21
1 STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN GHANA THE MINISTRY OF EDUCATION’S GOAL The provision of relevant education to all Ghanaians, at all levels to enable them acquire skills, that will assist them to develop their potential, to be productive, to facilitate poverty reduction and to promote socio-economic growth and national development.

STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

1

STRUCTURE OF DECISION

MAKING

AND

MECHANISMS OF FINANCING

EDUCATION

IN GHANA

THE MINISTRY OF EDUCATION’S

GOAL

The provision of relevant education to all

Ghanaians, at all levels to enable them acquire

skills, that will assist them to develop their

potential, to be productive, to facilitate poverty

reduction and to promote socio-economic growth

and national development.

Page 2: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

2

GOALS FOR THE EDUCATION

SECTOR

The Ministry of Education will provide the ff:

Facilities to ensure that all citizens, irrespective of age, gender and tribe, religion and political affiliation, are functionally literate and self-reliant

Basic education for all

Opportunities for open education for all

Education and training for skill development with emphasis on science, technology and creativity

Higher education for the development of middle and top-level manpower requirements.

VALUES

In providing these services, we will be guided

by the following values:

Quality Education

Efficient management of resources

Accountability and transparency

Equity

Page 3: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

3

POLICY GOALS

1. Equitable Access to

EducationIncrease access to and

participation in education

and training

Promote and extend pre-

school education

provide girls with equal

opportunities to access the

full cycle of education

POLICY GOALS

2. Quality of

Education

Improve quality of teaching and learning

for enhanced pupil/ student achievement

Promote good health and environmental

sanitation in schools and institutions of

higher learning

Improve the quality of academic and

research programmes

Identify and promote education

programmes that will assist in the

prevention and management of

HIV/AIDS.

Page 4: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

4

POLICY GOALS

3. Educational

Management

4. Science,

Technology

and TVET

Strengthen and improve

educational planning and

management

Extend and improve technical

and vocational education and

training

Promote and extend the

provision of science and

technology education and

training

FUNDING POLICY

Funding of education has been done principally by government since independent.Re-enforced by provisions in the 1992 constitution

Page 5: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

5

FUNDING POLICY

“Constitutional Provision”

Basic education shall be free, compulsory and available to allSecondary education in its different forms, including technical and vocational education, should be made generally available and accessible to all by every appropriate means, and in particular, by the progressive introduction of free education

FUNDING POLICY

“Constitutional Provision”

Higher education shall be made equally accessible to all on the basis of capacity by every appropriate means, and in particular, by the progressive introduction of free education.

Page 6: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

6

FACTORS INFLUENCING THE

FUNDING OF EDUCATION

The Education Reform Program of 1987

The fCUBE Program

The Growth and Poverty Reduction Strategy

The Education Reform Program of 2002 – White Paper

THE EDUCATION REFORM

PROGRAMME (1987)

Main objectives:

To expand and make access more equitable at

all levels of education

To change the structure of the pre-tertiary

education system (from 6-4-7 to 6-3-3)

To improve pedagogic efficiency and

effectiveness

Page 7: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

7

THE EDUCATION REFORM

PROGRAMME (1987) (contd.)

To make education more relevant by

increasing the attention paid to problem

solving, environmental concerns, pre-

vocational training, manual dexterity and

general skills training

To contain and partially recover educational

costs and to enhance sector management and

budgeting procedures

THE FCUBE PROGRAMME

Objectives were to improve by 2005,

The quality of teaching and learning

Access to and participation in basic education

Community participation in the delivery of

education

Resource management and allocation

Page 8: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

8

Tuition - free

Textbooks - free

Stationery -parents/guardians

Equipment/Tools - free

Meals/

Transportation - parents/guardian

(more resources to be moved to basic education)

THE FCUBE PROGRAMME

THE GPRS II – Update 2005

The programmes include activities geared towards:Increasing access to and participation in education and trainingBridging gender gap in access to education Improving quality and efficiency in delivery of education servicePromote and extend the provision of science, maths, tech and ICT education and training

Page 9: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

9

GOVT WHITE PAPER ON REFORMS

A portfolio of reforms to be implemented from 2007

Key objectives:Ensure that all children are given the foundation of high quality free education

Second cycle education is more inclusive and demand driven and market responsive to meet the needs of the Ghanaian economy

GOVT WHITE PAPER ON REFORMS

Key issues:

Basic education to be expanded to include 2yrs KG, 6 yrs primary, 3 yrs JHS. Entire basic education to be free.

Second Cycle to last for 4yrs and serve as terminal point of entry to the world of work.

Page 10: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

10

GOVT WHITE PAPER ON REFORMS

Second cycle to comprise of apprenticeship programme, including work-based and academic training

SHS will consist of general, vocational, technical and agricultural education

GOVT WHITE PAPER ON REFORMS

Some of the proposed activities to include:

Expansion of pre-school access to all basic schools

Capitation grant to all public basic schools

Basic level students to benefit from school feeding

Targeted programmes to improve access in underserved areas

Page 11: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

11

GOVT WHITE PAPER ON REFORMS

Access courses in training colleges

Textbook and ICT development policies

Widespread computer education, especially at training colleges

Expansion of research and library facilities in tertiary institutions

Strengthening linkages between the universities and industry

FUNDING SOURCES

Central GovernmentDiscretionary Budget

GETFund

HIPC

Social Impact Mitigation Levy

Development Partners

Internally Generated Funds

District Assemblies Common Fund

Other sources – PTA, Old Students, churches, others

Page 12: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

12

CENTRAL GOVERNMENT

FUNDS

Annual Budget Support to cover:

Personal Emolument

Admin Expenses

Service Activity Expenses

Investment Activity Expenses

GET Fund support, mainly in the area of

Investment Activity Expenses

CENTRAL GOVERNMENT

FUNDS

HIPC Fund support mainly in the area of

Service and Investment Activity

Expenses

Social Impact Mitigation Levy has been

used mainly to support the payment of

capitation Grant

Page 13: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

13

DEVELOPMENT PARTNER FUNDS

Supplementary to that of Government. Major donors are:

IDA

DFID

EC

AfDB

JICA

USAID

INTERNALLY GENERATED FUNDS

Increasingly becoming a major source o funding especially at the Tertiary level

Page 14: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

14

OTHER SOURCES

DACF

Scholarships and Educational Foundations

BUDGET CATEGORIES

140 - MOES

141 - GES HQ

142 - REGIONAL AND DISTRICT SERVICES

143 - SCHOOLS OF THE HANDICAPPED

145 - TERTIARY

Page 15: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

15

BUDGET ALLOCATIONS

Allocations based on:

the priority areas

Commitments

Agreements with Development partners, etc

EXPENDITURE DISTRIBUTION

SYSTEMS

Education is financed and managed through these managerial offices:

The MOES primarily oversees budget allocation and education policies.

The GES as an agency with coverage at regional and district level, implements the budget and the policies.

NCTE with coverage of the Universities, Polytechnics, etc

Page 16: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

16

EXPENDITURE DISTRIBUTION

SYSTEMS

Main channels for distribution of expenditures.

CAGD receives budgets from the MOFEP and distributes payments through the banks directly to teachers and other staff for the payment of personal emoluments (salaries)

GES District offices which receives its budget from headquarters and utilises it through the schools

EXPENDITURE DISTRIBUTION

SYSTEMS

MOES/GES HQ which receives the allocations to procure textbooks and other TLMs ad these are distributed through the District offices to the schools.

MOES/GES/GETFund which pays directly for investment expenditures

Page 17: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

17

LEGAL FRAMEWORK

Using the three financial management laws

Financial administration Act

Public Procurement act

Internal Audit Agency Act

DECENTRALIZATION OF

RESOURCES

Fiscal decentralization pursued through:

Budget Preparation/Implementation

Introduction of Readiness Criteria

Introduction of Capitation Grant

Page 18: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

18

DECENTRALIZATION OF

RESOURCES

Budget Preparation/Implementation

Use of enrolment, number of schools and level of

deprivation

The MTEF process entails the consolidation

of activities which has been selected by the

cost centres for budget preparation.

Releases are subsequently made to the same

cost centres for implementation of activities

DECENTRALIZATION OF

RESOURCES

Readiness Check

Three sets of districts

Ready

Partially Ready

Non-Ready

Page 19: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

19

CAPITATION GRANT

The allocation of resources direct to schools

Page 20: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

Ed

ucati

on

dis

cre

tio

nary

bu

dg

et

as a

% o

f to

tal d

iscre

tio

nary

bu

dg

et

(¢m

illio

n)

YE

AR

1999

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

2005

GD

P2

0,5

80

,00

0

2

7,1

52

,00

0

3

8,0

14

,00

0

4

7,7

64

,00

0

6

5,2

62

,00

0

77

,62

0,0

00

97

,61

9,0

00

Na

tio

na

l D

iscre

tio

na

ry

Bu

dg

et

3,8

38

,82

0

5,3

18

,79

8

6,3

29

,45

6

7,4

55

,80

1

10

,44

2,1

00

1

3,0

05

,37

9

1

8,5

28

,00

0

To

tal E

du

ca

tio

n

Dis

cre

tio

na

ry B

ud

ge

t7

68

,89

0

1

,03

2,9

44

1

,42

0,2

15

1

,80

0,0

28

2

,77

5,8

86

3,4

66

,00

8

4,2

95

,27

8

Actu

al E

du

ca

tio

n

Exp

en

ditu

re1

,02

0,8

77

1

,19

8,7

89

1

,82

1,9

79

2

,65

2,3

06

3

,62

5,7

60

4,3

38

,54

4

-

To

tal E

du

ca

tio

n

Dis

cre

tio

na

ry B

ud

ge

t a

s %

of

GD

P3

.7%

3.8

%3

.7%

3.8

%4

.3%

4.5

%4

.4%

% o

f n

atio

na

l d

iscre

tio

na

ry

bu

dg

et

sp

en

t o

n e

du

ca

tio

n2

0.0

%1

9.4

%2

2.4

%2

4.1

%2

6.6

%2

6.7

%2

3.2

%

Actu

al E

du

ca

tio

n

Exp

en

ditu

re a

s %

of

GD

P4

.96

%4

.42

%4

.79

%5

.55

%5

.56

%5

.59

%-

Actu

al E

du

ca

tio

n

Exp

en

ditu

re a

s %

of

To

tal

Dis

cre

tio

na

ry B

ud

ge

t2

7%

23

%2

9%

36

%3

5%

33

%-

So

urc

e:

Bu

dg

et

Sta

tem

en

t &

Eco

no

mic

Po

licy o

f th

e G

ove

rnm

en

t o

f G

ha

na

19

99

- 2

00

5

Page 21: STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING EDUCATION …siteresources.worldbank.org/.../5DecisionmakingfinancingGhana.pdf · STRUCTURE OF DECISION MAKING AND MECHANISMS OF FINANCING EDUCATION IN

SUB-SECTOR

Tota

l%

allo

cation

Tota

l%

allo

cation

Tota

l%

allo

cation

Tota

l%

allo

cation

PR

E-S

CH

OO

L98,1

18

2.0

234,7

20

4.1

252,3

87

3.4

369,7

41

4.2

PR

IMA

RY

1,6

45,9

95

33.8

1,8

33,9

30

31.7

2,1

64,8

73

29.5

2,7

51,3

16

31.3

JS

S912,7

18

18.7

929,1

97

16.0

1,2

98,7

08

17.7

1,3

03,6

15

14.8

SS

S638,2

50

13.1

1,1

51,9

54

19.9

1,5

16,4

45

20.6

1,8

03,7

20

20.5

NF

ED

46,0

51

0.9

65,5

32

1.1

29,4

54

0.4

63,5

35

0.7

SP

ED

37,9

39

0.8

92,8

98

1.6

146,3

59

2.0

108,5

28

1.2

TE

AC

HE

R E

DU

CA

TIO

N166,8

82

3.4

215,0

20

3.7

85,9

64

1.2

100,1

30

1.1

TV

ET

14,9

91

0.3

21,7

45

0.4

290,7

22

4.0

349,8

63

4.0

TE

RT

IAR

Y1,3

09,4

38

26.9

1,2

19,5

37

21.0

1,4

86,2

15

20.2

1,8

23,1

50

20.8

Oth

er

(Managem

ent, S

ubvente

d A

gencie

s)

5,6

55

0.1

29,5

07

0.5

72,9

17

1.0

109,7

71

1.2

TOTAL

4,8

76,0

37

100.0

5,7

94,0

40

100.0

7,3

44,0

44

100.0

8,7

83,3

69

100.0

MIN

IST

RY

OF

ED

UC

AT

ION

AN

D S

PO

RT

SE

XP

EN

DIT

UR

ES

AN

D A

LL

OC

AT

ION

S

AC

TU

AL

EX

PE

ND

ITU

RE

S

2003

2004

2005(j

an

-sep

t)2006

BU

DG

ET