40
The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae The key role of CTIO Mario Hamuy Universidad de Chile

The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

  • Upload
    vandieu

  • View
    225

  • Download
    2

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae

The key role of CTIO

• Mario Hamuy• Universidad de Chile

Page 2: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Composition of the Universe

Energía Oscura

70%

Materia Oscura

26%

Materia

Ordinaria

4%

Page 3: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

The Tololo Nearby Supernova Survey

First digital light curves of supernovae(cz < 2000 km/sec)

SN 1986G

SN 1992ASN 1991TSN 1991bg

SN 1989BSN 1987A

SN 1994D

SN 1990N

Page 4: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Supernova 1987A

M1:The scientific career is full of surprises

Page 5: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

El Universo en aceleración Cerro Calán, 12 Junio 2009

Supernova 1987A – 16” Telescope

National Geographic 1987

Page 6: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Supernova 1987A – Observations from Tololo

Compact star

Co Decay

Dust Formation

Page 7: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Workshop Santa Cruz – California - 1989

Page 8: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Workshop Santa Cruz – California - 1989

Leibundgut

Page 9: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

The absolute magnitudes of supernovae

σ = 0.61 mag

Baade 1938 -> Mpg = -14.3 +/- 1.1 mag

Van den Bergh 1960 -> Mpg = -18.7 +/- 1.1 mag (Type Ia)

Kowal 1968 - First Hubble Diagram

Page 10: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

The Calán/Tololo Project (1989-1996) - Members

•Mark Phillips

Bob Schommer

Mario Hamuy Nick Suntzeff

José Maza

Marina Wischnjewski

Roberto Antezana

Luis GonzálezLisa Wells

Roberto Avilés

Mark Phillips

Paulina Lira

Page 11: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Cerro El Roble Supernova Search (1979-1984)

Maksutuv Telescope at El Roble Observatory

José Maza

Marina Wischnjewsky

Luis González

Juan Parra

Pedro Hernández

50 supernovae!SN 1980N (Fornax A)

SN 1983K

Zeiss-Jena Blink comparator

Apoyo de:

Enrique d´Etigny

Claudio Anguita

Hugo Moreno

Page 12: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Propuesta Búsqueda a FONDECYT 1991 No -- 1992 Si

M2:If you lose a competition, you must persevere!

Page 13: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Calán/Tololo - Search

Cámara Curtis-Schmidt

Cerro Tololo

Blink Comparator

Cerro Calán

La Serena ���� Santiago

Supernova!Santiago ���� La Serena

Photographic Plate

Page 14: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Calán/Tololo - Followup

Page 15: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant
Page 16: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

(1) The discovery of 29 Type Ia supernovae in the Hubble flow

Page 17: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

(2) The recording of the most precise light curves ever obtained at that time thanks to the

CCD technology

(3) The proof that

Type Iawere not perfectstandard candles

Page 18: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

(4) The demonstration that Phillip´s relationship was qualitatively correct

Phillips 1993 Hamuy et al 1996

Page 19: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

(5) The dependence of supernova luminosities with host galaxy Hubble types

Page 20: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

(6) The establishment of a method to correct

supernova luminosities for host-galaxy reddening

Lira law (MS. Thesis UCH 1995)

Page 21: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

(7) The most precise calibration of thesupernova luminosities at that time (1994-1996)

Page 22: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

(8) The establishment of key tools to measuredistances with a precision never reached before

Hubble

,

,

Page 23: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant
Page 24: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant
Page 25: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant
Page 26: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Credit: Roger Smith/NOAO/AURA/NSF

Víctor Blanco

4 meter

Telescope Cerro Tololo

Page 27: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant
Page 28: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Search for distant supernovaeSupernova Cosmology Project (1988)High-Z Supernova Team (1994)

Page 29: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Precision Cosmology from Type Ia supernovae

The Universe is accelerating!

Independently confirmed by two groups:

Riess, Schmidt, Clocchiatti, Leibundgut et al. 1998

Perlmutter et al. 1999

redshift

distance

Page 30: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Cosmological Parameters (1998-1999)

Initially: acceleration modeled with Einstein´s cosmological constant

Page 31: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Two key results in cosmology from Calán/Tololo:(1) the Hubble constant

m = 5 log (cz) + (M – 5 log H0 +25)

ZP = M - 5 log H0 +25

log H0 = 0.2 x (M + 25 - ZP)

H0 = 63-72 km/s/Mpc(Sandage et al., Freedman et al)

Half of the data from HST data

Half of the data from supernovae in the Hubble flow

Page 32: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Page 33: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

M3:If you receive criticisms from an outstanding scientist it means you are doing

something relevant

Page 34: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Two key results in cosmology from Calán/Tololo:(2) the deceleration parameter

The discovery of the accelerating Universe was a differential measurement comparing low-z and high-z supernovae

The Calán/Tololo data represent half of the measurements

Page 35: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

The key role of CTIO in supernova science

The Tololo Nearby Supernova Program (Phillips, Suntzeff, et al) : 1986-2000?

The Calán/Tololo Program (Hamuy et al) : 1989-1993

The Supernova Cosmology Project (Perlmutter et al): 1992-1999Blanco 4m, BTC

The High_Z Team (Schmidt, Suntzeff et al): 1994-1998Blanco 4m, BTC

ESSENCE (Suntzeff et al): 2002-2005Blanco 4m, MOSAIC II

Dark Energy Survey (DES, Friemann et al): 2012-2016Blanco, 4m, DECam

LSST 2022-2032

Page 36: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Chilean Astronomy LSST Board meeting, April 10 2011

Page 37: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant
Page 38: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Courtesy of Kathy Vivas

Page 39: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant

Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory (est. 1962)Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy

Page 40: The acceleration of the Universe in the light of supernovae · The acceleration of the Universe in the ... host-galaxy reddening Lira law ... The Intrigue on the Hubble Constant