35
SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry Hugh Shaw The UK Secretary of State‟s Representative Maritime Salvage & Intervention BTA Annual Conference, Bristol 7 April, 2011

SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

  • Upload
    docong

  • View
    216

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug

Industry

Hugh ShawThe UK Secretary of State‟s Representative

Maritime Salvage & Intervention

BTA Annual Conference, Bristol7 April, 2011

Page 2: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

Key Milestones

Page 3: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

TORRY CANYON – 1967Intervention Convention [1969]

Page 4: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

AMOCO CADIZ - 1978

Page 5: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

BRAER – Shetland 1993

Page 7: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

SEA EMPRESS – 1996Introduction of the SOSREP (1999)

Page 8: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

Lord Donaldson‟s Review

1.The „Trigger‟ point is when there is “a threat of significant pollution” to the UK‟s pollution control zone, territorial waters or coastline;

2.Response to the threat of pollution from or involving an offshore installation to be compatible with same from shipping casualty

Page 9: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

Lord Donaldson‟s Review

3. MCA as a whole should play a much larger part in operations in response to a threat of significant pollution than has been the case in the past ;

4. Involvement of Ministers in Operational decisions is not a practicable option……

Page 10: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

Lord Donaldson‟s Review

There should be „ultimate‟ control of salvage by a

Secretary of State‟s Representative acting in the

overriding public interest

- SOSREP -

Page 11: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

The SOSREP Function

►One person to act as representative of

Secretary of State (s)

►Free to act without recourse to higher authority

►Ultimate & Decisive voice

►Can exercise Ultimate control

►Cannot choose to ignore a situation

►Tacitly approves all actions

►Whilst operations are in progress “Must be “Backed or sacked”

Page 12: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

Four Main Theatres of Activity

Search and rescue

„Salvage‟ - control and containment

of the cause of threat

Clean up at sea

Clean up of the shoreline

Page 13: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

ETV Contract Awarded to Klyne Tugs – 2001

Page 14: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

Coastguard Agreement for Salvage & Towage (CAST-2002)

Page 15: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

European ETV Deployment

Page 16: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

New Legislation

►The Offshore Installations [EPC] Regulations 2002

►Marine Safety Act 2003

- risk to safety

- persons in control of land + facilities

►EU Directives „SOSREP‟ Competent Authority for Places of Refuge‟

Page 17: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

Role of the SOSREP

To represent the Secretaries of State for Transport

and Department for Energy and Climate Changeby removing or reducing the risk to persons,property and the UK environment arising fromaccidents involving ships, fixed or floatingplatforms or sub-sea infrastructure within UKwaters, within the remainder of the UK PollutionControl Zone (UK PCZ) and on the UK ContinentalShelf.- Introduction to Maritime Counter Terrorism

Page 18: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

Dealing with an Incident –High Profile / Salvage

Page 19: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention
Page 20: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention
Page 21: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention
Page 23: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention
Page 24: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention
Page 25: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention
Page 26: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention
Page 28: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

Breakdowns & Intervention

Page 29: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

Existing Arrangements

►MCA DCPSO task ETV to proceed casualty

►Following risk assessment ETV Contractor permitted to seek commercial contract in competition with other tug operators/brokers

►SOSREP ability to direct Master to accept line. [IC, FC – Direction]

►SOSREP ability to request ETV to put line on board – seek payment via arbitration –Salvage Convention 1989

Page 30: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

Current ETV Capability

►24 hour availability

►Well practiced communications and exercises with UK Coastguard & French Prefecture Maritime

►Specialist expertise of the vessel‟s officers and crews.

►The importance of experienced and rehearsed team-work and co-ordinated action that is both safe yet able to take advantage of the precise moment when a connection can be made.

Page 31: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

►In the last twelve months alone the ETVs have played a major role not just in salvage but also in fire-fighting, flooding control, casualty evacuation, search and rescue, pollution counter-measures, recovery of floating debris, anchor-handling, vessel escort and hydrographic surveying.

Page 32: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

Government Decision not to renew ETV Contract – Sep 2011

►MCA no longer have ability to mobilise tug as a precautionary measure without „potential‟ for delays between Master, Brokers, Insurers, SOSREP and/or other parties

► SOSREP retains ability to direct Master to accept a line from a suitable tug

► SOSREP has ability to take such action as it appears to him necessary or expedient for the purpose for which the direction could have been given or was given.

► SOSREP no ability to direct a commercial tug to place a line on board a casualty…………….

Page 33: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

Lord Donaldson Intervention Omissions

1. Referred to persons owning or managing berths, wharfs or jetties to which the ship might be taken.

2. The local authority whose area might be affected by pollution from the ship.

3. Referred to those who may be able to render salvage services, the potential salvors of the vessel. Govt accepted that, at least when a potential salvor is not a United Kingdom subject, it is not possible to legislate to empower the Secretary of State to require him to render salvage services. Accordingly, we recommend no change in this respect.

Page 34: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

Way Forward►Transport Select Committee – 24 April 2010►Need for MCA to revisit existing procedures and

protocols.►CAST been used in a handful of incidents since

2002 – will we see an increase in its use?► Is there a need for the MCA to develop a new or

use another contract with tug owners/operators?►What standards/training are in place for

emergency towing?►Will commercial tug owners/salvors act under

direction of the SOSREP and seek award through arbitration under International Convention on Salvage, 1989?

►Vessels of Opportunity – Fit for Purpose - Bribery Act 2010.

Page 35: SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry · SOSREP - Working in Partnership with the Tug Industry ... Salvage Convention 1989. ... arbitration under International Convention

Thank You for listening………….

Any Questions?