47
IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 1 > Dokumentname > 23.11.2004 The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics H. Försching, R. Voß email : [email protected]

The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 1 >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics

H. Försching, R. Voß email : [email protected]

Page 2: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Outline

IntroductionAeroelastic problemsStatus of unsteady aerodynamic research at C. Possio‘s timeThe rising need to model compressibility in aeronauticsPossio‘s first research work in 1937The Possio Equation (1938)Further contributions to unsteady aerodynamics (1938-1940)Contributions outside aircraft aerodynamics (1940-1943)Extension of C. Possio‘s work after World War IIConclusion : Legacy and research today

Page 3: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 3 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

References

Garrick, Reed III (1981) : …….„There followed shortly afterward two short outstanding contributions by Camillo Possio in Italy. In 1938 he applied the acceleration potential to the two-dimensional nonstationary problem and arrived at an integral equation (Possio’s equation) the solution of which gives the loading over a flat plate airfoil in an airstream for a known motion of the plate, i.e., for a given downwash. …… Possio also gave an outline of the parallel problem for a supersonic mainstream. Possio’s brief brilliant career ended with his death during the war years.”

My experience : C. Possio’s 1938 paper “ L’azione aerodinamica sulprofilo oscillante in un fludio compressible a velocita iposonara” , (L’Aerotechnica), is among the 5 most cited papers about unsteady aerodynamics.

H.G. Küssner (1940) : „The oscillating wing for 0<Ma<1 has been investigated up to now in just a single investigation for the two dimensional problem [reference to C. Possio]”.

Page 4: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 4 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Camillo Possio – 1913 - 1945

Born on October 30th 1913 in TorinoStudent at Politechnico di Torino, Teachers : Modesto Panetti and Carlo Ferrari1936 laurea degree industrial engineering1937 laurea degree aeronautics1937 first scientific papers1938 Possio’s equationProfessor at Politechnico di Torino teaching

gas dynamics and thermodynamics Military service until 1940 teaching at Torino1939 3D unsteady flow and military research1940–1943 : Further research on 3D unsteady

flow, on windtunnel interference, hydrodynamic and acoustic problems

17 scientific publications

April 5th, 1945 : killed by an air attack on Torino

Page 5: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 5 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Aeroelastic Problems : The aeroelastic triangle

elasticforces

F DA DS

D

LR

SS

D = Divergence F = FlutterR = Control Reversal DA = Dynamic ResponseL = Lift Distribution DS = Dynamic StabilitySS = Static Stability

inertialforces

aerodynamic forces

Page 6: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 6 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Handley Page 0/400, tail+fuselage

Junkers F90 (1938), tail

Tacoma bridge, 1940

Historical Flutter Accidents

Junkers F13 –Stall (1930)

Page 7: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 7 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Sailplane Flutter

Page 8: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 8 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

[ ] [ ] [ ]unstAAM

LA +=⎟⎟

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛−= 0and

Flutter calculation as an Eigenvalue problem

⎩⎨⎧

=++−=++MkIhSLhkShm

h

h

ααα

αα

α

&&&&&&&&

iii

Qqqdt

d=

∂∂

−⎥⎦

⎤⎢⎣

⎡∂∂ LL&

Lagrange’s equation :

0

( )2... .... ( ) ( )

( ) unst

h tDOFs u t u u t

tα⎛ ⎞

= = +⎜ ⎟⎝ ⎠

0( ) i tunstu t u u e ω= +

Approach in frequency domain :

Eigenvalue problem, which needs knowledge of

• structural dynamic oscillations (mass, stiffness, damping)

• aerodynamic lift and moment, induced by motion of the structure

Page 9: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 9 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

The Key Role of Modelling Unsteady Motion-InducedAerodynamics

Figure : Ground Vibration Test (Do 17, 1942)

Modelling of the structure reachedsoon a sufficient capability, slenderwings were treated as beam-likestructures. Geometrically morecomplex modes were measured in Ground Vibration Tests, see figure.

So for flutter calculations since 1920 the determination of forcedoscillation-induced aerodynamic was the key problem.1937 -1943 C. Possiocontributed to progress in this field.

Page 10: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 10 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

First unsteady aerodynamic theories - incompressible

2 VL V Tπω

⋅= = ⋅

Wake vorticesReduced frequency :

k = ω l / V

Circulation is constantCVdsΓ = ∫uv v

Airfoil motion induces a change ΔΓ

change – ΔΓ = ε in the wake

:Lift L Vρ= Γ

V

Prandtl 1918

V

Phase-shifts

Birnbaum 1922

Page 11: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 11 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Increase of Speed in Aeronautics – a Grand Challengewith great influence and merit of C. Possio

1934 : Macchi-Castoldi MC72 water plane (709 kmh record flight)

1937 : Me109 (611 kmh)

1939 : He178, 700 kmh, the world‘s first jetpowered flight, 1942 : He280, 900 kmh

Page 12: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 12 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Ma < 0.8

Ma = 0.8

Ma >1Ma = 1 normal shock

Ma =1.2

Ma < 1

Ma >1Front bow shock weak shock

Growing complexity of forced unsteady compressible flow –in the 1930 years

Ma < 0.3 Laplace equation

Wave equation

Wave equation, 2 retarded wavesMa > 1.2

Mixed flow, no models

Mixed flow, steadycharacteristic models

Page 13: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 13 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

WithConferencepresidentGeneral Arturo Crocco

During a session at Villa Farnesina

The 1935 Volta Conferenceof the Royal Italian Academy of Sciences

(29 Sept. – 6 Oct. 1935 at Accademia dei Lincei, Roma).A milestone for modern compressible flow research

• Knowledge aboutcompressible fluids(gas dynamics) well developed before1930

• Applications onlyfor steam turbinesand ballisticprojectiles

• highest speeds forpropeller blade tips

Topic : high speed in aeronautics

Page 14: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 14 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Some topics of the 1935 Volta Conferenceand their influence of C. Possio‘s work

V. Karman calculated minimum wave drag shapes for axisymmetric bodies,Pistolesi derived Prandtl-Glauert- and other corrections for compressibility in subsonic and a similar rule for supersonic flows. But these were not applicable for unsteady flows.Busemann presented for the first time in history the concept of the swept wing as mechanism to reduce the large drag increase in high speed flight. Analysis of swept wings needs 3D theories, but Busemann’s concept was not significantly recognised. Ackeret presented subsonic and supersonic windtunneldesigns. Italian high-speed windtunnels in a new research center at Guidonia near Rome, were constructed under consultation of Ackeret. Possio later investigated windtunnelwall effects.Prandtl sketched a solution to attack the problems of compressible flow by the acceleration potential. The pressure jump across an oscillating lifting surface is directly proportional to the corresponding jump of the acceleration potential.Thiswas very important for Possio’s work.

22 / 1subsonicLc Maπα≈ −

sup 24 / 1ersonicLc Maα≈ −

Page 15: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 15 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Ma =1.2 Ma < 1

Ma >1 Front bow shock

weak shock

C. Possio’s first scientific publications (1937) –Development of a 3D streamfunction formulation for

rotational flowsSchlieren visualisation,

density gradient

V rotV T s× = − ⋅∇uv uv

Shadowgraph visualisation, 2nd deriv. density

The supersonic flow is constant in front of theshock. For curved shocks, shock strength and thus entropy increase behind the shock differs.

L. Crocco derived a relation between curl of velocity and entropy gradient behind the shock, and introduced a stream function for calculation of 2D and axisymmetric rotational flows.

C. Possio extended this concept to 3D flows.

Page 16: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 16 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

a Δt

v Δt

+P(x,z)

a Δt2

a Δt 1

ξ

η

arctan(1/β)

Ma > 1

Unsteady Supersonic Flow

C. Possio derived a wave equation for the velocity potential and as a basic solution the potential of an acoustic source of pulsating strength moving rectilinear with supersonic velocity. In supersonic flow, due to disturbance propagation, the effect of a single source pulse is felt at two different retarded times t1,2

( ) ( )222

2 2

2 2 2 2 2 22

2 2 2 2

( ) 0

1( ) , 0

( )

1 * 02

: ,/

( 1) 2 0

,

div vt

Dv v v v p and rotvDt t

p

a t t

Linearisation V i thus VxMa V a

Ma MaMax y V x t V t

x y

v

ρ ρ

ρρ ρ

ϕ ϕ

ϕ ϕ ϕ ϕ

ϕ

∂+ =

∂∂

= + ∇ = − ∇ ⋅⋅ ⋅⋅ =∂

=

⎧ ⎫∇Φ∂ Φ ∂⎪ ⎪ΔΦ − + ∇Φ + ∇Φ ∇ =⎨ ⎬∂ ∂⎪ ⎪⎩ ⎭= ∇Φ = + ∇ ⋅⋅⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ⋅Φ = +

=

∂ ∂ ∂ ∂− − + + =

∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂

v vv v v

v v

( ) ( )( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

( ) ( ) ( )

22 22

2 22

1,2 2

2 2

, ,,

1

at

a t x V t y

Ma x x yt

aMa

ξ η τ

τ ξ τ η

ξ ξ β ηβ

β

=− − − − − − −⎡ ⎤⎣ ⎦

− − − −Δ =

= −

m

Page 17: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 17 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Unsteady Supersonic FlowBy derivation he obtained the induced velocity component w normal to the flat plate, representing the thin airfoil. He combined the effects of two sources with infinitesimal small distance to the upper and lower side of the plate, and thus obtained the effect of a doublet singularity of pulsating strength. The unsteady supersonic flow was then modelled by a doublet distribution of varying strength along the flat plate chord.

Possio’s paper on this topic was published in “Pontificia Accademia Scientiarium Acta “, and the summary was written in Latin. Perhaps this is one reason, that - unlike others of his papers -it is not among those which have soon been reviewed or even translated in Germany. It appeared already in 1937, but it was referenced only 5 years later for the first time by v. Borbely 1942 in a different method. Results are from Schwarz and Jordan, 1944.

Ka = lift due to heave oscillation

____ in-phase

_ _ _ out-of-phase

Ma > 1 : Ka‘ = 0

Page 18: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 18 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Unsteady Subsonic CompressibleFlow Possio‘s Equation

Page 19: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 19 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

a Δt

v Δt

Ma = 0.79, ω* = 2.0,

ϕ = unsteady velocitypotential component

2 2 2 2 2 22

2 2 2 2

2 2

2 0

(1 )

Ma Max y V x t V t

Ma

ϕ ϕ ϕ ϕβ

β

∂ ∂ ∂ ∂+ − − =

∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂

= −

Unsteady Subsonic CompressibleFlow – Wave Equation for Velocity Potential ϕ

Page 20: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 20 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Possio‘s Equation – Acceleration potential

Dv Dv dppDt Dt

ρ ψρ

= −∇ ⇒ = −∇ = ∇∫ 2 p pVt

ψρ

∂Φ −= + = −

( )

2 2 2 2 2 22

2 2 2 2

2 2 2

2 2 22

(2)202

2 2

2

(1 ) 2 0

1 0,.... : ,.... ,....

4 *( , ) , exp ( )/ 2

( ) (/ 2 ** ,....

D

Ma MaMax y V x t V t

Transformation x x Vt y y t tax y t

Ma xx y a V i t i H Rl

xl MaRV

ψ ψ ψ ψ

ψ ψ ψ

ω ξψ ξ η ωβ β η

ξ βω ωωβ

∂ ∂ ∂ ∂− + − − =

∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂

∂ ∂ ∂+ − = = − = =

∂ ∂ ∂

⎛ ⎞− ∂= + ⋅⎜ ⎟ ∂⎝ ⎠

− +⋅= =

22)

,.... 1/ 2

yMa

β−

= −

vortex singularity can not be used as basic solution forcompressible flow Prandtl‘s acceleration potential ψ

in a shock-free flowfield, ψ is continuous, in contrast to ϕ

Page 21: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 21 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Possio‘s Equation

* 2

2

*

/ 2 *

2/ 2

( ) * *(2) (2)/ 21 02 2

*( )*(2)/ 20 2

( )( ) ( ,0, ) ( ) , ,/ 2

14 / 2 / 2

4 / 2

li t

l

Ma xil

xil

xw x w x t e p K Ma dV l

x Ma x Ma xK e i Ma H H

x l l

Ma xi e Hl

ω

ω ξβ

ω ξ

ω ω ξξ ξρ

ξ ω ξ ω ξβ ξ β β

ω ξωβ β

+−

−⋅

−−

⎛ ⎞−= ⋅ = Δ ⋅ ⋅⎜ ⎟

⎝ ⎠⎧ ⎫⎡ ⎤⎛ ⎞ ⎛ ⎞− − −⎪ ⎪= ⋅ −⎢ ⎥⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟⎨ ⎬− ⋅ ⋅⎢ ⎥⎝ ⎠ ⎝ ⎠⎪ ⎪⎣ ⎦⎩ ⎭

−+

*

2 / 2uix le du

ωξ β− ⋅

−∞

⎧ ⎫⎛ ⎞⎪ ⎪⎜ ⎟⎨ ⎬⎝ ⎠⎪ ⎪⎩ ⎭

l/2 l/2

x

y

η

α

V

Page 22: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 22 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Possio‘s Equation

01

( ) cot sin , : cos /2 n

np A A n with lθθ θ θ ξ

=

Δ = + =∑

0 1 1 22 2 2

1 1,2 2 16 2L M

L Mc A A c A AlV l V

π πρ ρ

⎛ ⎞ ⎛ ⎞= = + = = +⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟⎝ ⎠ ⎝ ⎠

• Name „Possio‘s Equation“ was introduced by H.G. Küssner

• Possio presented the equation in real- and imag. part, not in complex form

• the Kernel function, involving Hankel cylindrical functions, is singular forx = ξ, Possio computed the Kernel for a reduced spectrum of frequencies and for the Mach numbers 0,25, 0,50, 0,70

• first numerical solutions by using only 3 coefficients A0, A1, A2

• series expansion for Δp in chordwise direction :

Page 23: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 23 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Possio‘s first results – from the original paper

--- : Ma=0,

(a) : Ma=0.25,

(b) : Ma=0.50,

(c) : Ma=0.70

l/2 l/2

x

y

η

α

V

1P P P PL

l c V c d c V c l dcl V dt l V dtη π η π απ απ

π η π η π α π α• •

⎛ ⎞ ⎛ ⎞∂ ∂ ∂ ∂⎛ ⎞ ⎛ ⎞= + + +⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟∂ ∂ ∂ ∂⎝ ⎠ ⎝ ⎠⎝ ⎠ ⎝ ⎠

Page 24: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 24 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Transfer of Possio‘s original results to German Coefficients (Schwarz 1939)

// 4P Pb

V c d V ckV dt lπ ηω ω

π η π α• •

⎛ ⎞∂ ∂⎛ ⎞= − + ⎜ ⎟⎜ ⎟∂ ∂⎝ ⎠⎝ ⎠

Kb// = imag. Lift due to pitching

l/4

Δα

Possio‘s solution was restricted in frequency range.

More complex modes, like flaposcillations need more than 3 A-coefficients

Soon after Possio‘s break-through,also in Germany research on unsteady compressible aerody-namics started (not in othercountries), but first his results weresimply used for flutter analysis

Page 25: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 25 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Improved Solution Procedures for Possio‘s EquationDietze in 1942 developed the kernel function in terms of its relatively simple counterpart from incompressible flow, which had been presented by Possio in his paper too (mainly determined by tabulated Sine- and Cosine integrals). Starting from the incompressible solution, he derived an iteration procedure, consisting of successive approximations to an integral equation, the kernel of which is the difference ΔK between compressible and incompressible kernels. His results compare well with Possio’soriginal ones (symbols in figure). Convergence is improved, but ΔK is still singular. This disadvantage was later overcome by Fettis in 1952, by splitting the kernel into singular and a remaining part.

Page 26: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 26 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

1 Ma = 0

2 Ma = 0.5

3 Ma = 0.7

4 Ma = 0.8

5 Ma = 0.9

6 Ma = 0.95

1

2

34

56

Re(Δcp)

1 2 34

5

6

Im(Δcp)

ω* = 0.50

0.75 l

Δα

Possio‘s Equation – Computation of control surfaceoscillations using improved numerical methods

Page 27: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 27 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

The Need to include 3D Effects for Oscillating Wings

watertunnel

Prandtl‘sLifting Line Theory

Smoke visualisation

Until 1930 flutter calculations wereapplied adopting stripwise 2D unsteadyaerodynamic loads.

This became questionable for :

• Wings with aspect ratio (= area/chord) values < 5, esp. Tailplanes

• swept wings

Page 28: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 28 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

0 π x2π

Oscillating 3D Wings – a great Challenge

Unsteady (adapted from Sears)Bound vortices free vortices

Mathematical modelling and computation of the system of interacting bound and free vortices with spanwise varying strengthwas a complicated task, and resulted in different approximatemethods of Italian, German, British and American researchers :

Cicala, Possio, Küssner, Sears, Jones (1935-1940).

Incompressible Flow (Laplace –equation, vortex singularities), elliptic or rectangular wing planforms.

Page 29: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 29 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Possio‘s unsteady 3D Theory

x

yz

V

Σ

Γ Γ+ΔΓ

ΔΓ

Possio modelled bound and free vorticesseparately by vortex distributions(incompressible flow) γ (ξ,η), the strengthof which is series expanded in trigonometric series in x and y, and theoscillation velocity w as well. Choice of an elliptic planform simplified numericalspanwise integration.

Magnitude and phase of lift dueto heave oscillation of a wingwith elliptic planform. Resultsfrom different theories, 1943

Page 30: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 30 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Validation of incompressible unsteady aerodynamictheories - Watertunnel measurements of unsteadypressures

Flap rotation

First unsteadypressuremeasurments foroscillating airfoils, Drescher 1939

Page 31: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 31 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

C. Possio‘s work on Windtunnel Wall InterferenceC. Possio demonstrated that for an oscillating wing model disturbances from windtunnel walls are decreasing with frequency like 1/ω.

For two types of wind tunnel boundaries (solid walls and free jet) he calculated the tunnel boundary effects. For the case of an finite wing of span 6 and elliptical planform, pitching oscillations of the wing model (full span 2b of the wing was 50% of the diameter D of the circular test section), ω* = 2 π f b / (2 V) = 0.5.

unsteady lift coefficient was significantly changed by the tunnel boundary effect, esp. imaginary part.

Flutter Model of Ju288 in Braunschweig LFA A3

Windtunnel (1940)

Page 32: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 32 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

C. Possio‘s Impact on Küssner‘s „General Lifting SurfaceTheory“ (1940) for 3D unsteady compressible Flow about

oscillating surfaces of general planformH.G.Küssner (Göttingen) translated many Italian aeronautical papers, among them 10 of C. Possio, and thus was familiar with Possio’s work.In 1940 Küssner’s General Lifting Surface Theory. Using a Lorentz Transformation and acceleration potential corresponding to Possio’s 2D theory, he derived an integral equation relating the unknown load Δp(ξ,η ) on a lifting thin surface and the normal velocity component w at any other point (x ,y ) of the surface, by means of a new Kernel function K. He demonstrated that Possio’s equation was the 2D limiting case. This was the key to treat high speed flows, as well as swept and low aspect-ratio wings.Numerical solutions of the general 3D compressible case only after world war II, the most mature and common industrial method appeared in 1969 (Doublet-Lattice Method DLM)

( )2 2 2 2 2( )( ) 2

2 2 2 2 2 2

1 ( , )( , , , ) ,4 ( )

i Ma y zxxiV

S

p ew x y z t d d e dV z y z

ω λ λ β η βξξωξ ηξ η λπ ρ λ β η β

− + − +−−

−∞

Δ ∂=

∂ + − +∫∫ ∫

Page 33: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 33 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

0 .. .. .. .. .... .. ..

velocity potential of steady transonic flowsource distribution in flowfieldσ

Φ ==

02

2

2 2 2 *2

2 2 2 2

( 1)Ma

xi

x y z xγ

β

ψ ψ ψ ωλ ψ σβ

+ ∂Φ

⎛ ⎞ ⎡ ⎤∂ ∂ ∂ ∂+ + + = +⎜ ⎟ ⎢ ⎥∂ ∂ ∂ ∂⎝ ⎠ ⎣ ⎦

DLM ( Albano, Rodden 1968, only surface panels withconstant doublet strength) TDLM (Voß 1981)

(surface panels + volume elements)

Nonuniform Transonic Flow

v > a v<a

Extension of Possio‘s Theory to 3D Compressibleand Transonic Flow – Use of Computers

Page 34: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 34 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

 

Engine Pitch 

Wing Bending  Engine Yaw 

M = 0.90, TDLMM = 0.90, DLM

M = 0.60, TDLMM = 0.60, DLMM = 0.70, TDLMM = 0.70, DLMM = 0.80, TDLMM = 0.80, DLM

0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2

0Dam

ping Eng

ine Yaw

v∞/vD

TDLM versus DLMapplied to DO 728

TDLM versus DLMapplied to DO 728

Page 35: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 35 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

C. Possio‘s Work in Fields outside of AerodynamicsLateral firing from an airplane (1939) : This ballistic problem was probably chosen wrt. Possio‘s military service. For a projectilefired from board of an aircraft, in a direction different from airplane flight direction, spinning axis and projectile path are not parallel, yielding an aerodynamic angle of attackand thus aerodynamic forces. With elementary mathematical tools C.Possio computesthe airloads and the projectiles motion and shows that due to the spinning forces theprojectile axis soon turns parallel to its path.

Hydrodynamic problems (1941) : free water surface effects.Lift and drag of a 2D hydrofoil. The inviscid incompressible irrotational flow is governed by the Laplace equation for the velocity potential. The effect of the free water surface is modelled as a linear perturbation, governed by Laplace equation too. He computes this perturbation using the constraints that the additional velocity has to vanish at infinite distance from the hydrofoil, and that pressure on the water surface has a constant value. The hydrofoil is modelled by a (chordwise) vortex (distribution), the disturbance potential by additional point vortices.

( )

2

2

2 ,... ... ,1 2 /

exp 22 ,... ...

LL D

cc and c

ghh withV

παλ πλ

βλ β

βπ

= =+

= =

Vx

h

y

l

Γ

Page 36: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 36 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Extension of Possio‘s Equation to 2D turbomachine cascades – fan flutter

- l/2 l/2

τ2

τ1

V

y

x

τλ

α = α0 cos(ω t - θ )

α = α0 cos(ω t - 2θ )

α = α0 cos(ω t)

Blade distance τ

Stagger angle λ

Interblade phaseangle θ

Page 37: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 37 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

ω* = 0,6; τ /l =1,0; λ = 60°

1 ----- Ma = 0 2 ----- Ma = 0,7

*

2

( )( ) ( ) , , , , , ,b

b

xw x p K Ma n dV bω ω ξξ λ τ θ ξ

ρ −

⎛ ⎞−= Δ ⎜ ⎟

⎝ ⎠∫

1 ----- Ma = 0 2 ----- Ma = 0,7

ω* = 0,6; τ /l =1,0; λ = 60°

Possio‘s Equation for 2D plane cascade – influence of interblade phase angle θ on unsteady lift, Resonances

Adapted from

V. Carstens 1973

Page 38: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 38 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Extension of Possio‘sTheory for 2D

Windtunnelwall Interference on oscillating

airfoils

Page 39: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 39 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

mass

momentum

energy

Current Status

Page 40: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 40 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Time discretisation : Newmark procedure

Structure : [M ]w~ + [K ]w~ = f~ Q~ (w~, wç~, w~, t)ð ñFluid :

dt

dQ~= R~ Q~ (w~, wç~, w~, t)

ð ñ

wn

Qnà21

wn+1 wn+2

Qn+21

Qn+23

1

2

4

3

Energy error : ΔE ø (Δ t) 2

Current Flutter Simulation : Staggered Coupling Schemes

Page 41: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 41 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Computation of Flutter boundary

x/c

z/c

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2-0.4

-0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

Possio

Navier-Stokes

2VFic αμ ω

∞=The non-dimensionalflutter index

represented versus Mach number

Current Status of Unsteady Aerodynamics : Flutter in Transonic and Separated Flow

Page 42: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 42 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

NTPER = 500, NINNER = 40, 16 CPUs, 68 hrs / period !NTPER = 500, NINNER = 40, 16 CPUs, 68 hrs / period !

Current Status of Unsteady Aerodynamics : UnsteadyTransonic Separated Flow for 3D Configuration

Page 43: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 43 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

• Objective : minimised drag and relaxedflutter boundary

• Constraint : lift for a given Mach-Reynolds number combination

• Use of transonic Version (TDLM) of Possio‘s 2D equation

Current Use of Possio-type methods : Shape Optimisationwith aeroelastic objectives

Page 44: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 44 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Conclusion

Camillo Possio‘s work is today still relevant, solutions of „Possio‘s Equation“ are still in use,His work in unsteady aerodynamics is worldwide referenced,He prepared the path for the development of unsteadyaerodynamic standard methods after the war, in high speed up to transonic and supersonic flow, He gave sifnificant contributions to other fields than unsteadyaerodynamics,He was a brilliant mathematician and engineer, because he combined physical understanding, mathematical modelling of essential phenomena and complex numerical analysis,He had only 7 years time for research, but had a high impact on aeronautic research and technology. He probably would havebecome one of the greatest aerodynamicists.

Page 45: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 45 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

eT

V

e

L

α

neutral axis

elastic axis

α

V VD

Torsionaldivergence

xFokker D VIII (1918)

Static aeroelastic problems :Torsional Divergence

Page 46: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 46 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Camillo Possio’s scientific papers

1937Sul moto razionale dei gas, Atti Accad. Naz. Lincei,1937Sul problema della regolazione indiretta, Ric Ingen1937L’azione aerodinamica sul profile oscillante alle velocita

ultrasonore, Pontifcia Accademia Scientiarium Acta1938L’azione aerodinamica sul profilo oscillante in un fludio

compressible a velocita iposonara. L’Aerotechnica1938L’azione aeodinamica su una superficie portante in moto

oscillatorio. Atti Accad. Naz. Lincei,1938Determinazione dell’azione aerodinamica corrispondente alle

piccolo oscillazioni del velivolo. L’Aerotechnica1939Sul moto non stazionario di una superficie portante. L’Aerotechnica1939Sul moto non stazionario di un fludio compressible. Atti Accad. Naz.

Lincei,

Page 47: The Legacy of Camillo Possio to Unsteady Aerodynamics¶rsching.IFIP2005... · 2013. 12. 12. · IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 2> Dokumentname > 23.11.2004> Outline Introduction

IFIP2005-TC7, Torino 18 July 2005 Folie 47 > >Dokumentname > 23.11.2004

Camillo Possio’s scientific papers continued1939 L’azione aeodinamica su di una superficie portante in moto vario.

Atti Accad. Scienze Torino1939Sulla determinazione dei coefficienti aerdinamici che interessano la

stabilita del velivolo.1939Sullo sparo di fianco da bordo di un aereo. L’Aerotechnica1940Sul problema del moto discuntino di un’ala. Nota 1, L’Aerotechnica1940Sul problema del moto discuntino di un’ala. Nota 2, L’Aerotechnica1940L’ interference della galleria aerodinamica nel caso di moto non

stazionario, L’Aerotechnica1940Campo di velocita creato da un vortice in un fluido pesante a

superficie libera , L’Aerotechnica1941Sulle teoria del moto stazionario di un fluido pesante con superficie

libera, L’Aerotechnica1943The influence of the viscosity and thermal conductibility on sound

propagation. Atti Accad. Scienze Torino