspT}V`s�TWVYX[gdZa5TWV`s�T�s�VeT7[cf ! xcu5RUQ�agngV`s`w)�7\�Ryq,\kRjdqrzjOX:VYX RjQ�acn9V`si[cf�f�agqrVYs��7\�Ryq,\k�iVeb}V_�b}V`sWVed&T(Rjd�T}\�V�TWb,acRjd�Rjd�n5sWVrTYw:P�O:T�RUd�a�X:R �-Veb}Ved&Ti_�[9sWV�acdXkaczys�[�f�agqrV�RjQSagngVYs�7\�Ryq,\m�(V`bWV�d�[cT#_bWVYs�V`d9T�RUdmT}\�V^T}b}agRUdRUd�nks�VeT�aBT�aczjz¤� #Ld � Rjn9s`� % � ��acd/X % � U�iV�_�b}V`sWVed&T�Ve£�acQS_�zjV`s�[cf�T}\�VSbWVYs�O�zUT}s�[cf1TWV`s�TWRjd�nZ[gdmT}\�V5T��([k�&RjdX�s�[gf?f�agqeVRjQSagngVYs(b}V`sW_�V`q�T}RUo9Vezj�g�� \�V�bWVYs�Oz¡T,sSRUd8_/[&s�V�VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}RU[9d8sW[�f�acb�acb}VZogVeb}��Ved/qr[gOb}agngRjd�n� � \V

QS[9s�T5d�[gTWV`�([9b�T}\&��_agb�T�[cf�T}\�Rjs�QSVrT}\�[:X Rys�RUT}sSsWRUQS_�zjRyqrRUT�� aBT�sWVeo9Veb,acz(zUV`o9�Vezys`��hi[gTW\ZTW\�V�T}[g_:�LX:[B�7d�acdXkP�[cT�T}[gQ���O�_�bWV`_�bWVYs�V`d&T}aBT}RU[9ds�acb}V�sWRjQ�_zUV^agdXs�TWb,acRjng\&T�f{[9bW��acb,X5��TW\�V�_�[9sWVr�L�*��� RUdZqeagsWV�[cf*T}\�V�TW[g_���X:[B�7dZacdXkzj[B�JbWVYs�[g�zjO:TWRj[gd�_R¡£:VezysiRUdkqeagsWV#[gfHTW\�V�P�[cT�T}[gQ���O�_�� � Ob�T}\�Veb}QS[gb}Vgw&�(V�\a�ogV�Q�agdacn9V`XTW[pn9VrT�T}\�V`sWV�b}V`sWO�z¡T,s��7RUTW\�apsWO�bW_bWRys�Rjd�n9zU��sWQ�aczjz�d)O�Q�P�Veb([cf-Vr£�acQS_�zjV`s`� � \�RjsQSVrT}\�[:XSRjs?q`ac_agP�zjVi[gf�agX�X:b}V`s}sWRUd�n�T}\�V�T��([pQ�agRUdSRysWsWO�V`s?b}agRjsWV`X5P)�^TW\V��([9bW�[cf�N:\�Veb}b}ag\�VrTSacz�� � xS( ��dagQ�V`zU��T}\aBTS[cf#amVe£)TWVed/s�RjogVZX�aBT,acPa9s�V�[gf�zjagP/V`zUVYXf�agqeRjagz�_�[9sWV�acdX<TW\/aBT [gf�T}\�VeRjb�_�[9sWV�s�RjQSRUzyacb}RUT��<sW_agqeVmP/V`RUd�n<X:Rjs}qr[9d&TWRjd&O��[gO/s�qebWVYaBTWRjd�n a zU[B�iVeb#P/[9O�dX�[9dmTW\V5_�[9sWV�b}V`sW[gzjO:TWRj[gdm_�[9s}sWRUP�zjVg�pN)RjdqrV�TW\�V_�[9sWVr�L�*����Rys7a�qe[gd&TWRjd)O�[gO/sisW_a9qrVgw&T}\�V�_bW[9P�zUV`QE[cf�a5zj[B�(V`b(P�[gO�d/X�[gd TW\�Vb}V`sW[gzjO:TWRj[gd�Rys�bWO�zjV`X [gO:TY� � \Vk_�VebWf{[gb}Q�acdqeV X:Ve_�Ved/X�s�[gd T}\�VZd&OQ�P�Veb�[cfVr£�agQ�_zUVYs7acdX TW\�VpRjd�_�O�T�bWV`_�bWVYs�V`d&T}aBT}RU[9d��N)Veo9Veb,acz?_�[9s}sWRUP�RjzjR¡T}RUVYs�d�V`V`X�T}[�P�V�RUd)o9V`s�TWRjn9aBT}V`X;P�Vrf{[9bWV��iV q`acd�\a�o9V�a

P�VrT�T}Veb�_�Ryq�T}O�b}VZ[gf#T}\�V�s�T}bWV`d�ncT}\sSacdX<�iV`ac�)d�VYsWsWV`s5[cf�TW\�Rys�ac__�bW[&agq,\��F#Ld_agb�T}RjqeO�zjagb`w9TW\V�oBagbWRyacP�RjzjR¡T��S[cf�TW\�RysiQSVrTW\[)Xk�7RUTW\kTW\�V�d)O�Q�P�Veb�[gf*Vr£�acQS_�zjV`sacd/XkQS[9bWV�RjQ�_�[gbWT}agd&TWzj���7R¡T}\�TW\�VpRjd�_�O�T#bWV`_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd�� t ��a�ogV`zUVeTiPa9s�VYXb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gdmQSRjng\&T�TWO�b}d�[9O:T�TW[ZP/V�sWO�_/V`bWRj[gb�TW[Zzj[B� bWVYs�[9zUO�TWRj[gd�_�RU£:Vezyse�N)RjQSRUzyacb}zU�9w)�7R¡T}\kRjdqrb}V`a9s�V�Rjd T}\�V�d&OQ�P�Veb�[cfDVr£�acQS_�zjV`s(TW\V�d)O�Q5P/V`b�[cfDsWO�_:�_�[gbWTio9V`q�T}[gb,s1QSRjng\&T7RUd/qrb}V`agsWV��7\�Rjq,\kQSRUn9\9T7Q�ac�9V�RUT�X:R X�qeO�zUTiT}[�ac_�_�zj��T}\�RjsQSVrT}\�[:X f{[9b7bWVYaczU�¤T}RUQSVpac__�zURyqeacTWRj[gds`�

Page 56: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

��a9� �{P�� �¤q`� �¤a9� �{P/� ��qY�

� RUn9O�b}V % � ��© " V`sWO�zUT}s5[cf7V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWRjd�n�TW\�Vk_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s�[cf#am_�[9sWVr�L�*��� X:R¡�b}V`q�T}zU��f{bW[9Q@T}\�V#RjQ�acn9Vg� � \�V`sWV7f�agqeV`s��iVeb}V#agzjsW[p_�b}V`sWVed&T?RUd�TW\�V7T}b}agRUdRUd�n5s�VeTP�O:Ti�7R¡T}\ X:R ��V`bWV`d&T(_�[9sWV`s`���¤a9� � agqeV�RjQSagngV9w���P/�?��[&s�V7VYs�T}RUQ�aBT}RU[9d�OsWRUdnpTW\�VN W ] agzUn9[gb}R¡T}\�Q agdX��¤q`����[&s�V�V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWRj[gdZOsWRUdn N)¥�� b}Vengb}V`s}sWRU[9d��

Page 57: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� RUn9O�b}V % � U © " V`sWO�zUT}s5[cf7V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWRjd�n�TW\�Vk_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s�[cf#am_�[9sWVr�L�*��� X:R¡�b}V`q�T}zU��f{b}[gQ T}\�V�RjQ�acn9Vg� � \�V`sWV#f�a9qrVYs1�iVeb}V#d�[gTi_bWVYs�V`d9TiRUd TW\�V�T}b}agRUd�Rjd�n�s�VeTaBT�agzUz��

Page 58: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� RjngO�b}V % � ! v�©f#LQ�acn9V`si[cf�o)RjsWVeQSVYs7acdX TW\�V`RUb�qrzyags}se�� ��� � �%�(�.1.��� �%����1�� ���$>���� �]3¶�%�A� � ��� ���=�A���%�" VYqrVed&T}zU��hizyacd�¨ � %Y& ��acdX V X��iagb}X�skVrT�agz¤� � x ! ��\a�o9V��i[gb}�gVYX�[gd%OsWRUdnQ�aBT,q,\�RUdnk�*��� _agb}agQ�VeTWV`b}s�f{[gb�\�RUn9\�Veb�zjVeogV`z�RjQ�acn9V5acd/aczj�)sWRys��{[9b�o)Rys�Rj[gd��ac__�zURyqeacTWRj[gds�sWOq,\�ags(f�agqeV�RyX:V`d9T}R¡|�qeaBT}RU[9dZagdXZs�\�[B�7dkVedqe[gO�b,acn9RUdn�b}V`sWO�z¡T,se�#Ld5TW\�VYs�V7ac__�zURyqeacTWRj[gdsDT}\�V7�*��� _agb}agQ�VeTWV`b�a9q�T,s�ags�acd�RUQ�agngVif{V`acTWO�b}ViTW\acTRys�TW\Ved�OsWV`X�T}[5qe[gb}bWVYq�TWzj�5qezja9sWsWRUf{�^TW\V#RjQSagngV9� � \�V�qrzyacRjQ@T}\�Veb}Vrf{[9bWV7Rys1TW\acT�*��� _/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,s�acb}ViP�VrTWTWV`b�f{V`acTWO�b}V`s�T}\acd�T}\�V�d�[9bWQ�aczjzj��ags}s�OQ�VYX�RUQ�acn9Vf{V`acTWO�b}V`s5s�O/q,\ ags^_R¡£:Vezys^[9b���a�ogV`zUVeT}s`�;�¤s�V`VksWV`qrTWRj[gd ! � u�agdX � RUn9O�bWV ! � xg���#LdZ[gb,X:Veb�T}[5T}V`s�T7TW\�Rys�qezjagRUQ�w:�iV�Rjd&TWb}[:X:OqrVp[9d�Vps�O/q,\Zag_�_�zjRjq`aBTWRj[gd*w:dacQSVezj�gwo)RjsWVeQSV�b}V`qr[9ngd�RUTWRj[gd*�¥#Rys�V`QSV`s�agbWVST}\�V o)Rys�O/acz(agdaczj[gn9O�V`s�[gf7_�\�[gdVeQSV`sk� V ¨`¨`acT�acdX���[9ngngRj[� %<! �{����«#[B�(V`ogV`b`w�TW\V�Q�ag_�_�Rjd�n f{b}[gQ�_\�[gd�V`QSV`s�TW[Zo)RjsWVeQSV`s�Rys�a Q�acd)��T}[

[gdV Q�ac_�_RUd�n/��]#R ��V`bWV`d&T�_�\[gd�V`Q�VYsSqeacd�zUVYagX�T}[�a�s�Rjd�n9zUVkQ�[9O:TW\8s�\/ac_�Vacd/X�TW\)OsiT}[�a5sWRUdngzjV�o)Rys�V`QSVg��¥#Rys�V`QSV`s�zjRU�9V�_�\[gd�V`Q�VYsi\a�ogV�TWV`Q�_�[gb,acz-Ve£&�TWV`d&T`��«�[B�iVeogV`b`wBsW[#f�agb��(V�\a�o9V1Rjd&o9V`s�TWRjn9acTWV`X�o)RjsWVeQSVibWVYqr[gn9d�RUTWRj[gd5a9sWsWO�QSRjd�no)RjsWVeQSVYs�TW[5P/V�s�T,aBT}Rjq7RjQ�acn9V`s`� � \)Os(�(V�qr[gd/s�RyX:Veb1TW\�V�_�b}[gP�zjVeQ [cf�Q�ac__�RUdnRjdX:Rjo&RyX:OagzHRUQ�agngV`siT}[�o)RjsWVeQSVpqrzyags}s�VYse�

� ��� ��� �������W�#���#3 � �D':�� V�O/s�VYX�T}\�VSo)RjsWOacz?sW_�VeV`q,\;qr[9bW_OspX:V`s}qrb}RjP/VYX�Rjd V ¨e¨YaBT^acdX���[gn9ngRj[ � %<! �f{[gb1TW\�V�o)RjsWVeQSV#b}V`qe[gn9d�R¡T}RU[9dS_�bW[9P�zjVeQ��f#Ld�TW\�Rysiqr[gb}_�Os`w9u U _�\�[9d�VeQSV�qrzyags}s�VYs�7\�Ryq,\mQ�ac_s�TW[ ! (So)RjsWVeQSV�qezja9sWsWV`s�\a�ogV^P�VeV`d�RyX:Ved&TWRU|VYXH�#«�[B�iVeo9VebYw:TW\Veb}V��ags�sWO2X�qrRjVed&TSX�aBT,a�TW[�TWb,acRjd;f{[gb�[gd�zj��sWRU£;o)Rys�V`QSV`s�qezja9sWsWV`s ��u�qe[gdsW[gd/acd&Tqrzyags}sWV`s�acdXZu�og[B�iVezHqrzyags}sWV`s,��� � \�[9sWV�s�RU£Zqezja9sWsWV`s�acb}V � _�PQ � w � T}X�sW¨ � w � �)ngd�z � w� RUR � w � V`a � w � agag[ � agdX�a�_�b}[cT}[cT��)_�RyqeaczRUQ�acn9V7[cfHV`a9q,\�qrzyags}s�Rjs(s�\[B�7d�Rjd � RUn9O�b}V% � ! v� ]#VeT}agRUzysSacP�[gO:T�TW\�VYs�Vmqezja9sWsWV`s�acdX TW\�V`RUb�sWRU¨`V`sSacb}VZngRjogVed<acb}Vkn9RUo9VedRjd � agP�zjV % � ! � � \�V5TWb,acRjd�Rjd�n acd/XmTWVYs�T}RUdnksWVrT}s��iVeb}V�[gP�T}acRjd�VYXmP)��X�RUo)RyX:RUdnTW\V`sWV�sWVrT,s7b}[gO�n9\�zU��RjdZTW\�Vpb,aBT}RU[�[cf?x:© ! �

Page 59: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

���������� ������� ���������� ������� �������� �������������� "!�#��%$&�(')��*+�(,���������(�.-��$�� �0/�$0/�� ������.����� ��/��1/���/��2/����0/���� �����2��� �2�3/4� ������ ���"/�� ������ ��/4� �� 536 ��� 5 / 6 /��0/��"/4� 6 /�7 ����

� acP�zjV % � ! © � \�V�o&RysWVeQSV5qezja9sWsWV`s�acdX�TW\�V`RUbpags}sW[)qeRjacTWVYX�_�\�[gdVeQSV`s�acd/X�TW\�VsWRU¨`V�[gf�T}\�V�TWb,acRjd�Rjd�nSacdXkTWVYs�T}RUdnSsWVrT,se�

� ��� � � $&� 6������4���1':�D'����1� � �H':�����W�� �i[<X:R ��V`bWV`d&Tkf{VYaBTWObWV�bWV`_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gds �(V`bWV�RUd)ogVYs�T}RUn&aBT}V`XJagsZRjd�_�O:TZf{[gbqrzyags}sWR¡|/q`aBT}RU[9d�w�dagQ�V`zU�9w��a�ogV`zUVeT}s7acd/Xm�*���¦_agb}agQSVrTWV`b}s`� � \VpT��([�b}Ve_bWVe�sWVed&T}acTWRj[gds*zUVYagX�T}[�sW[gQSVe�7\acT�X:R ��V`bWV`d&T�ag_�_�b}[9agq,\V`s-f{[9b*o)RjsWVeQSV(bWVYqr[gn9d�RUTWRj[gdacd/X�T}\�VpRjX�V`a�RjsiT}[�qr[gQS_agbWV�TW\VpbWV`zjacTWRjogV�Q�V`bWRUT}s�[gf*T}\�V`sWV�T��([Sac__�bW[&agq,\�VYsacd/X�T}\�Veb}Vrf{[9bWV�TW\V�T��([Sb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gds`�

� � 069'. �08:9 0602� � 0 � .1A3.i� > .i:;��.19'.i���'02�������<; � \�Rys�QSVrT}\�[:X O:T}R¡�zjRj¨eV`s�agd�RjQSagngVe��Pa9s�VYX�bWV`_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd^Rjd��7\�Ryq,\5a�zjRUd�VYacb��{Q5O�z¡T}R¡�Lqrzyags}s,�N:¥�� qezja9sWsWRU|Veb^��ags^TWb,acRjd�V`X�TW[�a9qeqeVe_:T���a�ogV`zUVeT5qr[)V�X�qeRUV`d&T}s5[cf�TW\�VQS[9O:TW\SRjQSagngV�ags�Rjd�_�O:T1agdX�TW[�[gO:T}_�O:T�TW\V7o&RysWVeQSV7qrzyags}se� � \�V�RUd�_O:T}s�iVeb}VpX:VrT}Veb}QSRUd�VYX�P)�ksWVezjV`q�T}RUdn5T��iVezjogVpzj[B��b}V`sW[gzjO:T}RU[9dZ«�agacb7��a�ogV`zUVeTqe[)V�X�qrRjVed&T}s�O/s�Rjd�nSTW\VpQ�VeTW\�[:X�X:VYsWqebWRjP/VYX Rjdms�VYq�T}RU[9dZu� x�� ! �

� � 069'.\,+8Q-/c c >@.i:;��.19�.1���'02�������<; � \�Rys*QSVrT}\�[:X^b}VezjRUVYs�[9d�a#�����a9s�agd�Rjd&TWV`bWQSV`X�RjacTWV�b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T,aBTWRj[gd*� � [gbpT}\�Rjs�_�O�b}_/[&s�V9w U6! RjQSagngVYsf{b}[gQ TW\�Vmqr[9bW_Os��iVeb}VZOs�VYX T}[�qe[gds�TWb}OqrTSa�s�Rjd�n9zUV�_�Veb,s�[9d�QS[gO:T}\����� agdXSTW\V#QS[:X:Vez��ia9s�Q�aBT,q,\�V`XST}[^T}\�V#b}VeQ�acRjd�Rjd�npRjQSagngVYs?OsWRUdnT}\�VmN W ]Gaczjng[gb}RUTW\�Q�� � \�V TW[9_ _�b}RUdqeRU_/acz(qe[gQS_�[gd�V`d9T,s�[gf7TW\�V �[B�agdX�TWVe£)TWO�b}V sW_agqeV`sp�iVeb}V�d�[B� OsWV`X�ags�a�f{V`acTWO�b}V sWVrT^T}[�bWV`_�b}V`sWVed&TVYagq,\mRjQ�acngV9� t zjRUd�VYacb��{Q�Oz¡T}R¡�Lqrzyags}s}�#N)¥�� qezja9sWsWRU|Veb���ags7TWb,acRjd�V`XZT}[a9qeqeVe_:T�T}\�V�Q�aBT,q,\�Rjd�n��*��� _acb,acQSVrT}Veb,sS[cf�TW\V�QS[gO:T}\JRUQ�agngV�agsRjd�_�O�T�acdX TW[�[9O:TW_O:T7TW\�Vpo)Rys�V`QSV�qezja9sWs`�

N)RjdqrV�TW\�RyskRjsZa�Q�Oz¡T}R¡�Lqrzyags}s�_�b}[gPzUV`QZw#�(V�\/a�ogV�Ve£)_�Veb}RjQ�V`d&TWV`X��7R¡T}\JTW\�VTW[9_:�LX:[B�7d8X�V`qrRysWRU[9d8n9b}ag_�\�� � RUn/� % � !Y! w(sWVeV �ac�Ba���RjQ�a�w�VrT agz¤� � � �§��a9s�TW\�VQ�Oz¡T}R¡�Lqrzyags}s�s�TWb,aBT}Ven9�g� � \�Rys�s�T}b}acTWVen9��RUd)og[9zUo9V`s#TW\�V5TWb,acRjd�Rjd�nZ[cf(aZqrzyags}s�RU|V`bTW[5X:Rjs�TWRjd�n9O�RjsW\�P�VrT��iVeVed�agd)�^T��i[po&RysWVeQSV`s`wgVYagq,\�[cf-�7\�Ryq,\�Rjs(apzjRUd�VYacb(N:¥����� V1\a�o9V1qr[9Q�_/acb}V`X�TW\V(_�VebWf{[gb}Q�acdqeV?[cf:T}\�Rjs�T}V`q,\�d�Ry~&O�V1�7RUTW\�TW\�V(�&��d�VYacb}V`s�Td�V`RUn9\&P�[gb,s(TWVYq,\�d�Ry~9OVg�

Page 60: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� RUn9O�b}V % � !S! © W b}ag_�\�Ryqeagz�bWV`_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gdS[cf-TW\V7TW[9_:��X�[B�7d�Q�O�zUTWRU��qezja9sWs1qrzyags��sWR¡|/q`aBT}RU[9dZs�TWb,aBT}Veng�9� V agq,\Zd�[gd���zjV`acf�d�[:X:V�b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}s�a�qezja9sWsWR¡|/VebY�

� ��� ��� ���*�)A��L'������# � �W�)!HA#�)�)���1�� \�V�bWVYs�Oz¡T,s1[gf*o)RjsWVeQSV#b}V`qe[gn9d�R¡T}RU[9d�oBacb}�S�7R¡T}\�TW\V�X:RjQSVedsWRj[gd [gf�TW\V�Rjd�_�O:Tb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd�� � V��9Ve_:T�T}\�VpRUd_�O:T#X:RjQSVedsWRU[9d f{[9b�TW\�Vp��a�ogV`zUVeT(b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed��T}acTWRj[gdmqr[9ds�T}acd&T#acT ! x�acdX�oBagbWRjV`X TW\acT#[cfDTW\V��*���¦b}Ve_bWVYs�V`d9T,aBT}RU[9d�� � Vf{[gOdXkTW\acT�ags7zj[gdnSa9s�TW\VpRUd�_O:T�X:RjQSVedsWRj[gd��ia9s�zUVYsWs7TW\agd ! x:w:T}\�V������b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd OdX:VebW��_/V`b�f{[9bWQSV`X<qr[9Q�_/acb}V`X�T}[�TW\�V���a�ogVezjVrTSb}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}ac�TWRj[gd�acdX�n9a�ogV�T}\�VSsWagQ�V5bWVYs�Oz¡T��7\�Ved�TW\�V�RUd_�O:TpX:RUQSV`ds�Rj[gd��ia9s#P�b}[gOng\&TTW[ ! x:� � \�Rjs�_�bW[9PacPzU�<Q�VYacds�TW\acT�TW\�V�b}Ve_bWVYs�V`d9T,aBT}RU[9dacz7_�[B�(V`b�[cf�TW\�V�*��� Rjs�aczjQS[9s�T�RjX�Ved&TWRyqeagz?TW[�TW\acT5[cf���a�ogV`zUVeT}s`� � \�V�b}V`sWO�z¡T,s�qe[gQS_acb}Rjd�nTW\V5X:R ��V`bWV`d&T#bWV`_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gds�agdXmX:R ��V`bWV`d&T�Q�Oz¡T}R¡�Lqrzyags}s#s�TWb,aBT}VengRjV`s7f{[gb�agdRjd�_�O:T�X:RjQSVedsWRj[gd�[cf ! xZacb}V5_bWVYs�V`d9T}V`X�RUd � acP�zjV`s % � xZagdX % � u��N)RUd/qrV�TW\�VX�acT}a�s�VeT}s^agbWV�~&O�RUTWV�sWQ�aczjz¤w*TW\�V�b}V`sWO�zUT}s�_�b}V`sWVed&TWVYX�agbWV�a�o9Veb,acngVYs#[Bo9Veb ! v9vb,acdX:[9Q x:© ! s�_�zjRUT}s7[gf*TW\VpVr£�acQS_�zjV`s`�� \�V�RjX�V`a�[cfDOs�Rjd�n�TW\V�QS[9bW_�\/acP�zjV�Q�[:X:V`zH_acb,acQSVeTWVeb,s1f{[gb7\�Rjng\�V`b�zUV`ogVez

o)RjsWRj[gd�acdXZRjd9T}Veb}_�b}VrT}acTWRj[gdZRjs�n&acRjd�Rjd�nSngb}[gO�dX��?«�[B�iVeogV`b`w)[9O�b7bWVYs�Oz¡T,s��7R¡T}\o)RjsWVeQSV^b}V`qe[gn9d�R¡T}RU[9dms�V`VeQ TW[ksWVeV`Q T}[ qea9s�T�a�X:[gOP:T�[9d�TW\�V5O:TWRjzURUT���[cf�T}\�Rjsac__�bW[&agq,\�� *�O�b�_�bWV`o)RU[9Os�Vr£�acQS_�zjV`s^[cf�Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gd�bWVYqr[gn9d�RUTWRj[gd;acdX�_�[9sWVV`s�TWRjQ�aBT}RU[9d�sWVeV`QGTW[�RUd/X:Rjq`aBT}V5T}\�V�O:T}RUzjR¡T���[cf(O/s�Rjd�nZTW\�V������ _acb,acQSVrT}Veb,sags(T}\�Vp\�Rjng\�V`b���zUV`ogV`z/_agb}agQSVrTWV`b}s(T}[�P�V�V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWVYXH�?hiO:T�aBTWTWVeQS_:T}RUdnSTW[SOsWVTW\V`sWVi_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,sDa9sDf{V`acTWO�b}V`sDf{[9b�V`s�TWRjQSacTWRjd�nps�[9QSVi[gTW\�V`b�\�RUn9\�VebW��zUV`ogVez:q`aBT��Ven9[gb}RUVYs?X:[)V`s(d�[gTisWVeVeQ T}[5P�O�Sagd)�9T}\�Rjd�n5sWO�Ps�T}agd9T}Rjagz¤� � V�qe[gd���VYq�TWObWV#TW\acT"$#%# ��2���)���������� ��2� � ( � ��� !� ���������+� � �� &�( � �+)��= � & �9�� � �9������«�[B�iVeogV`bTW\Rjs�qr[gOzjXZQSVeb}Vezj� P�V�aS_�V`qrOzURyacb}R¡T��k[cf�TW\Rjs#_acbWTWRyqrO�zyacb�ag_�_�zjRjq`aBT}RU[9dZ[9b�[gObX�acT}a�sWVrTYw?acdX<s�[�Q�Oq,\�Q�[9bWVk�([9bW��d�V`V`X�s�TW[�P/V�X:[9d�V�T}[�ags}qrV`b�T,acRjd;TW\�VacP�[BogV�qr[9d���V`qrTWO�b}Vg�

Page 61: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

��$�� �.����� �2��� ��� ��� 536 �����$�� ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� ��� ��� � ��� ����.����� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� � ��� � ��� � ������ ����� ��� ��� ��� �� ��� ��� ��� � ������ ��� ����� ��� � ������� ��� �� ��� �� ��� � ���������� ��� ��� ������ ��� �� ������� ��� � ������ 536 ��� ��� �� ��� �� ��� ��� ������� ��� ��� ��� �

� -��$�� �.����� �2��� ��� ��� 536 ���

��$�� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� �� ��� ����.����� ��� ��� ��� �� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� �� ������������ ��� ��� ��� �� ��� �� ��� ��� ������ ��� ������ ��� � ��� �� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���������� ��� ��� ������� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� �� �������536 ��� ��� ��� ��� � ��� �� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� �

"$4-��$�� �.����� �2��� ��� ��� 536 ���

��$�� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� � ��� � ��� ��� ��� ����.����� ��� ��� ��� �� ��� � ��� ��� ��� � ��� �������� ��� � ��� �� ��� ��� ��� ��� ������� ��� ������ ��� ��� ������� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���������� ��� �� ��� ��� ��� �� ������� ��� ��� �������536 ��� ��� ��� ��� �� ��� �� ������� ��� �� ��� ��

" �-��$�� �.����� �2��� ��� ��� 536 ���

��$�� ��� ��� ��� � ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ����.����� ��� ��� ��� �� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� �������� ��� ��� ��� �� ��� ��� ��� ��� ������ ��� � ��� ��� �� ������� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��������� ��� ��� ��� �� ��� � ������� ��� �� �������536 ��� ��� ��� ��� � ��� �� ��� ��� ��� �� ��� ��

��-

� acP�zjV % � x:©^l([gd:f{OsWRj[gd�QSacTWb}RjqeV`s�f{[9bS�¤a9����������bWV`_�bWVYs�V`d&T}aBT}RU[9d�wH��d�VYacb}V`s�Td�V`RUn9\&P�[gbYw���� % w:�{P�����������bWV`_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd�wYzURjd�VYacb�N)¥���wYT}[g_:�LX:[B�7d^Q5O�z¡T}R¡�qrzyags}s`w��¤q`����a�ogVezjVrTW��b}Ve_bWVYs�V`d9T,aBT}RU[9d�w?��dV`acb}V`s�T�d�VeRjng\)P�[gbYw(� � % agdX���X���a�ogVezjVrTW��b}Ve_bWVYs�V`d9T,aBT}RU[9d�wgzjRUdV`acb#N:¥���w:T}[g_:�LX:[B�7dZQ�O�zUTWRU�Lqrzyags}se�

�0��������'������ 5 ������'���� ������� 6 �3$&��'��� �2����� � � 5�� � 5 � � 5�� 5 �

������������'����������.�������2� ��� � ��� � ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� �� �(��� ���<����'����������.��������� ��� � ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��

� acPzUV % � u�©/*�o9Veb,aczjz-a9qeqeO�b}a9qr��[gfDo)Rys�V`Q�V�b}V`qe[gngdR¡T}RU[9d��

Page 62: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� ��������� �

� ��� � � � �a� � � � � � � ��� ��

� ���

� \�Vp_agb}a9X:RjngQ [gf:��)�� ( �2����� �+������6+6<� =?���/����agX:oBagdqrVYXkP)�ZQ�acd)� b}V`sWV`agb}q,\�V`b}s`wP�O:TZd�[cT,acP�zj�8P&� " [:X:d�V`�8hib}[)[g�:s�acd/X�qr[g���i[gb}�gV`b}s � u U ��s�V`Ve�:s�T}[ O�dX:V`b��s�T}acd/X5\)O�Q�agd�RUd&TWV`zUzjRjngVed/qrV#agdX�P/V`\a�o)RU[9b1ags�T}\�V�b}V`sWO�zUT1[cf-f{[gOb?RUd&T}VebWT��7RUd�VYXaBTWTWb}RUPO:TWVYsew)dagQ�V`zU�9w:X:Veo9Vezj[g_�QSVed&T,acz�[gb}n9acdRU¨YaBTWRj[gd*w9sW[)qeRjagz/Rjd&TWV`b}a9q�TWRj[gd*w9V`Q5�P�[)X�RUQSVed&T^acd/X�_�\)�:s�RyqeagzDqe[gO�_zURjd�nw�agdX�Q5O�zUTWRU��QS[:X�acz�Rjd&TWVen9b}acTWRj[gd�� #Ld�TW\�Vf{b,acQSVe�i[gb}�5[gf*VeQ5P/[:X:RjV`X RUd&T}VezjzURjngV`dqrV9w&Rjd&TWV`zUzjRUn9Ved&TisW�:s�T}VeQ�siRjs�sW[gO�n9\&T1TW[5P/VP�O�RjzUT�P)��\a�o)RUdnkT}\�V sW�:s�T}VeQ X�RUb}V`qrTWzj�<��agdX�_�\)�:s�RyqeagzUzj����qe[gO�_zUVYX��7RUTW\�RUT}sVed)o)RjbW[9d�QSVed&T(acd/X�aczjzU[B�7Rjd�npT}\�V�s��:s�TWVeQ T}[5X:V`ogVezj[g_�Rjd ��a��:s�T}\aBT�aczjzU[B�8f{[gbTW\V�qe[gO�_zURjd�n�TW[;P�VmVr£:_�zj[gRUTWV`X<Rjd<��a��:s5P�VedVr|/qeRjagz�TW[�TW\�VmsW�:s�T}VeQ�� � \�Rjsf{b,acQSVe�i[gb}�mX:Ve_agb�T,s�f{bW[9QGTW\�V�f{b,acQSVe�i[gb}��[cfiqezja9sWsWRyqeacz t #��7\�Ryq,\�sWVeV`�)s�T}[P�O�RjzyXkRjd&TWV`zUzjRUn9Ved&T�s��:s�TWV`QSs7a9s7s�[9QSV��)RjdXZ[cf�s��)Q5P/[9zH_�bW[:qeV`s}s�[9b}s`�

� ��� �-��� 9 ��1 ������"$>���

t daBT}O�b}agz(~&O�VYs�T}RU[9d��7RUTW\�Rjd T}\�V f{b,acQSV`�([9bW��[cf#V`Q�P�[)X�RUVYX Rjd9T}VezjzURjngV`dqrVkRjs\�[B� q`acd�T}\�VZqe[gO�_zURjd�n�P�VrT��iVeV`d<sW�:s�T}VeQ�acdX Ved)o)RUb}[gd�QSV`d9T�P/V�agq,\RUV`ogV`X��� \�V`bWV�acb}V T��i[;zUV`ogV`zjsSaBT��7\�Ryq,\<TW\�Rys�~&O�V`s�TWRj[gd8qr[9O�zjX<P�V�agsW�gV`X�� t TSTW\�VzjVeogV`z�[cf�VeQ5P/[:X:RjQSVed&T`w*TW\�V�sW�:s�T}VeQ Q5Os�T^P/V�q`ac_agP�zUVS[gf(b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&TWRjd�nkTW\�VVed)o)RjbW[9d�QSVed&T�agdXZaBTiTW\�VpzjVeo9Vez-[cf�X:Veo9Vezj[g_�QSVed&TYw)TW\�VpsW�)s�TWV`Q Q�O/s�T7P�V�agP�zjVTW[SzjV`agbWdkTW\�VpoBagbWRj[gOsib}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T,aBTWRj[gd/s1Rjd)og[gzjogVYX agdXkTW\�Vp��a��:s([gf�Q�ac__�RUdnP�VrT��iVeVed;T}\�VeQ�� � \RUzjV�T}\�V`sWV RyX:V`a9s^\a�o9V�zUVYX;TW[�s�Rjngd�RU|/q`acd&T5agX�o�agdqrVYs^RjdTW\Vkb}V`agzUQ�[gf#\)O�Q�acd�[9RjX�b}[gP�[cT,s5agdX b}VezyaBT}V`X<s�V`ds�[9bWRU��Q�[gTW[9bpT}a9s��:s`w�TW\�V`RUbb}VezjVeoBacdqeV�f{[gb�_/V`b}qeVe_:T}RU[9dZRUT}sWVezUf?\a9s�d�[gT#P/V`Ved�f{O�zjzj�ZVe£:_�zU[9bWVYXH� � V5P/V`zURjVeo9VTW\/aBT�[gO�b��i[gb}��Rys�a�sWQ�aczjz&s�TWV`_5Rjd5qezjagbWRUf{�)RUdn�\�[B� sW�:s�T}VeQ�s�qeagd�P�ViV`Q�P�[:X:RUVYX

& x

Page 63: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� RUn9O�b}V (:� ! ©�l([gQ5P�RUdRUd�n�TW[g_���X:[B�7d�qe[gds�TWb,acRjd&T}s#�7R¡T}\�P/[gT�T}[gQ���O_�zUVYacb}d�Rjd�nf{[gb7_�Veb,qrV`_:TWRj[gd*�

acd/XkX:V`ogV`zU[9_/VYX�f{[9b7_/V`b}qeVe_:T}OaczHT,agsW�:se�� Vk\a�ogV�sWO�ngn9V`s�TWVYX�T}\aBT5[gd�V���a���[gf7a9q,\�RjVeo)RUdn�amqr[gO_�zURjd�n�P�VrT��iVeV`d

Ved)o)RjbW[9d�QSVed&Tkacd/XJ_/V`b}qeVeRjogV`b Rys�T}[�P�V�acPzUV�TW[�b}Ve_bWVYs�V`d9T TW\�V;qeacTWVen9[gb}RUVYs[cf7Rjd&TWVeb}V`s�T5Rjd�T}\�V V`d&o)RjbW[9d�QSVed&T �{�7\Rjq,\�q`acd P�V OdX:Veb,s�TW[)[:X�agspT}\�V�T}[g_:�X:[B�7dk�&d[B�7zUVYX:ngV�RUd�acdk[gb}n9acdRjsWQ��?acd/X�OsWV�zUVYacb}d�RUdn^TW[SQ�ac_ f{bW[9QEbWVeTWRjdaczRjd:f{[gb}Q�aBTWRj[gdZT}[STW\�V^_/acb,acQSVrT}Veb,sp�{�7\�Ryq,\�Rjs#O�dX:V`b}s�TW[)[:X�ags�T}\�V^P�[cT�T}[gQ���O�__�b}[:qrV`s}s,���7R¡T}\�RUd�TW\�V�TW[g_���X:[B�7dJb}Ve_bWVYs�V`d9T,aBT}RU[9d�� � V�RjzjzUOs�TWb,aBT}VmTW\RjskP�Rjn_�Ryq�T}O�bWV�Rjd � Rjn�O(:� ! �

� ��� ���f�=�=�0������� �(� ��H]�6"$�A� �

� \�V`bWVpacb}V�s�V`ogVeb,aczHX:Rjb}V`q�T}RU[9ds(TW\acT7f{O:TWObWVpb}V`sWV`agb}q,\�QSRjng\&T7T}ag�gV9� � VpzjRjs�T�af{Ve�%_�[9s}s�RjP�RjzURUTWRjV`s�P�Vezj[B�p�

� V £:_acdX�T}\�V(s}qr[9_/V�[gf&T}\�Rys�QSVrT}\�[:X�P&��RjQ�_zUV`Q�V`d&TWRjd�n#sWRUQSRjzjagb*s��:s�TWV`QSsf{[9b7[cT}\�Veb7_�Veb,qrV`_:TWOagzHT}a9s��:s`w:Vg� n�)T}b}a9q,�&Rjd�n�n9ag¨eV�acdXZVe�9V�P�zURjd��:s`�

� #Ld)o9V`s�TWRjn9aBT}V7TW\V#b}VezyaBTWRjogV#V�X�qea9qrRjV`s?[gf�_�RU£)V`z�������s(acdX�zjRjd�V�X:b,a��7Rjd�n������sST}[�QS[)X�Vez7RjQSagngVYse��N)[�f�agb��(Vm\a�o9VkO/s�VYX�T}\�Vm_�RU£:Vez#�����f{[9b�Vr£:_�b}V`s}s�Rj[gd8b}V`qr[9ngd�RUTWRj[gd8acdX�TW\VmzURjd�V�X:b,a��7RUdn������ f{[gb�_�[9sWVVYs�T}RUQ�acTWRj[gd�� #[cT}\�RUdnm_�bWV`ogV`d9T,s�Os�f{b}[gQ O/s�Rjd�nZTW\�V�_R¡£:Vez(�*��� f{[gb_�[9sWV^acd/Xka�zjRUd�V^X�b}a��7Rjd�nS�*��� f{[gb7Ve£:_�bWVYsWsWRj[gds`�

Page 64: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� hiO�RjzyX�aZo)Rjb�T}Oacz?a9q�TW[9b^s��:s�TWV`Q �7\�Ryq,\�RyspacPzUVST}[�agdaczj�)¨eV�aZ_/V`b}sW[gd/sVe£:_�bWVYsWsWRj[gdsDacdX�Q�ac_5TW\�V`Q2[gd&TW[�a�sW�:s�T}VeQ�f{[9b�sW�)d&TW\�VYs�Rj¨eRjd�n�bWVYaczjRjs�TWRyqRjQ�acn9V`s�[cf�acdmagqrTW[9b�� V ¨`¨`aBT�agdX���[gngn9RU[ � %�! �{���

� V £)TWVed/XJTW\Rjs�QSVrT}\�[:X�T}[<[gTW\�V`b�[gP���VYq�T}sZ[gf�RUd&T}Veb}V`s�T�sWOq,\¢a9s�qeacb,s`wRjdX:[)[9b7[gP���VYq�T}s`w:VrT,qc�

��� � ��� ���*���D')�� � !H���*�(':����!Z���# ��"������(�9�16�"#�W!-������A#�*�9':���1�#�� \�Rys��([9bW�kTW\�b}[B��s�O�_�Q�agd&�m~&O�VYs�T}RU[9ds�f{[gb�qr[gQS_�O�T}aBT}RU[9dacz�qr[9ngd�RUTWRjogV�sWqeR¡�Ved/qrVg� � \�V�X:Ve|d�RUTWRjogV�zjRjd��:s�TW[�V`Q�P�[:X:RUVYX�RUd&T}VezjzURjngV`dqrV�q`acdJP�V�X:b,a��7d<RUfTW\V`sWV�RyX:V`a9s�q`acd�P�V5Rjd&TWV`ngb,aBTWVYXm�7RUTW\�T}\�V��&RjdXm[gf(sWVedsW[gb}R¡��QS[cT}[gb#q`ac_agP�RUzjRU�TWRjV`s7TW\acT�\&OQSagd�[gRyXZbW[9P/[gT}s�\a�o9Vg� � [gb�Ve£:agQS_�zUV9wqeagdZTW\�VYs�VpRyX:V`a9s�P/V�Os�VYXTW[�QSag_�sWqeVed�V7f{VYaBT}O�bWVYs�T}[^agq�T}RU[9d�_acb,acQSVeTWVeb,s � ]�[^�iV�d�VeVYX�TW[pn9[pTW\�b}[gOng\Rjd9T}Veb}dacz�b}Ve_bWVYs�V`d9T,aBT}RU[9ds �e#�f�s�[/w�acb}V�TW\�VYs�V bWV`_�bWVYs�V`d&T}aBT}RU[9ds�daBT}O�b,acz1agdXVeQ5P/[:X:RjV`X��

Page 65: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� � � � �a� � ���� ��

� ! �^���9«�aczjzURjdagd t � �?O�RUzjzjV�acd/X�]���l([g\�V`d�� � VYaBTWObWV�Ve£)TWb,agq�T}RU[9d�f{bW[9Q@f�a9qrV`sOsWRUdn�X:Vef{[gb}QSagP�zjV�TWV`QS_�zjacTWVYse����� ������/�� � ( �/26�� ( � ����26 (-&�� ( ) � � ����� ����� ( �w �/�¤x9��© USU���!S!Y! w !'USU x:�

� x��^]5�(hiVe�)QSVeb agdX � �(��[9ngngRj[� � agqrVmb}V`qe[gn9d�R¡T}RU[9d�f{b}[gQ [gd�VmVe£�acQS_�zjVo)RUV`�p�R#Ld7� ( �9�����2�+� =2� (-& ������������������2��� ( �/�6 � ( � & �������/��� (0&�� ( ) � � ����� ����� ( �w_/acngVYs (cvgv � (gv + w�liacQ5P�b}RjX:n9Vgw:� t w �gOd�V !�UYU (:�

� u �^]5��h(V`�)Q�V`b7acdX � ����[gngn9RU[/� #LQ�acngV�b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gds?f{[gb�o)RjsWOagz�zjV`agbWd��Rjd�n�� �������/���ew/x + x���(9x + v9��© !�U vY( �O!�U v U w��9O�d�V !'USUS& �

� % �^]5�1hiVe�)QSVebYw t �iN)\agsW\)Oa�wiacdX � �?��[gn9ngRj[� V £�acQS_�zjVZP/agsWV`X<RUQ�acn9Vacd/aczj�)sWRys1acd/X�s��)d&TW\�VYs�Rys`� t � #��)�mV`Q�[ �[� !�% u ! w t bWTWRU|/qrRyacz�#Ld&TWVezjzjRUn9VedqeV�*agP/[9b}acTW[9bW�9w)��ags}sWa9q,\&O/s�VeT�T}sd#Lds�TWRUTWO�TWVp[cf � V`q,\�d�[9zU[9ng�9w !'USU u��

� (��^��� ��-hizja9q,�ZagdX��� �1a9qr[)[gP*� " V`qe[gn9d�RU¨`RUdn�f�agqeRjagz*Vr£:_�b}V`s}sWRU[9ds�Rjd�RjQ5�acn9V^s�VY~&O�VedqeV`s#Os�Rjd�n�zj[:qeacz�_acb,acQSVeTWVeb}Rj¨eV`XkQS[:X:Vezys�[gf�RjQ�acn9VpQ�[gTWRj[gd����� ������/�� � ( �/�6�� ( � ���/�6 (0&�� ( ) � � ���� � ����� ( �/w !�USUY& � " Veo)RjsWV`X^_�bWV`_�b}RUd&T`�

� & �5l���hibWVYac¨eV`z¤��������� = ���+� =� ( ���� ��6 ��� ( � ( �����;� # � �?b}V`s}s`w?liagQ�P�b}RyX:ngV9wxcv9v9x��

� + � �/� N-�^hib}O�d�V`b`� *�d _�Veb,qrVe_�TWOagz�bWVYagX:Rjd�V`s}s`�� �� �9� ( 6 ( =������6�� ��� ��� 1 w&�% © ! xcu �O! (9x:w !�U ( + �

� � �5l�� �ac�Ba���RjQ�a�w�������[9d9T}RUz�w�h���«�V`RjsWVezjVpacdX � ����[gn9ngRj[�D��Ve[g_zUV " V`qe[gng�d�RUTWRj[gdSRjd #LQ�acn9V�N)V`~&O�V`dqrVYs�P)�5N:O�_/V`bWo)Rys�VYX5�*V`agbWd�Rjd�n/� # ������� # ��) (�*( @�� �"!#!%$ �'&(� " # ��) (��*( @)�"!#!gw�xgvgvgv�

� U �5l��c��ac_/acngV`[gb}ngRj[gO�wY���S*�bWV`d5agdX � �c��[9ngngRj[� t ngVedVeb,acz9f{b}agQ�V`�([9bW��f{[gb[gP ��V`q�T�X�VrTWVYq�T}RU[9d�� #Ld*7� ( �������2�+� =�� (-& ��������� ������/�� � ( �/�6 � ( � & �������/���( � � ( ) � � ����� � ����� ( �w�h([9Q�Pa��9w1#LdX:Rya�w �&acd)OagbW� !�UYU ��

& (

Page 66: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� ! v � � �(liacd�d)�9� t qr[gQS_�O�T}aBT}RU[9dacz�ac__�bW[&agq,\�T}[�VYX:ngV�X:VeTWV`qrTWRj[gd�� � ���������2����@ ( �� 2����������5�/�6< ,������2��� # ��� �+�/����� ���6+6<� = �������rw��© &1+�U �1&SU ��w!�U � & �

� !S! �p����lia�o�agdacn9\�� � \acT � s#O_�Rjd�TW[9_:�LX:[B�7dm_�b}[)qeV`s}s�Rjd�n/�Q#Ld�� ���/�9����������2.��� ( ��� (0&� ����� ( �/��liacQ5P�b}RjX:n9V�ª#d�Rjo��/�?b}V`s}sew !'USU6! �

� ! x�� � � � ��l([)[cT}V`s`w W � �� V X:��acb,X�s`w9acd/X l�� �/� � a��)zU[9b`� t qrTWRjogV#ag_�_/VYacb,acdqeVQS[:X:Vezyse� #Ld � ( �������2�+� =2� (0& ����� � � � ( ������ � ( � & ���9�����9� ( � � ( ) � � ����� ����� ( �w � bWV`RUPO�bWn/w W Veb}Q�acd)�gw !�UYU ��

� ! u ��l��#l([gbWTWVYskagdXJ¥���¥?ag_�d�Rj��� N)O_�_/[9b�T�ogVYq�T}[gb dVrT��i[gb}�)s`� # ?�9� �+�/�" �9������+� =cw/xgv�© ! � xS(:w !�UYU (��

� !�% � " � � bWV`O�dX V �R*�s�O�d/akagdX � � W RjbW[&s�R�� � b,acRjd�Rjd�nksWO�_�_�[gbWT�ogV`qrTW[9b�Q�aB�q,\�Rjd�V`s`©<agd�ac__�zURyqeacTWRj[gd�TW[ f�a9qrV;X:VrT}V`qrTWRj[gd�� #Ld 7� ( �9�����2�+� =2�� ������ ( � & @ ( � � ( ) � � ����� � ����� ( � ��/� :�� ������� � ��� ( = ���+��� ( �/w)�1O�VebWTW[ " Ryqr[w�9O�d�V !�UYUi+ �

� ! (�� S� V P�Rj\acb,a�w �/��*�\)�&a�wagdX � � �Rys�\�Rjd�[/� " VYaczU�¤T}RUQSVpf�a9qrRyacz�Ve£:_�bWVYsWsWRj[gdX:VeTWV`qrTWRj[gd�P/agsWV`X�[gd�f{b}V`~&O�V`dqr��X:[9QSagRUd�TWb,acds�f{[gb}Q�� � ��� ��26 � ( ) ) � .�������� � ( ��� 2��� ��)�>=?� 7� ( ���������+� =�4� �� � w/x + x + © U6!�& �1U xS(:w !�USUY& �

� !�& �p��� V �)Q�acd*� � agqeRjagz&Ve£:_�bWVYsWsWRj[gds`�1#Ld�� 2�/�?� (>( � (0& � ( = ���+��� ( �!2�/� � ) ( .��� ( �w_acn9V`s7ugv ! � u9xcvw&N)O/sWsWVr£Hw�ª Sw !�USUYU �

� !]+ �p��� V �)QSagdJacdX V � �?� " [9sWVed)P�Veb}nJ� V Xse� ��������2�������� ?�9� � ���2�9�6 ��& ,����� ��/� �7� ��6<����� � ���2����� (0& � ( ����2��� ( � � � ������������� ( � � ���+� = ������ ����26 �5����� ( � � ( ���+� = / ,������)������ � ����b*#£)f{[gb,X�ª�d�RjogV`b}sWR¡T��;�?b}V`s}s`w�V`� �?[9bW�-w !'USUi+ �

� ! � �$#LbWf�acd t � V s}sWa�agdX t zjVr£p��Ved&TWzyacd/XH� t o)RjsWRU[9dps��:s�TWVeQ¢f{[gb*[gPsWVeb}o)RUd�n7agdXVr£)T}b}a9q�TWRjd�n�f�agqeRjagz�agqrTWRj[gd�_acb,acQSVrT}Veb,se�2#Ld 7� ( �������2�+� =�� � ����� � ( � & @ ( �� ( ) � � ����� � ����� ( � 2�/� :2��������� � ��� ( = ���+��� ( �/w*_agngV`s +�&�� �gu�wDN)V`acT�TWzjVgw� t w !�UYU�% �

� !�U � � [gd)� V ¨`¨`aBTY� V £�acQS_�zjVr��Pa9s�VYX�acdagzU�:sWRjs�acd/X�sW�&d&T}\�V`sWRjs�f{[9b�RjQ�acn9V`s�[cf\)O�Q�acdkf�agqeV`s`�D��a9s�T}Veb � s(T}\�V`sWRjs`w���a9sWs}agq,\)OsWVrTWT}sG#Lds�T}R¡T}O:TWVp[gf � V`q,\�d[gzU�[gn9�gw !'USUS& �

� xcv � � � W RUb}[9sWR�w1��� �9[gd�VYsew1agdX � ����[9ngn9RU[/� " VengOzjagbWRj¨`acTWRj[gd�T}\�Ve[9bW� agdXd�V`O�b}agz#d�VeT��([9bW�:s�agb}q,\R¡T}V`q�T}O�b}V`s`� � ��� �926 � ( ) � � ��� � ( �w + © x !�U � x &YU w!�UYU (��

Page 67: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� x ! ��l�� �� � a��&zj[gb W � �� V X��iagb}X�s�acd/X � � � �*l([)[cT}V`s`�^��VYacb}d�RUdn�TW[ZRyX:Ved&TWRUf{�acd/X�TWb,agq,�mf�a9qrV`s�Rjd�RjQSagngV�sWV`~&O�Ved/qrV`s`� #Ld*7� ( �������2�+� =�� (-& ����� ����������.�/�� � ( �/�6 � ( � & �������/��� ( �� � � ( )��� ��� � ����2�/��� ����� � ��� �5��� ( = ���+��� ( �w_agngV`s�x & v � x & (:w !�USU ���

� xgx��p«^� ��� W b,aBf�w � ��l(\Ved�w V ����VrT,a���agd�w�acdX V �*l([&sWacT�TW[/���*[:qeaBT}RUdn f�a9qrV`sacd/X�f�a9qrRyacz7_agb�T,se� � ( � @ ��� �@ � ( � � �0� ( � ( � � � � ( )�2����� � ����. 2�/�� ����� � ����. � ��� ( = ���+��� ( �/w:_acn9V`s %<!%�i%i& w !�USU (:��#Ldm����hiRjq,\sWVez?��V`X:RUTW[9b,�r�

� xcu �^N-��h�aczjO���a «^� t � " [B�7zjVe��acdX � � pacd/agX:V9� #VeO�b,acz�d�VrT��i[gb}��Pa9s�VYXf�agqeV�X:VrT}V`qrTWRj[gd�� � ����� � �92����@ ( � :2��������� �5�/26 ,����� ��/� # ?�9� �+�/���� ���6+6<� = �������rw-xcv�© xcu � u ��w !'USU ���

� x % �p����#�sWagb}X�acd/X t �`hizyac�9Vg�9l([gd&T}[gO�bW�¤T}b}a9q,�)RUd�n(P)��s�TW[:q,\a9s�T}Rjq�_�b}[g_/acn9acTWRj[gd[cf1qe[gdX�R¡T}RU[9dacz*X�VedsWR¡T��9� #Ld�7� ( ���9�����+� =�� (-& � � � ( ����2� � ( � & �������/��� ( �� ( ) � � ����� � ����� ( �/w�_acn9V`s�u % u � uY( & w !'USUY& �

� xS(��^N-� W [gd�n �/�`N)\�V`bWb,ac\�acd/X V �'*�d�n/�cª�dX:V`b}s�T}agdX:Rjd�n�_/[&s�V?X�Rjs}qrb}RUQSRjdaBT}RU[9dRjd s�RjQSRUzyacb}R¡T���s�_/agqrV9� #Ld ��� ��� & ���+� ����� # ?�9� �+�/� � ��� ( � � ( � & �����������rwog[9zUOQ�V^x�w�_acn9V`s (gxgu � (cu9x�w #[cT�T}RUdng\agQZw/ª Sw !'USUSU �

� x & ��l����&agqe[gPs`w t � � Rjd��9Vezys�T}VeRjd�wiagdX8]��(N�aczjV`sWRUd�� � ags�TSQ5O�zUTWRjbWVYs�[9zUO:T}RU[9dRjQSagngV�~9OVeb}�&Rjd�n/� #Ld� �����)� �� ��� ��7� ( �9�����2�+� =2��w !�UYU (���ª�d�RjogV`b}sWR¡T��[cf � agsW\�RUdncTW[9d�w � " � U (B��v ! �Lv & �

� x + �p��� �g[9d�V`s7agdX � �/��[9ngn9RU[/�1�m[:X:VezU��PagsWV`XZQ�aBT,q,\�RUdn�P)� zjRUd�VYacb�qr[gQ5P�RU�dacTWRj[gds�[gf/_�b}[cT}[cT��)_/VYse� t � R��cQSVeQS[/w9� # � t bWTWRU|/qrRyacz2#Ld&TWV`zUzjRjngVed/qrV7�*agP��UwliacQ5P�b}RjX:n9Vgw�� t w !�UYUS& �

� x � �p��� �g[9d�V`skacdX � �i��[gn9ngRj[���mO�zUTWRyX:RUQSV`ds�Rj[gd/acz#QS[9bW_�\/acP�zjV�QS[:X:Vezyse©t f{b}agQSVe�i[gb}��f{[9bZb}Ve_bWVYs�V`d9T}RUdn<acd/X�Q�aBT,q,\�RUdn<[9P���V`qrT�qezja9sWsWV`s`� #Ld7� ( �����9���+� =�� (-& ����� ��� ������/�� � ( �/�6 � ( � & �������/��� ( � � ( ) � � ����� � ����� ( �whi[gQ5Pa��gw2#LdX�Rjaw !�USU ���

� x U � � � �[g\�zjVebY��� ������6<� �� �9� ( 6 ( = B����RjogV`bWRjng\&T#�?OP�zURysW\�RUdnw �V`� �?[gb}��w!�US%1+ �

� ugv � ^� �bWOngVebYw����1��[cT}¨`s}q,\�w�acdX�l��1o9[gd�X:Vebk��aczys�PO�bWn/��]�VrTWV`bWQSRjdaB�TWRj[gdZ[cf*f�agqrV�_�[9sWR¡T}RU[9d acdX _/[&s�V��7RUTW\�a�zjV`agbWd�VYX�b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd�Pa9s�VYX[gd�zjagP/V`zUVYX�n9b}ag_�\s`� ��)��= � 2��� � ����� ( � � ( ) � � ���+� =gw ! (� �9�r© &Y& ( �1&i+ u�wt OngOs�T !�UYUi+ �

� u ! �p«^� l�����V`V�agdX " �:��� W [)[:X:�7Rjd���l([9zU[9b}siagsis�V`VedkP&�S\)O�Q�acd/siagdX�Q�aB�q,\�Rjd�V`s`�R#Ld�� � ��/��� � ,�������*2��� � ����) �������� (-& ��)��= �+� = ,�����) �,w_agngV`s % v !%�i% vi(:w&��a�� !�UYU�% �

Page 68: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� u9x��^N-�)��aczjzyaBT`� t TW\�V`[gb}��f{[9b1Q�Oz¡T}RUb}V`sW[gzjO:TWRj[gd�sWRUn9dacz�X:V`qe[gQS_�[9sWR¡T}RU[9d�© � \V��a�ogVezjVrT�b}Ve_�b}V`sWVed&T}acTWRj[gd�� � ����� ����2����@ ( ��:�� ���������5�/�6< ,����� ��/� # �.��� �+�/� ��������6+6<� = ���/���rw !S! � + �r© &1+]%"�1&SU u�w !'U � U �

� ugu �p]�a�o&RyX���acb}bY� � ����� ( � �� � ( ) � � ��� � ( �/26 ��� �,����� � = 2��� ( �;�+��� ( ����� � � .)�2��� ���/��������� ��� � ( �3��/� 7� ( ���������+� = (0&�� �������6 ��� &�( ��)��� � ( �� � � «^�� b}VeV`Q�acd�acdX�l([gQS_agd)�gwN:agd � b}agdqrRysWqe[w !�U �9x��

� u % � � �:¥�VrTWTWV`b���� �/���g[9d�V`s`w:����N)RUd\a5agdX � ����[9ngn9RU[/� � [9_:��X�[B�7d�zUVYacb}d�Rjd�n[cf�zj[B����zjVeo9Vez-o)RjsWRU[9d T,agsW�:se� � � ��������� & � ( 6 ( = Bw + � !Y! ��© USU<! �2USU�% w !�UYUi+ �

� uY(��p]5�Y�mOQ5f{[9b}X��9��aBTWTWV`bWd�TW\Ve[gb}�-©�a7O�d�RUf{�)RUdn�_/V`b}sW_�V`q�T}RUo9Vg��#Ld :���9�9���/��� ( �,� & 2 ������2����� & �������/���e��liacQ5P�b}RjX:n9V�ª#d�Rjo��/�?b}V`s}sew !�UYUS& �

� u & � ^�h*�zjRUo9VebYw � �ihiVeb,acb,XHw�agdX t ����Ved&T}zjagdXH�@��aBf§TWV`b`©��*RU_sZacd/X�f�agqeVTWb,agq,�9VebY��#Ld�7� ( �9�����2�+� =2��� ����� � ( � & @ ( � � ( ) � � ���� � ����� ( ��2��� :2��.��������� ��� ( = ���+��� ( �/w:_acn9V`s ! xgu ��! x U w9�1O�VebWTW[ " Ryqr[w !�USUY& �

� u + � �/��«�O/acd�n���� ����?\�RjzUzjRj_sew�«^� � VYq,\sWzUV`b�acdX;��� " acOs}s`� � \�V � V " V �X�acT}acP/agsWV(acd/X�V`o�agzUO/aBTWRj[gd�_�bW[:qeV`X:O�b}V(f{[gb�f�agqrVib}V`qr[9ngd�RUTWRj[gd5aczjng[gb}RUTW\�Q�s`���)��= ��2��� � ����� ( � � ( ) � � ���+� =gw !'& ��(9��© x U ( � u9v & w !�UYU ���

� u�� � �/�D�1zjacT�T`���?b}[gPagP�RjzURys�T}RjqS[9O:TW_O:T}s5f{[gb�s�O_�_/[9b�T�ogVYq�TW[9b�Q�agq,\RUd�VYs�agdXqr[9QS_acb}RjsW[gd/s�TW[�b}VengOzjagbWRj¨eVYX�zjRU�9VezjRU\[&[:X8QSVrT}\�[:X�se� #Ld �5� �22�/�����!�+�" 2� = � # �� = �+� � 6 ,����� � �������/� # � �?b}V`s}s`w !'USUYU �

� u U �$#�� " [gP�VebWT�l�� �V`Q�_>������acb���acd[Bo&RyqJh���N:qea9sWsWVezjzjacTWR " �Sh(b}[)[g�:s`wl���h(b}V`ag¨eV`z#� � Veb}bWV`zUz§�^agdX ��� � RUzjzURyacQ�sW[gd�� t zUTWVeb}dacTWRjogV�VYsWsWVedqeV`s�[cfRjd9T}VezjzURjngV`dqrV9�Q#Ld 7� ( �������2�+� =�� (0& � ����� #!gw�_/acngVYs US&<! �2US&i+ w���agX�RjsW[gd�w� #�w !'USU ��

� % v � S�DN:O�d�n�agdX � ����[9ngngRj[� V £�acQS_�zjVr��Pa9s�VYX�zjV`agbWd�Rjd�n�f{[9b�o)RUV`����P/agsWV`X\)O�Q�acdkf�agqeV�X:VeTWVYq�TWRj[gd*� � ����� ����2����@ ( � :2�����������5��26< ,����� 2�/� # �.��� �+�/� ��������6+6<� = ���/���rw-xcv© u U�� ( ! w !�USU ���

� %<! � � � V ¨`¨`acT�acd/X � ����[gn9ngRj[��¥#Rys�Oagz�N)_/V`V`q,\JN)�)d&TW\�VYs�Rys�P&� ��[gb}_�\�Rjd�n¥#RysWVeQSV`s`� # � ����� # ��) (�� ( @)� ��"!%$ �'&(� " # ��) (��*( @)�����gw !'USUSU �

� % x��p]�VeQSVrT}bWR � Veb}¨e[g_�[gOzU[&s�acd/X �VeRUTW\ � acTWVeb,s`� t d/aczj�)sWRys5agdX sW�&d&T}\�V`sWRjs[cf�f�a9qrRyacz1RjQ�acn9V s�VY~&O�VedqeV`spO/s�Rjd�n�_�\)�:sWRjq`acz1agdX�acdacTW[9Q�Ryqeagz?QS[:X:Vezyse�� ����� ����2���� ��� � ( ��� ( � :2�����������5��26< ,�����5��/� # ?�9� �+�/� ��� ���6+6<� = �������rw! (� & ��©)( &SU � ( +�U w !�UYU u��

� % u � t � ^� � Rj�&\[gd�[Bo�acdXp¥5� ��� t b}sWVed�Rjd�� ( 6 � � � ( ��� (0& ��6+6<.8� ( ���9� 7� ( ��6 ��)*���� �«�� � RUd/s�T}[gd�w � agsW\�Rjd�ncT}[gd�w/]�� l��Uw !�Ui+Y+ �

Page 69: thesis final - cbcl.mit.educbcl.mit.edu/publications/theses/thesis-kumar.pdf · VYacb}d Rjd n f{[9bph([gT T}[gQ O _ t d/aczj )sWRyse© " V`agz¡ TWRjQSV N: )s TWV`Q f{[gb agqeRjagz

� %S% �^N-��ª#zUzjQ�acd���� � =,� . " ���,��6 � ����� ( ���� # � �1bWVYsWs`w�liacQ�PbWRyX:ngV9w&� t w !'USUS& �� % (��^N-��ª�zjzUQ�agd^acdX " �Yh�agsWbWR�� " V`qe[gn9d�R¡T}RU[9d�P&��zjRUd�VYacbDqr[gQ5P�RjdaBT}RU[9d�[gf:Q�[:X)�Vezys`� � ����� ���������@ ( � 2�������� �5�/�6< ,��������/� # ?�9� �+�/� ��� ���6+6<� = �������rw! u© UYU x �O! v9v & w !�UYU6! �

� %Y& ��¥��/h(zyacd¨g� � � � ( )�2����� � ��� ( ����� � ����� � ( � (-& ��� ������. � �+)�������� ( ��26 �������(-& � ����� & � ( ) � �+� =�6 � ��)��= �r���1\�� ]5� � \�VYs�Rys��{Rjd W V`bWQ�acd���w�ª�dRUo9VebW�sWR¡T��k[cf � O�V`P�RUdngVed*w/xcv9vgv��

� %1+ ��¥�� �O�Q�acb?agdX � �g��[gn9ngRj[���*V`acb}d�Rjd�nc�Lh�agsWV`X t _�_�b}[9a9q,\�T}[ " VYacz � RjQSV� b}a9q,�&Rjd�n#agdX t daczj�:s�Rys�[cf � agqrVYse�i#Ld � ( �������2�+� =2� (-& ������� ( � �����(����������.�/�� � ( �/�6 � ( � & �������/��� ( �� � � ( )��� ��� � ����2�/��� ����� � ��� �5��� ( = ���+��� ( �w_agngV`s UY&���! v ! w W b}Ved[gP�zjVgw � b}agdqrV9wxcvgv9v��

� % � �^N-� V � W [9zU[B�7Ryq,\�¥��*¥?ac_�d�Rj��acd/X t �*N)QS[gzya���N:O�_�_�[gbWT�o9V`qrTW[gb�QSVrT}\�[:Xf{[gbif{O�d/q�TWRj[gd�ac__�bW[�£:RjQ�aBTWRj[gd*w9b}Ven9bWVYsWsWRU[9d�V`s�TWRjQ�aBTWRj[gd*w)agdX sWRjngdagz�_bW[g�qrVYsWsWRjd�n�@#Ld*� �"�,��/�������+� � � � ��26 ��� &�( ��)��� � ( �� � ( ���������+� = ,�����) �,wog[9zUOQ�V U w1_agngV`sSx � ! � x � + w?N:acd���aBT}Ve[/w�l t w !'USU1+ ���m[gb}n9agd pacO:f§�Q�acd�dm�1O�P�zjRjsW\�Veb,s`�

� %YU ��¥��H¥?ag_�d�Rj�-������� � �� � �9� (-& ��2������������26 " �9������+� = ����� ( �� B�5N:_�bWRjd�n9VebYw�V`� �?[9bW�-w !'USU (��

� (cv ��¥�� ��(¥?ag_�d�Rj��� � ��� �+)�2��� ( � (-& � ��������� ���/����� & ,����� ( � � ) �/�+������26��2��B�1N)_�b}Rjd�ngV`b���¥�Veb}zjagnw:hiVeb}zURjd�w !'U �9x��

� ( ! ��¥�� ��B¥?ac_�dRU�-� ��2������� ����26 " ��2��� �+� =������ ( �� B� � RjzUV`�gw�#Ve� �?[9bW�-w !'USU ��� (gx�� � ��¥�VeT�TWV`b#acd/X � ���[9ngn9RU[/����Rjd�VYacb7[gP ��V`q�T�qezja9sWsWV`s�acd/XkRjQ�acn9V�sW�)d9T}\�Vr�sWRjs�f{b}[gQ aZsWRjd�ngzjVSVr£�acQS_�zjVSRUQ�acn9Vg� � ����� ����2����?����� ( ��� ( � :�� ��������5�/�6< ,����� 2��� # ��� �+��� ��������6+6 � =?���/���ew !�U © + © + ugu �6+]% x:w !'USU1+ �