Support for gold open access publishing strategies at QUT

www.library.qut.edu.au

LIBRARY SERVICES

LIBRARY SERVICES


D I V I S I O N O F T E C H N O L O G Y , I N F O R M A T I O N A N D L E A R N I N G S U P P O R TD I V I S I O N O F T E C H N O L O G Y , I N F O R M A T I O N A N D L E A R N I N G S U P P O R T

Support for gold open access publishing strategies at QUT

Martin Borchert Associate Director, Library Services (Information Resources and Research Support)

Colleen ClearyLibrary Resource Services Deputy Manager

CRICOS No. 00213J


LIBRARY SERVICES

Special thanks to:

Stephanie Bradbury

Research Support Librarian

Paula Callan eResearch Access Coordinator

Christine Locke Electronic Resources Assistant


LIBRARY SERVICES

Make no mistake...

Green Gold


LIBRARY SERVICES

We’re going OA...OA is about making published scholarly articles (and other outputs) free, immediately, and permanently online in full-text for everyone via the web.

Green road of OA self-archiving is where authors deposit a free version of their published articles in an OA repository

Gold road of OA journal publishing is where authors pay to publish in paid gold OA journals which are then freely available via OA, or by publishing their articles in free gold OA journals.

20% of published articles were available OA in 2009.Bjork et al http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0011273 in PLOS Currents


LIBRARY SERVICES

It is generally accepted that OA supporters should implement green OA initiatives first and as the primary focus because green OA is the most transformative, and that gold OA initiatives should be implemented afterwards, or “green before gold”. This allows authors the greatest choice of journals in which to publish, and pushes the bulk of research outputs into the OA space (Harnad, 2005).


LIBRARY SERVICES

We’re going green...

Enabling Open Scholarship http://www.openscholarship.org/jcms/c_6226/open-access-policies-for-universities-and-research-institutions?hlText=policies

Cumulative growth of Green OA policies

Over 1,100 institutional OA repositories

Over 25 million records

91% journals and 63% publishers allow self-archiving


LIBRARY SERVICES

And we’re going gold ...

Free gold OA

Paid gold OA (author / research grant / library pays)

DOAJ lists >6,000 gold OA journals and the list is growing

500,000 full text articles OA


LIBRARY SERVICES

Challenges, barriers and misunderstandings

• Lack of awareness of awareness of OA and gold OA

• Smaller range of journals across disciplines

• Misconception that low levels of gold OA publishing reflect low acceptance

• Confusion over peer review• Perceived high cost by

researchers• Who will pay?• Misconception that authors are

paying to get published

• New journals don’t have time to develop high impact factors

• Support for traditional gated publishing methods

• Diversity of confusing publisher business models

• The hybrid double dipper business model

• Some publishers taking advantage of confusion regarding OA in order to resell free content for profit

• Misconception that OA is about punishing traditional publishers


LIBRARY SERVICES

Governance and strategy

• Information Resources Committee• Research Support Committee

F/1.3 QUT ePrints repository for research output

Collection Development Manual

CDM 3.1.5 Open Access


LIBRARY SERVICES

CDM 3.1.5 Open Access

QUT Library actively supports the [paid] gold road by: • Managing the subscriptions for, and paying author publication fees for true

gold road open access publishers such as: – BioMed Central – Public Library of Science – Hindawi Press

• Assisting academics with the publishing process

QUT Library will not support or pay author publication fees to commercial publishers that are double or triple dipping by simultaneously marketing their content using multiple business models including traditional subscriptions, gold road open access, and on-selling to aggregators.


LIBRARY SERVICES

QUT Library actively supports the [free] gold road by:

•Providing a free gold OA journal hosting service using Public Knowledge Project (PKP) Open Journal Systems (OJS)

Example: First Year in Higher Education International Journal https://www.fyhe.com.au/journal/index.php/intjfyhe


LIBRARY SERVICES

Selection of gold OA journals

• Alignment with QUT’s research strengths and priorities• QUT researcher feedback and demonstrated demand • Publisher reputation and journal quality • Publications are peer reviewed • Journal impact factor (publisher average)• Acceptable and affordable author publication fees• The publisher / journal uses a true gold open access

business model and not a hybrid “double dipper”• Budgetary implications for the Library Resource Allocation

(materials budget).


LIBRARY SERVICES

Supported

BioMedCentral (BMC)http://www.biomedcentral.com/

Public Library of Science (PLoS)http://www.plos.org/

Hindawihttp://www.hindawi.com/

Molecular Diversity Preservation International (MDPI)

http://www.mdpi.org/

International Union of Crystallography

http://www.iucr.org/


LIBRARY SERVICES

X or ?

Bentham Open

http://www.bentham.org/

Maney Open

http://www.maney.co.uk/

InTech

http://www.intechweb.org/

MedKnow

http://www.medknow.com/

Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association

http://www.oaspa.org/


LIBRARY SERVICES

Gold OA hit list


LIBRARY SERVICES

Promotion

http://www.tils.qut.edu.au/initiatives/researchsupport/comms/index.jsp


LIBRARY SERVICES

Promotion

http://libguides.library.qut.edu.au/content.php?pid=84068&sid=624533

+ Scholarly publishing seminars and workshops


LIBRARY SERVICES

Development of library staff

The Library has a research support seminar series for library staff to develop their knowledge and skills.

See paper “Borchert and Callan, (2011), Preparing Library staff for research support roles at QUT”

Support model

Research Support Team x 2 Development

Liaison Librarians x 20 Promotion and support

Library Resource Services Licensing and payment


LIBRARY SERVICES

Researcher uptake


LIBRARY SERVICES

BMC Hindawi

PLoS


LIBRARY SERVICES

Citations

Downloads

BMC gold open access journals in which QUT authors published had impact factors of ranging from 1.64 to 4.93 and SJR scores from 0.044 to 0.755.Hindawi journals had impact factors from 0.73 to 0.88 and SJR scores from 0.036 to 0.121.PLoS journals in which QUT published had impact factors ranging from 4.351 to 13.050 and SJR scores from 0.690 to 1.180.PLoS journals are averaging the highest in terms of impact, followed by BMC journals and then Hindawi journals.

Impact


LIBRARY SERVICES

Cost


LIBRARY SERVICES

QUT has paid US$80,294 to BMC since 2006, making the total average charge per article A$1,824.

QUT has paid US$18,510 to PLoS since, making the total average charge per article about A$2,477.

QUT has paid US$3,000 to Hindawi in 2010, making the average total charge per article in 2010 A$1,606, however, if a third article still in submission is published, the cost will be A$1,070.

These costs seem justifiable when compared to the costs found in the literature.


LIBRARY SERVICES

In summary

Paid gold OA provides a secondary (to green OA) avenue for making institutional publications available OA

There is growing list of gold OA journals to target

It is important to apply selection processes

Demand may be moderate / the cost my be acceptable

You really should try it!


LIBRARY SERVICES

Discussion.

Please read the paper in full.

Documents

Support for gold open access publishing strategies at QUT