Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Instructional Rounds
School District of Osceola
Osceola? Is that the place with the pie?
Demographics
District Enrollment: 1844 Free and Reduced: 28% Seven Municipalities Special tuition agreement with the state of Minnesota District Value: $728,943,879.00 Fund 10 Operational Budget: $17,690,622.00
Staff – 127 teachers
OES
Faculty: 34
Aides: 15
OIS
Faculty: 27
Aides: 7
OMS
Faculty: 30
Aides: 11
OHS
Faculty: 36
Aides: 18
School Campus
Osceola Elementary School Osceola Intermediate School
Osceola Middle School Osceola High School
Cascade Falls – Downtown Osceola
Meet and Greet
John
Six Secrets of Change
1. Love Your Employees
2. Connect Peers with Purpose
3. Capacity Building Prevails
4. Learning is the Work
5. Transparency Rules
6. Systems Learn
Summer 2009 - ARRA Dollars
The best way to improve schools is to develop the people within them.
Richard DuFour and Robert Eaker
A focus on Professional development
District Goals
Professional Learning Communities
Disciplinary Literacy
Response to Intervention
Why Literacy?
―About 70% of high school students need some form of remediation; the most common problem is that students cannot comprehend the words they read—not that they cannot read them.‖
(Biancarosa & Snow, 2004)
Why Literacy?
CCSS Shift to 50-50 Fiction/Nonfiction
Smarter Balanced Expectations
We needed Content area teachers to apprentice students to become readers of their content:
Text
Vocabulary
Students need to ―learn the language‖ of the content - Vocabulary is Essential
Literacy Coaching
A recent study of 17 schools along the East coast suggests that putting literacy coaches in schools can help boost students’ reading skills by as much as 32% over three years.
What is a Literacy Coach?
A literacy coach is one who helps teachers to recognize what they know and can do, assists teachers as they strengthen their ability to make more effective use of what they know and do, and supports teachers as they learn more and do more.
Year 1
Trained 14 Staff in Literacy Coaching model at CESA 11
Clearly fit with our District Goals
Jim Knight
Coaching: Approaches and Perspectives
Instructional Coaching: A Partnership Approach to Improving Instruction
Marilyn – District Mentorship 40 Day Contract with CESA 11
Practice Group
Year 2 - Instructional Coaching
Trained 10 more teachers at CESA 11; included math, social studies, and science teachers
Involved 2 Responsive Classroom coaches
Transitioned to Instructional Coaching
Asked for volunteer classrooms
Purpose: to build a collaborative environment; connect to our PLC efforts
Side by Side Coaching with Marilyn
The Coaching Cycle
Pre-conference
Peer Visit
-Modeling
-Side by Side
-Teacher Practice
Reflection
Feedback Casey, K. (2006). Literacy coaching: the essentials. Heinemann: Portsmouth, NH.
OSD Instructional Coaching 23
Changes in Year 3
New Superintendent
Few available dollars
No Marilyn – local sustainability
Coaches paid a small stipend
Year 3: OSD Coaching Cycle for 2011-2012 1. Coaches will each work with two people
2. Three classroom visits: fall, winter, and spring
3. Pre-conference to determine a focus question
4. Pre-conference notes
5. Visit the classroom and script what the teacher and students are doing (3 column chart – what the teacher is doing, what the students are doing, impact on learning)
6. Keep the focus question at the center of the visit.
OSD Instructional Coaching 25
OSD Coaching Cycle, cont.
7. Meet for a post-conference and review the visit.
8. The discussion should be centered on the focus question.
9. Record notes from the post-conference.
10. Make copies of the pre-conference, scripting, and post-conference forms for both of you.
11. Encourage the next visit to be connected to the discussion during the feedback conversation.
12. Coaching will be most effective if it sustained over time.
OSD Instructional Coaching 26
Summer 2012
Professional Development and Reflection Opportunity for Coaches
How do we build a sustainable system for instructional coaching in our district?
Our Reasons for Coaching 1
Avenue to talk about getting better together
Building a common language
Continue to look inward: Why am I doing what I am doing?
Opportunity to engage others in discussions about literacy
Reasons for Coaching 2
Opportunity to build knowledge in reading strategies and other best practices
Collaboration model – embedded professional development
Open doors for each other
Constructive feedback
Reasons for Coaching 3
A push to be better
Another set of eyes
Promotes conversation between buildings
Learning for all involved
Reasons for Coaching 4
Focused on specific areas for improvement
Directly connected to student learning and achievement
Tool for communication
Ties to the PDP process – Reflection and Collaboration
Reasons for Coaching 5
Cross grade/different content discussions
At grade/same content discussion
Ongoing process
Learn from others
Energy from others
Reasons for Coaching 6
Improve instruction
Grow as a professional
Non-judgmental
Reinforce beliefs
Empowering
Gain new ideas
Reasons for Coaching 7
See others ideas and styles
Builds continuity and consistency in expectations and practices
Identifies what good teaching looks like and sounds like
Learning community opportunities – working with peers, observing each other, professional conversations
Reasons for Coaching 8
Classroom management ideas
Increasing trust in and comfort with peer visits
Community building among staff
Curriculum continuity – see what skills/content are taught in different grades and courses
Meaningful conversations
Why do we need a coaching cycle?
fosters collaboration between teachers in order to impact student learning
allows teachers to transform knowledge into skill
helps teachers practice and refine the use of effective strategies
embeds professional development in our daily practice
OSD Instructional Coaching 37
Professional Learning Communities
There is abundant research linking higher levels of student achievement to educators who work in the collaborative culture of a professional learning community.
Rick Dufour, 2010
And this is where we got stuck…
Observation
1. An act or instance of noticing or perceiving
2. An act or instance of regarding attentively or watching
3. The action or process of observing something or someone carefully in order to gain information
4. The ability to notice significant details
5. A judgment on or inference from what one has observed
OSD Instructional Coaching 40
LEAD 21 Visitors
Visits vs Observations
Peer visits are collaborative, not evaluative
It is a ―peers helping peers‖ process
Peer Visits
Peer visits, in which small groups of
practitioners observe one another’s work,
take notes, and discuss with each other
what they learned, is a useful way to gather
information about the instructional practices
in the school, reflect on it, and use it to
improve teaching and learning.
OSD Instructional Coaching 43
Spotlighting/Highlighting
When coaching, our people identified these 3 questions:
What are we seeing?
What is going well?
What might others want to see?
We needed more people involved…
Harvard article
Why Rounds? 1
Based on the idea of medical rounds
Harvard Educational Research
A set of protocols and processes for observing, analyzing, discussing and understanding instructional practices that can be used to improve student learning
Why Rounds? 2
Everyone involved is working on their practice
Everyone is obliged to be knowledgeable about the common task of instructional improvement
Everyone’s practice should be subject to observation and reflection
Why Rounds? 3
Rounds as a culture building process will assist us in developing common language and common definitions about high quality instruction
Rounds will encourage us to engage in language that focuses on the outcomes of our behaviors
Why Rounds? 4
• Rounds connect to PLCs – a group of professionals who collaboratively assist one another in the process of improving their individual and collective practice
• Rounds can be a vehicle for PLC work, when the focus is on gathering evidence about a commonly-identified component of our practice, with the goal of enhancing our overall effectiveness
We Needed to Shift the Culture…
Collaborating on Matters Related to Learning
• District Goal: To Expand Instructional Coaching opportunities using Instructional Rounds
• Build a Culture of Trust
• Groups of 4 • All faculty, all buildings • Begin with Instructional Coaches classrooms • Welcome other classrooms • 2 x this year
– I noticed… – I wonder… – What if… – How might…
Team Structure
Teams of 4 facilitated by a coach
Half day
2 teams per day for a total of 4 full day subs
Coach created schedule
Started with coaches classrooms
Start day with a team meeting
Create focus points with team members
Everyone takes notes
Share notes/reflections/questions at the end
Possible Focus Areas
student engagement
reflection, inquiry
questioning
student work
directions
transitions
routines
teacher language
student language
classroom community
classroom climate
lesson structure
whole group, small group, individual instruction
differentiated opportunities
assessment
classroom management
scripting
Your Needs…
Be an active listener
Stay focused; have a clear purpose for the visit
Model and provide meaningful reflection
Keep discussions respectful, collegial, and productive
Keep student performance and achievement at the center of every peer visit
A Coach’s Role During Instructional Rounds
Financial Support
26 Coaching Stipends at $350 = $9100
8 hours of Summer PD at $20/hour for ea. coach = $4160
32 Teams (some coach more than one team)
16 Days of Rounds x 2 opportunities (fall and spring)
16 days x 4 subs per day = 64 Subs days
64 sub days x $100 = $6400
Total: $19660
Title 1, Title 2A, Special Ed.
Becky
OHS – Not enough participation
Use Email to Your Advantage…
Rather than ―Who is willing to open their room…‖ Amanda wrote, ―Let me know if your room isn’t open.‖
School Board Meeting Share Out
• 2nd opportunity during second semester
• OMS tying IR to their personal goals that were set using the Charlotte Danielson Model
• OES and OIS will be seeing the opposite time of the day (morning last time and afternoon second time)
• Pride Cards – Sharing positives
• Sharing at staff meetings
• ALL OHS classrooms were visited
• Approved the opportunity to do IR in a different building
Stephanie F.
Focus Questions 1
How are spelling, vocabulary, and meaning reinforced in our classrooms?
How do teachers build reading stamina with students?
What is the big idea/objective/essential learning outcome for today’s lesson?
Focus Questions, 2
What is student engagement like in our classrooms today? How was it maximized?
What are the best practices happening in our classrooms? How are they impacting student learning?
How do teachers check for understanding in their lessons?
Focus Questions 3
What can we noticed about lesson design?
What do we notice about teacher talk and student talk in our classrooms?
What can be done to eliminate student confusion?
To what extent is the activity in the classroom focused on learning as opposed to management or discipline?
OSD Instructional Coaching 65
Focus Questions 4
How is inquiry used to engage students in learning and extend their thinking?
How do we use academic choice to engage students in learning?
How can we facilitate effective student collaboration?
ARI Secondary Team 2009 66
Focus Questions 5
How do we evaluate student learning through formative assessment?
How does our use of questioning impact student learning?
How is technology used to extend student learning? How can it impact motivation and engagement?
Focus Questions 6
What routines have been established that support classroom community and student learning?
How can established procedures facilitate student collaboration?
How do teacher interactions with students impact learning in our classrooms?
OSD Instructional Coaching
68
OMS Instructional Rounds
A tool for mentoring:
• A great way to connect new teachers with experienced teachers in the same content area.
• Connecting mentees with opportunities to see specific engagement routines being modeled in other classrooms.
Stephanie C.
www.teachingchannel.org
Jim Knight: The Big Four http://www.instructionalcoach.org/big4/
Activity: The Big Four
I can identify classroom practices according to The Big Four
Other connections: The Danielson Framework, Strong’s Performance Standards, Wisconsin Teacher Standards, InTASC Standards
Scripting the classroom with Three Column Notes
Rounds Discussion
What did you see the teacher doing?
What did you see the students doing?
How was student learning impacted?
What questions did you have about what you saw?
More possibilities:
– I noticed…
– I wonder…
– What if…
– How might…
Summer 2012 Why do we want to have Rounds?
Improves instruction
Opens discussion
Professional development for self/reciprocal
Improves student achievement
District goal…PLC
Common path for common assessment
Tech growth
Supports new people
Highlights what is going well
What is working?
Everyone is learning
Vertical alignment/understanding (current lesson planning) grade above and below
Builds PLC/grade level
Positive teachers
Clear expectations – pre/post conference guidelines
Shared vision – backwards planning
Reflection (depth)
LEAD21 – visitors/experiences/conversations have challenged us
What are the challenges?
Time (a lot on plate)
Reading – schedules all at same time – coverage
Not everyone onboard; fully participating
Someone watching me vs. someone noticing
Convincing everyone that they need the opportunity
Not enough time between visits/reflection
Accountability? Trust level
Still concern about administration connection/evaluation
No staff development hours/carrot
That it’s about best practices and not content
Possible Modifications
How might we use prep time rather than subs?
Can we visit other districts as well as other buildings in our district?
Can there be financial incentive?
How can we become comfortable using video and then working with a coach?
Can we genuinely create a culture of classrooms with an ―open invitation‖ to visitors?
Joe
We Will Continue…
To purposefully share out and celebrate the good things we are seeing
To connect focus questions to personal and team goals
To communicate a clear vision – common understanding
To acknowledge the positives and expertise
We Will Also Continue…
To challenge our teachers to notice and name best practices regardless of content area
To support professional development on best practices
To grow the use of reflective sentence stems, positive collegial conversations, and coaching language
Feedback from the Instructional Rounds Survey – 65 responses
Three Main Purposes for Instructional Rounds
Promote collegial conversations that become part of our school’s professional learning culture.
Increase school-wide reflection on best practices to increase student achievement.
Identify strategies that you would like to incorporate into your own practice.
Three Main Focus Points
Instructional best practices
Student engagement
Assessment techniques
Rounds Structure
Instructional Rounds should be announced in advanced.
Twelve to 15 minutes should be spent in each classroom.
Team members may speak to students as long as the instructional flow is not interrupted.
Notes may be taken in the classroom.
Teams are interested in knowing the learning target for the class period.
Teams may decide to have group or individual focus points for their rounds.
Additions Provide flexibility to address the needs of
the staff
-specific classrooms
-specific content
-different buildings
-different districts
-by goal or focus
Expect an ―open door‖ culture on coaching days
Norms for Teams on Rounds
Be prompt
Stay entire time
Have an open and positive attitude
Be engaged/present (no cell phones, email, or side conversations)
Be respectful and reflective
Be helpful and encouraging
Keep Rounds’ conversations confidential
Amy
Here is an example of what instructional rounds can do for our students when we implement the best practices we are seeing.
Fourth grade was using a power point for vocabulary in LEAD 21; Michon had shared this at a workshop a while back. Then, I went to James’ room for instructional rounds and saw that he added pictures to go with the words. I used pictures with the vocabulary words for the first time in Unit 5, and had phenomenal results on vocabulary test results WITHOUT the worksheets of students writing down the definitions. We also discuss the words each day, and they drew pictures for some of the words, but that was it! Only 8 students missed one word, and the rest got 100%. Jo also shared that she adds movement where possible to the vocab. words, and I think that is a great practice I’d like to adopt also.
Instructional rounds are “on the job” staff development.
Notice and Name, Say Thanks
MAP Over Time Grades 3 & 5
Implementing CCSS MAP Gr. 6
Kindergarten Over Time
Tested at Grade K
SP10 F/P
GRL
(D)
SP11 F/P
GRL
(D)
SP12 F/P
GRL
(D)
SP13 F/P
GRL
(D)
Total Tested 112 135 114 123
Above Benchmark 41 56 38 53
At Benchmark 22 33 43 44
Below Benchmark 49 46 33 26
% Above Benchmark 36.6% 41.5% 33.3% 43.1%
% At Benchmark 19.6% 24.4% 37.7% 35.8%
% Below Benchmark 43.8% 34.1% 28.9% 21.1%
Kindergarten F&P C vs. D
Current Grade K
SP13 F/P
GRL
(D)
SP13 F/P
GRL
(C)
123 123
53 99
44 14
26 10
43.1% 80.5%
35.8% 11.4%
21.1% 8.1%
Grade 4 Over Time
Tested at Grade 4
SP10 F/P
GRL
(S)
SP11 F/P
GRL
(S)
SP12 F/P
GRL
(S)
SP13 F/P
GRL
(T)
137 134 125 111
87 103 93 89
11 18 7 9
39 13 25 13
63.5% 76.9% 74.4% 80.2%
8.0% 13.4% 5.6% 8.1%
28.5% 9.7% 20.0% 11.7%
Connections
Professional Learning Communities
Mentors/New to System Teachers
Educator Effectiveness Goals
SLOs
PDP
A way to create evidence and artifacts of things that are working
Jim Knight
High Impact Instruction
Unmistakable Impact
Leading Instructional Rounds in Education – Thomas Fowler-Finn
School-Based Instructional Rounds – Lee Teitel
School Administrator Magazine
January 2014 Issue
http://www.aasa.org/content.aspx?id=31242
Engaging Teachers in Classroom Walkthroughs Kachur, Stout, Edwards
Source for survey Questions
#educoach on Twitter Wednesday Nights – 9pm
Educational Leadership – Summer 2013 – Digital Issue http://www.educationalleadership-digital.com/educationalleadership/201306#pg1
Twitter @curriculumgirl
Renee
Anyone too busy to reflect on one’s practice is also too busy to improve. -Robert Garmston