SRINIV - McNally Sayajimcnallysayaji.com/manage/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/UFR-30.09.2020.pdfSRINIV ASH SINGH Digitally signed by SRINIVASH SINGH DN: c=IN, o=Personal, 2.5.4.20=6bcf47bd9bb1da2e33

SRINIVASH SINGH

Digitally signed by SRINIVASH SINGH DN: c=IN, o=Personal, 2.5.4.20=6bcf47bd9bb1da2e33b33657f3597eca4e0ecd5addd96f06c3371f118c567ff7, postalCode=700094, st=WEST BENGAL, serialNumber=32f3c0af0ec6e7a9aac9298e0bb92ee8496ff208bb8ab3a9380b5459234d4219, cn=SRINIVASH SINGH Date: 2020.11.10 15:33:10 +05'30'

ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA

Digitally signed by ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA Date: 2020.11.10 16:19:14 +05'30'

saikat.S1498

Typewritten Text

saikat.S1498

Typewritten Text

saikat.S1498

Typewritten Text

SRINIVASH SINGH


ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA


SRINIVASH SINGH


ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA


SRINIVASH SINGH


ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA


SRINIVASH SINGH


ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA


V. SINGHI & ASSOCIATES Phone: 2210 1124Chartered Accountants 2210 1125

E-mail: [email protected] Mangoe Lane

Surendra Mohan Ghosh SaraniKolkata – 700 001

Independent Auditor’s Review Report on the Standalone Unaudited FinancialResults for the quarter and half year ended 30th September, 2020

Review Report toThe Board of DirectorsMcNally Sayaji Engineering LimitedCampus 2B, Ecospace Business Park11F/12 Rajarhat, New TownKolkata – 700156

1. We have reviewed the accompanying Statement of Standalone Unaudited FinancialResults of MCNALLY SAYAJI ENGINEERING LIMITED (“the Company”) for thequarter and half year ended 30th September, 2020 (“the Statement”).

2. This Statement, which is the responsibility of the Company's Management andapproved by the Board of Directors, in accordance with the recognition andmeasurement principles laid down in Indian Accounting Standard 34 (“Ind AS 34”)“Interim Financial Reporting” prescribed under Section 133 of the Companies Act,2013, as amended, read with relevant rules issued thereunder and other accountingprinciples generally accepted in India. Our responsibility is to express a conclusion onthe Statement based on our review.

3. We conducted our review of the Statement in accordance with the Standard onReview Engagements (SRE) 2410 “Review of Interim Financial InformationPerformed by the Independent Auditor of the Entity”, issued by the Institute ofChartered Accountants of India. This Standard requires that we plan and perform thereview to obtain moderate assurance as to whether the Statement is free of materialmisstatement. A review is limited primarily to inquiries of the Company personneland analytical procedures applied to financial data and thus provides less assurancethan an audit. We have not performed an audit and accordingly, we do not expressan audit opinion.

4. Basis for Adverse Conclusion

The Company has not recognised interest expense on bank borrowings andInter-Corporate borrowings amounting to Rs. 1,575 Lakhs and Rs. 318 Lakhsrespectively for the half year ended 30th September, 2020 (including Rs.785 lakhsand Rs.162 lakhs interest expense on Bank borrowings and Inter-Corporateborrowings respectively for the quarter ended 30th September, 2020). Amount ofinterest expense not recognised on bank borrowings and inter-corporate borrowingsduring the year ended 31st March, 2020 was Rs. 2,678 Lakhs and Rs. 631 Lakhsrespectively. As a result, finance costs, liability on account of interest and totalcomprehensive loss are understated to that extent.

This constitutes a material departure from the requirements of Indian AccountingStandard 109 “Financial Instruments”.

ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA


5. Based on our review conducted as stated in Paragraph 3 above, and for reasonsstated in Paragraph 4 above, the Statement of Standalone Unaudited FinancialResults has not been prepared in accordance with the applicable Indian AccountingStandards and other recognised accounting practices and policies and has notdisclosed the information required to be disclosed in terms of Regulation 33 of theSEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015, asamended including the manner in which it is to be disclosed, or that it contains anymaterial misstatement.

6. Emphasis of Matters

a) Material uncertainty related to Going Concern

We draw attention to Note 6 to the Statement that the Company is unable to meetits financial commitments/covenants to lenders and various other stakeholders. TheCompany’s management is currently in discussion with the investor and lenders forcarrying out a debt restructuring proposal as informed to us by the Management.Such events and conditions indicate a material uncertainty which may cast asignificant doubt on the Company’s ability to continue as a going concern and thesame is solely dependent on the acceptance of the debt restructuring proposal.Based on the Board of Directors’ assessment of the successful outcome of therestructuring proposal, this Statement has been prepared on going concern basis.

b) Management’s assessment of impact of COVID-19

We draw attention to Note 4 to the Statement which describes the management’sassessment of impact of COVID-19, a global pandemic, on the financial position ofthe Company.

c) Recognition of Deferred Tax Assets

We draw attention to Note 7 to the Statement that the Company had recogniseddeferred tax assets of Rs. 5,397 Lakhs upto 31st March, 2019 expecting adequatefuture taxable profits to the Company against which the deferred tax assets canbe realised, which is solely dependent on the acceptance of the debtrestructuring proposal. However, the Company has not recognised further deferredtax assets thereafter on prudent basis.

ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA


d) Corporate Guarantee issued by the Company

We draw attention to Note 8 to the Statement regarding Corporate Guarantee issuedby the Company in favour of the lenders of the Holding Company, McNally BharatEngineering Company Limited to the extent of value of fixed assets at KumardubiUnit-1 having a book value of Rs. 471 Lakhs as on 30th September, 2020. The AuditReport of its Holding Company for the year ended 31st March, 2020 had expressedmaterial uncertainty related to Going Concern which is undergoing a debtrestructuring proposal, provision against the said guarantee in the Statement has notbeen considered necessary by the management during the half year ended30th September, 2020.

Our conclusion on the Statement is not modified in respect of these matters.

For V. SINGHI & ASSOCIATESChartered Accountants

Firm Registration No.: 311017E

(ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA)Place: Kolkata PartnerDate: 10th November, 2020 Membership No. 051371

UDIN: 20051371AAAACQ7178

ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA


SRINIVASH SINGH


ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA


SRINIVASH SINGH


ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA


SRINIVASH SINGH


ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA


SRINIVASH SINGH


ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA


SRINIVASH SINGH


ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA


V. SINGHI & ASSOCIATES Phone: 2210 1124Chartered Accountants 2210 1125

E-mail: [email protected] Mangoe Lane

Surendra Mohan Ghosh SaraniKolkata – 700 001

Independent Auditor’s Review Report on the Consolidated Unaudited FinancialResults for the quarter and half year ended 30th September, 2020

Review Report toThe Board of DirectorsMcNally Sayaji Engineering LimitedCampus 2B, Ecospace Business Park11F/12 Rajarhat, New TownKolkata – 700156

1. We have reviewed the accompanying Statement of Consolidated Unaudited FinancialResults of MCNALLY SAYAJI ENGINEERING LIMITED (“the Holding Company”)and its subsidiary (the Holding Company and its subsidiary together referred to as“the Group”), for the quarter and half year ended 30th September, 2020 (“theStatement”).

2. This Statement, which is the responsibility of the Holding Company's Management andapproved by the Holding Company’s Board of Directors, in accordance with therecognition and measurement principles laid down in Indian Accounting Standard 34(“Ind AS 34”) “Interim Financial Reporting” prescribed under Section 133 of theCompanies Act, 2013, as amended, read with relevant rules issued thereunder andother accounting principles generally accepted in India. Our responsibility is to expressa conclusion on the Statement based on our review.

3. We conducted our review of the Statement in accordance with the Standard onReview Engagements (SRE) 2410 “Review of Interim Financial InformationPerformed by the Independent Auditor of the Entity”, issued by the Institute ofChartered Accountants of India. This Standard requires that we plan and perform thereview to obtain moderate assurance as to whether the Statement is free of materialmisstatement. A review of interim financial information consists of making inquiries,primarily of persons responsible for financial and accounting matters, and applyinganalytical and other review procedures. A review is substantially less in scope thanan audit conducted in accordance with Standards on Auditing and consequently doesnot enable us to obtain assurance that we would become aware of all significantmatters that might be identified in an audit. Accordingly, we do not express an auditopinion.

We also performed procedures in accordance with the circular issued by the SEBIunder Regulation 33(8) of the SEBI (Listing Obligations and DisclosureRequirements) Regulations, 2015, as amended, to the extent applicable.

ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA


4. Basis for Adverse Conclusion

The Holding Company has not recognised interest expense on bank borrowings andon Inter-Corporate borrowings amounting to Rs. Rs. 1,575 Lakhs and Rs. 318 Lakhsfor the half year ended 30th September, 2020 (including Rs.785 lakhs andRs. 162 lakhs interest expense on Bank borrowings and Inter-Corporate borrowingsrespectively for the quarter ended 30th September, 2020). Amount of interestexpense not recognised on bank borrowings and inter-corporate borrowings duringthe year ended 31st March, 2020 was Rs. 2,678 Lakhs and Rs. 631 Lakhsrespectively as referred in Note 5 to the Statement. As a result, finance costs,liability on account of interest and total comprehensive loss are understated to thatextent.

This constitutes a material departure from the requirements of Indian AccountingStandard 109 “Financial Instruments”.

5. Based on our review conducted as stated in Paragraph 3 above, and for reasonsstated in Paragraph 4 above, the Statement of Unaudited Consolidated FinancialResults has not been prepared in accordance with the applicable Indian AccountingStandards and other recognised accounting practices and policies and has notdisclosed the information required to be disclosed in terms of Regulation 33 of theSEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015, asamended including the manner in which it is to be disclosed, or that it contains anymaterial misstatement.

ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA


6. Emphasis of Matters

a) Material uncertainty related to Going Concern

We draw attention to Note 6 to the Statement that the Holding Company is unable tomeet its financial commitments/covenants to lenders and various other stakeholders.The Holding Company’s management is currently in discussion with the lenders forcarrying out a debt restructuring proposal as informed to us by the Management.Such events and conditions indicate a material uncertainty which may cast asignificant doubt on the Holding Company’s ability to continue as a going concernand the same is solely dependent on the acceptance of the debt restructuringproposal of the Holding Company. Based on the Board of Directors’ assessment ofthe successful outcome of the restructuring proposal, this Statement has beenprepared on going concern basis.

b) Management’s assessment of impact of COVID-19

We draw attention to Note 4 to the Statement which describes the management’sassessment of impact of COVID-19, a global pandemic, on the financial position ofthe Group.

c) Recognition of Deferred Tax Assets

We draw attention to Note 7 to the Statement that the Group had recogniseddeferred tax assets of Rs. 6,234 Lakhs upto 31st March, 2019 expecting adequatefuture taxable profits to the Group against which the deferred tax assets can berealised, which is solely dependent on the acceptance of the debt restructuringproposal. However, the Group has not recognised further deferred tax assetsthereafter on prudent basis.

d) Corporate Guarantee issued by the Holding Company

We draw attention to Note 8 to the Statement regarding Corporate Guarantee issuedby the Holding Company in favour of the lenders of its Holding Company, McNallyBharat Engineering Company Limited to the extent of value of fixed assets atKumardubi Unit-1 having a book value of Rs. 471 Lakhs as on 30th September, 2020.The Audit Report of its Holding Company for the year ended 31st March, 2020 hadexpressed material uncertainty related to Going Concern which is undergoing a debtrestructuring proposal, provision against the said guarantee in the Statement has notbeen considered necessary by the management during the half year ended30th September, 2020.

Our conclusion on the Statement is not modified in respect of these matters.

ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA


7. Other Matter

The Statement includes the results of MBE Coal & Mineral Technology India PrivateLimited, a wholly owned subsidiary of the Holding Company.

We did not review the financial information of one subsidiary included in theStatement whose financial information, reflect total assets of Rs. 6,363 Lakhs, totalrevenue of Rs. 936 Lakhs and total comprehensive loss of Rs. 168 Lakhs asconsidered in the statement for the half year ended 30th September, 2020. TheseFinancial results/information are certified by the management.

Our conclusion on the Statement is not modified in respect of the above matter.

For V. SINGHI & ASSOCIATESChartered Accountants

Firm Registration No.: 311017E

(ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA)Place: Kolkata PartnerDate: 10th November, 2020 Membership No. 051371

UDIN: 20051371AAAACQ7178

ANIRUDDHA SENGUPTA


Documents

SRINIV - McNally Sayajimcnallysayaji.com/manage/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/UFR-30.09.2020.pdfSRINIV ASH SINGH Digitally signed by SRINIVASH SINGH DN: c=IN, o=Personal, 2.5.4.20=6bcf47bd9bb1da2e33