26
Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings of Lyon Smart Community Project in France (Report #1) Copyright 2014, Toshiba Corporation. 19 th June, 2014

Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Smart Community Summit 2014Objectives and Key Findings of Lyon Smart Community Project in France (Report #1)

Copyright 2014, Toshiba Corporation.

19th June, 2014

Page 2: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Overview of TOSHIBA Smart Community Projects

2※Officially Announced by Oct. 2013Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 3: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Lyon Smart Community PJ aims at introducing Japanese state-of-art technology to a part of

Redevelopment of Lyon Confluence and Lyon Smart Community Projects

y y g p gy predevelopment of Lyon Confluence, which is led by Grand Lyon. This PJ also plans to achieve 5 years ahead to the EU “20-20-20” target.

Zero Carbon Zero Garbage

Sustainable Water Management Biodiversity

Guidelines of the Action Plan of rredevelopment urban area g

Sustainable Mobility Use of local Materials Local Food

y Local Culture and Heritage Economic Development Quality of LifeSupport

【Task1】 【Task3】

Positive Energy Building Energy Monitoring system

Community Management

System

【Task4】

a rf

ace

Area

: 150

haSu

320-20-20:A 20% reduction in EU greenhouse gas emissions from 1990 levels, raising the share of EU energy consumption produced from renewable resources to 20%, and a 20% improvement in the EU's energy efficiency

Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Zero Emission Transport system

【Task2】

Lyon Confluence district is a former industrial area

Page 4: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Smart Community Projects in LyonGrand Lyon holds approximately 40 PJs focusing on fields of urban transportation, energy, and

Grand Lyon Grand Lyon Smart Data

Multipassurbain

Multipassurbain

Services NFC

Services NFC

Grand Lyon holds approximately 40 PJs focusing on fields of urban transportation, energy, and new service. Among these PJs, Lyon Smart Community PJ attracts most attentions from all over the world.

Cellule expérimentation

Cellule expérimentation

Espaces logistiques

urbains

Espaces logistiques

urbains

Smart Data

ForCityForCityCapteurs urbains

innovants

Capteurs urbains

innovants Sols facilesSols faciles

Centrede consolidation

Centrede consolidation

urbainurbain

Mobilier urbain

interactif

Mobilier urbain

interactif

NFCNFC

Smart Electric Lyon

Smart Electric Lyon

Lyon Smart

Community

Lyon Smart

CommunityLinky de consolidation

des chantiersde consolidation

des chantiersGreenlys

TransformTransform

Watt&Moi

Linky

Velo'V

Covoiturage dynamiqueCovoiturage dynamique

Sun Moov’Sun Moov’

Autopartage électrique généralisé

Autopartage électrique généraliséNaviaNavia

Living LabLiving Lab

CitylogCitylog

FreilotFreilot

GeoVéloGeoVélo

Optimod'Lyon E-PartageE-PartageOpticitiesOpticities

WingletsWingletsCovoiturageCovoiturage

Autolib'Autolib'Move in Pure

Move in Pure

DepollutingDepolluting

Completed Current experiments Projects

PiseoPiseo Axel'oneAxel'one

ProvademseProvademse SupergridSupergrid

IDEELIDEEL GayaGaya

THDTHD Plateformeinfo d'aggloPlateformeinfo d'agglo

Data center d'agglo

Data center d'agglo

4

p p j

Innovative servicesInnovation infrastructures New mobility Energy / smart grids

Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 5: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Project StructureCooperate with French enterprises and local authorities as main partnersCooperate with French enterprises and local authorities as main partners.

MOAADEME

Support

Entrustment

Entrustment

リヨン経済開発公社SupportSupport

ImplementationAgreement (IA)

TOSHIBA and TOSHIBA SOLUTIONS

French Partners

【Task1】 【Task2】 【Task3】 【Task4】

TOSHIBA and TOSHIBA SOLUTIONS

Rooftop PV)

Japanese partners

KENGO KUMAAND ASSOCIATES

(Facade PV)

(Phase Change Material)

(Electric Vehicles)

(Absorption Chiller)

AND ASSOCIATES

(Commissionning)System Integrators

5Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 6: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Task1 Positive Energy Building (HIKARI)Goal Beginning of demonstration from May, 2015

Achievement of Positive Energy Buildings (PEB) by introducing state-of-art technologies, energy production systems, energy storage systems, eco-saving technologies as well as energy management systems in the P-Plot (HIKARI) located in Lyon Confluence area, a group of three mixed-use

Goal g g y

y g pbuildings (office, dwellings and retail) with total floor space of 12,000 square meters. The architect is Kengo Kuma.

Introduced technologies・solutionsEnergy Production; Roof-top PV, façade PV, Cogeneration system(by France), Absorption ChillerEnergy Storage; Smart battery, Phase Change MaterialEnergy Saving; LED bulbs, Radiant ceiling panel(by France)Energy Management; BEMS(Building Energy Management System)

HEMS(Home Energy Management System)gy g yGreen IT

Demonstration Items① Achievement of PEB with minimized operation cost① Achievement of PEB with minimized operation cost ② Integrated Energy and performance evaluation of all introduced machines③ Market evaluation of Omotenashi system which is introduced in HEMS④ Establishment and evaluation of commissioning manuals for sustainable building energy performance ⑤ Effectiveness evaluation of PV performance deterioration

6Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 7: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

TASK 1 Definition of PEBPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energy

than it consumes over 1 year, based on primary energy calculation.

A. Renewable Energy C. Energy Produced(P i E )

PhotovoltaicProduction PV production

B. Energy Consumed(P i E )

(Primary Energy)

3.2kWh/kWh

Inside HIKARI Building

CommercialPower

Energy Consumption: HVAC, Lighting, office equipment, hot water, etc

(Primary Energy)3.2kWh/kWh

Oil CGSCGSHeat

Source System

HeatSource System

SurplusEnergy

0.2kWh/kWh 3.2kWh/kWh

Gas 1.1kWh/kWh

PEB = Yearly (B Energy consumed) < Yearly (C Energy produced)

7Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

PEB = Yearly (B. Energy consumed) < Yearly (C. Energy produced)

Page 8: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

TASK 1 Evaluation of PEB (simulation)10,000 500,000

6,000

8,000

,

300,000

400,000

,

Wh]

0

2,000

4,000

Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov DecEner

gy[k

Wh/

day]

0

100,000

200,000

nerg

y B

alan

ce[k

W

-6,000

-4,000

-2,000Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec

Prim

aly

E

-300,000

-200,000

-100,000

Cum

ulat

ive

En

-10,000

-8,000

-500,000

-400,000

Consumption of Heat Resource Consumption of Common Space Consumption of Shop

Perform a model/plan for operating the building over a period of 1 year to achieve the Positive E B ildi l d t l th i t b d th t t d fi d b th d l Th

Consumption of Heat Resource Consumption of Common Space Consumption of ShopConsumption of Dwelling Consumption of Office Consumption of Rapeseed OilConsumption of Gas Production of CGS Production of PVCumulative Energy Balance

8Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Energy Building goals and control the equipment based on the strategy defined by the model. The model will take into consideration electrical. equipment and comfort parameters of the building.

Page 9: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Integrated management for energy production, energy storage and energy saving

Task1 BEMS and Cloud BEMSg g gy p , gy g gy g

by local BEMS (on-site) and cloud BEMS.

CloudBEMS

<Main function> Optimized electrical and thermal utilization Commissioning

Energy

Green IT

Omotenashi

<Office Area>Local BEMS

(on-site)

PV Failure Detection System

Monitor and management Schedule control

gyManagement

System

Blind Motor

Irradiation control

OmotenashiHEMS

LED bulbs

Radiant Ceiling Panel

Air ConditionerImage-based

Human presence detection Activity detection Head count calculation Light intensity measurement

Dimming controlincorporated with image-based sensor

Energy SavingMachine

Hot Water TankIce-storage Tank

LED bulbs Air ConditionergSensor

Smart BatteryEnergy Storage

Hot waterCold waterElectricity

PV(roof-top)

PV(facade) CogenerationAbsorption

Chiller

Hot Water Tankg(PCM)

Smart BatteryMachine

Energy ProductionMachine

9

Grid Power Electricity Rapeseed Oil

Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 10: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Task1 Omotenashi HEMSOmotenashi (hospitality) HEMS for residential unit while using a platform of French HEMS.Omotenashi (hospitality) HEMS for residential unit while using a platform of French HEMS.

ZigBee(Wireless)l

CloudHEMS

IJENKOServer

InternetCloudBEMS

Smartl

Human Presence S

WindowO/C S

BlindC

HeaterC

Temp.S

CO2S

LightingS

Control S i h

Energyi

HEMSBox

KNX(Wired)

ZigBee(Wireless)ControlEngine

PlugSensor O/C Sensor Cont. Cont. Sensor Sensor Sensor Switch Metering

Lighting, Home AppliancesBlindWindow Radiant Ceiling

panelRegzaTablet

Distribution Panel, water meter, etc.

Visualization

Installation of Human presencesensor in eachroom for

10Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

estimating actions

Page 11: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Task1 Green ITGreen IT consists of managing energy consumption of IT equipment which mayGreen IT consists of managing energy consumption of IT equipment which may increase year by year by using the existing information of office area coming from BEMS.

Office Energy Consumption by usage type

↑Presenceinformation

↓Power management(On/Off、Standby mode)

Energy consumption↑Modify configuration↑

Lighting

OA / IT

Cooling

Source : Arene 2009

g

Heating

11Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 12: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Task2 Zero Emission Transport SystemGoal Beginning of demonstration from October, 2013

The goal is to realize a zero emission transport system by introducing an EV car sharing system powered by renewable energy. The effects of using these PV systems on the power supply and demand balance will also be demonstrated. Besides, SUNMOOV’ also aims to solve the issues such as lack of parking spaces and traffic

Goal g g

jam which represent real urban issues.

Electric Vehicles; 15 EV (Mitsubishi Motors) and16 EV (PSA)

Introduced technologies・solutions

Charging Stations; 30 normal chargers and 3 rapid chargers (CHAdeMO)Car Share Systems; 1 set (Transdev by France)μEMS; 1 set

[Charging availability inquiry to ERDF and PV power generation di ti b d th f t]prediction based on weather forecast]

Optimized Charging System; 1 set[Charging Station scheduling to optimize PV utilization and EV rotation rate]

① PV utilization rate, EV rotation rate② Effectiveness evaluation of rapid chargers③ Resolution of PV power generation prediction

Demonstration Items

12

③ Resolution of PV power generation prediction④ Evaluation of adaptable EV to PV performance

Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 13: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Task2 Car Sharing System ArchitectureBasing on EV reservations and forecasts of PV generation, EV car sharing will be powered by renewable energy and g g g p y gymainly by PV solar panels to be installed in building rooftop within La Confluence district (70% of EV energy needs to be covered).

PVOwner

PV generation information Phase 2(from July 2014)

MeteoFrance μEMS

Weatherinformation Charging Schedule

Optimization System

ion,

le Phase 1ERDF

Go or No Go for charging

erva

tion

info

rmat

ondi

tion

Char

geSc

hedu

Phase 1

Car sharing system(reservation, billing)

ChargingControl System

Rese

EV c

o

Charge Command

NO. Normal Chargers

RapidChargers

① 5 St d 1 St d① 5 Stands 1 Stand

② 5 Stands

③ 5 Stands

④ 5 Stands 1 Stand

13Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Use Authorization⑥ 5 Stands

⑥ 5 Stands 1 Stand

Page 14: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

10:00 11:00 12:00 13:007:00 8:00 9:00 14:00 15:00 16:00 17:00 18:00 19:00 20:00 21:00 22:00 Before

Task2 Charging Time Adaption

EV Cha ging

Consistent full charging due to unpredictable power demand

BeforeEV1

EV2

EV Charging Time and Running

Time Cut-down of unnecessary charging time with power

NowShortened charging timeShortened charging time

EV1

100%

charging time with power demand prediction

⇒High EV availability

Time

EV2

50%

0%

EV Remaining charging amount

BeforeBeforeEV2

0%

EV Car Sharing:Running Ti

:Charging Ti

Power demand prediction

Power demand prediction

NowEV2

14

Time Time

Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 15: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Task2 Use Case (1)【Case 1】 When the weather is sunny, the EV with small remaining energy will be powered in priority.y, g gy p p y

PV installedin the Lyon Confluence

Commercial Power(Renewable Energy produced by local company)

Charging

Control System

NC NC NC QC

15Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 16: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Task2 Use Case (2a)【Case 2a】 When the weather is cloudy or at night, we do not charge the EV if the 【 】 y g , g

reservation schedule is not full.

PV installedin the Lyon Confluence

Commercial Power(Renewable Energy produced by local company)

Charging

Control System

NC NC NC QC

16Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Reserved Reserved

Page 17: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Task2 Use Case (2b)【Case 2b】 When the weather is cloudy or at night, we charge the EV by using renewable energy y g g y g gy

produced by local company (grid) if the reservation schedule is full.

PV installedin the Lyon Confluence

Commercial Power(Renewable Energy produced by local company)

Charging

Control System

NC NC NC QC

17

Reserved Reserved Reserved

Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 18: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Task2 Use Case (3a)【Case 3a】 When returning the EV to the station the user will return the EV to normal【Case 3a】 When returning the EV to the station, the user will return the EV to normal

charger if there is no reservation after.

PV installedin the Lyon Confluence

Commercial Power(Renewable Energy produced by local company)

Charging

Control System

NC NC NC QC

18Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 19: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Task2 Use Case (3b)【Case 3b】When returning the EV to the station, the user will return the EV to g ,

rapid charger if there is a reservation after.

PV installedin the Lyon Confluence

Commercial Power(Renewable Energy produced by local company)

Charging

Control System

NC NC NC QC

19

Reserved

Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 20: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Task2 Use Case (4)【Case 4】 When returning the EV to the station, the user will return the EV to rapid charger g , p g

if there is a surplus power from PV system.

PV installedin the Lyon Confluence

Commercial Power(Renewable Energy produced by local company)

Charging

Control System

NC NC NC QC

20Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 21: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Task3 Energy Monitering in existing residencesGoal Beginning of demonstration from June, 2014

A home energy monitoring system (targets: electricity, water and gas) has been introduced in the social housing complex of Cité de Perrache, and a demonstration for residence action pattern change will be conducted by sending alarms or recommendations respecting to their actual energy usage.

Goal g g ,

p g gy g

Introduced technologies・solutionsMulti-circuit recorder being installed in distribution board to measure the energy consumption

amount of each electrical circuitamount of each electrical circuit Add-on device Pulse transmission device for water and gas meterWireless internet environmentTabletVisualization server

Demonstration Items Upper Class

① Evaluation of visualization system(electricity, gas, water)② Evaluation of suitable visualization system in Europe③ Energy saving evaluation by visualization by appliances and

Lower Class

Middle Class

Targeted user in this task.Sense of energy saving → low

③ Energy saving evaluation by visualization by appliances and recommendation system

21

Lower ClassSense of energy saving lowCooperation with social housing is inevitable for a wider diffusion

Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 22: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Task3 Cite de Perrache and the SystemMore than 70% from 275 housings participate in this demonstration PJMore than 70% from 275 housings participate in this demonstration PJ.

CMS

internet

<Visualization System Screen>

internet

Distribution Board

Power consumptiondata

Monitoring data

I/F

Internetrouter

SensorsEnergy monitor

I/F

22

Tablet Water meter Gas meter

Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 23: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Task3 Opening Ceremony on June 14th

Symbolic Action by French andJapanese partners.

More than 100 citizensparticipated in this event.

23Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 24: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Task4 – Community Management SystemBeginning of Demonstration from June, 2014Goal

The CMS (Community Management System) aims at collecting and analyzing in real time data from Task1〜Task3, energy data from other buildings within Confluence district, data from PV systems and data from weather stations as well as static data (inhabitants city information etc ) The CMS also aims at

g g ,Goal

well as static data (inhabitants, city information, etc.). The CMS also aims at supporting green initiatives and policies by focusing on energy for the Grand Lyon and the other stakeholders.

I t d d t h l i l tiCMS(Community Management System) x1 setCommunication Interface to all kinds of sub systems x1 set

Introduced technologies・solutions

Demonstration Scenario

① Evaluation of building energy performance and effectiveness of regulation value

② Evaluation of modification of existing residences

③ Evaluation of enlightenment for sense of energy saving

④ Effectiveness of regional energy demand and Response

24

Response⑤ Evaluation of EV utilization

Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 25: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Task4 Role of CMS■Role of CMS:a dynamic tool for urban energy planning

By energy data collection and analysis, we can realize:(1)visualization of dynamic urban energy performance(2)information provision to enterprise or citizen to arouse behavior and conscious

revolutionrevolution ② Grand Lyon and Toshiba has agreed to integrate the following data for the CMS:-Energy Information from Gov CitizensPartners

③ Create indexes from the ll d d f l i l i

buildings in the district-PV systems in the district-Weather stations of SPL-ERDF GIS Open Data of Grand Lyon

Gov

collected data for real-time analysis and for sharing information.

-GIS Open Data of Grand Lyon

CMS +α

① Basis data is the community energy performance data from each TASK of LSC project

25

TASK1 TASK2 TASK3Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」

Page 26: Smart Community Summit 2014 Objectives and Key Findings ......PEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring to a building that produces more energyPEB (Positive Energy Building) is referring

Our Future Steps Based on the KnowledgeImplementation with knowledge of energy solution

ネルギ モビリテ 水 環境ファシリテ

情報ルスケ セキ リテ 商業 物販

その他ライフサポ ト

ライフサポートサービスインフラ

統合(SCMS)

対象項目

Implementation with knowledge of energy solution FS/demonstration with integrated life-support service

エネルギー モビリティ 水・環境 ティ情報通信

ヘルスケア セキュリティ 商業・物販 ライフサポートサービス

安全 12 3 1 3 3 4 3 2 2

安心 17 4 1 3 3 5 3 2 2

利便 15 7 1 2 3 2 2 2 2

快適 11 5 1 2 1 3 2 2 4

住民視点(QOL)

(SCMS)要求事項

Stabilized energy supply model1

Life SupportLife SupportEnergyEnergy

公平 10 4 1 2 2 3

喜び 11 3 3 2 2 2

経済メリット 21 6 3 2 2 2

効率運営 27 10 5 5 6 4 3 3 3

効率運用 27 6 5 3 5 3 4 3 3 32 Wide-area energy management

Stabilized energy supply model1Energy saving

System stabilization Cost downsocial

infrastructure

security transportationDisaster

Prevention,Security

ブランディング戦略 22 6 4 2 2 4 3 3 3

産業活性化 19 2 3 3 1 7 3 2

地域特性 9 3 2 1

文化保全 2 2

世代循環 2 2 1

防災 10 1 2 3 2

発展・成長(街視点)

2 gy gmodel

Regional Activation

DR allocation

Comfort

System stabilization

Low CO2 emission

Energy saving

Cost down

Thermal and power supply model3

medical・Health care

Commerce・shops

防災 10 1 2 3 2

防犯 1 1 2 1 2

経済メリット 11 1 1 3 3

地域環境 17 6 1 4

地球温暖化防止 23 6

資源節約 13 3

生物多様性 1

持続可能性(国視点)

Thermal and power supply model3

security

Utilization of undiscovered resource

Regional Activation Cost down

26

生物多様性 1

貧困対策 2

その他政策Demonstration(implementation) FS・demonstration

(Technology and business model)Smart Community Summit 2014「Lyon Smart Community PJ」