Study Period Report on

Registration Procedure

SC32WG2 Interim Meeting, Seoul071205

H. Horiuchi

SC32WG2 N1070

Current 　 status of the ISO/IEC19763

　 Information Technology – Framework for metamodel interoperability 　（ MFI ） -• Part 1: Reference model 　　　　　　　　　　　　　 　 published 　• Part 2: Core metamodel 　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　 2nd FCD• Part3: Metamodel for ontology 　 registration Published• Part4: Metamodel for model mapping 　　 2nd CD　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　　

2

As of Nov., 2007

•Part-3 2nd Ed ： + Ontology evolution & maintenance Preparing WD•Part-5 ：　 Process registration Preparing WD •Part 6 ：　 Registration Procedure Study period

New Parts:

2007/12/07 The 6th Seminar on Metadata Standardization

The goals of the study

• The final goal is preparing a draft WD on “Registration Procedure ” to the coming Australia Meeting (May, 2008)

• Investigate and Stock take requirements on the Registrations as widely as possible.

• Implement and check the procedure• Propose a common procedure consolidating

both procedures of MDR + MFI

The Registrations

4

Authority

Evidence of Approval

Request for Approval

Registry

Approval

Public Area

It should be official, reliable and sustainable.

Regulation & Standards

2007/12/07 The 6th Seminar on Metadata Standardization

Current status of the study project• Preparing an actual implementation of the

standards (MFI + MDR+ Core Component)• The project should be useful for developing a

new part (Registration Procedure)of MFI• Especially, the MFI project in Japan is keeping

contacts and collaborations with PLIB (ISO TC184/SC4, IEC SC3D) and JACIC (Japan Association for Construction Information Center)

SOSO

SO IRDI

OID Publisher

TermnetOther Dictionary

Registered Objects

Registered Model

Registration Authority

Administered Item

USERUSER

USER Registrar

JTC1

Name SpaceName

SpaceName Space

MFI/MDR RegistryMaintenance

Harmonizer

Data & Registry Quality Criteria Data & Registry

Quality Guidelines

Data Formulation Rules (11179-4)

Subject matters of the Part-6

Current 11179-6

• No specific guideline or criteria for registry• IRDI acceptance• No active protocols for change and

maintenance, including notification of chnage on contents

Basic Ontology

Cross Domain ROR (A Proposal to METI )

8

Model Mapping Service

Industrial domain

Domain　Model

基本情報要素Data Elements ROR

Domain Ontology

Ontology Search Service

Terminology

Terminology

Terminology

Registration Quality

RA

RA

RegistrationProcedure

UUID

OID

UID Domain Ontology

Terminology

RA

UID

Registration Authority

Value Domain

Industrial domain

MFI Registry

Domain A Domain B2007/12/07 The 6th Seminar on Metadata Standardization

Expected Evolution & Study Targets

Registration Procedure

Registration & Maintenance Procedure

MDR+MFI

ISO/IEC11179-6

ISO Directive

JTC1 Directive

ISO 15000(ebXML RS)

IEC Common Database ProcedureISO 29002ISO 8000ISO 13584

ISO/IEC 11179-4; Formulation of data

9

ISO/IEC19763-6

2007/12/07 The 6th Seminar on Metadata Standardization

ISO 9000

Approach

Registration & Maintenance Procedure

MDR+MFI

IEC Common Database ProcedureISO 29002ISO 8000ISO 13584-XXX

UN/CFACTCCTSUCM

JACIC(Construction )

TC184/SC4

IEC SC3D

UN/CEFACT

TMG

TC211

Expected Evolution of MDR & MFI

Common Administration

Information

Metadata Registration

Model Registration

“Common Facility” for both MDR & MFI

ISO/IEC11179 Edition 2MOF (ISO/IEC19502)

ISO/IEC11179 Edition 1

Data Elements

SC14IRDS (ISO/IEC 10728)

MOF (OMG)

ISO/IEC19763ISO/IEC11179 Edition 3

112007/12/07 The 6th Seminar on Metadata Standardization

Metamodel for Ontology Registration

Metamodel for MDR(ISO/IEC11179)

ODM

MFI Core model

Ontology components

Common facility of MDR(ISO/IEC11179 ED3)

Data Elements

Basic Classes

Basic Relationship

Metamodel for Metamodel for DL

Metamodel for OWL

MOF

MFI-2

MFI-3

MDR standards

Describe

Registration

　　 Ontology 　 by ODM

Administrative Information

ISO/IEC19763-3

Metamodel for ontology registration

12

MDR MFI Register Ontology Repository

Administered Item

specify

ISO　29002　(TC184SC4)

ISO 29002-10Product

characterization (cataloguing)

ISO 29002-20Concept dictionary resolution services

(CDRS)

ISO 29002Exchange of Product and Service Characteristic Data (EPSCD)

ISO 22745-40Master data

representation

ISO 22745-14Dictionary query

interface

schema subset

ISO 29002-5Identifier format

ISO 22745-13Identification of concepts and terminology

constrain

Current Par-6 of 11179Registrar/Control

CommitteeSubmitter Steward

Registry

Request Recorded

Qualified

Incomplete

Recorded

Preferred Standard

Identifies path of lead responsibility

*Note: Timing of registration status progression is entirely dependent upon the submitter/steward/registrar.

Submitsto registry

Identifies &documents

item

Proposes itemfor Standard

status

Checks qualityof item & reviews

data

Proposes itemfor Preferred Standard

status

Confirms/resolvescompleteness of

registration proposal

Confirms/resolvesquality of item

registration proposal

Acknowledgesstatus & submits for

review

Confirmsconcurrenceas Standard

Acknowledgesstatus & submits for

review

Confirmsconcurrence as

Preferred Standard

Provisionally Qualified

Provisionally Standard

ProvisionallyPreferred Standard

Standard

Candidate

RegistrationStatus

Progression

Request Candidate

Checks item & reviews

data

Registrar/Control

CommitteeSubmitter Steward

Registry

Request Recorded

Qualified

Incomplete

Recorded

Preferred Standard

Identifies path of lead responsibility Identifies path of lead responsibility

*Note: Timing of registration status progression is entirely dependent upon the submitter/steward/registrar.

Submitsto registry

Submitsto registry

Identifies &documents

item

Identifies &documents

item

Proposes itemfor Standard

status

Proposes itemfor Standard

status

Checks qualityof item & reviews

data

Checks qualityof item & reviews

data

Proposes itemfor Preferred Standard

status

Proposes itemfor Preferred Standard

status

Confirms/resolvescompleteness of

registration proposal

Confirms/resolvescompleteness of

registration proposal

Confirms/resolvesquality of item

registration proposal

Confirms/resolvesquality of item

registration proposal

Acknowledgesstatus & submits for

review

Acknowledgesstatus & submits for

review

Confirmsconcurrenceas Standard

Confirmsconcurrenceas Standard

Acknowledgesstatus & submits for

review

Acknowledgesstatus & submits for

review

Confirmsconcurrence as

Preferred Standard

Confirmsconcurrence as

Preferred Standard

Provisionally Qualified

Provisionally Standard

ProvisionallyPreferred Standard

Standard

Candidate

RegistrationStatus

Progression

RegistrationStatus

Progression

Request Candidate

Checks item & reviews

data

Core Component Harmonization

Expected Major contents of Part-6• Concept of operation• Registries of Administered Items• Functional operating procedures – Roles and

Responsibilities; RA,RO,SO,• Harmonization Process• IRDI: International Registration Data Identifier• Registry Quality • Conformance

Schedule

• The Final report : May 2008• Draft procedure : May 2008• Candidate of WD : May 2008• Proof of Concept : Dec., 2008• CD