26
0 The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the University of Istanbul 29 May Summary The research starts from the classification of the interpretation of Islamic punishments within two Patterns, namely, the jurisprudential view and the contemporary modernism. The second is splitted in two Patterns of the interpretive approach, which links them to their Legal objectives, and the linguistic interpretation, which explains the punishment by the metaphor. The researcher seeks to characterize these cases and then balance them in the traditional jurisprudence. The study discusses the correctness of the including the punishment in the purposes or means, and the validity of the abandonment of means? The second part of the study is devoted to discussing the linguistic interpretation proposed by the modernists who suggested interpreting the cutting hand of the thief with imprisoning them. The research concluded that the punishments are one of the constant means which do not accept the metaphorical interpretation nor replacement . Key words

The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    9

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

0

The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand

Dr. M. Anas Sarmini

Assistant Professor at the University of Istanbul 29 May

Summary

The research starts from the classification of the interpretation of Islamic punishments

within two Patterns, namely, the jurisprudential view and the contemporary modernism. The

second is splitted in two Patterns of the interpretive approach, which links them to their Legal

objectives, and the linguistic interpretation, which explains the punishment by the metaphor.

The researcher seeks to characterize these cases and then balance them in the traditional

jurisprudence. The study discusses the correctness of the including the punishment in the

purposes or means, and the validity of the abandonment of means? The second part of the study

is devoted to discussing the linguistic interpretation proposed by the modernists who suggested

interpreting the cutting hand of the thief with imprisoning them.

The research concluded that the punishments are one of the constant means which do not

accept the metaphorical interpretation nor replacement .

Key words

Page 2: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

1

Islamic punishment, interpretation, Legal objectives, means, cutting the hand of the

thief

Page 3: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

2

(1)

Page 4: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

3

Page 5: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

4

(7)

Page 6: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

5

Page 7: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

6

Page 8: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

7

Page 9: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

8

http://mohammadhabash.org/2016/09/03

Page 10: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

9

Page 11: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

10

Page 12: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

11

Page 13: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

12

Page 14: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

13

Asım Cüneyd Köksal, Fıkıh ve Siyaset

Page 15: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

14

Page 16: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

15

Page 17: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

16

Page 18: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

17

http://www.ahl-alquran.com/arabic/show_article.php?main_id=912

Page 19: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

18

Page 20: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

19

Page 21: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

20

Page 22: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

21

Page 23: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

22

Page 24: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

23

Page 25: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

24

http://www.ahl-alquran.com/arabic/show_article.php?main_id=912

www.eastlaws.com

Page 26: The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting ... fileù The Interpretations of the Thief's Punishment of Cutting off Hand Dr. M. Anas Sarmini Assistant Professor at the

25

61. Fıkıh ve Siyaset, Asım Cüneyd Köksal, Klasik Yayınlar, 2016.