SCS &GIS ENABLED PROJECT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION PHASE OF GAS DISTRIBUTION PROJECT

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/20/2019 SCS &GIS ENABLED PROJECT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION PHASE OF GAS DIS…

    1/14

    http://www.iaeme.com/IJMET/index.asp 156 [email protected]

    International Journal of Mechanical Engineering and Technology (IJMET)Volume 6, Issue 8, Aug 2015, pp. 156-169, Article ID: IJMET_06_08_015Available online athttp://www.iaeme.com/IJMET/issues.asp?JTypeIJMET&VType=6&IType=8ISSN Print: 0976-6340 and ISSN Online: 0976-6359© IAEME Publication

     ________________________________________________________________________ 

    SCS &GIS ENABLED PROJECT

    MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FORDEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION

    PHASE OF GAS DISTRIBUTION PROJECT

    G. Dhamodaran

    Department of Mechanical Engineering, School of Mechanical Engineering,

    AMET University, Chennai

    R. J. Golden Ranjith

    Assistant Professor, Dept. of Mechanical Engineering,

    Bharath University, Chennai, India

    ABSTRACT

    Background/Objectives : To investigate the usefulness of requirement of‘ Supervisory Control System for Gas Distribution Construction Project

     Management ’. 

    Methods/Stati sti cal analysis : Human Video interface model preparationand updating the live progress of the project to Update on the monitorinstalled in Central Project Room thru Arc GIS and other Pipeline modules

    interlinking with GPS Technology.

    Results/Findings : Can be implemented at construction projects of Gas

     Distribution Project where there will be complex Network of pipelines andwere geographically dispersed.

    Conclusion/Application : “Supervisory Control System with GIS data fordevelopment and implementation phase for Gas Distribution Construction

     Project Management” can be implemented.

    Key words:

    Human Video Interface Monitor- Large size monitor where the entirenetwork of the Gas distribution circuit can be seen and required selection can

     be made based on the requirement.

    GIS -Geographical Information System  –  Integrated Tool/Application

    having Geographical information’s which maps all data related to the pipelinenetwork.

  • 8/20/2019 SCS &GIS ENABLED PROJECT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION PHASE OF GAS DIS…

    2/14

    SCS & GIS Enabled Project Management System for Development and ImplementationPhase of Gas Distribution Project

    http://www.iaeme.com/IJMET/index.asp 157 [email protected]

    Central Project Room- The Project Management room installed with theMonitor from where Progress is analysed and further front generation and

     planning act ivities can be planned

    Pipelines modules- The pipeline drawing software’s which produce the

    alignment sheets

    Pipeline alignment sheets- the drawing to the pipeline will all data likelength, corridor, co-ordinates, fittings, cable details, turning points etc.

    GPS Technology- The Radio frequency transfer technology thru which the progress can be updated.

    SCS- Supervisory Control System- System with HMI enables to manage theProject having the facility of real-time updation of the data thru GPStechnology.

    Cite this Article:  Dhamodaran, G. and Golden Ranjith, R. J. SCS & GISenabled Project Management System for Development and Implementation

     phase of Gas Distribution Project.  International Journal of Mechanical Engineering and Technology, 6(8), 2015, pp. 151-164.http://www.iaeme.com/IJMET/issues.asp?JTypeIJMET&VType=6&IType=8

    1. INTRODUCTION

    The Pipeline network of the Gas distribution is a more complex network andconstruction of these kind of networks is a big task as many activities like Survey,Land acquisition, Right of way acquiring, Right of Use acquiring, excavation, laying,

    testing, padding, cables installat ion, back filling, restoration etc..

    There may be Trunk lines, lateral lines, Branch lines, final flow lines which will

     be many numbers according to the distribution network, size of the p ipelines will bevarying with respect to the consumers located in one particular line or area. Also therewill be many nodes, turning points to avoid any other facilities, with this kind of

    complex networks; Project management becomes cumbersome exercise to haveoverall control over the Entire Project.

    To overcome that Computer enabled methodology which will be having there preloaded data like pipeline routing, and ot her data. will have to be graphicallyrepresented and daily progress in each field are to be updated. Updation is easy in

     present days as many internet or GPRS enabled messengers are available in themarket like Whats-app, Telegram etc.. Constructing these complex pipeline facilities

    for Gas Distribution Network are challenging tasks and generally this activity drivesthe project.

    2. PRESENT METHOD AND ITS DIFFICULTIES

    2.1. Present method being followed in the industry

    In general, Every major portions either in terms of Trunk lines or in terms ofarea/Villages are being segregated and contracted with some agencies and based on

    the progress reports and rare occasion meetings the progress is measured and there isno solid method available for front generation other than individuals’ capabilities.

    Also conducting regular meeting with all the contractor by Project Manager is a

    simple task and the person representing the individual area. Village/Trunk line alsomay not have th full knowledge about the happenings and further plans. To overcome

  • 8/20/2019 SCS &GIS ENABLED PROJECT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION PHASE OF GAS DIS…

    3/14

    G. Dhamodaran and R. J. Golden Ranjith

    http://www.iaeme.com/IJMET/index.asp 158 [email protected]

    this one Project Management Cell with Supervisory Control System may be requiredand the updation s to be made simple.

    2.2. Difficulties in present methods

    As many of the areas were spread over many of the villages and many of the districts,

    only best way is to have the regular meetings with each of the one on regular intervalsat any office accessible by every one of the project. Here in this system everyone hasto spend the time may be whole day oe even more than a day. Because to this, themeeting once in a week cannot be arranged and co-ordination becomes cumbersome

    and hence delays the project

    3. PROPOSED METHODOLOGY

    In the Proposal submitter here, the Central Control Room has to be located withsomewhere at the central location of the Gas distribution area. There in the CentralControl Room, One big size with all required storages, servers, UPS, Work Station,

    Preloaded software, Pre-loaded pipeline route/geographical data. HMI Screens etc.A point to multipoint low band width radio connection will serve the purpose,

    where the entire distribution network will get connected to the CCR. Where everrequired some FOC network can also be implemented if required and volume of datatransmission is high in nature. From the work location real-time updation by

    respective field engineer will update the master data thru the radio network or GPRSenabled smart mobile phone where an application will have to be developed to

    connect to Servers and HMI monitors. All networks and servers to be made accessiblethrough LAN/ WAN / WEB / GPRS Network.  

    3.1. Database creation and Server Management

    The following steps to be followed to create the master database. The Pipeline Datamanagement system based on Engineering and GIS to be developed by experiencedspecialist vendor. The entire field facilities and pipeline network to be mapped usingSatellite images procured for the Field development area.

    A master database of entire pipeline information will be created using GIS tools.The master database to include detailed facility layouts, pipeline alignment drawings,

    facility location database, support facility information, ROU information, linkedtechnical specifications, sparing schedule, maintenance schedule, and piggingschedule.

    The Following minimum features will be provided in the Engineering Cum GIS

     based pipeline database management system:  Drawing release status

      ROU application status

      ROW application status

      Revenue Survey details

      Other lands acquisition status

      Land over/ROU Compensation payment Status

      Soil status

      Excavation Status

     

    Pipeline/Cable /other material arrival Status

      Joints Welding Progress

  • 8/20/2019 SCS &GIS ENABLED PROJECT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION PHASE OF GAS DIS…

    4/14

    SCS & GIS Enabled Project Management System for Development and ImplementationPhase of Gas Distribution Project

    http://www.iaeme.com/IJMET/index.asp 159 [email protected]

      Lowering Status

      Testing status and Reports

      Backfilling Status

      Pigging schedules

     

    Customised report generation.  Accessibility to all relevant information / documents / drawings etc.

    The proposed method is having majorly two parts called 1. GeographicalInformation System (GIS) and 2. Supervisory Control System (SCS)

    3.1.1. Geographi cal I nformati on System

    This is Software supplied by various companies around the world which helps inviewing and managing the integrated pipeline network. This Spatially enabled GIS

    Model manages the all pipeline attributes in centre line data with ensuring accuracy indata.

    GIS system meets all the general and minimum requirement such as Database setup, survey data uploading and reference, data exchange between various stakeholders,Alignment sheet Generations, Crossing drawings, Reference drawings, MTOPreparation etc. As this stores High Resolution Satellite imagery, data accuracy will

     be attained.

    The following Steps to be followed

      Taking the High Resolution Satellite Imageries and updating in server

      Verification of the Survey data

    o  Verification with respect to Spheroid/Ellipsoid Parameterso  Verification with respect to topological and topographical parameters

    Verification by superimposing Survey data with HRSIs

      Uploading and updating the database server

      Carrying out detailed Engineering works

    With this the following minimum engineering deliverables can be extracted

      Integrated Alignment Sheets

      Crossing Drawings

      Pipeline, Electrical and FOC standard drawings

      Integrated MTOs for various disciplines

    The following are the some of the important survey data which may be required toupdate the database

      Land base information

      Feed Data

      Detailed Route Survey information

      Topographical Survey information

      Ground Profile data

      Population Density Index 

  • 8/20/2019 SCS &GIS ENABLED PROJECT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION PHASE OF GAS DIS…

    5/14

    G. Dhamodaran and R. J. Golden Ranjith

    http://www.iaeme.com/IJMET/index.asp 160 [email protected]

    Flowchart for Database Setup and utilizing for Detailed Engineering

    Figure 1 Flow Chart for GIS Data base setup, updation and Detailed Engineering

    •Data Base Setup

    BasicData

    •HRSI

    •Admin Privilages

    •Land Base Information

    •Feed Data

    Survey

    •Route Survey Infomation

    •Topographicla Survey Information

    Ground Profile Data•Population Density Index

    Update

    Data

    Process

    Integrated Alignment Sheets

    Standard / Reference Drawings

    MTOs

  • 8/20/2019 SCS &GIS ENABLED PROJECT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION PHASE OF GAS DIS…

    6/14

    SCS & GIS Enabled Project Management System for Development and ImplementationPhase of Gas Distribution Project

    http://www.iaeme.com/IJMET/index.asp 161 [email protected]

    Some of the major Advantages of using Geographical Information System

      Efforts required to manage records can be minimised

      Efforts require to communicate with increased noumbers of stake holders can beminimised

     

    Multiple data editors at one time can be increased with respect to size of the Project  Ease of Producing the Reports

      Ease of Producing Engineering Deliverables

      Visualisation by viewing the status in Web browser

      Integrated link between Construction Contractor, Owner, Project Manager, Financinginstitute, Surveyors, engineers, Inspectors, Detail engineering Contractor, ROUAgents, Environmental Team, CSR Team etc.

      Ease maintenance of E-log book

      Viewing and Referring Survey shots whenever required

      Permissions Status

     

    Ease MIS Reporting

      Crossing and legal permission Status

      Accuracy in Data

      Integrity in data

      Efficient Project Management

      Developing various Databases

      Production of various Auto Cad Drawings

      Linking Graphics to tables an d databases

      Editing As built drawings

     

    Tracing of Joints and status reporting

      Uniqueness in data management

      Aligning all project managers in one approach

      Ease interface with SQL Servers

      Ease in exporting graphics in required format

      Generations of notification and alerts on daily updates and pending works

    3.1.2. Supervisory Control System

    The Central Control Room will be manned 24/7 and monitors the field parameters and

    equipment status & alarms. The Control Room Operators will be responsible foralerting the Filed Construction team for any Follow up actions and control actions to

     be taken at any of the field sites visa viz. Trunk lines, Branch lines, Lateral Lines,Field Lines or any other Permanent facilities oft the Project

    This control Room will be Equipped with the large Video cum HMI Monitor

    where the entire Pipeline network will be visually seen and the required portions can be enlarged and seen. With the help of any suitable application thru the GPS

    frequency Signal site construction progress will be updated in the master data whichwill be of real-time updation.

     Network system required to transmit the data could be either LAN/WIFI/Wireless

    technology or any other thing. The follow up actions can be automatically or

    manually sent to the required portion or the project manager.

  • 8/20/2019 SCS &GIS ENABLED PROJECT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION PHASE OF GAS DIS…

    7/14

    G. Dhamodaran and R. J. Golden Ranjith

    http://www.iaeme.com/IJMET/index.asp 162 [email protected]

    Remote Terminal Units(RTU) can be installed and important nodal points thruwhich the data can be communicated to the th central control Room. These RTUs will

     be collecting data from the Various facilities and p ipeline segments and transfer themto the Central Control Room.

    The instrumentation & automation data from the Well will require low bandwidth;

    data polling will be on real-time basis. A point to multi point microwave radionetworks will meet the requirement. There may be other low band width requirements

    for IT voice network and for Security Automation. These can also be connectedthrough the same Radio network

    3.2. Various WBS and Activities to get covered

    With the implementation of this SCS the following WBS may be getting coveredalong with applicable Activities

    Engineering-

    Detail Engineering Status,

    MTOs,Alignment Sheet Revision Status,

    Schedule of releasing the other documents related to the particular section or part ofthe pipeline or facilities.

    Procurement-

    MR Status,

    RFQ Status,

    Material delivery status,

    Material shifting status to erection location

    Legal-Permiss ion Status,

    Land Acquisition Status,

    Crossing Details,

    ROU Application Status,

    ROW Status,

    Compensation S tatus,

    Local agitation details

    Construction-

    Excavation,Grading

    Bedding,

    Stringing,

    Joints welding,

    Lowering,

    Testing,

    Back filling,

    Restoration

  • 8/20/2019 SCS &GIS ENABLED PROJECT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION PHASE OF GAS DIS…

    8/14

    SCS & GIS Enabled Project Management System for Development and ImplementationPhase of Gas Distribution Project

    http://www.iaeme.com/IJMET/index.asp 163 [email protected]

    Other these, there are many other options can also be inducted in the Engineering-Cum-GIS based construction data base.

    3.3. Options to be made available in menu

    With the implementation of this SCS the following WBS may be getting covered

    along with applicable Activities.

    The following table shows the list of options that may be required as a minimumto continue the construction

    3.3.1. Engi neeri ng Phase

    Table 1 Various Menu options required during Engineering Phase

    Phase Location Entity Activity ProgressTime

    lineDocument

    Quantity

    Status

    Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 Level 5

    Sub

    Level-1

    Sub level-

    2

    Sub

    level-3

    Engineering

    TrunkLine/

    Lateralline/

    Branchline/ Flow

    Line/From

    Chainage/To

    Chainage

    Alignmentsheet

    Preparation

    StartedTarget to

    StartView

    Procurement

    Village/Survey

     Number/Land

    Owner

    MTODraft

    ReleaseIn

     progressTarget to

    FinishDownload

    Legal

    otherEngineerin

    gDeliverable

    approvalComplete

    dTarget toRelease

    Retrive

    Constructi

    on

    Release Approved Extract

    FinalRelease

    Sent forApproval

    Upload

    Revised Comment

    Released

    Menu such as status of the all deliverables, their time line data can be fed. Also

    the quantity status also can be included either in terms of numbers or in terms of percentages. In order to track the engineering deliverables the options like comment,

    upload etc can now be included.

  • 8/20/2019 SCS &GIS ENABLED PROJECT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION PHASE OF GAS DIS…

    9/14

    G. Dhamodaran and R. J. Golden Ranjith

    http://www.iaeme.com/IJMET/index.asp 164 [email protected]

    Concern area manager/project engineer can upload the status immediately eitherthru eh Android enabled application in smartphone or any other means of system

    inclusion.

    3.3.2. Procurement Phase

    Table 2 Various Menu options required during Procurement Phase

    Phase Location Entity Activity ProgressTimeline

    Document

    Quantity

    Stat

    us

    Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 Level 5

    Sub

    Level-

    1

    Sub level-2

    Sub

    level

    -3

    Engineering

    TrunkLine/Lateral

    line/Branch

    line/FlowLine/From

    Chainage/To

    Chainage

    MR Preparation StartedTargetto Start

    View

    Procurement

    Village/Survey

     Number/Land

    Owner

    RFQDraft

    ReleaseIn

     progress

    Targetto

    FinishDownload

    Legal Delivery approval CompletedTarget

    toRelease

    Retrieve

    Construction Release Approved Extract

    Final

    Release

    Sent for

    Approval Upload

    Published Revised Comment

    BidsReceived

    Released Check

    Evaluated

    Ordered

    Received

  • 8/20/2019 SCS &GIS ENABLED PROJECT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION PHASE OF GAS DIS…

    10/14

  • 8/20/2019 SCS &GIS ENABLED PROJECT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION PHASE OF GAS DIS…

    11/14

    G. Dhamodaran and R. J. Golden Ranjith

    http://www.iaeme.com/IJMET/index.asp 166 [email protected]

    Payments status to various applications can also be tracked with this and the localagitations and related FIRS can also be tracked and accordingly further front can be

    generated.

    3.3.4. Constr ucti on Phase

    Table 4 Various Menu options required during Construction Phase

    Phase Location Entity Activity ProgressTime

    lineDocument

    Quantity

    Status

    Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 Level 5Sub

    Level-1

    Sub level-

    2

    Sub

    level-3

    Engineering

    Trunk Line/Lateral line/Branch line/

    Flow Line/From

    Chainage/ ToChainage

    Trench Grading StartedTargetto Start View

    Procurement

    Village/Survey

     Number/Land Owner

    Pipeline ExcavationIn

     progress

    Targetto

    FinishDownload

    Legal Cable Bedding CompletedTarget

    to

    Release

    Retrieve

    Construction Stringing Extract

    Welding Upload

    Lowering Comment

    Testing Check

    Back filling

    Restorations

    During Construction phases, various construction activities status can be traced

    centrally like Excavation, bedding, laying, welding, lowering, testing, back filling etc.

    Further front can be generated from the Central Control Room.

    4. DATA FEEDING, UPDATING, PROCESSING AND

    MANAGEMENT.

    Central Construction Control Centre should be manned for all 24x7 days. There will

     be a monitor where the entire Gas distribution network will be visible. Wherever

  • 8/20/2019 SCS &GIS ENABLED PROJECT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION PHASE OF GAS DIS…

    12/14

    SCS & GIS Enabled Project Management System for Development and ImplementationPhase of Gas Distribution Project

    http://www.iaeme.com/IJMET/index.asp 167 [email protected]

    required, the particular portions can be zoomed and edited. GIS images of the Gasdistribution network area have to be preloaded into the system. Individual area

    managers/construction heads or the Field engineers will be provided wither withlaptop or Smartphone with application. Accesses have to be provided to the respective

    construct ion man to update the current happenings.

    With the real-time updation, the Person monitoring the data at CCCC can easilygenerate the front and send to the succeeding persons or to the same person if he is

    alone to carry out the succeeding act ivities.

    Example: Operator takes out the locations where all testing completed and

     backfilling is balance. His output will be in terms of Line number/Village name/Trunkline/Feed line / Chainage details etc. This list Operator will be sending to the Civil co-ordinator to initiate the backfilling works.

    Figure 2 Schematic drawing of concept of ‘Central Construction Control Centre’ 

    Central Construction Control Centre

  • 8/20/2019 SCS &GIS ENABLED PROJECT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION PHASE OF GAS DIS…

    13/14

    G. Dhamodaran and R. J. Golden Ranjith

    http://www.iaeme.com/IJMET/index.asp 168 [email protected]

    5. RESULTS

    This kind id system is used in operation phase for many projects as “Supervisory

    Control System and Data Acquisition”. Our Aim is to extend that kind of Central project Control Concepts which will increase the efficiency of the Project

    management.

    6. DISCUSSION

    6.1. Advantages of using this system

    This system has more advantages like,

    a. 

    Efficient Project management b.

     

    Better revision management in drawings and documentsc.

     

    Complete reliability on the work progress and frontd.

     

    Accurate reportse.

     

    Provides clear guidelines for planning, and forecastingf.

     

    Provides access to multiple users so that many people can work in same time

    g. 

    Tracing facility of materials, reports, documents history etc.h.

     

    Helps in generating many data bases.i. 

    Controls Duplication works j.

     

    Continues expedition from the Site teamk.

     

    Single Point Co-ordination system which minimise the error.l. 

    Completely provides real time tracking of the progressm.

     

    Generates Front for almost all disciplines included in the scopen.

     

    Minimal investment and no major operational costo.

     

    Less Manpower requirement

    7. CONCLUSION

    As this reduces lot of man-hour wastages and time this method can be encouraged formany of the Pipeline projects like Gas Distribution Projects.

    ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

    Informally many other forms the same concept is being used partially in many of the

    Gas distribution Projects. With little improvement and value addition will yield goodresults in terms of the efficient Project Management.

    REFERENCES

    [1] 

    Al-Momani, A. H. Construction delay: A quantitative analysis.  International

     Journal of Project Management , 18(1), 2000.[2]

     

    Ammar, M. A. and Mohieldin, Y. A. Resource constrained project schedulingusing simulation. Construction Management and Economics, 2002.

    [3] 

    Assaf, S. A. and Al-Hejji, S. Causes of delay in large construction projects. International Journal of Project Management , 2006.

    [4] 

    Chan, A. P. C., Scott, D. and Chan, A. P. L. Factors affecting the success of aconstruction project.  Journal of Construction Engineering and Management,2004.

    [5] 

    Graham, G. E., Maxwell, D. A. and Vallone, A. How to Optimize Gas Pipeline Networks. Pipeline Industry, June, 1971. 41 – 43.

    [6] 

    Martch, H. B. and N. J. McCall. Optimization of the Design and Operation of Natural Gas Pipeline Systems. Paper No. SPE 4006, Society of PetroleumEngineers of AIME, 1972.

  • 8/20/2019 SCS &GIS ENABLED PROJECT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION PHASE OF GAS DIS…

    14/14

    SCS & GIS Enabled Project Management System for Development and ImplementationPhase of Gas Distribution Project

    http://www.iaeme.com/IJMET/index.asp 169 [email protected]

    [7] 

    Flanigan, O. Constrained Derivatives in Natural Gas Pipeline SystemOptimization. Journal of Petroleum Technology, May, 1972, pp. 549.

    [8] 

    Mah, R. S. H. and Schacham, M. Pipeline Network Design and Synthesis. Advances in Chemical Engineering , 10, 1978.

    [9] 

    Cheesman, A. P. How to Optimize Gas Pipeline Design by Computer. Oil and

    Gas Journal , 69(51), December 20, 1971, pp. 64.[10]

     

    Cheesman, A. P. Understanding Origin of Pressure is a Key to Better WellPlanning. Oil and Gas Journal , 69(46), November 15, 1971, pp. 146.

    [11] 

    Edgar, T. F., Himmelblau, D. M. and Bickel, T. C. Optimal Design of GasTransmission Network. Society of Petroleum Engineering Journal , 30, 1978, pp.96.

    [12] 

    Hasan, H. S. and Dr. Ramesh Babu, P. SCS Analysis and Control of MobileRobot for Pipe Line Inspection. International Journal of Mechanical Engineeringand Technology, 4(5), 2013, pp. 01 – 09.

    [13] 

    Olorunniwo, F. O. A Methodology for Optimal Design and Capacity Expansion planning of Natural Gas Transmission Networks. Ph.D Dissertation, The

    University of Texas Austin, May, 1981[14]

     

    Wong, P. J. and Larson, R. E. Optimization of natural gas pipeline systems viadynamic programming. IEEE Trans. Auto. Control , AC-13(5), October 1968, pp.475 – 481.

    [15] 

    Harris, R. B. and Ioannou, P. G. Scheduling projects with repeating activities. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management , 1998.