Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Peter Watson
ET, phone homeAre we alone in the universe?
Peter Watson
The Good News
• We’ve found a lot of places to go
• Probably even life out there….
Peter Watson
The Bad news• We can’t get there
Peter Watson
The Really Bad news• We had better fix things here…
Peter Watson
The Really, Really Bad news• We may not have long enough
PW
Image Credit: ALMA (ESO/NAOJ/NRAO), NSF
HL Tauri from ALMA
Star has just got going: we can see the disc of hot gas forming planets
Peter Watson
An (almost) new-born star: β-Pictoris
• still surrounded by dust
• But it’s had time to form at least one giant planet
• so are planets common?
Peter Watson
Picture by Etienne Rollin
Now we are seeing lots of other solar systems
Like this! (except this is our sun and Venus, June 5)
Kepler• observed 150000 stars
every 30 mins.
• Note 0.1 % change• 4 hours• symmetrical shape
Vega
Deneb
Peter Watson
How many?• 6 planets known since pre-history
• Uranus: 1781
• Neptune: 1846
• Pluto: 1931
Note: even this is an underestimate:Kepler has 2321 candidates, 61 74 confirmed
Peter Watson
21/10/2019
• https://apod.nasa.gov/apod/ap151205.html
Peter Watson
•Orbit has to be aligned with earth
•Need to see several transits
•Does best with large planets, close to star
•“hot Jupiters”
Peter Watson
Kepler 11 has at least 6 planets
Peter Watson
•Kepler 22b: first earth-sized planet in Goldilocks zone (not too hot, not to cold!)
Peter Watson
So planetary systems are common: do they look like ours?
Peter Watson
• Lot of stars have hot Jupiters
• Some don’t know they should be in circular orbits!
• HD80606b goes from 500°C to 1200°C in 6 hours
• Lots go backwards
Not really
Peter Watson
•CoRoT-7b
•mass ~ five Earth, radius~ 1.7 Earth
•year lasts ~20 hours
•FAR too hot (1500°)Peter Watson
•Planets in orbit round binary (double-star) systems: Kepler 16b
Peter Watson Peter Watson
• ~Earth sized planet + ~Neptune sized planet
• Every 97 days approach to ~1.5 million km
Kepler 36
Credit: Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics/David Aguilar
Peter Watson
Kepler-47
• First Binary Star 2-Planet System
Peter Watson
• Maybe we need a planet called Vulcan.
• Star Trek puts it round the star 40-Eridani: quite sensible
• Green ring is “habitable zone”
On the other hand ...
Peter Watson Peter Watson
Peter Watson
Water planet: K2-18B
Peter Watson
And now.. (Feb 2017)• TRAPPIST-1 system
Transiting Planets and Planetesimals Small Telescope
Peter Watson
• 7 planets, all within orbit of Mercury
• Several in Goldilocks zone
Peter Watson
And now..• Like this!
• Star is cool red dwarf
• Not what we would expect for life support
Peter Watson
• There may be many planets that don’t orbit stars
• A real αστήρ πλανήτης (astēr planētēs), meaning "wandering star"
• Except we have defined planets to be in orbit round stars!
Peter Watson
• Seems likely ALL stars have planets
• We haven’t had time to observe orbits of longer than a year or so
• Maybe more than 100 billion planets in the Milky Way
• Many similar to Earth
Conclusions
So let’s
go
Peter Watson
So what does this do for alien life?
•Where are they?
Peter Watson
The Wow signal• 1977 from Big
Ear observatory (Ohio)
• Very big signal, never repeated
• Before GUI’s!
Peter Watson
Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence
• Vast amounts of data from Arecibo are never analysed
• If aliens are smart enough to communicate over large distances AND too dumb to use cable, we could pick up their signals
A depressing corollary
• Fermi’s question: where are they?
• if the universe is full of planets (it is) and some have liquid water (almost certainly) and evolution is universal (why wouldn’t it be?)…..
• Why isn’t the galaxy full of inhabited planets with intelligent species who want to talk to us?
Peter Watson
The Drake Equation• How many advanced civilizations are there in our
galaxy (50 billion stars)?
• # of new stars born each year = 10
• fraction of stars with planets = 100%
• # of habitable planets/system = 0.5
• probability that life evolves =100%
• prob. that life develops intelligence =5%
Peter Watson
• prob. that intelligent life can communicate across space =5%
• lifetime of intelligent civilization =3500 yrs
• # of times a civilization could re-develop =1
• Total number of civilizations in our galaxy at the moment?
• http://www.as.utexas.edu/astronomy/education/drake/drake.html-old
•42!!!!!!!!!!!!•Well, you decide which number I got wrong!
An image that is embedded in our sub-conscious
•No evidence that Nature is working towards more complex and intelligent beings
•Steven Jay Gould has pointed out that this is probably temporary: viruses have much better survival values than humans
• Note whole orders of living beings have disappeared from the earth for no apparent reason.
• E.g Burgess shale
•
•this is Opabinia
• this is Orthrozanclus Maybe intelligence isn’t such a great idea!
• Maybe intelligent species last a really short time
Hiroshima Aug 5 1945
Hiroshima Aug 6 1945
In summary:
• There are lots of planets
• No known or foreseeable technology will get us to a extra-solar planet
• Total absence of any evidence for extra-terrestrial life suggest it is very uncommon: pick your own reason why
• If you want to play your own games with the data, go to http://exoplanet.eu