Studies in Social and Political Thought, Volume 19

8/12/2019 Studies in Social and Political Thought, Volume 19

1/186

)*

social & political thought

S(ec!a$ Fea,-*e= Te'*!+!&g ,e P'+,c'$'&!a$< Dec'$'&!+!&g Te'*1Ed#.ed b3 E''a Ba..e&& L)1'a( a(d L/c3 Ma3b(

Ma.%!^J1(%! F.a%*a%/^Ma%0.! Ha%"a S A("a%/a( Sa)!. F.a*#%! B.a*0(!5 N%c$+(/+*

A*,!c$e+Ba.a#&&e a!a#(-. He#de!!e, La(!/a!e a(d ."e E-ca*e ,)' ."e W),&d

A*.!3 R5!.

De')c,ac3- E,a ) Re&a.#0e Dec(eA*.!3 G%b/+*

T1) T/((e&e,- D#!!#(! T",)/!" ."e D#e,e(ce- #( ."e C")'-%3kF)/ca/&. Deba.eXa2%!. Sc+00

W#%#*ed#a E2a'*&e ), a F/./,e E&ec.,)(#c De')c,ac3[Dec#-#)( D#-c#*(e a(d D#-c)/,-e #( ."e C)&&ab),a.#0e E(c3c&)*aed#a

S5(2a%* F%.!.^B(a!//

B''#+ Re.!e/edP+(%0%c/ a* 0$! I)a#%*a0%+*b3 Ra3')(d Ge/--

Hab!.)a/ a* Ra3(/ D%/,10%*# 0$! P+(%0%ca(b3 Ja'e- G),d)( F#(&a3-)( a(dFab#a( F,e3e("a!e(

F+. a N!3 C.%0%-1! +" P+(%0%ca( Ec+*+)5b3 Be,(a,d S.#e!&e,

T$! Pa0$+(+#%!/ +" I*%2%1a( F.!!+)b3 A2e& H)((e."O" J!3/ a* A*%)a(/b3 A(d,e1 Be($a'#(A+.*+ "+. R!2+(10%+*a.%!/b3 Be( Wa.-)(

$* 17 . J* 2010

$* 19 !* 2011


2/186

studies in social and political thought

S01%!/ %* S+c%a( a* P+(%0%ca( T$+1#$0#- a *ee,k,e0#e1ed b#a((/a& $)/,(a& *,)d/cedb3 *)-.!,ad/a.e -./de(.- 'a(3 ) 1")' a,e ba-ed a. ."e U(#0e,-#.3 ) S/--e2T"e $)/,(a& -ee%- .) )-.e, a(d *,)').e #(.e,d#-c#*(a,#.3 #( -)c#a& a(d *).#ca&

.")/!". #( add#.#)( .) *,)0#d#(! a */b-"#(! *&a.),' .) $/(#), acade'#c-I&,e*&a,!'&a$ Ad.!+'*1 B'a*d

R)be,. P#**#( f A2e& H)((e." f Se3&a Be("ab#bGa3a.,# C"a%,a0),.3 S*#0a% f F,ed,#c Ja'e-)( f H)'# B"ab"a

A&e--a(d,) Fe,,a,a f W#&a' O/."1a#.e f S#')( Ja,0#-S"ad#a D,/,3 f Ma,.#( Ja3 f Ad,#a(a Ca0a,e,)

G),d)( F#(&a3-)( f R)be,. G))d#( f A(d,e1 C"#..3

Ed!,'*!a$ G*'-(

C",#- OKa(e f S#')( M/--e&& f Ve,e(a E,&e(b/-c"Z)e S/."e,&a(d f T#' Ca,.e, f R P"#&* H)'b/,!

A,."/, W#&&e'-e f H/1 Ree- f E&). R)-eT")'a- Jee,3 f C",#- A&&-)b,))%A(!e&a K)'a( f A&a-.a#, Ke'*

Re.!e/e*+C",#- OKa(e R P"#&* H)'b/,! H/1 Ree-C",#- A&&-)b,))% T#' Ca,.e, A&a-.a#, Ke'*

C",#-.)- Had$#)a(()/ A,."/, W#&&e'-eE''a Ba..e&& L)1'a( L/c3 Ma3b(

C'(1ed!,!&g a&d P*''f*ead!&gT#' Ca,.e, S#')( M/--e&& H/1 Ree-

A,."/, W#&&e'-e E''a Ba..e&& L)1'a( L/c3 Ma3b(

De+!g& a&d T1(e+e,,!&g

S#')( M/--e&&

S01%!/ %* S+c%a( a* P+(%0%ca( T$+1#$0Ce(.,e ), S)c#a& a(d P).#ca& T")/!".Sc"))& ) H#-.),3 A,. H#-.),3 a(d P"#&)-)*"3

U(#0e,-#.3 ) S/--e2Fa&'e, B,#!".)( BN QN

C)(.ac. --*.h-/--e2ac/%

///;+-++e0;ac;-#c+(,++(,///;++(,"'-*&a$;/'*d(*e++;c'%

T$%/ %//1! +" SSPT 3a/ )a! ,+//%b(! b5 a c+*0.%b10%+* ".+) 0$!C!*0.! "+. S+c%a( a* P+(%0%ca( T$+1#$0 a0 0$! U*%2!./%05 +" S1//!4

i c)*3,#!". #- ,e.a#(ed b3 ."e a/."),-


3/186

contents

Volume 19 Summer 2011

S(ec!a$ Fea,-*e=Te'*!+!&g ,e P'+,c'$'&!a$< Dec'$'&!+!&g Te'*1

I(.,)d/c.#)( ,)' ."e Ed#.),-E))a Ba00!(( L+3)a* a* L1c5 Ma5b(%*

T"e C)&)(#a.3 ) We-.e,( P"#&)-)*"3 C"#(e-e P"#&)-)*"3 a- V#e1ed #(F,a(ce

Ma.%!^J1(%! F.a%*a%/^Ma%0.!

I(d#!e()/- E*#-.e')&)!3 a(d ."e Dec)&)(#-a.#)( ) P)-.c)&)(#a-'Ha%"a S A("a%/a(

O( ."e B,)%e( C)(0e,-a.#)( be.1ee( P)-.c)&)(#a-' a(d I(.e&&ec./a&- #(."e Pe,#*"e,3Sa)!. F.a*#%!

Dec)&)(#4#(! C)-')*).a(#-' G/a'a( P)'a de A3a&a- Ea,&3 Re-*)(-e.) a S#(!/&a, Ae-."e.#c Ec)()'3B.a*0(!5 N%c$+(/+*

A*,!c$e+

Ba.a#&&e a!a#(-. He#de!!e, La(!/a!e a(d ."e E-ca*e ,)' ."e W),&d

A*.!3 R5!. De')c,ac3- E,a ) Re&a.#0e Dec(e

A*.!3 G%b/+*

T1) T/((e&e,- D#!!#(! T",)/!" ."e D#e,e(ce- #( ."e C")'-%3kF)/ca/&.Deba.eXa2%!. Sc+00

W#%#*ed#a E2a'*&e ), a F/./,e E&ec.,)(#c De')c,ac3[Dec#-#)( D#-c#*(e a(d D#-c)/,-e #( ."e C)&&ab),a.#0e E(c3c&)*aed#aS5(2a%* F%.!.^B(a!//


4/186

Re.!e/+

P).#c- a(d ."e I'a!#(a.#)( b3 Ra3')(d Ge/--C$.%/ A((/+b.++'

Habe,'a- a(d Ra1&- D#-*/.#(! ."e P).#ca& Ed#.ed b3 Ja'e- G),d)(F#(&a3-)( a(d Fab#a( F,e3e("a!e(H13 R!!/

F), a Ne1 C,#.#+/e ) P).#ca& Ec)()'3 b3 Be,(a,d S.#e!&e,Da**5 Ha53a.

T"e Pa.")&)!#e- ) I(d#0#d/a& F,eed)' He!e&- S)c#a& T"e),3 b3 A2e&H)((e."P$%(%, H+#$

O Je1- a(d A(#'a&- b3 A(d,e1 Be($a'#(V!.!*a E.(!*b1/c$ a* C+(%* McQ1%((a*

Ad),() ), Re0)&/.#)(a,#e- b3 Be( Wa.-)(L1'! Ma*6a.,+1.

C*2


5/186

I&,*'d-c,!'& f*'% ,e Ed!,'*+=Te'*!+!&g ,e P'+,c'$'&!a$< Dec'$'&!+!&g Te'*1

b3 E''a Ba..e&& L)1'a(a(d L/c3 Ma3b(

P)-.c)&)(#a-' a(d dec)&)(#-a.#)( b)." -*ea% .) ')0#(! be3)(d c)&)(#a&),de,- b/. ")1 ."#- #- acc)'*-"ed ,e'a#(- c)(.e-.ed A,e -.a.e- c)(.,)&&ed

b3 -e..&e, c)&)(#a& *e)*&e- %e Ca(ada ), A/-.,aa dec)&)(#-ed[ W"e,e d)."e3 -.a(d #( ,e&a.#)( .) A,#ca( ), A-#a( -.a.e- c)(.,)&&ed b3 &)ca&*)*/&a.#)(- b/. -/b$/!a.ed #( 1),&d *).#c- .",)/!" #(.e,(aedc)&)(#a-' a(d #(.e,(a.#)(a& #(.e&&ec./a& a(d ec)()'#c #'*e,#a-'[ T"#-a&& *)#(.- .) ."e *,)b&e' ) ")1 1e ."#(% ab)/. c)&)(#a-' H#-.),#ca&&3e(.a(!&ed 1#." c)&)(#a-' ."e E(!".e('e(. .,ad#.#)( e'e,!ed #( a-*ec##c .#'e a(d *&ace I(deed ."e acade'#c d#-c#*(e- .) be )/(d #( '/c") ."e We-. .)da3 1e,e b),( ) ."e a!e ) E'*#,e )( a c)(.#(e(. ")'e .)')-. ) ."e c)&)(#a& *)1e,- ) ."e da3 W"#&e )."e, *"#&)-)*"#e- a,e*a,)c"#a-ed #( ."e acade'3 a&1a3- .) be -e. 1#."#( ."e c)(.e2. ,)' 1"#c"

."e3 e'e,!ed ."e E/,)*ea( #- a**a,e(.&3 &e. /(.a#(.ed b3 c/&./,e ),"#-.),3 T"#- *,#0#&e!#(! ) E/,)*ea(kde,#0ed e*#-.e')&)!#e- a&-) "a- #.-,)).- #( c)&)(#a& d)'#(a.#)( 1#." ."e &a..e, "a0#(! a--e,.ed a *a,.#c/&a, a(d.).a#(! &)!#c )0e, ."e *a-. 3ea,- #(-#-.#(! ."a. E/,)*ea( %()1&ed!e#- -/*e,#), .) )."e, %()1&ed!e- E/,)*ea( %()1&ed!e ,e*,e-e(.- ,a.#)(a.3-c#e(ce a(d ,ea-)( 1"#&e )."e, 1a3- ) %()1#(! a,e c)(-.,/c.ed a-.,ad#.#)(a& #,,a.#)(a& -*#,#./a& a(d c)(.e2./a& Ye. ."e We-.e,( acade'3"#-.),#ca&&3 ")'e .) a*)&)!e.#c- ), e'*#,e a(d #(&/e(ced "ea0#&3 b3

E(!".e('e(. #dea&- ) *,)!,e-- "a- -ee( )0e, ."e *a-. ."#,.3 3ea,- b)."."e a--e,.#)( ) *)-.c)&)(#a& 0)#ce- a(d ."e e'e,!e(ce ) a *)-.c)&)(#a&*).#c- ) dec)&)(#-a.#)( T"e %()1&ed!e- a(d 0)#ce- ) c)&)(#-ed *e)*&e()1 ,e&e0a(. #( ."e acade'3 a(d acce--#b&e !&)ba&&3 "a0e ,e0ea&ed.,e(c"a(. #(-#!".- a(d *,)d/c.#0e c,#.#+/e- ."a. "a0e ca&&ed #(.) +/e-.#)('a(3 *)*/&a, a--/'*.#)(- ab)/. c/&./,e *)1e, -)c#e.3 a(d ')de,(#.3

T"e )*e(#(! /* ) -)c#a& a(d *).#ca& .")/!". .) +/e-.#)(- )*a,)c"#a-' a(d c)(-e+/e(.&3 e(.a(!&e'e(. 1#." c)&)(#a-' "a- -e0e,a'*ca.#)(- F#,-. #. *,e-e(.- /- 1#." a 1),&d ) ."e),3 1"#c" #- ().(ece--a,#&3 ,)).ed #( We-.e,( E/,)*ea( .,ad#.#)(- a(d 1"#c" ."e,e),e )e,-"e&*/& a(d *,e0#)/-&3 #!(),ed #(-#!".- ), be..e, /(de,-.a(d#(! a 1),&d

be3)(d E/,)*ea( c)(ce*./a& b)/(da,#e- T"#- #- a -#!(##ca(. c"a&&e(!e a-


6/186

B* L; & M=': I)(

S"#&a' ac%()1&ed!e- #( ."e ca-e ) #(.e,(a.#)(a& ,e&a.#)(- ."e),3 b/. #. #-1),." /(de,.a%#(! -#(ce !&)baa.#)( "a- 'ade #. #(c,ea-#(!&3 d##c/&. ),We-.e,( c#0#a.#)( .) 'a-+/e,ade a- ."e !e)kc/&./,a& ,e.a#(e, ) a /(#0e,-a&e2*e,#e(ce ) ')de,(#.3 ] ^ Sec)(d #. *)-e- a /(da'e(.a& c"a&&e(!e

.) -)'e ) ."e c),e c)(ce*.- ) c)(.e'*),a,3 -)c#a& a(d *).#ca& .")/!". #(."e acade'3 ')de,( .,ad#.#)(a& -)c#e.3 de')c,ac3 a(d -) ),."W"a. "a**e(- .) ."e #dea ) ')de,(#.3 1"e( #. #- ,ec)(ce#0ed a- c)kc)(-.#./.ed b3 c)&)(#a-'[ A- B"a'b,a *)#(.- )/. ."e We-.e,( e2*e,#e(ce"a- bee( .a%e( b)." a- ."e ba-#- ), ."e c)(-.,/c.#)( ) ."e c)(ce*. )')de,(#.3 a(d a. ."e -a'e .#'e ."a. c)(ce*. #- a,!/ed .) "a0e 0ad#.3 ."a..,a(-ce(d- ."e We-.e,( e2*e,#e(ce ] ^ T"#,d #. b&/,- ."e b)/(da,#e-) 1") 1e a,e .a&%#(! ab)/. 1"e( 1e -*ea% ) -)c#e.3 ')de,(#.3E/,)*e ), ."e We-. I )/, b)/(da,#e- "a0e bec)'e 'ea(#(!&e-- ."e(1e '/-. /(da'e(.a&&3 -"#. )/, #'a!#(a.#)(- a- ,e-ea,c"e,- .)ac%()1&ed!e #(.e,c)((ec.#)(- ."a. "a0e bee( a(d c)(.#(/e .) be )b-c/,edO(ce ac%()1&ed!ed a(d ,ec)!(#-ed 1e '/-. acce*. ."e ,e-*)(-#b#.3 .)ac. )( ."e-e -"#.-;

T"e,e "a0e bee( .1) 'a#( -.,a(d- ) .")/!". ."a. #( ,ece(. 3ea,- "a0ed,#0e( ),1a,d ."e a!e(da ) ."e),#-#(! ."e *)-.c)&)(#a& a(d dec)&)(#-#(!."e),3 T"e-e "a0e c)&&ec.#0e&3 *,)0#ded ."e #(-*#,a.#)( ), ."#- -*ec#a&-ec.#)( T"e #,-. #- *)-.c)&)(#a& ."e),3 1")-e )/(d#(! -c")&a,- a,e ).e(

c#.ed a- Sa#d ]^ B"ab"a ]^ a(d S*#0a% ]^ P)-.c)&)(#a& .e,a./,eca&&- ), a d,a'a.#c c"a(!e #( acade'#c ."#(%#(! a1a3 ,)' ."e *e,ce*.#)() c)&)(#a-' a- be#(! *,#'a,#&3 ab)/. -.a.e- a(d b),de,- a(d .)1a,d- a(a(a&3-#- ) ."e c/&./,a& a(d e*#-.e'#c &e!ac#e- ) c)&)(#a-' I. #- *e,"a*-*e,.#(e(. .) ().e ."e( ."a. *)-.c)&)(#a-' "a- .a%e( '/c" &)(!e, .) b,ea%#( .) ."e d#-c#*(e- ) *).#ca& -c#e(ce a(d #(.e,(a.#)(a& ,e&a.#)(- ."a(-)c#)&)!3 a(d .e,a./,e M),e ,ece(.&3 Wa&.e, M#!()&) ] ^A(#ba& Q/#$a() ]^ a(d )."e,- "a0e be!/( .) -*ea% ) Dec)&)(#a& ."e),3a- a ."e),e.#ca& -c"))& 1")-e ),#!#(- a,e (). -) '/c" a c,#.#+/e ) E/,)*e,)' 1#."#( a- a ."e),3 ) c)&)(#a.3j')de,(#.3 ,)' 1#.")/. W"e(c)&)(#a.3 a(d ')de,(#.3 a,e 0#e1ed a- .1) -#de- ) ."e -a'e c)#( a(3a(a&3-#- ) ."e *,e-e(. '/-. be -ee( .",)/!" ."e &e(- ) ."e c)&)(#a.3 )*)1e, T"#- !#0e- ."e "#-.),#ca& e0e(.- ) c)&)(#a-' 0e,3 ,ea&c)(.e'*),a,3 #'*ca.#)(-

W#."#( ."e-e .1) b,)ad #e&d- ."e,e a,e ) c)/,-e a *&e."),a )d#e,e(. *e,-*ec.#0e- a(d ."e),#e- a- 1e&& a- 'a(3 c,)--)0e,- B)."*)-.c)&)(#a& a(d dec)&)(#a& .")/!". *,)b&e'a.#-e ."e /(#0e,-a-#(! c&a#'-

1"#c" "a0e c"a,ac.e,#-ed E/,)*ea( We-.e,( *"#&)-)*"3 ,)' ."eE(!".e('e(. *e,#)d )(1a,d- I( ."#- -e(-e ."e( b)." a,e *).#ca& *,)$ec.-."a. -ee% .) "#!"!". #'*c#. a--/'ed e*#-.e')&)!#ca& "#e,a,c"#e- Ye.

4


7/186

B* L; & M=': I)( 5

1"#&e *)-.c)&)(#a-' "a- e'e,!ed ,)' 1#."#( ."#- ,a'e1),% dec)&)(#a&."e),#-.- -/c" a- M#!()&) "a0e -)/!". .) ."e),#-e ,)' ."e b),de,- )c)&)(#a.3 ,)' )/.-#de E/,)*ea( .")/!". F/,."e,'),e ."e-e a,e $/-. .1)-.,a(d- ) .")/!". a(d (/'e,)/- #(.e,0e(.#)(- "a0e bee( 'ade 1"#c"

ca((). ea-#&3 be -&)..ed #(.) e#."e, b)2A- *)-.c)&)(#a-' a(d dec)&)(#-a.#)( ,e'a#( c)(.e-.ed &e2#b&e a(da'b#!/)/- .e,'- ."e3 c)(.#(/e .) -e,0e a- .)/c"-.)(e- ), -)'e ) ."e ')-.c)(.e(.#)/- d##c/&. a(d *)1e,/& d#-c)/,-e- )cc/,,#(! b)." #( ."e acade'3a(d #( -)c#a& *).#c- a,)/(d ."e 1),&d T"e I-,aekPa&e-.#(#a( c)(c. "a-

bee( ."e),#-ed a- a -e..&e, c)&)(#a& c)(c. A'e,#ca( #(.e,0e(.#)(- #( I,a+a(d A!"a(#-.a( a,e d#-c/--ed a- e(ac.'e(.- ) (e)kc)&)(#a& #'*e,#a-'#(d#!e()/- I(d#a(- a--e,. ."e#, #de(.#.3 a!a#(-. ."e I(d#a( -.a.e a- d)#(d#!e()/- Ba(./ *e)*&e #( -)/."e,( A,#ca ."e-e c)(c.- a,e ,e0ea&ed a-&a3e,ed c)'*&e2 a(d "3b,#d #( *a,. .",)/!" *)-.c)&)(#a& a(d dec)&)(#-#(!d#-c)/,-e- T"#- /(de,-c),e- ."e (ece--#.3 ) */-"#(! ."e-e d#-c)/,-e- e0e,/,."e, #'*e,#a-' a(d c)&)(#a-' ,e'a#( ac.#0e ),ce- #( -)c#e.#e- a(d*).#ca& ),de,- a,)/(d ."e 1),&d a(d a- -/c" *)-.c)&)(#a& #(-#!".- a(ddec)&)(#-#(! ac.#)( '/-. ,e'a#( -#'#&a,&3 d3(a'#c T"#- #- ."e #'*e./-

be"#(d ."#- -*ec#a& -ec.#)( *)-.c)&)(#a& a(d dec)&)(#-#(! a(a&3-e- a,e ,#c"a(d (ece--a,3 a,ea- ) e2*&),a.#)( #( -)c#a& a(d *).#ca& .")/!". a(d1a,,a(. )/, c)(.#(/ed a..e(.#)( a(d e(!a!e'e(.

T"#- c)(0#c.#)( "a- bee( c)(#,'ed b3 ."e )0e,1"e&'#(! ,e-*)(-e .)."e ca&& ), *a*e,- ), ."#- -*ec#a& -ec.#)( ) S01%!/ %* S+c%a( a* P+(%0%ca(T$+1#$0 T"e -/b'#--#)(- ,ece#0ed ,)' )/, c)(.#(e(.- 1e,e ,e'a,%ab&e#( ."e d#0e,-#.3 ) *e,-*ec.#0e- #--/e- c)(ce*.- a(d a**,)ac"e- ."e3,e*,e-e(.ed a(d ."e #(.,#!/#(! a(d ()0e& #(-#!".- ."e3 )e,ed I(deed #.1a- a d##c/&. .a-% .) c"))-e a')(! -/c" -.,)(! a(d e(!a!#(! a,.#c&e- a(d1e 1)/&d %e .) e2*,e-- )/, ."a(%- .) a&& ) ."e a/."),- 1") */. ),1a,d."e#, 1),% ), c)(-#de,a.#)( Eac" ) ."e -ec.#)(- a,.#c&e- ,e*,e-e(.c)(.,#b/.#)(- .) ."e deba.e- a(d d#-c)/,-e- -/,,)/(d#(! )(e ) ."e %e3c"a&&e(!e- ac#(! -)c#a& a(d *).#ca& .")/!". .)da3 (a'e&3 ")1 .),ec)(c#&e c),e c)(ce*.- a(d #dea- ,)' ca()(#ca& a/."),- 1"#c" .")/!"/(#0e,-a& #( ."e#, c&a#'- a,e /(de(#ab&3 E/,)*ea( #( ."e#, ),#!#(-

I( ."e #,-. ) ."e )/, a,.#c&e- Ma,#ekJ/e F,a#(a#-kMa#.,e #(0e-.#!a.e-."e ,ece*.#)( ) C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 #( F,a(ce S"e #(d- C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3#- b)." ..&e %()1( #( F,a(ce a(d (). !e(e,a&&3 ,ec)!(#-ed a- a 0ad*"#&)-)*"3 T"#- d,#0e- F,a#(a#-kMa#.,e .) a-% d)e- C"#(a (). ."#(%[E/,)*ea( *"#&)-)*"3 de,#0ed ,)' ."e E(!".e('e(. *,ed)'#(a.e- a(d

C"#(e-e c)(.,#b/.#)(- a,e '),e c)'')(&3 0#e1ed a(d d#-'#--ed a-1#-d)' ), -*#,#./a.3 T"e a/."), ")1e0e, #(d- C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 .)

be 1),."3 ) #(c&/-#)( #( ."e ca.e!),3 *"#&)-)*"3 a(d a- -/c" a..,#b/.e-


8/186

#.- e2c&/-#)( .) c)&)(#a-. ),#e(.a-. a(d e/,)ce(.,#-. *e,-*ec.#0e- 1"#c"a**ea, .) d)'#(a.e acade'#a

Ha#a S A&a#-a& e(!a!e- d#,ec.&3 1#." ."e 'a,!#(a-a.#)( )#(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!#e- b3 *)-.c)&)(#a-' a(d *)-.c)&)(#a& ."e),#-.- #(

I(d#!e()/- E*#-.e')&)!3 a(d ."e Dec)&)(#-a.#)( ) P)-.c)&)(#a-'T",)/!" #(0e-.#!a.#)( ) *)-.c)&)(#a& ."e),#-.- 1") "a0e add,e--ed e0e(#( a '#.ed 1a3 #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 A&a#-a& c&ea,&3 #&&/-.,a.e- ."ed#c").)'#-ed ,a'e1),%- ."a. /(de,*#( ."e -e!,e!a.#)( ) #(d#!e()/-e*#-.e')&)!3 ,)' *)-.c)&)(#a& e*#-.e')&)!3 S"e */-"e- ."#- e(+/#,3/,."e, b3 c)(-#de,#(! dec)&)(#-a.#)( #( ,e&a.#)( .) ."e c"a&&e(!e- *)-ed b3#(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!#e- A&a#-a& a,!/e- *e,-/a-#0e&3 ."a. #( ),de, .)dec)&)(#-e *)-.c)&)(#a-' ."e c)'*c#.3 ) *)-.c)&)(#a-' #( ."e')de,(#.3jc)&)(#a.3 c)'*&e2 '/-. be ac%()1&ed!ed a(d add,e--ed a(d/,."e, ."a. a c,#.#ca& -e&k,e&e2#0e -.a(ce '/-. be de0e&)*ed .)1a,d- ."ee*#-.e')&)!#ca& )/(da.#)(- ) *)-.c)&)(#a-'

F)&&)1#(! ."#- #( O( ."e B,)%e( C)(0e,-a.#)( be.1ee(P)-.c)&)(#a-' a(d I(.e&&ec./a&- #( ."e Pe,#*"e,3 Sa'e, F,a(!#e dea&- 1#."."e ,ece*.#)( ) *)-.c)&)(#a& c,#.#+/e #( ."e *e,#*"e,3 S*ec##ca&&3 F,a(!#e#(0e-.#!a.e- ")1 A,ab #(.e&&ec./a&- "a0e ,e-*)(ded .) Ed1a,d Sa#d-O,#e(.a-' He /-e- ."e c)(.e2.kd,#0e( ().#)( ) ."e *,)b&e'k-*ace .)1a,( a!a#(-. ."e /(#0e,-a-#(! .e(de(c#e- ) *)-.c)&)(#a-' a(d *,e-e(.-

."e 1),% ) Ma"d# A'#& a(d Sade% Ja&a& a&kA4' a- de')(-.,a.#(! "#- ca-eU&.#'a.e&3 F,a(!#e #- a,!/#(! ), a( e2ca0a.#)( ) ."e *).#ca& ,)'/(de,(ea." ."e e*#-.e')&)!#ca& c,#.#+/e #( *)-.c)&)(#a& .")/!". a- a 1a3 .),e(e1 ."e b,)%e( c)(0e,-a.#)( be.1ee( ."e 'e.,)*)&e a(d ."e *e,#*"e,3

I( ."e #(a& a,.#c&e Dec)&)(#4#(! C)-')*).a(#-' G/a'a( P)'ade A3a&a- Ea,&3 Re-*)(-e .) a S#(!/&a, Ae-."e.#c Ec)()'3 B,a(.&e3N#c")&-)( )e,- a .")/!"./& a(d c,#.#ca& c)(-#de,a.#)( ) ."e .e2./a& a(d!,a*"#c #(.e,0e(.#)(- ) G/a'a( P)'a N#c")&-)( -%#&/&&3 */.- ."#--e0e(.ee(." ce(./,3 A(dea( #(.) c)(0e,-a.#)( 1#." )."e, ea,&3 *"#&)-)*"e,-) !&)ba-a.#)( a(d a,!/e- ."a. G/a'a( P)'a -/cce--/&&3 dec)&)(#-e-*)-.c)&)(#a-' .",)/!" "#- (a0#!a.#)( ) ae-."e.#c b),de,- a(d a,c"#0a&c)de -1#.c"#(! I( -) d)#(! N#c")&-)( 'a%e- a -.,)(! ca-e ), ."e#'*),.a(ce ) #(0e-.#!a.#(! ae-."e.#c d#0e,-#.3 a- a c,#.#ca& *a,. ) ."e *)1e,d3(a'#c- ) E'*#,e H#- e(!a!e'e(. 1#." ."e "#-.),#ca& a(d c)(.e'*),a,3#'*ca.#)(- ) G/a'a( P)'a- #(.e,0e(.#)(- *e,),' ."e d/a& */,*)-e )!,)/(d#(! "#- ."e),e.#ca&&3 (/a(ced a,!/'e(. a(d a--/,#(! ."e #'*),.a(.*&ace ) ."e-e 1),%- #( *)-.c)&)(#a& .")/!". a(d ."e),3

T"e-e )/, a,.#c&e- ,)' ea,&3 ca,ee, ,e-ea,c"e,- )e, 0a&/ab&e #(-#!".-#(.) ."e (e1 !e(e,a.#)( ) dec)&)(#-#(! a(d *)-.c)&)(#a& -c")&a,-"#* T"ea/."),- "a0e bee( ,)b/-. #( ."e#, c,#.#c#-' ) ."e #e&d 1"#&e 'a#(.a#(#(!

6 B* L; & M=': I)(


9/186

7

."e#, a#." #( ."e /(de,&3#(! ').#0e- ) ."e *,)$ec. We 1)/&d %e .) ."a(%F,a#(a#-kMa#.,e A&a#-a& F,a(!#e a(d N#c")&-)( ), ."e#, ded#ca.#)( a(de(!a!e'e(. .",)/!")/. ."e *,)ce-- a(d *a,.#c/&a,&3 ), ."e#, "a,d 1),% #('ee.#(! .#!". */bca.#)( dead(e- We 1)/&d a&-) %e .) ."a(% a&& ."e

,e0#e1e,- 1") -) !e(e,)/-&3 -"a,ed ."e#, .#'e a(d e2*e,.#-e T"e#, c,#.#ca&e(!a!e'e(. "e&*ed e(),')/-&3 .) -.,e(!."e( b)." ."e +/a.3 a(d #'*ac.) ."e a,.#c&e- #( ."#- -*ec#a& -ec.#)( F#(a&&3 ."e ed#.),- 1)/&d %e .) ."a(%C",#- OKa(e a(d S#')( M/--e&& a. S01%!/ %* S+c%a( a* P+(%0%ca( T$+1#$0 ),."e#, -/**),. a(d ), .a%#(! )( a ."e'e )/.-#de ) ."e /-/a& $)/,(a& c)(.e(.We a,e ")()/,ed .) be a *a,. ) 1"a. 1e bee0e #- a( #'*),.a(.#(.e,0e(.#)( b,#(!#(! (e1 0)#ce- .)!e."e, #( a 0#!),)/- a(d (ece--a,3d#-c)/,-e ."a. c)(.,#b/.e- .) ."e a(a&3-#- a(d ac.#)( ."a. 1#&& 1e ")*e "e&*.) .,a(-ce(d c)&)(#a& ba,,#e,- a(d .) #'a!#(e .,/&3 *)-.kc)&)(#a& /./,e-

E%%a Ba,,e$$ L'/%a& @e;";b;$'/%a&/a*/!c#;ac;-# #- a P"D -./de(. #(."e S)c#)&)!3 De*a,.'e(. a. ."e U(#0e,-#.3 ) Wa,1#c% a(d ,ece#0ed "e,MA #( H#-.),3 ,)' ."e U(#0e,-#.3 ) V#c.),#a ]Ca(ada^ He, ."e-#-#(0e-.#!a.e- ."e a**ca.#)( ) I(d#!e()/- 'e.")d)&)!#e- .) '#--#)(a,3"#-.),#e- #( B,#.#-" C)&/'b#a a(d #- c)(ce,(ed 1#." ."e e."#ca& a(d &)!#-.#ca&c"a&&e(!e- ) I(d#!e()/-kSe..&e, "#-.),#ca& ,e-ea,c"

L-c1 Ma1b$!& @$;%a1b$!&/a*/!c#;ac;-# #- a P"D -./de(. #( ."e S)c#)&)!3De*a,.'e(. a. ."e U(#0e,-#.3 ) Wa,1#c% He, ,e-ea,c" )c/-e- )( ."e 1a3-#( 1"#c" B,#.a#(- c)&)(#a& "#-.),3 #- #'*ca.ed #( #.- c)(.e'*),a,3 a-3&/',e!#'e S"e #- a&-) ,e-ea,c" a--#-.a(. ), ."e ESRC (e.1),% C)((ec.edH#-.),#e- C)((ec.ed S)c#)&)!#e- Re."#(%#(! ."e G&)ba& a(d c)k),!a(#-e,) a ),."c)'#(! c)(e,e(ce Re."#(%#(! ."e M)de,( C)&)(#a-' E'*#,ea(d S&a0e,3 ]J/&3 ^

B!b$!'g*a(1

B"ab"a H K ]^ T$! L+ca0%+* +" C1(01.!L)(d)( R)/.&ed!e

B"a'b,a G K ]^ R!0$%*'%*# M+!.*%05 P+/0c+(+*%a(%/) a* 0$! S+c%+(+#%ca(I)a#%*a0%+*Ba-#(!-.)%e Pa&!,a0e Mac'#&&a(

M#!()&) W ]^ L+ca( H%/0+.%!/]G(+ba( D!/%#*/ C"#c"e-.e, P,#(ce.)(U(#0e,-#.3 P,e--

M#!()&) W ]^ DELINKING T"e R"e.),#c ) M)de,(#.3 ."e L)!#c )C)&)(#a.3 a(d ."e G,a''a, ) Dekc)&)(#a.3 C1(01.a( S01%!/]^ k

B* L; & M=': I)(


10/186

M#!()&) W ]^ E*#-.e'#c D#-)bed#e(ce I(de*e(de(. T")/!". a(d DekC)&)(#a& F,eed)' T$!+.5 C1(01.! a* S+c%!05]k^ k

Q/#$a() A ]^ C)&)(#a.3 ) P)1e, E/,)ce(.,#-' a(d La.#( A'e,#caN!,a*0(a V%!3/ ".+) S+10$ ]^ k

Sa#d E W ]^ O.%!*0a(%/)L)(d)( R)/.&ed!e a(d Ke!a( Pa/&

S"#&a' R E ]^ I*0!.*a0%+*a( R!(a0%+*/ a* N+*^W!/0!.* T$+1#$0I),!.%a(%/) C+(+*%a(%/) a* I*2!/0%#a0%+*/ +" G(+ba( M+!.*%05 L)(d)(R)/.&ed!e

S*#0a% G C ]^A C.%0%-1! +" P+/0c+(+*%a( R!a/+* T+3a. a H%/0+.5 +" 0$!Va*%/$%*# P.!/!*0B)-.)( Ha,0a,d U(#0e,-#.3 P,e--

8 B* L; & M=': I)(


11/186

Te C'$'&!a$!,1 'f We+,e*& P!$'+'(1=

C!&e+e P!$'+'(1 a+ V!e/ed !& F*a&ce

b3 Ma,#ekJ/e F,a#(a#-kMa#.,e

Ab+,*ac,

C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 #- ..&e %()1( #( F,a(ce a(d #- ().!e(e,a&&3 ,ec)!(#-ed b3 .1e(.3k#,-. ce(./,3 F,e(c"*"#&)-)*"e,- a- a *"#&)-)*"3 T"e3 ).e( ,e!a,d #.-

c)(.,#b/.#)(- a- 1#-d)' .")/!". ), -*#,#./a.3 B/. 1"e( 1e-./d3 #. #( de.a#& 1e a,e c&ea,&3 aced 1#." a *"#&)-)*"3 W"3."e( #- C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 #-)&a.ed ,)' *"#&)-)*"3 #( F,a(ce[I- #. *e,"a*- )(&3 ."e We-.e,( 1),&d ."a. "a- ."e ,#!". a(dab#.3 .) ."#(%[ D)e- (). C"#(a a&-) ."#(%[ T"#- *a*e, a..e'*.-.) /(de,-.a(d ."#- -.a.e ) aa#,- b3 -ee%#(! c&/e- ."a. '#!".e2*&a#( 1"3 ."e ().#)( ."a. C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 #- ().*"#&)-)*"3 ,e'a#(- *,e0a&e(. #( F,a(ce .)da3 T"#- #--/e 'a3

be /(de,-.))d # 1e *&ace #. #( ."e c)(.e2. ) ."e ,e&a.#)(-"#*be.1ee( ."e We-. a(d ."e )."e,- a(d ."e,e),e #( a c)&)(#a-.),#e(.a-. a(d e/,)ce(.,#-. *e,-*ec.#0e I. #- *)--#b&3 beca/-e."e 1),&d ,e'a#(- ca/!". #( a *e,-#-.e(. #(.e&&ec./a& c)&)(#a.3a(d a( e(.,e(c"ed e/,)ce(.,#-' ) .")/!". -/c" ."a. ."e We-.d)e- (). ,ec)!(#-e ."e *"#&)-)*"#e- ) )."e,- T"e We-. -.#&&)cc/*#e- ."e e*#-.e')&)!#ca& ce(.,e ) ."e 1),&d a(d c)(-.#./.e-a /(#+/e ,ee,e(ce *)#(. ) %()1&ed!e F#(a&&3 -)'e -)&/.#)(-c)/&d be -)/!". #( ),de, .) dece(.,a-e *"#&)-)*"3 b3 )*e(#(!

/* *)--#b#.#e- ), ."e d#0e,-##ca.#)( a(d &)ca-a.#)( )%()1&ed!e a(d *,)0#(c#a#(! ."e We-. #( *"#&)-)*"3

I&,*'d-c,!'&

C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 #- ..&e %()1( #( F,a(ce a(d #- (). )#c#a&&3 ,ec)!(#-edb3 .1e(.3k#,-. ce(./,3 F,e(c" *"#&)-)*"e,- a- a *"#&)-)*"3 A *"#&)-)*"3#- "e,e /(de,-.))d .) be a c,#.#ca& a(d ,a.#)(a& ac.#0#.3 'ade *)--#b&e 1#."."e e'e,!e(ce ) ."e (+#+/]), ,ea-)( .")/!". d#-c)/,-e a(d -./d3^ #(a(c#e(. G,eece 1"#c" a#'- .) d#-c)0e, ."e .,/." .",)/!" +/e-.#)(#(! ."e/-e ) ,a.#)(a.3 a(d ."e c,ea.#)( ) c)(ce*.- a(d 1"#c" beca'e ad#-c#*(e de0e&)*ed a(d #(-.#./.#)(a-ed #( ."e We-. ]La&a(de


12/186

G)d#( ^ F,e(c" *"#&)-)*"e,- ,e!a,d C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 &e--a- a&.e,(a.#0e ,ea-)(#(! a(d '),e a- 1#-d)' .")/!". ), -*#,#./a.3 W#."#(F,a(ce C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 #- ).e( ca&&ed C"#(e-e .")/!". ]-ee ),e2a'*&e J/&e( C"e(! G,a(e. ^ a(d )(&3 C"#(e-e

*"#&)-)*"3 b3 a -'a&& (/'be, ) a/."),- ]B#&&e.e, Ka&.e('a,% ^T"e F,e(c" *"#&)-)*"e, F,a(9)#- J/&e( e'*&)3- C"#(a a- ."e )."e, #(),de, .) *,)0)%e .")/!". 1#."#( We-.e,( *"#&)-)*"3 He -.,)(!&3d#e,e(.#a.e- ."e C"#(e-e 1#-e 'a( a(d ."e G,ee% *"#&)-)*"e, ]J/&e(^ He a,!/e- ."a. 1"e( -)'eb)d3 .e&&- 'e ."a. C"#(e-e .")/!". #- ().a *"#&)-)*"3 I a(-1e, ."a. #. #- .,/e C"#(e-e .")/!". c)/&d de0e&)* #.-e( ."a. -e(-e b/. #. "a- (). 'ade ."#- c")#ce ]J/&e( ^ A&a#( Bad#)/*,a#-e- F,a(9)#- J/&e( ), *,)0#d#(! -.,/c./,e- .) C"#(e-e .")/!". beca/-e1"e( "e ,ead C"#(e-e .")/!". 1#.")/. *,e*a,a.#)( a(d c)(ce*./a& 1),%

"e d#-'#--ed #. a- -'a&& .a&% a- d#d He!e& 'a(3 3ea,- ea,e, ]Bad#)/ ^

H)1e0e, 1"e( -./d#ed #( de.a#& C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 d)e- de-e,0e.) be #(c&/ded #( ."e ca.e!),3 *"#&)-)*"3 l /(de,-.))d .) 'ea( a( ac.#0#.3) ."#(%#(! 1"#c" .,#e- .) /(de,-.a(d a(d .) e2*&a#( ."e 1),&d a(d "/'a(e2#-.e(ce a(d 1"#c" #- c)'')( .) "/'a(%#(d a *"#&)-)*"3 1"#c" #- )*e(e()/!" .) (). e2c&/de a(3."#(! ."a. '#!". "e&* #( ."#- e(dea0)/, T"#- d)e-'ea( ."a. C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 &ac%- ."e E/,)*ea( #'*e,a.#0e ) ,a.#)(a.3

a(d ."a. C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"e,- de*&)3 ),'- -/c" a- *)e.,3 a(d 'e.a*"),1"#c" a,e (). #(.,#(-#c .) E/,)*ea( *"#&)-)*"3 H)1e0e, -/c" d#e,e(ce-d) (). (eed .) be -ee( a- d#-+/a#ca.#)(- C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 c)(.a#(- .e2.-1"#c" de')(-.,a.e a( ac. ) ."#(%#(! a( a..e'*. .) e2*&a#( ."e 1),&d a(d"/'a(%#(d a- 1e&& a- ,e&ec.#)(- )( ."e ),!a(#-a.#)( ) -)c#e.3 F), #(-.a(ceZ$1a*#6% 1,#..e( b3 ."e Ta)#-. *"#&)-)*"e, ) ."e -a'e (a'e #( ."e ."ce(./,3 BC c)(.a#(- ,e&ec.#)(- )( dea." ."e *).#ca& ),!a(#-a.#)( )-)c#e.3 a(d "a**#(e-- T"e Z$1a*#6%a&-) -")1- ,e&ec.#)(- ."a. c)/&d bec)(-#de,ed a- (a./,a-.

W"3 ."e( #- C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 #-)&a.ed ,)' *"#&)-)*"3 #( F,a(ce[I- #. *e,"a*- )(&3 ."e We-.e,( 1),&d ."a. "a- ."e ,#!". a(d ."e ab#.3 .)."#(%[ D)e- C"#(a *+0."#(%[ T"#- #dea ."a. C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 #- (). a*"#&)-)*"3 1a- #,-. (%ed .) ."e #(.,)d/c.#)( ) C"#(e-e c/&./,e a(d*"#&)-)*"3 #( F,a(ce #( ."e ." ce(./,3 b3 ."e Je-/#. '#--#)(a,#e-P"#&)-)*"e,- ) ."e E(!".e('e(. ,ead a(d ,e&a3ed ."e c)(.e(. ) ."eE%"5%*# a* C1.%+1/ L!00!./ +" /+)! M%//%+*!./ +" 0$! S+c%!05 +" J!/1/ ".+)F+.!%#* M%//%+*/ .) ."e (e2. !e(e,a.#)(- ) *"#&)-)*"e,- a(d -) )( ,)' ."e,e.) &a.e, *"#&)-)*"e,- B/. ."e-e de-c,#*.#)(- a,e -%e1ed Je-/#.- 1e,e #(c)(.ac. 1#." $/-. )(e -)c#a& c&a-- ) ."e C"#(e-e *)*/&a.#)( (a'e&3 ."eMa(da,#(- T"e3 a&-) "ad .) $/-.#3 ."e#, '#--#)(- .) R)'e a(d *,e-e(.C"#(a #( a *)-#.#0e !". H)1e0e, a. ."a. .#'e C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 1a-

F-M*: "* C= + %** P=10


13/186

F-M*: "* C= + %** P= 11

c)(-#de,ed a- a *"#&)-)*"3 b3 *"#&)-)*"e,- ) ."e E(!".e('e(. -/c" a-V)&.a#,e B/. #( ."e ." ce(./,3 .",)/!" ."e ,#-e ) O,#e(.a-' a(d-c#e(.##c ,ac#-' ."e )&d ad'#,a.#)( ), C"#(a .,a(-),'ed #(.) c)(.e'*.a- de-c,#bed b3 He!e& He!e& a,!/ed ."a. C"#(a ,e*,e-e(.#(! ."e be!#((#(!

) ."e ab-.,ac.#)( a(d ."e c"#&d"))d a!e ) ."e S*#,#. "a- () *"#&)-)*"3]He!e& ^I( "#- b))% O.%!*0a(%/) ]^ ."e ."e),#-. Ed1a,d W Sa#d ]k^

de-c,#be- O,#e(.a-' a- a c)(-.e&&a.#)( ) a&-e a--/'*.#)(- /(de,&3#(!We-.e,( a..#./de- .)1a,d ."e Ea-. O,#e(.a-' #- de*#c.ed a- ."e We-.e,(-.3&e ) d)'#(a.#(! ,e-.,/c./,#(! a(d "a0#(! a/."),#.3 )0e, ."e O,#e(. a-1e&& a- ."e c)(-.#./.#0e d#-c)/,-e ) ."e We-. )( ."e O,#e(. T"e O,#e(. #- ."e)b$ec. ) ."e d#-c)/,-e- 'e--a!e a(d #.- a/."),- a,e ."e O,#e(.a-.- F,)'."e ." ce(./,3 )(1a,d- !e(e,a.#)(- ) *"#&)-)*"e,- "ad b/#&. a(

#'a!#(a,3 ) C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 1"#c" #- -.#&& )b-e,0ab&e #( acade'#cd#-c)/,-e .)da3 T"e -.a./- ) C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 #( F,a(ce "a- bee(-./d#ed #( ."e $)/,(a& E40.>)! O.%!*0 _ E40.>)! Occ%!*0 1#." ."e -*ec#a& #--/eY ak.k#& /(e *"#&)-)*"#e C"#()#-e[ _I- ."e,e a C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3[` I( ."#-#--/e ."e a/."),- ().ed ."a. C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 #- (). c)(-#de,ed a- a*"#&)-)*"3 M)-. a,.#c&e- .,3 .) ,e-)&0e ."#- *,)b&e' ) ."e e2#-.e(ce )C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 b/. #( !e(e,a& ."e *,)b&e' #- -./d#ed 1#."#( ."eWe-.e,( ca.e!),#e- ) *"#&)-)*"3 a(d C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 #- a(a&3-ed

.",)/!" a We-.e,( &e(- T"#- 'a%e- ."e *,)b&e' a**ea, #(-)&/b&e ]-eeC"e(! ^ Jea(kF,a(c)#- B#&&e.e, "a- a&-) .,#ed .) e2*ca.e C"#(e-e*"#&)-)*"3 .",)/!" .,a(-&a.#)(- ) ),#!#(a& .e2.- 1"#c" c)(.,a-. 1#.".,ad#.#)(a& ,e*,e-e(.a.#)(- ) C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 a- '3-.#c#-' T"#-'3-.#c#-' 'a#(.a#(- ."e '3." ) ."e ,ad#ca& )."e,(e-- ) C"#(a ]-ee B#&&e.e, ^

J)"( J C&a,%e -c")&a, ) ."e "#-.),3 ) #dea- "a- a&-) c)(.,#b/.ed .)."e -./d3 ) ")1 ."e We-. ,ece#0ed O,#e(.a& *"#&)-)*"#e- He a#'- .)"#!"!". ."e (a,,)1(e-- ) E/,)ce(.,#c #(.e&&ec./a& "#-.),#)!,a*"3 b3

e0)%#(! %e3 ')'e(.- ) ."e e(c)/(.e, be.1ee( ."e .1) -#de- ) ."e 1),&da(d b3 e2a'#(#(! ."e #(.e&&ec./a& ,e&a.#)(- be.1ee( We-. a(d Ea-. ]-eeC&a,%e ^ A((e C"e(! 1)(de,ed #( "e, #(a/!/,a& &ec./,e a. ."e C)&&;!ede F,a(ce D)e- C"#(a ."#(%[ C"e(! -.,e--ed ."a. ."e 'a#( #--/e "a- a&1a3-

bee( .) ."#(% C"#(a b/. -"e a&-) a-%ed # C"#(a #- e0e( a&&)1ed .) ."#(%a(d ."#(% ), #.-e& ]-ee C"e(! ^ F#(a&&3 Ca,#(e De)),. a(d Re#( Ra/dd#-c/--ed ."#- -/b$ec. #( a $)/,(a& e(.#.&ed P$%(+/+,$5 Ea/0 a* W!/0 De)),.-./d#ed ."e *,)b&e' ) ."e e2#-.e(ce ) C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 a(d e2.,ac.ed)/, *)--#b&e *)-#.#)(- 1"#&e Re#( Ra/d ,e*,)ac"ed De)),. ), a#(! .)!e. .) ."e b)..)' ) ."e *,)b&e' (a'e&3 E/,)ce(.,#-' ]-ee De)),. a(d Ra/d ^

T"#- *a*e, a#'- .) /(de,-.a(d ."e c)(.e(.#)( l C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3


14/186

F-M*: "* C= + %** P=

#- (). a *"#&)-)*"3 l .",)/!" a c)&)(#a-. ),#e(.a-. a(d E/,)ce(.,#-.,ead#(! E/,)ce(.,#-' #- /(de,-.))d "e,e a- a %#(d ) e."()ce(.,#-' a(d a-a( #de)&)!3 ]c)(-c#)/- ), /(c)(-c#)/-^ .) )c/- )( a(d .a%e a- #.- &eadE/,)*ea( c)(ce,(- c/&./,e a(d 0a&/e- a. ."e e2*e(-e ) .")-e ) )."e,

c/&./,e-

A- -/c" a %e3 +/e-.#)( #- ."e )&&)1#(! I- #. beca/-e ."e 1),&d,e'a#(- #( a *e,-#-.e(. #(.e&&ec./a& c)&)(#a.3 a(d a( e(.,e(c"edE/,)ce(.,#-' ) .")/!". ."a. ."e We-. d)e- (). ,ec)!(#-e *"#&)-)*"#e- )."e )."e,-[

Te Ce&,*a$!,1 'f We+,e*& P!$'+'(1

T"e ce(.,a.3 ) ."e We-. #( #.- *e,ce*.#)( ) %()1&ed!e ca( be -./d#ed #(),de, .) /(de,-.a(d 1"3 ."e We-. ,e*,e-e(.- )."e, *"#&)-)*"#e- a- ()(k

*"#&)-)*"#e- C)(ce*.- ) We-. a(d Ea-. ), Occ#de(. a(d O,#e(. a,ec/&./,a& !e)!,a*"#c a(d *).#ca&&3 #(-.#./.ed c)(ce*.- A- Sa#d a,!/ed ."e#dea- ) O,#e(. a(d Occ#de(. "a0e a "#-.),3 a(d a .,ad#.#)( ) .")/!".#'a!e,3 a(d 0)cab/&a,3 ."a. "a0e !#0e( #. ,ea.3 a(d *,e-e(ce ] ^O,#e(.a-' *,)d/ce- #'a!#(a.#0e !e)!,a*"#e- a(d ."e We-. "a- c)(-.,/c.ed#.-e& #( c)'*a,#-)( .) ."e O,#e(. ]G,e!),3 ^ U.a Ja(--e(- "a- a&-)a,!/ed ."a. ."e We-. de#(ed a(d -.#&& de#(e- #.-e& #( c)(.,a-. .) ."e Ea-.1#." ."e ,e-/&. ."a. ."e .1) c)(ce*.- a,e de*e(de(. /*)( a -e,#e- )

)**)-#(! 0a&/e- ] ^ T"e b),de, be.1ee( We-. a(d Ea-. "a- ."/-bee( #(0e(.ed a(d ,e*,)d/ced )0e, .#'eT"e d#-c)/,-e ) O,#e(.a-' c,ea.ed a -e,#e- ) b#(a,3 )**)-#.#)(-

a(d *a#,- a(d Occ#de(. a(d O,#e(. a,e a( #'*),.a(. e2a'*&e ) ."#- I( ."#-c)(-.,/c.#)( a(d ,e*,e-e(.a.#)( ) ."e 1),&d ."e We-. -ee'- .) ,e*,e-e(.."e -.,)(! a(d -/*e,#), ce(.,e ) ."e 1),&d 1#." ."e ,e-. -e,0#(! a- #.-*e,#*"e,#e- T"#- #dea ) ."e We-. a- a ce(.,e ca( be )/(d #( ."e #e&d )"#-.),3 a- a,!/ed b3 Na)%# Sa%a# -*ec#a-. ) Ja*a(e-e #(.e&&ec./a& "#-.),3F), "#' "#-.),3 -ee'ed .) be a( e.e,(a& *,)ce-- ) /(##ca.#)( a(d

ce(.,aa.#)( 1#." E/,)*e a. ."e ce(.,e He(ce 1e de-#!(ed ."e "#-.),3-#'*&3 a- a *,)ce-- ) E/,)*ea(#4a.#)( ]Sa%a# ^ T"#- *"e()'e()() ."e a**,)*,#a.#)( ) ."e 1),&d b3 ."e We-. "a- #.- ),#!#( #( ."e e2*a(-#)() E/,)*ea( ,e!#)( de0e&)*ed b3 ."e Je-/#.- a(d e2*),.ed .",)/!"c)&)(#-a.#)( T"#- e2*a(-#)( ca( be )b-e,0ed .)da3 #( ."e *"e()'e()( )!&)ba-a.#)( G&)ba-a.#)( #- ."e !&)ba& e2.e(-#)( ) c/&./,a& *).#ca& a(dec)()'#c e2c"a(!e- T"#- *"e()'e()( "a- *,#'a,#&3 bee( a *,)ce-- )/(e+/a& e2c"a(!e a(d ab-)&/.e d)'#(a.#)( 1#." ."e Occ#de(.jWe-. a(d ."eG&)ba& N),." a. #.- ce(.,e .,a(-e,,#(! ."e#, c/&./,e .) ."e T"#,d W),&d ."eS)/." a(d ."e O,#e(.jEa-. ]Be--#- k^

Acc),d#(! .) S)*"#e Be--#- ] ^ We-.e,( -/*,e'ac3 #- (). )(&3*,e-e(. #( *e,-)(a& ee(!- b/. a&-) a**ea,- .) -.,/c./,e -)c#e.3 .",)/!"

12


15/186

d#-c)/,-e a(d #(.e&&ec./a& -*"e,e- T"e-e a--e,.#)(- ca( be /(de,-.))d.",)/!" ."e #dea ."a. O,#e(.a-' #- a d#-c)/,-e c)(-.,/c.ed .",)/!"-.e,e).3*e- #'a!e- a(d ,e*,e-e(.a.#)(- T"e We-. #(.e,*,e.- de*#c.- a(d-*ea%-"+.."e O,#e(. I( ."#- -e(-e ."e We-. *,)d/ce- a ca.e!),#-ed d#-c)/,-e

]Sa#d ^ Sa#d .",)/!" ."e 1),%- ) M#c"e& F)/ca/&. ] ^"a- #de(.##ed O,#e(.a-' a- a d#-c)/,-e ."a. "e&*- .) /(de,-.a(d ."eWe-.e,( -3-.e'a.#c d#-c#*(e ."a. a&&)1ed We-.e,( c/&./,e .) 'a(a!e a(d.) *,)d/ce ."e O,#e(. ]Sa#d ^ T"#- c)(.e2. ca( "e&* /- /(de,-.a(d1"3 !e(e,a&&3 -*ea%#(! We-.e,( *"#&)-)*"3 #- c)(-#de,ed a- ."e )(&3*"#&)-)*"3 0$![ *"#&)-)*"3 a')(! F,e(c" acade'#c- T"e )."e,*"#&)-)*"#e- d) (). 'a..e, beca/-e ."e3 a,e )&% 1#-d)' c)(#(ed .)),b#.#(! a,)/(d ."e ce(.,e a- *e,#*"e,#e- (e!&ec.ed a(d #(e,#), (e0e, ab&e.) ,eac" ."e *,#0#&e!ed "#!"e, -.a./- ) We-.e,( *"#&)-)*"3 T"/-

*"#&)-)*"3 #- ."e *,)*e,.3 ) ."e We-. T"#- -#./a.#)( #- #2ed b3 a( #'a!#(ed),#!#( 1"#c" .))% ,)). #( A(c#e(. G,eece a(d ."e( #( E/,)*e '),e 1#de&3T"#- ab#.3 .) ."#(% a(d *"#&)-)*"#-e #- de(#ed .) )."e,- We-.e,(*"#&)-)*"3 #- -ee( a- ."e 'a.,#2 ) .")/!". a(d e0e,3 .")/!". 1"#c"d#0e,!e- ,)' #. #- (). acce*.ab&e beca/-e #. $e)*a,d#-e- ."e We-.- ce(.,a&a(d d)'#(a(. *)-#.#)(

I. -ee'- ."a. be"#(d ."#- +/e-.#)( ) ."e ab#.3 ) ."e )."e,- .) ."#(%."e,e a,e ,e'(a(.- ) a c)&)(#a-. .")/!". a(d a *e,-#-.e(. O,#e(.a-' T"#-

#- ."e ca-e ), ."e +/e-.#)(#(! ) ."e e2#-.e(ce ) C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 b3We-.e,( *"#&)-)*"e,- +/e-.#)(#(! 1"#c" #- (%ed .) e(.,e(c"ed ),'- )#(.e&&ec./a& c)&)(#a-' I. '#!". a**ea, ."a. 1#." dec)&)(#-a.#)( #( ."e-ec)(d "a& ) ."e ." ce(./,3 ."e-e ().#)(- ) c)&)(#a& #(&/e(ce a(dd)'#(a.#)( b3 ."e We-. )( ."e 1),&d "a0e d#-a**ea,ed B/. ."#- #- (). ."eca-e F), -)c#)&)!#-. A(#ba& Q/#$a() ."e ')-. *)1e,/& '3." ) ."e -.ce(./,3 c)(-#-.- #( ."e #dea ."a. ."e e'#(a.#)( ) ."e c)&)(#a&ad'#(#-.,a.#)(- #- e+/a& .) ."e dec)&)(#4a.#)( ) ."e 1),&d ]G,)-)!/e& k^ I(deed ."e *)-. ) *)-.c)&)(#a-' #(d#ca.e- ."a. c)&)(#a.3

c)(.#(/e- /(de, (e1 ),'- a(d *)-.kOcc#de(.a-' #(d#ca.e- ."a.Occ#de(.a-' c)(.#(/e- .) be ,e*,)d/ced /(de, (e1 ),'- ]M#!()&) ^

Acc),d#(! .) Q/#$a() ."e c)(ce*. ) c)&)(#a.3 ) *)1e, #- a-3-.e' c)(-.#./.ed b3 '/&.#*&e a(d "e.e,)!e(e)/- ),'- ) -e2/a& *).#ca&e*#-.e'#c ec)()'#c -*#,#./a& (!/#-.#c a(d ,ac#a& "#e,a,c"#e- a(d -3-.e'-) !&)ba& d)'#(a.#)( a(d e2*&)#.a.#)( ]Q/#$a() #( G,)-)!/e& ^ F,)' ."#- *e,-*ec.#0e c)&)(#a.3 a(d ')de,(#.3 a,e .1) -#de- )."e -a'e c)#( C)&)(#a.3 #- ."e c)(.#(/#.3 ) ."e d)'#(a.#)( a(d ) ."e),'- ) e2*&)#.a.#)( 1"#c" )&&)1 ."e d#-a**ea,a(ce ) c)&)(#a&ad'#(#-.,a.#)(- *,)d/ced b3 "e!e')(#c -.,/c./,e- a(d c/&./,e- ) ."eca*#.a-.j*a.,#a,c"a& ')de,(jc)&)(#a& 1),&dk-3-.e' ]G,)-)!/e& ^

F-M*: "* C= + %** P= 13


16/186

F-M*: "* C= + %** P=

I. -ee'- ."a. c)&)(#a.3 #- be3)(d c)&)(#a-' a(d c)(-.#./.e- a -e. ) 0a&/e-1"#c" -.,/c./,e- a( #de)&)!3 b),( 1#." ."e ')de,(jc)&)(#a& 1),&d #( ."e." ce(./,3 ]1#." ."e e(c)/(.e, ) A'e,#ca b3 C",#-.)*"e, C)&/'b/- a(d)."e, e2*&),e,-^ T"#- #- a *,#(c#*&e a(d a c)(.,)& -.,a.e!3 1"#c" !)e- be3)(d

-#'*&e ec)()'#c e2*&)#.a.#)( C)&)(#a.3 #(-.#./.e- E/,)ce(.,#-' 1"#c"bec)'e- a -)/,ce ) ,e!#)/- e."(#c a(d ]e-*ec#a&&3^ e*#-.e'#cd#-c,#'#(a.#)(- I. #'*e- ."e c)&)(#-e,- be"a0#)/, a- 1e&& a- ."ec)'*),.'e(. ) ."e c)&)(#-ed

C)&)(#a.3 #- ."e,e),e (). )(&3 ec)()'#c b/. a&-) #(.e&&ec./a&Acc),d#(! .) ."e !e)!,a*"e, P"#**e Pe&&e.#e, We-.e,( e2*a(-#)( "a- ().)(&3 bee( ec)()'#c a(d *).#ca& b/. a&-) c/&./,a& a(d #(.e&&ec./a& ]k^ T"e )/(da.#)(- ) %()1&ed!e 1e,e )/(d ]a(d a,e -.#&& )/(d^ #(We-.e,( c#0#-a.#)( a(d #( #.- '/&.#*&e a(d c)'*&e2 *)--#b#.#e- a- &)(! a-

."e c)(ce*./a-a.#)( ]) ."e ,#!". a(d ) ."e &e.^ ,e'a#(- 1#."#( ."e,a'e1),% ) &a(!/a!e a(d ')de,(#.3 ]Fa&-kB),da #( M#!()&) k^ A- M#!()&) e2*&a#(-

F,)' ."e ." .) ."e ." ce(./,#e- ."e c)&)(#a& d#e,e(ce "a-bee( ."e 'ec"a(#-' 1"#c" "a- /(de,0a&/ed ."e ()(k1e-.e,(%()1&ed!e T"e d)/b&e e*#-.e'#c c)(-c#e(ce ) ."e ")1 .) bea( A,#ca( *"#&)-)*"e, ]E4e^ ), a( I(d#a( "#-.),#a(

]C"a%,aba,.3^ #- -.#&& ,e&e0a(. .)da3 T"e ')().3*#c e*#-.e'e) ')de,(#.3 #- ac#(! ."e *&/,#.)*#c e*#-.e'e ) c)&)(#a.3_ ` T"#- #- a( e*#-.e'e ) b),de,- ) ."e ed!e ) ."e .")/!".a(()/(ced ,)' ."e *e,-*ec.#0e ) ."e c)&)(#a.3 ] ^

I(.e&&ec./a& c)&)(#a.3 #- #&&/-.,a.ed b3 ), #(-.a(ce ."e e2*),. ) We-.e,(c)(ce*.- a(d d#-c#*(e- .) A-#a a. ."e e(d ) ."e ." ce(./,3 T"#-%()1&ed!e #- e2*),.ed 0#a ."e e2*a(-#)( ) ."e e*#-.e'#c a(d *"#&)-)*"#ca&We-.e,( c)(ce*.- a- '/c" a- b3 ."e c&a--##ca.#)( ) ."e -)c#a& -c#e(ce- a(d

"/'a(#.#e- T"#- !&)ba& e2*a(-#)( ) ."e -)c#a& -c#e(ce- #'*e- ."a.#(.e&&ec./a& c)&)(#a.3 ,e'a#(- #( *&ace e0e( # ."#- c)&)(#4a.#)( #- ca/-edb3 !))d #(.e(.#)(- 'ade b3 *e)*&e ) ."e &e. a(d -/**),.- dec)&)(#4a.#)(]M#!()&) ^

C!&a a&d ,e Acade%!c D!+c!($!&e+ !& F*a&ce

T"e "/'a(#.#e- 1"#c" a,e b/#&. /-#(! We-.e,( ca.e!),#e- ),!a(#-e ."e,e&a.#)(-"#* be.1ee( ."e 1),&d a(d %()1&ed!e .",)/!" a( #(.e,*&a3 )-/b$ec.#0e .ec"(#+/e- a(d *,ac.#ce- Na)%# Sa%a# a(d O-a'/ N#-"#.a(# "a0ede-c,#bed a c&a--##ca.#)( 1"#c" ),!a(#-e- ."e 1),&d ) %()1&ed!e a(d"/'a(#.#e- T"#- #- ."e d#-.#(c.#)( be.1ee( $1)a*%0a/ a- -/b$ec. )%()1&ed!e a(d a*0$.+,+/ a- )b$ec. ) %()1&ed!e ]S)&)')( a(d Hab#b

14


17/186

^ I( !". ) ."#- C"#(a "a- bee( ,e*,e-e(.ed b3 ."e We-. a- a c)(ce*. ),a( )b$ec. ) -./d3 C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 #( F,a(ce -/e,- ,)' #.- c)(-.,/c.#)(a- a( )b$ec. ) -./d3 ,e(de,#(! #. a&1a3- #(e,#), .) F,e(c" *"#&)-)*"#ca&)e,#(!- C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 #- /-ed a- a( a,!/'e(. a ca-e ."a. ."e We-.e,(

*"#&)-)*"e, /-e- #( ),de, .) #'*,)0e "#- ), "e, -3-.e'

C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 #- a&-) /-ed b3 -)'e F,e(c" *"#&)-)*"e,- #("e&*#(! .) /(de,-.a(d -#&e(ce- #( We-.e,( .")/!". I( ."e *,eace .) ."eF,e(c" ed#.#)( ) Sa#d- O.%!*0a(%/) T40e.a( T)d),)0 1,).e ."a. d)'#(a.#)(c)/&d be e2*,e--ed b3 ."#- c)(ce*. I 3)/ -a3 .) -)'eb)d3 I "a0e ."e .,/."ab)/. 3)/ #. #- #(),'#(! ."e (a./,e ) '3 %()1&ed!e b/. #. #- a&-) a,e&a.#)(-"#* #( 1"#c" I d)'#(a.e a(d ."e )."e, #- d)'#(a.ed ]Sa#d ^ I( "#- ,e&a.#)( 1#." C"#(a ."e We-.e,( *"#&)-)*"e, #- #( a *)-#.#)( )d)'#(a.#)( beca/-e "e "a- ."e .,/." ab)/. ."e )."e, beca/-e "e $/d!e- a(d

!#0e- ]), de(#e-^ ."e *"#&)-)*"3 &abe& T"#- /-e ) ca.e!),#e- #( ),de, .)d#-.#(!/#-" be.1ee( *"#&)-)*"3 a(d C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 #&&/-.,a.e- a(a,!/'e(. e'*&)3ed b3 ."e -)c#)&)!#-. C",#-.#(e De&*"3 Acc),d#(! .) "e,.) c&a--#3 #- .) "#e,a,c"#-e T"e *)1e, ) &a(!/a!e a(d ) ."e d#-c)/,-e #- .)(a'e -)'e."#(! ), -)'e)(e a(d ."e( c,ea.e a ,ea.3 a !,)/* a(d #(*a,.#c/&a, .) d#-.#(!/#-" /- a(d ."e )."e,- ]-ee S"a,* ^

C&a--##ca.#)( ) ."e *"#&)-)*"#e- "#e,a,c"#-e- ."e' beca/-e ."e-e .1))*e,a.#)(- a,e (%ed a(d /(c.#)( -#'/&.a(e)/-&3 ]De&*"3 ^ T"#-

().#)( ) d)'#(a.#)( ca( be c"a,ac.e,#-ed b3 d#-c)/,-e beca/-e ."e 'a-.e,#- ."e )(e 1") #- -*ea%#(! "e -*ea%- ), ."e )."e, a(d ) ."e )."e, La(!/a!e*a,.#c#*a.e- #( ."e We-.- #(.e&&ec./a& "e!e')(#c c)(-.,/c.#)( ) )."e,-O,#e(.a-' "a- bee( de-c,#bed a- %()1&ed!e )( ."e O,#e(. b/. a&-) a-*)1e, A- M#c"e& F)/ca/&. a,!/ed #( D%/c%,(%*! a* P1*%/$ *)1e, #'*e-%()1&ed!e a(d b)." a,e c)(-.#./.ed .)!e."e, ."e,e #- () *)1e, ,e&a.#)(1#.")/. ."e c),,e&a.#0e c)(-.#./.#)( ) a #e&d ) %()1&ed!e (), a(3%()1&ed!e ."a. d)e- (). *,e-/**)-e a(d c)(-.#./.e a. ."e -a'e .#'e *)1e,,e&a.#)(- ]F)/ca/&. ^ F)/ca/&. .")/!". ."a. &a(!/a!e #- a /(c.#)(

) *)1e, T"/- *)1e, c#,c/&a.e- #( ."e c)(.e2. ) ,e*,e-e(.a.#)( T"e,e #- ac)((ec.#)( be.1ee( d#e,e(ce- *)1e, a(d ,e*,e-e(.a.#)(- I. #- a( e2e,c#-e) ."e -3'b)c *)1e, .",)/!" ,e*,e-e(.a.#)(a& *,ac.#ce- T"e -.e,e).3*e-c,ea.ed b3 &a(!/a!e a,e a %e3 *)#(. #( -3'b)c 0#)&e(ce P)1e, #- (). )(&3.) c)(-.,a#( b/. #. #- a&-) .) *,)d/ce ]Ha&& ^ I( ."e ca-e ) C"#(e-e*"#&)-)*"3 ."#- *)1e, a&&)1- ), ."e *,)d/c.#)( ) (e1 )b$ec.- )%()1&ed!e ]-/c" a- ."e O,#e(.^ a(d (e1 ),'- ) %()1&ed!e ]-/c" a-O,#e(.a-'^

T"e )."e, %e3 *)#(. 1"#c" c)/&d "e&* .) e2*&a#( 1"3 C"#(e-e*"#&)-)*"3 #- (). -ee( a- a *"#&)-)*"3 #( F,a(ce #- ."e /(#0e,-a-a.#)( )We-.e,( %()1&ed!e O(e ) ."e ce(.,a& c&a#'- ) We-.e,( *"#&)-)*"3 #- #.-/(#0e,-a-. 0)ca.#)( a *,e.e(.#)( .) ."e /(#0e,-a& 1"#c" #- ."e c"a,ac.e,#-.#c) E/,)*e acc),d#(! .) J,!e( Habe,'a- ]^ A- Ke(.a O"$# a(d

F-M*: "* C= + %** P= 15


18/186

F-M*: "* C= + %** P=

M#c%"ae& X#a,a- /(de,(e ."e Ge,'a( *"#&)-)*"e, "a- a,!/ed 1#.")/.a(3 c)(.,ad#c.#)( a(d 1#.")/. /-#(! ."e 'e.a*"3-#ca& c)(ce*.#)( ) ."e/(#0e,-a& ."a. *,e.e(.#)( .) ."e /(#0e,-a& #- a c"a,ac.e,#-.#c ) ."e We-. a(d."e c,#.e,#)( ) 0ad (),'- ), e0e,31"e,e a(d a(3 .#'e ]O"$# a(d X#a,a-

^U(#0e,-a-' #- a&-) ."e 'a-% ) e."()ce(.,#-' I( ."#- 0e#( T)d),)0"a- a,!/ed ."a. ."e /(#0e,-a& "#d ."e 1#&& ) E/,)*ea( e."()ce(.,#-' ),E/,)ce(.,#-' ] ^ I( ."a. -e(-e #. #- (). *)--#b&e .) ,ec)!(#-e a(),#!#( ), *"#&)-)*"3 )."e, ."a( G,eece (), a *"#&)-)*"3 ]C"#(e-e*"#&)-)*"3 ), e2a'*&e^ )."e, ."a( We-.e,( *"#&)-)*"3 E(,#+/e D/--e&*,)*)-e- ."a. ."e ),#!#( ) ."#- /(#0e,-a-. bee ca( be )/(d #( De-ca,.e-1") #(#.#a.ed ."e e!)k*).#c ) %()1&ed!e De-ca,.e- *&aced E/,)*ea( 'a(a. ."e &e0e& ) G)d #(a-'/c" a- "e .")/!". ."e )/(da.#)( ) %()1&ed!e 1a-

."e #,-. a(d #(d/b#.ab&e *,#(c#*&e D/--e& a,!/e- ."a. !#+ c+#%0+ 1a-*,eceded b3 !#+ c+*-1%/01/I c)(+/e, ."e,e),e I a' ] #( G,)-)!/e& ^ E/,)*e "a- c,ea.ed ."e /(#0e,-a& b/. "a- '#.ed #.- a,ea- )a**ca.#)( T"#- #- a *,)ce-- ) e2c&/-#)( N)1ada3- ."e c,ea.),- ) ."#-().#)( ) ."e /(#0e,-a& "a0e (). ,e()/(ced ."e#, ,#!". .) a**&3 #. T"e3c)(.#(/e .) c&a--#3 1"a. #- #(-#de a(d )/.-#de ."e /(#0e,-a&

T"e c)(-e+/e(ce ) ."e /(#0e,-a-a.#)( ) %()1&ed!e #- ."a. .")/!".-a,e (). -#./a.ed T"/- ."e We-. a--/'e- ."e *a.e,(#.3 ) .")/!".- Wa&.e,

M#!()&) +/).e- E(,#+/e D/--e& 1") -*ea%- ab)/. ."e &ac% ) -#./a.ed.")/!". 1"#c" ), "#' -")1- ."e 0a!/e(e-- ) ."e E/,)*ea( ')de,(ca*#.a-. /(#0e,-a& ]M#!()&) ^ T"e c)(cea&'e(. ) ."e &)ca-a.#)() ."e -/b$ec.- e(/(c#a.#)( #'*e- a "#e,a,c"3 ) %()1&ed!e A.e,a**,)*,#a.#(! ."e ),#!#( ) b,#!". #dea- ), %()1&ed!e E/,)*e 1a- ab&e .)c&a#' #(.e&&ec./a& a/."),#.3 a(d e-.ab-" ."e )."e,- a- #(e,#), T"#--#./a.#)( "a- &)!#ca&&3 *e,'#..ed #.- d)'#(a.#)( )0e, ."e )."e,- a(d ."e*)--#b#.3 .) c)&)(#-e ."e' #( ),de, .) ed/ca.e a(d !#0e ."e' -/*e,#),%()1&ed!e ."e &a..e, ) 1"#c" 'a3 a,#-e ,)' ."e )."e,- ."e'-e&0e- A- a

c)(-e+/e(ce ."#- &ac% ) &)ca-a.#)( ) ."e -/b$ec. eed- ."e /(#0e,-a-.'3." I(deed b3 (). dec&a,#(! 1") #- a. ."e ),#!#( ) a( #dea ), d#-c)0e,3."e We-. a**,)*,#a.e- ."#- #dea a(d a. ."e -a'e .#'e e,a-e- ."e ),#!#( ) ."e#dea ), d#-c)0e,3 T"#- #- 1"a. "a**e(ed "#-.),#ca&&3 #( *,#(.#(! .ec"()&)!3G/.e(be,! #( Ge,'a(3 #- -a#d .) be ."e #(0e(.), ) *,#(.#(! beca/-e #( "e "ad ."e #dea .) /-e ')0ab&e &ead c"a,ac.e,- .) *,#(. B/. acc),d#(! .)

J)-e*" Need"a' a(d E.#e'b&e ."#- .ec"(#+/e 1a- a&,ead3 /-ed ), ce(./,#e-#( C"#(a

B3 ."e e,a-/,e ) ."e &)ca-a.#)( ) ."e -/b$ec. #( ."e *)1e, a(de*#-.e'#c ,e&a.#)(-"#* We-.e,( *"#&)-)*"3 a(d -c#e(ce'a(a!ed .) *,)d/ce a /(#0e,-a-. '3." 1"#c" c)0e,- ), ,a."e,

16


19/186

"#de- ."e e*#-.e'#c &)ca-a.#)( #( *)1e, ,e&a.#)(-"#*- ,)'1"#c" ."e -/b$ec. -*ea%- ]G,)-)!/e& ^

T"/- ."e We-. .a%e- )( ."e !))d ,)&e b3 c)&)(#-#(! ."e )."e,- #(

),de, .) *,)0#de ."e' 1#." -c#e(ce a(d c#0#-a.#)( a(d ."#- c)(-.#./.e- a,ea-)( .) e2.e(d #.- #(.e&&ec./a& a(d -*a.#a& .e,,#.),3 T"e We-. bee0e- #( #.-c#0#-#(! '#--#)( a- 1e&& a- #( #.- ec)()'#c #(.e,e-.- I( ."e ." ce(./,3 a(d."e be!#((#(! ) ."e ." ce(./,3 a&& ."e E/,)*ea( *).#ca& ')0e'e(.-a,!/ed ."a. "/'a(#.3 1a- &ed b3 a( ),de, a -ca&e a(d ."a. ."e .)* ) ."#-"#e,a,c"3 1a- )cc/*#ed b3 ."e We-. S)*"#e Be--#- c)(ce#0e- ) ."#- #dea a-."e -e,#)/- '#--#)( ) c#0##(! ."a. ."e 1"#.e 'a( /(de,.a%e- a(d 1"#c"."e( ca( be /-ed a- a( e2c/-e ), a&& #.- e(.e,*,#-e- ] ^

C$-e+ f'* a Dece&,*a$!+a,!'& a&d a Dec'$'&!+a,!'& 'f We+,e*& P!$'+'(1

S)&/.#)(- *,)*)-ed b3 *)-.kc)&)(#a& ."e),#e- ca( "e&* .) dekce(.,a-e a(ddekc)&)(#-e F,e(c" *"#&)-)*"3 F#,-. #. #- *)--#b&e .) c)/(.e,ac. ."e #dea ."a.."e We-. #- ."e )(&3 )(e .) ")&d %()1&ed!e a(d -) "a- ."e *)1e, .) d)'#(a.e."e )."e,- A -)&/.#)( c)/&d be .) *,ac.#-e a ,e&a.#0#-' ,e!a,d#(! c/&./,e-a(d %()1&ed!e #( ."e 1),&d T"e ca.e!),#e- ) ."e We-.e,( d#-c#*(e- a,e)/(ded /*)( We-.e,( c,#.e,#a 1"#c" "a0e bee( #(-.#./.ed b3 -*ec##c

de#(#.#)(- Ma(3 F,e(c" *"#&)-)*"e,- ,e/-e C"#(a a(d )."e,- ."e ab#.3.) *"#&)-)*"#-e beca/-e ,ec)!(#-#(! ."e-e )."e, *"#&)-)*"#e- '#!".dece(.,e We-.e,( *"#&)-)*"3 Acc),d#(! .) M#!()&)

I. #- c,/c#a& _ ` .) ,e."#(% ."e a,.#c/&a.#)(- #( ."e *,)d/c.#)(a(d d#-.,#b/.#)( ) %()1&ed!e a(d ."e ,)&e ) ."e H/'a(#.#e-."e S)c#a& Sc#e(ce- a(d ."e Na./,a& Sc#e(ce- #( ."e c),*),a.e/(#0e,-#.3 /(de, 1"#c" 1e a,e #(! a(d 1),%#(! _ ` _I`.#'*e- !)#(! be3)(d (a.#)(a& .e,a./,e- a(d &))%#(! a. ."e

&a,!e, *#c./,e #( ."e -.,/c./,e ) c)&)(#a& *)1e, &a(!/a!e a(d."e #(.e,-.a.e -3-.e' ] ^

T"e -ec)(d -)&/.#)( c)/&d be .) #(0e,. ."e *,)ce-- ) c)'*a,#-)(be.1ee( ."e ce(.,e a(d ."e *e,#*"e,3 1"#c" eed- #(.e&&ec./a& c)&)(#a.3a(d O,#e(.a-' T"#- c)'*a,#-)( c)/&d be #&&/-.,a.ed b3 ."e !,a''a.#ca&c)(-.,/c.#)( ."e3 a,e %e /- 1"e,e ."e 1),d ."e3 'ea(- ."e )."e,- a(d."e 1),d /- 'ea(- ."e We-. I. c)/&d ."e,e),e be a -)&/.#)( .) *,ac.#ce a*)-.kc)&)(#a& &a(!/a!e a- Na)%# Sa%a# "a- a,!/ed Acc),d#(! .) Sa%a# ."#-dec&a,a.#)( l ."e3 a,e %e /- l ,ee,- .) ."e c)(0#c.#)( ) ."e a((#"#&a.#)() ."e )."e, 1"#c" #( #.- )."e,(e-- #- *,)bab&3 ."e '#--#)( ) ."e ')(#-."#-.),3 ] ^ T"e a&.e,(a.#0e c)/&d be ."e e2*,e--#)( 1e a,e %e

F-M*: "* C= + %** P= 17


20/186

F-M*: "* C= + %** P=

."e' b/. #( ."#- e2*,e--#)( ."e ce(.,a.3 ) ."e We-. #- () &)(!e, e(-/,edA ."#,d -)&/.#)( ), ,e-.),#(! ."e 1")&e- -"a..e,ed b3 ."e /(#0e,-a-.

d#-c)/,-e ) We-.e,( *"#&)-)*"3 c)/&d be .) .a%e #(.) acc)/(. ."e !e)*).#c-) %()1&ed!e A 1a3 .) *,ac.#ce ."#- #dea 1)/&d be .) "#!"!". ."e -*a.#a.3

) e*#-.e')&)!3 a(d .) ."),)/!"&3 "#-.),#c#-e #. T"a. #- .) -a3 )(e "a- .)-ee% 1"e,e a(d 1"e( a( #dea "a- bee( .")/!". T"#- e2e,c#-e 1#&&c)(-e+/e(.&3 dekce(.,a-e We-.e,( .")/!". I. 1#&& "#!"!". -e0e,a&e*#-.e')&)!#ca& )c# 1),&d1#de 1#." ()(e a**ea,#(! -/*e,#), .) a(3 )."e,Acc),d#(! .) M#!()&) e*#-.e')&)!3 #- (). ak"#-.),#c I. #- (). a(3'),e a(ea, "#-.),3 1"#c" !)e- ,)' G,eece .) ."e *,)d/c.#)( ) We-.e,(c)(.e'*),a,3 %()1&ed!e E*#-.e')&)!3 '/-. be -*a.#a-ed "#-.),#c#-ed b3*&a3#(! ."e c)&)(#a& d#e,e(ce ] ^ T"/- a -)&/.#)( c)/&d be .) */.."e We-. #( *e,-*ec.#0e a(d (). .) *&ace #. #( ."e ce(.,e b/. a- a ,e!#)( a')(!

)."e,-S/c" #dea- ec") D#-*e-" C"a%,aba,.3- *,)*)-a& .) *,)0#(c#a-e

E/,)*e *a,.#c/&a,&3 #( ."e #e&d ) "#-.),3 ]-ee C"a%,aba,.3 ^ T"#--)&/.#)( 1)/&d be .) ."#(% ) e0e,3 c/&./,e e0e,3 c#0#-a.#)( a- a ,e-/&. )e2c"a(!e- be.1ee( a(d c)(.ac.- a(d b)(d- 1#." )."e,- W"e."e, -/c" a/(#0e,-a-. "/'a(#-' ca( be c)/(.e,ba&a(ced b3 ,e-*ec. ),e*#-.e')&)!#ca& d#0e,-#.3 ,e'a#(- .) be -ee(

C'&c$-+!'&

T"e-e c&/e- "a0e "e&*ed /- .) be..e, /(de,-.a(d ."e-e #--/e- b3 c)(-#de,#(!.) 1"a. e2.e(. C"#(a ."#(%- ), # #. #- )(&3 ."e We-.e,( 1),&d ."a. "a- ."e,#!". a(d ."e ab#.3 .) ."#(% T"e #--/e ) ."e e2#-.e(ce ) )."e, *"#&)-)*"#e--/c" a- C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 'a3 be e2*&a#(ed 1#." a c)&)(#a-. ),#e(.a-.a(d E/,)ce(.,#-. *e,-*ec.#0e T"e 'a#( ,ea-)( be#(! ."a. *"#&)-)*"3/(de,-.))d a- We-.e,( *"#&)-)*"3 #- ce(.,a-ed beca/-e ."e We-. #- -ee(a- ."e ce(.,e ) 1),&d %()1&ed!e We-.e,( *"#&)-)*"3 #- 'a,%ed b3

E/,)ce(.,#-' a(d b3 c)&)(#a.3 ) .")/!". We-.e,( *"#&)-)*"3 c)(-#de,-#.-e& a- d)'#(a(. a(d ."#- #dea !#0e- #. ."e a--e,.ed ,#!". .) c)&)(#-e a(dc#0#-e )."e,- T"e )."e,- ."#(% ) ."e'-e&0e- #( c)'*a,#-)( .) ."e We-.a(d ."e "#e,a,c"3 ) %()1&ed!e #'*e- ."a. C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 #- -ee( a-a *e,#*"e,a& a(d /(ab&e .) ,eac" ."e ce(.,e ,e*,e-e(.ed b3 We-.e,(*"#&)-)*"3 T"e /(#0e,-a-' ) We-.e,( *"#&)-)*"3 #- ,e#(),ced b3ce(.,a-' a(d #(.e&&ec./a& c)&)(#a.3 a- 1e&& a- ."e &ac% ) .e'*),a& a(d-*a.#a& -#./a.#)( ) ."e .")/!".- #( ."e 1),&d T"e ,e&a.#0#-' ) c/&./,e- a(d%()1&ed!e a- 1e&& a- ."e -*ac#a-a.#)( a(d "#-.),#c#-a.#)( ) %()1&ed!ec)/&d "e&* .) dece(.,e We-.e,( *"#&)-)*"3 A ')d##ca.#)( ) ."e 1a3 .)c)(-.,/c. c)'*a,#-)(- be.1ee( ),'- ) %()1&ed!e c)/&d a&-) "e&* .) b,ea%."e -c"e'a ) ce(.,e a(d *e,#*"e,#e- ."a. #- -) ).e( #de(.##ed T"e-e c&/e-

18


21/186

c)/&d "e&* F,e(c" -c")&a,- .) c),,ec. ."e#, c/&./,a& '3)*#a ]C&a,%e ^ a(d a&&)1 ), ."e *,ac.#ce ) a (e1 1a3 ) ."#(%#(! ab)/. ."e 1),&d a(d."e 'a(3 *"#&)-)*"#e- 1#."#( #.

Ma*!eJ-$!e F*a!&a!+Ma!,*e @%"%a!,*ec!,1-;ed-;# #- Re-ea,c" Fe&&)1 #(."e De*a,.'e(. ) A-#a( a(d I(.e,(a.#)(a& S./d#e- a(d #( ."e H)(! K)(!Ad0a(ced I(-.#./.e ), C,)--kD#-c#*(a,3 S./d#e- ) C#.3 U(#0e,-#.3 ) H)(!K)(! He, ,e-ea,c" #(.e,e-.- a,e We-.e,( a(d C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 Ta)#-'a(d dec)&)(#a& ."#(%#(!

E&d&',e+

1 See Z"/a(!4# ] ^

2 T"e c)(ce*. ) %)a#%*a%.![), #'a!#(a,3 #- b),,)1ed ,)' C),(:/-Ca-.),#ad#- a(d 'ea(- #(0e(.#)( ]-ee Ca-.),#ad#- ^

3 O( ."e-e ().#)(- ) e."()ce(.,#-' a(d e/,)ce(.,#-' -ee T)d),)0 ]^

4 See Sa%a# a(d N#-"#.a(# ]^

5

F), #(-.a(ce M)(.e-+/#e/ #( ."e ." ce(./,3 /-ed C"#(a .) #'*,)0e "#-*).#ca& -3-.e' ]-ee M)(.e-+/#e/ ^

6 F,a(9)#- J/&e( a F,e(c" *"#&)-)*"e, /-e- C"#(e-e *"#&)-)*"3 #( ),de,.) /(de,-.a(d ."e /(.")/!".k) #( We-.e,( .")/!". ]-ee J/&e( a(dMa,c"a#--e ^

7 See Need"a' ]^ a(d E.#e'b&e ]^

B!b$!'g*a(1

Bad#)/ A ]^ O/!. c+*/0.1%.! P+1. F.a*;+%/ J1((%!* Pa,#- Se/#&

Be--#- S ]^ L[Occ%!*0 !0 (!/ a10.!/ H%/0+%.! [1*! /1,.


22/186

F-M*: "* C= + %** P=

Ca-.),#ad#- C ]^ L[I*/0%010%+* %)a#%*a%.! ! (a /+c%C"e(! A ]^ La C$%*! ,!*/!^0^!((!Pa,#- Fa3a,d

C&a,%e J J ]^ O.%!*0a( E*(%#$0!*)!*0 T$! E*c+1*0!. b!03!!* A/%a* a*

W!/0!.* T$+1#$0Ne1 Y),% R)/.&ed!e

De)),. C ]^ I- T"e,e S/c" a T"#(! a- C"#(e-e P"#&)-)*"3[ A,!/'e(.-) a( I'*c#. Deba.e P$%(+/+,$5 Ea/0 a* W!/0]^ k

De)),. C ]^ I- C"#(e-e P"#&)-)*"3 a P,)*e, Na'e[ A Re-*)(-e .)Re#( Ra/d P$%(+/+,$5 Ea/0 a* W!/0]^ k

De&*"3 C ]^ C(a//!. D+)%*!. Q1% /+*0 (!/ a10.!/Pa,#- La Fab,#+/eD/--e& E ]^ F%(+/+"?a ! (%b!.ac%*Me2#c) Ed#c)&

D/--e& E ]^ P$%(+/+,$5 +" L%b!.a0%+* Ne1 Y),% O,b#- B))%-

E.#e'b&e R ]^ L[E1.+,! c$%*+%/! ]V)& ^ Pa,#- Ga&'a,d

Fa&-kB),da O ]^ C%!*ca P.+,%a 5 C+(+*%a(%/)+ I*0!((!c01a( (+/ *1!2+/ .1)b+/

B)!).a Va&e(c#a

F)/ca/&. M ]^ L[O..! 1 %/c+1./Pa,#- Ga&'a,d

F)/ca/&. M ]^ L!/ )+0/ !0 (!/ c$+/!/Pa,#- Ga&'a,d

F)/ca/&. M ]^ S1.2!%((!. !0 ,1*%. Na%//a*c! ! (a ,.%/+*Pa,#- Ga&'a,d

G)d#( C ]^ D%c0%+**a%.! ! ,$%(+/+,$%! Pa,#- Fa3a,d

G,a(e. M ]^ La P!*/


23/186

G,e!),3 D ]^ T$! C+(+*%a( P.!/!*0Ma&de( B&ac%1e&&

G,)-)!/e& R ]^ Le- #'*ca.#)(- de- a&.:,#.:- :*#-.:'#+/e- da(- &a,ed:#(#.#)( d/ ca*#.a-'e !&)ba& T,a(-')de,(#.: *e(-:e ,)(.a,e e.

c)&)(#a.: _.,a(- A De0#&&: a(d A Ve,eec%e(`M1(0%01!/]^ kHabe,'a- J ]^ E*0.! *a01.a(%/)! !0 .!(%#%+* (!/

F-M*: "* C= + %** P= 21


24/186

F-M*: "* C= + %** P=

M#!()&) W ]^ G:)*).#+/e de &a c)((a#--a(ce c)&)(#a.: d/ *)/0)#,e. d#:,e(ce c)&)(#a&e _.,a(- A Q/e,,#e(`M1(0%01!/]^ k

M)(.e-+/#e/ C L S ]^ D! ([E/,.%0 !/ L+%/]B))% C"a*.e, ^ Pa,#-

Ga&'a,dNeed"a' J ]^ Sc%!*c! a* C%2%(%6a0%+* %* C$%*aCa'b,#d!e Ca'b,#d!eU(#0e,-#.3 P,e--

O"$# K a(d X#a,a- M ]^ ,.+12!. ([1*%2!./!( E//a% ! #


25/186

T"),a0a& J ]^ De &a *"#&)-)*"#e e( C"#(e 6 &a C"#(e da(- &a*"#&)-)*"#e P!./,!c0%2!/ c$%*+%/!/ k

T)d),)0 T ]^ N+1/ !0 (!/ a10.!/Pa,#- Se/#&

Z"/a(!4# ]^ Z"/a(!4# #( P$%(+/+,$!/ 0a+@/0!/_.,a(- L K#ak"1a3 a(dB G,3'*a-` Pa,#- Ga&'a,d

F-M*: "* C= + %** P= 23


26/186

I&d!ge&'-+ E(!+,e%'$'g1 a&d ,e Dec'$'&!+a,!'& 'f

P'+,c'$'&!a$!+%

b3 Ha#a S A&a#-a&

Ab+,*ac,

T"#- *a*e, .,ace- ."e #(0)&0e'e(. ) *)-.c)&)(#a-' #( ."e'a,!#(a-a.#)( ) #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!#e- I. be!#(- b3#&&/-.,a.#(! ")1 *)-.c)&)(#a-' 'a#(.a#(- a d#c").)'#-ed

c)(ce*./a& ,a'e1),% ."a. c&ea,&3 -e*a,a.e- #(d#!e()/-e*#-.e')&)!3 ,)' *)-.c)&)(#a& e*#-.e')&)!3 T"#- #- )&&)1edb3 a( e2a'#(a.#)( ) #(d#!e()/- #(.e,0e(.#)(- ."a. "a0e ().ed."e e*#-.e')&)!#ca& #'*e,#a-' ) We-.e,( 1a3- ) %()1#(!a(d ."e (eed .) dek(% ,)' ."e-e T"e( ."e *a*e, e2a'#(e-dec)&)(#-a.#)( #( ,e&a.#)( .) #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!#e- 1"#c"&ead- .) a d#-c/--#)( ) M#!()&)- ')de,(#.3jc)&)(#a.3 *)1e,c)'*&e2 T"#- e2*&),a.#)( ,e0ea&- ."a. ."e d#c").)'#-#(!,a'e1),% ."a. *)-.c)&)(#a-' a**e- .) #(d#!e()/-e*#-.e')&)!#e- #- -3'*.)'a.#c ) a *,))/(d -"),.c)'#(! T"#-c)(ce,(- *)-.c)&)(#a-'- &ac% ) a c,#.#ca& -.a(ce .)1a,d- #.-)1( e*#-.e')&)!#ca& )/(da.#)(- (a'e&3 #.- e(.a(!&e'e(.1#." M#!()&)- c)&)(#a.3j')de,(#.3 *)1e, c)'*&e2 T"e*a*e, c)(c&/de- 1#." a b,#e c)(-#de,a.#)( ) ."e 0#ab#.3 ) adec)&)(#-ed *)-.c)&)(#a-'

I( C)&)(#a.3 ) P)1e, a(d Dekc)&)(#a& T"#(%#(! Wa&.e, D M#!()&)

#(-#!"./&&3 *)#(.ed )/. ."a. c)/(.e,k#(./#.#0e&3 *)-.c)&)(#a-' #- a #e&d) %()1&ed!e #( (eed ) dec)&)(#-a.#)( He -.a.ed T"e ,ad#ca& d#e,e(cebe.1ee( l )( ."e )(e "a(d l *)-.kc)&)(#a& ."e),3 a(d *)-.kc)&)(#a.3 #(!e(e,a& a(d dekc)&)(#a& *,)$ec.- l )( ."e )."e, "a(d l e- #( ."e !e(ea&)!3) .")/!". #( 1"#c" eac" *,)$ec.- )/(d #.- e(e,!3 a(d #.- 0#-#)( ]M#!()&) ^ M#!()&)- *)#(. a**ea,- .) be 0ad P)-.c)&)(#a-' ca(().e(!a!e 1#." #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!#e- /(&e-- #. a&-) ./,(- a c,#.#ca& !a4e.)1a,d- #.- )1( ."e),e.#ca& e(.a(!&e'e(. 1#." ."e ')de,(#.3jc)&)(#a.3

*)1e, -.,/c./,e I( -"),. *)-.c)&)(#a-' ca((). -/-.a#( #.- e."#ca& */,c"a-e/(&e-- #. dec)&)(#-e- #.-e& I( ."#- a,.#c&e *)-.c)&)(#a-'- e(c)/(.e, 1#."#(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!#e- #- /-ed a- a ."e),e.#ca& 3a,d-.#c% ), 'ea-/,#(!*)-.c)&)(#a-'- e."#ca& */,c"a-e I. #- *,/de(. a. ."#- $/(c./,e .) *)#(. )/.


27/186

."a. ."e .e,'- !,%/0!)+(+#5a(d !,%/0!)+(+#%!/a,e /-ed #(.e,c"a(!eab&3 .)#(d#ca.e a ca.e!),3 ."a. #- /(da'e(.a&&3 a. )dd- 1#." *)-.c)&)(#a-'-e*#-.e')&)!3 T"e *&/,a& /-a!e #(d#ca.e- a( a1a,e(e-- ) ."e *&/,a.3 )#(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!#e- a(d ."e -#(!/&a, /-a!e #- #(.e(ded .) c)(0e3 ."e

#dea ."a. ."e-e e*#-.e')&)!#e- a,e /(##ed #( ."e#, a**ea& .) *,ekc)&)(#a&1a3- ) %()1#(! a(d #(d#!e()/- 1a3- ) %()1#(! ."a. e(c)'*a---*#,#./a& ec)()'#ca& e(0#,)('e(.a& a(d -)c#a& d#'e(-#)(- T"e e#cac3 )a**&3#(! #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!#e- .) a c,#.#+/e ) *)-.c)&)(#a-' #-/,."e, $/-.##ed b3 ."e ac. ."a. ."e-e a,e *)-#.#)(ed )/.-#de ."e')de,(#.3jc)&)(#a.3 c)'*&e2 #de(.##ed b3 M#!()&) a- a( #(.e!,a& *a,. )c)&)(#a& *)1e, T"e,e),e ."#- -./d3 #- b3 (ece--#.3 d#a!()-.#c b/. ().e2"a/-.#0e #( #.- a**,)ac" T"e e,/d#.e *)-.c)&)(#a-. 1#&& ().e ."e )'#--#)() 'a(3 ."e),#-.- ,)' ."e d#-c/--#)( T"e-e )'#--#)(- a,e (ece--a,3 !#0e(."e )c/- ) ."#- e2*&),a.#)( #- ."e c)(-#de,a.#)( ) *)-.c)&)(#a& ."e),#-.-1") "a0e add,e--ed #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 L#%e1#-e ."#- a,.#c&e 1#&& ().e(!a!e #( a( e2.e(-#0e ,e0#e1 ) ."e c)(-#de,ab&e 1),% d)(e b3 #(d#!e()/-."#(%e,- a(d c,#.#c- e2ce*. .) #(0)&0e .")-e 1") "a0e bee( d,a1( /*)( b3*)-.c)&)(#a& ."e),#-.- 1") "a0e e2*&),ed ), c)''e(.ed )( ."e ,e&a.#)(-"#*

be.1ee( #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!#e- a(d *)-.c)&)(#a-'

F*'% Na,!.!+% ,' I&d!ge&'-+ E(!+,e%'$'g1

T,ac#(! ."e !e(ea&)!3 ) #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 #( *)-.c)&)(#a-' ,e0ea&-."a. ."e #(d#!e()/- 0)#ce 1a- #,-. add,e--ed a- (a.#0#-' 1"#c" ca( be*e,ce#0ed a- a ),' ) c/&./,a& e--e(.#a-' a(d ."e( a- a '),e (/a(cedc)(ce*./a-a.#)( ) #(d#!e()/- 1),&d0#e1- #( #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3

T"#- ')0e'e(. .)1a,d- a be..e, /(de,-.a(d#(! ) ."e #--/e- a--)c#a.ed 1#."#(d#!e()/- *e)*&e- e2*,e--#)(- ) ,e-#-.a(ce ca'e ab)/. a- a ,e-/&. )*)-.c)&)(#a-'- !,)1#(! a1a,e(e-- ) ."e c,#-#- ,e!a,d#(! #.- )1( e."#ca&*/,c"a-e a(d ."e e*#-.e')&)!#ca& c"a&&e(!e ."a. #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!#e-*)-e

T"e *)-.c)&)(#a& e(!a!e'e(. 1#." #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 a&1a3-)cc/,- 1#."#( a d#c").)'#-#(! ,a'e1),% Fa()( acc/,a.e&3 de-c,#bed ."ed#c").)'#-ed c)(d#.#)( ) (a.#0e a(.#kc)&)(#a& #(.e&&ec./a&- a- #(d#0#d/a&-1") a,e ca/!". be.1ee( ."e b)/,!e)#- ,e*,e-e(.a.#0e- ) ."e ')."e,c)/(.,3 a(d a( a(2#)/- #'*/&-e .) ./,( .) a(c#e(. c/&./,e- a- a -)/,ce )(a.#)(a& c/&./,e #( a( e),. .) -",#(% a1a3 ,)' ."a. We-.e,( c/&./,e #(1"#c" ."e3 a&& ,#-% be#(! -1a'*ed ] ^ H#- ce(.,a-a.#)( )

(a.#)(a& be,a.#)( a- ."e /&.#'a.e a#' ) a(3 ,ec)/,-e .) #(d#!e()/-a(c#e(. c/&./,e c)(#(ed "#' .) a '#.ed 0#e1 ) (a.#0#-' ."a. d#d ()..a%e #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 #(.) c)(-#de,a.#)( F), Fa()( (a.#0#-'

A+: I)* E*= 25


28/186

A+: I)* E*=

,e'a#(ed a *)--#b&e a(d c)'*e.#(! -)/,ce ) *)-.c)&)(#a& #de(.#.3 a"ea&."#e, c")#ce ), ."e !e(e,a& *-3c")kaec.#0e e+/#b,#/' a(d a(#(d#ca.), ) ."e a#&/,e ) c)&)(#a& a--#'#&a.#)( ] ^ Fa()( (e0e,c)(-#de,ed (a.#0#-' a- )e,#(! a ,ad#ca&&3 d#e,e(. e*#-.e')&)!3 1"#c"

'a3 *,e-e(. a( e(.#,e&3 d#e,e(. *e,-*ec.#0e )( be,a.#)( ."a. 'a3 ), 'a3(). "a0e a(3."#(! .) d) 1#." (a.#)(a& c)(-.,/c.- I( ac. #(d#!e(#-.- "a0e+/e-.#)(ed ."e (a.#)( a- a( #dea& ),' ) a *)*/&a, ')de,( *).#ca&),!a(#-a.#)( Ba-ed )( Fa()(- ,ea-)(#(! *)-.c)&)(#a& c,#.#c- '/-. ."e( a-%."e'-e&0e- ."e )&&)1#(! +/e-.#)( H)1 ca( c)&)(#a-. a--#'#&a.#)( bedec&a,ed a a#&/,e # ."e c)(ce*./a& a(d #(deed c)!(#.#0e c)'*&e2 ]#eWe-.e,( ,a.#)kce(.,#c e*#-.e')&)!3^ ."a. 1a- "#!"&3 #(-.,/'e(.a& #(c)&)(#-a.#)( #( ."e #,-. *&ace -.#&& !)0e,(- a&& e2*,e--#)(- ) ,e-#-.a(ce .)a--#'#&a.#)([ I( )."e, 1),d- # ."e,e #- () e*#-.e')&)!#ca& ,/*./,e ca( ."e,e

be be,a.#)([ T"e d#c").)'3 ."a. Fa()( ().ed bec)'e- ."e ')d/- )*e,a(d#), '/c" ) *)-.c)&)(#a-'- c)(-#de,a.#)( ) #(d#!e()/- *e)*&e-e2*,e--#)(- ) a(.#kc)&)(#a-' W"e( #(d#!e()/- *e)*&e- ,e-#-.a(ce #--/b$ec.ed .) a *)-.c)&)(#a-. e*#-.e')&)!#ca& !a4e #. #- d#c").)'#-ed #(.).1) ')de- ]^ ')de- ) #(d#!e()/- ,e-#-.a(ce ."a. a,e acce*.ab&e .) ."#-e*#-.e')&)!3 a(d ]^ ')de- ."a. a,e c)(-#de,ed ,e.,)!,ade a(d a,c"a#c

beca/-e ."e3 be&)(! .) a( #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3T"e *e,ce#0ed &ac% ) a ,)&e ), #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 1#."#( ."e

."e),e.#ca& ba-.#)( ) *)-.c)&)(#a-' !a#(- ),.")d)23 ,)'*)-.c)&)(#a-'- )/(da.#)(a& c,#.#c Ed1a,d Sa#d A&.")/!" Sa#d/(e+/#0)ca&&3 ,e$ec.ed a&& ),'- ) (a.#0#-' "e d#d ,ec)!(#-e ."e ab-e(ce) a( e*#-.e')&)!#ca& c,#.#+/e a. ."e ')-. /(da'e(.a& &e0e& ) ."ec)((ec.#)( be.1ee( ."e de0e&)*'e(. ) a "#-.),#c#-' a(d ."e ac./a&*,ac.#-e ) #'*e,#a-' ] ^ N)(e."e&e-- "e ,e$ec.ed ."e #dea ),e-*)(d#(! .) ."e .3,a((#ca& c)($/(c./,e ) c)&)(#a& *)1e, 1#." -c")&a,&3O,#e(.a-' -#'*&3 b3 *,)*)-#(! a( a&a(ce be.1ee( (a.#0#-. -e(.#'e(.

b/..,e--ed b3 -)'e 0a,#e.3 ) (a.#0e #de)&)!3 ]#b#d ^ T"#- a(.#*a."3.)1a,d- (a.#0#-' e2.e(d- .) )(e ) Sa#d- a(d #(deed *)-.c)&)(#a-'-')-. a,de(. )e- A#$a4 A"'ad A"'ad *e,ce*.#0e&3 acc/-ed ."e e'e,!#(!#e&d ) be#(! *)-.')de,(#-'- 1ed!e .) c)&)(#4e .e,a./,e- )/.-#deE/,)*e a(d #.- N),." A'e,#ca( )-")).- ] ^ H)1e0e, "#- #,'ded#ca.#)( .) ),.")d)2 Ma,2#-' *,e0e(.ed "#' ,)' -ee#(! be3)(d*)-.c)&)(#a.3 a- a 'a..e, ) c&a-- a(d be3)(d ."e (ece--#.3 ) &a/(c"#(!a( /(e(d#(! c,#.#+/e ) ca*#.a-. ')de,(#.3 .) c)/(.e, c)&)(#a-' ]A"'ad ^ W#." "#- Ma,2#-' #,'&3 e(.,e(c"ed #( ."e We-.e,( e*#-.e'e

A"'ad ,e$ec.ed (a.#0#-' a- a ),' ) c/&./,a& d#e,e(.#a-' 1"#c" .,ea.-#(d#!e()/- c/&./,e a- -e&k,ee,e(.#a& a/.)()')/- #( #.- )1( a/."),#.3a(d ."e,e),e /(a0a#&ab&e ), c)!(#.#)( ), c,#.#c#-' ,)' a -*ace )/.-#de

26


29/186

#.-e& ] ^ He a&-) a#&ed .) ().#ce ."e ,ad#ca& -/b0e,-#0e *).e(.#a&*)-ed .) *)-.c)&)(#a-' b3 #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3

Be(#.a Pa,,3 'a(a!ed .) ,e-c/e (a.#0#-' ,)' )/.,#!". d#-'#--a& b3*)-.c)&)(#a-' a(d ,e./,( #. .) a '),e .)&e,a(. Fa()(#a( Ma,2#-'

H)1e0e, Pa,,3 c)/&d (). -/**),. ."e ")*e&e-- a..e'*. .) &)ca.e a(d ,e0#0e*,#-.#(e *,ekc)&)(#a& c/&./,e- ] ^ D)e- ."#- 'ea( ."a. (a.#0ee*#-.e')&)!#e- a,e .) be 1")&&3 ,e$ec.ed[ Pa,,3 *,ed#ca.ed ."e acce*.a(ce )."e-e e*#-.e')&)!#e- ba-ed )( ,e-*)(-e- .) ."e )&&)1#(! W") #- ,e0#-#.#(!."e ,e*)-#.),#e- ) 'e'),3 a(d c/&./,a& -/,0#0a&- #( ."e ca/-e ) *)-.c)&)(#a&,ea-"#)(#(! a(d 1"3 ."e3 a,e d)#(! -) ] ^[ S"e ."e,e),e acce*.ed,ec)/,-e .) (a.#0#-' +*(5a- a -)/,ce ) &)ca.#(! .,ad#.#)(- ) *,).e-. I( )."e,1),d- Pa,,3 acce*.ed ')de- ) #(d#!e()/- *e)*&e- ,e-#-.a(ce c)(-#de,ed-/#.ab&e ), *)-.c)&)(#a-. e*#-.e')&)!3 1"#c" /* .) ."#- *)#(. 1e,e!)0e,(ed b3 a Ma,2#-. e*#-.e'e ."a. e(0#-#)(ed a 'a.e,#a-. a(.#kca*#.a-.a(.#kc)&)(#a-. (a.#)(a& be,a.#)( ')0e'e(. a- a( #dea& I( ac. Pa,,3-ded#ca.#)( .) ."#- 'a.e,#a-. e*#-.e')&)!3 #- -.,#%#(!&3 a**a,e(. #( 1"a. ca()(&3 be ,ead a- a debe,a.e )0e,&))%#(! ) ."e c"a&&e(!e ) #(d#!e()/-e*#-.e')&)!3 He, &ac% ) c)(-#de,a.#)( ) ."#- #--/e #- e0#de(. ,)' "e,dec#-#)( .) '#. "e, e2*&),a.#)( ) M/d#'be- acc)/(. ) A,#ca( G()-#- .)"#- c)''e(.- )( Fa()( de-*#.e ."e ac. ."a. M/d#'be- -#!(a& ac"#e0e'e(.1a- ."a. "#- 1a- ."e #,-. -#!(##ca(. #(.e,0e(.#)( #( *)-.c)&)(#a-'- (e!&ec.

) #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 ]^I( ac. M/d#'be- #(.e,0e(.#)( ().1#."-.a(d#(! ."e 'a#(-.,ea' )*)-.c)&)(#a& ."e),3 c)(.#(/ed l a(d #( ac. -.#&& c)(.#(/e- l .) "a0ed##c/&.#e- 1#." ,e!a,d .) #.- ,e&a.#)(-"#* .) #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 T"ed##c/&.3 #- e2*,e--ed #( *)-.c)&)(#a-'- /(,e!#-.e,ed -/b$ec.#)( ) a&&e(!a!e'e(.- 1#." #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 .) a d#c").)'#-ed ,a'e1),%A- *)-.c)&)(#a-' be!a( .) de0e&)* a !,ea.e, c,#.#ca& a1a,e(e-- ) #.- )1(e."#ca& */,c"a-e 2%/^8^2%/."e (eed .) acc)/(. ), #(d#!e()/- %()1&ed!e ac"a(!e #( .e,'#()&)!3 )cc/,,ed l ."a. #- ."e .e,' %*%#!*+1/ !,%/0!)+(+#5,e*&aced ."e .e,' *a0%2%/) l .) -#!(a& ."#- (e1&3 de0e&)*ed -e(-#.#0#.3N)(e."e&e-- *"#&)-)*"#ca& *)-.-.,/c./,a-. a(d "#-.),#c#-. *)-.c)&)(#a-.e(!a!e'e(.- 1#." #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 c)(.#(/ed .) a**&3 ad#c").)'#-#(! ,a'e1),% 1#.")/. ,ec)!(#-#(! ."a. ."e We-.e,( ,a.#)kce(.,#ce*#-.e'e -/**),.#(! *)-.c)&)(#a-' #- a- M/d#'be ().ed *a,. a(d *a,ce&) ."e ."e c)&)(#4#(! -.,/c./,e ] ^

I( "#- 1),% B!5+* O.%!*0a(%/) E//a5/ +* C.+//^c1(01.a( E*c+1*0!.]^ Da&&'a3, a..e'*.ed .) &)ca.e *)#(.- ) *"#&)-)*"#ca& c)(0e,!e(ce

be.1ee( d#e,e(. e*#-.e')&)!#e- a(d )(.)&)!#e- ."a. 1)/&d a&&)1 a c,)--kc/&./,a& d#a&)!/e a(d *,)').e c,#.#ca& e(!a!e'e(. be.1ee( d#e,#(!c/&./,e- He /-ed Ra#'/(d) Pa(#%%a,- d#a.)*#ca& "e,'e(e/.#c- 1"#c"

A+: I)* E*= 27


30/186

d#e,- ,)' ')()c/&./,a& a(d "#-.),#c#-. ),'- ) #(.e,*,e.a.#)(]Da&&'a3, ^ D#a.)*#ca& "e,'e(e/.#c- ,ee- )( d#a&)!/e a(d*,)ce--e- ) ,ec#*,)ca& &ea,(#(! ]#b#d^ Da&&'a3, *)-#.ed a( )(.)&)!3 ))*e((e-- 1"#c" #'*e- a. &ea-. a ce,.a#( 1#&(!(e-- .) .,a(-ce(d

e-.ab-"ed ca.e!),#e- #( a0), ) a ,ee, ,ec)!(#.#)( ) ae( ek),'- ."/-*e,'#..#(! )."e,(e-- .) be #( a ()(*)--e--#0e 1a3 ]#b#d ^ I( ."#- 1a3."e E/,)ce(.,#c#.3 ) ce,.a#( 0a&/e- ."a. a,e c)(-#de,ed /(#0e,-a& l -/c" a-be,.3 a(d e+/a.3 l #- ea-#&3 ,ec)!(#-ed T"e-e 0a&/e- a,e -ee( a-

+/a.#e- ) #(d#0#d/a& a!e(.- _ ` ) a/.)()')/- e!)- -ee( a-c)(-.#./.#0e b/#&d#(! b&)c%- ) -)c#a& e a- a c),)&&a,3 -)c#a&d#-.#(c.#)(- ), d#e,e(.#a.#)(- "a0e .) be $/-.##ed ),&e!#.#'a.ed a!a#(-. ."e be(c"'a,% ) /(#),'#.3 ), e+/a&be,.3 ]#b#d ^

T"e e(d )b$ec.#0e #- .) c)/(.e, ')()."#c /(#0e,-a-' 1#." d#a.)*#ca&"e,'e(e/.#c- -) a- .) ')0e .)1a,d- a &a.e,a& /(#0e,-a-' 1"#c" #- a'a./,e -.a(ce 1"e,e /(#0e,-a& *,#(c#*&e- a,e () &)(!e, )/(d be3)(dc)(c,e.e d#e,e(ce- b/. #( ."e "ea,. ) ."e &)ca& ), *a,.#c/&a, #.-e& ."a. #- #(."e d#-.#(c. .)*)!,a*"3 ) ."e 1),&d ]#b#d ^

A&.")/!" Da&&'a3, d#d (). d#,ec.&3 add,e-- ."e .)*#c ) #(d#!e()/-

e*#-.e')&)!#e- #. #- -ae .) a--/'e ."a. ."e3 a,e #(c&/ded #( ."e ca.e!),#e-) ."e &)ca& a(d *a,.#c/&a, ,)' 1"#c" &a.e,a& /(#0e,-a-' ca( bec)(-.,/c.ed H#- *,#0#&e!#(! ) *"#&)-)*"3 a- ."e 'ed#/' ) e2*&),a.#)(1)/&d a**ea, .) 'a,!#(a-e #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!#e- ."a. ca((). beada*.ed .) ."e -.a(da,d- ) *"#&)-)*"#ca& -*ec/&a.#)( a(d ."a. /(c.#)(acc),d#(! .) ."e#, )1( #(.e,(a& &)!#c l ."e#, )1( !()-#- 1"#c" 'a3de(#!,a.e We-.e,( ,a.#)kce(.,#c ,ea-)( a&.)!e."e, T"e d#c").)'3 #- #'*c#.#( Da&&'a3,- d#-c)/,-e 1"e,e ."e,e #- () c,#.#ca& -e&k,e&ec.#)( )( ."ee*#-.e')&)!#ca& )/(da.#)(- ) "#- )1( d#-c)/,-e a(d #.- %e&3#(c)'*a.#b#.3 1#." #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 L)ca& a(d *a,.#c/&a,e*#-.e')&)!#e- 'a3 l a(d ."#- #- ')-. ).e( ."e ca-e l be )**)-ed .) ."e,a.#)kce(.,#-' ."a. #- ."e )/(da.#)( ) Da&&'a3,- *"#&)-)*"#ca& -3-.e'Da&&'a3, #- (). a. a&& -e(-#.#0e .) ."#- ac. #( "#- *,)*)-a& ), a &a.e,a&/(#0e,-a-' T"#- 1)/&d 'ea( ."a. "#- &a.e,a& /(#0e,-a-' a *"#&)-)*"#ca&c)(-.,/c. de0e&)*ed ,)' -a#d ,a.#)kce(.,#c )/(da.#)(- 1)/&d be /-ed .)a&&)1 #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!#e- .) "a0e ."e#, -a3

T"e *)-.-.,/c./,a-. -c"))& ) *)-.c)&)(#a-' -#'#&a,&3 a**e- a

d#c").)'#-ed ,a'e1),% .) #(d#!e()/- d#-c)/,-e .",)/!" ."e c)(ce*. )."e "3b,#d T"#- )cc/,- #( -*#.e ) R)be,. Y)/(!- #(.e,0e(.#)( .",)/!"1"#c" *)-.c)&)(#a-' be!a( .) ,e&ec. c,#.#ca&&3 )( #.- )1( ."e),e.#ca&

A+: I)* E*=28


31/186


32/186

/('ed#a.ed -ec/&a,#-' a(d #.- e2c&/-#)( ) ."e ,e!#)(- ."a. "a0e .a%e()( ."e *).#ca& #de(.#.3 ) *,)0#d#(! a&.e,(a.#0e 0a&/ek-3-.e'- .) .")-e )."e 1e-. .) #(a&&3 dec&a,e ."a. *)-.c)&)(#a-' de-*#.e #.- e-*)/-a& )-/ba&.e,( ,e-#-.a(ce -ca,ce&3 0a&/e- -/ba&.e,( ,e-#-.a(ce ."a. d)e- ().

)*e,a.e acc),d#(! .) #.- )1( -ec/&a, .e,'- ] ^ Ne0e,."e&e-- Y)/(!"#'-e& #- (). d#e,e(. beca/-e "e a#&ed .) e2*&),e ."e e*#-.e')&)!#ca'*),. ) Ga(d"#- -*#,#./a-ed a(.#kc)&)(#a& d#-c)/,-e 1"e( "e (e!&ec.ed.) e2a'#(e 1"a. 1a- a,!/ab&3 ."e ')-. ),'a.#0e e&e'e(. #( G"a(d#-d#-c)/,-e I( ac./a.3 ."#- d#-c)/,-e 1a- ba-ed )( a( e*#-.e')&)!3 ."a. 1a-,)).ed #( a ,ed#-c)0e,ed H#(d/#-' 1"#c" (). )(&3 )**)-ed We-.e,(')de,(#.3 b/. a&-) ,e*,e-e(.ed a -*#,#./a& *a." ), Ga(d"# "#'-e& Y)/(!-ee'ed c)(.e(. -#'*&3 .) a&&/de .) ."e #(&/e(ce ) ."e T"e)-)*"#ca& S)c#e.3)( Ga(d"#- d#-c)/,-e B3 c)(.,a-. Y)/(! e2a!!e,a.ed Ga(d"#- /-e ) ."e.))&- ) ')de,(#.3 .) *,)').e ."#- -*#,#./a-ed a(.#kc)&)(#a-' ."e,eb3-/!!e-.#(! -)'e -),. ) *"#&)-)*"#ca& c)'*c#.3 1#." ."e /(de,*#((#(!- )')de,(#.3 )( Ga(d"#- *a,. Beca/-e ) "#- ."e),e.#ca& c)''#.'e(.- Y)/(!1a- )b!ed .) "3b,#d#-e Ga(d"#- d#-c)/,-e a(d ."e )(&3 1a3 "e c)/&d d)-) 1a- b3 -/!!e-.#(! ."e "3b,#d#-a.#)( ) Ga(d"#- d#-c)/,-e 1#."')de,(#.3 U&.#'a.e&3 ."e e*#-.e')&)!#ca& #'*),. ) Ga(d"#- #(.e,0e(.#)(,e'a#(- /(,e!#-.e,ed

A-#de ,)' M/d#'be- ]^ #(.e,0e(.#)( A,# D#,%- ]^

P+/0c+(+*%a( A1.a T$%. W+.( C.%0%c%/) %* 0$! A#! +" G(+ba( Ca,%0a(%/) 1a-*e,"a*- )(e ) ."e #,-. 1),%- ) *)-.c)&)(#a-' .) add,e-- #(d#!e()/-e*#-.e')&)!3 H)1e0e, D#,%- #(.e,0e(.#)( 1"#c" #(c#de(.a&&3 .,ea.-#(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 a- a ca.e!),3 a**ea,- .) be ()."#(! '),e ."a( a(/a(ced ec") ) Pa,,3- *)-#.#)( I(-.ead ) /&&3 e2*&),#(! ."e -#!(##ca(ce) -/c" e*#-.e')&)!#e- a(d ,ec)!(#-#(! ."e c"a&&e(!e ."e3 *)-e .)*)-.c)&)(#a& -./d#e- D#,% l #'*e&&ed b3 "#- #de)&)!#ca& c)''#.'e(. .)'a.e,#a-' l -/b-/'ed ."e-e e*#-.e')&)!#e- /(de, '/&.#k"#-.),#ca-' Hede#(ed '/&.#k"#-.),#ca-' a- ."e '/&.#*&e a(d a&.e,(a.#0e #(d#!e()/-"#-.),#ca& .,a$ec.),#e- ."a. *,e-e(. d#e,e(. e*#-.e')&)!#e- ] ^ Hede-c,#bed #(d#!e()/- *e)*&e- a- *,)d/c.- ) a ')de,( "#-.),#ca& e2*e,#e(ce1") a,e #(.e,(a&&3 d#e,e(.#a.ed *a,.a%e ) ."e -)c#a& #de)&)!#ca& a(dc/&./,a& d#0e,-#.#e- ) ."e *,e-e(. a(d c)(-e+/e(.&3 ")&d d#0e,-e 0#e1- )."e *,e-e(. ."e *a-. a(d ."e /./,e ]D#,% ^ I(#.#a&&3 #. 'a3 ().

be c&ea, ")1 D#,% -/-.a#(ed ."e d#c").)'#-#(! ,a'e1),% B/. )( c&)-e,e2a'#(a.#)( #. bec)'e- a**a,e(. ."a. 1"#&e "e a&&)1ed #(d#!e()/- *e)*&e-.) "a0e ."e#, )1( "#-.),#ca& .,a$ec.),3 a(d e0e( de#(ed ."e' #( .e,'- ) ."a.

.,a$ec.),3 "e d#d (). acce*. ."e#, e*#-.e')&)!#ca& c)(.,#b/.#)( T"e

.,a(-#.#)( ,)' ."e ,ec)!(#.#)( ) #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 .) '/&.#k"#-.),#ca-' #- ac"#e0ed .",)/!" "#- .,ea.'e(. ) "#-.),3 a- e*#-.e')&)!3

A+: I)* E*=30


33/186

A+: I)* E*=

1"#c" #- ba-ed )( ."e #dea ) ."e c)(.e'*),a(e#.3 ) #(d#!e()/- *e)*&e-]D#,% ^

T,ea.#(! "#-.),3 a- e*#-.e')&)!3 a(d e2*&),#(! #(d#!e()/-e*#-.e')&)!3 )( #.- )1( .e,'- a,e 0e,3 d#e,e(. ,e-ea,c" a**,)ac"e- T"e

a**ca.#)( ) D#,%- '/&.#k"#-.),#ca-' 'ea(- e2*&),#(! c)(.e'*),a,3a,.#c/&a.#)(- ) #(d#!e(#-' #( c)((ec.#)( 1#." *a-. "#-.),#e- ,a."e, ."a( *a-.e*#-.e')&)!#e- I(-.ead ) .,3#(! .) .,ace ."e e*#-.e')&)!#ca& c)(.#(/#.3

be.1ee( *a-. a(d *,e-e(. a,.#c/&a.#)(- ) #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 D#,%e2a'#(ed ."e-e a,.#c/&a.#)(- ,)' ."e 0a(.a!e *)#(. ) -"a,#(! a c)'')("#-.),3 1"#c" #- !)0e,(ed b3 a -#'#&a, "#-.),#ca& de.e,'#(#-' D#,%,ec)!(#-ed ")1e0e, ."a. "#-.),3 "a,d&3 *)--e--e- a /(#0e,-a&e*#-.e')&)!#ca& )/(da.#)( a(d -/,*,#-#(!&3 add,e--ed ."#- #--/e #( a(e(d().e

I ,eae ."a. ."#- "#-.),#c#4a.#)( ) #(d#!e(#-' d)e- 0#)&e(ce .)#(d#!e()/- c)(ce*.#)(- ) .#'e a(d -*ace 1"#c" ,e*/d#a.eE/,)A'e,#ca( ().#)(- ) "#-.),3 _ I(d#!e(#-' #.-e&")1e0e, "a- bee( ,e1),%ed b3 ."e "#-.),#ca& de0e&)*'e(.-d#-c/--ed "e,e -) ."a. ."e,e a,e a&-) *)-.')de,( a(d*)-.c)&)(#a& I(d#a(- ] ^

He,e D#,%- -)&/.#)( 1a- .) #(c),*),a.e #(d#!e()/- bee- ."a. ,e*/d#a.ed"#-.),3 a- e*#-.e')&)!3 #(.) '/&.#k"#-.),#ca-' ] ^ T"#- -.a.e'e(.e--e(.#a&&3 e-.ab-"e- ."e *&a/-#b#.3 ) -/b-/'#(! #(d#!e()/-e*#-.e')&)!3 ."a. ,e*/d#a.e- "#-.),3 /(de, ."e ,/b,#c ) "#-.),#)!,a*"3#,,e-*ec.#0e ) c)(.,ad#c.#)(- #(0)&0ed #( -/c" a( ac.#)( O0e,a&& D#,%-c)''e(.- ab)/. ."e #'*),.a(ce ) #(d#!e(#4a.#)( ) e*#-.e')&)!3 a- a(ece--a,3 #,-. -.e* be),e ac"#e0#(! a !e(/#(e #(.e,kd#-c/,-#0#.3 a,e'e,e&3 a ),' ) 0e,ba& ac+/#e-ce(ce ] ^

A&.")/!" *)-.c)&)(#a& c,#.#c- -ee' .) ,ec)!(#-e ."e #'*),.a(ce )#(c&/d#(! #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!#e- ."e3 *,ed#ca.e ."#- acce*.a(ce )(e*#-.e')&)!#e- c)(),'#(! .) eac" c,#.#c- )1( ."e),e.#ca& c)(ce,(- a(da#a.#)(- T"#- ac. ) *,ed#ca.#)( "a- (ece--#.a.ed ."e ad)*.#)( ) ad#c").)'#-#(! ,a'e1),% ), ."e .,ea.'e(. ) #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3M),e)0e, ."e /-e ) ."#- ,a'e1),% #(d#ca.e- ."e a#&/,e ) *)-.c)&)(#a-'.) ,e&ec. c,#.#ca&&3 )( #.- e*#-.e')&)!#ca& !e(ea&)!3 T"#- a#&/,e "#!"!".- a'a$), &a1 -#(ce a(.#kc)&)(#a& #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!#e- d) #(deed e2#-.a(d '),e #'*),.a(.&3 "a0e bee( ), -e0e,a& decade- d#-c/--ed #( -e,#)/-

-c")&a,&3 1),%-

31


34/186

A+: I)* E*=

F*'% I&d!ge&'-+ E(!+,e%'$'g1 ,' Dec'$'&!+a,!'&

T"e,e #- a -/b.&e b/. -/b-.a(.#a& d#e,e(ce be.1ee( /&& a(d c)(d#.#)(a&acce*.a(ce ) #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 I( "#- .e,a,3 'a-.e,*#ece H+)b.!/

! )a?6 M#!/e& (!e& A-./,#a- *,)0#ded a ,e'a,%ab&3 c)'*&e2 a,.#c/&a.#)() #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 ] _`^ T"e e.")- a(d /(da'e(.a& &)!#c) H+)b.!/ ! )a?6a,e e2*,e--ed #( ."e )&&)1#(! *a--a!e ,)' ."e ()0e&

T"e 'a#4e #'*)0e,#-"e- ."e ea,." a(d 'a%e- () )(e ,#c"Ne#."e, ."e b)-- (), ."e 'e( S)1( .) be ea.e( #. #- ."e -ac,ed-/-.e(a(ce ) ."e 'e( 1") 1e,e 'ade ) 'a#4e S)1( .) 'a%e')(e3 #. 'ea(- a'#(e ), ."e 'e( 1") 1e,e 'ade ) 'a#4e]A-./,#a- _` ^

N)1 ,)' ."e 0a(.a!e *)#(. ) a -.a(da,d *)-.c)&)(#a& #(.e,*,e.a.#)( ."ee2*,e--ed -a(c.#.3 ) ."e &a(d ca( be /(de,-.))d a- be#(! #( (e 1#." a(.#kca*#.a-. e2*&)#.a.#)( a(d #- a 'e.a*"),#ca& e2*,e--#)( de().#(! ."e#'*),.a(ce ) &a(d ), Ma3a( #de(.#.3 H)1e0e, ."e ."#,d -e(.e(ce ) ."#-*a--a!e 1)/&d (e0e, be /(de,-.))d .e,a&&3 a- a 0#.a& e*#-.e')&)!3 ,)'1"#c" a 1")&e 1),&d0#e1 #- c)(-.,/c.ed F,)' ."e 0a(.a!e *)#(. )E(!".e('e(.kba-ed ,ea-)( #. #- "a,d&3 ,a.#)(a& .) acce*. A-./,#a-

*)-#.#(! ."a. 'e( a,e 'ade ) 'a#4e H)1e0e, ,)' ."e 0a(.a!e ) *)#(.) Ma3a( e*#-.e')&)!3 'e( 1") a,e 'ade ) 'a#4e #- a ed 1a3 )%()1#(! S#'#&a, #(d#!e()/- 0)#ce- ab)/(d #( *)-.c)&)(#a& -)c#e.#e-,e0ea(! )."e, 1a3- ) %()1#(! a(d be#(! M),e)0e, ."e-e )."e, 1a3- a,e(). b3 de#(#.#)( be(#!( F), e2a'*&e #(d#!e()/- ,e!#)/- .,ad#.#)(- #(G/a.e'a&a "a0e "e&*ed /-"e, #( a 1a0e ) ,e0e,-e ,ac#-' #( a( e),. .)e2c&/de (a%*+/ ,)' #(d#!e()/- c)''/(#.#e- ]Wa,,e( ^ Re!a,d&e--#(d#!e()/- 1a3- ) %()1#(! (eed .) be ac%()1&ed!ed a- 0adc)(.,#b/.#(! a(d #(deed *)1e,/& e*#-.e')&)!#e- # *)-.c)&)(#a-' #- .)/*")&d #.- e."#ca& */,c"a-e

I(d#!e(#-. -c")&a,- "a0e */. ),1a,d ,e-)(a(. #(.e,0e(.#)(- ."a. ().e."e e*#-.e')&)!#ca& #'*e,#a-' ) ."e We-. F), e2a'*&e Ta#a#a%e A&,ed]^ e2*&),ed ."e ),!#(! ) #(d#!e()/- ),'- ) !)0e,(a(ce ba-ed )(#(d#!e()/- %()1&ed!e a(d a -e&kc)(-c#)/- .,ad#.#)(a-' Pe,"a*- ."e ')-.,e'a,%ab&e e2a'*&e l a(d #(deed ."e ')-. -.,#%#(! )0e,-#!". b3*)-.c)&)(#a-.- l #- ."e 1),% ) L#(da T/"#1a# S'#." ]^ 1") -)/!".()."#(! &e-- ."a( ."e dec)&)(#-a.#)( ) ,e-ea,c" 'e.")d- ba-ed )( a

-ca."#(! c,#.#+/e ) *)-.c)&)(#a& e*#-.e')&)!3 I( "e, -./d3 S'#." d#--ec.ed*)-.c)&)(#a-' a(d ec")ed ."e )b$ec.#)( */. ),." b3 A"'ad ,e!a,d#(!*)-.c)&)(#a-'- a**,)*,#a.#)( ) ."e ."#,d 1),&d I(d#!e()/- acade'#c-

32


35/186

A+: I)* E*=

-"e -a#d -/-*ec. ."a. *)-.kc)&)(#a-' "a- bec)'e a -.,a.e!3 ),,e#(-c,#b#(! ), ,ea/."),#4#(! ."e *,#0#&e!e- ) ()(k#(d#!e()/- acade'#c-

beca/-e *)-.c)&)(#a-' "a- bee( de#(ed #( 1a3- 1"#c" &ea0e )/.#(d#!e()/- *e)*&e- ."e#, 1a3- ) %()1#(! a(d ."e#, c/,,e(. c)(ce,(-

]S'#." ^ I( c)(.,a-. .) A"'ad ")1e0e, S'#." #- #,'&3 *&aced1#."#( a c,#.#ca& *e,-*ec.#0e ."a. ,ec)!(#-e- ."e c)'*c#.3 be.1ee( We-.e,(e*#-.e')&)!3 a(d ."e c)(.#(/#(! c)&)(#-a.#)( ) a&& #e&d- ) ,e-ea,c" E0e(.")/!" -"e -ee'ed .) c)(&a.e ')de,(#.3 a(d ')de,(#-' 1#." ."#-e*#-.e'e -"e #de(.##ed ."e E(!".e('e(. a- ."e *,)!e(#.), ) We-.e,(e*#-.e')&)!3 ]#b#d ^ T) #&&/-.,a.e ")1 ,ad#ca&&3 d#e,e(. #(d#!e()/-1a3- ) %()1#(! ca( be ,)' We-.e,(k ), E(!".e('e(.k!e(e,a.ede*#-.e')&)!3 S'#." *,)0#ded -e0e,a& e2a'*&e- #(c&/d#(! ."e )&&)1#(!T"e Ma),# 1),d ), .#'e ), -*ace #- ."e -a'e ]#b#d ^ F/,."e,'),eS'#." ec")e- A-./,#a- a),e'e(.#)(ed .e,a,3 #(.e,0e(.#)( #( "e,de-c,#*.#)( ) #(d#!e()/- -*ace I(d#!e()/- -*ace "a- bee( c)&)(#4edLa(d ), e2a'*&e 1a- 0#e1ed a- -)'e."#(! .) be .a'ed a(d b,)/!". /(de,c)(.,)& T"e &a(d-ca*e ."e a,,a(!e'e(. ) (a./,e c)/&d be a&.e,ed b3 Ma(_ ` (). -#'*&3 ), *"3-#ca& -/,0#0a& b/. ), e2*&)#.a.#)( a(d ae-."e.#cc)(ce,(- ]#b#d ^ B/. S'#." #- ')-. c)'*e&(! 1"e( -"e e2a'#(e- ."ee*#-.e')&)!#ca& #'*),. ) #(d#!e()/- -*#,#./a.3

T"e a,!/'e(.- ) d#e,e(. #(d#!e()/- *e)*&e- ba-ed )(-*#,#./a& ,e&a.#)(-"#*- .) ."e /(#0e,-e _ ` "a0e bee( d##c/&.a,!/'e(.- ), We-.e,( -3-.e'- ) %()1&ed!e .) dea& 1#." ),acce*. T"e-e a,!/'e(.- !#0e a *a,.#a& #(d#ca.#)( ) ."ed#e,e(. 1),&d 0#e1- a(d a&.e,(a.#0e 1a3- ) c)'#(! .) %()1a(d ) be#(! 1"#c" -.#&& e(d/,e 1#."#( ."e #(d#!e()/- 1),&dC)(ce*.- ) -*#,#./a.3 1"#c" C",#-.#a(#.3 a..e'*.ed .)de-.,)3 ."e( .) a**,)*,#a.e a(d ."e( .) c&a#' a,e c,#.#ca& -#.e-) ,e-#-.a(ce ), #(d#!e()/- *e)*&e- T"e 0a&/e- a..#./de-c)(ce*.- a(d &a(!/a!e e'bedded #( bee- ab)/. -*#,#./a.3,e*,e-e(. #( 'a(3 ca-e- ."e c&ea,e-. c)(.,a-. a(d 'a,% )d#e,e(ce be.1ee( #(d#!e()/- *e)*&e- a(d ."e We-. I. #- )(e) ."e e1 *a,.- ) )/,-e&0e- 1"#c" ."e We-. ca((). dec#*"e,ca((). /(de,-.a(d a(d ca((). c)(.,)& _ ` 3e. ]#b#d ^

S'#."- )1( *)-#.#)( #- c&ea, ,)' "e, de-c,#*.#)( ) ")1 "e,!,a(d')."e, #(-.#&&ed #( "e, -*#,#./a& ,e&a.#)(-"#*- .) ."e &a(d a(d '),e

#'*),.a(.&3 ), S'#." "e&*ed "e, de0e&)* a -e(-e ) +/#.e *"3-#ca&!,)/(ded(e-- ."a. 'ade "e, -ce*.#ca& ), ca/.#)/- ab)/. ."e '3-.#ca&'#-.3ke3ed d#-c)/,-e ."a. #- -)'e.#'e- e'*&)3ed b3 #(d#!e()/- *e)*&e .)

33


36/186

A+: I)* E*=

de-c,#be )/, ,e&a.#)(-"#*- 1#." ."e &a(d a(d ."e /(#0e,-e ]#b#d ^ T"#--e(-e ) !,)/(ded(e-- ) 1"#c" -"e -*ea%- ,ee,- .) ."e 0e,3 'a.e,#a& 1a3#( 1"#c" #(d#!e()/- 1a3- ) %()1#(! 1e,e c,/c#a& ), -/,0#0a& We "ad .)*,ed#c. .) &ea,( a(d ,e&ec. 1e "ad .) *,e-e,0e a(d *,).ec. 1e "ad .)

dee(d a(d a..ac% 1e "ad .) be ')b#&e 1e "ad .) "a0e -)c#a& -3-.e'- 1"#c"e(ab&ed /- .) d) ."e-e ."#(!- ]#b#d ^ He(ce S'#." d)e- (). c)(-c#)/-&3d#c").)'#-e #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 a- d) *)-.c)&)(#a& c,#.#c- b/. ,a."e,c)(-c#)/-&3 /!(!c0/1"a. a-*ec.- ) #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 -"e 1a(.- .)e'*"a-#-e A. ."#- *)#(. #. 'a3 be -a#d ."a. S'#." ')d##e- ."e Fa()(#a(d#c").)'#-ed #(.e&&ec./a& I( "e, d#-c)/,-e #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 #- ."e*,#0#&e!ed &)c/- T"e #(.e&&ec./a& #- a1a,e ) ."e d#c").)'3 a(d '),e)0e,#- -e&kc)(-c#)/-&3 -e&ec.#0e T"#- #- 1"3 S'#."- dec)&)(#-a.#)( d)e- ().'ea( a(d "a- (). 'ea(. a .).a& ,e$ec.#)( ) a&& ."e),3 ), ,e-ea,c" ), We-.e,(%()1&ed!e Ra."e, #. 'ea(- *,#),#.#-#(! ."e #(d#!e()/- 1),&d 0#e1 a(d#.- c)(ce,(- a(d ."e( c)'#(! .) %()1 a(d /(de,-.a(d ."e),3 a(d ,e-ea,c",)' ."a. *e,-*ec.#0e ]#b#d ^

F), -)'e *)-.c)&)(#a& c,#.#c- l %e M/d#'be a(d Q/a3-)( ]^ l%()1#(! ."e-e c)(ce,(- a(d 1),&d 0#e1 ) 1"#c" S'#." -*ea%- ,e+/#,e-a( #(.e,-ec.#)( 1#." a(.",)*)&)!3 I. #- a. ."#- #(.e,-ec.#)( 1#." a(.",)*)&)!3."a. ."e #--/,e- ) *)-.c)&)(#a-' be!#( .) e'e,!e T"#- #- 1"e,eM/d#'be- ce&eb,a.ed e*#-.e')&)!#ca& #(.e,,)!a.#)( ) c)&)(#a& %()1&ed!e

be!a( He #(0e-.#!a.ed ."e e*#-.e')&)!#ca& -"#.- #( a(d ."e *"#&)-)*"#ca&c)(.,#b/.#)( .) 1"a. "e ,ee,,ed .) a- A,#ca( !()-#- l ."a. #- ."e-c#e(.##c a(d #de)&)!#ca& d#-c)/,-e )( A,#ca ]M/d#'be ^H)1e0e, M/d#'be *)#(.ed )/. ."e -"ee, #'*)--#b#.3 ) e-ca*#(! ."e*,))/(d&3 e(.,e(c"ed ,)).- ) ."e We-.e,( e*#-.e'e #( ."#- !()-#- ]#b#d^ I(-.ead ) "a,%#(! bac% .) a *,#-.#(e *a-. "e c)(-.,/c.ed ,)' 1#."#(."a. e*#-.e'e a ."e),e.#ca& ,a'e1),% ."a. e(ab&ed a "#!"&3 -e&kc,#.#ca&a(.",)*)&)!3 B3 c)(.,a-. S'#." e'*"a-#-ed ."e -)#&ed ,e*/.a.#)( ."a.a(.",)*)&)!3 a- a( #(-.,/'e(. ) c)&)(#-a.#)( "a- ac+/#,ed a')(!-.#(d#!e(#-.- T"#- 0#e1 ) a c)(.a'#(a.ed a(.",)*)&)!#ca& !a4e ca( bec)(-#de,ed ."e &a/(c"#(! *ad ), 1"a. #- *e,"a*- ."e ')-. ."),)/!"."e),e.#ca& #(.e,0e(.#)( #( ."e dec)&)(#-a.#)( ) %()1&ed!e #( !e(e,a&M#!()&)- dec)&)(#-a.#)( e2.e(d- a, be3)(d ."a. ) M/d#'be- -e&kc,#.#ca& a(.",)*)&)!3 a(d ec")e- #(d#!e(#-. )b$ec.#)(- .) a(.",)*)&)!3 ().ed

b3 S'#." M#!()&) 'a#(.a#(ed ."a. dec)&)(#-a.#)( #'*e- a dek(%#(!,)' a(.",)*)&)!#ca& a!e(da- _ ` .) a!e(da- ."a. e'e,!e ,)' ."edec)&)(#a& (eed- ) #(d#!e()/- c)''/(#.#e- ] ^

T"#- dek(%#(! #(0)&0e- a ."),)/!"!)#(! c,#.#+/e ) ."ee*#-.e')&)!#ca& )/(da.#)(- ) We-.e,( d#-c)/,-e 1"#c" "#!"!".- ."e#(.e,de*e(de(ce ) c)&)(#a.3 a(d ')de,(#.3 A&.")/!" c,#.#c- %e S'#."

34


37/186

A+: I)* E*= 35

a(d Ba..#-.e "a0e ,e0ea&ed a( a1a,e(e-- ) ."#- c)((ec.#)( ()(e "a0ee2*)-ed #.- de*."- a- d#d M#!()&) 1")-e 1),% -/,*,#-#(!&3 a#&ed .)'e(.#)( S'#."- ca&& ), dec)&)(#-a.#)( M#!()&) )&&)1ed Q/#$a()- ]^&ead a(d ca&&ed ), ."e dec)&)(#-a.#)( ) be#(! a(d %()1&ed!e ."a. e2.e(d-

be3)(d ."e 'e,e .a%e)0e, ) ."e -.a.e b3 ."e &)ca& e.e ] ^M#!()&)- -#!(a& ac"#e0e'e(. 1a- "#- ,ea-a.#)( ."a. dec)&)(#-a.#)( -.a,.-1#." ."e ,ec)!(#.#)( ) ."e )&&)1#(!

T"e,e #- () ')de,(#.3 1#.")/. c)&)(#a.3 c)&)(#a.3 #-c)(-.#./.#0e ) ')de,(#.3 a(d (). de,#0a.#0e T"e,e #- a -#(!&e')de,(#.3jc)&)(#a.3 ."a. #- ."e c)(-e+/e(ce ) ."e !e)*).#ca&d#e,e(.#a& d#-.,#b/.#)( ) e*#-.e'#c *).#ca& ec)()'#c a(dae-."e.#c ]e! -e(-#(! -/b$ec.#0#.3^ *)1e, ]#b#d ^

M),e)0e, ."#- c)'*&e2 #- /(da'e(.a&&3 d#c").)'#-#(! c)&)(#a&d#e,e(ce- e*#-.e'#c a(d )(.)&)!#ca& a,e c)(-.,/c.ed #( ."e ,"e.),#c )')de,(#.3 l #(e,#), be#(!- ]c)&)(#a& )(.)&)!#ca& d#e,e(ce^ ,ac#a&&3 ),-e2/a&&3 a,e be#(!- (). 1e&& -/#.ed ), %()1&ed!e a(d /(de,-.a(d#(!]c)&)(#a& e*#-.e'#c d#e,e(ce^ ]#b#d^ I( add#.#)( ."e -#.e ) c)(.e-.a.#)( #-e*#-.e')&)!3 M#!()&)- ."e-#- *,)0#de- a *,))/(d /(de,-.a(d#(! ) ."ea),e'e(.#)(ed d#c").)'#-#(! d,#0e )b-e,0ed #( *)-.c)&)(#a-'-

e(!a!e'e(. 1#." #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 T"#- #- beca/-e "#- c,#.#+/e,e0ea&- ."a. ."e -)/,ce ) *)-.c)&)(#a-'- d#c").)'#-#(! d,#0e #- #.-de*e(de(ce /*)( a We-.e,( ,a.#)kce(.,#c e*#-.e')&)!3 ."a. d)e- ().,ec)!(#-e ."e #(.e,de*e(de(ce ) c)&)(#a.3 a(d ')de,(#.3 T"#-de*e(de(ce #- 1"a. a- #(d#!e(#-.- -/c" a- S'#." "a0e a&,ead3 #(./#.ed%ee*- *)-.c)&)(#a-' a- a( a**,)*,#a.#0e d#-c)/,-e 1#." ,e!a,d .)#(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3

T'/a*d+ a Dec'$'&!+ed P'+,c'$'&!a$!+%>

I a dec)&)(#-ed *)-.c)&)(#a-' #- ."e !)a& ."e( a c&)-e, &))% a. ."e ,)).ca/-e ) *)-.c)&)(#a-'- ,ec)/,-e .) ."e d#c").)'#-#(! ,a'e1),% #-,e+/#,ed W#.")/. a( a1a,e(e-- ) ."e c)&)(#a.3j')de,(#.3 c)'*&e2*)-.c)&)(#a& c,#.#c- "a0e () c")#ce b/. .) d#c").)'#-e T"#- #- 1"3 Dee*#%aBa",# #- c)'*e&&ed .) a(()/(ce #( ad0a(ce ."e /&.#'a.e a#&/,e ) a(3 e),..) /(de,-.a(d 1a3- ) %()1#(! ."a. "a0e a&&)1ed -/-.a#(ab#.3 a(d-/,0#0a& a')(! *)-.c)&)(#a& c)''/(#.#e- beca/-e ."e3 1)/&d ,e+/#,e

ded#ca.ed e(!a!e'e(. 1#." a c)(.e2. /(a0a#&ab&e .) ')-. 'e.,)*).a(a/d#e(ce- ] ^ He, c)''e(. -/!!e-.- a( #'*c#. a(d *e,"a*--/bc)(-c#)/- ,ec)!(#.#)( ) ."e #'*)--#b#.3 ) .,a(-!,e--#(! ."e


38/186

A+: I)* E*=

d#c").)'#-#(! ,a'e1),% T"e ac. ."a. Ba",# 1a- c)(.e(. 1#." 'e,e&3*)#(.#(! )/. ."#- *"e()'e()( l #(-.ead ) e2a'#(#(! #.- /&& #'*ca.#)(-), *)-.c)&)(#a-' l #- -3'*.)'a.#c ) a *,))/(d a(2#e.3 ."a. !)0e,(-*)-.c)&)(#a-'- e(c)/(.e, 1#." #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!#e- T"e a(2#e.3

"a- a !,ea. dea& .) d) 1#." L?*e4- )b$ec.#)( .) ."e (a#0e -ea,c" ), a'3."#ca& -#(!/&a, a/."e(.#c 0)#ce ), ."e #(d#!e(e a- # C)&/'b/--c,/(c" /*)( ."e -a(d "ad (e0e, "a**e(ed ] ^ Beca/-e ."e3a,e /(ab&e .) ad)*. a ,ad#ca&&3 c,#.#ca& -.a(d*)#(. .)1a,d- ."e#, )1(e*#-.e')&)!#ca& ,)).- *)-.c)&)(#a& c,#.#c- "a0e () c")#ce b/. .) #'a!#(e ."e/(a--#'#&ab&e )."e, ,)' 1#."#( a d#c").)'#-ed 1),&d0#e1 T"e3 ca(().), e2a'*&e /(de,-.a(d ."a. a ,ec)/,-e .) #(d#!e()/- e*#-.e')&)!3 (eed(). */,-/e a( e#."e,j), -ce(a,#) l ."a. #- !%0$!. a (a.#0e a/."e(.#c/(.a,(#-"ed 0)#ce +.a( a&,ead3 "3b,#d c)&)(#a&&3 c)(.a'#(a.ed -/b$ec.

S'#." be-. de-c,#bed ."e ac./a& -.a(ce ) 'a(3 #(d#!e(#-.- b3 *)#(.#(! )/.")1 -)&/.#)(- a,e *)-ed ,)' a c)'b#(a.#)( ) ."e .#'e be),e c)&)(#4ed.#'e a(d ."e .#'e be),e ."a. *,ekc)&)(#4ed .#'e Dec)&

Documents

Studies in Social and Political Thought, Volume 19