26
9/26/2012 1 That's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced Vision Institute Course Objectives better understand the “new” definition of glaucoma list and ID the characteristics of glaucoma Differentiate glaucomatous fields from neurological Differentiate glaucomatous fields from neurological fields and other types of VF loss Identify the classic findings of the glaucomatous optic disc Become better adept at differentiating glaucomatous optic nerves from other ON pathologies/ abnormalities To differentiate what is not glaucoma one must first have a firm grasp of what glaucoma is… Glaucoma Defined Glaucoma Defined A multi-factorial optic neuropathy characterized by loss of retinal ganglion cells and optic atrophy, resulting in visual field defects and changes in the optic nerve. No IOP criterion Hallmark Findings in glaucoma IOP elevation The Glaucomatous disc The Glaucomatous disc VF loss NFL loss IOP: What is normal really? Normal IOP is not a number Could be defined as that pressure which does not lead that pressure which does not lead to glaucomatous optic atrophy to glaucomatous optic atrophy to glaucomatous optic atrophy to glaucomatous optic atrophy All eyes do not respond the same to given pressure levels Numerous studies on measuring IOP All show normal mean IOP ranges from 15-17mm Hg I tell patients: can be normal from 8-21 mm Hg

That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

1

That's Not Glaucoma:

Tales from a referral centerGregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAOAdvanced Vision Institute

Course Objectives

• better understand the “new” definition of glaucoma• list and ID the characteristics of glaucoma• Differentiate glaucomatous fields from neurological• Differentiate glaucomatous fields from neurological

fields and other types of VF loss• Identify the classic findings of the glaucomatous optic

disc • Become better adept at differentiating glaucomatous

optic nerves from other ON pathologies/ abnormalities

•To differentiate what is not glaucoma one must first have a firm grasp of what glaucoma is…

Glaucoma DefinedGlaucoma Defined

A multi-factorial optic neuropathy characterized by loss of retinal ganglion cells and optic atrophy, resulting in visual field defects and changes in the optic nerve. No IOP criterion

Hallmark Findings in glaucoma

• IOP elevation• The Glaucomatous disc• The Glaucomatous disc• VF loss• NFL loss

IOP: What is normal really?

• Normal IOP is not a number• Could be defined as that pressure which does not lead that pressure which does not lead

to glaucomatous optic atrophyto glaucomatous optic atrophyto glaucomatous optic atrophyto glaucomatous optic atrophy▫ All eyes do not respond the same to given pressure

levels

• Numerous studies on measuring IOP▫ All show normal mean IOP ranges from 15-17mm Hg• I tell patients: can be normal from 8-21 mm Hg

Page 2: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

2

OHTS: What have We learned?

Ocular HTN is Defined As:

• IOP > 21 (AAO); IOP > 24 (OHTS)• Without VF Defect• Without ONH Abnormalities• Without A/C Angle Abnormalities

OHTS

Mission:• Evaluate the safety and efficacy of topical ocular

hypotensive medication in delaying or preventing thehypotensive medication in delaying or preventing the development of primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) in individuals with elevated IOP

• Identify baseline demographic and clinical factors that predict which participants will develop POAG

OHTS

• The OHTS Entry Criteria▫ Aged 40 to 80 years▫ Normal visual fieldsNormal visual fields Humphrey 30-2

▫ Normal optic discs▫ Untreated IOP: 24 to 32 mmHg in qualifying eye 21 to 32 mmHg fellow eye

OHTSSummary• Treatment produced about a 20% reduction

in IOP.T d d i id f POAG i• Treatment reduced incidence of POAG in OHTS participants by more than 50% at 5 years from 9.5% in the observation group to 4.4% in the medication group.

• Little evidence of safety concerns with Tx.

OHTSSignificant Baseline Predictive Factors

• Corneal thickness was the single most powerful predictor of progression in the OHTSOHTS.

Dr. Heuer (OCHS investigator)

Page 3: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

3

Corneal ThicknessCorneal Thickness

Corneal Thickness (CCT)

< 545 um greater risk

> 545 um less risk> 545 um less risk

* 2.5 mm correction factor for every 50 um change in CCT ( Doughty and Zaman survey

Ophthalmology 2000)

Corneal Thickness (µm) Correction Value

405 7

425 6

445 5

465 4

485 3

505 2

525 1

IOP Conversion

545 0

565 -1

585 -2

605 -3

625 -4

645 -5

665 -6

685 -7

705 -8Correction values according tocorneal thickness of 545 µm.

Misclassification ConcernsMisclassification Concerns

• This will have significant implications on everyday practice.

▫ Misclassification based on measured IOP▫ Many may have inadequately controlled IOP▫ Many OHT’s may be over-treated▫ May mean we will set even lower TP’s

OHTS OHTS

Page 4: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

4

OHTS

Summary

• Not every patient with OH should be treated• Consider measuring corneal thickness in all patients with

OH or glaucoma g• Recommend treatment to OH patient at moderate to high

risk, taking into consideration:

▫ Age » Low Overall Incidence POAG in OH▫ Medical Status » Burdens of Treatment▫ Life Expectancy » Risk Factors▫ Likely Treatment Benefit

LTG/NTG: Does it exist?

• Leaders in the field are not in total agreement!

• Most consider those with glaucomatous optic• Most consider those with glaucomatous optic neuropathy with IOP never higher than 21 NTG▫ Although IOP has significant influence on progression 30% reduction in IOP is assoc. with protection of VF and

nerve status

• Other factors involved besides IOP

The Glaucomatous Disc

• rim thinning/notching• drance hemesdrance hemes• baring of the circumlinear vessels• nasalization of vessels• laminar baring

VF loss in glaucoma

OCT/ NFL in glaucoma

NFL analysisNFL analysisDon’t get blinded by the Science

Page 5: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

5

GDx vs. OCT The most common things that will lead you to misdiagnosis………

• Abnormal disc appearance: pale, oblique/ tilted,or pp p qotherwise anomalous disc• Unexplained VF abnormalities• #1 NFL abnormalities ( GDx, OCT, HRT)▫ Don’t put all your eggs in that basket!

Advanced Optic nerve AssessmentAssessment

Optic Disc assessment

(The Five R's)

This section was developed byThis section was developed by

Robert N. Weinreb, MDRobert N. Weinreb, MDFelipe Medeiros, MDFelipe Medeiros, MD

Hamilton Glaucoma CenterHamilton Glaucoma CenterUniversity of California, San DiegoUniversity of California, San Diego

Remo Susanna Jr., MDRemo Susanna Jr., MDUniversity of San Paulo, BrazilUniversity of San Paulo, Brazil

Optic Disc/RNFL ExaminationOptic Disc/RNFL ExaminationOptic Disc/RNFL Examination Optic Disc/RNFL Examination “The 5Rs”“The 5Rs”

11 Observe the scleral Observe the scleral RRing ing to identify the limits of to identify the limits of the optic disc and its sizethe optic disc and its size

Five Rules for Assessment of the Five Rules for Assessment of the Optic Disc in GlaucomaOptic Disc in Glaucoma

This section was developed by Robert N. Weinreb, MD, Felipe Medeiros, MD, and This section was developed by Robert N. Weinreb, MD, Felipe Medeiros, MD, and Remo Susanna Jr, MD.Remo Susanna Jr, MD.

Page 6: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

6

11 Observe the scleral Observe the scleral RRing ing to identify the limits of to identify the limits of the optic disc and its sizethe optic disc and its size

22 Identify the size of theIdentify the size of theRRimim

Five Rules for Assessment of the Five Rules for Assessment of the Optic Disc in GlaucomaOptic Disc in Glaucoma

This section was developed by Robert N. Weinreb, MD, Felipe Medeiros, MD, This section was developed by Robert N. Weinreb, MD, Felipe Medeiros, MD, and Remo Susanna Jr, MD.and Remo Susanna Jr, MD.

11 Observe the scleral Observe the scleral RRing ing to identify the limits of to identify the limits of the optic disc and its sizethe optic disc and its size

22 Identify the size of theIdentify the size of theRRimim

Five Rules for Assessment of the Five Rules for Assessment of the Optic Disc in GlaucomaOptic Disc in Glaucoma

33 Examine theExamine the RRetinal etinal nerve fiber layernerve fiber layer

This section was developed by Robert N. Weinreb, MD, Felipe Medeiros, MD, This section was developed by Robert N. Weinreb, MD, Felipe Medeiros, MD, and Remo Susanna Jr, MD.and Remo Susanna Jr, MD.

11 Observe the scleral Observe the scleral RRing ing to identify the limits of to identify the limits of the optic disc and its sizethe optic disc and its size

22 Identify the size of theIdentify the size of theRRimim

Five Rules for Assessment of the Five Rules for Assessment of the Optic Disc in GlaucomaOptic Disc in Glaucoma

33 Examine the Examine the RRetinal etinal nerve fiber layernerve fiber layer

44 Examine the Examine the RRegion of egion of parapapillary atrophyparapapillary atrophy

This section was developed by Robert N. Weinreb, MD, Felipe Medeiros, MD, This section was developed by Robert N. Weinreb, MD, Felipe Medeiros, MD, and Remo Susanna Jr, MD.and Remo Susanna Jr, MD.

11 Observe the scleral Observe the scleral RRing ing to identify the limits of to identify the limits of the optic disc and its sizethe optic disc and its size

22 Identify the size of theIdentify the size of theRRimim

Five Rules for Assessment of the Five Rules for Assessment of the Optic Disc in GlaucomaOptic Disc in Glaucoma

33 Examine the Examine the RRetinal etinal nerve fiber layernerve fiber layer

44 Examine the Examine the RRegion of egion of parapapillary atrophyparapapillary atrophy

55 Look for Look for RRetinal and etinal and optic disc hemorrhages optic disc hemorrhages

This section was developed by Robert N. Weinreb, MD, Felipe Medeiros, MD, This section was developed by Robert N. Weinreb, MD, Felipe Medeiros, MD, and Remo Susanna Jr, MD.and Remo Susanna Jr, MD.

Rule #1Rule #1

Observe the scleral Observe the scleral RRing to ing to identify the limits and the size identify the limits and the size of the optic discof the optic disc

Vertical Vertical

Scleralring

Scleralring

Optic Disc SizeOptic Disc Size

Horizontal Horizontal disc diameterdisc diameter

disc disc diameterdiameter

Page 7: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

7

Measurement of optic disc size with Measurement of optic disc size with direct direct ophthalmoscopeophthalmoscope

Small aperture (5 degree) of Small aperture (5 degree) of WelchWelch--Allen direct Allen direct

hth lhth l

Optic Disc SizeOptic Disc Size

ophthalmoscopeophthalmoscope

Size of light spot ~ size of average optic discSize of light spot ~ size of average optic disc

Measurement of optic disc size withMeasurement of optic disc size withbiomicroscopybiomicroscopy

Volk lensVolk lensMeasure length of slit beamMeasure length of slit beam

Optic Disc SizeOptic Disc Size

Avg vertical diameter: 1.8 mmAvg vertical diameter: 1.8 mm

Correction factorsCorrection factors

Volk 60D Volk 60D –– x 1.0x 1.0

Volk 78D Volk 78D –– x 1.1x 1.1Volk 90D Volk 90D –– x 1.3x 1.3

Avg horizontal diameter: 1.7 mmAvg horizontal diameter: 1.7 mm

Size of cup varies with size of disc Size of cup varies with size of disc Large discs have large cups in healthy eyesLarge discs have large cups in healthy eyes

1 41 4 1 91 9 2 42 4

Optic Disc SizeOptic Disc Size

Identify small and large optic discsIdentify small and large optic discsSmall discs:Small discs: avg vertical diameter <1.5 mmavg vertical diameter <1.5 mmLarge discs:Large discs: avg vertical diameter >2.2 mmavg vertical diameter >2.2 mm

SmallSmall

1.41.4

AverageAverage

1.91.9

LargeLarge

2.42.4

Optic Disc SizeOptic Disc Size

Small discs with glaucoma may have small cupsSmall discs with glaucoma may have small cups

Rim Rim thinningthinning

Rim Rim thinningthinning

Be cautious with myopic discsBe cautious with myopic discs

Optic Disc SizeOptic Disc SizeRule #2Rule #2

Identify the size of the Identify the size of the neuroretinal neuroretinal RRimim

Page 8: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

8

Rim widthRim widthDistance Distance between between border of disc border of disc and position of and position of blood vesselblood vessel

SS

NN TT

ISNT RULEISNT RULE

blood vessel blood vessel bendingbending

ISNT ruleISNT ruleIInferior > nferior > SSuperior > uperior > NNasal > asal > TTemporalemporal

II

Localized Rim Thinning/NotchingLocalized Rim Thinning/Notching

NotchingNotching

NotchNotch

Observe the color of the rim Observe the color of the rim to identify pallor to identify pallor

A pale rim increases the likelihood for A pale rim increases the likelihood for a nona non--glaucomatous optic neuropathyglaucomatous optic neuropathy

Diffuse pallorDiffuse pallor

Pallor > cupPallor > cup

PallorPallor

CupNonNon--glaucomatousglaucomatous

neuropathyneuropathy

Rule # 3Rule # 3

Examine the Examine the RRetinal nerve etinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL)fiber layer (RNFL)

Page 9: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

9

RNFL ExaminationRNFL Examination

•• Best performed using redBest performed using red--free light free light (red(red--free photographs or green light)free photographs or green light)

•• Look atLook atStriationsStriationsBrightnessBrightness

•• Look for Look for diffusediffuse and and localizedlocalized RNFL lossRNFL loss

Visibility of parapapillary retinal vesselsVisibility of parapapillary retinal vessels

RNFL RedRNFL Red--Free PhotographsFree Photographs

BrightBrightstriationsstriations

Diffuse RNFL LossDiffuse RNFL Loss

Diffuse RNFL lossDiffuse RNFL lossDiffuse loss of striate pattern + Diffuse loss of striate pattern + increased visibility of retinal vessel bordersincreased visibility of retinal vessel borders

Bright Bright striationsstriations

Diffuse lossDiffuse lossof striationsof striations

Normal RNFLNormal RNFLDiffuse RNFL lossDiffuse RNFL loss

(advanced glaucoma)(advanced glaucoma)

Diffuse RNFL LossDiffuse RNFL Loss

Localized RNFL LossLocalized RNFL Loss

Localized RNFL defectLocalized RNFL defectWedgeWedge--shaped dark areashaped dark area

Rule # 4Rule # 4

Examine the Examine the RRegion of egion of parapapillary atrophy (PPA)parapapillary atrophy (PPA)p p p y p y ( )p p p y p y ( )

Page 10: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

10

Parapapillary AtrophyParapapillary Atrophy

Alpha zoneAlpha zone•• HypoHypo-- and hyperand hyper--

pigmented areaspigmented areas

•• Present in normal as well Present in normal as well as in glaucomatous eyesas in glaucomatous eyes

Beta zoneBeta zone•• Atrophy of the retinal Atrophy of the retinal

pigment epithelium (RPE) pigment epithelium (RPE) and choriocapillarisand choriocapillaris–– Large choroidal vessels Large choroidal vessels

become visiblebecome visible

•• More common in More common in glaucomatous eyesglaucomatous eyes

Beta zoneBeta zone•• Width of beta zone Width of beta zone

inversely correlates with inversely correlates with rim width at same arearim width at same area

•• Larger beta zone Larger beta zone thinner rimthinner rim

Thin rimThin rim

Parapapillary AtrophyParapapillary Atrophy

•• Progression of beta zone Progression of beta zone associated with associated with progressive glaucomaprogressive glaucoma

Larger Larger zonezone

Rule # 5Rule # 5

Look for Look for RRetinal and etinal and optic disc hemorrhagesoptic disc hemorrhages

Optic Disc HemorrhageOptic Disc HemorrhageIndicative of glaucoma progressionIndicative of glaucoma progression

FlFlFlameFlame--shapedshaped

hemorrhagehemorrhage

Optic Disc HemorrhageOptic Disc Hemorrhage

Normally disappears after 2Normally disappears after 2--6 months6 months

Optic Disc HemorrhageOptic Disc HemorrhageDetection of disc hemorrhages requires Detection of disc hemorrhages requires careful careful optic disc examinationoptic disc examination

Page 11: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

11

Theories of ONH DamageMechanical Theory

• Abnormal levels of IOP cause direct damage on ON• Compression of laminar sheets

Di i f l i• Distortion of laminar pores• Crimp or pinch axons of GC causing blockage

of axonal transport apoptosis• In LTG, if not purely due to vascular

insufficiency, ON tissue must have some connective tissue abnormality/susceptibility

Vascular Theory• Assumes a decrease in blood flow in lamina cribrosa blocks

axoplasmic flow by reducing energy available to keep system operational.• Increase IOP causes a reduction of blood flow in intraocular

vessels and prelaminar ONHvessels and prelaminar ONH• True only of choroidal circulation• Retinal circulation has “auto regulatory mechanisms”• Auto-regulation of blood flow for blood vessels supplying

ON (may be lacking)

* Evidence - dramatic improvement of blood flow following adequate lowering of IOP.

Page 12: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

12

The pale disc: (What glaucoma is not)

Differential Diagnosis1. Compression2. Ischemia3. Disc Drusen4. Disc anomalies\

Clinical Findings/ Intro case

• 74/AA/Female referred in for floaters OS x 4 days. (-) decreased VA painless small spots comes and goes• Med Hx: (+) HTN ( ) DM ( ) CVA• Med Hx: (+) HTN (-) DM (-) CVA• Meds: Loratadine, Clonidine HCL, Benicar• OCHx; (-) prior Hx glaucoma (-) trauma (-) injury

(-) blood loss, hypotensive episodes, transfusions, Reynaud’s, migraines

Clinical Findings

• DVA cc OD 20/25 OS 20/20 • Color NML• Pupils (-) APD• Ext. Nml• SLE; 1+ cs/2+ ns OU

• Ta OD 20 OS 20 @ 3:22 pm

Clinical Findings

• DFE: Vitreous syneresis OU, macula Cl OU ; Optic nerve; FPH OD; heme off nerve OS, p ; ; ,C/D ratio .60/.80 OD OS .55/.60 vessels attenuated

• Periphery: (-) Tears (-) Holes (-) RD’s

Optic nerves: Initial visit Diagnosis and Plan

• Diagnosis▫ COAG Suspect▫ HTR O U▫ HTR O.U.▫ IR Heme OS HTN vs Drance Heme• Plan▫ Ordered blood work-up, ESR, CRP, CBC with diff.▫ Fasting Blood Glucose, HgA1C▫ Check HTN, BP with PCP, photo document▫ Order Carotid Duplex Study

Page 13: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

13

Testing: Gonio / Pach

• PACH: OD 518 OS 521

• Gonio: open grade 3-4 360° OU plateau Iris OU

Visual Fields/ initial visit

GDxVisual Fields / at Follow up

Optic Nerves FollowOptic Nerves Follow--up: IOP OD 20 OS 18up: IOP OD 20 OS 18

Case # 1 TM

▫ 51/AA /F seen in consultation for glaucoma / 2nd opinion▫Patient using Cosopt for years in OS BID▫Documented VF defect OS only since 11/04▫Non-progressive

Page 14: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

14

Key questions to ask your glaucoma patients

• History of blood loss/ i.e. surgery, MVA, pregnancy/ deliverypregnancy/ delivery• Blood transfusions• Hypotensive episodes or crisis• Migraines• Reynaud's Phenomenon• Ocular trauma/ blunt

Medical hx.• Med Hx.:(-) DM, elevated cholesterol, (-) HTN,

(-) MS, (+) history of epilepsy/ blacked out two times in 2002, diagnosed as seizures, (+) Hx. hypothyroid• Fibroids removed, no transfusions, or significant

blood loss per patient

• Oc. Hx: treatment for “low tension glaucoma” for years OS, Cosopt BID OS▫ Pretreatment IOP 11 OD 10OS (-) injury, surgery

• Possible family hx. of glaucoma in (PGM)

Medical Hx.

• Meds: Synthroid vitamins, Kepra• Ocular Meds: Cosopt BID OS

Clinical findings/ Case 1

• DVA cc: OD 20/20 OS 20/20• Pupils: trace APD OS, color vision nml OU

• SLE: Cl cornea OU, (-) endopigment, A/C deep and quiet (-) PX, iris nml OU (-) TID and NVI. Lens trace CS/NS OU.• Ta @ 10:01 OD 12 OS 12

DFE:

• Vitreous clear OU, macula clear, optic nerve enlarged cups with temporal sloping OU, C/D ratio .65 round OD, .70/.60 OS with pale rim from 9-5:00; Large ON size OUg

• Vessels mild attenuation• Periphery clear OU

Optic nerve photos/ case 1 Tm

Page 15: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

15

TESTING: VF’s and Gdx/ NFL

• VF’s show a full and normal OD, OS inferior altitudinal VF loss

• Gdx. NFL analysis: Thin superior NFL OS

VF’sVF’s

What do we have, let’s add it up!

• Large nerves with large cups• Pale nerve OS, never worked up!Pale nerve OS, never worked up!• Low IOP, on and off meds • VF defect, long standing inferior altitudinal

GDx/ NFL analysis

Note thin NFL

superiorly OS

Testing ordered

• CBC with Diff, ESR, CRP, ANA, ACE, Serum Lysozyme, clotting factors, serum protein S and C

• Carotid Doppler/ Duplex study• Echo cardiogram

Testing results

• All normal; clean carotids and echo.• Dx. : Ischemic event of unknown etiology vs,

possible old MS?possible old MS?

• Plan: D/C Cosopt▫ F/u visits (3) show IOP’ s between 09 and 13 OU

• Ordered MRI of head and orbits R/O compression/MS…….Normal

Page 16: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

16

Follow-up visits

IOP has been 8-10 on three visits OS off meds

Case # 2 MP / 73yo Asian male

Referred by PCP for reduced VA OS> OD progressive

Previously Dx. of COAG and NAION OS Referred to PCP for “vascular w/up” 2002

Patient was started on Xalatan therapy (09/19/05) but  Patient was started on Xalatan therapy (09/19/05) but stopped med, lost to follow‐up till ( 04/22/09). 

Medical HX.: +MI, +HTN, + elevated cholesterol Meds: Flomax, HCTZ, amlodipine (Norvasc), Trazodone, 

Bypass surgery in 2000

Intracranial surgery in 2008 ( tumor removed)

Case # 2 MP 

Ocular Hx. : Possible AION OS, glaucoma suspect       (poor compliance), no injury, cataract OU

Pretreatment pressures of 27 OD/OS

Previously treated with Lumigan, and Cosopt

Hx. Of non‐compliance

Surgery; ALT OS 02/10/04,  OD 03/05/04

Case # 2 MP: Clinical Exam (4/22/09) 

DVA cc       OD 20/40          OS HM @ 3Ft.

Pupils: 1+ APD OS; 50% desaturation to bright light

External: NML

SLE: microcystic degeneration, peripheral cornea OU, (‐) endopigment. A/C (‐) PX OU deep and quiet      Lens 2+ CS/NS OU

Ta @ 9:51 am    21 OD       27 OS

Case # 2 MP: Clinical Exam 

DFE: Vitreous Cl OU, macula CL OU, vessels HTR I

Optic Nerves: large cupping , .80/.70 OD, .85/.80 OS with pale temporal rim OU  (See Photo)with pale temporal rim OU. (See Photo)

Periphery Cl OU, (‐)tears, holes, detachments

Ordered VF OD only today

Showed right homonymous VF loss

Optic Nerve PresentationOD OS

Page 17: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

17

Analysis of Visual FieldsAnalysis of Visual Fields

4/22/09 Va 20/40 OD

Analysis of Visual FieldsAnalysis of Visual Fields

09/15/09 VA CF@ 3ft,

Previously 20/200 

Diagnosis

Bilateral Optic atrophy 2˚ to compressive lesion (old)

Pituitary adenoma

Progressive VF Loss OS>OD

Glaucoma suspect, Ocular HTN off treatment

Cataract

HTR OU

Retrospective analysis of Visual FieldsOS (12/09/02)  OD (12/09/02) 

Retrospective analysis of Visual FieldsOS (9/19/05) OD (9/19/05)

Points to consider/ Points to consider/ Sins of OmissionSins of Omission

Patient seen originally  on 03/20/02 Dx. NAION OS 

No VF Done ( Sin of Omission) on pale disc

Found later to have VF loss OS (12/9/02)9

New Diagnosis : HH  Failure to recognize need for neuro‐imaging study with homonymous VF loss.

First head CT –Scan was done on 06/19/08

DVA (03/20/02)    OD 20/25    OS 20/200

Optic nerves C/D .35 round OD, .50 round OS pale disc 

Page 18: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

18

The Sins of Omission/CommissionThe Sins of Omission/Commission

1st Diagnosis: AION Non‐arteritic OS    (3/20/02)

(no blood work‐up) CRP and ESR 

2nd Diagnosis: Right Homonymous hemianopia  2nd Diagnosis: Right Homonymous hemianopia consistent with left occipital CVA     (12/09/02)

(12/9/02) no CT was done until 06/08

Vision dropped to CF OS in 9 months from original visit

Tx. On 12/9/02……. Lumigan qhs OU

For a Pituitary adenoma

Head CT ( 6/19/08)Head CT ( 6/19/08)Head CT ( 6/19/08)Head CT ( 6/19/08)Large homogeneously enhancing sellar mass with 

suprasellar extension

Very well defined and does not invade surrounding structures

Does have mass effect, favor pituitary adenoma

MRI of head on 7/18/08MRI of head on 7/18/08MRI of  head on 7/18/08MRI of  head on 7/18/08

Plan

Consider treatment of pressure if consistently above   i h T i l  f  C23 with Trial of  Cosopt

Follow‐up IOP in 1 month      OD17    OS17

Observe

Case # 3 VWCase # 3 VW51yo/ AA/FReferred for 2nd opinion on glaucomaTreated OS only for about a year: Timolol 0.5% BID, Xalatan QHS, VF defect OS.

Case #3: VW

• Medical Hx. : The triad; (+) HTN, (+) DM, and elevated cholesterol▫ Taking HCTZ K+ No cholesterol meds at this time▫ Taking HCTZ, K+, No cholesterol meds at this time

▫ Ocular Hx.: (+) past history of glaucoma suspect on treatment. (-) hx. of trauma, blood loss , migraines, transfusions,

Reynaud’s, hypotensive episodes

Page 19: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

19

Clinical findings

• DVA cc: 20/20 OD 20/20 OS• Pupils: 2+ APD OS• EOM’s: full without restriction pain or diplopia• EOM s: full without restriction pain or diplopia• SLE: Cornea Cl (-) endo-pigment; A/C Deep and

quiet, iris nml OU (-) TID (-) NVI; Lens NS 1+ OU• TA @ 9:30 am OD 15 OS 16, ▫ PACH 581 OD 591 OS, CTA 11 OD 12 OS

DFE

• Macula,vitreous Cl. • optic nerves pink/healthy OD/pale disc OS (9-3)optic nerves pink/healthy OD/pale disc OS (9 3)• C/D .55/.45 OD, .60/.65 OS• Vessels Attenuated

Optic Nerves V.F./Initial/ 7-22-09

V.F./Follow Up/ 11/18/09GDx

Page 20: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

20

Dx

• COAG suspect• Optic atrophy 2 to ischemia likely (HTN,DM,COD)• Mild Cataract OU

• Plan: order carotid duplex study, echocardiogram to search for embolic source.• blood work-up: ESR, CBC w/diff, ANA, ACE sickle

cell screen, C-RP, serum protein electrophoresis, D/C Timolol for now, continue Xalatan qhs OS

Follow - Up

• F/U visit• D/C Timolol BID OS• TA 20 OD 17 OS• TA 20 OD 17 OS• IOP changed only 1 point!

Test Results Show

• Echocardiagram: mild calcification of the mitral valve leaflets• Carotid Doppler: mild amount of smooth plaque in• Carotid Doppler: mild amount of smooth plaque in

the proximal portion of the internal carotid arteries bilaterally.• <50% stenosis• Blood work-up all normal

Follow-Up Visit

• Px on Xalatan only OS qhs ▫ (-) neurological symptom inventory.

• DVA OD 20/15 OS 20/15• Pupils 2 + APD OS• TA 15 OD 11 OS @ 8:18 am• Corrected TA 11 OD 7 OS• Externals: PA 7mm OU

Follow-Up Visit con’t

• Px spared MRI due to: Health Hx, DM, TTN, and elevated cholesterol• DVA 20/15 OU• DVA 20/15 OU• Color vision normal OU• VF’s stable over 3 visits• (-) neuro symptom inventory• Will follow closely for 1 year VF repeat 3 months

Follow-up VF/ No change

Page 21: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

21

Follow-up

• Patient spared MRI due to:▫ Health Hx. : DM, HTN, AND ELEVATED

CHOLESTEROLCHOLESTEROL▫ DVA 20/15 OU▫ Color vision Nml OU▫ VF’s stable over 3 visits▫ (-) neurological symptom inventory

• Will follow closely for 1 yr./ repeat VF 3 mo.

CASE # 4CASE # 4

Clinical Findings and History SJ

• 50/AA/F Referred for 2nd opinion/glaucoma• Med Hx: (+) HTN, elevated cholesterol, ▫ (+) MS Dx 1 yr prior symptoms of tremor▫ (+) MS Dx. 1 yr prior symptoms of tremor, ▫ MS confirmed w/ MRI Dec. 2009

• Meds: Lisinopril, Prevastatin, Rebif

History

• Fm Hx of Glaucoma – Father( ) ( ) h d d f▫ (+) HTN,(+) DM, mother deceased from MI

• OcHx: (-) Trauma/(-)Sx, ▫ (+) previous Dx optic neuritis OS, no previous Hx or

prior tx for glaucoma

Clinical Findings:

• DVA with OD 20/20 OS 20/20• Pupils: (-) APD• SLE: clear cornea ( )endo pigment A/C clear ( ) PX• SLE: clear cornea, (-)endo-pigment, A/C clear (-) PX,

Iris nml, lens 1 + NS OU• Ta 18 OD 21 OS Pach: 562 OD 551 OS

• Corrected TA OD 16 OS 19

DFE

• Vitreous and Macula CL OU, Optic nerves tilted and obliquely inserted OU, temp. sloping, questionable bilateral temporal pallor.• periphery: Clear OU (-) T, H, RD’s

Page 22: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

22

Optic Nerves/ ODOS

Testing

• VF 24-2: OD Superior Bjerrum, OS Inferior Nasal Loss, Superior/Temp para-central scotoma

•• OCT/NFL OCT/NFL OD Inferior NFL thin, OS normal

Dx

• COAG Suspect OD>OS• VF defects• Probable old optic neuritis with secondary OA and• Probable old optic neuritis with secondary OA and

VF loss

Visual Fields OCT/NFL

Page 23: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

23

CASE # 5 SGCASE # 5 SG

Clinical Findings and History

• 45/B/M – referred in for Glaucoma OS treated for years since 2005 for LTG OS only.• IOP’s ranged from 10 15 mm Hg OU Tried• IOP s ranged from 10-15 mm Hg OU. Tried

Lumigan an Xalatan in past OS only, well controlled IOP without meds now.• Med Hx: (+) DM (NIDDM) (-) HTN (+) Elevated

cholesterol• Meds: Metformin, glipizide and Actos

Clinical Findings and History con’t

• Ocular Hx: ?LTG OS, (-) Hx trauma/eye, (-) Hx blood loss, transfusions, hypotensive episodes

• Fm Hx of glaucoma- father• Clinical Findings: DVA cc OD 20/20 OS 20/25• Pupils Trace APD OS• SLE cornea clear OU, A/C D/Q (-) PX; iris Nml,

Lens 1+ NS/Trace CS OD Trace CS/NS OS,

IOP

• TA OD 13 OS 14 PACH OD 508 OS 483 Corrected TA 14.0 OD 17.0 OS

DFE

• Vitreous/Macula Cl, ▫ Optic Nerves C/D .5/.55 OD .60R OS – Temporal

Pallor OS Vessels nml OUPallor OS, Vessels nml OU,

▫ Periphery Cl OU (-) T, H, RD’s OU

Optic Nerves

Page 24: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

24

VF (old)08/20/09

Visual Fields 2/15/10

OCT/NFL Testing

• VF OD Full OS stable inferior para central scotoma• VF OD Full, OS stable inferior para-central scotoma, OCT/NFL slight NFL thinning OS superior

Dx

• COAG Suspect vs LTG suspect OS only• VF defect OS• Likely AION OS R/O compression• Likely AION OS R/O compression• NIDDM without DR• Mild cataracts OU

Plan: PCP to recheck BP + cholesteral and glucoseOrder MRI of Head/Orbits w/contrast (both come back negative)

CASE # 6CASE # 6

Page 25: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

25

History (MG)

• 77/AA/F – Px previously treated for COAG (< 10 yrs) by another practice comes to us to get refill on Cosopt taking BID OUon Cosopt taking BID OU• pre-treatment IOP’s 20 OD 20 OS

(-) Complaints (-) Fm Hx Glaumcoma

• Med Hx: (+) HTN (+) arthritis (+) sinusitis chronic (-) Hx for CVA (-) cardiovascular disease• Meds: Terazosin, Metoprolol, Lisinopril, HCTZ

History con’t

• OcHx. (-) Hx trauma (-) CVA (-) eye sx (-) blood loss, hypotensive episodes/crises (-) low BP, (-) migraines (-) Reynaud’s (-) transfusions( ) migraines ( ) Reynaud s ( ) transfusions

Clinical Findings

• DVA cc OD 20/40 OS 20/20• Pupils: (-) APD• SLE: Cornea Cl ( ) endopigment A/C D/Q OU• SLE: Cornea Cl (-) endopigment, A/C D/Q OU

(-) PX

• SLE lens mixed combined form cataracts both eyes

• TA OD 18 OS 20 @ 9:50 am

DFE

• Macula Cl OU; Optic nerve: PFH OU (-) Pallor; C/D OD .70 round OS .65/.60, vessels A/V crossing changes OU with HTR II OUvessels, A/V crossing changes OU with HTR II OU• Periphery: flat intact 360° OU

VF Initial (12-10-07) VF Follow-up (11-11-08)

Page 26: That's Not Glaucomamtoa - Missouri Optometric … › ... › 2012_Conf › thats_not_glaucoma.pdfThat's Not Glaucoma: Tales from a referral center Gregory M. Schultz O.D. , FAAO Advanced

9/26/2012

26

OCT/NFL Dx.

• COAG by Hx but VF does not match disc appearance• Questionable VF possibly 2 to CVA of inferior

occipital lobesoccipital lobes• Plan: MRI of brain with contrast • Findings of MRI consistent with chronic

ischemic/vascular change in the inferior occipital lobes bilaterally no acute CVA

Pearls you can take to the bank

• In glaucoma the VF should always match or be explained/supported by the disc/NFL findings

• Pallor can be a subtle but common finding but is not a sign of glaucoma but rather ischemia or compression

• If you note pallor/OA be ready to work it up!

Lastly, Don’t be Blinded by the Science!

Your diagnosis consists of 5 parts:1. Careful Pointed Hx2. IOP evaluation3. VF assessment4. Careful inspection of the optic nerve5. And lastly NFL evaluation!

Gregory M. Schultz, OD, FAAOClinical Director

Advanced Vision InstituteHampton Virginia

[email protected]