Seminar Paper Corrected

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/3/2019 Seminar Paper Corrected

    1/16

    INTEGRAL COACH FACTORY - MODERN TRENDS IN SUB-URBAN

    ROLLING STOCKL.M.Sahore, Chief Electrical

    Engineer/ICF

    Indian Railways a mammoth railway system that runs across the length

    and breadth of the Indian sub-continent over 65000 kms of track, carrying

    12 million passengers every day. In the commercial capital of India i.e the

    Mumbai megapolis alone, every day, over 6.5 million users patronise the

    most intensively used sub-urban railway system in the world, the Mumbai

    suburban. The population of Mumbai has gone up from 40 lakhs in 1947 to

    120 lakhs in 2000 and it is expected to cross 200 lakhs by 2015. This

    extraordinary growth in population has been posing a tremendous

    challenge to the Indian Railways and all efforts are made to ensure that

    the services on the Mumbai sub-urban commensurate this growth rate.

    The Mumbai suburban railway system is the lifeline of the megapolis,

    helping these 6.5 million people commute between home and work spots

    everyday for the last more than eighty years. Despite being taxed to its

    limits , the Mumbai suburban boasts of extremely high efficiency levelswith punctuality record showing figures in excess of 95 %.

    During peak hours, despite running trains at frequencies of a train every 2

    to 3 minutes, each 12 car train is packed with more than 6000 passengers,

    a per coach capacity exceeding 500 passengers which translates to a

    passenger loading density of a near impossible to imagine figure of 16

    passengers per sq.m of area. Needless to say, transportation of local

    passengers over the suburban sections of Mumbai has become the

    biggest challenge of the time for Indian Railways.

    The Mumbai suburban started in 1925, with a 1500 V DC system ofelectrification. With progressive growth in the population of Mumbai, the

    frequency of trains and the passenger loading has been increasing year

    by year. The 1500 V DC system of electrification has been getting

    stretched with the need for additional substations to meet the

    augmented load. Today a stage has come when the 1500 V DC system

    has reached saturation. There is a need to switch over to a higher system

    voltage so that the requirement of substations comes down. The 25 kV AC

    system available in the rest of the electrified routes on Indian Railways, is

    now being adopted in a phased manner in Mumbai. The targets for

    conversion is now set on Western Railway 31.03.2009 for complete

    conversion to 25kv ac single phase system in MUTP phase I whereas theconversion targets for Central Railway being 31.03.2010.

    The trains running on the 1500 V DC system are with DC series traction

    motors with series parallel system of control and friction brakes (electro-

    pneumatic). Since, the conversion has to be done without disturbing the

    existing services, the switchover to 25 kV AC calls for a rolling stock suited

    for dual voltage operation. The necessity for Change in Propulsion from a

    1500 V DC system to 25 KV AC system has been combined with a change

    in the drive from DC drive to three phase AC drive so that the technical

  • 8/3/2019 Seminar Paper Corrected

    2/16

    problems associated with the DC drive limitations could be overcome

    and the following benefits of three phase technology also could be

    derived :-

    a) Use of VVVF based three phase drive using GTO/IGBT based converterinverters for 4 QC control.

    b) Use of three phase squirrel cage type induction motors, free fromcommutation problems and need for frequent attention to brush gear

    associated with DC motors.

    c) Higher power is to weight ratio of AC traction motors 25 to 30 % higherpower for the AC motors

    d) Availability of regenerative braking feature more than 35 % powersaving vis-a-vis DC drive in addition to reduction in wheel and brake shoe

    wear. The saving in the power bill of the Railways is to the tune of Rs. 0.5

    crores per rake per year. In addition, this feature has also enabledRailways to accrue carbon credit .

    e) Use of microprocessor based control system and TMS for smootheracceleration, effective monitoring of all performance and safety related

    parameters for enhanced performance, safety and reliability

    The development of the rolling stock for the Mumbai suburban has also

    undergone a sea change in other areas too and a new look AC DC rake

    equipped with world class aesthetics introduced in Mumbai area are

    becoming a sort of role model to be adopted in future AC EMU stock, so

    that commuters are provided with latest state of art technological

    coaches. The latest features are briefly discussed below:

    a) Drivers safetyThe drivers cab is in line with UIC 651 requirements with respect to

    dimensions, layout of the cab, visibility from the drivers cab, drivers desk

    and location of main operating equipment and control system and

    drivers seat. With the provision of nose cone sliding doors on both the

    entrances and routing of the cables through roof and side walls, the

    dimensional requirement of head room, access, visibility and level floorhave been achieved. Wider lookout glasses are provided for better track

    and signal visibility. In lieu of toughened look out glass, a polycarbonate

    lookout glass which is stone proof and shatter proof has been used. With

    the provision of fluorescent lamp with enclosed diffuser, a uniform level of

    illumination of 200 lux has been achieved compared to 30 lux in the

    existing coaches and 60 lux as prescribed in UIC. In addition to the

    fluorescent tubes, spot lights also have been provided for the use of the

    drivers during driving. With the provision of 2 nos. of 400mm sweep

  • 8/3/2019 Seminar Paper Corrected

    3/16

    swivelling type carriage fans in the drivers coach, the ventilation

    requirement has been met to ensure 55 m3 of air per min per fan.

    The drivers desk and main operating equipments and control system such

    as the master and braking control(MBC), brake instrumentation,

    speedometer(SPM) and the man machine interface(MMI) have been

    organised in such a manner that the driver need not divert his attention

    while operating these equipments from observation of the tracks and

    signals. The controls for head light, flasher, automatic vigilance device,lights & fans for the coaches and the indication equipments are also

    suitably located to have ease of access to operate these equipments

    from the drivers seat. Each of these switches, instrumentations have been

    provided with bakelite indications for proper identification during

    operation. Sufficient leg space have been provided for leg and knee

    movement between the seat and the desk. The drivers seat has been so

    designed to facilitate the vertical adjustment as well as longitudinal

    adjustments duly taking into account anthropometric dimensions with

    reference to the conditions of visibility of signals. The Man Machine

    Interface provides graphic information regarding the working of various

    equipment and amenities on the entire train formation and trouble

    shooting guidance. An Automatic Warning System is provided to ensure

    brake application in the event of restrictive signal.

    Further to enhance the drivers comfort, cab air-conditioning is also being

    planned. The front face of the EMU has been redesigned with a nose

    cone design to impart a world class look which in addition has helped in

    crediting more space.

    b) Low Noise Pneumatic Compressors for air supply & SS pipelines:Low noise reciprocating type of compressor with 3 phase 415 V

    drive, built-in inter and after coolers have been provided in these

    trains. These compressors have inlet air from under frame whereas

    the compressors in existing design have inlet air from passenger

    area through a separate filter. These compressors deliver 920 lpm at

    rated speed. Due to use of stainless steel pipelines and fittings in

    new train for air supply system as well as use of regeneration

    braking, the duty cycle of compressor have been in the order of

    OLD DESIGN OF CAB IN DC EMU CAB DESIGN IN NEW GENERATIONEMU

  • 8/3/2019 Seminar Paper Corrected

    4/16

    27% with all compressors in service. A typical comparison indicates

    distinct advantage of air supply system.

    Details Existing rakes New rake

    Compressor

    rating

    9.7 kW 110 V dc 6.7 kW 3 415 V

    Noise level 80 db 66 db

    Duty cycle 60% 27%

    Air intake / filter External In built.

    c) Brake blending, Wheel slip / slide protection & Anti skid controlsThis new generation AC DC EMUs

    have been provided with advanced

    braking control mechanism to

    achieve maximum regenerative

    braking over full range of speed. This

    system of regeneration braking is fully

    blended with electro pneumatic (EP)brakes, so that any set of braking

    effort demand in EP region is met by

    maximum regenerative energy for Motor coaches and EP brakes for

    trailer coaches to supplement difference between the demand

    and the regenerative braking effort achieved. The system also

    takes care of the condition of (i) Non-effectiveness of regenerative

    braking by changing over to EP fully and (ii) EP failure condition by

    changing over to automatic brakes within a preset time

    automatically through BECU (brake electronic control unit).The

    wheel slip and slide protection system in all modes of acceleration

    and deceleration (braking) and anti skid control for regenerative

    mode are integrated into traction control unit to achieve these

    controls.

    For EMU and main line applications, ICF has already switched over from

    cast iron brake blocks to composite brake blocks which has reduced the

    frequency of brake block replacement by a factor of four. This has also

    considerably reduced resource requirement for maintenance as well as

    maintenance costs.

    d) Polycarbonate SeatsThe present desktop is provided with MS frame with powder coating and

    the seat made up of compreg laminated sheet conforming to RDSO

    specn. C 9407 type 1. These sheets generally require replacement due to

    wear and tear.

    Polycarbonate has been used for the passenger seat material in lieu of

    compreg which will result in reduced wear and tear and maintenance.

  • 8/3/2019 Seminar Paper Corrected

    5/16

  • 8/3/2019 Seminar Paper Corrected

    6/16

    outer frame rods, etc. There used to be number of complaints of thefts

    and miscreants activities as no grills to prevent such activities are provided

    in the windows of the coach. These windows were also very small in size

    and not possible to look through them for observing the names of the

    stations from the window.

    Windows also had a problem of poor ventilation during rainy days

    when the window glass is closed. The

    size of the windows were 610 x 762 mm.

    Windows of AC DC EMU:

    a. Window frames Alu. IS: 733 86, 64300 WP

    b. Fixed louver shutter Polycarbonate clear finish

    2.5mm thick

    c. Movable Glassshutter Assy. IS: 2553 (Part 1) 1990. 6mm thick.

    i. Second class clear toughened safety float glassii.

    First class tinted medium brown toughened safetyfloat glass.

    d. Grill S.S. AISI 304. Powder coated (clear)e. Inner fame Alu. To IS: 737: 86, 31000 HZ Powder coated.f. The size is 915 x 990 mmg. 3mm Stainless Steel wire for grills to Specn. IS: 6528

    f) State-of-the-art coach lighting systemIn existing DC EMU trains, the coach illumination is achieved by 26 no. of 1

    x 18 W fluorescent tube in a mesh type fitting. The illumination thusachieved was around 30 lux. A scientifically designed lighting system

    using Fluorescent lights with energy efficient electronic lamp ballast has

    been provided in the passenger area. In the new trains, 1 x 36 w fitting

    with polycarbonate diffuser is arranged in the central duct to have

    uniform illumination of 300 lux. These fittings have been developed to

    confirm to IP 66 to have jet washable feature. These fittings will be

    requiring less maintenance due to higher IP level protection against dust

    etc.

    g) GPS based Passenger Information SystemA GPS based passenger information system with high quality LED

    displays, high performance speakers and LED destination boards

  • 8/3/2019 Seminar Paper Corrected

    7/16

    has been provided in the passenger area. The selected LEDs ensure

    excellent day time visibility as well as angular vision.

    The passenger information system - a complete new feature of the

    new train which has the following salient facilities:

    Destination indicator (head code) in drivers compartment withhigh resolution LED.

    Public Address system with speakers in each coach, Microphone indrivers cab.

    Auto announcement of stations and other information Visual graphic display of station names and platform in the coach

    (LED type with wider view angle).

    Driver guard communication Data communication through CANBUS & RS 485 communication.

    Auto volume control through ambient noise monitoring

    h) Ventilation systemA very serious problem on Mumbai

    suburban has been that of a verysuffocating ambience in the interiors

    in the event of Super Dense Crush

    Passenger Loading - in a trailer

    coach almost 600 passengers travel

    during peak hours. A major

    improvement done on the new

    generation EMUs manufactured by ICF for the Mumbai suburban (MRVC)

    is the provision of a forced ventilation system to get over this problem.

    The Ventilation system comprises three main components or

    subsystems:

    1. Air handling units (AHUs) discharge outside fresh air to thesaloon area. There are two AHUs per rail coach.

    2. The fresh air ducts distribute the outside fresh air evenlyover the length of the rail coach. The fresh air leaves the

    duct through diffuser grills.

    3. Ceiling fans tore-circulate the air in the passenger area.A ventilation system cannot guarantee the highest possible level of

    comfort to rail passengers. For optimum comfort, it is not sufficient to

    ensure only a defined supply of fresh air, but in addition, temperature as

    well as humidity and air velocity have to be controlled. This can only be

    achieved by means of an air conditioning system. The ventilation system,

    however, is well suited to control the concentration of carbon di-oxide in

    the breathable air, thus eliminating potential health hazards. In addition,

    the dilution of body odours will significantly add to the passenger comfort.

  • 8/3/2019 Seminar Paper Corrected

    8/16

    Calculation of Fresh Air Flow Rate:

    Under HDCL (High density crush load) conditions, a coach may carry up

    to 600 passengers.

    Doors & windows are closed and no natural ventilation takes place. If no

    fresh air is provided, the concentration of carbon di-oxide concentration

    would reach unacceptable limits within a few minutes as a simplified

    calculation shows:

    The CO2 generation rate of a person is approximately 0,0003 m3/min

    (ANSI/ASHRAE standard 62-2001, informative appendix C). CO2

    concentrations exceeding 5000 ppm are considered dangerous for

    health (ANSI/ASHRAE standard 62-2001, table B-1).

    Within one minute, 470 passengers will generate (0,0003 m3/min x

    470 x 1 min) 0.141 m3 of CO2. With the given coach dimensions and

    taking into account the volumetric effect of the passenger load, the

    air volume in the fully-loaded coach will be approximately 50 m3.

    At a CO2 generation rate of 0,141 m3/min and assuming a CO2Concentration of 500 ppm in the ambient fresh air, the maximum

    permissible CO2 concentration of 5000 ppm would be exceeded

    within less than 2 minutes!

    A forced ventilation system is, therefore, required if no sufficient natural

    ventilation can be provided. ANSI/ASHRAE standard 62-2001

    recommends that the steady-state CO2 concentration in a space should

    not be greater than about 700 ppm above outdoor level. If this can be

    achieved, not only the CO2 concentration will be acceptable (500 ppm +

    700 ppm = 1200 ppm). At the same time, odours from human bioeffluents

    will be diluted to an extent that 80% of unadapted visitors to a space will

    feel comfortable. The required ventilation rate (flow of fresh air) can be

    determined as follows:

    V = N/(CR CA)

    V = Ventilation rate

    N = CO2 generation rate per person

    CR = CO2 concentration inside the rail car

    CA = CO2 concentration in the outdoor ambient air

    with

    (CR - CR) = 700 ppm and

    N = 0,0003 m3/min

    This ventilation rate amounts to approximately 7 l/s/passenger.

    With a load of 600 passengers, the ventilation system will have to provide

    a flow of fresh air at a rate of (7 l/s/passenger x 600 passengers) = 4200 l/s

    = 15000 m3/h.

  • 8/3/2019 Seminar Paper Corrected

    9/16

    Fresh Air Duct Arrangement:

    As specified in documents there is 1 duct running at the centre of the

    coach.

    AHU Arrangement:

    Each rail coach is fitted with two roof mounted air handling units (AHUs).

    The AHUs are located in roof troughs & end wall of the coaches.

    Note: By using two AHUs per coach, the velocity in the fresh air duct

    System is brought under control, as with only 1 AHU, the duct

    Velocity would not be manageable.

  • 8/3/2019 Seminar Paper Corrected

    10/16

    The AHU arrangement satisfies the permitted moving dimensions. D-seals

    will be provided around the fresh air blower openings. These D- seals

    will be compressed and a leak-tight connection to the duct will be

    established as soon as the AHU is fastened to the coach.

    Description of Main components:

    In the following, the main components of the proposed ventilation system

    will be described.

    Air Handling Unit:

    Each rail coach is provided with two air handling units (AHUs). The AHUs

    will be completely interchangeable.

    The AHU comprises 2 motor/blower units. The motors are RDSO-approved,

    3 phase induction motors. The insulation system is capable to withstand

    the voltage stress from the trains static inverter. The motor leads are

    wired to quick-release connectors conforming to RDSO and Indian

    Defense Standard Joint Services specification.

    Electric

    D-seal

    Blower

    500

    21

    32

    1120

    1240

    86

  • 8/3/2019 Seminar Paper Corrected

    11/16

    Based on the extensive experience M/s. SIDWAL has gained in the design,

    manufacturing and maintenance of roof mounted railway air conditions,

    the weather protection grills on the outside of the case assembly have

    been selected, dimensioned and located to ensure that no rain water

    can enter the fresh air duct.

    The fresh air enters the blowers through air screens. They consist of

    corrugated expanded aluminium sheets. The purpose is to preventforeign particles of substantial size (e.g. insects, leaves, etc.) from entering

    the fresh air duct. The air screens are removable.

    The AHU case assembly will be manufactured from grade 202 with 1%

    nickel stainless steel. This alloy is being used in Ducting and Paneling in AC

    DC EMU coaches being built at ICF. Other alloys are available on request.

    Electrical Control System:

    The electrical control system comprises:

    Contactors to operate the blower motors MCBs and motor protection relays

    No switchgear is installed inside the AHU. All switch gear are

    accommodated in an existing coach control panel.

    Fresh air Duct & Diffusers:

    The duct is completely made of stainless steel. For the ease of

    manufacturing, transport and assembly the duct is structured into

    sections.

    Diffuser grills are arranged along the duct length. The grills are ruggedlydesigned, made of aluminium and power-coated for enhanced corrosion

    protection.

    Design Verification:

    A full-scale mock-up of the complete ventilation system was set up and

    tested before the final design was released for production. With help of

    this mock-up, it is possible to test and verify all system components before

    start of production, e.g.

    the distribution of fresh air flow over the length and width of thecoach

    the fresh air flow rate in different modes of operation and underdifferent operating conditions (e.g. windows open/closed).

    the air velocity at diffuser grills and at defined heights from the floor the power consumption, influence of voltage variations & phase

    unbalances

    the sound pressure level at different modes of operation eventhough the actual coach may show somewhat different test results.

  • 8/3/2019 Seminar Paper Corrected

    12/16

    Ceiling Fan arrangement:

    The ceiling fans are very important for the passenger comfort. Since the

    ventilation system is unable to control temperature and humidity, a high

    air velocity is most welcome in a hot and humid climate.

    It is important to understand that the fresh air supply system

    does not much contribute to the air velocity in the passenger

    area. The velocity felt by the passengers is mainly

    determined

    by the ceiling fan arrangement.

    Measures to prevent ingress of water

    The water ingress in the AHU and duct posed the biggest challenge. Most

    critical location was the drawal of rain water through the intake filter of

    AHU which draws air @ 15000 m3 / hr. The following measures have

    helped in arresting water leakage:

    1. Double gaskets have been provided all along the periphery ofthe AHU instead of only around duct cut out.

    2. Sealing the metal interface as additional precaution3. Rubber skit around AHU air inlet.

    Challenges of technology adoption and new practices in manufacturing

    the AC DC EMU: World class cabling practices

    The new look AC DC EMU had posed challenges in the form of new

    equipments, new connectors, huge workload in form of volumes of wiring

    and cabling activity. ICF had been traditionally manufacturing DC EMU,

    AC EMUs & DEMUs with DC drives. The traction control methods followed

    in these type of SPVs were traditional methods requiring comparatively

    less wiring and inter vehicular couplers etc. A brief comparison of work

    load in terms of man hours is given below:

    Coach

    type

    AC

    EMU

    AC/DC

    EMU

    (BHEL)

    AC/DC

    EMU

    (Siemens)

    B Coach 5823 7595 10096

    C Coach 1476 2350 3629

    D Coach 1566 3980 5668

    HC

    Coach

    1557 4149

  • 8/3/2019 Seminar Paper Corrected

    13/16

    The new generation EMU deploys Train Management System (TMS) which

    is achieved by integrating and multiplexing signals for control and

    monitoring of the system. This new system calls for multi vehicular bus

    (MVB) for achieving the control and monitoring. Thus it is extremely

    important to handle and lay the special cables for this purpose.

    There are 34 types of cables used in the new trains including those of

    special purpose cables. In this type of train deploying multiplexing anddata transmission, the electromagnetic interface among the cables,

    circuits are very important considerations as the effect of EMI can be

    disastrous affecting the control of the train. In order to overcome the

    problem of EMI & EMC, the circuits were categorized into A, B & C and

    the minimum clearance was prescribed between them. The cables are

    laid in aluminium conduits located at prescribed distance and earthing

    are provided at every 1m interval to take care of shielding.

    The cables have been laid in the conduits and trays with proper care of

    edge protection at inlet and outlet of conduits, Abrasion resistant conduitand wrappers are used over wires while the wires are laid on end wall and

    in open area. These practices protect the cables against abrasion at

    sharp edges and protection against other materials. These practices are

    one of the best cabling practices in railway coaches which will provide

    trouble free service with respect to cables.

    This train deploys various type of cables and circuits calling for new type

    of I.V. couplers for connection between coaches and new type of

    connectors within the coaches. A set up of a motor coach (Mock up )

    has been created to achieve wiring & connection in free area (as motor

    coach area is cramped with equipments). Here in mock up, a group ofworkmen lay the cable of entire coach, terminate with various types of

    connectors (Harting type), marking ferrules etc. This process simplified the

    wiring in high tension compartment and also cut down the belt time

    drastically.

    Belt time reduction

    Belt time

    ACEMU 25 days

    AC DC (BHEL) 45 days

    AC DC EMU(Siemens)

    30 days

    Testing & Commissioning:

    Testing and commissioning has been the essential component of train

    manufacturing. These new generation trains having train management

    system, requires different protocol compared to the existing EMUs.

    Generally the commissioning tests are divided into two parts, i.e.,

    precommissioning at ICF (coach builder) and commissioning at Mumbai.

  • 8/3/2019 Seminar Paper Corrected

    14/16

    The precommissioning checks involve continuity check, high voltage test

    and current sharing test before control energisation.

    The steps later followed are

    i. Loading of softwareii. 110 V dc (control ckt) proving test also known as static

    control test

    iii. 3 phase testsiv. brake testsv. HV (1500 dc, 25 kV AC) static testvi. HV dynamic test at Basic unit level followed by Rake

    level.

    In addition Rake protocol is also done during rake test which includes PIS,

    changeover etc. These trains are tested during precommissioning in form

    of Basic units comprising of 3 coaches, i.e., each 3 coach (BU) has one

    Motor coach in the middle and two trailer coach on either end. The End

    basic units (EBU) have driving coach as one of the trailer coach whereas

    the middle basic units (MBU) have one NDTC (a trailer coach havingcompressor) as one of the component. Thus for completing one rake

    formation, four BUs (2 EBUs + 2 MBUs) have to be pre-commissioned and

    the rake is formed thereafter.

    The precommissioning period have been also brought down from 7 days

    to 3 days for BUs and 10 days to 5 days for rakes. Thus substantial

    reduction in precommissioning time has helped in reducing the net time

    taken in turning out the rake from coach builders (ICF) premises.

    Energy conservation:

    The present Mumbai Suburban system is run on DCEMU rakes on Central

    and Western Railways. These trains are provided with Rheostatic control

    and Electro pneumatic braking through Friction Brake Blocks. The specific

    energy consumption for these DCEMUs is in the order of 40 KWH / 1000

    GTKM. The 3 phase AC DC EMUs with regenerative braking has a specific

    energy consumption of 29.5 KWH/GTKM.

    The data on the W.Rly indicate that the regeneration is on an average

    greater than 35%. The projected figures of energy consumption / saving

    in the EMU rakes in Mumbai area will bea. Present consumption (204 rakes) : 55 Cr. Units (KWH)

    b. After MUTP 1 if present D.C. EMU

    Technology were continued (253 rakes) 75 Cr. Units (KWH)

    c. After MUTP-1 with New technology EMU

    rakes having regenerative braking

    are introduced (253 rakes) : 55 Cr. Units (KWH)

    d. Energy Saving inspite of increase in

    rake holding from 204 to 253 : 20 Cr. Units (KWH)

  • 8/3/2019 Seminar Paper Corrected

    15/16

    2.0 Benefits of Carbon Credits: Credit accruals;This is the first project in transport sector to be qualified for carbon

    credit.

    Reduction in Carbon consumption:

    Coal : 4.6 x 108 Kg

    LPG : 14.26 x 108 Ltr.

    Crude Oil : 21.46 x 108 Ltr.

    Natural Gas : 21.6 x 108 m3

    Reduction in Pollution:

    CO2 : 2.092 x 108 Kg

    SO2 : 18 x 108 gm

    SPM : 5 x

    108 gm

    Soot Carbon :

    0.2 x 108 gm

    NO : 20 x108 gm

    Cost of the rakes:

    The cost of the rakes is also

    important aspect of the manufacturing process. Due the advanced

    features of the propulsion system and use of FRP paneling, stainless steel

    for roof panels, hand hold, partition and luggage rack, seat frames and

    polycarbonate for seats, the cost of these rakes are higher compared to

    existing DC EMU rakes. The largest metro in India has witnessed new type

    of EMUs during the last few years with 3 phase propulsion system. Acomparison of cost per 12 car equivalent is given below:

    Cost / 12 Car Feature

    New AC/DC

    EMU, MUTP

    Phase I

    INR. 25 Cr. 3 propulsion, + Air ventilation

    (2007) (Corton steel coach

    body)

    DMRC Phase I INR 84Cr 3 propulsion + air conditioning

    + auto door closure+ stainless

    steel coach body (2004)

    A brief of Public Reaction as first AC DC EMU rake with Siemens electrics

    rolled out to Mumbai area.

    This train has passed through a critical review by traveling public and

    media in Mumbai. The leading national dailies and local dailies have

    quoted the public responses.

    Well lit, well ventilated commuter friendly. Silver bullet. A popular name given by the public.

  • 8/3/2019 Seminar Paper Corrected

    16/16

    Future generation is here It is quite spacious ,airy and bright

    With the introduction of more and more AC DC EMU rakes with Siemens

    electrics, the image of suburban trains is changing, ending the ordeal of

    esteemed commuters. Till today 19 rakes have been inducted in the

    Mumbai area, providing additional service. By the end of the current

    financial year, a total of 50 rakes would be inducted which will ease out

    the congestion and crowding.