The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    1/39

    The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference To Big

    Bazar

    Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements

    For the award of the degree of

    Master of Business Administration

    In

    Software Enterprise Management

    Under the guidance of

    Internal Guide and Supervisor

    Mrs. Shipra Sharma

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    2/39

    ABSTRACT

    Pantaloons Retail Limited is Indias leading retailer that operates

    multiple retail formats in both the value and lifestyle segment of the

    Indian consumer maker. Pantaloons include a chain of fashion outlets

    that is Big Bazaar, a uniquely Indian hypermarket chain, Food Bazaar, a

    supermarket chain, blends the look, touch and feel of Indian bazaars

    with aspects of modern retail like choice, convenience and quality.

    The research project deals about the waiting line management at retail

    outlets like Big Bazaar. It basically stresses on the problems faced by the

    organizations in managing the waiting lines throughout the day,

    especially at the peak hours and festival season.

    The scope of my project involves understanding the concept of waiting

    lines and find out better ways to manage them. It aims at studying the

    various techniques adopted for managing waiting lines at retail stores

    like Big Bazaar and see whether it is effective enough to serve thenumber of footfalls.

    The deliverable on the completion of my project will serves as input for

    the subsequent phases and will give a better understanding of waiting

    line management and its implementation.

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    3/39

    ACKNOWLEDGMENT

    It is really a matter of pleasure for me to get an opportunity to thank allthe persons who contributed directly or indirectly for the successfulcompletion of the project report, Study of Waiting Line Management

    With Reference To Big Bazaar.

    First of all I am extremely thankful to my college CDAC for providingme with this opportunity and for all its cooperation and contribution. Ialso express my gratitude to my Project mentor and guide Mrs. ShipraSharma. I am highly thankful to our respected project guide for giving

    me the encouragement and freedom to conduct my project.

    I am also grateful to all my faculty members for their valuable guidanceand suggestions for my entire study.

    I would also like to thank the Big Bazaar team for extending theirvaluable time and cooperation.

    Neeta KumariRoll no. : 03611809912

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    4/39

    Table of ContentsExecutive summary.

    1. Introduction........5

    1.1.Companys Profile...5

    1.2.Organisation Structure ......................................................................9

    1.3.Purpose of the Study .......................................................................10

    1.4.Significance of the Study................................................................ 11

    1.5. Objective ........................................................................................12

    1.6.Scope ............................................................................................... 13

    2.1. Indian Retail Market ...................................................................... 14

    2.2.Big Bazaar Retail Life Cycle .......................................................... 16

    2.3.Service Time Distribution .............................................................. 17

    3.Research Methodology ...................................................................... 20

    4. Analysis of Data ............................................................................. 362

    5.Conclusion ......................................................................................... 30

    6.Bibliography.32

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    5/39

    List of Tables and Figures

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    6/39

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    7/39

    the length of lines and time customers spend in checkout lanes. Early

    research in this area concerned identifying theoretical models to explain

    how consumers perceive longer than expected waits in checkout lines.

    Lewins (1943) early field theory suggested that when perceived

    waiting.

    Self-service machines are multiplying in grocery and discount stores at a

    blistering speed. Self-service is fast becoming a viable alternative to

    conducting transactions, from ATM machines to gas pumps to self-

    checkout at retail stores. Customers are demanding better and fasterservice, and the scarcity and cost of labor are leading to more and more

    businesses exploring this alternative. The problem confronting managers

    is the limited source of available information to help them in their efforts

    to choose among checkout systems. Managerial decision making

    processes are more complex because front end service requirements vary

    among stores. So, grocery store managers are constantly exploring

    different queuing techniques and evaluating current technology to help

    them make better strategic decisions in their choices of POS (point of

    sales) checkout terminals.

    Research shows that studies have been done in the area of how

    customers time spent in waiting lines affects customers behavior andthere are limited studies on how managers choose appropriate checkout

    systems for their businesses. Hkust and Hkust (2002), in their study

    expressed that limited research has been conducted to determine how

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    8/39

    service waits can be controlled. They suggested that, to control the time

    customers wait in line, researchers must determine the factors that cause

    more than expected wait time in checkout lines. Researchers argue that

    service waits can be controlled by two techniques: operations

    management or perception management (Katz, Larson, & Larson, 1991).

    By conducting this research, A Comparative Study of the Electronic

    Self Checkout System and the Cashier Operated checkout System

    managers will have available some added information to help them in

    their decisions between choosing among checkout systems.The project was carried out in with an objective of knowing satisfaction

    level of customer at Big Bazaar and do customers are aware about the

    different types product and Services and different offers provide at Big

    Bazaar. The total sample size taken was one hundred (100) from various

    customers of Allahabad at Big Bazaar. The research shows that the

    customer satisfaction at Big Bazaar is very good and so many customers

    are not aware of the product and services provided by the Big Bazaar

    which are not provided by other Retail stores. On the other hand we

    have also the existing customers of Big Bazaar who are satisfied with

    the working style of retail store, but want continuous updates about the

    new offers and other products of Big Bazaar.The India Retail Industry is the largest among all the industries,

    accounting for over 10 per cent of the country GDP and around 8 per

    cent of the employment. The Retail Industry in India has come forth as

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    9/39

    one of the most dynamic and fast paced industries with several players

    entering the market. But all of them have not yet tasted success because

    of the heavy initial investments that are required to break even with

    other companies and compete with them. The India Retail Industry is

    gradually inching its way towards becoming the next boom industry.

    The total concept and idea of shopping has undergone an attention

    drawing change in terms of format and consumer buying behavior,

    ushering in a revolution in shopping in India. Modern retailing has

    entered into the Retail market in India as is observed in the form ofbustling shopping centers, multi-storied malls and the huge complexes

    that offer shopping, entertainment and food all under one roof.

    A large young working population with median age of 24 years, nuclear

    families in urban areas, along with increasing workingwomen population

    and emerging opportunities in the services sector are going to be the key

    factors in the growth of the organized Retail sector in India. The growth

    pattern in organized retailing and in the consumption made by the Indian

    population will follow a rising graph helping the newer businessmen to

    enter the India Retail Industry.

    In India the vast middle class and its almost untapped retail industry are

    the key attractive forces for global retail giants wanting to enter intonewer markets, which in turn will help the India Retail Industry to grow

    faster. Indian retail is expected to grow 25 per cent annually. Modern

    retail in India could be worth US$ 175-200 billion by 2016. The Food

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    10/39

    Retail Industry in India dominates the shopping basket. The Mobile

    phone Retail Industry in India is already a US$ 16.7 billion business,

    growing at over 20 per cent per year. The future of the India Retail

    Industry looks promising with the growing of the market, with the

    government policies becoming more favorable and the emerging

    technologies facilitating operations.

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    11/39

    Introduction

    1.1.Company Profile

    Big Bazaar comes under the Pantaloon Retail India Limited (PRIL).

    PRIL was early to realize the potential of the huge middle-class

    population in India. We started the operations with a trouser brand,

    Pantaloon. In the initial stages we had small format outlets branded

    Pantaloon Shopee, which were franchise operations realizing theproblems associated with franchise model, we decided to have our own

    retail outlets. They launched the own retail store, Pantaloons. In

    1997, they launched Big-Bazaar a hypermarket with over 1, 70,000

    products as the first offering in value retailing segment. They have

    introduced the concept of seamless malls in India through the new

    format Central. We have wide network of Pantaloons stores spread

    across the country.

    Hence, apart from retailing lifestyle products, it ventured into value

    retailing by launching the hypermarket chain. Big Bazaar is a chain that

    stocks all home need products under one roof; spread over 30,000 square

    feet of land, across different cities in India. It has been positioned as Is

    se sasta aur acha kahin nahi, (Nothing cheaper and better anywhere)

    indicating the value of stores. Products are cheaper than the market price

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    12/39

    by as much as 5 to 60%. Apparels are cheaper by 25 to 60%while the

    price difference on the other products varies between 5 to 20%.

    On Oct. 12, 2001, we launched Big-Bazaar as offering in the valueretailing segment. By removing inefficiencies from the distribution chain

    we are able to unleash attractive savings, which are passed on to the

    consumer. Big-Bazaar is Indias first hypermarket in the discount store

    format. Big-Bazaar provides more than 2,00,000 items- food, grocery,

    utensils, kitchen needs, home needs, bath needs, toys, stationary,

    electronics & white goods which are sold at a discount to the maximum

    retail price. Price is the principal value proposition at these stores.

    A big driver of the Big Bazaar is the product variety. This is achieved by

    selling wide range of products & through the Shop-in-Shop format. As

    a result, a typical Big-Bazaar comprises shops that stocks medicines,

    optical accessories, camera rolls, bakery products, dry fruits, crockery,

    glassware, health & beauty products, ladies accessories, electronics

    infant necessities, watches, clocks, computer accessories, food &

    beverages, stationary, readymade garments, household appliances, home

    furnishings, baggage We believe this is a win-win situation as the

    customer is assured of product availability, the shop owner can benefit

    of the in structure & we enjoy assured income without needing to stock

    inventory. Also the shop-in-shop offering is able to increase the

    customer traffic in to the stores. The Big-Bazaar has been positioned to

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    13/39

    the customer as a place where the customer can shop for each &

    everything for which if goes to a market.

    They have also launched private label initiative in Big-Bazaar.Understanding of the apparel industrial, decades of experience& a

    vertically, integrated structure provides with more compelling reasons to

    expand the number of private labels. We have launched a full range of

    accessories to supplement the apparel business including imitation

    jewellery, sunglasses, watches, mobile phones etc

    Analysts attribute the success of PRIL to cheaper sourcing of products

    and lower distribution cost. Pantaloons sourced its products through

    Consolidators. There was a consolidator for each product category.

    These consolidators were responsible for procuring quality goods at the

    cheapest possible price, and were paid commissions on their sale at the

    store. The consolidator directly dealt with manufacturers, and as a result

    the distribution cost could be slashed as no intermediates were involved.

    In addition to discounts on products through the year, Big Bazaar also

    held events such as Kitchen Mela, Trouser Mela, etc. to attract

    customers.

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    14/39

    http://bp3.blogger.com/_RoZOCtRoIGc/RoJr3EfPZdI/AAAAAAAAAKU/C57NqlUBCs4/s1600-h/Pantaloon-Retail-All-Brands.png
  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    15/39

    Organisation Structure

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    16/39

    1.3. Purpose of the Study

    The current competitive market and the development of a dizzying array

    of electronic payment technologies in recent years, however, has

    dramatically raised the profile of point of sales systems as key

    competitive weapons within the retail industry. Managers are frequently

    confronted with the problem of deciding whether to increase the number

    of cashier checkout counters or replace them with the new electronic

    checkout machines.

    This study addresses some of the host of factors that can help managers

    to decide which customer checkout system is better or best for their store

    and the customers. The study will investigate such factors as the number

    of items checked out by customers in each system within a specified

    time period and the average time it takes to check out each customer

    within each system. The research will also investigate factors dealingwith error rates, managers and customers affective reactions and

    confidence.

    Furthermore, the study will assess and compare acquisition,

    implementation and operation costs for each system within a specified

    period of time. The answer to these questions will complement the

    information managers require when making strategic decisions on their

    choices of checkout system. The rationale behind the investigation of the

    factors includes the average time it takes to checkout each customer that

    enters the queue, the number of items checked out by each customer, the

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    17/39

    error rate calculated for each system, the operational cost associated with

    each system, and the level of affective reactions and confidence of

    customers and managers selected for this research.

    1.4. Significance of the Study

    The retail business has experienced a steady increase in the level of

    competitiveness within the industry. Managers of retail businesses are

    always confronted with the problem of improving customer checkout

    systems, thereby increasing their customers satisfaction, maintaining a

    good customer base, and increasing company profits. It is becoming a

    widespread belief among retailers that there is a positive correlation

    between profit and good customer service. Also, research has shown that

    consumer buying patterns are highly influenced by how long they think

    they have to wait in line to be checked out, or to receive services in a

    business.

    The following issues make this study significant: (1) Businesses are very

    concerned about how efficiently their checkout systems work and are

    always in search of ways to improve them. (2) Consumers want fast

    checkout lanes: consequently the length of time a customer waits in lineto be checked out may influence the choice of a store in which he or she

    shops.

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    18/39

    (3) Influences from current advances and changes in retail and

    supermarket checkout technology have increased managerial problems

    in choosing among alternative methods of checkout.

    (4) Managers of retail businesses are seeking information that can help

    them in their decision-making process when choosing appropriate

    checkout systems. (5) There is a paucity of academic research studies

    comparing differences in checkout systems. (6) Findings from this study

    will add to the limited body of literature that could help managers make

    better strategic decisions in their choices for selection of the better

    checkout system. Finally and most importantly, there are very few retail

    businesses in Jackson, Mississippi that have the electronic self-checkout

    machines. Most of these stores are just starting to install, or are

    contemplating replacing some of their traditional cashier operated

    checkout terminals with the electronic self-checkout machines. Thisresearch will add to the level of needed information store managers

    require to make better decisions among their choices of checkout

    systems.

    1.5. Objectives

    Specifically the objectives of the report can be listed as:

    To study and understand the significance of Waiting Linemanagement in the current business environment

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    19/39

    1.6. Scope

    The scope of my project involves understanding the concept of waiting

    lines and find out better ways to manage them. It aims at studying the

    various techniques adopted for managing waiting lines at retail storeslike Big Bazaar and see whether it is effective enough to serve the

    number of footfalls.

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    20/39

    2.1.Indian Retail Market

    The retail market in India is estimated at about US$ 410 billion and

    constitutes about 60% of private consumption and about 35% of India's

    GDP. With Indian GDP expected to grow at 7-8 % in the next coming

    years, the retail market is expected to touch US $860 billion by 2018. In

    recent years, this sector has witnessed a lot of interest from both

    domestic and global players, who have committed investments worth US

    $30 billion, which will lead to increase in the share of modern retail

    from the current 4.5% to almost 25% of the total retail market by 2018.

    The Indian retail market is the fifth largest retail destination globally.

    The current size of the Indian retail industry stands at $511 billion in

    2013. Simultaneously, modern retail is likely to increase its share in the

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    21/39

    total retail market to 22 per cent by 2014. Organized retail in India raked

    in US$ 25.44 billion turnover in 2007-08 as against US$ 16.99 billion in

    2006-07, a whopping growth rate of 49.73 per cent (according to the

    Credit Rating and Information Services of India). Organized retail has

    increased its share from 5 per cent of total retail sales in 2011 to 8 per

    cent in 2012. It is currently around 12 per cent. India has one of the

    largest numbers of retail outlets in the world. Of the 12 million retail

    outlets present in the country, nearly 5 million sell food and related

    products.

    Though the market has been dominated by unorganized players, the

    entry of domestic and international organized players is set to change the

    scenario. Per capita retailing space is about 2 sq. ft (compared to 16 sq.

    ft in the U S). India's per capita retailing space is thus the lowest in the

    world. Around 7% of the population in India is engaged in retailing, ascompared to 20% in the USA.

    Statistically, the global retail industry is witnessing a CAGR of 5.5% is

    slated to grow at the same rate till 2012. The above graph shows an

    overall trend of the global retail revenues.

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    22/39

    2.2.Big Bazaar retail life cycle

    The following graph shows the retail life cycle and we can say that Big

    Bazaar is currently at the Growth Stage.

    Introduction

    Growth

    Maturity

    Decline

    Time

    Cash flow

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    23/39

    Service Capacity versus Waiting Line Trade-Off

    Arrival and Service Profiles

    2.3. Service Time Distribution

    Another important feature of the waiting structure is the time the

    customer or unit spends with the server once the service has started.

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    24/39

    Waiting line formulas generally specify service rate as the capacity of

    the server in number of units per time period (such as 12 completions

    per hour) and not as service time, which might average five minutes

    each. A constant service time rule states that each service takes exactly

    the same time. As in constant arrivals, this characteristic is generally

    limited to machine-controlled operations.

    When service times are random, they can be approximated by the

    exponential distribution. When using the exponential distribution as an

    approximation of the service times, we will refer to as the average

    number of units or customers that can be served per time period. Line

    Structures As Exhibit shows, the flow of items to be serviced may go

    through a single line, multiple lines, or some mixtures of the two. The

    choice of format depends partly on the volume of customers served and

    partly on the restrictions imposed by sequential requirements governingthe order in which service must be performed.

    1. Single channel, single phase This is the simplest type of waiting line

    structure, and straightforward formulas are available to solve the

    problem for standard distribution patterns of arrival and service. When

    the distributions are nonstandard, the problem is easily solved by

    computer simulation. A typical example of a single-channel, single-

    phase situation is the one-person barbershop.

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    25/39

    2. Single channel, multiphase A car wash is an illustration because a

    series of ser-vices (vacuuming, wetting, washing, rinsing, drying,

    window cleaning, and parking) is per-formed in a fairly uniform

    sequence.

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    26/39

    3.1.Research Methodology

    The term waiting line system is used to indicate a collection of one or

    more waiting lines along with a server or collection of servers thatprovide service to these waiting lines. The example of ICA supermarket

    is taken for waiting line system discussed in this chapter include: 1) a

    single waiting line and multiple servers (fig.1), 2) multiple waiting lines

    (arranged by priority) and multiple servers (fig.2) , and 3) a single

    waiting line and a single server (fig.3). All results are presented in next

    chapter assuming that FIFO is the waiting line discipline in all waiting

    lines and the behavior of queues is jockey The supermarkets may consist

    of multiple units to perform same checkout operation of sales, which are

    usually set all together besides the entrance of the supermarket. Each

    unit contains one employee. This kind of a system is called a multiple-

    server system with single service facility, in other words multiplecheckouts counters (service units) with sales checkout as a service

    available in a system. There are two possible models for multiple-server

    system: Single-Queue Multiple-Server model, and Multiple-Queue

    Multiple-Server model.

    Using the same concept of model, the sales checkout operating units are

    all together taken as a series of servers that forms either single queue or

    multiple queues for sales checkout (single service facility) where the

    arrival rate of customers in a waiting line system and service rate per

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    27/39

    busy server are constants regardless of the state of the system (busy or

    idle).

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    28/39

    4. Analysis of Data

    Customers are served on a first-come, first-served (FIFO) basis as a

    salesman of checkout operation unit becomes free. The data has been

    collected for only two out of five servers on Wednesday (weekday) by

    using questionnaires (Appendix A). It was assumed that the customers

    crowd is more, on average, on weekday. Although the sales checkout

    unit has 5 parallel counters out of which 2 were observed (each of them

    has an individual salesman to deal with the customers in a queue), it is

    possible that some of the checkout units are idle. The data collected from

    questionnaires were tabulated in a spreadsheet in order to calculate the

    required parameters of queuing theory analysis (Appendix B). Firstly,

    the confidence intervals are computed to estimate service rate and arrival

    rate for the customers. Then the later first part of the analysis is done for

    the model involving one queue and 2 parallel servers (fig.1), whereas the

    second part is done by queuing simulation for second model involving 2

    queues for each corresponding parallel server (fig.2).

    We can estimate confidence intervals for average service rate and

    average arrival rate. Assuming service time and arrival time are id with

    N (0,1), then the

    95% confidence interval for arrival rate can be:

    Confidence Intervals

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    29/39

    Similarly, 95% confidence interval for service rate can be:

    Confidence Intervals for weekday:

    We have,

    Mean (service time) = 01:06 minutes per customer (read clock as

    min:sec)

    SD (service time) = 00:06 min

    Mean (arrival time) = 00:37 min per customer

    SD (arrival time) = 00:06 min

    And n = 41 customers

    95% Confidence Intervals for Service Time:

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    30/39

    Mean (service time) - 1.96 (SE(service time)) = 54 sec/customer

    Mean (service time) + 1.96 (SE(service time)) = 78 sec/customer

    SE = SD/sqrt(n)

    95% Confidence Intervals for Service Rate:

    1/[Mean(service time) + 1.96 (SE(service time))] = 0.01282 = 46

    customers/sec

    1/[Mean(service time) - 1.96 (SE(service time))] = 0.01852 = 67

    customers/sec** **(0.01852 sec *60 *60)

    95% Confidence Intervals for Arrival Time:

    Mean (arrival time)1.96 (SE(arrival time)) = 24 sec /customer

    Mean (arrival time) + 1.96 (SE(arrival time)) = 49 sec /customer

    95% Confidence Intervals for Arrival Rate:

    1/[Mean(arrival time) + 1.96 (SE(arrival time))] = 0.02041

    = 73 customers/sec**

    1/[Mean(arrival time) - 1.96 (SE(arrival time))] = 0.04167 = 150

    customers/sec **(0.02041 sec *60 *60)

    Interpretation of confidence intervals

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    31/39

    The confidence intervals show that 73 to 150 customers arrive in 2-

    server system within an hour whereas 46 to 67 customers are served.

    That means there are still some customers not being served and are

    waiting for their turn in a queue to be served. This is due to a service

    time provided by a server to the customers. The service time can vary

    between 54 sec to 78 sec per customer.

    Expected Queue Length

    We can find the expected length of queue by using empirical data. In

    survey, the number of customers waiting in a queue was observed

    ( Appendix B ) . The average of that number in a system is

    (1+1+3++2+0)/41 = 2.07 customers per minute on average waiting in

    a queue in asystem within 25 min of data collection time.

    Queuing Analysis

    On Wednesday (weekday), customers arrive at an average of 98

    customers per hour, and an average of 55 customers can be served per

    hour by a salesperson.

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    32/39

    Results for Weekday applying Queuing model 1 (fig.1)

    The parameters and corresponding characteristics in Queuing Model

    M/M/2, assuming system is in steady-state condition, are:

    c number of servers = 2

    arrival rate = 98 customers per hour

    serving rate = 55 customers per server per hour

    c (2) (55) = 110 (service rate for 2 servers)

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    33/39

    = /(c) =98 / 110 = 0.8909

    = = 1.7818

    Overall system utilization = = 89.09 %

    The probability that all servers are idle (Po) = 0.5769

    Average number of customers in the queue (Lq) = =6.8560

    Average time customer spends in the queue (Wq) = Lq/ = 0.0700 hours

    Interpretation of results for waiting line management

    The performance of the sales checkout service on weekday is

    sufficiently good. We can see that the probability for servers to be busy

    is 0.8909, i.e. 89.09%. The average number of customers waiting in a

    queue is Lq = 6.8560 customers per 2-server. The waiting time in a

    queue per server is Wq = 4.2 min which is normal time in a busy server.

    This estimate is not realistic as the model shows that the customers make

    a single queue and choose an available server. Hence we can consider

    each server with a queuing. M/M/1 queue is a useful approximate model

    when service times have standard deviation approximately equal to their

    means.

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    34/39

    Results for Weekend applying Queuing model 2 (fig.2)

    The parameters and corresponding characteristics inQueuing Model

    M/M/1, assuming system is in steady-state condition, are:

    c number of servers = 1

    arrival rate = 98 customers per hour for 2 servers i.e. 49 customers

    serving rate = 55 customers per server per hour

    = /(c) =(98 2)/ 55 = 0.8909

    = = 0.8909 (= in case of c = 1)

    Overall system utilization = = 89.09 %

    The probability that all servers are idle (Po) = 0.1091

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    35/39

    Average number of customers in the queue (Lq) = 7.2758

    Average time customer spends in the queue (Wq) = Lq/ = 0.1485 hours

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    36/39

    5. Conclusion

    The retail sector has played a phenomenal role throughout the world in

    increasing productivity of consumer goods and services. It is also the

    second largest industry in US in terms of numbers of employees and

    establishments. There is no denying the fact that most of the developed

    economies are very much relying on their retail sector as a locomotive of

    growth. The India Retail Industry is the largest among all the industries,

    accounting for over 10 per cent of the countrys GDP and around 8 per

    cent of the employment. The Retail Industry in India has come forth as

    one of the most dynamic and fast paced industries with several players

    entering the market. But all of them have not yet tasted success because

    of the heavy initial investments that are required to break even with

    other companies and compete with them. The India Retail Industry is

    gradually inching its way towards becoming the next boom industry.

    For launching Big bazaar in India city is companys mission to expand

    the business. For this purpose company is carrying out many marketing

    strategy. To study this marketing strategy I will be visiting the mall and

    also the manager to collect the data from them. Also Ill be collecting

    data from the customer as what strategies they liked.

    This paper reviews a waiting line management for Big Bazaar. The

    average queue length can be estimated simply from raw data from

    questionnaires by using the collected number of customers waiting in a

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    37/39

    queue each minute. We can compare this average with that of queuing

    model. Three different models are used to estimate a queue length: a

    single-queue multi-server model, single-queue single-server and

    multiple-queue multi-server model. In case of more than one queue

    (multiple queue), customers in any queue switch to shorter queue

    (jockey behavior of queue).Therefore, there are no analytical solutions

    available for multiple queues and hence queuing simulation is run to find

    the estimates for queue length and waiting time.

    The empirical analysis of queuing system of Big Bazaar supermarket is

    that they may not be very efficient in terms of resources utilization.

    Queues form and customers wait even though servers may be idle much

    of the time. The fault is not in the model or underlying assumptions. It is

    a direct consequence of the variability of the arrival and service

    processes. If variability could be eliminated, system could be designedeconomically so that there would be little or no waiting, and hence no

    need for queuing models.

    With the increasing number of customers coming to Big Bazaar for

    shopping, either for usual grocery or for some house wares, there is a

    trained employee serving at each service unit. Sales checkout service has

    sufficient number of employees (servers) which is helpful during the

    peak hours of weekdays. Other than these hours, there is a possibility of

    short Queues in a model and hence no need to open all checkouts

    counters for each hour. Increasing more than sufficient number of

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    38/39

    servers may not be the solution to increase the efficiency of the service

    by each service unit. When servers are analyzed with one queue for two

    parallel servers, the results are estimated as per server whereas when

    each server is analyzed with its individual queue, the results computed

    from simulation are for each server individually.

  • 8/14/2019 The Study of Waiting Line Management With Reference to Big Bazar

    39/39

    Bibliography

    Bhatti, S. A., Bhatti, N. A. (1998), Operations Research anIntroduction, Department of Computer Science, Oxford University

    Press, pp. 315356

    Hillier, F. S., Lieberman, G. J. (2001), Introduction to OperationsResearch, McGraw-Hill higher education, 7

    thedition, pp. 8348.

    Karmakar,R(2012) Managing Resources in Retailing, StrategicManagement journal pp 21-33.

    Agarwal P., Laney,C.(2011) Waiting Line analytics, InternationalJournal of business Management pp 112-134.

    Rathore, A.(2013) Resource Recombination in ManagementReview pp 12-24.