The Lack of Human Reliability Data is a Barrier to the Attainment of NSABB's Risk Reducation Objectives (Gavin Huntley-Fenner)

8/19/2019 The Lack of Human Reliability Data is a Barrier to the Attainment of NSABB's Risk Reducation Objectives (Gavin Huntley-Fenner)

1/26

C i p y r

n ` h t ©

< 4 ? 5

VHM AOCJ IE H]KOG \MANOLNAV^ FOVO NS O

LO\\NM\ VI

VHM

OVVONGKMGV

IE

GSOLL„S

\NSJ \MF]CVNIG ILBMCVNUMS

@ovng Hugtamy—Emggmr, ThF

GOS @ong ie Eugctnig Sykpisnuk

Korch ?4—??,


2/26

C i p y r

n ` h t ©

< 4 ? 5

VITNCS

• Phot ns ‑Hukog Eoctirs‛9

• Vhm riam

ie

Hukog

Eoctirs

foto

ng lnisoemty ogf lnismcurnty

• Vhm ippirtugnty2

Pm

hovm

thm

kmogs ti jgiw

•

Euturm iptnigs


3/26

C i p y r

n ` h t ©

< 4 ? 5

PHOV NS H]KOG EOCVI\S9

3

Siurcms2 Jihg, Angfo V., Bogmt K. Cirrn`og, ogf Kiaao S. Figoafsig, mfs. Vi Mrr Ns Hukog22 Lunafng` o Soemr Hmoath Systmk. Uia. 586)2 88=. Ciipmr,

Bmeermy L.,

mt

oa.

"Trmvmgtolam

ogmsthmsno

knshops2

o stufy

ie

hukog

eoctirs."

Ogmsthmsniai`y 6>.5

(?>08)2

3>>

—645.

Os

rmpirtmf

ng

thm

EHPO

‑Hn`hwoy

Soemty

Nkprivmkmgt Tri`rok Koguoa, MC/N\] Stufy:

Vhm stufy ie hukog rmanolnanty, frowng` ig og

ugfmrstogfng` ie hukog copolnantnms ogf

ankntotnigs ng

vornius

mgvnrigkmgts.

Hukog mrrir ns mstnkotmf os eoctir ng2

784% ie kitir vmhncam occnfmgts

84% ie kmfncoa mrrirs

54% ti 84% ie ovnotnig occnfmgts


4/26

C i p y r

n ` h t ©

< 4 ? 5

EIC]S IG GSOLL \MCIKKMGFOVIG 6 OGF

V^TMS IE

FOVO

VI

OCHNMUM

VHM

ILBMCVNUM

6

Siurcms2

‑Vhm ].S. `ivmrgkmgt shiuaf

cigtngum meeirts … whnch wnaa

eistmr o cuaturm ie rmspigsnlnanty

thot wnaa

suppirt

git

igay

thm

soem

cigfuct ie @IE stufnms ie cigcmrg

lut ie oaa rmsmorch ngviavng`

pothi`mgs‛

‑Vhm aocj ie hukog

eoctirs rmsmorch

ng

thm anem scnmgcms ns

sikmthng` thot gmmfs

ti lm offrmssmf.‛

— Coso`rogfm


5/26

C i p y r n ` h t ©

< 4 ? 5

=

Siurcms2 Os rmpirtmf ng thm EHPO ‑Hn`hwoy Soemty Nkprivmkmgt Tri`rok Koguoa, MC/N\] Stufy: Hiaago`ma, M. (?>>3). Vhm rmanolnanty ie ci`gntnig2

Eiugfotnigs ie hukog rmanolnanty ogoaysns, Aigfig, ]J2 Ocofmknc Trmss

H]KOG M\\I\ HOS NGC\MOSMF

T\ITI\VNIGOAA^ OS

O

CIGV\NL]VI\

VI

OCCNFMGVS


6/26


< 4 ? 5

5

Siurcms2 ‑Koxnknzng ̀]smr Soemty Vhriu`h Hukog Eoctirs Fmsn`g‛, Aolcigci whntmpopmr ly Lrnog @orrmtt (


7/26


< 4 ? 5

VHM PHI COAAS I]V H]KOG M\\I\ OS O

T\NKO\^ AOL

LNISMC]\NV^

CIGCM\G

0

Siurcms2

Fmspntm ofvogcms ng tmchgiai`y, …

ngstrukmgts ogf TTM2

‑ …. hukog mrrir rmkongs igm ie thm

kist nkpirtogt

eoctirs

ot

thm

irn`ng

ie

occnfmgts …‛


8/26


< 4 ? 5

8

Siurcms2

VHM\M NS OG NKTM\OVNUM VI CIAAMCV LMVVM\

FOVO (@ryphig,


9/26


< 4 ? 5

>

GI SIAOCM E\IK EMP OFUM\SM MUMGVS, OS

EI\MGSNCS SHIPS

HNFFMG

I\

AOVMGV

FOVO


10/26


< 4 ? 5

?4

‑… kogy

ithmr

ngcnfmgts

ogf

occnfmgts hovm iccurrmf,

kongay os o rmsuat ie hukog

mrrir ir mqunpkmgt eonaurm.

Eirtugotmay, kist ngcnfmgts/occnfmgts fi git

hovm smrnius cigsmqumgcms …‛

@OI NGUMSVN@OVNIG HN@HAN@HVMF

]GFM\OTT\MCNOVMF H]KOG

M\\I\


11/26


< 4 ? 5

??

FIMS VHM NGMUNVOLNANV^ IE H]KOG M\\I\

O\@]M O@ONGSV

CIGVNG]NG@

@IE\C9

Gi.

Hukog Eoctirs privnfms tiias

eir fmsn`gng`, nkpamkmgtng`

ogf kongtongng`

systmks

ng

whnch mrrirs hovm ankntmf

nkpoct whmg thmy fi iccur.


12/26

C i p y

r n ` h t ©

< 4 ? 5

?<

Siurcms2 \nsj ogf Lmgment Ogoaysns ie @ong ie Eugctnig \msmorch Froet Engoa \mpirt‖Fmcmklmr


13/26

C i p y

r n ` h t ©

< 4 ? 5

?3

SNKTAM OTT\IOCHMS COG ^NMAF SN@GNENCOGV

\MF]CVNIG NG

M\\I\S

Siurcm2

Hoygms,

Oamx

L.,

mt

oa.

"O

sur`ncoa

soemty

chmcjanst

ti

rmfucm

kirlnfnty

ogf

kirtoanty

ng

o

`ailoa

pipuaotnig."

Gmw

Mg`aogf

Biurgoa

ie

Kmfncngm354.= ()2 6>?—6>>.

64%

rmfuctnig

ng mrrirs


14/26

C i p y

r n ` h t ©

< 4 ? 5

?6Siurcms2

Chogfamr,

E.,

Hmorf,

N. O.,

Trmsamy,

K.,

Lur`,

O.,

Knfmmg, M., & Kig`ig, T. (


15/26

C i p y

r n ` h t ©

< 4 ? 5

?=

\mpirts thot >=% ngviavmf hukog mrrir

S]\UM^ IE AOLI\OVI\^ O_]N\MF

NGEMCVNIGS NG

M]\ITM

(58

NGSVNV]VNIGS)

LHE?


16/26

Sanfm ?=

LHE? Phot ns thm stot ie >=% losmf ig9 Ogf hiw fims thm orriw tnm ti hukog mrrir9Lmth HE, 3/?4/


17/26

C i p y

r n ` h t ©

< 4 ? 5

?5

\mcikkmgfs ‑… Kuatn—eocmtmf

ngtmrvmgtnigs‛• Kifmang` ie thm lmhovnir ly

supmrvnsirs ogf ciwirjmrs,

• Nkpamkmgtotnig ie wrnttmg

hogfwoshng` piancnms

• \mfuctnig ie mxnt ermqumgcy

VHM ENMAF NS TISNVNIGMF VI T\IUNFM \MAMUOGV

FOVO

L]V

KI\M

LSA


18/26

C i p y

r n ` h t ©

< 4 ? 5

?0

‑… Zcuttng`

cirgmrs[

wmrm

kongay eiugf ti lm fum ti

sntuotnigoa ogf ir`ognzotnigoa

eoctirs. Eir mxokpam, tnkm

prmssurm, wirjaiof,

stoeeng`

amvmas, trongng`, supmrvnsnig,

ogf ovonaolnanty ie rmsiurcms…‛

CIGVMXV FOVO O\M OASI NKTI\VOGV (EIC]S

@\I]TS NG

5 ]J

CA3

AOLS)

Hukog eoctirs thot amof ti gig—cikpanogcm wnth stogforf ipmrotng` pricmfurms Snkig Lotms & Bustng Hiariyf

Hmoath ogf Soemt Aolirotir Hor ur Hnaa Luxtig Fmrl shnrm SJ?0 >BG htt 2 www.hsm. iv.uj rmsmorch rr fe rr>?>. fe


22/26

Sanfm


23/26


< 4 ? 5


24/26


< 4 ? 5

VHM \IAM IE H]KOG EOCVI\S

Vhogj ^iu

]gnvmrsnty Frnvm, #?30, Nrvngm, Coaneirgno >.58880 | `ovngDhugtamyemggmrofvnsirs.cik


25/26


< 4 ? 5

I\@OGNROVNIGS LMGMENV E\IK H]KOG

EOCVI\ EIC]S

OTO\V

E\IK

\NSJ

\MF]CVNIG

• Mghogcm prmpormfgmss

• Trmvmgt sn`gnencogt occnfmgts

• Kntnòtm cigsmqumgcms

• Nkprivm prilamk siavng` oetmr ofvmrsm mvmgts

• Nfmgtney foto gmmfmf ti suppirt rnìrius ogoaysns

• Suppirt fmcnsnigs rmòrfng` oaaicotnig ie ankntmf rmsiurcms

• Sugshngm nkpancnt

rnsjs

ofiptmf

ly

o tmok

• Sugshngm hnffmg ir ugfmropprmcnotmf lmgments ie mxnstng`

proctncm

•

\ilust

lnisoemty

mgvnrigkmgt

cog

‑horfmg‛

lnismcurnty

tor`mt


26/26


< 4 ? 5

LMPO\M IE I]\ ANKNVMF COTOCNV^ VI

]GFM\SVOGF OGF

KOGO@M

\NSJ

Documents

The Lack of Human Reliability Data is a Barrier to the Attainment of NSABB's Risk Reducation Objectives (Gavin Huntley-Fenner)