Upload
thefrontsightpost
View
221
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/13/2019 Smuggling, Displacement and Instability: The Legacy of Pakistani Meddling on the Indian Subcontinent
1/17
"#$%%&'(%) *'+,&-./#/(0 -(1 2(+0-3'&'045 67/8/%-.4 9: ;-
8/13/2019 Smuggling, Displacement and Instability: The Legacy of Pakistani Meddling on the Indian Subcontinent
2/17
"#"
$%& '()*&+,(-.-/ %01*(-/ (2 324%.)01*.) 01 &5*-&+&6/ -&6&7.)* *( *%& '8--&)*
,(60*0'.6 -&.60*0&1 (2 *%& 9):0.) 18;'()*0)&)*< 324%.)01*.) %.1 %01*(-0'.66/ ;&&)
*%& '86*8-.6 .): &'()(+0' '-(11"-(.: (2 =(8*% 310.> 9* 01 . 7&-0*.;6& +&6*0)4 ,(*
(2 &*%)0' 0:&)*0*0&1 .): -&6040(81 70&?1@ .1 ?&66 .1 *-0;.6 '86*8-&1 *%.* 1,.) *%&
+(:&-) *&--0*(-0&1 (2 A.B01*.)@ $.C0B01*.)@ $8-B+&)01*.)@ DE;&B01*.)@ F%0). .):
9-.)> 324%.)01*.)G1 '(+,6&5 4&(4-.,%/@ &*%)0' ,(,86.*0()1 .): %01*(-0'.6
-&6.*0()1%0,1 ?0*% 0*1 ;(-:&-0)4 '(8)*-0&1 %.7& :0-&'*6/ '()*-0;8*&: *( 0)*&-).6
'()260'*1 ?0*%0) 324%.)01*.)@ .): 18;1&H8&)*6/ 1%.,&: *%& 1*-.*&40' -&.60*0&1 (2
0*1 )&04%;(8-1@ &1,&'0.66/ A.B01*.)>
$%01 &11./ ?0*% .**&+,* *( '(7&- *%& (-040)1 (2 '()*&+,(-.-/ '()260'* 0)
324%.)01*.) ;&40))0)4 1%(-*6/ ;&2(-& *%& =(70&* 0)7.10() 0) I&'&+;&-@ JKLK .):
&5,6.0) *%& '(+,6&5 -&6.*0()1%0, ;&*?&&) *%&!"#$%&''() .): &5*&-).6 6(401*0'.6
2(-'&1 70. A.B01*.) ?%0'% 6&: *( *%& '-&.*0() (2 *%& $.60;.) 0) JKKM>J $%01 &11./
?066 1%(? %(? 916.+0' 28):.+&)*.601+@ 2(1*&-&: 8):&- *%& '.-&286 &/& (2 *%&
A.B01*.)0 1*.*& .,,.-.*81@ '-&.*&: . :&1*.;060E0)4 2(-'& ?0*%0) *%& -&40() .):
28-*%&- &5.'&-;.*&: *%& ,-(;6&+1 (2 %8+.) :01,6.'&+&)*@ 066&4.6 1+84460)4 (2
:-841@ .-+1 .): '(++(:0*0&1 .): -&40().6 0)1*.;060*/ *%.* :01-8,*1 *%& 607&1 (2
,(,86.*0()1 0) *%& -&40()@ &1,&'0.66/ 0) A.B01*.)> N%06& *%01 &11./ ?066 2('81
,-0+.-06/ () *%& (-040)1 *%& 324%.) '()260'* .): %(? *%&/ '-&.*& 1*-.*&40'
:06&++.1 2(- A.B01*.)@ 0* 1%(86: ;& )(*&: *%.* *%& '()*&+,(-.-/ '()260'*1 0)
324%.)01*.) :( )(* 10+,6/ .22&'* *%& 9):0.) 18;'()*0)&)*< ,(,86.*0()1 0)
O.6./10.@ $%.06.):@ P4/,*@ 364&-0. .): *%& D)0*&: =*.*&1 .-& .66 .22&'*&: ;/ *%&
%01*(-0'.6 -&.60*0&1 (2 324%.)01*.)>
J
Rashid, A. (2000) Taliban: Islam, oil and the new great game in Central Asia . London; New York: I.B.Tauris. p. 1
8/13/2019 Smuggling, Displacement and Instability: The Legacy of Pakistani Meddling on the Indian Subcontinent
3/17
"Q"
>:%7-('+0-() ;- 9* 01 &11&)*0.6 *( ;&40) ?0*% *%& &): (2 *%& I8--.)0 I/).1*/@
?%&) =.:.- O(%.++&: I.8:@ '(810) .): ;-(*%&-"0)"6.? (2 R0)4 S.%0- =%.%@
:&,(1&: =%.% .): '-&.*&: . T&,8;60' 0) 324%.)01*.)> # D):&- I.8:@ 324%.)01*.)
1&'8-&: &5*&)107& :&7&6(,+&)*.6 .0: 2-(+ *%& =(70&* D)0() 0) &5'&11 (2 UJ>VJ
;0660() D=I 2(- *%& &'()(+/ .): *%& +060*.-/ Q@ '-&.*0)4 1*-()4 *0&1 ;&*?&&)
324%.)01*.) .): *%& D==T@ 1( +8'% 1( *%.* 0) JKLV@ 6&2*01* (220'&-1 ?&-&
0)1*-8+&)*.6 0) '-81%0)4 .) 916.+0' 28):.+&)*.601* +(7&+&)* .): 2(-'0)4 *%&+
*( -&6('.*& (8*10:& (2 324%.)01*.)G1 ;(-:&-1 0) )&04%;(8-0)4 A.B01*.)G1 '0*/ (2
A&1%?.- 8):&- *%& .81,0'&1 (2 *%&) A.B01*.)0 A-0+& O0)01*&- S8620H.- 360
W%8**(>M $%01 ?.1 *( ;& . +.C(- 2.'*(- 0) *%& '(+0)4 '()260'* 0) 324%.)01*.) 0)
-&4.-:1 *( *%& '-&.*0() (2 *%&!"#$%&''() >
9) 3,-06 JKLX@ O.-501* &6&+&)*1 (2 *%& .-+/ (7&-*%-&? I.8: .):
+.11.'-&: %01 &)*0-& 2.+06/ .): &)*(8-.4& 0) .) 8),-&'&:&)*&: 1%(? (2
;-8*.60*/@ .): 0)204%*0)4 (''8--&: ?0*%0) *%& '(++8)01* -&40+& '-&.*&: *?(
2.'*0()1Y *%&*%$+, Z*%& +.11&1[ .): -$./%$0 Z26.4[>V $%& 18;1&H8&)*
:&'6.-.*0() (2 #(%$' ;/ *%& 324%.)00"++$%1 .): 2%$)1 ?&-& . ,-(:8'* (2 *%&
'(++8)01* 2.'*0()1G 6.'B (2 8):&-1*.):0)4 (2 *%& 324%.) '86*8-&@ .): %01*(-/> \)
I&'&+;&- #V *%@ JKLK@ *%& =(70&*1 0)*&-7&)&: 0) 324%.)01*.) () ;&%.62 (2 *%&
# Ibid p.12Q Ibid p.13M Ibid p.12V Ibid p.13
8/13/2019 Smuggling, Displacement and Instability: The Legacy of Pakistani Meddling on the Indian Subcontinent
4/17
"M"
'(++8)01* -&40+& .): 0)1*.66&: W.;-.B R.-+.6@ *%& -$./%$0 6&.:&-@ .1
A-&10:&)*> 31 *%& O.-501*1 4.0)&: ,(?&-@ *%&/ :01,6.'&: +.)/ 324%.) *-0;.6
6&.:&-1 0)*( A.B01*.)@ . 2.'*(- *%.* ?(86: .6*&- *%& '(8-1& (2 A.B01*.)G1 %01*(-/>
9) ()& :&'0107& +(7&@ 324%.)01*.) %.: C81* ;&&) *%-(?) 0)*( *%& %&.* (2 F(6:
N.- ;&*?&&) *%& D==T .): *%& D)0*&: =*.*&1>
2+&-#) 07/ A/+0) -(1 07/ BC/-0'9( 9: 07/ D9&4 A-CC'9C
N%06& 916.+0' &5*-&+01+@ (- 28):.+&)*.601+@ ?.1 )(* '-&.*&: 1,&'020'.66/
2(- *%& 324%.) '()260'*@ *%& 2(1*&-0)4 (2 916.+0' 28):.+&)*.601+ 0) A.B01*.) ?.1 .
'()7&)0&)* ?./ 2(- 3+&-0'.) F(6: N.--0(-1 *( 6&7&-.4& &*%)0'0*/ .): -&6040()@
.): *%& -&284&& ,(,86.*0() .4.0)1* *%&0- =(70&* &)&+0&1> 916.+01+G1 +.--0.4& *(
N&1*&-) 48)1 70. A.B01*.)G1 9=9 ?.1 '&-*.0)6/ . '()7&)0&)* ()&@ ;8* 60**6& :0: *%&
D)0*&: =*.*&1 B)(? *%.* *%&0- (?) '-&.*0() ?(86: .**&+,* *( :&1*-(/ *%&0- 0)0*0.6
;&)&2.'*(-1 /&.-1 :(?) *%& 60)&>
A.B01*.)G1 2(1*&-0)4 (2 916.+0' 28):.+&)*.601+ ?.1 )(* . ,8-&6/ N&1*&-)
'-&.*0()@ ;8* -.*%&- . '(+,6&5 :&7&6(,+&)* .-010)4 2-(+ *%& 7&-/ '-&.*0() (2
A.B01*.) *%-(84% A.-*0*0() 0) JKML< *%& 18;1&H8&)* 0)2685 (2 :022&-&)* &*%)0'
4-(8,1 ?0*% 916.+0' *-.:0*0()1 0)*( A.B01*.)@ &1,&'0.66/ 0)*( *%& ](-*%?&1*
^-()*0&- A-(70:&)'& Z]N^A[@ .1 ?&66 .1 *%& '()7&-4&)'& (2 =.8:0 N.%0;;01+ _
.): 9):0.) I&(;.):0 916.+ L ?0*%0) *%& .-&. ,-(70:&: .) 0:&.6 ;.1& (2 (,&-.*0()1
*( *-.0) .): (-'%&1*-.*& .)*0"=(70&* ?.--0(-1> D):&- *%& -&40+& (2 S0. .6"a8H@
0$'.$11$1 ;&'.+& *%& ,-0+.-/ +&.)1 (2 &:8'.*0() 2(- 324%.)01*.) -&284&&1 .):
,((- A.B01*.)01 *%.)B1 *( &5*&)107& 4(7&-)+&)* 28):0)4> b9) JKLJ *%&-& ?&-&
_ Gohari, M. J. (2000) The Taliban: ascent to power . Karachi: Oxford University Press. pp. 26-43L Rashid, A. (2000) p.88
8/13/2019 Smuggling, Displacement and Instability: The Legacy of Pakistani Meddling on the Indian Subcontinent
5/17
"V"
()6/ Kcc 0$'.$11$1 0) A.B01*.)d 0) JKXX *%&-& ?&-& X@ccc 0$'.$11$1 .):
#V@ccc 8)-&401*&-&: ()&1@ &:8'.*0)4 (7&- %.62 . +0660() 1*8:&)*1>eX $%01 )&*?(-B
(2 0$'.$11$1 ?.1 1&* 8, 6.-4&6/ ;/ *%& I&(;.):0 '-&.*&: fD9@ .): ;&4.) *(
&:8'.*& 1*8:&)*1 ;/ ,6.'0)4 1&+0"&:8'.*&: 0"++$%10) .-&.1 )&.- *%&
324%.)01*.)"A.B01*.) ;(-:&-@ .): . 4-.:8.6 0+,(10*0() (2 4%$.($ 6.? ?.1
&22&'*&:59* 01 0+,(-*.)* *( )(*& *%.* =.8:0 3-.;0. 6.-4&6/ 28):&: *%& 0$'.$11$1 0)
A.B01*.)@ .): +.*'%&: D>=> .0: (2 UM"V ;0660() D=I (2 .0: ;&0)4 1&)* *( *%&
!"#$%&''() 70. A.B01*.)0 9=9 '())&'*0()1 ?0*% (81*&: *-0;.6 '%0&21 ;&*?&&) JKXc"
JKK#@ ?%06& (*%&- P8-(,&.) .): 916.+0' '(8)*-0&1 4.7& . *(*.6 (2 UJc ;0660() D=I
:8-0)4 *%& 1.+& *0+& ,&-0(:K *( 204%* *%& =(70&* 2(-'&1 0) 324%.)01*.)> 31 *%&
'()260'* 0)*&)1020&: .): A.B01*.) 2(8): 0*1&62 ;&'(+0)4 *%& '&)*-.6 ,6./&- 0) *%&
F(6: N.-@ -&6040(81 &5*-&+01+ ;&4.) *( 1%.,& A.B01*.)G1 .;060*/ *( '()*-(6 0*1
10*8.*0() .1 0* -&6.*&: *( 9):0.@ ;8* .61( +(6: *%& 7&-/ 2.;-0' (2 A.B01*.)0 1('0&*/>
N%06& *%&!"#$%&''() '(++.):&-1 6.-4&6/ :-&? *%&0- '()'&,* (2 #(%$'
2-(+ . -0'% 8):&-1*.):0)4 (2 *%&0- (?) &*%)0' %01*(-/@ +.)/ (2 *%& 204%*&-1
'(+0)4 (7&- *%& ;(-:&-1 (2 A.B01*.) :0: )(*< *%&0- 28):.+&)*.6
'()'&,*8.60E.*0() (2 ;(*% 916.+ .): *%& -&40() ?&-& 1%.,&: 1(6&6/ ;/ *%&0- *0+&
1,&)* 0) A.B01*.)0 0$'.$11$1 .): 28&6&: ;/ . 4&)&-(81 -&1&)*+&)* (2 *%& =(70&*
-&40+& *%.* %.: +8-:&-&: +&+;&-1 (2 *%&0- 2.+060&1 .): :01,6.'&: *%&+
-&40().66/> $%& &:8'.*0().6 1/1*&+ (2 *%&0$'.$11$1 @ ?%0'% ,-&.'%&: +.)/
%/;-0:0E&: .): -.:0'.60E&: 2(-+1 (2 916.+ Jc @ '(8,6&: ?0*% *%& 1*&.:/ 0)2685 (2
?&.,()1 *( 204%* *%& =(70&*1 &):&: 8, '-&.*0)4 . 10*8.*0() *%.* ,&-,&*8.*&:
X Ibid, p.89K Ibid, p.18Jc 6 bid, p.90
8/13/2019 Smuggling, Displacement and Instability: The Legacy of Pakistani Meddling on the Indian Subcontinent
6/17
"_"
*-0;.6 .): &*%)0' '()260'* ?0*%0) *%& -&40() 6()4 .2*&- *%& T8110.)1 ?&-& (81*&:
2-(+ 324%.)01*.) 0) JKXK>
67/ @'+/ 9: 07/ +$,(-$)
32*&- *%& 6.1* =(70&* *-((,1 6&2* 324%.)01*.) () *%& JV*% (2 ^&;-8.-/@ JKXK@ *%&
].C0;866.% 4(7&-)+&)* 0) R.;86 *%.* ?.1 2(-+&-6/ 18,,(-*&: ;/ *%& =(70&* 8)0()
'.+& 8):&- ;601*&-0)4 .**.'B1 ;/ *%& !"#$%&''()7 .): 2&66 () 3,-06 JL *%@JKK#JJ >
^(- *%& )&5* *?( /&.-1@ . ,(?&- 7.'88+ ?.1 6&2* 0) 324%.)01*.) *%.* '-&.*&:
;0**&- 0)204%*0)4 ;&*?&&) 2(-+&-6/ 8)020&:!"#$%&''() '(++.):&-1 ?%( ?&-&
.604)&: ?0*% &*%)0' 4-(8,1 0):04&)(81 *( 324%.)01*.) .): 0*1 ;(-:&-0)4 1*.*&1
*%.* 86*0+.*&6/ 1,0-.6&: 0)*( &*%)0' '()260'* .): 28-*%&- :&1*-(/&: 324%.)01*.)G1
-(.: 0)2-.1*-8'*8-&@ .1 ?&66 .1 :01,6.'&: &7&) +(-& 324%.)1> 31 ?.-6(-:1 ;.'B&:
;/ )&04%;(8-0)4 1*.*&1 2(84%* *( '.-7& (8* -&40().6 0)268&)'& 0) 324%.)01*.)@
A.B01*.) *%-&? *%& +.C(-0*/ (2 0*1 18,,(-* ;&%0): g86;8::0) a&B+.*/.->
a&B+.*/.- ?.1 . 2.7(8-0*& !"#$%&''() '(++.):&- ?%( ?.1 %&.706/ 28):&: .):
18,,(-*&: ;/ *%& 9=9 .4.0)1* *%& =(70&*1< A.B01*.)G1 '.6'8681 0) 18,,(-*0)4
a&B+.*/.-@ .) &*%)0' A81%*8).): 2(8):&- (2 8(9:;(;61+$0( @ J# . -.:0'.6
28):.+&)*.601* 4-(8, ;.1&: 0) A.B01*.)@ ?.1 *%.* A.B01*.)0 -&40().6 0)268&)'&
?(86: ;& 1*-&)4*%&)&: ?0*% a&B+.*/.- .* *%& %&.: (2 *%& 324%.) 4(7&-)+&)*@
.1 *%& T.;;.)0 4(7&-)+&)*G1
8/13/2019 Smuggling, Displacement and Instability: The Legacy of Pakistani Meddling on the Indian Subcontinent
7/17
"L"
!"#$%&''() '(++.):&-@ 3%+&: =%.% O.1(8:@ &*%)0'.66/ . A&-10.) $.C0B@JQ?%(
?.1 :0-&'*6/ (,,(1&: *( a&B+.*/.-G1 ,-.'*0'&: 2(-+ (2 916.+> JM O.1(8: ?(86:
6.*&- ,6./ . '-8'0.6 -(6& .4.0)1* *%& $.60;.)G1 ;-8*.6 *.B&(7&- (2 324%.) 1('0&*/ ;/
4(0)4 *( ?.- .4.0)1* *%& 916.+0' 28):.+&)*.601*1 .1 *%&/ 1?&,* *%-(84% *%&
'(8)*-/ ;&40))0)4 0) JKKM>
31 ;.**6&1 -.4&: () 0) R.;86 2(- '()*-(6 (2 324%.)01*.) ;&*?&&) *%&
T.;;.)0 4(7&-)+&)* .): a&B+.*/.-G1 2(-'&1@ *%& '(++8)0*0&1 1'%((6&: ;/ *%&
0$'.$11$1 0) A.B01*.) 4-&? &7&- +(-& :01'()*&)*&: ?0*% *%& 0)204%*0)4 0)
324%.)01*.) ;&*?&&) *%& 2(-+&-!"#$%&''() '(++.):&-1< '(--8,*0() 4-&?
.+()41* *%& -.)B1 (2 *%& '(++.):&-1G +&)@ .): .*-('0*0&1@ ;-0;&-/ .): b.)*0
916.+0'e ;&%.70(8- ;&'.+& '(++(),6.'& .+()41* *%& 1(6:0&-1 204%*0)4 0)
324%.)01*.)> 9-()0'.66/@ *%&>$+(:$) &)*-.)'& 0)*( 324%.)01*.) 0) JKKM ?.1 .
:0-&'* '()1&H8&)'& (2 *%& b.)*0"916.+0'e '():8'* (2 *%& *-0;&1+&)Y b2(- 1(+&
324%.)01 *%& $.60;.) '-&.*&: %(,&1 *%.* . +(7&+&)* 6&: ;/ 10+,6& 916.+0'
1*8:&)*1 ?0*% .) .4&):. (2 ;-0)40)4 ,&.'& *( *%& '(8)*-/ +04%* 18''&&: 0) 20).66/
:01,(10)4 (2 *%& ?.-6(-: 2.'*0()1 ?%0'% %.: :&7.1*.*&: ,&(,6&G1 607&1 10)'& *%&
'(++8)01* -&40+& 0) R.;86 %.: ;&&) (7&-*%-(?) 0) 3,-06 JKK#>e JV 9:&(6(40'.66/
1,&.B0)4@ *%&>$+(:$) ;&60&7& 0) 8)0*0)4 *%& O8160+ ?(-6: 8):&- . 4-&.*&- 916.+0'
F.60,%.*& *( &)18-& &H8.60*/ .): 1&'8-0*/ 2(- .66 ,&(,6&1 0) .''(-:.)'& ?0*%
916.+0' ,-0)'0,6&1> J_ $%& 18;1&H8&)* 6&4.'/ .): &7(68*0() (2 >$+(:$) 0:&(6(4/
;&*-./1 *%& 7&-/ ).*8-& 8,() ?%0'% *%& +(7&+&)* ?.1 2(8):&:@ %.1 :0-&'*6/
JQ Gohari, M. J. (2000) p. 18JM Cooley, J. K. (2000) p.143JV Rashid, A. (2000) p. 5J_ Kaushik, S. N. (1993) pp. 8-9
8/13/2019 Smuggling, Displacement and Instability: The Legacy of Pakistani Meddling on the Indian Subcontinent
8/17
"X"
'-&.*&: *%& '8--&)* '():0*0() (2 :01,6.'&+&)*@ '(--8,*0() .): 70(6&)'&
324%.)01*.)>
9) JKKM@ . 1+.66 4-(8, (2 >$+(:$) ?&-& '()2-()*&: ;/ )&04%;(8-1 0)
=0)4&1.- .): *(6: (2 . 6('.6 '(++.):&- ?%( %.: .;:8'*&: *?( *&&).4& 40-61 .):
;-(84%* *%&+ ;.'B *( %01 '.+,@ ?%&-& *%&0- %&.:1 ?&-& 1%.7&: .): *%&/ ?&-&
-&,&.*&:6/ -.,&:> $%& >$+(:$) .**.'B&: *%& '.+,@ 2-&&: *%& 40-61 .): %8)4 *%&
'(++.):&-@ '.,*8-0)4 6.-4& H8.)*0*0&1 (2 .-+1 0) *%& ,-('&11> JL 9) *%& 2(66(?0)4
+()*%1@ *%&>$+(:$) ?&-& .,,-(.'%&: *( %&6, ?0*% 10+06.- '0-'8+1*.)'&1@ .):
;&'.+& . '& ?$/=@ ,&.'&+.B0)4 2(-'& ?0*%0) *%& -&40()" . 1(-* (2 T(;0) a((:
2048-& .4.0)1* *%& 0)C81*0'&1 %.,,&)0)4 0) *%& -&40()> $%&>$+(:$) @ 6&: ;/ O866.%
\+.- `. A.1%*8)" 4-&? 0) ,-&1*04& ;&'.81& \+.- b.1B&: 2(- )( -&?.-: (- '-&:0*
2-(+ *%(1& %& %&6,&:@ ()6/ :&+.):0)4 *%.* *%&/ 2(66(? %0+ *( 1&* 8, . C81*
916.+0' 1/1*&+e>JX 31 *%&>$+(:$) 4.0)&: 2.7(8- 0) *%& -&40() *%-(84% 2-&&0)4
-(.:1 2-(+ ?.-6(-:1 .): 0)1*.660)4 1*-0'* 4%$.($ 6.? ?%&-&7&- *%&/ 60;&-.*&:>
$%& 9=9@ ?%( ?&-& ;.'B0)4 a&B+.*/.-G1 .**.'B1 .4.0)1* R.;86@ 1%02*&: 18,,(-* *(
*%&>$+(:$) .2*&- *%&/ ?() . 1&-0&1 (2 B&/ 70'*(-0&1 .4.0)1* a&B+.*/.-G1 2(-'&1
.): ,-(7&: *%.* *%&/ ?&-& '.,.;6& (2 '()*-(660)4 324%.)01*.)G1 +86*0"&*%)0'
2.'*0()1 ;&**&- *%.) *%& '8--&)* -&40+&@ .1 ?&66 .1 %.70)4 *%& .;060*/ *( .:7.)'&
A.B01*.)G1 .+;0*0()1>JK 31 *%&>$+(:$) &1*.;601%&: *%&+1&67&1 .1 *%& ()6/ +.C(-
-&40().6 ,(?&- (8*10:& (2 *%& 4(7&-)+&)* 0) R.;86@ *%&/ :&1,&-.*&6/ 1(84%*
-&'(4)0*0()< ?%06& =.8:0 3-.;0.@ A.B01*.) .): *%& D)0*&: 3-.; P+0-.*&1
-&'(4)0E& *%&>$+(:$) @ *%& -&1* (2 *%& 9)*&-).*0().6 F(++8)0*/ :(&1 )(* #c < *%&
JL Ibid , p.25JX Ibid , p,25JK Ibid, pp. 27-30#c Gohari, M. J. (2000) p. 96
8/13/2019 Smuggling, Displacement and Instability: The Legacy of Pakistani Meddling on the Indian Subcontinent
9/17
"K"
2.068-& (2 *%& 0)*&-).*0().6 '(++8)0*/ *( -&'(4)0E& *%&>$+(:$) %.1 ;&&) .)
0+,(-*.)* 2.'*(- 0) *%& ()4(0)4 70(6&)'& ?0*%0) *%& -&40()@ .1 *%&>$+(:$)
1*-8446& *( 4.0) *%& -&'(4)0*0() *%.* *%&/ 1( :&10-&@ .): %.7& *8-)&: *( &7&)
+(-& -.:0'.6 0:&(6(40&1 *( 2(-'& -&'(4)0*0() ?0*%0) *%& 0)*&-).*0().6
'(++8)0*/> #J
67/ >:%7-( A-45 6C-::'. I8-0)4 *%& Q -: .): M *%
'&)*8-0&1 3>I>@ 324%.)01*.)G1 -(.:1 ?&-& ,.-* (2 *%& =06B T(.:@ 2&--/0)4 4((:1
;&*?&&) F%0).@ 9):0. .): *%& N&1*>## 324%.)01*.)G1 &5*&)107& -(.: )&*?(-B 01
'&)*-.6 *( .)/ -&40+&G1 .'*070*0&1@ .1 ?.-6(-:1 .): 2.'*0()1 *%.* '()*-(6 1*-0,1 (2
-(.: '81*(+.-06/ '(66&'* *.5&1 2(- 1.2& ,.11.4& (2 7&%0'6&1 .): ,&(,6&> $%&1&
*.5&1 .-& 6&70&: 0) *%& 2(-+ (2 +()&/ .): '(++(:0*0&1< 48)1@ .++8)0*0()@ 2((:
.): (06 .-& &5'%.)4&: 2(- 1.2& ,.11.4& .6()4 *%& ?./ 2-(+ . 1%0,+&)*G1 (-040) *(
0*1 :&1*0).*0()>#Q 31 *%& F93 28))&6&: ?&.,()1 0)*( 324%.)01*.) 70. *%& 9=9
:8-0)4 *%& JKXc1@ )&*?(-B1 ?&-& 2(-+&: ?0*%!"#$%&''() '(++.):&-1 *%.*
6.1*&: 0)*( '()*&+,(-.-/ *0+&1> F(++.):&-1 18'% .1 a&B+.*/.-@ ?%(
&7&)*8.66/ 10:&: ?0*%!"++$% \+.-@ 81&: *%&0- &1*.;601%&: 60)B1 ?0*% *%& 9=9 *(
28&6 *%&0- '.+,.04)1 0) 324%.)01*.)< -&'&070)4 *-8'B 6(.:1 (2 ?&.,()1@
'(++8)0'.*0()1 &H80,+&)* .): 6(401*0'.6 18,,60&1 0)*( 324%.)01*.) #M@ .):
&5,(-*0)4 -.? (,08+ (- +(-,%0)& ;.1& ;.'B (7&- *%& ;(-:&- 0)*( A.B01*.) 0) *%&
#J Ibid , pp. 134-142## Ibid , p, 84#Q Cooley, J. K. (2000), p. 56#M Ibid , p. 55
8/13/2019 Smuggling, Displacement and Instability: The Legacy of Pakistani Meddling on the Indian Subcontinent
10/17
"Jc"
1.+& *-8'B1>#V I8-0)4 *%& JKXc1 *%& 1*&.:/ 0)2685 (2 ?&.,()1@ .): +()&/ 0)*(
*%& -&40() '-&.*&: 0)*&-).6 1*-02& 0)10:& (2 A.B01*.)@ .1 *%&0$'.$11$1 .): 916.+0'
,.-*0&1 18'% .1 *%& $%01 '-&.*0() ?.1 . +&.)1 2(-
A.B01*.) *( ,-(C&'* ,(?&- ?0*%0) *%& -&40()@ ;8* .61( *%& 1(8-'& (2 0*1 4-&.*&1*
,-(;6&+1@ .1 *%& .))8.6 *-.:& .6()4 *%& 324%.)01*.)"A.B01*.) ;(-:&- 01 ?(-*%
;0660()1 (2 :(66.-1@#K ;8* %.1 .61( '-&.*&: . :-84 &,0:&+0' ?0*%0) A.B01*.) .): *%&
-&1* (2 *%& -&40()@ *%.)B1 *( *%& ,-(602&-.*0() (2 1+84460)4 -(8*&1>Qc
#V Ibid , p. 132 #_ Gayer, L. (2007) Guns, Slums and Yellow Devils: A Genealogy of Urban Conflicts in Karachi, Pakistan.
Modern Asian Studies . 41 (3), pp. 522, 527#L Anif, M., 1989 quoted in Ibid , p, 530#X Riphenburg, C. J. (2005) Ethnicity and Civil Society in Contemporary Afghanistan. Middle East Journal .
59 (1), p. 45#K Ibid , p. 46Qc See Apendix A
8/13/2019 Smuggling, Displacement and Instability: The Legacy of Pakistani Meddling on the Indian Subcontinent
11/17
"JJ"
*'+,&-./#/(05 F90 G$+0 -( >:%7-( ;C93&/#
$%& -&40() (2 324%.)01*.) .): A.B01*.) %.1 1&&) . '(+;0)&: J>_V +0660()
,&-1()1 :01,6.'&: 0)*&-).66/@ .): . -&284&& ,(,86.*0() (2 .,,-(50+.*&6/ Q
+0660() ,&(,6&QJ@ +(1* (2 *%&+ 6&.:0)4 0)'-&.10)46/ :&1*0*8*& 607&1< $%&-& 01 .)
&1,&'0.66/ %04% -.*& (2 ,(7&-*/ 0) *%& A.1%*8) ;&6*@ ?%0'% %.1 '(--&6.*&: *( *%&
&5,.)10() (2 '-0+& .): -&6040(81 &5*-&+01+ ?0*%0) *%& .-&.@ 28-*%&- 28&60)4 *%&
-&40().6 '()260'*1>Q# 31 324%.)01*.)G1 0)*&-).6 1*-02& '()*0)8&1 *( 1&): +(-&
-&284&&1 0)*( A.B01*.)@ *%& '/'6& ,&-,&*8.*&1 0*1&62 .): A.B01*.) ;&'(+&1 &7&)
+(-& .22&'*&: ;/ *%& &7&)*1 *%.* 0* %&6,&: *( 1&* 0) +(*0()QQ
=9H'(% I9CJ-C1
$%& 324%.)01*.) '()260'* %.1 1%.,&: A.B01*.) .1 +8'% .1 A.B01*.)0
+&::60)4 %.1 1%.,&: *%& +(:&-) 1*.*& (2 324%.)01*.)> $%& .''&,*&: ,-.'*0'&1 (2
'(--8,*0() .): *-.220'B0)4 ?0*%0) *%& -&40() %.7& 28&6&: *%&>$+(:$) ?.- +.'%0)&
*( *%& ,(0)* (2 1&62"181*.0)+&)* ?0*%(8* &5*&-).6 28):0)4 .): '-&.*&: . :-84
&,0:&+0' 0) A.B01*.)> $%& '()260'*G1 &22&'* () (''8,.)*1 (2 *%& ]N^A .):
W.6('%01*.) .-&.1 %.1 .61( 1&&) *%& '-&.*0() (2 %04%6/ -.:0'.60E&: 916.+0' .4&):.1
,(1* JKXc@ ?%0'% %.7& ;-(84%* *-&+&):(81 70(6&)'& *( A.B01*.)01 0) *%&0- (?)
).*0()> $%& 0-()/ (2 *%& &)*0-& 10*8.*0() 2(- A.B01*.) 01 *%.* *%&0- :(+&1*0'
,-(;6&+1 .-& . ,-(:8'* (2 *%& 4(7&-)+&)* Z.): 6.-4&6/ *%& 9=9G1[ :&10-& *( ;& *%&
-&40().6 4"))( O8160+ ,(?&-%(81& 0) *%& -&40()@ .1 ?&66 .1 ,-(*&'* 0*1&62 .4.0)1*
QJ Ferris, E. & Winthrop, R. (2010) Education and Displacement: Assessing Conditions for Refugees and Internally Displaced Persons affected by Conflict . p. 2
Q# Riphenburg, C. J. (2005), p. 46QQ
Akhtar, N. (2008) Pakistan, Afghanistan, and the Taliban. International Journal on World Peace . 25 (4),pp. 4973.
8/13/2019 Smuggling, Displacement and Instability: The Legacy of Pakistani Meddling on the Indian Subcontinent
12/17
"J#"
?%.* *%&/ ,&-'&07&: .1 .) 0)'-&.10)46/ ;&6604&-&)* 9):0.) 1*.*&>QM 9) (-:&- *(
.''(+,601% *%01 *.1B@ A.B01*.) -&H80-&: . 1*-()4@ '(++0**&: O8160+ ?.--0(->
N0*% N&1*&-) 1*.*&1G .):4"))( 3-.; ).*0()1G 28):0)4@ *%&!"#$%&''() ".):
18;1&H8&)*6/ *%&>$+(:$); ?&-& ;(-)> $%& '.6'8681 (2 *%& 3+&-0'.)1 .): *%&
A.B01*.)01 *%.* *%&0- 916.+0' &5,&-0+&)* ?(86: ;& &.106/ '()*-(66.;6& %.1 10)'&
;&&) :01,-(7&)@ .1 A.B01*.)G1 &'()(+/ .): 0)*&-).*0().6 0+.4& %.7& ;&&)
1&7&-&6/ :.+.4&: ;/ *%&0- 18,,(-* (2 *%& >$+(:$) .): (*%&- .22060.*& 4-(8,1 *%.*
*-.0)&: 0) 0$'.$11$1 0) A.B01*.)> O&+;&-1 (2 *%&1& 4-(8,1 %.7& ,&-,&*-.*&:
.**.'B1 0) R.1%+0-@ 9):()&10.@ *%& D)0*&: =*.*&1 .): 9):0.< .66 (2 ?%0'% '.) ;&
*-.'&: ;.'B *( *%& 324%.)01*.) .): A.B01*.) *%-(84% *%&0- 0:&(6(40'.6 -((*1 (-
*%&0- '(++.):&-1> QV
$%& 0:&(6(40'.6 2-.+&?(-B (2 *%& 4-&.*&- 916.+0' 1*.*& .1 0)0*0.66/
,(-*-./&: ;/ *%& !"#$%&''() &7(67&: 4-&.*6/ .2*&- . 4&)&-.*0() (2 ?.- 0)
324%.)01*.) .): &+&-4&: 8):&- *%& >$+(:$) . :022&-&)* ;&.1* *%.)B1 *(
'()*-0;8*0()1 2-(+ 0$'.$11$1 .): 0)268&)'&1 2-(+ A$%(::(10 > N%06& *%01 &11./
:(&1 )(* :01'811 *%& 0)268&)'& (2 \1.+. W0) j.:&) .): B+;C$&'$ () *%&>$+(:$)
-&40+&@ *%& 0)2685 (2 2(-&04) #(%$'(1 0)*( A.B01*.) .): 324%.)01*.) 1%(-*6/ .2*&-
JKK_ .66(?&: 2(- 28-*%&- -.:0'.60E.*0() .): :011&+0).*0() (2 28):.+&)*.601*
0:&(6(40&1 46(;.66/@ '(+0)4 *( . %&.: ?0*% *%& =&,*&+;&- JJ*%@ #ccJ *&--(-01*
.**.'B1 () *%& N(-6: $-.:& F&)*&-1 0) ]&? k(-B> Q_
9* 01 '6&.- *%.* A.B01*.)G1 ,(60'0&1 (2 '(8)*&-0)4 0)268&)'& 2-(+ 9):0. .):
9-.) ?&-& . '-&.*0() (2 '()7&)0&)'& *%-(84% *%& 3+&-0'.) :&10-& *( 1*(, *%&
QM Gohari, M. J. (2000) p. 119QV Ramakrishna, K. (2005) Deligitimizing Global Jihadi Ideology in Southeast Asia. Contemporary
Southeast Asia . 27 (3), p. 354Q_ Gohari, M. J. (2000) p. 136
8/13/2019 Smuggling, Displacement and Instability: The Legacy of Pakistani Meddling on the Indian Subcontinent
13/17
"JQ"
.:7.)'& (2 *%& =(70&* D)0()> D)2(-*8).*&6/@ *%& '8--&)* 1*-.*&40' ,-(;6&+1
:(+&1*0'.66/ 2(- A.B01*.) .): .;-(.: 1*&++0)4 2-(+ *%& F(6: N.- .):
A.B01*.)G1 -&40().6 .+;0*0()1 .-& . '()10:&-.;6& ,-0'& *( ,./ 2(- *%& -&6.*07&
4.0)1 +.:& ;/ 3+&-0'. .): A.B01*.) -&1,&'*07&6/>
8/13/2019 Smuggling, Displacement and Instability: The Legacy of Pakistani Meddling on the Indian Subcontinent
14/17
"JM"
8/13/2019 Smuggling, Displacement and Instability: The Legacy of Pakistani Meddling on the Indian Subcontinent
15/17
"JV"
>;;KF*2L M
QL
QLAvailable from: www.unodc.org/pakistan/en/country-profile.html (Accessed 11 January 2013).
8/13/2019 Smuggling, Displacement and Instability: The Legacy of Pakistani Meddling on the Indian Subcontinent
16/17
"J_"
8/13/2019 Smuggling, Displacement and Instability: The Legacy of Pakistani Meddling on the Indian Subcontinent
17/17
"JL"
N2N82EO@>;DP
Akhtar, N. (2008) Pakistan, Afghanistan, and the Taliban. International Journal on World Peace . 25 (4), pp.4973.
Anon (2013) United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime: Pakistan Country Profile [online]. Available from:www.unodc.org/pakistan/en/country-profile.html (Accessed 11 January 2013).
Cooley, J. K. (2000) Unholy wars: Afghanistan, America, and international terrorism . New ed. London !;Sterling, Va: Pluto Press.
Ferris, E. & Winthrop, R. (2010) Education and Displacement: Assessing Conditions for Refugees and Internally Displaced Persons affected by Conflict . pp.142.
Fineman, M. (1992) Afghan Leader Najibullah Forced to Resign by Rebels. The Tech . 17 April. [online].Available from: http://tech.mit.edu/V112/N21/afghan.21w.html (Accessed 31 October 2013).
Gayer, L. (2007) Guns, Slums and Yellow Devils: A Genealogy of Urban Conflicts in Karachi, Pakistan. Modern Asian Studies . 41 (3), pp. 515544.
Gohari, M. J. (2000) The Taliban: ascent to power . Karachi: Oxford University Press.
Kaushik, S. N. (1993) Politics of Islamization in Pakistan: a study of Zia regime . South Asia studies series29. New Delhi: South Asian Publishers.
Ramakrishna, K. (2005) Deligitimizing Global Jihadi Ideology in Southeast Asia. Contemporary Southeast Asia . 27 (3), pp. 343369.
Rashid, A. (2000) Taliban: Islam, oil and the new great game in Central Asia . London; New York: I.B.Tauris.
Riphenburg, C. J. (2005) Ethnicity and Civil Society in Contemporary Afghanistan. Middle East Journal . 59(1), pp. 3151.