The New Security - Post "9/11"

Wivenhoe Management Group

THE NEW SECURITYTHE NEW SECURITYPost “9/11”Post “9/11”

AN INTRODUCTION TO SECURITY

ENGINEERING FOR ARCHITECTS


Security TodaySecurity Today

• America is vulnerable to a terrorist attack

• Implementing proper Security is a challenge

• There are many types of threats

• Countermeasures must be effective


The American ChallengeThe American Challenge

• Logistics

• Geography

• History

• Response

• Cost

• Threat Level

• Human Factor

• Apathy


Post “9/11”Post “9/11”

• The application of New Security requires specialized countermeasures to specific threats

• Countermeasures may range from criminal background checks to sophisticated electronic systems such as facial recognition controlled access systems.


Typical Counter MeasuresTypical Counter Measures

Security Management Systems (Access Control)

CCTV Camera SurveillancePerimeter Access ControlVehicle TrackingHead End Monitoring Techniques


The New SecurityThe New SecurityPost “9/11”Post “9/11”

Three Important Aspects Of The New Security:

• Vulnerability Assessments (VA’S)• Security At Concept Stage• Importance Of Security Design Criteria


Vulnerability AssessmentsVulnerability Assessments

What is a Vulnerability Assessment (VA)?

• A Quick History

• What is the Purpose?

• What are the Benefits?

• Government Security Directives


An Analysis Of A VAAn Analysis Of A VA

• Identify Threat Level

• Identify Critical Assets

• Assess Present/Planned Security

• Evaluate Consequences

• Recommendations On Acceptable Risk


A Quick HistoryA Quick History

• 1998 Identification of 8 Key Infrastructure that were considered particularly vulnerable to terrorist attack and which would have significant consequences on the operation of the United States


Key InfrastructureKey Infrastructure


Federal ActionFederal Action

• EPA Mandate 2002

• State Of New Jersey– Attorney General’s Office

• Homeland Security– Federal Level– State Level

• Federal Funding


Purpose Of VA’SPurpose Of VA’S

• A properly performed Vulnerability Assessment will identify the weaknesses of a facility to specific threats.

• Threats may be external (terrorists, criminals, etc) or may be internal (employees, contractors, etc)


Industry QuotesIndustry Quotes “Every decade, the architecture profession takes on a new

responsibility. In the 1960s, it was urban planning. During the ‘Seventies we took on environmental design, and the ‘Eighties were all about development and design/build. We had to fully integrate computers and the web into our practices in the ‘Nineties. In whatever we’re calling this current decade, architects (and their consultants) are now being asked to consider the security of the areas in and around their buildings. Our designs, and more importantly, their occupants, are vulnerable to not just terrorism, but also crime, and civic/natural disasters. The public is looking to the government and other institutions to assure their safety in the built environment. These entities are turning to their professionals. This is the new imperative for our practices. “


Industry Quote By….Industry Quote By….

Regan Young, AIA

Principal

Regan Young England Butera

Mt. Holly, New Jersey


Benefits Of A VABenefits Of A VA

• In simple terms, the benefits of a VA can be stated as follows:– Identification of Appropriate Threat Level– Identification of Critical Assets– Measurement of Consequences– Sound Recommendations

Security Improvements Mitigation


Without Performing A VAWithout Performing A VA

• What is Threat Level?• What are the Critical

Assets?• What is Likely to

Happen?

• What will be the Response?

• What are the Likely Consequences?

• Who will be held Responsible?



Industry QuotesIndustry Quotes “In the light of various incidents following the terrible

events of “9/11,” it was felt that this school district should move forward with a major upgrade to its existing security. We were advised to commence with a Vulnerability Assessment (VA) that would, if nothing else, identify our strengths and weaknesses in security from all angles. It was good advice, as the results of the VA provided exceptional insight and important data that has allowed the school district to identify major issues on a priority basis, select systems that will be both cost-effective and functional, and which now provides a Basis of Design for all future school construction.”


Industry Quotes (Cont.)Industry Quotes (Cont.)

“There is no question that knowing the relevant threat level, understanding exactly what your critical assets are, assessing the likely risk and consequences, and making intelligent choices based on such information, provides far more effective security than if we had simply relied on a local contractor to install a security system”



Mark Cowell

Superintendent

Pemberton School District

Pemberton, New Jersey


RecommendationRecommendation

• It is strongly recommended that every project undertake an appropriate VA

• The VA should follow one of the standards RAM, CCPS, ASIS, NFPA, or Industry Best Practices when supervised by experienced and certified independent security professionals


Security at the Concept or Security at the Concept or SchematicSchematic Stage Stage• Apply CPTED principles throughout

• Don’t build in security problems that have to be overcome with expensive electronic security systems

• Consider appropriate circulation routes inside the building to control access

• Security Partitioning


Industry QuotesIndustry Quotes

“The cost for security will be significantly reduced with proper architectural design, particularly at the concept stage”



Ronald S. Libengood, CPP CEO SecuraComm Consulting, Inc. Pittsburgh, PA


Security FactorsSecurity Factors

• Location

• CPTED Considerations

• Environment

• Structural Design

• Planned Use

• Special Circumstances



Concept Security ConsiderationsConcept Security Considerations

• Access

• Egress

• Adjacent Property

• Traffic Flow

• Parking

• Hazmat

• Deliveries

• Perimeter

• Exposure

• Special Requirements



StatementStatement

It is again strongly recommended that every architect consider bringing-in a Security Professional at the Concept Stage to provide experienced advice on Security



“Security design involves more than the application of electronic technology at the end of the architectural process - diverse issues arise during all phases of the project.


Industry Quotes (Cont.)Industry Quotes (Cont.)

“Code requirements for means of egress and the architect’s desire for the unimpeded flow of people and materials throughout the building are diametrically opposed to the demands of security.

The resolution of this conflict is critical to the success of the project - the key is to solve the right problem at the right time.”



Peter James, AIA Nadaskay Kopelson Architects Morristown, New Jersey


Security Design CriteriaSecurity Design Criteria

• Definition

The Evaluation of Basic Concepts in Security to Provide the Necessary Level of Protection for the Total Facility

Most Important Aspect


Bad Design CriteriaBad Design Criteria


Good Design CriteriaGood Design Criteria

• Provides a solid base of reasoning for the actual security design

• Provides continuity

• Minimizes liability

• Avoids negligence



“When the difference between a properly designed Security System, and a flawed Security System design can be a person’s life, it is frankly irresponsible for any individual involved in the security design process, to employ anything less than proper security design criteria based on experience, professional understanding, and established risk expertise.”



Steven S. Wilder Principal Sorrenson & Wilder Associates Bradley, IL


Industry ExampleIndustry Example

• Recent School District where No Criteria was established for the CCTV System– Camera locations– Camera Performance– Camera Monitoring


Determining Good Design CriteriaDetermining Good Design Criteria

• Very Simple

– Utilize security professionals that have substantial experience with Security Industry Requirements, Guidelines, and Individual Client Site/Facility Needs


Presentation SummaryPresentation Summary

• Vulnerability Assessments

• Security at the Concept Stage

• Importance of Security Design Criteria


FINAL STATEMENTFINAL STATEMENT

• IF WE LEAVE YOU WITH NO OTHER THOUGHT TONIGHT IT SHOULD BE THAT POST “9/11” SECURITY IS A SERIOUS BUSINESS

• PLEASE DON’T TAKE IT LIGHTLY


QuestionsQuestions

Some questions that you might want to consider:1 What is the Impact of Security on Cost

2 What is the Impact of Security on Building Design

3 What is a Credible Threat


Industry QuoteIndustry Quote

“We are in fact designing the nervous system of the building. Its function is the detection of threats so that pain can be avoided or lessened. The instigation of pro-active or defensive action is often necessary to protect people, property and buildings. The ramifications of this extend to all aspects of building design, whether it is integrating security systems with other control systems to create a smart building, or increasing the structural strength of the building.”


Summary SlideSummary Slide

• POST “9/11” SECURITY IS NOW AN INTRINSIC PART OF BUILDING DESIGN

Documents

The New Security - Post "9/11"