21
SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR tables at: http://hoth.ccssc.org/mcsnr/test.php

SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE

MAGELLANIC CLOUDS

JOHN R. DICKELJOHN R. DICKELUNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICOUNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO

ANDAND

ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMSROSA MURPHY WILLIAMSCOLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITYCOLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY

Preliminary SNR tables at:http://hoth.ccssc.org/mcsnr/test.php

Page 2: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

SNR IDENTIFICATION

• EXTENDED GENERALLY SHELL -LIKE OBJECT - 0.2 PC FOR 1987A TO 158 PC FOR DEM L203

(1 PC IS 4 ARCSEC AT THE LMC AND 3.4 ARCSEC AT THE SMC)

• NON THERMAL RADIO SPECTRA - TYPICAL SPECTRAL INDICES, = -0.5,

WHERE Sf = const f

• THERMAL X-RAYS - TYPICAL TEMP ~ 1 keV WITH A LARGE SPREAD

• CAVEAT - PULSAR WIND NEBULAE HAVE FLATTER RADIO SPECTRA AND NON-THERMAL HIGH ENERGY X-RAY TAILS

• [S II]/ Ha > 0.4

Page 3: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

= -0.48

DEM L81

= 0.0

Page 4: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

X-RAY SPECTRUM OF N103 SNR

(usually incorrectly called N103B)

LEWIS, K. ET AL. 2003 ApJ, 582, 770

THIS SHOWS THE THERMAL NATURE OF THE EMISSION

Page 5: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

SNR MCELS J0521-6542

[S II] H

[S II]/H

RATIO3 COLOR

Page 6: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

TYPE CLASSIFICATION OF MAGELLANIC CLOUD SNRS

CORE COLLAPSE: PRESENCE OF A PULSAR OR OTHER COMPACT REMAINS IN A REGION OF YOUNG STARS OXYGEN RICH

TYPE Ia: XRAY SPECTRA SHOW LINES OF HIGHLY IONIZED INTERMEDIATE

MASS ELEMENTS BALMER DOMINATED IN OPTICAL

Page 7: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

0540-693 - A PROTOTYPE COMPOSITE SNR 50-MSEC PULSAR, PWN, O-RICH SHELL,ORGANIZED POLARIZATION IN THE PWN

6-CM RADIO IMAGE

Page 8: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

N157B ANOTHER COMPOSITE

X-ray - contours are 5,10,20,30,40,100,300,600 counts from 0.1-10 keV

The 16-msec X-Ray pulsar is at the center of the bright X-Ray contours and at the position of the cross in the radio image.

Radio - contours are2,3,4,6,7 nJy/beam

The shell can be seen faintly on the southern part of the radio image.

Page 9: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

SPECTRUM OF N157B

IT WILL BE VERY DIFFICULT TO MAKE ONE CONTINUOUS SPECTRUM FOR THIS OBJECT

Page 10: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

X-RAY SPECTRUM OF N103 SNRNOTE THE MANY LINES OF HIGHLY

IONIZED INTERMEDIATE-MASS ELEMENTS

LEWIS, K. ET AL. 2003 ApJ, 582, 770

Page 11: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

H LINE PROFILE TOWARD THE TYPE Ia BALMER-DOMINATED SNR 0519-

675

UNEQUILIBRATED VELOCITY 1180 KM/SEQUILIBRATED 1580 KM/S

SMITH, R. C. ET AL. 1991, ApJ, 375, 652

Page 12: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

N19 AREA IN THE SMC

RED: X-RAY CONTOURS GREYSCALE: 13-CM RADIO

JY/B

EA

M

Page 13: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

N19 AREA IN THREE WAVELENGTHS

H22cm Radio 1.5 - 8 keV X-ray

Page 14: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

SOME STATISTICS

LMC SMC

TOTAL NUMBER OF SNRS 49 19

CORE COLLAPSE 12 4

TYPE Ia 6 1

UNKNOWN 31 14

STANDARD STATISTICS EXPECTED IN IRREGULAR

GALAXIES PREDICT ABOUT 10% TYPE Ia SNe.

Page 15: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

RADIO LUMINOSITY vs DIAMETER FOR LMC SNRs

CONCLUSION: THERE IS NO CORRELATION OF LUMINOSITY WITH DIAMETER

(IN AGREEMENT WITH PREVIOUS STUDIES)

1987A

DEM L71

slope -1.13corr coef 0.08

Page 16: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

X-RAY - RADIO LUMINOSITIES OF LMC SNRs

CONCLUSION: BRIGHTER X-RAY EMISSION MAY, IN GENERAL, CORRESPOND TO BRIGHTER RADIO BUT THERE IS NO CLEAR CORRELATION

DEM L71

slope 0.77corr. coeff 0.41

DEM L71

Page 17: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

1.1 keV 2keV 5 keV

CHANDRA IMAGE OF CAS A

Page 18: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

X-RAY IMAGE AND RADIO CONTOURS OF THE OXYGEN RICH SNR N132D,

THE BRIGHTEST LMC RADIO SOURCE

Page 19: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

radio X-ray optical in the light of [O III] characteristic of oxygen rich SNRsNote that the radio shell lies outside the X-ray one – an unusual

condition in shell SNRs.

SNR 1E0102-72.3 in the Small Magellanic Cloud

Page 20: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

THE MAGELLANIC CLOUD CANDIDATES ARE ABOUT 20 TIMES FURTHER AWAY THAN CAS A SO THE REQUIRED SENSITIVITY NEEDS TO BE INCREASED BY A FACTOR OF 400.

THE INTERNATIONAL X-RAY OBSERVATORY (IXO) WILL BE ABOUT 100 TIMES MORE SENSITIVE THAN CHANDRA THEREFORE WITH MODESTLY LONGER EXPOSURES THE FIRST TASK FOR IXO SHOULD BE TO FIND THE COOLING NEUTRON STARS IN N132D AND 1E0102-723.

THE REWARD FOR DOING SO: A BOTTLE OF EITHER DICKEL TENNESSEE WHISKEY OR GRUET NEW MEXICO CHAMPAGNE

Page 21: SUPERNOVA REMNANTS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS JOHN R. DICKEL UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO AND ROSA MURPHY WILLIAMS COLUMBUS STATE UNIVERSITY Preliminary SNR

Preliminary SNR tables at:

http://hoth.ccssc.org/mcsnr/test.php

Please send us references, new data, etc.

We will eventually get proper pages for each SNR.