' rrNUrEs oF rHE MEETING oF DlSrRlc LEVEL =E!!E!l: lPjlBAlSAt-c'ol!!'lrrEE

3-cT saRAKELA.KHARsAwaN.JHARKHA IE H SEPTEMBER 2015

The 2'd meeting of Disirlct Level Experl Appraisal committee (DEAC) Saraikela _ Kha6awan

J harkhand was held on 6th September, 20 16 lnder ihe Chaimanship oi Shri Farl Bhushan n

ihe Confe€nce Room '107, Dislrict Colleciorate Sa€ikela_Kharsawan The lollowing

members were Presenl

t. Shri Fani Bhushan 'Cheiman

Executive Engin@r, Minor lrrigation

Divieion, Samikel..

Shri Sanl.y Kunar Sh.ma

Assi.tant Minins Ofncer, S.Eif.la.

Regionrl officor, JSPCB

Shri B.N.Tripathi

Ranoa Foresr ofiicer, Chandil.

Ranqe Forest Oflicer, saEikela.

D.partment of Metalhrgical and

Materiab Enqinoering, N. l.T. JamshedPur'

Departnent of civil Eosin€e.ing,

2_

3,

6,

Shri Fani Bhushan, chai.man of the Dislrict level Expert Appralsal oommiltee, welcomed allmembeE lo meeling.va ous proposals which were received bv DEIAA, saaikela andfoMarded to OEAC for lheir technical apPraisal came up for discusion. AccordlngLv, lheproject proponents were asked 10 make techn cal preseniaiion for ihe appraisal of lheir prcjeclbefoE the mmmittee.

The ,oLlowing salient obseNations made durlns the preseniations (Prcject _ wise) in brierdesetue serious 6nsideElion.

Prcjects recommended to OEIAA for considoration ofqrand of EC.

Proposals related to Stone Mining (Existins Lease)

ProDosal rclated to Stone llitinino lNew Proiect|

ll. Baliasai Stone DeoPsit of applicant M/s Triveni Engicons Pvt Ltd at Mouza_Baliasai,Thana- Rajnag.r (Govindpur), Dist- saraikera-Kha6awan, Jha*hand (9.03

Acres or 3-654Ha.) Co.sult nt. MIS Safe Environment, Jamsh.dPor, RQP - Dr.curupinder Singh Jaiswal,

This is a Stone Mi.ing Prcjeoi for having an area of 9.03 ades or 3.654Ha [Khala No 72, PlolNo-76 & 741. The committee noted thal as per Form l[4 it is a poposalfor Fresh mining leaseforwhich PP s seking Ec. considering the fact that it is 82 calegory of Pojecl as per EIANolifcarlon daled14.g.2oo6 and The Gazette of lndia no.125 Oated 15/012016 lheEnvironmental lmpacl Assessment as well as Pubic consuliation is not equned Thecommitte€ telt thaiTOR ls noi reqo red nor any formal EWEMP is to be prepared as per TheGazetle. These presc be exemptions (Based on guldelnes an decision taken vide MoEFNorifietion date 14 09 2006) are recommended by the Commiltee in the instant case.Tne proted was revieweo 11 lghl ol OIM No - J-13012/1212013/lA_ll(l). dated 2al0r/2011 of\rOEF SFIM(JladatrqLidel,res ddted 07/0512013 drd GaTeFe Nonficadon dared

15/01/2016 wlth Especl to proposed l\,lining Pan, Environmental Proteciing measoreproposd to be adopted Proposal ior @rrying olt csR aciivilies for scio economicaevelopmenl development o, green belt, due corsideEllor of occupallonal health, etc lnview oiihe size ol th; mine, production Ete and the mneElmined and the assurance slvenby PP thai he willgive due consideralion lo environmenl by maintaining haul roads and watersprinking on same, @rrying oul CSR aclivities fol Socia_economic developmenl,d;vebp;ent or sreen bell, due conslderaiion of occupationa heaih of peEons engaged in

mining. The committee felt that the operation ol the mine wil have not have anv maior impacton tha suroundings. The indic.ted project 6ost ls Rs s0.'14 Lakhs and a provision of Rs 9 69Lakhs wllbe kept for Envtonment managemeniThe detailof mine capacty as perAppbved Mining Plan areMineable Proved Resetue' :

Mineable Proved Reserva :

224330.625MT12242313M-l

Year wise Produciion as PerApproved fi4ining Plan Repod for frve veaB is as follows69999 86 l',17

69998.97 MT69999.56 MT69999.89 MT6715312 MT

The daily production as per Form tlu is 233.33 tones

PP hds sJbmrtted cenrf,cates rrom Ctrcte Oficer. DFO & D[,tO. -e rr.ornatol we,eerarred and fou.d o be sanstafiory. ',6.o,..1F.p.,-. 'J !1. .r-o eo eol"','- 'il" d ..00 5do .o ."p.1q dr. .. , o"j Ir o"e'Lrl VdrJo6r-. od, peroo. ecr..tE ,0. /o..:.r,o,rroe ROp

Based on the pr8entarion mada ad information provide the Committee decided thatthe prcpcal for Batiasai Ston6 Deopsit(New prcject) of.pptic.ntM/s Triveni Enoiconspvt. Lrd. at Molza-Batia5aiiThana- R.jnasar (Govindpur), Disr- s"6ir,.i"-^naEiwani.

Jha.khand (9,03 Ac.es or 3.6S4Ha,) be recommonded for conside.ed ofuErM suDrect to.bove mentioned obsgrvations for grant of Ec. Th€ variousconditions for gEnt ofEC are qiven.l Annexurc t.

1. The Enviromslat Ctealarce is subject to g.ant of mining tease by the Deparlmenl oflndustries, Mines & ceotogy, Government of Jharkhand ro pp and-at other Sratub;Condilions as nnposed by various/ DislrictAuthorilies are comptied wth

2. No mining shal be undertaken ]r the foresl areaforeslry clearance l4inimum distance shal be mainta]nedstipLlaled in altappticab e cuidetres.

3. EC issubjecliothe g.anr of t\,4ining Leasetolhe dghtfutowner.

4. Environmentat CteaEnce is subject to finat order oi the Hon,bte Supreme Coun oflndia/ Nationalcreen Tribunat/ MOEF Gutdetines appticabtelo Minor t\,tinerats

wilhout obtaining lhe equisile pnorfrom Reserved/P.olected Forest as

approved by concerned authorilies as per DETAAin line with Dci,ls Guidetine

5, ENiro,]msi., Cteararle is suqecl ro oharnrrg c,eararce Lnder ^e WbtrerP'oteclion) Acl. '972 from the coloeLenr aulhor as mav be appt.cabte ro rhE poen Linqse any found in ML area (as mentioned in va.ious schedu es) tn case round rhey sh;uh ;egiven prolecllon, coitected alive wiih the hetp or the expert and lEnsfered them or handingover them lothe concerned aLtho.ities. ConseDation ptan, tf appli€bJe hasto be adheredio

6. The mining operalionssha[ be resiricred to abovegrolrnd water labte and it shootd notinteBect the ground waldr tabte. tn cas of working betow lhe ground ,",o r"Or", p,ioispprovaloflhe Ground Waier Dneciorare Governmenr ofJharkhand / Cenl.atcround t ;abrBodrd chdil oa ooraheo Aelcnes heighr ard stope shal be rantaned as[,lining Plan. The mlning ptan has to be golguidelines. safeiy me6ure shal be adopied

7. PP shattmaintain minimum disiancefrom Reserued / protected Foresls

8. The project proponent shall ensure thal no naturat walercouBe and / or warer-e,cou'ces sfal be obsl ucted dLe to ary r.nng oparal ons AdeqLale reasucs shatoeEKen 'or corseryalion ard orolec-ion ot fte hBr order aro tle se@.d order slleams aryemanating / passing thmugh ihe mine tease area dunng the couEe of mining opeEto;.

:1. "- 11" '"" ::'' alv ear rerpoa,[ @ srocd a, edrna,led sirss, o.y afuI qr-ourd

ror be rept Jruiit'/ed ior toro Tt-e ropsorrsnat' be Lseo ior t-" *"".rr,.. *O A-""o"- -

]01 the_c srur be 10 ereha ourps{s). [,tor rorrs am mrnagemenr or Fhaor aledareai sratr .o{ nue Jn lhe vegeiarbr becomes se{ sustarnrng conptErce sta-rs srat, besubmitled to lhe Jhafthand stale polurion Contro] Board, n"*h *O rc

"""i""i A"gi;;Oflices on six mo.thty basis.

1l Carch drainS and srlatior po.os oi aop.op.Ere size sha,t be rolsrJdeo a,oJno fie1: T"ls *b-srade d nnerar djlo(s) .o pevelr ,ul on or walel ard row orseore4ts drrecitv :nlo thp agILu[JE, ietds ard oher wa,a, bodies fl-e wate. so .orbcred

.q Ine mrne area t-aur.oadc g,een betr deve,opnerr elc. ,heorarl> shal be

'eoJbnvdesatled pdn.Jbr,y aler tna Tonroor and r ainla.npd prooe,ty

'12. Dimension ofthe rctaining wal ar the toe otthe OB benches within the mine to checkru. offand sihalion shal be based on the rain fal data

13 Oreelbei snal, be deverooed at' atorg lhe mrne naut roao\ JneHroled proponenl st-a,tdo i,ee Dtanldhor in ar tedst 3390 oi lhe soare oreterabtv aolg:f;per,pherv a1o h vacat spee tdsr g,owrg ano ,o€t soec,es wrt, be pta.ted ,i c€,e b;d rsnor-alar'abE w.r the taas-. or il rc rol possib,e to pall ueFs o ra lo 1a-Lre o. tano ther ppwtr oo necessary a ioEstaton al otherpta.e/land

14, EiieclNe s.teguro reasures sdct as regutar wdter spnrkt.rg cf.a[ be cd.r ed oJt incn@rdreas prole ro air potulor at I av,ns hqt- teves oip".*,"," "",r. _+ * r"rai"garc unbad.ng poinl ard tEnc.er po,nls. Frlenc,ve wa,er splntrrg sl at, oe @r,Fd out o;haul road which shoutd be made pucca with sujbble wale. drainage arEngements. tt shoutdbe ersrred thdr tF ATblenl An Ouatiy pa.arete.s confo," ,o ,,,. .o_._p,"""rio"o Urrn.Centralpolution conr@lBoard rn lhE red,rd

't5. The prolecr propoient shoutd ihptement sLttableg'ort wara. resoJTeq ir he drFd 11 col-L.talonGovemfi ent of Jharkhand / Cenhat cround Water Board.

16. The prcjecl proporenl shaltif reqliEd, obiatn necessary prio. pemission / NOC ofthecompetent authorities ror drawl or requisite quanlity or waier req;red for the projecr

conservaiion measures to augmentwith Ground Waier Diectorale,

17, Suiiable rain waterconsulralion wilh the cround

hafrestrng mea!res snatr be pated and np,emerred rrwaler utredorale Gove,.rert ot Jhahhand / cenkdt crolnd

-18. Vehicular emissions shall be kept under 6ntbl and rcguLarly monitorcd. MeasLrEsshallbe iaken ior mainlenan@ ofvehicles used in mining operarions and in r€nsporrarion ofmineral The l,lineral TEnsportation shall be €iiied out thbugh lhe overed lrucks on]y andihe vehicles carryirO the rnireralshallnot be ovenoaded.

19, No blasting shallbe caded out afier the sunsei Blasting operation shallbe caried outdu.ing lhedaylime. Conkolled blasting shallbe practiced. The milgalive measures for contolofground vibrations and lo arresi lly rocks and bouldeBshould be mpehented.

20- Orlls sha I eilher be operated wilh the dust exitractoB or equipped wth water injecllon

21. PP shal obtain requisite permisson lrom the conerned DGI'rlS before any blasti.g

22. Effeclive safeguard measures shoud be iaken to conrrol fugitive emissions so as toensure that RSPM (PI'rl 10 AND P[,] 2 5) leve s are wilh n prescr bed limits.

23. P.e pacement medi.al examination and perodi@l medi@l examination of thewo(ers enqaaed in ihe proieclshallbe €ried out and records mainlained.

24. The prcject proponent shal lake al pecaulonary measures during mioing ope€Uonfor con*tuation and prolection of endansered fauna.

25. Povision shall be made for the housing of construct on labor wiihin the site with allnecessary infraslructure and facilil es such as fuellor @oking mobie to let, septic ianks, safedrinking Mler, Medical healih care, etc. The housing may be in the iorm oi temporarysiructures to be €moved afier lhe completion of ihe pDject

26. Proper safely measures as per statutory requrement are lo be ihplemented aroundthe mlned out pit prior io closure ot sile. The proponenr shallersure that barbed wre lencings done a onq lhe pil as a safely precaution.

27. Alinalmine closure plan along wiih @rp!s iundshallbe submitted to Jharkhand Siale Pollution Controlin advance oriinalm ne closure for approval.

28, The prcjecl proponenl shallobiain Consentlo Establish (CTE) and Consent 10 Operaie(CTO) lrom ihe Jharkhand Slale Pollltion Conl.ol Board and efieciively implemenl altheconditions stipulated theein

dut approved by CompeientAuthoityBoard. Ranchiand to conerned DIVO

B. General Conditions

,. No change in mning technology and scope of working shoud be made withoutprlor approva of rhe stalutory authorities / Department of lndustries, Mines & GeologyGovernmeni of Jharkhand / Jharkhand State Polution Conlrol Board Ranchi during the

2, No change in ihe caiendar plan incuding excavalion, quantum of mineral andwaste shorld be made

3. The project proponent sha make all nte.nalroads pLcca and shallmainlan goodhousekeeping by rcgularcleanlng and wetting ofthe haulroads and ihe premses.

4. The prclect proponeit shall procure / h re I lraclo. & tanker separaiely which shallbe dedicaied for waier sprink ing and green belt deve opment

5. The pqect proponent shall maintain reg ster for producronsubmit reiurn io the Board.

6, The proiects poponents shal not cut trees / carry out tree teellngwitholt the permission ofcompetenl aulhorty.

7, [leasures should be laker for contD] of noise leve s below prescribed norms in thewoi( envionment. WolkeB engaged in opeEliors of HEMM, etc. Should be provided with

a. lndlstial wasle water (worlGhop and waste waler fom lhe mine) should be propenycolleded, lreaied so as to contirm to lhe standards oil and qea* trap shoLld be instaledbefore discharge of workshop effl uenls.

9. Perso.nelwo*ing lr dusty areas should wear prctective respnalory dev@ ard theyshould also be provided wiih adequale tialning and inlomalion on saiev and hea ih aspecls.Occu palional hea lh sutoeilance prcg€m ot lhe workers should be undeiGken penodicaly io obserue3ry mntraclions due lo exposu.e 1o dusl and take @reciive measues, if needed

'10. Oispensarytacilities for FiBtAid shallbe prcvided al sile

ll. A separate environmenlal managemern / monitoring cell with suiiable quaifiedpeBonne should be setiup underthe cont olofa Senior Executive, who willrepon dteclly loihe Head of lhe Organizaiion.

12, The flnds eama*ed for envirormental proleclion measure should be kept in sepamleaccount and shoud not be diverled for other purpose. Yea. wise expenditue should bereponed to ihe Jharkhand Siate Poluiion Contml Board, Ranchi PP shall carry out CSTRacUvales as per Govemme.t Guidelnes (% o, pront / turnover) of at leasl Rs 1 per ion

-13. The Jharkhand State Pottuatiogn Controt Board, Ranch dtrecuy or through ttsRegional Officer, shal monilor compliance of rhe stiputated conditions. The p;ojeclauthorities should extend futt cooperalion to the ofti@(s) by furnishing the requisite data/informaion/ monilorina reports

15. The pbponent shal uptoad the si,alus of compiance of the environmentatclearance conditions, inctudng resuls of monitored dala on then websiie and sha]updalelhe same periodicatly. ttshal simuttaneously be sent to Jharkhand State poflutionConkol Board and its concerned Regional Ofti@ The criteria polltanl tevets nametylSPM, RSPII, SO2, NOx (ambieni tevets) of cntica sect orat parameter, tndicaled fo. theprcjecl shall be monitored and disptayed at a convenient tocation near lhe project shalbe monitored and disptayed at a convenient tocation nearthe matn gate forthe companyln lhe empany in the publicdomatn.

16. The Environmentat statemeni for each financtat year endtng 31st march in Form-Vas is Mandaied to be submiiied bythe prcjeci proponenrio the Jharkhand Siare polulionControlBoard as prescribed hderlhe Environment (proteciion) rutes 19a6, as amendedsubseqlenrly shall also be put on lhe website of the company atong the status ofcompliance ol EC condiiions and shal atso to the concerned Regionat Offce oi JSPCBby E mail

1_ The Authority reserves the righiconditions or to revoke the cteaEnce ifto the saiisfaction oiAuthorily or for that

proponent shailsubmil six monlhty reports on lhe status ofcomptianceenvironmenta clearance conditions inctuding resuls of monilored

copies as well as by e mait) to the Jharkhand State po uiion Cont.olto ils @n@rned ReqionalOffice.

17. slaiutory deaEnce shallbe obtatned before stad ofminins operations.

2. The Environmental Ctearance accorded shal be valid for the periodrenewal of rease of the mine (seneraly 10 yea6) The pp shal not ]ncreaserale and alter lease areaduring the validity of Environmentat Ctearan@

3. ln ese of any deviation or atteEtion in the prcject proposed form those submitledto DEIAA Jharkhand for cleaEnce, a fresh reference shoutd be made io DETAA toassess ihe adequaoy of the conditions imposed and to incorporale any new conditions if

io add any new condition or modify the aboveaonditions stpulaied above are rot imptementedmatter for any otherAdmrnistrative reason

The above stiputations woutd be enfor@d among other under the Waier

f:.1:1,"s^:::1,:l-:'.-""lulbn) Acr 1s86. Hazdds,;" (M"6";..i, ;";;;;;rhe-rran_,Boundary rvtovement) Rures 2oo8 and the p,r; Li.;i,,y i;:;;; ffi,U;:1.:n^Ill.,l-.,1,:T:,0:*ts and rures made there lnder and

"Lo *y ot* o,0.,"

i^",::1,:1:r-",!.:l bl: "*r.*e

courr of India /Hish co,n "r

L*tr,*a.""J ,"v ",n..court of Law retatrnq to the subtect maher

Any.Appeal against this Environme.tat Ctearance shal ]ie wiih the NaUonat GreenTribunal, ifprefetred, within a period of 30 days from ihe date of issue of Envnonmenta;Clearance as prescribed undersection 16 oilhe Natrons creen Tribunat Act 20 t o

It was. decided that the minutes of me€ting be rorwarded to thec-onsideEtion. Vote of th.nks was detiv€re<t by Shri S.njay(iil.nber Secr€rary, DEAC)and the meetinq ende<r.

(8.N. Tripati)

(Sanjay Kumar shaha) (Or. A. P. sinha)