39
!"##$#% ’()*+ ,-./-!01 234 0,53567,1 73 82!/7,782/5!9 8!7,73: /’( ,";<"=(> )#* 0?@#@A$?> $# 8)=<$?$B)<@=C 8=$?$#% D 2# 0EB;@=)<@=C 1<"*C @F !(><)"=)#<> $# <’( -1G :(=A)#C )#* 2"><=$) ,’=$><@B’ !@>(#<’); -#$H(=>$<C @F 1@"<’(=# ,);$F@=#$)G .@> 2#%(;(>G ,2 ?=@>(#<’);I">?J(*" KL 4(?(AM(= NOKP 2;; !$%’<> !(>(=H(*J

The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

  • Upload
    lamthu

  • View
    217

  • Download
    2

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

!"##$#%&'()*+&,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&&

& & &

&

&

&

&

/'(&,";<"=(>&)#*&0?@#@A$?>&$#&8)=<$?$B)<@=C&8=$?$#%&D&2#&0EB;@=)<@=C&1<"*C&@F&

!(><)"=)#<>&$#&<'(&-1G&:(=A)#C&)#*&2"><=$)&&

&

&

&

&

,'=$><@B'&!@>(#<');&

-#$H(=>$<C&@F&1@"<'(=#&,);$F@=#$)G&.@>&2#%(;(>G&,2&

?=@>(#<');I">?J(*"&

&

&

&

&

&

KL&4(?(AM(=&NOKP&

2;;&!$%'<>&!(>(=H(*J&

&

& &

Page 2: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

$$&

! !

Page 3: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

$$$&

"#$%&!'(!)'*+&*+,&.$><&@F&Q$%"=(>&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&$H&.$><&@F&/)M;(>&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&$H&-*+.'/01+2'*&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&K&"3&'.&+21#%!4.#5&6'.7&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&N&8)CRS')<R9@"RS)#<+&2&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A(?')#$>A&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&N&T)=$)#<>&@F&B)=<$?$B)<$H(&B=$?(&A(?')#$>A>&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&P&,')=)?<(=$><$?>&)#*&(E)AB;(>&@F&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&U&8=(H$@">&=(>()=?'&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&U&!(;)<$@#>&M(<V((#&>(;;(=&)#*&M"C(=&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&L&

)'*1&8+0#%!4.#5&6'.7&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&KK&/=)*$<$@#);&(?@#@A$?&<'(@=C&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&KK&!)<$@#);&?'@$?(&<'(@=C&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&KK&1"BB;C&)#*&*(A)#*&*(<(=A$#(&<'(&B=$?(W&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&KN&S')<&$>&B=$?(W&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&KX&8=$?(&)>&?@AA"#$?)<$@#&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&KP&,@AA@*$<C&F(<$>'$>A&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&KU&6"<");$>A&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&KU&Q(A$#$><&<'(@=C&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&KY&

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

& Q"<"=(&=(>()=?'&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&NL&)'*1%0,2'*,&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&NL&9&(&.&*1&,&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&XK&2BB(#*$E&K&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&XP&2BB(#*$E&N&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&X[&&

Page 4: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

$H&

?2,+!'(!42<0.&,!!

42<0.&!@+&,@AB)=)<$H(&?;)>>$F$?)<$@#&@F&<=)*$<$@#);&)#*&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A(?')#$>A>&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&X&

42<0.&!A+&\"C(=R>(;;(=R=(;)<$@#>&$#&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A@*(;>&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&KO&&

?2,+!'(!"#$%&,!

"#$%&!@+&8)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&M">$#(>>(>&$#&<'(&-1G&:(=A)#C]2"><=$)&)#*&@<'(=&?@"#<=$(>&JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ&Y&

&&

Page 5: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

K&

/'(&,";<"=(>&)#*&0?@#@A$?>&$#&8)=<$?$B)<@=C&8=$?$#%&D&2#&0EB;@=)<@=C&1<"*C&@F&!(><)"=)#<>&$#&<'(&-1&)#*&:(=A)#C&

-*+.'/01+2'*!!

7#&NOOYG&V'(#&A">$?&F)#>&@F&<'(&M)#*&!)*$@'()*&V(#<&@#&<'(&@FF$?$);&V(M>$<(&<@&M"C&<'($=&#(V&);M"A&!"#$%&"'()*G&)#&@FF(=&?)A(&"B&)F<(=&?;$?^$#%&<'(&_M"C`&M"<<@#&<')<&A@><& F)#>& ')*& #(H(=& >((#& )#CV'(=(& (;>(& M(F@=(+& 8)C&V')<& C@"&V)#<J& /'@"%'& ')=*& <@&M(;$(H(& F@=&A@><&V'(#& <'(C& F$=><& >)V& <'(& ;(<<(=R><=$#%R);<(=#)<$H(& <@& <'(&">");&#"AM(=&>@A(V'(=(&M(<V((#&<'(&(EB(?<(*&aNO&<@&aPO&-1&*@;;)=>&F@=&)&A">$?&);M"A&<'(>(&*)C>G&<'(& M"C(=>b& ?=(*$<& ?)=*>&V(=(& $#*((*& @#;C& ?')=%(*&V$<'& <'(& )A@"#<& (c"$H);(#<& <@& <'(&>(;FR*(<(=A$#(*&B=$?(J&8=$?(>&B)$*&F@=&<'(&A">$?&);M"A&=()?'(*&F=@A&=)<'(=&?'()B&M(<>&<')<&%@<&<'(&A">$?&*@V#;@)*&F@=&#@<'$#%&M"<&)&?;$?^G&<@&M(#(H@;(#<&B)<=@#>&V'@&*(?$*(*&<@&>(<& <'($=&@V#&B=$?(&B@$#<&)<&dLLJLL&\=$<$>'&B@"#*>&e)BB=@E$A)<(;C&aKUO&-1&*@;;)=>f&F@=&<'(&?=()<$H(&?@AA@*$<CJ&&

&/'(& H);")<$@#& @F& <'(& );M"A& <'">& V)>& ?;()=;C& )& >"Mg(?<$H(& (#?@"#<(=& V$<'& <'(&B=$?(J&S)>&$<&<')<&>@A(&B(@B;(&=();;C&H);"(*&<'(&);M"A&)<&aKUOW&5=&*$*&<'(C&>((&$<&)>&)#&)?<&@F&?')=$<)M;(&%$H$#%G&>"BB@=<$#%&<'($=&M)#*G&$==(>B(?<$H(&@F&)#C&=(;)<$@#&M(<V((#&B=$?(&)#*&H);"(W&6@=(&$AB@=<)#<;CG&V')<& $>&B=$?(W&7#&<'(&V$*(><&>(#>(G& $<&?)#&M(&*(F$#(*&)>&)&#"A(=$?& F$%"=(&B"<&@#<@& ?@AA@*$<$(>G& >(=H$?(>& )#*&%@@*>& <')<& $>& >"BB@>(*& <@& $#*$?)<(&H);"(& <@& V'@(H(=& $>& $#<(=(><(*& $#& )?c"$=$#%& <'@>(& ?@AA@*$<$(>G& >(=H$?(>& @=& %@@*>J& 7<&A)^(>&<'$#%>&?@AB)=)M;(G&)#*&);;@V>&F@=&B(@B;(&<@&(E?')#%(&A@#(<)=C&?"==(#?C&$#&;$("&@F&B'C>$?);G& (A@<$@#);&@=& >(=H$?(&%@@*>&)#*&B=@*"?<>& <')<& <'(C& ?@";*&@<'(=V$>(&">(& <@&(#%)%(&$#&V')<&$>&?@AA@#;C&=(F(==(*&<@&)>&)#&(E?')#%(&@#&<'(&A)=^(<J&

&8=$?(& $>& ?="?$);& $#& <=)*$<$@#);& (?@#@A$?& ?@#?(B<$@#>& @F& A)=^(<>& )#*& (E?')#%(J&4(<(=A$#(*& MC& <'(& >(;;(=& M(F@=(')#*G& <'(& B=$?(& B=@H$*(>& <'(& F=)A(V@=^& F@=& (?@#@A$?&$#<(=)?<$@#>& )#*& ><="?<"=(>& '@V& B(@B;(& ?@#?($H(& @F& H);"(& )#*& A)=^(<& (E?')#%(J&h@V(H(=G&V')<&')BB(#>&$F&<'(&>(;;(=&;()H(>&<'(&B=$?$#%&*(?$>$@#&@B(#&<@&<'(&M"C(=G&)#*&A@=(@H(=G& );;@V>& <'(&M"C(=& <@&*(<(=A$#$><$?);;C&B)=<$?$B)<(& $#& F$#*$#%&)&H);$*&)#*& F$#);&B=$?(& F@=& )#& (?@#@A$?& (E?')#%(G& )>& $#& <'(& ?)>(& @F& !)*$@'()*b>& A">$?& );M"AW& 1"?'& )&>$<")<$@#& $#H@;H(>& <'(& #@#R<=)*$<$@#);& (?@#@A$?& B=$?$#%&A@*(;& @F& 8)CRS')<R9@"RS)#<&e8S9SfJ& 8S9S& %$H(>& M"C(=>& F";;& ?@#<=@;& <@& >(<& <'($=& @V#& B=$?(>& F@=& )& B=@*"?<& @=&>(=H$?(J&1(;;(=>&V'@&@FF(=&B=@*"?<>&@=&>(=H$?(>&"#*(=&8S9S&?@#*$<$@#>&?)##@<&=(g(?<&M"<&')H(& <@& )??(B<& B"=?')>(>& F@=& )#C& B=$?(& )M@H(& @=& (c");& <@& i(=@& ej$AG&3)<<(=G&k& 1B)##G&NOOZfJ&&

T(=C& ;$<<;(& )?)*(A$?& )<<(#<$@#& ')>& M((#& %$H(#& <@& 8S9S& )#*& B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%J& 8S9S&)#*&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A@*(;>& ')H(& M((#& ><"*$(*& <@& >@A(& (E<(#<& $#&:(=A)#CG& M"<& #@& =(>()=?'& (E$><>& <')<& =(;)<(>& <@& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%& $#& <'(& -1J& /'$>&

Page 6: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

N&

B)B(=& H(=$F$(>& )#*& (E<(#*>& <'(& ><$;;& ="*$A(#<)=C& *(>?=$B<$@#>& )#*& (E$><$#%& <'(@=(<$?);&A@*(;>&@F&8S9S&)#*&$<>&F()<"=(>&)>&)&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A@*(;J&6@=(@H(=G&F@;;@V$#%&j$A& (<& );Jl>& eNOOZf& ?);;& F@=& F"=<'(=& =(>()=?'& )#*& )& ?";<"=);& )#);C>$>& @F& B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%G&<'(&B=(>(#<&B)B(=&)<<(AB<>&<@&?;@>(&<'$>&%)B&$#&<'(&;$<(=)<"=(&MC&<)BB$#%&$#<@&<'(&A()#$#%>G& A@<$H)<$@#>& )#*& ?";<"=);& B=)?<$?(>& >"==@"#*$#%& 8S9S& )#*& B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%J&

2F<(=& )& M=$(F& *(F$#$<$@#& )#*& <'(@=(<$?);& ?@#?(B<");$i)<$@#& @F& 8S9S& )#*&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A@*(;>&M)>(*&@#&>(?@#*)=C&)#*&;$<(=)<"=(&=(>()=?'G&)&M=$(F&=(H$(V&@F& B=(H$@">& =(>()=?'& @#& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%& )#*& =(;)<(*& B=)?<$?(>& ?=()<(>& <'(&F@"#*)<$@#& F@=& )& ?@AB=('(#>$H(& )#);C>$>J& 1"M>(c"(#<;CG& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%& $>&*$>?">>(*& )%)$#><& <'(& M)?^*=@B& @F& ?";<"=);G& >@?$@;@%$?);& )#*& <=)*$<$@#);& (?@#@A$?&<'(@=$(>&<@&F@=A&<'(&?@#?(B<");&F=)A(V@=^&F@=&<'(&(AB$=$?&)#);C>$>&@F&?)>(&><"*$(>&F=@A&<'(& =(><)"=)#<& $#*"><=C& $#& <'(&-1&)#*&:(=A)#CJ& Q@;;@V$#%& <'(& =(>()=?'&c"(><$@#>& )#*&<'(& A(<'@*@;@%CG& <'(& =(>";<>& @F& >(?@#*)=C& *)<)& )#);C>$>G& c");$<)<$H(& $#<(=H$(V>& )#*&B)=<$?$B)#<& @M>(=H)<$@#& )=(&*$>?">>(*& $#& ;$%'<& @F& <'(& ?@#?(B<");& F=)A(V@=^&M(F@=(& <'(&?@#?;">$@#&B=@H$*(>&?;@>$#%&=(A)=^>J&&

"3&'.&+21#%!4.#5&6'.7!

B#=CD3#+CE'0CD#*+F!G!8#.+2128#+'.=!8.212*<!5&13#*2,5!!

8)CRS')<R9@"RS)#<& e8S9Sf& $>& )& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%& A(?')#$>A&?')=)?<(=$i(*& MC& )M>@;"<(& ?@#>"A(=& ?@#<=@;& @H(=& B=$?(>J& /=)#>)?<$@#& B=$?(>& F@=& %@@*>&)#*&>(=H$?(>&@FF(=(*&"#*(=&8S9S&?@#*$<$@#>&)=(&(#<$=(;C&*(<(=A$#(*&MC&<'(&M"C(=J&/'(&>(;;(=&?)##@<&=(g(?<&)#C&B=$?(&@FF(=(*&MC&<'(&M"C(=&ej$A&(<&);JG&NOOZfJ&8=$?(>&F@=&8S9S&<=)#>)?<$@#>&?)#&H)=C&F=@A&i(=@&<@&$#F$#$<(J&S'$;(&8S9S&A)C&$#?=()>(&<'(&M"C(=>b&$#<(#<&<@&B"=?')>(G&>(;;(=>&F)?(&<'(&=$>^&@F&M"C(=>&)M">$#%&<'($=&?@#<=@;&)#*&B)C&#@<'$#%&)<&);;&@=&)&B=$?(&M(;@V&<'(&>(;;(=b>&?@><>J&&

8S9S&?)#&M(&?;)>>$F$(*&)>&)&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A(?')#$>A&<')<&=(c"$=(>&<'(&M"C(=& <@&B)=<$?$B)<(& $#& <'(&B=$?(&*(<(=A$#)<$@#J&S$<'@"<& <'(&M"C(=b>& B)=<$?$B)<$@#G& <'(&<=)#>)?<$@#& $>& #@<& B@>>$M;(J& 6@=(@H(=G& <'(& >(;;(=& %=)#<>& <@& <'(& M"C(=& <'(& F";;&=(>B@#>$M$;$<C&)M@"<& <'(& F$#);&B=$?(&)#*&@"<>@"=?(>& <'(&B=$?$#%&*(?$>$@#J&Q@;;@V$#%&j$A&(<&);J&eNOOZfG&<'$>&B)B(=b>&?;)>>$F$?)<$@#&@F&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A(?')#$>A>&$>&M)>(*&@#&<'(& A)=^(<& A)^$#%& A(?')#$>A>& MC& 4@;)#& )#*& 6@@#& eNOOOfG& V'@& B=@B@>(& <'=((&?)<(%@=$(>&@F&B=$?$#%&)#*&M"C(=R>(;;(=R$#<(=)?<$@#>&<')<&?=()<(&)&A)=^(<&F@=&(E?')#%(J&& &

Page 7: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

X&

!"#$%&'(!"#$%&'(')*+,"-.'//*0*-')*$1"$0")('2*)*$1'."'12"&'()*-*&')$(3"&(*-*14"%,-5'1*/%/""" "

)*%"+*,-./'",-&%.0-"*,1'2&3&%./'4$5&%6'.,78*%'6&3&%./'6&//&%6'67"89-)*$1" :7";,+,(/,"89-)*$1" <7"=>-5'14,"

" " ""

""

"

9,&:-*:9,&1'9,&'6&//&%'.,7'*,&'4$5&%'

?7"@,)"A(*-,""B2,),(%*1,2"C3"/,..,(D"

E7"@,)"A(*-,""B7&-&%;",&7'45'4$5&%D"

F7"G93,(H@,..,(""I,4$)*')*$1"

" " "

" " "@,..,("/,)/"%*1*%9%"&(*-,"0$(")('1/'-)*$1&&

" J,/" I$"& &

"

""

I$),/!"#5'()"&'().3"C'/,2"$1"(,/,'(-5"C3"K*%",)"'.7L":MMNL"&7"F"O"&7"<E7&&&

4@;)#&)#*&6@@#& eNOOOf&*$FF(=(#<$)<(&M(<V((#&)f& >(<&B=$?(&A(?')#$>A>G&V'$?'& F()<"=(&B)>>$H(&M"C(=>&V'@&')H(&#@&=@;(& $#&>(<<$#%& <'(&B=$?(>&B=(R*(<(=A$#(*&MC& <'(&>(;;(=G&Mf&<'(&M"C(=]>(;;(=&#(%@<$)<(*&B=$?(&A(?')#$>A&?')=)?<(=$i(*&MC&B=$?(&F;(E$M$;$<C&)#*&>@A(&

<.='>.;&:?*$%:9@,:A%"0&' <4='A.5:BC.-:?*$:B.,-'

<0='A.5:BC.-:?*$:D.,'

<7='A.5:BC.-:E*7:B.,-6'

<&='A.5:?*$%:!."%:2C.%&'

<F='A.5:!*%:2*;&*,&:G/6&'

&&&&&

H$5&%'

2&//&%6'

&&&&&

&&&&&

GI0C.,#&'

2&//&%6'

H$5&%6'

2&//&%'

&&&&&H$5&%6'

2&//&%'

H$5&%'

2&//&%'

H$5&%'

2&//&%'

H$5&%'

Page 8: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

P&

*(%=((&@F&M"C(=&B)=<$?$B)<$@#&$#&F$#*$#%&<'(&F$#);&B=$?(&F@=&)&<=)#>)?<$@#&@=&(E?')#%(G&)#*&?f& )"?<$@#>& )#*& (E?')#%(>G& V'$?'& $#H@;H(& )& '$%'& *(%=((& @F& M"C(=& B)=<$?$B)<$@#& )#*&A@*(=)<(;C&><=@#%&?@#<=@;&@H(=&<'(&F$#);&B=$?(&B)$*J&

/'(>(& >$<")<$@#>& ?)#& M(& F"=<'(=& ?;)>>$F$(*& )>& '@=$i@#<);& )#*& @#(R<@R@#(&$#<(=)?<$@#>J&2&'@=$i@#<);& $#<(=)?<$@#& ?@AB=$>(>& >(H(=);& M"C(=>& )#*]@=& >(H(=);& >(;;(=>J&h@=$i@#<);& $#<(=)?<$@#>& V$<'& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& (;(A(#<>& <@& <'(& B=$?$#%& B=@?(>>& $#?;"*(&)"?<$@#>G&=(H(=>(&)"?<$@#>&@=&)#&(E?')#%(&A)=^(<>&eQ$%"=(&KfJ&2&@#(R<@R@#(&$#<(=)?<$@#&F()<"=(>&@#;C&@#(&>(;;(=&)#*&@#(&M"C(=J& 7<&($<'(=& $#?;"*(>&)& <=)*$<$@#);&>$<")<$@#&V$<'&)&#@#RB)=<$?$B)<@=CG&>(<&B=$?(&*(<(=A$#(*&MC&<'(&>(;;(=&eQ$%"=(&KJPf&@=&@#(R<@R@#(&A)=^(<&$#<(=)?<$@#>&V$<'&M"C(=]>(;;(=&#(%@<$)<$@#>&eQ$%"=(&KJUfJ&&

/'(&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A@*(;&V$<'& <'(&'$%'(><& ?@#<=@;& ;(<>& <'(&M"C(=& >(<& <'(&B=$?(& eQ$%"=(& KJ[fJ& 7#& >@A(& ?)>(>G& <'(& >(;;(=& ')>& >(<& )&A$#$A"A& B=$?(& F@=& <'$>& <CB(& @F&<=)#>)?<$@#G& >"?'& )>& <'(& A$#$A"A& B=$?(& @#& (\)CJ& /'(& M"C(=& *@(>& #@<& ^#@V& <'$>&<'=(>'@;*&B=$?(G&)#*&<'(&<=)#>)?<$@#&V$;;&M(&>"??(>>F";&@#;C&$F&<'(&M"C(=&A((<>&@=&(E?((*>&<'(&<'=(>'@;*&B=$?(&V$<'&'$>&@=&'(=&@FF(=J&/'$>&$>&">");;C&=(F(==(*&<@&)>&3)A(R9@"=R5V#R8=$?(&eQ$%"=(&KJ[)fJ&7#&?@#<=)><G&$F&<'(&M"C(=&*(<(=A$#(>&<'(&B=$?(&)#*&<'(&>(;;(=&*$*&#@<&>(<& )&A$#$A"A&B=$?(& F@=& )& >"??(>>F";& <=)#>)?<$@#G& <'(&B=$?$#%&A(?')#$>A& $>&*(F$#(*&)>&8)CRS')<R9@"RS)#<&@=&>@A(&H)=$)#<&@F&$<G&$#?;"*$#%&8)CRS')<R9@"R,)#G&8)CRS')<R:@*RS)#<>G&8)CR9@"=RQ)$=R1')=(&@=&8)CRQ@=R1@A(@#(R0;>(&eQ$%"=(&KJ[MRFfJ&&H#.2#*+,!'(!8#.+2128#+2I&!8.21&!5&13#*2,5,!

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

B#=CD3#+CE'0C)#*J! 7#& ?@#<=)><& <@& 8S9SG& 8)CRS')<R9@"R,)#& =(;)<(>&A@=(& <@&<'(&?"><@A(=b>&(?@#@A$?&)M$;$<C&=)<'(=&<')#&<'(&V$;;$#%#(>>&<@&B)C&)&?(=<)$#&)A@"#<&@F&A@#(CJ&!)<'(=&<')#&)>^$#%&V')<&>@A(@#(&V)#<>&<@&B)CG&V'$?'&$AB;$(>&<')<&<'(&B=$?$#%&*(?$>$@#&A)C&M(&$==(>B(?<$H(&@F&<'(&M"C(=b>&(?@#@A$?&>$<")<$@#G&8)CRS')<R9@"R,)#&)>^>&<'(&?"><@A(=&<@&)*g"><&<'(&B=$?$#%&B@$#<&'(&@=&>'(&$>&)M;(&<@&B)C&)??@=*$#%&<@&$#?@A(&)#*&F$#)#?$);&>$<")<$@#J&/'$>&?@#><$<"<(>&)#&$AB@=<)#<&c");$<)<$H(&*$><$#?<$@#&$#&=(;)<$@#&<@&<'(&?"><@A(=b>& F$#)#?$);& )M$;$<CG& V'$?'& 8S9S& F)$;>& <@& ?)B<"=(& >$#?(& $<& ;()H(>& <'(& B=$?$#%&*(?$>$@#&@B(#&<@&H@;$<$@#J&/'$>&A)C&B(=')B>&M(&A@=(&=(;)<(*&<@&)&B(=>@#b>&?')=)?<(=&<')#&(?@#@A$?&)M$;$<CJ&2>^$#%&<'(&?"><@A(=&<@&B)C&V')<&'(&@=&>'(&?)#&<'">&$AB;$(>&)&;@%$?&<')<&

Page 9: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

[&

>"M;$A$#);;C& ?)==$(>& )& A@=(& B=@#@"#?(*& (AB)<'(<$?& *$A(#>$@#& ?@AB)=(*& <@& 8S9SG&V'$?'&$>G&'@V(H(=G&#@<&<@&>)C&<')<&?"><@A(=>&)?<");;C&B)C&V')<&<'(C&(?@#@A$?);;C&?)#&)>&$<&M(?)A(&?;()=&F=@A&F"=<'(=&=(>()=?'J&

6@=(@H(=G& <'(& 8)CRS')<R9@"R,)#& B=$?$#%& A(?')#$>A& )?'$(H(>& $<>& $##@H)<$H(&?')=)?<(=& #@<& @#;C& MC& @"<>@"=?$#%& <'(& B=$?$#%& *(?$>$@#G& M"<& );>@& MC& )??@"#<$#%& F@=&'(<(=@%(#($<C&)A@#%&?@#>"A(=>J&8(@B;(&V$<'&>A);;(=&M"*%(<>&)=(&#@<&(E?;"*(*&M(?)">(&<'(& >(;FR*(<(=A$#(*& B=$?$#%&A(?')#$>A& );;@V>& <'(A& <@& B)C&V')<(H(=& <'(C& ?)#& )FF@=*G&V'$?'& A)C& M(& #@<'$#%& @=& >@A(<'$#%& #@#RA@#(<)=CG& >"?'& )>& H@;"#<)=C& V@=^& $#& <'(&^$<?'(#&@=&@#&@<'(=&*"<$(>&$#&<'(&=(><)"=)#<J&5#(&>B(?$F$?&(E)AB;(&@F&8)CRS')<R9@"R,)#&$>&<'(&+,-.#/+(#,00#-%1#.%23#4%56&$#&4(#H(=G&,@;@=)*@G&V'(=(&?"><@A(=>&)=(&)>^(*&<@&B)C&V')<&<'(C&?)#&)FF@=*&)#*&$F&<'(C&?)##@<&)FF@=*&<@&*$>?')=%(&)#C<'$#%&@F&A@#(<)=C&H);"(G&<'(C&?)#&B)C&V$<'&V')<&<'(C&?)#G&>"?'&)>&H@;"#<((=&V@=^&$#&<'(&^$<?'(#J&

7#&<(=A>&@F&<'(&;)=%(=&B$?<"=(G&$#&A$*RNOOX&<'(&7"8#9(:0;#4%56&$#&1);<&.)^(&,$<CG&-/G&M(%)#&>(=H$#%&A();>&)>&)&?@AA"#$<C&?)Fm&"#*(=&8)CRS')<R9@"R,)#&?@#*$<$@#>J&2>&)&=(>";<&@F&<'(&$#$<$)<$H(G&)&<@<);&@F&PL&=(><)"=)#<>&)#*&?@AA"#$<C&?)F(>&$#&NX&><)<(>&)?=@>>&<'(& -1& )=(& ?"==(#<;C& B=@H$*$#%& A();>G& F@@*& )#*& *=$#^& "#*(=& 8)CRS')<R9@"R,)#&?@#*$<$@#>KJ&/'(&><)<(*&A$>>$@#&@F&<'(&#@#RB=@F$<&@=%)#$i)<$@#&$>&<@&(;$A$#)<(&'"#%(=&)#*&=(*"?(&F@@*&V)><(&$#&;@?);&?@AA"#$<$(>&)?=@>>&<'(&-1J&&

B#=CD3#+CK'/CD#*+,J! 2#@<'(=& $#<(=(><$#%& H)=$)#<& <')<& ?)A(& "B& *"=$#%& <'(&=(>()=?'&$>&<'(&B=$?$#%&A@*(;&@F&8)CRS')<R:@*RS)#<>J&/'(&no"><&,@@^$#%b&*$#(=&$#&3@=<'&,)=@;$#)& <')<& F$=><& @B(#(*& $#& NOKN& ')>& $#<=@*"?(*& C(<& )& *$FF(=(#<& H(=>$@#& @F& )&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A@*(;J&2F<(=&*(?;$#$#%&=(H(#"(>&$#&<'(&>"AA(=&@F&NOKPG&<'(&@V#(=&$#<=@*"?(*&'(=&#(V&B=$?$#%&><=)<(%C&<')<&)>^(*&?"><@A(=>&<@&B)C&V')<&%@*&V)#<>J&/'(&@V#(=&@F&<'(&*$#(=&*$*&#@<&=(>B@#*&<@&)#&$#<(=H$(V&=(c"(><G&V'$?'&$>&V'C&<'(&)#);C>$>&$>&B"=(;C&M)>(*&@#&>(?@#*)=C&>@"=?(>&)#*&<'(&*$#(=b>&Q)?(M@@^&B)%(J&&

p"$<(&?;()=;CG&8)CRS')<R:@*RS)#<>&F()<"=(>&)&A@=(&B=@#@"#?(*&A@=);&(;(A(#<&)#*&)&A@=);$i$#%&?')=)?<(=&$#&<')<&$<&@"<>@"=?(>&<'(&B=$?$#%&*(?$>$@#&#@<&<@&<'(&?"><@A(=&);@#(G&M"<& <@& )& F$%"=(&@F& =(;$%$@">&)"<'@=$<C& <')<&B@<(#<$);;C&')>&)& ><=@#%& $#F;"(#?(&)#*&B@V(=&@H(=&<'(&*(?$>$@#>&)#*&)?<$@#>&MC&B(@B;(J&0>B(?$);;C&V'(#&<'(&=(;)<$@#>'$B&<@&%@*&e<'$>& $>& $#& =(;)<$@#& <@& ,'=$><$)#& =(;$%$@#& >$#?(& <'(& @V#(=& @F& <'(& *$#(=& $>& ,'=$><$)#f& $>&><=@#%&)#*&)#&(>>(#<$);&B)=<&@F&<'(&M"C(=>&;$F(G&)&B=$?$#%&*(?$>$@#&)??@=*$#%&<@&V')<&%@*&V)#<>&(E(=<>&)&'$%'&)A@"#<&@F&B=(>>"=(&@#&<'(&M"C(=G&B@<(#<$);;C&A@=(&>@&?@AB)=(*&<@&8S9S&@=&8)CRS')<R9@"R,)#G&*(B(#*$#%&@#& <'(&*(%=((& <@&V'$?'&)&B(=>@#& $>& =(;$%$@">J&6@=(@H(=G& <'(& 8)CRS')<R:@*RS)#<>& A)C& F()<"=(& )& %"$;<R$#*"?$#%& (;(A(#<G& V'$?'&

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&K&Q";;&;$><&)H)$;)M;(&@#&VVVJ@#(V@=;*(H(=CM@*C()<>J@=%]@<'(=R?@AA"#$<CR?)F(>]&

Page 10: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

U&

(A@<$@#);;C&M;)?^A)$;>&M"C(=>&)#*&><=$^(>&)&?@##(?<$@#&M(<V((#&M">$#(>>&)#*&=(;$%$@#J&/'(& !@A)#& ,)<'@;$?& ,'"=?'& <(#*>& <@& ')H(& )#& $A)%(& @F& <=)*$<$@#);;C& ')H$#%& M((#&)BB=@B=$)<(*& <@& ?@#H$#?(&B(@B;(& <@& B)C& ;)=%(& >"A>&@F&A@#(C& <@& <'(& ?'"=?'& e1<($#F(;>G&NOKXfJ& 7#& <'(& ?)>(& @F& 8)CRS')<R:@*RS)#<>G& $<& A)C& #@<& M(& )#C& $#<(#<$@#);& <)^$#%&)*H)#<)%(&@F&=(;$%$@">&)FF$#$<CG&M"<&$<&$>&$AB@=<)#<&<@&)<&;()><&M(&)V)=(&@F&<'(&A@=);&)#*&?@##@<)<$@#);& $AB;$?)<$@#>& <')<& <'$>& $#<(=>(?<$@#& M(<V((#& M">$#(>>& )#*& =(;$%$@#&$;;"><=)<(>J&)3#.#1+&.2,+21,!#*/!&L#58%&,!'(!8#.+2128#+'.=!8.212*<!!

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ej$A& (<& );JG& NOOZfJ& 1"=B=$>$#%;CG& '@V(H(=G& 8S9S& ')>& );>@& >"??(>>F";;C& M((#&$#<=@*"?(*& $#& =(><)"=)#<>G& V'(=(& A)=%$#);& ?@><>& )=(& =)<'(=& '$%'J& /)M;(& K& >'@V>& )&?@AB)=)<$H(&)>>(AM;C&@F&M">$#(>>(>&F=@A&<'(&=(><)"=)#<G&?=()<$H(&)#*&@<'(=& $#*"><=$(>&V$<'&<'(&8S9S&B=$?$#%&A@*(;&($<'(=&B(=A)#(#<;C&$AB;(A(#<(*&@=&B=(H$@">;C&">(*&)>&)&B=@A@<$@#);&<@@;J&B.&I2'0,!.&,&#.13!

/@& <'(& M(><& @F& AC& ^#@V;(*%(G& <'(=(& $>& #@& B=(H$@">& =(>()=?'& @#& 8S9S& $#&?@AA"#$?)<$@#& )#*& ?";<"=);& ><"*$(>J& 1@A(& ><"*$(>& $#& @<'(=& *$>?$B;$#(>& ')H(& ;@@^(*& )<&<'(&B'(#@A(#@#&@F&8S9SJ&7#&<'(&A)=^(<$#%&;$<(=)<"=(G&j$A&(<&);J&eNOOZf&')H(&><"*$(*&)&>(<& @F& F)?<@=>& )#*& M"C(=& ?')=)?<(=$><$?>& <')<& $#F;"(#?(& <@& H)=$@">& (E<(#<>& <'(& B=$?(&*$>?')=%(*& <@& >(;;(=>& "#*(=& 8S9S& ?@#*$<$@#>J& 7#& )#& (EB(=$A(#<);& F$(;*& ><"*CG& <'(&)"<'@=>& $AB;(A(#<(*& <'(& 8S9S& A@*(;& )<& @#(& =(><)"=)#<G& @#(& ?$#(A)& )#*& @#(&*(;$?)<(>>(#& $#& :(=A)#C& $#& <'(& Q=)#^F"=<& )=()J& 2F<(=& @M>(=H$#%& <'(& M">$#(>>& F@=& <V@&V((^>& $#&<'(&M(%$##$#%&@F& <'(&><"*CG&8S9S&V)>& $#<=@*"?(*&F@=&<V@&V((^>&)<&);;& <'=((&M">$#(>>(>&)#*&?"><@A(=>&V(=(&>"=H(C(*&)F<(=&B)C$#%J&/'(&)"<'@=>&?=()<(*&)&<'(@=(<$?);&F=)A(& <')<& A@*(;>& <'(& $#F;"(#?(& @F& ?"><@A(=>b& ;@C);<CG& F)$=#(>>G& );<="$>AG& B=$?(&?@#>?$@">#(>>G&$#?@A(G&>)<$>F)?<$@#&)#*&=(F(=(#?(&B=$?(>&@#&B=$?(>&B)$*&F@=&<'(&>(=H$?(>&=(?($H(*J&& &

Page 11: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

Y&

J.4/&'(!"A'()*-*&')$(3"&(*-*14"C9/*1,//,/"*1")5,"P@L"Q,(%'13H89/)(*'"'12"$)5,("-$91)(*,/"

" E.6-%*,*;5' D%&.-"3&'K,7$6-%5' 9-C&%'K,7$6-%"&6'A&

%;.,

&,-'K;L/&;

&,-.-"*

,'

P@8"H"$)5,("-$91)(*,/"• R,1)*./"'/"813)5*14L"S,.C$9(1,L"8P@"• T,(('C*),L"@,')).,"• A314.,U/"V$$2"T(9-WL"R$/"814,.,/"• G,)),("X$(.2"#'0YL"Z*45.'12"A'(WL"I["• A'1,('L"@)7"R$9*/"B/)$&&,2D"• \1,"X$(.2"#'0YL"@'.)"R'W,"#*)3L"PT"• @8S="#'0YL"],1+,(L"#\"• K'(%'K*)-5,1L"G,(W,.,3"• [9/)"#$$W*1G&]'..'/L"I#"• S$/'*-"#$00,,"Z$9/,L"@,')).,"• #.*0)$1^/"#'0,),(*'L"R$/"814,.,/"B-.$/,2D"• #*)3"#'0,"G'W,(3L"\1)'(*$L"#'1'2'"• @'1)$(*1*"Q(*..L"I,_"J$(W"#*)3"B-.$/,2D"• @&$W'1,L"X'/5*14)$1"• S'2,"_*)5"R$+,"#'0YL"I,_"\(.,'1/"• S$)5,(^/"K*)-5,1L"'-($//"P@8""• X,21,/2'3/L"@'1)'"#.'('"• `*%'.'"#$$W/L"=+,(3C$23"=')/L"#5'&,."Z*..L"I#"

• @$9."K*)-5,1L";,2"G'1WL"I,_"[,(/,3"

• #$,9('4,"T5,')(,L"R787""• #'/5%9/*-7$(4"• 8('.*,7-$%"• I$*/,)('2,7-$%"• @5,,C'7-'"• Z9%C.,G912.,"Q'%,/"• Q*(."T'.W"BaV,,2")5,"81*%'./bD"

• V9.)$1"T5,'),(L"R'1-'/),(L"A8"

• T5,"Z9C"T5,')(,"#$%&'13L"G$/)$1"

• ]'..'/"T5,'),("#,1),(L"Tc"

• I,_"=12"T5,'),(L"PK"• V$(9%"T5,')(,L"S]"• T5,"#')'/)($&5*-"T5,')(,L"Tc"

• 8`R"T5,'),(L"\Z"• R$14"X5'(0"T5,')(,L"#T"

• J$4'"#*(-.,"]$_1)$_1L"R787L"#8"

• J$4'"Z$..3_$$2L#8& "

&&

& "

Q,(%'13"H"89/)(*'"• K*/5";,/)'9('1)L"V('1W09()"• X*,1,("],,_'1L"`*,11'"• X,*1,(,*"B_*1,"C'(DL"G,(.*1"O"Id(1C,(4"• #'0Y"R*,C.*14L"S91*-5"• I'1'#'0,L"K(,%/"• "

• T5,'),("K$1/)'1e" • f$$"Sd1/),("• G$23"814,./L"V('1W09()L"Q=;"

• =+,182'%72,"B/)$&&,2D"

• I,-W"8))'-W"%'//'4,/L"Q=;"

• A'(W5$),.L"\)),1/5,*%"

A%*;

*-"*,.

/'K;L/&;

&,-.-"*

,'

P@8"H"$)5,("-$91)(*,/"• R*)).,"G'3L"R$12$1L"PK"

& "• ;'2*$5,'2"8.C9%"ag1";'*1C$_/bL":MMh"

• gC*/"Z$),./L"@*14'&$(,& "

&&

& "Q,(%'13"H"89/)(*'"

• =)(9/-'";,/)'9('1)L"#$.$41,L"Q=;"• P1),(%"8&0,.C'9%L"V9.2'L"Q=;"

• T5,'),("894/C9(4" • gC*/"Z$),./"Q,(%'13"• Z$),."T'11,15$0L"@'/C'-5_'.2,1"

• ](,5C9-5/-59.,L"G,(.*1"BC$$W/D"

• ]@#"X'11,i=*-W,.L"Z,(1,"B/&$()/D"

• V@`"V('1W09()"0$$)C'.."B/&$()/D"

• 8&$..$"\&)*WL"B,3,_,'(H4.'//,/D"

Page 12: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

Z&

j$A& (<& );J& eNOOZf& F@"#*& <')<& <'(& B=$?(>& B)$*& MC& ?"><@A(=>& F@=& <'(& *$FF(=(#<&>(=H$?(>&)#*&B=@*"?<>&)=(&>$%#$F$?)#<;C&%=()<(=&<')#&i(=@&*(>B$<(&<'(&F)?<&<')<&i(=@&V)>&)&B(=F(?<;C& H$)M;(& @B<$@#& <@& ?'@@>(& F@=& <'(& ?"><@A(=>J& /'$>& $>& )& F$=><& ?');;(#%(& <@& <'(&=)<$@#);&?'@$?(&A@*(;&$#&<=)*$<$@#);&(?@#@A$?&<'(@=C&>$#?(&?"><@A(=>&)BB)=(#<;C&*@&#@<&M(')H(&(#<$=(;C&=)<$@#);&$#&B"=>"(&@F&>(;FR$#<(=(><&)#*&B=@F$<&A)E$A$i)<$@#&e4@;)#G&NOKNq&!$<<(#M(=%&k&/=(%)=<'(#G&NOOLfJ&6@=(@H(=G&j$A&(<&);J&eNOOZf&>"%%(><&<')<&<'(&B=$?(>&B)$*&MC&?"><@A(=>&"#*(=&8S9S&?@#*$<$@#>&*(B(#*&;)=%(;C&@#&<'(&M"C(=>b&$#<(=#);&=(F(=(#?(&B=$?(>& F@=&>$A$;)=&B=@*"?<>&)#*&<'(&B=@B@=<$@#&@F&<'(&B=@F$<& <')<&<'(&M"C(=& $>&V$;;$#%&<@&>')=(&V$<'&<'(&>(;;(=J&8"<&*$FF(=(#<;CG&<'(&F$#);&B=$?(&*(B(#*>&B)=<;C&@#&<'(&_B=@B@=<$@#&@F&'@V&A"?'&<'(&M"C(=&$>&V$;;$#%&<@&>')=(&@F&'$>]'(=&eB@<(#<$);f&*();&B=@F$<&V$<'&<'(&>(;;(=`&ej$A&(<&);JG&NOOZG&BJ&NZfJ&&

7#<(=(><$#%;CG&<'(&F)?<@=>&@F&);<="$>A&)#*&;@C);<C&<"=#(*&@"<&<@&M(&$#>$%#$F$?)#<&$#&<'(&@H(=);;&A@*(;&)#*&<'">&*$*&#@<&>((A&<@&$#F;"(#?(&<'(&F$#);&B=$?(>&*$>?')=%(*&<@&<'(&>(;;(=>J&7#><()*G&<'(&F$#*$#%>&>"%%(><&<')<&<'(&)A@"#<&@F&A@#(C&)&?"><@A(=&$>&V$;;$#%&<@&B)C& )#*& >')=(& V$<'& <'(& >(;;(=& $>& B=$A)=$;C& )>>@?$)<(*& V$<'& <'(& ?"><@A(=b>& _F)$=#(>>G&>)<$>F)?<$@#G&B=$?(&?@#>?$@">#(>>&)#*&$#?@A(`&eBJ&NZfJ&Q@=&<'(&B=(>(#<&><"*CG&<'(&F)?<@=>&F=@A&<'(&A@*(;&V$;;&$#F@=A&<'(&c");$<)<$H(&$#c"$=C&$#<@&M"C(=>b&)#*&>(;;(=>b&A@<$H)<$@#>&)#*&B=)?<$?(>&=(%)=*$#%&8S9S&)#*&<'(&=(>";<>&V$;;&M(&<'(A)<$?);;C&?@#>$*(=(*&)%)$#><&<'(&M)?^*=@B&@F&;@C);<CG&F)$=#(>>G&);<="$>AG&B=$?(&?@#>?$@">#(>>G&$#?@A(G&>)<$>F)?<$@#G&)#*&=(F(=(#?(&B=$?(&<@&>((&$F&>@A(&A()#$#%F";&?@##(?<$@#>&(A(=%(J&

Q$#);;CG& j$A& (<& );J& eNOOZf& F@"#*& <')<& <'(& =(H(#"(>& $#& <'(& =(><)"=)#<& )#*& <'(&*(;$?)<(>>(#& $#?=()>(*& "#*(=& 8S9S& ?@#*$<$@#>J& 7#& F)?<G& <'(& =(><)"=)#<& e<&*=f& )?<");;C&^(B<& <'(& 8S9S&A@*(;& )F<(=& <'(& (#*& @F& <'(& ><"*C& )#*& =(B@=<(*& B@>$<$H(& =(>";<>& (H(#&A@#<'>& )F<(=V)=*>J& 7<& ?"==(#<;C& ><$;;& @B(=)<(>& "#*(=& <'(& >)A(& 8S9S& ?@#*$<$@#>J& /'(&?$#(A)G&@#&<'(&?@#<=)=CG&(EB(=$(#?(*&)&*(?=()>(&$#&=(H(#"(J&

5<'(=&><"*$(>&=(;)<(*&<@&8S9S&?@#>$*(=&<'(&);<(=#)<$H(&B=$?$#%&A@*(;&$#&<(=A>&@F&>')=(*&>@?$);&=(>B@#>$M$;$<CJ&7#&)&F$(;*&(EB(=$A(#<G&:#((iCG&:#((iCG&3(;>@#&)#*&\=@V#&eNOKOf& <(><(*& '@V& <=)*$<$@#);& F$E(*& B=$?$#%& ?@AB)=(>& <@& <'(& 8S9S& B=$?$#%&A@*(;& $#&?@AM$#)<$@#&V$<'&)#&)?<&@F& ?')=$<)M;(&%$H$#%J&/'(&)"<'@=>& ;@@^(*&)<&B'@<@& >);(>&)<& <'(&(#*&@F&)&=$*(&$#&)#&)A">(A(#<&B)=^J&7#&>@A(&%=@"B>G&)#&@B<$@#&<@&*@#)<(&');F&@F&<'(&B=$?(&F@=& <'(&B'@<@&V)>& @FF(=(*& <@& <'(& ?"><@A(=>J& Q$#*$#%>& $#*$?)<(& <')<& <'(& ?@AM$#)<$@#&@F&?')=$<C&)#*&8S9S&>$%#$F$?)#<;C& $#?=()>(>&=(H(#"(>&%(#(=)<(*& F=@A&B'@<@&>);(>J& 7#& <'(&(EB(=$A(#<G&=(H(#"(>&%(#(=)<(*&F=@A&B'@<@&>);(>&"#*(=&8S9S&?@#*$<$@#>&B)$=(*&V$<'&?')=$<C&V(=(&)M@"<&XOOr&'$%'(=&?@AB)=(*& <@&B'@<@&>);(>&"#*(=& F$E(*&B=$?(&@=&8S9S&?@#*$<$@#>&V$<'@"<&?')=$<C&)>&V(;;&)>&F$E(*&B=$?(&?@#*$<$@#>&$#&?@AM$#)<$@#&V$<'&?')=$<CJ&&

Page 13: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

L&

:#((iC&(<& );J& eNOKOf&)=%"(& <')<& <'(& ?"><@A$i(*&*@#)<$@#>& ?"><@A(=>& ?)#&A)^(&"#*(=& 8S9SRB;">R?')=$<CR?@#*$<$@#>& )?<$H)<(& )& >(#>(& @F& >')=(*& >@?$);& =(>B@#>$M$;$<CG&V'$?'& );;@V>& ?"><@A(=>& _<@& *$=(?<;C& (EB=(>>& >@?$);& V(;F)=(& ?@#?(=#>& <'=@"%'& <'(&B"=?')>$#%&@F&A)<(=$);&%@@*>`&eBJ&XN[fJ&7#&<'$>&>(#>(G&<'(&8S9S&B=$?$#%&A@*(;&F"#?<$@#>&)>& )& >@A(V')<& B)=)*@E$?);&A(*$)<$#%& *(H$?(& $#& <')<& $<& (#)M;(>& B(@B;(& <@& ')H(& )%(#?C&)#*&>(;FR*(<(=A$#)<$@#&@H(=&B=$?(>&<'(C&B)C&M"<&)<&<'(&>)A(&<$A(&A)E$A$i(>&B=@F$<>&F@=&<'(&?@AB)#CJ&

7#&)& ;)<(=&><"*CG&:#((iCG&:#((iCG&!$(#(=&)#*&3(;>@#&eNOKNf&$#H(><$%)<(*&8S9S&B=$?$#%&)#*&*(?$>$@#&A)^$#%&)%)$#><& <'(&M)?^*=@B&@F& $*(#<$<C&)#*&>(;FR>$%#);$#%J&\)>(*&@#&<'=((&F$(;*&(EB(=$A(#<>G&<'(&)"<'@=>&>"%%(><&<')<&V'(#&?"><@A(=>&)=(&);;@V(*&<@&>(<&<'($=&@V#&B=$?(>&F@=&)&B=@*"?<&@=&>(=H$?(G& F(V(=&?"><@A(=>&)?<");;C&A)^(&<'(&B"=?')>(&?@AB)=(*&<@&)&>$<")<$@#&V$<'&;@V&F$E(*&B=$?(>J&:#((iC&(<&);J&eNOKNf&F"=<'(=&>"%%(><&<')<&?@#?(=#>&)M@"<& $*(#<$<C&)#*&>(;FR$A)%(&)=(& <'(&A)$#&*=$H(=>&@F& <'$>& _@B<R@"<&M(')H$@=`&eBJ& KfJ& 7#& B)=<$?";)=G& <'(& )"<'@=>& )=%"(& <')<& =)<'(=& <')#& <)^$#%& <'(& =$>^& @F& F((;$#%&(A@<$@#);& *$><=(>>& *"(& <@& B)C$#%& )& ;@V& )#*& B@<(#<$);;C& "#F)$=& B=$?(& <@& <'(& >(;;(=G&?"><@A(=>&@F<(#&?'@@>(&<@&)M)#*@#&<'(&B"=?')>(&?@AB;(<(;CJ 9&%#+2'*,!$&+6&&*!,&%%&.!#*/!$0=&.!

/'(& 8S9S& B=$?$#%& A@*(;& *$>="B<>& <'(& ?@#H(#<$@#);& =(;)<$@#>'$B& M(<V((#&M"C(=>& )#*& >(;;(=>& $#& )& A)=^(<& >$<")<$@#& $#& <')<& <'(& >(;;(=& *@(>& #@<& B=(R*(<(=A$#(& )&=(%";)<$#%&B=$?(& F@=&)& >"??(>>F";&B"=?')>(&M"<&(#<$=(;C&@"<>@"=?(>&B=$?$#%& <@& <'(&M"C(=&eQ$%"=(& Nf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e.((G&NOOOq&S)#%G&KLL[fG& 0"=@B()#& )#*& 3@=<'R2A(=$?)#& B(@B;(& ">");;C& =(><=$?<& M)=%)$#$#%& B=)?<$?(>& <@&(EB(#>$H(&@=&"#$c"(&$<(A>G&>"?'&)>&)"<@A@M$;(>&@=&)=<&B$(?(>J&&& &

Page 14: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

KO&

!"#$%&'M!"G93,(i/,..,(i(,.')*$1/"*1"&'()*-*&')$(3"&(*-*14"%$2,./"

I$),/!"#5'()"&'().3"C'/,2"$1"K*%L"I')),("'12"@&'11L":M6M7"&&-#*(=& 8S9S& ?@#*$<$@#>G& <'(& M"C(=& ')>& <'(& @BB@=<"#$<C& <@& B)C& )#C& B=$?(G&

$#?;"*$#%& i(=@J& /'$>& >'$F<>& <'(& =(;)<$@#>'$B& M(<V((#& M"C(=& )#*& >(;;(=& F=@A& M($#%&%@H(=#(*& MC& <=)*$<$@#);& A)=^(<& (?@#@AC& #@=A>& <@& M($#%& %@H(=#(*& MC& >@?$);& )#*&$#<(=B(=>@#);& M(')H$@=);& #@=A>G& V'$?'& $#& <"=#& ')>& )#& $AB)?<& @#& <'(& M"C(=b>& B=$?$#%&*(?$>$@#&e5><(='">G&KLLYfJ&8)=<$?";)=;C&B=(H);(#<& $#&*(A@?=)<$?&>@?$(<$(>G&<'(>(&>@?$);;C&?@#<$#%(#<&(E?')#%(&#@=A>&)=(&<$(*&<@&#@=A)<$H(&F@=A>&@F&*$><=$M"<$@#G&V'$?'&(#<)$;&<')<&B(@B;(&#)<"=);;C&B"=>"(&)#&(c");&);;@?)<$@#&)#*&*$><=$M"<$@#&@F&=(>@"=?(>&e0;><(=G&KLZLq&j$A& (<& );JG& NOOZfJ& 7F& )& M"C(=& ?'@@>(>& <@& B)C& i(=@& F@=& )& B=@*"?<& @=& >(=H$?(& B"=?')>(*&"#*(=& 8S9S& ?@#*$<$@#>G& <'(>(& >@?$);& #@=A>& )=(& H$@;)<(*G& V'$?'& A)C& ;()*& <@& >@?$);&B=(>>"=(>G&B(=>@#);&(A@<$@#);&><=(>>&)#*&*$>)BB=@H);&MC&B((=>&e2=$(;CG&\=)?')G&k&6($(=G&NOOLq& 0;><(=G& KLZLq& T(#^)<(>)#G& KLUUfJ& /'(& ;)<(#<& F()=& @F& <'(>(& B@<(#<$);& #(%)<$H(&=(B(=?">>$@#>& $>& <'(& =()>@#& F@=& A@><& B(@B;(& <@& B)C& B=$?(>& %=()<(=& <')#& i(=@& D& (H(#&<'@"%'&<'(C&')H(&<'(&?')#?(&<@&B)C&i(=@&D&V'$?'&><)#*>&$#&><)=^&?@#<=)><&<@&<'(&?;)$A>&@F&=)<$@#);& ?'@$?(& <'(@=C& )#*& B=@F$<& A)E$A$i)<$@#& $#& <=)*$<$@#);& (?@#@A$?& <'(@=CJ& /'(&M(#(F$<& @F& B)C$#%& i(=@& V@";*& ')H(& <@& M(& '$%'(=& <')#& <'(& )#<$?$B)<(*& #(%)<$H(&=(B(=?">>$@#>&>"?'&)>&B(=>@#);&(A@<$@#);&><=(>>&)#*&>@?$);&*$>)BB=@H);J&&

&2#@<'(=&=()>@#&V'C&B(@B;(&)=(&$#?;$#(*&<@&B)C&B=$?(>&%=()<(=&<')#&i(=@&A)C&M(&=(;)<(*& <@& <'(& )=%"A(#<& MC& j)'#(A)#G& j#(<>?'& )#*& /');(=& eKLZUf& )M@"<& B(@B;(&B=$@=$<$i$#%& F)$=#(>>& )#*& (c");& *$><=$M"<$@#J& 1B(?$F$?);;CG& <'(& )"<'@=>& ?;)$A& <')<& B(@B;(&<(#*&<@&?'@@>(&A@#(<)=C&;@>>&@H(=&"#(c");&*$><=$M"<$@#G&V'$?'&?@#<=)><>&V$<'&(?@#@A$?&<'(@=$(>&@F&=)<$@#);&?'@$?(&)#*&>(;FR$#<(=(><J&Q"=<'(=A@=(G&?'@@>$#%&<@&B)C&B=$?(>&%=()<(=&<')#& i(=@G& @=& %=()<(=& <')#& <'(& F$E(*& B=$?(G& A)C& %@& M)?^& <@& :#((iC& (<& );Jl>& eNOKNf&)=%"A(#<& )M@"<& $*(#<$<C& )#*& >(;FR>$%#);$#%G& V'$?'& ><=$#%>& )& ?'@=*& V$<'& .C##& eKLLOfG&V'@&)=%"(>&<')<&B(@B;(&B@<(#<$);;C&">(&B=$?(&)>&)&<@@;&<@&A)#)%(&$AB=(>>$@#>&MC&@<'(=>&$#&@=*(=&#@<&<@&?@A(&)?=@>>&)>&?'()B&@=&B@@=&e>((&);>@&j$A&(<&);JG&NOOZfJ& &

&

C3")5,"C93,("

C3"C$)5")5,"/,..,("'12")5,"C93,(""

C3")5,"/,..,("&

],),(%*1')*$1"$0")5,"&(*-,"

• ;,+,(/,"89-)*$1/"• A$_,("@5$&&*14"

• A'3iX5')iJ$9iX'1)"• A'3iX5')iJ$9i#'1HA'3iJ$9(iV'*(i@5'(,"• A'3iX5')iQ$2iX'1)/"• A'3iV$(i@$%,$1,i=./,"• I'%,iJ$9(i\_1iA(*-,"• #.'//*-"89-)*$1/"& • G'(),("S'(W,)/"

• A(*-,"I,4$)*')*$1/"

Page 15: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

KK&

)'*1&8+0#%!4.#5&6'.7!

".#/2+2'*#%!&1'*'521!+3&'.=!

/=)*$<$@#);& (?@#@A$?& <'(@=C&A)^(>& )& #"AM(=& @F& )>>"AB<$@#>& )M@"<& $#*$H$*");&*(?$>$@#RA)^$#%& )#*& ?'@$?(>& $#& <'(& A)=^(<B;)?(J& /'(& (?@#@A$?& V)C& @F& <'$#^$#%& B"<>&>?)=?$<C& $#& <'(& ?(#<(=& @F& )<<(#<$@#& $#& <'(& ><"*C& @F& ?'@$?(>& $#*$H$*");>& A)^(& $#& <'(&A)=^(<B;)?(& e4@;)#G& NOKNfJ& /=)*$<$@#);& (?@#@A$?& <'(@=C& )>>"A(>& <')<& $#& )& >$<")<$@#&V'(=(& B=@*"?<>& )=(& >?)=?(G& $#*$H$*");>& A)^(& ?'@$?(>& $#& B)=<$?";)=& V)C>& M)>(*& @#& )&#"AM(=&@F&F)?<@=>J&/V@&@F&<'(&A@><&$AB@=<)#<&F)?<@=>&<')<&$#F;"(#?(&$#*$H$*");&*(?$>$@#&A)^$#%&)=(&@BB@=<"#$<C&?@><&)#*&<'(&A)E$A$i)<$@#&@F&H);"(&F@=&B(=>@#);&M(#(F$<&e8(=;@FFG&NOOLfJ&

&5#(&)>>"AB<$@#&(#<)$;>&)#&)>>(>>A(#<&@F&<'(&@BB@=<"#$<C&?@><>J&!$<<(#M(=%&)#*&/=(%)=<'(#&eNOOLf&*(F$#(&@BB@=<"#$<C&?@><&)>&_<'(&H);"(&@F&<'(&M(><&);<(=#)<$H(&F@=%@#(&$#&A)^$#%&)#C&?'@$?(`&eBJ&KYfJ&4@$#%&@#(&<'$#%&">");;C&(;$A$#)<(>&<'(&B@>>$M$;$<C&@F&*@$#%&)#@<'(=& <'$#%J& 7#*$H$*");>& V$;;& A)^(& ?'@$?(>& )%)$#><& <'(& M)?^*=@B& @F& <'(& )#<$?$B)<(*&M(#(F$<>&@F&);<(=#)<$H(&?'@$?(>&)H)$;)M;(&)<&)&?(=<)$#&A@A(#<J&0)?'&B=@M;(A&<')<&')>&)&>(<&@F& );<(=#)<$H(>& )H)$;)M;(& <@& ?'@@>(& F=@A& $AB;$(>& F@=(%@$#%& )& ?(=<)$#& )A@"#<& @F& H);"(G&V'@>(& A)E$A$i)<$@#& $>& <'(& ";<$A)<(& %@);& F@=& <'(& $#*$H$*");& $#& <=)*$<$@#);& (?@#@A$?&<'$#^$#%&e4@;)#G&NOKNfJ&

2#@<'(=&)>>"AB<$@#&$>&=(;)<(*&<@&<'(&A)E$A$i)<$@#&@F&H);"(&F@=&B(=>@#);&M(#(F$<J&7#&<=)*$<$@#);&(?@#@A$?&<'(@=CG&$#*$H$*");&?'@$?(>&)=(&M)>(*&@#&<'(&%@);&<@&A)E$A$i(&<'(&H);"(&)#*&B(=>@#);&M(#(F$<&@F&)#&)?<$@#J&0?@#@A$><>&)>>"A(&<')<&<'(&B=$A)=C&@Mg(?<$H(&$#&$#*$H$*");&?'@$?(>&$>&<@&A)E$A$i(&<'(&H);"(&@F&<=)#>)?<$@#>&)#*&B=@*"?<>&e8(=;@FFG&NOOLq&!$<<(#M(=%&k&/=(%)=<'(#G&NOOLfJ&6@=(@H(=G&B(=>@#);&B=@F$<&)#*&M(#(F$<&)=(&>@"%'<&)F<(=&$#& ;$#(& V$<'& <'(& @V#& >(;FR$#<(=(><J& 7#*$H$*");& ?@#>"A(=>& <=C& <@& A)E$A$i(& >)<$>F)?<$@#&;(H(;>&V'(#&A)^$#%&(?@#@A$?&?'@$?(>&e4@;)#G&NOKNfJ&&9#+2'*#%!13'21&!+3&'.=!

6)E$A$i)<$@#&@F&B(=>@#);&>)<$>F)?<$@#&)#*&B=@F$<&?')=)?<(=$i(&<'(&=)<$@#);&?'@$?(&<'(@=C& D& )& <=)*$<$@#);& F=)A(V@=^& F@=& "#*(=><)#*$#%& $#*$H$*");& (?@#@A$?& M(')H$@=J&0?@#@A$?);;C& =)<$@#);& $#*$H$*");>& )#);Ci(& <'(& M);)#?(& M(<V((#& ?@><& )#*& M(#(F$<& <@&)?'$(H(& A)E$A"A& B(=>@#);& M(#(F$<& )#*& B=@F$<& e4@;)#G& NOKNfJ& !)<$@#);$<C& $#& (?@#@A$?&<(=A>&$>&=(;)<(*&<@&?'@$?(&B)<<(=#>&D&=)<'(=&<')#&$#*$H$*");&?'@$?(>&D&<')<&=(B()<(*;C&)#*&>C><(A)<$?);;C& F)H@=& <'(& ?'@$?(& F@=&A)E$A"A&B(=>@#);&B=@F$<& )#*&M(')H$@=& <')<& >(=H(>&>(;FR$#<(=(><&e8(=;@FFG&NOOLfJ&&

/'(& =)<$@#);& ?'@$?(& A@*(;& @F& (?@#@A$?& M(')H$@=& $>& =(;)<(*& <@& <'(& ?@#?(B<& @F&'@A@&(?@#@A$?">& $#& <=)*$<$@#);&(?@#@A$?& <'(@=CJ&/'(&'@A@&(?@#@A$?">G&@=&(?@#@A$?&'"A)#G& >((^>& <@& ;(<& =)<$@#);$<C& )#*& )& #)==@V& >(;FR$#<(=(><& %"$*(& );;& M(')H$@=& )#*&

Page 16: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

KN&

*(?$>$@#>G& V'$?'& )=(& A@<$H)<(*& MC& >"Mg(?<$H(& g"*%A(#<>& <@V)=*& B(=>@#);& M(#(F$<&e!$<<(#M(=%&k&/=(%)=<'(#G&NOOLfJ&&/'(&'@A@&(?@#@A$?">&><)#*>&$#&?@#<=)><&<@&<'(&'@A@&=(?$B=@?)#>G&V'$?'& >((>& '"A)#& M(')H$@=& )>& M($#%&A@<$H)<(*& MC& ?@;;(?<$H(& =(?$B=@?$<CG&?@@B(=)<$@#G&A"<");&)$*&)#*&$AB=@H(A(#<&@F&<'(&$AA(*$)<(&>"==@"#*$#%>J&

&Q=@A&)&?=$<$?);&B(=>B(?<$H(G&=)<$@#);&?'@$?(&<'(@=C&F)$;>&<@&)??@"#<&F@=&$==)<$@#);&M(')H$@=&=@@<(*&$#&#@#R(?@#@A$?&<'$#^$#%&)#*&$%#@=(>&?";<"=);&)#*&A@<$H)<$@#);&F)?<@=>&<')<& $#F;"(#?(& $#*$H$*");& ?'@$?(>J&6@=(@H(=G& =)<$@#);& ?'@$?(& <'(@=C& ')>& M((#& ?=$<$c"(*&F@=&$AB;C$#%&A(<'@*@;@%$?);&$#*$H$*");$>A&e0;><(=G&KLZLfG&V'$?'&)>>"A(>&<'(&$#*$H$*");&)?<$@#>&)#*&M(')H$@=>&)=(&<'(&>@;(&?)">(&)#*&*=$H(=&@F&?@;;(?<$H$<$(>&)#*&>@?$);&*C#)A$?>J&\(>$*(>&$#*$H$*");&)?<$@#>&);@#(G&'@V(H(=G&B@;$<$?>G&?";<"=(&)#*&>@?$);&$#><$<"<$@#>&B;)C&)&B$H@<);&=@;(&$#&<'(&*(?$>$@#RA)^$#%&B=@?(>>(>&@F&$#*$H$*");>&)#*&%=@"B>J&&

2#@<'(=& ?=$<$c"(& ?)A(& F=@A& 8$(==(& \@"=*$("G& V'@& )=%"(>& <')<& =)<$@#);& ?'@$?(&<'(@=C& $AB;$(>&)&%=)H(&A$>?@#?(B<$@#&@F& <'(&V)C>& $#&V'$?'&>@?$);&)?<@=>&A)^(&?'@$?(>&e\@"=*$("G&NOO[fJ&\@"=*$("&?@#<(#*(*&<')<&>@?$);&)%(#<>&*@&#@<&M)>(&);;&<'($=&*(?$>$@#>&@#& (EB;$?$<& =)<$@#);& )#*& (?@#@A$?& F)?<@=>J& 7#><()*G& <'(C& @F<(#& F@;;@V& )&A@=(& B=)?<$?);G&$AB;$?$<& ;@%$?J& 7#& @<'(=& V@=*>G& $#*$H$*");>& A)^(& *(?$>$@#>& $#& ;$#(& V$<'& <'($=& B=)?<$?);&>(#>(& )#*& _F((;& F@=& <'(& %)A(`& e\@"=*$("G& KLLOG& BJ& UUf& =)<'(=& <')#& $#& B"=>"(& @F& B=@F$<&A)E$A$i)<$@#&)#*&>(;FR$#<(=(><J&&

&7#& <(=A>&@F&);<(=#)<$H(&(?@#@A$?&A@*(;>& <')<&@"<>@"=?(& <'(&B=$?$#%&*(?$>$@#& <@&<'(&?@#>"A(=G&$<& $>&$#<(=(><$#%&<@&?@#>$*(=&A@*(;>&>"?'&)>&8S9S&)%)$#><&<'(&M)?^*=@B&@F&=)<$@#);&?'@$?(&A@*(;&$#&<')<&8S9S&=(>(AM;(>&)&F"#*)A(#<);&?');;(#%(&<@&<=)*$<$@#);&(?@#@A$?& )#*& =)<$@#);& ?'@$?(& <'(@=CJ&2??@=*$#%& <@& =)<$@#);& ?'@$?(& <'(@=CG& )& ?@#>"A(=&V@";*& <=C& <@& A)E$A$i(& <'(& @V#& B=@F$<& )#*& A)^(& *(?$>$@#>& $#& B"=>"(& @F& >(;FR$#<(=(><J&h(#?(G&V'(#& B=@H$*(*&V$<'& <'(& ?'@$?(& @F& B)C$#%& )#C& )A@"#<& @F&A@#(C& M(<V((#& i(=@&)#*&$#F$#$<(&F@=&)&B=@*"?<G&$#&<'$>&?)>(&F@@*G&<=)*$<$@#);&(?@#@A$?&<'$#^$#%&V@";*&;()*&<@&<'(&?@#?;">$@#&<')<&<'(&M"C(=&V@";*&B)C&i(=@J&8)C$#%&#@<'$#%&V@";*&M(&<'(&;@%$?);&)?<$@#&<@&<)^(&)??@=*$#%&<@&<'(&=)<$@#);&?'@$?(&<'(@=C&@F&(?@#@A$?>&M(?)">(&$<&(#)M;(>&<'(&M"C(=&<@&=(<)$#&<'(&A)E$A"A&)A@"#<&@F&A@#(C&$#&<'(&@V#&')#*>G&V'$?'&A)E$A$i(>&@V#&B=@F$<&)#*&$#?"=>&B=)?<$?);;C&#@&@BB@=<"#$<C&?@><J&&M088%=!#*/!/&5#*/!/&+&.52*&!+3&!8.21&N!

2#@<'(=& F"#*)A(#<);& $*()& <@& <'(& <=)*$<$@#);& (?@#@A$?& ;@%$?& =(;)<(>& <@& <'(&)>>"AB<$@#& <')<& )& B=@*"?<b>& >"BB;C& )#*& *(A)#*& *(<(=A$#(& <'(& B=$?(& @F& <')<& B=@*"?<&e!$<<(#M(=%&k&/=(%)=<'(#G&NOOLfJ&0?@#@A$><>&)>>"A(& <')<& <'(&=(;)<$H(& ;(H(;>&@F& >"BB;C&)#*&*(A)#*&*$=(?<;C&)#*&*(<(=A$#$><$?);;C&$#F;"(#?(&B=$?(>&$#&<'(&A)=^(<B;)?(&)#*&<')<&)&><)M;(&B=$?(&=(c"$=(>&(c"$;$M=$"A&M(<V((#&>"BB;C&)#*&*(A)#*J&5F<(#&<$A(>G&<'$>&;@%$?&$>&><$;;&)BB;$?)M;(&)#*&B=$?(>&@F&B=@*"?<>&>"?'&)>&F$>'&(A(=%(&F=@A&>"BB;C&)#*&*(A)#*&$#&

Page 17: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

KX&

<'(& A)=^(<J& /'(& F$>'$#%& $#*"><=C& $>& )& B=$A(& (E)AB;(& @F& '@V& *(?)*(>& @F& >(H(=(&@H(=F$>'$#%& ')>& =(?(#<;C& ;(*& <@& %@H(=#A(#<& $#<(=H(#<$@#>& <@& B=@<(?<& #)<"=);& F$>'&B@B";)<$@#>& e:@;*M"=%& k& 3)C;@=G& NOO[fJ& !(><=$?<$@#>& @#& F$>'$#%& ')H(& *=$H(#& *@V#&>"BB;$(>J&4(A)#*G&'@V(H(=G&')>&=(A)$#(*&><)M;(&)<&'$%'&;(H(;>&>$#?(&<'(&?"><@A(=>&')H(&M(?@A(&">(*&<@&(#g@C$#%&F=(>';C&?)"%'<&F$>'&@#&)&*)$;C&M)>$>J&7#&>'@=<G&*(A)#*&F@=&F$>'&$>&'$%'&V'(=()>&>"BB;C&')>&%@#(&*@V#&*"(&<@&;$A$<$#%&=(><=$?<$@#>&@#&F$>'$#%&%=@"#*>&)#*&*(?;$#$#%& F$>'& B@B";)<$@#>& e4(;%)*@G& NOOXfJ& /'(& ?@#>(c"(#?(& @F& )& *(?=()>(& $#& >"BB;C&V$<'& ><()*C& ;(H(;>& @F& *(A)#*& $>& )#& $#?=()>(& $#& <'(& B=$?(& F@=& )& ?@AA@*$<C& <')<& ')>&M(?@A(&>?)=?(=&<')#&M(F@=(J&7#&>"?'&)&?)>(G&>"BB;C&)#*&*(A)#*&*@&*(<(=A$#(&<'(&B=$?(J&

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g@=$<C&@F&?"><@A(=>&<@&M"C&<'(&B=@*"?<J&:(#(=);;CG&<'(&'$%'(=&<'(&B=$?(>G&<'(&A@=(&=(H(#"(>&)=(&%(#(=)<(*&B(=&"#$<&>@;*G&M"<&<'(&#"AM(=&@F&B$(?(>&<')<&)=(&>@;*&*(?=()>(>&M(?)">(&;(>>&B(@B;(&M"C&<'(&B=@*"?<&e!$<<(#M(=%&k&/=(%)=<'(#G&NOOLfJ&&

&/=)*$<$@#);&(?@#@A$?&<'$#^$#%&?@#?($H(>&B=$?(&<'=@"%'&)&<=)#>)?<$@#);&B)=)*$%A&<')<&*$=(?<;C& =(;)<(>&B=$?(& <@& H);"(J& ,@#>"A(=>&">");;C& (c")<(& <'(&B=$?(& <'(C&B)C& F@=& )&B=@*"?<&<@&<'(&H);"(&@F&<')<&B=@*"?<J&7#&@<'(=&V@=*>G&B=@*"?<&H);"(&$>&(EB=(>>(*&<'=@"%'&<'(&B=$?(&<')<&)&?@#>"A(=&')>& <@&B)C& F@=& <')<&B=@*"?<J&1(;;(=>&@F&)&B=@*"?<&);>@&>(<& <'(&

Page 18: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

KP&

B=$?(&@F&)&B=@*"?<&<'(C&)=(&>(;;$#%&)??@=*$#%&<@&<'(&H);"(&<'(C&)<<=$M"<(&<@&<')<&B=@*"?<&)#*]@=& <'(& )A@"#<& @F& ;)M@=& <')<& <'(C& B"<& $#G& V'$?'& (?'@(>& <'(&6)=E$><& #@<$@#& @F& <'(&(c");$<C&M(<V((#&;)M@=&B"<&$#&<@&B=@*"?(&)&B=@*"?(&)#*&B=$?(&?')=%(*&F@=&<')<&B=@*"?<J&&B.21&!#,!1'550*21#+2'*!

8=$?(&);>@&F"#?<$@#>&)>&)&F@=A&@F&?@AA"#$?)<$@#J&7#&(?@#@A$?&<'(@=CG&<'(&B=$?(&@F&)& B=@*"?<& @=& ?@AA@*$<C& ?@AA"#$?)<(>& $AB@=<)#<& $#F@=A)<$@#& <@&A)=^(<&B)=<$?$B)#<>J&6)=^(<& B=$?(>& ?@AA"#$?)<(& ?="?$);;C& $AB@=<)#<& $#F@=A)<$@#& <@& )f& ?@#>"A(=>& )M@"<&B=@*"?<& )H)$;)M$;$<CG& <@& B=@*"?(=>& )M@"<& ?@#>"A(=& B=(F(=(#?(>& )#*& ?f& <@& $#*$H$*");>&)M@"<& <'(& =(;)<$H(& H);"(&@F& B)=<$?";)=& ^$#*>&@F& B=@*"?<>G& ^#@V;(*%(& )#*& >^$;;>& <')<& )=(&>@;*&e8(=;@FFG&NOOLfJ&&

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b>&?)B)?$<C&<@&>(#*&>$%#);>&<@&M"C(=>& )#*& >(;;(=>& )M@"<& >"BB;C& )#*& *(A)#*& ;(H(;>J& !$>$#%& B=$?(>& A)C& B@$#<& <@&$#?=()>$#%& *(A)#*& @=& *(?=()>$#%& >"BB;CJ& 7==(>B(?<$H(& @F& <'(& "#*(=;C$#%& ?)">(& )#*&$#*(B(#*(#<& F=@A& ?@#>"A(=>G& B=$?(& $#?=()>(>& ?@AA"#$?)<(& <@& );;&A)=^(<& B)=<$?$B)#<>&<')<&>"BB;C&>'@";*&);>@&$#?=()>(&@=&<')<&*(A)#*&>'@";*&*(?=()>(&F@=&B=$?(>&<@&%@&*@V#&)%)$#&e4@;)#G&NOKNfJ&

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e2==@VG&KL[LfJ&&

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

Page 19: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

K[&

7#& )&A)=^(<& ?@#<(E<G& (?@#@A$><>&*$FF(=(#<$)<(& M(<V((#&*$FF(=(#<& <CB(>&@F& H);"(G&$#?;"*$#%&A)=^(<&H);"(G&#)<"=);&H);"(&)#*&(E?')#%(&H);"(G&<'(&;)<<(=&<V@&@F&V'$?'&V$;;&M(&?@#>$*(=(*& F@=& <'(& B"=B@>(& @F& <'(& B)B(=& )<& ')#*J& 5#& <'(& A@><& M)>$?& ;(H(;G& ?;)>>$?);&(?@#@A$?&<(=A$#@;@%C&?@#?($H(>&@F&H);"(G&@=&">(&H);"(G&)>&)#&@Mg(?<G&B=@*"?<G&@=&(#<$<Cb>&$##)<(& ?)B)?$<C& <@& >)<$>FC& '"A)#&#((*>& e4@;)#G& NOKNfJ&6)=^(<& H);"(& $>& <'(& B@V(=& @F& )&%@@*& @=& ?@AA@*$<C& <@& B"=?')>(& @<'(=& %@@*>& @=& ?@AA@*$<$(>& $#& <'(&A)=^(<B;)?(& )<& )&%$H(#& <$A(& e8(=;@FFG& NOOLfJ&S'(=()>&A)=^(<& H);"(>& )=(& ">");;C& H@;)<$;(G& #)<"=);& H);"(>&)=(& ?')#%$#%& @#;C& $F& <'(& (>>(#<$);&A@*(>& @F& B=@*"?<$@#G& *$><=$M"<$@#& )#*& ?@#>"AB<$@#&"#*(=%@& ?')#%(J& Q"=<'(=A@=(G& #)<"=);& H);"(>& )=(& <'(& H);"(>& <')<& V@";*& B(=>$><& $#& )#&(?@#@A$?&H)?""A&V$<'@"<&?@AB(<$<$@#&)#*&A)=^(<&B=(>>"=(>&e4@;)#G&NOKNfJ&0E?')#%(&H);"(&$>&@F<(#&">(*&>C#@#CA@">;C&V$<'&B=$?(J&7#&<'$>&>(#>(G&B=$?(&$>&>((#&)>&)&?@AA@*$<C&@=&B=@*"?<b>&B@V(=&<@&?@#<=@;&A@#(C&$#&(E?')#%(J&/'(&F@?">&@F&(E?')#%(&H);"(G&@=&B=$?(G&$>& @#& <'(& ?@AA)#*& @F&A@#(C& <')<& $>& $#& <'(&A)=^(<G&V'(=()>& <'(& %(#(=);& *(F$#$<$@#& @F&H);"(&=(;)<(>&A@=(&<@&<'(&B@V(=&@F&M($#%&)M;(&<@&?@#<=@;&B=@*"?<>&)#*&?@AA@*$<$(>&<')<&)=(& $#& (E?')#%(G& M"<& #@<& <'(&A@#(<)=C& (c"$H);(#<& <'(=(@F& e4@;)#G& NOKNq& !$<<(#M(=%& k&/=(%)=<'(#G&NOOLfJ

7<&$>&$AB@=<)#<&<@&#@<(&<')<&H);"(&)#*&B=$?(&)=(&$#(E<=$?)M;C&$#<(=<V$#(*&V$<'&<'(&#@<$@#&@F&B@V(=J&T);"(&$>&B@V(=G&>B(?$F$?);;C&(E?')#%(&H);"(&@=&<'(&B=$?(&@F&)&?@AA@*$<C&@=& B=@*"?<& $#& <')<& <'(C& ?)==C& $#F@=A)<$@#& <')<& (E(=<>& B@V(=& @F& @<'(=& B;)C(=>& $#& <'(&A)=^(<B;)?(&)#*&?)#&M(&">(*&<@&(E(=<&B=(>>"=(&$#&<'(&A)=^(<&)#*&B"=?')>(&@=&>(;;&%@@*>J&6@=(@H(=G&$<&$>&">(F";&<@&?@#>$*(=&<'(&h(%(;$)#&#@<$@#&@F&(E?')#%(&H);"(&<')<&$AB;$(>&<'(&<=)#>?(#*(#?(&@F&)&B=@*"?<&@=&%@@*b>&"#$H(=>);G&A)<(=$);&(E$><(#?(&<@&)>>"A(&)&>@?$);;C&?@#><="?<(*&(E?')#%(&H);"(&@F&)&'$%'(=&@=*(=J&/'$>&>@?$);;C&?@#<$#%(#<&(E?')#%(&H);"(&$>&>@A(<$A(>&)& =(;)<$H(;C&'$%'(=&@#(G&#)A(;C&">(&)#*&B@>>(>>$@#&H);"(G& ?@AB)=(*& <@& <'(&#)<"=);&H);"(&@F&<'(&B=@*"?<&@=&%@@*J&7<&$>&<'$>&#@<$@#&<')<&*(?@#><="?<>&(?@#@A$?&;$F(&$#&<(=A>&@F&<'(&"#*(=;C$#%&>@?$);&*C#)A$?>&)#*&<'($=&><="?<"=);& $#F;"(#?(&@#&H);"(&)#*&$<>&B(=?(B<$@#>&MC&?@#>"A$#%&$#*$H$*");>J&

&Q$#);;CG&)#&$AB@=<)#<&$*()&<@&?@#>$*(=&$>&<'(&;)M@=&<'(@=C&@F&H);"(J&,@$#(*&MC&<'(&$AB@=<)#<&<'$#^(=>&2*)A&1A$<'G&j)=;&6)=E&)#*&4)H$*&!$?)=*@G&<'(&;)M@=&<'(@=C&@F&H);"(&'@;*>&<')<&<'(&(?@#@A$?&H);"(&@F&%@@*>&)#*&>(=H$?(>&>'@";*&(c");&(E)?<;C&<'(&)A@"#<&@F&;)M@=& <')<&V@=^(=>& @=& B=@*"?(=>& B"<& $#& <@& B=@*"?(& @=& C$(;*& <'@>(& %@@*>& )#*& >(=H$?(>&e4@;)#G&NOKNfJ&/'(&^(C&<(#(<&@F&;)M@=&<'(@=C&)<<(AB<>&c")#<$F$?)<$@#&)#*&(AM@*$A(#<&@F&);;&;)M@=&=(c"$=(*&<@&B=@*"?(&@=&B=@H$*(&)&A)=^(<)M;(&?@AA@*$<C&$#&@=*(=&<@&)==$H(&)<&)&<'(@=(<$?);& F@"#*)<$@#& F@=& =();& B=$?(>G& @=& #)<"=);& B=$?(>G& @F& B=@*"?<>& )#*& %@@*>& $#& <'(&A)=^(<&B;)?(& eo"#)#^)=G&KLZNq&8()?'G&KLLXfJ&S'$;(&'$%';C& $#F;"(#<$);&)#*& $AB@=<)#<& <@&<'(& V@=^>& @F& 6)=E& )#*& @<'(=>G& )#& $AB@=<)#<& ;$A$<)<$@#& @F& <'$>& <'(@=C& $>& <')<& <'(&

Page 20: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

KU&

?@#<(AB@=)=C& (?@#@A$?& ;)#*>?)B(& F()<"=(>& )& V$*(& )==)C& @F& B=@*"?<>G& %@@*>G& >(=H$?(>&)#*& ?@AA@*$<$(>& <')<& )=(& (E<=(A(;C& ')=*& <@& c")#<$FC& $#& <(=A>& @F& B'C>$?);& ;)M@=J& 7<& $>&<'(=(F@=(&)BB;$?)M;(&<@&<'(&(?@#@A$?&;$F(&@F&<'(&NK><&?(#<"=C&@#;C&<@&)&?(=<)$#&(E<(#<J&)'55'/2+=!(&+2,32,5!

2&=(>@"=?(F";&6)=E$)#&?@#?(B<&=(;)<(*&<@&B=$?(&)#*& $<>&=(;)<$@#&<@&H);"(G&>"BB;C&)#*& *(A)#*& $#& <'(&A)=^(<B;)?(& $>& ?@AA@*$<C& F(<$>'$>AJ& 7#& )&A)=^(<& >$<")<$@#&V'(=(&%@@*>&)#*&?@AA@*$<$(>&)=(&(E?')#%(*&F@=&A@#(CG&B=$?(>&)=(&<'(&$#*$?)<$H(&*(H$?(>&<')<&@H(=)=?'& <=)#>)?<$@#>& )#*& B(=?(B<");& H);"(& e!"M$#G& KLYXfJ& ,@AA@*$<C& F(<$>'$>A&?@#?($H(>& @F& <'$>& >$<")<$@#& )>& M($#%& *(B(#*(#<& @#& <'(& (?@#@A$?& =(;)<$@#>'$B& M(<V((#&B=@*"?<>&)#*& <'(&A@#(C&B)$*& F@=& <'(>(&B=@*"?<>&MC&?@#>"A(=>J&!)<'(=& <')#& <'(&>@?$);&=(;)<$@#>& <')<& )=(& #(?(>>)=C& <@& B=@H$*(& ;)M@=& F@=& <'(& B=@*"?<$@#& @F& B=@*"?<>G& $<& $>& <'(&(?@#@A$?&$#<(=B;)C&M(<V((#&B=@*"?<>&)#*&A@#(C&D&<'(&;)<<(=&@F&V'$?'&$>&(B$<@A$i(*&MC&B=$?(>& ?')=%(*& $#& <'(& A)=^(<& D& <')<& )=(& <'(& ?(#<=);& )>B(?<& @F& >@?$(<CJ& 7#& <'$>& >(#>(G&?@AA@*$<C&F(<$>'$>A&(#<)$;>&<'(&$*()&<')<&B(@B;(&)<<=$M"<(&$#<=$#>$?&H);"(&)#*&@Mg(?<$H(&=();$<C& <@& (#<$<$(>& <')<& )=(& A(=(;C& @F& )M><=)?<G& >"Mg(?<$H(& (?@#@A$?& H);"(& e6@==$>@#G&NOOUq&!"M$#G&KLYXfJ&

,@AA@*$<C& F(<$>'$>A& F"=<'(=& $AB;$(>& )& F$E)<$@#& @#& ?@AA@*$<$(>& )#*&A@#(C& $#&<'(& >(#>(& <')<& B(@B;(&A)^(& >(#>(& @F& (?@#@A$?& M">$#(>>& )#*&A)=^(<>& $#& <(=A>& @F& <'(&?@><>& F@=& <'(&B=@*"?<$@#&@=& <'(&B"=?')>$#%&B=$?(>&@F&B=@*"?<>& e6@==$>@#G&NOOUq&!"M$#G&KLYXfJ&.$^(V$>(G&>"BB;C&)#*&*(A)#*&)=(&);>@&F(<$>'$i(*&<@&<'(&(E<(#<&<')<&<'(C&B=@H$*(&<'(&F"#*)A(#<);&M)>$>&F@=&B(@B;(b>&"#*(=><)#*$#%&@F&<'(&(?@#@AC&)#*&A)=^(<&*C#)A$?>J&Q$#);;CG& =(;)<$#%& M)?^& <@& <'(& *$>?">>$@#& @F& H);"(G& <'(& $*()& @F& ?@AA@*$<C& F(<$>'$>A& );>@&(#<)$;>& <')<& <'(& A)=^(<& H);"(& @F& )& B=@*"?<& @=& ?@AA@*$<C& $>& V')<& B=(*@A$#)#<;C&*(<(=A$#(>&B(@B;(b>&<'$#^$#%&)#*&B(=?(B<$@#&)#*&'@V&<'(&B=$?(&$>&=(;)<(*&<@&>"BB;C&)#*&*(A)#*&=)<'(=&<')#&<'(&)A@"#<&@F&;)M@=&<')<&V(#<&$#<@&<'(&B=@*"?<&@=&>(=H$?(J&;0+0#%2,5!

!@@<(*&$#&)#)=?'$><&(?@#@A$?>&)#*&')H$#%&$<>&@=$%$#>&$#&<'(&$*()>&)#*&V=$<$#%&@F&B'$;@>@B'(=& 8$(==(Ro@>(B'& 8=@"*'@#G& <'(& #@<$@#& @F& A"<");$>A& $#& <'(& ?@#<(E<& @F&(?@#@A$?>& $>&M)>(*&@#&)#&"#*(=><)#*$#%&@F&H);"(& $#& <(=A>&@F& ;)M@=G&);>@&=(F(==(*&<@&)>&<'(&)F@=(A(#<$@#(*& ;)M@=& <'(@=C&@F&H);"(J&S'(#&>(;;$#%& ;)M@=&@=& $<>&B=@*"?<G& <'(&%@@*G&?@AA@*$<C&@=&B=@*"?<&=(?($H(*&$#&(E?')#%(&>'@";*&(AM@*C&@=&$AB;$?)<(&<'(&(E)?<&>)A(&)A@"#<& @F& ;)M@=& )#*& "<$;$<C& <')<& V)>& #(?(>>)=C& <@& B=@*"?(& <'(& <=)*(*& (#<$<C& e,@'(#G&KLNYfJ& 7#&=(;)<$@#&<@&A"<");$>AG&<'(&#@<$@#&@F&=(?$B=@?$<C&)#*&A"<");&)$*&)>&*(H(;@B(*&MC& <'(&!">>$)#& <'(@=$><&8(<(=&j=@B@<^$#&C$(;*>&)#&)**$<$@#);& ;(#>& F@=&)& ?@AB=('(#>$H(&)#*& *$FF(=(#<$)<(*& ?@#>$*(=)<$@#& @F& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%J& \(>$*(>& *(H(;@B$#%& <'(& $*()&<')<&A"<");& )$*& )#*& =(?$B=@?$<C& )=(& $#<=$#>$?& (;(A(#<>& @F& >A);;& >@?$(<$(>G& ?";<"=(>& )#*&

Page 21: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

KY&

?@AA"#$<$(>G& j=@B@<^$#b>& )=%"A(#<& $>& ><=@#%(><& )#*& A@><& )BB;$?)M;(& <@& <'(& B=(>(#<&><"*C&$#&$<>&?=$<$c"(&@F& $#*$H$*");$>A&)#*&$#*$H$*");$><$?&?";<"=(&<'=@"%'&<'(&B=@A@<$@#&@F& A"<");& )$*& $#& >@?$(<C& e0#%(;M(=<G& NOKNfJ& S'(=()>& <'(>(& (;(A(#<>& )=(& B(=<$#(#<& <@&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A@*(;>G&$<&$>&$AB@=<)#<&<@&#@<(&<')<&<'(&)#)=?'$?R?@AA"#$><&$*()>&)#*& (;(A(#<>& @F& j=@B@<^$#b>& <'(@=$(>& )#*& <'$#^$#%& )=(& #@<& $#& ;$#(& V$<'& <'$>& B)B(=b>&?@#?(B<");$i)<$@#&)#*&)BB=@)?'&=(%)=*$#%&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%J&4&52*2,+!+3&'.=!!

\(>$*(>& =(?$B=@?$<C& )#*&A"<");$>AG& F(A$#$><& <'(@=C& );>@& B=@H$*(>& )#& $#>$%'<F";&B(=>B(?<$H(& @#& 8S9S& )#*& <'(& ?";<"=(>& )#*& (?@#@A$?>& @F& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%J& 7#&B)=<$?";)=G&:$M>@#R:=)')A&eNOONG&NOOUf&$>&(>B(?$);;C&$#F@=A)<$H(&F@=&<'(&B=(>(#<&><"*CJ&1'(& )=%"(>& <')<& (?@#@A$?& A@*(;>& )=(& #@<& *$?'@<@A@">& @=& M$#)=CG& M"<& F);;& );@#%& )&>B(?<="A& @F& B@>>$M$;$<$(>J& 0)?'& M">$#(>>G& $#*"><=CG& @=& (?@#@AC& ?@AM$#(>& <'(>(&B@>>$M$;$<$(>&*$FF(=(#<;CG& >@& <'(=(& $>&#@&@#(& <="(&?)B$<);$>AG&#@=&)=(& <'(=(& _);<(=#)<$H(>`&B(=&>(J&8S9S&F$<>&>@"#*;C&$#<@&<'$>&F=)A(V@=^J&/'@"%'&#@<&)&A)$#><=()A&<=(#*&$#&<'(&%)><=@#@A$?& =(><)"=)#<& $#*"><=CG& )& F)$=& )A@"#<& @F& =(><)"=)#<>& (AB;@C& <'(&A@*(;&V$<'&%@@*&>"??(>>J&7<&A)C&#@<&M(&?@AB;(<(;C&>?);)M;(&V$<'$#&?"==(#<&(?@#@A$?&$*(@;@%CG&M"<&$#&;$#(& V$<'& :$M>@#R:=)')Al>& eNOOUf& F=)A(V@=^G& $<& *@(>& #@<& ')H(& <@& M(& D& $<& >$AB;C&(E(AB;$F$(>&)#@<'(=&(?@#@A$?&B@>>$M$;$<CJ& 7<& $>& $AB@=<)#<& <@&#@<(&'@V&<'$>& F=((>&">&C@"&F=@A&')H$#%&<@&*(>?=$M(&8S9S&)>&);<(=#)<$H(G&@=&)>&>@A('@V&$#F(=$@=&@=&>"M@=*$#)<(&<@&>(;;(=RM)>(*&A@*(;>J&

9&,&#.13!:0&,+2'*,!

\)>(*& @#& <'(& )M@H(& =(H$(V& @F& ;$<(=)<"=(& )#*& <'(& <'(@=(<$?);& F=)A(V@=^G& <'(&F@;;@V$#%&=(>()=?'&c"(><$@#>&)=(&B@>(*J&

Kf h@V& $>& <'(& 8S9S& A@*(;& ">(*& $#& =(><)"=)#<>& $#& <'(& -1& )#*&:(=A)#C]2"><=$)W&

Nf S')<& )=(& <'(& ?";<"=(>G&A()#$#%>& )#*&A@<$H)<$@#>& $#& <(=A>&@F& B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A@*(;>&$#&=(><)"=)#<>&$#&<'(&-1&)#*&:(=A)#CW&

;&+3'/'%'<=!

2& A$E(*& A(<'@*>& )BB=@)?'& V)>& ?'@>(#& F@=& <'(& B=(>(#<& ><"*C& <@& ?)B<"=(& <'(&A)E$A"A& )A@"#<& @F& $#F@=A)<$@#& F=@A& <'(& )H)$;)M;(& *)<)& >@"=?(>J& Q$=><G& 7& ?@#*"?<(*&>(?@#*)=C& )#);C>$>& @F& (EB(=$A(#<& )#*& >"=H(C& *)<)& F=@A& B=(H$@">& ><"*$(>& @#&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&$#&<'=((&:(=A)#&=(><)"=)#<>&ej$A&(<&);JG&NOOZfJ&Q@=&<'(&A@><&B)=<G&<'(& *)<)& V)>& ">(*& <@& M"$;*& )& <'(@=(<$?);& F=)A(V@=^& F@=& <'(& B=(>(#<& ><"*C& =(%)=*$#%&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A(?')#$>A>J&/@&%"$*(&$#<(=H$(V&c"(><$@#>&)#*&)#);C>$>G&7&">(*&j$A&(<& );Jl>& eNOKOf& =(%=(>>$@#& A@*(;G& V'$?'& c")#<$<)<$H(;C& (E)A$#(>& <'(& $#F;"(#?(& @F&

Page 22: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

KZ&

?"><@A(=>b& ;@C);<CG& F)$=#(>>G& );<="$>AG& B=$?(& ?@#>?$@">#(>>G& $#?@A(G& >)<$>F)?<$@#& )#*&=(F(=(#?(&B=$?(>&@#&<'(&B=$?(&*$>?')=%(*&<@&<'(&>(;;(=&"#*(=&8S9S&?@#*$<$@#>J&

1(?@#*G&>(A$R><="?<"=(*G&c");$<)<$H(&$#<(=H$(V>&V(=(&?@#*"?<(*&V$<'&<'(&'(;B&@F&)& c"(><$@#& ?)<);@%"(& e2BB(#*$E& Kf& <@& %(<& )#& $#R*(B<'& "#*(=><)#*$#%& @F& <'(&A()#$#%>G&B=)?<$?(>& )#*& A@<$H)<$@#>& )=@"#*& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%& ej$#%G& KLLLfJ& 7#?;"*$#%& F@"=&:(=A)#&)#*&F@"=&-1&2A(=$?)#&=(>B@#*(#<>G&($%'<&$#<(=H$(V>&V$<'&)#&)H(=)%(&;(#%<'&@F&PY& A$#"<(>& V(=(& ?@#*"?<(*& V$<'& F@"=& F(A);(& )#*& F@"=& A);(& @V#(=>& @=& A)#)%(=>& @F&=(><)"=)#<>& @=& F@@*& <="?^>& V$<'& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%& A@*(;>J& /'(& B)=<$?$B)<$#%&=(><)"=)#<>& $#?;"*(*& <'(& <&*=# =(><)"=)#<& $#& Q=)#^F"=<G& :(=A)#CG& >%"8:%# ?:8%;@# A8:#9&8"8:#A88)%"#$#&T$(##)G&2"><=$)G&<'(&98&"8:8&#$#&3s=#M(=%G&:(=A)#CG&<'(&?8228:#9(:0;#4%56# $#& h$%';)#*& 8)=^G& 3oG& B%"%4%56# $#& j=(A>G& 2"><=$)G& >1"C08D*# F@@*& <="?^& $#& .@>&2#%(;(>G& ,2G& )#*&+,-.#4%56# $#&4(#H(=G& ,5J& 1$E& $#<(=H$(V>&V(=(&'(;*& H$)& 1^CB(G& @#(& $#&B(=>@#& )#*& @#(& =(>B@#*(#<& )#>V(=(*& <'(& c"(><$@#>& H$)& (A)$;J& S'(=(& )BB;$?)M;(G&=(?@=*(*& $#<(=H$(V>& V(=(& <=)#>?=$M(*& )#*& ;)<(=& (#<(=(*& $#<@& 3T$H@& >@F<V)=(G& V'(=(&<'(A)<$?& ?@*$#%& )#*& )#);C>$>& V)>& B(=F@=A(*J& /'$>& F@=A(*& <'(& M)>$>& F@=& )%%=(%)<$#%&<'(A)<$?&#@*(>&)#*&?;"><(=$#%&@B$#$@#>G&<'(A(>&)#*&B)<<(=#>&V$<'&A$#$A);&@H(=;)B&F@=&>"M>(c"(#<&)#);C>$>&)#*&<'(@=(<$?);&(E<=)B@;)<$@#&eh)AA(=>;(C&k&2<^$#>@#G&KLZXq&j$#%&k&h@==@?^>G&NOKOfJ&

/V@&B(=>@#);&$#<(=H$(V>&D&@#(&@F&V'$?'&V)>&)#>V(=(*&H$)&(A)$;&D&V$<'&@#(&A);(&)#*&@#(&F(A);(&=(>B@#*(#<&V(=(&'(;*&V$<'&?"><@A(=>&@F&<'(&>1"C08E*&F@@*&<="?^&">$#%&)&>(?@#*&c"(><$@#&?)<);@%"(&e2BB(#*$E&NfJ&/'(&=(>B@#*(#<>&F=@A&<'(&?"><@A(=&>$*(&V(=(&=(?="$<(*&*"=$#%&B)=<$?$B)#<&@M>(=H)<$@#G&V'$?'&V)>&">(*&)>&)&?@AB;$A(#<)=C&A(<'@*&<@&<'(&$#<(=H$(V>J&&

0<'#@%=)B'$?& B)=<$?$B)#<& @M>(=H)<$@#& @F& B"=?')>$#%& )#*& >(;;$#%& "#*(=&8S9S]8)CR9@"=RQ)$=R1')=(&?@#*$<$@#>&V)>&(AB;@C(*&<@&%(<&$AA(=>(*&)#*&$#H@;H(*&$#&<'(& ?";<"=(& )#*& B=)?<$?(& @F& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%& F=@A& )& ?"><@A(=b>& B(=>B(?<$H(J&8)=<$?$B)#<& @M>(=H)<$@#>& ?@#>$><(*& @F& <V@& *)C>& @F& *$=(?<& @M>(=H)<$@#& )#*& $#F@=A);&$#<(=H$(V>& V$<'& ?"><@A(=>& @F& <'(& 8C#%;(b>& F@@*& <="?^G& ;@?)<(*& #()=& <'(& -#$H(=>$<C& @F&1@"<'(=#&,);$F@=#$)&,)AB">&)#*&#()=&<'(&S(><&.@>&2#%(;(>&6(*$?);&,(#<(=G&=(>B(?<$H(;CG&M@<'& ;@?)<$@#>&M($#%& $#&.@>&2#%(;(>G&,2J&8)=<$?$B)#<&@M>(=H)<$@#&>(=H(*&<'(&B"=B@>(&@F&<)BB$#%& $#<@& *$FF(=(#<G& B@<(#<$);;C& ?@#F;$?<$#%& )>B(?<>& )#*& )AM$H);(#?(& M(<V((#&=(B=(>(#<)<$@#>G& <'(& >@?$);& A()#$#%>& )#*& M(')H$@=>& =(%)=*$#%& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%&e4(S);<G& 4(S);<G& k&S)C;)#*G& KLLZfJ& 2&A@*(=)<(& <CB(& @F& B)=<$?$B)#<& @M>(=H)<$@#&V)>&(AB;@C(*& <@& )?'$(H(& )& >@"#*& M);)#?(& M(<V((#& F="$<F";& $#H@;H(A(#<& )#*& #(?(>>)=C&*$><)#?(&<@&<'(&>"Mg(?<>&F@=&<'(&=(>()=?'(=&<@&=(A)$#&@Mg(?<$H(&e2<^$#>@#&k&h)AA(=>;(CG&KLLPq&4(S);<& (<& );JG& KLLZfJ&/'(&%@);&V)>& <@&%(<& )#& $#>$*(=&B(=>B(?<$H(&MC& F@=& (E)AB;(&

Page 23: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

KL&

M"C$#%&B=@*"?<>&"#*(=&8S9S&?@#*$<$@#>&)>&)&=(>()=?'(=G&M"<&)<&<'(&>)A(&<$A(&A)$#<)$#&<'(& =@;(& @F& <'(& @Mg(?<$H(& )#*& >"FF$?$(#<;C& *(<)?'(*& @"<>$*(=& F@=& <'(& =(>()=?'& <@& M(&"#M$)>(*&)#*&#("<=);J&

9&,0%+,!#*/!>2,10,,2'*!

B.'1&/0.&,!#*/!5&#*2*<,!'(!8#.+2128#+'.=!8.212*<!

/'(&H)=$@">&F@=A>&@F&*)<)&?@;;(?<$@#&C$(;*(*&)&=$?'&)==)C&@F&=(>";<>J&2<&A8:#9&8"8:#A88)%"G&<'(&B'$;@>@B'C&)=@"#*&<'(&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A(?')#$>A&@F&8S9S&@=&_8)CR2>R9@"RS$>'`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c")<(J`&&

2?=@>>&<'(&M@)=*G&=(><)"=)#<&@V#(=>&=(B@=<(*&<')<&<'(&A)g@=$<C&@F&?"><@A(=>&$>&)M;(&<@&F$#*&)&F)$=&B=$?(G&V'$?'&$>&V'C&@H(=);;G&<'(&M);)#?(&$>&'(;*&)#*&<'(&M">$#(>>(>&)=(&>"><)$#)M;(J&2<&<'(&?8228:#9(:0;#4%56#$#&3(V&o(=>(CG&F@=&(E)AB;(G&)M@"<&N[r&@F&<'(&<$A(&B(@B;(&B)C&A@=(&<')#&<'(&>"%%(><(*&B=$?(J&&

/'(& ">");& B=@?(*"=(& $#& <'(& =(><)"=)#<>& )#*& <'(& F@@*& <="?^& *$FF(=>& >;$%'<;C& $#&<(=A>&@F& g)=%@#&)#*&<(=A$#@;@%CJ&5#&<'(&@#(&')#*G&@FF$?$);;C&#@#RB=@F$<&M">$#(>>(>& ;$^(&<'(&?8228:#9(:0;#4%56#$#&3(V&o(=>(C&@=&<'(&+,-.#4%56#$#&4(#H(=&">(&<'(&V@=*&*@#)<$@#&$#&<'($=&>B)?(>J&,"><@A(=>&?)#&A)^(&*@#)<$@#>&)#*&$#&<'(&?8228:#9(:0;#4%56@#>"%%(><(*&B=$?(>& )=(&A(#<$@#(*& )<& <'(& ?@"#<(=J& ,@#<=)=$;CG& <'(&B'$;@>@B'C& )#*& >(<& "B& )<&>1"C08E*#F@@*&<="?^#$>&*$FF(=(#<J&/'(&@V#(=&@F&<'(&F@@*&<="?^&>)$*+&_7&*@#b<&">(&<'(&V@=*&*@#)<$@#&M(?)">(&7&)A&#@<&)&#@#RB=@F$<&@=%)#$i)<$@#G&)#*&<'(=(&$>&#@&@"<>$*(&F"#*$#%J&7&);>@&*@#b<&>((&$<&)>&M)=<(=$#%&M(?)">(&7&*@#b<&(H(=&B">'&M)?^&@#&AC&?"><@A(=>J`&/'(&>)A(&%@(>&F@=&A8:#9&8"8:#A88)%"@#V'@>(&@V#(=&);>@&?@#F$=A(*&<')<&<'(C&*@&#@<&)>>@?$)<(&<'(A>(;H(>&V$<'& )#C& ^$#*& @F& *@#)<$@#RM)>(*& A@*(;J& 7<& M(?)A(& ?;()=& F=@A& <'(& $#<(=H$(V>& V$<'&@V#(=>& )#*& ?"><@A(=>G& '@V(H(=G& <')<& <'(=(& $>& )#& (;(A(#<& <@& M)=<(=$#%& )#*& *@#)<$@#>&<')<&B(@B;(&=(;)<(&<@&V'(#&<'(C&)=(&<=C$#%&<@&*$%(><&)#*&"#*(=><)#*&<'(&?@AB;(<(&?@#<=@;&@H(=&<'(&B=$?(&<'(C&)=(&B)C$#%&$#&8S9S&@=&8)CR9@"=RQ)$=R1')=(J&2>>@?$)<$@#>&)#*&;$#^>&V$<'&F)A$;$)=&?@#?(B<>&>"?'&)>&M)=<(=$#%&>((A&<@&'(;B&A)#C&B(@B;(&<')<&)=(&"#F)A$;$)=&V$<'&8S9S&)#*&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%J&?'=#%+=!

,"><@A(=& ;@C);<C& >((A>& <@& M(& )& ?="?$);;C& $AB@=<)#<& F)?<@=& F@=& )& F"#?<$@#$#%&8S9S&A@*(;J& 7#& %(#(=);G& =(><)"=)#<& @V#(=>& );;& =(B@=<(*& F=(c"(#<& @"<;$(=>& )M@H(& )#*&

Page 24: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

NO&

M(;@V& <'(&A()#G& M"<& <'(&@H(=);;& )H(=)%(&B=$?(&B)$*&"#*(=&8S9S&?@#*$<$@#>& $>& ><)M;(G&V'$?'&$>&_M)>(*&@#&)&><=@#%&%=@"B&@F&;@C);&?"><@A(=&V'@&?@A(&$#&>(H(=);&<$A(>&)&V((^G`&)>&@#(&=(><)"=)#<&@V#(=&>)$*J&Q@=&>1"C08E*#F@@*&<="?^G&<'(&;@C);&?"><@A(=>&A)^(&"B&_NORXOr&@F&<'(&*)$;C&=(H(#"(`G&V'$?'&$>&)&>$%#$F$?)#<&)A@"#<J&

&5#&<'(&@#(&')#*G&<'(>(&F$#*$#%>&(?'@&j$A&(<&);Jl>&eNOOZf&?;)$A>&<')<&;@C);<C&B;)C>&)&=@;(&=(%)=*$#%&<'(&B=$?(&*$>?')=%(*&<@&<'(&>(;;(=J&h@V(H(=G&=)<'(=&<')#&$#?=()>$#%&<'(&B=$?(&*$>?')=%(*&<@&<'(&=(><)"=)#<G&)>&)=%"(*&M(F@=(G&<'(&?"==(#<&><"*Cb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b&B=$?(&B@$#<&=(A)$#(*&><)M;(&>;$%'<;C&)M@H(&)H(=)%(J&

2#@<'(=&=(?"==(#<&<'(A(&)A@#%&=(><)"=)#<&@V#(=>&)>&V(;;&)>&?"><@A(=>&V)>&<'(&#@<$@#&@F&>(;FR>"><)$#)M$;$<CJ&/'(&@V#(=>&B(=?($H(*&<'(&A)g@=$<C&@F&;@C);&?"><@A(=>&<@&M(&?@#>?$@">&)M@"<&A)$#<)$#$#%& <'(&=(><)"=)#<& F@=& <'(A>(;H(>&)#*&?@#<=$M"<$#%& <'($=&B)=<&$#&@=*(=&<@&M(&)M;(&<@&?@A(&M)?^&)#*&(#g@C&<'(&F@@*&)<&<'(>(&B=$?(>J&8"<&*$FF(=(#<;CG&<'(&_;@C);& ?"><@A(=>& B)$*& <'(& B=$?(& <'(C& <'$#^& V$;;& ^((B& <'(& M">$#(>>& %@$#%G`& )>& @#(& -1&=(><)"=)#<& @V#(=& (EB;)$#(*J& /'$>& >)A(& #@<$@#& V)>& )BB)=(#<& )A@#%& <'(& %=@"B& @F&@M>(=H(*&?"><@A(=>G&V'@&?@#F$=A(*& <')<& <'(C&V(=(& _<=C$#%& <@&B)C&(#@"%'& <@&^((B& <'(&M">$#(>>&);$H(`&>@&<'(C&?@";*&?@A(&M)?^&)#*&()<&)<&8S9S&B=$?(>G&V'$?'&<'(C&B(=?($H(*&<@&M(&;@V(=&<')#&<'(&A)=^(<&><)#*)=*&F@=&>$A$;)=&B=@*"?<>J&)'550*2+=!#*/!,'12#%!258#1+!

2<&A8:#9&8"8:#A8)%%"@#<'(&=$?$#%&A@*(;&V)>&)&=(>";<&@F&<'(&@V#(=b>&?@AA$<A(#<&<@&?=()<(&)#&_)??(>>$M;(G&$#?;">$H(&>B)?(&F@=&?@AA"#$<C&V'(=(&#@M@*C&$>&(E?;"*(*&M)>(*&@#& (?@#@A$?& )M$;$<C& @=& $#?@A(J`& 5#(& @F& <'(& F@"#*(=>G& )& ><"*(#<& )<& <'(& <$A(&V'(#& <'(&=(><)"=)#<&V)>&F@"#*(*G&>)$*+&_S'(#&V(&@B(#(*&<'(&=(><)"=)#<G&V(&V)#<(*&@"=>(;H(>&<@&M(& )M;(& <@& M(& @"=& ?"><@A(=>J`& h(#?(& <'(& $#?;">$H(& B=$?$#%& A@*(;& <')<& *@(>& #@<&*$>?=$A$#)<(&)%)$#><&%=@"B>&V$<'&;@V(=&$#?@A(>&@=&>@?$@R(?@#@A$?&><)<">J&6@=(@H(=G&$#&;$#(&V$<'& >(H(=);&@<'(=& =(><)"=)#<>& ><"*$(*&*"=$#%& F$(;*V@=^G& <'(&)>B(?<&@F& ?@AA"#$<C&V)>& <$(*& <@& _'(;B$#%& ()?'& @<'(=G& ?@A$#%& <@%(<'(=& )#*& ?=()<$#%& )& %=@"B& <')<& <'$#^>&?@AA"#$<C`G&)>&@#(&-1&=(><)"=)#<&A)#)%(=&B"<&$<J&7<&M(?)A(&?;()=&<')<&A)#C&=(><)"=)#<>&#@<&@#;C&=(;$(*&@#G&M"<&);>@&>@"%'<&<@&$#*"?(&)&?@;;(?<$H(&A$#*>(<&)A@#%&?"><@A(=>&)#*&?@#>"A(=>J&_S(&V)#<&@"=&?"><@A(=>&<@&=();$i(&<')<&@#;C&<@%(<'(=&V(&?)#&M(&V')<&V(&)=(&)#*&?@#<$#"(&<@&*@&V')<&V(&*@J`&&

Page 25: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

NK&

/'$>& ?;()=;C& =(;)<(>& <@& 8(<(=& j=@B@<^$#b>& ?=$<$c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

&Q=@A&<'(&B(=>B(?<$H(&@F& <'(&>(;;(=>G& <'(&)>B(?<&@F&?@AA"#$<C&)#*&>@?$);& $AB)?<&V)>& ><=@#%;C& =(;)<(*& <@& <'(& *$FF(=(#?(& M(<V((#& 8S9S& )#*& 8)CRS')<R9@"R,)#J&0>B(?$);;C&F@=&<'(&=(><)"=)#<>&<')<&)>^&<'($=&?"><@A(=>&<@&B)C&V')<&<'(C&?)#&=)<'(=&<')#&V')<&<'(C&V)#<G&>"?'&)>&>%"8:%G#$<&V)>&>B(?$F$?);;C&)M@"<&_"#*(=><)#*$#%&V')<&C@"&?)#&)FF@=*& )>& @BB@>(*& <@& "#*(=><)#*$#%& V')<& C@"& V)#<& <@& )FF@=*`J& \(>$*(>& <'(& (#)M;$#%&)>B(?<& <')<&);;@V>&B(@B;(&V$<'&>A);;(=&M"*%(<>& <@&(#g@C& <'(&>)A(& F@@*&)>&B(@B;(&V$<'&#@=A);& $#?@A(>G& <'(& (AB')>$>& @#& <'$>& )>B(?<& );>@& $AB;$(>& )& *((B(=& A(>>)%(J& /'$>&A(>>)%(&$>&<)=%(<(*&)<&);;&?"><@A(=>&)<&)&A@=(&F"#*)A(#<);&;(H(;&$#&<')<&<'(&8)CRS')<R9@"R,)#&B=$?$#%&A@*(;& $>& $#<(#*(*&<@&_A)^(&B(@B;(&<'$#^&)M@"<&<'($=&=@;(&)>&)&?$<$i(#`&)#*&$F& <'(C&?)#&)FF@=*&<@&B)C&)& ;$<<;(&A@=(G& <'(C&>'@";*&*@&>@& $#&@=*(=&<@&'(;B&>@A(@#(&V'@& ?)##@<J& 7<& $>& '(=(& V'(=(& <'(& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%& A@*(;b>& B@<(#<$);& F@=& ?$H$?&(#%)%(A(#<&)#*&)?<$H)<$@#&>"=F)?(>J&

&7#& <'(&-1G& )& ?@AA@#&A@<$H)<$@#& F@=& <'(& (><)M;$>'A(#<& @F& )& =(><)"=)#<& @=& F@@*&<="?^&V$<'&)&B=$?$#%&A@*(;&V$<'&?"><@A(=&B=$?(&?@#<=@;&>((A>&<@&M(&'"#%(=&)#*&;)?^&@F&)??(>>&<@&'();<'C&F@@*J&/'(&A)g@=$<C&@F&=(><)"=)#<&@V#(=>&H@$?(*&<'($=&?@#?(=#&V$<'&<'(&F@@*&>$<")<$@#&$#&<'($=&;@?);&?@AA"#$<$(>&@=&A@=(&%(#(=);;C&)?=@>>&<'(&-1J&2#&$#<(=(><$#%&A(<)B'@=&=(%)=*$#%&<'$>&>$<")<$@#&$#&<'(&.2&)=()&V)>&<'(&_F@@*&*(>(=<J`&

_7F& C@"& ;@@^& )<& <'(& )H)$;)M$;$<C& @F& F=(>'& )#*& '();<'CG& >"><)$#)M;(&F@@*& $#& )& #($%'M@='@@*& >"?'& )>& 1)#<)& 6@#$?)& @=& \(H(=;C& h$;;>G&C@"&')H(&)&V$*(&H)=$(<C&@F&@B<$@#>J&7F&C@"&;$H(&$#&)&#($%'M@='@@*&@H(=& '(=(& e-1,& )=()fG& @=& 4@V#<@V#& .@>& 2#%(;(>G& V'$?'& $>& <'(&;)#*& @F& <'(& *=$H(RMC& )#*& <'(& *=$H(R<'=@"%'G& )#*& );>@&V'(#& C@"&;$H(&$#&<'@>(&)=()>&V'(=(&C@"&')H(&<@&<=)H(;&;)=%(&*$><)#?(>&<@&%(<&'();<'C&)#*&F=(>'&>"><)$#)M;(&F="$<>G&<')<b>&V'(=(&V')<&7&?);;&F@@*&*(>(=<>&)=(&;@?)<(*G&V'(=(&C@"&')H(&<@&%@&@"<>$*(&@F&C@"=&>B'(=(G&C@"=&;@?)<$@#&g"><&<@&')H(&)??(>>&<@&<'(>(&<CB(>&@F&@B<$@#>J`&

Page 26: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

NN&

/'(&>1"C08E*#F@@*&<="?^&<=$(>&<@&?@H(=&<'(>(&_F@@*&*(>(=<>`&>$#?(&<'(C&);>@&<(#*&<@&')H(& B@B";)<$@#>& V$<'& V()^(=& )H(=)%(& >@?$@R(?@#@A$?& ><)<">G& B)=<$?";)=;C& $#?@A(G& $#&@=*(=&<@&B=@H$*(&)??(>>&<@&F=(>'G&'();<'C&)#*&>"><)$#)M;(&B=@*"?<>J&/=)#>B@=<)<$@#&?@><>&)#*& <=)H(;& <$A(& <@& %(<& @"<& @F& <'(& _F@@*& *(>(=<>`& @F<(#& ^((B& B(@B;(& F=@A& A)^$#%& <'(&'();<'C&?'@$?(G& ;(<&);@#(& <'(& F)?<& <')<& F=(>'G&"#B=@?(>>(*& F@@*& <(#*>& <@&M(&>$%#$F$?)#<;C&A@=(& (EB(#>$H(& <')#& B=@?(>>(*& ?@#H(#$(#?(& @=& F)><RF@@*J& 0H(#& $#& >"BB@>(*;C& A@=(&)FF;"(#<& )=()>G& >"?'& )>& 1)#<)& 6@#$?)& $#& .@>& 2#%(;(>G& <'(=(& $>& )& _H(=C& ;)=%(& '@A(;(>>&B@B";)<$@#G& )#*& >@& <'(C& %$H(& A(& V')<(H(=& ?')#%(& <'(C& ')H(G& )#*& ?;()=;C& 7bA& ;@@>$#%&A@#(C&@#&<')<&*();G&M"<&@<'(=V$>(&<'(C&V@";*&#@<&')H(&)??(>>&)<&);;&)#*&$<&)H(=)%(>&@"<&V$<'&<'(&F;(E$M;(&B=$?$#%&A@*(;G`&)??@=*$#%&<@&<'(&@V#(=&@F&<'(&>1"C08E*#F@@*&<="?^J&/'$>&>'@V>&<')<&$#&>@A(&$#><)#?(G&<'(&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A@*(;&;$<(=);;C&(#)M;(>&(E?;"*(*&%=@"B>&<@&B)=<$?$B)<(&$#&>@?$(<C&)#*&=(%)$#&?(=<)$#&B=$H$;(%(>J&

7#&)&>@?$@R%(@%=)B'$?&?@#<(E<G&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A@*(;>&A)C&M(&$#>$%'<F";&<@&A)B& #($%'M@='@@*>& )#*& (?@#@A$?& )??(>>& $#& )& >B)<$);& >(#>(& >$#?(& <'(& A)g@=$<C& @F&M">$#(>>&@V#(=>&$#<(=H$(V(*&F@=&<'$>&><"*C&?'@>(&)&;@?)<$@#&V'(=(&<'(C&>)V&<'(&#((*&<@&M)<<;(& <'(& ;)?^& @F& (c");& )??(>>& <@& '();<'C& F@@*J& 6@=(@H(=G& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%&M">$#(>>(>&A)C&);>@&(AM@*C&>@A(&F@=A&@F&?@"#<(=&?";<"=(&<')<&(EB@>(>&)&>(<&@F& ;)=%(=&>@?$(<);&B=@M;(A>&>"?'&)>&>B)<$);&)#*&(?@#@A$?&$#(c");$<C&$#&<=)#>$<$@#);&#($%'M@='@@*>&)>&V(;;&)>&(?@#@A$?&*$>?=$A$#)<$@#& $#& <'(& F@@*& $#*"><=C&)#*&c"(><$@#)M;(&);;@?)<$@#&@F&%@H(=#A(#<&)#*&B=$H)<(&F"#*$#%&<@&B=@*"?<$@#&$#*"><=$(>&<')<&>"BB;C&?'()B&B=@*"?<>&<@&<'(&F)><RF@@*&)#*&B=@?(>>(*&F@@*>&$#*"><=$(>J&&

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

Q@><(=$#%& )& ?";<"=(& @F& >')=(*& >@?$);& =(>B@#>$M$;$<C& $#& >@A(& $#><)#?(>G&B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%& );>@& >((A>& <@& $AB;C& <'(& (;(A(#<>& @F& A"<");& '(;BG& ?@AA"#$<C&$AB)?<&)#*&=(?$B=@?$<CG&V'$?'&V(=(&@F<(#&)<<)?'(*&<@&<'(&=(><)"=)#<>&)#*&<'($=&A$>>$@#>&)#*& A@<$H)<$@#>J& 5#(& =(><)"=)#<& @V#(=& (AB')>$i(*& <')<& _(H(=C@#(& $>& V(;?@A(& F@=& )&A();G&)#*&$<&)&;$<<;(&M$<&;$^(&C@"&)=(&'(;B$#%&@<'(=>&$F&C@"&?)#&)#*&@<'(=>&V$;;&'(;B&C@"&$F&C@"& #((*& $<G& )#*& <')<b>& '@V& V(& );;& M(#(F$<& V$<'@"<& A"?'& >)?=$F$?(J`& ,');;(#%$#%& <'(&#@<$@#& <')<& M">$#(>>(>& B=$@=$<$i(& $#*$H$*");& M(#(F$<>& )#*& ?@AB(<$<$@#& $#& <'(& A)=^(<&B;)?(G& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%& =(>$*(>& V$<'$#& )& >B)?(& V'(=(& =(?$B=@?);& (E?')#%(& @F&=(>@"=?(>G&;)M@=&)#*&>(=H$?(>&F@=&A"<");&M(#(F$<&<(#*&<@&$AM"(&<'(&A@*">&@B(=)#*$J&

Page 27: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

NX&

)0%+0.&!

2<&A8:#9&8"8:#A88)%"@#)#& $#<(=(><$#%& ?";<"=);& *$A(#>$@#& )BB)=(#<;C& ;(*& <@& <'(&$#<=@*"?<$@#& @F& <'(& );<(=#)<$H(& B=$?$#%& A@*(;J& 5=$%$#);;C& F=@A& 8)^$><)#G& @#(& @F& <'(&F@"#*(=>& M=@"%'<& <'(& $#F;"(#?(& @F& 8)^$><)#$& ?";<"=(J& 2BB)=(#<;CG& $#& 8)^$><)#G& _B=$?(& $>&>((#&)>&)&M)>$>&F@=&M)=<(=G&)&><)=<$#%&B@$#<&F@=&#(%@<$)<$@#J`&7#&<'$>&?)>(G&<'">G&)&*$FF(=(#<&(?@#@A$?& )#*& ?";<"=);& M)?^%=@"#*& V)>& <'(& $#>B$=)<$@#& F@=& <'(& $AB;(A(#<)<$@#& @F& )&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&);<(=#)<$H(&B=$?$#%&A@*(;&$#&)#&2"><=$)#&=(><)"=)#<J&&

S')<&);>@&(A(=%(*&F=@A&<'(&$#<(=H$(V>&V)>&)&<'(&$AB@=<)#?(&@F&<'(&B;)?(RM)>(*&?";<"=(&e0>?@M)=G&NOOKfG&V'$?'&M(?@A(>&?;()=&V'(#&;@@^$#%&)<&<'(&(E)AB;(>&@F&<'(&+,-.#4%56& $#&4(#H(=&)#*&>1"C08E*#F@@*& <="?^& $#&.@>&2#%(;(>J&2??@=*$#%& <@& <'(&@V#(=>&@F& <'(&+,-.# 4%56G& <'(& ?";<"=(& @F& 4(#H(=& ')>& );V)C>& ?=()<(*& @"<>$*(& <'(& M@E& <'$#^$#%& )#*&$#%(#"$<CG& )>& $<& $>& A@=(& B=@%=(>>$H(& <')#& @<'(=& ?$<$(>J& /'$>& $>& <="(& ?@#>$*(=$#%& <')<&4(#H(=&V)>&<'(&F$=><&?$<C&<@&;(%);$i(&A)=$g")#)&)#*&.@>&2#%(;(>&$>&@#(&@F&<'(&><)<(>&V$<'&<'(& A(*$?);& A)=$g")#)& B=@%=)AJ& /'(=(& )=(& );>@& )& ;@<& @F& A$?=@M=(V(=$(>& )#*& >A);;&M">$#(>>(>& <')<& $AB;(A(#<& ?=()<$H(& V)C>& <@& ^((B& <'(& M">$#(>>(>& ="##$#%J& 7#& .@>&2#%(;(>G& <'(& ;@?);;C& M@@A$#%& g"$?(& ?";<"=(& V)>& );>@& A(#<$@#(*& )>& )#& $AB@=<)#<&?@AB@#(#<&F@=&<'(&>"??(>>&@F&<'(&B=$?$#%&A@*(;J&

7#& <(=A>& @F& #)<$@#);& ?";<"=(G& F"=<'(=& =(>()=?'& V@";*& M(& #((*(*& <@& M(& )M;(& <@&A)^(& ?;)$A>& )M@"<& B@<(#<$);& B)<<(=#>& @=& *C#)A$?>& <')<& "#F@;*& )>& )& F"#?<$@#& @F& -1& @=&:(=A)#& ?";<"=(J& h@V(H(=G& M)>(*& @#& <'(& (AB$=$?);& F$#*$#%>& $#& <'$>& ><"*CG& >$A$;)=&B=)?<$?(>& >((A& <@& (E$><& )?=@>>& ?";<"=(>& $#& 8S9S& =(><)"=)#<>G& $#?;"*$#%& >$A$;)=&A@<$H)<$@#>&)#*&A()#$#%>&)<<)?'(*&<@&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%J&".0,+!

&/'(&#@<$@#&@F&<="><&V)>&)#@<'(=&)>B(?<&@F&?(#<=);&$AB@=<)#?(&<@&<'(&=(><)"=)#<>&V$<'&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A@*(;>J&/="><&$#&)#*&MC&?"><@A(=>&V)>&>((#&)>&<$%'<;C&=(;)<(*&<@&?";<"=);&<=(#*>&@H(=&<'(&B)><&C()=>& $#&<(=A>&@F&<'(&=$>(&@F&<'(&7#<(=#(<G&>@?$);&A(*$)G&)#*&A@=(&=(?(#<;CG&A@M$;(&)BB;$?)<$@#>&>"?'&)>&-M(=G&,@4=$H(=&)#*&2$=M#MJ&&

_9@"b=(& %(<<$#%& $#<@& ><=)#%(=>b& ;$H(>G& '@">(>G& ?)=>G& )#*& <'(& V)C&V(bH(& M((#& $#<(=)?<$#%& @H(=& <'(& 7#<(=#(<& )#*& <(?'#@;@%CG& <')<b>&<'(&=$>(&@F& <'(&>')=$#%&(?@#@ACJ& 7&*@#b<&^#@V&$F& $<b>&)&?)">(&@=&)&>CAB<@A& @F& )& >@?$);& A@H(A(#<& <@V)=*>& >$AB;C& <="><$#%W& 5=&)>^$#%t&)#*&<')<b>&V')<&7&*@G&7&)>^&AC&?"><@A(=>&<@&V=$<(&)&B=$?(&<')<& <'(C&V@";*& ;$^(& <@&%$H(G&)#*& 7&')H(& <="><&)#*& 7&')H(& F)$<'& $#&AC& ?"><@A(=>& )#*& <'(& %@@*#(>>& @F& B(@B;(& <')<& <'(C&V$;;& B)C& )&B=$?(&<')<&F$<>&V$<'$#&<'($=&M"*%(<>J`&

Page 28: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

NP&

/="><&V)>&)&^(C&<'(A(&F@=&A8:#9&8"8:#A88)%"#)>&V(;;J&_S(&%$H(&?=(*$<&)#*&%$H(&M)?^G& M)>(*& @#& <="><G&V(& %$H(& <'(A& )& <="><& ;@)#& )#*& '@B(& <')<& $<& ?@A(>& M)?^J_& h(#?(G&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&>((A>&<@&M(&)&<="><RM)>(*G&B(=>@#);&A@*(;&F@=&(?@#@A$?&(E?')#%(&<')<&=(;$(>&@#&)#*&(A(=%(>&F=@A&A"<");&F)$<'J&B.'/01+O!8.21&!#*/!I#%0&!

2& #"AM(=& @F& $#<(=(><$#%& ?@#><="?<$@#>& @F& H);"(& )#*& B=$?(& (A(=%(*& F=@A& <'(&$#<(=H$(V>&V$<'&<'(&=(><)"=)#<&@V#(=>J&2<&A8:#9&8"8:#A88)%"@#<'(&c"(><$@#&@F&H);"(& $>&<$(*&<@&V')<&)#*&'@V&A"?'&B(@B;(&')H(&()<(#&$#&?@AM$#)<$@#&V$<'&F)$=#(>>G&>)<$>F)?<$@#G&)#*&<'(&)M$;$<C&<@&B)CJ&/'(&@V#(=>&V)#<&B(@B;(&<@&<'$#^&)M@"<&_V')<&$>&<'(&H);"(&@F&<'(&F@@*& <')<& <'(C& )=(& ?@#>"A$#%`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`&

2#& $AB@=<)#<& >$A$;)=$<C& )A@#%& A@><& @F& <'(& $#<(=H$(V(*& =(><)"=)#<& @V#(=>&=(;)<(>&<@&)&?@AA$<<(*&F@?">&@#&)#&(E?(;;(#<&B=@*"?<&=)<'(=&<')#&B=@F$<&A)E$A$i)<$@#J&2&=(?"==(#<& #@<$@#& V)>& <')<& <'(& =(><)"=)#<& @V#(=>& V)#<(*& <@& >)<$>FC& <'(& ?"><@A(=>&B=$A)=$;C&V$<'& <'(&B=@*"?<G& )#*& );>@&V$<'& <'(&B=$?(J& _/'(&B@$#<& $>& #@<& =();;C& F@=&A(& <@&A)^(& )>& A"?'& A@#(C& )>& '"A)#;C& B@>>$M;(J`& /'$>& #@<$@#& ><)#*>& $#& ><)=^& ?@#<=)><& <@&<=)*$<$@#);& (?@#@A$?& <'(@=Cb>&A)E$A&@F&B=@F$<&A)E$A$i)<$@#& $#& ;$#(&V$<'&B(=>@#);& >(;FR$#<(=(><& )#*& );>@& B@>(>& )& ?');;(#%(& <@& <'(&S);;& 1<=((<& ?";<"=(& <')<& $AB;$(>& <'(& %@);& <@&A)^(&)>&A"?'&B=@F$<&)>&'"A)#;C&B@>>$M;(J&&

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

/'(& #@<$@#& @F& H);"(R?@#>?$@">#(>>& )#*& ?');;(#%$#%& <'(& F@?">& @#& A@#(C& );>@&(#<)$;>&B)=);;(;>& <@& <'(&=$>(& $#&B@B";)=$<C&)#*&<=(#*$#(>>&@F& F@@*&<="?^>&);;&@H(=& <'(&-1J&Q@@*&<="?^>&F()<"=(&)&*$FF(=(#<&>@=<&@F&A@*(;&V$<'@"<&F$E(*&=(#<>&)#*&)&*$FF(=(#<&V)C&@F&()<$#%J& 6)#C& B(@B;(& ')H(& ><@BB(*& %@$#%& <@& =(><)"=)#<>& )F<(=& (EB(=$(#?$#%& F$#)#?$);&

Page 29: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

N[&

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

2&=(?"==(#<& <'(A(& $#&);;& $#<(=H$(V>G&M@<'&@#& <'(&>(;;(=&)#*& <'(&M"C(=&>$*(G&V)>&<'(&=(F(=(#?(&B=$?(J&_8(@B;(&">");;C&=(F(=(#?(&@<'(=&(EB(=$(#?(>&@=&(E?')#%(>&<'(C&')*&V$<'&>$A$;)=&B=@*"?<>&)#*&F)?<@=&<')<&$#&$#&<(=A>&@F&"#*(=><)#*$#%&V')<b>&)&F)$=&A)=^(<&H);"(&V'(#&<'(C&B)CJ`&/'$>&?@#F$=A>&B=(H$@">&=(>()=?'&$#&<')<&<'(&=(F(=(#?(&B=$?(&$>&)#&$AB@=<)#<& ?@AB@#(#<& F@=& B(@B;(& <@& *(?$*(& V'$?'& )A@"#<& <@& B)C& V'(#& <'(C& ')H(& <@&*(<(=A$#(&<'(&B=$?(&<'(A>(;H(>&ej$A&(<&);JG&NOOZfJ&/'$>&><"*Cb>&(AB$=$?);&)#);C>$>&>'@V>&<')<& $#& >@A(& ?)>(>G& B=$?(& =(F(=(#?(&B@$#<>& (H(#&B=@H$*(& )& >(#>(&@F& >(?"=$<C& )#*& )$*& <@&)H@$*&)&F((;$#%&@F&=(A@=>(&V'(#&B)C$#%J&\C&<'(&>)A(&<@^(#G&?"><@A(=>&=(B@=<(*&<@&F((;&)&_>(#>(& @F& %"$;<`& );=()*C& M(F@=(& M"C$#%& "#*(=& 8S9S& ?@#*$<$@#>& M(?)">(& <'(C& F(;<& <')<&<'(C&V(=(&="##$#%&<'(&=$>^&@F&B)C$#%&<@@&;$<<;(J&&

/'$>&(?'@(>&0;><(=l>&eKLZLf&)=%"A(#<&)M@"<&>@?$);;C&?@#<$#%(#<&(E?')#%(&#@=A>&$#&*(A@?=)<$?&>@?$(<$(>G&V'$?'&(#<)$;>&B@<(#<$);&(A@<$@#);&*$><=(>>&V'(#&>@?$);&#@=A>&@F&(c");& *$><=$M"<$@#& )=(& H$@;)<(*J& Q"=<'(=A@=(G& =(>";<>& F=@A& <'(& B)=<$?$B)#<& @M>(=H)<$@#&);>@& >"%%(><(*& <')<& B(@B;(& V(=(& H(=C& ?@#?(=#(*& )M@"<& V')<& <'($=& $AA(*$)<(& B((=>b&=()?<$@#& <@& <'(& B(=>@#);& B=$?$#%& *(?$>$@#&V@";*& M(J& 8)=<$?$B)<$#%& $#& <'(& )?<& @F& M"C$#%&"#*(=& 8S9S& ?@#*$<$@#>& >((A(*& <@& (EB@>(& >@A(& ?"><@A(=>& <@& $AA(*$)<(& >@?$);&B=(>>"=(>G&>;$%'<&B(=>@#);&(A@<$@#);&><=(>>&)#*&F()=&@F&*$>)BB=@H);&MC&B((=>G&V'$?'&$>&$#&;$#(& V$<'& B=(H$@">& =(>()=?'& @#& >@?$);& #@=A>& $#& *$><=$M"<$@#& )#*& <=)#>)?<$@#>& e2=$(;CG&\=)?')G&k&6($(=G&NOOLq&0;><(=G&KLZLq&T(#^)<(>)#G&KLUUfJ&

5#(& c"(><$@#& F@=& F"<"=(& =(>()=?'& B(=<)$#>& <@& ?"><@A(=>b& =(;$)#?(& @#& =(F(=(#?(&B=$?(>& V'(#& *(<(=A$#$#%& <'(& @V#& B=$?(& B@$#<& $#& )& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%& >$<")<$@#& )>&>"%%(><(*&MC&<'$>&><"*Cb>&F$#*$#%>&)>&V(;;&)>&MC&j$A&(<&);J&eNOOZG&NOKOfJ&7F&M"C(=>&#((*&=(F(=(#?(& B@$#<>G& *@(>& <')<& $AB;$?$<;C& A()#& #@#R8S9S& @=& #@#RB)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%&A@*(;>& A"><& (E$><W& 7<& ?@";*& M(& )#& $#<(=(><$#%& (EB(=$A(#<& $#& F"<"=(& ><"*$(>& <@& )>>(>>&V'(<'(=&8S9S&)#*&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A@*(;>&?)#&@#;C&(E$><&$#&?@AM$#)<$@#&V$<'G&@=&B(=')B>& (E$><>& )>& )& ?@#>(c"(#?(& @FG& <=)*$<$@#);& B=$?$#%& A@*(;>& V$<'& B=(R*(<(=A$#(*&B=$?(>J&/'$>&%@(>&)<& <'(&'()=<&@F& <'(&'$%';C& =(;(H)#<&)#*&B(=<$#(#<&c"(><$@#&)>& <@&V')<&(E<(#<&<=)*$<$@#);&(?@#@A$?&B=)?<$?(>&)=(&$#%=)$#(*&)#*&(AM(**(*&$#&?";<"=(&>@&B(@B;(&

Page 30: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

NU&

B@<(#<$);;C& ')H(& *$FF$?";<$(>& V'(#& <'(>(& #@=A)<$H(& )>>"AB<$@#>& )#*& B=)?<$?(>& )<& <'(&$#<(=>(?<$@#&@F&?";<"=(&)#*&(?@#@A$?&;$F(&)=(&?');;(#%(*&@=&M=@^(#J&

/'(&c"(><$@#&@F&H);"(&)#*&(E?')#%(&V)>&)#@<'(=&$#<(=(><$#%&)>B(?<&<')<&(A(=%(*&F=@A&<'(&(AB$=$?);&)#);C>$>&@F&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&)>&(AB;@C(*&MC&<'(&=(><)"=)#<>J&2<&<'(&+,-.#4%56# $#&4(#H(=G& ,5& )#*& <'(&?8228:#9(:0;#4%56# $#&h$%';)#*&8)=^G&3o& @FF(=& <'(&?"><@A(=>&V'@&)=(&#@<&)M;(&<@&B)C&<@&*@&H@;"#<((=&V@=^&$#&(E?')#%(&F@=&)&A();J&5#&<'(&@#(& ')#*G& <'$>& (E)AB;(& (E(AB;$F$(>& '@V& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%& A@*(;>& )??@"#<& F@=&'(<(=@%(#($<C&)A@#%&?"><@A(=>&)#*&?=()<(&)&>$<")<$@#&V$<'&(c");&)??(>>&$==(>B(?<$H(&@F&$#?@A(&)#*&F$#)#?$);&)M$;$<CJ&5#&<'(&@<'(=&')#*G&$<&$AB;$(>&)#&)BB=@B=$)<$@#&@F&H);"(&)#*&B=$?(& V'(=(& <'(& ;)M@=& <'(@=C& @F& H);"(& '@;*>& <="(& $#& )& ?@#<(AB@=)=C& >"><)$#)M;(& )#*&B=@F$<)M;(&M">$#(>>&(H(#&<'@"%'&<'(& <'(@=C& $>&>)$*& <@&M(&A@><;C& $#)BB;$?)M;(& <@& <@*)Cb>&F@=A>& @F& (E?')#%(J& 7#& B)=<$?";)=G& <'$>& F@=A& @F& B)C$#%& F@=& )& A();& MC& %$H$#%& M)?^& <'(&)A@"#<&@F& ;)M@=& <')<&V)>&#(?(>>)=C& <@&B=@*"?(&<'(&A();& $AB;$(>& <'(&6)=E$><&#@<$@#&@F&<'(& ;)M@=& <'(@=C&@F&H);"(J&1$A$;)=;CG& <'(& F$#*$#%>&);>@& ><=$#%&)&?'@=*&V$<'& <'(&#@<$@#&@F&A"<");$>A&)#*&=(?$B=@?);&);<="$>AJ&/'(&@V#(=&@F&<'(&?8228:#9(:0;#4%56&(EB;)$#(*+&&

_S(&V)#<&<@&@FF(=&@#(&@F&<'(&A@><&M)>$?&#((*>&<')<&)&B(=>@#&')>G&V'$?'& $>& F@@*G&@=&>"><(#)#?(G&M"<& $#&=(<"=#&V(&V)#<& <@&%$H(&C@"&<'(& @BB@=<"#$<C& <@& *@& M(& )M;(& <@& *@& >@A(<'$#%& $#& (E?')#%(& F@=&<')<G&V'(<'(=&$<b>&B)CG&@=&H@;"#<((=&C@"=&<$A(&@=&C@"=&>^$;;J`&

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i$#%&'@V&F@@*&$>&A)*(&)#*&V')<&^$#*&@F&V@=^&%@(>&$#<@&$<G&>@&$<b>&#@<&@#;C&)M@"<&<'(A&B)=<$?$B)<$#%&$#&F$#*$#%&)&B=$?(G&M"<&);>@&A(#<);;C&$#&)?^#@V;(*%$#%&$<>&?=()<$@#G`&)>&<'(&@V#(=&@F&)&:(=A)#&8S9S&=(><)"=)#<&#@<(*J&/'$>&@B(#>&)&V$#*@V&@F&@BB@=<"#$<C& <@& ?');;(#%(& <'(& F(<$>'$i$#%&@F& ?@AA@*$<$(>& )#*& <'(& )>?=$B<$@#&@F& $#<=$#>$?&H);"(&<@&@F<(#&)=M$<=)=$;C&B=$?(*&%@@*>&)#*&B=@*"?<>J&

S')<&"#$<(>&A@><&=(><)"=)#<&)#*&F@@*&M">$#(>>(>&>"=H(C(*&F@=&<'(&B=(>(#<&><"*C&$>& <'($=& $#<(#<$@#& <@& ?')#%(& <'(& ?"==(#<& B(=?(B<$@#>& @F& (?@#@A$?& $#<(=)?<$@#J& Q@=&(E)AB;(G&<'(&@V#(=&@F&<'(&>1"C08E*&F@@*&<="?^&?@#<(#*(*&<')<&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&)#*&F;(E$M;(&B=$?$#%&$>&)M@"<&_>'$F<$#%&'@V&B(@B;(&)BB=@)?'&<'(&(E?')#%(G&?')#%$#%&B(=>B(?<$H(>&)#*&

Page 31: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

NY&

B(=?(B<$@#>G&)#*&);>@&A)^(&<'(A&(EB(=$(#?(&)&#(V&F@=A&@F&A(=?')#<&(E?')#%(J`&,;()=;CG&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A@*(;>&(E(AB;$FC&)&?');;(#%(&<@&<'(&<=)*$<$@#);&(?@#@A$?&<'(@=C&@F&=)<$@#);&?'@$?(J&2;;&=(><)"=)#<&@V#(=>&@=&A)#)%(=>&>"=H(C(*&F@=&<'$>&><"*C&=(B@=<(*&<@&?@#><)#<;C&')H(&?"><@A(=>&<')<&B)C&)M@H(R)H(=)%(&B=$?(>J&0>>(#<$);;CG&<'(&H(=C&F)?<&<')<&B(@B;(& B)C& )#C<'$#%& %=()<(=& <')#& i(=@& V'(#& <'(C& ')H(& <'(& ?')#?(& <@& B)C& i(=@& F@=& )&B=@*"?<& *$>B=@H(>& =)<$@#);& ?'@$?(& <'(@=C& V$<'$#& <'(& ?@#<(E<& @F& <'$>& ><"*Cb>& =(>()=?'&M(?)">(&=)<$@#);&?'@$?(& <'(@=C&V@";*&B=(*$?<& $#*$H$*");>& <@&);V)C>&A)E$A$i(&B(=>@#);&B=@F$<&$#&B"=>"(&@F&>(;FR$#<(=(><J&/'(&?"><@A(=>b&>')=$#%&A(#<);$<C&)#*&V$;;$#%#(>>&<@&B)C&(H(#&V'(#&#@<&')H$#%& <@&B)C& ?@#<=)*$?<>& =)<$@#);& ?'@$?(& )#*& $;;"><=)<(>& <')<& <'(=(& )=(&@<'(=&A(*$)<$#%&F)?<@=>&)<&V@=^&<')<&$#F;"(#?(&$#*$H$*");&?'@$?(&)#*&B=$?$#%J&

/'(&B=)?<$?(>G&A()#$#%>&)#*&A@<$H)<$@#>&)=@"#*&8S9S&$;;"><=)<(*&$#&<'$>&><"*C&);;@V& F@=& )& =(?@#>$*(=)<$@#& @F& <=)*$<$@#);& (?@#@A$?& <'(@=C& )#*& >"%%(><& <')<& <'(&<=)*$<$@#);& (?@#@A$?& V)C& @F& <'$#^$#%& *@(>& #@<& %(#(=);;C& '@;*& <="(& F@=& );;& >(?<@=>& @F&>@?$(<C&)#*&<'(&A)=^(<B;)?(J&0?@#@A$><>&)=%"(&<')<&$#*$H$*");>&?)=(F";;C&)>>(>>&)#*&<=C&<@& A$#$A$i(& @BB@=<"#$<C& ?@><>& V'(#& A)^$#%& )#& (?@#@A$?& *(?$>$@#J& S'(#& %@$#%& <@& )&=(><)"=)#<G&B(@B;(&">");;C&>B(#*&A@#(C&@#&)&A();&M(?)">(&<'(C&#((*&<@&()<&)#*&(#g@C&<'(&F@@*J&S')<&')BB(#(*G&'@V(H(=G&V'(#&B(@B;(&V(=(&B=@H$*(*&V$<'&<'(&?')#?(&<@&B)C&V')<& <'(C& V)#<(*& *$*& #@<& >((A& <@& F$<& <=)*$<$@#);& (?@#@A$?& <'(@=C& )M@"<& $#*$H$*");&M(')H$@=&)#*&?'@$?(J&S'(#&$#*$H$*");>&')H(&<'(&?')#?(&<@&B)C&aO&<'(&@BB@=<"#$<C&?@><>&@F&B)C$#%&)#C&)A@"#<&)M@H(&aO&)=(&(E<=(A(;C&'$%'J&/'(&)A@"#<&>B(#<&@#&)&F=((&B=@*"?<&?@";*&A"?'&=)<'(=&M(&">(*&F@=&@<'(=&@Mg(?<$H(>&@=&B"=?')>(>&<')<&=(c"$=(&B)CA(#<J&/'(&8S9S&=(><)"=)#<>G&'@V(H(=G&H(=C&=)=(;C&=(B@=<(*&<')<&?"><@A(=>&B)$*&#@<'$#%&)<&);;&F@=&<'(&A();>&<')<&<'(C&?@#>"A(*G&M@<'&$#&<'(&-1&)#*&$#&:(=A)#CJ&&B.21&,O!,088%=!#*/!/&5#*/!

/=)*$<$@#);&(?@#@A$?& <'(@=Cb>& F@?">&@#& <'(&@BB@=<"#$<C&?@><&@F&?'@$?(>&)#*& <'(&A)E$A$i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

8S9S& F"#?<$@#>& )>& )#& );<(=#)<$H(& B=$?$#%& A@*(;& <')<& ?');;(#%(>& <=)*$<$@#);&(?@#@A$?& <'(@=C& )M@"<& <'(& *(<(=A$#$><$?G& ?)">);& =(;)<$@#>'$B& M(<V((#& >"BB;C& )#*&*(A)#*& ;(H(;>& )#*& B=@*"?<& B=$?(>J& /'(& =(><)"=)#<>& ><"*$(*& F@=& <'$>& B)B(=& )=(& ?;()=&(E)AB;(>& @F& )& #@#R<=)*$<$@#);& M(')H$@=);& =(;)<$@#>'$B& M(<V((#& B=$?(& )#*& >"BB;C& )#*&

Page 32: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

NZ&

*(A)#*& ;(H(;>G& >'@V$#%& <')<& B=$?(>& $#& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%& >$<")<$@#>& *@& #@<& >((A& <@&);V)C>&$#?=()>(&V'(#&*(A)#*&%@(>&"B&)#*&>"BB;C&;(H(;>&=(A)$#&?@#><)#<J&Q@=&(E)AB;(G&>(H(=);& $#<(=H$(V(*& =(><)"=)#<& @V#(=>& =(B@=<(*& )#& $#?=()>(& $#& ?"><@A(=>& *"=$#%& <'(&(?@#@A$?& =(?(>>$@#& )=@"#*& NOOZJ& \@<'& $#& :(=A)#C& )#*& $#& <'(& -1G& B(@B;(& ?)A(&A@=(&F=(c"(#<;C&<@&A)^(&">(&@F&<'(&F@@*&B=@H$>$@#&V'(=(&<'(C&?@";*&>(;FR*(<(=A$#(&<'(&B=$?(J&2&'$%'&B(=?(#<)%(&@F& ?"><@A(=>&V(=(& F)A$;$(>&)#*&B(@B;(&V'@&V(=(&><="%%;$#%&*"=$#%&<'(&=(?(>>$@#J&&

S'(=()>&<'(&#"AM(=&@F&B(@B;(& <')<&?)A(&<@&()<&D&)#*&<'">&<'(&*(A)#*&F@=&<'(&B=@*"?<& D& $#?=()>(*G& <'(& )H(=)%(& B=$?(& %(#(=);;C& V(#<& *@V#& *"=$#%& <')<& <$A(J& Q@=&(E)AB;(G& <'(&B=$?(&)<& <'(&+,-.#4%56#$#&4(#H(=G&,5&V(#<&*@V#&<@&)#&)H(=)%(&@F&aN&B(=&A();& F=@A& )& B=(RNOOZR=(?(>>$@#& B=$?(& @F& aYJ[O& @#& )H(=)%(J& 2<& <'(& <&*=& =(><)"=)#<& $#&Q=)#^F"=<G&:(=A)#CG&<'(&)H(=)%(&B=$?(&<')<&B(@B;(&V(=(&V$;;$#%&<@&B)C&);>@&*(?=()>(*&<@&B=$?(>& >;$%'<;C& )M@H(& uN& 0"=@>& V'$;(& <'(& =(><)"=)#<& V)>& >(=H$#%& )M@"<& NOr& A@=(&?"><@A(=>J& 1$#?(& NOKNG& )M@"<& XOr& @F& <&*=E*# ?"><@A(=>& ')H(& @#;C& M((#& B)C$#%& uKRN&0"=@>&D&)#&(c"$H);(#<&<@&aKJ[RNJ[&-1&*@;;)=>&D&F@=&)&?@AB;(<(&;"#?'&A();G&V'$;(&*(A)#*&;(H(;>& ')H(& M((#& $#?=()>$#%& >;$%'<;CJ& /'(>(& (AB$=$?);& F$#*$#%>& ?');;(#%(& <=)*$<$@#);&(?@#@A$?&<'(@=Cb>&*(A)#*&=(;)<$@#>'$B&)#*&>"%%(><&<')<&)>&*(A)#*&$#?=()>(>G&B=$?(>&*@&#@<&)"<@A)<$?);;C&F@;;@VG&M"<&$#&F)?<&*(?=()>(&$#&>@A(&$#><)#?(>J&G5$2I#%&*1&!2*!10%+0.&!#*/!&1'*'521,!

!@@<(*& $#& F(A$#$><& <'(@=CG& :$M>@#R:=)')Al>& eNOONG& NOOUf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

/'$>& ?";<"=);;C& (?@#@A$?& )#*& (?@#@A$?);;C& ?";<"=);&>CAM$@>$>& );>@& ?=C><);;$i(*&F=@A&(AB$=$?);&)#);C>$>&)#*&*)<)J&/'(&@V#(=&@F&>1"C08D*&F@@*&<="?^&>)$*&<')<&'$>&M">$#(>>&vV)#<>&)#*&')>& <@&A)^(&)&B=@F$<G& )#*&*@(>&#@<& =(;C&@#&)#C&@"<>$*(& F"#*$#%&@=&M(#(F$<>&F=@A&M($#%& )&#@#RB=@F$<& @=%)#$i)<$@#vG& M"<& )<& <'(& >)A(& <$A(& $<& ')>& )&B=@F@"#*;C& >@?$);&)%(#*)&<@&>B=()*&'();<'CG&>"><)$#)M;(&F@@*&?";<"=(>&)#*&F)?$;$<)<(&)??(>>&<@&'();<'C&F@@*&F@=&*$>)*H)#<)%(*&%=@"B>&V$<'&;$A$<(*&F$#)#?$);&)M$;$<CJ&

0E(AB;)=C& F@=& A@><& =(><)"=)#<>& )#*& ?)Fm>& $#& <'$>& ><"*CG& <'$>& M">$#(>>& '(#?(&$#')M$<>& M@<'& <'(& ?)B$<);$><$?G& (?@#@A$?& >B'(=(& )>& V(;;& )>& <'(&=();A& @F& B@>$<$H(&>@?$);&?')#%(&)#*&?@AA"#$<C&$AB)?<J&\C&<'(&>)A(&<@^(#G&$<&$#?)=#)<(>&<'(&$*()&<')<&<'(=(&$>&#@&

Page 33: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

NL&

@#(& <="(& ?)B$<);$>AG&#@=&)=(& <'(=(&(?@#@A$?&);<(=#)<$H(>&B(=& >(J& 7#& <'$>& >(#>(G& $<& $>&#@<&@#;C& <')<& 8S9S& )#*& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%& A@*(;>& (E(AB;$FC& *$FF(=(#<& (?@#@A$?&B@>>$M$;$<$(>G& M"<& <'(C& );>@& (B$<@A$i(& M=$*%$#%& >B)?(>& V'(=(& (?@#@A$?&?)B$<);$>A&?@);(>?(&V$<'& ?";<"=);& $#%(#"$<C& )#*& >@?$);& $##@H)<$@#G&V'$?'& <=";C& c");$F$(>&)>&)#*&?(A(#<>&<'(&#@<$@#&@F&(?@#@A$?&?";<"=(>J 40+0.&!.&,&#.13!

/'(& ;@%$?& <@& )BB;C& 8S9S& )#*& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%& F=@A& )& A)=%$#);& ?@><>&><)#*B@$#<&$>&$#<(=(><$#%&)#*&A)^(>&>(#>(&)<&F$=><&>$<(G&M"<&$<&><$;;&M(%>&<'(&c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

)'*1%0,2'*,!

/'$>&B)B(=&$>&)#&$AB@=<)#<&?@#<=$M"<$@#&<@&)?)*(A$?);;C&?)B<"=$#%&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&A@*(;>& $#& <'(& =(><)"=)#<&)#*& F@@*& <="?^& $#*"><=CJ&Q@;;@V$#%&j$A&(<&);J& eNOOZf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

6@=(& $AB@=<)#<;CG& <'$>& B)B(=b>& )#);C>$>& )#*& *$>?">>$@#& @F& 8S9S& )#*& >$A$;)=&H)=$)#<>& @F& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%& A@*(;>& F=@A& )#& $#<(=*$>?$B;$#)=C& B(=>B(?<$H(G&?@AM$#$#%&?@AA"#$?)<$@#&<'(@=CG&?";<"=);&><"*$(>&)#*&(?@#@A$?>G&)FF@=*>&#@H(;&$#>$%'<>&$#<@& )#& (?@#@A$?& ?";<"=(& @F& B=$?$#%& <'=@"%'& B)=<$?$B)<$@#J& 0H(#& <'@"%'& ;@?);;C&?@#><=)$#(*&)#*&?"==(#<;C&B=(>(#<&@#;C&$#&)&>A);;&#"AM(=&@F&=(><)"=)#<>&)#*&F@@*&<="?^>&$#& <'(& -1& )#*& :(=A)#C]2"><=$)G& B)=<$?$B)<@=C& B=$?$#%& $>& )#& $#?=()>$#%;C& (A(=%(#<&?";<"=);& B'(#@A(#@#G& )>& F@=& (E)AB;(& <'(& #"AM(=& @F& ?@AA"#$<C& ?)Fm>& <')<& F@;;@V& <'(&7"8#9(:0;#.F8:1'(;1#.%2*#A@*(;&$>&%=@V$#%J&

Page 34: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

XO&

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b>&)#*&<'(&>(;;(=b>&B(=>B(?<$H(&)#*&<'(&A@*(;b>&$AB;(A(#<)<$@#&$#&H)=$@">&?@#<(E<>&)#*&>$<")<$@#>J&&

6@=(&M=@)*;CG& <'$>&B)B(=b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i)<$@#J&7#><()*G&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&B=$?$#%&(AM@*$(>&)&=$?'&=(B@>$<@=C&F@=&)=%"$#%&$#&F)H@=&@F&<'(&'@A@&=(?$B=@?)#>G&V'$?'&B=@A@<(>& <'(& $*()& @F& '"A)#& ?@@B(=)<$@#& )#*& <'(& *(>$=(& <@& $AB=@H(& <'(& ?@;;(?<$H(&(#H$=@#A(#<J&&

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i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

&& '

Page 35: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

XK&

9&(&.&*1&,!!

2=$(;CG&4JG&\=)?')G&2JG&k&6($(=G&1J&eNOOLfJ&4@$#%&%@@*&@=&*@$#%&V(;;W&7A)%(&A@<$H)<$@#&)#*&A@#(<)=C&$#?(#<$H(>&$#&M(')H$#%&B=@>@?$);;CJ&G=8#,H8:&I%"#.I("(H&I#$8F&8)G&JJeKfG&[PPD[[[J&

2==@VG&jJ&oJ&eKL[LfJ&/@V)=*&)&/'(@=C&@F&8=$?(&2*g"><A(#<J&7#&6J&2M=)A@H$<i&e0*JfG&G=8#,00(I%2&("#(5#.I("(H&I#$8*(K:I8*L&eBBJ&PKD[KfJ&1<)#F@=*+&1<)#F@=*&-#$H(=>$<C&8=(>>J&

2<^$#>@#G&8JG&k&h)AA(=>;(CG&6J&eKLLPfJ&0<'#@%=)B'C&)#*&B)=<$?$B)#<&@M>(=H)<$@#J&M%";'((N#(5#OK%0&2%2&F8#$8*8%:I=G&PeNXfG&NPZDNUKJ&

\@"=*$("G&8J&eKLLOfJ&G=8#0(C&I#(5#Q:%I2&I8J&1<)#F@=*&-#$H(=>$<C&8=(>>J&\@"=*$("G&8J&eNOO[fJ&G=8#+(I&%0#+2:KI2K:8*#(5#2=8#.I("(H1J&,)AM=$*%(G&-j+&8@;$<C&8=(>>J&,@'(#G&hJ&eKLNYfJ&>:(K;=("E*#+(0K2&("#(5#2=8#+(I&%0#>:('08HJ&3(V&9@=^G&39+&T)#%")=*&

8=(>>J&4(;%)*@G&,J&.J&eNOOXfJ&R&*=#2(#STSTU#+KQQ01#%";#;8H%";#&"#I=%"C&"C#C0('%0#H%:N82*J&

8(#)#%G&62.29172+&S@=;*Q$>'J&4(S);<G&jJ&6JG&4(S);<G&\J&!JG&k&S)C;)#*G&,J&\J&eKLLZfJ&8)=<$?$B)#<&@M>(=H)<$@#J&7#&hJ&!J&

\(=#)=*&e0*JfG&M%";'((N#(5#H82=(;*#&"#IK02K:%0#%"2=:(Q(0(C1&eBBJ&N[LDNLLfJ&S);#"<&,=((^G&,2+&2;<)6$=)&8=(>>J&

4@;)#G&0J&:J&eNOKNfJ&!"2:(;KI2&("#2(#-&I:(8I("(H&I*&e[<'&(*JfJ&!(**$#%G&,2+&\T/&8"M;$>'$#%J&

4@;)#G&!J&oJG&k&6@@#G&9J&0J&eNOOOfJ&8=$?$#%&)#*&6)=^(<&6)^$#%&@#&<'(&7#<(=#(<J&V(K:"%0#(5#!"28:%I2&F8#-%:N82&"CG&PWeNfG&[UDYXJ&

0;><(=G&oJ&eKLZLfJ&BK2*#%";#?(02*#5(:#2=8#+(I&%0#+I&8"I8*J&,)AM=$*%(G&-j+&,)AM=$*%(&-#$H(=>$<C&8=(>>J&

0#%(;M(=<G&2J&eNOKNfJ&M80QX#Y8C8"*8&2&C#'8=&";8:"#(;8:#=8058"L#.&"8#Q(0&2&*I=8#+N&ZZ8#ZK:#9%=:"8=HK"C#=8K28J&Ss=iM"=%+&jw#$%>')">(#&k&3("A)##J&

0>?@M)=G&2J&eNOOKfJ&,";<"=(&>$<>&$#&B;)?(>+&!(F;(?<$@#>&@#&%;@M);$>A&)#*&>"M);<(=#&><=)<(%$(>&@F&;@?);$i)<$@#J&>(0&2&I%0#Y8(C:%Q=1G&STeNfG&KXLDKYPJ&

:$M>@#R:=)')AG&oJ&jJ&eNOONfJ&\(C@#*&%;@M);&H>J&;@?);+&0?@#@A$?&B@;$<$?>&@"<>$*(&<'(&M$#)=C&F=)A(J&7#&2J&h(=@*&k&6J&SJ&S=$%'<&e0*>JfG&Y8(C:%Q=&8*#(5#>()8:U#>0%I&"C#+I%08&eBBJ&N[DUOfJ&5EF@=*+&\;)?^V(;;J&

:$M>@#R:=)')AG&oJ&jJ&eNOOUfJ&G=8#.";#(5#4%Q&2%0&*H#/%*#98#<"8)#!23U#,#R8H&"&*2#4:&2&[K8#(5#>(0&2&I%0#.I("(H1J&6$##()B@;$>+&-#$H(=>$<C&@F&6$##(>@<)&8=(>>J&

:#((iCG&2JG&:#((iCG&-JG&3(;>@#G&.J&4JG&k&\=@V#G&2J&eNOKOfJ&1')=(*&>@?$);&=(>B@#>$M$;$<C+&)&F$(;*&(EB(=$A(#<&$#&B)CRV')<RC@"RV)#<&B=$?$#%&)#*&?')=$<)M;(&%$H$#%J&+I&8"I8#/B8)#\(:N@#BL\L3G&]SJe[LZLfG&XN[DYJ&*@$+KOJKKNU]>?$(#?(JKKZUYPP&

Page 36: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

XN&

:#((iCG&2JG&:#((iCG&-JG&!$(#(=G&:JG&k&3(;>@#G&.J&4J&eNOKNfJ&8)CRV')<RC@"RV)#<G&$*(#<$<CG&)#*&>(;FR>$%#);$#%&$#&A)=^(<>J&>:(I88;&"C*#(5#2=8#B%2&("%0#,I%;8H1#(5#+I&8"I8*#(5#2=8#^"&28;#+2%28*#(5#,H8:&I%G&PTJeKLfG&YNXUDPOJ&*@$+KOJKOYX]B#)>JKKNOZLXKOL&

:@;*M"=%G&!JG&k&3)C;@=G&!J&eNOO[fJ&Q"<"=(&>()>?)B(>G&F$>'$#%G&)#*&F$>'&F)=A$#%J&R:("2&8:*#&"#.I(0(C1#%";#2=8#."F&:("H8"2G&]eKfG&NKDNZJ&

h)AA(=>;(CG&6JG&k&2<^$#>@#G&8J&eKLZXfJ&.2="(C:%Q=1U#>:&"I&Q08*#&"#Q:%I2&I8J&.@#*@#+&/=)H$><@?^J&

o"#)#^)=G&8J&3J&eKLZNfJ&-%:_E*#.I("(H&I*J&5EF@=*+&8'$;$B&2;;)#J&j)'#(A)#G&4JG&j#(<>?'G&oJ&.JG&k&/');(=G&!J&hJ&eKLZUfJ&Q)$=#(>>&)#*&<'(&)>>"AB<$@#>&@F&

(?@#@A$?>J&V(K:"%0#(5#?K*&"8**G&`JePfG&NZ[DXOOJ&j$AG&oJR9JG&3)<<(=G&6JG&k&1B)##G&6J&eNOOZfJ&8)CRS')<R9@"RS)#<&D&2&3(V&8)=<$?$B)<$H(&

8=$?$#%&6(?')#$>AJ&V(K:"%0#(5#-%:N82&"CG&WJeKfG&KDPXJ&j$AG&oJR9JG&3)<<(=G&6JG&k&1B)##G&6J&eNOKOfJ&8)CRS')<R9@"RS)#<&R&8=)E$>=(;(H)#i&"#*&

j@#>"A(#<(#H(=');<(#J&a8&2*I=:&52#Rb:#?82:&8'*)&:2*I=%52G&cTeNfG&KPYDKULJ&j$#%G&3J&eKLLLfJ&/'(&c");$<)<$H(&=(>()=?'&$#<(=H$(VJ&7#&,J&,)>>(;;&k&:J&1CA@#&e0*>JfG&

OK%0&2%2&F8#-82=(;*#&"#7:C%"&*%2&("%0#$8*8%:I=U#,#Q:%I2&I%0#YK&;8&eBBJ&KPDXUfJ&.@#*@#+&12:0J&

j$#%G&3JG&k&h@==@?^>G&,J&eNOKOfJ&!"28:F&8)*#&"#OK%0&2%2&F8#$8*8%:I=J&/'@">)#*&5)^>G&,2+&12:0J&

.((G&4J&9J&eNOOOfJ&!(<)$;&M)=%)$#$#%&M(')H$@"=&@F&2A(=$?)#&)#*&,'$#(>(&?"><@A(=>J&.K:(Q8%"#V(K:"%0#(5#-%:N82&"CG&]WeK]NfG&KLODNOUJ&

.C##G&6J&eKLLOfJ&,'@@>(&C@"=&@V#&B=$?(+&2#&(EB;@=)<@=C&><"*C&=(c"$=$#%&)#&(EB)#*(*&H$(V&@F&B=$?(b>&F"#?<$@#>J&,;F%"I8*#&"#4("*KH8:#$8*8%:I=G&PdeKfG&YKODYKPJ&

6@==$>@#G&jJ&eNOOUfJ&-%:_@#AK:N=8&H@#98'8:U#R(:H%2&("*#(5#-(;8:"#+(I&%0#G=(KC=2J&.@#*@#+&12:0J&

5><(='">G&/J&.J&eKLLYfJ&8=@R1@?$);&,@#>"A(=&7#F;"(#?(&1<=)<(%$(>+&S'(#&2#*&h@V&4@&/'(C&S@=^W&V(K:"%0#(5#-%:N82&"CG&ePePfG&KUDNLJ&

8()?'G&/J&eKLLXfJ&!"28:Q:82&"C#$&I%:;(J&,)AM=$*%(G&-j+&,)AM=$*%(&-#$H(=>$<C&8=(>>J&8(=;@FFG&oJ&6J&eNOOLfJ&-&I:(8I("(H&I*&e[<'&(*JfJ&\@><@#G&62+&8()=>@#&0*"?)<$@#J&!$<<(#M(=%G&.JG&k&/=(%)=<'(#G&/J&eNOOLfJ&>:&"I&Q08*#(5#H&I:(8I("(H&I*J&Q;)<&S@=;*&

j#@V;(*%(J&!"M$#G&7J&7J&eKLYXfJ&.**%1*#("#-%:_E*#0%'(:#2=8(:1#(5#F%0K8J&6@#<=();+&\;)?^&!@>(&\@@^>J&1<($#F(;>G&8J&eNOKXfJ&,#>8(Q08#,;:&52U#G=8#4:&*&*#(5#2=8#$(H%"#4%2=(0&I#4=K:I=#&"#,H8:&I%J&

3(V&9@=^G&39+&1$A@#&)#*&1?'"><(=J&T(#^)<(>)#G&6J&eKLUUfJ&0EB(=$A(#<);&><"*C&@F&?@#>"A(=&M(')H$@=&?@#F@=A$<C&)#*&

$#*(B(#*(#?(J&V(K:"%0#(5#-%:N82&"C#$8*8%:I=G&]ePfG&XZPDXZYJ&

Page 37: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

XX&

S)#%G&!J&eKLL[fJ&\)=%)$#$#%&H(=>">&B@><(*RB=$?(&>(;;$#%J&.K:(Q8%"#.I("(H&I#$8F&8)G&]JeLfG&KYPYDKYUPJ&

!& !

Page 38: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

XP&

G88&*/2L!@!x+&& -*+&.I2&6!:0&,+2'*!)#+#%'<0&F!P6*&.,Q;#*#<&.,& ,'=$><@B'&!@>(#<');&4)<(+& & -1,&7#<(=H$(V((+& & &

&Kf S'C&')H(&C@"&><)=<(*&V$<'&8)CRS')<R9@"RS)#<&]&<'(&B)=<$?$B)<@=C&

B=$?$#%&A(?')#$>AW&Nf S')<&*@(>&$<&A()#&<@&C@"&<@&')H(&<'$>&B=$?$#%&A@*(;W&Xf S')<&V)>&C@"&A@<$H)<$@#&M('$#*&<'(&$AB;(A(#<)<$@#&@F&<'$>&$*()W&Pf S'(=(&*@(>&<'$>&$*()&?@A(&F=@AW&h@V&*$*&C@"&F$#*&@"<&)M@"<&$<&$#&<'(&

F$=><&B;)?(W&[f S')<&)=(&<'(&B(@B;(b>&=()?<$@#>&V'(#&<'(C&?@A(&$#<@&<'(&=(><)"=)#<&)#*&

F$=><&;()=#&)M@"<&<'(&);<(=#)<$H(&B=$?$#%W&&Uf S')<&*@&<'(&B(@B;(&V'@&F=(c"(#<;C&?@A(&M)?^&>)CW&h@V&*@&<'(C&F((;&

)M@"<&$<W&&Yf h@V&*@&B(@B;(&F$#*&<'($=&B=$?(>W&4@&<'(C&')H(&=(F(=(#?(&B=$?(>&$#&<'($=&

A$#*>G&)#*&$F&C(>G&V')<&)=(&<'(CW&Zf 2=(&<'(=(&A)#C&;@C);&?"><@A(=>&<')<&@F<(#&?@A(&M)?^W&Lf S'@&?@A(>&<@&C@"W&S')<&^$#*&@F&B(@B;(&)=(&'(&A@><&F=(c"(#<&H$>$<@=>W&

S'@&*@&C@"&#(H(=&>((W&KOf h@V&*@&C@"&^((B&<'(&M">$#(>>&%@$#%W&7>&<'(&8)CRS')<RC@"RV)#<&<'(&@#;C&

V)C&B(@B;(&B)CW&4@&<'(C&')H(&<@&B)C&F$E(*&B=$?(>&F@=&*=$#^>W&KKf 4$*&<'(&F$#)#?$);&?=$>$>]=(?(>>$@#&')H(&)#C&#@<$?()M;(&$#F;"(#?(&@#&C@"=&

M">$#(>>W&2#*&F$#);;C&>@A(&A@=(&B'$;@>@B'$?);&c"(><$@#>&$#&%(#(=);&)M@"<&C@"=>(;F+&

KNf S')<&$>&A"<");$<C&]&A"<");$<C&F@=&C@"W&KXf &S')<&$>&?=()<$H$<C&]&?=()<$H$<C&<@&C@"W&

& &

Page 39: The Cultures and Economics in Participatory Pricing d An

,-./-!01&234&0,53567,1&73&82!/7,782/5!9&8!7,73:&

&

X[&

&&

G88&*/2L!A!x+&& -*+&.I2&6!:0&,+2'*!)#+#%'<0&F!)0,+'5&.,& ,'=$><@B'&!@>(#<');&4)<(+& & -1,&7#<(=H$(V((+& & &

&Kf S'(#&)#*&V'(=(&*$*&C@"&M"C&>@A(<'$#%&"#*(=&8)CRV')<RC@"RV)#<&

?@#*$<$@#>W&Nf 4$*&C@"&^#@V&<')<&C@"&?@";*&>(<&C@"=&@V#&B=$?(&M(F@=(&C@"&V(#<&<@&%(<&<'(&

>A@@<'$(&)<&<'(&F@@*&<="?^W&Xf h@V&*$*&C@"&F((;&V'(#&C@"&V(=(&B)C$#%&C@"=&@V#&B=$?(W&S')<&*$*&$<&A()#&

<@&C@"W&Pf S')<&^$#*&@F&=(;)<$@#>'$B&*$*&C@"&F((;&V)>&B=(>(#<&M(<V((#&C@"&)#*&<'(&

@V#(=&@F&<'(&F@@*&<="?^W&S)>&$<&*$FF(=(#<&F=@A&)&#@=A);&B"=?')>(W&7F&C(>G&$#&V')<&V)C&)#*&V'CW&

[f h@V&*@&C@"&F((;&)M@"<&<'(&V@=*$#%&_8)C&C@"=&F)$=&>')=(`W&S')<&*@(>&<'$>&A()#&<@&C@"W&h@V&*@(>&<'$>&$#F;"(#?(&C@"=&B=$?(&*(?$>$@#W&

Uf S')<&V)>&C@"=&F$=><&<'@"%'<&V'(#&<'(&@V#(=&@F&<'(&F@@*&<="?^&<@;*&C@"&<')<&C@"&?)#&B)C&C@"=&@V#&B=$?(W&

Yf S')<&V)>&C@"=&=(F(=(#?(&B=$?(&M(F@=(&C@"&F@"#*&@"<&<')<&C@"&?@";*&>(<&<'(&B=$?(&C@"=>(;FW&h@V&A"?'&V@";*&C@"&')H(&B)$*&#@=A);;C&)#*&V'CW&S'(=(&*$*&<'(&=(F(=(#?(&B=$?(&?@A(&F=@AW&

Zf 5#?(&C@"&F@"#*&@"<&<')<&C@"&?@";*&>(<&<'(&B=$?(&C@"=>(;FG&*$*&C@"&F((;&;$^(&B)C$#%&*$FF(=(#<;C&<')#&">");W&7F&>@G&V'CW&

Lf S(=(&C@"&$#?;$#(*&<@&%$H(&)&<$BW&7F&>@G&V'C&)#*&*@&C@"&">");;C&%$H(&<$B>W&KOf S@";*&C@"&%@&<@&<'(&>)A(&F@@*&<="?^&)%)$#W&7F&>@G&V'CW&KKf S'C&*@&C@"&<'$#^&*@(>&<'(&@V#(=&@F&<'(&F@@*&<="?^&@FF(=&'$>&B=@*"?<>&"#*(=&

B)CRV')<RC@"RV)#<&?@#*$<$@#>W&S'C&*@&C@"&<'$#^&*@(>&'(&;(<&'$>&?"><@A(=>&*(?$*(&V')<&<'(C&V)#<&<@&B)CW&

KNf 4@&C@"&<'$#^&B)CRV')<RC@"RV)#<&$>&)&%@@*&$*()W&KXf S')<b>&<'(&*$FF(=(#?(&F@=&C@"&M(<V((#&B)CRV')<RC@"RV)#<&)#*&B)CRC@"=R

F)$=R>')=(W&2#*&F$#);;C&>@A(&A@=(&B'$;@>@B'$?);&c"(><$@#>&$#&%(#(=);&)M@"<&C@"=>(;F+&KPf S')<&$>&A"<");$<C&]&A"<");$<C&F@=&C@"W&K[f S')<&$>&?=()<$H$<C&<@&C@"W&&e8;()>(&F((;&F=((&<@&)**&)#C&=(;(H)#<&$#F@=A)<$@#&@=&?@AA(#<>&<')<&C@"&F((;&)=(&$AB@=<)#<&F@=&A(&<@&M(<<(=&"#*(=><)#*&<'(&A()#$#%>&)#*&A@<$H)<$@#>&)=@"#*&<'$>&);<(=#)<$H(&(?@#@A$?&B=)?<$?(J&7bA&);>@&H(=C&<')#^F";&F@=&)#C&)**$<$@#);&$#B"<&<')<&C@"&F((;&$>&$AB@=<)#<&)#*&<')<&*$*&#@<&?@A(&"B&$#&<'(&c"(><$@#>Jf&&