35
Russia Business and Economic Outlook An easy-to-use overview by Dr Daniel Thorniley 29 May 2016

Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

RussiaBusinessandEconomicOutlook

Aneasy-to-useoverview

byDrDanielThorniley

29May2016

Page 2: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Introduc:on.What’sthisfor?

•  Thissetofslidesisaimedtoprovideyouwithaneasy-to-useoverviewofthekeybusinessandeconomicdriversintheRussianeconomytoday.

•  Regularreadersofmyreportswillbeusedtoseveraloftheargumentsandnumbersasthesematerialsstemfromtheregularreportsyoureceiveandifyourequiremorein-depthanalysis,thenpleasedoreverttoexisFngandfuturereports

•  However,theseslidespresentaone-stop-shopoverview•  Theyarenice-to-haveforexperiencedexecuFvesoperaFnginRussiabutcouldproveeven

veryhelpfulforyourcolleaguesinRussiaandespeciallyforcolleaguesworkingoutsidethemarket

•  TheyarealsointendedasaneasybutdetailedintroducFonintothemarketforyourinternaFonalmanagement

•  YouwillnotethatIcovertheeconomicoutlookandthenbusinesssectorsandthenreviewsomekeydriversandbestpracFceissues

•  Ihopetheywillproveusefulandifyouhaveanyfeedback,justletmeknowDrDanielThorniley,29May2016

Page 3: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Execu:vesummary(1)

•  Manycompaniesare“doingok,surviving,doingbeLerthansurviving,makingmoneyorbeaFngexpectaFons”intheRussianmarkettoday

•  BusinessinRussiaistoughandchallengingbutitisnotaloneinthis•  Mostdevelopedandemergingmarketeconomiesarealsostrugglingsuchas

Brazil,LaFnAmerica,SouthAfrica,Sub-SaharaAfrica,SaudiArabia,manyMEAmarketsandwhileChinaisabigandcriFcalmarket,ittooischangingandnotaseasyasinthepast

•  ThepointisthereisnoeasyplacetoruntoifacompanythinksofdownsizinginRussia

•  Companiesshouldnotbethinkingofpullingoutbutofre-assessingtheirwholeglobalbusinessfootprintincludingemergingmarketsandinthisstrategyRussiahasaplaceandroletoplay

Page 4: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Execu:vesummary(2)

•  Ourmiddlecasescenarioisforoiltoaverage$45-58perbarrelforthenext2-3yearsandthisistheconsensus

•  OnthatbasistheRussianeconomywillgrowatabout2%annuallyinthenext3-5years

•  Onthisbasisandpresumingamorestableoilpriceatthelevelsquotedabove,thentheroublewillachievesomerelaFvestability

•  Inspring2016wehaveseenamorestableandhigheroilpriceandthustheroublehasstabilisedatabout74-77totheEuroand65-68tothedollar

•  ThecurrentstabilityhasmadesomeexecuFvesstatethat“springhasarrivedinRussia”becausetheweatherisbeLerandsoistheoilprice,theroubleandbusinesstrends

Page 5: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Execu:vesummary(3)

•  Tosummarise:ifthecentralscenariooutlinedhereoccurs,thismeansthatwesterncompanieswillbeabletoachieve1.  Moderate/goodroublesalesgrowthof5-14%2.  ThiswillbeinamoresteadyroubleandentailthatFXsalesarealsoinrange

of5-10%3.  CompaniesaremanagingandwillmanagecostsandsoprofitabilityinRussia

isnotbad4.  TheROIinRussiaissFllgood5.  RussiaisandwillremainavolumemarketandMARKETSHAREwillremaina

criFcalfactor•  These5factorsmakeRussiaapotenFallydecent,reasonableandgoodmarket

locatedinEuropewhenmanyothermarketswillbestrugglingrelaFvely•  WeunderlinethatthisisNOTareturntotheglorydaysofbusinessin2001-to

2008and2010-2012whensaleswereboomingandprofitswerefabulousandROIwasexcellent

Page 6: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Execu:vesummary(4)

•  TheRussianmarketandyourbusinesshasgonethrough3-5“NewNormals”:theoilprice,theroublefreefloat,slumpininvestments,lossofconfidence,westerneconomicsancFons,deterioraFngpoliFcalrelaFonswiththeWest,asqueezeoninternaFonalfinances

•  WefeelthatourMiddleScenariooutlinedabovehasalargepercentagechancethatthiscantakeplace(70%+)

•  However,wedonotgivemuchhopetotheBestCasebecausewedonotthinkthatoilwillreachsustainablyalevelof$65-80becauseIranianflowsandtheconstantbalancingeffectofUSshalesuppliesoughttopreventtheoilpricefromsoaring.Oilwellover$70wouldentailRussianGDPhummingalongat3.0+withstrongerconfidenceandbeLerindustrialandinvestmentnumbers.Wegivethebestcaseonlya10%likelihood

Page 7: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Execu:vesummary(5)

•  Theworstcaseisthatoilsuppliesprovestrongerandthattheoilpricestabilisesat$20-35abarrelwhichwouldmeanthatwithonlyslowstructuraleconomicreforms,theRussianeconomywouldbestuckatflatGDPgrowthandinfactinasteadystreamofnegaFvenumbersfluctuaFngat-1.0%to-2.5%.ThiswouldentailmostconsumpFonandindustrialnumbersstuckatsub-par,negaFvelevels.ButwebelievethattherewillbesluggishglobalGDPgrowthandthatoilsupplieswillbemorestrainedthanexpectedandthusthisNegaFveCaseisjusta20%possibility.

•  BUTtheoilpriceisakey,criFcaldefiningfactorfortheRussianeconomyunFlthegovernmenteventuallyandslowlystartstoreformtheeconomy.

Theoilpriceistheroublevalue

Page 8: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Russiaasaprioritymarket

Thischarthasalsoremainedthesameforthelast3-5years.DespiteallthepoliFcal,financial,commercial,currencyturmoil,RussiaremainstheNo.1prioritymarketforthehugemajorityofcompaniesacrossthewholeCEEregionandalsotheMEAregion.NoothermarketcombinesthelocalcurrencygrowthandthevolumeofbusinessthatRussiadoes.

Page 9: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Businesssectors(1)

GloballyandinRussiawecandefinebusinesstrendsbysectorsasfollows:1.  PharmaceuFcalsisthebestsectoralthoughgovernmentspendingisunderstrain

inmanymarkets.MedicalequipmentsalesareunderpressureinRussiabutsomepartsaredoingrelaFvelyok.Roublesalesgrowthformanycompaniesin2015-16increasedby5-14%butlessforsomemedicalproducts

2.  Consumerproductsaregreatlymixedwithsomegoodandbadtrendsglobally:downtrading,ownlabel,e-commerce.InRussiageneralconsumerproductsandFMCGhavesurvivedwellbutnotatglorydaysofthepastandRussianconsumersarealsodemandingvalueformoneybutmanycompaniesarealsogrowingroublesalesat5-15%.Somesub-sectorsoffoodandbeveragesarepreformingabitlesswellthanthis.

Page 10: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Businesssectors(2)

3.  BUTitistheB2BsectorwhichgloballyandinRussiaisundermostbusinesspressure:theRussianB2Bmarketfacesglobalchallengesbutalsospecificones:

–  Weakinvestment,decliningtradewhichmeanslessinvestmentandlessindustrialoutput,fallingconfidence,highinterestratesinRussia,lessinternaFonalfinance,westernsancFons.

–  AllthesecombinedmakeforastressedB2Benvironmentandthissectoralso

includestwooftheweakestlinksinRussianbusiness:theautomoFvesectorandITsalestothefederalgovernment.Boththesesub-sectorsare-25%to-50%inroublesandstrugglingbadly.RecentlyjustoneortwocompanieshavetalkedofaminiimprovementinautomoFveandsomechinksinsomesub-supplies.ButthisisperhapsonlytheveryFnybeginningofaslowrecovery.

Page 11: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Businesssectors:consumerproducts(3)

•  Remarkably53%ofcompaniesinthissectorforecastdouble-digitroublesalesgrowthin2016,anumberquitesimilartothatfor2015

•  Thisshrinksto15%inFXtermswhile21%offirmspredictsingle-digitFXincreasesthisyear•  GenerallyfoodandbeveragesareperformingslowerthanFMCGsanddurables•  Aswenoteelsewhere:companiesareposiFvelysurprisedbythepersistentresilienceofthe

Russianconsumer•  AsoneMDnotes:“Idon’tknowhowtheRussianconsumersmanage;theyaregreat!”•  Butmostofthebusinessgrowthcomesfrompriceincreaseswhilevolumesandcategories

arelessstrong:in2015consumerproductcompaniesraisedpricesbyanaverageof15-23%withsomefoodandtobaccocompaniesincreasingpricesby25-35%

•  Priceincreasesin2016willdependontheroublefluctuaFonsandthecurrentstabilitysuggestthatpriceincreaseswillbesoperthanlastyear,alsotakingintoaccountlowerinflaFonin2016

•  WhiletheconsumerisresilientandwhilebrandscansFllsellwellinRussia,theRussianconsumerhaschanged,likehis/herglobalcounterpart:RussianconsumerswantVALUEandarewillingtodowntradeandpurchasebrandslessfrequently

Page 12: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Businesssectors:consumerproducts(4)

•  OneMDreportshowhisdrinkscompanyisintroducingsub-premiumbrandwhichkeepsvolumesupbutofcoursetakesprofitperunitdown

•  AnotherMDwasveryastutewhenshesaid:“Oneofthethingswetrytodoisto“stretchtheexisFngbrands”andtoseewhatwecandowithpricingandsizes”

•  CPcompaniesareresearchingtheircustomersmuchmoreand“slicinganddicing”consumersegments

•  Premiumhasheldupbutwitnesseddowntrading;discountandcheapsegmentshavedonewell;whilethemid-priceandmid-brandprovethemostcomplexandtroublesome

•  Westernplayersdoarguethattheirown“mid-brands”cancompetewellandthatsomemid-rangeFMCGproductsareholdingupagainstretailownlabel

•  “Good-enough-to-have”compeFFonisarealchallengeandlocalchampionshavenotgoneaway;newcomersareinfiltraFngthemarketandinsomecasesChinesefirms

•  Allcompaniesarere-assessingtheirregionalandCISpolicy•  ButoneMDstatesthat:“Russiaismoreamarketofchannelsthangeographicregions.We

break-downthecountryintoroutetomarket.”•  RussianretailisgerngmoreaggressiveasmoderntakesovermorequicklyfromtradiFonal

outlets

Page 13: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Businesssectors:pharmaceu:cals&health(5)

•  PharmaceuFcals(dependingonsub-sectors)isholdingupwhilemedicalequipmentisunderstrongerdownwardpressureasthefederalauthoriFescutbudgetsbyatleast10%andlookmoreto“local”providers

•  Acrossthesector30%forecastgooddoubledigitroublesalesgrowthin2016asin2015•  Andasolid55%offirmsexpectsingle-digitsalesincreasesthisyear•  Butthrough2015,mostcompanieshadtodowngradetheirforecasts•  OverallreimbursedpharmaceuFcalsisfacingthemostpressurewhilesellingtomunicipal

authoriFesandhospitalsisharderaswellbutbusinessdoesconFnue•  SalestothesmallbutgrowingprivatehealthsectoraregoodbutasoneMDnotedlastweek:

“OursalestotheprivatesectorareverystrongbutnotyetsufficienttocompensateenFrelyforlostbusinesswithcentralandregionalauthoriFes”

•  TherelaFvelybestsectorisOTC/retailsalesandheretoocompaniesbenefitfromtheresilienceoftheRussianconsumer

•  ExecuFvesinthissectorknowwellthat65-70%+ofpharmaceuFcalandmedicalproceduresarepaid“our-of-pocket”.

Page 14: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Businesssectors:pharmaceu:cals&health(6)

•  TheMDofamajoruniversalpharmaceuFcalcompanyhasnoted:“ThefurtherawayIgetfromthegovernment,themoremoneyImake”

•  AnothernotesthathefeelsliketheMDofanFMCGcompanybecause“alloureffortsareontheretailsector:markeFng,adverFsing,consumerbehaviour”.

•  OneregionalCEOcommentedthat:“5yearsagowepredicatedourbusinessmodelonthe2020healthprogram.WewouldinvestandmakelotsofprofitablesalestotheRussiangovernment.Thatwastheplanbutnottoday’srealitynorthefuture”

•  Companiesinthissectorhavetoalsodiversifyandlocaliseiftheycan•  Many/mostcompaniesinthissectorhavelocalisedtosomeoralargeextentin2014-2015

butsFllsome20%plantofurtherlocalisein2016•  ThisiscriFcalinthissectorbecausethegovernmentispressingforeignfirmstodosoifthey

wantaccesstomarketandtenders•  ButexecuFvessFllremainuncertainaboutthedetailsoftenderprocessesandwhatthefinal

definiFonof“localisaFon”willbe.LegislaFon,notforthefirstFme,ismurky•  Medicalequipmentreportedgreatsalesandprofitsin2012-13buthavefacedtwosFffer

years.ButconvergencewillhelpasEuropeanpercapitahealthspendingis4-5FmesthatinRussiawhileUSlevelsare10Fmeshigher

Page 15: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Businesssectors:B2B(7)

•  Ourtablesbelowforsectors(seeslide17)showthatonly3%ofB2Bcompaniespredictdouble-digitroublesalesin2016whilefully62%forecastsingledigitsand28%willbeflat

•  ItshouldbenotedthatthesenumbersarenoFceablybeLerthan2015when29%sawnegaFveroublesaleswhichisnotthefeaturefor2016

•  TheB2BsectorhasbeenposiFvelyaffectedbythecurrentposiFvetrends:strongeroil,roublestabilisaFon,beLertrendsinindustryandrealwages(aperinflaFon)haveturnedposiFveagainthankstoinflaFoncomingdown.

•  ItisreasonabletoassessfortheB2Bsectorthat2016willbearecovery-modeyearandthat2017oughttoseea3-5yearmorestableandmoderatelyimprovingbusinessenvironment.

•  ButtherecoveryinB2BistheslowestandtheweakestbutsFllarecovery.

Page 16: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Businesssectors(8)

•  Weopenstatethat60%ofRussia’sbusinessproblemsrelatetooiland40%tosancFons.BUTthisignoresthefactthattheeconomicrecessioninRussiastartedinJanuary2013,fully15monthsbeforetheCrimeacrisis.

•  Andthedownturnstartedininvestmentandindustrywhichfor36-38monthsreportednegaFvefigures.WenotethatthereissomethingwrongatthecoreoftheRussianeconomywhichwillrequirerealstructuralreformsinlegislaFon,taxaFonandfighFngcorrupFon.

•  WedonotanFcipatemajorposiFveshipsquicklybuttheenvironmentwillremainoneinwhichwesterncompaniescanachievereasonableresultsinacompliantfashion.

Page 17: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Organicsalesgrowthinroublesbysector2015and2016

Allcompanies Consumerproducts Pharma/health B2B/industrial

2015 2016 2015 2016 2015 2016 2015 201620%+ 13 12 19 28 9 4 0 010%+ 21 27 30 25 21 26 6 35-10% 22 36 19 21 29 48 28 361-5% 17 11 20 7 26 13 11 31Flat/zero 10 10 3 4 6 8 28 28Minus1-10% 8 6 3 0 3 0 12 4Minus10%+ 8 2 6 7 6 0 17 0

Page 18: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

FXsalesoutlook2016bysectors

2016

Consumerproducts

Pharma/Health B2B/Industrials

10%+ 15 0 0

5-10% 7 12 11

1-5% 14 25 22

Flat/zero 18 21 33

Minus1-10% 21 24 22

Minus10%+ 7 21 11

Page 19: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Theeconomicoutlook2009to2020

2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020GDP -7,9 4,3 4,3 3,4 1,3 0.6 -3,7 -1,3 1,3 1,8 1,9 2,0Retailsales -5,5 6,3 7,2 5,7 3,9 2,5 -10,0 -0,5 2,0 2,3 2,4 2,4Householdspending -7,6 5,5 6,8 7,9 4,7 1,8 -10,1 -2,6 1,5 2,2 2,5 2,5Realwages -2,8 4,4 4,9 8,2 5,2 1,9 -9,5 -1.7 1,7 2,6 3,0 3,02Disposableincome 1,0 3,7 2,8 3,7 3,3 2,1 -4,0 -1,0 1,7 2,2 2,4 2,5InflaFon(year-end) 8,8 8,7 6,1 6,6 6,5 11,4 12,9 7,5 6,4 6,3 6,1 6,0Unemploymentrateaverage 7,9 7,6 6,5 5,3 5,5 5,3 5,4 5,6 5,5 5,4 5,4 5,3Grossfixedinvestment -17,9 5,6 9,8 6,0 -0,3 -4,8 -7.6 -3,2 2,5 3,3 3,5 4,0Industrialoutput -10,8 8,3 4,7 2,6 0,3 1,1 -3,4 -0,5 1,7 2,3 3,0 3,1FXreserves($bn)year-end 447 485 510 528 509 385 365 385 395 410 415 435Rouble/$(year-end) 30,3 30,4 32,1 30,4 32,9 58,0 73,0 68,0 71,0 74,0 77,0 81,0Rouble/Euro(year-end) 43,4 40,0 41,5 40,1 45,1 72,0 78,0 77,0 78,0 80,0 82,0 85,0Budgetbalance(%ofGDP) -6,3 -3,5 -0,2 0,0 -0,5 -0,5 -2,8 -3,7 -2,7 -1,7 -1,3 -0,7Current-accountbalance(%ofGDP) 3,8 4,9 4,9 3,6 1,6 2,7 4,8 4,3 3,5 2,8 1,5 1,3

Page 20: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Economicscenariosandtheroublefor2016atdifferentoilprices

Averageoilprice2016 GDP Infla:on

average Rouble/US$ Rouble/EURAverage

$80-85 3.2% 5.8% 45-52 52-58$70-80 2.4% 6.0% 52-57 58-64$60-70 2.2% 6.4% 57-60 64-66$55-60 1.8% 6.6% 60-63 66-69$50-55 1.3% 7.0% 61-66 69-72$45-50 0.3% 7.7% 62-68 72-75$35-45 -1.3% 8.2% 63-69 74-78$25-35 -2.5% 11.5% 80-84 86-92

Page 21: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Centralscenario-2016economicoutlook(oilaverages$40-47)

GDP -1,3%InflaFon(year-end) 7.5%InflaFon(average) 8.2%Consumerspending -2.2%Investment -3.2%Industrialoutput -0.5%RoubletoUSdollaraverage 63-69RoubletotheEuroaverage 73-78

Page 22: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Spring:meintheRussianeconomy?

•  SeveralfactorsappearbeLerfornow:–  Theoilpriceisover$45perbarrel(andwedidpredict$28-35wastoolow).–  Theroubleisbobblingat74-76totheEuro(closetolevelsrecordedin

FebruaryandSeptember2015).–  InflaFonisdownto7.3%inMarchandApril.–  RealwagesthereforehaveimprovedtoslightlyposiFveterritorythisspring.–  Thekeyinterestrateat11.0%willprobablybecutattheBank’snextmeeFng

to10.5%andweforecastfurthercutsbringingtherateto9.25%to9.0%bytheendof2016orfirstquarter2017.

•  IFtheroublestabilisesatcurrentlevelsandifthebaseeffectsturnoutstrongerthanexpected,theninflaFonin2016willaverage8.0%andfinishinDecember2016atabout7.5%.WethenseeinflaFonaveraging7.0%in2017andendingthatyearat6.4%.

•  InterestrateswillfollowinflaFondownwardsandend2016atabout9.25%orat9.0%aroundtheturnoftheyear2016-17.

Page 23: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

TheBig-5factorsinfluencingtheRussianeconomy(1)

1.   Theoilprice

Wedoconfirmourlong-standingassumpFonthatwithoilatabout$45-55overthenext18monthsandthatanyupsideriskstemsfromlesssupplythanisgenerallyanFcipated.Theconsensusviewforthenext1-2yearsisactuallystrongerthanthisat55-60+andCiFanFcipate$70perbarrelatend-2017.OfcourseanyofthesehighernumberswouldonlybenefittheRussianeconomy(seescenariosbelow).Butmedium-termwefeelthatanewinflowofIranianoilsuppliesandtheabilityofUSshaleproducerstopopbackintothemarketwhenpricesrisewillactasarestrainingfactorontheoilpricemedium-term.Therefore:$45-58possibleoverthenext12-18monthsandeven$55-62overthenext3yearsbutanyhighernumbersustainablydoesnotlookvalid

Page 24: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

TheBig-5factorsinfluencingtheRussianeconomy(2)

2.   Therouble

Therouble’sfutureisinextricablylinkedtotheoilpriceandthetwonumbersaremovingintandemmorecloselythanatanyFmeinthelast10years.

Theoilpriceistheroublevalue.RussianciFzenssFllhavesomefaithintheroubleand67%claimtopreferholdingroublesavingsratherthanFXones.

Page 25: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

TheBig-5factorsinfluencingtheRussianeconomy(3)

3.   EasternUkraineTheimportant,cynical,facthereis‘thepercepFon”ofwhatishappening.TheofficialwesternviewisthathosFliFesarecalmerthantheywereandasanFcipated,thishasbecomeafrozenconflict.

4.   Westernsanc:onsAnydiminishingofUSsancFonslooksextremelyunlikelyinthenext1-3years.ThenewUSPresident(whoevershemaybeJ*),willnotfighttheUSCongress,whichwillcertainlyberepublican,overreducingsancFonswithRussia.ThereisasmallandslightlygrowingchancethatEuropeansancFonscouldbemodifiedratherthaneliminatedoverthenext18months.GermanandUSinfluencetendtoensurethatEuropeansancFonsarekeptinplace.Butanychangeinthe“moodmusic”onsancFonscouldhavequickposiFveeffectspushingtheroubleup+5%justonrumoursorraisingtheroublevalueby8-15%ifEuropeansancFonswererescinded.

Page 26: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

TheBig-5factorsinfluencingtheRussianeconomy(4)

5.   ChinaandtheUSA

RussiaisdependentonChinesegrowth:ifChineseGDPdipsdown,thenglobalmarketstumbleandtheoilpricecollapsestakingtheroublewithit.TheUSinfluenceflowsthroughinterestratepolicy:whentheFederalReserveplansseveralinterestratehikes,thenallemergingmarketsandtheroublecomeunderdownwardpressure.SomeoftherelaFvecurrencystabilitytodaystemsfromthefactthattheUSFederalReserveseemstobeinaholdingpaLernonraisingrates:in2016wenowonlyanFcipate1-2increasesinsteadofatotalof3-4.

Page 27: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Thesitua:oninindustryinRussia(1)

•  InFebruary-March2016industrialoutputyear-on-yearwasclosetozerowhichisoneofthebestfiguresin2-3years!

•  BusinessconfidenceimprovedagaininAprilto-4from-7inJanuary.Thisnumberisveryseasonal(alwaysweakatturnoftheyear)butthenumbersdoindicateastrongposiFveseasonaltrend,whichisbeingmaintainedsofarintospring.

•  Industrialoutputishelpedinpartby1.  importsubsFtuFon,2.  defencespendingand3.  tradeandinvestmentwithChinaandAsia.ButwehaveunderscoredthatnoneofthesefactorsoffersanygoldensoluFontoRussianindustryandGDP.

•  ThePMIindicatorimprovedto49.8inJanuary(andafigureof50.0suggestsgrowth)butthensankinMarchto48.3andtoalowof48.0inApril.

Page 28: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Thesitua:oninindustryinRussia(2)

•  CarregistraFonswereupby125,000inMarchcomparedwith82,000inatradiFonallypoorJanuary.Butthenumbersreflectonlyasluggishseasonalimprovement,whichsuggeststhattheautomoFveindustrysFllhasmanymonthsofstruggleahead.

•  WesFckfornowwithourannual2016industrialgrowthfigureof-0.5%withsomesmallupside.

•  Butbeforewegettoocarriedaway,investmentnumbersaresFllbad.Grossfixedinvestmentwasdownby-7.6%in2015andwerevisedownwardsouresFmateforthisyearto-3.2%.Thisisbasedonanotherweakfigureof-8.4%inbothFebruaryandMarchandclosetotheJanuaryfigure.SancFons,finances,interestrates,foreigninvestmenttrendsandweakconfidenceinthemedium-termareallholdingbacktheinvestmentnumbers.

Page 29: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Keyissuesinbusiness:bestcorporateprac:ce(1)

1.  Marketshareiskey:ourwordsofadviceandcommentsonBestPracFcewhichfollowallrelatetoretainingorachievingsustainablemarketshare.

2.  Short-termfinancialplanningissFllverytough.OneFMCGmanagingdoctoradvises:“Makeaplan,have2-3scenariosandsFckwithit”.

3.  ThelargemajorityofexecuFvesaresuretheywillmaketheirroublebudgetsthisyearandeven75%thinktheywillgetclosetomakingtheirFXbudgetthisyear

4.  Wheneverthe2017budgetcyclestarts,makesurenottogetcaughtintheinfamousbudgettrapofsernghightargetsintheautumnonlytoseeexternalfactorsworsenlater.

5.  LocalisaFon:westerncompaniesrealisethattogetdeeperintothelocalmarketsandtoaccesslocaltenders,theyneedtobemorelocalisedandthisisanon-goingtrend.AsoneexecuFveputitbluntly:“Localiseordie”.OtherexecuFveshavearguedthatlocalisaFonhasmadeallthedifferencetotheir2015results(seebelow).

Page 30: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Keyissuesinbusiness:bestcorporateprac:ce(2)

6.  MorecompaniesareconsideringRussiaasanexportmarket.Inthepasteveryonewantedtogetintothebig,boomingdomesFcmarketbutFmeshavechanged.It’s“nicetohave”abitofexportstoboostoverallbusiness.

7.  Sourcing:ascompanieschoosetolocalise,thenmoresourcingcanpotenFallybedoneinRussia.ButmanyexecuFvessFllcomplainaboutthelackoflocally-producedqualityinputs.ButgiventheneedtopurchasecheapterinputsandalsotocreategoodrelaFonswiththeRussianauthoriFes,morecompaniesareswitchingorreducingtheirsourcingfromregularEUorUSsuppliersandbuyingmorefromAsianones(orRussianswherepossible).

8.  DiversificaFon:beingadiversifiedconglomerateisprovinggoodforsomefirmsasthisspreadstheriskandwhilesomesalestosomesectorsmayhaveslumped(automoFve,IT),theyarecompensatedbycomparaFvelystrongersaleselsewhere(consumer-related).OneUSconglomeratearguesthat:“Wegrew20%indollarslastyearthankstohavingbusinessspreadacrosstheRussianeconomy.WedosupplytotheautomoFveindustrywhichisagonybutothersectorsaredoingwellforus”.

Page 31: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Keyissuesinbusiness:bestcorporateprac:ce(3)

9.  SeveralcompaniesreportprivatelythattheyaremakinglargeinvestmentsinlogisFcsandwarehousing;somecompanieswithlargeexisFngmarketshareswanttoprotectthoseorplantoexpandthismarketshare.

10. Remarkably25-35%ofcompaniesrespondtooursurveythattheywillbemakingnewinvestmentinRussiain2016inmanufacturing,logisFcsorwarehousing.Thisisstrikinglyhigh.

11. GenerallypharmaceuFcalsandhealtharethefavouredsectors,consumerproductsareaverage(good/mixed)andB2BistheweakestbusinesssectorwithrecentlytheITandautomoFveindustrysFckingoutasbadlystrainedsectors.

12. ThegovernmentbudgetfordiscreFonarysectorswascutbyabout10%lastyearandthiswillberepeatedin2016;sellingtotheRussiangovernmentishardwork.

13. ConsumerproductcompaniesremainhugelyimpressedattheresilienceoftheRussianconsumer.

14. Brandorvalue?ExecuFvesarehavingstrongdebatesaboutwhetherpremiumbrandswillholdupthisyearagainsttheeconomicodds.Mostappreciatethattheywillneedtowidentheirporxoliotoreachmoreconsumersegments.

Page 32: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Keyissuesinbusiness:bestcorporateprac:ce(4)

15. Andofcoursethebigstoryis(andhasbeenforseveralyearsgloballyandinRussia)affordableinnovaFon:adapFngyourproductporxolioandpricepointstoconsumerswhodemandmorevalue.RussiacouldbeagoodfuturemarketasitcanofferbothagoodbrandmarketandopportuniFesforaffordableinnovaFonamongthelower-workingclassandwithconsumersintheregions.Notallmarketsofferthisappealingmix.

16. GreaterconsumersegmentaFonisaglobalbusinesstrendsandonerequiredinRussia:ifacompanyhad10consumersegmentsin2012,itshouldhave25today.Companieshaveto“sliceanddicetheconsumer”muchmoreandunderstandwhatmoFvateshim/her.

17. What’shappeningwithmid-price/mid-brandproductsandservices?GloballyandinRussiathisisthetoughestnuttocrack.Manycompaniessupportthispointandsomefeeltheyhaveignoredthissectorwhilefocusingonbrandordiscount.Morecompaniesareresearchingthemid-levelofbusinesstoseeiftheyaremissingatrick.

Page 33: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Keyissuesinbusiness:bestcorporateprac:ce(5)

18. Relatedtothis,theRussianregionsremainimportantasapartofbusinessstrategyandhavebeensoformanyyearsnowbutcompaniesrealisetheymustdomoretocompensateforaslowingMoscow.UsuallytheregionshaverelaFvelylessdisposableincomepercapitaandsodifferentmarkeFngandpricepointshavetobeestablished.

19. VolumeorPrice?ExecuFvesalsodebateheatedlyaboutwhethertoputtheirbusinessfocusongrowingandprotecFngvolumesorpriceincreases.Generallyvolumesaregoingtobehardertoachieve.

20. Pricerises:muchbusinessgrowthin2015cameasmanycompaniesraisedpricesinarangeof10-35%.For2016companiesbudgetforfewerpricehikesthisyearbutthentheroubleslumpatthestartoftheyearmademanycompaniesre-thinktheirpricestrategywithmorepricehikesplanned.Thenagain,theroublerallyofrecentweeksmeansthatexecuFveswillneedtothinkevenonemoreFme.Companiesseethisasatrickyexercise:theywanttomonitorandmatchcompeFtorsbutalsoseektoavoiddamagingeitherthecategoriesortheirownmarketshare.

Page 34: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Keyissuesinbusiness:bestcorporateprac:ce(6)

21. FinancingwillremainchallengingforB2Bsaleseventhoughthecentralinterestratefellbackto11%lastyearandwillfalltoabout9.0%attheendof2016

22. Manufacturingfirmscomplainaboutrisinginputcosts.23. Somemanagingdirectorsareverywaryofcurngtoodeeply:“Wecannotfullyfix

mostoftheshort-termproblemswithouttakingstepsthatwillcertainlydamagethelong-termhealthofthebusiness”(seesecFonabove).

24. CompaniesareeithergenerallysaFsfiedwiththeircurrentdistribuFonset-up(62%ofcompanies)becausetheyfixeditoverthelast18months.Butofthosewhoarereviewingwhattodo,thereisnoclearpaLern:13%willincreasethenumberofdistributors;10%willreducethatnumberand7%plantotakeonmorethemselves.

25. Generallywesterncompaniesarenotcurngbackonstaff(54%notatallin2016;andafurther42%willconfinethemselvestocutsbelow10%oftotalstaff);companiesarekeepingaFghtreinonsalariesandpayingbelowinflaFon(65%offirmsandanother30%offeringinflaFonorjustabove).

Page 35: Russia Business and Economic Outlook · • The Russian market and your business has gone through 3-5 “New Normals”: the oil price, the rouble free float, slump in investments,

Copyright

©2016DTGlobalBusinessConsul:ngGmbHSource:DT-GlobalBusinessConsulFngGmbHandCEEMEABusinessGroupresearchBasicdatasourcescomefromcentralbanks,ownintelligencenetwork,CEEMEABusinessGroupcorporatesurvey,governmentsandotherpublicsources.InterpretaFon,views,forecasts,businessquotesandbusinessoutlooksbyDT-GlobalBusinessConsulFngGmbHandCEEMEABusinessGroup.ThismaterialisprovidedforinformaFonpurposesonly.ItisnotarecommendaFonoradviceofanyinvestmentorcommercialacFvitywhatsoever.DTGlobalBusinessConsulFngGmbHacceptsnoliabilityforanycommerciallossesincurredbyanypartyacFngoninformaFoninthesematerials.Contact:DrDanielThorniley,President,DT-GlobalBusinessConsulFngGmbHM:+43676534685/E:[email protected]/W:www.ceemeabusinessgroup.comDT-GlobalBusinessConsulFngGmbHKeinergasse8/33,1030Vienna,AustriaCompanyregistraFon:FN331137t