34
THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE Which IoT Platform 2017 SPONSORED BY:

THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

THE ENTERPRISEBUYER'S GUIDEWhich IoT Platform 2017

SPONSORED BY:

Page 2: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which
Page 3: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

47IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

Sponsored by:

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

Decision making in respect of which IoT solutionsand platforms to select gets more challengingwhen successful IoT engagement meansprocessing large amounts of data in real-time tosupport current business operations. It can bemore challenging still to integrate these newreal-time data flows with traditional batchupdate data typical of IT systems already in use.Those challenges increase further when thesedata flows need to interoperate smoothly andsecurely across several different businessoperations, all in real-time.

To cater for these and other challenges and createan IoT solution that will stand the test of time, IoTplatforms are increasingly being viewed as thestarting point to build on. Put simply, the aim of

an IoT platform is to reduce the time and cost ofgetting new IoT solutions built and implementedby using components already available and beingused in other IoT solutions. An IoT platform takesadvantage of the fact that the majority of what isneeded for most IoT solutions is the same anddoes not need to be reinvented for everyapplication: it can be predesigned and madeavailable through a platform. The platform thenalso provides the means for implementing thoseelements that are specific to the particularapplication, as well as customising andconfiguring the solution for the specific need.

So how does a business user, also referred as anadopter, go about choosing the right IoT platformfor them?

For an increasing number of businesses, IoT is rapidly moving from a nice-to-have to astrategic necessity. At its simplest, an IoT solution provides the opportunity to saveoperational costs, introduce new service revenue opportunities, or help to ensurecompliance with new regulations, writes Robin Duke-Woolley. In practice, IoTplatforms are therefore becoming more and more a combination of these dressed upin a wide range of business needs, some more urgent than others

How to select theright IoT platform

The author, RobinDuke-Woolley, ischief executive ofBeecham Research

GUIDE INTRODUCTION

Page 4: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

48

GUIDE INTRODUCTION

What actually is an IoT platform?An IoT platform is a software middleware suitethat facilitates secure monitoring, control andanalysis of device and sensor behaviour in thefield. In essence, it provides an enabling layerbetween these connected devices or sensors anduser applications. There are two main parts of acomplete IoT platform – the part that managesthe physical connectivity to the devices andother systems to ensure that essential data iscollected, and the part that processes the data.Although both parts are required for a completeIoT solution they are often provided by differentvendors, reflecting their different areas ofexpertise.

There are several layers to an IoT solution andthese are becoming increasingly complex asmarket needs develop. The architecture can beshown in a variety of ways, with Figure 1illustrating the main elements: the externalsensors/actuators/devices/gateways connected tothe platform via networks and other infrastructure.

Within the platform itself, there are essentiallyfour layers – communication services, devicemanagement, data management and applicationdevelopment. Above those layers are the userapplications themselves – the elements the useractually sees. Across all of these layers issecurity, which binds them together to ensurethere are no weak points either within each layeror across the layers. Indeed, that securitycapability must also bind the sensor and networklayers not included in the platform itself – afurther crucial consideration in platform design.

While this describes how IoT platforms arestructured, the vast majority of them do notcater for all layers, at least not yet. For example,

providing communication services is acompletely different task to applicationdevelopment and to detailed analytics of devicedata. Each platform vendor has their ownexpertise and to get a sense of what they offer,Beecham Research has defined seven IoTplatform categories, as follows:

1. Communication centric – offering a strong focus on connectivity management capabilities

2. Device management centric – offering a strong focus on device management

3. Data management and analytics centric – designed to provide strong data management, orchestration, and analytics capability

4.Application development centric – enabling application development on different typesof devices.

5. Vertical centric – designed to support the development of IoT solutions in specific sectors or sub-sectors, examples could be smart city, manufacturing.

6. Consumer IoT centric – similar to vertical centric above, but with a strong focus on consumer IoT applications such as smart home.

7. IoT developer centric – offering solutionsfor IoT developers including software and hardware.

These categories are not mutually exclusive, sothat a vendor’s offering may belong to more thanone of these. To take one example, Living PlanITis vertical centric because they are focused onsmart city solutions. However, for those solutionsthey also focus on data management andanalytics centric capabilities.

There are several layers to an IoT solution andthese are becoming increasingly complex as

market needs develop. The architecture can beshown in a variety of ways Figure 1: Elements of an IoT platform architecture

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

Sponsored by:

Page 5: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

Choosing the right platformBeecham Research has been tracking theM2M/IoT platforms market since 2008, whenthere were just 14 of them on the market. Nowthere are over 400, by our count around 420 atthe end of 2016. The chart in Figure 2 shows thisgrowth and it is clear from this that the numberof new platforms is going to continue growingfor a while.

As noted above, the IoT platform is an importantstarting point for adopters planning their IoTsolutions. However, with so many of them now onthe market, it is a highly confusing one. Inaddition, such platforms are going through a fastrate of development with updates, acquisitionsand re-brandings occurring frequently. They arebecoming increasingly sophisticated as well asmore specialised. For those who do notunderstand the subtleties, this adds greatly tothe confusion. It also increases the prospect ofadopters making incorrect choices for theirneeds and only finding out the consequences ofthese after much time and financial resourceshave been spent.

The IoT navigation tool, created by BeechamResearch and IoT Global Network acting inpartnership and featured onwww.iotglobalnetwork.com, is designed toaddress this confusion by enabling adopters tobetter understand the options available to them.It is the first fully-independent online tool tomatch adopter needs with IoT platformcapabilities.

The aim of the system is to assist adopters tomake informed decisions about which platformsare most likely to meet their requirements at anyparticular time. It does not seek to recommendone platform over others, but does seek to

narrow the field to a level that adopters canmanage effectively. It means they can commencea more valuable dialogue with the mostappropriate vendors at an earlier stage.

The user accesses the IoT navigation toolthrough an authentication process. It then asksthe user to answer a set of questions that coverthe needs of the IoT solution the user isexploring. These questions are via drop-downmenus. The system then matches thoserequirements with the information about theplatforms and selects those most likely to be ofinterest. The user is then guided to a short listweb page. He or she can click on each platformindividually, through to a web page thatdescribes it in more detail.

Making a final choiceHaving got to a short list of potentially suitableplatforms, the user then needs to discuss withpotential vendors in more detail the IoT solutionthat is to be catered for. Depending on need,such discussions may be straightforward butincreasingly we expect these to become moreinvolved as the user requirements become moresophisticated. To illustrate what that means inpractice, Beecham Research has identifiedupwards of 100 questions that may need to becovered for a more complex solution. It is herethat a framework of the topics that need to becovered is particularly useful. One suchframework is currently being devised by the IMC(IoT M2M Council) as a set of RFPs (Requests forProposal) for IoT platforms. These documentswill provide adopters with checklists of thefundamental elements that should be covered forany IoT solution.

Having got to ashort list ofpotentiallysuitableplatforms, theuser then needs todiscuss withpotential vendorsin more detail theIoT solution that isto be catered for

49

www.beechamresearch.com

Figure 2: The number of IoT platforms on the market

Sponsored by:

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

Page 6: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

IOT PLATFORMS TO WATCH

The subject of connectivity is receivingrenewed focus at present. This is due to theincreasing interest in low power wide areanetwork (LPWAN) technologies, the advent to5G cellular, and growing acceptance in themarket that connectivity is often still a challengeto get right. As a result, platforms with astrong focus on connectivity features are inthe spotlight. Those come from well-knownmobile network operators like AT&T, with itsAT&T IoT Platform, and Vodafone, but alsomanaged IoT services providers or IoT mobilevirtual network operators (MVNOs) such asStream Technologies, with its IoT-X platform.

The world of LPWAN is also gathering attention,with platforms like Actility’s ThingPark. Thereare then companies historically involved inmobile communications such as Nokia, with itsIMPACT (Intelligent Management Platform forall Connected Things) platform that has astrong focus on connectivity, but also looks atother layers in the stack such as analytics andapplication development.

Climbing the stack towards devicemanagement, we find dedicated platforms todevice management such as Wind River’sHelix. Continuing further up the stack,dynamic companies such as Cumulocity –recently acquired by Software AG – arefocusing on analytics and applicationenablement services with a strong focus onintegration with third parties and ecosystemformation. The analytics and applicationdevelopment layers have different offersbased on different factors such as extensionof analytics features and engagement withdevelopers through a clear open software-based approach. At these layers, IBM, withits Watson IoT unit, is a strong market playersetting the trends in emerging areas such asmachine learning and artificial intelligence.On the analytics side, Hitachi with Lumadais another interesting case, building on thedeep industrial operation technologyknowhow of Hitachi and combining withsuperb analytics capabilities gatheredthrough acquisitions such as Pentaho.

Which IoT platformsare best meetingorganisations’ needs?

The IoT platform landscape could resemble a university course for the richnessand diversity of the offer, writes Saverio Romeo. If the adopter wants to pass theexam by selecting the right platform, a great deal of study may be necessary.Here, we do not want to cover the entire landscape, but we do want to give somesuggestions for starting that study journey. That journey strongly depends on therequirements and the context, but there are some themes and features worthhighlighting that are common parts of the decision-making process

Companies formedin the dynamic

Irish tech start-upscene have

managed to scaleup fast in the

highly competitiveenvironment of

Industrial IoT

50

Sponsored by:

Page 7: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

There are then companies that could belabelled as vertical centric, but that have theclear intention to expand their verticalfootprints. Bosch with its IoT Suite is a case inpoint. Although originally a mobilitycomponents producer, Bosch has advancedquickly into the area of software and hasrecently shown strong potential for the smartcities, smart home and smart transportationareas, with a high level of focus in the IoT andartificial intelligence capabilities. Bosch seemsto be leaving behind its traditional culture as a‘manufacturing everything’ company andstarting to be open to collaborations andpartnerships. Among the most interestingsigns is its recent-announced partnership withAmazon Web Services (AWS).

Another established player such as PTC-ThingWorx is moving from an almost solelyindustrial focus towards other verticals such asretail. PTC-ThingWorx is getting greatattention on the use of virtual reality (VR) andemerging concepts such as digital twins.

However, the IoT platform landscape is notonly made of large enterprises and establishedplayers. The innovative contribution comingfrom small and medium-sized companies andstart-ups continue to feed the space withideas.

Companies formed in the dynamic Irish techstart-up scene have managed to scale up fast

in the highly competitive environment ofIndustrial IoT. EpiSensor, originally an IoTequipment company, has forged a very strongpartnership with Asavie, another Irish IoTcompany which is focused on secureconnectivity management, and Dell, whichadds its IoT Gateway to the overall solution.

Waylay of Belgium puts great emphasis onthe key topic of data orchestration andintegration. myDevices with Cayenne tries tomake IoT solution development easy andrapid. Carriots, from Spain, wants to simplifyIoT solution development with a step-by-stepapproach flexible enough to work in severaldifferent sectors. Arrayent aims at the brandsand the consumer IoT space. There are thencompanies vertical focused in specific areas ofmanufacturing (such as Wi-Next), on theIndustrial Internet widely (CloudPlugs), smartcity projects (LivingPlanIT), and smart agri-food solutions (Yodiwo).

The sheer variety and scope of activities thatIoT platform providers are engaging indemonstrates a vibrant market which providesa sometimes bewildering array of choices topotential customers. Passing the exam ofselecting the right platform for your projectwill certainly require an amount of homeworkto be completed before a fully-informeddecision can be made. The good new is thatthere is almost certainly an ideal solution outthere for you.

The author,Saverio Romeo, isprincipal analyst atBeecham Research

The sheer variety andscope of activitiesthat IoT platformproviders areengaging indemonstrates avibrant market whichprovides a sometimesbewildering array ofchoices to potentialcustomers

51

Sponsored by:

Page 8: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

INTERVIEW

Robin Duke-Woolley: There are an increasingnumber of IoT platforms in the market. What isAT&T’s place in this market and how do you seeyour role as different to the many others?

Mobeen Khan: There’s all the stuff about beingsecure, scalable, highly available and all thethings you would expect from a carrier-gradeservice, but let’s take that as read. We mainly lookat platforms in two different ways. Firstly, thereare platforms that AT&T has and continues toinvest in that allow us to let customers managetheir IoT connectivity solutions in the mostefficient and advanced way possible. Theseplatforms enable our Global SIM, they enablepolicy management, SIM management, multi-network and global connectivity and many otherfeatures and we have had those for many yearsand have been part and parcel of our

differentiation in the marketplace. The umbrellafor that today is called our AT&T Control Center.All of our customers use these systems eitherdirectly through the portal or using applicationprogramme interfaces (APIs) to manage their IoTsolution connectivity. This is AT&T’s ServiceManagement.

RD-W: Just for clarification on that, can youexplain what you mean by policy management?

MK: There are many kinds of policies, proceduresand behaviour that you need to capture. Forexample, let’s say you manufacture a machine inVietnam and you ship it to Germany and then itgets deployed in Canada. You might set policiesthat when it’s in Vietnam and on the assemblyline being tested running diagnostics these wouldbe a no-charge event. When it’s in Germany, and ▼

IoT platformsmust accommodate

organisations’ needsto operate them at

multiple levelsDifferent organisations require different functionality from IoT platforms inorder to operate their services effectively. IoT platforms therefore must be

able to operate at a variety of levels in order to satisfy market and end userdemands, Mobeen Khan, the associate vice president for IoT Solutions at

AT&T, tells Robin Duke-Woolley, the founder and chief executive ofBeecham Research

IN ASSOCIATION WITH AT&T

52

Sponsored by:

Page 9: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

about to be shipped, the geofence of thewarehouse it’s in knows there will be a separatecharge billed to XYZ account because it’s not yetbeen shipped to a customer. Then when it getsactivated in Canada, now the billing starts for thecustomer that bought that machine andactivated it. You can pre-programme thoseprocedures as a policy profile in the ControlCenter in advance so you don’t have to do thatevery time the machine is shipped, or testedor activated.

RD-W: Is AT&T’s second set of IoT platformsthen at a higher level than connectivity?

MK: Yes. The second set of platforms we invest inare those that allow systems integrators anddevelopers to build and deploy in a scalable andreliable way the IoT solutions themselves. This isat the application layer. For example, let’s say youare an IBM Bluemix developer. Your applicationsrun in Bluemix, and your data is saved in Bluemix.You could go into Bluemix, set up an account andgo to their IoT page and what you would find isthe AT&T Control Center. You could activate theAPIs of that Control Center through Bluemix,which allows you to build the end solution andactivate devices and all that. And you will findAT&T’s IoT platforms which are called Flowand M2X.

What those allow you to do is basically get datafrom these IoT devices into an app or into ananalytics portal or into the cloud. Why is thatimportant? It sounds simple but getting datafrom IoT devices is a very complex proposition.It is complex because there are no standards.It’s not like you have Android and iOS andeverything knows exactly where to go. There isno procedure there.

There are thousands of variations of operatingsystems, communication protocols, and chip sets,and the ability to write on top of the device chipset. There are literally thousands of combinations.Developers of these IoT solutions have tobecome experts in device programming but theyspend an inordinate amount of time just gettingthe data. Not so much what they’re going to dowith the data. IoT solutions are all about

There are thousands of variations ofoperating systems, communication

protocols, and chip sets, and the ability towrite on top of the device chip set

Mobeen Khan, AT&T

53

Sponsored by:

Page 10: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

manipulating the data and making new insightsand using it in your processes. But they’respending too much time just getting the data inthe first place. What we are trying to solve withour platform is to get you the data in an easy wayso you can start to integrate it into yourapplications. That’s the second layer of platformsthat we focus on.

RD-W: What other activities at this applicationlayer are you supporting?

MK: There are five main elements that we focuson from a technical strategy perspective:

First, we integrate with the device ecosystem. Asa carrier, we are close to the device ecosystembecause we certify every one of those devices onour network. We know how these devices workand we are embedding those capabilities into ourplatform on the other side of the devices and inthe cloud that will extract the data much moreeasily than anyone else can. Being a carrier, weknow those devices, it’s a competitive advantagefor us in the platform space. There are thousandsof platforms out there. They all focus on the data

layer and what to do once you have the data.We’re fine with that, with that runningsomewhere in a cloud or even something likeBluemix running that. But that piece of gettingthe data, that’s really hard. We’re focusing ongetting you the data.

Second, if you look at the cloud world and theapps in the app world, you have essentially a halfdozen key players in the cloud world, where CIOshave made an edict to say my data and my appswill live in this cloud. What we have done is puttogether an architecture where if you build thatIoT solution within the AT&T platform and Flow,you can deploy that in a cloud of your choice. Soagain, going back to the Bluemix example, if youstart with Bluemix, you enter the Flow platform,build your app and extraction of data you want torun and then deploy it in Bluemix. That isimportant from a policy perspective for ourenterprise customers and to offer them choice.

Third, in our platforms we are promoting bothinternal AT&T add-on products as well as ourthird-party partner products. For example, weoffer a business messaging solution for ourcustomers. Take the example of a machinedeployed. When an alarm comes off the machineyou can use a business messaging solution tosend a secure message to your technicians to goand fix that machine. That is an IoT solutionmoving into the realm of an operational solution.We have many products there, so we areexposing those products and APIs of thoseproducts in our platform. That makes it easy for adeveloper to have access and use those in oneenvironment rather than going to many differentenvironments. For example, with IBM again, theycan use their IoT Watson nodes – the analyticnodes – right inside our IoT platforms. So, if youare going to collect data from this machine, andyou’re going to pass it on to a Watson analyticsengine to give you predictive analytics aboutwhether this engine is about to fail, you could do

INTERVIEW

If you look at the cloud world and the apps inthe app world, you have essentially a halfdozen key players in the cloud world, whereCIOs have made an edict to say my data and myapps will live in this cloud

54

Sponsored by:

Page 11: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

that from within the environment because we arepre-integrated with IBM Watson.

Fourth, this is making sure that the developershave the reference applications and solutions aswell as many pre-built components that they canuse so they don’t have to start from scratch. So,the inventory we have built of those pre-builtapplets are examples that make it easy fordevelopers and system integrators to startstacking on top of. They can share those amongtheir teams, and they can share them with thecommunity at large.

The fifth and final part is making sure that theunderlying architecture and technology is built onopen source, and built as you would expect froma network operator. So it’s highly scalable – youcan deploy ten devices or ten million devices – itsreliable, secure, high capacity, a high availabilityenvironment.

Those are the five key elements of what we arefocusing on to build our platforms and platforminfrastructure. These relate to the second layer ofAT&T’s platforms that is more applications-focused.

RD-W: Is the first platform – the servicemanagement platform – based on Cisco Jasper?

MK: Yes, the first platform – the AT&T ControlCenter – is based on the Cisco Jasper platformand we continue to make additions andintegrations to it to make it more valuable. That isa continuous improvement cycle. The secondplatform – the application platform – has nothingto do with Cisco Jasper. It is an AT&T set ofproducts that we have built and it is based onopen source technology.

RD-W: Have you invested more in the secondthan the first?

MK: We are investing in both but the first one wehave a partner and the second one we arebuilding it on our own.

RD-W: As far as customers are concerned, doyou bring together those two platforms as onesolution, or do you separate them out?

MK: They are separate. The two platforms are

separate in the sense that the AT&T ControlCenter is used by every single customerregardless of how they build the application andwhether they use AT&T platforms to build theirapplications or not. They will use the ControlCenter to manage their services, which means allof their connectivity. On the other hand, theapplication level platforms are optional in thesense that a customer can build their applicationin IBM Bluemix starting from first line of code anddo not need to access AT&T’s application layerplatforms as part of that. If they do, they havethose additional services. On the other hand, theControl Center is something that every customertouches and uses.

RD-W: Does that mean you have separatepricing for the Control Center platform andthen Flow and M2M?

MK: Regarding the Control Center, the standardpieces are part and parcel of our connectivityservices. You can add other managed services ontop of that, which are paid services. The Flow andM2M platforms are an added layer of charge thatare based on price per month charges in top ofconnectivity.

RD-W: Are all platforms available worldwide?

MK: The Control Center is available everywhere.Our customers manage their Global SIMsanywhere in the world from the Control Center.Flow and M2X are available in North Americatoday and we are looking at deployments inEurope and elsewhere.

RD-W: There is maybe a perception in themarket that other companies bring the IoTsolutions. This strategy that you have outlinedindicates that is certainly not the case.

MK: Exactly so. The question we get asked is –what does AT&T bring? The answer is – we play atevery layer of the IoT stack, in ways that othercompanies just do not play. From all the thingswe’re talking about, from multi-network, toservice management and to the softwareplatform, it’s all about our accumulatedknowledge. We have been in this market for along time and understand the complexities ofmaking IoT solutions really work. www.att.com

55

Sponsored by:

Page 12: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

In Michigan winters are tough with extendedperiods of snow and sub-zero temperatures. TheCity of Holland has sought to keep pedestrianssafe from slipping on ice and snow by installing aSnow Melt system which uses waste heat fromthe city’s power generation plant to thawpavements across the municipality. Whilst idealfor its purpose, the system is costly to operaterequiring heat to be pumped around the city toensure all areas receive heat to enable thawingto occur.

“The Snow Melt system has been of tremendousvalue,” confirms Peter Hoffswell, the broadbandservices manager and technologist at the HollandBoard of Public Works. “Without the Snow Meltsystem, our downtown would basically shutdown. It’s using waste heat from the process ofproducing power in our power plant but we dohave to run pumps. These pumps are very largeand the less we can run them, the better so I waswondering if there could be a way we canoptimise our Snow Melt system by adding asensor system to it.”

Colleague Carl Thorwall, an electric powerengineer at the Board of Public Works, takes upthe story: “We never really had a good way ofmeasuring temperatures and performance,” hesays. “The challenge was always how do you getthe wires back to the powerplant but Peter hadthe idea of using wireless and connecting a

temperature sensor in a [paving] brick and theproject blossomed from there.”

Hoffswell began experimenting to develop a wayto measure temperature throughout the city,turning to the AT&T Starter Kit to create aprototype device. “Our first prototype is a boxwith the AT&T IoT Starter Kit and a set ofsensors,” he explains. “At the heart of the systemis AT&T Flow which makes the developmentprocess very easy.”

“One of the great things about Flow is that thereis an online code sharing component to it so theexample code that other people have developedout there and are willing to share is available,”Hoffswell adds. “That’s like a goldmine becauseyou don’t have to figure it out yourself. Someoneelse has already done it for you.”

The project swiftly gathered pace. “With Peter’sprototype we’re looking at making a smart brickwhere we reduce the size of the prototype andpackage all of the electronics in the back of abrick,” says Thorwall. “We’d then monitor thetemperature of the brick that is inserted into thepaver slabs, giving us the actual temperature ofthe various areas downtown.”

In this way a network of sensors covering thedowntown areas of Holland will be created. “If Ididn’t have Flow then I would have to hard code

In the City of Holland, Michigan, USA, the board of public works has turned to IoT to manage its SnowMelt system for clearing foot paths of snow and ice around the city more effectively. Here, we explorehow AT&T’s Flow was utilised to enable the city to design and develop a wireless sensor network

IoT Starter Kit enables enhancementsto Snow Melt system

IN ASSOCIATION WITH AT&T

CASE STUDY

“With Peter’sprototype we’re

looking at making asmart brick where

we reduce the size ofthe prototype andpackage all of theelectronics in theback of a brick,”

The prototype created using the AT&T IoT starter kit

56

Sponsored by:

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

Page 13: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

About the AT&T IoT Starter KitThe AT&T IoT Starter Kit comes witheverything a developer requires to starttheir next IoT project: hardware, services,data and integrations.

The kit contains the following itemsenabling developers to get started withsystems to address many different typesof IoT applications. These include:• Prepaid SIM• Humidity sensor• Fast LTE connectivity• Temperature sensor• I2C port• Arduino-compatible pinout• Cellular shield• Host board

The AT&T IoT Starter Kit is a completedeveloper kit with all the tools, servicesand integrations needed for design, build,deploy, manage and scale-up of IoTprojects. All the capabilities that areneeded for a project to scale up fromprototype to production come in the kit,so users can: prototype, build and hostIoT applications with AT&T Flow; launch,manage, and scale a connected devicebusiness or enterprise deployment fromthe AT&T Control Center; and access thedata plans and SIMs required to fullyaddress each project. The AT&T IoTStarter Kit comes with 300MB of dataand additional data can be added asprojects grow.

it myself,” adds Hoffswell. “It is great because I can bring the raw datafrom our sensor out in the street and react to it. My AT&T Flow has aTwitter integration so if the temperature falls below freezing at streetlevel, we’re in trouble and we’ll actually get a tweet alerting us.”

This translates into operational cost savings, as Thorwall explains:“Having the ability to monitor the temperatures of bricks gives us thecapability to reduce the pumping load and this saves money onenergy and pumping costs for the city.”

For Hoffswell, the ease of development offered by AT&T Flow hasbeen a key enabler of the project. “The AT&T IoT Starter Kit reallygives you the full set of tools,” he says. “Not only the hardware butthe software that allows you to go from an idea to a prototype to anactual running production device.”

www.att.com

Peter Hoffswell, Holland Board of Public Works

Carl Thorwall, Holland Board of Public Works

57

Sponsored by:

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

Page 14: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

58 IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyers' Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

Starhome Mach is headquartered in Zurich, Switzerland and Stream Technologies is based in London, UK. Starhome Mach has300 employees and Stream has 33. Both companies do not disclose their financial information.

Stream enables more than 700 global enterprises, including Fortune 500 companies, and Starhome Mach has an exceptionalcustomer base that encompasses more than 300 global mobile network operators in over 130 countries, including many of thetier-1 operators and 24 leading telecom groups. Both companies are private and don’t publicly disclose customers.

www.starhomemach.com/products/CLM www.stream-technologies.com/iotx/

Company summary

In order to develop a strong and healthy IoT business, and in order to differentiate themselves in the very crowded IoTconnectivity space, mobile network operators (MNOs) need a robust and feature-rich connected devices platform (CDP), at areasonable total cost of ownership (TCO). Many operators that implemented a CDP in the past, realise now that the solution is notflexible enough to support their new connectivity business needs, and is also too costly to manage.

Starhome Mach and Stream’s joint offering covers the complete IoT connectivity lifecycle. The IoT Connectivity LifecycleManagement platform delivers a real-time, worry-free experience for the IoT-engaged MNO and their enterprise customers.

The offering includes:• IoT device provisioning (2G, 3G, 4G, LoRa and NB-IoT)• Real-time device monitoring• Real-time alerting and troubleshooting• Steering of roaming to optimise QoS and coverage in IoT• Multi-tiered account structure capabilities• Powerful application programme interface (API) integration capabilities • GSMA eUICC compliant

One of the stand-out synergies of the joint offering is service continuity. This enables MNOs to balance between wholesaleagreements constraints and quality of service needed for each connected device.

IoT platform offering

Unlike other solutions in the market, Stream and Starhome Mach integrate their solution directly into the MNO’s core networkwhich increases the reliability and puts the companies in the best position to identify and handle the quality of service issues ofthe MNO’s end customers in real-time and cost effective manner.

The companies claim their joint offering consists of several unique features including : • Multi-tiered accounts to support complex enterprise environments• Technology agnostic platform (eUICCID, LoRaWAN , LTE-M, NB-IOT) • Real-time device monitoring, alerting and troubleshooting• Easy integration to the network (the companies have many years of successful integration experience addressing hundreds of

network solutions in all types of networks)• Steering of roaming to optimise QoS and coverage in IoT • Powerful API integration capabilities• Multi-tiered accounts• Modularity – can integrate on top of, or side-by-side existing CDP• Short deployment time • eSIM subscription and download ready

Key differentiators

Starhome Mach: Eli Berman, director of product management, Starhome [email protected] Tel: +972-54-2522146

Stream Technologies:Niall Strachan, chief product officer, Stream [email protected] +44 (0)844 800 8520

Contact Information

COMPANY PROFILE

IN ASSOCIATION WITH STARHOME MACH AND STREAM TECHNOLOGIES

Page 15: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

59

Digicel Business required a connectivitymanagement platform that could be integratedinto existing network components such asprovisioning application programme interfaces(APIs), billing and the core network for theDigicel Group roaming SIM card offering. Thecentral requirement was to enable the DigicelGroup to offer its roaming SIM solution to itssubsidiary networks and enterprise customers viaindividual instances of the connectivity platform.This would allow each local Digicel operator toon-board and manage its own customers.

In addition to subscriber management and billingservices, Digicel required an element of managedconnectivity to facilitate the creation of privateaccess point names (APNs), segregatedcustomer traffic and intelligent IP routing inorder to open up new business opportunities inthe M2M and IoT market.

What was the answer?The IoT-X solution involved deploying a Digicelbranded instance of IoT-X onto Stream andStarhome Mach’s existing US infrastructure andintegrating all of Digicel’s core components to fitits business processes and requirements formulti-tenant architecture for their 33 subsidiarynetworks.

“Progressive carriers like Digicel are hungry formulti-technology, access agnostic solutionsbecause IoT requires more than just activating aSIM card,” says industry analyst James Brehm.“The adoption of IoT-X places Digicel squarelyamong the most innovative network operators inthe IoT marketplace.”

The deployment included: • The IoT-X Enterprise Interface, which allows

Digicel’s end customers to manage their account and subscribers.

• The IoT-X Customer Management interface, which allows Digicel support representatives to create, manage and support customers and their SIM cards if required.

• RESTful Enterprise APIs, which allow customers to integrate elements of the platform into their own applications. This includes custom branded API documentation which is hosted online for ease of use.

• RESTful Management APIs, which enable the automation of provisioning and customer account creation.

• IaaS (Infrastructure as a Service), which facilitates managed data transit and RADIUS services.

These core components were then integratedinto Digicel’s core network through thefollowing means: • Integration into Digicel’s existing billing system

to facilitate the provisioning of SIM cards onto the home location register (HLR) and produce call data records (CDRs) for each subscriber.

• Integration between Digicel’s core network and Stream’s APN infrastructure to facilitate authentication, authorisation and accounting for each subscriber.

• Integration into two packet gateways to provide a geographical and resilient connection to facilitate the transit of data from each subscriber to the internet or customer- application.

When Digicel required a connectivity managementplatform to enable it to provide connectivityservices to the 33 M2M markets throughout theCaribbean, Central America and Asia Pacificregions, it turned to the IoT-X platform from StreamTechnologies – which now benefits from additionaltechnologies from Starhome Mach

Digicel Groupuses IoT-X tomanage customerconnectivity

IN ASSOCIATION WITH STREAM TECHNOLOGIES AND STARHOME MACH

CASE STUDY

“Progressivecarriers like Digicelare hungry formulti-technology,access agnosticsolutions becauseIoT requires morethan just activatinga SIM card,”

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

Page 16: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com60

How was IoT-X delivered? The platform was deployed within an eight-weektime-frame, which ranged from the project kick-offto the first Digicel customer being deployed onIoT-X. The rapid deployment of the solution wasaccomplished through tight project managementand clear requirements gathering supported bythe agile integration properties of IoT-X. Followingon from the deployment and integration of theplatform, Digicel is provided with managed servicesupport around successful onboarding and billingof Digicel’s end customers during a crawl, walk,run phase.

What Were the Results? As a result of deploying IoT-X, the Digicel Group isnow capable of targeting previously unattainablemarkets through its Jamaica based sales teams orvia any of its 33 subsidiary networks.

Each network can easily create new customeraccounts, apply flexible tariffs that can be tailoredand allocate SIM cards to customers. The endcustomer is able to manage their account andsubscriber lifecycle process themself. At the endof each month, billing information is reported toeach Digicel network and this information can beintegrated into third-party invoicing systems togenerate the end invoice for M2M services.

These capabilities have allowed Digicel to createthe following business offerings: • M2M Managed Connectivity • M2M Security Services• M2M Smart Metering• M2M Vehicle Services

About Digicel Since launching in Jamaica in April 2001, Digicel hasbecome one of the fastest growing mobiletelecommunications operators in the Caribbean region. Today Digicel is known for its strong commitment toproviding consumers with the best value, best service andbest network across Jamaica and the Caribbean. Thiscommitment led the company to establish Digicel Biz in2005, which later grew into Digicel Business in 2006.

Digicel Business was established to meet the businessdemands of Jamaican organisations such as governmentministries and agencies, private and publicly listedcompanies as well as small and medium sized enterprises.Digicel Business provides customers with customisedproducts and services to suit their business needs and helpsthem to improve efficiencies across their operations whileachieving savings.

Today, Digicel Business serves more than 70% of corporateJamaica, offering a wide variety of products and servicesranging from voice, data, IP-PBX, roaming, closed usergroup service, BlackBerry solutions, ICT, plus businesscontinuity solutions from its Tier III Certified data centre.Digicel Business continues to integrate the best people, themost innovative solutions, the strongest coverage inJamaica and superior customer service to deliver on theirstrategy and create value and growth for companies.

www.stream-technologies.comwww.starhomemach.com

CASE STUDY

Page 17: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

61IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyers' Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

Actility is located in Paris, France, with regional offices in the UK, Benelux, USA, Hong Kong, Singapore, China, Taiwan, Japan,Korea and Australia. The company has 150 employees and does not disclose financial information, although it recently raised$75m in a Series D funding round. Customers include: Orange, Swisscom, KPN, Comcast, Proximus, Digita, Netzikon, APT,Softbank, Inmarsat, Comsol, du and NTT

www.actility.com/products

Company summary

Actility’s ThingPark is a carrier grade solution enabling scalable low power wide area (LPWA) networks and interoperable IoTapplications and services.

ThingPark Wireless is a core network management and supervision solution for LPWA connectivity, designed from the beginningfor carrier-grade solutions.

ThingPark OS is a central IoT management service which enables operators to manage services and offers, and monetise theirnetwork.

ThingPark X is a data analytics and control framework which exposes data from connected things to applications and connectswith cloud platforms, and also offers off the shelf IoT industrial applications.

ThingPark Market is a B2B ecommerce platform for buyers and sellers, aggregating, distributing and connecting IoT devices andapplications to the ThingPark platform.

ThingPark is fully modular and can be optimised to specific customer requirements. In particular enterprise customers can benefitfrom highly scalable solutions from small campus deployments managing a few gateways and tens-hundreds of connectedobjects for a solution addressing a single use case, right the way up to national-scale private networks covering multiple locationsfor a wide range of use cases (such as a smart city platform). The platform also offers additional services such as internationalroaming management and a location/tracking application programme interface (API), if required.

IoT platform offering

Actility is a pioneer in LPWA technology, and being a leading innovator in the space brings an early to market advantage indeveloping and deploying solutions. For example, earlier this year Actility announced the availability of roaming betweennetworks for IoT devices based on early implementation of the standard designed and ratified by the LoRa Alliance. Thistechnology leadership position has helped Actility win many major deployments, and also drives the recruitment of partners tothe ecosystem.

Although expertise in LoRaWAN is at the heart of Actility’s success to date, we have recently announced that the ThingParkplatform will support devices connected over the 3GPP cellular technologies, LTE-M and NB-IoT. Through partnership andacquisitions, Actility is also extending the capabilities of the ThingPark platform in other directions. For example, workingexclusively with Abeeway, Actility is now offering ThingPark Location, a unique service combining the capabilities of GPS, networkbased location technology, Assisted GPS, beacons and WiFi sniffing into a single flexible capability to find, track or geofence anyconnected IoT sensor.

Key differentiators

David Royet, EMEA business development director: [email protected]

Contact Information

COMPANY PROFILE

IN ASSOCIATION WITH ACTILITY

Page 18: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

INTERVIEW

Saverio Romeo: What strategic argument isleading Nokia in the Internet of Things arena?

Marc Jadoul: Nokia creates the technology toconnect the world. Powered by the research andinnovation of Nokia Bell Labs, we servecommunications service providers (CSPs),governments, large enterprises and consumerswith the industry’s most complete, end-to-endportfolio of products, services and licensing. Our company mantra is all about shaping thefuture of technology to transform the humanexperience. We strongly believe that IoT networks,platforms, applications, and ecosystems areinstrumental to realizing that vision. We enable thatthrough four key areas: mobile broadband and 5Gnetworks for the IoT, cloud and software solutions,security solutions, and connected devices.

SR: How do you see the status of the IoT market?

MJ: The term IoT is used all around, but there isno single definition for it. IoT is an evolution ofmachine-to-machine (M2M) communication,which enables networked devices to exchangeinformation and perform actions without themanual assistance of humans.

There is an essential difference between M2M andIoT: how the data is generated by all thesedevices and how it is used to create value. IoT isfuelled by the convergence of M2Mcommunications and big data analytics.

While traditional M2M applications often targetthe automation, and industrial systems andprocesses, the IoT provides companies withinnovative means for new products and services.Today, we are basically still very much in a M2Mera, but things are moving fast towards the IoTvision. The IoT Community, which is the name ofNokia’s IoT ecosystem, has all the tools forenabling that rapid transition.

SR: Besides different interpretations andforecasts of the future of IoT, the consensus isthat we are moving towards fully connectedenvironments. Which is the key element forenabling that evolution?

MJ: Nokia considers IoT technologies as a meansfor realizing the programmable world vision,which is an ultra-connected environment in whichmassive numbers of objects will become boundtogether with intelligence that is built upon vastamounts of data processed in the cloud and usedto automate and simplify processes, and tocreate new services.

Connectivity is a key feature for theprogrammable world. Connected devices needrobust and scalable connectivity. Today there aremany different access technologies, but not allare addressing the critical needs for IoTconnectivity, security and battery life. This is thekey reason for the emerging 3GPP standards –NB-IoT, LTE-M, EC-GSM – in low power wide areanetworks (LPWAN).

High availability and low latency will be requiredfor many critical IoT solutions. Extendedcoverage will be essential to penetrate deep intobuildings, while Multi-access Edge Computing(MEC) allows to rapidly process content at thevery edge of the network. And, finally, 5G willenable the data-rich applications of the IoT.

SR: Connectivity is then a building block foryour vision of the IoT. Can you tell me moreabout the role of software and platforms?

MJ: Technological developments in storage,processing, visualisation, cloud networking andartificial intelligence (AI) are opening new roadsfor application innovation and new value creation.By adding software intelligence and automationinto every connection, process and service, newopportunities are becoming possible. The valueof the IoT lies in the data, its manipulation and itsrepresentation. Therefore, IoT-specific IT andoperations technology (OT) platforms play acrucial role.

Eventually, IoT is going to become an integralpart of the evolving enterprise IT environment.Enterprise architects will be looking for commonoff the shelf (COTS) components, and work withsystem integrators that can make them fit withtheir current IT infrastructure, rather than

The IoT platform landscape is among the most dynamic and rich areas in the IoT community.Here, Saverio Romeo, the principal analyst at Beecham Research, interviews Marc Jadoul, the

market development director for Internet of Things at Nokia to learn about the company’s viewon the IoT and its IMPACT (Intelligent Management Platform for All Connected Things)

Discovering IMPACT, the Nokiahorizontal IoT platform

IN ASSOCIATION WITH NOKIA

62

High availabilityand low latencywill be required

for many criticalIoT solutions

Page 19: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com63

deploying vendor-driven end-to-end solutions. Inthis scenario, data integrity, privacy and securityare prime concerns to take into consideration.

SR: How does IMPACT help the move towardsfully connected environments?

MJ: A horizontal platform breaks the silos of theM2M world facilitating development of differentapplications just reusing the platform features.The connected environments are then developedquickly and more cost efficiently. IMPACT doesthat. It enables application developers, devicemanufacturers and service providers to usecommon infrastructures, and share platformfunctions and data.

SR: Can you then describe the key features ofIMPACT?

MJ: IMPACT stands for an Intelligent ManagementPlatform for All Connected Things. It providescustomers with a standards-based platform forsecurely managing any device, protocol, orapplication. The key elements of IMPACT are:• IMPACT’s device management function already

provides lifecycle management for more than 1.5 billion managed devices and 80,000 device types are recognised.

• Data collection layers between the devices or aggregators and the applications facilitate data acquisition as well as fault and power monitoring,provisioning, configuration, remote diagnostics

• IMPACT securely onboards devices. It collects andanalyses the data gathered from these devices. These are exposed through an application programme interface (API) layer with an extensible object model that allows for flexible devices and use cases to be added without programmatic change.

• It also provides a console for remote monitoring data and event. It provides an application enablement component that helps platform users to develop applications.

• The platform also includes network, cloud and end-point security. It implements the latest Lightweight M2M (LWM2M) security model for IoT device management and is backed by Nokia’s extensive security portfolio.

• Finally, a connectivity management component manages high volumes of connections from sensors and devices, including those that with embedded SIMs and eSIMs and LPWAN devices. It also offers flexible deployment and modules for billing, mediation and customer relationship management (CRM).

• IMPACT is agnostic from a connectivity pointof view.

• IMPACT can be simply integrated with third party application enablement and connectivity management platforms.

SR: Can you share some examples of how IMPACTcan serve different sectors and applications?

MJ: In the applications layer, we have a two-sidedapproach. On one hand, we are building-out ourecosystem, which already has over 340 partners. But we are also implementing several use casesthat focus on a selected number of verticals, forwhich we see clear market drivers and viablebusiness cases. These include examples in theautomotive, utilities, public safety, smart citiesand healthcare industries.

SR: Does IMPACT enable those applications ordoes the offering include a set of pre-developed application services as well?

MJ: The latest release of the IMPACT platformcomes with a starter pack of pre-integratedapplications that allow customers to deploy ainitial set of secure revenue-generating IoTservices for smart cities and fleet managers:video analytics powered by Nokia Bell Labs’machine learning algorithms, smart parkingapplication, smart lighting application, andvehicle applications.

IMPACT is also a component of the Nokia smarthome solution, based upon our Z-Wave andZigBee enabled residential gateway, and a mobileapplication for your smartphone or tablet tocontrol and manage the devices.

SR: On what type of business model is IMPACTbased? Do you offer related services such assupport and integration with other solutions?

MJ: The IMPACT platform is multi-tenant and canbe provided as an on-premise as well as a cloud-based solution. It enables secure XaaS hosting ofdevices, applications and data from different IoTservice providers.

IMPACT combines with our NetGuard securityportfolio to monitor IoT devices, detect malware,draw correlations between events in differentparts of the network, and set security parametersto minimise the chance of successful attacks.Furthermore, our Global Services people have theexpertise to design, plan, integrate and customisethe connectivity, platform and application layersto meet the needs of different customers. Andfinally, we have recently launched the NokiaWorldwide IoT network grid, our global managedconnectivity service that enables CSPs to quicklybecome IoT providers. www.nokia.com

Marc Jadoul, Nokia

The IMPACTplatform is multi-tenant and can beprovided as anon-premise aswell as a cloud-based solution

Page 20: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com64

To complete their work efficiently, techniciansusually require a service vehicle, an inventory ofparts, mechanical tools, measuring and testingdevices, a laptop and a mobile device. Standardsolutions often only address pieces of theproblem in silos and these kinds of enablers donot necessarily address the problem of creatingan efficient workday. Work orders are generallyprovided in paper form and ensuring that theright inventory and tools are in the vehicle isoften a manual process involving a degree ofguesswork. Further inefficiencies are likelybecause dispatchers are usually unaware of workorder status, inventory usage, tool status, and soon, until a technician returns to the depot withreports and paperwork for the day or week. Inaddition, many equipment activation processesmay require interaction with a central operationscentre and/or demand that a technician contact acall centre and enter a queue to have someone

activate a product or service to test it. Thestreamlined automation made possible by today’stechnology is clearly absent.

A recent example of the application of the NokiaIMPACT horizontal platform for IoT into the fieldservice segment was market trialled in NewZealand. This case study example had multiplestandalone vertical applications that wereintegrated and centrally managed due to thecapabilities of the IMPACT IoT platform. Thehorizontal integration of fleet management,customer premise equipment provisioning,inventory management, as well as technicianvideo communications and training, enabledbusiness value to be unlocked by greatlyimproving the productivity of the entirebroadband installation process for Chorus, a NewZealand national broadband service provider.Beyond productivity improvements, there was an ▼

Today’s widespread use of field service technicians and vehicles – coupled with the speed oftechnological innovation – calls for a transformational technology solution that changes the face of field

services and the supply chain. Many types of enterprises depend on a field service force to set up, install,enable and maintain their products, services and applications. Almost any type of product or service that

requires a reasonably complex setup and installation process on the customer’s premises will utilise afield service technician to perform the associated tasks

Nokia horizontal platformpositively IMPACTs productivity

at Chorus New Zealand

CASE STUDY

IN ASSOCIATION WITH NOKIA

Page 21: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com65

additional revenue opportunity identified byoffering a new provisioning service for thecommunications service providers (CSPs) withdirect customer contact.

The solutionFigure 1 shows how the IMPACT IoT platform wasdeployed to solve the problem by integratingmanagement of sensors and devices, workflowand inventory, enhanced communications,support for material delivery and management,and real-time visibility to system status by thekey players within the value delivery chain. Such asolution could save time, reduce errors, minimisecost, increase collaboration, and provide betterdocumentation while simultaneously improvingthe experience of the most important player inthe chain – the end customer. Improvingcustomer experience along the entire value chainand providing a positive return on investment(ROI) in the process makes such a solution anobvious choice to create and implement.

Business benefitsThe value chain and players that perform theinstallation process may sometimes be complex.The more complex, the more importanttransparency and access to real-time statusbecome. As an example, in the case of thismarket trial the network provider uses third-partyinstallers. There are numerous relationships andmuch complexity built into the value chain thatperforms broadband installations under theChorus brand. This has clear benefits in efficiencyand time-to-market, but requires all players tohave a common ability to share data and havereal-time visibility of installation status — which

can be provided by the IMPACT solution. In thiscase, the benefits flow to the entire chain, buteven if the relationships were simpler, theconcept still provides value because even within asingle company these organisational boundariesand resulting challenges exist. Deployment ofIMPACT with the visibility to data enabled greatlyreduces complexity of the installation process.

Results summary• 30% to 40% of the warehouse manager’s time

was saved via IMPACT inventory management application integration to enable inventory automation and tracking.

• Errors and mistakes due to use of paper and manual inventory tracking were eliminated by automating workflow and integration with IMPACT.

• Total installation time was reduced by between one-third to one-half.

• US$77 dollars (NZ$102, €71) per update per vehicle can be avoided utilizing IMPACT device management to perform OTA vehicle and device updates.

• Training documentation was simpler to find and track.

Figure 1 – Nokia IMPACT platform applied to the field service segment

www.nokia.com

The value chain and players that perform theinstallation process may sometimes be complex. Themore complex, the more important transparency and

access to real-time status become

Page 22: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

66 IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyers' Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

Company summary Vodafone is one of the world’s largest telecommunicationscompanies and provides a range of services including voice,messaging, data and fixed communications. Vodafone hasmobile operations in 26 countries, partners with mobilenetworks in 49 more, and fixed broadband operations in 17markets. As of 31 December 2016, Vodafone had 470 millionmobile customers and 14.3 million fixed broadband customers.Vodafone Group has 108,000 employees and Vodafone IoThas 1,400. For more information, please visit:www.vodafone.com.

Vodafone IoT Vodafone IoT was established as a separate line of businesswithin Vodafone Group Enterprise in 2010. The VodafoneManaged IoT Connectivity Platform is fully owned andmanaged by Vodafone IoT. Vodafone IoT currently has over50 million IoT connections as of Q3 16/17.

Financial information Vodafone is publicly listed and the company’s latest resultscan be viewed in detail here:www.vodafone.com/content/dam/vodafone/investors/financial_results_feeds/tradingupdate_31december2016/q3-16-17-presentation.pdf

Customers Vodafone IoT customers include: BMW, Porsche, Amazon,Yamaha, Ekso Bionics, ASD Healthcare, Somfy, Moocall,Kärcher, TomTom, Globe Tracker, Philips, Ford, Kone, AntTail,Atlas Copco, Mobike, DriveNow, Medtronic, Polar Krush andFeintool.

IoT platform offeringThe Vodafone Managed IoT Connectivity Platform is acomprehensive platform comprising of advanced connectivitymanagement software integrated with Vodafone’s dedicated

IoT core network and global SIM. This provides a high-level ofperformance and security in over 200 destinations. The corenetwork is entirely dedicated to IoT so Vodafone has controlof its availability, security and service levels, offering a servicethat addresses mission critical IoT use cases and standards.

The Vodafone Managed IoT Connectivity Platform is highlycustomisable which means that we can shape and configuresolutions to address the needs of different customer verticals.For instance a large multi-national automotive company mayneed distinct and different services and configuration fordifferent markets.

In the automotive sector, the platform is at the heart of theInternet in the Car service that provides diagnostics,infotainment, Wi-Fi hotspot and consumer billing to many ofthe world’s leading vehicle manufacturers in accordance withlocal market regulations.

For the utility sector we introduced various features and thecapability to support the mass roll out and provisioning ofservices, including quality of service over 4G for smart grid,IPv6 for smart metering as well as customer specificdevelopment to support the change of supplier.

Key differentiators• A dedicated global SIM, network and platform. The network is not shared with the consumer mobile network and has specifically dedicated international mobile subscriber identity (IMSI) ranges for IoT• The underlying design of the platform is highly secure because of its close integration with the IoT core network and the global SIM• Complete control of the roadmap enables Vodafone to rapidly develop and enhance the platform to be reactive to new industry and customer requirements• The Vodafone Managed IoT Connectivity Platform has demonstrable scale in terms of process and technology - important for customers deploying large numbers of devices across the globe as well as for medium and small organisations that want a platform that is proven and established• Vodafone is the only mobile network operator that offers its IoT platform to CSPs/MNOs, in addition to selling directly to Vodafone customers. For operators, our platform is accompanied by an IoT Partner Enablement Programme that delivers immediate competitive advantage in the rapidly expanding IoT market

www.vodafone.com/business/iot/managed-iot-connectivity-platform

Tel: 0044 7444 325 793Email: [email protected]

Contact Information

COMPANY PROFILE

IN ASSOCIATION WITH VODAFONE

Page 23: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

67

If you drive a modern car there’s a goodchance you’ve come into contact with aFeintool product. Feintool is a world leader infineblanking, a production technique forcomplex steel parts commonly used in theautomotive sector. Whether it’s a seatbelt or atransmission part, there’s a good chance that itis a Feintool product.

100 million items a yearFeintool produces around 50 of its largepresses a year, each taking several months tobuild. Once in service, each machine workshard. A press producing clutch parts for an

automotive manufacturer could produce upto 100 million items a year, working aroundthe clock.

“These machines typically operate 18-21 shiftsa week,” says Marc Schneeberger, the businessdevelopment manager at Feintool.“Maintenance has to be carefully planned.There is limited downtime.”

For Feintool this challenge represents anopportunity. How to keep its presses runninglonger, reduce maintenance costs and getcloser to its best customers? ▼

Feintool is a manufacturer of presses for fineblanking. The company has created amonitoring system that refines data into actionable insights. The solution, calledFEINmonitoring, promises to ensure the smooth running of Feintool machines,optimise production uptime for Feintool customers and provide them with a webportal access to its machine data

Testing disc carriers for transmissionsSource: Feintool

A Feintool employee processestransmission components Source: Feintool

Feintool workstirelessly to eliminatemanufacturing downtime

IN ASSOCIATION WITH VODAFONE

CASE STUDY

“Maintenance hasto be carefullyplanned. There islimited downtime”

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

Page 24: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

68

Keeping the presses runningCreating a stand-alone condition monitoringsolution locally on the press failed to addressthe problem. “We still needed an engineer tovisit or download the data with a remotemaintenance tool and assess the press,” saysSchneeberger. “Often we were arriving toolate. To be really effective we needed to getthe data sent from the press, in near real-time,to an engineer off-site.”

Feintool needed connectivity independent ofthe customers’ network and it needed a globalsolution. “We’re global, our customers areglobal, efficiency is a global concern,” adds

Schneeberger. “Also, we wanted a platform onwhich to manage this service, and forcustomers to make sense of the data. Finally,we wanted a solutions provider expert in datasecurity matters. This is not our area ofexpertise, and we will not risk our customers’data.”

The solutionMitch Greeley, a condition monitoring engineerat Feintool, explains that Vodafone camealong at the right time. “We had the idea andour service team were very keen on extendingour offer to customers, but Vodafone camewith the expertise,” he says.

The Vodafone IoT service sees a Machinelink3G device connected to all new Feintoolpresses. This device is then connected viaVodafone global IoT SIMs; customers can thenmonitor Feintool presses via Vodafone’sRemote Monitoring and Control Service(RMCS). Feintool can ship presses toanywhere in the world and activate theconnectivity when necessary.Vodafone, Greeley continues, met everyrequirement for the successful roll-out of theconnectivity. “The 3G connectivity standsseparate to the customers’ network, Vodafoneunderstands data security, and it is thecomplete solution,” he adds. “Since wedecided on Vodafone we’ve had to do verylittle work.”

To read more Vodafone IoT case studies visit:http://www.vodafone.com/iotcasestudies

CASE STUDY

Tool maintenance is essential for ultraprecise parts production

Source: Feintool

Quality checking for a disc carrier Source: Feintool

“We had the ideaand our service

team were very keenon extending our

offer to customers,but Vodafone camewith the expertise”

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

Page 25: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

69IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyers' Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

Cumulocity is the leading Internet of Things (IoT) device management and application enablement platform. Cumulocity is usedby global brands, including Deutsche Telekom, Software AG and Gardner Denver, to power IoT solutions in manufacturing, fleetmanagement, consumer electronics and many more verticals.

Cumulocity’s headquarters is in Dusseldorf, Germany with regional offices in Boston, USA and Singapore. As a member of theSoftware AG group (Frankfurt TecDAX: SOW), Cumulocity is supported by 1,800 consultants in 70 countries. It is fully alignedwith the Software AG Digital Business Platform and spearheads the exploitation of IoT in our customers’ digital transformations.

The Cumulocity IoT platform is a white-label product that allows IoT solutions to be built by end-users in minutes and freelyextended with open publicly documented application programme interfaces (APIs) and software development kits (SDKs). As aresult, Cumulocity is one of the most widely used IoT platforms in the market with customers including: Telstra, Telia Company,Etisalat, NTT Communications, Teleena, QuarkIoE, Tieto, Sensor Technik Wiedemann, Octo, PayPal, E.On, Lyreco, Certuss, Winoraand Trackerando.

Company summary

Cumulocity is an open IoT platform that allows users to develop IoT solutions in minutes and deploy them with carrier gradesecurity, reliability and scalability. Our mass customisable IoT platform incorporates device management, real-time analytics andvisualisation, which can be easily tailored via publicly documented APIs, an open user interface (UI) framework and open sourcedevice apps. The platform is device, network and use case agnostic with more than 150 pre-integrated devices, connectivitymanagement platform integration and industrial fieldbus support.

As a horizontal platform, Cumulocity is used in a wide variety of solutions across all industry segments including: vehiclemonitoring, preventative maintenance, supply chain optimisation, consumer electronics, energy grid management, insurance,building management, traffic monitoring, structural monitoring, logistics and mobile payments.

Cumulocity can be deployed across more than 160 global cloud data centres, on-premise, on-site or as a multi-layered hybrid. Ouractive partner eco-system and 3,000 strong developer community ensure that our customers’ IoT initiatives are successful.

IoT platform offering

• Full IoT solution platform with connectivity management adapters, device connectors, device management, real-time analytics, visualisation, application hosting and integration.

• Power user focus allows office IT skilled end-users to build their own IoT solutions in minutes.• IoT domain model enables device establishment on connection, automatic management of changes and device abstraction in

applications.• Open, publicly documented and extensible through plug-ins, APIs and hosted applications which means that there is no

vendor lock-in and a 3,000 strong developer community available for support.• White-label product, rebrandable and fully industrialised with advanced automation processes which ensure that customer

and end-customer branded IoT solutions can be developed and maintained with ease.• Carrier grade for security, reliability and scalability with flexible deployment across geo-distributed cloud, on-premise, on-site

and multi-layered hybrids with high availability options. We are regularly assessed against the stringent security and operational regulations of our many telecommunication operator customers.

Key differentiators

[email protected]

Contact Information

COMPANY PROFILE

IN ASSOCIATION WITH CUMULOCITY

Page 26: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

70

Rising consumerisation, regulatory constrictionand increasing global competition are drivingeconomic change. Organisations must learn togrow, reduce risks and simplify their operationalpractices with alarming speed to avoiddisruptions to their businesses. As organisationsface change, they are proactively choosing todigitise their products and assets to exploitnew opportunities and take advantage ofoperational efficiencies.

Companies like Gardner Denver have harnessedinnovation in their businesses to take advantageof the connected, digital future. By embeddingtechnology in its solutions, Gardner Denver isable to redefine the relationship between itself, itspartners and its customers. The company is nolonger strictly reliant on product-based sales andhas used Internet of Things (IoT) technology toinnovate and diversify.

The Cumulocity IoT platform allows GardnerDenver’s business-to-business customers torapidly, efficiently and securely improve thereliability of equipment, co-innovate with newcustomer offerings and create long-termrelationships between partners in its ecosystem.Businesses are changing their strategies andtechnologies to be ahead of the disruptions theyare facing.

About Gardner DenverGardner Denver is a leading, global provider ofhigh-quality industrial equipment, technologies

and services to a broad and diverse customerbase through a family of highly recognisedbrands. The company was founded in 1859 andhas 40 manufacturing facilities located in theAmericas, EMEA, and Asia Pacific with offices in32 different countries. With an extensive networkof dedicated sales companies and distributors,Gardner Denver offers global expertise with trulylocal service capability, ensuring their advancedtechnologies are backed up with full support.

Improved machinery performanceGardner Denver’s customers rely on thecontinuous operation of their industrialequipment. Eliminating downtime is the ultimategoal for industrial equipment and Gardner Denverpartners and customers take pride in the qualityand performance of their equipment. So GardnerDenver wanted to find a cost-effective way toincrease machine quality and reduce downtime. Gardner Denver sells its equipment through astrong, global set of partners and distributors, soit needed a way to capture operationalinformation from its machinery and provide it tothe organisations best placed to support itscustomers. Each partner and distributor takespride in, and ownership of, its customers, sohaving a solution that is secure and unique toeach partner and distributor is very important.

Gardner Denver adopts theCumulocity IoT PlatformGardner Denver adopted and configured theCumulocity IoT Platform to provide condition

CASE STUDY

Gardner Denver performs condition monitoring on its industrial air compressors to give customers remotevisibility of operation and to allow proactive servicing. The company turned to Cumulocity to provide anIoT platform to enable it to innovate and diversify from selling products to selling services

Compressed air assured withCumulocity IoT platform

IN ASSOCIATION WITH CUMULOCITY

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

Page 27: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

71

monitoring for its highly important industrial aircompressor business. Gardner Denver chose aircompressors as a first deployment for theCumulocity platform because of the need for asecure, unique IoT platform for the distributorsand service partners for each of its 16 brands.This IoT solution provides Gardner Denver withreal-time monitoring of various operationalparameters on its air compressors; real-timedetection of fault situations; online storage andon-demand distribution to the correct GardnerDenver service partner; remote configuration ofthe industrial air compressors; and customisedmanagement, operational and technicaldashboards. And equally important, eachCumulocity IoT Platform is fully rebranded foreach Gardner Denver brand, providing a uniquelybranded customer experience that distributorsand service partners can offer.

ResultsCumulocity’s IoT Platform allows Gardner Denverto successfully offer its IoT-powered conditionmonitoring service to its global customersthrough its extensive network of distribution andservice partners. Proactively monitoringequipment, identifying faults and sharing thatinformation in real-time with partners increasesthe value that these distribution and servicepartners can offer to their customers.

End-customer benefits of an IoT-poweredGardner Denver air compressor include:

• Equipment downtime minimised: Proactive monitoring increases equipment reliability which improves operational efficiencies of customer organisations.

• Reduce time for servicing: Information about the detected faults, that couldn’t be resolved remotely, are used to prepare service engineers

and proactively source space parts.

• Remote usage visibility: Real-time visibility of operating statistics provides a transparent view of the customer organisations’ needs and possible requirements for early equipment replacements.

• Extensible for additional equipment: Future-proofed and can be used with any additional equipment and for customer specific requirements.

Key benefits to Gardner Denver of using theCumulocity IoT platform include:

• Very fast time to market: Adoption of the fully customisable, tailor-made Cumulocity software allowed the Gardner Denver condition monitoring service to be available in weeks.

• Multi-brand and multi-partner support: The flexible Cumulocity IoT Platform provides sophisticated user-access controls that align to the eco-system of distributors and service partners for each of Gardner Denver’s many compressor brands.

• Cost-effective pricing model: The usage-based monthly Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) fee grows with customer additions. And set-up fees were fully transparent.

Sia Abbaszadeh, the vice president of globalmarketing and technology at Gardner Denver,describes the value that the company has foundfrom its IoT solution. “Cumulocity allows us toprovide a uniquely branded, secure IoT platformmonitoring solution to each of our compressordistributors and service partners,” he says. “Thisallows them to offer a high-quality, real-timemonitoring solution to their customers.” www.cumulocity.com

Cumulocity’s IoTPlatform allowsGardner Denver tosuccessfully offer itsIoT-poweredcondition monitoringservice to its globalcustomers through itsextensive network ofdistribution andservice partners

Air compressor operation is displayed on dashboards

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

Page 28: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

IOT PLATFORMS

72

Sponsored by:

An IoT platform is actually something that doeswhat a user wants it to do and the definition isincreasingly fluid and determined from theperspective of the user. “An IoT platform needs tonot have not only the technical capabilities toenable businesses to adopt IoT with minimalcapex and with maximum agility and reach, butalso the business capabilities that allowbusinesses to generate new revenues from IoTservices,” says Mick Higgins, the vice president ofMobility at Tata Communications. “It needs to beunderpinned by global ubiquitous connectivityand partnerships in the world’s mobileecosystem.”

Others take a similar view, identifying a blend oftechnical capabilities augmented with flexibilityand reach. “An IoT platform is really any cloud-based product that can connect with IoT devicesto provide interconnectivity or functions thatwould otherwise be significantly morecomplicated to achieve,” says Craig Foster, themanaging director of HomeServe Labs. “As astandalone term IoT platform doesn’t mean thatmuch, but it is useful to have a category so thatIoT developers know that it’s something targetedtowards them and could help them add morefunctionality more quickly. Like anything, theterm can be widely used and abused andshouldn’t be relied on as clear definition ofexactly what to expect. There is no reason whyone device couldn’t use multiple IoT platforms.”

For Jason Kay, the chief commercial officer atIMS Evolve: “A platform that can unlock access touseful data from existing and future

infrastructure, enabling the ability to make betterbusiness decisions and release continuous andevolving value across your estate,” he explains.“An IoT platform needs to be able to use existingdata and contextualise against existing systems,giving an organisation the ability to automate ordistribute useful and actionable informationefficiently and effectively. An effective IoTplatform needs to be delivered by a solutionsprovider that is able to work with an organisationto gain the maximum value from the solution andcontinue to recognise, as well as have the abilityto implement, new value opportunities.”

It’s really a case of horses for courses. "Forcompanies aiming to solve real world problemsusing the IoT, there are usually two focal points toconsider: the thing itself and the analytics beingapplied to the data. This helps define the purposeof an IoT platform,” explains Iain Woolley, thehead of technology at Breed Reply. "In turn, thishelps the business manage their things, such asidentifying and authenticating, on-boarding newthings, keeping track of the status of things,updating firmware, and transferring data to andfrom things. It also assists in managing theanalytics, such as receiving and storing data,processing data into useful information,identifying and authenticating users andpresenting information to users."

Whether the term IoT platform is helpful is opento interpretation but it has created a marketplacethat is extremely wide and difficult to understandamid conflicting definitions and marketing. “IoT isa fragmented ecosystem, with a broad set of

What an IoT platform is and what it should do plagues the greatest minds in IoT. In short, aplatform is simply something to base something else on but that doesn’t necessarily help

organisations looking to decide which platforms to use, writes George Malim

One platform does not fit allIoT operations so organisations

will mix and match

Whether the term IoTplatform is helpful

is open tointerpretation but it

has created amarketplace that isextremely wide and

difficult tounderstand amid

conflicting definitionsand marketing

Page 29: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com73

Sponsored by:

requirements including devices, BSS/OSS,connectivity, analytics, applications and relatedservices,” confirms Higgins. “In a similar way tothe way that a universally accepted definition ofthe scope of service delivery platforms has neverbeen clearly defined, there is a risk the samething will happen to IoT platforms. It would behelpful if an industry definition or map of what anIoT platform is could be agreed upon.”

Others see the applicability of the IoT platformtag. “The term IoT has proved to be both usefuland confusing within our industry,” acknowledgesKay. “It has enabled us as an organisation toquickly and effectively describe what our solutioncan do through a recognisable term thatpreviously, was a challenge to condense. Withthis common understanding of the term however,comes the challenge of overcoming preconceivedideologies and misconceptions led by misleadingmarketing and PR within the industry. Someindustry players have fallen for the temptation ofre-badging old technology in order to jump onthe bandwagon or define IoT in context of verylinear applications, because it suits their deliverycapability, rather than platforms that can betransformative to value creation in the enterprise.”

Yet, while some platform vendors havecomprehensive platform propositions, others arespecialised so consensus is hard to find. Thisleaves organisations sifting through marketinginformation to find what they need. The idea of aone-size-fits-all, holistic platform is probablywrong too.

“Anyone who thinks they’ll be able to use an IoTplatform to solve all of their problems is going tobe sorely mistaken and will hit walls in the futureas they want to adapt their software to do moreinteresting things,” says Foster. “However an IoTplatform can be a good way to accelerate theinitial development. Generally, the best tip wouldbe to go for one of the most famous platformsbut don’t over rely on their functionality. Makesure you have intelligent, experienced andcapable developers who can build their ownfunctions so that you’re always able to switchaway if or when needed”

Higgins acknowledges the challenge: “It isdifficult to sift through the noise, but the starting

point should be the aims and objectives that anorganisation wants to set for its IoT initiative,” headds. “From this the requirements can bedefined, which will help to identify theappropriate IoT platform or services that theorganisation wishes to use.”

Nevertheless, there are common capabilities andattributes that make up an IoT platform and mostofferings will encompass at least some. “The keyattributes should be the ability to build morequickly and to provide better interconnectivitybetween devices,” says Foster. “This is especiallyimportant for sensors and triggers that operate inreal-time and need a central control. By using aplatform you should make it easier to integrateyour device and therefore remove a lot ofpotential barriers.”

Even within the relative confines of an IoTconnectivity platform, Higgins identifies a seriesof core capabilities. “From the perspective of IoTconnectivity, the need is for secure, low cost,controllable and global network coverage,” hesays. “This ensures guaranteed connectivity forbusinesses’ IoT devices, regardless of theirlocation around the world. You need acomprehensive set of applications programmeinterfaces (APIs) that can be used to access andintegrate with the platform and services, so oncea business is on-boarded, they can quickly makeuse of the global connectivity via the platform.You also need an online portal to be able tomonitor and control devices.”

For Kay, it’s simple, IoT platforms should be:“Proven at scale, rapidly deployable, involveminimal capital expenditure, integrate withexisting infrastructure, utilise existing data andsystems, deliver value directly to your corepurpose and provide an evolving solution throughcontinuous engagement, delivering new value.”

That statement in a nutshell forms as good ashopping list as any for an organisation lookingfor an IoT platform. However it would be wise torecognise that a single platform is unlikely toaddress all an organisation’s needs and, even if itdid, an organisation probably should considerplatforms from more than one vendor in order toaccess sector specialisms most effectively.

Mick Higgins, TataCommunications

Jason Kay, IMSEvolve

“From the perspective of IoT connectivity,the need is for secure, low cost, controllable

and global network coverage”

Page 30: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

N

EW

NWNE

Empowering your choice of IoT platformThe only completely independent analyst-driven tool designed to help

enterprises evaluate and navigate the IoT platform landscape.

Contact either:Robin Duke-Woolley at Beecham Research [email protected] Bisnar at IoT Global Network [email protected]

Find the best match platform for your enterprise at:

www.iotglobalnetwork.com

Powered by the partnership ofBeecham Research and IoT Global Network

Page 31: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

75IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyers' Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

Wind River, an Intel company, is headquartered in Alameda, California, USA, and has more than 2,000 employees. For more than30 years, Wind River has helped the world’s technology leaders power generation after generation of the safest, most securedevices in the world. The company’s software runs the can’t fail computing systems of the most important modern infrastructure,including mission critical aircraft, trains, automobiles, medical devices, manufacturing plants and communications networks.

Wind River technology is in more than two billion devices throughout the world and backed by our industry-leading professionalservices, award-winning customer support and robust partner ecosystem.

www.windriver.com/products/helix/device-cloud

Company summary

Wind River Helix Device Cloud, an IoT device management platform, enables users to reduce the complexities of building andoperating large-scale device deployments. Device Cloud solves the problem of connecting and managing devices remotely. Itautomatically collects and integrates data from thousands of disparate devices, machines, and systems, enabling operators totrack device status and content, be aware of issues, and proactively determine when updates are needed.

With its ability to connect machines and devices, manage machine-generated data, and remotely execute software updates,organisations can lower development costs, accelerate deployment timelines, and free resources to work on creatingdifferentiated products that stand up to the competition.

With Device Cloud, organisations can:• Maintain secure two-way connectivity to gateways and embedded systems that power intelligent devices• Keep mission-critical IoT devices fully operational, with immediate notification of issues and tools for remote diagnosis and repair• Manage the inventory of device configurations and software to stay on top of what is running in the field• Upgrade new devices when first activated in the field and push new updates out as released• Integrate with other enterprise systems to monitor and share device status

IoT platform offering

With Device Cloud, customers can:• Rely on Wind River’s expertise to accelerate IoT project delivery and reduce project risk• Avoid spending time and resources on building device management functionality• Achieve predictable operating costs through a pay-as-you-grow hosted service• Make use of 24/7 hosting operations and security provided by Intel.

Key differentiators

www.windriver.com

Contact Information

COMPANY PROFILE

Page 32: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com76

Data may be the hero of the IoT story, but thereal workhorses are devices at the edge of theIoT system – the things in the Internet of Things.They’re out in the field either generating andtransmitting data to a centralised platform orperforming automated tasks that generatedata. A mundane job, perhaps, yet the overallperformance of a system often hinges on thehealth of field devices. If a device, sensor,embedded agent, or gateway begins faltering,the consequences can be dire.

Life on the edgeThe challenge of maintaining devices may

sound basic compared with aggregatingand analysing data, but it's essential to a

successful IoT strategy. At a minimum,device manufacturers and system

operators need a way to monitorthe health of devices in the field to

prevent system disruption anddowntime. More importantly,they need to have an actionplan: how to remedy thoseproblems that will eventuallyoccur.

With IoT, change isconstant. Businesspriorities will shift ascompanies gain insightsabout their operations

from the data. Sosystem operators

need an efficient,scalable way to

provide updatesacross a large

fleet ofdevices.

Security,

too, is a major concern. If a vulnerability isdiscovered in device software, patches must bedeployed quickly – before intruders can exploitthe gaps.

Remote control for the device lifecycleDevice manufacturers and system developersneed to plan for these contingencies at thedesign stage. It’s not feasible or cost-effective torely on truck rolls for fixes and updates. Instead,what’s needed is a way to perform these tasksremotely, at scale, and over the internet.

But IoT data collection typically runs just one-way – from device to cloud. Even when operatorsdetect device anomalies, they typically don't havethe tools to push commands back to the deviceand fix the issue. So the initial design of an IoTsystem must consider the entire operatinglifecycle, from deployment to decommissioning.

Several distinct but interrelated issues must beaddressed:

1. Commissioning and provisioning: Oncedevices are deployed and connected, operatorsneed a way to activate and provision themefficiently. Today, that often means physicallygoing from device to device and loadingapplications or performing upgrades manually.IoT system operators need to be able toconfigure, provision, and manage field devicesremotely.

2. Security: Device security is critical to an IoTsystem. Hackers often target endpoint devices asa means of gaining entry. And security breachesat the device level can have severe consequences:financial losses, damage to credibility, evenendangerment of human life. But securingdevices is challenging since they're vulnerable toboth physical tampering and network-bornethreats.

3. Monitoring and management: Systemoperators need the right tools to monitor remotedevice performance and check for security

FEATURE

For most enterprises, the compelling case for IoT is the ability to access valuable databeing generated by hundreds or even thousands of field devices. That can happenonly if the devices delivering that data and the gateways that direct data to enterprisesystems are continually performing as expected

Why device managementmatters in IoT and how toachieve it

IN ASSOCIATION WITH WIND RIVER

Page 33: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com77

vulnerabilities. They also need to be able to sendinstructions to those devices to correct aproblem or change a function. This requires fulltwo-way communication, where responses todevices can be completely automated.

4. Integration: Historically, informationtechnology and operational technology systemshave been kept separate. But IoT systems need tobe integrated, with a centralised place toaggregate, analyse and store data.

5. Updates and upgrades: While the devices inenterprise applications can perform for years, thesoftware running on them will require regularupdates and upgrades: from bug fixes to securitypatches to overall software improvements. Andonce an upgrade or a new application is ready,operators need to be able to deploy it quicklyand cost-effectively to many devices at once.

6. Decommissioning: Developers must plan forend-of-device life at the design stage sooperators can easily and remotely remove adevice from service.

The challenge facing every IoT system developerand operator is how to gain consistently reliableand secure remote control over devices typicallyfar away and connected via the public internet.

The answer in the cloudDevice management should be part of an IoTstrategy from inception. But trying to builddevice management and two-waycommunication capabilities into a system fromscratch can take time, devour resources, increasecosts, and delay deployment.

A more practical solution is to use technologydesigned specifically for IoT device deploymentand management. Wind River Helix Device Cloud

is the ready-built platform that makes it possible,enabling operators to safely and securelymonitor, manage, service, and update devices inthe field.

Device Cloud automatically collects and integratesdata from disparate devices, machines, and systems,enabling operators to track device status, sharedata, and proactively determine when updatesare needed. Using an embedded software agent,device properties and operating data can betransmitted securely to the cloud. Operators caneasily view device information through a web-based management console, perform diagnostics,and take prompt corrective action.

The cloud-based platform is also designed tointegrate with enterprise systems that utilise oranalyse data from IoT networks. Device Clouddata and event forwarding ensures that devicehealth issues will signal other systems of potentialproblems, allowing them to respond accordinglyand prevent ingestion of potentially bad data.

Optimised operationsWith IoT adoption becoming widespread, agrowing number of enterprises are unlocking thevaluable data generated by their everydayoperations: gaining business insights, optimisingoperations, improving profitability, anduncovering new business opportunities. But IoTcan only be effective if connected devices areactively monitored and managed. Fortunately,technology exists that makes it easier to buildthat capability into IoT devices and systems.Utilising Device Cloud, device manufacturers andIoT system developers can accelerate devicedeployment and close a critical gap in IoToperations, ensuring that the devices enterprisesdepend on for crucial business data are secure,responsive, and performing at the highestpossible level.

Figure 1: IoT system operators need to manage devices across their entire lifecycle

www.windriver.com

Devicemanagementshould be partof an IoTstrategy frominception

Page 34: THE ENTERPRISE BUYER'S GUIDE - IoT Now...IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017 47 Sponsored by: Decision making in respect of which

78

Using accelerators like the Accenture IoT Device Platform(AIDP) in its Connected Device Design Studios, Accentureis testing potential use cases for its clients on a variety ofnetworks including LoRa, Sigfox, narrowband-IoT (NB-IoT),Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and cellular. The tests are said byAccenture to be reducing overall programme costs byshowing which technologies will help create innovativesolutions offering the right quality of service, bringing themquickly to market and ready to scale.

Working with Vodafone, Accenture claims it is among thefirst companies to rapidly prototype and test an IoT usecase on the operator’s live commercial NB-IoT network. Forexample, with the AIDP accelerator tool, Accenture’sStudios have been able to build a smart waste solutionwhich went from design through prototyping to testing onVodafone’s NB-IoT network in less than six weeks.

AIDP is a product of Accenture Mobility. Phil Vann,managing director of Accenture Mobility, told IoT Now,“Accenture has formed the Connected Devices &Embedded Software global practice which I lead out ofLondon. It represents about 1,200-1,300 engineers. Thatallows us to address device manufacturers across a suite ofindustries. Telecoms is a core part of what we do. Weexpanded in the early days into automotive, medicalequipment, industrial equipment, as well as horizontals likethe semi-conductor industry, aerospace and defence.”

Accenture Mobility has set up a number of device designstudios around the globe. As well as paper-basedconsulting, the company offers rapid prototyping to provethat a technology really does what it says it will do for aparticular application. It is also important to see if it meetsthe commercial needs of that particular devicemanufacturer or IoT use case.

“We became an ARM Embed cloud partner,” said Vann. “Weneeded our own prototyping platform to take clients fromthe advisory stage into a world where we could rapidlyprototype new device types, and consider the economicsof doing so. We built a roadmap of different AIDP devices,in four brackets; gateways, which comes from technologyand clients such as Intel. In that case we're adopting OEMdevices and modifying those. When it relates to edge-constrained devices, wearables or ultra-constrained devicesthere wasn't anything that would meet our needs. So westarted building the first AIDP, which is the edge-constrained version, the big brother of the AIDP suite withall of the functionality. It's got a suite of communicationprotocols; Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, naturally, but also support forthe emerging LPWAN technology modules … Sigfox,Ingenu, LoRaWAN, and more recently, Narrowband IoT.”

The edge-constrained version of AIDP is the size of a smallopen hardware development platform, like a Raspberry Pi,with all of those technologies pre-integrated.

This year at Mobile World Congress Accenture Mobility hada smart waste demo on the Vodafone stand, as theoperator had just turned on the NB-IoT network in Spainand could demonstrate a number of solutions.

The response was apparently good, with the technologynow being real. “There's been a lot of anticipation ofnarrowband-IoT or the 3GPP solutions to the LPWANproblem. Having it physically working at MWC was a realmental shift for the people that saw the demo, it stoppedbeing an academic (exercise), and became a real-worlddiscussion where there was a physical device that wasgenuinely connected to the network, that wascommunicating data, that was starting to demonstratesome of the promises of the technology,” said Vann.

IOT DEVICE PLATFORMS

The cost of devices and connectivity can make or break an Internet of Things (IoT) business case, butnow a professional services firm is working with a Tier-1 network operator to test clients’ use casesbefore bringing them to market. Jeremy Cowan reports

Accenture creates IoT device platforms in four flavours,demos NB-IoT smart waste collection with Vodafone

This interview with Phil Vann of Accenture Mobility can be seen in full at:www.iot-now.com (Search “Vann”).

AIDP micro, the Narrowband IoT version, created forthe smart waste demo at Mobile World Congress

IoT Now - April / May 2017 I The Enterprise Buyer’s Guide – Which IoT Platform 2017

www.iotglobalnetwork.com