75
Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h 0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing magnetic field Jean-Philippe MIQUEU PhD student, University of Rennes 1 Advisors : Monique DAUGE, Nicolas RAYMOND 17 May 2016 Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (-ih+ A) 2 when h 0 17 May 2016 1 / 42

Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    6

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h → 0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles)

Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing magneticfield

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU

PhD student, University of Rennes 1Advisors : Monique DAUGE, Nicolas RAYMOND

17 May 2016

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 1 / 42

Page 2: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Summary Plan

1 Introduction

2 Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve

3 Quadratic cancellation of the magnetic field

4 Conclusion: analogies with waveguides

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 2 / 42

Page 3: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction

1 Introduction

2 Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve

3 Quadratic cancellation of the magnetic field

4 Conclusion: analogies with waveguides

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 3 / 42

Page 4: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction Physical motivations

Superconductivity

Levitation.avi

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 4 / 42

Page 5: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction The magnetic Laplacian

The aim: spectral analysis of the elliptic operator Ph,A,Ω = (−ih∇+ A)2

Ph,A,Ω = (−ih∇x + A(x))2 =

d∑j=1

(hDxj + Aj (x))2, Dxj = −i∂xj

Dimension: d = 2Ω ⊆ R2 open setA = (A1,A2) ∈ C∞(Ω,R2);h: the semiclassical parameterB = ∇× A: the magnetic field

If we develope...

(−ih∇+ A)2 = −h2∆ − 2ihA · ∇ − ih∇A + A2

... it looks like a Schrodinger operator −h2∆ +V ... without electric potential...

Magnetic Laplacian = Schrodinger operator with magnetic fieldWhy is it interesting?

1 Physical applications in surface superconductivity (Ginzburg-Landau functional)2 Different from the electric case(?)3 Some connections with waveguides(?)

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 5 / 42

Page 6: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction The magnetic Laplacian

The aim: spectral analysis of the elliptic operator Ph,A,Ω = (−ih∇+ A)2

Ph,A,Ω = (−ih∇x + A(x))2 =

d∑j=1

(hDxj + Aj (x))2, Dxj = −i∂xj

Dimension: d = 2Ω ⊆ R2 open setA = (A1,A2) ∈ C∞(Ω,R2);h: the semiclassical parameterB = ∇× A: the magnetic field

If we develope...

(−ih∇+ A)2 = −h2∆ − 2ihA · ∇ − ih∇A + A2

... it looks like a Schrodinger operator −h2∆ +V ... without electric potential...

Magnetic Laplacian = Schrodinger operator with magnetic field

Why is it interesting?1 Physical applications in surface superconductivity (Ginzburg-Landau functional)2 Different from the electric case(?)3 Some connections with waveguides(?)

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 5 / 42

Page 7: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction The magnetic Laplacian

The aim: spectral analysis of the elliptic operator Ph,A,Ω = (−ih∇+ A)2

Ph,A,Ω = (−ih∇x + A(x))2 =

d∑j=1

(hDxj + Aj (x))2, Dxj = −i∂xj

Dimension: d = 2Ω ⊆ R2 open setA = (A1,A2) ∈ C∞(Ω,R2);h: the semiclassical parameterB = ∇× A: the magnetic field

If we develope...

(−ih∇+ A)2 = −h2∆ − 2ihA · ∇ − ih∇A + A2

... it looks like a Schrodinger operator −h2∆ +V ... without electric potential...

Magnetic Laplacian = Schrodinger operator with magnetic fieldWhy is it interesting?

1 Physical applications in surface superconductivity (Ginzburg-Landau functional)2 Different from the electric case(?)3 Some connections with waveguides(?)

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 5 / 42

Page 8: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction A connection with (broken) waveguides

Existence of a bound state for an electric Laplacian...The Lu-Pan operator: the self-adjoint Neumann realization on R2

+ ofLLPθ = −∆ + Vθ, with Vθ(s, t) = t cos θ − s sin θ and θ ∈ (0, π)

Known result:For all θ ∈ (0, π) there exists an eigenvalue of LLP

θ below the essential spectrumwich equals [1,+∞).K. Lu, X.-B. Pan, Surface nucleation of superconductivity in 3-dimensions. (1998).

B. Helffer, A. Morame, Magnetic bottles for the Neumann problem: the caseof dimension 3. (2002).

Figure : First eigenfunction of LLPθ for θ ∈ kπ

2 , k ∈ 0.9, 0.85, 0.8, 0.7

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 6 / 42

Page 9: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction A connection with (broken) waveguides

Existence of a bound state for an electric Laplacian...The Lu-Pan operator: the self-adjoint Neumann realization on R2

+ ofLLPθ = −∆ + Vθ, with Vθ(s, t) = t cos θ − s sin θ and θ ∈ (0, π)

Known result:For all θ ∈ (0, π) there exists an eigenvalue of LLP

θ below the essential spectrumwich equals [1,+∞).K. Lu, X.-B. Pan, Surface nucleation of superconductivity in 3-dimensions. (1998).

B. Helffer, A. Morame, Magnetic bottles for the Neumann problem: the caseof dimension 3. (2002).

Figure : First eigenfunction of LLPθ for θ ∈ kπ

2 , k ∈ 0.9, 0.85, 0.8, 0.7

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 6 / 42

Page 10: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction A connection with (broken) waveguides

Existence of a bound state for an electric Laplacian...The Lu-Pan operator: the self-adjoint Neumann realization on R2

+ ofLLPθ = −∆ + Vθ, with Vθ(s, t) = t cos θ − s sin θ and θ ∈ (0, π)

Known result:For all θ ∈ (0, π) there exists an eigenvalue of LLP

θ below the essential spectrumwich equals [1,+∞).K. Lu, X.-B. Pan, Surface nucleation of superconductivity in 3-dimensions. (1998).

B. Helffer, A. Morame, Magnetic bottles for the Neumann problem: the caseof dimension 3. (2002).

Figure : First eigenfunction of LLPθ for θ ∈ kπ

2 , k ∈ 0.9, 0.85, 0.8, 0.7Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 6 / 42

Page 11: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction A connection with (broken) waveguides

... recall Duclos and Exner’s result

Waveguide of width ε > 0 in 2D: Φ(s, t) = γ(s) + tn(s), (s, t) ∈ R× (−ε, ε)

Known result:For a waveguide straight at infinity but not everywhere, there is always an eigen-value below the essential spectrum cross section (in the case of a circular crosssection in dimensions two and three).

P. Duclos, P. Exner, Curvature-induced bound states in quantum waveguides intwo and three dimensions. (1995).

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 7 / 42

Page 12: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction A connection with (broken) waveguides

... recall Duclos and Exner’s result

Waveguide of width ε > 0 in 2D: Φ(s, t) = γ(s) + tn(s), (s, t) ∈ R× (−ε, ε)

Known result:For a waveguide straight at infinity but not everywhere, there is always an eigen-value below the essential spectrum cross section (in the case of a circular crosssection in dimensions two and three).

P. Duclos, P. Exner, Curvature-induced bound states in quantum waveguides intwo and three dimensions. (1995).

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 7 / 42

Page 13: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction A connection with (broken) waveguides

Magnetic waveguides

Waveguide: a tube Ωε ⊆ Rd about an unbounded curve γd: dimension ≥ 2ε > 0 shrinking parameterεω: the crosssection with ω ⊂ Rd−1 bounded and simply connected

Spectral analysis of the magnetic operator L[d]ε,bA with Dirichlet boundary :

L[d]ε,bA = (−i∇x + bA(x))2 on L2(Ωε,dx), b > 0

What is the spectral influence of a magnetic field on a waveguide?

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 8 / 42

Page 14: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction A connection with (broken) waveguides

Magnetic waveguides

Waveguide: a tube Ωε ⊆ Rd about an unbounded curve γd: dimension ≥ 2ε > 0 shrinking parameterεω: the crosssection with ω ⊂ Rd−1 bounded and simply connected

Spectral analysis of the magnetic operator L[d]ε,bA with Dirichlet boundary :

L[d]ε,bA = (−i∇x + bA(x))2 on L2(Ωε,dx), b > 0

What is the spectral influence of a magnetic field on a waveguide?

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 8 / 42

Page 15: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction A connection with (broken) waveguides

Magnetic waveguides

Waveguide: a tube Ωε ⊆ Rd about an unbounded curve γd: dimension ≥ 2ε > 0 shrinking parameterεω: the crosssection with ω ⊂ Rd−1 bounded and simply connected

Spectral analysis of the magnetic operator L[d]ε,bA with Dirichlet boundary :

L[d]ε,bA = (−i∇x + bA(x))2 on L2(Ωε,dx), b > 0

What is the spectral influence of a magnetic field on a waveguide?

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 8 / 42

Page 16: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction Framework

Spectral framework: Ω bounded, simply connected, with smooth boundary

We consider a self-adjoint realization of Ph,A,Ω which is the Friedrichsextension of the quadratic form:

C∞(Ω,C) 3 u 7→ Qh,A,Ω =

∫Ω

|(−ih∇+ A)u|2 dx

whose form domain V is: V = H1(Ω).

Domain of Ph,A,Ω: u ∈ H2(Ω), (−ih∇+ A)u · n = 0 on ∂Ω︸ ︷︷ ︸Neumann magnetic boundary condition

Spectrum of Ph,A,Ω : (λn(h))n∈N∗ = λ1(h) ≤ λ2(h) ≤ · · · ⊆ R+, discrete

Problematic: behaviour of the eigenvalues and the eigenfunctions when h→ 0

(λn(h), ψn,h) ∼h→0

?

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 9 / 42

Page 17: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction Framework

Spectral framework: Ω bounded, simply connected, with smooth boundary

We consider a self-adjoint realization of Ph,A,Ω which is the Friedrichsextension of the quadratic form:

C∞(Ω,C) 3 u 7→ Qh,A,Ω =

∫Ω

|(−ih∇+ A)u|2 dx

whose form domain V is: V = H1(Ω).

Domain of Ph,A,Ω: u ∈ H2(Ω), (−ih∇+ A)u · n = 0 on ∂Ω︸ ︷︷ ︸Neumann magnetic boundary condition

Spectrum of Ph,A,Ω : (λn(h))n∈N∗ = λ1(h) ≤ λ2(h) ≤ · · · ⊆ R+, discrete

Problematic: behaviour of the eigenvalues and the eigenfunctions when h→ 0

(λn(h), ψn,h) ∼h→0

?

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 9 / 42

Page 18: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction Framework

Spectral framework: Ω bounded, simply connected, with smooth boundary

We consider a self-adjoint realization of Ph,A,Ω which is the Friedrichsextension of the quadratic form:

C∞(Ω,C) 3 u 7→ Qh,A,Ω =

∫Ω

|(−ih∇+ A)u|2 dx

whose form domain V is: V = H1(Ω).

Domain of Ph,A,Ω: u ∈ H2(Ω), (−ih∇+ A)u · n = 0 on ∂Ω︸ ︷︷ ︸Neumann magnetic boundary condition

Spectrum of Ph,A,Ω : (λn(h))n∈N∗ = λ1(h) ≤ λ2(h) ≤ · · · ⊆ R+, discrete

Problematic: behaviour of the eigenvalues and the eigenfunctions when h→ 0

(λn(h), ψn,h) ∼h→0

?

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 9 / 42

Page 19: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction Framework

Spectral framework: Ω bounded, simply connected, with smooth boundary

We consider a self-adjoint realization of Ph,A,Ω which is the Friedrichsextension of the quadratic form:

C∞(Ω,C) 3 u 7→ Qh,A,Ω =

∫Ω

|(−ih∇+ A)u|2 dx

whose form domain V is: V = H1(Ω).

Domain of Ph,A,Ω: u ∈ H2(Ω), (−ih∇+ A)u · n = 0 on ∂Ω︸ ︷︷ ︸Neumann magnetic boundary condition

Spectrum of Ph,A,Ω : (λn(h))n∈N∗ = λ1(h) ≤ λ2(h) ≤ · · · ⊆ R+, discrete

Problematic: behaviour of the eigenvalues and the eigenfunctions when h→ 0

(λn(h), ψn,h) ∼h→0

?

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 9 / 42

Page 20: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction Framework

Spectral framework: Ω bounded, simply connected, with smooth boundary

We consider a self-adjoint realization of Ph,A,Ω which is the Friedrichsextension of the quadratic form:

C∞(Ω,C) 3 u 7→ Qh,A,Ω =

∫Ω

|(−ih∇+ A)u|2 dx

whose form domain V is: V = H1(Ω).

Domain of Ph,A,Ω: u ∈ H2(Ω), (−ih∇+ A)u · n = 0 on ∂Ω︸ ︷︷ ︸Neumann magnetic boundary condition

Spectrum of Ph,A,Ω : (λn(h))n∈N∗ = λ1(h) ≤ λ2(h) ≤ · · · ⊆ R+, discrete

Problematic: behaviour of the eigenvalues and the eigenfunctions when h→ 0

(λn(h), ψn,h) ∼h→0

?

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 9 / 42

Page 21: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction References

Literature

S. Fournais, B. Helffer, Spectral methods in Surface Superconductivity,Progress in Nonlinear Differential Equations and their Applications, 77, BirkhauserBoston Inc., Boston, MA, 2010.

N. Raymond, Little Magnetic Book. Preprint, 2016.

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 10 / 42

Page 22: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction References

Non vanishing magnetic field:Constant magnetic field B ≡ 1:

Bolley, Helffer (1997), Bauman-Phillips-Tang (1998), del Pino, Felmer, Sternberg(2000), (2D, disc),Helffer, Morame (2001), (2D, smooth boundary),Helffer, Morame (2004), (3D, smooth boundary),Bonnaillie (2005), (2D, corners),Fournais, Persson (2011), (3D, balls).

Non vanishing and variable magnetic field B:Lu, Pan (1999) ; Raymond (2009) (2D, smooth boundary),Lu, Pan (2000) ; Raymond (2010) ; Helffer, Kordyukov (2013), (3D, smoothboundary),Bonnaillie-Noel (2005), Bonnaillie-Noel, Dauge (2006), Bonnaillie-Noel, Fournais(2007), (2D, corners),Bonnaillie-Noel, Dauge, N. Popoff (2016), (3D, corners).

Vanishing magnetic field:Montgomery (1995), (the first case when the model of cancellation appears),Helffer, Morame (1996) (behaviour of the ground state in hypersurface),Pan, Kwek (2002), (2D, Neumann boundary condition),Helffer, Kordyukov (2009), (hypersurface),Dombrowski, Raymond (2013), (cancellation along a closed and smooth curve inthe whole plane),Bonnaillie-Noel, Raymond (2015), (broken line of cancellation inside Ω, Neumannboundary condition),Attar, Helffer, Kachmar (2015), (minimizing of the energy when theGinzburg-Landau parameter tends to infinity, Neumann boundary condition).

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 11 / 42

Page 23: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction References

Non vanishing magnetic field:Constant magnetic field B ≡ 1:

Bolley, Helffer (1997), Bauman-Phillips-Tang (1998), del Pino, Felmer, Sternberg(2000), (2D, disc),Helffer, Morame (2001), (2D, smooth boundary),Helffer, Morame (2004), (3D, smooth boundary),Bonnaillie (2005), (2D, corners),Fournais, Persson (2011), (3D, balls).

Non vanishing and variable magnetic field B:Lu, Pan (1999) ; Raymond (2009) (2D, smooth boundary),Lu, Pan (2000) ; Raymond (2010) ; Helffer, Kordyukov (2013), (3D, smoothboundary),Bonnaillie-Noel (2005), Bonnaillie-Noel, Dauge (2006), Bonnaillie-Noel, Fournais(2007), (2D, corners),Bonnaillie-Noel, Dauge, N. Popoff (2016), (3D, corners).

Vanishing magnetic field:Montgomery (1995), (the first case when the model of cancellation appears),Helffer, Morame (1996) (behaviour of the ground state in hypersurface),Pan, Kwek (2002), (2D, Neumann boundary condition),Helffer, Kordyukov (2009), (hypersurface),Dombrowski, Raymond (2013), (cancellation along a closed and smooth curve inthe whole plane),Bonnaillie-Noel, Raymond (2015), (broken line of cancellation inside Ω, Neumannboundary condition),Attar, Helffer, Kachmar (2015), (minimizing of the energy when theGinzburg-Landau parameter tends to infinity, Neumann boundary condition).

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 11 / 42

Page 24: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Introduction Interest of vanishing magnetic field

Why considering vanishing magnetic fields?

Mathematical reasons: analyze the spectral influence of the cancellation of themagnetic field in the semiclassical limit.Study of “magnetic waveguides”:

N. Dombrowski, F. Germinet, G. Raikov, Quantization of edge currentsalong magnetic barriers and magnetic guides. (2011).

... inspired by the physical considerations:

J. Reijniers, , A. Matulis, K. Chang, F. Peeters, Confined magneticguiding orbit states. (2002).

M. Hara, A. Endo, S. Katsumoto, Y. Iye, Transport in two-dimensionalelectron gas narrow channel with a magnetic field gradients. (2004).

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 12 / 42

Page 25: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve

1 Introduction

2 Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve

3 Quadratic cancellation of the magnetic field

4 Conclusion: analogies with waveguides

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 13 / 42

Page 26: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Assumptions

Γ Ω

Figure : Domain Ω and the (smooth) vanishing curve Γ.

Assumptions:] (Γ ∩ ∂Ω) <∞ and Γ is non tangent to ∂Ω

|∇B(x)| 6= 0, ∀ x ∈ Γ

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 14 / 42

Page 27: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Localisation phenomena : concentration of the modes when h→ 0

Ground state g1 of the electric Laplacian −h2∆ + |x|2 in R2:

g1(x) =1√h

exp(−|x|

2

2h

), h =

15

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 15 / 42

Page 28: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Localisation phenomena : concentration of the modes when h→ 0

Ground state g1 of the electric Laplacian −h2∆ + |x|2 in R2:

g1(x) =1√h

exp(−|x|

2

2h

), h =

110

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 15 / 42

Page 29: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Localisation phenomena : concentration of the modes when h→ 0

Ground state g1 of the electric Laplacian −h2∆ + |x|2 in R2:

g1(x) =1√h

exp(−|x|

2

2h

), h =

120

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 15 / 42

Page 30: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Localisation phenomena : concentration of the modes when h→ 0

Ground state g1 of the electric Laplacian −h2∆ + |x|2 in R2:

g1(x) =1√h

exp(−|x|

2

2h

), h =

140

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 15 / 42

Page 31: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Localisation phenomena : concentration of the modes when h→ 0

Ground state g1 of the electric Laplacian −h2∆ + |x|2 in R2:

g1(x) =1√h

exp(−|x|

2

2h

), h =

180

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 15 / 42

Page 32: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Where does the first eigenfunction(s) localize in the semiclassical limit?

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 16 / 42

Page 33: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Different ”areas” on Ω

(1) Ω\Γ

(2) ∂Ω\Γ

(3) Γ\∂Ω

(4) ∂Ω ∩ Γ Ωx(1)j

x(1)j

Ωx(2)j

x(2)j Ωx(3)

j

x(3)j

Ωx(4)j

x(4)j

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 17 / 42

Page 34: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

”Zoom” on areas

1 Localisation:

x = Φ(s, t)2 Change of variable ⇒ Flat geometry:

s

t

(0, 0)3 Scaling: X − xj =

x−xjhβ

σ

τ

(0, 0)4 Approximation on the whole (half) space + Linearisation :

Ph,A,Ωxj∼

h→0hpP1,Amod,R2

(+)

”Ph,A,Ω ∼h→0Ph,A,Ω

x(1)j

⊕Ph,A,Ωx(2)j

⊕Ph,A,Ωx(3)j

⊕Ph,A,Ωx(4)j

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 18 / 42

Page 35: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

”Zoom” on areas1 Localisation:

x = Φ(s, t)

2 Change of variable ⇒ Flat geometry:

s

t

(0, 0)3 Scaling: X − xj =

x−xjhβ

σ

τ

(0, 0)4 Approximation on the whole (half) space + Linearisation :

Ph,A,Ωxj∼

h→0hpP1,Amod,R2

(+)

”Ph,A,Ω ∼h→0Ph,A,Ω

x(1)j

⊕Ph,A,Ωx(2)j

⊕Ph,A,Ωx(3)j

⊕Ph,A,Ωx(4)j

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 18 / 42

Page 36: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

”Zoom” on areas1 Localisation:

x = Φ(s, t)2 Change of variable ⇒ Flat geometry:

s

t

(0, 0)

3 Scaling: X − xj =x−xjhβ

σ

τ

(0, 0)4 Approximation on the whole (half) space + Linearisation :

Ph,A,Ωxj∼

h→0hpP1,Amod,R2

(+)

”Ph,A,Ω ∼h→0Ph,A,Ω

x(1)j

⊕Ph,A,Ωx(2)j

⊕Ph,A,Ωx(3)j

⊕Ph,A,Ωx(4)j

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 18 / 42

Page 37: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

”Zoom” on areas1 Localisation:

x = Φ(s, t)2 Change of variable ⇒ Flat geometry:

s

t

(0, 0)3 Scaling: X − xj =

x−xjhβ

σ

τ

(0, 0)

4 Approximation on the whole (half) space + Linearisation :

Ph,A,Ωxj∼

h→0hpP1,Amod,R2

(+)

”Ph,A,Ω ∼h→0Ph,A,Ω

x(1)j

⊕Ph,A,Ωx(2)j

⊕Ph,A,Ωx(3)j

⊕Ph,A,Ωx(4)j

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 18 / 42

Page 38: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

”Zoom” on areas1 Localisation:

x = Φ(s, t)2 Change of variable ⇒ Flat geometry:

s

t

(0, 0)3 Scaling: X − xj =

x−xjhβ

σ

τ

(0, 0)4 Approximation on the whole (half) space + Linearisation :

Ph,A,Ωxj∼

h→0hpP1,Amod,R2

(+)

”Ph,A,Ω ∼h→0Ph,A,Ω

x(1)j

⊕Ph,A,Ωx(2)j

⊕Ph,A,Ωx(3)j

⊕Ph,A,Ωx(4)j

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 18 / 42

Page 39: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Model operator and operator of referenceY

Xx(1)

j

The magnetic Laplacian P1,A,R2 ( h = 1 ) in the model case when B ≡ 1:

D2Y + (DX − Y )2

By unitary transforms we are reduced to the harmonic oscillator:

H = D2Y + Y 2, on R

Bottom of the spectrum of the operator H:

inf Sp(H) = 1

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 19 / 42

Page 40: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Model operator and operator of referenceY

Xx(1)

j

The magnetic Laplacian P1,A,R2 ( h = 1 ) in the model case when B ≡ 1:

D2Y + (DX − Y )2

By unitary transforms we are reduced to the harmonic oscillator:

H = D2Y + Y 2, on R

Bottom of the spectrum of the operator H:

inf Sp(H) = 1

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 19 / 42

Page 41: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Model operator and operator of referenceY

Xx(1)

j

The magnetic Laplacian P1,A,R2 ( h = 1 ) in the model case when B ≡ 1:

D2Y + (DX − Y )2

By unitary transforms we are reduced to the harmonic oscillator:

H = D2Y + Y 2, on R

Bottom of the spectrum of the operator H:

inf Sp(H) = 1

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 19 / 42

Page 42: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Model operator and operator of reference

τ

σ

x(2)j

The magnetic Laplacian P1,A,R2+

( h = 1 ) in the model case when B ≡ 1:

D2τ + (Dσ − τ)2

By unitary transforms we are reduced to the De Gennes operator:

G(ξ) = D2τ + (τ − ξ)2 on R+, Neuman boundary condition

Bottom of the spectrum of the operator G(ξ):

µ1(ξ)= inf Sp(G(ξ))

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 20 / 42

Page 43: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Model operator and operator of reference

τ

σ

x(2)j

The magnetic Laplacian P1,A,R2+

( h = 1 ) in the model case when B ≡ 1:

D2τ + (Dσ − τ)2

By unitary transforms we are reduced to the De Gennes operator:

G(ξ) = D2τ + (τ − ξ)2 on R+, Neuman boundary condition

Bottom of the spectrum of the operator G(ξ):

µ1(ξ)= inf Sp(G(ξ))

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 20 / 42

Page 44: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Model operator and operator of reference

τ

σ

x(2)j

The magnetic Laplacian P1,A,R2+

( h = 1 ) in the model case when B ≡ 1:

D2τ + (Dσ − τ)2

By unitary transforms we are reduced to the De Gennes operator:

G(ξ) = D2τ + (τ − ξ)2 on R+, Neuman boundary condition

Bottom of the spectrum of the operator G(ξ):

µ1(ξ)= inf Sp(G(ξ))

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 20 / 42

Page 45: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Model operator and operator of reference

σ

τ

x(3)j

The magnetic Laplacian P1,A,R2 ( h = 1 ) in the model case when B(σ, τ) = τ :

D2τ +

(Dσ −

τ 2

2

)2

By unitary transforms we are reduced to the Montgomery operator:

M(η) = D2τ +

(τ 2

2 − η)2

on R

Bottom of the spectrum of the operator M(η):

ν1(η) = inf Sp(M(η))

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 21 / 42

Page 46: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Model operator and operator of reference

σ

τ

x(3)j

The magnetic Laplacian P1,A,R2 ( h = 1 ) in the model case when B(σ, τ) = τ :

D2τ +

(Dσ −

τ 2

2

)2

By unitary transforms we are reduced to the Montgomery operator:

M(η) = D2τ +

(τ 2

2 − η)2

on R

Bottom of the spectrum of the operator M(η):

ν1(η) = inf Sp(M(η))

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 21 / 42

Page 47: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Model operator and operator of reference

σ

τ

x(3)j

The magnetic Laplacian P1,A,R2 ( h = 1 ) in the model case when B(σ, τ) = τ :

D2τ +

(Dσ −

τ 2

2

)2

By unitary transforms we are reduced to the Montgomery operator:

M(η) = D2τ +

(τ 2

2 − η)2

on R

Bottom of the spectrum of the operator M(η):

ν1(η) = inf Sp(M(η))

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 21 / 42

Page 48: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Model operator and operator of referenceτ

σθ

x(4)j

The magnetic Laplacian P1,A,R2+

( h = 1 ) in the model case when:

B(σ, τ) = τ cos θ − σ sin θ.

We get the Pan and Kwek operator:

Kθ = D2τ +

(Dσ + στ sin θ − τ 2

2 cos θ)2

on R2+, Neumann boundary condition

Bottom of the spectrum of the operator Kθ:

inf Sp(Kθ) = ζθ1

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 22 / 42

Page 49: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Model operator and operator of referenceτ

σθ

x(4)j

The magnetic Laplacian P1,A,R2+

( h = 1 ) in the model case when:

B(σ, τ) = τ cos θ − σ sin θ.

We get the Pan and Kwek operator:

Kθ = D2τ +

(Dσ + στ sin θ − τ 2

2 cos θ)2

on R2+, Neumann boundary condition

Bottom of the spectrum of the operator Kθ:

inf Sp(Kθ) = ζθ1

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 22 / 42

Page 50: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Model operator and operator of referenceτ

σθ

x(4)j

The magnetic Laplacian P1,A,R2+

( h = 1 ) in the model case when:

B(σ, τ) = τ cos θ − σ sin θ.

We get the Pan and Kwek operator:

Kθ = D2τ +

(Dσ + στ sin θ − τ 2

2 cos θ)2

on R2+, Neumann boundary condition

Bottom of the spectrum of the operator Kθ:

inf Sp(Kθ) = ζθ1

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 22 / 42

Page 51: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Properties of the Pan and Kwek operator

Proposition:

inf Spess(Kθ) = M0 = inf SpessP1,A,R2

Proposition:

ζ01 = ζπ1 = M0

ζθ1 < M0, for all θ ∈ (0, π)

X.-B. Pan, K.-H. Kwek, Schrodinger operators with non-degenerately vanishingmagnetic fields in bounded domains. (2002).

Proposition:For all θ ∈ (0, π), ζθ1 is a eigenvalue and the associated eigenfunctions belong toS (R2

+).

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 23 / 42

Page 52: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Case Operator of reference Infimum of the spectrum

(1)H = D2

Y + Y 2

on R1

(2)G(ξ) = D2

τ + (τ − ξ)2

on R+ with Neumann boundary conditioninfξ∈R

(µ1(ξ)) = Θ0

(3)M(η) = D2

τ +(τ2

2 − η)2

on Rinfη∈R

(ν1(η)) = M0

(4)Kθ = D2

τ +(

Dσ + στ sin θ − τ2

2 cos θ)2

on R2+ with Neumann boundary condition

ζθ1

Numerical computations:Θ0 = µ1 (ξ0) ≈ 0.5901, with ξ0 =

√Θ0 ≈ 0.7682

M0 = ν1 (η0) ≈ 0.5698, with η0 ≈ 0.35

ζπ2

1 ≈ 0.5494

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 24 / 42

Page 53: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Heuristic about the rule of model operators

Back to the operator Ph,A,Ω: summary of the operator hierarchy

x(`)j ∈ Ω\Γ, ∂Ω\Γ, Γ\∂Ω, ∂Ω ∩ Γ

Case (`) Operator h dependantScaling

β, hp , R2(+)

Infimum of

the spectrum

(1)h2D2

y + (hDy − |B(x(1)j )|y)2

on R2

12 , h, R2 1|B(x(1)

j )|h

(2)h2D2

t + (hDs − |B(x(2)j )|t)2

on R2+ with Neumann boundary condition

12 , h, R2

+ Θ0|B(x(2)j )|h

(3)h2D2

t +(

hDs − |∇B(x(3)j )| t

2

2

)2

on R2

13 , h4/3, R2 M0|∇B(x(3)

j )|23 h 4

3

(4)h2D2

t +(

hDs + |∇B(x(4)j )|

(st sin θ(x(4)

j )− t2

2 cos θ(x(4)j )))2

on R2+ with Neumann boundary condition

13 , h4/3, R2

+ ζθ(x(4)

j )

1 |∇B(x(4)j )|

23 h 4

3

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 25 / 42

Page 54: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Statement of a (weak) result

Approximation of the bottom of the spectrum of Ph,A,Ω when h→ 0

Theorem:Under the condition

infx∈∂Ω∩Γ

ζθ(x)1 |∇B(x)|2/3 < M0 inf

x∈Ω∩Γ|∇B(x)|2/3

we have two results:1 Equivalent of the first eigenvalue

λ1(h) = h4/3 infx∈∂Ω∩Γ

ζθ(x)1 |∇B(x)|2/3 +O(h5/3).

2 Exponential concentration of the first eigenvectorThere exist C > 0, α > 0, h0 > 0, s. t. for all h ∈ (0, h0)∫

Ω

e2αh−1/3d(x,∂Ω ∩ Γ)|ψ1,h(x)|2 dx ≤ C‖ψ1,h‖2L2(Ω).

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 26 / 42

Page 55: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Numerical simulations

Computation of the first ten eigenvalues for decreasing values of h

Figure : First ten eigenvalues λn(h) rescaled by h−4/3 according to 1h ∈ [20, 150], B(s, t) = s,

Ω = [− 32 ,

32 ]× [−1, 1]. Finite elements, 24× 16 quadrangular elements, Q10.

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 27 / 42

Page 56: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Numerical simulations

First ten eigenmodes in modulus, h = 1150

(1) 0.5370 (2) 0.5812 (3) 0.7905 (4) 1.1004 (5) 1.4603

(6) 1.4728 (7) 1.4750 (8) 1.7237 (9) 1.7738 (10) 1.8811

Figure : Modulus of ψn,h and numerical value of λn(h)h−4/3. Finite elements, 24× 16quadrangular elements, Q10.

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 28 / 42

Page 57: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve Numerical simulations

Phase of the first ten eigenmodes, h = 1150 : high oscillations in 1

h

(1) 0.5370 (2) 0.5812 (3) 0.7905 (4) 1.1004 (5) 1.4603

(6) 1.4728 (7) 1.4750 (8) 1.7237 (9) 1.7738 (10) 1.8811

Figure : Argument of ψn,h and numerical value of λn(h)h−4/3. Finite elements, 24× 16quadrangular elements, degree Q10.

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 29 / 42

Page 58: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Quadratic cancellation of the magnetic field

1 Introduction

2 Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve

3 Quadratic cancellation of the magnetic field

4 Conclusion: analogies with waveguides

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 30 / 42

Page 59: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Quadratic cancellation of the magnetic field Assumptions

Γ

Ωx0ϑ(x0)

Figure : Domain Ω and the (smooth) vanishing curve Γ.

Assumptions:] (Γ ∩ ∂Ω) <∞ and Γ is non tangent to ∂Ω

∃!x0 ∈ Γ\∂Ω with |∇B(x0)| = 0|∇B(x)| 6= 0, ∀ x ∈ Γ\x0Hessx0 B 6= 0 and ϑ(x0) ∈ (0, π)

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 31 / 42

Page 60: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Quadratic cancellation of the magnetic field The model operator

s

t

ϑ = 2 tan ε

The magnetic Laplacian P1,A,R2 ( h = 1 ) in the model case when B(σ, τ) = t2 − ε2s2:

Xε = D2τ +

(Dσ + ε2σ2τ − τ 3

3

)2

Spectrum of Xε : (κn(ε))n∈N∗ = κ1(ε) ≤ κ2(ε) ≤ · · · ⊆ R+, discrete

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 32 / 42

Page 61: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Quadratic cancellation of the magnetic field Statement of a (weak) result

Approximation of the bottom of the spectrum of Ph,A,Ω when h→ 0

Theorem:We have:

1 Equivalent of the first eigenvalue

λ1(h) = CB0 h3/2 +O(h7/4),

where CB0 =Ξ(x0)1/2κ(ε(x0)) with Ξ(x) =

√trt HessB(x)HessB(x)

2√ε(x)4+1

and ε(x0) givenby ϑ(x0) = 2 tan ε(x0).

2 Exponential concentration of the first eigenvectorThere exist C > 0, α > 0 and h0 > 0, s. t. for all h ∈ (0, h0),∫

Ω

e2αh−1/4d(x,x0)|ψ1,h(x)|2 dx ≤ C‖ψ1,h‖2L2(Ω).

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 33 / 42

Page 62: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Quadratic cancellation of the magnetic field The small angle limit : partial semiclassical problem

Numerical simulations: bottom of the spectrum of the symbol Xα,ξ of Xε

Xα,ξ = D2τ +

(ξ + α2τ − τ 3

3

)2

, in R

Figure : The ”band function” %1(α, ξ) = inf(α,ξ)∈R2

Sp(

Xα,ξ)

ξ

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 34 / 42

Page 63: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Quadratic cancellation of the magnetic field The small angle limit : partial semiclassical problem

Numerical simulations: first mode

k = 1 k = 2 k = 3 k = 4 k = 5

k = 6 k = 7 k = 8 k = 9 k = 10

Figure : Modulus of the first mode ψn,h, for ε =

(1√2

)k. Finite elements, 48× 6 quadrangular

elements, degree Q10.

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 35 / 42

Page 64: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Quadratic cancellation of the magnetic field The small angle limit : partial semiclassical problem

Approximation of the bottom of the spectrum of Xε when ε→ 0

Theorem:

1 Existence of the minimum for the operator symbolThere exist (α0, ξ0) in a compact set of R2 s. t.

%1(α0, ξ0) = min(α,ξ)∈R2

%1(α, ξ).

2 Equivalent for the bottom of the spectrumFor all n ≥ 1 such that κn(ε) = O(ε0), there exist C > 0 and h0 > 0 s. t.for all h ∈ (0, h0)

|κn(ε)− %1(α0, ξ0)| ≤ Cε.

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 36 / 42

Page 65: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Conclusion: analogies with waveguides

1 Introduction

2 Magnetic field vanishing along a smooth and simple curve

3 Quadratic cancellation of the magnetic field

4 Conclusion: analogies with waveguides

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 37 / 42

Page 66: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Conclusion: analogies with waveguides The zeros locus (when h → 0) plays the rule of a waveguide

(Broken) Montgomery operator... recall (again) Duclos and Exner’s result

Straight line of cancellation on the whole plane:D2τ +

(Dσ + στ sin θ − τ2

2 cos θ)2

has essential spectrum.

Straight line of cancellation on the half-plane with Neumann boundarycondition:D2τ +

(Dσ + στ sin θ − τ2

2 cos θ)2

has at least one eigenvalue ∀θ ∈ (0, π).

Broken line of cancellation on the whole plane:D2τ +

(Dσ + στ sin θ + sgn(t) τ

2

2 cos θ)2.

Numerical conjecture:There exists θ0 ∈ (π4 ,

π2 ) s. t. the firt Rayleigh quotient is equal to the infimum of

the essential spectrum (M0) for all θ ∈ [θ0,π2 ) and strictly less for all θ ∈ (0, θ0).

V. Bonnaillie-Noel, N. Raymond, Breaking a magnetic zero locus: modeloperators and numerical approach. (2015).

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 38 / 42

Page 67: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Conclusion: analogies with waveguides The zeros locus (when h → 0) plays the rule of a waveguide

(Broken) Montgomery operator... recall (again) Duclos and Exner’s result

Straight line of cancellation on the whole plane:D2τ +

(Dσ + στ sin θ − τ2

2 cos θ)2

has essential spectrum.

Straight line of cancellation on the half-plane with Neumann boundarycondition:D2τ +

(Dσ + στ sin θ − τ2

2 cos θ)2

has at least one eigenvalue ∀θ ∈ (0, π).

Broken line of cancellation on the whole plane:D2τ +

(Dσ + στ sin θ + sgn(t) τ

2

2 cos θ)2.

Numerical conjecture:There exists θ0 ∈ (π4 ,

π2 ) s. t. the firt Rayleigh quotient is equal to the infimum of

the essential spectrum (M0) for all θ ∈ [θ0,π2 ) and strictly less for all θ ∈ (0, θ0).

V. Bonnaillie-Noel, N. Raymond, Breaking a magnetic zero locus: modeloperators and numerical approach. (2015).

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 38 / 42

Page 68: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Conclusion: analogies with waveguides The zeros locus (when h → 0) plays the rule of a waveguide

(Broken) Montgomery operator... recall (again) Duclos and Exner’s result

Straight line of cancellation on the whole plane:D2τ +

(Dσ + στ sin θ − τ2

2 cos θ)2

has essential spectrum.

Straight line of cancellation on the half-plane with Neumann boundarycondition:D2τ +

(Dσ + στ sin θ − τ2

2 cos θ)2

has at least one eigenvalue ∀θ ∈ (0, π).

Broken line of cancellation on the whole plane:D2τ +

(Dσ + στ sin θ + sgn(t) τ

2

2 cos θ)2.

Numerical conjecture:There exists θ0 ∈ (π4 ,

π2 ) s. t. the firt Rayleigh quotient is equal to the infimum of

the essential spectrum (M0) for all θ ∈ [θ0,π2 ) and strictly less for all θ ∈ (0, θ0).

V. Bonnaillie-Noel, N. Raymond, Breaking a magnetic zero locus: modeloperators and numerical approach. (2015).

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 38 / 42

Page 69: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Conclusion: analogies with waveguides The zeros locus (when h → 0) plays the rule of a waveguide

(Broken) Montgomery operator... recall (again) Duclos and Exner’s result

Straight line of cancellation on the whole plane:D2τ +

(Dσ + στ sin θ − τ2

2 cos θ)2

has essential spectrum.

Straight line of cancellation on the half-plane with Neumann boundarycondition:D2τ +

(Dσ + στ sin θ − τ2

2 cos θ)2

has at least one eigenvalue ∀θ ∈ (0, π).

Broken line of cancellation on the whole plane:D2τ +

(Dσ + στ sin θ + sgn(t) τ

2

2 cos θ)2.

Numerical conjecture:There exists θ0 ∈ (π4 ,

π2 ) s. t. the firt Rayleigh quotient is equal to the infimum of

the essential spectrum (M0) for all θ ∈ [θ0,π2 ) and strictly less for all θ ∈ (0, θ0).

V. Bonnaillie-Noel, N. Raymond, Breaking a magnetic zero locus: modeloperators and numerical approach. (2015).

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 38 / 42

Page 70: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Conclusion: analogies with waveguides The magnetic field in 2D acts as the torsion in 3D

Limit ε→ 0 for the Dirichlet Laplacian on the tube Ωε

The Dirichlet Laplacian in dimension 2:Known result:The Dirichlet Laplacian on the tube Ωε converges (in a suitable sense) to:

Leff = −∂2s −

κ(s)

4 on L2(γ, ds), (κ is the curvature).

P. Duclos, P. Exner, Curvature-induced bound states in quantumwaveguides in two and three dimensions. (1995).

The Dirichlet Laplacian in twisted waveguide in dimension 3:Known result:The Dirichlet Laplacian on the tube Ωε converges (in a suitable sense) to:

Leff = −∂2s −

κ(s)

4 +C(ω)θ′(s)2 on L2(γ, ds),

where θ is the angle function and C(ω) is a positive constant whenever ω is nota disk or annulus.

G. Bouchitte, M. L. Mascarenhas, L. Trabucho, On the curvature andtorsion effects inone dimensional waveguides. (2007).

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 39 / 42

Page 71: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Conclusion: analogies with waveguides The magnetic field in 2D acts as the torsion in 3D

Limit ε→ 0 for L[2]ε,bA = (−i∇x + bA(x))2on the tube Ωε, with b ∼ ε−1

L[2]ε,bA on L2(R× (−ε, ε),m(s, t)dsdt) ∼ L[2]

ε,bA on L2(R× (−ε, ε), dsdt)

∼ L[2]ε,bAε on L2(R× (−1, 1),dsdτ)

Known result:There exist K , ε0, C > 0 such that for all ε ∈ (0, ε0),∥∥∥∥(L[2]

ε,ε−1Aε− ε−2λDir

1 (ω) + K)−1−(Leff,[2]ε − ε−2λDir

1 (ω) + K)−1∥∥∥∥ ≤ Cε,

where λn(ω)Dir is the n-th eigenvalue of the Dirichlet Laplacian ∆Dirω on L2(ω),

andLeff,[2]ε = −ε−2∆Dir

ω + T [2] ,

T [2] = −∂2s −

κ(s)

4 +( 1

3 + 2π2

)B(γ(s))2 .

D. Krejcirık, N. Raymond, Magnetic effects in curved quantum waveguides.(2013).

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 40 / 42

Page 72: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Conclusion: analogies with waveguides The magnetic field in 2D acts as the torsion in 3D

Counting of eigenvalues?Known result:For all waveguide with corner, there is a finite number of eigenvalues below thethreshold of the essential spectrum.

M. Dauge, Y. Lafranche, N. Raymond, Quantum waveguides with corners.(2012).

Number of eigenvalue(s) of Kθ when θ → 0? Numerical answer:

Figure : Eigenvalues ζθn below the bottom of the essential spectrum, for θ ∈ kπ60 , 1 ≤ k ≤ 30

V. Bonnaillie-Noel, N. Raymond, Breaking a magnetic zero locus: modeloperators and numerical approach. (2015).

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 41 / 42

Page 73: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Conclusion: analogies with waveguides The magnetic field in 2D acts as the torsion in 3D

Counting of eigenvalues?Known result:For all waveguide with corner, there is a finite number of eigenvalues below thethreshold of the essential spectrum.

M. Dauge, Y. Lafranche, N. Raymond, Quantum waveguides with corners.(2012).

Number of eigenvalue(s) of Kθ when θ → 0?

Numerical answer:

Figure : Eigenvalues ζθn below the bottom of the essential spectrum, for θ ∈ kπ60 , 1 ≤ k ≤ 30

V. Bonnaillie-Noel, N. Raymond, Breaking a magnetic zero locus: modeloperators and numerical approach. (2015).

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 41 / 42

Page 74: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Conclusion: analogies with waveguides The magnetic field in 2D acts as the torsion in 3D

Counting of eigenvalues?Known result:For all waveguide with corner, there is a finite number of eigenvalues below thethreshold of the essential spectrum.

M. Dauge, Y. Lafranche, N. Raymond, Quantum waveguides with corners.(2012).

Number of eigenvalue(s) of Kθ when θ → 0? Numerical answer:

Figure : Eigenvalues ζθn below the bottom of the essential spectrum, for θ ∈ kπ60 , 1 ≤ k ≤ 30

V. Bonnaillie-Noel, N. Raymond, Breaking a magnetic zero locus: modeloperators and numerical approach. (2015).

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 41 / 42

Page 75: Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian with vanishing ... · Spectral analysis of the magnetic Laplacian when h →0 17 May 2016, Conference on waveguides (Porquerolles) Spectral

Conclusion: analogies with waveguides

Thank you!

Jean-Philippe MIQUEU (University of Rennes 1) Spectral analysis of (−ih∇ + A)2 when h → 0 17 May 2016 42 / 42