Upload
robert-goode
View
214
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
1/124
SPIRIT SERVANT:
NARRATIVES OF SHIKIGAMI ANDONMYŌDŌ
DEVELOPMENTS
PANG CAROLYN ( B.A. ( Hons.) , NUS )
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
2/124
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Acknowledgements are more than a list of names; it is recognition of those
who have been crucial in making this thesis possible and gratitude to all the important
people in my life who have always inspired and supported me during my research.
Mentors are a crucial beacon to guide me when I felt lost during times of
confusion. I would like to express my deepest gratitude to my supervisor, Dr Scot
Hislop for his insightful advice, infinite patience and constant concern for my well-
being. Despite the inevitable stress and frustrations, my studies have always been a
journey of great enjoyment because of his continual support. I am immensely
indebted to Dr Lim Beng Choo for her constant emotional support and much-needed
guidance. I always find strength in her gentle and motherly concern to strive on. I
want to thank Professor Komine Kazuaki and Professor Masuo Shinichir ō who
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
3/124
Friends are my treasured travel companions on this crazy adventure that we
call life. Let us continue to have fun together on this unpredictable life journey. To
Karen Feng, for making my life in Tokyo wonderful and memorable. To Yuen
Shumin, for being a wonderful buddy in study, tutorship, travel, fashion... in summary,
everything! To Kam Thiam Huat, for devotedly connecting all the JS batches. You are
the unsung hero of the department. To my long-time close friends, Kah Yen, Su Lynn,
Jau Chern and Chien Tee, for more than a decade of precious friendship and caring
support. To Letitia, Clarence, Serene, Esther, Karl and Susan for all their valuable
support, advices and companionship. To all JS students, for making my life in NUS
full of fond and cherished memories.
I owe much thanks to the Japanese Studies administration staff for making my
school life so much more enjoyable. To Ms Lee Bee Ling, for her good-natured
accommodation of my random moments and appreciation of my wacky antics. To Ms
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
4/124
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Acknowledgments ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ i
Table of Contents ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- iii
Summary ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- v
List of Figures -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- vii
Glossary --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- viii
Chapter 1 Introduction ------------------------------------------------------------------ 1
1.1 The Early Developments of Onmyōdō ----------------------------------------- 3
1.2 Methodological and Theoretical Issues ---------------------------------------- 5
1.3 Looking at the Spirit Servant through the Chapters ------------------------- 10
1.4 A Note about Semantics and Terminology ----------------------------------- 12
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
5/124
3.3 A Category of Magic Skill: Shin-sarugakuki -------------------------------- 41
Chapter 4 Developments in Shikigami Narratives:
From Augury to Assassin ------------------------------------------------ 49
4.1 Analytical Spy and Physical Materiality: Ōkagami ------------------------ 51
4.2 Corporeality, Lethal Weapon and Knowledge-based Exclusivity: Konjaku
monogatari- shū ----------------------------------------------------------------- 54
4.3 Deadly Curse and Retaliation Spells: Uji-shui monogatari --------------- 61
Chapter 5 Shift in Shikigami Narratives:
From Spirit Servant to Unbridled Supernatural Signs ------------ 70
5.1 Loss of Control and Indiscriminate Harm: Zokukojidan ------------------- 71
5.2 Bridge Augury and Twelve Guardian Deities: Genpeijōsuiki ------------- 77
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
6/124
SUMMARY
Despite its significant influence on the early history and religious practices of
Japan, Onmyōdō is a much-neglected strain of study in the Japanese fields of religious
and historical research due to its Sino-centric origins and position as an occult
practice. In this thesis, my interest lies in highlighting the role of Onmyōdō in early
Japanese history through a literary analysis of one of its emblems, the shikigami,
while at the same time, emphasizing the complex relationship between religion,
literature and history. Onmyōdō (陰陽道) which is literally translated as Way of Yin
and Yang or Japanese Yin Yang Theory, is a religious practice based on Chinese
Taoism employing Yin Yang theory and Theory of the Five Elements, and was
particularly influential during the Heian period. In view of the syncretic nature of
t J li i hiki i h th t di iti f b i il
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
7/124
between religion, literature and history. The subsequent adoption of later literary
descriptions of shikigami by the contemporary religious institutions of Onmyōdō such
as Seimei Shrine in Kyoto and Abe no Seimei Shrine in Osaka reveals mutual
influences between literature and religion and suggests the importance of literature in
shaping the way religious institutions construct their religious identity and practices.
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
8/124
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1 Shikigami statue ----------------------------------------------------------------- 90
Figure 2 Small-scale model of Ichijō-modori Bridge -------------------------------- 90
Figure 3 Hand-phone strap on sale at Seimei Shrine -------------------------------- 90
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
9/124
GLOSSARY
The translations and explanations given here are mine.
kijin 鬼神 Demon gods or invisible spiritual beings with super-
human powers. (It is also read as kishin or onigami.)
Onmyōdō 陰陽道 Way of Yin and Yang, Japanese Yin Yang Theory. (It
is also read as Inyōdō or Onyōdō.)
onmyōji 陰陽師 Master or diviner of Yin and Yang, yin-yang master. (It
is also read as onyōji.)
Onmyō-ryō 陰陽寮 Onyō Bureau, Bureau of Yin and Yang.
onyō 陰陽 Theory of Yin and Yang. (It is also read as inyō.)
shikigami 式神,
識神
Frequently identified as a spirit servant to onmyōji. (It
i l d hikiji ) Th h diff Chi
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
10/124
_________________
CHAPTER ONE
_________________
INTRODUCTION
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
11/124
CHAPTER 1. Introduction
The image of Onmyōdō (陰陽道, Way of Yin and Yang) as a superstitious
occult practice with Sino-centric origins has led to the tendency to occlude Onmyōdō
from mainstream scholarship and overlook its deep ties with Japanese historical
developments and its role in early Japanese social, cultural and religious history.
Through a study of literary descriptions of one of its emblems, shikigami, I seek to
highlight the significance of Onmyōdō in Japanese religiosity and early history and
emphasize the complex relationship between religion, literature and history.
Onmyōdō is a religious practice with a philosophical system based on Chinese yin-
yang thought and Theory of the Five Elements (五行説 , gogyō setsu) that had
developed independently in Japan. This system of beliefs requires a strict observance
f i i d b d l d h f d l
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
12/124
CHAPTER 1. Introduction ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
study of the relationship between literature and history to rework the traditional
scholarly perception of literary narratives as an insignificant and unreliable source of
social and cultural study.
1.1 The Early Developments of Onmyōdō
With the introduction of Chinese yin-yang thought and importation of
specialists of divination and calendar from Paekche 1 and books on Taoist arts of
invisibility and magic from the sixth century 2 , the history of Onmyōdō became
intrinsically tied with Japanese history. The arrival of Chinese Taoism and Yin Yang
Theory signaled a new development in Japanese religions as they subsequently
synthesized with early Shintoism that utilized Chinese geomancy and the yin-yang
system while mutually influencing Esoteric Buddhism and Shugendō.3 The earliest
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
13/124
CHAPTER 1. Introduction ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
state institution under the Taihō-r itsuryō (大宝律令 , Taihō code) in 701 6 and
underwent reorganization under the Yōrō-ritsuryō (養老律令, Yōrō code) in 718.7
Onmyōdō flourished as it was established as part of the state apparatus under the
Onmyō-ryō where its practitioners served the court and imperial family. The close
association of Onmyō-ryō with the imperial family and the use of Onmyōdō rituals
for both preventive and curative purposes among the Heian aristocrats served to
support and legitimize the spread of Onmyōdō practices.
By the tenth century, Onmyōdō, which literarily means, “The Way of Yin and
Yang”, became a widespread term and court officials serving in the Onmyō-ryō wer e
commonly known as onmyōji (陰陽師), which is literally translated as onyō master or
yin-yang master.8 Allan Grapard notes that the “director [of the Onmyō-ryō] himself
ibl f d h l d hil h l b d d
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
14/124
CHAPTER 1. Introduction ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Fujiwara no Tamemitsu (藤原為光), Matsuo-gimi (松雄君).11 Kuchizusami became
widely used as a learning guide for young Heian aristocrats and heavily influenced
late Heian educational compendia. The encyclopedic guide listed various information
under nineteen categories that had titles such as “Geography”, “Animals” and
“Periods within the Year.”12 Prognostication was given particular emphasis under the
major categories of “Onmyōdō”, “Heavenly Phenomenon” and “Medicine”. 13 The
influence of Onmyōdō was such that it became a required subject of learning for
Heian aristocrats. Although Onmyōdō found its origins in Chinese Taoism and yin-
yang thought, the rapid indigenization of Chinese cultural and religious influences
during the Heian period resulted in significant developments away from its Chinese
roots to create a new philosophical system that was distinctly Japanese. However, the
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
15/124
CHAPTER 1. Introduction ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
suffers from the problem of meandering through a confusing bedlam of historical
changes in time without offering a clear, coherent explanation. The second
retrospective approach of studying shikigami from a comparative analysis of
meanings through the centuries arose from the existence of a broad library of folk
literature, diary records and anthologies of historical, court and military tales. In my
initial research on shikigami, I took the first approach of studying its characteristics as
offered in Japanese tales, much as most Japanese scholars have attempted. Yet,
instead of deciphering this elusive entity, I found myself increasingly intrigued by
what its function is and what it pertains to the early Heian literati who read the tales
and even within the practice of Onmyōdō itself. If we simply look at the
characteristics of shikigami, there is a tendency to subsume it under the category of
supernatural beings without considering the deeper historical impact of its existence,
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
16/124
CHAPTER 1. Introduction ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
by society.14
This concept of the myth of shikigami as a societal creation instead of
institutional prescription will be further examined in Chapters 3, 4 and 5 where I will
trace the developments of shikigami descriptions with an overview of the historical
developments of Onmyōdō. Due to an apparent lack of official documents that define
shikigami and consistent details from the diverse practice of Onmyōdō itself, I
referred to related Japanese classical literature to allow for an understanding of what
my thesis is discussing.
There are numerous tales about Onmyōdō in Japanese classical texts that
range from early eighth century to fifteenth century period. The texts of Mumyōshō
(無名抄), Tsukikarima- shū (月刈藻集), Nagatobon heike monogatari (長門本平家物
語 ), Hōjōkudaiki (北条九代記 ), Kokonchomon- jū (古今著聞集 ), Ochikubo
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
17/124
CHAPTER 1. Introduction ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
depictions of shikigami from the works of Makura-no sōshi, Shōyūki, Shin-sarugakuki,
Ōkagami, Konjaku monogatari- shū, Uji-shui monogatari, Zokukojidan and
Genpeijōsuiki for analysis. As my interests lie in examining the symbolism of
shikigami, what it reflects about early Japanese society and its relationship with the
historical developments of Onmyōdō, I take a chronological approach towards the
analysis of texts to show how literary descriptions of shikigami transmuted and
acquired new attributes from the early eleventh century to early fifteenth century
period.
I do not attempt to construct a meta-narrative to explain the impetus behind
the construction of tales about shikigami. Instead, my intent is to highlight the
embeddedness of shikigami tales in the social context of their production. It is also
my intent to emphasize the symbiotic relationship between the developments of
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
18/124
CHAPTER 1. Introduction ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
happened but rather to celebrate patterns of holiness that gave shape to history [italics
are my own].”15
Legends reveal underlying cultural and religious patterns that provide
a new perspective to the study of the past while reaffirming the subjectiveness of
literature.
My study of shikigami myths through an interweave of related literary tales
and historical diary records attempts to extract patterns of thought and highlight the
function of literary narratives as providing alternative perspectives to “official”
historical narratives. I follow David Bialock’s idea of the “symbolic discourse of
texts”16 which focuses on the representative and performative functions of literary
texts and recognizes the “embeddedness of texts in the material conditions of their
production (including their graphic form) and the ways in which they intersect with a
variety of doctrinal, ritual and symbolic practices.”17
Bialock highlights the problem
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
19/124
CHAPTER 1. Introduction ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
rather than a single direct, top-down trajectory. The assumption that the agents of
literary creations were only the aristocratic class would unduly discredit the
contribution of other classes and defeat my purpose in validating the symbolic value
of literary narratives. In order to avoid such a prescriptive assumption, my reference
to the participants in the textual constructions of shikigami in this thesis refers to the
literate class, which in other words refers to anyone who had access to literary
materials and immediate participation in the creation of literary texts.
1.3 Looking at the Spirit Servant through the Chapters
Shikigami is not a common folk belief figure of worship like kitsune (狐,
foxes) or deified individual with historical origins like Kitano cult’s Sugawara no
Michizane (菅原道真, 845 - 903) but an esoteric figure of imagination existing
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
20/124
CHAPTER 1. Introduction ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
proceed with a descriptive analysis of shikigami based on specific Japanese tales and
diary records as what most Japanese scholars had done previously, but I situate my
analysis of the texts within a historical context dictated by the developments of
Onmyōdō.
The encounter with shikigami in my research reveals a close connection
between textual constructions of shikigami and the historical developments of
Onmyōdō where descriptions of shikigami in literary texts and historical diaries
adjusted to the new circumstances when changes in Onmyōdō took place. This
continual textual construction of shikigami was a fluid and active process that was
surprisingly sensitive to the changes in Onmyōdō and nuances of social expectations.
I will show in Chapter 3 how early records of shikigami presented it as a metaphoric
reference to an augury tool. In Chapter 4, I will show how later texts described
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
21/124
CHAPTER 1. Introduction ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
employed as part of the main title of this thesis. The term “spirit servant” is
particularly suited to my intention of positing the questionable functions of shikigami
narratives as shown in the title of the concluding chapter, “Who is the Spirit Servant
Serving?” which presents a rhetorical question that reiterates the main concern of this
thesis: To whom does it serve in actuality? Although the common understanding is
that shikigami acts as a spirit helper to onmyōji, a deeper probe into the circumstances
surrounding the construction of its myths and the subsequent adoption of this
“fictional knowledge” by contemporary religious institutions of Onmyōdō question
the functions of shikigami narratives. It also highlights the issue of whether its
existence was meant to serve the intentions of the institution of its belonging, its
literary creators or the readers.
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
22/124
CHAPTER 1. Introduction ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
effectively translates to the comparison of elite versus popular tendencies. Under this
conventional scholarship, “yin-yang refers in effect to two rather different sets of
practices: one that was gradually disseminated to Japan by populations of immigrants
arriving from the continent and a second based on a textual tradition that was
transmitted directly to the court.”19 This deliberate separation has led some scholars to
adopt “the term yin-yang thought (in’yō shisō) to distinguish between the intellectual
system of correlative cosmology based on the yin-yang five agents cycles (in’yō
gogyō), which had an elaborate textual tradition, and the term on’yōdō20 to refer to
magical techniques ( jujutsu) used in geomancy, purification, and other ritual
practices.”21
The second point is the recent scholarship approach of studying Onmyōdō
from the perspective of cultural hybridity that “even when the tension between
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
23/124
CHAPTER 1. Introduction ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
other forms of rituals and purification rites, concepts about inyō expanded and
developed further variations.24
Another mention to be made here is the complexity embodied in the concept
of “shikigami”. The various readings of shiki, shiki-no-kami and shiki-jin, and
different Chinese characters of 式神, 識神 and 職神 are used to refer to shikigami.
The single Chinese character, 式 is sometimes used to represent shikigami. In the
Japanese dictionary, Nihon kokugo daijiten, shikigami is described as a kijin (鬼神,
demon god) who is commanded by the yin-yang masters of Onmyōdō and possesses
the ability to freely morph and perform marvelous magic. 25 Another Japanese
dictionary, K ō jien gives the same explanations of shikigami as being under the
commands of onmyōji and having shape-shifting and magical abilities but described it
26
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
24/124
CHAPTER 1. Introduction ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
literary texts but supplement it with corresponding dates based on the Gregorian
calendar for easy reference. I consulted K ō jien (6th ed. Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten,
2008), Kokushi daijiten (Tokyo: Yoshikawa K ōbunkan, 1979-97) and Nihon kokugo
daijiten (2nd ed., vol. 6. Tokyo: Shōgakukan, 2001) for the verification of Japanese
terms, names and dates. For the translation of Japanese official titles, I generally
follow the translations listed in Helen Craig. McCullough and William H.
McCullough’s A Tale of Flowering Fortunes. I referred to Nihon koten-bungaku
daijiten (Tokyo: Meiji Shoin, 1998) for the verification of periods of production of
cited texts. I referred to Zuixin hanyu dacidian (Selangor: United Publishing House
(M) SDN.BHD., 1997), Zhongguo fangshu dacidian (Guangdong: Zhongshan
University Publishing, 1991) and A Chinese-English Dictionary (Revised Edition)
(Peking: Foreign Language Teaching and Research Press, 1997) for the verification of
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
25/124
_________________
CHAPTER TWO
_________________
PREVALENT CONCEPTIONS OF SHIKIGAMI
IN CONTEMPORARY SCHOLARSHIP
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
26/124
CHAPTER 2. Prevalent Conceptions of Shikigami in Contemporary Scholarship
An overview of literature about shikigami shows variations in the way it is
described through the centuries, which has consequently resulted in different
understandings about this entity in contemporary Japanese scholarship. As Japanese
scholars have employed different literary texts and time periods for analysis, this has
produced varied and sometimes contradictory definitions of the shikigami. In this
chapter, I present definitions from Japanese classical texts and scholarship on
Onmyōdō to allow for a broad understanding of current interpretations of shikigami.
The purpose here is to show that the various definitions are due to different
conceptions of shikigami in contemporary scholarship which has neglected to take
into account the changing significance of shikigami through the centuries. From the
study of contemporary research on Onmyōdō, I have categorized the various
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
27/124
CHAPTER 2. Prevalent Conceptions of Shikigami in Contemporary Scholarship ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
duties of the Onmyō-ryō, that one of the Onmyō-ryō’s duties was senzei (占筮). This
is a form of augury using augury sticks and principles based on the Book of Changes
(易经, I-Ching ).1 Court onmyōji were regarded as responsible for the tasks of augury
and predictions which subsequently augmented their image as diviners.
During the Heian period, an onmyōji was often consulted in the event of a ke
(怪, 恠, strange occurrence), where he used shikisen to determine if the unusual
occurrence held further implications. Onmyōji specialized in shikisen, particularly the
rikujin-shikisen (六壬式占), a type of complex augury calculation that was said to
have been introduced into Japan during the late sixth to early seventh century.
Shikisen was widely used by practitioners of Onmyōdō in the Nara period until the
mid-sixteenth century where it was replaced by ekisen (易占), a type of augury
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
28/124
CHAPTER 2. Prevalent Conceptions of Shikigami in Contemporary Scholarship ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
the jūni-shi have to be carefully coordinated through mathematical calculations to
match the dates and times with the symbolic astrological signs. Onmyōji would then
use the result to ascertain if the ke had any detrimental effects and advise what actions
should be taken to alleviate them.
Suzuki Ikkei sees ke as an important factor in the association of shikigami
with shikisen, taking examples from historical diaries such as Teishinkōki (貞信公記,
907-948), Midōkanpakuki (御堂関白記, 995-1021) and Shōyūki (小右記, 978-1032)
to illustrate the broad and varied definitions of ke. Ke might first appear as
commonplace, nondescript occurrences such as a crow dropping its excrement on
someone, and it required a knowing eye to recognize the deeper implications behind
such incidences. Suzuki emphasizes that ke is a sign of forthcoming calamity, not the
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
29/124
CHAPTER 2. Prevalent Conceptions of Shikigami in Contemporary Scholarship ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
shaped ideas of shikigami as a spiritual entity.8
Murayama also points out that the two
shikigami which Abe no Seimei (安倍晴明, 911-1005), a famous onmyōji who
served six emperors from Emperor Suzaku (朱雀天皇, r.930-46) to Emperor Ichijō
(一条天皇, r.986-1011), was fabled to command is a symbolic representation of the
chokuban’s Heaven and Earth panels. 9 Suwa gives more details about the close
relationship between shikigami and shikisen by explaining that the twelve shinshō (神
将 , guardian deities or warrior gods) which legends claimed Abe no Seimei
commanded, were likely based on the twelve cardinal points on the chokuban’s Earth
panel that relate to the jūni-shi.10 Although jūni-shi do not possess a clear identity,
they were given characteristics of divinity in Onmyōdō and existed as shugojin (守護
神, guardian gods or protector spirits) that were often invoked during rites. 11 The
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
30/124
CHAPTER 2. Prevalent Conceptions of Shikigami in Contemporary Scholarship ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Suzuki provides another perspective of shikigami where he views the inter-
changeable use of the Chinese character, 識 ( shiki, consciousness) with 式 in
reference to shikigami (式神, 識神) in late Heian literary texts as a reflection of
human cognition. He provided several examples of “shikigami” (識神) in Buddhist
texts, such as Bosatsushotaikei ( 菩 薩 処 胎 経 ), which defined it as an
anthropomorphic realization of the active psychological or mental state ( shiki, 識).13
Suzuki is one of the few Japanese scholars in the field of Onmyōdō research to
attempt the study of the origins of shikigami and his early efforts to identify the
source of shikigami take the approach of examining examples from Konjaku
mongatari- shū (今昔物語集, 1120) and Uji-shui monogatari (宇治拾遺物語, 1213-
1221) and using the religious backdrop of the two anthologies of tales to present the
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
31/124
CHAPTER 2. Prevalent Conceptions of Shikigami in Contemporary Scholarship ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
classical texts and concluded that the Chinese character, 式 was initially used in the
early Heian period but was later inter-changeably used with 識 in reference to
shikigami (式神,識神).16 As mentioned in an earlier section, Suzuki is one of the few
Japanese scholars who speculates that the use of 式 for shikigami (式神) was initially
intended as a metaphorical allusion to onmyōji’s mastery over shikisen (式占).17 After
a study of the religious background of Konjaku mongatari- shū and comparisons with
Buddhist texts to examine the meanings behind 識, Suzuki surmises that despite
referring to the same entity in Onmyōdō, the use of 識神 to represent shikigami
suggests that it is later viewed as a form of anima rather than augury abilities. Suzuki
proposes that 識神 is a collateral existence produced by the active psyche which
possesses autonomous control over the consciousness (識, shiki).18 The concept of
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
32/124
CHAPTER 2. Prevalent Conceptions of Shikigami in Contemporary Scholarship ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
under Tadayuki, Tale 16”
21
of Konjaku mongatari- shū, as a competition of mental
strength rather than magic skills.22
He argues that shikigami is a literary
representation of Chitoku’s will and psychological intention to assess Seimei’s
capabilities. When Chitoku faced Seimei, competitive desire overtook him and
weakened his state of mind, causing him to lose sight of his original intention. As
such, he lost control over his will, his “shikigami”, which allowed Seimei to
overcome and “conceal” his shikigami. In other words, Seimei and Chitoku’s battle of
wits is actually a struggle of control over one’s own will and desire. Suzuki’s concept
of shikigami as a form of human cognitive power is a fascinating interpretation that
highlights a psychological approach towards the study of shikigami and suggests a
possible influence of Buddhism on Onmyōdō philosophical ideas since the late Heian
period.
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
33/124
CHAPTER 2. Prevalent Conceptions of Shikigami in Contemporary Scholarship ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
examination of the historical context behind the legends of Abe no Seimei, he takes
literary examples from texts such as Shin-sarugakuki (新猿楽記, 1052), Ōkagami (大
鏡, mid-eleventh to early twelfth century), Uji-shui monogatari and Gen peijōsuiki (源
平盛衰記 , end fourteenth to early fifteenth century), to classify shikigami
characteristics. He then uses the classification of shikigami characteristics to identify
two main traits; the first trait refers to magic that utilizes the innate powers of objects
to carry out tasks and the second is that of the role of a “kakyū-no-kenzoku-shin” (下
級の眷属神, lower-ranking deities attached to Buddhist divinities).
24
Suwa gives
literary examples of Seimei using a leaf to kill a toad or controlling a piece of paper to
do his bidding as indicative of the employment of an object’s inner powers to perform
tasks 25 and defined shikigami as magic that allows onmyōji to draw on the innate
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
34/124
CHAPTER 2. Prevalent Conceptions of Shikigami in Contemporary Scholarship ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
inner life-force or essence which is believed to exist everywhere and in everything
from animate to inanimate objects. The inherent essence in objects can be utilized by
magic spells and the process that involves the utilization of this innate energy and its
resulting effect is termed “shikigami”. The onmyōji is dependent on objects that
possess the energy, such as a leaf or paper, and magical incantations to summon the
powers existing within the relevant objects, which implies that shikigami is seen as a
naturally-existing energy instead of internal magical prowess cultivated through
individual spiritual practice. This animistic view of shikigami as an external form of
energy that onmyōji can utilize runs into the problem of identifying the nature of
energy that it originated from. However, an examination of the deeper significance
behind this animistic definition suggests that shikigami is actually a means through
which the onmyōji controls the innate energy in natural elements with magical
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
35/124
CHAPTER 2. Prevalent Conceptions of Shikigami in Contemporary Scholarship ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
abilities, but he admits that none of the characteristics can be clarified or proven in
present-day scholarship.29
Miura studies the relationship between Onmyōdō and
magic by focusing on magic spells in Onmyōdō tradition in his paper with an
emphasis on jujutsu (呪術, magic spells and incantations) and juhō (呪法, magic
rituals)30 which he sees as having been influenced by fuko (巫蠱) and the Taoist
magic of goraihō (五雷法), a spell that controls supernatural elements such as ghosts
and fox spirits.31
Fuko (巫蠱), or gu (蠱) in Mandarin, is a Chinese poisonous curse
that is created by sealing five venomous creatures such as centipede, toad, snake,
scorpion and gecko in a sealed jar and letting them devour each other. The sole
surviving creature is believed to be the most powerful as it contains the venom of the
other creatures and it becomes the gu which is used to carry out spells and cause the
32
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
36/124
CHAPTER 2. Prevalent Conceptions of Shikigami in Contemporary Scholarship ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
and bring all kinds of illnesses through the gu till the victim died, or even stealthily
shift the victim’s wealth to the gu owners’ houses.35 A more sinister aspect of gu is its
ability to allow its owner to control the soul of the dead victim.36
Miura sees similar
characteristics between gu and shikigami. He takes the tale of an onmyō ji, Dōma (道
摩) from Kojidan and Uji-shui monogatari, whose act of sealing a curse in an earthen
pot to harm Fujiwara no Michinaga (藤原道長 , 966-1027) as indicative of gu
practices and refers to Genpeijōsuiki to suggest that shikigami could also be gu in
human form.37 By relating shikigami to gu magic spells, Miura presents shikigami as
a form of malignant human-created curse rather than energy tapped from naturally-
existing elements. Miura’s study of shikigami from the perspective of gu associates
magic rituals in Onmyōdō tradition with Chinese magic spells and suggests that the
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
37/124
CHAPTER 2. Prevalent Conceptions of Shikigami in Contemporary Scholarship ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Hisao, Miki Sumito, Matsuo Satoshi and Nagai Kazuko describe shikigami as a kijin
(鬼神, demon gods or invisible spiritual beings with super-human powers) in their
annotations of Japanese classical texts. Komine Kazuaki’s annotation of Konjaku
monogatari- shū identifies it as a kakyū-shin (下級神 , lower-ranking subordinate
deity)38 while Mabuchi Kazuo calls it a seirei (精霊, spirit, ghost or genie).39 Harima
Mitsutoshi’s annotation of Zokukojidan (続古事談, 1219) refers to it as a reijin (霊神,
spiritual being or deity that performs striking miracles).40
Annotations in Japanese
classical texts establish shikigami as a supernatural being though it is uncertain as to
whether it should be viewed as a spirit ( seirei), lower-ranking deity (kakyū-shin,
reijin) or demon god (kijin). The difficulties in expressing the complex ideas
embodied in shikigami can also be seen in Western translations of Japanese classical
41
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
38/124
CHAPTER 2. Prevalent Conceptions of Shikigami in Contemporary Scholarship ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
meanings of shikigami by overlooking its particularities and distinct niche in Japanese
religious thought.
Some Japanese scholars have tried to compare shikigami with other
supernatural beings to establish a better understanding of what it is. Using an example
of the fourteenth century illustrated scroll painting, Fudōriyaku-engi emaki (不動利益
縁起絵巻), Toyoshima sees the portrayal of shikigami as two diminutive helpers
assisting Seimei in a ceremonial purification rite to subdue demons of ailments as
similar to the attendant roles of Kongara (矜羯羅) and Seitaka (製多迦), the gohōdōji
(護法童子, attendant gods that is commanded by divine protectors of the Buddhist
Laws) to Fudōmyōou (不動明王) in Esoteric Buddhism.45 He then quotes from a
Tendai Esoteric Buddhist text, Anchi mitsukuketsu kyōryōchi (安鎮秘口決境領知) to
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
39/124
CHAPTER 2. Prevalent Conceptions of Shikigami in Contemporary Scholarship ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
shikigami, where the qualities of possessing both invisible and physical forms, being
summoned through incantations and under the commands of their masters were
regarded as key influences in the development of shikigami.49
Despite the difficulty in
establishing the category of supernatural being that shikigami belongs to, it can be
understood here that shikigami is commonly viewed as a spirit entity that can be
summoned by human onmyōji through spells and incantations, rather than bestowed
by divinities or attained after a long process of spiritual self-cultivation.
Literary descriptions of shikigami in various texts present a gamut of qualities
that range from being an amorphous entity to having a variety of physical forms and
abilities such as being able to act as a messenger, perform mundane household chores,
aid in ceremonial rituals, give predictions, set curses, spy, assassinate people and
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
40/124
CHAPTER 2. Prevalent Conceptions of Shikigami in Contemporary Scholarship ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
this by illustrating how ideas of shikigami evolved in tandem with changing ideas
about Onmyōdō. I will also clarify that the variations in descriptions of shikigami
characteristics through the centuries suggest shifting ideas about the significance of
shikigami.
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
41/124
_________________
CHAPTER THREE
_________________
EARLY SHIKIGAMI NARRATIVES:
THE AMORPHOUS ENTITY
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
42/124
CHAPTER 3. Early Shikigami Narratives: The Amorphous Entity
In the previous chapter, I highlighted the tendency of Japanese scholars to
neglect the time periods and historical context that shaped literary descriptions of
shikigami. This resulted in different conceptions and definitions of shikigami in
contemporary Japanese scholarship. In the following chapters, I focus on a literary
analysis of ten tales from the works, Makura-no sōshi, Shōyūki, Shin-sarugakuki,
Ōkagami, Konjaku monogatari- shū, Uji-shui monogatari, Zokukojidan and
Genpeijōsuiki, together with historical records, to show how textual constructions of
shikigami changed over the early eleventh to early fifteenth century period as a result
of historical developments in Onmyōdō. A chronological order of analysis of the
selected tales is given in tandem with the corresponding periods of Onmyōdō
developments to situate the shikigami within a clear historical context and allow for
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
43/124
CHAPTER 3. Early Shikigami Narratives: The Amorphous Entity ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
spying agents or supernatural beings with physical forms under the command of
onmyōji. The early thirteenth century literature, Uji-shui monogatari casts shikigami
as a deadly curse with a physical form that would take effect only when sent by
onmyōji. In contrast, another early thirteenth century work, Zokukojidan and the end-
fourteenth century to early fifteenth century work, Genpeijōsuiki present a sinister
transformation in shikigami characteristics where it appeared uncontrolled by onmyōji,
with the ability to freely manifest in the open and even cause harm to innocent
passersby.
This transformation from an amorphous power to a subservient corporeal
being to a freewheeling entity offers a thought-provoking hint about historical
developments in Onmyōdō that had effected such changes in literary descriptions
about its emblem.
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
44/124
CHAPTER 3. Early Shikigami Narratives: The Amorphous Entity ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
period. The mid-Heian work of Makura-no sōshi is one of the few Japanese texts with
the earliest mention of shikigami. This text shows that the early prototypical
shikigami was perceived to be an augury tool instead of a supernatural force or
immanent being. Makura-no sōshi is by Sei Shōnagon (清少納言, 966? - after 1017)
and was completed in 1001-1002.1 It is a miscellany of the author‟s observations and
thoughts about court life, people, nature, habits and miscellaneous things. It provides
one of the earliest records of shikigami. The cha pter, “When I first went into court
service”2 describes an episode of Empress Teishi (皇后定子, 976-1000) asking Sei
Shōnagon if she was fond of her when a sudden loud sneeze from the Table Room
interrupted Sei Shōnagon‟s reply. As the sneeze occurred when the author was giving
her answer, the empress jested that it was a sign that she was lying to her and left. Sei
Shōnagon was greatly dismayed by this episode and bitterly resented the person
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
45/124
CHAPTER 3. Early Shikigami Narratives: The Amorphous Entity ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
by the strength or weakness of its hue –
but that red nose bloomed false.
And so my flowering heart withers alone
To find itself in misjudged misery.
„Please take this to Her Majesty to lift her spirits,‟ I said,
and added, „The god of divination [式の神, shiki-no-kami]
knows all. I stand in great awe of him...‟”3
The sneezing episode was a minor affair that had so distressed the young,
inexperienced Sei Shōnagon such that she found it necessary to evoke shikigami
( shiki-no-kami) as proof of her sincerity. In an attempt to convince the empress, Sei
Shōnagon referred to shikigami as a vow of her honesty and loyalty and proclaimed
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
46/124
CHAPTER 3. Early Shikigami Narratives: The Amorphous Entity ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
referred to tadasu-no-kami (糺の神, god of Tadasu), a sacred augury forest of the
Shimogamo Shrine (下鴨神社) that was believed to be able to verify truths, in a letter
to Sei Shōnagon after the sneezing incident to tease her about whether she would be
able to maintain any lie when faced with the augury of truth. Sei Shōnagon‟s written
reply to the empress‟s letter referred to the sneezing incident and the depth of her
sincerity by punning on the homophone, hana, which means nose (鼻) or flower (花)
and declared that the sneeze caused by the “red nose” that had “bloomed false” was a
misleading indication of her sincerity. She then ended the letter with a note about her
belief in the divination abilities of the shiki-no-kami (式の神, god of shiki) to reveal
the truth of her words in response to Empress Teishi‟s mentioning of the augury tool
of truth, tadasu-no-kami in her letter. Sei Shōnagon cleverly used the term, “ shiki-no-
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
47/124
CHAPTER 3. Early Shikigami Narratives: The Amorphous Entity ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
activities.6 The influence of onmyōji in the Heian imperial court is particularly seen in
the routine practice of mono-imi7 (物忌, period of purification) and kata-imi8 (方忌,
directional taboos) by the imperial family and aristocratic class in accordance with
daily augury predictions by court onmyōji. The acknowledged status of court onmyōji
as specialists of augury and their expertise in the use of shikisen might have
influenced ideas about shikigami and associated it with an augury tool, such as that
expressed in Makura-no sōshi.
The mention of shikigami in the interaction between Sei Shōnagon and
Empress Teishi and the open use of shikigami as a means of oath-swearing in
Makura-no sōshi indicate that shikigami was already a familiar concept that existed in
the Heian imperial court during the early eleventh century. The lack of explanations
about shikigami in Sei Shōnagon‟s written reply to Empress Teishi was based on the
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
48/124
CHAPTER 3. Early Shikigami Narratives: The Amorphous Entity ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
the political and social environment during the regencies of Fujiwara no Michinaga
(藤原道長, 966-1027) and Fujiwara no Yorimichi (藤原頼通, 992-1074). In the entry,
“Officials”9 in section “Troubles”10 of chapter 20, “Extraordinary Events, Part 10”11,
it was recorded that the Minister of the Left, Fujiwara no Michinaga was troubled
with illness by a shikigami in the second year of Chōhō era (長保二年, 1000):
(Chōhō era 2nd
year, 5th
month) Same year, same month,
eighth day, it is said that shikigami was the cause of the
Minister of the Left‟s troubles.12
This concise entry was recorded together with numerous brief documentations
of illnesses and troubles suffered by the imperial family and aristocrats Unlike
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
49/124
CHAPTER 3. Early Shikigami Narratives: The Amorphous Entity ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
A reason for this added characteristic could probably be due to the people‟s
attitudes towards illnesses and their cures in early Japan. Allan Grapard observes that
beliefs in the exorcism and “magical” cure of diseases already existed during the Nara
period and such treatments were conducted by the Bureau of Medicine that had
experts consisting of one hakase (博士, doctor), two masters, and six disciples.13
This
association of medical problems with magical cures can also be seen in Shigeta
Shinichi‟s study of the relationship between aristocrats and onmyōji during the Heian
period in which he describes the process where aristocrats often consulted doctors
along with onmyōji and Buddhist monks in the event of illnesses. 14 Traditional
medical treatments were still practiced but the belief that diseases caused by the
supernatural needed magical cures resulted in a twofold process of medical
consultation that involved both medical and magico-religious solutions. Buddhist
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
50/124
CHAPTER 3. Early Shikigami Narratives: The Amorphous Entity ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
medicinal cures. Some of the rites conducted by onmyōji for curing illnesses or
expulsion of spirits responsible for illnesses are taiyaku-sai (大厄祭), kiki-sai (鬼気
祭) and kaijo (解除).
3.3 A Category of Magic Skill: Shin-sarugakuki
The central government‟s decline in power during the mid-tenth century
created a tumultuous milieu of social and political disorder.16
Rebellions from
disgruntled and ambitious noblemen such as Taira no Masakado (平将門, ? - 940) and
Fujiwara no Sumitomo (藤原純友, ? - 941) were eventually subdued but “difficult
social conditions caused by drought, famine, epidemic, and great fires, plus a sudden
increase in robbery, murder, and suicide, convinced many people that the end of the
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
51/124
CHAPTER 3. Early Shikigami Narratives: The Amorphous Entity ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
religious practice and the increasing role of onmyōji as ritual priests and
thaumaturgical sorcerers.19
This gradual transformation of onmyōji from a specialist of yin-yang theory to
a diviner with magical skills can be detected in Shin-sarugakuki, a fictional work by
the Professor of Literature, Fujiwara no Akihira (藤原明衡 , 989-1066) that was
completed in 1052. Shin-sarugakuki describes the principal occupations of the period
in detail and is perceived as the predecessor of the later genre of ōrai-mono (往来物,
textbooks).20 It is regarded as an important literary contribution to the history of
Japanese customs, theater and performances with Marian Ury describing this work as
presenting the “principal occupations of the time and their vocabulary with
encyclopedic thoroughness.”21 The descriptive commentary about various artisans and
performers of the time illustrates a vivid picture of the social environment in the late
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
52/124
CHAPTER 3. Early Shikigami Narratives: The Amorphous Entity ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
manipulate human souls... Although he had a human form,
he was able to communicate mentally with otherworldly
beings.23
The awe over the legendary abilities and magical powers of onmyōji was
carefully presented by Fujiwara no Akihira who listed Kamo no Michiyo‟s expert
knowledge of augury and formidable command over various elements such as wild
beasts, deities, supernatural beings and humans in the tale. The description that
Michiyo was able to command shikigami (仕式神, shi shikigami) suggests that this
was one of the abilities that a highly skilled onmyōji was expected to possess. The
close relationship between the onmyōji and shikigami that is seen here will be
reiterated in later tales about onmyōji such that shikigami eventually became an
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
53/124
CHAPTER 3. Early Shikigami Narratives: The Amorphous Entity ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
statutes for annual rituals that was completed in 927 upon the orders of Emperor
Daigo (醍醐天皇, r. 897-930) and finally authorized and enacted in 967. As observed
and succinctly summarized by Felicia Bock, the statutes in Engi-shiki “seem to
indicate that the major portion of the work of the Yin-Yang Bureau consisted of
observing heavenly patterns (astronomy-astrology), performing calendrical
calculations, preparing the annual calendar for the court and administrative offices,
operating the water clocks, announcing the hours of dawn and sunset, and conducting
the Na festival24
, as well as teaching these sciences and arts.”25
There appeared little
within the government manual to indicate that onmyōji had the power or authority to
command supernatural or spiritual forces26 though Shin-sarugakuki presented ideas
about the expected abilities of onmyōji that included supernatural prowess.
The magical abilities that the onmyōji, Kamo no Michiyo was described to
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
54/124
CHAPTER 3. Early Shikigami Narratives: The Amorphous Entity ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Onmyōdō to be initially recognized as a form of proto -science (原始科学, genshi
kagaku) rather than a superstition (迷信, meishin).28 This initial classification of
Onmyōdō as a science for the health of both state and individual instead of a magico-
religious practice is further found in Grapard‟s description of the Japanese
bureaucratic system where “divination by turtle shell was not assigned to the Bureau
of Yin and Yang in Japan, but to the Department of Shrines, where it was performed
by the Nakatomi29
and Urabe30
sacerdotal lineages.”31
Yamashita Katsuaki analyzes
that Onmyōdō was placed on par with the Tenyaku-ryō (典薬寮, Bureau of Medicine)
and regarded as a form of specialized skill and knowledge. 32 The regard for the
technical skills of Onmyōdō is particularly seen in the establishment of facilities to
educate and train students to become onyō specialists.33 The notable lack of mention
of control over shikigami or any supernatural elements in the assigned duties of the
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
55/124
CHAPTER 3. Early Shikigami Narratives: The Amorphous Entity ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
elements called for the habit of consulting onmyōji before the aristocrats embarked on
their daily activities.35
The late ninth to early tenth century saw changes in the original
functions of the Onmyō-ryō to include more ritual activities that focused on pollution
taboos and purification rites such as spirit exorcisms.36
By the later half of the tenth
century, the heavy engagement of the Onmyō-ryō in conducting ceremonial rituals
and magical rites gradually cast court onmyōji as ritual priests and thaumaturgical
sorcerers.37
The portrayal of onmyōji as a diviner with magical skills and ability to
command supernatural elements in Shin-sarugakuki can be found in Yamashita
Katsuaki‟s study of Onmyōdō during the Heian period. Yamashita provides three
main reasons for the development of Onmyōdō from a philosophical proto-science
into a magico-religious practice that resulted in the thaumaturgical image of onmyōji
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
56/124
CHAPTER 3. Early Shikigami Narratives: The Amorphous Entity ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
came from the social demands for such magical powers and sorcery and the final
reason was the active use and mastery of related books on rituals and magic by
onmyōji in response to such demands.41
Yamashita sees the development of Onmyōdō
into a magico-religious practice through the adoption of ceremonial rituals and
magical rites to be a result of a response to state demands for such a change in their
role. 42 Such a development in Onmyōdō concomitantly resulted in literary
descriptions of onmyōji possessing magical skills, as seen in Shin-sarugakuki where
the onmyōji is described as being able to summon supernatural beings and create
spells.
From the literature of Makura-no sōshi, Shōyūki and Shin-sarugakuki, a
changing description of shikigami from a reference to the shikisen augury to a cause
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
57/124
CHAPTER 3. Early Shikigami Narratives: The Amorphous Entity ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
distinct development in shikigami characteristics. As onmyōji became increasingly
involved in magical ceremonial rites that cast Onmyōdō as a magico -religious
practice, shikigami moved from its original manifestation as an amorphous
representation of shikisen augury powers and magic skills to become a figure of
supernatural existence with magical skills.
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
58/124
_________________
CHAPTER FOUR _________________
DEVELOPMENTS IN SHIKIGAMI NARRATIVES:
FROM AUGURY TO ASSASSIN
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
59/124
CHAPTER 4. Developments in Shikigami Narratives: From Augury to Assassin
The late Heian period was marked by the declining influence of the
aristocratic class with the advent of the feudal Kamakura regime. Throughout the late
eleventh century, social developments were strongly influenced by Buddhist ideas of
mappō (末法
, latter days of the Buddhist Law), a period characterized by irrevocable
spiritual decline and political and social turmoil.1 Allan Grapard points out that
during this period,
“...history was not seen anymore as the symbolic manifestation
of the will of the kami and their associated buddhas and
bodhisattvas, but as a devolutionary process over which human
beings had little or no power. Time was conceived of as an
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
60/124
CHAPTER 4. Developments in Shikigami Narratives: From Augury to Assassin ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
the level of efficacy of the rituals called for the service of thaumaturgists believed to
possess powers that could enhance the rituals. As the aristocrats were the most active
participants in the ritual activities, onmyōji were expected to perform functions that
expanded beyond those stated in Engi-shiki. The late Heian period saw the heavy
involvement of court onmyō ji in ceremonial and purification rites as a result of
demands from the imperial family and aristocratic class. As the Onmyō-ryō took on a
more significant role in the performance of ceremonial rites for the state, Onmyōdō
underwent a gradual transformation from a specialized philosophical proto-science
into a magico-religious practice that cast onmyō ji as diviners and ritual priests with
supernatural powers. Consequently, textual constructions of shikigami were subjected
to the same transformation that imbued supernatural abilities into the previously
functionally-ambiguous shikigami. In this chapter, I employ tales from the late Heian
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
61/124
CHAPTER 4. Developments in Shikigami Narratives: From Augury to Assassin ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
(花山寺). As he passed by Abe no Seimei’s house along Tsuchimikado (土御門)
street, he overheard Seimei announcing a prediction derived from observations of
unusual astrological signs about his forthcoming abdication and later, instructing a
shikigami to enter the imperial palace. The extract below details the episode where
Seimei was commanding the shikigami:
“...“One of you spirits had better go on ahead to the
Palace,” Seimei said. And they tell me that an invisible
person pushed open the door and answered, “It looks as
though His Majesty has just passed the house.” (He may
have seen the Emperor’s retreating figure. Seimei’s
residence was at the intersection of Tsuchimikado and
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
62/124
CHAPTER 4. Developments in Shikigami Narratives: From Augury to Assassin ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
material limitations differ from the earlier amorphous descriptions of shikigami in
Makura-no sōshi as the augury tool of shikisen with the fluid ability to know all the
happenings in the imperial court. Tachibana Kenji and Kato Shizuko’s annotations of
Ōkagami note that the shikigami’s protean powers of transformation (hengenjizai) are
controlled by onmyōji which indicate that shikigami did not naturally possess a
physical form but its appearance was instead dictated by its onmyōji master.5 In this
tale, the author adopted a third person narrative to specifically state that shikigami
was an invisible being (me ni ha mienu-mono) that was unseen by normal humans.
The author deliberately stated that it is hearsay that shikigami was an “invisible
being” which leaves an ambiguous end to the episode and avoids the issue of whether
shikigami was visible to the emperor.
Abe no Seimei (安倍晴明, 921-1005) was a historical figure who served six
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
63/124
CHAPTER 4. Developments in Shikigami Narratives: From Augury to Assassin ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
to enhance an onmyōji’s capability in manipulating many elements. The portrayal of
Seimei’s possession of several shikigami performs as a verification of his prowess and
magical abilities. This indication of magical prowess is repeated in another tale in the
late Heian work, Konjaku monogatari- shū that will be discussed in the section below.
4.2 Corporeality, Lethal Weapon and Knowledge-based Exclusivity: Konjaku
monogatari- shū
Konjaku monogatari- shū is a collection of more than a thousand tales by an
anonymous author that consists of thirty-one scrolls with three missing scrolls. It is
speculated to be completed in 1120.7 Joseph Kitagawa describes it as “probably the
most valuable source regarding the religious beliefs and practices of the masses
during the Heian period.”8 The majority of the tales deals with Buddhist philosophical
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
64/124
CHAPTER 4. Developments in Shikigami Narratives: From Augury to Assassin ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
signs as punishment for the monk’s insolence. When Chitoku left after Seimei asked
him to revisit another day, he was alarmed to discover that his pages had disappeared
and quickly went back to apologize to Seimei and ask for their return. The episode
ended with Chitoku being highly impressed with Seimei`s magical abilities and
requesting to become his disciple. Below is an excerpt of the battle of wits between
Seimei and Chitoku:
“...Seimei guessed that the old fellow knew more than he
let on and had actually come to test him. On his mettle
now, he decided to have a bit of fun himself. The two
boys seemed to be genies.11
Seimei prayed silently that if
they were, they should vanish; and he secretly cast a spell
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
65/124
CHAPTER 4. Developments in Shikigami Narratives: From Augury to Assassin ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The account of Seimei’s ability to control another onmyōji’s shikigami works
to impart a sense of awe of his mastery over supernatural elements. The use of
shikigami as a gauge of onmyōji’s power and knowledge is highlighted by Chitoku’s
test for Seimei and his strong admiration of Seimei’s ability to manipulate another’s
shikigami.
The earlier tale in Ōkagami describes shikigami as an “invisible being” with
the physical power to open doors and vocal and analytical abilities to report
happenings to Seimei. Konjaku monogatari- shū provides a more definite image of
shikigami where it is able to take on a physical human form with a degree of realism
that can deceive unknowing people into believing that it is real. There are no visible
signs to verify the existence of shikigami at first sight and even Seimei who is
renowned for his impressive magical skills and knowledge, had to verify his
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
66/124
CHAPTER 4. Developments in Shikigami Narratives: From Augury to Assassin ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
certain talisman ( fu) and with the formal chanting of an incantation or spell ( zhou).”13
Mitamura also observes that “in general, two main groups of [T]aoist hand signs can
be distinguished: those that developed in direct imitation of Buddhist mudras, and
those that can be described as uniquely [T]aoist finger techniques. Hand signs
deriving from Buddhist mudras include signs signifying “lotus”, “bridge”, “sword”
and so on. They are the same in name and execution, yet their specific description in
[T]aoist texts makes it clear that they were given an additional significance. Here,
unlike in Buddhism, each finger segment was linked with the larger cosmos by being
associated with the eight trigrams, seven stars of the Dipper, or twelve zodiac
positions.”14
In Ōkagami, Seimei’s exceptional mastery over shikigami is shown by his
possession of many shikigami at his command. The ability to manipulate several
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
67/124
CHAPTER 4. Developments in Shikigami Narratives: From Augury to Assassin ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
knowledge of the skill to control another onmyōji’s shikigami .16 Despite Chitoku’s
fearsome magical powers and excellent control over his own shikigami, he is depicted
as inferior to Seimei due to his inability to conceal and manipulate another onmyōji’s
shikigami. The fluidity of control over shikigami implies that it is not permanently
bound to a particular person whether by spells or mental control. Chitoku’s
experience reveals the belief that if one possesses necessary knowledge of the spell,
shikigami can be easily manipulated and even captured from another onmyōji. In
other words, the control over shikigami can be cultivated and obtained through the
possession of the requisite knowledge rather than dependence on heavenly gifts or
boons from divinity. This autonomy from divine grants and reliance on specialized
knowledge and training conversely caused restrictions to the attainment of such
magical knowledge.
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
68/124
CHAPTER 4. Developments in Shikigami Narratives: From Augury to Assassin ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
responsibility of being sacerdotal lineages of Onmyōdō. The ritsuryō state is
described by Ian James McMullen as opening the way to the “political ascendency of
oligarchic noble lineages”, which resulted in monopolies in the various spheres of
politics, religions and culture as certain family lineages were accorded hereditary
specialties. 21 As the ecclesiastic practitioners of Onmyōdō were of aristocratic
lineages, the possession of texts about Taoism, yin-yang theory and ceremonial rites
were primarily controlled by the Abe and Kamo sacerdotal lineages that in effect,
prevented commoner onmyōji from accessing such knowledge. This divergence
between commoner onmyōji and court onmyōji is represented by Chitoku’s defeat
due to his lack of the knowledge of the spells possessed by Seimei.
In the later part of the same tale, “The Tutelage of Abe no Seimei under
Tadayuki, Tale 16”, the command of shikigami and the legendary powers of Seimei
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
69/124
CHAPTER 4. Developments in Shikigami Narratives: From Augury to Assassin ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
just end up committing a sin.” ...He picked up a blade of
grass, muttered something, and tossed the grass at a frog.
The grass crushed the frog and killed it instantly. The
monks looking on turned pale with fear.”23
This anecdote is an accolade to Seimei’s moral character as seen in his
reluctance to kill an innocent life for the sake of entertainment. In this account, Seimei
admitted that there are limitations on an onmyōji’s power where it is difficult to kill a
human with magic despite the possibility of doing so. Yet, this is contradicted by his
display of the killing of a frog where a blade of grass was powerful enough to
instantly crush the frog. Japanese scholars such as Toyoshima Yasukuni and Suwa
Haruo see Seimei’s action of muttering incantations into the blade of grass and using
CHAPTER 4 D l i Shiki i N i F A A i
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
70/124
CHAPTER 4. Developments in Shikigami Narratives: From Augury to Assassin ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
situation in his house where shutters would lower and rise while doors would close
when there was no human around.24
The final part of the tale reiterates the corporeality of shikigami in more detail
where it is recorded that the descendents of Seimei could hear sounds made by
shikigami in Seimei’s original abode, the Tsuchimikado house.25 The suggestion here
is that the shikigami possessed by Seimei continued to exist even after the death of
their master. Shikigami were said to remain in the head household but did not appear
to be inherited by the descendents of Seimei since they could only hear but could not
see or control them. Shikigami is not a hereditary substance that can be passed on
physically or biologically to another person but specific knowledge is required to
possess them. As highlighted by Chitoku’s experience in the earlier part of the tale, it
requires the knowledge of the spell before one can control a shikigami which suggests
CHAPTER 4 D l t i Shiki i N ti F A t A i
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
71/124
CHAPTER 4. Developments in Shikigami Narratives: From Augury to Assassin ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
supernatural existence that has the potential to bring lethal harm to small creatures
such as a frog. The level of mortal harm that shikigami was believed to be capable of
is given in more detail in a tale from the mid-Kamakura work of Uji-shui monogatari
in the section below. Uji-shui monogatari is a collection of a hundred and ninety-
seven assorted tales said to be completed in the period 1213-1221 by an anonymous
compiler. The tales show strong Buddhist influence and about eighty similar tales can
be found in Konjaku monogatari- shū. In tale 26 in scroll 2, section 8 titled “Seimei
sealing the young Archivist Minor Captain’s curse,”26 Seimei witnessed the setting of
a shikigami curse on a popular chamberlain and decided to save him. It was later
revealed that the curse was initiated by the jealous brother-in-law of the chamberlain
who desires for his death. The tale ended with Seimei successfully saving the
chamberlain by causing the deadly curse to retaliate and kill the spell-caster instead.
CHAPTER 4 Developments in Shikigami Narratives: From Augury to Assassin
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
72/124
CHAPTER 4. Developments in Shikigami Narratives: From Augury to Assassin ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
unintelligible muttering. The fall night was long. At dawn
there was a knock on the door, and Seimei had the
chamberlain send someone to answer. It was a messenger
from the enemy diviner. The chamberlain’s brother -in-
law, who lived in another part of the house, was so
jealous of the chamberlain that he had this diviner set a
genie on the chamberlain to kill him. Seimei had spotted
the genie. “The gentleman was so strongly protected,” the
messenger loudly announced, “that the genie came back
and killed my master instead!””27
In this episode, the corporeality of shikigami is described to be in the physical
CHAPTER 4 Developments in Shikigami Narratives: From Augury to Assassin
8/15/2019 Spirit Servant Shikigami
73/124
CHAPTER 4. Developments in Shikigami Narratives: From Augury to Assassin ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
“corresponds exactly to the rise to ascendancy of the Fujiwara house and to the
regency of Fujiwara no Mototsune [藤原基経, 836-891], a fact which reveals that
political worries in Heian Japan were as if symbolically manifested in an increased
consciousness of the course of nature in relation to human affairs.” 29 In Grapard’s
description of this phenomenon, he explains that the “notable increase in records of
natural occurrences interpreted as heavenly warning or blessings is related to the
evolution of the goryō [御霊, vengeful spirits]30 belief system, and might be viewed
as a manifestation of popular criticism of governmental p