Upload
jolie
View
27
Download
2
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Section 3300 Exhibit “A” / RX Forms. Brett A. Shearer, R/W Specialist ODOT Central Office. Section 3301 Introduction. All legal descriptions prepared by or for the Ohio Department of Transportation shall be in accordance with the Ohio Revised Code 4733 - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Citation preview
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
1
Section 3300Exhibit “A” / RX Forms
Brett A. Shearer, R/W Specialist ODOT Central Office
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
2
Section 3301 Introduction• All legal descriptions prepared by or for the Ohio
Department of Transportation shall be in accordance with the – Ohio Revised Code 4733 – Ohio Administrative Code Section 4733-37– All applicable county conveyance standards– The Real Estate Policies & Procedures Manual and applicable
District guidelines • Property rights and interests acquired by ODOT are
conveyed through the use of an instrument.• The instruments contain three parts, the Conveyance, the
Acknowledgement and the “Exhibit A” (RX Forms).
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
3
Section 3301 Introduction
• A legal description prepared for ODOT are attached to the instrument as “Exhibit A” on the appropriate RX Form.
• It is the responsibility of the right of way designer and/or reviewer to revise and correct any legal descriptions deemed unacceptable for transfer/recording.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
4
Section 3302 Legal Description Format All legal descriptions shall be prepared using the applicable RX
Forms as supplied by ODOT. Always Download the Forms to use Current Version
Provide legal descriptions that have prior approval by the applicable county office when required by the scope of services document or county regulations.
Submit a paper copy of the legal description signed, sealed and dated, along with an electronic copy in a format as specified by the District Real Estate Administrator.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
5
Section 3303 Legal Description Procedure
• The right of way designer and/or reviewer shall prepare each legal description containing the following data:
The bearings and distances of each take line that must match the bearing and distances given in the right of way plans (R/W Detail Sheets or R/W Boundary Sheet).
• A citation to the public record of the appropriate prior deed(s).Example: Prior Instrument Reference as of the date this survey
was prepared: *Correct citation to county record (e.g., Deed Book and Page, Volume and Page, Official Record, etc.)* of *______* County, Ohio. NOT “Grantor Claims Title”
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
6
Section 3303 Legal Description Procedure
• When describing a bearing/direction, use the words "degree," "minutes," and "seconds." Symbols may be used at the discretion of District Real Estate Administrator.
• The bearing precision shall be to the nearest second.
• Specification of any monuments, e.g., iron pins, iron pipes, railroad spikes, etc., shall be cited in the legal description as found or set.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
7
Section 3303 Legal Description Procedure • Sufficient identification and clarification of the intent of
a course to follow an existing line, if applicable. Here are a few examples:
"...with the grantor's Easterly property line...". "...with the existing Southerly Right of Way line...". "...with the existing centerline of Right of Way...".
• Station and offset calls, at angles, breaks, intersections, etc. shall be included at the discretion of the District Real Estate Administrator.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
8
Section 3304 Closing Statements • The following closing statements (when applicable)
must follow the metes and bounds section of each and every legal description. The closing statements should appear in separate paragraphs, in the order shown below:
Provide a statement indicating the current Auditor's Permanent
Parcel number(s) in which the parcel of land is located. Also provide a breakout of the Present Road Occupied (PRO) in the take area when applicable. When a parcel contains multiple Auditor's Parcel numbers provide a breakout of the area contained in each auditor's parcel number, including the Present Road Occupied (PRO) in the take.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
9
Section 3304 Closing Statements
• Example of a multiple auditor's parcel number:The above described area contains 0.0362 acres of land, more or less, of which the present road occupies 0.000 acres of land, more or less, of which 0.0208 acres is part of Franklin County Auditor's Permanent Parcel number 010-120894, and 0.0154 acres is part of Franklin County Auditor's Permanent Parcel number 010-120893.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
10
Section 3304 Closing Statements
• Parcels which an Auditor's Parcel number cannot be found, provide a statement indicating that the described area is NOT a part of any currently assigned Auditor's Parcel number.
• Basis of bearings used in the legal description
• Surveyor’s name that prepared the legal description, his/her surveyor's Ohio registration number, signature, and the date of writing and/or survey
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
11
Section 3304 Closing Statements
• A statement that the legal description is based on a survey, including reference to the responsible surveyor and the date of the survey.
• SAMPLE LEGAL DESCRIPTIONS– Are available at the respective District Offices
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
12
RX Forms Website• http://
www.dot.state.oh.us/DIVISIONS/PRODMGT/PRODUCTION/ROW/Pages/row.aspx OR
• Pages/RX_Forms.aspx• RX Guidance Memo dated July 21, 2006• RX Form Training Guide
– Gives assistance for completing RX Forms– Always Download Forms to use Current Version
• Contact Brett Shearer if you need assistance with forms or need modifications to meet counties requirements– [email protected]
phone: 614-728-6142
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
13
RX Forms (251 WDV)
RX 251 PID 5889 Rev. 10/06 PARCEL #-WDV
-WDV CTY-RTE-SEC CTY-RTE-SEC Version Date MM/DD/YY
PARCEL #-WDV Error! Reference source not found. -WDV
CTY-RTE-SEC ALL RIGHT, TITLE AND INTEREST IN FEE SIMPLE
IN THE FOLLOWING DESCRIBED PROPERTY WITHOUT LIMITATION OF EXISTING ACCESS RIGHTS
IN THE NAME AND FOR THE USE OF THE "NAME OF LPA AND / OR COUNTY" COUNTY, OHIO
Grantor/Owner, for himself and his heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns, reserves all existing rights of ingress and egress to and from any residual area (as used herein, the expression “Grantor/Owner” includes the plural, and words in the masculine include the feminine or neuter).
[Surveyor’s description of the premises follows]
Project Identification Number (PID)- Each project will be assigned an unique PID number.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
14
RX Forms (251 WDV)
RX 251 PID 5889 Rev. 10/06 PARCEL 23-WDV2
-WDV CTY-RTE-SEC CTY-RTE-SEC Version Date MM/DD/YY
PARCEL 23-WDV2 Error! Reference source not found. -WDV
CTY-RTE-SEC ALL RIGHT, TITLE AND INTEREST IN FEE SIMPLE
IN THE FOLLOWING DESCRIBED PROPERTY WITHOUT LIMITATION OF EXISTING ACCESS RIGHTS
IN THE NAME AND FOR THE USE OF THE "NAME OF LPA AND / OR COUNTY" COUNTY, OHIO
Grantor/Owner, for himself and his heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns, reserves all existing rights of ingress and egress to and from any residual area (as used herein, the expression “Grantor/Owner” includes the plural, and words in the masculine include the feminine or neuter).
[Surveyor’s description of the premises follows]
Parcel Information- The parcel number and identification (type of take) assigned to the ownership. If the ownership has multiple parcel identifiers of the same type a number shall follow.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
15
RX Forms (251 WDV)
RX 251 PID 5889 Rev. 10/06 PARCEL 23-WDV2
-WDV CTY-RTE-SEC WAR-48-21.05 Version Date MM/DD/YY
PARCEL 23-WDV2 Error! Reference source not found. -WDV
WAR-48-21.05 ALL RIGHT, TITLE AND INTEREST IN FEE SIMPLE
IN THE FOLLOWING DESCRIBED PROPERTY WITHOUT LIMITATION OF EXISTING ACCESS RIGHTS
IN THE NAME AND FOR THE USE OF THE "NAME OF LPA AND / OR COUNTY" COUNTY, OHIO
Grantor/Owner, for himself and his heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns, reserves all existing rights of ingress and egress to and from any residual area (as used herein, the expression “Grantor/Owner” includes the plural, and words in the masculine include the feminine or neuter).
[Surveyor’s description of the premises follows]
County, Route, and Section (CTY-RTE-SEC)- This is the county the project is located in, the route number of the roadway being improved, and the section number, a.k.a. straight line mileage
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
16
RX Forms (251 WDV)
RX 251 PID 5889 Rev. 10/06 PARCEL 23-WDV2
-WDV CTY-RTE-SEC WAR-48-21.05 Version Date 10/31/06
PARCEL 23-WDV2 Error! Reference source not found. -WDV
WAR-48-21.05 ALL RIGHT, TITLE AND INTEREST IN FEE SIMPLE
IN THE FOLLOWING DESCRIBED PROPERTY WITHOUT LIMITATION OF EXISTING ACCESS RIGHTS
IN THE NAME AND FOR THE USE OF THE "NAME OF LPA AND / OR COUNTY" COUNTY, OHIO
Grantor/Owner, for himself and his heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns, reserves all existing rights of ingress and egress to and from any residual area (as used herein, the expression “Grantor/Owner” includes the plural, and words in the masculine include the feminine or neuter).
[Surveyor’s description of the premises follows]
Version Date- This is the date that the form was last updated and should be updated any time changes are made.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
17
RX Forms (251 WDV)
RX 251 PID 5889 Rev. 10/06 PARCEL 23-WDV2
-WDV CTY-RTE-SEC WAR-48-21.05 Version Date 10/31/06
PARCEL 23-WDV2 Error! Reference source not found. -WDV
WAR-48-21.05 ALL RIGHT, TITLE AND INTEREST IN FEE SIMPLE
IN THE FOLLOWING DESCRIBED PROPERTY WITHOUT LIMITATION OF EXISTING ACCESS RIGHTS
IN THE NAME AND FOR THE USE OF THE WARREN COUNTY, OHIO
Grantor/Owner, for himself and his heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns, reserves all existing rights of ingress and egress to and from any residual area (as used herein, the expression “Grantor/Owner” includes the plural, and words in the masculine include the feminine or neuter).
[Surveyor’s description of the premises follows]
Name of LPA and/or County- This field is only required on parcels that use the V modifier (parcel identifier). Enter the appropriate county, city and county, and/or township and county names.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
18
RX Forms (251 WDV)
RX 251 PID 5889 Rev. 10/06 PARCEL 23-WDV2
-WDV CTY-RTE-SEC WAR-48-21.05 Version Date 10/31/06
PARCEL 23-WDV2 Error! Reference source not found. -WDV
WAR-48-21.05 ALL RIGHT, TITLE AND INTEREST IN FEE SIMPLE
IN THE FOLLOWING DESCRIBED PROPERTY WITHOUT LIMITATION OF EXISTING ACCESS RIGHTS
IN THE NAME AND FOR THE USE OF THE WARREN COUNTY, OHIO
Grantor/Owner, for himself and his heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns, reserves all existing rights of ingress and egress to and from any residual area (as used herein, the expression “Grantor/Owner” includes the plural, and words in the masculine include the feminine or neuter).
[Surveyor’s description of the premises follows]
Surveyor’s Description- Is the area where the surveyor will either type or paste the legal description in accordance with the current Ohio Revised Code 4733 and 4733-37, all applicable County Conveyance Standards the Real Estate Policies and Procedures Manual, and applicable District guidelines.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
19
RX Forms (282 U)The first paragraph of the Utility RX Form (282 U) must be
customized for the particular utility company and utility type. This paragraph will describe the purpose of the take.
RX 282 PID ##### Rev. 09/06 PARCEL #-U
- U CTY-RTE-SEC CTY-RTE-SEC Version Date MM/DD/YY
PARCEL #-U Error! Reference source not found. -U
CTY-RTE-SEC PERPETUAL EASEMENT FOR UTILITY PURPOSES
IN THE NAME AND FOR THE USE OF NAME OF UTILITY
The first paragraph(s) must be fully customized for the particular utility company and utility type (gas, water, electric, multi-purpose, etc.).
[Surveyor’s description of the premises follows]
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
20
LPA RX Forms
• Are available to download at the following address:– www.dot.state.oh.us/Divisions/ProdMgt/Production/row/Pages/RX_Forms.aspx
• Used when the LPA is acquiring in its own name• Temporary Easements “T” must be in the name of the
agency administering the construction.• Therefore “TV” takes should be used sparingly
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
21
Local Public Agencies and Designing their
RW Plans
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
22
Local Let Program
• The National Transportation Act has made available certain Federal funding for use by local public agencies. The Federal Highway Administration designated ODOT as the agency in Ohio to administer FHWA’s Federal funding programs.
• Section 5501.03 (C) of the Ohio Revised Code provides that ODOT may coordinate its activities and enter into contracts with other appropriate public authorities to administer the design, qualification of bidders, competitive bid letting, construction, inspection, and acceptance of any projects administered by ODOT, provided the administration of such projects is performed in accordance with all applicable Federal and State laws and regulations with oversight by ODOT.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
23
Federal Funding SourcesMetropolitan Planning Organizations (MPO) – 17 statewide
• Surface Transportation Program (STP)• Transportation Enhancement funds• Congestion Mitigation and Air Quality (CMAQ)
County Engineers Association of Ohio (CEAO)• County Local Bridge (LBR)• County Surface Transportation Program (CSTP)
ODOT • TEP, Small City Program (LPA’s outside of an MPO)• Municipal Bridge Program
Earmark and Discretionaryhttp://www.dot.state.oh.us/local/ http://www.dot.state.oh.us/local/
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
24
Traditional/Non-Traditional Traditional
• Project sponsor is a local public agency: cities, counties, parks, TID’s etc.
• Funding source is Federal or State or both.• Local contracts for all design services.• ODOT administers the project as its own: plan
review, bidding, award and construction management.
• In most cases the LPA acquires RW if needed.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
25
Non-Traditional• Project sponsor is a local public agency:
cities, counties, parks, TID’s etc.• Funding source is Federal or State or both.• Local contracts for all design services.• Local administers the project.• Local acquires RW if needed.
Traditional/Non-Traditional
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
26
Federal Money in RW No Federal Money in RW
TraditionalLPA
Acquiring
1. R/W Plan Review2. REA #1 Executed3. LPA Compliance with REA
Listing Prequalified Individual & Fee Schedule
4. Environmental Clearance & Federal Authorization
5. District Authorization to Commence Acquisition
6. District Monitor Acquisition
7. LPA to Submit R/W Certification
8. Compliance Review by District
1. R/W Plan Review2. REA #2 Executed3. LPA Compliance with REA
Listing Prequalified Individual & Fee Schedule
4. District Authorization to Commence Acquisition
5. District Monitor Acquisition
6. LPA to Submit R/W Certification
7. Compliance Review by District
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
27
Federal Money in RW No Federal Money in RW
Non-Traditional
LPA Acquiring
1. R/W Plan Review2. Outline Letter “A”3. LPA Complies with Outline
Letter Listing Pre-qualified Individual
4. Environmental Clearance & Federal Authorization
5. District Authorization to Commence Acquisition
6. District Monitor Acquisition
7. LPA to Submit R/W Certification
8. Compliance Review by District
1. R/W Plan Review2. Outline Letter “B”3. LPA Complies with Outline
Letter Listing Pre-qualified Individual
4. District Authorization to Commence Acquisition
5. District Monitor Acquisition
6. LPA to Submit R/W Certification
7. Compliance Review by District
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
28
• What are the differences between and ODOT RW plan and a LPA RW plan?
• Other than the project sponsor and administration …..
Absolutely Nothing Well, maybe a couple of things ….
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
29
Types of Title Required• Federal/State $$$ in RW – Fee only
Why? ORC prohibits charging underlying fee owner to vacate easement rights. Feds cannot recoup their investment.
• Local $$$ in RW – Can be Fee or Standard Highway Easement.
Bike trails utilizing utility corridors or area with environmental issues can use long term lease agreements or easements. FHWA will not accept license agreements.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
30
• RX Forms• If ODOT is acquiring for LPA, appropriate form
must be used.• If LPA is acquiring, ODOT’s forms are optional.
• Other property rights i.e.. Channel, Slope, Temporary etc. as applicable.
A work agreement/right of entry cannot substitute for work outside of permanent RW. Owners must be compensated (FMV established by an appraisal) for use of their land.
Types of Title Required
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
31
•Traditional
Must use ODOT format per RW manual.•Non-Traditional
If local has standardized drawings, minor variations allowed. Mostly title block, legends and line style. Plat, property map, summary and plan sheets required.
PLAN Format
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
32
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
33
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
34
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
35
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
36
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
37
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
38
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
39
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
40
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
41
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
42
R/W Plan Review Process
Doug Raters, P.E. ODOT District 8 REA
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
43
RIGHT OF WAY PLAN REVIEW PROCESS• Preliminary Right of Way Plan Review
Responsibilities– Consultant In-house Review (QC) ODOT WILL NOT DO YOUR QUALITY CONTROL!!– Completed Right of Way Checklist
• Preliminary Right of Way Submittal– Items needed/included
• Review Scope Document• Review Right of Way Attachment• Plan Sheets• Title reports for review, if Scoped
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
44
RIGHT OF WAY PLAN REVIEW PROCESS
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
45
RIGHT OF WAY PLAN REVIEW PROCESS
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
46
RIGHT OF WAY PLAN REVIEW PROCESS
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
47
RIGHT OF WAY PLAN REVIEW PROCESS
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
48
RIGHT OF WAY PLAN REVIEW PROCESS• Final Right of Way Plan Review Responsibilities
-Comply with Preliminary Right of Way Review Comments-Review Stage 2 Roadway Detailed Design Comments-Be sure the Take, Save and Do Not Disturb items on both the R/ W and Roadway Plans agree-Field Review for Topo Update-Ownership Updates-Update of Utility Information from Field review &
CommentsSufficient Right of Way Takes for Utility Relocations
Early Right of Way AcquisitionOil and Gas Wells / Leases
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
49
RIGHT OF WAY PLAN REVIEW PROCESS• Standard Legal Description Format
– County Recording Requirements – Legal Description as Exhibit “A” & RX Forms
– http://www.dot.state.oh.us/real/• RX Guidance Memo dated July 21, 2006• RX Form Training Guide• Always Download Forms to use Current Version
– Right of Way Monumentation– Reference and Witness Survey Monuments– Legal Description Checklist
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
50
RIGHT OF WAY PLAN REVIEW PROCESS• Final Right of Way Plan Reviewer Responsibilities
– Consultant In-house Final Review (QC)• Complete Right of Way Plan Review Check Sheet and
Submit• AGAIN, ODOT IS NOT DOING YOUR QC CHECK!!
– Legal Description Review with Closure Sheets• Complete Legal Description Review Check Sheet and
Submit• Make sure they match the plans!!
– Titles/Ownership updates
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
51
RIGHT OF WAY PLAN REVIEW PROCESS• Right of Way Tracings Submittal
– Address Final Right of Way Review Comments– Date Field Review completed applied to the Legend Sheet– Date Ownership Verified applied to the Legend Sheet– Date R/W Plan COMPLETED applied to the Legend Sheet– Appropriate size and number of Copies of Right of Way Plan
Sets• Mylars (Per Scope / District Office)
– All Legal Descriptions• Signed and Sealed “Original” • Pre-Approval of Descriptions
– County Engineer's or Tax Map Stamp / Letter of Approval– Electronic Format of Plan and Descriptions Per Scope– Title Reports (if Scoped)
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
52
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
53
QUESTIONS?
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
54
QUALITY CONTROL
• Plan Review Evaluation
• Two reviews:– Initial Evaluation when Right of Way Tracings are
accepted by the District. Depending on the project size an interim evaluation may be done.
– Secondary Post – Acquisition Evaluation completed by the acquiring agency. This evaluation can only lower the initial score not raise it.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
55
QUALITY CONTROL
• Types of Review:
– Reference the March 27, 2000 Consultant Evaluation System Manual for details of ODOT’s Evaluation System.
– The System includes rating forms specific to agreement type, including Design, Environmental, Bridge Inspection, Task Order, Real Estate Acquisition and Construction Inspection. Common to all agreements is the management and timeliness criteria and scoring.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
56
QUALITY CONTROL• Management Review
– Was the Consultant project manager in control of the services provided to ODOT?
– Did the Consultant communicate adequately with the Department Staff?
– Did the Consultant coordinate, actively manage and closely monitor the work of sub-consultants and various technical disciplines involved in the project?
– Was the Consultant responsive to requests from the Department and other reviewing agencies, including requests for information and requests to make minor changes in the work?
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
57
QUALITY CONTROL
• Timeliness Review– Did the Consultant meet the final contract time
requirements?
– Did the Consultant meet intermediate submittal dates?
Were plans and descriptions received on time(commitment date), were all review submissions receivedon time, and were plan revisions completed in a timelymanner?
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
58
QUALITY CONTROL
• Performance Review for R/W Plan Production
– Right of Way limits & parcel types established properly?
– Details complete and plan preparation meets ODOT requirements, including topography and title information?
– Local County Right-of-Way plan and legal description requirements met?
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
59
QUALITY CONTROL
• Feedback from R/W Acquisition Process (Secondary Post- Acquisition)– Did the R/W Plan, as prepared, provide for a neat, clear
and easily read plan?
– Was the R/W plan format in conformance with Section 3100 and 3200 of the Real Estate Policies and Procedure Manual?
– Were the title data and parcel areas accurate, complete, and current?
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
60
QUALITY CONTROL
– Were the R/W plans and descriptions prepared in accordance with the local county conveyance standards?
– Were the topography and property improvements both below and above ground, accurate, complete and current?
– Did the design of the proposed R/W and the types of title shown “best fit” the actual field conditions?
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
61
QUALITY CONTROL
REAL ESTATE RATINGS
Plan Review Evaluation (District) Post-Acquisition Evaluation (Region)
RATING CRITERIA
10-8-5-1 Scoring System Each rating requires a written comment
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
62
QUALITY CONTROL
Exceeds (E) - 10 points
The consultant exceeded the requirements and expectations of the scope of services
Satisfactory (S) - 8 points
Acceptable work product with minimal involvement by the Department
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
63
QUALITY CONTROL
Improvement Required (IR) - 5 points
The consultant’s work required substantive comments by the Department
Unsatisfactory (U) - 1 point
Extensive involvement by Department personnel required
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
64
What Happens to the R/W Plans after they are submitted to ODOT
Dave Dicke, ODOT District 2 REA
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
65
My presentation today will:
• Review the reason we are here• Identify and expand user’s needs for good plans• Discuss reasons plans change• Who pays for changes and why• Remind you why we need quality in plans
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
66
The Power Of Eminent Domain Is Immense
• There is a blatant public dislike of eminent domain• Agencies are often perceived as abusing their
power when using it• Governmental Agencies Must:
– Deal honestly and with empathy
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
67
5th Amendment U.S. Constitution “No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or
otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the Militia, when in actual service in time of War or public danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offense to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb, nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, Without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use without just compensation.”
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
68
Eminent Domain OverviewUniform Act passed by US Congress 1/2/71. The law is called
the Uniform Relocation and Real Property Acquisition Policies Act.
Code of Federal Regulations 49 CFR 24. subpart B for Real Property Acquisition and Part C for General Relocation Requirements.
The codes amplify the Uniform Act and give more direction to an agency for carrying out the law.
State Governments must establish lead agencies. ORC 163.01 – 163.62 Ohio Administrative Code create State
law and policy. And the Governor named ODOT to be the lead agency.
Section 19, Article I, Ohio Constitution“…When taken … for the purpose of making or repairing
roads, which shall be open to the public, without charge, a compensation shall be made to the owner, in money…”
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
69
What does all this have to do with me and this class?
• A clear policy and procedure is in place for ODOT projects from inception to project completion.
• This P&P includes the preparation of r/w plans. • When r/w is needed your plan becomes the foundation to
which the acquisition process is built. Eminent domain may be used to conclude the process.
• The accuracy and concept of the plan cannot be flawed or the process may fail.
• As eminent domain remains a focal public issue the need for the accuracy of the plan and concept is amplified.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
70
Users of R/W Plans
• Title Agents: to identify all interests to be acquired• Appraisers and Reviewers: to evaluate the effect• Acquisition Agents: to acquire the needed rights• Relocation Agents: assist in the moving of people
and property• Property Owners: to understand the issues• Attorneys: to litigate the issues and values• Surveyors: as a permanent record of the
transaction
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
71
Users of R/W Plans
• Real Estate Agents: for future sales• Future Right of Way Plan Designers: as a
permanent record • County Auditors: to assess taxes• County Engineers: to maintain records and roads• City Engineers/Service Directors: as reference and
for planning purposes, a permanent record• Assistant Attorney General Attorneys: litigation and
appeal
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
72
What causes us to change plans
• Survey error historical or by consultant error• Topo error/missing, items added after 1st survey • Construction design error requiring revision• FED/ODOT design criteria change• Owner/ODOT negotiated change• Court ordered change or as a result of settlement• Construction contractor desire/error• Constructability issues may be an error
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
73
Common Errors/Omissions on R/W PlansCOMMON ERRORS/OMISSIONS ON R/W PLANS
1. Topography is often outdated or not properly depicted - needs to be updated just before final
tracing submission. 2. Septic and leach lines that could possibly be affected by the project need to be shown on the
final plans. The consultant should talk to the property owner or occupant about these and other underground or hidden amenities such as wells, private water lines, security systems, etc.
3. Show all structures within 100 feet, in their proper location, with a distance to the proposed
right of way line. 4. Trees- show correct location and describe individually those that are not part of casual
growth and that add intrinsic value. 5. All items inside temporary takes but outside construction limits should be labeled “Take” or
“Do Not Disturb”. 6. Structures near a take should be marked “Do Not Disturb” and described - i.e. 1-story
commercial- with addresses shown. 7. Show all existing field drives. Replace as necessary. 8. Show all fences and gates in their proper location and describe them as to type. 9. The starting/commencing point and lead-in of legal descriptions needs to be shown on plan. 10. Metes and bounds on plans should match metes and bounds on legal. 11. Do not create encroachments by marking items “Do Not Disturb” in new permanent right of
way. 12. Be certain that all topography on right of way sheets agrees with topo on construction
plan/profile sheets, especially take/save items. 13. Current owner info is often outdated. Update per scope and Right of Way Attachment. 14. Existing private/utility easements not shown. Recording data and area overlaps to be on
Summary and/or Detail sheets. 15. Legals don’t meet County recording standards- i.e. auditors parcel splits, lead-ins,
commencing/beginning points, etc.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
74
Common Errors/Omissions on R/W Plans
COMMON ERRORS/OMISSIONS ON R/W PLANS
1. Topography is often outdated or not properly depicted - needs to be updated just before final tracing submission.
2. Septic and leach lines that could possibly be affected by the project need to be shown on the
final plans. The consultant should talk to the property owner or occupant about these and other underground or hidden amenities such as wells, private water lines, security systems, etc.
3. Show all structures within 100 feet, in their proper location, with a distance to the proposed
right of way line. 4. Trees- show correct location and describe individually those that are not part of casual
growth and that add intrinsic value. 5. All items inside temporary takes but outside construction limits should be labeled “Take” or
“Do Not Disturb”. 6. Structures near a take should be marked “Do Not Disturb” and described - i.e. 1-story
commercial- with addresses shown. 7. Show all existing field drives. Replace as necessary. 8. Show all fences and gates in their proper location and describe them as to type. 9. The starting/commencing point and lead-in of legal descriptions needs to be shown on plan. 10. Metes and bounds on plans should match metes and bounds on legal. 11. Do not create encroachments by marking items “Do Not Disturb” in new permanent right of
way. 12. Be certain that all topography on right of way sheets agrees with topo on construction
plan/profile sheets, especially take/save items. 13. Current owner info is often outdated. Update per scope and Right of Way Attachment. 14. Existing private/utility easements not shown. Recording data and area overlaps to be on
Summary and/or Detail sheets. 15. Legals don’t meet County recording standards- i.e. auditors parcel splits, lead-ins,
commencing/beginning points, etc.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
75
How soon do you need them?
• In most if not all cases ASAP• Changes/corrections will require rework of many
documents.• Delivery of those documents may hold up a closing or
appropriation filing, hence a project clearance, hence utility relocation
• Which effect sale date, funding, and may effect environmental issues within the plan, and may well delay completion for another year… over just a few day delay in plan delivery….. Caused by a mistake or a negotiated settlement.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
76
Mistakes
Mistakes in Plan Detail Costs TIME!!! Timing in R/W is Critical to Project Delivery!
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
77
Survey error, plan contractor. Contractor will be liable for costs to revise.
Errors in Plan
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
LUC
LUC-2-32.21 2008 R/W plan with errors
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
LUC-2-31.55 PLAN DONE 4-30-1952
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
Error by not confirming existing R/W
• Used old 1952 plan for right of way• Assumed 1952 r/w was acquired by deed• Used ODOT 42 year root title as “enough”• Did not confirm types of record transfer• Owners object to ODOT assumed property line• Plans show no PRO• Plans must be corrected• Acquisition on hold, will require corrections
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
81
Survey error missed topo, plan contractor liable for changes
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
82
Plan change from negotiations/appropriation, consultant will be paid for changes This was the design before
changes.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
83
Pine Street revision created during pre appropriation meetings with the owner. This required the consultant to create a new r/w plan sheet along with construction
plan changes in a matter of a few weeks. Consultant will be paid for revisions.
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
84
Your plans are the foundation
• Mistakes will cause the rework of those to follow you.
• Errors will cost time and money. Both the agency and your company/insurance
• Topography missed may lead to revision, under compensation and appropriation
• Your plans may be the next case reviewed by the court system…. Getter’ done, right!
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
85
Your plan is the beginning of a complex processLets get it right for those who follow….
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
86
Pre-Qualification Course
• Quiz
• Quiz Review
• Open Discussion
Ohio Depar t ment of Tr anspor t at ion – R/W P l an Devel opment
87
Proposed C/L
No construction limits