Upload
lamtu
View
217
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
2010
Submitted By:-
Mr. Bibekananda Panda
(Consultant Summer Intern SGPA)
Xavier Institute Of Management,
Bhubaneswar
STUDY OF JOB FAIRS BY THE DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIES & COMMERCE,MADHYA PRADESH Submitted to:
Department Of Industries & Commerce , Madhya Pradesh
2
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This project would not have been completed without the support of several people, and I
would like to extend my gratitude to those who have directly or indirectly contributed to
this project.
I would like to take this opportunity to express my deep gratitude to Mr.R.K.Bajpai(Joint
Director Directorate Of Industries), Mr. Balbir Singh(Assistant Director Directorate Of
Industries), Mr. Manoj Agnihotri(DEO Ujjain), Mrs. Usha Gupta(DEO Vidisha) & Mrs. Mamta
Wikey (DEO Jabalpur).
I am indebted to Mr. H.P.Dixit(Director General SGPA ) Dr. Umesh Kumar Pandey(Director
Governance SGPA), Dr. Syed Mohd. Hyder Rigvi(Director Policy Analysis SGPA), Mr. Akhilesh
Argal(Director Governance SGPA) for providing me the chance to undertake this study and
enhance my learning besides giving guidance throughout the project . I would also like to
thank Mr.Gaurav Khare (Project Officer KM SGPA), Mr. Gaurav Agarwal(Project Officer
Policy Analysis SGPA) , Mr. Amit Srivastava(Project Coordinator SGPA) ,Mrs. Richa Mishra
for their support and assistance. Their inspiration, commitment, interest, positive attitude,
unwavering faith in me has been a motivating factor and it is difficult to imagine how I
would have completed this project without their continuous support.
3
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This research project was aimed at studying the job fair scheme of the Department
Of Industries & Commerce, Madhya Pradesh , finding out its shortcomings and giving
recommendations for improving its effectiveness and reach among the job seekers. The Job
Fair scheme is a great scheme started by the department by which many job seekers will be
getting direct employment. Besides this, the scheme will also help many companies in
getting adequate man power in an effective and easy manner. This project is currently giving
very impressive results with around 10000 people getting jobs in the financial year 2009-10.
But , the department is facing a lot of problems in implementing this scheme. To
quote a few problems, the District Employment Officer is not having any information about
the number of companies in the district as well as in the state. This project aims to address
this and many problems faced by the department.
This project is carried out using quantitative as well as qualitative analysis. In
quantitative analysis univariate analysis, Factor analysis and Cluster Analysis has been used
whereas qualitative analysis has been done from the brain storming sessions with the
department staffs. Apart from the recommendations for the problems that came out during
the discussions the report also gives an insight into the best practices in conducting a job
fair in an effective manner.
4
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction------------------------------------------------------------------------------5
Research Objective---------------------------------------------------------------------6
Research Methodology----------------------------------------------------------------7
Quantitative Analysis-------------------------------------------------------------------8
Univariate Analysis-----------------------------------------------------------------8
Factor Analysis Of Job Fair Effectiveness----------------------------------------------13
Factor Analysis Of Job Fair Reach Among Job Seekers-----------------------------18
Cluster Analysis------------------------------------------------------------------------------20
Qualitative Analysis--------------------------------------------------------------------24
Recommendations---------------------------------------------------------------------25
Job Fair Best Practices-----------------------------------------------------------------34
Annexure A(Questionnaire)----------------------------------------------------------45
Annexure B(List Of Websites To Get Company Related Information)-----52
References--------------------------------------------------------------------------------53
5
Introduction
The growing emphasis on increased efficiency and effectiveness has led to right
sizing of employees in various public and private organisation. This has adversely impacted
the number of people getting direct employment. Also with the increase in the number of
educated youth in the state , self employment has come up as an important solution to the
problem of unemployment.
JOB FAIR scheme is launched by the Department of Industries and commerce ,
Madhya Pradesh for private as well as public sector employers so that more and more job
seekers can be employed. The results of this scheme are amazing as in the financial year
2008-09 around 10000 and in the financial year 2009-10 around 9881 people got jobs
through these job fairs.
Currently the job fairs organised by the department can be divided into two basic
categories –
1. Job fairs that are organised for private sector employers.
2. Job fairs for Indian Air Force.
Though the figures of employment are inspiring , the department is facing a lot of
problems in implementation of this scheme. The department is not having any fixed flow of
industries coming to recruit from job fairs. Another problem is the district employment
officer does not have any information of how many industries are there in the district and
the details of the contact persons of these industries. The department is not having clear-
cut guidelines of how the job fairs should be organised. This report intends to provide an
insight into the current position of the job fair scheme in the state as well as provides
recommendations to overcome the current lacuna in it. This report also provides a list of
best practices to conduct a job fair.
6
Research Objective
The overall objective is to study the job fairs conducted by the
Department of Industries and Commerce , Madhya Pradesh and make
recommendations for further improvement of the systems and processes.
The objective can be divided further into various sub-objectives as follows:-
1. To examine how job fairs are being conducted in Madhya Pradesh.
2. To increase the flow of information to the district employment officer
regarding the details of industries and their contact details.
3. Recommendation regarding how to provide post job fair services to the
job seekers.
4. Also recommendations for the overall improvement in the reach and
effectiveness of job fairs.
7
Research Methodology
Target Group
Since research objective is studying the effectiveness as well as the reach of the job
fairs , the following type of people were targeted:-
1. People who have attended job fairs organised by the dept(29 in number)
2. People who are in search of jobs and are registered in their respective district
employment exchanges but have not attended any job fairs(86 in number)
Methodology
The research methodology includes survey using a structured questionnaire . The analysis was done by using quantitative methods(Univariate , Factor analysis and Cluster analysis) as well as by qualitative methods with the help of brain storming sessions with the department staff. The quantitative analysis was done by using either EXCEL or SPSS tool.
Sampling technique and size
The sampling technique using is random sampling. All the respondents who fall into either of the two target groups were selected.
86 people were approached at Vidisha , Ujjain , Jabalpur and Bhopal who are registered in the district employment exchanges and are in search of jobs but have not attended any of the job fairs.
29 people were approached at Vidisha , Ujjain , Jabalpur and Bhopal who have attended the job fairs conducted by the department.
8
QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS:-
Univariate analysis was done first by using EXCEL to understand the respondents’
background and to check the general attributes. Then Factor analysis was done to find out
the important factors that the respondents consider are important for the effectiveness and
reach of the job fairs. Then it is followed by Cluster analysis where in the segmentation of
the respondents has been done which is helpful in designing job fairs to cater to all the
segments.
Univariate Analysis
Educational Level
In the profiling of the respondents by educational level , we see that
around 35% respondents belong to the 12th pass group , the next
category belongs to the graduate group which is around 27% followed by
around 17% belonging to the post-graduate group. These three groups
combined together covers around 80% of the respondents. So, a majority
of our respondents are well educated . Only 15% belonged to the 10th
pass group and 6% belonged to the below 10th group.
Below 10th
10th
12th
Graduate
Post Graduate
Below 10th 6.09%
10th 14.78%
12th 34.78%
Graduate 26.96%
Post
Graduate 17.39%
9
Technical Education
The profiling of the respondents by technical education reveals that around
50% of our respondents have some sort of technical education (ITI , Diploma
, Computer trainings like Tally) , whereas the rest 50% do not have any
technical education. Currently , the companies that are visiting the job fairs are giving jobs which do
not involve any prior technical education. So, though job fairs are catering to the needs of 50% of
the job seekers who do not have any technical education at the same time the job fairs do not cater
to the rest 50% of the job seekers with technical education.
Knowledge Of Internet Or Email
Yes
No
Yes
No
Yes 49.57%
No 50.43%
10
As much as 29% of our respondents have knowledge about internet and
know how to use emails while the rest 71% of our respondents do not know
how to use internet and emails. So, a lot of information about the job fairs as
well as information about the scheme can be sent to the 29% of the job seekers through internet
and email.
Mobile Connection
The profiling of the respondents reveals that around 50% of the respondents
have mobile phones and the rest 50% do not have mobile connectivity. So,
the information about the job fairs can be very easily and conveniently sent
to these 50% of the job seekers either through SMS or phone calls.
Awareness About The Scheme
Around 70% of our respondents are not even aware about the scheme whereas only 30% of
the job seekers are aware of the scheme. So, somehow the promotions done for the scheme as well
as for the job fairs were not effective enough in creating awareness about the scheme among the
job seekers.
Yes
No
Yes 28.70%
No 71.30%
Yes 49.57%
No 50.43%
11
Homesickness
When asked about whether they are interested in working outside Madhya
Pradesh as much as 47% of the job seekers said in affirmative whereas 53%
of them said that they are not interested in working outside their
Aware
Not Aware
Willing
Not Willing
Aware 29.57%
Not
Aware 70.43%
Willing 47.83%
Not
Willing 52.17%
12
hometown. But a lot of companies that are visiting the job fairs are offering them jobs outside
Madhya Pradesh. So, naturally though many people get jobs in the job fairs , they do not actually
join these jobs as they do not want to work far away from their homes.
People Perception About Department Staff’s Efficiency
As much as 41% of the job seekers are of the opinion that the department
staff in the district employment offices are efficient whereas 26% said they
are not efficient . Around 33% of the job seekers said that the department
staff in the District employment offices are neither efficient nor inefficient.
Cooperativeness Of The Department Staff
Efficient
Not Efficient
Neutral
Cooperative
Not Cooperative
Neutral
Efficient 40.87%
Not
Efficient 26.09%
Neutral 33.04%
13
When asked around 29% of the respondents replied that the
department staff in the district employment offices are cooperative
and 37% replied that they are not cooperative. Around 35% of the
respondents said that the department staff are neither cooperative nor
uncooperative.
FACTOR ANALYSIS OF JOB FAIR EFFECTIVENESS
Factor analysis is a data reduction technique that aims at grouping the input
variables, which have dependency with each other, into factors that underlie the input
variables. . Initially the total number of factors in the factor analysis is equal to the total
number of input variables. But after the factor analysis the total number of variables in the
study can be reduced by discarding the insignificant factors based on certain criterion.
The factor analysis was performed on the question that asked the respondents to
rate the variables on a likert scale wherein the variables were the factors that make a job
fair effective. The variables are:-
Cooperation of the department staff
Efficiency of the dept. Staff
Distance of the job fair from your home
Prior information about the job fair
Distance of the place of job from home
Salary
Working Condition
Post job fair Support
The tool used for this analysis was SPSS V 16.0 and the technique used was the most
popular Principal Component matrix method. The rotation method used is Varimax with
Cooperative 27.84%
Not
Cooperative 37.11%
Neutral 35.05%
14
Kaiser Normalization. The details of the interpretation are explained as we move further in
this report.
ANALYSIS OF SPSS OUTPUT
COMMUNALITY:-
Extraction communalities are the variances of the variables accounted for by the
factors in the factor solution. Large values of communality of all the variables except that of
distance of job fair from home and prior information on job fair indicate that they fit well
with the factor solution, and thus should not be dropped from the analysis.But, in the
analysis these variables are also considered to get greater insight.
Communalities
Initial Extraction
Coop_dept_staff 1.000 .506
Efficiency_dept_staff 1.000 .539
Dist_job_fair_home 1.000 .475
Prior_info_jobfair 1.000 .474
Dist_workplace_from_
home 1.000 .546
Salary 1.000 .760
Working_Condition 1.000 .735
Post_job_fair_support 1.000 .599
Extraction Method: Principal Component
Analysis.
15
EIGEN VALUES:-
The eigenvalue for a given factor measures the variance in all the variables which is
accounted for by that factor. If a factor has a low eigenvalue, then it is contributing little to
the explanation of variances in the variables and may be ignored as redundant with more
important factors. In the data below ; 8 components (factors) would be needed to explain
100% of the variance in the data. However, using the conventional criterion of stopping
when the initial eigen value
drops below 1.0, only 3 of the 8 factors were actually extracted in this analysis. These 3
factors account for 57.929% of the variance in the data.
Total Variance Explained
Component
Initial Eigenvalues
Extraction Sums of Squared
Loadings
Rotation Sums of Squared
Loadings
Total
% of
Variance
Cumulative
% Total
% of
Variance
Cumulative
% Total
% of
Variance
Cumulative
%
1 1.841 23.010 23.010 1.841 23.010 23.010 1.784 22.297 22.297
2 1.553 19.412 42.422 1.553 19.412 42.422 1.544 19.304 41.601
3 1.241 15.507 57.929 1.241 15.507 57.929 1.306 16.328 57.929
4 .986 12.327 70.256
5 .805 10.061 80.318
6 .724 9.056 89.374
7 .446 5.572 94.946
8 .404 5.054 100.000
Extraction Method: Principal Component
Analysis.
SCREE PLOT:-
The scree test plots the components as the X axis and the corresponding eigenvalues
as the Y axis. As one moves to the right, toward later components, the eigenvalues drop.
When the drop ceases and the curve makes an elbow toward less steep decline, Scree test
says to drop all further components after the one starting the elbow.In the scree plot below
we see that the scree plot drops at 7 and then ceases to drop.
16
FACTOR LOADING:-
The factor loadings, also called component loadings are the correlation coefficients
between the variables (rows) and factors (columns). Because these are correlations,
possible values range from -1 to +1. There was a huge cross loading in the component
matrix which didn’t give clean set of factors. So it was rotated using varimax method and
the rotated component matrix is depicted below.
17
Rotated Component Matrixa
Component
1 2 3
Coop_dept_staff -.176 -.171 .668
Efficiency_dept_staff -.641 .270 .237
Dist_job_fair_home .684
Prior_info_jobfair .430 .537
Dist_workplace_from_home .683 .227 .167
Salary .306 -.816
Working_Condition .420 .734 -.141
Post_job_fair_support -.370 -.680
Extraction Method: Principal Component Analysis.
Rotation Method: Varimax with Kaiser Normalization.
a. Rotation converged in 6 iterations.
REPORTING AND ANALYSING THE FACTOR OUTPUT:-
On the basis of the rotated component matrix output the various variables are clubbed into
different factors and the factors are named on the basis of the underlying variables. The
data reduction technique helps us to cut down from 8 variables to 3 factor variables. And
they are in the order of their importance.
Factor 1
Efficiency of the department staff
Distance of job fair from home
Distance of the place of job from home
Factor 2
Salary
Working condition at the jo
18
Factor 3
Cooperation of the department staff
Prior information on job fair
Post job fair support
FACTOR ANALYSIS OF JOB FAIR REACH AMONG THE JOB SEEKERS
The factor analysis was performed on the question that asked the respondents to rate the variables on a likert scale wherein the variables were the factors that are required for the job fairs to reach out to job seekers.The variables are:-
Technical knowledge of the dept. Staff Efficiency Of the Dept. Staff Promotion of the job fair Location of the District employment office Segmentation Of Job Seekers
ANALYSIS OF SPSS PUTPUT COMMUNALITY Large values of all the communalities except that of efficiency of department staff & location of district employment exchange indicate that they fit well with the factor solution and thus should not be dropped from the analysis.
Communalities
Initial Extraction
Tech_Knowledge_Dept_Staf
f 1.000 .767
Efficiency_Dept_Staff 1.000 .260
Promotion_Job_Fair 1.000 .645
Location_Of_DEX 1.000 .398
Segmentation_Job_Seekers 1.000 .588
Extraction Method: Principal Component Analysis.
EIGEN VALUES In the data below ; 5 components (factors) would be needed to explain 100% of the variance
in the data. However, using the conventional criterion of stopping when the initial eigen
19
value drops below 1.0, only 2 of the 8 factors were actually extracted in this analysis. These
2 factors account for 53.158% of the variance in the data.
Total Variance Explained
Component
Initial Eigenvalues
Extraction Sums of Squared
Loadings
Rotation Sums of Squared
Loadings
Total
% of
Variance
Cumulative
% Total
% of
Variance
Cumulative
% Total
% of
Variance
Cumulative
%
1 1.487 29.737 29.737 1.487 29.737 29.737 1.472 29.436 29.436
2 1.171 23.421 53.158 1.171 23.421 53.158 1.186 23.722 53.158
3 .943 18.857 72.015
4 .797 15.949 87.964
5 .602 12.036 100.000
Extraction Method: Principal Component
Analysis.
FACTOR LOADING
There was cross loading in the component matrix which didn’t give clean set of factors. So it
was rotated using varimax method and the rotated component matrix is depicted below.
Rotated Component Matrixa
Component
1 2
Tech_Knowledge_Dept_Staf
f .245 .841
Efficiency_Dept_Staff .509
Promotion_Job_Fair -.797
Location_Of_DEX .608 -.170
Segmentation_Job_Seekers -.384 .664
Extraction Method: Principal Component Analysis.
Rotation Method: Varimax with Kaiser Normalization.
a. Rotation converged in 3 iterations.
20
REPORTING AND ANALYSING THE FACTOR OUTPUT
On the basis of the rotated component matrix output the various variables are clubbed into different factors and the factors are named on the basis of the underlying variables. The data reduction technique helps us to cut down from 5 variables to 2 factor variables . And they are in the order of their importance:-
Factor 1 Technical knowledge of department staff Segmentation of job seekers
Factor 2 Promotion of job fair
So, from the factor analysis it comes out that job fair reach among the job seekers can be improved by segmenting the job seekers and conducting job fairs for each segment . Also, if the technical knowledge of the department staff can be improved and proper promotion of the job fairs is done then the job fairs will be reach out a large number of job seekers who will benefit from it.
CLUSTER ANALYSIS
Cluster analysis or clustering is the assignment of a set of observations (respondents) into
subsets (called clusters) so that observations in the same cluster depict homogeneous
characteristics in some sense. Cluster Analysis is a multivariate procedure used in
segmentation applications in research.
Methodology:
The Hierarchical clustering or Linkage methods were used for this process. Here, it is not
specified in advance, how many clusters are to be extracted. A range of solutions is specified
from the SPSS package, from a 1-cluster solution to an n-cluster solution, where n is the
number of objects (respondents) being studied. In this case n-the number of respondents is
115. Using SPSS package, the Agglomeration schedule and the Dendogram are obtained.
Using an appropriate Euclidean distance four clusters were carved out. A Euclidean distance
of 18 is used.
The clustering variables are :-
1. Age
21
2. Technical Knowledge
3. Annual Family Income
4. Educational Qualification
Cluster 1
Number of respondents – 33
Age group – 18-25(predominantly)
Technical knowledge – No(predominantly)
Educational Qualification – 12th(predominantly)
Cluster 2
Number of respondents – 47
Age group -22-30
Technical knowledge – almost an equal mixture of yes and no
Educational Qualification – graduates and post graduates
Cluster 3
Number of respondents – 32
Age group- 26-35
Technical knowledge – almost an equal mixture of yes and no
Educational Qualification – 10th and 12th
We can clearly see in the dendogram given below that 3 respondents are not clearly
forming any cluster and so can be clearly taken as outliers. The three clusters given
above are clearly indicating that the different types of job fairs are necessary which
will cater to the needs of each of these clusters. Currently , there is no distinction
between any two job fairs.
22
* * * * * * * H I E R A R C H I C A L C L U S T E R A N A L Y S I S * * * * * * Dendrogram using Average Linkage (Between Groups) Rescaled Distance Cluster Combine C A S E 0 5 10 15 20 25 Label Num +---------+---------+---------+---------+---------+ 10 ─┐ 115 ─┼─────┐ 4 ─┘ │ 58 ─┐ ├─┐ 88 ─┤ │ │ 8 ─┼─────┤ ├───┐ 20 ─┘ │ │ │ 109 ───────┘ │ │ 28 ───────┬─┘ │ 79 ───────┘ ├───────┐ 59 ─┐ │ │ 80 ─┼─────┐ │ │ 2 ─┘ ├─┐ │ │ 111 ───────┘ │ │ │ 31 ─┐ ├───┘ │ 41 ─┤ │ ├─────────────┐ 9 ─┼─────┐ │ │ │ 17 ─┘ ├─┘ │ │ 1 ───────┘ │ │ 36 ─┬─────┐ │ │ 104 ─┘ ├───┐ │ │ 52 ───────┘ │ │ │ 53 ─┬─────┐ ├─────────┘ │ 105 ─┘ ├─┐ │ │ 37 ───────┘ │ │ │ 66 ─┐ ├─┘ │ 77 ─┼─────┐ │ │ 50 ─┘ │ │ │ 60 ─┐ ├─┘ │ 78 ─┤ │ │ 22 ─┼─────┘ │ 46 ─┘ │ 54 ─┬─────┐ │ 62 ─┘ ├─┐ │ 25 ─┬─────┘ │ ├─────────────┐ 34 ─┘ ├───┐ │ │ 90 ─┐ │ │ │ │ 103 ─┼─────┐ │ │ │ │ 38 ─┘ ├─┘ │ │ │ 49 ───────┘ │ │ │ 39 ─┐ │ │ │ 91 ─┼─────┐ ├───────┐ │ │ 23 ─┘ │ │ │ │ │ 93 ─┐ ├───┐ │ │ │ │ 107 ─┤ │ │ │ │ │ │ 14 ─┼─────┤ │ │ │ │ │ 83 ─┤ │ │ │ │ │ │ 89 ─┘ │ ├─┘ │ │ │ 64 ───────┘ │ │ │ │ 57 ─┐ │ │ │ │ 102 ─┼─────┐ │ │ │ │ 13 ─┘ ├─┐ │ │ │ │ 97 ───────┘ ├─┘ │ │ │ 40 ───────┬─┘ │ │ │ 65 ───────┘ ├─────────────┘ │ 82 ─┐ │ │ 101 ─┤ │ │ 3 ─┤ │ │
23
16 ─┤ │ │ 26 ─┤ │ │ 11 ─┼─────┐ │ │ 12 ─┤ ├─┐ │ │ 5 ─┘ │ │ │ │ 63 ───────┘ ├─────┐ │ │ 6 ─┬─────┐ │ │ │ │ 100 ─┘ ├─┘ │ │ │ 44 ─┬─────┘ │ │ │ 92 ─┘ ├─────┘ │ 43 ─┬─────┐ │ │ 110 ─┘ ├─────┐ │ │ 18 ─┬─────┘ │ │ │ 51 ─┘ ├─┘ │ 19 ─┬───────┐ │ │ 30 ─┘ ├───┘ │ 71 ─┬─────┐ │ │ 72 ─┘ ├─┘ │ 68 ─┐ │ │ 81 ─┼─────┘ │ 35 ─┘ │ 24 ───────┬─┐ │ 33 ───────┘ ├───────────────────────────────────┐ │ 15 ─────────┘ │ │ 74 ───────┬─────┐ │ │ 113 ───────┘ ├─────────────────┐ │ │ 32 ───────┬─────┘ │ ├───┘ 70 ───────┘ │ │ 84 ─┬─────┐ │ │ 98 ─┘ ├───┐ │ │ 69 ───────┘ │ │ │ 85 ─┐ ├───────────┐ ├─────────────┘ 87 ─┼─────┐ │ │ │ 21 ─┘ │ │ │ │ 112 ───────┼───┘ │ │ 75 ───────┘ │ │ 96 ───────┬─┐ │ │ 99 ───────┘ ├───┐ │ │ 29 ─┬─────┐ │ │ ├───────┘ 73 ─┘ ├─┘ │ │ 86 ───────┘ ├───┐ │ 67 ─┬─────┐ │ │ │ 95 ─┘ ├─┐ │ │ │ 7 ─┬─────┘ │ │ │ │ 55 ─┘ ├───┘ │ │ 56 ─┬─────┐ │ │ │ 61 ─┘ ├─┘ ├─────┘ 45 ─┬─────┘ │ 47 ─┘ │ 42 ─┬─────┐ │ 106 ─┘ ├─────┐ │ 108 ───────┘ │ │ 94 ─┐ ├───┘ 114 ─┤ │ 48 ─┼─────┐ │ 76 ─┘ ├─────┘
27 ───────┘
24
Qualitative Analysis
Qualitative analysis is generally done to get greater insight into a problem area. In
this report qualitative analysis has been done from output of brain storming sessions with
the department staffs. After a lot of discussions with the department staffs the problems
faced by the staffs while implementing the job fair scheme are as given below:-
No database of companies to contact for the job fairs.
No feedback mechanism in place
Most private companies look for people in the age group 18-25 but a lot of people
register themselves who are in the age 25-35
Less number of people actually joining the companies they are getting in the job fairs
because of low salary and bad working and living conditions.
Currently job fairs are not distinguishing between different type job seekers because
of which the turn out for the job fairs is low.
Lack of preparation for the job fairs by the job seekers. This is especially for the job
fairs conducted for recruitment into Indian Air Force.
The companies are not responding to the letters of the field staff properly.
25
RECOMMENDATIONS
1. STATE LEVEL PLACEMENT CELL:-
From the analysis of the response from the job seekers , it is clear that for the job
fairs to become successful quality of jobs becomes an important factor. But , after
interviewing the department staff at the district employment offices , it is clear that
majority of the companies that visit the job fairs come for either trainee workers or security
guards. Besides , the district employment offices do not have a database of industries in
their area. Also the technical knowledge of the department staff is not sufficient enough to
make use of the internet to get the details of industries and to contact them for vacancies.
Also , it is clear from the analysis that a large number of job seekers have technical
knowledge but the job fairs do not cater to them. Besides , the number of staff in many
district employment offices are not sufficient enough to conduct job fairs effectively.
This problem can be solved by a state level cell which will not only act as a helping
hand to all the district employment offices to conduct the job fairs but also in coordinating
various things.
Currently, the job fairs are conducted in the following way.
26
But, in this structure there are a lot of problems:
1. The district employment office does not have a database of companies in their area,
their contact details and the vacancies.
2. In many district employment offices adequate number of staff is not there to
conduct job fairs.
3. Besides , many companies do not even respond to their letters.
All the above problems can be solved with the following proposed way of conducting the
job fairs. As the state level cell will be contacting the companies, the companies will not
respond to these letters in a more positive sense. Besides, the state placement cell can
maintain a database of companies and their contact details. Also , the staffing problem in
various district employment offices for conducting job fairs can be sorted out as the state
placement cell will be coordinating the staffing from among the staffs in the neighbouring
district employment offices. In this way, the scheme can be successfully implemented in all
the districts of the state.
Besides , with the establishment of the state level cell automation of a lot of tasks will
be possible.
27
FUNCTIONS OF THE STATE PLACEMENT CELL
Standardization of various processes involved in the conduction of a job fair
Development of an employer database
Develop long term relationship with various employers like Indian Air Force, Indian
Navy , Indian Army as well as various private players
Development of an annual plan with targets and proper timelines for all the district
employment offices regarding job fairs
Develop long term relationship with various leading newspapers and television
channels in the state regarding promotion of job fairs
Conducting a mega job fair in the state annually
Ensuring that sufficient number of staff are provided to each district employment
office for the conduction of the job fairs.
After the introduction of the state placement cell the departmental structure will look
like the following:
28
STRUCTURE OF THE STATE PLACEMENT CELL
A. STATE PLACEMENT OFFICER
He is responsible for overseeing all the activities of the State Placement Cell. His
tasks include the following:-
1. Preside over marketing , employer relations , event staffing and
operations.
2. Oversee adherence to job fair procedures at each district level.
3. Assign responsibilities and tasks to each member of the team.
29
4. Monitor all activities.
B. EMPLOYER RELATIONS STAFF
These are the people who contact the companies and get their vacancies and
make them commit for attending a job fair. These people should have knowledge of
the internet and emails as they will have to dig for various information from the
internet. A list of various websites from where these information can be found are
given in the annexure. Besides they can take the help of the department to get
details of industries in the state. The tasks of the employer relations staff include:-
- Develop plan to attract companies to the job fairs
- Draft and send letters and materials to solicit employer participation
- Attain commitments and agreements on terms of participation
- Develop an employer database.
- Provide ongoing assistance to employer participants with all the necessary
information.
C. MARKETING STAFF
These are the people responsible for the promotion of the job fairs. Their tasks
include:-
- Develop a plan to standardize the promotion of the job fairs via print and
electronic media.
- Obtain annual agreements with the leading newspapers and television channels
in the state for promotion of the job fairs.
- Write press releases and arrange media coverage of job fair events
- Target potential sponsors and develop annual sponsorship agreements with
them
30
D. LOGISTICS AND STAFFING COORDINATOR
He is responsible for ensuring that sufficient number of staff are provided for
organising a job fair. Many times , the staffs in district employment offices are engaged in
other activities. Besides, there are many districts where there are not sufficient number of
staff to organize a job fair. In these cases, the staffing coordinator will direct staff from the
district employment offices of the neighbouring districts to go and help in organizing a job
fair in a district. In this way , the staffing problem can be solved and job fair scheme can be
successfully implemented in all the districts. His tasks include:-
- Coordinate with the district employment offices regarding the dates and venue
of the job fair.
- Ensure sufficient number of staff in a district for conducting the job fair.
- Supervise all the activities involved in the job fairs.
E. ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF
Their work is to provide general clerical support to all other members of the state
placement cell. Their tasks include:-
- Word process all the letters , documents etc.
- Organize and maintain all the documents
- Assist all the members in their tasks by providing clerical support.
After the introduction of the state placement cell the activities involved for conducting a
job fair will look like the following:-
32
2. MEGA JOB FAIR:-
Annually one mega job fair can be conducted covering the entire state at the state
capital in which all the interested companies from around the state as well as from across
the country can participate and recruit in large numbers. Through these mega job fairs a
large number of job seekers will be placed at one go and also these events will create
awareness as well as enthusiasm among the job seekers.
3. Currently job fairs are being organised for recruitment into Indian Air Force. On
similar lines job fairs can be organised for recruitment into Indian Navy and Indian
Army.
4. From the analysis , it is clear that most of the job seekers do not prepare before the
job fairs. This is especially necessary for the job fairs for recruitment into Indian Air
Force. By, beforehand preparation the turn out of these job fairs can be increased a
lot. For this , counselling can be provided through the counselling scheme being run
in various districts. The counselling should include what type of questions are
generally coming in these examinations as well as what kind of books to be read. The
counselling should also include the benefits of getting into these jobs.
5. Currently , the recruiters are not being charged with any fee when they come to
recruit from the job fairs. Now, as the department is providing a service to the
recruiters a small amount of fee should be charged from the recruiters for coming
into the job fairs.
6. As the promotions are necessary for the job fairs to be conducted in the districts,
the state placement cell can sign agreements with leading newspapers , television
channels for promotion of these events on an annual basis. This will standardize the
promotion campaigns at each of the districts.
7. Job fairs are the events where large number of job seekers turn out for jobs. There
are many institutions as well as in the district as well as in the entire state which are
always on the look out for these events to showcase their offers as well their
33
products to the masses. So, advertisement fees can be collected from these
organisations and institutions by providing them ad-space in the job fairs.
8. Currently , the job seekers are being for job fairs through letters. But , the analysis
has revealed that around 50% of the job seekers are having mobiles. So , they can be
contacted by sending SMS to their mobile phones. Besides, after a job fairs the exact
date and place of joining can also be provided to the selected candidates by sending
the information to their mobile phones through SMS.
34
JOB FAIR BEST PRACTICES
What Is A Job Fair?
A Job Fair is an employment strategy to fast-track the meeting of job seekers and
employers. Job Fairs are generally single day affairs typically held in cities multiple times a
year. Job Fairs are typically held in large assembly halls with a single booth for each
employer. Companies attend job fairs to screen candidates for existing or future job
openings. For job seekers , job fairs are a convenient way to apply to several companies and
to get interviewed immediately. Job Fairs also enable job seekers to interact with the
employers and to obtain company and career information.
Steps To Organize and Implement Job Fairs
A. JOB FAIR TEAM
Each District employment officer should designate members of their team . The
following table shows the positions and responsibilities :-
Position Responsibilities
1. District Employment Officer Responsible for overseeing all facets of job
fair planning and implementation.
2. Marketing Coordinator Responsible for job fair promotions. He is
also responsible for getting sponsorships.
3. Logistics and Staffing Coordinator Responsible for obtaining job fair venue and
for providing equipments , supplies and
staffs.
4. Employer Coordinator Responsible for attracting and commiting
employers for the job fairs ; providing
guidelines for employer participation .
5. Signage Staff Responsible for creating banners , posters
35
and promotional materaials.
6. Administrative Staff Responsible for providing general clerical
functions and for assisting all other members
of the job fair team
Hold initial meeting of the Job Fair Team and review, clarify, and refine
groundwork
issues, such as:
- team member responsibilities and tasks
- Job Fair goal and objectives
- scope of Job Fair (dependant on budget and resources)
- tentative dates (consider weather, holidays, conflicting events)
- potential venues
- potential sponsors
- major logistical issues (e.g., public event permits, insurance, etc.)
- major tasks and timeframes
- possible themes (tied to goals or objectives, or derived from contemporary
vocational / employment topics)
On the second meeting of the Job Fair Team (1-2 weeks after the first meeting),
consider stakeholders (people or organizations that may have a vested interest in the
Job Fair). Stakeholders include:
- employers in the region
- job seekers in the region
- the providers of the Job Fair who organize, provide,
and conduct the Job Fair
- sponsors or donors / contributors who may provide money or in-kind
products to help fund and support the Job Fair
- exhibitors who might show products or services at the Job Fair
- vendors who might supply products or services to carry out the Job Fair
36
Form a stakeholders group consisting of key staff, several participating employers, and
sponsors. If desired, include a limited number of job seekers, vendors, and exhibitors in the
stakeholders group. Hold several Stakeholder meetings during the planning and
organization phase of the Job Fair to discuss and obtain feedback on objectives, activities,
schedules, etc.
During subsequent meetings of the Job Fair Organization Team, carry out the
following activities:
- Generate a detailed budget allocation
- Provide regular updates on tasks and activities
- Discuss problems, delays and constraints – create solutions
- Make and coordinate assignments
- Revise the Job Fair timeline on an ongoing basis
B. JOB FAIR TEAM SUPERVISOR (District Employment Officer)
The Job fair team supervisor is responsible for overseeing all facets of Job Fair planning,
organization, and implementation.
( Tasks)
1. Control job fair budget and procurement
JOB FAIR BUDGET ITEMS
What should you include in the budget – the answer to this is EVERYTHING! Job Fairs
do cost money, so careful allocation of the budget is essential. Here is a list of basic
items found in Job Fair budgets:
- Venue / facility rental
- Utilities (electricity, etc.)
- Equipment (including rental of booth partitions, tables, chairs)
- Supplies
- Advertising and promotions
- Printing costs (brochures, signs, banners, forms, Job Fair packets, etc.)
37
- Decorations
- Job Fair staff
2. Preside over marketing, logistics, employer relations, event staffing, and operations
3. Network with employer groups, and community officials and councils
4. Oversee development and adherence to Job Fair procedures
5. Direct Team members – assigns responsibilities, tasks, and activities
6. Ensure provision of staff, time, resources, supplies, etc., as needed to organize and
conduct the Job Fair
7. Monitor all activities
8. Monitor Job Fair preparation and implementation timelines
9. Make corrective actions as needed
10. Motivates Job Fair Team
11. Call and coordinate meetings
12. Ensure Job Fair sponsorship
13. Report to the Directorate about the job fairs
C. MARKETING COORDINATOR
The Marketing and Sponsorship Coordinator is responsible for Job Fair promotion and public
relations, and for attaining sponsors. The tasks of the Marketing coordinator includes the
following:-
1. Develop detailed plans and timeline for assigned tasks and activities
2. Develop a plan to publicize the Job Fair via print and electronic media
3. Compose and prepare ads, announcements, flyers, brochures, posters, and
billboards Coordinate printing and distribution of ads, announcements, etc.
4. Procure radio and TV advertisement
5. Write press releases and arrange media coverage of Job Fair events
6. Identify and target potential corporate or company sponsors
7. Visit appropriate corporate executives to sell benefits of Job Fair sponsorship
8. Facilitate agreement on sponsorship details (e.g., appearance of corporate logos on
38
printed media, corporate recognition in press coverage and radio / TV spots, etc.)
9. Attain agreements on terms of sponsorship (e.g., memorandums of understanding,
contracts, etc.)
THE IMPORTANCE OF MARKETING
Job Fair marketing is serious business. Marketing and promotion are necessary for strong
attendance. Good marketing tells employers and job seekers why they need to attend the
Job Fair and what’s in it for them. Employers and job seekers need to be convinced that
your Job Fair is worth attending. Job Fair goals and objectives play an important role in
marketing - if they’re clear the promotional campaign will be clear-cut. Here are some
common marketing methods:
- Advertisements
- Signs
- brochures
- Flyers
- e-mail blast
- fax distribution list
- mailing list
- networking
- partnerships with other organizations
- past participation
- press / media release
SPONSORSHIP BASICS
Sponsorships are in! Companies spend billions of dollars sponsoring all types of events
(including Job Fairs). Having sponsors is the best way to augment meager Job Fair
budgets. Sponsorships are a win-win opportunity – sponsors get exposure to targeted
audiences, and the job fair team gets additional resources to produce high-quality Job Fairs.
Sponsors should understand the Job Fair’s goals and should be approached from the
standpoint of creating a long-term partnership. Don’t approach them just because they
have something you want. Understand what they need from the relationship and then build
a sponsorship package. Personally contact sponsors and explain the tangible benefits of
39
sponsorship.
Sponsorship exposure can include:
- recognition with Job Fair participants
- pre Job Fair mailings
- logo on items
- web site banner ads
- promotional materials
- ads, announcements
- job Fair registration kit
- signs
- media coverage
D. LOGISTICS AND STAFFING COORDINATOR
The Logistics and Staffing Coordinator is responsible for procuring the Job Fair venue;
providing equipment, supplies, staffing and management of the Job Fair. His tasks include:-
1. Develop detailed plans and timeline for assigned tasks and activities
2. Acquire venue (e.g., community center, auditorium, plaza). Consider size
requirements, suitability for Job Fair set-up, public access and transport, parking,
etc.). Attain agreement on venue usage
3. Obtain necessary permits
4. Plan and diagram lay-out of venue (e.g., position and arrangement of booths, tables,
registration desk, workshop or presentation areas, signs, and decorations)
5. Develop plan for placement, set-up, and take-down of booths, tables, chairs, etc.
6. Make an emergency plan outlining procedures for fire, medical emergencies,
violence, and severe weather
7. Procure all supplies, equipment, and services (contract with vendors if necessary)
8. Coordinate Job Fair sign placement and set-up
9. Ensure adherence to Job Fair Schedule
10. Determine staffing - number and type (paid or volunteer) for the following Job Fair
Event Team
40
E. EMPLOYER COORDINATOR
The Employer Coordinator is responsible for attracting and committing employers
(companies) to the Job Fair; providing guidelines for employer participation; and serving
participants’ needs before, during, and after the Job Fair. His tasks include:-
1. Develop detailed plans and timeline for assigned tasks and activities
2. Develop plan to attract employers to the Job Fair
3. Draft letters and materials (e.g., registration packets) to solicit employer participation
4. Identify and target potential companies
5. Send letters and registration packets to targeted companies (or visit them
personally). Explain Job Fair details to promote benefits of participation
6. Attain commitments and agree on terms of participation (see box below for factors to
consider)
7. Assemble an Employer database (for use in subsequent Job Fairs)
8. Draft necessary documents and forms
9. Provide ongoing assistance to employer participants (e.g., help with vacancy
announcements, suggestions for booth decorations, ideas for giveaways, etc.)
10. Arrange and conduct employer orientation session prior to Job Fair
11. Provide and collect the Job Fair evaluation form
12. Take steps to ensure each employers’ satisfaction with the Job Fair
GUIDELINES FOR COMPANY PARTICIPATION IN JOB FAIRS
As a condition of participating in the Job Fairs, companies should agree to:
- send 1-3 recruiters or hiring supervisors to staff Job Fair booths
- actively recruit for existing or future vacancies at the Job Fair
- interview Job Fair attendees for job openings
- take job applications at the Job Fair
- reasonably decorate booths and provide company materials
- complete and submit the following Job Fair forms and reports:
1. Agreement to Job Fair Terms & Conditions Form
41
2. Job Fair Registration Form (including company particulars and vacancy
Information for inclusion in the Job Fair packet)
3. Job Fair Activity Report (information and statistics regarding job seeker
Contacts , applications received, interviews, and job offers made at the Job
Fair)
4. Job Fair Evaluation Form
5. Follow-up reports (subsequent hiring from Job Fair, etc.)
F. SIGNAGE STAFF
The signage staff is responsible for creating Job Fair logo and theme-art;designing
brochures, posters, and banners, and promotional materials; and designing and fabricating
Job Fair signs.
The Job Fair Organizing Team may well decide to contract this function to an outside person
or agency.The tasks of the signage staff includes :-
1. Develop detailed plans and timeline for assigned tasks and activities.
2. Create a logo or symbol that lends itself to the theme of the Job Fair.
3. Design and produce Job Fair flyers, posters, ads, promotional materials, signs,
banners, etc. (in consultation with other members of the Job Fair Organizing Team)
4. Oversee printing of posters, brochures, signs, etc.
5. Advise Logistics Coordinator on sign placement and set-up.
THE IMPORTANCE OF SIGNS AT THE JOB FAIR
Signs are important to direct Job Fair attendees and to provide information. Signs, posters,
and banners also give the Job Fair a professional appearance and manner. Well before the
Job Fair, decide what signs you need, their style, their size, and approximately how many.
Here are some things to consider:
- All signs should be uniform, showing the Job Fair logo, denoting the Job Fair
theme, using uniform fonts, format, and colors
- Make directional signs, showing the way to areas of the Job Fair, directions to the
42
toilets, etc.
- Determine how you’ll display the signs – with easels, taped or tacked to walls or
Partitions
- Don’t forget tools and equipment needed to hang signs – stool, step ladder, tacks,
hammer, tape
- Make signs to acknowledge sponsors and contributors
- Make sure signs are large enough and are high enough to be seen
Allocate a large part of the sign budget for the registration sign or banner. This sign is
important because it’s the first sign participants see in the Job Fair and will convey an
important first impression about the professionalism of the Fair.
G. ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF
The administrative staff is responsible for providing general clerical functions and for
assisting all other members of the job fair team. His tasks include:-
1. Word process letters, forms, reports, and other papers
2. Organize and maintain all hard and electronic documents
3. Assist in procuring Job Fair supplies, equipment, and services
4. Take notes of ongoing activities pertaining to Job Fair organization and
implementation.
5. Track and revise schedules
6. Assist all Team members with clerical and logistical needs
7. File documents and or store materials for the next Job Fair (budgets, forms, letters,
lists, memos, signs, posters, templates, press releases, advertising & promotion
materials, planning and meeting notes, schedules, timelines, reports, evaluations,
supplies, equipment, etc.)
43
ACTIVITIES FOR THE JOB FAIR
BEFORE THE JOB FAIR
- Send special invitations to institutions and individuals with interests in employment
- and workforce issues (e.g., unions, local government, schools, persons with special
needs, banks, etc.)
- Gather the employers who will participate to prepare for job fair, provide
instructions,
map of booths highlight their placement in the job fair, discussion expectations,
answer questions, prepare them for gathering critical data using forms.
- Optional, but a best practice, host a seminar for employers to address contemporary
labour and job topics (e.g., hiring employees, retraining employees, labour laws,
motivating, rewarding and recognizing employees)
- Offer workshops to screened job seekers on Job Fair preparation
- Inspect, clean, and prepare the venue
- Fine-tune placement and locations of booths and tables
- Designate locations away from the Job Fair noise and activity where employers can
conduct interviews
- Determine exact sign locations
- Determine strategic locations to place Job Fair staff
- Prepare name tags for Job Fair event staff
- Make sure the staff knows what to do (e.g., greet job seekers and employers and
provide directions; circulate around the room to assist attendees with questions)
- Post vacancy announcements at accessible locations and arranged so that
participants can quickly locate the type jobs they are seeking
DURING THE FAIR
- Place volunteers at all entrances to greet participants and, when practical, to escort
them to the particular employers and to randomly select and pass out evaluation
44
forms to attendees during the fair.
- Have representatives present for special interest groups, such as older workers,
veterans, youth, persons with disabilities, etc.
- Periodically, offer snacks for employers who cannot get away
from their booths.
- Take pictures or video of the Job Fair to use in subsequent promotional materials or
job seeker training.
AFTER THE JOB FAIR
- Evaluate the Job Fair using evaluation forms and personal dialogues—be sure to
include forms from the randomly selected participants.
- Gather the employers within 10 days after the fair to collect their data, to disucss
their
experience, and to hear their suggestions for improvements.
- Summarize results from employers, participant evaluation forms, review and provide
summarized comments to headquarter.
- Incorporate suggestions into the next Job Fair. Endeavor to improve each Job Fair!
- File documents and or store materials for the next Job Fair (budgets, forms, letters,
lists, memos, signs, posters, templates, press releases, advertising & promotion
materials, planning and meeting notes, schedules, timelines, reports, evaluations,
supplies, equipment, etc.)
45
ANNEXURE: A
Questionnaire For Beneficiaries
1. Name :-
2. Address:-
3. Age:- a. 18-21 b. 22-25 c. 26-30 d. 31-35 e. More than 35
4. Gender:-
Male Female
5. Educational Qualification:- a) Below 10th b) 10th c) 12th d) Graduate e) Post Graduate f) Illiterate
6. Do you have any technical qualification (for example Engineering or ITI or Diploma or
computer knowledge) ? Yes No
46
7. Do you know how to use emails and internet? Yes No
8. Do you have a mobile connection? Yes No
9. What is your Annual Family Income?
a. Less than 1 lakh b. 1-2 lakh c. 2-3lakh d. More than 3 lakh
10. Are you aware of the job fair scheme launched by government? Yes No
11. Have you visited any employment exchange office? Yes No
12. What is the reason for your visit to the employment exchange? a) Pungeon b) For career counselling c) To enquire about job fairs d) For post job fair enquiry e) Personal reasons
13. Name of the employment office to which you belong.
14. Distance of the employment exchange from your stay?(State in kilometres)
47
15. Number of people in your acquaintance who got jobs through employment exchange.
16. How many job fairs you have attended? a) 1 b) 2 c) 3 d) 4 e) 5 f) More than 5
17. How did you come to know about the job fairs you have attended? a) Newspaper Advertisement b) Posters c) Letter from the employment office d) From friends e) Call from the employment office f) Advertisement in television g) Pamphlets
18. Did you get any job in the job fairs you have attended?(State the number of jobs you got)
19. Did you join any job that you got through the job fairs? Yes No
20. Reason for not joining the job that you got through job fair (If NO in question 16)? a) Bad working condition b) Low salary c) Did not get job in the native place d) Family problems e) Got better opportunity elsewhere f) Interest in higher education
48
21. Are you interested in working outside your hometown? Yes No
22. Do you have any previous work experience? Yes No
23. How many years of work experience you have ? a) Less than 1 year b) 1-2 years c) 2-3 years d) More than 3 years
24. Why did you leave your previous job (if having work experience)?
a) Bad working conditions b) Low salary c) Internal Politics d) Family problems e) Health problems f) Higher education
25. Have you been contacted by the Employment office before any job fair? Yes No
26. How the employment office contacted you before job fairs? a) Over telephone b) Through letter c) Through emails d) Through SMS
49
27. Have you been contacted by the Employment office after the job fair ? Yes No
28. How the employment office contacted you after the job fairs? a) Over telephone b) Through letters c) Emails d) SMS
29. How do you rate the efficiency of the staff in the employment office?(1 being the lowest to 5 being the highest)
30. How do you rate the cooperativeness of the staff in the employment office?(1 being the lowest – 5 being the highest)
31. Did you get any pre-placement training before attending any job fairs? Yes No
32. For how long you prepared before a job fair? a) Less than 1 month b) 1-2 months c) 2-3 months d) More than 3 months
33. How do you rate the overall effectiveness of the Job Fairs you have attended? a) Highly effective b) Moderately effective c) Less effective d) Not effective at all
34. Suggest any improvement in Job fairs.
50
35. Are you interested in higher education? 36. Rate the following parameters that you think are necessary for the job fairs to be
effective (1 being the least important and 5 being the most important)
1 2 3 4 5 Cooperation of the department staff
Efficiency of the dept. Staff
Distance of the job fair from your home
Prior information about the job fair
Distance of the place of job from home
Salary Working Condition
Post job fair Support
37. Rate the following parameters that you think are necessary so that job fair scheme can reach out to more number of people.(1 being the least important – 5 being the most important ).
1 2 3 4 5 Technical knowledge of the dept. Staff
Efficiency Of the Dept. Staff
Promotion of the job fair
Location of the District employment
52
ANNEXURE: B(List Of Websites & Directories To Get Company
Information)
1. ASSOCHAM Business Directory 2. Directory On
Construction And Real Estate Industry 3. Directory on
HEALTHCARE & MEDICAL EQUIPMENT (All segments of the healthcare industry - pharmaceuticals, hospitals, healthcare services like diagnostics, laboratories, medical / surgical equipments and health insurance services have been covered in the directory)
4. Directory Travel Tourism & Hospitality Industry (The Directory contains names, addresses, telephone, fax, E-mail, Nature of Business and Cities of Operation of the Travel Agents, Tour Operators, Hotels, Restaurants etc)
5. http://ecosystem.pluggd.in/index.php/indian-startup-directory- this website gives details of startup industries in India
6. http://desistartups.wordpress.com/indian-startups-list-desistartups-prabhu/
7. http://indianwebstartups.com/Index.aspx 8. http://numsum.com/spreadsheet/show
9. http://www.surfindia.com/madhya-pradesh
10. http://www.tradeindia.com
11. http://www.indiamart.com
12. http://www.altaindia.com/madhyapradesh-companies.php 13. http://envfor.nic.in/cpcb/17cat/mpcat.htm 14. http://www.companysites.info/regions/in/1748/madhya- pradesh 15. http://www.ratlam.nic.in/industries.htm
16. http://www.disabilityindia.org/selfEmployment.cfm - list of
employment exchanges for physically handicapped people