29
Norwegian Ministry of Finance The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth - avoiding the resource curse Siv Jensen, Minister of Finance Columbia University, 15 April 2015

The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal: Startside

The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

- avoiding the resource curse

Siv Jensen, Minister of Finance

Columbia University, 15 April 2015

Page 2: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

Outline

Petroleum revenues and fund mechanism

Governance

Investment strategy

Fund performance

Responsible management

2

Page 3: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

Discovery of oil in 1969 – the Ekofisk oil field

3

Photo: Kjetil Alsvik/Conoco Phillips

Petroleum revenues and fund mechanism

Page 4: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance4

Blessing or curse:

Poor performance in resource-rich countries

Transmission channels

• Dutch disease – lack of

fiscal discipline

• Bad investments - fund

invested domestically

• Loss of focus on structural

policy

• Poor governance & weak

institutions (rent-seeking )

Page 5: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

Petroleum revenues are temporary and volatile

Petroleum revenues not income in

traditional sense

Income stemming from depletion of

non-renewable natural resources

Transform windfall gain to permanent

increase in consumption

Need for separating current accrual

from spending

5

Extraction Path

Consumption path before

petroleum discovery

Consumption path after

discovery

Timet0

Necessitates saving a

large part of petroleum revenues

Petroleum revenues and fund mechanism

Page 6: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

GPFG is fully integrated with fiscal policy

6

Fund

Petroleum revenues

State Budget

Transfer to finance non-oil deficit

Fiscal policy guideline

Over time spend Fund real return

(estimated at 4 percent)

Return on investmentsPetroleum revenues

Non-oil revenues

Expenditures

Petroleum revenues and fund mechanism

Page 7: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

1970 1990 2010 2030

Norway

EU-28

Denmark

Sweden

7

Source: Ministry of Finance (National Budget 2015)

Number of elderly (67 years and above) in

proportion to the number of people of working age

(20 – 66). Percent

Percent of trend GDP for mainland-Norway

2060-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

1970 2000 2030 2060

State’s netcash flow

Structual budgetdeficit

Estimatedreal return

Sharp increase in public pension expenditures coincides with

declining funding contribution from the GPFG – a long term

challenge to government finances

Petroleum revenues and fund mechanism

Page 8: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

Outline

Petroleum revenues and fund mechanism

Governance

Investment strategy

Fund performance

Responsible management

8

Page 9: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Governance structure marked by clear lines of

responsibilities

9

The Storting – Norwegian Parliament

Ministry of Finance

Norges Bank (NBIM)

Operational manager

Government Pension Fund Act

National Budget

Annual Report to the Storting

Material changes presented to Parliament prior to implementation

Management mandate

Regulation on risk management, reporting and responsible

investments

Quarterly and annual reports

Investment strategy advice

Governance

Page 10: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

High degree of transparency in Fund management

Prerequisite to ensuring broad support for

and trust in the management of Fund

Management mandate states; …greatest

possible degree of transparency within the

limits defined by a sound execution of the

management assignment

→ Reporting

→ Holding lists

→ Voting records

Contributes to a robust investment strategy → Anchoring of risk profile with stakeholders

10 Governance

Page 11: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

Outline

Petroleum revenues and fund mechanism

Governance

Investment strategy

Fund performance

Responsible management

11

Page 12: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

Investment strategy premised on Fund objective,

investment beliefs and Fund characteristics

Highest possible long-term financial return within a moderate level of

risk.

The investment strategy is in particular characterized by:

Diversification

Harvesting risk premiums

Exploitation of the Fund's long-term horizon

A moderate degree of active management

Responsible management

Cost efficiency

A clear governance structure

Investment strategy12

Page 13: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

13

1998

40 % equities

2000

Some emerging

equity markets*

2002

Non-government

bonds

2004

More emerging markets

**,

Ethical guidelines

2005

Inflation-linked

bonds

2006 2007

High-yield bonds,

Commodity derivaties,

New risk management

requirements

60 % equities,

small-cap

2008

Real estate

All emerging equity

markets*

The investment strategy of the Fund has been developed

gradually

New framework for

responsible investments

2011

First investment in real

estate

2012

New geographical

distribution for the

equity and bond index

2014

*Benchmark index

**Investment universe

Investment strategy

Page 14: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

The investment strategy

GPFG strategic benchmark index

Global Equities(excl. Norway)

«Market weights»

60 %

Global Fixed Income(excl. Norway)

70 % Govt. (GDP weights)30 % Corporates (Market weights)

35-40 %

Global Real Estate(excl. Norway)

0-5 %

14

FTSE Group

Index vendor

Barclays

Index vendor

IPD

Index vendor

Investment strategy

Page 15: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Broad geographical distribution of Fund investmentsActual investments at yearend 2014

15

Source: Norges Bank

Investment strategy

Page 16: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal: Tekst med liggende bilde

Real estate investments

First investment in unlisted real estate completed in

April 2011 – Regent Street, London

First unlisted property investment in the US in

February 2013 – New York City, Washington D.C.

and Boston

Objective: Global real estate portfolio

16

Photo: The Crown Estate

Investment strategy

Foto: Boston PropertiesFoto: Boston Properties

Foto: Anton Grassl/Esto

Foto: Bill Horsman

Foto: Eastdil Secured

Page 17: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

The Fund holds significant ownership shares in global

marketsYearend 2014

Average holdings in equity markets Average holdings in fixed income markets

17

Sources: Norges Bank and Ministry of Finance

Investment strategy

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

1.2

1.4

1.6

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

1.2

1.4

1.6

200

2

200

3

200

4

200

5

200

6

200

7

200

8

200

9

201

0

201

1

201

2

201

3

201

4

Developed markets

Emerging markets

Total

0.0

0.4

0.8

1.2

1.6

2.0

0.0

0.4

0.8

1.2

1.6

2.0

200

2

200

3

200

4

200

5

200

6

200

7

200

8

200

9

201

0

201

1

201

2

201

2

201

4

Government & Government related bonds

Corporate bonds (including securitized)

Total

Page 18: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Investment strategy – Equity proportion

No “optimal” equity allocation

Return and risk considerations

Single most important decision for total

portfolio risk

High risk bearing capacity – The Fund

is highly resilient to short-term return

volatility

Large fund Harvesting risk premia to

a large extend confined to «classical»

listed equity and fixed income markets1

10

100

1,000

10,000

100,000

1

10

100

1,000

10,000

100,000

18

99

19

05

19

11

19

17

19

23

19

29

19

35

19

41

19

47

19

53

19

59

19

65

19

71

19

77

19

83

19

89

19

95

20

01

20

07

Equities

Fixed Income

18

Source: Dimson, Marsh and Staunton

Real return measured in US $

Investment strategy

Page 19: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

New assessment of real estate and infrastructure investments

We will assess whether the 5 pct. limit

on real estate should be increased and

if we should open up for

infrastructure investments

Has appointed and expert group:

Stijn Van Nieuwerburgh, NYU

Richard Stanton, UC Berkeley

Leo De Bever, ex. CEO AIMCo

The government will conclude in the

annual report to be presented in the

spring of 2016.

19

Equities

60 %

Bonds

37.8 %

Real estate

2.2 %

Page 20: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

Outline

Petroleum revenues and fund mechanism

Governance

Investment strategy

Fund performance

Responsible management

20

Page 21: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

GPFG is among the largest funds in the world

6,431

0 %

20 %

40 %

60 %

80 %

100 %

120 %

140 %

160 %

180 %

200 %

220 %

240 %

260 %

280 %

-

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014

Fund size as share of GDP (excl. oil) (rha)

21

Sources: Norges Bank and Ministry of Finance

Market value development 1996 -2014.

NOK billion (lha) and per cent of GDP (excl. oil) (rha)

Fund performance

Page 22: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

Outline

Petroleum revenues and fund mechanism

Governance

Investment strategy

Fund performance

Responsible management

22

Page 23: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Framework for responsible management

23

Ministry of Finance

Norges Bank

(Central Bank)

Council on Ethics

General framework on

responsible management

Responsible

management

Recommendations on

observation & exclusion

ReportingReporting

Exchange of information

Recommendations

Management framework

& GuidelinesGuidelines

Responsible management

Page 24: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

Exercise of ownership rights

Exercise of ownership rights is based on

international recognised principles

Overall purpose of active ownership is to

safeguard the Fund’s financial values

Strategic focus areas

→ well-functioning, legitimate and efficient markets

→ equal treatment of shareholders

→ shareholder influence and board accountability

→ children’s rights

→ climate change risk management

→ water management

24

Corporate governance

Environmental and

social issues

Responsible management

Markets

Page 25: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

Exclusion and observation of companies

Product-based exclusion

→ produce weapons that violate fundamental humanitarian

principles in their normal use

→ produce tobacco

Conduct-based exclusion – serious or systematic

violations of fundamental ethical norms

→ human rights including child labour

→ individuals’ rights in situations of war or conflict

→ gross corruption

→ severe environmental damage

→ other particularly severe violations of fundamental ethical

norms

25 Responsible management

Page 26: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

Fossil-fuel investments and ownership tools

Report from expert group

Public consultation process

The Ministry’s assessments in Report

No. 21:

Strengthen ownership and dialogue

New conduct based exclusion criteria

26

Page 27: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

27

Page 28: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

28

Summary

• Norway has established a robust and long-term fiscal framework that integrates oil revenueso Separate income and spending of oil revenues

o Invest surplus oil savings abroad

o A well-designed fund mechanism serves as a tool to support wise and long-term budget decisions

• A sound governance framework is a prerequisite for good management over timeo Clear lines of responsibility

• Transparent management and an investment strategy with widespread supporto High degree of transparency

o A strategy developed “step by step” based on comprehensive professional assessments

o Risk should be managed, controlled and communicated

Page 29: The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth Jensen Presentation_April... · Norwegian Ministry of Finance Engelsk mal: Startside The Management of the Norwegian Petroleum Wealth

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Engelsk mal:Tekst uten kulepunkter

Links

Ministry of Finance

www.regjeringen.no/en/dep/fin

Government Pension Fund

www.government.no/gpf

Norges Bank Investment Management

www.nbim.no/en

Council on Ethics

www.etikkradet.no/en

29

Contact details

Norwegian Ministry of Finance

Asset Management Department

P.O.Box 8008 Dep

NO-0030 Oslo, Norway

Visiting Address: Akersg. 40

Telephone: +47 22 24 41 63

Fax: +47 22 24 95 91

E-mail: [email protected]