5
ISSN 03621197, Human Physiology, 2011, Vol. 37, No. 7, pp. 763–767. © Pleiades Publishing, Inc., 2011. Original Russian Text © I.B. Ushakov, Yu.A. Bubeev, 2009, published in Aviakosmicheskaya i Ekologicheskaya Meditsina, 2009, Vol. 43, No. 5, pp. 3–7. 763 In the history of medicine, there have not been so many disciplines with the purpose of “glancing beyond the horizon” in both direct and metaphoric sense. One of these sciences is air medicine, which celebrates its 100th anniversary this year. Air medicine (AM) is a modern hightech division of medical science aimed at solution of the problems of medical support for flights of aircrafts of different types. This branch of medicine studies the interaction between the human body and unusual environmental conditions during professional flight work and devel ops the measures for high efficiency and safety of human flights by various aircrafts. AM has fundamental medical and biological bases, systematic methodology, and pronounced practical and economic significance. Air medicine is not a kind of transport medicine. It is based on a great many laws of occupational medicine but has a fundamental specificity, because flight work is one of the most complex and dangerous kinds of occupational activities. It is connected with leaving Earth’s surface and highspeed motion in a threedimensional space. It is inherently character ized by human exposure to the combined effects of physical, chemical, psychic and biological factors, information loads, and the necessity to make decisions under the conditions of time deficit accompanied by intense psychoemotional stress (Fig. 1). The foundations of air medicine were laid by I.M. Sechenov and D.I. Mendeleev, coryphaei of Russian science. In 1875, Mendeleev first suggested the concept of an airtight cabin for flights in the upper atmosphere after analyzing the causes of the death of the crew of the Zenit aerostat; he himself ballooned to a height of 3000 m. On the basis of the physiological analysis of the same tragedy, Sechenov reported, at the The 100th Anniversary of Air Medicine I. B. Ushakov a and Yu. A. Bubeev b a Institute for Biomedical Problems, Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, 123007 Russia b State Research Institute of Military Medicine, Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation, Moscow, 127083 Russia DOI: 10.1134/S0362119711070309 EDITORIAL Locomotor system, Cardiovascular and Central nervous Gastrointestinal Hematopoietic and Emotional and information stresses immune systems tract system respiratory systems excretory system, fluidandelectrolyte balance Mechanoacoustic: Altered gas environment Temperature and Radiations and fields: Toxic overload, acceleration, vibration, noise and barometric pressure: hypoxia, hyperoxia, hypercapnia, hypobaria, etc. microclimatic: hypothermia, hyperthermia, etc. ionizing, nonionizing Fig. 1. Major groups of flight work factors and physiological systems involved in implementation of their effects.

The 100th anniversary of air medicine

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The 100th anniversary of air medicine

ISSN 0362�1197, Human Physiology, 2011, Vol. 37, No. 7, pp. 763–767. © Pleiades Publishing, Inc., 2011.Original Russian Text © I.B. Ushakov, Yu.A. Bubeev, 2009, published in Aviakosmicheskaya i Ekologicheskaya Meditsina, 2009, Vol. 43, No. 5, pp. 3–7.

763

In the history of medicine, there have not been somany disciplines with the purpose of “glancingbeyond the horizon” in both direct and metaphoricsense. One of these sciences is air medicine, whichcelebrates its 100th anniversary this year.

Air medicine (AM) is a modern high�tech divisionof medical science aimed at solution of the problemsof medical support for flights of aircrafts of differenttypes. This branch of medicine studies the interactionbetween the human body and unusual environmentalconditions during professional flight work and devel�ops the measures for high efficiency and safety ofhuman flights by various aircrafts.

AM has fundamental medical and biological bases,systematic methodology, and pronounced practicaland economic significance. Air medicine is not a kindof transport medicine.

It is based on a great many laws of occupationalmedicine but has a fundamental specificity, becauseflight work is one of the most complex and dangerouskinds of occupational activities. It is connected withleaving Earth’s surface and high�speed motion in athree�dimensional space. It is inherently character�ized by human exposure to the combined effects ofphysical, chemical, psychic and biological factors,information loads, and the necessity to make decisionsunder the conditions of time deficit accompanied byintense psychoemotional stress (Fig. 1).

The foundations of air medicine were laid byI.M. Sechenov and D.I. Mendeleev, coryphaei ofRussian science. In 1875, Mendeleev first suggestedthe concept of an airtight cabin for flights in the upperatmosphere after analyzing the causes of the death ofthe crew of the Zenit aerostat; he himself ballooned toa height of 3000 m. On the basis of the physiologicalanalysis of the same tragedy, Sechenov reported, at the

The 100th Anniversary of Air MedicineI. B. Ushakova and Yu. A. Bubeevb

a Institute for Biomedical Problems, Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, 123007 Russiab State Research Institute of Military Medicine, Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation, Moscow, 127083 Russia

DOI: 10.1134/S0362119711070309

EDITORIAL

Locomotor system,

Cardiovascular and

Central nervous

Gastrointestinal

Hematopoietic and

Em

otio

nal

an

d in

form

atio

n s

tres

ses

immune systems

tract

system

respiratory systems

excretory system,fluid�and�electrolyte

balance

Mechano�acoustic:

Altered gas environment

Temperature and

Radiations and fields:

Toxic

overload, acceleration,vibration, noise

and barometricpressure: hypoxia,

hyperoxia, hypercapnia,hypobaria, etc.

microclimatic:hypothermia,

hyperthermia, etc.

ionizing,non�ionizing

Fig. 1. Major groups of flight work factors and physiological systems involved in implementation of their effects.

Page 2: The 100th anniversary of air medicine

764

HUMAN PHYSIOLOGY Vol. 37 No. 7 2011

USHAKOV, BUBEEV

11th Congress of Naturalists and Physicians, on thepulmonary gas exchange at a drop in barometric pres�sure. AM owes the basic knowledge of blood circula�tion control necessary for the analysis of accelerationeffects during the flight to the classical studies by theRussian physiologist Academician I.P. Pavlov, startedas early as in 1877.

However, it is accepted that the birthday of airmedicine in Russia is July 14, 1909. On that day, thequestion of necessary medical examination of pilotswas raised at the meeting of the All�Russian FlyingClub.

The Flying Club decree states: “It is recognized tobe necessary to permit the club members to performflights only after medical examination.”

In a year, the War Department of Russia issuedOrder no. 481 containing “The List of Diseases andPhysical Handicaps Preventing the Service of Offic�ers, Low Rank Men, and Civilian Mechanical Engi�neers in Aeronautical Units on Board the Balloonsand Airplanes” and established the first physical eval�uation board. The first scientific institution for inves�tigation of the problems faced by air medicine, theLaboratory of Air Medicine, was founded in Russia in1912 by S.E. Mintz, senior physician of the aviationschool.

Involvement of aviation in the First World Warposed an acute problem of employment and selectionof a vast number of people fit for flight work in terms ofthe state of health. The first mention of the regularappointment of aviation medical officer dates back tothe autumn of 1918, when the position of medicalofficer was established in an aviation detachment dur�ing the defense of the city of Tsaritsyn. A medicalofficer in the aviation detachment was bound to per�form special examination of pilots, their way of lifeand nutrition; special nutritional regulations for flightpersonnel were established at that time as well.

The problems of medical screening and psycholog�ical tests of persons entering aviation schools were ofparticular significance for air medicine. The selectionfor aviation services was first carried out according tothe principle of comprehensive clinical examination ofcandidates and individual personality assessment.

An air medical officer is a specialist supposed toensure occupational health and reliable performanceof all people responsible for flight work efficiency andflight safety. A medical officer should pay attention tothe study of methods for diagnosing premorbid statesand diseases with asymptomatic (latent) progress. Anair medical officer usually deals with a healthy personwho should meet the enhanced requirements for fly�ing. Therefore, an air medical officer should be activeand persistent in taking necessary preventive mea�sures. An important feature of this activity is the abilityto think scientifically, from making decisions aboutpilot’s readiness for a particular flight to giving expertopinion on their flight fitness.

Numerous studies by AM specialists have shownthat the influence (especially repeated and long�term)of flying occupational factors is accompanied by a syn�drome�like set of changes at the molecular, cellular,and tissue levels (Fig. 2). They result in the followingtwo major unfavorable processes: accelerated biologi�cal aging (Fig. 3) and partial health insufficiency(table).

Occupational specificity of aircrews is that a gener�ally poor state of health rather than a disease per semay threaten the safety of aircrews, passengers, andpopulation under the airplane routes. Hence, the key

Unfavorable factors

Decrease in activity and efficiency of energy exchange

Signs of decrease in adaptation potential

Increase of O2 Oxidation and Decrease in

Decrease in Increase in Changeover of

Accelerated ageing Partial insufficiency

consumptiontion at rest

phosphorylationuncoupling

capacity ofaerobic energy

sources

oxidativepotential of

mitochondria

the share ofanaerobic

energyproduction

metabolismmainly to

metabolismof fats

of health

Fig. 2. Syndrome�like states under the major unfavorablefactors of light work.

Bio

logi

cal a

ge,

yr

Biological ager

Biological age

Chronological age, yr

60

50

40

30

of population

of a pilot

5040

Fig. 3. General biological regularities of age�specific work�ing capacity of a pilot. Calculation chart of the ratio ofchronological and biological age.

Page 3: The 100th anniversary of air medicine

HUMAN PHYSIOLOGY Vol. 37 No. 7 2011

THE 100th ANNIVERSARY OF AIR MEDICINE 765

concept of AM introduced in 1986 by V.A. Ponomar�enko, member of the Russian Academy of Education,is occupational health as the ability of the body to pre�serve the given compensatory and protective proper�ties that provide the capacity for work under all condi�tions of occupational activity.

The schematic diagram of interrelationshipbetween the structural elements of occupationalhealth and longevity is shown in Fig. 4. The compo�nents such as biological age (basic component) andfunctional states (dynamic component) are a kind ofcriteria for the effects of different factors on humanbody. At the same time, it is advisable to use biologicalage for estimation of chronic/cumulative exposuresand the functional states for estimation of acute expo�sures, including extreme exposures going beyondmaximum permissible standards.

Occupational health includes three most importantcomponents (Fig. 4): occupationally important quali�ties, functional reserves, and the genotypic/pheno�typic state of a person. The concept of professionallongevity of pilots and cosmonauts is formed with dueregard for the necessary level of education and trainingof specialists, as well as the reliability and safety ofactivity, which will be mentioned hereinafter.

Flight work practice shows a clear interdependenceof occupational health and flight safety (Fig. 5).

Reliability is the probability of obtaining certainresults in occupational activity without health damageand saving an aircraft. The reliability of activity is thebasis of flight safety.

All the above is the subject of medical accidentology.Flight safety is the task of a functioning aviation

system on preventing or countering the threat of flightaccidents.

The aviation system includes people, aviation, andspecial equipment combined structurally and func�tionally for flight performance and comprehensivemission support. This system is conventionally dividedinto five elements: (1) the mission management team;(2) the pilot/operator; (3) the aircraft (AC); (4) theexternal environment; and (5) the mission supportgroup.

The key element in each component of this systemis a person with definite professional knowledge, skillsand abilities, first and foremost the flight personnel.

An air medical officer is enlisted in the missionsupport group of the functioning aviation system anddirectly participates in the medical support of flights.

The medical support of flights is a system of orga�nizational, therapeutic and preventive, physiologicaland hygienic, and psychological measures taken tomaintain the high level of occupational health andworking capacity of the flight personnel and missionsupport group.

Thus, the field of interest of air medicine includesoccupational health, specific states of the human bodyunder flight conditions, unusual conditions of occu�

pational activity of aircrew members, and specificoccupational conditions during normal flights andparticularly during in�flight emergencies.

The goal of research in air medicine is to providereliable flight performance and flight safety, to developmeasures for the maintenance of occupational healthand longevity of flight personnel, and to preserve highworking capacity during all kinds of flights.

The objectives of aviation medicine are as follows:(1) Investigation of the influence of different flight

factors on the human body with consideration foroccupational activity; development of physiologicaland hygienic requirements for the life support systemsof aircrafts.

The ratio of morbidity rate in pilots and ground persons

Disease Ratio

Urolithiasis 6 : 1

Myocardiodystrophy and other diseases of car�diovascular system (CVS)

4 : 1

Functional diseases 4 : 1

Bradyacuasia 3.7 : 1

Vasomotor rhinitis 3.2 : 1

Degenerative and dystrophic diseases of back�bone

2.7 : 1

Immunodeficient and autoimmune diseases 2 : 1

Gastrointestinal diseases 1.5 : 1

Occupational

High level Reliability

Occupational health

Functional states

Clinical Occupationally Functional

Biological age

longevity

of educationand training

and safetyof work

(dynamiccomponent)

(genophenotypical)status significant qualities reserves

(base component)

Fig. 4. Schematic diagram of interrelations between struc�tural elements of occupational health and longevity.

Page 4: The 100th anniversary of air medicine

766

HUMAN PHYSIOLOGY Vol. 37 No. 7 2011

USHAKOV, BUBEEV

(2) Investigation of the specificity of human activ�ity during emergency situations and development ofmedical requirements for special and personnel sur�vival equipment.

(3) Investigation of specificity of occupationalactivity of the crews of different types of aircrafts anddifferent mission support groups. Development ofmedical guidelines for enhancing flight safety and effi�ciency of preparation of aircrafts, equipment, anddevices with regard to the human factor.

(4) Determination of psychophysiological capaci�ties of pilots during aircraft operation; elaboration ofthe medical and technical requirements for indicationand signaling systems during flight and control.

(5) Investigation of the causes of flight emergenciesand flight accidents associated with the state of healthand disturbance of working capacity of aircrews; elab�oration of medical requirements for accident riskreduction.

(6) Substantiation of medical standards and guide�lines for selection and training of aircrews, missionmanagement teams, and the personnel of mission sup�port groups; substantiation of physiological andhygienic requirements for flight simulators.

(7) Development of the methods and medical andtechnical requirements for the medical facilities mon�itoring the health and working capacities of aircrewsand mission support personnel.

The first (general) group of research methods of theair and space medicine includes physiological, clini�cal, electrophysiological, psychological and othermethods of health control. The research methods ofthe second (specific) group are divided into two sub�groups. The first one includes the methods used underlaboratory conditions. These are the modeling of flight

factors and pilot’s activity in ground�based simulatorsand its separate elements at control panel mock�ups,test benches and facilities. The second subgroupincludes experimental studies under flight conditionsin specially equipped flying test beds.

During flight experiments, the requirements formedical equipment considerably increase. It must bespace�saving, reliable during the work under the influ�ence of occupational factors (G�loads, vibrations,noises, etc.), light�weight, and providing reliablerecording of medical and biological parameters byconventional methods and, if necessary, by themethod of telemetry.

The principal duty of an air medical officer, i.e.,health care, maintenance of occupational work capac�ity and prolongation of occupational longevity offlight personnel, is fulfilled through a set of measuresin three main fields: medical, psychophysiological,and physiological–hygienic.

The medical field includes a set of therapeutic andpreventive measures. Their pivot is organization andimplementation of medical supervision. It is based onthree basic principles: continuity, succession, andindividual�oriented approach.

The problems of psychophysiological training are asignificant field of activity of air medical officers. Theygo beyond the limits of theoretical investigation of thebases of air medicine and community health. Thisrange of problems is associated with practical forma�tion in pilots of occupationally important qualitiesproviding higher tolerance to flight factors, physicaland mental stability during flight work.

The most important element of the work of airmedical officer is the sanitary and hygienic control ofnutrition under ground conditions and on board theplane, recreation arrangement, and the control overobservance of storage regulations for pilot’s specialequipment and conditions of working with toxic andtechnical liquids. It is also necessary to control theavailability of airfield medical station and the level ofits equipment with medical and technical facilities andto continuously check the food and medical packs ofseat kits.

In recent years, all of these problems have beenincluded into the global system of ergonomic provi�sions of the human factor in aviation (Fig. 6). It isobvious that air medical officers are engaged in thework long before the moment when pilots start to per�form their daily occupational activities.

In the case of international flights, medical officersmust do medical surveillance of aircrews performingflights to problem countries in respect of quarantineinfections, carry out chemoprophylaxis, and controlprophylactic immunization of crew members.

It should be emphasized that aviation has beengaining height and speed owing to the efforts of airphysiologists and physicians.

Inci

den

t pe

r 10

00 o

pera

tion

al h

ours

HealthyDiseases of CVSDiseases of gastrointestinal tractDiseases of backbone

14

12

10

8

6

4

2

0

1234

1 2 3 4

Fig. 5. Occupational health of a pilot and flight safety: theinfluence of diseases on performance efference.

Page 5: The 100th anniversary of air medicine

HUMAN PHYSIOLOGY Vol. 37 No. 7 2011

THE 100th ANNIVERSARY OF AIR MEDICINE 767

High�altitude, anti�G and shockproof equipmentin its medical substantiation provided pilots withhealth, necessary level of capacity for work, and flightsafety.

The results of fundamental research in air medicineenabled the flights at high altitudes and hypersonicvelocities, delivered pilots from altitude and decom�pression sicknesses, traumatism and death because ofthe loss of consciousness. Over 15000 most compli�cated experiments with people and hundreds of thou�sands of experiments with animals were required todevelop physiological substantiations of high�altitudeequipment for high performance aircrafts. As a result,the frequency of flight accidents for the above reasonsis no more than 0.2–0.5% of all accidents and crashes.

Thus, AM is a young independent scientific andpractical discipline, which has its own subject, goalsand objectives, and specific methods of research. Itsdevelopment always advances today’s requirements,with due consideration of the prospects of aviationdevelopment. It may be confirmed by development ofspace medicine, which has originated within the airmedicine and now ensures opportunities for long�term spaceflights.

“Aerospace medicine, as well as human reserves,has no limits, but there are scientific laws of physiol�ogy, hygiene, psychology, and medical ethics,” wroteProf. S.A. Bugrov in 2001.

Investigation of these laws is the subject of air med�icine.

Development of

Conceptualization

Development Expert judgment Participation

FDT, ST

Participation in the

Commercial production.

initial ergonomicdata, preparation(approval of TTRfor pilot project),

formation ofregulatoryframework

of a system

of initialergonomicdata, expertexamination

of pilot project,preparation

of RS for ED

Preparation of

and experimentalevaluation of

ergonomic decisionsof development

engineer, solution ofproblems of humanfactor management,preparation of test

program

Specimen ED.Draft design,

mock�up, prototype

in the testingof

experimentalmodels

Preparationof the Act

control of testing ofaerospace models.

Medical control of theinfluence of workfactors on health,

occupational longevity,assimilation and training

of aviation specialists.Making arrangements for

the medical problemsof flight safety

Use(aerospaceequipment)

pilot projectmanufacturing,and preparation

of ST

of WDD

Fig. 6. The system of ergonomic, including hygiene–sanitary, management of the models of aviation and space equipment at allstages of its “lifecycle”: TTR, tactical and technical requirements; RS, requirements specifications; ED, experimental design; ST,state testing; FDT, flight development tests; WDD, working design documents.