99
“With the ‘Arab Spring’ affecting North Africa, this book is a very useful introduction to exactly how the region has reached its present situation.” - Dr Trevor James, Historical Association

Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Slides to accompany a lecture given to guests on the “Queen Mary 2.” These are the slides as delivered, extemporaneously.

Citation preview

Page 1: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

“With the ‘Arab Spring’ affecting North Africa, this book is a very useful introduction to exactly how the region has reached its present situation.”

- Dr Trevor James, Historical Association

Page 2: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Revolutions in the Middle East:

Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond.

Page 3: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

OutlineWhat is happening?

Where is it happening?

Who is involved?

Why now?

Scenes from Midan Tahrir, Cairo

What next?

Conclusions, or Lessons

Page 4: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

What is happening?

Page 5: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

A lot of things are happening at once.

They are happening for various reasons

and are producing various outcomes.

Page 6: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

“Let’s change ‘brink of chaos’ to ‘Everything is wonderful.’ ”

© The New Yorker, 2010

Page 7: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

“Democracy is the worst possible form of government,

apart from all the others that have been tried.”

Winston Churchill(1874-1965)

Page 8: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Where is it happening?

Page 9: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 10: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Country

Tunisia

Egypt

Libya

Yemen

Syria

Algeria

Pop. (mi#ions)

10

80

7

24

22

35

Page 11: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Country

Tunisia

Egypt

Libya

Yemen

Syria

Algeria

Number of dead

225

875

25 - 30,000

1,500

3,500

8

Pop. (mi#ions)

10

80

7

24

22

35

Page 12: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Tunisia

Page 13: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Zine el-Abdine Ben Ali

Page 14: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

As honest as the day is long?

Page 15: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

23 years, 2 months

Page 16: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Egypt

Page 17: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 18: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Hosni Mubarak

Page 19: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 20: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

29 years, 4 months

Page 21: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Yemen

Page 22: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Ali Abdullah Saleh

Page 23: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

33 years ... and counting

Page 24: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Libya

Page 25: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 26: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Muammar Gaddafi

Page 27: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 28: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 29: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 30: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

42 years, 11 months

Page 31: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 32: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 33: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 34: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 35: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Who is involved?

Page 36: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 37: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 38: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Mohamed Bouazizi

from Sidi Bouzid, Tunisia

died 4 January, 2011

Page 39: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 40: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 41: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

...and Bush Jnr., Clinton, Bush Snr., Reagan, Carter ...

Page 42: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Obama, Bush Jr., Clinton, Bush Snr., Reagan, Carter ...

... and Ford and Nixon.

Page 43: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

“Do not try to do too much with your own hands.

Better the Arabs do it tolerably well than that you do it perfectly.

It is their war and you are to help them,not to win it for them.”

T.E. Lawrence (1917)“Twenty-seven Articles”

Page 44: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Why now?

Page 45: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 46: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 47: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 48: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 49: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 50: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 51: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Scenes from Midan Tahrir, Cairo

Page 52: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 53: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 54: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 55: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 56: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 57: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 58: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 59: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 60: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 61: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 62: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 63: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 64: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 65: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 66: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 67: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 68: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 69: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 70: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 71: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 72: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 73: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 74: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 75: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 76: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 77: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 78: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 79: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 80: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 81: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 82: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 83: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

11 February 2011

Page 84: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 85: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 86: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 87: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 88: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 89: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 90: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 91: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 92: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond
Page 93: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

12 February A rare quiet moment in the Citadel

Page 94: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

What next?

Page 95: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Ben Ali, Saleh, Gaddafi and MubarakCombined rule = 128 years

Page 96: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

“We don’t really have a Middle East policy,which is just as well, because if we did it would be the wrong one.”

Former CIA station chief

Page 97: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Conclusions, or Lessons

i) There is no such thing as “Arab exceptionalism”

ii) These revolutions are driven by nationalism- Muslims are not just Muslims

iii) Young people have more energy than older people

iv) Leaderless revolutions can succeed

v) The alternative to democracy is chaos

Page 98: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

Thank you,

or as we say in Arabic,

شكرا(shukran!)

Page 99: Revolutions in the Middle East: Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Beyond

“… crafted with originality and ingenuity … a good sense of story-telling … an enjoyable read”

- Lirim Azemi, Think Africa Press