27
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

The economics of Piracy

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

This report investigate the causes and consequences of international piracy, with a particular focus on piracy emanating from Somalia. This report is produced by Geopolicity Inc. It encourages reproduction and dissemination of material in this report.

Citation preview

Page 1: The economics of Piracy

! !!

!

!

!

!"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

!"#$!%&'(')*&+!',!-*./&0!!!-*./1$!2/(+')+!3!4*5$6*#''7+!',,!1#$!8'/+1!',!9')/6*/!!!!!:/0!;<==!

!

!!!!!

!!

!9>$&*/6*+1+!*(!%&'(')*&!?(1$66*@$(&$!

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

Page 2: The economics of Piracy

! #!

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

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

C**".#8%1,".&,&.A&-@":&(2(*#'#17"&)'(+./8&,"1%&".&2.(-+'1#()"/)-"-#,,&3#)/1#()"(4"3/1&.#/*" #)"1%#,"2/2&.@"D&2.(-+'1#()" 4(." .&,/*&" (." (1%&." '(33&.'#/*" 2+.2(,&,6" #)'*+-#)8" &-+'/1#()/*" 2+.2(,&,6"3/7" #)'+." 4&&,@"C22*#'/1#()," 4(."2&.3#,,#()" 1(" .&2.(-+'&"(."-#,,&3#)/1&":&(2(*#'#17"'(27.#8%1"3/1&.#/*,6"/)-"/**"E+&.#&,"'()'&.)#)8".#8%1,"/)-"*#'&)'&,6",%(+*-"5&"/--.&,,&-"57"&B3/#*"1("2#./'7F8&(2(*#'#17@'(3@"

G":&(2(*#'#17"H)'@"IJ!KKL"

!

Page 3: The economics of Piracy

! ##!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!"#$%&'()*+,-($..&$#(%*(/&(%0&(1&#2(&''&34&(*5(#$%"*3$,(.#*5"%(6$7"6"8"39(&3%#&.#&3&+#'(-&'4#"/&-("3(3&*:4,$''"4$,(&4*3*6"4';(<7.&4%&-(.#*5"%'(-&%&#6"3&(-&4"'"*3'(/$'&-(*3(%0&("35*#6$%"*3($1$",$/,&;(=0&('+..,2(*5(."#$%&'>(%0&#&5*#&>("'(4,*'&,2(#&,$%&-(%*(%0&(&7.&4%&-(/&3&5"%'(*5(/&"39($(."#$%&($3-(%0&($''*4"$%&-(#"'?(

$-@+'%&-(4*'%';(

(

A$'&-(*3(%0&()*#?(4*3-+4%&-(0&#&>("34"-&3%'(*5(."#$42($#&('&%(%*(&7.$3-('+/'%$3%"$,,2(/&2*3-(B*6$,"()$%&#'(:(9"1&3(%0&(#"'"39("34*6&(-"'.$#"%2(/&%)&&3(."#$%&'($3-(3*3:."#$%&'(C(#&D+"#"39($(E,*/$,(F*3%$4%(E#*+.(%*(/&(5*#6&->($3-(3&)($..#*$40&'(%*(

$2'66&%#"4(,$)($3-(&35*#4&6&3%(%*(/&(-&1&,*.&-;(

(

G'(.$#%(*5(%0&(*1&#$,,("3%&#3$%"*3$,(4*66+3"%2(&39$9&6&3%>(+3-&#'%$3-"39(%0&(F*'%'($3-(A&3&5"%'(*5(."#$42>($'()&,,($'(%#$4?"39()0$%()&(4$,,(%0&(!"#$%&(H$,+&(F0$"3>(%*("34,+-&(%0&(%#$4?"39(*5(5"3$34"$,(5,*)'>()",,(/&($3(&''&3%"$,(4*6.*3&3%(*5($(E,*/$,(

I$#"%"6&(B&4+#"%2(B&4%*#(J&1&,*.6&3%(KEI:BBJL($..#*$40;(E&*.*,"4"%2>(&6.,*2"39("%'($,#&$-2(&'%$/,"'0&-(E,*/$,(<4*3*6"4(!"#$42(I*-&,>("'()&,,(.,$4&-(%*(.#*1"-&(/*%0(

'%#$%&9"4($3-(9#*+3-(,&1&,($3$,2%"4$,($3-(-"$93*'%"4('+..*#%;((

!

!

!

Page 4: The economics of Piracy

! ###!

!"#$%"#&"<#./'7"(44"1%&"M(/,1"(4"N(3/*#/"%/,"#)'.&/,&-"+)/5/1&-"#)".&'&)1"7&/.,@"C*.&/-76"#)"1%&"4#.,1"E+/.1&."(4"J!KK6"0&"%/A&",&&)"/)"/*/.3#)8"&,'/*/1#()"#)"%+3/)"/)-"4#)/)'#/*"'(,1,"/,,('#/1&-"0#1%"1%&"'.#3&@"N(3/*#" 2#./1&," %/A&" /11/'9&-"(A&." KKO" ,%#2," /)-"%&*-" (A&." PPQ"%(,1/8&," 4(." ./),(36" 9#**#)8" ,&A&)"'.&0"3&35&.,@""

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

H1," 4(.0/.-B*((9#)8"/,,&,,3&)1"(4" 1%&"2.&-#'1&-"&R2/),#()"(4"2#./'7"/)-" #1,"/,,('#/1&-" #32/'16" #,"/"-#,%&/.1&)#)8" .&3#)-&."(4" 1%&"2.&,,#)8")&&-" 1("-&/*"0#1%" 1%#,"2.(5*&3@"$%&" .&2(.1" ,1/1&," 1%/1" 1%&")+35&."(4"N(3/*#"2#./1&,"'(+*-"-(+5*&"57"J!KS6"0%#*&"1%&"&'()(3#'"'(,1"(4"2#./'7"'(+*-"3(.&"1%/)"-(+5*&"#)"1%&")&R1"1%.&&"7&/.,@""

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

"

'(()*+,-./(*V)&"W/.1%"=+1+.&"=(+)-/1#()"

";""&$9/<:#"$13$&+()/'$/4$!"#$%&'()$*+(+'#=3$3(+:7>$,-)#$%./"/01.$2/3($/4$5&'1(10#$61'&.78?$

"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!K"N&&"%112YZZ('&/),5&7()-2#./'7@(.8Z(52Z'(,1B(4B2#./'7B%(3&"

Page 5: The economics of Piracy

! #A!

"

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

• U&" &,1#3/1&" 1%&" '(,1" (4" 2#./'7" 1(" 1%&" #)1&.)/1#()/*" '(33+)#17" 0/," 5&10&&)"234567896:"9:;;:,(" #)" J!K!" 5/,&-" ()" +22&." /)-" *(0&." 5(+)-" /,,+321#(),6" /)-" #," *#9&*7" 1(" #)'.&/,&" 1("3(.&" 1%/)" 234;:8;<$ =*>>*'(" 57" J!K\6" 8#A&)" 1%&" .&5(+)-" ()" 3/.#1#3&" 1./-&" A(*+3&6" 1%&"8&(8./2%#'/*"&R2/),#()"(4"2#./'7"#)'#-&)1,"/)-"+,&"(4"3(.&",(2%#,1#'/1&-"1/'1#',?"

• $(1/*" #)'(3&" 1(" 2#./1&," /)-" 4.(3" 2#./'7" (44" 1%&" M(/,1" (4" N(3/*#/" #)" J!K!" 0/," 5&10&&)"234?<8@:9"3#**#()"5/,&-"()"+22&."/)-"*(0&."5(+)-"/,,+321#(),"/)-"'(+*-".#,&"1("]N^J!!B_!!"3#**#()"57"J!K\"5/,&-"()"2.(X&'1#(),@":#A&)"1%&",+22*7"/)-"-&3/)-"4(."2#./'7",&.A#'&,6"/)-"#)'(3&"-#,2/.#17"5&10&&)"2#./1&,"/)-")()B2#./1&,6"1%&.&"#,"2*&)17"(4".((3"4(."&R2/),#()?"

• C,,+3#)8" ()*7" K6\!!" /'1#A&" 2#./1&," (44" 1%&" '(/1," (4" N(3/*#/6" /" 2#./1&" '/)" &R2&'1" 1(" &/.)"5&10&&)"]N^KSQ6SP!"/)-"]N^P`_6J!!"(A&."/"1%&(.&1#'/*"4#A&B7&/."'/.&&.@"H4"2#./1&,"&)8/8&"#)"1%&" )&R1" 5&,1" /*1&.)/1#A&" 1%&7" 0(+*-" &/.)" ]N^K_6\!!" (A&." 1%&#." &)1#.&" 0(.9#)8" *#4&6"%#8%*#8%1#)8" 1%&" #)'(3&" -#,2/.#17" 5&10&&)" 1%&,&" '%(#'&,@" $%&" .&2(.1" /*,(" .+)," ,'&)/.#(,"5/,&-"()"P6!!!"2#./1&,?"

• a/,&-"()"(22(.1+)#17b'(,1"/)/*7,#,6"0&"4(.&'/,1"/)"/))+/*"#)'.&/,&"#)"1%&")+35&."(4"2#./1&,"(4"5&10&&)"J!!B_!!6"5/,&-"()"2.&,&)1"-&3/)-"/,,+321#(),@"V+."/)/*7,#,"(4"1%&",2.&/-"(4"2#./'7",+88&,1,"1%/1"#4"1%#,"(''+.,6"2#./'7".#,9,"5&'(3#)8"/",#8)#4#'/)1"2.(5*&3"/'.(,,"/**"3/X(."C4.#'/)6"c#--*&"W/,1&.)"/)-"</'#4#'"D#3"3/.#1#3&",7,1&3,?"

• $%&"&R2/),#()"(4"8*(5/*"2#./'7" #)'#-&)1," I,&&"c/2"KL6"0%#'%" #)'.&/,&-"4.(3"JOS" #)"J!!\"1("__\" #)"J!K!" IJK`"(4"0%#'%"0&.&"(44" 1%&"M(/,1"(4"N(3/*#/L6" #,"/*.&/-7"/1"K\!"57"C2.#*"J!KK@""$%#," '(+*-" #)'.&/,&" 1(" 3(.&" 1%/)" S!!" #)'#-&)1," 57" J!K\6" 5/,&-" ()" 1%&" /22*#'/1#()" (4",+22*7Z-&3/)-"/)-"(22(.1+)#17"'(,1"1%&(.7?"

• $%&" <#./1&" [/*+&" M%/#)" %#8%*#8%1," 1%&" *#)9/8&" 5&10&&)" 2#./1&,6" 4#)/)'#&.," /)-" ,2(),(.,@""<#./1&," /.&" A#,#5*&" /)-" 9)(0)6" 4#)/)'&.," /.&"%/.-&." 1(" 1/'96" /)-" ,2(),(.," .&3/#)" #)A#,#5*&@""c(.&(A&.6" 0%#*,1" 1%&" 3/X(.#17" (4" ./),(3," /.&" -&*#A&.&-" 57" C#.B-.(26" &A#-&)'&" ,+88&,1," /",#8)#4#'/)1"2.(2(.1#()"(4"2.('&&-," I!_!B\!dL"/.&" 1./),4&..&-"(+1"(4"N(3/*#/"+,#)8" #)4(.3/*"3()&7"1./),4&.",7,1&3,6"2.&,&)1#)8"/"A+*)&./5#*#17"1("1%&"CceZM=$",7,1&3?"

•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

Page 6: The economics of Piracy

! K!

"

3'+<$*"!*1"=3$=36*

!"#$%"#& EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE???!!

$0$12345$*6277'#8 EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE ?F!*

3'+<$*"!*1"=3$=36 EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE=!*

'1#"=876*'=&*'++#$54'34"=6 EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE;!*

>?! 4=3#"&2134"= EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEG!*

@?! 7$3A"&"<"B41'<*"+6$#5'34"=6EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEH!*

C?! 3A$*D4#'3$*E5'<2$*1A'4=F EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEI!*

G?! $6347'34=B*3A$*1"636*"!*D4#'18EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEJ!*

H?! $6347'34=B*3A$*+$=$!436*"!*D4#'18*!"#*D4#'3$6 EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE =<!*

I?! 3#'1J4=B*!4='=14'<*!<"%6 EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE =G!*

K?! D#"D"6$&*'134"=*#$6$'#1A*!#'7$%"#JEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE =K!"'((/L/MN*C))&R"K" :*(5/*"<#./'7"H)'#-&)1,@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@KO"

7)OMN*c/2"K" :&(8./2%#'/*"WR2/),#()"(4"<#./'7"IJ!!\BJ!KKL@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@_"

!:PQR/MN*=#8+.&"K" H)-#'/1#A&"<#./1&"[/*+&"M%/#) @@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@S"=#8+.&"J" C8&)'7"f"H),1#1+1#()/*"C'1(.,"C'.(,,"1%&";<#./1&"[/*+&"M%/#)> @@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@O""3)9;/MN*$/5*&"K""""""e(0Bg#8%"M/,&"C))+/*Ze#4&1#3&"<#./1&"D&A&)+&,"#)"]N^"a/,&-"()"K6\!!"<#./1&, @@@@@@@@@@@@@@@KJ"$/5*&"J""""""e(0Bg#8%"M/,&"C))+/*Ze#4&1#3&"<#./1&"D&A&)+&,"#)"]N^"a/,&-"()"P6!!!"<#./1&, @@@@@@@@@@@@@@@KJ"$/5*&"P""""""c/.#1#3&"<#./'7"=#)/)'#/*"H)A&,1#8/1#()"V21#(), @@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@KP"$/5*&"_" M(.&"V21#(),"4(."W'()(3#'"/)-"=#)/)'#/*"$./'9#)8@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@KS"*+,L/MN*a(R"K" """"V5,&.A/1#(),"()"<.#3/.7"/)-"N&'()-/.7"h/1/"N(+.'&, @@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@\"a(R"J" """""<#./'7"f"<.(4#1&&., @@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@Q"""""""""""""""

Page 7: The economics of Piracy

! J!

""

'1#"=876*'=&*'++#$54'34"=6*ac<" " " a&,1"c/)/8&3&)1"<./'1#'&,"M:<MN" " " M()1/'1":.(+2"4(."<#./'7"V44"1%&"M(/,1"(4"N(3/*#/"Mc=" " " M(35#)&-"c/.#1#3&"=(.'&,"hU$" " " h&/-"U&#8%1"$())/8&"W]"iC[=VD" " W+.(2&/)"])#()"i/A/*"=(.'&"W]DV<Ve" " W+.(2&/)"<(*#'&"V44#'&"=MM" " " =+**7"M&**+*/."M()1/#)&.,%#2"=MV" " " =(.&#8)"/)-"M(33()0&/*1%"V44#'&"=H]" " " =#)/)'#/*"H)1&**#8&)'&"])#1"H:Ch" " " H)1&.8(A&.)3&)1/*"C+1%(.#17"4(."h&A&*(23&)1""Hca" " " H)1&.)/1#()/*"c/.#1#3&"a+.&/+"HcV" " " H)1&.)/1#()/*"c/.#1#3&"V.8/)#T/1#()"Hi$WD<Ve" " H)1&.)/1#()/*"M.#3#)/*"<(*#'&"V.8/)#T/1#()"HD$M" " " :+*4"(4"C-&)"H)1&.)/1#()/**7"D&'(8)#T&-"$./),#1"M(..#-(."HNc" " " H)1&.)/1#()/*"N/4&17"c/)/8&3&)1"M(-&"H[$N" " " H)4(.3/*"[/*+&"$./),4&."N7,1&3,"j=D" " " j#-)/2"4(."D/),(3"eVN" " " e/0"(4"1%&"N&/"eDH$" " " e()8"D/)8&"H-&)1#4#'/1#()"/)-"$./'9#)8"cCDeV" " c/.#1#3&"e#/#,()"V44#'&"chC" " " c/.#1#3&"h(3/#)"C0/.&)&,,"cHN" " " c/)/8&3&)1"H)4(.3/1#()"N7,1&3"cNC" " " c/.#1#3&"N#1+/1#()"C0/.&)&,,"cNMBgVC" " c/.#1#3&"N&'+.#17"M&)1.&"B"g(.)"(4"C4.#'/"cNND" " " c/.#1#3&"N&'+.#17"N&'1(."D&4(.3"c$V" " " c()&7"$./),4&."V2&./1(.,"c$N" " " c/.#1#3&"$./),2(.1"N7,1&3"VW=" " " V)&"W/.1%"=+1+.&"<=D" " " <#./'7"=(."D/),(3"<DM" " " <#./'7"D&2(.1#)8"M&)1.&"<[M" " " <#./1&"[/*+&"M%/#)"NgChW"" " N%/.&-"C0/.&)&,,"/)-"h&B'()4*#'1#()"<.('&,,"NVeCN" " " H)1&.)/1#()/*"M()A&)1#()"4(."1%&"N/4&17"(4"e#4&"/1"N&/"NNCN" " " N%#25(/.-"N&'+.#17"C*&.1"N7,1&3""]jc$V" " ])#1&-"j#)8-(3"c/.#1#3&"$./-&"V2&./1#(),"]eaM" " " ]*1./"e/.8&"a+*9"M/..#&."]eMM" " " ]*1./"e/.8&"M.+-&"M/..#&."]iMeVN" " ])#1&-"i/1#(),"M()A&)1#()"()"1%&"e/0"(4"1%&"N&/"]iVhM" " ])#1&-"i/1#(),"V44#'&"()"h.+8,"/)-"M.#3&"]i<VN"" " ])#1&-"i/1#(),"<(*#1#'/*"V44#'&"4(."N(3/*#/""]iNMD"" " ])#1&-"i/1#(),"N&'+.#17"M(+)'#*"D&,(*+1#()"]NCHh" " " ])#1&-"N1/1&,"C8&)'7"4(."H)1&.)/1#()/*"h&A&*(23&)1"[eMM" " " [&.7"e/.8&"M.+-&"M/..#&."

Page 8: The economics of Piracy

! P!

""

>?* 4=3#"&2134"=*D&3/.9/5*7" *#11*&" 0(.9" %/," 5&&)"'()-+'1&-" ()" 1%&" &'()(3#'," (4" 2#./'7@"M+..&)1"&44(.1,"b" #)'*+-#)8" 1%&"2#()&&.#)8"0(.9"(4"V)&"W/.1%"=+1+.&"IVW=L"b"4('+,&,"()" '/*'+*/1#)8" -#.&'1" /)-" #)-#.&'1" '(,1,6"5+1"-(&,")(1"/,,&,," 1%&"5&)&4#1," /''.+#)8"1("2#./1&,6" 4#)/)'#&.,6" ,2(),(.,6"/)-"(1%&."3/X(." ,1/9&%(*-&.,6" 0%(" .&/2" 3(.&".&A&)+&" 4.(3" 2#./'7" 1%/)" 2#./1&,"1%&3,&*A&,@" <#./'7" %/," &3&.8&-" /," /"3/.9&1"#)"#1,"(0)".#8%16"A/*+&-"/1"5&10&&)"]N^_@`BQ@P"5#**#()"#)"J!K!"/*()&6"5/,&-"()"1%&".&,+*1,"(4"1%#,".&,&/.'%@"

$%&" 2/,1" -&'/-&" %/," ,&&)" /)"+)2.&'&-&)1&-" #)'.&/,&" #)" 2#./'76"5&10&&)" 1%&" D&-" N&/" /)-" H)-#/)" V'&/)"I-&,2#1&" a&,1"c/)/8&3&)1" <./'1#'&,L6" (44"1%&" N(3/*#" M(/,1" I/" K\" 4(*-" #)'.&/,&" #)".&'&)1"7&/.,L6"/)-"#)"1%&"N1./#1"(4"c/*/''/"/)-" N#)8/2(.&@" $%&" 8&(8./2%#'" 1./X&'1(.7"(4"2#./1&"/'1#A#17"#,"/*,("0(..7#)8"I,&&"A/B$;"5&*(0L6"0#1%"/".&-+'1#()"(44"1%&"'(/,1"(4"a/)8*/-&,%" 5&#)8" (44,&1" 57" ,+5,1/)1#/*"#)'.&/,&," (44" 1%&" '(/,1" (4" N(3/*#/@" U#1%"1%&"5&)&4#1,"/''.+#)8"1("#)-#A#-+/*"2#./1&,6"/1" (A&." K!!" 1#3&," 1%&" )&R1" 5&,1" (21#()6"1%&.&"0#**" 5&" )(" ,%(.1/8&" (4"0#**#)8" */5(."+)*&,," 1%&" '(,1," 5&8#)" 1(" (+10&#8%" 1%&"5&)&4#1,@"

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

U#1%" 1%&" M:<MN" '+..&)1*7" 4('+,&-" ()"#32.(A#)8" I#L" 3#*#1/.7" /)-" (2&./1#()/*"'((.-#)/1#()6" #)4(.3/1#()" ,%/.#)86" /)-"'/2/'#17" 5+#*-#)8" I##L" X+-#'#/*" 8(A&.)/)'&"/)-" ,1.&)81%&)#)8" I###L" ,%#22#)8" ,&*4B/0/.&)&,,6"/)-"(1%&."'/2/5#*#1#&,6"/)-"I#AL"2+5*#'" #)4(.3/1#()6" 0&" 5&*#&A&" 1%&"/5,&)'&"(4"/"-&-#'/1&-"U(.9#)8":.(+2"()"W'()(3#',"/)-"=#)/)'#/*"$./'9#)8" " I/'.(,,"1%&" &)1#.&" A/*+&" '%/#)L" .&3/#)," 1%&"C'%#**&," %&&*" (4" 1%&" '+..&)1" /22.(/'%@"C)/*71#'"/)-"-#/8)(,1#'"0(.9"b"/'.(,," 1%&"2#./'7" A/*+&" '%/#)" 0#**" -&&2&)"+)-&.,1/)-#)8" (4" %(0" 2#./'7" #," 4#)/)'&-"/)-"'()-+'1&-"57"0%(36"0%&.&"/)-"%(0@"

$%&" -#,'+,,#()" 2/2&." (+1*#)&," /" )&0"/22.(/'%"b"5+#*-#)8"()"&R#,1#)8"0(.9" B"57"-#44&.&)1#/1#)8" 5&10&&)" 2#./1&," /)-"2.#A/1&&.,6" /)-" 4#)/)'#&.," /)-" ,2(),(.,?"/'.(,," 1%&" &)1#.&" A/*+&B'%/#)@" H)" /--#1#()"1("#-&)1#47#)8"1%&"'(,1,"1("8*(5/*"3/.#1#3&",%#22#)8" #1" /*,(" #-&)1#4#&," 1%&" 3/)7"#)1&.&,1" 8.(+2," 1%/1" 5&)&4#1" I-#.&'1*7" /)-"#)-#.&'1*7L"4.(3"2#./'7"b"0#1%"1%&"3/X(.#17"(4"5&)&4#1,"/''.+#)8"1(")()B2#./1&,@""

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

Page 9: The economics of Piracy

! _!

7'D*>* B$"B#'DA41'<*$0D'=64"=*"!*D4#'18*S@TTHU@T>>V*

*

"

"

!"#$%&'()*+,#-)./001)2+3+)

4'565$7#738)9.//0:)

Page 10: The economics of Piracy

! \!

"

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

• W,1#3/1&," %/A&" )(1" 5&&)"&,1/5*#,%&-" ,'#&)1#4#'/**7" (." 5/,&-"()"/)"/''&21&-"&'()(3#'"3(-&*?"

• C)/*7,#," #," (41&)" 4(+)-&-" ()"#)/-&E+/1&"(."3#,,#)8"-/1/6"/1" 1%&"#)1&.)/1#()/*6" '(+)1.7" /)-" 3/.9&1"*&A&*"IN&&"J'K$;"5&*(0L?"

• c/)7" '(,1" '/*'+*/1#()," I#)'*+-#)8".&B.(+1#)8" /)-" 3/'.(&'()(3#'"#32/'1L" /.&" 5/,&-" ()" +)1&,1&-" (."+)B1&,1/5*&"/,,+321#(),?"

• c(,1" '/*'+*/1#()," /.&" 5/,&-" ()"'(,16" )(1" '(,1," /)-" 5&)&4#1," /,"2.(A#-&-"%&.&?"

• D&,&/.'%"%/,")(1"4(**(0&-"/"A/*+&B'%/#)"/22.(/'%"/,"/-A('/1&-"%&.&6"+)-&.3#)#)8" #32(.1/)1" '/+,/*"*#)9/8&," /)-" (22(.1+)#1#&," 4(."1/.8&1#)8" M:<MN" 1.+,1" 4+)-"#)1&.A&)1#()?"

• c+*1#2*&" /8&)'#&," /.&" .&,2(),#5*&"4(." 1%&" '(**&'1#()"(4" -#,'.&1&" -/1/6"7&1" )(" ,#)8*&" &)1#17" /88.&8/1&,"1%&,&" ,(+.'&," #)1(" /" ,#)8+*/.",(+.'&"(4"'(33()".&4&.&)'&?""

• U&,1&.)"./1#()/*B*&8/*",7,1&3,"/.&"'()4.()1&-" 57" #)4(.3/*" ,7,1&3,6"0%&.&"-#,'*(,+.&"(4" 4#)/)'#/*" 4*(0,"/)-" 1./),4&.," /.&" '()'&/*&-"5&10&&)"/8&)1,?"/)-6"

• M(+)1.7" 5/,&-" 4#&*-" /,,&,,3&)1,"%/A&")(1"5&&)" '()-+'1&-6" #)" ,2#1&"(4"1%&"#),#8%1,"1%#,"0(+*-"2.(A#-&@""

"

+"0*>* "+6$#5'34"=6*"=*D#47'#8*'=&*6$1"=&'#8*&'3'*6"2#1$6*

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

"• -*./C#+Y""W,1#3/1&,"(4"1%&")+35&."(4"2#./1&,"(44"1%&"'(/,1"(4"N(3/*#/"A/.#&,"4.(3"K6\!!"1("P6!!!?"• L/(+')+Y""WR/'1"./),(3"2/73&)1,"/.&")(1"/''+./1&*7".&2(.1&-?"• M*N/&I*(FY"$(1/*")+35&."(4"8*(5/*"%#X/'9#)8,"1%/1"*&/-"1("./),(3"2/73&)1,"A/.#&,"4.(3"__"1("\P"(A&."

1%&",/3&"2&.#(-6"/)-"1%&.&"/.&"-#44&.&)1".&2(.1,"()"./),(3,"A/*+&,6"0%#'%"/.&"/*,("2((.*7"-#,'*(,&-?"• O(+E./(&#$ P'+C+Y" U%#*,1" #),+./)'&" #)-+,1.7" 2.&3#+3," /)-" ,+.'%/.8&," '/)" 5&" '/*'+*/1&-6" 2.(4#1"

3/.8#),"/.&"+)9)(0)"/,"/.&"2/7(+1,6"4(."1%&"#)-+,1.7"/,"/"0%(*&?"• L#8L'EC*(FY" N(3&" &,1#3/1&," #)-#'/1&" 1%/1" +2" 1(" K!d" (4" ,%#2," /.&" 4(.'&-" 1(" .&B.(+1&" /," /"

'(),&E+&)'&" (4" 1%&" 1%.&/1" (4" 2#./'76" 1%(+8%" 1%#," 4#8+.&" #," -#44#'+*1" 1(" ,+5,1/)1#/1&" /)-" &'()(3#'"A/*+&"(4",+'%"-&'#,#(),"-#44#'+*1"1("E+/)1#47"IN&&"3#&C*'($5"#)".&*/1#()"1("'(,1,L?"/)-6"

• A/&.'#&'(')*&$P'+C+Y"$%&"3/'.(&'()(3#'"#32/'1"(4"2#./'7"()"'(/,1/*",1/1&,"#,"A#.1+/**7"#32(,,#5*&"1("'/*'+*/1&6"8#A&)":h<"A(*/1#*#176"&R'%/)8&"./1&"4*+'1+/1#(),"/)-"#)'.&/,#)8"2.#3/.7"/)-",&'()-/.7"'(33(-#17"2.#'&,"/,"/".&,+*1"(4"4#)/)'#/*"'.#,#,"/)-"8*(5/*"2(*#1#'/*"+).&,1@"

Page 11: The economics of Piracy

! S!

"

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

'(,1," /)-" 5&)&4#1," /'.(,," 1%#," 4./3&0(.96"#-&)1#47#)8" 1%&" 8.&/1&,1" /.&/," (4" A/*+&"/--#1#()@" W/'%" 7&/.6" %#8%&." A/*+&" /--#1#()")/1+./**7"*&/-,"1("8.&/1&."2.(4#1,@"IN&&"N&'1#()"\"5&*(0L"

a&7()-" 1%&" #33&-#/1&" 2#./1&" A/*+&B'%/#)6",+5,1/)1#/*" I+)-#,'*(,&-L"A/*+&"/--&-"/''.+&,"1(" (1%&." ,#8)#4#'/)1" /8&)1," ,+'%" /," 3/.#1#3&"#),+.&.," IN&&" a(R" JL6" 2.#A/1&" ,&'+.#17" 4#.3,6"g/0/*/" IH[$NL" -&/*&.," /)-" 2.(-+'&.," (4"-&1&..&)1" 1&'%)(*(8#&,@" C)" #)-#'/1#A&" I/)-"2+.&*7" -&,'.#21#A&L" 2#./1&" A/*+&B'%/#)" #,"2.(A#-&-" #)" V*FE.#$ ;" 5&*(06" %#8%*#8%1#)8" 1%/1"*/)-B5/,&-" ,+22(.1" /'1#A#1#&," /.&" 3(.&"2.(4#1/5*&" 1%/)" ,&/B5/,&-" /'1#A#1#&,6" /)-" 4/."*&,," .#,97" /*,(@" V*FE.#$ @" #-&)1#4#&," 1%&" 3/#)"/8&)1,"/'.(,,"1%&"A/*+&"'%/#)@"a&#)8"/"2#./1&"#,"/"A&.7".#,97"5+,#)&,,6"7&1"#)"/"4./8#*&",1/1&"0#1%"/)"#)&44&'1#A&":(A&.)3&)16"4#)/)'#)8"2#./'7"#,".&*/1#A&*7" .#,9" 4.&&" (A&." 1%&" *()8&." 1&.3@" $%&"0(.,1" ,'&)/.#(" 4(."/" 4#)/)'#&." #," 1%/1"%&" *(,&,"%#," 5(/1" /)-" &E+#23&)1@" $%&" 0(.,1" ,'&)/.#("4(." /" 2#./1&" #," -&/1%@" $%&.&" #," )(" 0(.,1",'&)/.#(" 4(." #),+./)'&" '(32/)#&,6" /," 1%&7"3&.&*7"2/,,"()".#,9,"/,"2.&3#+3,@"

*!4B2#$*>* 4=&41'345$*D4#'3$*5'<2$*1A'4=*

*!"#$%&'()*#$+%#,-%,#&'./0$%+1'2#3+1'4033,)"-$50)+'&%-67'

8")$)-"$9':&+0,#-&+'.8")$)-"&#+1';<0)+0#+1':$)+03'!$=3&)%+7'

2>$<%&>'/0$#>")?'$)>':$)+03'@&?05$50)'A&-B)"-$9'4$<$C"9"5&+'

:&-#,"%3&)%'$)>'!#0-,#&3&)%'

!"#$%#&"'$()*+,*"&$

-#.'

$%#&"'

$$!/00

123$(

)*+,*"&$

()C0

,)>'D0?"+5-+'

E'403

3,)

"-$5

0)+'

F$#"53&'

G<&

#$50

)+'

G,%C0

,)>'D0?"+5-+'

;,<<

0#%';

&#H"-&+'

I"#&

-%'40+%+'

:$)+03

'@&?05

$50)

+'

4"+"./"&$5(002167$89:;$

4"+"./"&$5(002167$<9:;$

8")$)-&#+1';<0)+0#+'GJ-"$9+1'8$3"9"&+'

!"#$%&+1';,<<0#%'4#&K1''%#$>&#+1'H&B"-9&'0K)&#+1'

A#$)+9$%0#+1''C,+")&++'$)>'+,<<9"&#+6''

!"#$%&%'()(*+",-.//0"

Page 12: The economics of Piracy

! !!

!"#$%&'(' )#&*+,'-'"*./"/$/"0*)1')+/0%.')+%0..'/2&'34"%)+,'5)1$&'+2)"*6'""

!"#$%#&%'(')*$+$,*-&%'

.*&+/-%'

!"#$%&"'($)*+,,-./)

0,(."1-#"2)32"##(.')

&-"/')4)56"#$2(.')

7.8')4)9+#:1-#')

0$+12*$3''45,*+2%'

7;;-+#/"#/')<)&--==((,(.')

9>0<?@>*)

A"#'-8')<)B-'/"C()D(C-1"/-.')

9-/6(.%*6:,)5.(E))

F:G)5-88"#$((.($H)

9".:#(%&"'($)*+,,-./)

5",/":#'I)&-"/'E":#I)J+"./(.8"'/(.I)9"/(K)

?#/(.#"1-#"2)D"L"2)M-.;(')

3:.";N)3.(L(#1-#)

0.C"#:O"1-#')

P(/(..(#/)>(;6)5-8,"#:(')

6+&*$-'!-,7&*/8'9#:"+$*-%'6+&*;:-'

<$%7&-&%'

B-'/"C()P(/(#1-#)M";:2:1(')

*6:,)0E#(.')

.*&+/-'=->-2'?+27-'9@+*$''A3-$/%'

<$/-&$+;#$+2'?+27-'9@+*$''A3-$/%'

!"#$%&%'()(*+",-.//0"

M+/+.()A('(".;6I)Q"'($)-#)-+.)C2-Q"2)R;-#-8:;)9-$(2)"#$)5-'/)&(#(S/)

7#"2N':')M."8(E-.=)E:22)",,-.1-#);-'/')"#$)Q(#(S/')";.-'')/6:')L"2+();6":#))

3.-L:':-#')<)T6"/))*+,,2:(.')

U-L(.#8(#/)0V;:"2'I)72%*6"Q""Q)(/;W)

*-8"2:)X)A(C:-#"2))!"E)R#G-.;(8(#/)

Page 13: The economics of Piracy

! !!

!"#$%$ &'()*+$,$&("-'.//(0$

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

'(*)/$+$0*%/.'*%1'()2#$/"").'• 2/,/@>L$-%E>%,#$%/E1$*=$%06%$66$=,+3$%A03$<*D$*,%0<% @/5%$*60<=$D$*,B%C+</=>%#/1%E$$*%,</*160<D$-%

+*,0%/%@F=</,+3$%/*-%#+A#@>%0<A/*+L$-%+@@+=+,%EF1+*$11K%• N*%D/*>% <$1C$=,1B% ,#$% 0<A/*+L/,+0*% 06% C+</=>% 0C$</,+0*1% +1% AF+-$-%D0<$% E>% ,#$% C<+*=+C@$1% 06% C<+3/,$%

$*,$<C<+1$%,#/*%D+@+,/<>%1,</,$A>%/*-%C@/**+*AKO%• "#$<$%/<$%DF@,+C@$%/=,0<1%/110=+/,$-%5+,#%/*>%A+3$*%0C$</,+0*%</*A+*A%6<0D%+*,$<*/,+0*/@%/=,0<1B%1$*+0<%

A03$<*D$*,% 066+=+/@1% 5#0% C<03+-$% C0@+,+=/@% C<0,$=,+0*% /*-%D0*$>% @/F*-$<$<1% 5#0% 6/=+@+,/,$% </*10D%,</*16$<B%,0%A<0F*-%,$/D1%=0DC01$-%06%@0=/@1K%

• P+*/*=+$<1% /*-% 0,#$<% C<0D+*$*,% EF1+*$11% /*-% C0@+,+=/@% 6+AF<$1% 5+,#% /11$,1% +*% ,#$% 6+1#+*A% +*-F1,<>B%C<03+-$%Q1$$-%D0*$>R%60<%,#$%C+</,$%A<0FC1%,0%6F*=,+0*B%/1%5$@@%/1%<$10F<=$1%/*-%$SF+CD$*,K%

• P+*/*=+$<1%T%1C0*10<1%/<$%E$@+$3$-%,0%<$,/+*%/CC<0U+D/,$@>%VMW%06%,#$%</*10D%D0*$>B%=0DC/<$-%5+,#%,#$%C+</,$1%,#$D1$@3$1%5#0%,/I$%OMWKX%%

• Y*% +*,$<*/,+0*/@%*$,50<I%D01,@>%06%70D/@+%$UC/,<+/,$1% <$/=#+*A%/1% 6/<%/1%.0<,#%YD$<+=/%/*-%ZF<0C$%<$C0<,$-@>%E/=I1%,#$%1C+I$%+*%C+</=>%+*%Y6<+=/*%5/,$<1%/*-%E$>0*-K%[+,#%#$@C%6<0D%,#$%*$,50<IB%70D/@+%C+</,$1%E<0FA#,%+*%D0<$%,#/*%\OM%D+@@+0*%+*%</*10D%+*%(MM!KV%

• ]$10@3+*A%C+</=>%+1%*0,%10@$@>%/%70D/@+%C<0E@$DB%5+,#%6+*/*=+/@%E/=I$<1%/*-%C<06+,$$<1%60F*-%+*%=0F*,<+$1%/=<011%,#$%50<@-%+*=@F-+*A%4$E/*0*%/*-%,#$%)*+,$-%Y</E%ZD+</,$1B%/1%5$@@%/1%=<+D+*/@%A/*A1%+*%^$D$*B%/*-%A@0E/@%+*1F</*=$%=0DC/*+$1%+*%,#$%[$1,K%_%%9,#$<%3/@F$%=#/+*%/A$*,1%/<$%-+1C@/>$-%+*%P+AF<$%(K%%

'3*$%'45%26%7'829*:$'($)*+,';)2<0.'Y1%06%(MM!%,#$%N*,$<*/,+0*/@%`/<+,+D$%aF<$/F%8N`a:%+-$*,+6+$-%60F<%D/+*%C+</=>%A/*A1%0C$</,+*A%+*%,#$%,</-$%<0F,$% @+*I+*A% ,#$%]$-%7$/%5+,#% ,#$%`$-+,$<</*$/*%7$/%3+/% ,#$%7F$L%2/*/@?% 8+:%%&"'($)*+,$!'-+!.,)""/'0+$1)'2.$/3' 4(-025B% =0DD/*-$-% E>% b/<//-% `0#/D$-B% E$@+$3$-% ,0% 1C$=+/@+L$% +*% +*,$<=$C,+*A% 1D/@@% E0/,1% /*-%6+1#+*A% 3$11$@1% /<0F*-% c+1D/>F% 0*% ,#$% 10F,#$<*% =0/1,% 8++:%%&"'6$/7$' #/+.8B% =0DD/*-$-% E>% 7#$+I#% ^F1F6%`0#/D$-%7+/-% 8+++:% )/$3*)*+,$!'9+:$!*' ;*1&"/:",'0C$</,+*A%/<0F*-%;F*,@/*-B%I*05*%/1% ,#$%;F*,@/*-%b<0FC%8+3:%&"'9+:$!*'6$/*,"1% J%,#$%D01,%C05$<6F@%/*-%10C#+1,+=/,$-%06%,#$%C+</,$%A<0FC1%5+,#%/%D+@+,/<>%1,<F=,F<$%/*-% @$-%E>%5/<@0<-%YE-+%`0#/D$-%Y65$>*$Kd% e/=I%4/*AB%7C$=+/@%Y-3+1$<% ,0% ,#$%7$=<$,/<>Jb$*$</@%0*%4$A/@%N11F$1%]$@/,$-% ,0%;+</=>%066% ,#$%20/1,%06%70D/@+/B% 1,/,$1% ,#/,% ,#$<$%/<$%/<0F*-%&BVMM%C+</,$1%/*-%&(%D/H0<%1C0*10<1K%9F<%/*/@>1+1%+*-+=/,$-%F*=$<,/+*,>%5+,#%<$A/<-1%/=,F/@%*FDE$<1%06%/=,+3$%C+</,$1B%5#+=#%5$%/11FD$%,0% E$% #+A#$<% ,#/*% 06,$*% SF0,$-K% % "#$% bF@6% 06% Y-$*% N*,$<*/,+0*/@@>% ]$=0A*+L$-% "</*1+,% 20<<+-0<% 8N]"2:% #/1%+DC<03$-% 1$=F<+,>% 06% C/11/A$% EF,% C+</=>% +*=+-$*,1% #/3$% *05% +*=<$/1$-% 1FE1,/*,+/@@>% 0F,1+-$% 06% ,#+1% ,</*1+,%/<$/K%

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!(%)7%f$C/<,D$*,%06%7,/,$%555K1,/,$KA03g,gCDgCC/gC+</=>g=O(__&K#,D%O%(MM!%).%7$=F<+,>%20F*=+@%<$C0<,%=0*6+<D1%,#$%$U+1,$*=$%06%6+*/*=+$<1%X%+E+-%%V%Q70D/@+%C+</=>%E/=I$-%E>%+*,$<*/,+0*/@%*$,50<IRB%`7.a2B%555KD1*E=KD1*K=0D%_%Q70D/@+/h1%C+</,$1?%/%@0*A%5/<%06%,#$%5/,$<1RB%"#$%Z=0*0D+1,B%e/*%d,#%(M&M%d%555KA@0E/@1$=F<+,>K0<AgD+@+,/<>g50<@-gC/</gC+</,$1K#,D%

Page 14: The economics of Piracy

! '!

%

12$ /0.'3).'45$.6/$*"0.0$"-$&'()*+$"#$<$%/<$%,50%D/H0<%=01,% @$3$@1%,0%C+</=>?%8+:% ,#$% =01,1% 06% D/<+,+D$% C+</=>% ,0% ,#$%$%/")%*/$2%*:' +299<%$/,'/*-% 8++:% =01,1% 06%)<%%$%&' 0$)*+,' 20")*/$2%.% 0*% @/*-% /*-%1$/K%"#+1%1$=,+0*%0F,@+*$1%=01,%=/@=F@/,+0*1%/,% ,#$% +*,$<*/,+0*/@% @$3$@% EF+@-+*A% 0*% ,#$%50<I% 06% 9ZPK% 7$=,+0*% X% C<03+-$1% ,#$%C<$@+D+*/<>%<$1F@,1%06%-$,/+@$-%=01,JE$*$6+,%/*/@>1+1%E/1$-%0*%$U+1,+*A%6+AF<$1K%%

`0-$@+*A% ,#$% =01,% 06% C+</=>% ,0% ,#$%+*,$<*/,+0*/@%=0DDF*+,>%=/*%0*@>%$3$<%E$%/*%+*-+=/,+3$%$U$<=+1$B%60<%<$/10*1%0F,@+*$-%+*% 8"+/$2%' =% /E03$K% N6% 5$% /<$% ,0% /11$11%A$*$</@% 0<-$<1% 06% D/A*+,F-$B% A<$/,$<%/*/@>1+1% /*-% -+1=@01F<$% 06% +*60<D/,+0*%/@0*A%,#$%3/@F$J=#/+*% +1% <$SF+<$-B%/1% +1%/*%+DC<03$-%F*-$<1,/*-+*A%06%#05%=01,1%/*-%E$*$6+,1%/==<F$%/=<011%DF@,+C@$%/=,0<1%/*-%103$<$+A*% -0D/+*1K% ;+</=>B% /1% /*% +@@$A/@%/=,+3+,>B% <$@+$1% 0*% ,</-+,+0*/@g+*60<D/@%1>1,$D1% ,0% #+-$% 3/@F$J,</*16$<1B% D/I+*A%,#+1%,/1I%/1%=0DC@$U%/1%F*-$<1,/*-+*A%,#$%0C+FD%3/@F$%=#/+*K%%

.$3$<,#$@$11B% EF+@-+*A% 0*% ,#$% +*+,+/@%=01,+*A%50<I% =0*-F=,$-% E>%9ZPB%5$%#/3$%$1,/E@+1#$-% /% ;:2>*:' ?+2%29$+' 321":%8bZ`:B%5#+=#% 8+:% +*=<$/1$1% ,#$%=0*6+-$*=$%@$3$@%06%6+*-+*A1%/*-%8++:% +10@/,$1%=01,1%/*-%E$*$6+,1% /=<011% ,#$% $*,+<$% 3/@F$J=#/+*B%5#+@1,% 8+++:% +-$*,+6>+*A% C0,$*,+/@%@$3$</A$g,F<*+*A%C0+*,1% ,0% 1,<$*A,#$*% ,#$%C<+0<+,+L/,+0*%06%+*,$<*/,+0*/@%/*-%*/,+0*/@%1FCC0<,K% f+<$=,% 201,1% +*=@F-$% 8+:% </*10D%C/>D$*,1% 8++:% +*1F</*=$% C<$D+FD1% /*-%1F<=#/<A$1% 8+++:% -$,$<<$*,% =01,1% 8+3:% <$J<0F,+*A%06%3$11$@1%3+/%2/C$%06%b00-%i0C$%83:% ./3/@% ;<$1$*=$% 83+:% C<01$=F,+0*1% 83++:%+*,$<*/,+0*/@% 0<A/*+L/,+0*/@% -$,$<<$*,1%83+++:%-$/,#1%,0%#01,/A$1%/*-%=<$51%/*-%8+U:%+*-+<$=,% =01,1% <$@/,$-% ,0% ,#$% A<05,#%C$<60<D/*=$% 06% <$A+0*/@% @+,,0</@%$=0*0D+$1K%%

9F<% =/@=F@/,+0*1% 1FAA$1,1% ,#/,% ,#$% -+<$=,%=01,1%06%0$)*+,'$%'=@A@%</*A$%6<0D%B8CDEFGHEH'>$::$2%%5+,#%+*-+<$=,%=01,1%</*A+*A%6<0D%B8CAE=GAEI' >$::$2%E% "0,/@% =01,1% ,#$<$60<$%$SF/@% E$,5$$*% B8CJEKGIED' >$::$2%K% "#$1$%=/@=F@/,+0*1% <$6@$=,B% /1% 1#05*% E$@05% 87$$%Y:B% ,#/,% ,#$% *FDE$<% 06% 3$11$@1% ,</*1+,+*A%,#$% 7F$L% 2/*/@% +1% E$1,% =0<<$@/,$-% 5+,#%[0<@-% "</-$% P+AF<$1% /*-% *0,% +*=+-$*,% 06%C+</=>B% +DC@>+*A% ,#/,% <$J<0F,+*A% 06% 1#+C1%#/1% C$<#/C1% E$$*% 03$<% $1,+D/,$-K%%i05$3$<B% C+</=>% #/1% +*=<$/1$-%1+A*+6+=/*,@>% -$1C+,$% @05$<% ,</-$% 30@FD$K%96%1+A*+6+=/*=$%87$$%a:% +1% ,#/,%,#$%=01,1%06%</*10D1% /*-% <$3$*F$1% /==<F+*A% /,% ,#$%@$3$@%06%,#$%C+</,$%3/@F$%=#/+*%/<$%-5/<6$-%E>% =01,1% 60<% D$<=#/*,% 1#+CC+*AB% 5#+@1,%0,#$<%1,/I$#0@-$<1%#/3$%60F*-%,#$D1$@3$1%5+,#%1+A*+6+=/*,%*$5%D/<I$,%0CC0<,F*+,+$1K%

%

!"

#!!!"

$!!!!"

$#!!!"

%!!!!"

%#!!!"

%!!$" %!!%" %!!&" %!!'" %!!#" %!!(" %!!)" %!!*" %!!+" %!$!"

,-./"01234"5,6-14.7",-./"8292:";-<=61><?@" A61:B"012B."5,6-14.7"A0C@"

D.E>692:"F>124?"G94>B.9<H"5,6-14.7"GCI@" D.H<"6J"A61:B"F>124?"G94>B.9<H"5,6-14.7"GCI@"

!"#$

%&'()

*"+*,-#'.$+/&0'

!"#$%&'#()*)+#,-)./#01#/2--&+)3&4#5036#72-+4#,-)4&#

8"#$60990*:#;#<)=)+#(2131#>5)-?#@)*12A#B)CA&*31#

!"#!$""#!%""#!&""#!'""#

!()"""#!()$""#!()%""#!()&""#!()'""#!$)"""#

*+,-./-#

0,-12+,34#

*45*.16,7#

8494224,9#:4312;9<#=>1;?4/4,9#

@+A+B#C.234-#

D2.-4316.,-#

8494224,34#E27+,;F+6.,-#

G.H# I;7J#

Page 15: The economics of Piracy

! &M!

%

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

9F<% <$1$/<=#%#/1%$1,/E@+1#$-%/% =01,% E$*$6+,%D0-$@% ,0% =/@=F@/,$% ,#$% <+1I%/-HF1,$-%=01,1%/*-%E$*$6+,1%06%C+</=>K%%"#+1%D0-$@% +1% 60<DF@/% -<+3$*% /*-% <$SF+<$1%D0<$% ,#/*% OM% 3/<+/E@$1B% 10F<=$-% 6<0D%-+66$<$*,%-/,/%10F<=$1%/*-%F1+*A%-+66$<$*,%/11FDC,+0*1K%)1+*A%,#+1%D0-$@B%/*-%E/1$-%0*%$U+1,+*A%+*60<D/,+0*%5$%#/3$%E$$*%/E@$%,0% -$,$<D+*$% 8+:% ,#$% 0CC0<,F*+,>% =01,% 06%C+</=>% 8++:% /3$</A$% +*=0D$1% C$<% >$/<% C$<%

C+</,$% 8+++:% @+6$,+D$% $/<*+*A1% /*-% 8+3:% ,#$%<+1I% /-HF1,$-% =01,1% 06% -$/,#B% +*HF<>% /*-%+DC<+10*D$*,% /*-% @+6$% $/<*+*A1B% /D0*A%0,#$<%0F,CF,1K%a/1$-%0*%=$<,/+*%$=0*0D+=%/11FDC,+0*1B% 5$% /<$% /@10% /E@$% ,0%$U,</C0@/,$%,#$%@+I$@>%C/,#%06%C+</=>%066%,#$%

20/1,1% 06%70D/@+/B% /A/+*%E/1$-% 06% 6/+<@>%5$@@% 60F*-$-%/11FDC,+0*1K!%

-002)/<%$/$".?%2@$/<@>B% +6% 5$%F1$%,#+1%D0-$@B%/*-% +-$*,+6>%,#$% C<$=+1$%-/,/% <$SF+<$-%,0% +*=<$/1$%

=0*6+-$*=$% @$3$@1B% ,#$*% ,#$% 03$</@@%,</H$=,0<>%06%=01,1%/*-%E$*$6+,1%5+@@%E$%6/<%

E$,,$<%F*-$<1,00-%

j% /+-+*A% ,#$%C0@+=>%

<$1C0*1$% 06%2b;27%

D$DE$<%1,/,$1K%

PF<,#$<B% +6%6+$@-JE/1$-%

<$1$/<=#% +1%=0*-F=,$-%

/=<011% ,#$%3/@F$% =#/+*B%

/*-%,#+1%+1%@+*I$-%,0%,</=I+*A%6+*/*=$1%87$$%7$=,+0*%_:B%/@0*A1+-$%@/5%$*60<=$D$*,%/*-%-$,$<<$*,% 0C$</,+0*1B% ,#$% =01,1%5+@@% E$A+*%,0% 0F,% 5$+A#% ,#$% E$*$6+,1G% 5#+=#% ,#$>%=F<<$*,@>%-0%*0,K'

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!% N,% 5+@@% /@10% E$% +DC0<,/*,% ,0% F*-$<,/I$% =<011J*/,+0*/@%=0DC/</,+3$% 50<I% /*-% ,0% F*-$<1,/*-% 5#>% C+</=>% +*%70F,#% Z/1,% Y1+/% C$/I$-% E$,5$$*% &''!J(MMMB% /*-% ,#$*%6$@@%</C+-@>K%

Page 16: The economics of Piracy

! &&!

!*/*' 8L2)/#*::.?% .$$-@$11% ,0% 1/>% ,#$%D0-$@% +1% /1% 1,<0*A% /1% ,#$% /3/+@/E@$% -/,/K%%[#+@1,% =$<,/+*% 3/<+/E@$1% 8+K$K% C+</=>%+*=+-$*=$:% /<$% 6/+<@>% 5$@@% -0=FD$*,$-B%0,#$<% -/,/% 8+K$K% /=,F/@% </*10D% C/>D$*,1B%*FDE$<% 06% C+</,$1B% *FDE$<% 06% C+</,$%-$/,#1B%</,+0%06%</*10D%C/>D$*,1%/==<F+*A%/=<011% ,#$% 3/@F$% =#/+*:% /<$% C00<@>%-0=FD$*,$-K% b$0C0@+=+,>% +1% /E@$% ,0%C<03+-$% /*% +*-$C$*-$*,% 10F<=$% 06% C+</=>%<$@/,$-% -/,/B% /AA<$A/,$-% /=<011% /@@%+*,$<*/,+0*/@% 0<A/*+L/,+0*1% /*-% E/1$-% 0*%E0,#%$=0*0D+=g6+$@-JE/1$-%3/@F$%-/,/K%

P..<90/$2%.?%9F<% /11FDC,+0*1% /<$% E/1$-%0*% #+A#J3/@F$% -/,/% 10F<=$1% 5#$<$3$<%C011+E@$B% EF,%D0<$% +*60<D/,+0*% +1% *$$-$-%,0% /11+1,% ,#$% 2b;27K% 9F<% <$1$/<=#% 1#051%,#/,% ,#$<$% +1% /% #FA$% C/F=+,>% 06% -/,/% +*%<$@/,+0*% ,0% ,#$% $=0*0D+=% /*-% 6+*/*=+/@%/1C$=,1% 06% C+</=>G% /% C<0E@$D% ,#/,% 5$%E$@+$3$% =/*% E$% 1FE1,/*,+/@@>% 03$<=0D$%F1+*A% /=,+0*J<$1$/<=#K% 9F<% <$1$/<=#% /@10%F*=03$<$-% 1+A*+6+=/*,% +*=0*1+1,$*=+$1% +*%CFE@+1#$-% D/,$<+/@% 6<0D% 066+=+/@%0<A/*+L/,+0*1K% 9F<% D0-$@% A$*$</,$1% @05B%D$-+FD% /*-% #+A#% E0F*-% /11FDC,+0*1B%C<03+-+*A%/%</*A$%06%<$1F@,1K%%"#$%</*A$%06%/11FDC,+0*1% 5+@@% <$-F=$% /1% ,#$% <$1$/<=#%=0*,+*F$1K% 70D$%06% ,#$% =0<$% /11FDC,+0*1%D/-$%/<$%0F,@+*$-%E$@05?%%

• bf;g=/C+,/% +*% 70D/@+/% +1% $1,+D/,$-% /,%)7\VMMg/**FDK% 93$<% /*% /3$</A$%50<I+*A% @+6$,+D$B%5#+=#%5$%/11FD$% ,0%E$% ('% >$/<1B% /% 70D/@+% D/*% D/>% $/<*%)7\&XBVMMK% [$% F1$% ,#+1% /1% 0F<% *$U,%E$1,%/@,$<*/,+3$%,0%$*A/A+*A%+*%C+</=>G%

• [$% /11FD$% ,#/,% C+</,$1% $*A/A$% +*%C+</=>% 60<% OJV% >$/<1B% /@,#0FA#% 6F<,#$<%<$1$/<=#% 5+@@% E$% =<+,+=/@% ,0% +*=<$/1+*A%,#$% =0*6+-$*=$% @$3$@% 06% ,#+1%/11FDC,+0*K% [$% /11FD$% ,#$% /3$</A$%/A$% 06% /% C+</,$% ,0% E$% (V% >$/<1B% ,#+1% +1%,#$% /A$% ,#/,%5$% /11FD$% -$/,#B% +*HF<>%0<%+DC<+10*D$*,%D/>%0==F<G%%

• 9F<% D0-$@% <F*1% 1=$*/<+01% E/1$-% 0*%e/=I% 4/*AR1% 6+AF<$% 06% &BVMM% C+</,$1% 066%

,#$% 20/1,% 06% 70D/@+/B% EF,% /@10% FC% ,0%OBMMM%/=,+3$%C+</,$1B%E/1$-%0*%3/<>+*A%10F<=$1% /*-% 6+$@-% E/1$-% -+1=F11+0*1B%5+,#%/**F/@%@011$1%06%FC%,0%(MM%@+3$1%/%>$/<G%

• [$% /11FD$% ,#/,% C+</=>% 1F==$11% </,$1%</*A$% 6<0D% ((% 8/1% +*% (MM':B% OM% 8/1% +*%(M&M:% /*-% XM% 8/1% +*% (MMd:% C$<% =$*,%E/1$-% 0*% )7% b03$<*D$*,% 8f0--:%<$C0<,1G%

• [$% /11FD$% ,#/,% ,#$% /3$</A$% </*10D%C/+-% #+-$1% 1+A*+6+=/*,% -$3+/,+0*B% /*-%,#$<$60<$% =0DCF,$% </*10D1% 6<0D%)7\OKV% ,0% )7\XKV% D+@@+0*% E/1$-% 0*%(M&M% 6+AF<$1B% 5+,#% <0' /2% OMW% 06% ,#+1%<$/=#+*A% ,#$% C+</,$% =<$5K% "#+1% OMW%1#/<$% +1% 1C@+,% $SF/@@>% E$,5$$*% ,#$%/3$</A$% =<$5% 1+L$B% 5#+=#% 5$% #/3$%-$,$<D+*$-% E/1$-% 0*% *FD$<0F1%10F<=$1%/*-%+*,$<3+$51G%/*-B%

• P+*/*=+$<1%/*-%1C0*10<1%D$$,%@/*-%/*-%1$/% E/1$-% 0C$</,+0*/@% =01,1K% B0' /2%dMW% 06% /@@% </*10D1% C/>D$*,1% /<$%-+1,<+EF,$-% ,0% 6+*/*=+$<1B% 1C0*10<1B%b03$<*D$*,% 066+=+/@1% /*-% 0,#$<%+*,$<$1,%A<0FC1B%$U=@F-+*A%,</*1/=,+0*1%=01,1K'%

;+</,$1%6/=$%,#$%=01,1%06%-$/,#B% +*HF<>%/*-%+DC<+10*D$*,K% a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

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!'%[$%-0%*0,%E$@+$3$% ,#$%dM?OM% 1C@+,% ,0%E$%/==F</,$B%EF,%,#+1%+1%,#$%1,/*-/<-%</,+0%SF0,$-K%PF<,#$<%<$1$/<=#%5+@@%A0%/%@0*A%5/>%,0%F*-$<1,/*-+*A%5#/,%-$,$<D+*$-%</,+01%/*-%3/@F$%=#/+*%1C@+,1K%

Page 17: The economics of Piracy

! &(!

Q*>:".' A% /*-%%% E$@05% C<03+-$% C011+E@$% <$3$*F$% 1FDD/<+$1% E/1$-% 0*% $U+1,+*A% +*60<D/,+0*%/*-%-+66$<$*,%/11FDC,+0*1K%%

Q*>:"'A%C<$1$*,1%:26R'9"1$<9'*%1'L$&L'>2<%1'.+"%*)$2.%E/1$-%0*%/%,0,/@%06%&BVMM%C+</,$1B%/%</*10D% </*A$% 06% )7\OKVJ)7\XKV% D+@@+0*B% /*-% 1F==$11% </,$1% </*A+*A% 6<0D% ((JXM% WK% "#$%1=$*/<+01% C<$1$*,$-% /<$% E/1$-% 0*% I*05*% +*=+-$*,1% +*% (M&M% 8(&':G% /A/+*% 066% ,#$% =0/1,% 06%70D/@+/K%%"#$%<$1F@,1%/<$%=@$/<K%a/1$-%0*%,#$1$%E<0/-%/11FDC,+0*1%/*-%/%</*A$%06%0,#$<%=01,1%/-HF1,$-%E$*$6+,1B%,#$%/3$</A$%C+</,$%=0F@-%$/<*%E$,5$$*%)7\OOBd(_%/*-%)7\d!B!XM%/%>$/<B%-$C$*-+*A% 0*% ,#$% </*10D% C/+-K% Y3$</A$% @+6$,+D$% $/<*+*A1% 03$<% /% C$<+0-% 06% V% >$/<1% </*A$%E$,5$$*%)7\&_!B_OM%/*-%)7\O'XBMMMB%/A/+*%-$C$*-+*A%0*%,#$%3/@F$%06%</*10D%C/>D$*,1B%5#+=#%5$%=0*1+-$<%+1%06,$*%03$<%+*6@/,$-K%%Z+,#$<%5/>B%$3$*%,#$%@05%=/1$%1=$*/<+0%60<%C+</,$%<$3$*F$1% +*-+=/,$1% <$DF*$</,+0*%/,%_d% ,+D$1% ,#$%=F<<$*,%/**F/@%C$<%=/C+,/%bf;%j%/*-%,#$%#+A#$<%=/1$%FC%,0%&Vd%,+D$1%,#/,K%%

Q*>:"'=%C<03+-$1%,#$%1/D$%1,/,+1,+=1%E/1$-%0*%/*%/11FDC,+0*%,#/,%,#$<$%DF1,%E$%D0<$%,#/*%&BVMM%C+</,$1K%"#+1%+1%E/1$-%0*%6+$@-%<$C0<,1%06%/,,<+,+0*%</,$1%8-$/,#B%-$6$=,+0*B%+DC<+10*D$*,%$,=K:% /*-% ,#$% $UC/*-+*A% +*=+-$*,1% </,$K% %)*-$<% ,#$% OBMMM% C+</,$% 1=$*/<+01B% /3$</A$% /**F/@%$/<*+*A1% </*A$% 6<0D% )7\OMB__M% ,0% )7\O'BX(MB% 60<% /% C+</=>% @+6$,+D$% $/<*+*A% 06% E$,5$$*%)7\&VOBOMM%/*-%)7\&'dB&MMK%"#+1%1=$*/<+0%D/I$1%,#$%/3$</A$%C+</,$%1/@/<>%5#+@1,%50<I+*A%/1% /% C+</,$% E$,5$$*% _&% /*-% d'% ,+D$% D0<$% C<06+,/E@$% ,#/*% ,#$% *$U,% E$1,% 0CC0<,F*+,>K

%[#/,% +1% +DC0<,/*,% #$<$% +1% *0,% ,#$% /=,F/@%/==F</=>% 06% ,#$% 6+AF<$1% C$<% 1$B% /@,#0FA#%,#$>%-0%C<03+-$%/%1+A*+6+=/*,%1,0<>@+*$B%+,%+1%,#/,%5+,#%FC%,0%dM%W%06%<$3$*F$1%/==<F+*A%,0%6+*/*=+$<%/*-%1C0*10<1B%/*-%5+,#%DF=#%%

%06%,#+1%D0*$>%A0+*A%+*,0%$UC/*-+*A%C+</=>%0C$</,+0*1B%,#$*%C+</=>%+1%5+,#0F,%-0FE,%/%A<05+*A% D/<I$,K% P0<% C+</,$1% 5#0% 5$<$%0*=$% 6+1#$<D$*B% C+</=>% #/1% *05% E$=0D$%,#$%/@,$<*/,+3$%@+3$@+#00-%06%=#0+=$K%

.89:;$<$=>?@6ABC$*8D;$)EEF8:G=AH;IAJ;$0>J8:A$&AK8I;$(;L;EF;D$AE$M0N$!8D;O$>E$<P7QQ$&AK8I;D$$ $ =>?;K$*8D;$ 3AOO:;$*8D;$ 6ABC$*8D;$

)$ 4>$"H$&AK8I;D$ &VMM% &VMM% &VMM%

!$ (8ED>JD$ \OBVMMBMMM% \XBMMMBMMM% \XBVMMBMMM%

*$ 0FRR;DD$(8I;$ ((W% OMW% XMW%

S$ %Q<Q$'ERAO;EID$ (&'% (&'% (&'%

/$ 5S&G&;K$*8TAI8$ VMM% VMM% VMM%

-$ )L;K8B;$'ER>J;G&AK8I;G+;8K$ )7\OOBd(_% )7\V(BV_M% )7\d!B!XM%

5$ -G/$U$4>$>H$.AJ;D$)L;K8B;$'ER>J;$ _d% &MV% &Vd%

6$ )L;K8B;$&AK8I;$=AH;IAJ;$/8KEAEBD$ M0N<VWPVXQ$ M0N%V%PWQQ$ M0NXY1P%QQ$

% % % % %

.89:;$%$=>?@6ABC$*8D;$)EEF8:G=AH;IAJ;$0>J8:A$&AK8I;$(;L;EF;D$AE$M0N$!8D;O$>E$XPQQQ$&AK8I;D$% % =>?$*8D;$ 3AOO:;$*8D;$ 6ABC$*8D;$

)$ 4>$"H$&AK8I;D$ OMMM% OMMM% OMMM%

!$ (8ED>JD$ \OBVMMBMMM% \XBMMMBMMM% \XBVMMBMMM%*$ 0FRR;DD$(8I;$ ((W% OMW% XMW%

S$ %Q<Q$'ERAO;EID$ (&'% (&'% (&'%/$ 5S&G&;K$*8TAI8$ VMM% VMM% VMM%-$ )L;K8B;$'ER>J;G&AK8I;G+;8K$ )7\OMB__M% )7\OVBMXM% )7\O'BX(M%

5$ -G/$U$4>$>H$.AJ;D$)L;K8B;$'ER>J;$ _&% dM% d'%

6$ )L;K8B;$&AK8I;$=AH;IAJ;$/8KEAEBD$ M0N<7XPXQQ$ M0N<Z7P%QQ$ M0N<YZP<QQ$

Page 18: The economics of Piracy

! &O!

%

V2$ .()*['45$-'4)4*')=$-="\0$

"</=I+*A% ,#$% 6+*/*=+/@% 6@051B% /=<011% ,#$%3/@F$J=#/+*% #/1% *$3$<% E$$*% /,,$DC,$-B%>$,% +,% +1% E0,#% F<A$*,@>% *$$-$-% /*-%/=#+$3/E@$K%b+3$*%,#/,%70D/@+%C+</,$1%#/3$%/,,/=I$-% _XM% 1#+C1% /*-% ,/I$*% D0<$% ,#/*%OB&VM% #01,/A$1% 1+*=$% (MMdB% ,</=I+*A%6+*/*=$1%+1%*0,%HF1,%/E0F,%D0*$>%C$<%1$B%+,%+1%/@10%/E0F,%C<0,$=,+*A%@+3$1%/*-%1$=F<+*A%D/<+,+D$% ,</-$% +*% 5#/,% #/1% E$=0D$% /%30@/,+@$% >$/<% /=<011% ,#$% `+--@$% Z/1,% /*-%bF@6%06%Y-$*K%`0*$>%,</*16$<%0C$</,0<1%+*%70D/@+/%+*=@F-$%f/#/E1#++@B%k/</*%ZUC<$11B%`F1,/SE/@B% YD/@% ZUC<$11B% c//#% ZUC<$11B%i0-/*% b@0E/@B% 9@>DC+=B% YD/*/% ZUC<$11B%N6,+*% ZUC<$11% /*-% "/5/I/@% ZUC<$11K% "#$1$%0C$</,0<1% #/3$% =0**$=,+0*1% ,#<0FA#0F,%,#$%`+--@$%Z/1,B%,#$%)cB%D/+*@/*-%ZF<0C$B%/*-%,#$%)7K%

"#$%).B%).9f2B%N."Z];94gZ)]9;94%/*-%0,#$<% 1C$=+/@+L$-% /A$*=+$1% /<$% $*A/A$-%,#<0FA#%,#$%2b;27%EF,%,#$<$%/<$%@+D+,1%,0%5#/,%60<D/@%+*,$<*/,+0*/@%+*1,+,F,+0*1%5+,#%=0*1,</+*$-%0F,<$/=#%06%+*60<D/@%/*-%+@@+=+,%1>1,$D1% =/*% /=#+$3$K% "#$% i/5/@/% 1>1,$D%+*%Y6A#/*+1,/*%#/1%E$$*%#$/3+@>%1,F-+$-%j%+*% 6/=,% $3$*% F1$-% E>% ,#$% +*,$<*/,+0*/@%=0DDF*+,>% j% EF,% ,</=I+*A% +@@+=+,% 6@051% #/1%10% 6/<% *0,% /11+1,$-% +*% +-$*,+6>+*A%+*-+3+-F/@1% +*30@3$-% +*% ,</66+=I+*AK% [#+@1,%

,#$% F@,+D/,$% /+D% DF1,% E$% ,0% ,</=I% -05*%/*-%+*,$<-+=,%,#$%6+*/*=+/@%D$/*1%,#/,%6F*-%C+</=>% 0C$</,+0*1B% ,#+1% =/*% 0*@>% E$% -0*$%0*=$% ,#$%3/@F$J=#/+*% +1%-0=FD$*,$-%0*%/%D/<I$,%1$AD$*,/,+0*%E/1+1K%%

Y%I$>%60=F1%06%6F,F<$%<$1$/<=#%DF1,%E$%0*%8+:%,#$%C/>D$*,%/*-%@/F*-$<+*A%06%</*10D%C/>D$*,1% 8++:% /11$,% ,</=+*A% 8+++:% 5#$<$%<$@$3/*,B%+*60<D/@%D0*$>%,</*16$<%1>1,$D1%8+3:% C+</,$% 3/@F$% =#/+*% /*/@>1+1% 83:% C/*$@%1F<3$>1% 06% C+</,$1% 83+:% /*-% ,#$%=0*10@+-/,+0*%/*-%1#/<+*A%06%-/,/%E$,5$$*%+*,$<*/,+0*/@% =00C$</,+0*% C/<,*$<1K%N."Z];94% 5+@@% *$$-% ,0% @$/-%DF=#% 06% ,#+1%50<I% EF,% DF1,% E$% 1FCC0<,$-% E>% /*%+*-$C$*-$*,%<$1$/<=#%0<A/*+L/,+0*B%+-$/@@>%E/1$-% +*% ,#$% `+--@$% Z/1,% 5+,#% /% 1,<0*A%*$,50<I%/=<011%,#$%i0<*%06%Y6<+=/K%7F=#%/*%0<A/*+L/,+0*%DF1,%/@10%E$%/E@$%,0%C<03+-$%/% =0F*,$<JE/@/*=$% ,0% 066+=+/@% 6+AF<$1% /*-%,/I$%A<$/,$<% <+1I1% +*%-/,/%/*-%3/@F$%=#/+*%<$C0<,+*A% /*-% +*3$1,+A/,+0*1K% Q*>:"' D%E$@05% 0F,@+*$1% /% *FDE$<% 06% @0A+=/@%D/<+,+D$% C+</=>% 6+*/*=+/@% +*3$1,+A/,+0*%0C,+0*1% j% +*% 1FCC0<,% 06% ,#$% P+*/*=+/@%Y=,+0*%"/1I%P0<=$%J%+-$/@@>%,0%E$%,/=I@$-%E>%/%>$,J,0JE$J$1,/E@+1#$-%S;(S8';)2<0'T'0*%?+2%29$+.'*%1'U$%*%+$%&K%

%

.89:;$X$38KAIAJ;$&AK8R]$-AE8ERA8:$'EL;DIAB8IA>E$"TIA>ED$$ -AE8ERA8:$ .K8R^AEB$ 0F9@

-FERIA>ED$&K>T>D;O$)TTK>8RC$$ S;:AL;K]$3;RC8EADJ$

&% ]/*10D%;/>D$*,% ]$1$/<=#%$*,+<$%</*10D%C/>D$*,%C<0=$11%g%1>1,$D%E/1$-%0*%=/1$%1,F-+$1%

N."Z];94%g%Z)]9;94%N*-$C$*-$*,%]$1$/<=#%%

(% Y11$,%"</=+*A% Y1%C$<%1,/*-/<-%C<0=$-F<$1% N."Z];94gZ)]9;94%

O% `"9gNl"7% ]$1$/<=#%+*,0%i/5/@/%1>1,$D1%/*-%</*10D%C/>D$*,%g%@/F*-$<+*A%C<0=$11%

N*-$C$*-$*,%]$1$/<=#%

X% l/@F$%2#/+*%]$1$/<=#% 20*-F=,%-$,/+@$-%+*J=0F*,<>%3/@F$%=#/+*%/*/@>1+1%06%,#$%;l2%

N*-$C$*-$*,%]$1$/<=#%

V% N*%20F*,<>%;+</,$%;/*$@%7F<3$>%%

20*-F=,%C0@+,+=/@J$=0*0D>%/*/@>1+1B%1,</,$A+=%=0*6@+=,%/11$11D$*,%/*-%C+</,$%8C/*$@:%1F<3$>%

N*-$C$*-$*,%]$1$/<=#%

_% f/,/%20*10@+-/,+0*B%7#/<+*AB%200<-+*/,+0*%

Z1,/E@+1#%/%A@0E/@%Q;+</,$%;0<,/@R%/1%/%)*+6+$-%f/,/%iFEB%C<03+-+*A%=0DD0*B%,+D$@>B%SF/@+,>%-/,/K%

N."Z];94%N*-$C$*-$*,%]$1$/<=#%

%

Page 19: The economics of Piracy

! !"!

#

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

• J%&0,=# %47.B.47.4,# +%.37# '47# 7.0C#D'0.7# &.0.'&(-# (*<37# *A.&(*2.# ,-.#B&*D3.2# *+# 0,',.# (3'00%+%.7K%4+*&2',%*4L# 0,&.4?,-.4%4?#%4,.&4',%*4'3# 7%'3*?<.# '47#<47.&0,'47%4?L#

• 1.(*47=# %,# (*<37# B&*A%7.# +*&# '# 0%4?3.K(*40*3%7',.7# 7','# 0*<&(.# ,-',# ('44*,#D.# B&*A%7.7# D)# %4,.&4',%*4'3#*&?'4%H',%*40# 7<.# ,*# ,-.%&# *+,.4#4'&&*53)# 7.+%4.7# 2'47',.09##G47.B.47.4,# &.0.'&(-# (*<37# D.#(*47<(,.7# *4# '4# '?&..7# &.0.'&(-#+&'2.5*&C# '47# (*<37# B*B<3',.# '#(.4,&'3# 2*7.3# 5%,-# %40,%,<,%*4'3#%4+*&2',%*4#5-.4#'A'%3'D3.9#@-%0#(*<37#D.# (*2B3%2.4,.7# 5%,-# D.0B*C.# +%.37#D'0.7#(*<4,&)#A'3<.K(-'%4#'00.002.4,#5*&CL#

• @-%&7=# %,# 5*<37# '33*5# 7%++%(<3,# 0<D>.(,#'&.'0# 0<(-# '0# ,-.# &*3.# B3').7# D)# ,-.#M'5'3'# 0)0,.2=# 0,',.# 0B*40*&.7#B&%A',..&# 4.,5*&C0# '47# &'40*2#B')2.4,0# ,*# D.# &.0.'&(-.7=# 5%,-*<,#7%&.(,#%40,%,<,%*4'3#*&#3.?'3#%2B3%(',%*40#A%0#N#A%0#+%47%4?0L#

• J%4'33)=# %,# 5*<37# B&*A%7.# '#(*<4,.&B*%4,# ,*# B<D3%(# %4+*&2',%*4#'&*<47# 5-%(-# '00<2B,%*40# (*<37# D.#,.0,.7# '47# 0,&.4?,-.4.7=# '47# B*3%(%.0#+%4.K,<4.79#

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

/00#*-1$&-&!'( +$2( 3$-*4( 5#&$-'6( @-%0#&.0.'&(-#-'0#D..4#(*47<(,.7#<0%4?#'4# %4K-*<0.#2*7.3# ,*# ('3(<3',.# D*,-# '??&.?',.#%4,.&4',%*4'3# (*0,0# '47# (*0,0# ',# ,-.# 3.A.3#*+# ,-.# '(,<'3# B%&',.# A'3<.# (-'%4=# '47# 5.#D.3%.A.# ,-',# (*4,%4<%4?# ,-%0# &.0.'&(-# 5%33#)%.37# 0%?4%+%('4,# &.0<3,09# # T47.&0,'47%4?#,-.# ?3*D'3# (*0,0# *+# B%&'()# 5%33# 0,&.4?,-.4#'&?<2.4,0# +*&# ?&.',.&# &.0*<&(%4?9#M*5.A.&=#*43)#(*<4,&)#D'0.7#'(,%*4#A'3<.K(-'%4# 5*&C=# 0<BB*&,.7# D)# 7.0C# D'0.7#'4'3),%('3# '47# 7%'?4*0,%(# 5*&C# '47#+%4'4(%'3# ,&'(C%4?# 5%33# %7.4,%+)# 5-*# %0#+%4'4(%4?#'47#0B*40*&%4?#B%&'()=#-*5#'47#5-.&.9#@-.#+*33*5%4?#U#.4,&)#B*%4,0#5*<37#'BB.'&#,*#B&*A%7.#'# 3*?%('3#+&'2.5*&C#+*&#+<,<&.#'(,%*4K&.0.'&(-9#

3$-*4( 5#&$-( 7I# 8#'-&$9( 5&*+"4I# V'0.7# *4#0,'47'&7# .(*4*2%(# 2*7.3%4?# 7.3%A.&#&.?<3'&# &.B*&,0# ,*# ,-.# /S$/1# 2.2D.&0=#B&*A%7%4?#<B#,*#7',.#;<'&,.&3)#'4'3)0%0#*4#?3*D'3#'47#B%&',.#3.A.3#(*0,0#'47#D.4.+%,0L#

Page 20: The economics of Piracy

! !:!

3$-*4( 5#&$-( :I# ;+,1!( 8<+&$( =$+,4'&'I#T47.&,'C.#7%&.(,#A'3<.K(-'%4#5*&C#*4#'47#*++#,-.#(*'0,#*++#1*2'3%'#,*#(3.'&3)#%7.4,%+)#A'3<.# '77.7# '(&*00# ,-.# .4,%&.# 3'47# '47#2'&%,%2.# A'3<.K(-'%4=# %4(3<7%4?# 7%++.&.4,#0*A.&.%?4# (-'44.30=# 0*# ,-',# ,-.# 0%2B3%0,%(#WXIYX#0B3%,0#'&.#'#,-%4?#*+#,-.#B'0,=#'47#5.#('4# %7.4,%+)# 5-*# ?.,0# 5-',=# 5-.4=# '47#-*59#J%?<&.#8#*<,3%4.0#'#0%2B3%0,%(#A%.5#*+#,-.#'?.4()#+&'2.5*&CL#

3$-*4( 5#&$-( >I#?$2!*'-+$2&$9( 5&*+"4( +$2(-<!( @$)#*%+,( A#$!4( B*+$')!*( C4'-!%'I##Z'<4(-# '# ,-*&*<?-# &.0.'&(-# B&*?&'2=#D'0.7# *4# 0<&A.)0# '47# C.)# %4+*&2'4,#'4'3)0%0# %4# 1*2'3%'# '47# ,-%&7# (*<4,&%.0# ,*#,&'(C# &'40*2# B')2.4,# +3*50# O03%B0# '47#(*7.0P=#B*00%D3.#3'<47.&%4?#*+#&.A.4<.0#,*#,-%&7#(*<4,&%.0#'47#*,-.&#&.3',.7#+%4'4(%'3#(&%2.0L#

3$-*4( 5#&$-( DI# E&$+$"&+,( +$2( =''!-(B*+"F&$9I# # G,# %0# 3*?%('3# ,*# 7.,.(,=# ,&'(C=#7%0&<B,=# '47# %4,.&7%(,# %33%(%,# +%4'4(%'3#,&'40'(,%*40# (*44.(,.7# ,*# $J[# '47# ,-.#(&%2%4'3# 4.,5*&C0# ,-',# +%4'4(.# ,-.29#\.A.3*B%4?# B&*(.7<&.0# +*&# B%.&(%4?#%4+*&2'3# D'4C# 0.(&.()# B&'(,%(.0#5%33# 4..7#,*#D.#7.A.3*B.79#

3$-*4(5#&$-(GI#@$2!0!$2!$-(H+-+(=$+,4'&'I##V<%37#*4#'4#.0,'D3%0-.7#.(*4*2%(#&.0.'&(-#('B'D%3%,)L# ,*# B&*A%7.# '# (.4,&'3# -<D# +*&#(&*00K4',%*4'3# (*2B'&',%A.# 5*&C=#.(*4*2%(# '4'3)0%0# '47# A'3<.K(-'%4#,&'(C%4?9#

3$-*4( 5#&$-( I6( @2!$-&)4&$9( =,-!*$+-&.!(J&.!,&<##2'(+$2(K*#L-<(E1-1*!'I#G,#5%33#D.#A%,'3# ,*# <47.&0,'47# ,-.# 2'%4# .(*4*2%(#+'(,*&0# 7&%A%4?# *4.K,%2.# +%0-.&2'4# ,*#<47.&,'C.# -%?-3)# (&%2%4'3# '(,%A%,%.09##/3.'&3)# ,-.# 7&%A.&0# .6B'47%4?# B%&'()# 0,.2#+&*2# '# +<47'2.4,'3# &.0,&<(,<&%4?# %4#%4(*2.#0*<&(.0=#7<.#,*#+*&.%?4#+%0-%4?#*++#,-.# /*'0,0# *+# 1*2'3%'# '47# (*4+3%(,=#

+*33*5%4?# ,-.# (*33'B0.# *+# 1%'7# V'&&.F0#S*A.&42.4,# %4# !]]!9# ^.,=# '0# '# &.0<3,# *+#%40.(<&%,)=# %4,.&4',%*4'3# &.B*&,%4?# *4#S\$_S`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aA.4#,-*<?-# ,-.# 0*K('33.7# E!"#$%&''()*"+,&-$+(.) "/) 0"1+#2+F# 4*5# %4(3<7.0#(&%2%4'3#?'4?0=# %,#0..20#3*?%('3#,-',#2'4)#*+# ,-.# &**,# ('<0.0# *+# (&%2%4'3# '(,%A%,)# ',#0.'#'&.#%4#+'(,#,*#D.#+*<47#*4#7&)#3'479#

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

b..,%4?# ,-.# *D>.(,%A.0# *+# ,-.# \>%D*<,%#/*7.#*+#/*47<(,#'47#T`#1.(<&%,)#/*<4(%3#[.0*3<,%*40# &.;<%&.0# ,-.#2.2D.&0# *+# ,-.#/S$/1#,*#(*40%7.&#,-.0.#.4,&)#B*%4,0#'0#'#2.'40# ,*# D*,-# (*2D',%4?# ,-.# 0B&.'7# *+#B%&'()=# '47# B&*?&.00%A.3)# &.2*A%4?# ,-.#('<0.0#*+#,-%0#2*7.&4#7')#0(*<&?.9#

Page 21: The economics of Piracy

! !"!

!"#$%&'&()*%&+,-.)/0&1)*&23)/)4.3&"/5&6./"/3."$&!*"37./8&&2/-*9&:)./-0& ;"./&<3-.=.-.%0& 2>,%3-%5&?%0@$-0& :)00.#$%&?%0,)/0.#.$.-9&

AB&()0-./8&:.*"39& #$%&'( )*( +,&( -.)/$.( 01)*)231( 435$16( 7)'&.( '&8&.)9&'( ,&5&:($;;5&;$+&( 3*+&5*$+3)*$.( 9532$56( $*'( %&1)*'$56( '$+$:( +,<%(3*15&$%3*;( 1)*=3'&*1&( .&8&.%( $*'( 5&.&8$*1&:( %+5&*;+,&*3*;($%%<29+3)*%:( $*'( 5&2)83*;( 1)*+5$'31+3)*%( +)( <*'&5%+$*'( +,&(1)%+>/&*&=3+(5$+3)(3*(5&$.($*'(*)23*$.(+&52%?(

! @<$5+&5.6(AB)%+()=(435$16C(D&9)5+%(+)(+,&(B-4BEF(! E<99.6($*'('&2$*'(%1&*$53)%(! B)%+($*'(;&);5$9,31$.(=)5&1$%+(95)G&1+3)*%F(! H*'&5%+$*'3*;(935$+&(I=3*$*13$.J('538&5%?(

! HK(! L*'&9&*'&*+(D&%&$51,(M&$2(

! N0O((

CB&:.*"-%&D"$@%&(E"./&</"$90.0F&G/5%*0-"/5./8&-E%&:.*"39&H@0./%00&;)5%$&

O)..)P3*;(+,&(2)*&6(+5$3.(I95)1&&'%(=.)P(<9(+,&(935$+&%(1,$3*()=(1)22$*'J(95)83'&%($(=)523'$/.&()99)5+<*3+6(+)(<*'&5%+$*'(+,&(%+5<1+<5&($*'(=<*1+3)*3*;()=(2$53+32&(935$16(*&+P)5Q%?(E+$*'$5'(8$.<&( 1,$3*(P)5Q( +)( 3'&*+3=6( +,&( $;&*16( 1,$3*( 3*8).8&'(P3..( /&(%<99.&2&*+&'( P3+,( %)13)>&1)*)231( P)5Q( +)( <*'&5%+$*'( P,$+('538&%(935$16:(=5)2($(95)=3+(2$Q3*;(9&5%9&1+38&?((R$.<&>$''&'(/6($;&*+( P3..( 5&8&$.( %9)*%)5:( =3*$*13&5( $*'( 935$+&( %,$5&%( $*'( +,&(&*+35&(%<99.6($*'('&2$*'(1,$3*?(

! B.&$5.6( ')1<2&*+( ,)P(2)*&6( =.)P%( $15)%%( +,&( &*+35&( 8$.<&>1,$3*F(

! S&%153/&(+,&(8$.<&>$''3+3)*(95)1&%%F(! L'&*+3=6(+<5*3*;($*'(3*8&%+2&*+(.&8&5$;&(9)3*+%F(! H*'&5%+$*'( $*'( <%&( +)( B-4BE( 2&2/&5( $'8$*+$;&( P,$+(2)+38$+&%(935$16($++$1Q%F(

! L'&*+3=63*;(+,&*(,3++3*;(%&.&1+&'(935$+&(%<99.6(.3*&%(! H*'&5%+$*'(.3*Q%(/&+P&&*(5$*%)2(9$62&*+%($*'($.>E,$/$$/(

! L*'&9&*'&*+( D&%&$51,(M&$2((

(

IB&G/5%*0-"/5./8&-E%&JD!K&:*)3%00&

L*+&*%38&( 3*8&%+3;$+38&( =3&.'P)5Q( P)<.'( /&( 1)*'<1+&'( +,5)<;,(=)52$.( $*'( 3*=)52$.( '3%1<%%3)*%( P3+,( $( P3'&( 8$53&+6( )=(3*=)52$*+%:()*(+,&(;5)<*'(3*(E)2$.3$($*'(3*(.3++)5$.(%+$+&%()==(+,&(-<.=()=(T'&*($*'(U)5*()=(T=531$?(M,&(5&%&$51,(P)<.'(1)8&5( +,&(2$3*( LRME( '&$.&5%( 3*( V>W( .3++)5$.( %+$+&%( +)( /<3.'( <9( $( %).3'(<*'&5%+$*'3*;()=(,)P(+,&(5&;3)*$.(*&+P)5Q(=<*1+3)*%($*'(P,31,($;&*+%($5&(=$8)5&'(/6(+,&(2$53+32&(935$16(*&+P)5Q%?(

! T*( $'$9+&'( =5$2&P)5Q( =)5( +$5;&+3*;( =3*$*13$.( =.)P%( =5)2(935$16:( 9&5,$9%( %323.$5( +)( )+,&5( )5;$*3X&'( +5$*%*$+3)*$.(15323*$.(*&+P)5Q%((

! M5$1Q3*;( 5$*%)2( 9$62&*+( 95)1&%%&%( =)5( Q*)P*( ,3;,( 95)=3.&(,3G$1Q3*;(3*13'&*+%(I#$%&'()*(1$%&(%+<'3&%J(

! @<$*+3=63*;(+,&(*&Y<%(/&+P&&*(935$16($*'(U$P$.$(%6%+&2F(! T%%&%%3*;( +,&( 329)5+$*1&( )=( U$P$.$( *&+P)5Q%( =)5( +,&(2)8&2&*+()=(935$16(5&.$+&'(95)=3+%?(

! HE(E+$+&(! L*'&9&*'&*+(D&%&$51,(M&$2((

! HKNSB(! Z)5.'(#$*Q([(L7O((

'B&6./"/3."$&"/5&<00%-&!*"37./8&

M,&(<*1,&1Q&'(=.)P()=(935$16(95)1&&'%(3%($(=)523'$/.&()/%+$1.&(+)('&+&55&*1&?(M,&5&=)5&:(/$%&'()*( 3*8&%+3;$+38&(P)5Q($*'(=3&.'(/$%&'( 9$*&.( %<58&6%:( )9+3)*%( =)5( '&8&.)93*;( 95)1&'<5&%( +)(93&51&( /$*Q( $*'( U$P$.$( %&15&16( 95$1+31&%( P,3.%+( 1)*=3%1$+3*;(15323*$.(3*1)2&%($*'($%%&+%(*&&'%(+)(/&('&8&.)9&'?(D&%&$51,3*;($%622&+531($.+&5*$+38&(1)<.'(63&.'(%3;*3=31$*+(5&%<.+%?(

! O)..)P( +,&( 2)*&6( +,5)<;,( +,&( =)52$.( $*'( 3*=)52$.( 2)*&6(+5$*%=&5(%6%+&2F(

! T(=5$2&P)5Q(=)5('&$.3*;(P3+,(935$16($%($(+5$*%*$+3)*$.(1532&F(! T( =5$2&P)5Q( =)5( 3*+&;5$+3*;( =3*$*13$.( $*'( $%%&+( +5$1Q3*;( 3*+)(3*+&5*$+3)*$.(.$P(&*=)51&2&*+()9&5$+3)*%F(

! HKNSB(! LKM0D4N\(I#TSTJ(! LKM0D4N\(T*+3>7)*&6(\$<*'&53*;(H*3+(

! 0HDN4N\(! HE(M5&$%<56(

LB&J/5%,%/5%/-&M"-"&</"$90.0&

M)( &%+$/.3%,( $( ;.)/$.( A3*+&;5$+&'C( '$+$( ,</( =)5( $*$.6%3%( $*'('3$;*)%+31( P)5Q:( +)( 2&&+( +,&( *&&'%( )=( +,&( 3*+&5*$+3)*$.(1)22<*3+6:( /<3.'3*;( $( %+5)*;( =)<*'$+3)*( )=( &83'&*1&( =)5(%+5&*;+,&*3*;(9).316($*'(3*%+3+<+3)*$.(5&%9)*%&%(+)(935$16?(

! N*&( E+)9( N*.3*&( S$+$( 4)3*+( =)5( T..( 7$53+32&( 435$16( D&.$+&'(S$+$(

! M32&.6( 3*=)52$+3)*:( 3295)8&'( 3*+&5*$+3)*$.( %6%+&2(&==313&*16($*'(&==&1+38&*&%%?(

! L*'&9&*'&*+(D&%&$51,!](! N0O(

LB&J5%/-.19./8&<$-%*/"-.=%&N.=%$.E))50&"/5&O*)P-E&6@-@*%0&&

H*'&5+$Q&( ;5)P+,( '3$;*)%+31( $*'( 3*8&%+2&*+( 1.32$+&( P)5Q( +)(<*'&5%+$*'(+,&(.3++)5$.($*'(2$53+32&(&1)*)23&%:(3'&*+3=63*;(+,&(%)<51&%()=(;5)P+,($*'($.+&5*$+38&(.38&.3,))'()99)5+<*3+3&%?((

! E)<51&%($*'(S538&5%()=(.313+($*'(3..313+(;5)P+,(! 7$15)>&1)*)231( $*'( .38&.3,))'( ;$3*%( )=( $( 5&%<29+3)*( 3*(3*+&5*$+3)*$.( =3%,3*;:( $*'( )9+3)*%( =)5( =.&&+( 95)+&1+3)*( $*'(P&$.+,(5&'3%+53/<+3)*(

! L*'&9&*'&*+(D&%&$51,(((

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!]((B)<.'(/&(1))5'3*$+&'(P3+,(L*+&..3;&*1&(N9&5$+3)*$.(O5$2&P)5Q%^(E$*$(LEB(1)8&5%(+,&(K)5+,:(7)2/$%$(LEB(1)8&5%(T5&$(B&*+5$.($*'(S$5(0%(E$.$$2(1)8&5%(T5&$(E)<+,((

Page 22: The economics of Piracy

! !_!

<//%>&A& O$)#"$&:.*"39&J/3.5%/-0&&O$)#"$&:.*"39&J/3.5%/-0&QARRASCTATU&#9&?%8.)/&

( ARRA& ARRC& ARRI& ARR'& ARRL& ARRV& ARRW& ARRX& ARRR& CTTT& CTTA& CTTC& CTTI& CTT'& CTTL& CTTV& CTTW& CTTX& CTTR& CTAT& !)-"$&

E)<+,(0$%+(T%3$( XX& VI& AV& IX& WA& AC'& RC& XR& AVA& C'C& ALI& ALI& AWT& ALX& ATC& XI& WT& L'& 'V& WT& CYT'I&

T=531$( T& T& W& V& CT& CL& 'V& 'A& LL& VX& XL& WX& RI& WI& XT& VA& ACI& AXR& CWT& CLR& AYLWR&

L*'3$*(E</>B)*+3*&*+( T& L& I& I& AV& C'& IW& CC& 'L& RI& LI& LC& XW& IC& IV& LI& IT& CI& IT& CX& VWC&

T2&531$( T& T& V& AA& CA& IC& IW& IL& CX& IR& CA& VL& WC& 'L& CL& CR& CA& A'& IW& 'T& LWX&

O$5(0$%+( A'& W& VR& IC& 'W& AW& AR& AT& V& CT& AW& AW& AR& AL& CT& L& AT& AA& CI& ''& 'CC&

D&%+()=(Z)5.'(( L& IA& C& T& AI& V& AW& L& L& W& V& L& '& V& AI& X& R& C& '& '& ALC&

( !]_( !]"( !]V( `]( !aa( bba( bWa( b]b( V]]( W"`( VVc( V_]( WWc( Vb`( b_"( bV`( b"V( b`V( W!]( WWc( (c:WW"(

E)<51&^(L7#(dD&9)5+%()*(T1+%()=(435$16($*'(T52&'(D)//&56(T;$3*%+(E,39%d(T**<$.(D&9)5+%?((

(

(

&

&

!"

#!"

$!!"

$#!"

%!!"

%#!"

&!!"

$''$" $''%" $''&" $''(" $''#" $'')" $''*" $''+" $'''" %!!!" %!!$" %!!%" %!!&" %!!(" %!!#" %!!)" %!!*" %!!+" %!!'" %!$!"

,-./0"123/"4352" 467582" 9:;52:",.<=>-:?:@:/" 4A@7582" B27"123/" C@3/"-6"D-7E;""

Page 23: The economics of Piracy

! !a!

N)3"-.)/0&)1&"3-@"$&"/5&"--%4,-%5&"--"370Y&Z"/@"*9&S&M%3%4#%*&QARRA&SCTATU&\)1$+3)*( !``!( !``b( !``V( !``W( !``c( !``"( !``_( !``a( !```( b]]]( b]]!( b]]b( b]]V( b]]W( b]]c( b]]"( b]]_( b]]a( b]]`( b]!]( M)+$.(

L*')*&%3$( cc( W`( !]( bb( VV( c_( W_( "]( !!c( !!`( `!( !]V( !b!( `W( _`( c]( WV( ba( !c( W]( !:bV!(D&'(E&$[(-NTe((ee( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !V( !`( !!( !a( !a( !]( !]( !V( `b( !Vb( _a( W!W(E)2$.3$[(SG3/)<+3(ee( (( (( (( !( !W( W( c( `( !W( `( !( "( (( V( (( !]( V!( !`( a]( !V`( VWc(7$.$11$(E+5$3+%( Vb( _( c( V( b( V( (( !( b( _c( !_( !"( ba( Va( !b( !!( _( b( b( b( b"c(L*'3$( (( c( !( (( a( !!( !c( !b( !W( Vc( b_( !a( b_( !c( !c( c( !!( !]( !b( c( bW"(K3;&53$( (( (( b( (( !( W( `( V( !b( `( !( !W( !( (( (( !b( Wb( W]( b`( !`( !`a(7$.$6%3$( !( b( (( W( c( c( W( !]( !a( b!( !`( !W( c( `( V( !]( `( !]( !"( !a( !aV(4,3.3993*&%(( (( c( (( c( bW( V`( !"( !c( "( `( a( !]( !b( W( (( "( "( _( !( c( !_a(E)<+,(B,3*$(E&$( !W( "( V!( "( V( b( "( c( V( `( W( (( b( a( "( !( V( (( !V( V!( !cV(#5$X3.( (( (( W( _( !_( !"( !c( !]( a( a( V( "( _( _( b( _( W( !( c( `( !V"(R3&+*$2( (( (( (( b( W( (( W( (( b( "( a( !b( !c( W( !]( V( c( !!( `( !b( !]_(N2$*( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( V`( ba( !"( (( V( (( W( (( `!(E3*;$9)5&(E+5$3+%( (( (( (( V( b( b( c( !( !W( c( _( c( b( a( _( c( V( "( `( V( a_(M,$3.$*'( (( (( (( (( W( !"( !_( b( c( a( a( c( b( W( !( !( b( (( b( b( _`(4&5<( (( (( (( (( !( b( !( !( b( W( !( "( _( c( "( `( "( c( !V( !]( _`(01<$')5( (( (( (( V( (( V( !]( !]( b( !V( a( !b( b( !( (( !( (( b( b( V( _b(B,3*$[U)*;(f)*;[7$1$<( (( (( !( "( V!( `( c( b( (( b( (( (( !( V( W( !( (( (( !( !( "_(R&*&X<&.$( (( (( (( (( (( !( V( !( "( V( !( a( !V( _( b( W( !( V( c( _( "c(-<3*&$( (( (( (( !( !( b( V( b( "( "( c( b( W( c( !( W( b( (( c( "( cc(E)<+,(T=531$( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( V( (( V( b( Vc( (( !!( (( (( (( cc(M$*X$*3$( (( (( b( !( b( V( W( V( V( b( (( V( !( (( (( `( (( !W( c( !( cV(E53(\$*Q$( (( (( b( !( "( `( !V( !( "( V( !( b( b( (( (( !( W( !( (( (( cb(Uf[(\<X)*[U$3*$*( (( (( b_( !b( _( W( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( c!(B).)2/3$( (( (( !( (( !( V( (( W( W( !( !( _( !]( c( b( b( (( !( c( V( c](E&*&;$.( (( (( (( (( (( b( "( b( !( (( (( V( !a( a( !]( (( (( (( (( (( c](L8)56(B)$%+( (( (( (( !( (( W( W( !( c( c( !( c( b( W( V( !( (( V( b( W( Wc(B$2&5))*( (( (( (( (( (( (( V( c( V( b( _( c( b( W( b( !( (( b( V( c( WW(-,$*$( (( (( (( (( !( b( b( W( b( b( (( c( V( c( V( V( !( _( V( (( WV(\)1$+3)*(*)+($8$3.$/.&( c( V!( b( (( !( (( (( !( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( W!(S)23*31$*(D&9</.31( (( (( (( (( (( !( V( W( b( W( c( _( "( b( !( (( (( (( (( (( Vc(-<6$*$( (( (( !( (( (( b( (( b( (( !( (( !b( "( b( !( !( c( (( (( b( Vc(E3&55$(\&)*&( (( (( (( (( (( V( V( (( (( (( !!( !( a( c( (( b( b( (( (( (( Vc(g$2$31$( (( (( (( (( (( !( V( b( b( (( (( b( c( _( a( V( !( (( (( (( VW(f&*6$( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( _( (( c( `( b( !( !( (( (( W( b( !( (( Vb(M);)(( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( a( !( c( b( _( !( (( !( b( (( ba(U$3+3( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( !( (( !( !( "( b( (( b( b( W( c( bc(L5$*(( (( (( (( (( a( b( V( !( V( !( !( (( b( (( (( b( b( (( (( (( bc(0$%+(B,3*$(E&$( (( !( !]( "( (( !( !( (( (( !( b( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( bV(

Page 24: The economics of Piracy

! !`!

N)3"-.)/0&)1&"3-@"$&"/5&"--%4,-%5&"--"370Y&Z"/@"*9&S&M%3%4#%*&QARRA&SCTATU&T*;).$( (( (( V( (( (( (( !( !( !( V( !( (( V( (( (( W( !( b( (( (( b](L5$h( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( b( (( (( !( !]( b( b( (( (( b( !`(76$*2$5( (( (( (( (( (( !( b( (( !( c( V( (( (( !( (( (( (( !( !( (( !c(-$/)*( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( b( V( b( (( _( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !c(T5$/3$*(E&$(ee( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( b( (( (( (( b( b( b( W( (( !( b( !c(i&2&*( (( (( (( (( (( !( c( (( (( !( !( c( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !W(SDB( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( V( W( !( b( V( !V(0;69+( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( b( !( !( b( (( (( !( (( (( b( (( (( b( !b(7)X$2/3h<&( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( b( !( !( (( (( !( (( V( b( (( (( !](j$35&( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( b( (( _( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( `(4$9<$(K&P(-<3*&$( (( (( (( (( (( !( !( V( (( (( !( !( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( a(7$'$;$%1$5( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( V( (( b( !( (( !( (( (( (( a(E).)2)*(L%.$*'%( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( !( b( (( b( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( _(-<3*&$(#3%%$<( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( V( b( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( _(T./$*3$( (( (( (( (( (( (( c( !( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( _(L+$.6( (( (( (( (( !( b( (( !( b( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( _(M$3P$*( (( (( (( (( b( (( (( (( (( (( b( !( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( "(4$*$2$( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( !( (( b( b( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( "(HET( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( !( (( !( (( !( !( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( "(7)5)11)( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( !( (( (( (( !( !( (( !( !( (( (( "(B$2/)'3$( (( (( !( !( !( !( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( c(B$53//&$*( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( W( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( c(B)%+$(D31$( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( V( !( c(M53*3'$'($*'(M)/$;)( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( b( !( (( !( (( (( (( (( c(7$<53+$*3$( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( !( b( (( !( (( (( (( (( c(B</$( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( W( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( W(B)*;)( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( !( W(-$2/3$( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( V( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( W(-5&&1&( (( (( (( (( (( !( b( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( W(L*'3$*(N1&$*(ee( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( !( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( !( (( W(M<5Q&6( (( (( (( (( !( !( b( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( W(U)*'<5$%( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( !( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( V(E$.8$')5( (( (( (( (( (( !( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( V(\3/&53$( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( !( (( !( V(HT0( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( b( (( (( (( (( (( (( V(Hf( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( b( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( V(7&Y31)( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( b(K31$5$;<$( (( (( (( (( !( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( b(E<53*$2&( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( b( (( (( (( b(

Page 25: The economics of Piracy

! b]!

N)3"-.)/0&)1&"3-@"$&"/5&"--%4,-%5&"--"370Y&Z"/@"*9&S&M%3%4#%*&QARRA&SCTATU&T.;&53$( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( b(#&*3*( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( b(0h<$+)53$.(-<3*&$( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( b(#<.;$53$( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( b(S&*2$5Q( (( (( (( (( !( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( b(O5$*1&( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( b(D<%%3$( (( (( (( (( !( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( b(E$<'3(T5$/3$( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( !( (( (( b(T5;&*+3*$( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( !(-<$+&2$.$( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !(7$5+3*3h<&( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !(H5<;<$6( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !(053+5&$( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( !(T5$/3$*(-<.=( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !(T<%+5$.3$( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !(#&.;3<2( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( !(B$%93$*(E&$( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( !(-&)5;3$( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !(-<.=()=(N2$*(ee( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( !(7$.+$( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !(K&+,&5.$*'%( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !(4$13=31(N1&$*( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( !(4)5+<;$.( (( (( (( (( (( (( !( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( !(E&61,&..&%( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( ]((( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( (( ((

M)+$.(=)5(+,&(6&$5( !]_( !]"( !]V( `]( !aa( bba( bWa( b]b( V]]( W"`( VVc( V_]( WWc( Vb`( b_"( bV`( b"V( b`V( W!]( WWc(!]:a`b(

E)<51&^(L7#(dD&9)5+%()*(T1+%()=(435$16($*'(T52&'(D)//&56(T;$3*%+(E,39%d(T**<$.(D&9)5+%?(( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

(e( -<.=()=(T'&*($++$1Q%()*.6($''&'($%()=(b]]!?((O<5+,&5:(-<.=()=(T'&*($*'(D&'(E&$($++$1Q%(P&5&()53;3*$..6(1$.1<.$+&'(3*(+P)(%&9$5$+&(5)P%(=5)2(b]]"(>(b]!]?((ee( O5)2(b]]"(>(b]!]:($++$1Q%(3*(-<.=()=(T'&*:(T5$/3$*(E&$:(D&'(E&$:(E)2$.3$:(-<.=()=(N2$*($*'(L*'3$*(N1&$*($5&($++53/<+&'(+)(E)2$.3(935$+&%(&

&

&

&

Page 26: The economics of Piracy

! b!!

&

&

K)4"$."&?%8.)/"$&[&D"*9./8&K-"-.0-.30&QCTATU&

()@/-*9&OM:\(",.-"&

GKMAA&:),@$"-.)/&AC& ]MJ&K3)*%&AI&

]MJ&?"/7./8&

&!J&A'?"/7./8&

!J&K3)*%&

J4,)*-0&GKMAL&

2>,)*-0&GKM&

J/-%*/"-.)/"$&!)@*.04&*%3%.,-0&GK&^&4.$$.)/&

QCTTXU&AV&_"=.%0&AW&

K)4"$."& "]]( `:Vc`:]]]( K[T( K[T( !_a( !?!(_`a(73..3)*(

V]](73..3)*( K)+(3*1.<'&'( K[T(

`%/9"& aa_( W]:]W":c""( ]?W_( !ba( !cW( b?!(!]?__(#3..3)*(

W?aab(#3..3)*( !:V`a:]]]:]]]( !_(3*1?(1)$%+;<$5'(

a%4%/& !:]"!( bV:ca]:]]]( ]?WV`( !VV( !W"( b?b(`?b!c(#3..3)*(

`?bVW(#3..3)*( aa":]]]:]]]( b"(3*1?(1)$%+;<$5'(

!"/b"/."& c"]( WV:_V`:]]]( ]?cV( !c!( !!"( b?_(c?`]!(#3..3)*(

b?W`(#3..3)*( !:Vca:]]]:]]]( !`(1)$%+;<$5'()*.6(

2*.-*%"& WbW( c:bbW:]]]( ]?W_b( !"c( !bV( b?"("]!(73..3)*(

!W(73..3)*( K)+(3*1.<'&'( b!(3*1?(1)$%+;<$5'(

J/5."& !:!_"( !:!`V:Wca:]]]( ]?c!`( !!`( a_( V?V(ba_?c(#3..3)*(

!_c?_(#3..3)*( !b:W"!:]]]:]]]( !]`(3*1?(1)$%+;<$5'(

K@5"/& !:"Va( WV:`V`:c`a( ]?cV!( !c]( !_a( !?"(_?_c(#3..3)*(

!V?"b(#3..3)*( VV!:]]]:]]]( !](3*1?(1)$%+;<$5'(

K%93E%$$%0& !]:_!W( bW:aV_( ]?aWV( c_( W`( W?a(`cb(73..3)*(

Wbc(73..3)*( V"":]]]:]]]( c(1)$%+;<$5'()*.6(

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!(L7O:(Z)5.'(01)*)231(N<+.))Q(S$+$/$%&(Ib]!]J(!b(HK(Z)5.'(4)9<.$+3)*(45)%9&1+%:(L*'3$>L*'3$%+$+(!V(H*3+&'(K$+3)*%(U<2$*(S&8&.)92&*+(D&9)5+(Ib]!]J(!W(E&&(M5$*%9$5&*16(L*+&5*$+3)*$.:(B)<*+56(D$*Q3*;%(Ib]!]J(!c(E&&(BLT(Z)5.'(O$1+(#))Q(IH%&'(;38&*(.$1Q()=(LOL(5&9)5+3*;()*(E)2$.3$J(!"(E&&(Z)5.'(#$*Q:(L*+&5*$+3)*$.(M)<53%2(D&1&39+%:(Ib]]aJ(!_(E&&(g$*&%(O3;,+3*;(%,39%($*'(L*'3$*(K$86(B)2/$+$*+(8&%%&.%(Ib]!]J(

Page 27: The economics of Piracy

! !!!

!

"

""

"

"

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

#$%&%'()(*+",-)."/01('2"&(31)+45$%&%'()(*+.)%0"

!

"